A dynamical systems model for the total fission rate in Drp1-dependent mitochondrial fission Authors: Anna K. Leinheiser, Colleen C. Mitchell, Ethan Rooke, Stefan Strack, Chad E. Grueter Published: 2024 ABSTRACT Mitochondrial hyperfission in response to cellular insult is associated with reduced energy production and programmed cell death. Thus, there is a critical need to understand the molecular mechanisms coordinating and regulating the complex process of mitochondrial fission. We develop a nonlinear dynamical systems model of dynamin related protein one (Drp1)-dependent mitochondrial fission and use it to identify parameters which can regulate the total fission rate (TFR) as a function of time. The TFR defined from a nondimensionalization of the model undergoes a Hopf bifurcation with bifurcation parameter μ=k+Mk- where M is the total concentration of mitochondrial fission factor (Mff) and k+ and k− are the association and dissociation rate constants between oligomers on the outer mitochondrial membrane. The variable μ can be thought of as the maximum build rate over the disassembling rate of oligomers. Though the nondimensionalization of the system results in four dimensionless parameters, we found the TFR and the cumulative total fission (TF) depend strongly on only one, μ. Interestingly, the cumulative TF does not monotonically increase as μ increases. Instead it increases with μ to a certain point and then begins to decrease as μ continues to increase. This non-monotone dependence on μ suggests interventions targeting k+, k−, or M may have a non-intuitive impact on the fission mechanism. Thus understanding the impact of regulatory parameters, such as μ, may assist future therapeutic target selection. 1 Introduction Mitochondria are dynamic organelles that maintain a steady-state through three general processes: mitochondrial biogenesis, mitophagy, and mitochondrial dynamics (fission and fusion) [1–6]. Upon acute stress, mitochondria can undergo hyperfission resulting in an increase in fragmentation, which shifts their size distribution [7]. These fragmented mitochondria have decreased ATP production, decreased oxygen consumption, increased reactive oxygen species production, and an increased susceptibility to programmed cell death [8] [7]. Moreover, inhibition of mitochondrial hyperfission can blunt the impact of cellular injury. In cardiomyocyte-like HL1 cells, through the inhibition of fission signaling (including cyclin dependent kinases Cdk 1, 2 and 5), roscovitine protects cells from ischemia/reperfusion injury in vitro [8]. Further in vivo studies in rats demonstrate that inhibiting hyperfission in early stages of ischemia protect against long-term ischemic injury including a decrease in infarct size and improvement in function [9]. In male mice, studies demonstrate inhibition of Drp1-dependent mitochondrial fission by the outer mitochondrial AKAP1/PKA complex protects neurons from ischemic stroke [10]. However, deletion of key mitochondrial fission and fusion proteins (Mff or Drp1) results in heart failure [11]. Disruptions in the balance between fission and fusion has also been observed to affect normal development, and these disruptions have been implicated in neurodegenerative diseases [12] indicating that a balance between fission and fusion is crucial to cell health across diverse cell types. Drp1 is a key player in mitochondrial fission through its interaction with the outer mitochondrial membrane (OMM) [13–17]. Drp1 is recruited to the OMM and binds to membrane receptors such as mitochondrial fission factor (Mff), MiD49, and MiD51 [13, 17–20]. The receptor Mff is essential for recruiting Drp1 to mitochondria [17], and over-expression of Mff increases mitochondrial fission while over expression of MiD49 and MiD51 inhibits fission [13, 20]. For these reasons, the nonlinear dynamical systems described below focus on Drp1 and Mff interactions. Drp1 oligomerizes to form a chain like structure, an oligomer, which wraps around the mitochondria leading to a fission event. While Drp1 recruitment, oligomerization, and interaction with outer mitochondrial membrane receptors is known to occur [13, 18, 19], the specific contributions of these processes to the fission rate is incompletely understood. Therefore there is a need to understand the molecular mechanisms coordinating mitochondrial dynamics. We develop a nonlinear dynamical system for a Drp1-dependent fission mechanism and use parameter sensitivity analyses, bifurcation analysis, and a nondimensionalization of the model to identify which parameters have the greatest effect on the total fission rate (TFR) as a function of time. The TFR is the number of fission events per second. We will refer to our nonlinear dynamical system as the Fission Model. The TFR defined from the nondimensionalization of the Fission Model undergoes a Hopf bifurcation with bifurcation parameter μ=k+Mk-, where M is the total concentration on Mff; k+ and k− are the association and dissociation rate constants, respectively, between oligomers and single Drp1-Mff complexes on the outer mitochondrial membrane. The parameter μ can be thought of as the maximum build rate over the disassembling rate of oligomers. Even though the nondimensionalization of the system results in four dimensionless parameters, we found the cumulative total fission (TF), which is the total number of fission events over a set time period, depends strongly on only one of them, μ. Thus we identify μ to be a key regulatory parameter for Drp1-dependent mitochondrial fission. 2 Model: A nonlinear dynamical system for Drp1-dependent mitochondrial fission Mitochondrial fission is the process of a mitochondrion dividing into two daughter organelles. The Fission Model presented here is a system of nonlinear ordinary differential equations (ODEs) which focus on Drp1-dependent mitochondrial fission following cellular injury when the concentration of Drp1 in the cytosol is increased. The mechanism our model approximates begins with the recruitment and binding of cytosolic Drp1 tetramers with Mff anchored to the OMM via its hydrophobic C-terminal transmembrane domain. Since Drp1 exists in a predominately tetrameric form in the cytosol [14], the model focuses on the recruitment of Drp1 tetramers. Fig 1B shows GFP tagged Drp1 encircling the mitochondria, which illustrates the recruitment phase of the mechanism. Fig 1D shows red mitochondria encircled with a cyan ring structure where the cyan color is from the overlay of green Drp1 and blue Mff. This illustrates Drp1-Mff interactions on the OMM. Confocal images of heterologous cells probed for the mitochondrial marker COXII (A), transiently transfected with GFP-Drp1 (B), and stained for Mff (C). The overlayed image (D) shows Drp1/Mff (green/blue) complexes in cyan. Note the cyan ring structures encircling the red mitochondria. This demonstrates Drp1 oligomerization with Mff on mitochondria. The model tracks the concentration of these Drp1-Mff complexes as they build oligomers of various sizes. Once an oligomer reaches a sufficient size, which will be discussed in more detail later, a fission event occurs. After a fission event, Drp1 tetramers and Mff proteins instantly return to their respective unbound pools within the model (Fig 2). The Fission Model is a common pool model and represents the fission activity of an entire cell. Therefore, the concentration of Mff on the OMM is the concentration across all mitochondria. The model focuses on the oligomerization process in order to better understand how changes upstream of a fission event affect the number of fission events per second. The mechanism our model approximates begins with the recruitment of Drp1 tetramers from the cytosol to the outer mitochondrial membrane where they bind to Mff. These Drp1-Mff complexes build oligomers which constrict around the outer membrane and lead to a fission event. After a fission event, Drp1 tetramers and Mff proteins return to their respective unbound pools in the cytosol and on the outer mitochondrial membrane. Created with BioRender.com. The variables and parameters that makeup the Fission Model are T: concentration of cytosolic Drp1 tetramers—units nM T: concentration of cytosolic Drp1 tetramers—units nM M: concentration of Mff in an unbound form anchored to the OMM—units nM M: concentration of Mff in an unbound form anchored to the OMM—units nM C1: concentration of Drp1-Mff complexes (oligomers of size one) on the OMM—units nM C1: concentration of Drp1-Mff complexes (oligomers of size one) on the OMM—units nM Ci: concentration of oligomers of size i for 2 ≤ i ≤ N on the OMM—units nM Ci: concentration of oligomers of size i for 2 ≤ i ≤ N on the OMM—units nM k1: association rate constant for cytosolic Drp1 and Mff on the OMM—units (nMs)−1 k1: association rate constant for cytosolic Drp1 and Mff on the OMM—units (nMs)−1 k−1: dissociation rate constant of a Drp1 tetramer to unbind from Mff—units s−1 k−1: dissociation rate constant of a Drp1 tetramer to unbind from Mff—units s−1 k+: association rate constant for Drp1-Mff complexes (C1) and oligomers Ci—units (nMs)−1 k+: association rate constant for Drp1-Mff complexes (C1) and oligomers Ci—units (nMs)−1 k−: dissociation rate constant for Drp1-Mff complexes (C1) and oligomers Ci—units s−1 k−: dissociation rate constant for Drp1-Mff complexes (C1) and oligomers Ci—units s−1 f(i): fission rate as a function of oligomer size—units s−1 f(i): fission rate as a function of oligomer size—units s−1 The size of an oligomer refers to the number of Drp1-Mff complexes that makeup the oligomer. Oligomers of size i ≥ 2 on the OMM are assembled/disassembled one complex at a time, e.g. an oligomer of size four is formed from the association of a C3 and a C1 or the dissociation of a C1 from a C5. For i ≥ 1, the following reaction equation expresses the oligomerization process, Ci+C1⇆k+k-Ci+1. (1) Note that the association rate k+ and dissociation rate k− do not depend on the size of the oligomer. Hence a C1 is just as likely to bind to an oligomer of size five as to an oligomer of size twenty and likewise for the unbinding process. The oligomer construction process along with the assumption that k+ and k− are constant are motivated by the Drp1 oligomerization model in [14] and an actin filamentation model seen in [21]. Fig 3 is a reaction schematic of the model including recruitment, binding of Drp1 to Mff, oligomerization, and finally fission. A reaction schematic for the Fission Model: T—concentration of unbound Drp1 tetramers in the cytosol. M—concentration of unbound Mff on the OMM. T and M bind reversibly with rate constants k1 and k−1 to form Drp1-Mff complexes. C1—concentration of these Drp1-Mff complexes which are considered an oligomer of size one. These complexes bind sequentially with rate constants k+ and k− to form oligomers of size 2 through N. The fission rate f(i) is size-dependent. After a fission event, T and M return to their respective unbound pools. Created with BioRender.com. Within the mechanism, Drp1 travels from the cytosol to the OMM and back to the cytosol, so the Fission Model can be thought of as a compartmental model; one compartment is the cytosol, and the other compartment is the OMM. The two compartments have different effective spaces, so the Fission Model involves a dimensionless spatial correction term γ, which is the ratio of the effective space of the OMM to the effective space of the cytosol. Since the cytosol has a larger effective space than the OMM, the recruitment of Drp1 tetramers to the OMM minimally affects the concentration of Drp1 in the cytosol. Thus the cytosolic concentration of Drp1 (T) changes much more slowly over time compared to concentrations on the OMM. Using the law of mass action, we can build a system of nonlinear ODEs based off Fig 3. There are three terms in Eq (2) that track the fluctuations in the concentration of cytosolic Drp1 tetramers. The concentration of cytosolic Drp1 decreases when Drp1 binds to Mff, and the concentration increases after a fission event or if a C1 breaks apart (Fig 3). The decrease in concentration is accounted for with the −k1TM term in Eq (2). The increase after a fission event is accounted for with the summation ∑i=1Nif(i)Ci where N is the maximum oligomer size. In the summation, i refers to the size of an oligomer which corresponds to the number of Drp1 tetramers that make up that oligomer. Lastly, the k−1C1 term accounts for the increase from a C1 breaking into T and M. The spatial correction term γ accounts for the difference in the effective space of the cytosol and the OMM. Eq (3) behaves very similarly to Eq (2) except their is no γ term since we have already accounted for the difference in effective spaces in the previous equation. Eq (4) tracks the concentration of Drp1-Mff complexes (C1) over time. These complexes function as the building blocks for larger oligomers. If a Drp1 tetramer binds with an Mff protein, then C1 increases. If a Drp1 tetramer detaches from an Mff protein then C1 decreases. These two scenarios are accounted for with the terms k1TM and −k−1C1 in Eq (4). If an oligomer of size two breaks apart, then it breaks into two oligomers of size one. This scenario is accounted for with the term 2k−C2. Recall an oligomer is built one Drp1-Mff complex at a time (Eq (1)). Therefore, any oligomer larger than size two can only lose a single Drp1-Mff complex in a single reaction. The term k-∑i=3NCi accounts for the increase in C1 that would occur if any oligomer larger than size two loses a single Drp1-Mff complex. Similarly, the system loses two Drp1-Mff complexes if they bind to make an oligomer of size two. When building any size larger than two, only a single Drp1-Mff complex is lost in each reaction. These scenarios are accounted for with the term -k+(2C12+∑i=2N-1CiC1). Eq (5) represents the ODE for the concentration of an oligomer of size i where 2 ≤ i < N. These equations track the changes in the concentrations of oligomers as they grow on the OMM. An oligomer of size i is built by either an oligomer of size i−1 binding with a Drp1-Mff complex or by an oligomer of size i + 1 losing a Drp1-Mff complex. These reactions are accounted for with the terms k+Ci−1C1 and k−Ci+ 1 in Eq (5). Similarly an oligomer of size i can be used to build an oligomer of size i + 1 if it binds with a Drp1-Mff complex, or a complex could detach creating an oligomer of size i − 1. Both of these scenarios would decrease the concentration of oligomers of size i, so they are accounted for with the terms −k+CiC1 and k−Ci in Eq (5). The final term in this equation is the fission term which accounts for the loss of an oligomer due to a fission event. The parameter f(i) is the fission rate which is a function of oligomer size. Lastly, Eq (6) tracks the concentration of oligomers of size N which is the maximum oligomer size in this system. The concentration of oligomers of size N increases if an oligomer of size N − 1 binds with a Drp1-Mff complex (k+CN−1C1) and decreases if a Drp1-Mff complex detaches from an oligomer of size N (k−CN). The concentration will also decrease if an oligomer of size N becomes an active fission complex and causes a fission event (f(N)CN). T˙=γ(k-1C1-k1TM+∑i=1Nif(i)Ci), (2) M˙=k-1C1-k1TM+∑i=1Nif(i)Ci, (3) C˙1=k1TM-k-1C1+k-(2C2+∑i=3NCi)-k+(2C12+∑i=2N-1CiC1), (4) C˙i=k+Ci-1C1+k-Ci+1-k-Ci-k+CiC1-f(i)Ci2≤i