Molecular identification of whole squids and calamari at fairs and markets in regions of Latin America Authors: Bianca Lima Paiva, Alan Erik Souza Rodrigues, Igor Oliveira de Freitas Almeida, Kamila de Fatima Silva, Manuel Haimovici, Unai Markaida, Patricia Charvet, Vicente Vieira Faria, Bruno B. Batista, Acácio Ribeiro Gomes Tomás, Luis Fernando da Silva Rodrigues-Filho, Jonathan Stuart Ready, João Bráullio de Luna Sales Published: 2024 ABSTRACT The commercial importance of cephalopods has increased considerably, being an important fishing resource. However, during the preparation for commercialization of those species, they suffer the process known as “finning” which includes removing and separating the head, arm, skin or even having the body structure cut into rings, which ends up making it difficult or often prevents the identification of the species, which can lead to replacements. In this sense, the present study aimed to use the large ribosomal region, rrnL (16S rDNA) to genetically identify cephalopod species sold in markets and fairs in Latin America. Whole and processed samples were collected from supermarkets and directly from local fishers the approximate collection location. Each generated sequence was submitted to the blastn portal for molecular comparison and included in the database for subsequent genetic identification. Our results indicate labeling errors in samples from the State of Pará that contained the species Dosidicus gigas found only in the Pacific Ocean and were generically labeled as “National Lula”. No type of substitution was found among the samples that were being sold at fairs and markets, only labeling errors. Thus, our results demonstrate the effectiveness of the rrnL for identifying species and evaluating labeling errors.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1038/s41598-024-81134-2. Introduction Fisheries are one of the main widespread global economic resources with conservative estimates that the industry sustains around 59 million jobs in the primary sectors of fishing and aquiculture1 with fisheries products representing the number one food commodity of the world2. However, this high demand for fisheries products also results in significant pressure on aquatic organisms, with many species showing significant declines in populations3 and many of the vertebrate fisheries targets or bycatch have now been classified as threatened or endangered4–6. Unfortunately, few invertebrates are evaluated and classified with regard to IUCN Red List status as the vast majority are considered Data Deficient, including cephalopods7–10. Furthermore, after petroleum products, fisheries products are the second-most product prone to intentional or unintentional substitutions11,12, a factor that exacerbates the challenges to sustainably manage stocks13. In recent decades, the commercial importance of cephalopods has grown notably in volume of trade14–19. The number of cephalopod species that are targets of commercial fisheries has grown in recent times17, and given this, they represent the third largest marine group consumed by the human population (the largest two being finfish and crustaceans)18. And when it comes to commercial value, members of the family Ommastrephidae20 represent the largest volume of commercialization and global importance6. Loliginids represent the second family of interest for global captures due to their distribution limited to the continental shelf, in tropical and temperate regions around the world, as well as the high quality of the species’ meat16,21, having a high protein value, a wide variety of essential amino acids and extremely low-fat levels, making regular consumption of the species part of healthy and balanced diets22,23. Currently, cephalopods represent about 7% of seafood production, their landings have increased since 1961, reaching a record of captured and commercialized tons in 20204. In terms of cephalopods catches and consumption, Asian, European, African and North American countries have the ten largest fishing fleets in the world17, with Spain, Italy and Japan being the largest consumers19. In South America, the jumbo flying squid, Dosidicus gigas24 has been widely explored, being exported by Peru to more than 50 countries, where several attempts are being made to diversify new products made with the species among them, canned, pre-cooked, roasted and others25. This high demand for export means that the commercialization of entire species is greatly reduced or made difficult, with the need for processing often resulting in a longer shelf life of derived products22,23. However, processing most often removes or damages diagnostic features that are important for correct species identification through traditional taxonomic characteristics26. In the case of cephalopods, there is the removal of the intestines, skin, arms, tentacles, fins and head, where the species are often cut into rings or tubes27,28, thus removing all morphological characteristics which are used to identify species as sex, or sexual maturity, a process that make all species be commercialized under the umbrella term “calamari”27,29. These modifications make taxonomic identification difficult or even impossible, making it more prone to economic fraud where highly valued species, such as those from the family Loliginidae30, are replaced by species of lower commercial value, such as those from the Ommastrephidae, which becomes a concern for the international commercial market27,28, or often, unintentional substitution, where due to lack of systematic knowledge, suppliers themselves are unable to correctly identify the species, assigning them umbrella terms that shelter many different species31–33. Molecular methods have been widely used, firstly, to identify new species or populations of different species, thus providing a complement to pure systematic studies, with their applicability in the identification of species already consolidated in several different taxonomic groups34–37, especially DNA barcode methods23. This technique is based on analyzing the variability of a short nucleotide sequence (~ 650 bp) to assess differences between species. The cytochrome oxidase subunit I (coxI) gene was initially proposed by38, this region of the mitogenome includes both primary and conserved sites, as well as a suitable sequence of variation that allows differentiation between species39. There have been many criticisms regarding the choice of the cox1 gene as a barcode region, such as the presence of pseudogenes40,41. For mollusk species this is a major problem since several studies have already demonstrated the presence of alterations in the mitochondrial genome, including reorganizations, gene duplications and deletions42,43, in addition to bi-parental inheritance in bivalve species44. For cephalopod species, the main limitations of the application of the cox1 gene are found in the Ommastrephidae family due to several species having two copies of this gene45 making its application as a DNA barcoding tool inappropriate for this group. The large ribosomal region rrnL (also known as 16S rDNA) is another mitochondrial gene present in large copy number in cells and is a suitable alternative to be used as a molecular region for species identification, due to its conserved nature and the fact that, despite the challenges of aligning a non-coding region, is has already been widely used in phylogenetic analysis in cephalopod species, providing a good reference dataset46–51. Among the main advantages of using molecular methods in the identification of fishery products is the fact that it is easy to amplify target regions, as well as the fact that any portion of the body of a specimen or individuals from preparation processes such as cooking, frying, canning can be used52–54 though the degradation of DNA by these processes may mean that longer amplified fragments are less sensitive that shorter fragments. In this way, the applicability of molecular methods can help in the correct identification of the species being commercialized, which can reveal not only economic losses due to substitutions, as well as identify commercialization’s of species that may pose health risks55 or the presence of endangered species with prohibited capture, fishing and landing status, making it necessary to use appropriate tools to confirm product labeling and avoid commercial fraud56. Reliable molecular tools for barcoding DNA analysis have been developed to protect consumers from food frauds and health hazards and to improve the monitoring of endangered species due to overfishing and illegal commercial activities57. When complemented by molecular methods, market research can provide accurate species identification, even for products that have been through the finning and processing before sale58. DNA methods have been widely used for forensic analysis of food products because they provide an efficient, informative, sensitive and specific identification stimulus and because they can be applied to highly processed food products38,59. In Brazil, legislation on the cephalopod trade does not require all products to bear the common name and scientific name of the species marketed on their labels. This lack in the legislation can lead to the intentional substitution of fish-based products, which can cause economic loss to consumers. The European Union, in an attempt to seek solutions to reduce commercial fraud, has instituted regulations (EC 104/200; EC 2065/2001) that require member countries to make official lists available with scientific, common and commercial names of fish species that are being marketed, as well as requiring that product labels also be clearly informed60. Taking into account all the problems exposed regarding the commercialization of cephalopods, as well as the absence of official legislation labeling these products that are sold in Brazil. The present study aimed to use the fragment of the rrnL to identify which species of squid are being sold, both in the form of trays containing processed animals, and specimens sold whole in markets and fish fairs in some Latin American countries investigating whether there is evidence of intentional substitutions in the trade of cephalopod species. Methods Sampling For the present study, both whole and processed squid were collected directly from fishers or from supermarket chains in different regions of Brazil, Suriname, Mexico and French Guiana. For some samples, the place of origin (fishing) and purchase was different, with all information relating to these cases also duly recorded (samples purchased in Fortaleza-Ceara state, Brazil, had identification of origin, coming from Argentina and another package purchased in Belém-Para State, Brazil, also identified the origin of the content as Chile (Fig. 1). All specimens (whole and processed) utilized in the present study are already deceased animals. Subsequently, a small piece of muscle tissue was removed from each sample stored in 70% ethanol and subsequently stored at -4 °C until DNA extraction. About samples purchased in a processed form, each ring contained in the packaging was considered as a different sample. Each product tag with the assigned generic identification name, as well as the name of the distributor and fishing company were registered. Fig. 1Map showing all squid sampling places utilized in the present study. Colored circles correspond to each locality. See Table 1 for further definitions for localities names marked with *. Abbreviations represent the countries or Brazilian states from which samples were obtained where: AG = Argentina; AP = Amapá state, Brazil, PA = Pará state, Brazil, MA = = Maranhão state, Brazil, CE = Ceará state, Brazil, BA = Bahia state, Brazil, ES = Espirito Santo state, Brazil, RJ = Rio de Janeiro state, Brazil, SP = São Paulo state, Brazil, and SC = Santa Catarina state, Brazil, BR = Brazil; CH = Chile; GF = French Guiana; MX = Mexico; SR = Suriname. Map created with Ogis. Shapefile with projection WGS84. All Editions were made on Photoshop Cc2023. Source: Shapefile IBGE Map showing all squid sampling places utilized in the present study. Colored circles correspond to each locality. See Table 1 for further definitions for localities names marked with *. Abbreviations represent the countries or Brazilian states from which samples were obtained where: AG = Argentina; AP = Amapá state, Brazil, PA = Pará state, Brazil, MA = = Maranhão state, Brazil, CE = Ceará state, Brazil, BA = Bahia state, Brazil, ES = Espirito Santo state, Brazil, RJ = Rio de Janeiro state, Brazil, SP = São Paulo state, Brazil, and SC = Santa Catarina state, Brazil, BR = Brazil; CH = Chile; GF = French Guiana; MX = Mexico; SR = Suriname. Map created with Ogis. Shapefile with projection WGS84. All Editions were made on Photoshop Cc2023. Source: Shapefile IBGE DNA extraction, PCR and sequencing Total DNA was extracted from muscle tissue using the CTAB DNA extraction protocol61. The rrnL fragment was isolated and amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using the primers: L1987 (5’-GCCTCGCCTGTTTACCAAAAAC-3’) and H2609 (5’- CGGTCTGAACTCAGATCACGT-3’)62. The reactions were carried out containing a final volume of 15 µl, with 2.4 µl of dNTP (1.25mM), 1.5 µl of buffer solution (10X), 0.8 µl of MgCl2 (50 mM), 0.6 µl of each primer, 0.12 µl of Taq DNA polymerase (5 U/ul) (Invitrogen, Carlsbad-CA USA), 1 µl of genomic DNA (200 ng/ul), and ultrapure water to complete the final reaction volume. Reactions were performed according to Sales et al.48, whose protocol consists of initial denaturation at 94ºC for 2 min, followed by 30 cycles of denaturation at 94ºC for 30 s, hybridization at 51ºC for 1 min and extension at 72ºC for 2 min, with the final extension step of 72ºC in a period of 7 min. The quality and size of the PCR product were checked using 2% agarose gel electrophoresis. For sequencing of the fragments obtained, the PCRs were previously purified using 65% isopraponol and 70% ethanol, and the sequencing reactions were carried out with reagents from the BigDye Terminator V3.1 Cycle Kit and then sequenced on the SeqStudio Genetic Analyzer sequencer (Applied Biosystems) at the Instituto Tecnológico Vale-Desenvolvimento Sustentavél (ITV-DS) in Belém, Brazil. Data analysis The generated DNA sequences were aligned with the CLUSTAL W automatic alignment tool63 implemented in the Bioedit v7.0.9.1 program64. Subsequently, the sequences underwent visual inspection for possible automatic alignment errors, mainly given the variability in sequence lengths (508–533 bp) resulting from indel mismatches in the hyper variable region of the rrnL region. Two validation methods for molecular identification of the samples were used in the present study. At first, the Blastn tool, available on the GenBank portal (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genbank/) was used following a genetic similarity criterion of 98% for the taxonomic signature specific to each sequence. Based on the result of Blastn, sequences available from NCBI were aggregated for subsequent phylogenetic inferences for phylogenetic placement with the following species: Doryteuthis pleii65 (Slender inshore squid); Doryteuthis pealeii30 (Long-finned inshore squid); Doryteuthis sanpaulensis66 (Sao Paulo squid); Lolliguncula brevis65 (Thumbstall squid); Illex argentinus67 (Argentine shortfin squid); D. gigas (jumbo flying squid); Nototodarus gouldi68 (Gould’s flying squid); Nototodarus sloanii69 (Wellington flying squid) and Uroteuthis duvaucelii70 (Indian squid). The number of sequences generated in this study with the access code, as well as the sequences downloaded from GenBank are available in supplementary material 1. Additionally, for species delimitation as a second identification method, the TIM + F + G4 evolutionary model was estimated by ModelFinder software71, as the best model to our dataset. Subsequently, a Maximum Likelihood phylogenetic tree was estimated with IQ-tree v2.2.0 program package72 using Ultrafast Bootstrap73 based on 1000 pseudoreplicates. The software Figtree v1.4.474 was used to edit the phylogenetic tree. To visualize the data, Barplot and PieDonut were generated in Software R75, using the “ggplot2” and “webr” packages, respectively. The support values of the generated ML tree could de see in Supplementary material 2. Results Molecular identification A total alignment of 552 bp of the rrnL mitochondrial gene fragment (including gene region + indels) were generated from 181 squid samples. Comparison of sequences (without indels) using the Blastn revealed the presence of eight species that were widely traded throughout the Latin American region, namely: D. pleii (525 bp), D. pealeii (515 bp), D. sanpaulensis (521 bp), L. brevis (519 bp), I. argentinus (511 bp), D. gigas (508 bp), N. sloanii (508 bp), N. gouldi (508 bp) and U. duvalcelii (533 bp) (Table 1). Table 1Squid species identified in the present study based on rrnL fragment (16 S rDNA).Sampling placeLabel identificationProcessing/ Place of purchaseBlastn ID (%)Molecular IdentificationBragança – PA-Whole (Fair)100 D. pleii (n = 2) Florianópolis - SCLula Nacional (National squid)Whole (Supermarket)100 D. pleii (n = 6) Lula (squid)Whole (Supermarket)> 99.21 I. argentinus (n = 6) Salvador-BALula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.59 D. pleii (n = 4) Fortaleza-CE1Lula Brasileira(Brazilian squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.79 I. argentinus (n = 3) Fortaleza-CE2Lula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.79 I. argentinus (n = 2) Vitória-ESLula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.59 D. pleii (n = 4) Buzios-RJLula (squid)Whole (Fair)100 D. pleii (n = 5) São Luis-MALula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.8 D. pleii (n = 5) Imbituba-SCLula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.8 D. pleii (n = 4) Campeche-MXLula (squid)Whole (Fair)100 D. pealeii (n = 2) Santos-SPLula (squid)Whole (Fair)99.8 L. brevis (n = 1) Lula (squid)Whole (Fair)99.8 D. sanpaulensis (n = 5) Belem-PA3Lula Nacional (National squid)Processed in rings (Supermarket)> 99.41 D. gigas (n = 9) Cabo norte-APLula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.39 D. pleii (n = 8) Lula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.59 D. pealeii (n = 26) Lula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.80 L. brevis (n = 27) Castanhal-PALula Nacional (National squid)Processed in rings (Supermarket)> 99.41 D. gigas (n = 27) Suriname-SR-Whole (Fair)> 99.79 D. pleii (n = 6) -Whole (Fair)> 99.80 D. pealeii (n = 5) Curitiba-PR-Whole (Fair)100 L. brevis (n = 3) French Guiana -GFCalamars marinés (marine squids)Processed in rings (Supermarket)> 98.88 N. sloanii (n = 10) Petits Calmars marinésProcessed in rings (Supermarket)> 99.43 U. duvaucelli (n = 6) Belém-PALula G Inteira (Whole Large Squids)Whole(Supermarket)> 99.80 D. pleii (n = 4) Lula em Anéis (Squid Rings)Processed in rings (Supermarket)99.79 D. gigas (n = 1) Data about sampling places, label identification, kind of processing, and genetic similarity match is provided. Numbers above some of the sampling places indicate the actual origin place from where the samples came: 1 – Santa Catarina State; 2 – Argentina; 3 – Chile. See Supplementary Material 1 for detailed table showing the Blastn results per sample. Table 1Squid species identified in the present study based on rrnL fragment (16 S rDNA).Sampling placeLabel identificationProcessing/ Place of purchaseBlastn ID (%)Molecular IdentificationBragança – PA-Whole (Fair)100 D. pleii (n = 2) Florianópolis - SCLula Nacional (National squid)Whole (Supermarket)100 D. pleii (n = 6) Lula (squid)Whole (Supermarket)> 99.21 I. argentinus (n = 6) Salvador-BALula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.59 D. pleii (n = 4) Fortaleza-CE1Lula Brasileira(Brazilian squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.79 I. argentinus (n = 3) Fortaleza-CE2Lula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.79 I. argentinus (n = 2) Vitória-ESLula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.59 D. pleii (n = 4) Buzios-RJLula (squid)Whole (Fair)100 D. pleii (n = 5) São Luis-MALula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.8 D. pleii (n = 5) Imbituba-SCLula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.8 D. pleii (n = 4) Campeche-MXLula (squid)Whole (Fair)100 D. pealeii (n = 2) Santos-SPLula (squid)Whole (Fair)99.8 L. brevis (n = 1) Lula (squid)Whole (Fair)99.8 D. sanpaulensis (n = 5) Belem-PA3Lula Nacional (National squid)Processed in rings (Supermarket)> 99.41 D. gigas (n = 9) Cabo norte-APLula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.39 D. pleii (n = 8) Lula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.59 D. pealeii (n = 26) Lula (squid)Whole (Fair)> 99.80 L. brevis (n = 27) Castanhal-PALula Nacional (National squid)Processed in rings (Supermarket)> 99.41 D. gigas (n = 27) Suriname-SR-Whole (Fair)> 99.79 D. pleii (n = 6) -Whole (Fair)> 99.80 D. pealeii (n = 5) Curitiba-PR-Whole (Fair)100 L. brevis (n = 3) French Guiana -GFCalamars marinés (marine squids)Processed in rings (Supermarket)> 98.88 N. sloanii (n = 10) Petits Calmars marinésProcessed in rings (Supermarket)> 99.43 U. duvaucelli (n = 6) Belém-PALula G Inteira (Whole Large Squids)Whole(Supermarket)> 99.80 D. pleii (n = 4) Lula em Anéis (Squid Rings)Processed in rings (Supermarket)99.79 D. gigas (n = 1) Data about sampling places, label identification, kind of processing, and genetic similarity match is provided. Numbers above some of the sampling places indicate the actual origin place from where the samples came: 1 – Santa Catarina State; 2 – Argentina; 3 – Chile. See Supplementary Material 1 for detailed table showing the Blastn results per sample. Squid species identified in the present study based on rrnL fragment (16 S rDNA). Lula Brasileira (Brazilian squid) Whole (Supermarket) Data about sampling places, label identification, kind of processing, and genetic similarity match is provided. Numbers above some of the sampling places indicate the actual origin place from where the samples came: 1 – Santa Catarina State; 2 – Argentina; 3 – Chile. See Supplementary Material 1 for detailed table showing the Blastn results per sample. All sequences evaluated in the present study, when compared to data from GenBank, obtained an identification at species level with > 98% similarity. Of the 181 samples identified, 18 samples showed 100% similarity with D. pleii (n = 13), D. pealeii (n = 2) e L. brevis (n = 3), from the following locations respectively: Bragança, Florianópolis, Búzios, Campeche and Curitiba. The remaining of the identified samples (47) had a minimum similarity value of 99.80% with D. pleii (n = 9), L. brevis (n = 28), D. sanpaulensis (n = 5) e D. pealeii (n = 5), from the following locations: São Luís, Imbituba, Santos, Cabo Norte (all four from Brazil), and Suriname. Furthermore, 11 samples showed a minimum similarity value of 99.79% with I. argentinus (n = 5) and D. pleii (n = 6) coming from Santa Catarina, Argentina and Suriname. 34 samples showed a similarity value of 99. 59% with the species D. pleii (n = 8) and D. pealeii (n = 26) from Salvador, Fortaleza, Vitória and Cabo Norte, respectively. Among the samples from French Guiana and Belém, 11 samples showed a minimum similarity value of 99.43% with the following species, U. duvaucelii (n = 6), D. pleii (n = 4) and D. gigas (n = 1). Finally, 36 samples obtained a similarity value of 99.41% for D. gigas, from Chile (n = 9) and Castanhal (n = 27). Eight identified samples showed a similarity of 99.39% with D. pleii, coming from Cabo Norte. Among the samples from Florianopolis, six showed a minimum similarity value of 99.21% with I. argentinus while 10 remaining samples from French Guiana showed a value of 98.88% for N. sloanii. No kind of species substitution (intentional or not) was found in the present study. Twenty-nine sequences were added from GenBank, based on the degree of similarity of previously identified sequences, 27 of which are related to species identified with Blastn and three sequences of the species N. gouldi, resulting in a final alignment of 210 sequences. All sequences previously identified in Blastn were recovered in highly supported clades, separating two genetically distinct families, Loliginidae and Ommastrephidae, with five and three species identified, respectively. The results found with the Maximum Likelihood tree were in agreement with the genetic similarity analysis (NCBI-Blast), except in some cases referring to the structures within some species (Fig. 2). Fig. 2Maximum Likelihood phylogenetic tree showing the phylogenetic placement of the squid samples identified in the present study based on rrnL mitochondrial gene fragment (16 S rDNA). Each species is represented by its respective colored outline illustration: D. pleii – Brown; D. pealeii – Orange; D. sanpaulensis – Pink; L. brevis – Yellow; D. gigas – Red; U. duvalcelii – Purple; N. sloanii – Blue e I. argentinus – Green. Dashed shapes indicate the position of DNA sequences obtained from GenBank associated to each respective species clade. Image processing was done using the Adobe Photoshop Cc2023 software. Maximum Likelihood phylogenetic tree showing the phylogenetic placement of the squid samples identified in the present study based on rrnL mitochondrial gene fragment (16 S rDNA). Each species is represented by its respective colored outline illustration: D. pleii – Brown; D. pealeii – Orange; D. sanpaulensis – Pink; L. brevis – Yellow; D. gigas – Red; U. duvalcelii – Purple; N. sloanii – Blue e I. argentinus – Green. Dashed shapes indicate the position of DNA sequences obtained from GenBank associated to each respective species clade. Image processing was done using the Adobe Photoshop Cc2023 software. Within the family Loliginidae, three genera were recovered, Lolliguncula, Doryteuthis and Uroteuthis, totalizing 123 individuals identified. The most abundant species was D. pleii with 48 individuals forming a branch with 78% bootstrap support associated with different regions (Table 1; Fig. 2). Doryteuthis pealeii corresponds to the taxon with the second highest abundance among Loliginidae, totaling 33 identified sequences forming two clades with support values of 96% and 78%, respectively. Lolliguncula brevis (n = 31) formed a group with the sequences downloaded from GenBank according to the respective taxon with a support value of 97%. Uroteuthis duvaucelii (n = 6) was recovered with a high support value (99%), however there is evidence of strong distinct grouping structures with sequences from GenBank. Doryteuthis sanpaulensis (n = 5) formed a cluster with 100% support value with a structure established between sequences from Santos-SP. Species from three other genera were also identified, Dosidicus, Illex and Nototodarus (all belonging to the family Ommastrephidae), with a total of 58 individuals. The most abundant species for this family was D. gigas with 37 individuals forming a branch with 99% support value. Illex argentinus (n = 11) formed a clade with 98% support with internal structuring being recovered with 87% support from sequences belonging to samples from Florianopolis In the case of sequences of N. sloanii (n = 10), 97% support value separated them from N. gouldi, also demonstrating a support value of 99% that highlights this difference between the sequences, since the grouping with N. sloanii got the value of 97% together with the sequences from GenBank. In the previous analysis, some sequences obtained high genetic similarity with N. gouldi, but it was possible to observe the separation with a high bootstrap value among the congeners present in the database. Squid Processing level Most of squid sampled (71%) were being sold in whole form, while the remaining in processed form (29%) (Fig. 3a). The majority of individuals sold comprise Loliginidae, especially individuals that were being sold (whole) in their entirety at fairs. The most common species found was D. pleii (Fig. 3b) from the Southwestern Atlantic distributed among the states of Amapá, Pará, Maranhão, Bahia, Rio de Janeiro, Espírito Santo and Santa Catarina, all samples were being sold whole in supermarkets and fairs. Fig. 3Graphs demonstrating the quantified results of the present study. (a) PieDonut plot indicating the samples identified based on the type of processing and place of commercialization of the squid. (b) Bar plot summarizing the abundance of commercialized squid species. Graphics are generated with R53 and image processing was done using the Adobe Photoshop Cc2023 software. Graphs demonstrating the quantified results of the present study. (a) PieDonut plot indicating the samples identified based on the type of processing and place of commercialization of the squid. (b) Bar plot summarizing the abundance of commercialized squid species. Graphics are generated with R53 and image processing was done using the Adobe Photoshop Cc2023 software. The second most frequently found species was D. gigas purchased in the State of Pará, but with a secondary label on the reverse of the packaging indicating that the source of the product was Chile. In the case of this species, the individuals were being sold in a processed form (cut into rings), containing generic information on the labels as “Lula Nacional” (National Squid), “Lula Brasileira” (Brazilian Squid), or just “Lula” (Squid). The occurrence of labeling errors was observed in 100% of the products, when these samples come from the cities of Belém and Castanhal. Only one sample that was being sold in a supermarket in Belem was being sold without any information on the product label, containing only on the supermarket freezer label such as “squid in rings”. The third most common species was D. pealeii from Cabo Norte (Brazil) and Mexico. Another common species was L. brevis, being present in fairs from two locations Cabo Norte and Santos. All samples identified in the present was commercialized as whole being sold in fairs. Among the less frequently traded species identified in this study were I. argentinus, found both in fish markets in the city of Fortaleza but with Argentina as the place of origin on the label, and supermarket chains in Santa Catarina as a whole. The species N. sloanii was also identified less frequently, being sold in French Guiana in processed form (salads) in supermarkets, followed by U. duvaucelii which was also sold in French Guiana in the same way of N. sloanii. Finally, we found D. sanpaulensis and for D. pealeii from the Equatorial Northwest Atlantic, this last one a genetically distinct lineage of D. pealeii from North Atlantic. Discussion Incorrect labels end up deceiving jeopardizing consumers’ conscious choices, posing potential health risks76, as well as generating financial losses for consumers55. Additionally, from a conservation point of view, they “mask” the commercialization of species with prohibited fishing status77,78 or, when commercialized throughout the year, species that are undergoing period of reproductive closure end up being captured, thus causing possible future impacts on their recruitment and population stock79. Processing often removes or damages diagnostic characteristics that are important for the identification of species through conventional taxonomy26,56, which ends up contributing to the possible replacement of species of greater value commercial for others of lower value. The results generated in the present study indicate that a number of labeling errors occurred in products that had specimens sold in 2015 in a processed form as squid rings sold with the generic name “Lula Nacional” (National Squid), a name that suggests to the consumer that the product was caught in Brazil. All samples derived from squid labeled this way from the state of Pará in Brazil were genetically identified as D. gigas, a squid species found exclusively in the Pacific Ocean16,79. Additionally, a single sample that was being sold in processed form at the supermarket in Belém, with identification of “Lulas em anéis” (Squid Rings) in June 2022 which was also identified as D. gigas, was not in accordance with SDA Ordinance No. 544, of March 14, 2022 (article 16 in paragraph 1), where it is emphasized that “For products of the type D. gigas, it is mandatory to include scientific nomenclature, such as the explanatory affix to the product’s sales name”. This is the only species of cephalopods for which there is an ordinance that regulates commercialization in all Brazilian territory. Nevertheless, the replacement of commercial species cannot always be characterized as intentional commercial fraud. A portion of inappropriate labeling occurs unintentionally, largely due to the morphological characters used to identify species that can be easily mistaken, or simply when using vernacular names that are common to more than one species. To a certain extent, mislabeling may be the result of difficulties in identifying species, which occurs mainly in groups with few informative morphological characters and with a long history of cryptic species, such as in the Loliginidae species48,50,80,81 and Ommastrephidae82. Confusion can also arise due to different species having the same vernacular name, or different common names in different regions for the same species60. However, usually the substitutions of species, which always characterize commercial fraud, aims to obtaining higher profits83,84. Regarding the species purchased whole from markets in the Equatorial Northwest Atlantic that were identified in the present study, some considerations must be made. The squid fauna proposed for these regions is very similar to that reported for some regions of the North Coast of Brazil16. The presence of D. pleii, L. brevis and D. pealeii in these locations are in accordance with what has been proposed by recent molecular reviews with specimens from the North Coast of Brazil48,50,81,85. Two species of Doryteuthis identified in the present study are of high commercial importance in Brazil and in North America16,84–88, and, it is important to clarify that the lineage of D. pleii commercialized in Brazil corresponds to the valid species86, while the lineage exploited in North America corresponds to a not yet described species86. The same specific delimitation is valid for L. brevis85 and, although this is not a commercially important species89, on the North coast of Brazil it is often consumed by fishers90. For D. pealeii, the pattern is the opposite, with the lineage that occurs in Brazil being a new undescribed species81. According to our results, most of the samples were in agreement with the fauna found on the Brazilian coast91, indicating that the species that were being sold at fairs come from artisanal fishing, which contributes to the lack of supervision by the responsible governmental authorities, making it difficult to verify frauds. The lack of evidence of substitution among the products that were used in the present study denotes the difficulty in verifying the occurrence of substitution in samples that are sold in Brazil, due to the lack of information on the label, such as the name of the specific species name being sold for the consumer, thus making it difficult to track the replacement of one species of squid by another of the same genus, or family. For the species in the present study, in relation to other species sold in markets in Brazil and in Latin American countries utilized here, there was no case of commercial fraud, but rather a labeling error, since the specimens were sold only as “Squid”. The sequences that were identified as U. duvaucelii demonstrated evidence of strong different clades with sequences originating from the GenBank. This result is in agreement with other previous studies that already indicated the presence of multiple lineages within U. duvaucelii48,92. U. duvaucelii, presents a relevant morphological and genetic polymorphism within a wider geographic area93, and is of commercial importance in the Asian region, being mainly fished by artisanal fleets, but it already constitutes a high volume of exports, specially from Thailand to other countries. This species represents 68% of the cephalopod species exported by India16. The clade formed in the Maximum Likelihood (ML) tree reinforces this finding, although, the identification with Blastn suggests that all sequences generated in the present study correspond to the taxons in question. Different morphotypes of U. duvaucelii are recognized by commercial fishing. One of these are formed by a relatively large and a smaller form from the Gulf of Aden and the Arabian Sea94, and two other forms are known, one more robust and one more slender from the Eastern Pacific. In this sense, the diversity of the group may be underestimated, significantly affecting the management and conservation of the species. The results of molecular reviews carried out in recent years reinforce the presence of different species within U. duvaucelii48,95. One of the bottlenecks from the point of view of fisheries management and resource exploitation arises precisely when a given species targeted for exploitation has a cryptic species, because from the point of view of management and commercial exploitation, it would not be a single species under exploitation, but two or multiple at the same time, which can lead to a reduction in the population stock of these lineages, as the reproductive period and breeding area are often different between them96. Finally, the sequences of N. sloanii were well separated in the ML tree, although, for some sequences Blastn indicated a high similarity with N. gouldi. However, in the same topology, N. sloanii and N. gouldi formed distinct clades with high support value. One possible cause for this is the high level of similarity between species since until recently N. gouldi was considered a subspecies of N. sloanii. According to the information contained on the packaging label that these samples came from FAO fishing area 81 (Southwest Pacific), which is consistent with the species’ distribution area. It is worth noting that the samples identified as N. sloanii came from French Guiana and were being sold processed in supermarkets, containing all the information regarding the labeling described by the European Union in the “EC 104/200” regulation; EC 2065/2001”. Data obtained from FAO indicate that global catches for this species decreased in 2021, reaching a volume of 29,832 tons, data lower than the years 2020 and 2019, which had a volume of 41,928 and 43,795 tons, respectively. As previously found for other fisheries resources, the use of vernacular names (which present high variation at regional scales), the lack of standardized labeling (especially for processed subproducts), can lead to both substitutions (intentional or not) as well as the exploitation of fishing stocks with different management practices26,31,33,56. The management of cephalopod stocks differs greatly in relation to other fisheries resources, because of the biological characteristic of a short life cycle. The population size can therefore fluctuate considerably between seasons97,98, often leading to significant variations in recruitment99 (Roa-Ureta and Arkhipkin, 2007). This problem is accentuated when multiple species are exploited under a single name, causing an impact on two or more stocks instead of just one81,86. The difficulty of easily identifying morphologically similar species is one of the main challenges to obtain adequate data to establish conservation status and sustainable management practices. Molecular identification of many samples is one way in which this data could be obtained Our results clearly show that majority of species commercialized in the sampling places collected do not have standardized labelling, and identifications are based only on regional names. As there is no comprehensive Brazilian legislation for cephalopods that requires the common and scientific name of all species marketed labels, there is also no official list containing the common, commercial, or scientific names of the species sold in the country as well for Latin America Countries. In conclusion, based on the results of the present study, the samples identified as D. gigas that were being sold in a processed form (rings) in supermarkets, were considered incorrect labeling. For all other taxa identified in the present study, no occurrence of intentional or unintentional replacement was found. Because cephalopod species present high morphological plasticity, the use of molecular tools becomes necessary for the correct identification of species that are commercialized and this can help evaluate conservation status of species and planning for sustainable management of stocks. The lack of specific legislation on labeling for Brazilian cephalopod products (as in other Latin America Countries) may favor intentional and unintentional substitutions, bringing problems such as economic fraud. We are also relieved that our results continue to debunk the urban myth of calamari substitutions with pig rectum100. Electronic supplementary material Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material. Supplementary Material 1 Supplementary Material 1 Supplementary Material 2 Supplementary Material 2