Creep characterisation and microstructural analysis of municipal solid waste incineration fly ash geopolymer backfill Authors: Lijuan Su, Siyao Wu, Guosheng Fu, Wancheng Zhu, Xiangdong Zhang, Bing Liang Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractIn this work, an alkali-activated municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash-based filling material was prepared with MSWI fly ash as the raw material and slag as the auxiliary material. The filling body experiences long-term creep, which may have a direct effect on the stability of the overlying strata of the mine goaf. The long-term mechanical properties of the fly ash-based filling materials were tested with a triaxial rheological apparatus. First, uniaxial creep testing was carried out at five levels of axial stress: 50%, 60%, 70%, 80% and 90% of the uniaxial compressive strength (UCS). Then, triaxial creep testing was carried out by considering the geological environment of the goaf. The creep characteristics of fly ash-based filling materials under a three-dimensional stress state were explored. The results indicate that (1) under different stress levels, the creep curves of fly ash-based filling materials can be divided into three types: decelerated creep‒stable creep, decelerated creep‒constant creep, and decelerated creep‒constant creep‒accelerated creep. (2) The total creep deformation of the fly ash-based filling material is 0.46 ~ 0.78%, which is similar to the creep deformation of soft rock. The instantaneous deformation during loading contributes most of the total deformation. (3) The polymerization products generated in the fly ash-based filling material system can effectively cement the raw material particles, and the presence of gel can effectively delay the accelerating creep process of the material. (4) A nonlinear fractional-order model composed of an Abel dashpot can fully describe the complete process of decelerating creep-constant creep-accelerating creep.Keywords: Municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash, Filling material, Creep, Fractional order model, Pore structureSubject terms: Materials science, Engineering Introduction Owing to the continuous growth of the urban population, the output of municipal solid waste clearly increases. The incineration of domestic waste can reduce the municipal solid waste volume by approximately 90% and its mass by 70%, so it is an ideal method for waste disposal1–5. At present, the treatment of MSWI fly ash in China is still mainly based on safe landfills, and its utilization rate as a resource is still low. The rational use of MSWI fly ash is an inevitable trend to solve the problem of fly ash stacking6–11. The use of MSWI fly ash after alkali excitation treatment in the filling treatment of mine goafs can not only solve the land occupation problem of landfill schemes but also make full use of the potential activity of fly ash to prepare filling materials12–15. The filling body is subjected to long-term and stable pressure from the overlying strata during the service process, and its long-term mechanical properties are related to the stability of the entire goaf. Therefore, it is very important to study the creep characteristics of MSWI fly ash-based filling materials to facilitate the utilization of fly ash16. At present, there are few studies on the creep behavior of filling materials in mine goafs17,18. Cheng et al.19,20 prepared a filling body with iron tailings and composite Portland cement as the main raw materials, studied the creep hardening–damage characteristics of the filling body and deduced a nonlinear constitutive model of filling body creep. Chen et al.21,22 prepared filling paste samples with fly ash and cement as cementitious materials and analyzed the variation in the instantaneous elastic modulus during creep. Zhou et al.23 prepared a water-rich filling material by mixing cement, gypsum and lime with water and deduced a one-dimensional creep damage model of the material. Most of the above studies include uniaxial creep tests, and the corresponding constitutive models are one-dimensional models. In practical engineering, in addition to the axial pressure imposed by the overlying strata, the filling body is also subjected to the confining pressure of the surrounding soil or rock, and the real working environment is closer to a triaxial stress state. In addition, previous studies have mostly adopted the multistage loading method to carry out creep tests on filling materials. This loading method cannot eliminate the influence of early cumulative damage on later loading. Although there are few studies on the creep behavior of filling materials in goafs, research on the long-term mechanical properties of soft rock and clay materials has been relatively abundant. Owing to the diversity of raw materials for the preparation of filling, at present, most filling are prepared from solid waste. Therefore, the different components, different material sources and preparation processes used to prepare the filling significantly affect the creep performance of the filling. Zhu et al.24 described the parameters in the Merchant model by using the variable modulus method and proposed a three-dimensional creep model of clay related to the stress level of soft clay at the bottom of a caisson foundation. Guo et al.25 introduced a nonlinear SP element based on the Burgers model and established a three-dimensional creep constitutive model that can fit the shear creep curve of marine soft soil. The filling material is similar to soft rock and clay in terms of its working environment, bearing capacity and failure mode. The creep behavior of MSWI fly ash-based filling materials can be studied by referring to relevant theories. So far, scholars have less research on the characteristics of MSWI fly ash filler. Therefore, according to the microscopic characteristics and pore characteristics of MSWI fly ash filling material, the author has realized the stability of the filling material. In this work, MSWI fly ash is used as the main raw material to prepare goaf filling material, and the creep behavior of the filling body under uniaxial and ordinary triaxial loading is studied. The experimental study fully combines the existing uniaxial creep test of the filling body and the triaxial creep theory of rock and derives a three-dimensional fractional creep constitutive model that can describe the whole creep process of MSWI fly ash-based filling material. The research results provide a reference for the application of MSWI fly ash in the field of mine goaf filling. Test and loading scheme Sample preparation The circulating fluidized bed waste incineration-generated fly ash produced by the Fuxin Waste Incineration Power Plant was used in the test. The S95 grade slag was produced by Henan Platinum Casting Material Co., Ltd. An X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (PANalytical Axios, Netherlands) was used to detect the types and contents of elements and oxides in the fly ash and slag. The activators used in this article are sodium hydroxide and water glass, both purchased from Fuxin Chemical Products Co., Ltd. The test results are shown in Table 1. The modified water glass was prepared by dissolving sodium silicate (Na2O•2.85SiO2•H2O) and flake alkali (NaOH) in water. The main components and performance indices of the instant sodium silicate are shown in Table 2. The cost of the main raw material MSWI is 50 yuan/ton, and the cost of slag is 180 yuan/ton, making the overall cost very low. Table 1Main components and contents of municipal solid waste incineration fly ash and slag (%).Raw materialSiO2Al2O3CaOFe2O3MgONa2OK2OClSO3MiscellaneousMSWI25.3617.4624.495.294.334.433.249.224.751.43Slag34.2412.1540.330.775.34/0.55/5.331.29 Main components and contents of municipal solid waste incineration fly ash and slag (%). Table 2Main components and performance indicators of rapidly dissolving sodium silicate.Raw materialSiO2/%Na2O/%Ignition loss/%Crystal water/%ModulusDensity/(g·cm−3)Sodium silicate58.1020.900.1020.902.850.50 Main components and performance indicators of rapidly dissolving sodium silicate. The MSWI fly ash and slag were mixed at a ratio of 2:3, and 3% of the modified water glass was mixed with the alkali equivalent as the calculation standard, where the water glass modulus was 1. To ensure the fluidity of the fresh slurry to meet the onsite pouring conditions, the W/C ratio was set to 1.35. In accordance with the recommendations of the American Society for Materials and Testing and the International Society for Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering (ISRM), we selected a Φ50 mm × 100 mm cylindrical mold with an aspect ratio of 2:1 to pour the test piece. After pouring, the mold was placed on a shaking table (Z-56) to densify the slurry. After vibration, the mold was placed in a constant-temperature and constant-humidity standard curing box (YH-60b) for maintenance. The curing temperature was 20 °C, and the humidity was above 95%. After the sample was cured for 48 h, it was demolded and cured to the specified age. The material mix ratio used in this study was optimized via the BBD response surface method, accounting for the uniaxial compressive strength of the filling and the cost per cubic meter of the filling, and ultimately determining the optimal mix ratio in this study. CT test In this experiment, a 450 kV high-energy industrial CT device was used to obtain CT scanning images of the internal microstructure of the MSWI-based filling body sample under uniaxial compression. Industrial CT uses advanced high-frequency constant-voltage X-ray sources, digital imaging detectors, and high-precision mechanical detection platforms to accurately display the CT tomographic sections of the scanned sample. Loading scheme The creep test was carried out on the TKA-TCA-3 triple-saturated soil rheological triaxial apparatus produced by Nanjing Taikeao Technology Co., Ltd. Through the uniaxial compression test, the uniaxial compressive strength (UCS) of the samples with the abovementioned mixture ratio was found to be 2.5 ± 0.1 MPa at 28 days, and the uniaxial creep test was carried out on the samples, with 50%, 60%, 70%, 80% and 90% of the UCS as the design axial pressure. The test scheme is shown in Table 3. A triaxial creep test was designed on the basis of the uniaxial creep test results. The axial pressures were 50%, 70% and 90% of the UCS. The selection of the confining pressure was based on the engineering background and was calculated by referring to the empirical formula. The formula is as follows: Table 3Loading scheme for the uniaxial creep test.NumberSample height/mmSample diameter/mmAxial stress/MPaStress level/UCS%h1100.150.11.2550h2100.250.11.5060h3100.150.21.7570h4100.250.12.0080h5100.150.22.2590The stress level is the percentage of axial stress to UCS. Loading scheme for the uniaxial creep test. The stress level is the percentage of axial stress to UCS. In this formula, P is the confining pressure, MPa, and h is the burial depth, m. This test is designed on the background of a coal mine goaf in Fuxin city, Liaoning Province. The depth range of the coal mine goaf is between 20 and 40 m. Through the calculation of Eq. (1), the confining pressures of the triaxial creep test were determined to be 0.2 MPa, 0.3 MPa, 0.4 MPa, and 0.5 MPa. The final test plan is shown in Table 4. The creep test was carried out by loading separately, and each load was continuously applied for 72 h. The loading mode is shown in Fig. 1. Table 4Triaxial creep test design.ConfiningPressure/MPaAxial pressure/MPaConfiningPressureDifference/MPa1.25/MPa1.75/MPa2.25/MPa0.2/MPa1.05/MPa1.55/MPa2.05/MPa0.3/MPa0.95/MPa1.45/MPa1.95/MPa0.4/MPa0.85/MPa1.35/MPa1.85/MPa0.5/MPa0.75/MPa1.25/MPa1.75/MPa Triaxial creep test design. Creep test instruments. Microscopic characteristics of the samples Analysis of geological polymerization reactions Figure 2 shows the sample preparation process, microscopic morphology, and formation of the main gel product. The preparation process of the materials, stirring, sample molding, and curing are shown in Fig. 2. After the material forms a solidified body, it is scanned by an electron microscope to obtain the microscopic morphology of the gel material, which is roughly judged to exhibit a flocculent and three-dimensional network structure. Geopolymers form large amounts of silicate gel and aluminosilicate gel substances through the depolymerization‒condensation of Si‒O tetrahedra and Al‒O tetrahedra26,27. This gel product has a stable structure and fixes unreacted MSWI fly ash in an interwoven, entangled, and wrapped manner. Water glass provides stable active SiO2, and NaOH provides an alkaline environment during the adjustment of the water glass modulus, allowing many OH- ions to enter the material interior, breaking the surface glass of the material and releasing active Si4+, Al3+, Ca2+, and Na+ions into the Si‒O‒Si bond28. Through depolymerization‒condensation reactions, new gel substances are formed, as shown in the microscopic molecular structure morphology in Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of the sample preparation process, microscopic morphology, and formation of the main gel product. The combination of NaOH and water glass excites slag cementitious materials to produce fewer cracks on the surface, with products distributed in the structure in a flocculent and clustered form, stabilizing the material structure and presenting a regular arrangement29,30. Owing to the continuous intervention of Na+ ions, a small amount of N-A-S–H (sodium aluminosilicate gel) is generated in the polymerization product, which has a three-dimensional network structure and is entangled with the abovementioned gel substances, making it difficult to distinguish. The analysis of fine-scale tests on municipal solid waste incineration (MSWI) fly ash-based inorganic cementitious materials revealed that the predominant reaction products, including C-(A)-S–H gel, consisted of spherical and nanoscale particles31. The organic matter in the material reacts with the slag based polymer to form a new phase, which is named C-(A)–S–H/polymer gel. C-(A)-S–H/polymer gel has a high degree of polymerization, such as three-dimensional network structure, so it can bridge cracks in multiple directions and further inhibit crack propagation32,33. The simultaneous addition of MSWI and slag not only formed a network between organic and inorganic, but also formed a network structure of organic matter, mainly C-(A)-S–H/polymer gel. This leads to the cross distribution of different products on the micro surface, resulting in the formation of an interpenetrating network structure of organic–inorganic composite cementitious materials in three-dimensional space. The cross distribution of C-(A)-S–H/polymer gel, C-(A)-S–H gel and unreacted slag forms a three-dimensional network structure, which is more conducive to bridging cracks and improving toughness34,35. Pore structure characteristics Figure 3 shows a schematic diagram of the CT scan of the test sample. The scanning sections of the top layer, middle layer and bottom layer are shown in Fig. 3, and fine pores can be clearly observed. The pores in a sample are generally small and unevenly distributed. According to Fig. 3, the top layer of the section has more pores, the middle layer has fewer pores, and the bottom layer has fewer pores, which indicates that the internal gas in the material is discharged upward as a whole due to vibration and other reasons during the production process of the sample, resulting in this pore stratification phenomenon. CT scanning revealed that the pore distribution of the test sample was uneven, but the number of pores was small, which had little effect on the stability of the overall structure. Owing to the large number of pores in the top layer, the top bearing capacity of the sample is reduced, and then a creep test is carried out to evaluate the long-term stability of the sample. Schematic diagram of the CT scanning section of a sample. With the increase of hydrogen in the sample, the pore structure changes to a coarser distribution. The shrinkage of particles and the formation of pores may be caused by the evaporation of water in geopolymer matrix. Geopolymers are mostly composed of zeolite minerals with three-dimensional pore structure. Geopolymer molecular sieves have the same cell in a short time, but the pores do not change significantly in a long time. There is unreacted interlayer water in the geopolymer structure. Through external evaporation, the water in the sample volatilizes, and gradually forms some small pores. Some fine pores can be explained that the space filling trend of precipitated nano zeolites is related to the energy loss of covalent bonds between the crystal boundaries of nano zeolites: the more water used in synthesis, the more space for precipitation, so due to the energy loss, the smaller the trend of crystal boundary connection. This may be a valuable property of Geopolymer in some applications. Creep characteristics and discussion of MSWI fly ash-based filling materials Uniaxial creep characteristics The strain‒time curve of uniaxial creep is shown in Fig. 4. The curve in the figure shows that there are three main forms of creep curves for alkali-activated MSWI fly ash-based filling materials under uniaxial compression. The specific characteristics of the curve are as follows. ① As shown in Fig. 4 (a), (b) and (c), when the axial stress level is low, the creep curve is stable. At the moment of loading, the curve rises rapidly and then enters the decelerating creep stage. The deformation of a sample mainly occurs in the early stage of loading. When the sample is compacted, the creep curve enters the stable stage, and the increase range is small. Creep increases with time and remains constant, indicating stable creep. ② As shown in Fig. 4 (d), when the stress level increases to a certain level (80% of the UCS), the creep curve begins to change. After decelerating creep, the strain continues to increase, and the strain is linearly related to time, indicating metastable creep. ③ As shown in Fig. 4 (e), when the stress level reaches 90% of the UCS, the upper load is close to the bearing limit of the sample. With increasing time, the creep curve experiences a decelerating creep stage, a constant creep stage and an accelerating creep stage. When the creep amount accumulates to a certain extent, the curve rises rapidly, the sample is destroyed, and the creep curve shows unstable creep. Creep curves of the samples under uniaxial stress. Figure 4(e) shows a summary of the creep curves of different materials at different stress levels. The creep curve cluster reveals that the total creep amount of the fly ash-based filling material is 0.46 ~ 0.78%, which is similar to the creep deformation of soft rock36. The instantaneous creep amount is between 0.40% and 0.62%, accounting for 80.21 ~ 92.51% of the total creep amount of the sample. The instantaneous deformation of a sample during loading contributes most of the total deformation during the whole creep process. Figure 4(e)-(f) shows that the axial deformation of the fly ash-based filling material is different from that of ordinary rock when it is near failure. As described in Reference37, the deformation of ordinary rock is small when it is close to failure, and the failure process is short. In contrast, the failure of fly ash-based filling materials is relatively slow. When the axial pressure is 80% of the UCS, the material does not fail after 72 h, and the particles near the diagonal of the sample obviously move but are not separated. When the stress reaches 90%, although the sample eventually fails, it has experienced more than 10 h from the accelerating creep stage to material failure, and the strain in the accelerating creep stage exceeds 0.1%. This is mainly because the waste incineration fly ash-slag system generates gel products internally after alkali activation, and these polymerization products closely bond the raw material particles together. When subjected to external loads, the gel products between the raw material particles are compressed, which plays a role in cementation and buffering so that the particles do not separate too quickly while moving. Triaxial creep characteristics The conventional triaxial creep results of the MSWI fly ash-based filling materials under different confining pressures are shown in Fig. 5. Under the confining pressures tested, most of the samples did not fail, which indicated that the presence of confining pressure was beneficial to the stability of the filling body. There are three main types of triaxial creep test curves used in this study: ‘decelerating creep‒stable creep’, ‘decelerating creep‒constant creep’, and ‘decelerating creep‒constant creep‒accelerating creep’. As shown in Fig. 5 (c) and (d), when the confining pressure is 0.4 MPa and 0.5 MPa, the creep curves first decelerate creep and then stabilize creep. This is because the higher confining pressure provides lateral restraint for the sample so that the sample can obtain a higher bearing capacity in the axial direction, and its stability can be guaranteed. As shown in Fig. 5 (b), when the confining pressure is 0.3 MPa and the axial pressure is 2.25 MPa, the filling material enters the constant creep stage after decelerating creep, and the axial strain increases slowly, but the sample is not destroyed. As shown in Fig. 5 (a), when the confining pressure is low (0.2 MPa) but the axial pressure is high (2.25 MPa), the sample enters the accelerating creep stage after experiencing decelerating creep and stable creep and finally fails. This is because under the action of a higher axial stress, the lower confining pressure is not enough to restrain the development of internal cracks in the material, and the internal structure of the sample is destroyed after undergoing continuous deformation. Triaxial creep test results at different envelope pressures. Analysis of the creep deformation law The instantaneous strain, creep strain, and instantaneous elastic modulus of the samples under different confining pressures are listed in Table 5. According to Table 5, under different confining pressures, the instantaneous strain of the MSWI fly ash-based filling material is much greater than the creep strain. The instantaneous creep and creep strains both increase with increasing axial stress, and the ratio of the creep strain to the instantaneous strain is between 0.03 and 0.44. Under different confining pressures, the instantaneous elastic modulus increases with increasing axial stress. Table 5Strain and instantaneous elastic modulus.Confiningpressure/MPaAxial pressure/MPaInstantaneous strain/%Creep strain/%Strain ratioModulus of instantaneous elasticity/MPa01.250.43820.01680.0383285.31.750.51290.04460.0869341.22.250.63620.14200.2232353.70.21.250.48870.07130.1459255.81.750.57540.07960.1383304.12.250.63400.28010.4418354.90.31.250.45630.06170.1352273.91.750.56920.06680.1174307.42.250.59230.13370.2257379.90.41.250.39510.05990.1516316.41.750.53150.06250.1176329.32.250.60000.06030.1005375.00.51.250.38810.01790.0461322.11.750.52250.03850.0736334.92.250.58410.04300.0736385.2 Strain and instantaneous elastic modulus. The changes in the instantaneous strain and creep strain with respect to the confining pressure are plotted in Fig. 6. When the axial stress is 2.25 MPa, the instantaneous strain decreases with increasing confining pressure. When the confining pressure is 0, the instantaneous strain reaches a maximum. When the axial stresses are 1.25 MPa and 1.75 MPa, the instantaneous strain first increases but then decreases with increasing confining pressure and reaches the maximum value when the confining pressure is 0.2 MPa. When a sample is subjected to axial stress, the instantaneous “resistance” is the instantaneous strength of the sample. The instantaneous elastic modulus increases with increasing axial stress. Relationship between strain and confining pressure. The changes in the creep strain-to-instantaneous strain ratio and instantaneous elastic modulus with increasing confining pressure are plotted in Fig. 7. Figure 7 (a) shows that when the confining pressure increases, the ratio of the creep strain to the instantaneous strain first increases but then decreases. When the axial stress is 2.25 MPa and the confining pressure is 0.2 MPa, the ratio of the creep strain to the instantaneous strain reaches a maximum. Figure 7 (b) shows that when the confining pressure increases, the instantaneous elastic modulus first decreases but then increases. When the axial stress is 1.25 MPa and the confining pressure is 0.2 MPa, the instantaneous elastic modulus reaches the minimum value of 255.8 MPa. Strain ratio and instantaneous elastic modulus. Creep deformation rate analysis The straight-line segments in the ε‒log(t) curves of the samples under different confining pressures are drawn in Fig. 8. Under different confining pressures, as the axial stress increases, the slope of the ε-log(t) curve of the sample increases. Under different axial stresses, with increasing confining pressure, the slope of the ε-log (t) curve first increases but then decreases. When the confining pressure is 0.2 MPa, the slope of the ε-log (t) curve reaches a maximum. The results show that when the samples enter creep, the main load is the friction force between the solid particles in the samples. As the gap between particles gradually narrows, the strength of the samples is essentially stable. Under the action of each level of axial stress, the soil will form a corresponding strength according to the magnitude of axial stress, which is consistent with the above analysis conclusion of the relationship between the instantaneous elastic modulus and stress. Relationship of ε-log(t) under different confining pressures. Fractional creep constitutive model of MSWI fly ash-based filling material Selection of the one-dimensional creep constitutive model The test results reveal three forms of creep curves under constant loading: stable creep, metastable creep and unstable creep. To increase the universality of the model, the Burgers model is used to describe stable creep, metastable creep, decelerating creep and the constant creep stage of unstable creep (Fig. 9). Burgers model. According to the series rule, it can be obtained that Substituting the rheological models of the M body and K body into Eq. (2), we can obtain With , the creep model of the Burgers body can be obtained by integrating Eq. (3). The Burgers model can describe decelerating creep and stable creep, but it cannot directly describe accelerating creep. The existing classical components cannot meet the requirements of the constitutive model for accelerating creep. Therefore, it is necessary to introduce the fractional order model to describe the accelerating creep stage in the creep curve, which increases exponentially. The fractional order model derived from the ideal elastomer and ideal fluid has the ability to describe both solids and fluids, which is usually characterized by the Abel sticky pot. The rheological constitutive equation of the Abel sticky pot is shown in Eq. (5). In this formula, ξ is the viscosity coefficient of the Abel sticky pot, MPa·hβ, and β is the fractional order of the Abel sticky pot. With a constant stress, the rheological equation is calculated via Riemann–Liouville fractional differential operator theory. The creep equation of the Abel sticky pot can be obtained as follows: In this formula, Γ is the Gamma function. The test data indicate that constant creep or accelerating creep of the filling body will not occur under any first-order load but will be triggered when the load level exceeds a certain limit. Therefore, when the fractional-order model is used, a switch representing the long-term strength should be connected in parallel. When the stress level reaches the long-term strength limit, the sample undergoes constant or accelerated creep, and the Abel sticky pot starts. Finally, the nonlinear fractional-order viscoplastic element is connected in series with the Burgers model to obtain a nonlinear fractional-order viscoelastic plastic model that can reasonably describe the whole process of decelerating creep, stable creep and accelerating creep of the waste incineration fly ash-based mine filling material. According to the series rule, the overall constitutive relationship of the model can be obtained as shown in Eq. (7), and the model structure is shown in Fig. 10. The long-term strength of the fly ash-based filling material is obtained via the isochronous stress‒strain curve cluster method. According to Fig. 11 (a), the long-term strength is between 1.75 MPa and 2 MPa, which is close to 1.8 MPa. Structural form of the nonlinear fractional viscoelastic‒plastic model. Comparison of the creep test results. Fig. 11 (b) shows the creep curves of the samples under peak loads of 50%, 60%, 70%, 80% and 90% of the UCS and the fitting curves of the Burgers model. The curves in the figure show that the fitting effect of the model is good, and the calculated data are in good agreement with the measured data. When the axial stress level is small, that is, when the creep curve has no accelerating creep stage, the Burgers model can accurately describe the creep process and trend. When the axial stress level exceeds the long-term strength, the fractional order model can describe the metastable curve and the unstable curve. Derivation of the three-dimensional creep constitutive model Under the triaxial stress state, the stress tensor inside a sample is decomposed into a spherical stress tensor and a deviatoric stress tensor. The expressions of the spherical stress tensor and the deviatoric stress tensor are Here, is the principal stress, MPa, and is the Kronecker function. From the further derivation of Eq. (7), we can obtain where i, j and k can be 1, 2 and 3, respectively. On the basis of the basic assumption of material isotropy, the spherical stress tensor causes only the volume of the material to change without changing the shape of the material. In contrast, the deviatoric stress tensor causes only the shape of the material to change, so Hooke’s law involving the rheological problem is only the deviatoric tensor part. The strain tensor is decomposed into a spherical strain tensor εm and a deviatoric strain tensor eij: Equation (10) can be derived to obtain Under the triaxial stress state, the Hooke body expression of the material is as follows: In this formula, K is the bulk modulus, MPa, and G is the shear modulus, MPa. In this formula, μ is Poisson’s ratio. It is assumed that the spherical stress tensor causes elastic strain and that the deviatoric stress tensor causes creep. The creep equation of the material under the triaxial stress state can be expressed as In this formula, is the shear modulus of the Hooke body in the M body, MPa, and is the shear modulus of the Hooke body in the K body, MPa. By adding the spherical strain tensor on both sides of the deviatoric stress tensor in Eq. (14) and combining it with Eqs. (9) ~ (13), the three-dimensional creep equation of the Burgers model can be obtained as follows: On the basis of Eq. (15), the three-dimensional equation of the nonlinear creep model of the MSWI fly ash-based mine filling material is obtained by introducing the fractional-order Abel clay pot The triaxial creep data were fitted with Origin2021; the formula was edited with the explicit function Origin C, and the Levenberg‒Marquardt optimization algorithm was used for calculation. In the initial calculation, the parameters are controlled to be positive, the independent variable (time) is iterated from 0, and finally, the fitting curve is obtained. The fitting results of the creep curve data under different confining pressures are shown in Fig. 12, and the parameter identification results are listed in Table 6. Figure 12 shows that before the conventional triaxial creep test reaches long-term strength, the three-dimensional form of the Burgers model can predict the trend of the test data well, and the fitting results are in good agreement with the measured data. When the load level reaches the long-term strength of the material, the fractional order model is used, as shown in Figs. 12(a), (b) and (c). The model fitting curve is highly coincident with the test curve, which indicates that the fractional order model can also accurately describe the creep process of the MSWI fly ash-based filling material in the three-dimensional state38. The parameter identification results of the model are shown in Table 6. The data in the table indicate that the R2of the fitting results under different load conditions is greater than 98%, so the fitting results are good39,40. As shown in Fig. 12(d), to prove the applicability of the formula deduced in this study, the creep data of the filling materials prepared in References41and are fitted42. The calculation results indicate that the measured data and the fitted data are in good agreement; that is, the formula deduced in this paper has certain universality in describing the long-term mechanical properties of the filling materials in the mine goaf with an accelerating creep stage. Triaxial creep curve fitting results. Table 6Three-dimensional fractional order model parameter identification results.σ1/MPaσ3/MPaK/MPaGM/MPaηm/MPa•hGK/MPaηK/(MPa•h)ηF/(MPa•h)βR2/%1.250.2032.9026.46353.5450.367.88--99.141.250.3036.5832.21416.6760.4311.68--98.361.250.4039.0040.13524.6979.1414.57--99.011.250.5043.7847.62568.1882.2415.40--99.591.750.2028.3421.50260.9439.385.46--99.201.750.3032.4828.30305.9158.098.28--99.001.750.4036.0036.12441.1874.1410.88--98.211.750.5040.1042.34508.1377.5912.91--99.322.250.2013.5416.28236.4529.913.670.433.3299.322.250.3015.2216.60258.9633.894.400.030.6398.942.250.4017.6117.04259.1035.465.440.020.5299.012.250.5024.7418.73305.4138.286.460.020.4299.34 Three-dimensional fractional order model parameter identification results. Conclusion In this work, an alkali-activated MSWI fly ash-based filling material was prepared with MSWI fly ash as the raw material and slag as the auxiliary material. To evaluate the long-term stability of the fly ash-based filling materials, the creep properties were tested. First, the uniaxial creep test was carried out at five levels of axial compression: 50%, 60%, 70%, 80% and 90% of the UCS. The triaxial creep test was subsequently carried out on the basis of the uniaxial creep test, and the creep characteristics of the fly ash-based filling materials under a three-dimensional stress state were explored. Finally, the following conclusions were obtained. (1) When the MSWI fly ash-based filling material was subjected to a constant axial load, three forms of creep were observed: stable creep, metastable creep and unstable creep. When the axial load reached 90% of the UCS, the internal damage accumulation of the material accelerated. Therefore, the upper load of the MSWI fly ash-based filling material should not exceed 90% of the axial peak stress in actual application processes. (2) The total creep amount of the MSWI fly ash-based filling material was 0.46 ~ 0.78%, similar to the creep deformation of soft rock. The instantaneous deformation of the sample during loading contributed most of the total deformation. The polymerization products generated in the MSWI fly ash-based filling material system could effectively cement the raw material particles, and the presence of the gel could effectively delay the accelerating creep process of the material. (3) The Burgers model can describe decelerating creep and stable creep but cannot directly describe accelerating creep. The Abel sticky pot with a switch was connected in series with the Burgers model to obtain a fractional order model that can reasonably describe the whole process of decelerating creep, stable creep and accelerating creep of MSWI fly ash-based mine filling materials. When the fractional order of the Abel sticky pot was greater than 1, the model could describe the accelerating creep stage. Prospect The application direction of MSWI fly ash in the field of building materials or environmental materials needs to be further explored. The application direction of MSWI fly ash in the field of building materials or environmental materials needs to be further explored. In addition to the study of creep properties of MSWI fly ash as filling material, it is also necessary to explore the stability of other properties in order to better explore more possibilities of MSWI fly ash43–45. In addition to the study of creep properties of MSWI fly ash as filling material, it is also necessary to explore the stability of other properties in order to better explore more possibilities of MSWI fly ash43–45. Acknowledgements The authors wish to gratefully acknowledge the financial support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 52104132, 52074144). Author contributions Lijuan Su: Conceptualization, methodology, project administration, writing – original draft. Siyao Wu: Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Writing—review & editing. Guosheng Fu: Writing—review & editing, Investigation. Wancheng Zhu: Visualization, Software. Xiangdong Zhang: Resources, Formal analysis, Validation. Bing Liang: Data curation. Funding National Natural Science Foundation of China,52104132 Data availability The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request. Declarations Competing Interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.