Reduction in perforated appendicitis incidence between rural and urban populations after introducing social health insurance in Vietnam: A population‐based study Authors: Tran‐Nguyen Nguyen, Yiing‐Jenq Chou, Nicole Huang Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundOver the years, Vietnam has expanded its social health insurance (SHI) coverage to reduce health disparities. In this population‐based study, we examined the differences in incidences of perforated appendix between rural and urban populations in Vietnam since the expansion of SHI coverage in 2015. We also identified risk factors for perforated appendix in these populations.MethodThe 2015–2019 SHI inpatient claims data from the Social Security Agency of Dong Thap Province were used to elaborate the final sample of 6863 patients aged 18 years or above who underwent an appendectomy. Multivariable probit and logistic regression model were employed to obtain adjusted estimates.ResultsAn overall rate of 22.9% for perforated appendix among adults in Dong Thap was revealed. After the expansion of SHI, rural residents consistently had lower rates of perforated appendix than urban residents, but the differences between rural and urban residents were small and decreased over time, that is from 4.4% in 2015 to 3.4% in 2019. Older, male, and poor residents were at a higher risk of perforated appendix in both urban and rural areas. In rural areas, patients with comorbidities, patients who resided in remote communes bordering Cambodia, and patients who had district hospitals or commune facilities as their primary assigned providers were significantly more likely to develop perforated appendix.ConclusionUnder the SHI in Vietnam, no significant difference was observed in perforated appendicitis incidence between urban and rural residents. Additional efforts are required to reduce poorer outcomes among other high‐risk residents.Keywords: disparity, LMICs, perforated appendix, rural‐urban, Vietnam INTRODUCTION Rural–urban disparities have long been national and international concerns. On a global scale, approximately 56% of rural residents do not have health‐care coverage compared with 22% of urban residents. 1 This disparity is particularly evident in low‐ and middle‐income countries (LMICs). 2 Many studies have indicated that expanding health insurance coverage or adopting a universal health‐care system can improve access to health care and improve the health outcomes of the insured population, particularly in rural areas. 3 , 4 In 1992, Vietnam, a middle‐income developing country, implemented a social health insurance (SHI) program. To achieve the goal of universal coverage, this SHI program was expanded in 2015. This expansion entailed the implementation of a set of policies regarding the reduction of cost sharing, the elimination of district‐level referral requirements, the expansion of benefit packages, and an increase in provider payments. 5 Since this expansion, 92% of the entire population of Vietnam has been gradually enrolled into the SHI program (as of 2022). 6 Most of the currently available studies have evaluated rural and urban disparities in health care by using data collected before 2015 and measures such as out‐of‐pocket expenses, catastrophic health expenditures, and general outpatient or inpatient services. 7 , 8 Even studies evaluating the effects of the 2015 reform have focused only on general health services or impoverishment indicators. 9 , 10 , 11 To the best of our knowledge, no study has examined the effects of timely access to surgical care for common diseases such as appendicitis. Hospital admission for perforated appendix is a common indicator of poor access to high‐quality health care, reflecting delayed diagnosis and surgical treatment for appendicitis. 12 In this population‐based study, we described the trends in perforated appendix in rural and urban areas after the SHI expansion in 2015. We also identified risk factors for perforated appendix in urban and rural areas within the SHI system. METHODS Study settings and data collection Dong Thap, a province in Vietnam, had a total population of 1,601,300 residents in 2021. About 77% of the total population in Dong Thap Province lived in rural areas. 13 Of the 30 provincial and district level hospitals in Dong Thap Province, 18 hospitals are located in urban settings and 12 hospitals are located in rural settings. Physician‐ and nurse‐to‐population ratios were 0.93 and 1.49 per 1000 population in 2021. 14 Surgeons to population ratio was about 5.44 surgeons per 100,000 population in 2019. According to the geographic locations of the hospital providers, patients in either urban or rural settings could access a surgical provider within 30 km (maximum 1‐h riding motorcycle). Data were obtained from SHI inpatient claims for the period between 2015 and 2019 from the Social Security Agency of Dong Thap. Inpatient claims include information on birth year, sex, residential location, enrollment category, dates of hospital admission and discharge, procedure and diagnosis codes, and identifiers of assigned providers and treatment providers. Sampling and diagnosis of perforated and nonperforated appendix A total of 7602 patients aged 18 years or more who underwent an appendectomy in Dong Thap between 2015 and 2019 were identified using an adapted version of International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision, Clinical Modification (ICD‐10‐CM codes: K35, K36, and K37). Only those with either inflamed and unruptured appendix or perforated appendix as their main diagnosis were included in this study. After patients with incomplete information on patient and provider characteristics were excluded, the final sample comprised 6863 patients (Supporting Information S1: Appendix 1). ICD‐10‐CM codes K35.0, K35.1, K35.2, and K35.3 were used to identify perforated appendix. Other cases were referred to as normal appendicitis (Supporting Information S1: Appendix 2). Classification of rural and urban areas According to the regulation in Vietnam, areas are classified into three categories from the least urbanized to the most urbanized as follows: communes, townships, and wards (“xã”, “thị trấn”, and “phường” in Vietnamese, respectively). 15 Patients who resided in communes were referred to as rural residents, and patients who resided in wards and townships were referred to as urban residents. According to the Vietnamese government, a total of eight rural communes in Dong Thap near country borders are designated as remote areas. Therefore, patients living in these eight communes were referred to as remote area residents. Patient and hospital characteristics Patient characteristics such as age, sex, socioeconomic status (SES), and comorbidity were examined. In accordance with the SHI scheme, individuals living in poor and near‐poor households and unemployed individuals can receive SHI premium exemptions or subsidies. SES was defined based on an individual's receipt of SHI subsidies. Patients who received SHI premium exemptions or subsidies were referred to as poor, whereas the other patients were referred to as nonpoor (Supporting Information S1: Appendix 3). Charlson comorbidity index (CCI) was used to reflect the patient's health status and constructed as a dichotomous variable: without any comorbidity (CCI = 0) and with at least 1 comorbidity (CCI ≥1). The level of each patient's assigned and treatment providers were also examined. Providers were divided into three levels depending on their capacity and service scope from the least advanced to the most advanced as follows: commune facilities, district hospitals, and provincial hospitals. Statistical analysis To adjust for differences in the characteristics of patients, assigned providers, and treatment providers, probit regression models including these variables and interaction terms between the rural area status and year dummies were conducted to determine the differences in the annual trends in the rates of perforated appendix between rural and urban residents from 2015 to 2019. Because our observations can be clustered by providers, we included clustering in our models. Instead of reporting coefficients, we reported the marginal effects of independent variables. We also conducted a subgroup analysis by using logistic regression to identify risk factors for perforated appendix in urban and rural residents. A p value of <0.05 was considered statistically significant. All statistical analyses were conducted using SAS 9.4 and STATA 17.0 software packages. RESULTS During the study period, the overall rate of perforated appendix in Dong Thap was 22.9% (Table 1). The proportions of older patients, poor patients, and patients with comorbidities were significantly higher in rural areas than urban areas. A higher proportion of urban patients had provincial hospitals as their primary assigned providers than their rural counterparts. More than 90% of the patients in both rural and urban areas received their appendectomies in province hospitals. TABLE 1Characteristics of patients with appendicitis in Dong Thap, Vietnam, from 2015 to 2019.OverallRuralUrban N % N % N % p valueSample size6863100560581.7125818.3RuptureNo529177.1432677.296576.70.71Yes157222.9127922.829323.3Age18‐64582684.9472084.2110687.9<0.01≥65103715.188515.815212.1SexMale285041.5232641.552441.60.92Female401358.5327958.573458.4Socioeconomic statusPoor106515.591016.215512.3<0.01Non‐poor579884.5469583.8110387.7ComorbidityNo (CCI = 0)526276.7426276.0100079.50.01Yes (CCI ≥1)160123.3134324.025820.5Level of assigned providerProvince level219031.9145425.973658.5<0.01District level285041.5241143.043934.9Commune level182326.6174031.0836.6Level of treating providerProvince level634692.5520492.9114290.80.02District level5177.54017.21169.2Year201595814.074213.221617.2<0.012016116717.093816.722918.22017138420.2114620.523818.92018160823.4133823.927021.52019174625.4144125.730524.2 Characteristics of patients with appendicitis in Dong Thap, Vietnam, from 2015 to 2019. Rural–urban differences over time The crude rates of perforated appendix increased in both urban (from 23.6% to 25.3%) and rural areas (from 22.4% to 26.3%) from 2015 to 2019, although few fluctuations were observed (Figure 1). After adjustment, rural residents consistently had lower rates of perforated appendix, and the differences between rural and urban patients decreased over time (Table 2). The magnitudes of the differences were small. Trends in the rates of perforated appendix by area of residence. TABLE 2Differences in the adjusted rates of perforated appendix between rural and urban areas over time from 2015 to 2019.Marginal effect p value95% confidence intervalYear2015−0.0440.182−0.1090.0212016−0.0420.077−0.0880.0042017−0.0390.009−0.069−0.0102018−0.0370.001−0.059−0.0152019−0.0340.050−0.068−0.000 Note: These results were obtained after patient characteristics (age, sex, SES, and presence of comorbidities), level of assigned provider, level of treatment provider, and clustering for assigned providers were controlled for. Differences in the adjusted rates of perforated appendix between rural and urban areas over time from 2015 to 2019. Note: These results were obtained after patient characteristics (age, sex, SES, and presence of comorbidities), level of assigned provider, level of treatment provider, and clustering for assigned providers were controlled for. Risk factors for perforated appendix among urban and rural residents After adjustment, older patients in urban and rural areas had 3.12‐fold (95% confidence interval [CI] = 2.15–4.52) and 2.29‐fold (95% CI = 1.95–2.69) higher risks of perforated appendix compared with their counterparts. Male patients in urban and rural areas had 1.59‐fold (95% CI = 1.21–2.10) and 1.47‐fold (95% CI = 1.30–1.68) higher risks of perforated appendix than female patients (Table 3). Compared with nonpoor patients, poor patients in urban (odds ratio [OR] = 1.72, 95% CI = 1.14–2.60) and rural (OR = 1.21, 95% CI = 1.01–1.46) areas had a significantly higher risk of perforated appendix. In contrast to urban patients, rural patients with comorbidities (OR = 1.17, 95% CI = 1.01–1.35) had a significantly higher risk of perforated appendix compared with those without comorbidities. Compared with patients who resided in nonremote areas, rural patients who resided in remote communes bordering Cambodia (OR = 1.51, 95% CI = 1.15–1.98) had a significantly higher risk of perforated appendix. TABLE 3Risk factors for perforated appendix among rural and urban residents.Rural populationUrban populationCrude OR (95% CI)Adjusted OR (95% CI)Crude OR (95% CI)Adjusted OR (95% CI)Age18–64RefRefRefRef≥652.41 (2.06–2.81)2.29 (1.95–2.69)3.28 (2.30–4.65)3.12 (2.15–4.52)SexFemaleRefRefRefRefMale1.40 (1.24–1.59)1.47 (1.30–1.68)1.44 (1.10–1.87)1.59 (1.21–2.09)Socioeconomic statusNon‐poorRefRefRefRefPoor1.47 (1.26–1.73)1.21 (1.01–1.46)2.21 (1.55–3.15)1.72 (1.14–2.60)ComorbidityNoRefRefRefRefYes1.33 (1.16–1.53)1.17 (1.01–1.35)1.27 (0.93–1.73)0.94 (0.67–1.32)Remote statusNon‐remoteRefRefRemote1.46 (1.13–1.90)1.51 (1.15–1.98)‐‐Level of assigned providerProvinceRefRefRefRefDistrict1.45 (1.23–1.71)1.62 (1.37–1.92)1.13 (0.85–1.50)1.33 (0.98–1.79)Commune1.69 (1.42–2.01)1.42 (1.18–1.72)1.83 (1.13–2.98)1.363 (0.78–2.39)Level of treating providerProvinceRefRefRefRefDistrict0.16 (0.10–0.26)0.15 (0.10–0.24)0.29 (0.15–0.56)0.273 (0.14–0.54)Abbreviation: OR, odds ratio. Risk factors for perforated appendix among rural and urban residents. Abbreviation: OR, odds ratio. Although the level of primary assigned provider did not influence the likelihood of experiencing perforated appendix among urban patients, rural patients who had district hospitals (OR = 1.62, 95% CI = 1.37–1.92) or commune facilities (OR = 1.42, 95% CI = 1.18–1.72) as their primary assigned providers were significantly more likely to develop perforated appendix. Compared with patients who received treatment at provincial hospitals, urban (OR = 0.27, 95% CI = 0.14–0.54) and rural (OR = 0.15, 95% CI = 0.10–0.24) patients who underwent their appendectomies at district hospitals were significantly less likely to have perforated appendix. DISCUSSION After the expansion of the SHI system in 2015, the rate of perforated appendix in Dong Thap (22.9%) was relatively lower than the average rates (25.9%) reported in 22 other LMICs. 16 More specifically, the perforation rate reported in this study was comparable to those reported in some low‐ and middle‐income South Asian countries (Pakistan 20.0%, India 22.0%), 17 , 18 but significantly lower than those in African countries (28.5%–57.0%). 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 It is worth noting that the perforation rate observed in our study was comparable to other neighboring higher‐income countries such as Thailand (21.8%), 23 China (19.2%), 24 Taiwan (26.8%), 25 and South Korea (21.5%), 26 where these countries also have universal health insurance coverage. More importantly, since this SHI expansion in Vietnam in 2015, no clear disparities have been observed in the risk of perforated appendix between rural and urban residents. During the study period, the rate of enrollment into the SHI program increased from 62% to 86%, 27 and the out‐of‐pocket expenses of near‐poor individuals decreased to approximately one‐fifth in Dong Thap. 28 This reform has reduced the financial barriers to prompt diagnosis and treatment for appendicitis in rural areas. 7 It also presumably increased the availability and quality of health services in rural areas. Some reports revealed a similar level of health service readiness in both rural and urban commune health stations. 14 , 29 Compared with rural areas, rates of perforated appendix were slightly higher in urban areas, presumably because of the inappropriate care‐seeking behavior of urban residents. According to a recent review of LMICs, seeking appropriate treatment is delayed because of the following three factors: self‐medication and utilization of alternative drugs, poor awareness of symptoms, and treatment refusal for fear of hospitalization. 16 Self‐medication, particularly with antibiotics, is a common phenomenon in Vietnam. 30 In addition, self‐medication and direct purchase of medications from pharmacies without prescriptions are more common in urban areas than in rural areas. 31 According to a multicenter study, antimicrobial resistance, which results from self‐medication with antibiotics for common infections, is associated with adverse clinical outcomes among patients with acute appendicitis. 32 Consistent with previous studies in other Asian countries, older age, male sex, and low SES are high‐risk groups of perforated appendix, regardless of the patient's residency. 25 , 26 Compared with their counterparts, older and male patients may have a lower perception of pain, which may further delay their hospitalization. 33 The physiological progress of perforated appendix in older patients may be faster. 33 In Dong Thap, the absence of family members as caregivers due to seeking employment in neighboring provinces may hinder timely access to care for older residents. Even with health insurance coverage, patients with low SES in urban and rural areas remain disadvantaged in terms of timely access to care, presumably because of disparities in health‐care resources and health literacy. 34 Consistent with earlier findings in the United States, the diagnosis and treatment of appendicitis may be delayed in rural residents with comorbidities as a result of resource constraints and low quality of care in rural areas. 35 The accurate and timely diagnosis of appendicitis in the presence of atypical symptoms for common infections of the gastrointestinal tract may be challenging; the lack of advanced equipment and adequate skills among rural providers may further delay treatment among rural residents with other comorbidities. 36 Chronic conditions such as diabetes may also influence the function of the appendix and adjacent organs, thereby exacerbating the complications of appendicitis. 37 Another plausible explanation is the low quality of care and the inadequate management of diabetes or chronic conditions in rural areas. Rural residents from communes bordering Cambodia were at a higher risk of perforated appendix than other rural residents. Compared with rural residents from other inland communes, these patients are poorer and are required to travel larger distances to district‐ or province‐level hospitals for treatment. Furthermore, rural residents who had low‐level providers, such as commune health stations or district hospitals, as their primary source of care were at a higher risk of perforated appendix than their urban counterparts. The availability and quality of medicine, equipment, and treatment and the capabilities of medical staff in diagnosing and treating emergent surgical conditions such as appendicitis may be poorer in rural commune health stations and district hospitals than in provincial hospitals. 38 By contrast, the capabilities of medical staff in diagnosing and treating appendicitis in urban health stations and district hospitals may be more equivalent to those in provincial hospitals. In Vietnam, because rural areas have poorer service quality and low‐level providers, rural residents tend to seek care outside their residential areas, which presumably leads to a delay in their diagnosis and treatment. 39 Compared with patients who were treated at district hospitals, those who were treated at provincial hospitals had a significantly higher risk of perforated appendix. This finding has two plausible explanations. First, consistent with the results for high‐income countries, instead of receiving early treatment for appendicitis at the nearest health‐care facility, patients may choose to visit farther higher‐level hospitals, which may delay their treatment and increase the risk of perforated appendix. 36 Second, because provincial hospitals are better equipped than other service providers, patients with complications or perforated appendix may be referred or transferred to provincial hospitals. This study has some limitations. First, although we have included CCI to adjust for comorbidities, because of the inherent limitations of administrative data, such as the lack of detailed clinical information, residual confounding may still be possible. Second, the rate of perforated appendix resulting from the misdiagnosis of appendicitis may have been underestimated, thus representing another source of bias. Such underestimation may be either differential or nondifferential between urban and rural areas. No evidence is yet available regarding differential misdiagnosis rates between urban and rural areas in Dong Thap or even in Vietnam. Third, because of the heterogeneity in social, health care, and geographic characteristics, our findings may not be generalizable to other regions in Vietnam. CONCLUSION To the best of our knowledge, this is the first population‐based study to examine the disparities in access to care for appendicitis between rural and urban areas in Vietnam after the 2015 reform of the SHI program. After this reform, the overall rate of perforated appendix did not exceed that reported in neighboring more developed countries and in most of LMICs. In addition, rural residents did not have a higher risk of perforated appendix than their urban counterparts over time. However, older, male, and poor individuals had an increased risk of perforated appendix; thus, these population require further attention. Additional efforts are required to address the inadequate capacity and low quality of care in low‐level health facilities in rural areas and to ensure the availability of medications and medical supplies in low‐level service providers, particularly in commune health stations. AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS Tran‐Nguyen Nguyen: Conceptualization; data curation; formal analysis; investigation; methodology; resources; validation; visualization; writing—original draft; writing—review & editing. Yiing‐Jenq Chou: Conceptualization; investigation; resources; supervision; writing—original draft; writing—review & editing. Nicole Huang: Conceptualization; formal analysis; investigation; resources; supervision; validation; writing—original draft; writing—review & editing. CONFLICT OF INTEREST STATEMENT The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. ETHICS STATEMENT All authors comply with the journal's ethical policies. This study was granted ethical approval No. NYCU112178AE by Institutional Review Board A of National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University. The secondary data were provided by Social Security Agency of Dong Thap Province and individual identifiers are encrypted for ensuring patient anonymity and confidentiality. Supporting information Supporting Information S1 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This analysis uses data or information from Dong Thap Provincial People's Committee, Social Security Agency and Department of Health. The authors are grateful for their support. The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. Biography Nguyen Tran Nguyen, born and raised in Dong Thap Province in Vietnam's Mekong River Delta, earned a pharmacy degree from Can Tho University of Medicine and Pharmacy. He completed his master's degree in International Pharmacoeconomics and Health Economics at Cardiff University. Currently, he serves as an official in the Office of the People's Committee of Dong Thap Province, focusing on healthcare and health insurance policies. As a Ph.D. candidate in the International Health Program at National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University, his research emphasizes improving access to healthcare, mainly surgical services, to promote health equity for disadvantaged populations. REFERENCES Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supporting Information S1