A radiocarbon bomb pulse model for estimating the age of North Atlantic cetaceans Authors: Eva Garde, Susanne Ditlevsen, Jesper Olsen, Mads Peter Heide-Jørgensen Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractThe tusk of the male narwhal is a prolonged canine tooth, reaching a size of up to 3 m in length. The tusk erupts through the young narwhal’s upper left lip and, over time, develops into an elongated structure composed of dentine growth layers with an outer coating of cementum. In this study, we utilized bomb radiocarbon (14C) to estimate the ages of three narwhal tusks, which allowed us to validate the assumption that one growth layer is deposited annually in narwhal tusks. We used radiocarbon values from samples collected from the annual growth layers along the lengths of the erupted tusks and from the tip and base of embedded teeth, together with published radiocarbon data from three North Atlantic whale species, for the purpose of building a model of the incorporation of bomb radiocarbon in marine mammal tissues. The results obtained contribute significantly to our understanding of narwhal growth and longevity, enhancing our comprehension of isotope flow in the Arctic marine environment and their incorporation into the living tissue of a marine top predator. The bomb radiocarbon model can serve as a valuable reference chronology for dating museum or field specimens of narwhals and other North Atlantic marine animals.Keywords: bomb radiocarbon, isotope, age estimation, narwhal, marine mammal, Arctic Introduction Accurate age estimation techniques are vital for determining key biological parameters, including age at sexual maturity, first reproduction, age structures and life expectancy [1]. These parameters play a pivotal role in population dynamic models of marine mammals, aiding the assessment of sustainable resource utilization and providing guidance on sustainable removals [2]. In Greenland, Inuit hunters rely on narwhals (Monodon monoceros) for meat, dog food and tusks for crafts [3]. Narwhal skin, or ‘mattak’, holds cultural and commercial value, making hunting a key income source and narwhal population management a contentious issue [4,5]. This emphasizes the need to develop and validate narwhal age estimation methods. Age determination of odontocete (toothed) whales traditionally involves counting of dentine growth layer groups (GLGs) consisting of an opaque and a translucent layer deposited annually [6–8]. The erupted tusk of the male narwhal is composed of dentine GLGs with an exterior coating of cementum, and it likely continues to grow throughout the male narwhal’s life. The layers are considered to be deposited annually [9], a phenomenon observed in the teeth of other marine mammals [10,11], including the narwhal’s closest relative, the beluga whale (Delphinapterus leucas; [12]), although not yet directly proven for narwhals. Besides providing a mean of estimating age, the GLGs also capture materials such as trace elements and isotopes in the dentine growth layers, reflecting the narwhal’s diet and habitat [13,14]. Given that narwhals are long-lived creatures (greater than 80 years; [15]), the tusk effectively serves as a chronological time series archive of information about the narwhal and its environment throughout its lifetime [16]. In female narwhals, a tusk rarely erupts; instead, they possess two small embedded teeth in the upper jaw, which, similarly to the erupted tusk, store valuable information [17]. Males possess one erupted tusk and one embedded tooth. The embedded teeth cease growing at some point in the life of a narwhal, and they, therefore, only provide a partial chronology of the narwhal’s life [9]. Another well-established and dependable method used in the validation of age determination techniques of marine organisms is ‘bomb’ radiocarbon dating [18–20]. In hunted populations of cetaceans, where biological material can be sampled through collaborations with local hunters, the method has been used for age validation of beluga whales using teeth [12], humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) using eye lenses [21] and, recently, fin whales (Balaenoptera physalus) using earplugs [22]. The method represents one of the most robust age-validation approaches available for long-lived organisms that develop growth bands [23]. The sharp increase in atmospheric radiocarbon content resulting from nuclear testing in the mid- to late-1950s, known as the ‘bomb pulse’, rapidly permeated food webs worldwide, including marine systems in the North Atlantic and Arctic Oceans. This isotopic shift was incorporated into all organisms growing during that time, and 14C has since then been applied as a chemical baseline marker [24]. In this study, we investigated the use of bomb radiocarbon as a marker incorporated into discrete growth layers of three narwhal tusks to determine if the individual narwhals were born before or after the initial occurrence of the bomb pulse in the North Atlantic in 1958 [18]. We used the isotopes of δ13C and δ15N to demonstrate that the carbon source is of dietary origin and that the prenatal dentine isotopically can be distinguished from the postnatal dentine in the tusks and embedded teeth. Based on our findings, we re-evaluate previously published age estimates of the three tusks and investigate the assumption that one dentine growth layer forms annually in narwhal tusks. Using the radiocarbon data from the individual growth layers sampled along the length of the erupted narwhal tusks and from the tip and base of embedded teeth along with published radiocarbon values from three additional whale species, we establish a bomb radiocarbon model for Arctic and North Atlantic marine mammals for future dating purposes. Material and methods Sample collection and temporal timelines in tusks and teeth Narwhal tusks (n = 3; males) and embedded teeth (n = 8; six females and two males) were obtained from the Inuit hunt of narwhals in Northwest Greenland in collaboration with local hunters (figure 1a–c). Collection years were spanning from 1984 to 2008, and the year of death was recorded for all specimens (table 1). The three tusks had previously been sectioned and age estimated by counting of GLGs (table 1 and figure 1c; [26]). Two of the three tusks (no. 4976 and no. 956) were, based on length and number of GLGs, assumed to belong to narwhals born prior to the onset of the bomb pulse in the North Atlantic. The eight teeth were sourced from narwhals with known year of death post the bomb pulse. They were assumed to have been born before the bomb pulse, which was assessed based on body measurements (n = 7), and from age estimates obtained from the counting of GLGs in this study (n = 8) and/or from published age estimates using the aspartic acid racemization technique (AAR; n = 4; table 1; [25]). Sampling sites in Greenland and examples of an erupted tusk and an embedded tooth used in this study. (a) Map of Greenland showing sampling sites and number of specimens collected. (b) Illustration of a male narwhal with an erupted tusk and a female with no tusk. (c) Tip and base of tusk no. 4076; sectioned embedded tooth no. 1269; piece of sectioned tusk no. 4076, arrow pointing at growth layers. Table 1. Narwhal tusks and teeth used in this study with information on specimen ID, year of death, sampling site (IB: Inglefield Bredning; NI: Niaqornat; UU: Uummannaq), sex of the whale, specimen type, length (cm) and, if the neonatal line was present, body length (cm) of the whale, number of 14C samples collected, number of growth layers estimated and the aspartic acid racemization ages (AAR) in years [25].specimen IDyear of deathsampling site in Greenlandsexspecimenneonatal line presentlength of specimen (cm)body length (cm)14C samples (n)growth layers (n)AAR ages (years; ± s.e.)40762008IBMtusk—2554911760a—9562010NIMtusk—2484401070a—9532008NIMtusk(+)201471326—13361985IBMtooth+230450220—13381985IBMtooth+197490216—5601993UUFtooth+19.341021067.9 (4.9)5371993UUFtooth+17.540021147.8 (3.6)5621993UUFtooth+20.2425210101.0 (7.2)5591993UUFtooth+17.039021063.5 (4.6)12691984IBFtooth+20.4—210—12291984IBFtooth+19.933029— a Estimated number of growth layers missing in the tip: no. 4076, n = 10; no. 956, n = 1−3 [26]. Narwhal tusks and teeth used in this study with information on specimen ID, year of death, sampling site (IB: Inglefield Bredning; NI: Niaqornat; UU: Uummannaq), sex of the whale, specimen type, length (cm) and, if the neonatal line was present, body length (cm) of the whale, number of 14C samples collected, number of growth layers estimated and the aspartic acid racemization ages (AAR) in years [25]. Estimated number of growth layers missing in the tip: no. 4076, n = 10; no. 956, n = 1−3 [26]. The tusks and teeth increments represent periods in time. Where the very tip represents the oldest part, formed during the fetal stage and distinguished by the presence of the neonatal line [9], thus portraying the unborn animal, the base is the most recently deposited part, representing the older narwhal (figure 1c). When the tip is worn or broken off the tusk [27], the first available growth layer will represent the postnatal or young narwhal. The age represented by this first layer depends on the number of layers that are missing. For tusks no. 4076 and no. 956, the tip was broken off, and the neonatal line was not present. For tusk no. 953, the tip was worn but complete, and it was uncertain if the neonatal line was present (table 1). The growth layers from tip to base represent a chronological timeline from the year of birth to the year the last growth layer was formed. Sample preparation and isotope analyses Dentine powder samples were obtained by drilling into the individual GLGs of the erupted tusks and the tip and base of the embedded teeth for radiocarbon (14C; n = 46) and stable isotope (δ13C and δ15N; n = 36) analyses using a Foredom K.1030 Portable Rotary Micromotor Kit Portable (table 2). The growth layers at the base of the embedded teeth were very narrow. To obtain sufficient material, these samples cover a few GLGs, representing the final years of the narwhal’s life or the last years before tooth growth cessation. Table 2. Estimated tusk and embedded tooth chronologies and measured stable isotope values for the narwhals. The table includes information on specimen ID, the estimated chronology of sampled growth layers and the year when the growth layer was deposited, the 14C (pMC), δ13C (‰) and δ15N (‰) values with associated standard deviations ( ± s.d.) and the laboratory ID.specimen IDgrowth layeryear of growth layer deposition14C (pMC)δ13C (‰)δ15N (‰)laboratory ID4076a11196098.28 ± 0.51———4076a121961100.69 ± 0.38———4076a11196099.55 ± 0.40———4076a141963100.92 ± 0.38———4076a221971103.31 ± 0.49———4076a331982104.26 ± 0.39———4076a481997102.36 ± 0.39———4076b11196099.03 ± 0.34−14.5 ± 0.217.5 ± 0.4AAR-319744076b12196199.96 ± 0.30−14.9 ± 0.217.6 ± 0.4AAR-319754076b131962100.52 ± 0.28−14.5 ± 0.217.2 ± 0.2AAR-319764076b17196699.84 ± 0.27−14.7 ± 0.217.6 ± 0.4AAR-319774076b201969101.21 ± 0.31−14.2 ± 0.218.0 ± 0.4AAR-319784076b211970101.02 ± 0.32−13.9 ± 0.218.8 ± 0.2AAR-319794076b221971101.78 ± 0.29−13.7 ± 0.218.1 ± 0.4AAR-319804076b321981103.62 ± 0.31−13.7 ± 0.218.7 ± 0.4AAR-319814076b441993103.60 ± 0.29−13.8 ± 0.219.5 ± 0.4AAR-319824076b542003103.15 ± 0.34−13.9 ± 0.219.3 ± 0.4AAR-31983956b1195894.87 ± 0.26−14.2 ± 0.217.4 ± 0.4AAR-31984956b2195996.84 ± 0.28−14.1 ± 0.217.2 ± 0.2AAR-31985956b3196098.33 ± 0.28−14.2 ± 0.216.8 ± 0.4AAR-31986956b51962100.21 ± 0.27−14.2 ± 0.216.6 ± 0.4AAR-31987956b71964100.54 ± 0.28−14.3 ± 0.216.4 ± 0.4AAR-31988956b9196698.61 ± 0.31−14.0 ± 0.217.0 ± 0.4AAR-31989956b121969100.29 ± 0.31−14.4 ± 0.216.8 ± 0.4AAR-31990956b231980102.91 ± 0.27−14.2 ± 0.216.8 ± 0.4AAR-31991956b351992103.69 ± 0.29−14.1 ± 0.218.6 ± 0.2AAR-31992956b452002103.37 ± 0.29−14.5 ± 0.217.6 ± 0.4AAR-31993953a11982106.01 ± 0.40———953a61987105.49 ± 0.40———953a161997103.84 ± 0.44———1269_tipa0195895.57 ± 0.30−14.5 ± 0.221.0 ± 0.1AAR-356211269_basea101968101.28 ± 0.36−14.9 ± 0.217.4 ± 0.1AAR-356221229_tipa01975101.31 ± 0.38−14.7 ± 0.219.8 ± 0.1AAR-356231229_basea91984103.16 ± 0.34−14.7 ± 0.117.6 ± 0.1AAR-356241336_tipa0193892.65 ± 0.39−14.8 ± 0.220.1 ± 0.1AAR-356251336_basea20195894.12 ± 0.38−14.6 ± 0.217.7 ± 0.1AAR-356261338_tipa0194292.68 ± 0.33−14.0 ± 0.220.3 ± 0.1AAR-356271338_basea16195894.32 ± 0.57−14.5 ± 0.217.8 ± 0.1AAR-35628560_tipa0192592.66 ± 0.36−14.7 ± 0.120.7 ± 0.1AAR-35629560_basea10193591.81 ± 0.38−14.8 ± 0.218.4 ± 0.1AAR-35630537_tipa0194592.47 ± 0.30−15.3 ± 0.220.0 ± 0.1AAR-35631537_basea11195693.26 ± 0.36−14.3 ± 0.218.3 ± 0.1AAR-35632562_tipa0189293.27 ± 0.35−14.4 ± 0.220.5 ± 0.1AAR-35633562_basea10190292.92 ± 0.34−14.1 ± 0.218.3 ± 0.1AAR-35634559_tipa0193093.36 ± 0.32−14.4 ± 0.220.3 ± 0.1AAR-35635559_basea10194093.20 ± 0.35−14.4 ± 0.117.9 ± 0.1AAR-35636 a Center for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry, Lawrence Liverpool National Laboratory, USA (n = 10). b The Aarhus AMS Centre, Aarhus University, Denmark (n = 36). Estimated tusk and embedded tooth chronologies and measured stable isotope values for the narwhals. The table includes information on specimen ID, the estimated chronology of sampled growth layers and the year when the growth layer was deposited, the 14C (pMC), δ13C (‰) and δ15N (‰) values with associated standard deviations ( ± s.d.) and the laboratory ID. Center for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry, Lawrence Liverpool National Laboratory, USA (n = 10). The Aarhus AMS Centre, Aarhus University, Denmark (n = 36). The samples were analysed at the Aarhus AMS Centre (AARAMS, n = 36) and the Center for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (n = 10). Collagen was extracted using the modified Longin procedure with ultrafiltration [28–30]. The samples were dissolved in hydrochloric acid at 4°C for several days. The acid was renewed regularly until the mineral fraction was removed completely. Humic substances were removed using 0.2 M NaOH at 4°C, with frequent changes of the NaOH, each step lasting several hours, until the solution stayed clear. The samples were subsequently rinsed with 0.01 M HCl and gelatinized in 0.01 M HCl at 58°C for 3−4 days. The collagen was subsequently converted to CO2 by combustion in sealed evacuated quartz tubes with 200 mg CuO. The CO2 was reduced to graphite by the H2 reduction method using an iron catalyst and MgClO4 to remove the water [31,32]. The samples were 14C dated using the HVE 1 MV tandetron accelerator AMS system at AARAMS [33]. 14C dates are reported as per cent modern carbon (pMC) normalized to −25‰ according to the international convention using the 13C/12C ratios from the AMS analysis [34]. Stable isotopes δ13C and δ15N were measured on the extracted collagen using a continuous-flow IsoPrime IRMS coupled to an Elementar PyroCube elemental analyser at AARAMS. An in-house standard Gel-A was used as primary standard, yielding ± 0.2‰ and ± 0.3‰ for carbon and nitrogen analysis, respectively. Further, secondary in-house and international standards were used to check the normalization to the VPDB and AIR scale. Samples from the tip, or the first available growth layer in the absence of the tip, were used as radiocarbon reference points to infer if the narwhal was born prior to or after the onset of the bomb pulse in 1958. Dentine formed before the onset of the bomb pulse in the North Atlantic would contain only natural, low-level 14C concentrations of about 95 pMC; during the transition period, intermediate and increasing 14C levels; or after elevated levels above 95 pMC [23]. Thus, we used a pMC value of 95 to serve as the threshold for distinguishing growth layers formed prior to (less than 95 pMC) or after (greater than 95 pMC) the bomb pulse, as applied in the case of the Greenland shark (Somniosus microcephalus) [20]. To confirm our narwhal age chronologies, we compared the 14C levels in narwhal dentine with published 14C reference chronologies from the same region and from a surface ocean mixed-layer bomb pulse model [18,20,35]. Bomb radiocarbon model We developed a model reflecting bomb radiocarbon in Arctic and North Atlantic marine mammals using data from this study (table 2) and integrating published 14C values from beluga whales [12], humpback whales [21] and fin whales [22]. To our knowledge, this is the only published data on incremental and temporal radiocarbon deposition for North Atlantic cetaceans covering the bomb pulse period. A model for the time evolution of 14C in whale tissue around the bomb pulse provides a tool for dating measurements from other individuals and for conducting sanity checks on different dating methods. To describe the time-varying pMC values caused by the bomb pulse, we developed a five-parameter model relating pMC to year via a function as follows: This model assumes that before the bomb pulse, the pMC level is approximately equal to a. This is probably not entirely true; however, there are few data points before the bomb pulse, and no trend was detected in the data. The bomb pulse causes the pMC level to rise at a speed determined by the time parameter d1. We expect that after reaching a peak some years after the bomb pulse, the surface 14C level will decrease due to mixing with the 14C depleted deep ocean, determined by the time parameter d2, at a much slower speed than the rise, so that d2≫d1. Parameter c is the year at which the pMC takes the value a+b/2 and is expected to lie a few years after the increasing surface ocean 14C levels caused by the atmospheric nuclear bomb tests. The height of the peak is determined by b and the timescale separation. It takes the value a+b(d1/d2)(d2/d1-1)1-d1/d2 and occurs in the year c+d1log(d2/d1-1). Parameters were estimated with weighted nonlinear least squares (nls in R v. 4.2.1). Pointwise 95% confidence interval around the regression line was calculated from 1000 bootstrap samples based on residuals (boot within package boot 1.3–28 in R). An 80% prediction interval was constructed by the 10% and 90% quantiles from 1000 simulated samples from the fitted model. To test the accuracy of the model, we conducted an out-of-sample analysis by leave-one-out cross-validation (see electronic supplementary materials for details). Results and discussion Carbon and protein sources We used the stable isotopes δ13C and δ15N to evaluate the isotope source in the dentine samples. Depleted 13C and enriched 15N levels are indicative of metabolic and dietary carbon and signify a high trophic level, a characteristic shown in various marine mammals [12,14,36–38]. We found that the narwhal tusks and embedded teeth showed a depletion in 13C, with δ13C values ranging from −13.7‰ to −15.3‰. The average δ13C value was −14.4‰ (n = 36, table 2; electronic supplementary material, figure S2), which closely aligns with the average δ13C value of −14.3‰ reported by Stewart et al. [12] for beluga teeth. These depleted values demonstrate that the carbon source is of dietary origin. Prenatal dentine of narwhals can be distinguished from postnatal dentine by the δ15N level [38]. Zhao et al. [38, fig. 3] found that δ15N was considerably higher in the prenatal dentine of narwhals, compared to postnatal dentine, suggesting that the mother’s protein sources support fetal growth. Elevated δ15N levels were similarly observed at the prenatal tip of the embedded narwhal teeth (average: 20.3‰) compared to the postnatal base (average: 17.9‰, table 2; electronic supplementary material, figure S2). We propose that this feature can be used to assess the presence of prenatal dentine in cases where the presence of the neonatal line is uncertain. The tusks of no. 956 and no. 4076 were incomplete, lacking the neonatal line and growth layers at the tip, and it was previously estimated that 1−3 and 10 GLGs were missing, respectively (table 1; [26]). This observation is further supported by δ15N values from the first available layer at the tip of 17.4‰ ± 0.4 s.d. and 17.5‰ ± 0.4 s.d., respectively, which fall within the same range as the postnatal δ15N values of the eight embedded teeth (table 2; electronic supplementary material, figure S2). The δ15N levels exhibited a temporal increasing trend in both no. 956 and no. 4076, perhaps due to an age-related dietary shift. However, further research is needed to better understand individual and age-related foraging behaviours in relation to isotope profiles. No stable isotope values were generated for tusk no. 953. Age estimation of the three tusks from radiocarbon A 14C value of 94.87 ± 0.26 pMC from the first available growth layer from tusk no. 956 indicated that its deposition happened just around the time of the occurrence of the bomb pulse in the North Atlantic, using the 95 pMC criteria. Subsequent growth layers from no. 956 displayed an abrupt increase in 14C values, followed by a levelling of (figure 2; electronic supplementary material, figure S1). This sharp rise in 14C values aligns with the patterns observed in the North Atlantic reference chronologies from mid-1950s to the start of 1960s, followed by a decrease in 14C pMC from approximately 1970 and onward [18]. Based on this, we conclude that the first available layer of tusk no. 956 was formed in 1958, the first year when the bomb pulse was registered in other chronologies from the North Atlantic [18]. Accounting for 1−3 missing layers in the tip, narwhal no. 956 had a maximum age of 55 years, when it died in 2010. Radiocarbon values (pMC) against year for narwhals (n = 46, yellow diamonds, this study), belugas (n = 68, green squares, [26]), humpback whales (n = 12, blue triangles, [21]) and fin whales (n = 96, purple circles, [22]). The dark red line is the model fitted to radiocarbon values from all four whale species. The dark-shaded area shows the 95% confidence intervals, and the light-shaded area indicates the 80% prediction intervals. The year of maximum radiocarbon is estimated to 1988 with a pMC value of 103.5. The solid black line shows a modelled surface ocean mixed-layer bomb pulse for comparison [18,35]. The dotted lines mark the bomb pulse onset in 1958 and the 95 pMC threshold, distinguishing growth layers deposited before (less than 95 pMC) or after (greater than 95 pMC) the bomb pulse. The 14C values from 17 growth layers of tusk no. 4076 ranged from 98.28 ± 0.51 to 104.26 ± 0.39 pMC (table 2), exhibiting a sudden rise followed by stabilizing, as also observed for tusk no. 956 (figure 2; electronic supplementary material, figure S1). Given the absence of 10 GLGs from the tip [26], GLG 11 was the first available to be sampled, showing a 14C value of 98.28 ± 0.51 pMC. A similar pMC value for narwhal no. 956 was found in the year 1960 (98.33 ± 0.28; table 2). If we assume that narwhal tusks display similar 14C values at specific years in time and take into account the 10 missing GLGs, narwhal no. 4076 would have been born around 1950. When it died in 2008, it was then approximately 58 years. Narwhals no. 4076 and no. 956 were both large, adult males with extensive tusks (table 1), and we, therefore, anticipate similar ages, as also suggested by the radiocarbon values. Comparison of the 14C ages estimated in this study with ages based on the number of GLGs, assuming deposition of one GLG-yr, reported in a previous study [26], show good agreement for no. 4076 (58 versus 60 years, respectively), whereas the age based on number of GLGs for no. 956 seems to have been overestimated (55 versus 70, respectively). It is important to note that GLGs in tusks from older animals are often more challenging to discern and count due to compact layering, accessory layers, wear of the tusks and frequently broken tips [28,38,39]. Also, there is increased uncertainty in the GLG counts in the absence of the neonatal line, which is essential for reliable age estimates based on GLG counts [3]. We consider the 14C age of 55 years for no. 956 as more accurate than the previous estimate derived from the number of GLGs. For no. 953, the elevated but declining 14C values align with the reported number of GLGs (n = 26, [26]) and a birth year of 1982, assuming an annual deposition rate, when compared with reference chronologies. Model of bomb radiocarbon in North Atlantic whales We fitted the model to the data from the narwhals, belugas and fin whales separately, as well as for all four species combined (table 3 and figure 2). The data from narwhals did not converge, and they were instead fitted to a sigmoidal model with no decay after the bomb pulse. For humpback whales, only measurements after the bomb were available, but these data had a marginal impact on the overall model estimation (results not shown). The leave-one-out age prediction errors for individuals with at least one pMC value between 95 pMC and the max fitted value had a mean of 0.72 years, a median of 1.56 years and a standard error of 7.01 years. The radiocarbon model presented in this study, thus, offers a promising tool for dating whale samples from across the North Atlantic, utilizing the parameters outlined in table 3 (for details, see electronic supplementary material, table S1). Table 3. Model estimates for narwhal, beluga and fin whale and all whale species combined.parameterspeciesestimateloweruppera, initial level before bomb pulsenarwhal92.691.693.5a, initial level before bomb pulsefin whale92.992.393.5a, initial level before bomb pulsebeluga91.189.293.0a, initial level before bomb pulseall92.291.593.0b, asymptotic level after bomb (in four-parameter model, compare to b-a in five-parameter model)narwhal103.3102.6104.1b, max increment during bomb pulsefin whale11.08.813.1b, max increment during bomb pulsebeluga25.414.436.4b, max increment during bomb pulseall12.910.215.6c, approximate year at half rise of bomb pulseanarwhal196019591962c, approximate year at half rise of bomb pulseafin whale196419621966c, approximate year at half rise of bomb pulseaBeluga198319652001c, approximate year at half rise of bomb pulseaall196519621968d1, time parameter of bomb pulsenarwhal4.52.86.2d1, time parameter of bomb pulsefin whale5.03.56.4d1, time parameter of bomb pulsebeluga7.85.410.2d1, time parameter of bomb pulseall6.44.88.2d2, time parameter of slow decay after bomb pulsenarwhal———d2, time parameter of slow decay after bomb pulsefin whale339.6−231.3910.6d2, time parameter of slow decay after bomb pulsebeluga21.9−10.854.5d2, time parameter of slow decay after bomb pulseall218.2−47.0483.4 a Year where pMC = a + b/2. Model estimates for narwhal, beluga and fin whale and all whale species combined. Year where pMC = a + b/2. The initial appearance of bomb radiocarbon in different biological materials from our four whale species reflects the patterns detected in published marine reference chronologies worldwide and across a variety of species and tissues [18,20–22,26]. Since the carbon source for the four whale species is derived from their diet (e.g. fish and crustaceans), feeding at higher trophic levels or on long-lived prey would potentially slow the rate of increase in the bomb radiocarbon signal, extending its presence over a longer period [12]. Stewart et al. [12] concluded that this effect was observed in the belugas, which feed at several trophic levels. In belugas, the radiocarbon signal initially appeared at the expected year, but the subsequent incorporation extended beyond the 1970s into the 1980s. This trend was not observed in the other whale species, including narwhals, which also occasionally feed on long-lived species, e.g. Greenland halibut (Reinhardtius hippoglossoides; table 3 and figure 2; electronic supplementary material, figure S1). However, age estimation in belugas may be more prone to errors due to the difficulty in precisely enumerating GLGs, which in turn affects the interpretation of bomb pulse trajectory [7]. Conclusion This study provides compelling evidence that narwhal dentine growth layers serve as annual archives with information about the individual’s habitat. This information can be extracted and used as the basis for constructing chronological time series for an Arctic marine mammal and its ecosystems. Analysis of narwhal tusks, embedded teeth or similar biological incremental materials that preserve chronological records of biogeochemical data holds the potential to yield profound insights into fundamental questions related to age, life history, habitat, environmental fluctuations and climate change. The adoption of new methods and innovative technologies for analysing and interpreting data on 14C and stable isotopes represents a promising avenue for delving into the past and gaining a deeper understanding of the present. Furthermore, the radiocarbon model established in this study holds valuable utility, serving as a reference for dating carbon-based samples throughout the entire North Atlantic region. This resource becomes particularly significant when considering archived collections in museums, enhancing our capacity to uncover historical insights, or for obtaining age structures and other age-dependent parameters used in population modelling and management of hunted species. Acknowledgements Thanks to the Greenlandic hunters for providing samples from their narwhal hunt and to the funds for supporting our research. Also, thanks to Tom A. Brown and D. Erle Nelson for providing some of the 14C data used in this study and to the four referees whose comments improved the manuscript. Contributor Information Eva Garde, Email: evga@ghsdk.dk. Susanne Ditlevsen, Email: susanne@math.ku.dk. Jesper Olsen, Email: jesper.olsen@phys.au.dk. Mads Peter Heide-Jørgensen, Email: mhj@ghsdk.dk. Ethics The research presented in this article has been done in accordance with the institutional and national laws and protocols for animal welfare that are applicable in the jurisdictions where the work was conducted. Data accessibility Information on the narwhal specimens and raw data used in this study is enclosed in tables 1 and 2. Model equations are shown in the manuscript and the electronic supplementary material, and model parameters are listed in table 3. Importation of narwhal specimens into Denmark was authorized by CITES permits IM 0721-199/08, IM 0721-200/08 and DK-2021-0067486-01. The specimens are currently stored at the GINR in Copenhagen, Denmark. For information and access to specimens, contact lead author Senior Scientist Eva Garde. Supplementary material is available online [40]. Declaration of AI use We have not used AI-assisted technologies in creating this article. Authors’ contributions E.G.: conceptualization, data curation, formal analysis, funding acquisition, investigation, methodology, project administration, writing—original draft; S.D.: formal analysis, methodology, writing—original draft; J.O.: formal analysis, methodology, writing—original draft; M.P.H.-J.: funding acquisition, resources, writing—review and editing. All authors gave final approval for publication and agreed to be held accountable for the work performed therein. Conflict of interest declaration We declare we have no competing interests. Funding This study was funded by the Greenland Research Council, the Independent Research Fund Denmark (grant no. 0135-00228B), and NordForsk (grant no. 105053). S.D. was funded by Novo Nordisk Foundation (grant no. NNF20OC0062958). References Associated Data Data Availability Statement Information on the narwhal specimens and raw data used in this study is enclosed in tables 1 and 2. Model equations are shown in the manuscript and the electronic supplementary material, and model parameters are listed in table 3. Importation of narwhal specimens into Denmark was authorized by CITES permits IM 0721-199/08, IM 0721-200/08 and DK-2021-0067486-01. The specimens are currently stored at the GINR in Copenhagen, Denmark. For information and access to specimens, contact lead author Senior Scientist Eva Garde. Supplementary material is available online [40].