Internship during Certificate Course in Medical Editing by UHS and PAME Authors: Nabiha Farasat Published: 2024 Pakistan Association of Medical Editors (PAME) in collaboration with University of Health Sciences Lahore initiated a Certificate Course in Medical Editing in 2019 and so far six batches have qualified. Later on it started an advance course as well named as Certificate in Medical Journalism for Editors (CMJE).1 The second four days contact session of this CMJE course includes spending one day each at the three leading Impact Factor Journals in Karachi i.e. Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences, Journal of Pakistan Medical Association and Journal of College of Physicians & Surgeons Pakistan. CPSP is an important partner in this training course. Ours was the first batch of the internship program from June 15th to June 18th 2022.2 The purpose is to create a step-by-step approach towards Master’s Degree program. The objectives of this internship were to study the working of these impact factor journals in Pakistan which all follow different business models, acquaint with their management and publication process, and develop professional links. Twelve (12) participants (details mentioned in Table-I) visited and spent a day each at the Journal of College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan (JCPSP), Journal of Pakistan Medical Association (JPMA), and Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences (PJMS) where they were briefed about their functioning by the respective journal editorial staff. Names of participants in this internship programme are presented in Table-I while their affiliation and province to which they belonged are covered in Table-II. Table-IList of Participants in the Internship programmeSr. No:NameCity1.Dr. Abubakar Ali SaadDG Khan2.Dr. Afshan ShahidLahore3.Prof. Mariyah HidayatLahore4.Dr. Memoona MansoorIslamabad5.Dr. Mukhtar MehboobQuetta6.Dr. Nabiha FarasatQuetta7.Prof. Nadia NaseemLahore8.Dr. Neelofar YousafLahore9.Dr. Noor-i-KiranFaisalabad10.Dr. Rehana KhadimRawalpindi11.Dr. Wajid JawaidKarachi12.Dr. Ghulam MustafaRahim Yar Khan List of Participants in the Internship programme Table-IIParticipants and their affiliation.ProvinceTotal ParticipantsInstitutesPunjab61. Professor, Editor-in-Chief Biomedica, UHS2. Professor, Associate Editor at ESCULAPIO, official journal of Services Institute Medical Sciences, Lahore3.Associate Professor, Joint Editor at Shaikh Zayed Medical College, Rahim Yar Khan4. Professor, Editor Journal of UCMD at the University of Lahore5. Professor of Cardiology at DG Khan Medical College.6. ABWA Medical College, FaisalabadSindh11. Dow Medical College, KarachiIslamabad21. Managing Editor, Pakistan Armed Forces Medical Journal, Rawalpindi.2. Islamabad Medical and Dental College, IslamabadBalochistan21. Professor at Bolan Medical College, Quetta2. Benazir Hospital, Quetta Participants and their affiliation. After visiting these journal offices, detailed briefing and discussions, the participants prepared a detailed report based on their observations highlighting the positive aspects besides giving suggestions for improvement if any. They also highlighted how they are going to implement in their respective journals what they have learnt during this internship. Group leaders made their presentations at the joint session held at the CPSP Campus on June 18th 2024 which were later supplemented by input from other group members. Editors of all the above mentioned IF Journals and some of their editorial staff were also present on this occasion. It provided an excellent opportunity to the participants to learn how to run and manage a successful journal and also ensure its sustained publication in the long run. A summary of participants’ observations about these journals is presented in Table-III. Prof. Irshad Waheed Secretary College of Physicians & Surgeons Pakistan was the chief guest in the concluding session and joined the candidates in the Group Photograph. Table-IIIThe comparison of three Impact factor journal.Journals QualitiesJPMAPJMSJCPSPEstablished195319841992Impact Factor,1.0021.21.024CategoryXWXH-Index485249Acceptance &31%15%35%Rejection Rate169%85%65%ICMJE Criteria3YesYesYesPeer review processDouble-blindOpen Peer Review systemDouble-blindResearch publicationsAll types of studiesAll studies except KAP Surveys, animal studiesExcept KAP, Narrative and Survey all otherAuthorship ruleScientist, 6 or moreOnly 4 authors allowed in most casesMBBS, BDS up to 6Waiver Policy50% discount to student, reviewer on requestReviewers get discount on requestNoPrivileges of ReviewersCertificates, trainingDiscount to Reviewers in publication charges, for them processing fee is waived of, Books, Certificates, cash, Registration for training, courses, conferences, workshopsCertificates, paymentWithdrawal Policy50% payment after peer reviewAfter peer review BLACK LISTAt any stage without any actionFinancial resources33000 processing + publication feeRs. 5,000 processing + Rs. 30,000 publication charges20000 processing + publication fee The comparison of three Impact factor journal. Group photograph with Prof. Irshad Waheed Secretory CPSP, Karachi (18.6.22). CONCLUSION Dedication, sincerity, and collaborative work are the keys to the success of JCPSP, JPMA, and PJMS. PJMS stands first in its administrative work, incentives/waivers policy, workshops conduction, and conferences for the medical fraternity. JCPSP has a lenient authors withdrawal policy, an internal review policy, and best authorship rules. Commendable policies of JPMA include student corners, publications of KAP studies, Narrative Review, Experimental Animal studies, and Lab Diagnostics. It is very gratifying that PJMS and JPMA promote journalism by providing training to students and healthcare professionals. REFERENCES