TIDieR-WASH: A Guideline for Reporting Implementation of Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene Interventions Authors: Jonny Crocker, Emily Ogutu, Jedidiah S Snyder, Antoinette Kome, Ben Tidwell, Jan Willem Rosenboom, Jesse Shapiro, Jessy Samuyachi Mahongo, Kelly T Alexander, Michael E Gnilo, Om Prasad Gautam, Sara Hoffman, Sovattha Neou, Matthew C Freeman Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractIntroduction:Accurate information on context and implementation of public health interventions is necessary to replicate, adapt, and scale effective interventions and to interpret evaluations. Reporting the context and implementation of water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) interventions has been inconsistent and incomplete.Methods:To improve the reporting of WASH interventions, we developed the Template for Intervention Description and Replication for WASH (TIDieR-WASH) checklist and guide, by adapting and expanding the original TIDieR guide. We performed a scoping review of existing implementation reporting guidelines, and of current implementation reporting in WASH evaluations, to develop a list of candidate items to include in this checklist. We then used a 4-stages of review by international experts to reach consensus.Results:The resulting 14-item checklist comprises: a) name, b) theory of change, c) prior evidence, d) location and setting, e) context, f) suitability, g) implementers, h) recipients, i) targeting, j) activities, k) intervention dose, l) fidelity, m) costs, and n) materials. Definitions, explanations, examples, and instructions for use are reported in this article.Discussion:The checklist can be applied to all types of evaluations of WASH interventions, including direct service provision, behavior change, and systems strengthening interventions. We deliberately developed this guidance document to be accessible and relevant to practitioners and researchers. Adoption of this checklist will support transparent reporting of WASH implementation for research and practice. As with other sectors that have used TIDieR checklists, clear implementation reporting can assist with evidence synthesis, adaptation, and policy guidance. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP14780 Background Evaluation is the application of systematic methods to quantify and explore the link between a program or intervention and its intended outcomes.1 The results of evaluations can confirm and strengthen the evidence of intervention efficacy or effectiveness and can reveal heterogeneity of outcomes. Evaluations, including program evaluations and research studies, are one of the primary sources of evidence used to influence policy, practice, and funding decisions for foundations, nongovernmental organizations, governments, and multilateral agencies. High-profile impact evaluations can dramatically impact the funding and program landscape.2 Internal validity, external validity, and quality of reporting determine the value of evaluations. With inconsistent reporting of context and implementation, evaluations are not able to provide sufficient guidance for stakeholders to replicate, adapt, and scale successful interventions, and evidence synthesis across heterogeneous contexts and programs is a considerable challenge. Variation in context and implementation drives heterogeneity in effects of water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) interventions, and reporting context and implementation is critical for evidence synthesis and effective adaptation.3,4 WASH interventions focus on increasing access to and use of safe WASH services.5,6 External validity—the applicability of evaluation results to a new population—is difficult to assess and infrequently addressed in the authors’ experience. Reporting the implementation outcomes of WASH interventions in particular presents several challenges. WASH interventions are complex and multifaceted, which has led to challenges in adaptation and scale.7 Measuring implementation fidelity of multicomponent WASH interventions is complex but critical to understanding what was done (e.g., activities or inputs), what was delivered (outputs), and effectiveness (outcomes and impacts).8 Contextual considerations required for interventions must be reported alongside implementation outcomes to allow accurate interpretation of findings and ensure programmatic and policy relevance, because context can drive variation in outcomes between studies.9–11 We believe that accurate and consistent reporting of context and implementation would facilitate comparisons of interventions’ effectiveness and impact, and enable cost–benefit analyses of public health investment strategies. Failure to report these details can lead to an inaccurate conclusion that an intervention is ineffective, when it may have been inadequately implemented or unsuitable for a given context (known as Type III error—e.g., a school handwashing intervention where soap was never delivered).12 In addition, adaptation and scale-up of promising interventions are impossible without sufficient implementation details, such as implementer qualifications, and intervention activities and dose (the quantity of an intervention delivered and amount of participation). Despite extensive literature on the importance and application of process evaluation and implementation science,8,13,14 robust reporting of implementation details remains inconsistent in WASH and other environmental health interventions. As part of formative research, we found that even the most-cited WASH evaluations insufficiently reported the relevant implementation details needed to replicate, adapt, or scale up the evaluated interventions—as few as 5% reported all the implementation details required.15 This inadequate reporting presents a critical evidence gap because it limits accurate interpretation of evaluation findings and the subsequent use of those findings for evidence-based decision-making. The field of Implementation Science has emerged over the past dozen years with a suite of methods to develop standard language, definitions, and guidance on implementation processes and evaluation methods, among other things.16 Many health research reporting guidelines have been developed and widely adopted, aided in part by the EQUATOR Network repository for these guidelines (www.equator-network.org, accessed February 2022). For example, the CONSORT checklist for reporting clinical trials has been endorsed by 500+ journals and has demonstrated impact on the quality of reporting in peer-reviewed articles.17 Researchers with a focus primarily on clinical practice have called for standardization of reporting implementation strategies.18 The original Template for Intervention Description and Replication (TIDieR) checklist—designed to improve the completeness of reporting and the replicability of health care interventions within clinical trials—is also mandated by many journals.14 However, we lack guidance on how to report WASH and other environmental health interventions. Developing WASH-specific TIDieR guidance would facilitate transparent and consistent reporting of WASH interventions and could facilitate developing guidance for reporting implementation of environmental health interventions at large. We developed an easily adoptable checklist approach to report context and implementation of WASH interventions that can be used by researchers, policymakers, and practitioners to support comparisons across studies, programs, and contexts. Our goal is to provide clear and consistent guidance that improves how WASH intervention context and implementation is measured and reported by those conducting WASH evaluations. Ideally, this checklist should be consulted before an intervention begins, be it part of a research study, project, or program to inform measurement and monitoring and evaluation. At a minimum, the checklist should be used during the write-up stage to ensure that all the recommended items are clearly reported and document the location of that information. Methods for Developing the Checklist We developed the checklist using an iterative process comprising a) a review of existing reporting checklists; b) a scoping literature review; and c) four stages of expert review and consensus. To develop an initial list of reporting items for the checklist, we conducted an exploratory search to identify best practice guidelines for reporting details of interventions, projects, and implementation strategies in the fields of medicine and public health. We searched Google Scholar for articles that contained [(reporting OR checklist) AND (guidance OR guideline) AND (implementation OR intervention)]. We also reviewed the full list of 554 reporting guidelines stored on the EQUATOR Network, which compiles health research reporting guidelines (www.equator-network.org, accessed February 2022). We initially identified 14 distinct reporting items recommended by at least one of the four relevant reporting guidelines we identified, which included: a) the “Template for Intervention Description and Replication (TIDieR) Checklist and Guide”14; b) the “Specifying and Reporting Complex Behaviour Change Interventions: the Need for a Scientific Method” editorial19; c) the “Action, Actor, Context, Target, Time (AACTT)” framework for specifying behavior20; and d) “Implementation Strategies: Recommendations for Specifying and Reporting.”13 To refine this initial list, we conducted a scoping review to assess and categorize the level of reporting of context and implementation in WASH evaluations. The scoping review, which was conducted as a step in the development of this checklist, has been published elsewhere.15 We reviewed the 40 most-cited evaluations of WASH interventions published in the last 10 y (2012–2022) identified by searching Web of Science (www.webofscience.com) using the following search terms: [(water OR sanitation OR hygiene OR handwashing OR hand-washing OR hand hygiene OR WASH) AND (intervention OR implementation OR project OR program OR case study OR trial OR “evaluat*” OR “sustain*” OR “assess*” OR “impact*” OR “outcome*” OR protocol”)]. We then screened articles for eligibility and extracted data on context and implementation reporting. We tested the preliminary list of 14 reporting items on a subset of the articles that met our systematic search criteria and expanded the list to better represent the complexity of WASH interventions. We expanded the list by identifying details of context and implementation that were reported in the articles included in our scoping review that were not captured by the preliminary list of 14 items, then creating a new item to capture that detail. Using this process, we expanded the 14 items to a total of 25 items during the scoping review and used the 25-item list for the first stage of our expert review. A mapping of how these lists correspond to each other is in Table S1. Our expert review process had four rounds of feedback and consensus. In the first round, we presented the list of 25 items at an academic conference (to ∼35 session attendees representing all major geographic regions of the world) to solicit feedback on the clarity and comprehensiveness of the items (i.e., whether they covered all relevant context and implementation items for WASH interventions). The main feedback was on the perceived value of the checklist and a concern that a reporting guideline did not already exist specifically for WASH. In the first round, we presented the list of 25 items at an academic conference (to ∼35 session attendees representing all major geographic regions of the world) to solicit feedback on the clarity and comprehensiveness of the items (i.e., whether they covered all relevant context and implementation items for WASH interventions). The main feedback was on the perceived value of the checklist and a concern that a reporting guideline did not already exist specifically for WASH. The second round involved presentation and discussion of the 25 items among our advisory group of 14 experts. This group of experts are all coauthors; were from North America, Europe, Africa, and Asia; and were from research, implementation, and donor organizations. These experts were selected from the Emory team’s network of previous collaborators based on perceived expertise and knowledge on implementing and evaluating WASH interventions. In this stage we received feedback primarily on how to improve the terminology and definitions of the items. The second round involved presentation and discussion of the 25 items among our advisory group of 14 experts. This group of experts are all coauthors; were from North America, Europe, Africa, and Asia; and were from research, implementation, and donor organizations. These experts were selected from the Emory team’s network of previous collaborators based on perceived expertise and knowledge on implementing and evaluating WASH interventions. In this stage we received feedback primarily on how to improve the terminology and definitions of the items. The third round involved pilot-testing the checklist with practitioners from WASH teams from two nongovernmental organizations (CARE and World Vision International). WASH teams from each organization reviewed the checklist, noted which items they currently collected data on, and provided feedback on clarity and feasibility of each item. The main feedback was 2-fold: that the checklist needed to be accompanied by the full guidance document, including examples, before it would be feasible to use as a reporting tool; and that there was a lot of repetition between items. Thus, for the next round we collapsed the number of items and drafted the full guideline. The third round involved pilot-testing the checklist with practitioners from WASH teams from two nongovernmental organizations (CARE and World Vision International). WASH teams from each organization reviewed the checklist, noted which items they currently collected data on, and provided feedback on clarity and feasibility of each item. The main feedback was 2-fold: that the checklist needed to be accompanied by the full guidance document, including examples, before it would be feasible to use as a reporting tool; and that there was a lot of repetition between items. Thus, for the next round we collapsed the number of items and drafted the full guideline. The fourth round involved presentation and discussion of the next iteration of the checklist with 14 items along with the draft guidance document (containing item definitions, explanations, and examples) to our advisory group. After the fourth review, one additional item (costs) was added, and two items (context and enabling environment) were combined. The fourth round involved presentation and discussion of the next iteration of the checklist with 14 items along with the draft guidance document (containing item definitions, explanations, and examples) to our advisory group. After the fourth review, one additional item (costs) was added, and two items (context and enabling environment) were combined. For this expert review process we started with a list of potential checklist items rather than soliciting recommended items in an open-ended manner.21 We deemed this approach appropriate, because implementation reporting checklists for other sectors already existed as a starting point. This established method has been previously used for development of related guidelines.14,22,23 After each round of interaction with experts, the core team met to review feedback and revise the checklist and guideline for presentation and feedback at the subsequent expert review. Results: The Checklist, Definitions, and Explanations Instructions for Use The checklist that resulted from our checklist-development process is shown in Table 1. The checklist is relevant for many levels and scales of interventions and applies to reporting and evaluation of WASH interventions, regardless of their application in projects, programs, research, or policy. For complex or large-scale interventions that involve multiple components, multiple checklists can be filled out for each distinct component, or additional columns can be added to the checklist so that each intervention component has a separate column. Table 1TIDieR-WASH Checklist.ItemDefinition 1. NameProvide a name or phrase that describes the intervention. 2. Theory of changeDescribe how the intervention is expected to affect the target outcomes. 3. Prior evidenceDescribe any prior effectiveness evidence for this or related interventions. 4. Location and settingList the geographical locations and settings where implementation occurred. 5. ContextDetail all known relevant contextual factors for each location reached by the intervention. 6. SuitabilityJustify why the intervention is relevant and appropriate for where it was implemented. 7. ImplementersList all the institutions who provided each intervention or type of activity. 8. RecipientsReport the number of recipients or the population reached, and descriptive statistics of those recipients. 9. TargetingReport whether any intervention components were targeted to specific subpopulations, how they were targeted, and how the target subpopulations were identified. 10. ActivitiesProvide a clear, detailed description of the activities included, their procedures, and supporting activities. 11. Intervention doseQuantify the frequency and number of contacts between implementers and recipients, and the duration of those contacts. 12. FidelityReport fidelity monitoring and actual fidelity. Include any planned or unplanned modifications to the intervention. 13. CostsReport the program costs by activity category and input type. 14. MaterialsDescribe all materials delivered as part of the intervention or used to guide the intervention. TIDieR-WASH Checklist. 1. Name 1. Name 2. Theory of change 2. Theory of change 3. Prior evidence 3. Prior evidence 4. Location and setting 4. Location and setting 5. Context 5. Context 6. Suitability 6. Suitability 7. Implementers 7. Implementers 8. Recipients 8. Recipients 9. Targeting 9. Targeting 10. Activities 10. Activities 11. Intervention dose 11. Intervention dose 12. Fidelity 12. Fidelity 13. Costs 13. Costs 14. Materials 14. Materials The checklist can be considered a table of contents for the intervention, pointing to the location where additional detail can be found, because the information recommended in the checklist will (in most cases) be located in journal articles, project reports, implementation protocols and plans, and other gray-literature resources. As such, the information does not need to be reported within the checklist template itself, unless it is not located elsewhere. Instead, the checklist template should be used to direct readers to where the information is located. All information should be publicly available, and URLs should be provided for online sources. For information that is located behind a paywall, that information should be replicated in an online supplement or other free-to-access location if permitted. See Table S2 for an example of how the checklist should be completed. The checklist should be used even if not all items can be full reported (“Not available” can be entered in these cases). We recommend that the checklist be consulted prior to starting an intervention so that monitoring tools can be designed to capture the required information. Although this checklist was designed to be easily adoptable, organizations may find that new skills and data collection tools are needed to properly document and report all the items recommended in this guidance. For each of the 14 items in the checklist, we have provided additional details of what should be reported, the justification for including that item in the checklist, and multiple examples for each item in the Supplemental Material under “Reporting Examples,” some of which are reproduced from empirical studies.24–27 These examples are illustrative of the type of information that should be reported but are not necessarily sufficient reporting for a full program. Review of these examples is essential for those applying this checklist to their own evaluation. Not all checklist items require an equal level of detail—activities generally require the most text to adequately report, whereas intervention name requires one sentence. Checklist Items, Definitions, and Explanations Item 1. Name: Provide a name or phrase that describes the intervention. When reporting the intervention name, these guidelines should be followed: If an intervention does not have a specific name (or the name is not descriptive), then a phrase that describes the intervention can be used. If an intervention does not have a specific name (or the name is not descriptive), then a phrase that describes the intervention can be used. Intervention names or phrases should describe the category of intervention (e.g., drinking water, sanitation, hand hygiene, food hygiene) and the intervention strategy (e.g., community-led total sanitation, market-based systems strengthening).14 Intervention names or phrases should describe the category of intervention (e.g., drinking water, sanitation, hand hygiene, food hygiene) and the intervention strategy (e.g., community-led total sanitation, market-based systems strengthening).14 Any abbreviations or acronyms should be spelled out and explained. Any abbreviations or acronyms should be spelled out and explained. A specific name that clearly describes an intervention makes it easy to identify and distinguish different interventions, and to compare the intervention report with other reports that document similar interventions. Item 2. ToC: Describe how the intervention is expected to affect the target outcomes. A theory of change (ToC) should include all intervention components, all intervention components, mediators/intermediate outcomes, mediators/intermediate outcomes, moderators/external factors, moderators/external factors, target outcomes, target outcomes, arrows or some other indicator of causal relationships between items, and arrows or some other indicator of causal relationships between items, and explanation of how consideration of the ToC informed intervention design.28 explanation of how consideration of the ToC informed intervention design.28 A ToC describes how the intervention is expected to lead to the target outcomes. It shows the steps through which intervention components or activities translate into outcomes using if/then causal relationships that are evidence-based or hypothesized (e.g., provision of handwashing facilities and soap will increase pupil hand hygiene following toileting) and identifies mediating and moderating factors that affect outcomes.29 Related items that can be reported in place of a ToC if they meet the same criteria are impact pathway, causal pathway, logic model, conceptual framework, mechanism, or theory. Each intervention component should be included in the ToC to show how it contributes directly or indirectly to target outcomes. The ToC should include mediators, moderators, target outcomes, and their definitions. “Mediators” (or intermediate outcomes) are the immediate changes or results that connect the intervention to the target outcomes. Mediators are considered necessary to achieve target outcomes, and listing and defining them can aid interpretation of effectiveness results.30 “Moderators” (or external factors) modify or influence causal relationships between intervention components and target outcomes and are often considered part of the context.30 “Target outcomes” communicate what the program was designed to impact. Reporting specific target outcomes is important for identifying the primary objective of the intervention, particularly when there is no impact evaluation. Reporting target outcomes can aid in identifying potential interventions to consider to address a gap or problem. Reporting the ToC, as well as measuring and reporting the mediators and moderators, can be useful for diagnosing what went wrong in instances where there was no impact by identifying which pathways were not successfully achieved. Specifically, a ToC can be used to identify if there was intervention failure through process measures (i.e., an intervention component was not completed per protocol) or theory failure (i.e., the results of the activities and outputs did not result in the anticipated change).7 Reporting a ToC is particularly important for WASH, in which there are many potential mediators (e.g., individual behaviors) and moderators (e.g., pathogen exposure via other routes) that can interrupt the causal pathway.2 Organizational and theoretical frameworks are rarely applied to design and adapt WASH interventions, but relevant frameworks that could improve WASH intervention design do exist.7 The F-diagram, which describes the contamination pathways, behavior change interventions frameworks like the Capability, Opportunity, and Motivation Behavior (COM-B) model; the Integrated Behavioral Model for Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (IBM-WASH); and others have supported the understanding of behavior and habit formation, among others.31–34 Item 3. Prior evidence: Describe any prior effectiveness evidence for this or related interventions. Prior evidence reporting should meet the following criteria: It should be reported for both the technology and intervention components (when available). It should be reported for both the technology and intervention components (when available). It should include complete references and links to prior evidence. It should include complete references and links to prior evidence. If there is no prior evidence for the intervention, its elements, or similar interventions, then justification for testing a novel approach should be reported. If there is no prior evidence for the intervention, its elements, or similar interventions, then justification for testing a novel approach should be reported. Prior evidence can come in many forms: Formative research, feasibility studies, biological plausibility or medical research, case studies, pilots, quasi-experimental and randomized trials, and local knowledge and experience can all constitute prior evidence. Prior evidence justifies the purpose of the intervention by showing the evidence base and indicates whether it is feasible and adaptable and whether it has previously produced results. Item 4. Location and setting: List the geographical locations and settings where implementation occurred. Reporting “Location” should name the country, region, and geographic areas where the intervention occurred, name the country, region, and geographic areas where the intervention occurred, include each location for multi-site interventions, and include each location for multi-site interventions, and be as specific as possible (e.g., down to the districts and numbers of communities per district). be as specific as possible (e.g., down to the districts and numbers of communities per district). Reporting Setting should list the types of places the intervention took place, such as household, community, school, health care facility, workplace, or level of government. Location information is often accompanied by a map, which can be strengthened by collecting GIS information from intervention sites. Knowing the intervention locations and settings is important for interpreting results and for decisions about whether to replicate or adapt the intervention. Item 5. Context: Detail all known relevant contextual factors for each location reached by the intervention. Context should cover all factors that may be relevant and have bearing on the intervention. Categories of factors that should be considered include social: cultural,religious,economicdemographic,normative, social: cultural,religious,economicdemographic,normative, cultural, cultural, religious, religious, economic economic demographic, demographic, normative, normative, environmental: built (infrastructure, services)natural (geography, geology, climate, weather, natural disasters, seasonal variation) environmental: built (infrastructure, services)natural (geography, geology, climate, weather, natural disasters, seasonal variation) built (infrastructure, services) built (infrastructure, services) natural (geography, geology, climate, weather, natural disasters, seasonal variation) natural (geography, geology, climate, weather, natural disasters, seasonal variation) governmental and institutional35: policies, standards, and regulations;strategies and guidelines;institutional capacities, roles, arrangements, and coordination (including governmental, nongovernmental, bi- and multilateral, and private-sector institutions);financing, budgeting, and fees; andmonitoring and surveillance governmental and institutional35: policies, standards, and regulations;strategies and guidelines;institutional capacities, roles, arrangements, and coordination (including governmental, nongovernmental, bi- and multilateral, and private-sector institutions);financing, budgeting, and fees; andmonitoring and surveillance policies, standards, and regulations; policies, standards, and regulations; strategies and guidelines; strategies and guidelines; institutional capacities, roles, arrangements, and coordination (including governmental, nongovernmental, bi- and multilateral, and private-sector institutions); institutional capacities, roles, arrangements, and coordination (including governmental, nongovernmental, bi- and multilateral, and private-sector institutions); financing, budgeting, and fees; and financing, budgeting, and fees; and monitoring and surveillance monitoring and surveillance In addition, reporting of context should note at which levels these factors are relevant. Levels that should be considered include32 societal/structural societal/structural community community interpersonal/household interpersonal/household individual (Note: Individual-level factors should be reported under items 7 and 8—implementers and recipients—and are only included in the list here for completeness.). individual (Note: Individual-level factors should be reported under items 7 and 8—implementers and recipients—and are only included in the list here for completeness.). Contextual factors are important drivers of implementation outcomes and intervention effectiveness,2,7,18,25,36 and are thus critical to report for accurate interpretation of results. They also help others decide whether a program can be effectively replicated in a different context, or whether it should be modified and adapted. Context is often measured as part of a preimplementation needs assessment, situational assessment, or baseline assessment. Measurement and reporting of social context factors should explicitly address gender and social inclusion. For example, gender norms, roles, and power dynamics at a household, community, and institutional level that may affect WASH implementation and outcomes; tribal or caste dynamics that may influence the intervention; or any specific morays associated with target groups (e.g., widows, persons with disabilities) should be reported. Reporting of governmental and institutional context factors should include some discussion and reflection on how these factors enable and hamper implementation, scale-up, and sustainability of the WASH intervention being reported. This set of factors is often referred to as the “enabling environment,” which has been defined as the set of interrelated conditions that impact the capacity of development actors in a sustained and effective manner and as the policy, institutional, and financial framework that is necessary for sustaining, scaling up, and replicating programs.35,37 Useful context domains for complex public health interventions have also been proposed.38 Describing potential and anticipated risks to successful implementation can also be part of describing the enabling environment. Enabling environment varies with the kind of intervention to be implemented. For instance, conditions for implementing a community-led total sanitation (CLTS) intervention may differ from conditions for implementing other sanitation interventions. Enabling environment can vary across locations for a single intervention. Item 6. Suitability: Justify why the intervention is relevant and appropriate for where it was implemented. Reporting of suitability should refer to the context,2 refer to the context,2 describe why the intervention is relevant (why it is needed for the location, setting, and population where it was implemented), and describe why the intervention is relevant (why it is needed for the location, setting, and population where it was implemented), and describe why the intervention is appropriate (demonstrate a reasonable expectation that the intervention will have the intended outcome and is sensitive to the context). describe why the intervention is appropriate (demonstrate a reasonable expectation that the intervention will have the intended outcome and is sensitive to the context). Reporting the suitability of the intervention shows that the intervention is appropriate and was deliberately chosen. Providing this information can help implementers to quickly relate the problem with the context. Implementers can also use this information to compare and replicate processes in related settings. Item 7. Implementers: List all the institutions who provided each intervention or type of activity. Reporting of implementers should include all institutions and local actors involved in implementation, all institutions and local actors involved in implementation, the role of each institution (i.e., what component of the intervention(s) each institution implemented), the role of each institution (i.e., what component of the intervention(s) each institution implemented), the background (including objectives or mandates), and qualifications (including experience and relevant) of the institutions and individuals within those institutions who were directly involved in the intervention, and the background (including objectives or mandates), and qualifications (including experience and relevant) of the institutions and individuals within those institutions who were directly involved in the intervention, and any aspects of intervention delivery whose implementation is gender-specific, and the proportion of individuals involved in implementation who were men and women. any aspects of intervention delivery whose implementation is gender-specific, and the proportion of individuals involved in implementation who were men and women. Implementation capacity is a recognized priority in the WASH sector and is critical for effective implementation.24,39,40 Implementation often requires community and stakeholders engagement to ensure maintenance and sustainability of intervention outcomes. Diversity of service providers may create more opportunity for intervention failures where interventions are not delivered as intended and decisions not based on evidence.7 Therefore, identification of different actors that implement each intervention component is critical. Implementation of WASH interventions often involves contributions by local actors and volunteers (e.g., community health workers, teachers, community leaders, mothers), so these actor types and their roles should be specified. Women in particular are often targeted to carry out community- and household-level tasks such as hygiene promotion and water treatment.3,41,42 When women or men are specifically targeted to carry out intervention activities, this should be specified. In addition, during intervention design, gender mainstreaming can be incorporated to address gender inequality in implementation roles and intervention outcomes.43 Item 8: Recipients. Report the number of recipients or population reached for each intervention activity, and descriptive statistics of those recipients. Reporting of recipients should include the number of recipients for each intervention activity. When intervention activities are targeted to population groups (e.g., households, communities, districts), then the number of these units may be reported instead, and the number of recipients for each intervention activity. When intervention activities are targeted to population groups (e.g., households, communities, districts), then the number of these units may be reported instead, and characteristics of recipients—generally sociodemographic indicators, including gender. characteristics of recipients—generally sociodemographic indicators, including gender. Intervention recipients are also referred to as the population reached, beneficiaries, and the target population. Where the size and characteristics of the population reached differ from the population targeted, these differences should be reported. In addition, where different intervention components are targeted to different subpopulations (such as education related to menstrual health being targeted to school-age girls), the characteristics of each subpopulation and the intervention components they received should be reported. Providing information about the recipients and outlining their categories is necessary for targeting interventions. A clear description of the recipients is critical in assessing whether interventions were delivered to intended persons/communities and whether there were any inequities. Providing specific numbers of recipients can guide other implementers when planning to deliver specific interventions. If an intervention is successfully implemented among specific numbers of recipients with cost implications, this information can inform the cost analysis for future interventions. Recipient information is generally provided as demographic characteristics in a table, which should include a gender breakdown. Item 9. Targeting. Report whether any intervention components were targeted to specific subpopulations, how they were targeted, and how the target subpopulations were identified. Reporting of targeting should cover any intervention components delivered to only certain sub-groups of the population, and any intervention components delivered to only certain sub-groups of the population, and if and how any components of the intervention were delivered differently to population sub-groups. if and how any components of the intervention were delivered differently to population sub-groups. Targeting refers to any tailoring of the intervention to specific groups or subpopulations. In WASH, vulnerable and underserved populations are often targeted to receive subsidies, tiered pricing structures for services, or tailored behavior change messaging.44 Access to WASH services is often inequitable; underserved populations often include those living in poverty, people living with disabilities, ethnic and cultural minorities, women, children, and the elderly.39,45–48 Several distinct populations may be targeted for direct action (e.g., creating a policy or enacting a program), behavior change (e.g., the key outcomes or mediators of interest), or to produce the resulting outcome or impact (e.g., health change). Reporting these distinct populations and the respective components of an intervention delivered separately or differently to subgroups allows those considering adapting or replicating an intervention to understand how to reach various segments of the target population. Targeting can also help with controlling spillovers, especially with trials. Item 10. Activities: Provide a clear, detailed description of the activities included, their procedures, and supporting activities. Reporting of activities should include all the following details: all activities implemented as part of the intervention, all activities implemented as part of the intervention, who led each activity, who led each activity, local actor, volunteer, and community member roles and contributions to each activity, local actor, volunteer, and community member roles and contributions to each activity, the temporality (start- and end-date) of each activity, the temporality (start- and end-date) of each activity, the mode of delivery (types of interactions between implementers and recipients, if activities were in person or remote, delivered to an individual or group, and how hardware was delivered, constructed, or installed), and the mode of delivery (types of interactions between implementers and recipients, if activities were in person or remote, delivered to an individual or group, and how hardware was delivered, constructed, or installed), and any subsidies delivered as part of the intervention; including who received the subsidies, how those recipients were identified, the level of subsidy (e.g., individual, household, community), the type and value of subsidies, and when they were provided. any subsidies delivered as part of the intervention; including who received the subsidies, how those recipients were identified, the level of subsidy (e.g., individual, household, community), the type and value of subsidies, and when they were provided. Activities and their details are the most critical component of implementation to report for others to be able to accurately interpret results, replicate, or adapt interventions. Details of activities can help the implementers make decisions on the replicating activities in other settings. Activity details can be used to measure intervention fidelity by comparing them to implementation plans. Activity details can help in identifying gaps with implementation and therefore with addressing those gaps. Item 11. Intervention dose: Quantify the frequency and number of contacts between implementers and recipients, and the duration of those contacts. For each activity that involves interactions between intervention implementers and recipients, the following should be reported: dose quantity (frequency or number of interactions), and dose quantity (frequency or number of interactions), and dose duration (how long interactions with training or intervention recipients lasted). dose duration (how long interactions with training or intervention recipients lasted). Dose can have many other dimensions beyond these minimum recommended components (quantity and duration) that merit reporting when relevant, such as intervention quality and level of engagement.49,50 Accurate reporting of dose may require prospective tracking of implementation activities, particularly for behavior change interventions, as recall-based interviews may not accurately capture the quantity and duration of interactions with recipients. Dose is a determinant of intervention resource requirements (human and financial) and of effectiveness. Thus, it is critical for interpreting outcomes, intervention adaptation and scale-up, and cost analysis. Although dose will generally be reported together with activities, it merits a separate item because of its importance and because it is underreported for WASH interventions. Dose can also convey time required by recipients, and it should be reported by subgroup (e.g., gender) when it differs between subgroups. Item 12. Fidelity: Report fidelity monitoring and actual fidelity. Include any planned or unplanned modifications to the intervention. Reporting of fidelity should cover the following: how fidelity was monitored and by who (i.e., oversight, implementation monitoring, quality control, or other efforts to ensure implementation proceeded as planned), and how fidelity was monitored and by who (i.e., oversight, implementation monitoring, quality control, or other efforts to ensure implementation proceeded as planned), and actual or measured fidelity to the intervention protocol or plan, including any planned or unplanned modifications to the intervention. actual or measured fidelity to the intervention protocol or plan, including any planned or unplanned modifications to the intervention. Monitoring of fidelity can be tracking of activities, modifications, or adaptations. It can also be efforts to ensure implementation goes according to plan, such as quality control and implementation oversight mechanisms, and should occur with any implementation with or without an impact evaluation. For reporting of measured or actual fidelity, the following details should be reported: what the modifications were, when and why they occurred, and what portion of the target population they applied to. Reporting of actual fidelity often refers to the intervention plan or protocol to highlight differences between plans and reality. Fidelity refers to the extent to which an intervention is implemented as planned, including the timing of implementation.51 The terms used to describe this concept vary among disciplines and include treatment integrity and implementation fidelity. Fidelity should not be confused with adherence, which for WASH refers to intervention recipients’ behaviors and would generally be considered an outcome. Fidelity is critical in assessing the effectiveness of an intervention.52 It shows the extent to which the intervention delivered matches the intervention plan. If all components of an intervention are implemented, it is easier to link the intervention to the outcomes and to understand the existing variations with interventions as planned and as implemented, the feasibility of intervention implementation, or even an intervention’s effectiveness.52–54 Item 13. Costs: Report the program costs by activity category and input type. Reporting of cost should cover all program costs (incurred by implementing agencies) and should be disaggregated by the following: actor actor activity category, e.g., planningmaterials developmentmanagementsupervisioncommunity eventshome visitsdistribution of materialsconstruction activity category, e.g., planningmaterials developmentmanagementsupervisioncommunity eventshome visitsdistribution of materialsconstruction planning planning materials development materials development management management supervision supervision community events community events home visits home visits distribution of materials distribution of materials construction construction input type, e.g., personnel timematerialstravel/transportationoverhead/indirect. input type, e.g., personnel timematerialstravel/transportationoverhead/indirect. personnel time personnel time materials materials travel/transportation travel/transportation overhead/indirect. overhead/indirect. Reporting of costs should follow a payer (or program) perspective in most cases. A payer perspective reports the costs that would be required to replicate the implementation of the intervention. The program funder should also be named. For economic evaluations, societal costs should be reported. Societal costs include the program costs and costs (financial and economic) incurred by organizations and individuals outside the main implementing organizations. These are particularly relevant for WASH interventions, in which local government, volunteers (teachers, community health workers), and community members often contribute time and resources.55 Payer-perspective costing is generally straightforward because most WASH interventions are funded by one organization or a few organizations, sometimes with government cost-sharing. Accurately costing WASH interventions (particularly with a societal perspective) can be challenging because of the complex institutional arrangements, cross-subsidies, flexible implementation, and local investments by volunteers and community members (financial or non).55 Activity-based costing and microcosting methods will provide more accurate estimates of costs due to these factors (as in comparison with top-down costing or gross costing). Although no comprehensive guides for costing WASH programs exist, there are relevant resources for costing nutrition and health programs56,57 and for reporting them.58 Cost data are used for budgeting future programs, assessing the scale of a program, assessing the intensity of the program (when costs are compared to the number of recipients) and are used for analyzing additional economic outcomes, such as cost efficiency, cost effectiveness, and cost–benefit ratios. Item 14. Materials: Describe all materials delivered as part of the intervention or used to guide the intervention. Reporting of materials should cover the following: any WASH technology transferred, or infrastructure built (e.g., water supplies, latrines, handwashing stations) any WASH technology transferred, or infrastructure built (e.g., water supplies, latrines, handwashing stations) physical materials provided, sold, or distributed (e.g., hand soap, construction materials, chlorine tablets) physical materials provided, sold, or distributed (e.g., hand soap, construction materials, chlorine tablets) software used in intervention delivery and links or digital copies (e.g., training manuals, behavior-change posters, educational pamphlets) software used in intervention delivery and links or digital copies (e.g., training manuals, behavior-change posters, educational pamphlets) incentives provided to implementers, volunteers, or intervention recipients (e.g., cash transfers, t-shirts, certificates). incentives provided to implementers, volunteers, or intervention recipients (e.g., cash transfers, t-shirts, certificates). Reporting of materials should include details about hardware, including how hardware was constructed and installed. Even for predominantly demand-side interventions, there may be details of the available hardware through local markets that are worth reporting, even if not directly provided by the intervention. This detail can help the implementers in planning, costing, and decision-making. Many WASH interventions involve software components. This material could include manuals, posters, incentive mechanisms, guidelines, policy documents, technology standards, or protocols that were used to guide implementation. When describing software, it is important to include copies of the materials or links to open-access, publicly available sources. This information can be placed as supplemental materials or added in an appendix to facilitate access. Sharing this information can reduce the instances of duplication of efforts and increase the possibilities of replication and therefore avoid misuse of resources. This information can be relevant for assessing fidelity as well. Discussion Who Should Use TIDieR-WASH? We recommend that the TIDieR-WASH checklist and guidance be used by anyone reporting a WASH intervention, including researchers, policymakers, and practitioners. The types of interventions could include those related to behavior change; provision of WASH services, infrastructure development, capacity building, systems strengthening; and interventions across different scales of interventions (e.g., pilots, community-based, district- and national-level programs) and different settings (e.g., household, community, school, health care facilities). The TIDieR-WASH guidance is most applicable to low- and middle-income settings, where the majority of inadequate access to WASH and thus the majority of WASH interventions occur.59 This checklist was jointly developed by experts from academic institutions, implementing organizations, policy organizations, and foundations to maximize relevance to audiences working for these different types of institutions. It is relevant for reporting on the delivery of an intervention, including any evaluation that is disseminated publicly in any format or outlet (peer-reviewed journals, project reports, organizational websites), and is also relevant for internal monitoring, evaluation, and learning efforts by WASH organizations (often referred to as “M&E” or “MEL”). Those reporting environmental health interventions other than WASH (e.g., clean cooking, food hygiene, bed nets, waste management) may also find this checklist useful. This version of the TIDieR checklist contains items and language well suited to WASH and environmental health interventions that are context-dependent and often involve externalities that affect intervention delivery and uptake. Rationale for TIDieR-WASH Our scoping review found that underreporting of implementation and context in WASH evaluations is a problem that exists even among the most-cited studies of the last 10 y.15 There is extensive evidence from the medical field that poor reporting of intervention details creates wasteful research that cannot be accurately interpreted14,60 and that reporting guidelines improve the completeness of reporting of clinical trials.61 The original TIDieR checklist published in 2014 has been cited more than 4,000 times according to PubMed (https://www.pmid2cite.com/) and more than 7,000 times according to Google Scholar (https://scholar.google.com/), demonstrating the scale of its impact. The widespread uptake of the TIDieR checklist has enabled systematic reviews that assess outcomes by intervention type or characteristic, such as finding that delivery mechanism (group vs. individual) and dose (number of sessions) may improve health outcomes for workplace lifestyle interventions62 and that postpartum weight management interventions delivered by health professionals yielded better outcomes than those delivered by nonhealth professionals.63 Although there are no systematic reviews of the original TIDieR checklist that investigate its impact on reporting quality (perhaps because it is only 10 y old), the CONSORT checklist first published in 1996 has had a demonstrated impact on the quality of reporting of randomized controlled trials,17 indicating that reporting guidelines can be beneficial. The original TIDieR checklist is designed for reporting of medical trials. There exist TIDieR extensions for population health and vaccine trials23,64 as well as nontrials.65 However, for all these existing guidelines, the checklist items, terminology, and examples were not developed for WASH or other environmental health interventions. Thus, we set out to develop a context and implementation reporting checklist and guideline optimized for WASH interventions. Although TIDieR-WASH is a reporting guideline, there are potential benefits to using this checklist to inform intervention design. Mainstreaming this checklist as a requirement for journal publication and as a funding requirement would support better adaptation and scale-up of WASH interventions. Certain checklist items (ToC, prior evidence, context, enabling environment, suitability, and targeting) all relate to how the intervention was designed and how it is appropriate for the context in which it was implemented. Considering these items during intervention design could ensure that the intervention is appropriately designed to yield target outcomes in a given context. Consideration of implementer roles, qualifications, and membership in vulnerable groups may also aid in addressing inequities and empowering vulnerable groups. Gender mainstreaming offers one such approach.43 Based on our experience and on feedback received at the 2022 Water & Health Conference,66 this checklist is ideally used prospectively to inform process monitoring. Implementation tracking, in which basic details of activities are recorded daily, can be used to collect data on recipients, activities, dose, fidelity, and costs in sufficient detail. Future extensions of this checklist could include definitions and examples specific to other types of environmental health interventions. WASH Interventions, Gender, and Social Inclusion The implementation of WASH interventions is affected by gender roles and norms and often relies on women for successful implementation. A recent systematic review of 133 WASH interventions found that 37% were gender-unequal and 63% were gender-blind (both of which should be avoided according to the WHO).43,48 None were classified as gender-sensitive, specific, or transformative, which are considered desirable. We recommend that gender influence on the intervention being reported, and gender-specific roles and burden be reported under context, implementers, recipients, targeting, and activities, ideally using the WHO Gender Responsiveness Assessment Scale.43 In addition, structural racism and colonialism impact global health67,68 and warrant deliberate consideration. Involving local communities in the design and implementation of interventions can be one method for doing so.67 The O’Neill–Lancet Commission on Racism, Structural Discrimination, and Global Health offers further resources on these important issues.68 Limitations There is immense variety of WASH interventions, and the examples provided in this guideline cannot cover them comprehensively. We attempted to include sufficient variety of examples that any WASH program can find relevance in this guideline. There is immense variety of WASH interventions, and the examples provided in this guideline cannot cover them comprehensively. We attempted to include sufficient variety of examples that any WASH program can find relevance in this guideline. This guideline does not include tools for measuring context and implementation; it instead focuses on how they should be reported. We reference and recommend tools for data collection throughout, but we did not set out to develop or provide data collection tools. This guideline does not include tools for measuring context and implementation; it instead focuses on how they should be reported. We reference and recommend tools for data collection throughout, but we did not set out to develop or provide data collection tools. Although this checklist and guide are designed to be easily adopted, some training and capacity building may be needed within implementing organizations to collect sufficient context and implementation data to report all recommended items. Although this checklist and guide are designed to be easily adopted, some training and capacity building may be needed within implementing organizations to collect sufficient context and implementation data to report all recommended items. Conclusion A lack of reporting standards for WASH interventions has resulted in critical challenges in adapting, adopting, and scaling interventions. It has also limited the ability of researchers and practitioners to synthesize evidence across programs to understand a fundamental question of which interventions work, where, and under what conditions. Our TIDieR-WASH checklist, if widely adapted by the WASH sector, would improve knowledge across the sector by creating normative methods for reporting intervention design and implementation outcomes. Supplementary Material Acknowledgments This project was funded by the Reckitt Global Hygiene Institute, award number 0000066281. The views and opinions expressed in this paper are those of the authors and not necessarily the views and opinions of RGHI or the US Agency for International Development. Conclusions and opinions are those of the individual authors and do not necessarily reflect the policies or views of EHP Publishing or the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials