National-wide survey of ophthalmic human resources in China in 2021 Authors: Jin-Da Wang, Chang-Xi Chen, Mei-Rui Liu, Li-Jun Zhang, Yan Sun, Kai Cao Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractPurposeTo evaluate the availability of human resources for ophthalmic services in mainland China.MethodsIn 2021, we conducted a nationwide survey of ophthalmic outpatient services across 2996 tertiary hospitals and 10,404 secondary hospitals in 31 provinces in mainland China.ResultsThe response rate was 73.6% (9856/13400), with 78.7% (7759/9856) providing ophthalmic services. By 2021, the total number of ophthalmologists, ophthalmic nurses, and optometrists was 48,652, 64,495, and 14,320, respectively. The densities (per 50,000 population) were 1.7, 2.25, and 0.47, respectively. The density of ophthalmologists was < 1 only in the XiZang region. The average doctor-patient ratio was 2584.8. In Shanghai and Zhejiang provinces, this ratio exceeded 4000.ConclusionThere are currently 1.7 ophthalmologists, 2.25 nurses, and 0.47 optometrists for every 50,000 people in China. The number of ophthalmologists has reached the global average, but the number of optometrists is far below the global average. And the medical pressure across China is uneven, with some provinces such as Shanghai and Zhejiang facing enormous pressure.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12913-024-11987-w.Keywords: Ophthalmic service, Human resources, Ophthalmologist, Ophthalmic nurses, Optometrists, China, National survey Introduction Ophthalmologists, ophthalmic nurses, and optometrists are the major forces involved in the provision of ophthalmic outpatient services. The World Health Organization (WHO), in its “Global Initiative for the Elimination of Avoidable Blindness: action plan 2006–2011” recommended that the ratio of ophthalmologists to the local population in Asia should reach 1:50,000 by 2021 [1]. Data show that in 2015, China’s figure reached 1.32 [2]. After a gap of 5 years, whether China still maintains this level and whether it can still reach the recommended level of WHO is of great interest to people. China is currently facing the challenge of a large aging population. According to the 7th census in 2021, 18.7% of the population is aged 60 years or older, and 13.5% is aged 65 years or older [3]. This aging demographic is increasing the burden of non-communicable diseases [4], including cataracts [5], age-related macular degeneration, glaucoma [6], and diabetic retinopathy [7]. It is estimated that by 2050, the number of age-related cataract patients in China will reach 187.26 million, significantly challenging the capacity of ophthalmic outpatient services. To answer the above questions, we conducted a comprehensive nationwide survey in 2021, encompassing all secondary and tertiary hospitals in the 31 provinces of mainland China, to gather vital information on ophthalmic human resources. Materials and methods Study design This was a nationwide survey with 2996 registered tertiary and 10,404 registered secondary hospitals in mainland China at the end of 2020. All hospitals were sent questionnaires.This study does not involve specific patients or participants, but is a survey of ophthalmic human resources data. Data collection Data were collected using a self-designed web-based questionnaire (https://www.wjx.cn/). Each participating hospital arranged for a doctor/nurse to complete the questionnaire. To minimize the time burden on medical staff, the questionnaire contains only 10 questions, the key information included: the number of ophthalmologists, the number of ophthalmic nurses, the number of optometrists, and the number of ophthalmic outpatient visits per year. Data cleaning (quality control) Before statistical analysis, we performed a data cleaning procedure, and any outliers were returned to the corresponding hospitals for verification. Outliers were identified in two steps: firstly, using the outlier test function from the “car” package of the open source R Program to locate the outliers and corresponding hospitals. For each outlier, the corresponding hospital was contacted for verification. For example, the number of ophthalmologists in secondary hospitals being higher than in a tertiary hospital indicates a mistake, as the tertiary hospitals in China usually represent the highest level of medical care and have the most medical resources. Estimation of total ophthalmic medical resources The vast majority of ophthalmic medical resources in China are in tertiary and secondary hospitals. Because some hospitals did not respond to the survey, we used the following formula to estimate the total number of ophthalmologists, ophthalmic nurses, and optometrists in mainland China: where N represents the total number of ophthalmologists (ophthalmic nurses or optometrists). i represents the province. N1 represents the total number of ophthalmologists in responding secondary hospitals. R1 represents the response rate of secondary hospitals. N2 represents the total number of ophthalmologists in responding tertiary hospitals. R2 represents the response rate of tertiary hospitals. Definition of ophthalmologist density The number of ophthalmologists per 50,000 people (similarly for ophthalmic nurses and optometrists). The 2021 population data of the 31 provinces came from the National Bureau of Statistics (https://data.stats.gov.cn) [8]. Doctor-patient ratio This ratio reflects the pressure of ophthalmic outpatient services in each province, defined as the total number of ophthalmic outpatient services divided by the number of ophthalmologists. Statistical analysis The open-source R program (https://www.r-project.org/, version 4.3.3) was used for data analysis. Frequencies and percentages were used to describe categorical variables. Lorenz curves and Gini coefficients were used to estimate the equity of each indicator among the 31 provinces of mainland China. The Gini coefficient, ranging from 0 to 1, was calculated from the Lorenz curve; a coefficient < 0.2 indicates that human resources are well allocated among the 31 provinces while a Gini coefficient > 0.6 indicates significant disparity [9]. Results Characteristics of investigated hospitals The names of the 31 provinces in mainland China are shown in Fig. 1. These provinces were classified into four regions: east, central, west, and northeast. The eastern region includes ten provinces: Beijing, Tianjin, Hebei, Shanghai, Jiangsu, Zhejiang, Fujian, Shandong, Guangdong, and Hainan. The central region includes six provinces: Shānxi, Anhui, Jiangxi, Henan, Hubei, and Hunan. The western region contains 12 provinces: Neimeng, Guangxi, Chongqing, Sichuan, Guizhou, Yunnan, Xizang, Shǎnxi, Gansu, Qinghai, Ningxia, and Xinjiang. Finally, there are three provinces in the northeastern region: Liaoning, Jilin, and Heilongjiang. Names and locations of 31 provinces of China mainland In this survey, 9856 hospitals responded, yielding an overall response rate of 73.6% (9856/13400). The response rates for secondary and tertiary hospitals were 77.9% (8100/10404) and 58.6% (1756/2996), respectively. Among the responding hospitals, 78.7% (7759/9856) had ophthalmic human resources and were able to provide ophthalmic services. Ophthalmic human resources in mainland China in 2021 The total numbers of ophthalmologists, ophthalmic nurses, and optometrists in mainland China in 2021 were 48,652, 64,495, and 14,320, respectively. On average, for every 50,000 people in mainland China, there were 1.70 ophthalmologists, 2.25 ophthalmic nurses, and 0.47 optometrists. The ophthalmologist density for each province is shown in Fig. 2A. The density of ophthalmologists was < 1 only in the Xizang Autonomous Region. Ophthalmic nurse density ranged from 0.38 (Tibet Autonomous Region) to 4.32 (Ningxia province) (Fig. 2B). The density of optometrists ranged from 0.19 (Xizang Autonomous Region) to 1.04 (Tianjin) (Fig. 2C). Density of ophthalmic medical resources of 31 provinces in China mainland in year 2021 (A) Ophthalmologists density of each province (B) Ophthalmic nurses density of each province (C) Optometrists density of each province Doctor-patient ratio The total number of ophthalmic outpatient visits in mainland China was 125,760,140 person-times in year 2021, and the average doctor-patient ratio was 2584.8. 12 provinces had a doctor-patient ratio higher than the average (Fig. 3). Among the 12 provinces, 8 were in the eastern region, accounting for 66.7% (8/12). Zhejiang Province, Shanghai Municipality, and Guangdong Province were the top three in terms of this ratio. Meanwhile, Xizang region had the lowest doctor-patient ratio, which was 1074.67. Ordered barplot of ophthalmic service pressure of 31 provinces in China mainland in year 2021 Equity of ophthalmic human resources across the whole mainland China The Lorenz curves showed the equity of distribution of ophthalmologists, ophthalmic nurses, optometrists among 31 provinces of China mainland. The best equity across provinces is the nurse distribution, then the ophthalmologists, the equity of the optometrist was the worst (Fig. 4). The Gini coefficients were 0.411, 0.399, and 0.423, respectively. Lorenz curve of ophthalmic human resources Discussion China, a rapidly developing low- and middle-income country, accounts for approximately 18.5% of the world’s population [10] and about 17% of the world’s gross domestic product [11]. For a country with a large population and a large economy, the situation of human resources in ophthalmology is worthy of attention, but in this regard we are very lack of data, so we conducted this survey. In 2015, the global ophthalmologist density was 1.58 per 50,000 people [2] while in China it was 1.32. Around the same period in 2014, India, with a population size close to China’s, had an ophthalmologist density of 0.672 [12]. By 2021, according to our survey, the ophthalmologist density in mainland China reached 1.70 per 50,000 people. It is estimated that the number of global ophthalmologists has been increasing at a rate of approximately 2.6% per year [2], suggesting that the global ophthalmologist density in 2021 should be approximately 1.79 per 50,000 people. Although the ophthalmologist density in China is still below the global average, the gap has been narrowed, and China has made remarkable improvements in the development of ophthalmologist resources in recent years. Since 2009, China has implemented reforms in the medical and health system to fulfill residents’ equal access to medical services [13], and these reforms have been somewhat successful, according to our survey. However, the Xizang Autonomous Region remains the weak link in China; the density of ophthalmologists in all other provinces in mainland China has reached the WHO’s recommended level, except for Xizang Autonomous Region. Indeed, the development of ophthalmic nurse and optometrist resources in the Xizang Autonomous Region lags significantly behind other provinces. We must acknowledge that the ophthalmic service pressure was significantly higher in the eastern coastal provinces of China, including Zhejiang province, Shanghai, Guangdong province, Tianjin, Jiangsu province, Beijing and Fujian province. Especially in Shanghai and Zhejiang province, the doctor-patient ratio exceeded 4000 in the year 2021. Meanwhile for Shānxi province, Hunan province, Jilin province, Hubei province, Heilongjiang province, Guizhou province and Xizang Autonomous Region, the doctor-patient ratio was below 2000. Thus, the Chinese government needs to consider optimizing medical resources allocation and strengthening the capacity building of ophthalmic services in underdeveloped provinces to enable residents to access treatment in local areas. Overall, mainland China has made remarkable improvements in the construction of ophthalmic human resources compared with that in year 2015 [2], the gap in ophthalmologist density between China and the global average has narrowed. However, several challenges remain. There is an imbalance in ophthalmic service pressure, with the Shanghai and Zhejiang province facing significantly greater pressure than other provinces. Additionally, there is also an imbalance in the development of ophthalmic human resources, with the Xizang Autonomous Region lagging behind other provinces in terms of ophthalmologists, nurses, and optometrists. The limitations of our study include a relatively low response rate. Besides, as this is a questionnaire study, there might be bias like non-response bias and selection bias. Additionally, due to limited research on ophthalmic outpatient service evaluation, it is challenging to make cross-sectional comparisons between China and other countries, or to conduct longitudinal comparisons within China itself. Such comparisons would help us better understand the development of China’s ophthalmic human resources construction. Supplementary Information Supplementary Material 1. Acknowledgements None. Abbreviation World Health Organization Authors’ contributions JDW and CXC analyzed and interpreted the survey data. MRL performed the data collection.KC designed the study. LJZ and YS verified the outliers, and reviewed the manuscript. All authors wrote and approved the final manuscript. Funding This study is supported by Beijing Natural Science Foundation (Code: 7242038) and sponsored by Beijing Nova Program (Code: 20220484224). Data availability The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate This study does not involve specific patients or participants, informed consent was deemed unnecessary by the Ethics Committee of Beijing Tongren Hospital, Capital Medical University. The Ethics Committee of Beijing Tongren Hospital approved this study. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Jin-DaWang and Chang-Xi Chen contributed equally in this study. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1. Data Availability Statement The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.