The accuracy of anatomic landmarks on the occlusal plane: a comparative study between conventional and 3D image method Authors: Supak Kingrungpetch, Weerapan Aunmeungtong, Pathawee Khongkhunthian Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundTo establish the occlusal plane, the conventional methods for facial analysis to gain accurate alignment of the occlusal plane are inadequate, while 3D technologies are an ideal diagnostic tool. The aims of this research are to compare the difference accuracy of anatomic landmarks on the occlusal plane and ala-tragus line between the conventional clinical method and 3D image method in both non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers.MethodsA total of 44 volunteers (22 non-orthodontic and 22 orthodontic treatment volunteers) with normal occlusion were selected. All volunteers received 2 operative methods for occlusal plane determination. In conventional method, the occlusal plane was defined by the fox plane line. The ala-tragus line was defined by the radio-opaque markers. In the 3D image method, the volunteers were recorded intraoral images, 3D facial images and CBCT images. A 3D virtual picture was created using EXOCAD® software. The occlusal plane was generated by the incisal and occlusal surfaces of the teeth. Both methods, the angles and distances between the occlusal plane and ala-tragus line were measured and compared statistically on both sides of each volunteer.ResultsBoth volunteers’ group, the mean angles and distances between the occlusal plane-ala tragus line in the conventional method were reported to be significantly greater than the 3D method (P < 0.05). The percentage difference of angles in conventional method were reported to be significantly higher by 13.61–21.58% (p < 0.05) compared to the 3D method. The percentage difference of distances in the conventional method were reported to be significantly greater than the 3D method by 4.73–7.51% (p < 0.05).ConclusionsWithin the limitation of the study, it can be concluded that both conventional and digital methods for establishing the occlusal plane are not parallel to the occlusal plane. The occlusal plane and ala-tragus line in the conventional method and the 3D method were significantly different in terms of angles and distances in both non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers. However, the deviation angle of both methods is approximately 13–20 degrees, which is clinically acceptable for occlusal plane establishment. The accuracy of both methods is still within the using in clinical implementation.Keywords: 3D Image, Ala-tragus line, Occlusal plane, Virtual picture Introduction Occlusal plane determination in edentulous patients has been proposed in several studies [1–3]. According to the glossary of prosthodontic terms 2017 (GPT-9), the occlusal plane or curve of occlusion is defined as the average plane generated by the incisal and occlusal surfaces of the teeth, wherein it is usually not a plane, but rather the planar mean of the curvature of these surfaces. The surfaces of wax occlusion rims molded to assist in the configuration of denture teeth, or a flat or curved mold used in placement of dentures [4]. The occlusal plane can be configured using features in both the mandibular and maxillary arches [5]. In the mandibular arch, several landmarks can be utilized to align the occlusal plane such as retromolar pad, the lateral border of the tongue or buccinator groove [6–8]. In the maxillary arch, an ala-tragus line is the most popular marker for establishing the occlusal plane [9, 10]. An ala-tragus line is defined as a line extending from the lower border of the ala of the nose to the upper border on the tragus of the ear along with a third point on the opposite tragus [11]. When observed in the mid-sagittal plane, the ala-tragus plane should be aligned to the occlusal plane where the occlusal plane should be at an incline about 10 degrees in relation to the Frankfort horizontal plane [4] (Fig. 1). The Occlusal plane and the Camper plane (ala-tragus line) The correct alignment of the occlusal plane is critical for a denture prosthesis [12]. The conventional methods of facial analysis for the proper alignment of the occlusal plane use either a two-dimensional (2D) photography or a fox plane device to evaluate the projection of distances and angles [13]. The fox plane device is used to check the parallelism in anteroposterior direction between the occlusal plane and ala-tragus line [14]. The cephalometric radiographs have been widely used in alignment of the occlusal plane and ala-tragus line, but these radiographs are based on the superimposition of the left and right sides [15]. While improvements and evolutions in optical scanning have led to a change from two-dimensional (2D) to the increasingly popular three-dimensional (3D) technology used in digital dentistry today [16], the management of dental treatment has been disrupted by the usage of 3D, for example, the radiological diagnosis and planning has been changed to cone beam CT-scan as well as the digital impression technique [17]. Three-dimensional (3D) innovations have proven to be the important diagnostic tools for facial examination as the graphics can be manipulated, turned, and magnified to provide a more realistic impression [15]. The feature points of a face can be electronically documented using face scanning while features of the oral region can be documented electronically using an intraoral scanner [18]. Moreover, dental cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) pictures provide volumetric data on jawbones and teeth, assisting in diagnostic and therapeutic management for total denture prosthodontics or oral physiotherapy [19]. Furthermore, data from CBCT, intraoral scans, and facial scans can be layered to create a "virtual picture" [20, 21]. Joda and colleagues reported systematic review of digital superimposition innovations to create virtual patients, superimposition of data on the facial soft tissue, bony structures and intraoral scan is currently a possible method to create a virtual patient under static conditions for improving results in diagnosis and treatment management [22]. Orthodontic treatment seems to have an effect on occlusion and masticatory function [23]. In clinical practice of orthodontic treatment plan, the goal of orthodontic treatment was to achieve normal occlusion. Bony landmarks in conventional method have been utilized in lateral cephalometric radiographs for occlusal plane orientation [24]. A systematic review of stable cranial parameters to assess the orientation of the occlusal plane. The interpupillary plane does not represent a reliable reference for evaluating the orientation of the occlusal plane. In dentate patients, The Frankfurt plane represents a more stable reference for occlusal plane determination [25]. Moreover, a systematic review of the effects of orthodontic treatment with four premolar extractions compared to non-extraction treatment. The evidence suggests that orthodontic treatment with four premolar extractions has no specific effect on the skeletal vertical dimension [26]. Currently, bony landmarks in 3D method provide accurate sagittal assessment. However, there is a limitation between soft tissue landmarks and the occlusal plane in both methods. Presently, conventional methods for facial analysis to gain accurate alignment of the occlusal plane are inadequate, while 3D technologies are an ideal diagnostic tool [20]. As a result, the aims of this research are to compare the conventional clinical approach with the 3D imaging approach in terms of occlusal plane and ala-tragus line anatomic landmark accuracy in non-orthodontic treatment volunteers and to compare the difference accuracy of anatomic landmarks on the occlusal plane and ala-tragus line between the conventional clinical method and 3D image method in orthodontic treatment volunteers. Methods This study was followed by Helsinki declaration and approved by the Human Experimentation Committee, Office of Research Ethics, Faculty of Dentistry, Chiang Mai University with certificate of human research number 16/2022. Sample size calculation and volunteer selection According to G*power analysis (Düsseldorf University, Germany), the significance level (α) was set at 0.05 and power of test (1-β) was set at 80%. Sample size was calculated, minimum 16 volunteers in each group were required. All volunteers received study information and signed their informed consent for study participation. Volunteer selection was followed by inclusion and exclusion criteria as shown in Table 1. Table 1Inclusion and exclusion criteriaInclusion criteriaExclusion criteriaVolunteers between 20–40 years oldSyndromic craniofacial anomalyVolunteers with permanent dentition (at least 24 teeth)Traumatic facial deformityVolunteers with a stable centric occlusion and molar classification ITemporomandibular joint diseasesVolunteers in good healthTooth mobility and tooth lossVolunteers with a good attitude and patient’s complianceRemaining deciduous teeth Inclusion and exclusion criteria Study design All volunteers received 2 operative methods for occlusal plane determination. Conventional method: The upper tragus, the middle point between upper tragus-lower border of the ala of the nose and the lower border of the ala of the nose were indicated with a lead foil radio-opaque marker on each of the volunteers. The line connecting the lead foil radio-opaque marker was referred to as an ala-tragus line. The volunteers were asked to hold a fox plane 3 times. The fox plane was positioned intraorally, touching the incisal edges of the upper incisors as well as the cusps of the left and right upper first molars. The occlusal plane was defined by the fox plane line (Fig. 2). Left and right profile photographs were taken with a digital camera using 3 images. In this study, a Sony A7III (Sony Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) with a resolution of 25.3 megapixels was used, which was suitable for computer analysis. The volunteers were remained naturally erect and upright, with straight backs and heads facing forward. Conventional method: The upper tragus, the middle point between upper tragus-lower border of the ala of the nose and the lower border of the ala of the nose were indicated with a lead foil radio-opaque marker on each of the volunteers. The line connecting the lead foil radio-opaque marker was referred to as an ala-tragus line. The volunteers were asked to hold a fox plane 3 times. The fox plane was positioned intraorally, touching the incisal edges of the upper incisors as well as the cusps of the left and right upper first molars. The occlusal plane was defined by the fox plane line (Fig. 2). Left and right profile photographs were taken with a digital camera using 3 images. In this study, a Sony A7III (Sony Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) with a resolution of 25.3 megapixels was used, which was suitable for computer analysis. The volunteers were remained naturally erect and upright, with straight backs and heads facing forward. The line connecting lead foil radio-opaque marker refers to the ala-tragus line and the line of fox plane refers to the occlusal plane 2.3D image method: The Trios 3® intraoral scanner (3Shape A/S, Copenhagen, Denmark) was used to collect intraoral 3D images and bite registration 3D images. For measurements, scan data files were stored as stereolithography (STL) files. A facial scanner (EinScan Pro 2X Plus® (EP + ®) (Shining 3D, Hangzhou, China)) was used to collect 3D facial images during the same appointment. The lead foil radio-opaque marker was used to mark the volunteers on the upper tragus, the center between upper tragus-lower border of the ala of the nose and the lower border of the ala of the nose. Volunteers were scanned in a neutral-facing position with closed lips and bite registration. Scan data files were saved using the polygon file format (PLY) for measurements. CBCT images were obtained using a DentiiScan 2.0® (NECTEC NSTDA, Pathum Thani, Thailand) with a voxel resolution of 0.4 mm. The Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) format was used to record all image data. All STL files, PLY files, and DICOM files were correlated using a best-fit alignment with EXOCAD® software 3 times (Exocad America Inc., Massachusetts, USA) (Fig. 3). 3D image method: The Trios 3® intraoral scanner (3Shape A/S, Copenhagen, Denmark) was used to collect intraoral 3D images and bite registration 3D images. For measurements, scan data files were stored as stereolithography (STL) files. A facial scanner (EinScan Pro 2X Plus® (EP + ®) (Shining 3D, Hangzhou, China)) was used to collect 3D facial images during the same appointment. The lead foil radio-opaque marker was used to mark the volunteers on the upper tragus, the center between upper tragus-lower border of the ala of the nose and the lower border of the ala of the nose. Volunteers were scanned in a neutral-facing position with closed lips and bite registration. Scan data files were saved using the polygon file format (PLY) for measurements. CBCT images were obtained using a DentiiScan 2.0® (NECTEC NSTDA, Pathum Thani, Thailand) with a voxel resolution of 0.4 mm. The Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) format was used to record all image data. All STL files, PLY files, and DICOM files were correlated using a best-fit alignment with EXOCAD® software 3 times (Exocad America Inc., Massachusetts, USA) (Fig. 3). A best-fit alignment of 3D image with EXOCAD® software Clinical outcome variables The difference between the angle of landmarks line: the comparison between the conventional method and 3D image method using the mean angle between the right ala-tragus line and right occlusal plane, as well as the left ala-tragus line and left occlusal plane. The computer programmed Screen Protractor was utilized to conduct measurement of the conventional method and EXOCAD® software was utilized to conduct measurement of the 3D image method (Fig. 4). The difference between the angle of landmarks line: the comparison between the conventional method and 3D image method using the mean angle between the right ala-tragus line and right occlusal plane, as well as the left ala-tragus line and left occlusal plane. The computer programmed Screen Protractor was utilized to conduct measurement of the conventional method and EXOCAD® software was utilized to conduct measurement of the 3D image method (Fig. 4). The angle of landmarks line 2.The difference between landmark line distances: the comparison between the conventional method and the 3D image method using the mean distances between the right ala-tragus line and right occlusal plane, as well as the left ala-tragus line and left occlusal plane. The measurements were taken on both sides at three locations, which included the lower border of the ala of the nose, the center, and the upper tragus. The digital ruler was utilized to conduct measurement of the conventional method and EXOCAD® software was utilized to conduct measurement of the 3D image method (Fig. 5). The difference between landmark line distances: the comparison between the conventional method and the 3D image method using the mean distances between the right ala-tragus line and right occlusal plane, as well as the left ala-tragus line and left occlusal plane. The measurements were taken on both sides at three locations, which included the lower border of the ala of the nose, the center, and the upper tragus. The digital ruler was utilized to conduct measurement of the conventional method and EXOCAD® software was utilized to conduct measurement of the 3D image method (Fig. 5). The distances of landmarks line Statistical analysis The statistical analyses were made with the SPSS Statistics 26 software (SPSS Inc., Chicago, Illinois). The normal distribution of data was tested by the Kolmogorov–Smirnov and Shapiro–Wilk normality test in each variance. All data parameters of both methods were evaluated. The statistical analysis was performed using a dependent sample T-test for comparison. Differences at p < 0.05 were considered statistically significant. All data parameters of both volunteers were evaluated. The statistical analysis was performed using an independent T-test for comparison. Differences at p < 0.05 were considered statistically significant. The reliability of study was presented in inter-rater and intra-class correlation coefficient. Patient demographic information was reported with descriptive statistics. Gender proportion was reported with Chi-square and Fisher’s Exact Test. Results According to the angle and distance of both methods were normally distributed (Shapiro–Wilk test). The reliability of study was presented in inter-rater and intra-class correlation coefficient. The intra-rater reliability was 0.942 (0.542–0.989) and inter-rater reliability was 0.863 (-0.14–0.97). The demographic information was presented in Table 2. A total of 44 volunteers (12 male and 32 female) aged between 20 to 40 years were participated in this study, including 22 volunteers with history of orthodontic treatment and 22 volunteers without history of orthodontic treatment. Gender proportion in non-orthodontic treatment volunteers and orthodontic treatment volunteers were not found to be significantly different (p = 0.31, Fisher’s Exact Test). Table 2Demographic informationVolunteersnMaleFemaleNon-orthodontic treatment volunteers22814Orthodontic treatment volunteers22418All volunteers441232 Demographic information The mean angles between the occlusal plane and ala tragus line in each method were presented in Table 3 and Figs. 6 and 7. The mean angles in the conventional method were reported to be significantly greater than that in the 3D method (P < 0.05). The percentage difference of angles in conventional method were reported to be significantly higher by 13.61–21.58% (p < 0.05) compared to the 3D method. Table 3Comparison of angles between the occlusal plane-ala tragus lineSubjectsAngle between ala tragus—occlusal planeMean angle of conventional technique ± SD (degree)Mean angle of 3D Technique ± SD (degree)Percentage difference**P-valuesAll volunteersRight4.78 ± 1.404.06 ± 0.9217.730.001*Left4.87 ± 1.464.14 ± 1.0117.630.001*Both side4.83 ± 1.424.10 ± 0.9617.800.000*Non-orthodontic treatment volunteersRight4.83 ± 1.324.19 ± 0.9915.270.023*Left4.84 ± 1.334.26 ± 1.0513.610.021*Both side4.84 ± 1.314.22 ± 1.0114.690.001*Orthodontic treatment volunteersRight4.47 ± 1.503.95 ± 0.8613.160.027*Left4.90 ± 1.614.03 ± 0.9721.580.024*Both side4.82 ± 1.543.98 ± 0.9121.100.001**The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level** Percentage difference=(mean angles of conventional technique-mean angle of 3D Technique)∗100mean angle of 3D Technique Comparison of angles between the occlusal plane-ala tragus line *The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level ** Percentage difference=(mean angles of conventional technique-mean angle of 3D Technique)∗100mean angle of 3D Technique Histogram of angles between the occlusal plane-ala tragus line in conventional technique. A Right side (B) Left side (C) Both side Histogram of angles between the occlusal plane-ala tragus line in 3D technique (A) Right side (B) Left side (C) Both side The mean distances between the occlusal plane and ala tragus line in each method were presented in Table 4, including the upper tragus, the center, and lower border of the ala of the nose. The mean distances in the conventional method were reported to be significantly greater than that in the 3D method (P < 0.05). The percentage difference of distances in the conventional method were reported to be significantly greater than the 3D method by 4.73–7.51% (p < 0.05) Figs. 8 and 9. Table 4Comparison of distances between the occlusal plane-ala tragus lineSubjectsDistance between ala tragus—occlusal planeMean distance of conventional technique ± SD (mm)Mean distance of 3D Technique ± SD (mm)Percentage difference **P-valuesAll volunteersRightupper tragus34.09 ± 2.1632.55 ± 2.514.730.000*middle31.20 ± 1.6029.14 ± 1.817.060.000*lower ala of the nose28.77 ± 1.0726.89 ± 1.456.990.000*Leftupper tragus34.03 ± 2.2332.40 ± 2.245.030.000*middle31.18 ± 1.9029.55 ± 1.915.510.000*lower ala of the nose28.70 ± 1.2327.09 ± 1.485.940.000*Both sideupper tragus34.06 ± 2.1832.47 ± 2.364.890.000*middle31.19 ± 1.7529.35 ± 1.866.260.000*lower ala of the nose28.73 ± 1.1526.99 ± 1.466.440.000*Non-orthodontic treatment volunteersRightupper tragus34.57 ± 2.1133.23 ± 2.924.030.029*middle31.62 ± 1.7529.41 ± 1.907.510.000*lower ala of the nose29.12 ± 1.0227.15 ± 1.507.250.000*Leftupper tragus34.65 ± 2.0832.79 ± 2.525.670.001*middle31.65 ± 1.8829.69 ± 2.136.600.000*lower ala of the nose29.07 ± 1.2327.28 ± 1.686.560.000*Both sideupper tragus34.61 ± 2.0733.01 ± 2.704.840.000*middle31.63 ± 1.7929.55 ± 2.007.030.000*lower ala of the nose29.09 ± 1.1227.21 ± 1.586.900.000*Orthodontic treatment volunteersRightupper tragus33.60 ± 2.1431.86 ± 1.855.460.002*middle30.78 ± 1.3528.87 ± 1.726.610.000*lower ala of the nose28.42 ± 1.0326.64 ± 1.396.680.000*Leftupper tragus33.40 ± 2.2432.00 ± 1.894.370.010*middle30.71 ± 1.8429.42 ± 1.694.380.005*lower ala of the nose28.33 ± 1.1426.90 ± 1.255.310.000*Both sideupper tragus33.50 ± 2.1731.93 ± 1.844.910.000*middle30.75 ± 1.6029.14 ± 1.715.520.000*lower ala of the nose28.37 ± 1.0826.77 ± 1.315.970.000**The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level** Percentage difference=(mean distance of conventional technique-mean distance of 3D Technique)∗100mean distance of 3D Technique Comparison of distances between the occlusal plane-ala tragus line *The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level ** Percentage difference=(mean distance of conventional technique-mean distance of 3D Technique)∗100mean distance of 3D Technique Histogram of distances between the occlusal plane-ala tragus line in conventional technique. A Right upper tragus (B) Right middle (C). Right lower ala of the nose (D) Left upper tragus (E) Left middle (F) Left lower ala of the nose. G Both side of upper tragus (H) Both side of middle (I) Both side of lower ala of the nose Histogram of distances between the occlusal plane-ala tragus line in 3D technique. A Right upper tragus (B) Right middle (C) Right lower ala of the nose. D Left upper tragus (E) Left middle (F) Left lower ala of the nose. G Both side of upper tragus (H) Both side of middle (I) Both side of lower ala of the nose The mean angles in the conventional method between non-orthodontic treatment volunteers and orthodontic treatment volunteers were presented in Table 5. The mean angles in both volunteers were not found to be significantly different (p > 0.05). Table 5Comparison of angles between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers in conventional techniqueAngle between ala tragus—occlusal planeNon-orthodontic treatment volunteers ± SD (degree)Orthodontic treatment volunteers ± SD (degree)P-valuesRight4.83 ± 1.324.47 ± 1.500.832Left4.84 ± 1.334.90 ± 1.610.893Both side4.84 ± 1.314.82 ± 1.540.96 Comparison of angles between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers in conventional technique The mean angles in the 3D method between non-orthodontic treatment volunteers and orthodontic treatment volunteers were presented in Table 6. The mean angles in both volunteers were not found to be significantly different (p > 0.05). Table 6Comparison of angles between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers in 3D TechniqueAngle between ala tragus—occlusal planeNon-orthodontic treatment volunteers ± SD (degree)Orthodontic treatment volunteers ± SD (degree)P-valuesRight4.19 ± 0.993.95 ± 0.860.379Left4.26 ± 1.054.03 ± 0.970.462Both side4.22 ± 1.013.98 ± 0.910.249 Comparison of angles between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers in 3D Technique The mean distances in the conventional method between non-orthodontic treatment volunteers and orthodontic treatment volunteers were presented in Table 7. The mean distances in both volunteers were not found to be significantly different (p > 0.05). Table 7Comparison of distances between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers in conventional techniqueDistance between ala tragus—occlusal planeNon-orthodontic treatment volunteers ± SD (mm)Orthodontic treatment volunteers ± SD (mm)P-valuesRightupper tragus34.57 ± 2.1133.60 ± 2.140.139middle31.62 ± 1.7530.78 ± 1.350.085lower ala of the nose29.12 ± 1.0228.42 ± 1.030.055Leftupper tragus34.65 ± 2.0833.40 ± 2.240.064middle31.65 ± 1.8830.71 ± 1.840.102lower ala of the nose29.07 ± 1.2328.33 ± 1.140.075Both sideupper tragus34.61 ± 2.0733.50 ± 2.170.063middle31.63 ± 1.7930.75 ± 1.600.074lower ala of the nose29.09 ± 1.1228.37 ± 1.080.09 Comparison of distances between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers in conventional technique The mean distances in the 3D method between non-orthodontic treatment volunteers and orthodontic treatment volunteers were presented in Table 8. The mean distances in both volunteers were not found to be significantly different (p > 0.05). Table 8Comparison of distances between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers in 3D TechniqueDistance between ala tragus—occlusal planeNon-orthodontic treatment volunteers ± SD (mm)Orthodontic treatment volunteers ± SD (mm)P-valuesRightupper tragus33.23 ± 2.9231.86 ± 1.850.71middle29.41 ± 1.9028.87 ± 1.720.329lower ala of the nose27.15 ± 1.5026.64 ± 1.390.249Leftupper tragus32.79 ± 2.5232.00 ± 1.890.247middle29.69 ± 2.1329.42 ± 1.690.653lower ala of the nose27.28 ± 1.6826.90 ± 1.250.413Both sideupper tragus33.01 ± 2.7031.93 ± 1.840.32middle29.55 ± 2.0029.14 ± 1.710.315lower ala of the nose27.21 ± 1.5826.77 ± 1.310.159 Comparison of distances between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers in 3D Technique Discussion The occlusal plane is important in prosthetic treatment planning [27] A proper occlusal plane alignment is a crucial parameter during the fabrication process of prosthesis [12]. Although the natural occlusal plane is curved due to the sagittal inclination of the teeth, a flat occlusal plane is practically formed as a reference for prosthesis construction [28]. Clinically, a common method to establish the tentative occlusal plane is by aligning it parallel to the ala-tragus line [29]. Kumar and colleagues [30] suggested that the Frankfort horizontal plane, ala-tragus line, and palatal plane can be used as reliable guides to establish the occlusal plane. An ala-tragus line is the most popular and extends from the ala of the nose to the tragus of the ear. The ala-tragus line is considered parallel to the occlusal plane, supported by evidence-based cephalometric radiographic analytical studies. According to the glossary of prosthodontic terms 2017 (GPT-9), in this study has shown that the ala-tragus line was defined as a line extending from the lower border of the ala of the nose to the upper border on the tragus of the ear along with a third point on the opposite tragus. The occlusal plane was defined as the average plane generated by the incisal and occlusal surfaces of the teeth [4]. The results of this study have shown that the mean angle in the conventional method was reported significantly greater than in the 3D method (P < 0.05), and the mean distance in the conventional method was reported significantly greater than in the 3D method (P < 0.05). Additionally, the percentage difference of angles in conventional method were reported to be significantly higher by 13.61–21.58% (p < 0.05) compared to the 3D method. The percentage difference of distances in the conventional method were reported to be significantly greater than the 3D method by 4.73–7.51%. (p < 0.05) in both non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers. Regarding the angle between the ala-tragus line and the occlusal plane, Khan and colleagues [11] conducted an evaluation on the parallelism of the ala-tragus plane in occlusal plane orientation. In their study, the angulation of the occlusal plane to Camper’s line was found to be4.25 degrees on right side and 4.50 degrees on left side, while Shrestha and colleagues [31] reported it as 5.18 degrees. Khan and colleagues [11] used the inferior border of the tragus as the posterior border of the ala-tragus line, while Shrestha and colleagues [31] used the center of the tragus as the posterior border of Camper’s line. Additionally, a study conducted by Raza and colleagues [32] reported the angulations of the occlusal plane to Camper’s line in dentate patients as 3.26 degrees and 2.34 degrees on right side and left side, respectively. Moreover, Nayar and colleagues [33] studied the angle between the ala-tragus line and the occlusal plane in dentate patients. There was no parallelism between the occlusal plane and ala-tragus positions. In our study, it was corresponding to this study that the ala-tragus line was not parallel to the occlusal plane on both sides due to the variations in the ala-tragus plane on both sides. A number of studies [31–33] have used two-dimensional (2D) photography or a fox plane device to evaluate the 2D projection of distances and angles between the ala-tragus lines and the occlusal plane [13]. Presently, three-dimensional (3D) technology has proven to be an important diagnostic tool for facial examination [15]. Rosati and colleagues [34] conducted three-dimensional full-face reconstruction which the results showed that the ala-tragus line was not parallel to the occlusal plane. Additionally, with the result from Valério and colleagues [35] which reported a tomographic study of 27 well-preserved adult skulls. These results showed that the ala-tragus line was not parallel to the occlusal plane. Our study agreed with the result of Rosati and colleagues’ s study and Valério and colleagues 's study. Regarding the distance between the ala-tragus line and the occlusal plane, Woelfel and colleagues [36] conducted a study and reported measurements in three locations: near the tragus, near the ala, and at the midpoint. They found that the distances were 29.9 mm at the tragus, 31.0 mm at the midpoint, and 31.3 mm near the ear. It was similar to our study that the mean distance between the ala-tragus line and the occlusal plane was higher at the upper tragus compared to the middle, and the middle showed a greater distance than the lower ala of the nose. Considering orthodontic treatment and non-orthodontic treatment, sagittal jaw relationship is an important relationship for orthodontic treatment planning. The measurements of orthodontic planning in conventional methods have been used the bony landmarks in lateral cephalometric radiographs such as the inclination between the AB plane and the occlusal plane or the inclination between SN plane and the occlusal plane [24]. The angle between AB plane and the occlusal plane has a strong correlation with vertical and horizontal growth directions [37]. Currently, bony landmarks in 3D method provide more accuracy than 2D method. The distance between the perpendicular projection of points A and B measured on the Frankfurt horizontal plane showed higher reliability in skeletal class determination on CBCT than 2D method [38]. However, there is a limitation of research on the parallelism between the ala-tragus line and the occlusal plane in orthodontic patients because the bony landmarks have been widely used in orthodontic treatment planning. An ala-tragus line is the soft tissue landmark and has been widely used in prosthetic planning. The results of this study have shown that the mean angles in both methods were not found to be significantly different between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers (p > 0.05). The mean distances in both methods were not found to be significantly different between non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers (p > 0.05). From our study, the orthodontic treatment was not affected to measurement the angle and distances between the ala-tragus line and the occlusal plane. Although the results of this study agreed with the previous findings [33–38] that the ala-tragus line was not parallel to the occlusal plane. In clinically, the ala-tragus line was still deemed a reliable landmark for occlusal plane determination such as full denture fabrication. This reliability was attributed to the differences in angles and distances between the ala-tragus line and occlusal plane observed in both methods. In addition, the percentage difference of angles in conventional method were reported to be significantly higher by 13.61–21.58% (p < 0.05) compared to the 3D method. The percentage difference of distances in the conventional method were reported to be significantly greater than the 3D method by 4.73–7.51%. (p < 0.05) in both non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers. Clinically, to implement the results of this study, there are some concerning about the limitation of the study such as the race of the volunteer, the anatomy of the Asia people and other may be different and the number of the volunteers. Further studies are required to confirm these results. Consequently, the study results support the use of the ala-tragus plane for reestablishing the occlusal plane in patients. Future investigations should focus on exploring more robust references for achieving optimal prosthetic and orthodontic outcomes. Conclusions Within the limitations of this study, it can be concluded that both conventional and digital methods for establishing the occlusal plane are not parallel to the occlusal plane. The occlusal plane and ala-tragus line in the conventional method and the 3D method were significantly different in terms of angles and distances in both non-orthodontic and orthodontic treatment volunteers. However, the deviation angle of both methods is approximately 13–20 degrees, which is clinically acceptable for occlusal plane establishment. The accuracy of both methods is still within the using in clinical implementation. Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Dr. Thanapat Sastraruji, Dental Research Center, Faculty of Dentistry, Chiang Mai University, for supporting statistical data analysis. Authors’ contributions Data collection, data analysis, and drafting article by Supak Kingrungpetch Study design, critical revision and correction of the article by Weerapan Aunmeungtong Approval of article secured by Pathawee Khongkhunthian. Funding The study was supported by Chiang Mai University research fund for center of excellence project (grant number: R000023419). Data availability Data is provided within the manuscript or supplementary information files. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate The study was approved by the Human Experimentation Committee, Office of Research Ethics, Faculty of Dentistry, Chiang Mai University with certificate of human research number 16/2022. All volunteers received study information and signed their informed consent for study participation. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement Data is provided within the manuscript or supplementary information files.