Satellite monitoring of long period ocean-induced magnetic field variations Authors: Christopher C Finlay, Jakub Velímský, Clemens Kloss, Rasmus M Blangsbøll Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractSatellite magnetic field observations have the potential to provide valuable information on dynamics, heat content and salinity throughout the ocean. Here, we present the expected spatio-temporal characteristics of the ocean-induced magnetic field (OIMF) at satellite altitude on periods of months to decades. We compare these to the characteristics of other sources of Earth’s magnetic field, and discuss whether it is feasible for the OIMF to be retrieved and routinely monitored from space. We focus on large length scales (spherical harmonic degrees up to 30) and periods from one month up to 5 years. To characterize the expected ocean signal, we make use of advanced numerical simulations taking high-resolution oceanographic inputs and solve the magnetic induction equation in three dimensions, including galvanic coupling and self-induction effects. We find the time-varying ocean-induced signal dominates over the primary source of the internal field, the core dynamo, at high spherical harmonic degree with the cross-over taking place at degrees 13–19 depending on the considered period. The ionospheric and magnetospheric fields (including their Earth-induced counterparts) have most power on periods shorter than one month and are expected to be mostly zonal in magnetic coordinates at satellite altitude. Based on these findings, we discuss future prospects for isolating and monitoring long period OIMF variations using data collected by present and upcoming magnetic survey satellites.This article is part of the theme issue ‘Magnetometric remote sensing of Earth and planetary oceans’.Keywords: geomagnetism, ocean dynamics, remote sensing Introduction Satellite observations are essential to our modern view of the ocean. They provide global information on circulation patterns [1,2], temperature [3], salinity [4] and biochemistry such as chlorophyll [5] on horizontal scales ranging from 10 to 10 000 km and spanning timescales of weeks to decades, enabling variability and trends in ocean properties to be monitored. These observations are nevertheless heavily focused on the ocean surface; a full understanding of the ocean and its changes also requires information on processes happening at depth. Float programs, in particular ARGO, have in recent years provided much valuable information in this regard [6]. Our knowledge of ocean flows, temperature and salinity as a function of depth nonetheless remains incomplete, especially at depths below 2000 m. Satellite measurements of gravity and magnetic fields involve an intrinsic integration of ocean properties over depth, so they provide complementary observational constraints on the ocean as a whole. For example, gravity measurements provide constraints on total ocean mass variations and ocean bottom pressure variations which depend on gravity through density integrated over a vertical water column [7]. The GRACE mission has already provided extremely valuable information in this regard, and the upcoming MAGIC mission aims to push such monitoring to higher spatial and temporal resolution [8]. Our focus here is instead on satellite measurements of the magnetic field and the information they can provide on integrated ocean properties on large length scales (of order 1000 km and larger) and long (monthly to decadal) time scales. Magnetic fields are generated by motional induction in the ocean, when electrically conducting water moves across magnetic field lines originating in Earth’s core [9–11]. We refer here to such fields as Ocean-Induced Magnetic Fields (OIMF), though it is important to note that they also depend on the electrical conductivity of the solid Earth where the induced currents close. Two classes of oceanic motions contribute to the OIMF. First, and so far best studied, are the magnetic signals due to ocean motions driven by periodic gravitational forcing of the lunisolar tides. Such tidal flows are predominantly two-dimensional, and they give rise to pronounced magnetic signals at the discrete frequencies of the individual tidal constituents [12–14], although nonlinear compound tides also exist [15]. The second class, which is our focus here, involves magnetic signals resulting from the general circulation of the ocean and its dynamics. The latter motions are driven both by winds and buoyancy (also known as thermohaline) effects including surface temperature variations and freshwater release, with timescales ranging from days up to centuries [16–18]. These general circulation motions of the ocean are again largely horizontal, although the small vertical transport plays a crucial role in the dynamics of the thermohaline part of the circulation. The kinetic energy of near-surface motions is dominated by mesoscale eddies (on length scales of hundreds of kilometres and shorter, and with typical timescales of days to months) [19], however, it is larger (basin-scale) gyres and overturning circulations that dominate thermohaline transport processes over longer timescales. Examples of large-scale ocean currents systems relevant here include the Antarctic Circumpolar Current (ACC), the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) including the Gulf stream, the Indian Ocean Circulation with its Monsoon dynamics, the Pacific Equatorial Currents that are related to the El Niño-Southern Oscillation climate pattern and the North and South Pacific Subpolar Currents including the Kuroshio Current [16,20]. The evolution of these large-scale current systems and their depth variations are of great interest for understanding Earth’s climate system [17]. The OIMF is expected to carry volume-integrated information on such processes, if it can be reliably extracted. In addition to being dependent on the amplitude and geometry of flows in the ocean, the OIMF also depends on the electrical conductivity of sea water, which in turn depends on temperature and salinity [21,22]. The ocean’s electrical conductivity thus varies with geographic location, depth and time, including seasonal variations and long-term trends. Variations in the large-scale OIMF will therefore also be produced by large-scale changes in ocean temperature (i.e. heat content) and salinity. Over the past decade, there has been significant progress in understanding and simulating the OIMF. There is now consensus regarding the basic features and expected amplitude of the time-averaged OIMF based on advanced simulations that make use of oceanographic data [23]. Simulations suggest the OIMF originates primarily from the upper 2000 m of the ocean where motions are larger and the temperature (hence electrical conductivity) is higher [24]. At Earth’s surface and satellite amplitude, it is dominated by the signature of the ACC [25–28]. There is however less consensus regarding the magnetic signal of ocean variability on timescales of months to decades; this depends on the input oceanographic information. For such simulations to be accurate it is important to treat ocean motions, temperature and salinity (as well as the derived electrical conductivity) in a self-consistent manner. This requires input of realistic four-dimensional (three-dimensional plus temporal) ocean properties while acknowledging that even the most up-to-date oceanographic information is incomplete. Systematic numerical experiments are required to address such uncertainties; here, we present only an illustrative example of the OIMF from one such simulation, a more extensive set of simulations is underway and will be reported in a future study. Turning to observations of the OIMF, ocean tidal signals can now be routinely extracted from satellite magnetic measurements. The largest and easiest to extract is the M2 tide [12,29,30] which is available as an L2 Data Product (SW_MTI_SHA_2C) from ESA’s Swarm satellite mission. The magnetic signals of the N2 and O1 tides have also been extracted [13,31] and most recently the weaker Q1 tide (amplitude at satellite altitude of order 0.1 nT) has been convincingly isolated [14]. In the most recent study by Grayver et al. [14], spherical harmonic models of the internal magnetic field with a specific period are fit to observations from the CHAMP and Swarm satellites, using only night-side data and after correcting for core and magnetospheric fields. The observed OIMF tidal signals agree well with predictions from numerical simulations taking the rather well-known tidal flows as input. These observations of the OIMF tidal signals are an important demonstration that the OIMF can be reliably retrieved from satellite magnetic measurements, despite the small signal amplitude, given appropriate processing and modelling of the signal. Trends in tidal properties, which may reflect trends in temperature, salinity or changes in underlying ocean circulation patterns, are of great interest; this is the next target for studies of the tidal OIMF. Turning to the more general OIMF signal from the ocean general circulation, as far as we are aware there has only been one published claim to have detected this, based on observations from the CHAMP satellite [32]. This result has however not yet been independently reproduced by other workers. Recently, Hornschild et al. [33] sought to make progress by assuming the OIMF signal from a simulation was correct, except for a spatially varying rescaling factor, which they estimated. There is clearly still much to do regarding observational studies of the general circulation-driven OIMF. The aim of this article is to document the space-time characteristics expected for the general circulation component of the OIMF, and to compare these to other (non-oceanic) magnetic field signals measured by satellites. Based on these comparisons the feasibility of extracting the OIMF will be assessed, and ways to make progress in this direction proposed. In §2, we review the physics of the OIMF, describe how it can be modelled and present its space-time characteristics. In §3, we review the present status of satellite geomagnetism, give an overview of sources of Earth’s magnetic field and describe the space-time characteristics of fields originating in the core, crust, ionosphere and magnetosphere. In §4, we discuss strategies for extracting the OIMF before finishing with discussion and conclusions in §5. Ocean-induced magnetic field Physics of motional induction Motion of an electrical conductor through a magnetic field induces an electric field across the conductor. In the presence of a closed conducting path, this results in an electrical current and an associated motionally induced magnetic field. The oceans produce a weak magnetic field in this way as they move through the magnetic field generated in Earth’s core. The OIMF Boi observed, for example, at a satellite at location (r;t)=(r,Ω;t)=(r,ϑ,φ;t) is an integral property of the electrical current density Joi induced in the oceans, including its closure in the solid Earth. The Biot–Savart law describes this relationship and may be written where G=Go∪Gse is the volume of the oceans and the solid Earth, taken here to be the region r≤a where a is the mean spherical radius of Earth’s surface and μ0=const is the magnetic permeability of free space. The current density Joi(r;t) is specified by Ohm’s law for a moving conductor to be Joi(r;t) thus depends point-wise on the electrical conductivity σ(r;t), the ocean flow velocity υ(r;t), the total magnetic field B(r;t) and the electric field Eoi(r;t) induced by time changes of the magnetic field. B(r;t)=Bc(r;t)+Boi(r;t) includes both a background magnetic field generated mostly in Earth’s core Bc(r;t) and the OIMF Boi(r;t). The electric field Eoi, current density Joi and magnetic field Boi associated with motional induction in the oceans are related by Maxwell’s equations. Under the quasi-static approximation that is appropriate for the slow changes considered here, these take the form Combining (2.2) and (2.3) and using the fact that | B c|≫| B oi|, gives Known in magnetohydrodynamics as the magnetic induction equation, this specifies the time evolution of Boi given the ocean flow velocity υ(r;t), the electrical conductivity of the oceans and solid Earth σ(r;t) and the core field Bc(r;t). Taking into account the divergence-free condition that holds for all magnetic fields, and an insulating boundary condition at the Earth’s surface, we therefore have the following set of equations that can be used to simulate the OIMF: where A is the insulating atmosphere r≥a, ∂G is the Earth/atmosphere interface, U(r;t) is the magnetic scalar potential in A, which decreases with radial distance in the absence of external sources and B0(r)=Boi(r;t=0) is the initial condition for the OIMF in G. The only physical approximation involved in the above equations is the quasi-static approximation of Maxwell’s equations, where displacement currents are neglected since low frequencies are considered. Time-dependent electrical conductivities, reflecting changes in the salinity and temperature of the oceans, are permitted. The time derivative of Boi in the induction equation (2.4) leads to inductive coupling between the highly conductive oceans, the moderately conductive seafloor sediments, and the poorly conductive lithosphere and mantle, as well as self-induction. Spatial variations of electrical conductivity imply the presence of galvanic coupling, as the electric currents prefer the least-resistive path through the heterogeneous medium. This can be demonstrated by writing separately the poloidal and toroidal parts of equation (2.4): The poloidal and toroidal magnetic fields, and corresponding toroidal and poloidal electric currents, are generated respectively by the toroidal and poloidal components of the Lorentz force per unit charge, υ×Bc [34]. Šachl et al. [23] have demonstrated that it is important to include galvanic coupling effects when simulating the OIMF by simultaneously modelling both the toroidal and poloidal fields. Equations (2.10) and (2.11) show that lateral variations of electrical conductivity couple the poloidal and toroidal fields, and that energy is exchanged between them. Numerical simulations Below we present results from numerical simulations of the OIMF based on a time-domain, spherical harmonic-finite element solver of equations (2.4)–(2.9). The numerical scheme was originally developed to model the electromagnetic response of an electrically heterogeneous Earth to time variations of the magnetic field of external (i.e. magnetospheric or ionospheric) origin [35–37], and later modified to simulate the OIMF by implementation of an internal forcing due to ocean flows [23,34,38]. The magnetic field in G, and the scalar magnetic potential in A are respectively expanded into truncated series of vector and scalar spherical harmonics: Here are the real, fully normalized scalar spherical harmonics, and the poloidal vertical, toroidal and poloidal horizontal vector spherical harmonics are defined as respectively. The magnetic field is further parameterized in the radial direction using piecewise-linear finite elements over the radial coordinate discretized by 0=r1