Derivations of the Total Radiation Belt Electron Content Authors: Jared C Pitzel, Christopher M Cully, Jean‐Francois Ripoll, Vivien Loridan, Chia‐Lin Huang, Harlan E Spence, Geoff D Reeves, Kyle R Murphy Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractWe present multiple derivations of the Total Radiation Belt Electron Content (TRBEC), an indicator of the global number of electrons that instantaneously occupy the radiation belts. Derived from electron flux measurements, the TRBEC reduces the spatial information into a scalar quantity that concisely describes global aspects of the system. This index provides a simple, global, and long‐term assessment of the radiation belts that enables systematic analysis. In this work, we examine the TRBEC using the adiabatic invariants of μ,K,L∗ which has been used in previous articles as this coordinate system removes reversible adiabatic effects. We then introduce a new expression to compute the TRBEC using the non‐adiabatic coordinates of E,αeq,L∗, relevant in the contexts of energetic electron precipitation, chorus, and hiss scattering where adiabatic invariant quantities are no longer conserved. From both expressions of the TRBEC we demonstrate that an erroneous factor of (2π)3 that appeared in previous works using the adiabatic derivation led to an overestimate of the reported electron populations. In addition, we quantify electron loss in the outer radiation belt 3.5200 MeV/G with a rate that decreases for increasing particle energy, showing that in the quiet phase between storms higher energy particles have more stable trajectories. The exponential decay implies a loss rate proportional to the number of available electrons in the radiation belts. In the μ ranges of 200–500 MeV/G (500–1,000 MeV/G), there is a 95% (90%) reduction in the TRBEC plots from the peak following the initial storm to the end of the decay period. Respectively, both these observations reproduce the results presented in Duderstadt et al. (2021) and Forsyth et al. (2016) from their TRBEC computations over comparable integration bounds. While the relative change is consistent between our work and the cited works, in both cases the absolute number of electrons in Figure 1 is a factor of ≈250 less than the previous results. This is accounted for by the factor of (2π)3 difference in the equations used to compute the TRBEC. The TRBEC computed in non‐adiabatic coordinates is shown in Figure 2 over the same period. The selected region in phase space mainly represents the TRBEC for relativistic particles in the slot region and outer radiation belt from top to bottom in Figure 2. Similarly to the adiabatic TRBEC, there is an increase in the number of particles after the storms on 1 March and 17 March across all energies. However, at L∗>4 there are multiple injections of lower energy particles, less than 100 keV, on 9 March that decay relatively quickly compared with the loss rates prior to it. This is consistent with simulations during this period that show the main driver of loss in the slot is due to whistler mode hiss waves which are most efficient in this energy range (Ripoll et al., 2017, 2019). This increase is not observed in Figure 1 due to the higher energy of the selected boundaries. A minimum of μ=50 MeV/G in Figure 1 is equivalent to a 244 keV equatorially mirroring particle at L = 4. The TRBEC of electron populations determined by the listed integration bounds in the non‐adiabatic coordinates of E,αeq,L∗. In the slot region (L∗=3.5 to 4, Figure 2 top panel) the electron populations decay quickly before converging to a stable value due to the noise floor of the MagEIS instrument. Outside of the slot region, the electron decay is largely exponential. For lower energies (<300 keV), the exponential decay is interrupted by the injection on 9 March, whereas for 300–1,000 keV electrons the exponential decay is sustained until the 17 March storm. The higher‐energy particles are more stable over this period, as shown by the decreased decay rate, and before 9 March represent the bulk of the electrons in the outer belt. These results show the strength of examining the TRBEC both in physical space E,αeq,L∗ and in adiabatic space μ,K,L∗. Higher‐energy particles show a slow exponential loss during quiet times that is particularly smooth in adiabatic space. Lower‐energy particles show injections and loss features due to non‐adiabatic processes where mapping to invariant space is less applicable. Summary We presented further developments and refinements to the Total Radiation Belt Electron Content (TRBEC) from its origins in Baker et al. (2001) for its continued use as a homogeneous long‐term radiation belt and space weather index. From an information perspective, it is clear that TRBEC significantly reduces the amount of spectral, spatial, and temporal information from measured fluxes, but its functionality comes by way of the ability to simplify a complex system into a scalar quantity. It provides a simple, global, and long‐term assessment of the radiation belt that enables systematic analysis. This relationship between the electron flux and the TRBEC parallels geomagnetic indices such as the Ap and Dst in that global disturbances to the magnetic field are computed and reduced by combining many magnetometer measurements. Furthermore, in the absence of acceleration or loss, the total number of particles is conserved which is a property not held by particle fluxes. We first presented a derivation of the TRBEC by specifying an electron population for a given range in the non‐adiabatic coordinates of energy, equatorial pitch angle, and L∗. Then, using the Hamiltonian formalism, we derived the TRBEC using action‐angle variables to present the TRBEC in terms of adiabatic invariant quantities, namely μ, K, and L∗. We followed these derivations by showing consistency in the normalization of these expressions and compared both derivations to previous results. We showed agreement with Selesnick and Kanekal (2009) and Zhang et al. (2017) with our non‐adiabatic derivation of the TRBEC, however, we also conclude that the adiabatic form of the TRBEC presented in Forsyth et al. (2016), Murphy et al. (2018) and used by Duderstadt et al. (2021) overstates the TRBEC by a factor of (2π)3 (≈248). The impact of the latter discrepancy on the listed papers is limited, since they focus on relative differences in electron populations rather than on absolute number. We showed numerically how we computed the TRBEC over a 20‐day period in 2013, finding similar trends as Forsyth et al. (2016) and Duderstadt et al. (2021) using the adiabatic formulation of the TRBEC. The TRBEC in physical space E,αeq,L∗ is newly derived here, and may be better adapted to describe dynamic radiation belts evolving in ways that do not conserve the two first adiabatic invariants. Beyond showing that particles undergo exponential decay, a future application of the TRBEC would be to use its ability to quantify electron loss from the radiation belts to estimate global precipitation rates during geomagnetic quiet intervals. Overall, the total number of electrons in the radiation belts is immense, reaching upwards of 1028 electrons at the peak of the storm studied. The total kinetic energy of those electrons is also very large, on the order of 1014 J. However, if these electrons could be collected then the combined rest mass would be on a more human scale: about 10 g. Acknowledgments We acknowledge the NASA Van Allen Probes, the late Craig Kletzing (University of Iowa), and the APL Science Gateway for use of data. Processing and analysis of the MagEIS data was supported by Energetic Particle, Composition, and Thermal Plasma (RBSP‐ECT) investigation funded under NASA's Prime contract number NAS5‐01072. This research was supported by the International Space Science Institute (ISSI) in Bern, through ISSI International Team project #477 (Radiation Belt Physics From Top To Bottom: Combining Multipoint Satellite Observations And Data Assimilative Models To Determine The Interplay Between Sources And Losses). J.‐F. Ripoll thanks the Direction Générale de l’Armament (DGA) and the Agence pour l’Innovation de Défense (AID) for funding the ASTRID project “PACTE‐ESPACE.” J. Pitzel and C. Cully acknowledge the support of the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC), funding reference number RGPIN‐2020‐05219. Volume Contained by a Dipole Shell Here we show that the exact ratio between the volume contained within a magnetic dipole shell and the volume of its enclosing sphere is 1635. Using the polar coordinates (r,λ), describes the radial distance of magnetic dipole field lines to the origin (e.g., Schulz & Lanzerotti, 1974). In polar coordinates, the volume of a solid generated by the revolution of the area bounded by a curve, given by r(λ), is where λ1 and λ2 are the bounding radii vectors of the curve (e.g., Phúc, 2020). The specific form of Equation A2 sweeps the curve around the geomagnetic pole axis (λ=π/2). Implementing the dipole field from Equation A1 with Equation A2 and evaluating the expression gives the volume contained within a dipole field line, Vdipole, in terms of the fractional volume of a sphere with a radius corresponding to the equatorial crossing distance of the dipole field lines. Comparisons to Previous Results In this Appendix, we show consistency between the TRBEC derived here and previous work by Selesnick and Kanekal (2009) (henceforth abbreviated as SK09) and Zhang et al. (2017) (henceforth abbreviated as Z17). Selesnick and Kanekal (2009) assume a differential flux (electron intensity) j For the case n=0 (i.e., an isotropic distribution function) in a dipole, and using NSK09 to denote the SK09 solution, the resulting TRBEC is given by their Equation 21: We reconcile nomenclatures by setting a=RE and noting that n=0 implies g=fp2: For our solution, we start with Equation 23 and note that the integral of W(α) over the range α=0 to π/2 is 16/35. Differentiating with respect to energy, setting L=L∗ (i.e., using the same dipolar assumption as in SK09 Equation 21), and dropping any dependence of f on α, Using E=γm0c2 gives which is consistent with Equation B3. For Zhang et al. (2017), we start with their Equation 6, giving the total content in a flux tube. Denoting their solution for the flux tube content with NFT: where A0 is the flux tube area at the equator and r0=LRE is the distance to the flux tube considered. Z17 uses a non‐relativistic formulation throughout, and their phase space density (denoted fv above and f in Z17) is in units of (distance×velocity)−3, related to the differential flux j as fv=mv2j (Z17, below Equation 6). The phase space density f in this work is in units of (distance×momentum)−3, defined as f=j/p2. In the non‐relativistic limit, p=mv and so fv=m3f. Converting fv and using r0=LRE: According to the paragraph preceding Z17 Equation 6, the term sinα0cosα01.30−0.56sinα0 is equivalent to Wα0 in this work (and is indeed a good approximation). Replacing the flux tube area A0 with a differential area element RELdLdθ and integrating gives a quantity that is directly comparable to our TRBEC N and which we will denote NZ17: performing the integral in θ gives Using the non‐relativistic relation E=1/2mv2 gives dv=dE/(mv), and so Or, with p=mv: which is equivalent to our Equation 23 in the non‐relativistic limit (γ=1). Pitzel, J. C. , Cully, C. M. , Ripoll, J.‐F. , Loridan, V. , Huang, C.‐L. , Spence, H. E. , et al. (2024). Derivations of the total radiation belt electron content. Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics, 129, e2024JA032940. 10.1029/2024JA032940 Data Availability Statement The Van Allen Probes flux data is available through the Coordinated Data Analysis Web (CDAWeb), or directly from the Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL), at https://cdaweb.gsfc.nasa.gov/ and https://rbsp‐ect.newmexicoconsortium.org/data_pub/ respectively. The PSD data is available from the Van Allen Probes Science Gateway at https://rbspgway.jhuapl.edu/. We thank the MagEIS and Van Allen Probes Science Gateway teams for providing these data sets. The MATLAB code used to compute the TRBEC in both the energy and adiabatic invariant coordinate frames, plus data files of the computed TRBEC are archived in an open‐access repository (Pitzel, 2024) and maintained at https://github.com/JPitzel/Total_Radiation_Belt_Electron_Content/. References Associated Data Data Citations Data Availability Statement The Van Allen Probes flux data is available through the Coordinated Data Analysis Web (CDAWeb), or directly from the Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL), at https://cdaweb.gsfc.nasa.gov/ and https://rbsp‐ect.newmexicoconsortium.org/data_pub/ respectively. The PSD data is available from the Van Allen Probes Science Gateway at https://rbspgway.jhuapl.edu/. We thank the MagEIS and Van Allen Probes Science Gateway teams for providing these data sets. The MATLAB code used to compute the TRBEC in both the energy and adiabatic invariant coordinate frames, plus data files of the computed TRBEC are archived in an open‐access repository (Pitzel, 2024) and maintained at https://github.com/JPitzel/Total_Radiation_Belt_Electron_Content/.