Fire effects on phytolith carbon sequestration Authors: Rencheng Li, Zhitao Gu, Richard S Vachula, Haiyan Dong, Mengtong Xu, Xiaofang Chen, Bin Xu, Yunwu Sun Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractPhytolith have been recognized as an important soil bioavailable Si source for plants, as well as a sink of C and heavy metals in soils. Though the impacts of fire and heat on phytolith sequestration of some nutrients (phosphorus, potassium) and heavy metals have been addressed, little attention has been paid to fire’s effects on phytolith carbon sequestration. In this study, the carbon and dissolved Si content of phytoliths extracted from 6 common grass species and their burned ashes, as well as phytoliths collected from different areas (burned, transitional, and unburned) of a pine forest, were compared to characterize the effects of open fire on phytolith carbon content, solubility, and carbon sequestration. The carbon content and Si dissolution of ashed phytoliths varied between plant species, and differed with phytoliths from modern plants. The topsoil phytoliths had increased carbon content, and generally decreased solubility across the gradient of unburned, transitional, and burned pine forest. We therefore conclude that open fire can cause changes in phytolith related carbon content and solubility, as well as its preservation in soils. This study provides new perspective on the effects of open fire on phytolith carbon sequestration and its estimation.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1038/s41598-024-81246-9.Keywords: Phytolith, Dissolved silicon, Carbon sequestration, FireSubject terms: Carbon cycle, Element cycles, Natural hazards Introduction Natural fires can have severe impacts on ecosystems, including the alteration of ecosystem productivity, biodiversity, and functioning, which often impact soil biogeochemistry, plant communities, human health, and animal populations1,2. Investigation and monitoring of fire effects on ecosystem elements like biodiversity, runoff, water quality and water supply3,4, as well as soil composition and nutrition5,6, can provide the basis for ecosystem restoration and management decisions. Soil composition and nutrition changes due to fire are often attributed to the input of fire-derived ashes composed of charcoal, phytolith, and mineral elements. The biogeochemical effects of fire ash on major elements such as C, N and P have been broadly studied across various climate regions7. Black carbon has a longer residence time in soil than non-burned C is thus considered to act as a long-term C sink7. SiO2 is an important component of ash, accounting for example for approximately 56.2% of rice straw ash by weight8. Phytolith is primarily composed of SiO2 and H2O, but also contains smaller organic components and various inorganic mineral elements9,10. In recent research, phytolith has been recognized as an important bioavailable Si source of soil, as well as an overlooked mechanism of C and heavy metal sequestration in soils11–16. Heat has an important influence on the dissolution properties of phytolith by affecting organic removal and surface modification, which alters elemental cycling in phytolith12,17. Therefore, an increasing number of studies have focused on the effects of fire and heat on the chemical composition and dissolution properties of phytolith. The physical and chemical properties of phytoliths might be altered by fire and heat. The physical features of phytolith (e.g. morphology, colour and opacity, refractive index, auto-fluorescence and molecular surface properties detectable by Raman spectroscopy and auto-fluorescence) are shown to change when subjected to high temperatures18–22. Burning of plant tissue activates simultaneous and successive processes, e.g., dehydration, decomposition, carbonization, volatilization and crystallization, which target organic matter, silica, or their associated substances. These processes could cause some heavy metal elements (As, Pb, Zn) to become encapsulated and/or absorbed with silica phases14,17,23. Upon heating to temperatures above 200℃ water molecules start to form from the surface hydroxyl groups of phytolith. The hydroxyl groups are completely stripped off at 600℃24. Phytoliths contain small amounts of organic components termed phytOC (phytolith occluded carbon) which ranges from 0.1 to 5.8%16,25–29. Phytoliths that have been exposed to fire often become darkened in color as compared to clear, unburned phytoliths18,19,28,30. The darkened color of burned phytoliths is probably derived from the oxidation of phytolith-occluded carbon (PhytOC)18. However, some authors have proposed that the darkened color is not generated from the occluded carbon in phytoliths but rather that black carbon is adsorbed by phytoliths exposed to open flames21,28. As phytoliths are important sources/carriers of nutrients (e.g., K and P)12,31, a fast-reacting Si source for soils and crops32,33, a notable tool of archaeobotany and paleoenvironmental reconstruction9,34,35, and important agents for the sequestration of organic matter and CO213,36–38, it is worthwhile to know how fire affects the dissolution of phytoliths. Phytolith solubility links to phytolith preservation in soils and sediments, as well as the cycling of elements in phytolith39–41. Fire/heat can change their solubility12,17,39. The effect of fire on phytolith solubility is related to temperature, phytolith elemental compositions, morphotypes and the plant species from which the phytolith are produced. When temperature increases, crystallization of silanol groups will form siloxane bonds, making the surface hydrophobic. This reaction reduces adsorption of water molecules on the surface and prevents the breakage of the surface siloxane bonds12,42. High treatment temperature can result in a re-arrangement and crystallization of silica in phytolith, decreasing its solubility. The release of Si and other elements (such as Si, K, P, Pb, As) in rice straw ash (treated in a muffle furnace) and biochar from pyrolysis increases with increasing treatment temperature. This is likely because the decomposition of organic matter increases the surface exposure of phytolith silica and thereby decreases its protective role (surface coverage, hydrophobicity). But, it is also likely a tradeoff beyond a certain temperature because of the increased crystallization of phytolith. Phytolith affected by fire and heat have different dissolution properties as a result of their variable chemical and physical forms11,12,17,31,38. The phytoliths of wheat extracted by dry ashing in a muffle furnace at 500℃ were less stable than unburnt phytoliths, and different morphotypes dissolved rather un-uniformly39. Soil organic matter collected from spruce, beech forest and peat were treated in a furnace at 350℃ and 500℃ to obtain black carbon and white ash, respectively, and their Si releases were compared. The Si release data showed fire can enhance solubility of biogenic silica43. Together, these observations led to the hypothesis that fire could have effect on phytolith carbon sequestration by changing its solubility and carbon content. To date, the transformation, morphology, and dissolution of phytolith affected by fire and heat have not been comprehensively addressed. Biochar, which is mainly comprised of phytolith, is a major component of the geological Si–C cycle44. Phytolith occluded carbon (PhytOC) is considered as a form of long-term carbon sequestration in soils25. Previous dissolution experiments showed that phytolith mixed with ash (produced from organic matter ashed in a furnace), black carbon, and/or soil brought exogenous and secondary silicon to be involved in the dissolution process12,17,39,43. Little is known about the effect of open fire on the carbon content and solubility of pure phytolith28,39, or what happens to this occluded carbon during vegetation fires45. Although the darken color of burned phytolith is probably resulted from adsorption of black carbon28, it is unclear how the adsorption of carbon influences the phytolith carbon sequestration. To unequivocally discern that fire effect on phytolith carbon sequestration, the carbon content and solubility of phytoliths extracted from 6 common grass species and their burned ashes are analyzed and compared to phytoliths collected from topsoils in a pine forest site burned by a forest fire, as well as transitional and unburned areas, to study the effect of open fire on phytolith carbon content, solubility, and carbon sequestration. Materials and methods Regional setting Grass and topsoil samples were collected from the Guilin Institute of Agricultural Sciences, the Guangxi Institute of Botany (Chinese Academy of Sciences), and a burned area of pine forest in Huangshankou Village in the Lingui District of Guilin City (110°7’20"E, 25°14’56"N), respectively. Guilin City is located in southwest China (Fig. 1). It is in the subtropical monsoon climate region, and is affected by both the SW maritime monsoon from the Indian Ocean and the SE maritime monsoon from the western Pacific Ocean. It has an annual mean temperature of 18.8 °C and total annual precipitation of 1874 mm. The long-term lowest and highest monthly mean temperatures are 15.6 °C for winter and 23.0 °C for summer46. Vegetation in the region is characterized by subtropical evergreen broad-leaved forest. The burned area sampled was on a mountain with an altitude less than 300 m. It has sandstone soil, and hosts a secondary coniferous forest composed of Pinus massoniana Lamb, Quercus L. Cunninghamia lanceolata (Lamb.) Hook (Chinese fir) and fern species. Pinus massoniana Lamb is the dominant plant species. Meanwhile, grass Panicoideae species, such Imperata cylindrica (L.) Beauv., Miscanthus floridulus (Lab.) Warb. ex Schum et Laut., and Setaria palmifolia (J.Koenig) Stapf. are widely distributed outside of forest stands. After the wildfire event occurred in 2021, the burned area’s vegetation was dominated by ferns, as well as a few shrub and Panicodeae species. Map of sampling locations(Satellite imagery comes from Esri, © OpenStreetMap contributors, TomTom, Garmin, Foursquare, METI/NASA, USGS). Sampling and analysis Sample preparation About 500 g of mature leaves of 3 crops (rice, maize and sugarcane) and 3 common grasses were collected in December, 2020 (grass species are listed in Table 1). These six grasses are all common subtropical plant species. These 3 crops were experimental plants, and provided (identified by agro-technician Zhisi Shi) from Guilin Institute of Agricultural Sciences, and. Three wild grasses were collected in roadside in Guangxi Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences. These three sampled grasses were transferred to the laboratory and submitted for identification by Professor Guangzhao Li (Guangxi Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences). To maintain the representativeness of sampled leaves, they were obtained from more than 10 individual plants grown within a 10 m2 area28. Table 1Descriptions of sampling grass species.Grass speciesSubfamilyGenusSampling locationOryza latifolia Desv.Oryzoideae Oryza Guilin Institute of Agricultural Sciences(110°18’59"E, 25°4’19"N)Zeamays L.Panicoideae Zea Saccharum officinarum Linn.Panicoideae Saccharum Miscanthus floridulus (Lab.) Warb. ex Schum et Laut.Panicoideae Miscanthus Guangxi Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences(110°18’35"E, 25°4’57"N)Setaria palmifolia (Koen.) Stapf.Panicoideae Setaria Imperata cylindrica (L.) Beauv.Panicoideae Imperata Descriptions of sampling grass species. Guilin Institute of Agricultural Sciences (110°18’59"E, 25°4’19"N) Guangxi Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences (110°18’35"E, 25°4’57"N) The sampling scheme of soil and sediment in the forest fire site is detailed by Wen et al.47. Samples of soils and gully sediments were taken from different slope positions of the mountain on which pine forest was burned in Huangshankou Village. A sample was also taken from an unburned forest 1–2 km away from the fire perimeter as a control. The sample from the unburned area is not located downwind of where the fire occurred based on the northeasterly prevailing wind direction. Samples were also taken from the transition area (Fig. 1), or the burned-unburned forest boundary, which spanned 200 m in this study48. The sampled forest stands in the burned-unburned transition area have a similar vegetation type as the burnt forest stands that were sampled. The transitional samples were only collected in the southern direction because the burned mountain is surrounded by the village, and the other direction burned completely. All samples were taken using a 5-point sampling method (five points from four vertices and the diagonal intersection of a quadrilateral), and 1–2 cm thick topsoil subsamples of the five points were mixed to form one sample, so as to maintain sampling representativeness. The plant litters were removed from the topsoils before sampling from the transitional area and unburned area. A total of 8 samples were obtained from the burned, unburned, and transitional areas in 2021 (detailed information is provided in Table 2). Table 2Descriptions of forest sampling sites.SamplenumberSampling typeTopographyVegetationBs1Soil from burned areaOn top of the hillPine, grassBs2Soil from burned areaSlopePine, fernBs3Soil from burned areaValleyPine, fernBs4gully sediment from burned areaValley, south of the burned areaTs1Soil from transitional areaSlope, southwest of the burned areaPine, fernTs2Soil from transitional areaSlope, south of the burnedPine, Quercus L.Ts3Soil from transitional areaValley areaPine, Quercus L.Us1Soil from unburned areaSlope, northeast of the burned areaPine, fern Descriptions of forest sampling sites. Phytolith extraction and classification All collected plant leaves were cleaned, dried, and cut into less than 5 mm pieces before phytolith extraction. The leaves were divided into two parts, with one part being used to extract phytoliths (as unburned phytolith). The second part of the leaves were used for open burning to obtain ashed phytolith. All grass leaves were burned on tinfoil under open air conditions to generate ashes (at approximately 420 °C38), , the ashes were collected to extract ashed phytolith28. The soil and sediment samples were dried in an oven (70 °C), then the roots were picked out prior to grinding samples. The dried and ground samples were passed through a 60-mesh screen (250 μm). Phytoliths for carbon content and dissolution analyses were extracted using a microwave digestion method modified from Parr18 and Parr et al.26. A relatively high temperature (200 °C) for the microwave digestion was chosen, and a two-step oxidation of phytolith with H2SO4 and K2Cr2O7 was used28. The specific steps of sample preparation were as follows: (1) Weigh cut plant leaves (~ 1 g), ashes (~ 0.5 g), and soil (sediment) (~ 5 g), and load each sample into the digestion tubes; (2) Add 15 ml HNO3 (superior grade) into the tubes to start the first microwave digestion, (3) Add 5 ml HNO3 (excellent grade pure) and 10 ml 30% H2O2 for the second digestion step (for microwave digestion system conditions, refer to Dong et al.,28), then transfer samples to centrifuge tubes and wash them with distilled water (at least 3 times, 2500 rpm, 5 min); (4) Add 2.5 ml concentrated H2SO4 and 2.5ml K2Cr2O7 (0.8 mol/L), heat the digestion vessel in a hot water bath (90 °C for 90 min) to test whether the extraneous organic material was removed completely, then wash with distilled water until the solutions are pH neutral. This step was repeated two times. (5) The ashed phytolith samples were separated into two subsamples. One subsample was bleached using NaClO3 to monitor its influence on the darkened color of burned phytolith. The bleached samples were shaken every 12 h, and let to stand for 48 h. After this process, the samples were washed until the solutions pH values were neutral. The phytoliths obtained were termed ‘ashed phytolith with bleaching’ samples. The phytoliths for morphology and assemblage analysis were extracted from ashes and soils (sediments) by using the wet ash method49. The extraction follows these steps: the removal of organic matter by H2O2, carbonates by HCl, and clay by decantation. A heavy liquid floatation extraction technique was applied for the soil samples. The extracted samples were identified under a Leica DM2500 biomicroscope at a magnification of ×400. Phytolith purity (no visible organic matter in the matrix) was noted for each sample. Phytolith morphology classification was conducted following published references47,50,51. All morphotypes were named according to the International Code for Phytolith Nomenclature 2.052. Determination of phytolith carbon content Carbon content in the phytolith samples was determined by an alkali-capacity spectrophotometry method53. For each extracted phytolith sample, 0.8 mol/l potassium dichromate was used to examine the extraneous organic materials outside of the phytolith cells, and to ensure complete removal of organic matter54,55. The specific steps are described by Li et al.29 and are as follows: The dried phytolith (0.01 g) was put in a 10 ml PTFE tube, 0.5 ml NaOH (10 mol L− 1) was added and left for 12 h. The samples were transferred to colourimetric tubes. C6H12O6 was used to prepare an organic C standard solution (0. 90,909 g L− 1), with 0, 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, and 2.0 ml of the standard placed in colourimetric tubes and the volumes brought up to 2.0 ml with ultrapure water. 1.0 ml K2Cr2O7 (0.8000 mol L− 1) and 4.6 ml H2SO4 were added to each phytolith sample and standard solution aliquots, and they were heated at 98 °C for 1 h. After cooling, all the samples were volumed to 25 ml and centrifuged (2500 r/min, 10 min). The supernatant of each sample and standard solution was placed into a 1 cm optical path cuvette, and the absorbance was measured at 590 nm using a photometer. The standard solution absorbances were used to plot a calibration curve and establish the regression equation to calculate the organic carbon content of the phytolith samples. Determination of dissolved Si CaCl2-extractable Si content (CaCl2-Si) is used to assess the bioavailable Si pool in soils40,56. We measured it through a kinetic extraction using a solid: liquid ratio of 0.03 g:50 mL(0.01 M CaCl2). For each sample, 30 mg of extracted phytolith powder was placed into an 80 ml plastic centrifuge tube. The phytoliths in the tube were shaken in 50 ml of CaCl2 solution at 20℃ for 1, 3, 5, 7 and 14 days. At the end of each extraction, the content of Si was determined using the molybdate blue method57,58. A reagent-blank experiment was also performed according to the aforementioned procedure. All analytical measurements were conducted in triplicate. The absorbance of samples processed was measured at 700 nm using a photometer. The absorbance data of standard Si solution were used to plot a calibration standard curve and calculate the content of DSi in the samples. The detailed experimental process is explained by Wang et al.58. Determination of dissolved Si An Independent Samples t-test (95% Confidence interval) and Paired-Sample t-test were performed to assess the statistical significance of the difference between the carbon content of ashed and unburned phytolith samples, and topsoil phytolith from different area of forest fire, respectively. Linear regression analyses were performed to reveal the relationship between the release rate and time of phytolith dissolution. Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS 19.0 software. Results Phytolith morphology and assemblage The six grass species produced different phytolith morphotypes and assemblages (see Supplementary Fig.S1). The darken burned phytolith varied with phytolith morphotype and the plant species burned. There were no visible plant tissues or microcharcoal particles in the phytolith slides after microwave digestion, suggesting that the elimination of non-related carbon was robust and complete28. The darkened color of burned phytolith became weakened after the bleaching process (Fig. 2). Burned and unburned phytoliths from six grass leaves. A: Unburned phytolith; B: Ashed phytolith with bleaching; C: Ashed phytolith. a: BULLIFORM FLABELLATE; b: BILOBATE; c: HAIR; d: RONDEL; e: ACUTE BULBOSUS; f, ELONGATE ENTIRE; g: ELONGATE DENTATE; h: SPHERIOID PSILATE; i: Scale of field of view = 50 μm. The phytoliths in the forest topsoil were dominated by BLOCKY IRREGULAR, TABULAR ELONGATE UNSCULPTED, TABULAR IRREGULAR, and TRIANGULAR PRISMATIC and had relatively low proportions of BULLIFORM FLABELLATE, BILOBATE, ACUTE BULBOUS. BILOBATE had high proportions of GSSCP (Grass silica short-cell phytoliths) present. Few SPHEROID PSILATE, BLOCKY RIDGED, BLOCKY SCROBICULATE phytoliths were identified. Sediment samples from the burned area had higher proportions of BULLIFORM FLABELLATE, SADDLE, and ELONGATE relative to the soil samples. The transitional and unburned areas had higher proportions of BILOBATE phytolith than were present in the burned area. There were more micro-charcoal particles in samples from the burned area than the transitb1ional and unburned areas (Fig. 3, Supplementary Fig.S2). A: phytolith morphotypes from forest topsoil samples. SADDLE; B: BILOBATE; C: CUBIC; D-E: BULLIFORM FLABELLATE; F: ELONGATE AMPLIATED ECHINATE; G: ELONGATE CAVATE TERMINAL; H: ELONGATE GRANULATE I: HAIR; J: MACROHAIR; K-L: ACUTE BULBOSUS; M-N: SPHEROID PSILATE; O-Q: TABULAR IRREGUALR; R: STOMA; S: BLOCKY IRREGULAR; T: BLOCKY SCROBICULATE; U: BLOCKY RIDGED; V: TABULAR ELONGATE UNSCULPTED; W-X: SCLEREID; Y: TRIANGULAR PRISMATIC; Z: ELONGATE PSILATE; Aa: TRACHEARY ANNULATE; Ab: Charcoal; Ac: Scale of the field of view = 50 μm. Phytolith carbon content The phytolith occluded carbon (PhytOC) of the six modern plants ranged from 0.2 to 1.3%. The ashed phytoliths that were unbleached and bleached had carbon content values that varied between 1.1 and 2.8%, and 0.4–2.1%, respectively. The average carbon content present difference (p = 0.00, n = 14, Paired Sample t-test) between unburned and ashed phytoliths from these plant species. The carbon content of each individual plant species showed an increase trend from unburned phytolith (from modern plant) to ashed phytolith with bleaching, to ashed phytolith (Fig. 4). Carbon content of phytoliths from 6 grass leaves varied with ashing (under open fire condition) and subsequent bleaching treatments. The carbon contents of soil phytolith samples from the forest fire (burned) area ranged from 0.78 to 1.64%, and exhibited relatively higher values (p = 0.029, n = 4, An Independent Samples t-test) than those of samples from the transitional and unburned areas. The carbon content and microcharcoal concentrations were much higher in phytolith samples from burned areas than those from unburned and transitional areas (Fig. 5). Carbon content of phytolith samples from the forest fire burned area (Bs1,Bs2, Bs3, Bs4), transitional area (Ts1, Ts2, Ts3) and unburned area (Us1). Dissolved silicon The blank control sample showed very low DSi content across the time period of analysis, indicating that the samples were not contaminated during the experimental process. The dissolved Si concentrations increased with the progression of test days for all of phytolith samples. Across the dissolution period, the ashed phytoliths generally contained lower DSi contents relative to phytoliths from modern unburned plant leaves. As examples, the DSi content of ashed phytolith decreased from 49.85 to 17.39 mg/kg, and from 56.28 to 19.07 mg/kg, for Oryza latifolia Desv. and Zea mays L. on the 14th day, respectively. Nevertheless, phytoliths of Saccharum officinarum Linn. showed no apparent difference between ashed and unburned samples, and Imperata cylindrica (L.) Beauv. had increased DSi after the burned treatment as opposed to the same pattern produced by the unburned treatment for the other plants (Fig. 6, Supplementary Table S1). The slope coefficients of functions fitted to the relationships between DSi release of phytoliths from 6 six grass leaves and CaCl2-extraction days ranged from 0.65 to 2.55. The range of these coefficients decreased from 0.27 to 1.03 with the implementation of the open combustion treatment (Fig. 6), showing the ashed phytolith procedure decreased the DSi release rate. Dissolved silicon release rate of unashed and ashed phytoliths from 6 grass species, as a function of time subjected to successive extraction treatments with 0.01 M CaCl2. Note: Red = burned phytolith; Blue = unburned phytolith; Black = Blank control. The phytoliths of topsoil samples from the burned area showed different release rates of Si. For example, sample Bs1 had the lowest release rate of Si content. The released silicon from forest fire (burned) and non-fire (transitional and unburned) areas increased as a function of the laboratory reaction time, though the unburned and transitional area phytoliths exhibited greater rates of silicon dissolution in the first five days (Fig. 7a, Supplementary Table S2). The slope coefficients of functions fit to the relationships between DSi release of soil phytolith and extraction days ranged from 1.50 to 1.63 for burned area samples, and from 2.22 to 3.10 for unburned areas samples (transitional and unburned areas), showing that Si release rate was generally smaller in the burned area samples relative to the unburned samples (Fig. 7b). Dissolved silicon release rate of the phytolith in topsoil samples from forest fire burned, unburned, and transitional areas as a function of time subjected to successive extractions with 0.01 M CaCl2. There were some differences of dissolution rates observed among the burned area samples (Bs1, Bs2 and Bs3) (Fig. 7, Supplementary Table S2). Negative correlation relationships (r = 0.48, n = 20, p = 0.03 < 0.05) existed between the slope coefficients of functions (fitted to relationships between DSi release and extraction days) and the carbon content of phytolith samples. Discussion Fire effects on phytolith morphology and assemblages The proportion of darkened phytolith varied between plant species and could be due to the differing combustion intensity and completeness of each plant fuel59,60. Fuel characteristics are also influenced by texture, surface and composition characteristics of the plant tissues. The complete combustion of some plant leaves could cause the phytolith absorbed less black carbon and low proportions of burned phytolith28. The burned phytolith morphotypes were present in these plant ashes supported the darkened phytoliths gave accurate results for freshly burned material18,21. However, the blackish color does not necessarily reflect heating. Some investigators believed blacken phytolith can be phytoliths extracted from reference plant material through wet oxidation22,61,62. Furthermore, Wilding et al.63 suggested that the blackish color observed on some fossil phytoliths can also be an iron or manganese coating. The burned and unburned blacken of phytolith in soils and sediments could be distinguished with its occluded carbon content or composition detection signal if the blacken color is from carbon adsorbed during the combustion28. The sampled forest vegetation was well represented by the topsoil phytolith assemblages. The dominant BLOCKY IRREGULAR, TABULAR ELONGATE UNSCULPTED with BLOCKY SCROBICULATE, BLOCKY RIDGED are characteristic of coniferous plants34,47,51,64,65. The TABULAR IRREGULAR and TRIANGULAR PRISMATIC are produced from broad leaved plants49,66, and pteridophytes65, respectively. These two morphotypes of phytoliths were also dominant, correctly indicating that they dominate the vegetation of the pine forest. The sediment samples from the burned area had greater proportions of BULLIFORM FLABELLATE, SADDLE, ELONGATE relative to the soil samples from the same area, suggesting that grass phytoliths were over represented in these soils due to taphonomic processes. BILOBATE is the major phytolith morphotype of the GSSCP and reflects the grass Panicoideae species that is widely distributed in southeast Asia tropical areas. Broadly, the vegetation recorded by the soil phytoliths in this study was consistent with a secondary coniferous forest composed of Pinus massoniana Lamb, Quercus L. Cunninghamia lanceolata (Lamb.) Hook (Chinese fir) and fern species. The fire had no apparent effects on phytolith morphologies and assemblages in topsoil from forest fire area, besides the increased proportions of microcharcoal particles19,47. Fire increases the carbon content of phytolith There is a controversial discussion on how to determine the carbon content of phytoliths (over-extraction vs. under-extraction)67. Santos and Alexandre68 worry that the high PhytOC values may derive from remnant organic contaminants on the surface of extracted phytoliths. Song et al.13 considered that the low PhytOC values were caused by oxidation and over-extraction. The PhytOC of 0.2–1.3% for six modern plant species were low relative to the high value range (0.2-5.8%, referred to16,29), and were also relatively low when compared the values reported for the same species (as examples, 1.93–2.46% for rice55, 3.88–12.35% for sugarcane26) was resulted from the increased temperature of our microwave digestion and the two-step oxidation of phytoliths with K2Cr2O728. The inner OC (here PhytOC) might be decomposed at lower rates38. As a result, the carbon content of phytolith should decrease because of the decomposition of its inner organic matter. However, the carbon content in ashed phytolith samples showed higher values relative to the PhytOC in modern plants and the ashed phytolith with bleaching samples. This result can be explained by carbon adsorbing to phytoliths exposed to open flames28. Although fire and heat normally decompose extraneous organic matter and increase surface exposure of phytolith to cause increased phytolith solubility, our data showed the phytoliths ashed under open conditions had decreased solubility, suggesting the black carbon adsorbed by phytolith caused this decrease. A similar experiment demonstrated that the surface charge of ashed phytolith samples derived from open burning determines the adsorption/retention of elemental arsenic onto the phytolith surface17. The PhytOC content of topsoil can also vary between microhabitats as a function of vegetation type, topography, and soil physicochemical properties because these factors influence the input, transportation, and preservation of phytolith13,16,53. In this study, all sampling points were from the same sandstone soil, and were deemed to have similar physicochemical properties except for pH. The lack of correlation between pH and phytolith carbon content suggests that soil pH has little effect on the carbon content of phytoliths. PhytOC differs between plant species because they produce variable phytolith morphotypes and assemblages9,25,54. Differences in topsoil phytolith carbon content between the burned and the unburned areas could reflect the influence of local community compositions of vegetation and micro-topography on phytolith assemblages. Although cell wall phytoliths have considerably higher carbon concentrations than lumen types, the relationship between carbon content and phytolith assemblage is difficult to resolve9,29,67. Us1,Ts3, Bs3 have nearly the same phytolith assemblages and corresponding vegetation, but have different carbon contents. Thus, the carbon content variations of samples between burned and unburned areas cannot be attributed to vegetation inputs or phytolith preservation. In addition, wind transportation probably mixes ashed phytolith and microcharcoal distributions between the burned and transitional/unburned areas47. Sample Us1 from the unburned area is located northeast of the burned area, and perpendicular to the prevailing northeast wind, and covered by thick litters. Therefore, it is reasonably believed that fire had less effect on the phytoliths of Us1 than for other samples. Although samples from the transitional area (Ts1 and Ts2) are downwind, the sampling sites were covered with thick litter which could have acted like a mat to prevent ashed phytolith and microcharcoal particles from penetrating into the soils. Furthermore, they are located on the leeward slope where forest vegetation is closed, thereby reducing the input of ashed phytolith and microcharcoal particles into the forest soils. Therefore, in-situ deposition of ashed phytolith and microcharcoal likely resulted in their highest concentrations resulting in the burned area. The increased phytOC values of topsoils from the burned area might have resulted from the contribution of ashed phytolith with adsorbed black carbon. However, the darken burned phytolith varied with phytolith morphotype and the plant species burned. There would be variability in carbon adsorption of burned phytoliths due to their specific plant morphotypes. Meanwhile, the forest fire temperature differs with their vegetation composition. It is limited to know how the carbon adsorption of burnt phytoliths change with the temperature of plant burning and forest fire. This concern needs to test the variability carbon adsorption of phytoliths from different plant burning ashes and forest fire topsoil. Fire decreases phytolith solubility Phytolith solubility is influenced by its SSA (specific surface area), morphology, chemical composition, and the taphonomic conditions to which it has been subjected13,17,39,41,69. As different plant species produce phytolith with different morphologies, assemblages, and chemical compositions, the phytoliths from our plant leaf samples exhibit variable solubilities. Phytoliths with different dissolution rates coexist in soil: quickly dissolved fresh phytoliths and slowly dissolved aged ones. The CaCl2 extracted-Si is considered to be controlled by the pool of fresh phytoliths in soil15. The phytoliths of the 6 plant leaves we analyzed showed decreased solubility after open burning, suggesting that the adsorption of black carbon decreased their surface exposure and thereby protectsed the phytolith by increasing its hydrophobicity. The negative correlation of DSi release rate with carbon content also demonstrates that the carbon content influenced the dissolution of ashed phytolith. Alternatively, rising temperatures could cause dehydroxylation of the silanol group, leading to more siloxane bonds and a more hydrophobic surface with reduced adsorption of water molecules and the prevention of siloxane bond rupture42. However, the Si dissolution of plants ashed in a furnace (phytoliths mixed with ash) and bio-char typically increased with temperature due to organic matter decomposition which increased the surface exposure of phytolith silica and decreased beyond a certain temperature because of the increased crystallization of phytolith12,17,31,38,43. These reports are at odds with our results but can be reconciled as follows: Firstly, the reported samples were always treated in a furnace through a series of increasing temperatures. The samples would have been oxidized homogeneously and ashed completely when the furnace temperature was set to a high value (for example, 550℃). Secondly, the furnace-treated samples would be less disturbed than phytoliths burned in situ. The homogeneous, complete, and in situ ash process will be conducive to decreasing the adsorption of black carbon, and increasing the surface exposure of phytolith. Further, more black carbon would be produced and adsorbed by phytolith in an open fire because of heterogeneous burning conditions (such as temperature, humidity, airflow, micro-topography etc.). In addition, the ashes of plant and soil organic matter contain not only phytolith silica, but also plant dissolved silicon, or other bio-silica which might be involved in the thermal reaction. Soil organic matter ash probably includes other bASi (biogenic amorphous silica) pools including protistic bASi (produced by protists), bacterial bASi (produced by bacteria), fungal bASi (produced by fungi), phytogenic bASi (produced by plants), and zoogenic bASi (formed in animals)70.The size, surface and/or elemental compositions of these different bASi pools could cause the dissolution rate of ashed phytolith to increase, as has been reported by some researchers17,39,43. Furthermore, dissolved Si in ash and bio-char is not only represented by the extractable phytoliths but also fragile silica structures, as the majority of phytolith might be stored in fragile silica structures71. Thus, it is possible and reasonable that phytolith ashed in open fire adsorbs black carbon and decreases the solubility of the phytolith. Future work will study the corresponding balance between phytolith dissolution and release of C. Phytolith solubility varied with between plant species39,55,72. Like we discussed for carbon content, the local plant community composition and micro-topography may influence each sample’s phytolith assemblage, and could thereby cause its solubility to differ between burned and unburned areas. Samples from the burned area did not have lower phytolith solubility compared to those from unburned areas before 5 days. This can be explained by the presence of two different pools in a sample, ashed phytoliths and un-ashed phytoliths. The un-ashed phytoliths have similar solubility and dominate the samples collected from 1 to 2 cm depth of the soil surface. Thus, the dissolution of Si content before the fifth day is determined by the pool of un-ashed phytoliths which are input and influenced by local micro-habitats. The dissolution of Si content after 5 days is possibly controlled by the pool of ashed phytoliths. Bs1 was located on the top of the mountain which has more open conditions and drier organic matter relative to other burned samples. The temperature range of a typical vegetation fire is 600–900℃, so phytolith exposed to temperatures higher than 500℃ for several hours will therefore be easily identified as burnt70. While at higher temperatures, Si crystallization of amorphous Si is observed, potentially lowering Si availability11. Therefore, phytoliths of Bs1 are probably partly crystallized and have lower Si dissolution because of the ventilated conditions and dry fuels that characterized their combustion. However, ashes contain immediately available alkali ions as well as phytolith-occluded alkali ions73. Burning and resulting burned products (ashes) can therefore increase the soil pH, which may cause phytolith dissolution and a subsequent decrease of phytolith carbon sequestration73. Our results especially highlight the need for further work focusing on how soil pH affects phytolith preservation following a forest fire to disentangle the combined effects of pH and black carbon adsorption. Fire effects on phytolith carbon sequestration and its implications PhytOC is a form of long-term carbon sequestration in soils25. Although a small quantity of PhytOC can be decreased by thermal decomposition38, open fire can cause phytolith to adsorb black carbon and increase its carbon content. The solubility rate of phytolith is related to phytolith preservation and carbon sequestration10,39,41. The black carbon adsorption of phytolith ashed in an open fire also further decreases solubility. Black carbon adsorbed to phytolith is recalcitrant to oxidation and dissolution, and so is thereby able to be preserved in soils and sediments, increasing soil carbon sequestration. Therefore, carbon estimation of forest fire and plant burning needs consider the fire effect on carbon content and solubility of phytolith, and phytolith carbon sequestration. As phytoliths represent the main fraction of bioavailable silicon in topsoils74, and fire decreased the solubility of burned phytolith, we suppose the silicon release from burned phytolith should be slowed and influence the soil available silicon pool and supply to the plant after forest fire event. Many regions and countries have banned on-site agricultural burning of straw because of views that it contributes to global CO2 and black carbon emissions. However, it is necessary to provide data quantifying the benefits and detriments of agricultural straw burning to objectively assess bans. Recent studies have demonstrated the positive effects of burning and returning burned straw to fields to recycle nutrients6,12 and as a means of sequestering phytolith carbon38. Here, our data revealed that phytoliths burned in an open fire can increase phytolith related-carbon content and decrease solubility rate, thereby improving carbon sequestration. The black carbon adsorbed by phytoliths during fires should be considered as a positive benefit of agricultural straw burning and quantified further to estimate the potential of phytolith to sequester carbon. In addition, phytoliths burned in an open fire had consistently higher carbon content and solubility which could prove a useful proxy for fire in paleoevironmental records. However, due to heterogeneities between plant species, transportation, and preservation, further work is needed to study whether the phytolith-related carbon and solubility rate could serve as paleofire indictors. Conclusions In this study, we show that burning and heat had important effects on phytolith preserved in plant ash and topsoils in an area burned by a forest fire. Burning phytoliths in an open fire increased their carbon content and decreased their solubility, with some variability between plant species. The phytoliths preserved in topsoils in burned, transitional, and unburned areas had different black carbon contents and solubilities because of preservation variations caused by local vegetation and topography. Phytoliths had higher carbon content, and generally lower solubility in the burned area relative to unburned areas (transitional and unburned). Open fire can cause phytolith to adsorb black carbon, thereby increasing its carbon content and decreasing its solubility. This process can improve phytolith carbon sequestration in soils. Ashes cause soil pH changes which probably influence preservation and phytolith solubility. To properly estimate the flux of atmospheric CO2 sequestered by soil phytoliths, black carbon adsorbed by phytoliths during fires should be considered and quantified. This research suggests on-site agricultural burning of straw can have positive benefits from the standpoint of phytolith carbon sequestration. Electronic supplementary material Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material. Supplementary Material 1 Supplementary Material 2 Acknowledgements We are grateful to Xiaobei Wei, Baifeng Cao, Cuiyu Wei and Tianxi Gan for help during the sampling and experiment. Author contributions RC Li: Supervision, conceptualization, validation, formal analyses, writing -original draft, funding acquisition. ZT Gu: Investigation, methodology, Software, Data curation. RS Vachula: Conceptualization, writing - reviewing and editing. HY Dong: Investigation, methodology, data curation, conceptualization. MT Xu, XF Chen, B Xu and YW Sun: Conceptualization, writing - reviewing and editing. All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version. Data availability The datasets generated and/or analysed during the current study are available in the [Supplementary Table.docx, Supplementary Figure. docx]. Declarations Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Contributor Information Rencheng Li, Email: lirencheng_xie@163.com. Haiyan Dong, Email: 1875864792@qq.com. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1 Supplementary Material 2 Data Availability Statement The datasets generated and/or analysed during the current study are available in the [Supplementary Table.docx, Supplementary Figure. docx].