Pattern of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea and Its Association with Other Eye Diseases at Anterior Segment Clinic in Menelik II Tertiary Referral Hospital Authors: Kiros Tesfay, Menen Ayalew Shibeshi Published: 2024 ABSTRACT PurposeThe purpose of the study was to assess the pattern of spheroidal degeneration of cornea (SDC) and its association with other eye diseases at the anterior segment clinic (ASC) in Menelik II Tertiary Referral Hospital.MethodsA hospital-based prospective descriptive study was conducted at ASC, in Menelik II Tertiary Referral Hospital, from May 2021 to September 2022. All enrolled patients meeting the inclusion criteria were selected and assessed with a structured questionnaire. Descriptive analysis was used to describe the study variables in terms of frequency and percentage. The results were presented using tables and figures.ResultsOut of 62 cases of SDC, 48 (77.4%) were male and 14 (22.6%) were female. It was more prevalent in the age groups of 60–69 and 70–79. Most respondents had outdoor activity (91.9%). A total of 24.2% of patients were found to have Stage I; 35.5% were found to have Stage II; and 40.3% were in Stage III. Posterior subcapsular cataract (PSC) was found in 10 (16.1%) SDC cases, post-trachomatous corneal opacity (CO) in 10 (16.1%) SDC cases, and non-trachomatous CO in 8 (12.9%) SDC cases, but none of them had an association with SDC.ConclusionBetween May 2021 and September 2022, sixty-two cases of SDC were found at the ASC in Menelik II Tertiary Referral Hospital. The data showed a preponderance of SDC in males and older subjects. Stage III and primary types are the leading presentations. It was observed predominantly in individuals who spent most of their time outdoors. Pterygium, corneal opacity, pseudoexfoliation (PXF), PSC, and glaucoma were noted; however, none of these had a significant association with SDC. Introduction Spheroidal degeneration of cornea (SDC) is an acquired degeneration of the cornea or conjunctivae that is characterized by the deposition of translucent golden-yellow globules and amber-colored oily spherules in the superficial layers of the cornea. These spherules accumulate typically near the limbus in the early stages and progressing toward the center of the cornea in a band-shaped pattern. Histochemical stains confirm that the droplets contain protein. It has been postulated that the protein material may result from the actions of ultraviolet (UV) light on serum proteins that diffuse into the cornea from limbal vessels. There are more than ten synonyms for SDC. This diversity is related to the variation in the geographic distribution of this entity and the descriptions given by various authors under different names. It was first described by Bietti in 1955 in the southwest region of Saudi Arabia.1–6 For convenience, the term SDC was used in this study. Fraunfelder et al categorized SDC into three forms: primary, secondary, and conjunctival types. The primary form is associated with aging in a normal eye, while the secondary form occurs in eyes with existing pathologies. The conjunctival type is marked by deposits on the conjunctiva with or without corneal involvement.7 SDC progresses through three stages based on tissue involvement: Stage 1 is peripheral, and vision is unaffected; Stage 2 involves the interpalpebral fissure, leading to visual reduction to 6/60; Stage 3 shows clusters of large golden droplets, severely impacting vision to the point of counting fingers or hand movements.8,9 Increasing age and exposure to UV light are the most common associated factors. Other proposed risk factors include dry eyes, malnutrition, corneal trauma or microtrauma, extremes of temperature, genetic factors, keratitis, lattice corneal dystrophy, and glaucoma. SDC presents symptoms such as intense foreign body sensations, pain, redness, photophobia, and deteriorating vision, significantly affecting patients’ quality of life.10–13 This study aims to assess the pattern of spheroidal degeneration of the cornea (SDC) and its association with other eye diseases among patients visiting Menelik II Tertiary Referral Hospital. Methods and Materials Study Area and Period A hospital-based prospective descriptive study was conducted at the anterior segment clinic (ASC) in Menelik II Tertiary Referral Hospital, located in Addis Ababa, from May 2021 to September 2022. This hospital is the leading and pioneering ophthalmology teaching center in the country. It serves as a teaching, research, and patient care service. Source Population All consecutive patients with eye diseases in Menelik II tertiary referral hospital who visited the hospital during the study period. Study Population All patients with SDC who visited Menelik II tertiary referral hospital at the ASC during the study period. Sample Size Determination and Sampling Technique All patients who visited the hospital with a diagnosis of SDC during the study period were included. Inclusion Criteria All patients evaluated by authors with a diagnosis of SDC. Data Collection Procedure Primary data was collected using a standardized data collection tool that incorporated all relevant study variables. The measured variables included age, sex, indoor or outdoor job, visual acuity (VA), pseudoexfoliation (PXF), pterygium, arcus senile, cataract, stage, and type of SDC. All enrolled patients meeting the inclusion criteria were selected and assessed using a structured questionnaire. After taking demographic details and history, all patients underwent a complete ocular examination. All examinations were carried out by the authors. VA was measured using a standard tumbling-E Snellen chart, and intraocular pressure was measured with an I-Care tonometer before pupillary dilation. All subjects were examined with a Haag-Streit slit lamp biomicroscope (SLB) in a suitable room. The SLB is specifically an instrument used to examine both anterior and posterior segments of the eye.14–17 The diagnosis of SDC was established based on several key observations: the presence of amber granules in the superficial cornea at the periphery of the interpalpebral area, progressively increasing opacification with the granules coalescing and spreading towards the center, and the appearance of nodules accompanied by surrounding stromal haze. Additionally, SDC was divided into three stages and three types. Only one eye was taken into consideration for bilateral involvement. The figures presented refer only to eyes with SDC of lesser grade. This is done to avoid overestimation. During the same inspection, the presence of pterygium and other ocular surface diseases were confirmed.2,7,9 The pupils were dilated with one drop of tropicamide 0.8% and phenylephrine hydrochloride 5% to allow examination of PXF, cataract, and optic disc. Moreover, the pupils were fully dilated, and no subjects in this study exhibited miotic or undilated pupils. All subjects’ eyes were examined using a SLB before and after pupillary dilatation for signs of PXF in the anterior segment. PXF was diagnosed on SLB by the presence of white or gray flakes resembling dandruff on the pupil border or the characteristic light gray membrane of exfoliation material on the lens anterior capsule surface, often with curled anterior edges. Glaucoma was diagnosed on the basis of cupped disc, characteristic visual field defect (Humphrey field analyzer), and IOP above 21 mm Hg as well.2,9,16 Data Analysis The data analysis was done using statistical software, statistical product and service solutions (SPSS), Version 26.0. Figures and tables were created using Microsoft Word and Excel. Descriptive analysis was used to describe the study variables by frequency and percentage. Statistical analyses were performed using chi-square tests for categorical variables, with P <0.05 taken as statistically significant. The results were presented using tables and figures. Ethical Approval Prior to the commencement of the study, ethical approval was obtained from the Research and Ethical Committee of the Ophthalmology Department at Addis Ababa University (Prof. Yilkal Adamu, Dr. Sadik Taju, and Dr. Tiliksew Teshome), under reference number OREC/007/21. Informed written consent was secured from all subjects, and the study was conducted in accordance with the principles outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki. Result Sociodemographic From May 2021 to September 2022, a total of 24,068 patients were seen at ASC, in Menelik II tertiary referral hospital. Among those visitors, 62 cases of SDC were found. Based on this data, the magnitude of SDC was 0.258%, or one SDC per 388 cases. The sociodemographic details were categorized into age, sex, and out-door or in-door job. The age of the subjects was categorized into the ages of <39, 40–49, 50–59, 60–69, 70–79, and >80 years, with 11%, 9.7%, 12.9%, 27.4%, 29%, and 9.7% in each of the categories, respectively. SDC was more prevalent in males than females; forty-eight (77.4%) with SDC were males, and fourteen (22.6%) were females (Table 1).Table 1Sociodemographic Characteristics in Cases of Spheroidal Degeneration of CorneaAgeCategoriesFrequency(N)Percent (%)<3971140–4969.750–59812.960–691727.470–791829>8069.7SexMale4877.4Female1422.6 Table 1Sociodemographic Characteristics in Cases of Spheroidal Degeneration of CorneaAgeCategoriesFrequency(N)Percent (%)<3971140–4969.750–59812.960–691727.470–791829>8069.7SexMale4877.4Female1422.6 Sociodemographic Characteristics in Cases of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea Outdoor and indoor activities Regarding the number of hours spent indoor or outdoor, most respondents (91.9%) were involved in outdoor activities, while only 8.1% participated in indoor activities (Table 2).Table 2Frequency of Outdoor or Indoor Activities of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea CasesActivitiesFrequency(N)Percent (%)Outdoor5791.9Indoor58.1 Table 2Frequency of Outdoor or Indoor Activities of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea CasesActivitiesFrequency(N)Percent (%)Outdoor5791.9Indoor58.1 Frequency of Outdoor or Indoor Activities of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea Cases Stage of SDC Cases A total of 15 (24.2%) patients were found to have Stage I, 22 (35.5%) were found to have Stage II, and 25 (40.3%) were in Stage III. Out of 62, 31 (50%) are primary types, 26 (40.9%) are secondary, and 5 (8.1%) are conjunctival types (Table 3).Table 3Stage of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea CasesStageFrequency(N)Percent (%)I1524.2II2235.5III2540.3 Table 3Stage of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea CasesStageFrequency(N)Percent (%)I1524.2II2235.5III2540.3 Stage of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea Cases Other Eye Diseases A frequency analysis had shown that PSC was found in 10 (16.1%) SDC cases, post-trachomatous CO in 10 (16.1%) SDC cases, non-trachomatous CO in 8 (12.9%) SDC cases, pterygium in 6 (9.7%) SDC cases, and primary open-angle glaucoma in 3 (4.8%) SDC cases. Sixteen (25.8%) cases of SDC had no other eye disease (Figure 1). Figure 1Other eye diseases found in cases of Spheroidal degeneration of cornea.Abbreviations: NSC, nuclear cataract; PI-CO, post inflammatory (non-trachomatous) corneal opacity; POAG, primary open-angle glaucoma; PSC, posterior subcapsular cataract; PT-CO, post-trachomatous corneal opacity. Other eye diseases found in cases of Spheroidal degeneration of cornea. Discussion In this study, a total of 62 SDC cases were found. The magnitude of SDC in this study was quite lower than the studies done by Amit Mohan (10.7%) and H Mohan Kumar (68.7%).2,4 This could be due to the short study period, and cases in their early stages might not visit a tertiary hospital. Ethiopian researchers had not yet published any work on this study topic. However, Rodger visited the Dahlak Islands in the former province of Ethiopia, Eritrea, in 1973 and showed that SDC accounted for 57% of all cases of blindness there.15 Similarly, a recent study done in the Islands of the Northern Red Sea Zone, Eritrea, showed that the prevalence of SDC was 19.6%.18 Another countrywide survey in the Republic of Djibouti found the overall prevalence for both sexes of all ages to be 2.8% for the rural population and 0.5% for urban dwellers.14 A study done by Johnson showed SCD was the third most common cause of blindness in Somalia, after cataract and glaucoma.16 Taylor et al studied 838 male watermen over the age of 30 from Chesapeake Bay in Maryland (USA) and found the prevalence of SCD was 19%. Comparably, Garner et al found a prevalence of 6% in England.1 In our study, the prevalence of the condition was higher in the age groups of 60–69 and 70–79, while it was notably lower in individuals aged above 80 years. This finding contrasts with a study conducted in Jizan, Saudi Arabia, where the highest prevalence was observed in the younger age groups of 21–31 and 32–41 years. Consistent with our findings, a study conducted among Greenlandic and Caucasian populations in Copenhagen reported an increase in prevalence with age, with higher rates observed in men compared to women. This trend is also noted despite the differences seen in studies from the Dahlak Islands and South West Africa.14,15 The higher prevalence among older adults and men can be attributed to prolonged and more frequent exposure to risk factors, particularly for those who spend a significant amount of time outdoors.9 The prevalence in males was higher than in females in most age groups. The greatest difference was seen in the age groups of 60–69 years and 70–79 years. The primary type is more prevalent in older age groups. Generally, all types of SDC were more prevalent in males and older age groups (Table 4 and Figure 2). Johnson discovered that among Labrador residents over 40 years old, the frequency was generally 60.1% for men and 13.5% for women.1Table 4Distribution Types of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea Cases by Age CategoriesAgePrimarySecondaryConjunctivalTotal<39250740–49231650–59620860–697731770–79107118>804206Total3126562 Figure 2Distribution of types of spheroidal degeneration of cornea cases by sex. Legends in the figure (color). Blue = Female. Red = Male. Green = Total. Table 4Distribution Types of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea Cases by Age CategoriesAgePrimarySecondaryConjunctivalTotal<39250740–49231650–59620860–697731770–79107118>804206Total3126562 Distribution Types of Spheroidal Degeneration of Cornea Cases by Age Categories Distribution of types of spheroidal degeneration of cornea cases by sex. Legends in the figure (color). Blue = Female. Red = Male. Green = Total. Nearly 92% of the study participants had outdoor activities for more than 8 hours a day, which is in agreement with a study done by Ahmed Alibrahim, where 78% of cases of SDC had outdoor work. It has been claimed that outdoor workers, such as fishermen, are highly susceptible to UV radiation exposure.17 Around 40.3% of the total of 62 cases examined were found to have Stage III, followed by Stage II (35.5%) and Stage I (24.2%). In the study done by Amit Mohan, 55% were stage I, stage II (32%), and stage III (13%).2 H Mohan Kumar showed in his study that 43.75% of patients had stage 1, 10.93% had stage 2, 7.81% had stage 3, and 6.25% had stage 4 SDC.4 In this study, PSC was observed in 10 cases, pterygium in 6 cases, and post-inflammatory conditions, including trachomatous CO, in 18 cases. No statistically significant associations were found between the observed other eye disease and the stage or type of SDC. In contrast, Resnikoff et al reported a link between SDC and conditions such as cataract, PXF, and pterygium, noting that UV irradiation plays a significant role in all these conditions.1 Limitation of the Study Short study period.Hospital-based rather than cross-sectional community study.Mild cases and those with no visually significant complaints might not visit a tertiary hospital. So, they might be missed. Short study period. Short study period. Hospital-based rather than cross-sectional community study. Hospital-based rather than cross-sectional community study. Mild cases and those with no visually significant complaints might not visit a tertiary hospital. So, they might be missed. Mild cases and those with no visually significant complaints might not visit a tertiary hospital. So, they might be missed. Conclusion Our study highlights key demographic pattern, potential risk factors, and other eye disease co-presented with SDC, offering valuable insights as the first investigation of its kind in Ethiopia. We recommend conducting further community-based studies with larger sample sizes to better understand the public health significance of SDC and to guide potential preventive measures within the Ethiopia context.