Research on magnetic force of magnetic seal in aero-engine Authors: Wanli Fan, Hua Su, Ke Li, Weiwei Hao Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractAiming at the magnetic seal in an aero-engine accessory, the range of magnetic force required for the normal operation of the magnetic seal is analyzed. The finite element analysis method based on the Maxwell stress tensor method is used to calculate the magnetic force between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring in the magnetic sealing system. The magnetic force under different magnetization modes and gaps is tested by the magnetic measuring test bench, which verifies the correctness of the magnetic calculation method. The effects of permanent magnet material, permanent magnet magnetization direction, magnetic seal structural parameters, and working conditions on the magnetic force between the dynamic ring/magnetic static ring in the magnetic seal are analyzed. Under the same structure, the magnetic force of NeFeB35, SmCo28, Alnico5, and Ferrite as magnetic static rings is compared. The results show that NdFeB35 has the largest magnetic force, SmCo28 is second, Alnico5 and Ferrite are relatively small, and their magnetic forces are about 1/4 to 1/5 of the first two materials. When the rotor or the casing is moving axially, NeFeB35 and SmCo28 materials with large magnetic force should be selected to meet the normal working requirements. Under the same material, the magnetic forces of axial, radial, and radiative magnetization modes are compared. the ratio of magnetic force under axial, radiative, and radial magnetization is about 2.3:1.1:1. If NeFeB35 and SmCo28 materials are axially magnetized, their magnetic forces will exceed the allowable range, which will increase the seal wear. The increase in the inner diameter of the dynamic ring and the gap between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring causes a decrease in the magnetic force. The increase in temperature affects the magnetic properties of permanent magnetic material, which leads to the decline of magnetic force between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring. The increase in rotor speed leads to the acceleration of the fluctuation frequency of the magnetic force. Still, the maximum and minimum values of the magnetic force under different speeds remain unchanged, and the maximum fluctuation rate is less than 3%. According to the analysis results, the fitting formula of magnetic force calculation is presented by the orthogonal test and the least squares method.Keywords: Magnetic seal, Magnetic force, Magnetic force measurement test, Magnetic force influencing factor analysis, Magnetic force calculation fitting formulaSubject terms: Engineering, Mechanical engineering Introduction The magnetic seal is a sealing technology that uses magnetic force to replace the spring force in traditional mechanical seals. Through the magnetic force of the permanent magnet material, the sealing interface can obtain enough contact pressure to achieve the sealing effect1. The magnetic sealing device mainly consists of a magnetic static ring and dynamic ring components (embedded graphite ring). Its working principle is that the magnetic static ring relies on the magnetic material’s magnetic force to attract the dynamic ring so that the static ring end face and the graphite ring end face are closely fitted to prevent the leakage of the working medium. As early as 1956 Robert Stevenson proposed a magnetic seal structure2, and it was further developed in the 1980s. In the following 60 years, the magnetic sealing structure has been continuously improved, with the emergence of some product patents3–5. It is because of the magnetic seal has the advantages of fewer structural components, compact structure, zero leakage, no pollution, easy installation and excellent performance in high-speed high-vibration working conditions, that magnetic seals are widely used in bearing chamber seals, aerospace engine accessory drive shafts, as well as automotive, marine, and railroad industries6–8. The magnetic force is directly related to the contact pressure of the sealing interface and affects the leakage and wear performance of the seal. The magnetic force in the magnetic seal not only depends on the permanent magnetic material, magnetizing direction, and other material magnetic performance parameters but is also closely related to the seal structure and operating conditions. In the actual application process, there is usually a small gap between the magnetic static ring and the dynamic ring. This gap will be subject to the environmental conditions of the seal and the wear state and change, which leads to changes in the magnetic force between the magnetic static ring and the dynamic ring, thus affecting the mechanical state of the magnetic sealing device and even the leakage of the seal and the wear performance. However, there are fewer studies on the quantitative effect of the gap change between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring on the magnetic force. Dezhong et al.9 utilized tie rods for distance adjustment between two ferromagnetic parts, measuring the adjustment distance through a grating scale and detecting the pulling force by a force sensor. Hong et al.10 used a screw to adjust the distance between two magnets and indirectly derive the size of the magnetic force at different distances through a pressure gauge. Both of the above magnetic force measurement devices cannot carry out the magnetic force at the micro gap and the distance adjustment accuracy is lower. In the study of magnetic force calculation, Li11 used the equivalent magnetic charge method to calculate the magnetic force and magnetic moment between a cube and a circular column, verified the effect of different magnetization directions on the magnetic force and magnetic moment between permanent magnets, and derived a mathematical model for the interaction of two shapes of permanent magnets by theoretical calculations. Shu et al.12 calculated the magnetic force between two magnets by modeling the force between magnetic dipoles. Li et al.13 derived the force generated by a single magnetic pole based on the principle of static magnetism and derived a formula for calculating the magnetic force. Qingtao et al.14 used the molecular current method for magnetic force calculation, proposed the formula for magnetic force calculation in the axial direction, and built a typical magnetic force calculation model for permanent magnet rings. Wei et al.15 used an empirical formula to calculate the magnetic force of an aero-engine accessory output shaft magnetic seal. By summarizing the existing magnetic force calculation methods, it can be seen that some are only applicable to the model with simple structure, some use simplified empirical formulas, and some only analyze the magnetic force changes from the perspective of the magnetic performance parameters, without fully considering the combined influence of the structure, material, and working conditions, it is difficult to satisfy the analysis of the magnetic force of the magnetic seals with complex structure and working conditions. Firstly, this paper introduces the structural composition and working principle of the studied magnetic sealing system and establishes the mechanical relationship between the magnetic force and the normal operation of the magnetic seal. The finite element analysis method based on the Maxwell stress tensor method is used to calculate the magnetic force between the dynamic ring/magnetic static ring in the magnetic sealing system. The magnetic force under different magnetization modes and gaps is tested by the magnetic measuring test bench, which verifies the correctness of the magnetic force calculation method. The effects of permanent magnet material, magnetizing direction, sealing working environment temperature, and rotor speed on the magnetic force between the dynamic ring/magnetic static ring are analyzed. Finally, the fitting formula for magnetic force calculation is established using the orthogonal test method and the least squares method, which provides a basis for the magnetic seal performance analysis and the optimization design. Magnetic seal structure and the effect of magnetic force on sealing work Structure and working principle of magnetic seals The magnetic sealing system consists of a seal mounting base, magnetic static ring, dynamic ring, graphite ring, O-ring, etc. Its typical structure is shown in Fig. 1. The magnetic static ring is a permanent magnetic material, the dynamic ring is a soft magnetic material, and the graphite ring is embedded in the dynamic ring. The magnetic static ring relies on the magnetic force of the permanent magnetic material to attract the dynamic ring, so that the end face of the static ring and the graphite ring are closely adhered to form the main sealing interface to prevent the leakage of the working medium. The O-ring 1 between the dynamic ring and the rotor shaft ensures that the dynamic ring rotates synchronously with the shaft without relative sliding through the friction between the O-ring and the rotor and the dynamic ring, and through its deformation to adapt the rotor axial/angular motion. O-ring 2 ensures that the magnetic static ring remains stationary under the frictional torque of the graphite ring by its elastic deformation. In addition, the three O-rings also play a secondary sealing role. The relevant geometric parameters of the magnetic seal are shown in Table 1, the material of each component and the magnetic performance parameters at room temperature are shown in Table 2, and the performance of the common four types of permanent magnet materials is shown in Table 3. Schematic diagram of the magnetic sealing system structure. Table 1Geometric parameters of magnetic seals.Structural parameters (symbols)Numerical value (in mm)Dynamic ring axial width (B)8.1Inside diameter of the gear edge on the upstream side of the dynamic ring (d2)17.5Dynamic ring inner diameter (D1)20.6 (range 18.5–22.5)Graphite ring inner diameter (d1)17.6Magnetic static ring outer diameter (D2)24.9Diameter of dynamic ring sealing groove (d0)22.5Outer diameter of dynamic ring ()24.6Outer diameter of the rotating shaft, inner diameter of the O-Ring1 ()16Dynamic/magnetic static ring gap (I)0.5 (range 0.3–0.7) Geometric parameters of magnetic seals. Table 2Material and magnetic property parameters of the components of the magnetic sealing system (room temperature).ComponentMaterialPerformance parameters (symbols)Numerical value (units)Magnetic static ringAlnico5Residual magnetic induction (Br)Coercivity (Hc)Maximum magnetic energy product (BH)maxWechsler hardness (HV)1.25(T)− 48,000 (A/m)40,000 (J/m3)650HVDynamic ringStainless steelsRelative permeability (2000ShaftAlloy steelRelative permeability (2000Graphite ringM234A0Relative permeability ()Rockwell hardness (HR)0.9999125 hO-ringFluoroelastomerShore hardness (HA)79HASolution domainAtmosphereRelative permeability ()1 Material and magnetic property parameters of the components of the magnetic sealing system (room temperature). Residual magnetic induction (Br) Coercivity (Hc) Maximum magnetic energy product (BH)max Wechsler hardness (HV) 1.25(T) − 48,000 (A/m) 40,000 (J/m3) 650HV Relative permeability () Rockwell hardness (HR) 0.9999 125 h Table 3Comparison of the properties of four types of permanent magnet materials (room temperature).Performance parametersFerriteAlnicoNdFeBSmCoResidual magnetic induction/T0.2–0.40.8–1.31.0–1.40.8–1.11Coercion 21060890780Maximum magnetic energy product/MGOe0.8–5.21.2–1.330–5215–32Curie temperature/°C450890310920Resistance to oxidation and corrosionExcellentExcellentCenterExcellentHardness/HV530650660550CostLowerCenterCenterHigher Comparison of the properties of four types of permanent magnet materials (room temperature). Magnetic force in relation to the proper functioning of the sealing system To ensure the reliability of sealing performance, the sealing interface must obtain sufficient closing force. The closing force in the magnetic seal is related to the magnetic force of the permanent magnet material, the medium pressure, and the inertia force caused by the axial movement of the seal system. According to the analysis results of the normal working mechanical conditions of the magnetic seal in literature16, the contact pressure p2 between the graphite ring and the static ring is: where Fc is the magnetic force, p4 is the sealing medium pressure, Ffo2 is the axial friction between the rotor and O-ring 1 (when the rotor moves to the left to take the negative sign), FG is the inertial force generated by the dynamic ring when the casing vibrates axially (when the casing vibration to the right to take the negative sign). To ensure the normal operation of the magnetic seal, the contact pressure between the graphite ring and the static ring p2 > 0. It can be seen that the larger the magnetic force, the larger the contact pressure at the seal interface, the more conducive to improving the sealing performance. However, the increase in interfacial contact pressure will increase the interface wear, in order to achieve the wear life requirements of the seal, the contact pressure between the graphite ring and the magnetic static ring should be limited. According to the specific wear requirements of the seal, the maximum value of the interface contact pressure can be determined. For example, given the graphite ring’s line wear rate per unit time of the magnetic seal (w = wear depth h/time t), the contact pressure should be satisfied according to the Archard model: where A is the end face area of the graphite seal ring, HB is the hardness of the graphite ring material, K is the wear coefficient, v is the linear velocity of the contact surface. To satisfy the sealing and wear requirements, that is, 0 < , according to formula (1), the magnetic force Fc should satisfy: When the axial runout of the rotor or casing is not considered, the design boundary value of the magnetic force depends mainly on the seal material, working conditions and structure. Shaft or casing runout in the aero-engine is unavoidable, and the influence of the movement of the rotor and the casing in different directions should be considered comprehensively in the magnetic force calculation. Calculation of the magnetic force range of magnetic seals under typical operating conditions For the magnetic seal structure dimensions and material parameters shown in Tables 1 and 2, take the typical working conditions as follows: at room temperature, the shaft rotating speed is 11,500 r/min, differential pressure is 0.15 MPa, and the sealing medium is oil. The friction and wear test results of graphite M234A0 are given in reference17, and the hardness of the friction pair is similar to that of the magnetic static ring material studied in this paper. According to reference17, the wear coefficient (K) of the graphite ring is determined to be .The hardness of the graphite ring is 125 h. According to reference16, when the rotor and casing move axially (vibration acceleration is 80 m/s2), the inertia force FG is 0.67 N, and the friction force is 23.86 N. Considering the vibration direction of the rotor and the casing comprehensively, the magnetic force range obtained by formula (3) is . If the axial movement of the shaft and casing is not considered, the inertia force , and the friction force . From formula (3) the range of the magnetic force is obtained as: Magnetic force calculation method and test verification Finite element methods for magnetic force calculations At present, the calculation methods of magnetic force mainly include the equivalent magnetic charge method, molecular current method, virtual displacement method and Maxwell stress tensor method18. The equivalent magnetic charge method and molecular current method are based on the assumption of an ideal model, and they are mainly suitable for calculating the magnetic force of permanent magnet materials with simple shapes. However, the result contains fourfold integration, so it is often necessary to calculate with the help of Monte Carlo19 simulation or numerical integration20. When the model structure is more complex, the amount of computation and error should not be underestimated. The virtual displacement method is mainly applied to the magnetic field generated by the static electric field. Considering the calculation efficiency and accuracy, this paper adopts the finite element analysis method based on the Maxwell stress tensor method to calculate the magnetic force. The basic flow of finite element simulation is shown in Fig. 2. Maxwell simulation flowchart. Since the sealing mount and O-ring have little influence on the magnetic field, the magnetic field finite element analysis model does not include the seal mounting seat and O-ring to reduce the size of the calculation model. For the magnetic seal shown in Fig. 1 and the structural parameters shown in Table 1, a finite element analysis model of the magnetic field is established based on Maxwell software, as shown in Fig. 3. Setting the magnetic static ring material and magnetizing direction (Fig. 3 shows the radial magnetizing method with N, S pole circumferential staggered arrangement), the material properties of each component of the magnetic sealing system and the finite element analysis solution domain are shown in Table 2. In order to determine the appropriate solution domain, the results of magnetic force calculations with different solution domain percentage offsets (shown in Fig. 4) are compared, and the solution domain percentage offset is determined to be 100% (i.e., the size of the solution domain was twice the size of the geometric model). According to the results of magnetic force calculation under different maximum grid cell sizes in Fig. 5, the maximum grid cell size is determined to be 3 mm, and the percentage of grid refinement at each step is 30%. Maxwell software platform provides two error indicators: energy error and delta energy variation, only when the energy error and delta energy variation are less than the set convergence error percentage, the calculation convergence stops. Figure 5 gives the convergence error percentage of 1% when the magnetic sealing system magnetic field finite element numerical simulation and analysis process of the two error indicators with the number of iterations of the change curve, according to the change curve can be seen, when the number of steps is greater than 25, the error curve tends to stabilise and the value is close to 0, and the energy error and delta energy change is less than 1%, so set the maximum number of steps for 30 (Fig. 6). Geometric model for finite element analysis of magnetic fields. Magnetic force at different solutions domain percentage offsets. Magnetic force at different maximum grid cell sizes. Curve of error with number of iterations. Figure 7 shows the distribution of magnetic induction intensity of the magnetic seal. It can be seen that the magnetic field distribution of the magnetic sealing system is consistent with the circumferential staggered four magnetic poles. The distribution of the magnetic induction intensity of the four parts is the same. The magnetic induction vector is opposite in the N and S poles. The magnetic induction intensity is mainly distributed in the N/S pole junction and the entire magnetic static ring. The farther away from the magnetic static ring, the weaker the magnetic field. Magnetic induction intensity vector distribution is more uniform, and the closed magnetic circuit follows the first law of the magnetic circuit Kirchhoff, i.e., the magnetic flux into any closed surface is always equal to the magnetic flux through the closed surface. Magnetic induction and magnetic induction vector distribution of magnetic sealing systems. Magnetic force testing In order to verify the correctness of the magnetic force calculated by the finite element method, a magnetic force measuring test device with an adjustable micro-gap was designed and developed, as shown in Fig. 8, which can realize 0.01 mm micro gap adjustment with higher adjustment accuracy compared with other magnetic force measurement devices, and can test the magnetic force between the dynamic ring and the static ring under different micro gaps. The test device includes a clamping module, a positioning module, a displacement adjustment module, a measurement module, and a base plate. The clamping module consists of an adapter plate and two table vises for fixing the upper and lower test pieces respectively. Table vise 1 is used to grip the upper test piece and is fixed on the adapter plate. The adapter plate is connected to the test head of the dynamometer by thread. Table vise 2 is used for clamping the lower test piece and is fixed to the dual-axis fine-tuning displacement table. The displacement adjustment module includes a test frame and a dual-axis fine-tuning displacement stage. The test frame is fixed to the base plate to adjust the vertical distance between the test pieces and the minimum adjustable distance is 1 mm. The dual-axis fine-tuning displacement stage is fixed to the base plate, through micrometer 1 and micrometer 2 to adjust the vertical and horizontal distance between the test pieces, the minimum adjustable distance is 0.01 mm. A dynamometer is used to measure the magnetic force between the specimens. The maximum load of the dynamometer is 100 N, the index value is 0.01 N, the measurement accuracy is up to 0.5%, and it has the function of maintaining the peak value. The base plate, clamping module, positioning module, and displacement adjustment module are all made of non-magnetic conduction materials or materials with very low magnetic permeability to avoid the influence of materials on magnetic force measurement during the test. Adjustable micro-gap magnetic force measurement test bench. The upper specimen (magnetic static ring) and the lower specimen (dynamic ring) in this test were processed according to the structure shown in Fig. 1, and the structure and magnetic parameters of the upper and lower specimens are shown in Table 4. The changes of magnetic force under different gaps in radial and axial magnetization modes (see Magnetic Force Testing section for the effect of different magnetization modes on magnetic force) were measured and compared with the results of finite element simulation, and the results are shown in Fig. 9. Table 4Material properties and magnetic performance parameters of each specimen.Test pieceStructure and dimensionsMaterialMagnetic parametersMagnetization directionMagnetic static ringUpper specimen 1 NdFeBGrade N35 Radial magnetizationUpper specimen 2 Axially magnetizationDynamic ringLower specimen 1Cr13 – Material properties and magnetic performance parameters of each specimen. NdFeB Grade N35 Comparison of magnetic experiment results with finite element simulation results. It can be seen that under the two magnetization methods, the magnetic force decreases approximately linearly with the increase of the gap, and the magnetic force of the axial magnetization method is higher than that of the radial magnetization under the same gap. The test results and simulation results are consistent with the trend of change. When the gap is less than 0.6 mm (the gap between the dynamic ring and static ring in the magnetic seal is generally less than 0.5 mm), the maximum error of the two is less than 10%, which verifies the validity of the magnetic finite element numerical simulation method in this paper. Analysis of magnetic force influencing factors The influence of different permanent magnet materials on magnetic force Common permanent magnet materials include neodymium-iron-boron (NdFeB) alloy, samarium-cobalt (SmCo) alloy, aluminum-nickel-cobalt (Alnico) alloy, and ferrite21. A comparison of the performances of the four types of permanent magnet materials is shown in Table 3. Permanent magnet material as a magnetic seal magnetic static ring material, in order to ensure the reliability of the seal, needs to have a high residual magnetic induction strength , large coercivity with high maximum magnetic energy product , in addition to the consideration of these magnetic performance parameters, should also have good mechanical properties. In order to investigate the influence of different permanent magnet materials on the magnetic force, the magnetic force between the dynamic ring/magnetic static ring with four kinds of permanent magnet materials (the magnetization mode is radial magnetization) is calculated by finite element method, and the results are shown in Fig. 10. As can be seen, the magnetic force difference of different magnetic static ring materials is obvious, among which, the magnetic force is the largest when NdFeB is used as a magnetic static ring material, and the magnetic force of ferrite is the smallest. Referring to the range of magnetic force determined under the typical working conditions of the seal in Sect. 1.3 (red dotted line in Fig. 10), only NdFeB35 and SmCo28 materials meet the usage requirements. Combined with Table 3, we can find that although NdFeB35 material has a larger magnetic force, it is not suitable for high-temperature and high-speed engine operation because of its general oxidation-resistant ability and large influence by temperature. SmCo28 has strong magnetism and high coercivity, outstanding oxidation, and corrosion resistance, which is suitable for the complex and harsh working environments. However, due to the samarium cobalt alloy containing rare earth elements, its price is relatively more expensive, generally for the same specifications of Alnico permanent magnet 4–5 times. Magnetic force between dynamic/magnetic ring with different magnetic static ring materials. Effect of permanent magnet magnetizing direction on magnetic force The permanent magnet must be processed into a suitable size by the hard magnetic material first. Considering the structure of the magnetic sealing system, the permanent magnet should be processed into a circular column and then magnetized accordingly using an external magnetic field. Different magnetization methods will obtain different magnetic pole directions, mainly including three magnetization methods: axial magnetization, radial magnetization, and radiative magnetization22. Axial magnetization refers to applying a magnetic field to magnetize along the axial direction of the permanent magnet, and the magnetization direction is perpendicular to the radial plane of the permanent magnet, i.e., the two end surfaces of the ring serve as the N-pole and S-pole respectively after magnetization, as shown in Fig. 11a. Radial magnetization refers to applying a magnetic field perpendicular to the radial direction of the permanent magnet to magnetize, and the magnetization direction is parallel to the radial plane of the permanent magnet, i.e., the two semicircular circumferences of the ring serve as the N-pole and S-pole, respectively, after magnetization, as shown in Fig. 11b. Radiative magnetization refers to the process of applying a magnetic field radiating outward from the center of the permanent magnet or pointing outward from the outside to the center of the permanent magnet, which is perpendicular to the radial direction of the permanent magnet, and the N and S poles after magnetization are the inner and outer cylindrical planes of the torus, respectively, as shown in Fig. 11c. The magnitude of the magnetic force between the dynamic/magnetic static ring for the three materials Alnico5, NdFeB35, and SmCo28 in different magnetization modes is given in Fig. 12. Figure 13 shows the vector diagram of the magnetic susceptibility direction of NdFeB35 under different magnetization modes. Schematic diagram of permanent magnet magnetization direction. Magnetic force magnitude of the three materials under different magnetization methods. Vector diagram of NdFeB35 magnetizing direction. It can be seen that, under the same material, when the permanent magnet is axially magnetized the magnetic force between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring is the largest, followed by radial magnetization, and radial magnetization is the smallest. For example, in the case of the magnetic static ring made of NdFeB35, the magnetic force in the case of axial magnetization is about twice as much as that of radiation magnetization, and the magnetic force in the case of radiation magnetization is about 1.1 times as much as that of the radial magnetization. The reason for this phenomenon is that in axial magnetization, the magnetic flux line of the permanent magnet is closed along its axis, which can produce the maximum magnetic flux on the two pole surfaces of the permanent magnet. Because the magnetic force is proportional to the magnetic flux, axially magnetized permanent magnets can produce the strongest magnetic force. In radiative magnetization, the magnetic field is radially spread outward, forming a relatively uniform distribution of the magnetic field. Although the magnetic circuit design of radiative magnetization is more flexible, the magnetic force is weakened relative to axial magnetization because the magnetic flux line is not directly closed along the axial direction, but is distributed along the radial direction. In radial magnetization, the magnetic domains are arranged perpendicular to the direction of the axis of permanent magnets, and this arrangement is not conducive to the formation of a strong magnetic domain structure, which results in the smallest magnetic force. Referring to the range of magnetic force determined under the typical working conditions of the seal in Sect. 1.3 (red dotted line in Fig. 12), the radial magnetization of NdFeB material, and the radial and radiative magnetization of SmCo material can meet the usage requirements. From Fig. 12, it can be seen that the magnetizing method has a great influence on the magnetic force. Therefore, when designing the magnetic sealing system, the magnetizing method of the permanent magnet should be reasonably selected for different engineering requirements to ensure that the magnetic sealing system can work stably. Influence of the structural parameters of the magnetic sealing system on the magnetic force In the structure of the magnetic sealing system studied in this paper, the dimensions of the outer diameter of the dynamic ring, the outer diameter of the magnetic static ring, and the inner diameter of the magnetic static ring are taken as constant values here because they are related to the overall system dimensions. The following mainly analyzes the influence of the dynamic ring inner diameter and the gap between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring on the magnetic force. According to the basic parameters of the structure shown in Table 1, the magnetic force of three different materials, Alnico5, NdFeB35 and SmCo28, is calculated by the finite element method under different inner diameters of the dynamic ring. All three materials are axially magnetized, and the results are shown in Fig. 14. It can be seen that with the increase of the inner diameter of the dynamic ring, the magnetic force acting on the dynamic ring of the magnetic static ring of the three materials decreases. This is because with the increase of the inner diameter of the dynamic ring, the action area between the magnetic static ring and the dynamic ring decreases, and the magnetic force is proportional to the area of action, so the magnetic force decreases with the increase of the outer diameter of the graphite ring. The magnetic force of NdFeB35 and SmCo28 is much larger than that of Alnico5 with the same inner diameter of the dynamic ring, but the magnetic force of NdFeB35 and SmCo28 decreases at a larger rate with the increase of the inner diameter. Magnetic force variation with different dynamic ring inner diameters. The results of the magnetic force calculations for three different static ring materials, Alnico5, NdFeB35, and SmCo28, at different dynamic/magnetic static ring gaps are given in Fig. 15. It can be seen that with the increase of the dynamic ring/magnetic static ring gap, the magnetic force of the three materials magnetic static ring acting on the dynamic ring gradually decreases, the reason for which is obvious, because the bigger the dynamic ring/magnetic static ring gap, the weaker the magnetic field strength of the magnetic static ring acting on the dynamic ring. The magnetic force of NdFeB35 and SmCo28 is much larger than that of Alnico5 under the same gap, but the magnetic force of NdFeB35 and SmCo28 decreases at a larger rate with the increase of the gap between the dynamic ring/magnetic static ring. Magnetic force variation with different dynamic/magnetic static ring gaps. Influence of operating parameters on the magnetic force For the magnetic seals studied in this paper, the effect of the variation of operating parameters such as temperature and rotor speed on the magnetic force is mainly discussed. Influence of temperature on magnetism The influence of temperature on the magnetic force is mainly reflected in the effect of temperature on the magnetic parameters of the seal. The effect of temperature on permanent magnets is mainly due to thermal motion, which causes the direction of the magnetic moments of individual atoms to change constantly and irregularly. At lower temperatures, the effect of electron exchange between two neighboring atoms in a permanent magnet is more significant than that of thermal motion. However, when the temperature rises to a certain degree, the magnetic moment in the permanent magnet will change the spatial orientation under the action of thermal motion, making the domains and domain walls that are already in a regular arrangement produce motion, which includes the rotation of the magnetic moment of the domains and the movement of the domain walls, resulting in some of the magnetic domains being arranged in disorder and irreversible demagnetization. With the disturbance of some magnetic domain arrangements, the magnetic induction of the permanent magnet material decreases along the demagnetization curve, and the magnetic induction will not recover even after the original temperature is restored, resulting in a loss of some of the magnetic energy23. Since the magnetic properties of permanent magnets will decrease continuously with increasing temperature, the temperature coefficient of residual magnetic induction strength and the temperature coefficient of coercivity are introduced for correction. The temperature coefficient of remanent magnetism , is the ratio of the percentage of reversible change in remanent magnetic induction to the degree of change in temperature when the temperature varies within a certain range, and is given by the following formula: The coercivity temperature coefficient , is the ratio of the percent reversible change in coercivity to the degree of temperature change when the temperature varies over a range, and is given by the following formula: where is the remanent magnetic induction at temperature T, is the coercivity at temperature T; is the remanent magnetic induction at temperature , and is the coercivity at temperature . Room temperature is usually chosen as . If () is positive, it means that the remanent magnetism (coercivity) increases with increasing temperature, and if it is negative, it means that the remanent magnetism (coercivity) decreases with increasing temperature. From Eq. (4), the correction formula for the residual magnetic induction strength of the permanent magnet material at the operating temperature T is as follows: From Eq. (5), the correction equation for the coercivity of the permanent magnetic material at the operating temperature T is given by: According to the Handbook of Chinese and Foreign Magnetic Materials, the temperature coefficients of remanent magnetization of Alnico5, NdFeB35, and SmCo28 are − 0.02%, − 0.12%, and − 0.03%, respectively, and the temperature coefficients of coercivity are − 0.07%, − 0.6%, and − 0.2%, respectively. Figure 16 shows the magnetic force calculation results of magnetic static rings (magnetization direction is radial magnetization) of three materials, Alnico5, NdFeB35, and SmCo28, at different temperatures. It can be seen that as the temperature increases, the magnetic force gradually decreases, which is because that as the temperature rises, the remanent magnetization and coercivity of permanent magnets are reduced, which in turn leads to a decrease in the magnetic force produced by the permanent magnets. Although the magnetic force of NdFeB35 is the largest at room temperature, the rate of decrease of its magnetic force with the increase of temperature is significantly greater than that of SmCo28 and Alnico5, and the magnetic force of NdFeB35 is even lower than that of SmCo28 at about 175 °C. Therefore, in designing the magnetic sealing system, we should take into consideration the high-temperature resistance and thermal stability of the selected permanent magnet to ensure that the system can maintain stable magnetic performance under different temperatures, thereby guaranteeing the sealing performance and reliability of the system. Calculated magnetic force at different temperatures for three materials. The relative permeability of the dynamic ring, the shaft, and the graphite ring materials also changes slightly in the high-temperature environment. In order to analyze its effect on the magnetic force, the relative permeability temperature correction factor is introduced as. where is the relative permeability at a temperature of T; is the relative permeability at a temperature of , is the relative permeability temperature correction coefficient, for the magnetic sealing material in this paper, the relative permeability temperature correction coefficient of the graphite ring (M234A0), the dynamic ring (1Cr13) and rotating shaft (16Cr3NiWMoVNbE) are − 0.02%, − 0.04% respectively, − 0.04%. In order to compare the degree of influence of the magnetic properties of static ring, dynamic ring, rotating shaft, and graphite on the magnetic force with temperature change, the influence of the magnetic performance parameters on the magnetic force with the change of temperature is calculated in three cases: (1) only the influence of magnetic static ring is considered; (2) the influence of magnetic static ring, rotating shaft, and dynamic ring are considered; (3) Consider the influence of magnetic static ring, rotating shaft, dynamic ring, and graphite. The magnetic static ring materials are all Alnico5, and the results are shown in Fig. 17. It can be seen that whether the magnetic performance parameters of the dynamic ring, rotating shaft, and graphite ring materials are considered to change with temperature are almost the same as magnetic force calculation results of the static ring permanent magnet material that are only considered to be affected by temperature. The influence of temperature on the magnetic properties of permanent magnet materials is dominant because the temperature has a greater impact on the coercivity and remanence of the magnetic static ring, thus directly affecting the magnetic force. For the structure and material of this paper, the influence of magnetic static ring accounts for 99.6%. Magnetic changes at different temperatures. Influence of rotational speed on magnetic force In the magnetic sealing system studied in this paper, the magnetic static ring made of permanent magnets is stationary, and the dynamic ring and the rotating shaft rotate at high speed during the working process. In order to investigate the effect of rotational speed on the magnetic force, the change of magnetic force under different rotational speeds is analyzed using the finite element method. The speed is different, that is, each rotation of a circle takes a different time, but the magnetic force changes in each circle are the same. Figure 18 shows the magnetic force with the number of revolutions of the rotating shaft when the magnetic static ring adopts three different materials: Alnico5, NdFeB35, and SmCo28 (three kinds of materials of the magnetic static ring are radial magnetization at room temperature). Influence of rotational speed on magnetic force. As can be seen in Fig. 18, with the rotation of the rotating shaft/dynamic ring, the magnetic force shows a slight periodic fluctuation, with a fluctuation rate of 2.84% for the Alnico5 material, 1.17% for the SmCo28 material, and 1.19% for the NdFeB35 material. As the permanent magnet material is a static ring, the dynamic ring will produce an induced magnetic field excited by the permanent magnet. When the dynamic ring and the rotating shaft rotate, the magnetic field around it will be distorted and changed to a certain extent, and this change in the magnetic field leads to periodic fluctuations in the magnetic force between the magnetic static ring and the dynamic ring, and an increase or decrease in the rotational speed will only affect the period of the fluctuation of the magnetic force and does not affect the magnitude of it. As the size of the magnetic force is mainly affected by the permanent magnetic material, the rotation of the dynamic ring/rotary shaft has little effect on the magnetic force. For the magnetic seal studied in this paper, the effect of the rotation of the dynamic ring/rotary shaft can be disregarded in the calculation of the magnetic force. Fitting formula for magnetic force calculation Construction of the fitting formula In order to facilitate engineering applications, improve the efficiency of magnetic force calculation of magnetic seals, and carry out the optimization design of magnetic seals in the future, this paper establishes a fitting formula for magnetic force calculation of magnetic seals. According to the analysis results of the magnetic force influencing factors mentioned before, it is known that the inner diameter of the dynamic ring (D1), the gap between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring (I), and the temperature of the magnetic static ring (T) have a greater influence on the magnetic force, so these three factors are selected as the design variables of the magnetic force fitting equations. This paper adopts the three-factor, nine-level orthogonal test design method to establish the L81(92) orthogonal test program. Based on the magnetic force analysis finite element model in “Magnetic force in relation to the proper functioning of the sealing system” section, the material of magnetic static ring is selected to be SmCo28, and the direction of magnetization is radiative magnetization (concerning the range of the magnetic force determined under the typical conditions of the seal in Sect. 1.3 and the effect of temperature on the magnetic force in Sect. 3.4.1, it is known that the use of samarium cobalt material can meet the requirements for the use of radiation magnetization. Radiation magnetization can meet the use requirements, and its magnetic force decreases slowly when the temperature rises compared with NdFeB35), 81 groups of sample magnetic force () calculation results are obtained through finite element numerical simulation, as shown in Table 5. Table 5Orthogonal test scheme and magnetic calculation results.Serial number(mm)I(mm)T(℃)(N)Serial number(mm)I(mm)T(℃)(N)119.50.36516.9942220.554516.652190.32520.1543220.68511.89320.50.52516.804422.50.76511.854230.71059.804520.50.558512.395210.42518.2946190.6510510.326220.72513.9947200.552515.967200.44516.844819.50.5510513.448220.356516.344920.50.410512.97921.50.62515.3550210.657511.8710200.458513.615119.50.78510.821122.50.58513.005222.50.47514.9112200.69511.325319.50.353518.531322.50.34518.525419.50.652514.6314230.352519.225519.50.65513.5215210.610510.7956200.310514.141620.50.37516.3057210.74512.8817210.553515.7158230.35517.7718210.355516.975921.50.658511.3319190.45516.3260210.459512.9820190.64514.106122.50.63514.6721220.655512.9662190.358514.9522220.39514.886321.50.510511.8623230.654513.466420.50.455515.4824190.59512.4665200.656512.352520.50.354517.6766230.67512.3426230.53516.146722.50.555514.2127220.4510512.436822.50.3510513.5928190.556513.5969210.56514.192919.50.49513.6070210.38515.5330230.48514.2871190.453516.943121.50.557513.0172200.357515.583222.50.659510.867320.50.79510.343321.50.33519.227421.50.75512.363421.50.454516.2075200.55514.813519.50.457514.2376200.73513.4336230.456514.9077220.43517.6637190.77511.337821.50.46515.553820.50.66512.967920.50.653514.023922.50.452517.638021.50.359514.244019.50.54515.5081220.57513.6241230.559511.83 Orthogonal test scheme and magnetic calculation results. Based on the results of the aforementioned analysis of the law of the influence of the inner diameter of the dynamic ring, the gap of the dynamic/magnetic static ring, and the temperature of the magnetic static ring on the magnetic force, the magnetic force fitting formula is assumed to be: where is the coefficient to be determined. The least squares method24 is used to determine the coefficients to obtain the fitting formula for the magnetic force calculation as follows: The goodness-of-fit test of the magnetic fitting formula for the above magnetic sample data shows that the decidable coefficient R2 0.983, indicating that the fitting formula for magnetic force has a high fitting accuracy. Validation of the fitting formula Six groups of data samples are randomly selected, and the magnetic force is calculated by a fitting formula and finite element numerical simulation respectively, and the results are shown in Table 6. It can be seen that the error between the magnetic force fitting formula calculation results and numerical simulation results is less than 2%, with good consistency. Table 6Comparison of calculated and numerically simulated values of magnetic fitting equations.Serial number (mm) (mm)T (°C)Fitting formula Simulation Inaccuracies (%)120.50.52516.915616.79500.712210.610510.855910.79100.603200.458513.675813.60700.50422.50.63514.889614.67001.475190.556513.644213.58500.436230.654513.585213.45800.94 Comparison of calculated and numerically simulated values of magnetic fitting equations. Conclusion Using the finite element simulation and analysis method based on the Maxwell stress tensor method, the magnetic force acting on the dynamic ring of the magnetic seal can be obtained effectively, and the error between the simulation results and the experimental results is less than 10%. Using the finite element simulation and analysis method based on the Maxwell stress tensor method, the magnetic force acting on the dynamic ring of the magnetic seal can be obtained effectively, and the error between the simulation results and the experimental results is less than 10%. The material of the magnetic static ring has an obvious influence on the magnetic force between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring. For several permanent magnet materials studied in this paper, NdFeB35 has the largest magnetic force, SmCo28 is second, Alnico5 and Ferrite are relatively small, and their magnetic forces are about 1/4 to 1/5 of the first two materials. SmCo28, although it is more expensive, has strong magnetic properties and high coercivity, while its oxidation and corrosion resistance are outstanding. The material of the magnetic static ring has an obvious influence on the magnetic force between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring. For several permanent magnet materials studied in this paper, NdFeB35 has the largest magnetic force, SmCo28 is second, Alnico5 and Ferrite are relatively small, and their magnetic forces are about 1/4 to 1/5 of the first two materials. SmCo28, although it is more expensive, has strong magnetic properties and high coercivity, while its oxidation and corrosion resistance are outstanding. The permanent magnet magnetizing method has a more significant effect on the magnetic force in the magnetic sealing system. Under the same material, when the permanent magnet is axially magnetized, the magnetic force between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring is the largest, followed by radiative magnetization, and radial magnetization is the smallest. Taking the magnetic static ring made of NdFeB35 as an example, the ratio of magnetic force under axial, radiative, and radial magnetization is about 2.3:1.1:1. The permanent magnet magnetizing method has a more significant effect on the magnetic force in the magnetic sealing system. Under the same material, when the permanent magnet is axially magnetized, the magnetic force between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring is the largest, followed by radiative magnetization, and radial magnetization is the smallest. Taking the magnetic static ring made of NdFeB35 as an example, the ratio of magnetic force under axial, radiative, and radial magnetization is about 2.3:1.1:1. The inner diameter of the dynamic ring and the gap between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring have a large effect on the magnetic force. The magnetic force of the magnetic static ring acting on the dynamic ring decreases with the increase of the inner diameter of the dynamic ring or the gap between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring. The inner diameter of the dynamic ring and the gap between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring have a large effect on the magnetic force. The magnetic force of the magnetic static ring acting on the dynamic ring decreases with the increase of the inner diameter of the dynamic ring or the gap between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring. The effect of temperature on the magnetic force between the dynamic ring/magnetic static ring is large, in which the effect of temperature on the magnetic performance parameters of permanent magnetic materials dominates, for the structure and materials in this paper, the effect of magnetic static ring accounted for 99.6%. The magnetic static ring of NdFeB35 material has the largest magnetic force at room temperature, but the rate of decrease of magnetic force with the increase of temperature is significantly larger than that of SmCo28 and Alnico5 material. However, the magnetic force of NdFeB35 is lower than that of SmCo28 at temperatures above 175°. The effect of temperature on the magnetic force between the dynamic ring/magnetic static ring is large, in which the effect of temperature on the magnetic performance parameters of permanent magnetic materials dominates, for the structure and materials in this paper, the effect of magnetic static ring accounted for 99.6%. The magnetic static ring of NdFeB35 material has the largest magnetic force at room temperature, but the rate of decrease of magnetic force with the increase of temperature is significantly larger than that of SmCo28 and Alnico5 material. However, the magnetic force of NdFeB35 is lower than that of SmCo28 at temperatures above 175°. The shaft rotating speed is different, that is, each turn with a different time, but the magnetic force change rule of each circle is the same, the increase or decrease of the speed will only affect the period of magnetic force fluctuations and does not affect its amplitude. The maximum fluctuation rate of magnetic force amplitude caused by rotation is 2.84% (Alnico material). For the magnetic seal studied in this paper, the calculation of the magnetic force may not take into account the impact of the rotor/dynamic ring rotation. The shaft rotating speed is different, that is, each turn with a different time, but the magnetic force change rule of each circle is the same, the increase or decrease of the speed will only affect the period of magnetic force fluctuations and does not affect its amplitude. The maximum fluctuation rate of magnetic force amplitude caused by rotation is 2.84% (Alnico material). For the magnetic seal studied in this paper, the calculation of the magnetic force may not take into account the impact of the rotor/dynamic ring rotation. According to the results of the single-factor analysis, the orthogonal test and the least squares method are used to fit the relationship between the magnetic force and the inner diameter of the dynamic ring, the gap between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring, and the temperature of the magnetic static ring. The fitted formula has a better consistency with the simulation results, which can improve the magnetic force calculation efficiency of magnetic seals, and facilitate the engineering applications and carry out the optimization design of magnetic seals. According to the results of the single-factor analysis, the orthogonal test and the least squares method are used to fit the relationship between the magnetic force and the inner diameter of the dynamic ring, the gap between the dynamic ring and the magnetic static ring, and the temperature of the magnetic static ring. The fitted formula has a better consistency with the simulation results, which can improve the magnetic force calculation efficiency of magnetic seals, and facilitate the engineering applications and carry out the optimization design of magnetic seals. This paper discusses the direct effect of temperature and rotational speed on the magnetic force, as a sealing system, temperature and rotational speed will also affect the temperature and deformation of the sealing system, thus indirectly affecting the magnetic force and sealing performance, for the given working conditions and structure, the magnetic force analysis under the action of magnetic-thermal-solid coupling should be carried out in the future. This paper discusses the direct effect of temperature and rotational speed on the magnetic force, as a sealing system, temperature and rotational speed will also affect the temperature and deformation of the sealing system, thus indirectly affecting the magnetic force and sealing performance, for the given working conditions and structure, the magnetic force analysis under the action of magnetic-thermal-solid coupling should be carried out in the future. Author contributions Wanli Fan: Methodology, Software, Writing-Original draft preparation. Hua Su: Conceptualization, Supervision, Guidance. Ke Li: Visualization, Software. Weiwei Hao: Validation. Data availability The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study available from the corresponding author on reasonable request. Declarations Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The datasets used and/or analysed during the current study available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.