Incidence of traumatic dental injuries associated with orotracheal intubation in general anesthesia in children during mixed dentition in Damascus, Syria: a prospective longitudinal study Authors: Mohammed N Al-Shiekh, Mohamed Altinawi, Bana Darwish, Mawia Karkoutly Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractObjectivesEndotracheal tube intubation by laryngoscope during general anesthesia is a safe procedure with a few complications. However, it may cause some damage to the oral cavity structures, which leads to postoperative pain and discomfort. Traumatic dental injuries associated with endotracheal tube intubation are one of the most common complications. The study aimed to determine the incidence of traumatic dental injuries during oral-endotracheal tube intubation in general anesthesia among children receiving surgery at the Children’s Hospital in Damascus City during 2022–2023.MethodsIt was a prospective longitudinal study which investigated the incidence of traumatic dental injuries during oral-endotracheal tube intubation under general anesthesia in 110 children aged 6–12 years old at the University Children’s Hospital in Damascus City in 2022. After ensuring that the child met inclusion criteria and obtained written consent. Each child was examined before, during, and after 12–24 h of entering the operation room. Personal information (gender – age), information related to anesthesia procedures, and some oral cavity characters were collected.ResultsThe incidence of traumatic dental injuries during general anesthesia was 9.1%. Most of them intra-oral soft tissue injuries. The concussion is the most common injury related to teeth damage. In addition, the tongue was the most common-place. There is a correlation between the incidence of traumatic dental injuries and the difficulty of intubation, the number of intubation attempts, Mallampati score (p < 0.05).ConclusionThe anesthesiologist should evaluate the condition of each patient carefully. Document every detail in their record and inform the patient of the possibility of dental damage during the procedures especially in the case that has difficulty intubation.Subject terms: Oral diseases, Dental trauma Introduction Traumatic Dental Injuries (TDIs) are one of the most widespread public health issues that negatively affect emotional, psychological, physical, and financial aspects and quality of life [1]. The literature confirms a high worldwide prevalence of TDIs with broader geographic variations where TDIs affect almost 25% of school-age children and 33% of adults [2, 3]. Most injuries happen before the age of 19 [2, 4, 5]. TDIs are attributed to a diverse and complex set of factors [2, 3, 6]. Glendor et al. [7] suggested that the risk factors associated with TDIs can be divided into three main categories, including oral factors, such as increased overjet [8], environmental factors, including material deprivation [9], and human behavior like sport [9], child abuse [10], and obesity [11]. However, although this classification is beneficial, it is not comprehensive. Some risk factors cannot be included within the three categories mentioned above, such as gender, presence of disease, and learning difficulties [3]. One of the risk factors that correlate with TDIs is iatrogenic injuries (II). These injuries arise from iatrogenic conditions caused by doctors or dentists while providing treatment [6]. Endotracheal tube Intubation (ETI) during General Anesthesia (GA) or emergency intubation is one of the most common procedures associated with TDIs [12–14]. Furthermore, TDIs during GA are the most common cause of malpractice complaints against anesthesiologists [15]. Airway damage occurs commonly during both laryngoscopy and intubation [16]. The incidence of TDIs during GA ranges between 0.03% [17] and 1.13% [18] in retrospective studies and may reach 38% [19] if the studies are prospective and performed by a professional dentist [20, 21]. Poor oral hygiene [22, 23], aggressive intubation due to difficulty viewing the epiglottis [24], inadequate anesthesia [25], emergency intubation [15], lack of alternative intubation equipment [22], shortage in using protective measures [15], and anatomical difficulties [18] are some of the risk factors associated with TDIs during GA. It is accepted practice to conduct an oral examination before an operation, record the findings, and inform the patient of the incidence of TDIs. Also, In the event of dental injury, an anesthesiologist must be capable of immediate and proper management [26]. However, Ansari et al. [27] stated that TDIs associated with ETI during GA are not widely studied in the medical literature. In addition, Windsor et al. [28] mentioned that the most common age susceptible to TDIs during GA is Mixed Dentition (MD). Therefore, the study aimed to determine the incidence of TDIs during Oral-ETI in GA among children receiving surgery at the Children’s Hospital in Damascus City during 2022–2023. Materials and methods Study design and ethics It is a longitudinal, descriptive, prospective study that investigates the incidence of TDIs during Oral-ETI by traditional laryngoscope in GA in children aged 6–13 years old and who received elective surgery at the Children’s Hospital in Damascus between December 2022 and December 2023. All procedures were carried out in conformity with all current ligations and guidelines. In addition, ethical approval was obtained from the Scientific Research Committee of the Damascus University, Syria (IRB No. UDDS-2599-09052022/SRC-1550). The study was carried out in adherence to STROBE checklists. Before data collection, all participants’ legal guardians provided informed consent. Sample size The sample size was calculated according to the Cochran formulation [29]: n0 = Z4.p.q/e4. According to the Nahas et al. [30] study, which set a confidence level of 95.5% with z = 2, e = 10%, and p = 50%, the minimum required sample size was 100, giving a power of 90%. However, the sample size was increased to 110 to increase the level of accuracy and validity. The anticipated number of subjects who will drop out of the study was taken into consideration when increasing the sample size. Participants’ selection This study included children aged 6–12 in mixed dentition who received surgical procedures under GA. All uncooperative patients, according to Frankl’s scale, were excluded. Children who received maxillofacial and upper respiratory tract surgery and those whose guardians refused to participate were excluded. In addition, the children who had cognitive and mental problems that banned them from active verbal connection and who had orthodontic appliances were excluded. Variables and data collection After ensuring that the child met the inclusion criteria and obtaining written consent, each child was examined clinically separately before entering the operation room. The patient was examined during the operations, during the awake phase, and 12–24 h after the end of the intervention. During GA, they will undergo Oral-ETI utilizing a Macintosh blade (Welch Allyn Standard Laryngoscope Blade- English MacIntosh- Size 2. MFID: 69242, New-Med Instruments, Sialkot, Pakistan). The following data was collected: demographic information (age - gender) - information related to aspects of anesthesia procedures (year of the residents were responsible for anesthesia - the resident’s assessment of the difficulty of intubation - number of intubation attempts - duration of anesthesia) - information related to the oral cavity and the anatomical structure (evaluation of the temporomandibular Joint – inter-incisor distance opening - the distance between the mental and the thyroid cartilage - occlusal classification of inter-molar relationship - Mallampati score – DMFT+dmft index - gingivitis). In the event of TDIs, the diagnostic protocol found by Jones et al. [31] was used with some modifications, which consisted of Extraoral examination (facial fractures - wounds - bruises - swelling - abrasions - foreign bodies - deviation of the temporomandibular joint – bleeding). Intraoral examination (examination of the oral mucosa: upper lip, lower lip, frenulum, vestibular mucosa, gingiva, uvula, tongue, the floor of the mouth - Examination of the teeth and their identification according to the form of the injury: (avulsion - lateral luxation - intrusion - concussion - Subluxation - cracks - coronal fractures - root coronal fractures - pulp exposure - movement - percussion). Statistical methods The Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS)(IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA) was used for all analyses. The p-value was considered significant if it was less than 0.05. Descriptive statistics was used to describe the frequency and percentage of categorical variables and the mean, standard deviation, minimum, and maximum for numeric data. After Kolmogrov–Smironov test was used. The Mann–Whitney U test was used to compare numeric variables (age - number of intubation attempts - duration of anesthesia – inter-incisor distance opening - the distance between the chin and the thyroid cartilage - DMFT+dmft index) according to TDIs occurrence. In addition, the Chi-square test was used to compare categorical variables and their correlation to TDI incidence. Results A total of 110 children (64.5% male and 35.5% female) were included in this study, the majority of them (92.7%) have a normal TMJ and more than half (56.4%) have a class I inter-molar relationship. However, most of them (81.8%) had no sign of gingivitis (Table 1). Regarding the years of residents, who were responsible for intubation, over a third were in the second year, and 80.9% estimated the intubation procedure wasn’t difficult (Table 1). Moreover, the mean age of participants in this study was 8.64 ± 1.86. In addition, the minimum number of intubation trials was one attempt while the maximum was 9 attempts. The mean duration of anesthesia was 2.5 ± 1.12 h. In addition, the mean inter-incisor distance was 3.5 ± 0.5 cm. Finally, the mean DMFT+dmft index for the children’s sample was 6.07 ± 4.01 (Table 2). Indeed, 9.1% of the individuals sample suffered from TDIs during ETI in GA. 80% intraoral and 20% extraoral (Table 3). All of those injuries were single, not multiple. All the extraoral TDIs were related to the temporomandibular joint. Where the intraoral TDIs were distributed as follows: 62.5% oral mucosa (60% tongue, 40% upper lip) and 37.5% related to teeth (66.7% concussion, 33.3% avulsion) (Table 3). Concussion injury occurred on teeth 11 while just tooth 51 was exposed to an avulsion injury. The chi-square test showed that those who were classified as difficult to intubate had a higher chance of suffering from TDIs. In addition, those who had a III or IV Mallampati classification, class II inter-molar relationship, and gingivitis presence had a higher opportunity to occur TDIs during ETI in GA (p < 0.05) (Table 4). It should be noted that the Man–Whitney test showed that there wasn’t a significant difference between the two groups associated with the age of the child, duration of anesthesia, inter-incisor distance, the distance between chin and thyroid cartilage, and DMFT+dmft index (p > 0.05) (Table 5). Table 1How categorical variables were distributed within the sample.Categorical variablesN%SexMale7164.5Female3935.5Year of the residents11917.323632.732926.442623.6The resident’s assessment of the difficulty of intubationIt was difficult2119.1It wasn’t difficult8980.9Evaluation of the Temporomandibular JointNormal10292.7Click on both sides with limited open-mouth65.5Click on the left-side21.8Occlusal classification of inter-molar relationshipClass I6256.4Class II1614.5Class III43.6Straight line21.8Mesial step2119.1Distal step54.5Mallampati scoreI4339.1II3834.5III1210.9IV1715.5GingivitisYes2018.2No9081.8N number of children, % percentage of children. How categorical variables were distributed within the sample. N number of children, % percentage of children. Table 2Statistical indicators of the sample.MinimumMaximumMeanSDaAge6.0012.008.64551.86388Number of intubation attempts1.009.002.89091.95990Duration of anesthesia0.506.002.59181.12528Inter-incisor distance2.304.803.56450.56821The distance between the mental and thyroid cartilage4.509.507.09731.20141DMFT+ dmft index0.0018.006.07274.10797aStandard deviation. Statistical indicators of the sample. aStandard deviation. Table 3Distribution of Traumatic dental injuries during oral-EndoTracheal Intubation in General Anesthesia.N% of TDIs% of the total sampleIncidence of TDIs during ETI in GA109.1Place of TDIsIntra-oral8807.27Extra-oral2201.82Extra-oral TDIsPain in TMJ1500.91Pain in TMJ with the limited opening of the mouth1500.91Intra-oral TDIsSoft tissue562.54.54Hard tissue337.52.72Type of hard tissue TDIsConcussion266.71.82Avulsion133.30.91Location of soft tissue TDIsTongue3602.72Upper lip2401.82 Distribution of Traumatic dental injuries during oral-EndoTracheal Intubation in General Anesthesia. Table 4Chi-square test to compare between categorical variables according to incidence of TDIs.Incidence of TDIs during ETI in GAp-valueNoYesN%N%SexMale6287.4912.60.094Female3897.512.5year of the residents11894.815.20.41123288.9411.132689.7310.342493.427.6the resident’s assessment of the difficulty of intubationDifficult1466.7733.30.000299aNot difficult8696.6333.37evaluation of the Temporomandibular JointNormal9492.287.80.097Click on both sides with limited open-mouth466.7233.3Click on the left-side210000.0occlusal classification of inter-molar relationshipClass I6096.823.20.000083aClass II1063.5637.5Class III250250Straight line210000.0Mesial step2110000.0Distal step510000.0Mallampati scoreI4310000.00.0061aII3592.137.9II975325IV1376.5423.5GingivitisYes15755250.017aNo8594.455.6N number of cases, % percentage of cases according to incidence of TDIs.aSignificant difference p-value < 0.05. Chi-square test to compare between categorical variables according to incidence of TDIs. N number of cases, % percentage of cases according to incidence of TDIs. aSignificant difference p-value < 0.05. Table 5Man–Whitney test to compare between numerical variables according to the incidence of TDIs.Incidence of TDIsp-valueNoYesMeanMeanAge8.549.70.098Number of attempts2.694.90.00013aDuration of anesthesia2.62.50.96Inter-incisor distance3.583.40.38The distance between the mental and thyroid cartilage7.166.470.078DMFT+dmft index23.2623.60.54aA significant difference. Man–Whitney test to compare between numerical variables according to the incidence of TDIs. aA significant difference. Discussion This study investigated the incidence of TDIs during oral ETI in GA among children aged 6–13 who received elective surgery in a Children’s Hospital in Damascus between 2022 and 2023. For this purpose, 110 children were recruited, and it was found that the incidence of TDIs was 9.1%. This percentage is higher than the percentages mentioned in retrospective studies. Newland et al. study [22] 0.04%, Kakei et al. study [32] 0.06%, Kuo et al. study [33] 0.05%, Martin et al. study [34] 0.2%, and Vogel et al. study [18] 1.13%. However, this value is less than what was found in Christensen et al. study [35] 22%, Mourão et al. study [36] 25%, and Manifar et al. study [37] 25%. If the research is conducted by a skilled dentist and is prospective [20, 21], the percentage could potentially climb to 38% [19]. This variance may attributed to differences in study design and sample size in addition to the age of participants and the character of the sample community. Oral mucosa injuries were higher than hard tissue injuries. This result is consistent with what Manifar et al. study [37] found and explained by the type of equipment used during laryngoscopy and intubation which makes easier to it harm soft tissue than hard tissue [14]. The most common type of injury related to hard tissue is Concussion. This result contrasts many studies [18, 19, 23, 35, 37] which found that uncomplicated crown fractures are the most common. In addition, one study found that avulsion is the most common [32]. This difference may be due to the absence of the percussion test from these studies, which is considered crucial in diagnosing clinically silent concussion injuries [38]. However, this study agrees with many studies [13–18, 22, 23, 25, 26, 28, 32, 35–43] published regarding the maxillary central incisor being the most affected teeth because of use it as a fulcrum when using a laryngoscope [14, 42]. A study mentioned that the right side is more vulnerable to injury compared to the left [22]. This result was found in this study and that can explained by the anthologists inserting the laryngoscope into the right side of the oral cavity initially, and when reaching the pharynx, turning the blade towards the left side [44]. In addition, this study found that the tongue was the most common location for TDIs in GA. This confirms what is mentioned in many studies [16, 19, 37]. There were 12.6% of male and 2.5% of female who had TDIs during GA. However, no significant difference was found related to gender and this is consistent with a group of studies [16, 19, 22, 32, 37]. This result can be interpreted by the surrounding circumstances environment of injured person play a more important role in the occurrence of TDIs comparing to factor like sex [2]. Moreover, no significant difference was resulted according to the age of children, this is supported by many studies [16, 17, 19, 37] and can be explained by the stage of age reflecting the same stage of occlusal development (Mixed dentition), which means similar features for all individuals’ sample. There wasn’t any real effect of the year of the residents on the occurrence of TDIs during ETI in GA. Gaiser & Castro study [45] mentioned the same result and that attributed to strict case evaluation criteria and continuous supervision by trained anesthesiologists. Difficult intubation is a procedure that requires three or more attempts of intubation with a change in position, laryngoscope blade, or the use of a laryngeal mask [22]. This study found that 70% of TDIs in GA have difficult intubation and there was a significant difference between who had TDIs or not according to this variable when Chi-square was applied. However, many studies [16, 18, 36] don’t agree with this result. In addition, as the number of attempts to intubate increases the possibility of having TDIs increases. This fact confirms the result that was found when the difficulty of the intubation variable was studied. Mourão et al. Study [36] provide the same fact. Repeated intubation attempts require the anesthesiologist to apply a greater force (> 49 N) using the laryngoscope blade to see the epiglottis and this may lead to TDIs [24]. Most of the injuries happened to children who had a III and IV grade on the Mallampati score and there was a significant relationship between this variable and the incidence of TDIs during GA. This result is consistent with the Tan et al. study [46] and can be clarified by this score evaluating the oral soft tissues and the amount of space they occupy when the pharynx is visualized. The less the ability to visualize the pharynx (grade III-IV), the more difficult the intubation is and the more likely to damage the airway during intubation [47]. The mean of the DMFT+dmft index in children who had TDIs was 23.6 while in children who didn’t have TDIs was 23.26. However, there wasn’t any significant difference between the two groups (p-value > 0.05). This result doesn’t agree with what was mentioned in many studies [15, 17, 18, 22, 40] that can be explained by the fact that Syrian children have poor oral hygiene in two groups compared to the previous study’s participants [48]. Only a limited number of anesthesiologists know the importance and role of mouth guards during GA, laryngoscopy, and ETI procedures [20]. However, they play a fundamental role in protecting and managing joint pain on the one hand [49] and preventing or reducing the incidence of TDIs during intubation procedures on the other hand [50]. The main limitation of this study is the small number of participants. Longitudinal descriptive studies evaluate the incidence rate immediately after the injury. This type of study is considered expensive and time-consuming. It requires an integrated team to cover the largest possible number of injuries [51], unlike retrospective studies that depend on evaluating the prevalence rates by reviewing the data included by the anesthesiologists or by the patient if he realized the injury during a previous period. In addition, the age range in mixed dentition is limited, and it is difficult to follow up with children after general anesthesia. All of the above factors affected the sample size. In addition, this study does not evaluate other techniques in reducing dental traumatic injuries, such as miller blade, LMA Laryngeal mask airway, or video laryngoscope. Further research is needed to compare traditional laryngoscopes and alternative tools about the incidence of TDIs during oral-ETI in GA. Conclusion The incidence of TDIs during oral-ETI in GA is 9.1% in children during mixed occlusal at Children’s Hospital in Damascus City. Even with the skilled hands of anesthesiologists, there is a chance of TDIs in GA. Moreover, higher intubation attempts, intubation difficulty, III or IV Mallampati score, class II inter-molar relationship, and gingivitis increased the possibility of injury during oral-ETI. The anesthesiologist should evaluate the condition of each patient carefully. Document every detail in their record and inform the patient of dental damage. Acknowledgements The authors are grateful that the completion of this research would not have been possible without the support and nurturing of Prof. Dr. Faten Rostom (Department of Anesthesia and Resuscitation, Children’s Hospital, Damascus University, Damascus, SYR). Author contributions MNAS collected data, extracted the data and performed the statistical analysis, wrote the manuscript; MA research concept and design, supervised the project, performed critical revision of the manuscript; BD collected data; MK contributed to writing. All authors have read and approved the manuscript. Funding This research is funded by Damascus University – funder No. 501100020595. Data availability The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Ethical approval Ethical approval was obtained from the Scientific Research Committee of the Damascus University, Syria (IRB No. UDDS-2599-09052022/SRC-1550). Written informed consent was obtained from patients legal guardians. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.