An Exploratory Study: Can Native T1 Mapping Differentiate Sarcoma from Benign Soft Tissue Tumors at 1.5 T and 3 T? Authors: Laura Dupont, Bénédicte M A Delattre, Marta Sans Merce, Pierre Alexandre Poletti, Sana Boudabbous, Dania Cioni, Brigitta G Baumert Published: 2024 ABSTRACT Simple SummaryThis study explored whether T1 relaxation time, a quantitative measurement taken during MRI scans that reflects tissue properties, can help differentiate between sarcomas and benign tumors in soft tissues. MRI scans of patients who had confirmed cases of either sarcomas or benign tumors and had not received prior treatment were analyzed. T1 values in both the tumors and surrounding healthy tissue were acquired with 1.5 T and 3 T MRI scanners. The results showed that sarcomas tended to have higher T1 values than benign tumors, although this difference was not always statistically significant. However, T1 values were notably lower in healthy tissues compared to sarcomas, especially at 3 T. While the study suggests that T1 mapping might help in distinguishing sarcomas from benign tumors, more standardized protocols and further research are needed to improve the accuracy of this technique.Keywords: T1 mapping, sarcoma, benign tumor, magnetic resonance imaging, 1.5 T, 3 T, differential diagnosis 1. Introduction Soft-tissue sarcomas are rare cancers typically presenting as painless, enlarging masses in nearly all areas of the body. Diagnosis involves advanced imaging and confirmation through biopsy. The primary treatment is surgery, possibly supplemented by radiation therapy or chemotherapy. However, the treatment lacks a standardized protocol, and management depends on different factors such as tumor size, grade, and patient condition. The prognosis for low-grade sarcoma is excellent (90% 5-year survival rate), while it is more reserved for high-grade sarcoma (5-year survival rate of 50–70%). Therefore, accurate and early diagnosis is crucial [1]. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a cornerstone in the characterization and evaluation of soft tissue tumors [2,3,4], as well as in the early screening of sarcomas [5,6]. Diffusion-weighted imaging (DWI) and perfusion and dynamic contrast-enhanced (DCE) MRI have been utilized to differentiate benign from malignant tumors and to predict sarcoma grading [6,7,8], as well as response to treatment [9,10,11]. DCE MRI sequences assess the perfusion of sarcomas, and changes in sarcoma perfusion parameters have been correlated with genetic subtypes, as well as with the degree and grade of necrosis [12]. These findings can be compared with DWI results where advanced techniques such as intravoxel incoherent motion (IVIM) and diffusion kurtosis imaging (DKI) were found to be associated with histopathological findings [13,14,15]. However, perfusion analysis of this heterogeneous group of rare tumors remains challenging [16,17,18,19]. Native T1 mapping is employed to convert signal intensity measurements into contrast agent concentration curves within tissues. T1, also called the longitudinal relaxation time, is measured in milliseconds (ms) and reflects intrinsic properties of tissues. T1 relaxation time has been shown to be of interest in detecting and characterizing tumors in various organs. For example, in cardiac imaging, T1 was found to be elevated in fibrotic tissues, correlating directly with biopsy-proven fibrosis [20]. In brain tumors, Piper et al. demonstrated that T1 was significantly higher in low-grade gliomas compared to meningiomas [21]. In breast imaging, high-grade invasive ductal carcinomas exhibited longer T1 relaxation times than low-grade tumors [22]. Additionally, T1 mapping has been successfully applied to differentiate phyllodes tumors from fibroadenomas in the breast, with a sensitivity of 0.89 and 1, respectively, as phyllodes tumors demonstrate longer T1 relaxation times [23]. T1 mapping has also been used to distinguish between mucinous and non-mucinous rectal adenocarcinomas [24] and between benign prostate tissue and prostate carcinoma [25]. Furthermore, although few cases concerning musculoskeletal applications have been published, Baidya et al. demonstrated that T1 could serve as a marker of chemotherapy response in osteosarcomas [26]. It is important to note that T1 relaxation time can vary according to different parameters, most notably magnetic field strength. For musculoskeletal tumors, T1 has been shown to increase by 20% at 3 T compared to 1.5 T [27]. Given the ability of T1 mapping to differentiate malignant tumors from benign tissues in various organs, investigating whether T1 values could distinguish benign soft tissue tumors from sarcomas would be highly valuable. The aim of our study was to determine whether native T1 relaxation time could be used to differentiate histologically proven sarcomas from benign soft-tissue tumors using appropriate DCE protocols. 2. Materials and Methods 2.1. Patient Inclusion Criteria A retrospective survey was conducted to select appropriate cases for the study. The database of all patients referred to the multidisciplinary sarcoma board was examined. Histological characterization of the lesion was required to be available. Only MRI examinations conducted prior to any biopsy, treatment, or surgery were included. Furthermore, MRI acquisitions needed to contain a native T1 map. This retrospective study was approved by the local institutional review board and conducted in accordance with the principles of the Helsinki Declaration. Informed consent from patients was waived due to the retrospective nature of the study. 2.2. MRI Protocol Regarding the MRI systems, 1.5 T and 3 T scanners from two different vendors (Philips, Best, Netherlands, and Siemens, Erlangen, Germany) were employed. The MRI protocol designed for all patients included pre- and post-injection sequences to enhance the visualization and characterization of the lesion. Prior to injection, T1-weighted (T1w) turbo spin echo (TSE) sequences and T2-weighted (T2w) TSE sequences with fat suppression (preferably using Short TI-Inversion Recovery (STIR)) or proton-density-weighted TSE with fat suppression were performed in one or two anatomical planes. A T1 map was acquired using a three-dimensional (3D) spoiled gradient echo sequence with fat saturation and varying flip angles (4° and 8°). The same sequence with a flip angle of 10° was utilized during contrast injection to observe wash-in and wash-out curves, lasting for 5 min, with the dynamic scan time maintained below 15 s. Following contrast injection, one or two anatomical planes were acquired using T1w TSE sequences with fat suppression. Each sequence was adapted to the area of interest. Table 1 summarizes the parameters of the T1 mapping sequence. Table 1Details of sequence parameters for T1 maps of patients.Patient CategoryVoxel Reconstruction SizeAcquisition Time per Flip AngleFlip Angle (°)TE/TR (ms)Number of SlicesMagnetic Field Strength (T)MRI SystemS1Sarcoma0.35 × 0.35 × 3 mm16 s4/83.6/7.4 193PhilipsS2Sarcoma1.14 × 1.14 × 3 mm4 s4/81.4/3.7201.5SiemensS3Sarcoma0.9 × 0.9 × 3.5 mm12 s4/82/4.4401.5SiemensS4Sarcoma1.1 × 1.1 × 4 mm10 s4/81.9/4.2401.5SiemensS5Sarcoma 1.6 × 1.6 × 3.5 mm11 s4/81.6/4.7403SiemensS6Sarcoma1.3 × 1.3 × 3 mm11 s4/81.6/4.7363SiemensS7Sarcoma0.75 × 0.75 × 4 mm13 s4/81.8/5.3363SiemensS8Sarcoma1.8 × 1.8 × 3 mm13 s4/81.5/4.9363SiemensS9Sarcoma0.35 × 0.35 × 3 mm17 s4/83.7/7.5683PhilipsS10Sarcoma1.1 × 1.1 × 3 mm13 s4/81.7/4.6363SiemensS11Sarcoma0.9 × 0.9 × 3.5 mm8 s4/81.9/4.3401.5SiemensS12Sarcoma0.73 × 0.73 × 3 mm18 s4/83.4/6.9443PhilipsS13Sarcoma0.8 × 0.8 × 3.4 mm17 s4/83.6/7.4443PhilipsS14Sarcoma1.1 × 1.1 × 3 mm13 s4/81.7/4.6363SiemensS15Sarcoma0.78 × 0.78 × 3 mm12 s4/81.6/3.3251.5PhilipsS16Sarcoma0.89 × 0.89 × 3.5 mm8 s4/82.0/4.3401.5SiemensT1Benign tumor1.5 × 1.5 × 4 mm13 s4/81.8/4.2641.5SiemensT2Benign tumor1.15 × 1.15 × 3 mm3.5 s4/81.4/3.7201.5SiemensT3Benign tumor1.0 × 1.0 × 4 mm8 s4/81.4/3.7361.5SiemensT4Benign tumor1.2 × 1.2 × 4 mm7 s4/81.4/3.7801.5SiemensT5Benign tumor0.8 × 0.8 × 3.4 mm17 s4/83.4/7.0443PhilipsT6Benign tumor0.63 × 0.63 × 3 mm8 s4/81.9/5.4183SiemensT7Benign tumor0.9 × 0.9 × 3.5 mm8 s4/82.0/4.3401.5SiemensT8Benign tumor1.1 × 1.1 × 4 mm9.8 s4/81.9/4.2 401.5SiemensT9Benign tumor1.1 × 1.1 × 4 mm13 s4/81.9/4.2 641.5SiemensMRI = magnetic resonance imaging; TE = echo time; TR = repetition time. Details of sequence parameters for T1 maps of patients. MRI = magnetic resonance imaging; TE = echo time; TR = repetition time. 2.3. Image Analysis On the Philips systems, native images from the T1-weighted 3D spoiled gradient echo sequence with fat saturation and two flip angles were transferred via a secured internal node to the Olea software SP28 (Olea, La Ciotat, France), where T1 maps were generated using the relaxometry module. On the Siemens system, the T1 map was generated online from the console. The T1 mapping images were transmitted to our picture archiving and communication system (PACS) for archiving. The Osirix DICOM viewer (Bernex, Switzerland) was utilized to perform measurements on the T1 maps. Regions of interest (ROIs) were delineated on the T1 maps within the lesion, encompassing the entire lesion volume. For healthy muscle, measurements were taken across five consecutive slices (for small corresponding lesions) or ten consecutive slices (for larger lesions). All ROIs were reviewed by a senior musculoskeletal radiologist. Corresponding mean, median, skewness, and kurtosis of the T1 relaxation times were reported. 2.4. Statistics The data extracted from the images were analyzed using Python software (Python Software Foundation, Python Language Reference, Version 3.8.5, available at http://www.python.org, accessed on 1 September 2024). Two different homogeneity tests were applied for inter-group and intra-group comparisons. The comparison of parameters between benign tumors and sarcomas was performed using the Mann–Whitney U test, while the comparison of benign tumors or sarcomas against healthy tissues utilized the Wilcoxon test. 3. Results 3.1. Patient Inclusion Out of 316 patients referred to our tertiary center with soft tissue tumors, only 16 patients with confirmed sarcomas and 9 patients with histologically confirmed benign tumors were included in the study; see the patient inclusion diagram in Figure 1. The types of sarcomas and benign tumors are summarized in Table 2. Patient inclusion diagram. Table 2T1 relaxation time (ms) in lesions (mass) and muscles of all patients.PatientDiagnosisGradeMean T1 in Lesion (ms)T1 Standard Deviation in Lesion (ms)Mean T1 in Muscle (ms)T1 Standard Deviation in Muscle (ms)Field StrengthS1Undifferentiated Sarcoma 3331243416681363S2Dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans-209263811922311.5S3Synovial sarcoma 28101477281221.5S4Synovial sarcoma32766108510222161.5S5Pleomorphic sarcoma 3313859914354603S6Leiomyosarcoma2224798315862573S7Myxoid fusocellular sarcoma 3313233633205653S8Myxofibrosarcoma322942618311583S9Synovial sarcoma2320853611752593S10Pleomorphic sarcoma3349458218323743S11Fusiform cell sarcoma 216966569295211.5S12Myxofibrosarcoma3113449121804843S13Leiomyosarcoma26948910921413S14Osteogenic sarcoma 3264561313571933S15Osteogenic sarcoma 31831203915744911.5S16Leiomyosarcoma-31966798991331.5T1Desmoid tumor-124627512161311.5T2Myxoma-319186412662201.5T3Solitary fibrous tumor-202137510132121.5T4Mesothelial cyst-81442411621441.5T5Schwannoma-81460509583T6Inflammatory pseudotumor-165125413861783T7Angiolipoma-7505728531191.5T8Desmoid tumor-1106295311331.5T9Desmoid tumor-1206227280451.5 T1 relaxation time (ms) in lesions (mass) and muscles of all patients. 3.2. T1 Values in Sarcomas and Benign Tumors An example of a T1 map involving sarcomas and benign tumors is shown in Figure 2, while Figure 3 and Figure 4 illustrate the distribution of T1 relaxation times in sarcomas and benign tumors, as well as the measurements in healthy muscle for comparison. At 3 T, lower T1 values were observed in healthy muscle compared to sarcomas (p3T = 0.020), while this difference was not significant at 1.5 T (p1.5T = 0.063). Additionally, T1 values in healthy muscle did not significantly differ from those in benign tumors (p1.5T = 0.156 and p3T = 1). Additionally, no significant differences in T1 values were observed between healthy muscle tissue from sarcoma and benign tumor cases (p1.5T = 0.472 and p3T = 0.226). Table 2 provides detailed information on the T1 relaxation measurements across all patients. Case example for sarcoma and benign tumor. Upper line: T1 relaxation maps (scale 500–3500 ms) for a synovial sarcoma (left) and benign solitary fibrous tumor (right). Bottom line: T1w with fat suppression for corresponding slice. T1 relaxation time (ms) in lesion and in muscle for patients with sarcoma or benign tumor for a magnetic field of 1.5 T. Number of patients in each group is indicated (N) at the top of the graph. Red triangles represent mean T1. T1 relaxation time (ms) in lesions and in muscles for patients with sarcoma or benign tumor for a magnetic field of 3 T. Number of patients in each group is indicated (N) at the top of the graph. Red triangles represent mean T1. 3.3. T1 Histogram Parameters in Sarcomas and Benign Tumors The skewness and kurtosis of T1 relaxation times were also measured, with the histogram parameters summarized in Table 3. Different tendencies were observed at 1.5 T and 3 T. Specifically, skewness was significantly lower in benign tumors compared to sarcomas at 1.5 T, while the opposite trend was observed at 3 T. Additionally, at 1.5 T, skewness was significantly lower in muscle tissues of patients with benign lesions compared to those with sarcomas. Kurtosis showed a large standard deviation in the sarcoma group at both 1.5 T and 3 T, affecting both lesions and healthy areas. Table 3Summary of histogram parameters for all patients, separated by field strength. SarcomaBenign Tumorp-Value Sarcoma-Benign TumorLesionHealthy Musclep-ValueLesionHealthy Musclep-Value 1.5 T Mean [ms] (mean ± SD) 1701 ± 4501072 ± 2690.0631502 ± 7201131 ± 2740.1560.260 Median [ms] 18029509501238 N 67 Skewness (mean ± SD) 3.22 ± 3.692.48 ± 1.251.0000.58 ± 1.920.79 ± 0.640.3750.022 Kurtosis (mean ± SD) 31.00 ± 52.932.67 ± 39.240.8445.94 ± 13.294.12 ± 3.840.5780.195 3 T Mean [ms] 2214 ± 8091470 ± 3580.0201126 ± 3671056 ± 5501.0000.119 Median [ms] 2510149911261056 N 102 Skewness (mean ± SD) 0.04 ± 0.870.94 ± 0.690.0270.22 ± 0.201.26 ± 0.360.5000.373 Kurtosis (mean ± SD) 1.00 ± 2.534.92 ± 5.330.160−0.71 ± 0.007.98 ± 4.130.5000.053 Summary of histogram parameters for all patients, separated by field strength. 4. Discussion Despite the limited number of included cases, to the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to focus on the added value of T1 mapping for soft tissue tumors. At both 1.5 T and 3 T, we observed higher (though not statistically significant) T1 mean values in sarcoma lesions compared to healthy muscles, which aligns with the observations made by Baidya et al. [26]. The T1 values reported by Baidya were of the same order of magnitude but lower than our own findings. The values at 1.5 T reported by these authors were 831 ms for sarcomas and 683 ms for muscles, compared to 1701 ms and 1072 ms, respectively, in our study. Other studies have reported similar findings, showing higher T1 values in phyllodes tumors compared to fibroadenomas [23]. Additional researchers have demonstrated that T1 relaxation times are higher in malignant breast tumors compared to benign ones [28]. Our T1 values were quite similar to those measured by Stanisz et al. [29]. According to these authors, at 1.5 T, normal T1 relaxation values in skeletal muscles were recorded at 1008 ms, while we obtained values of 1072 ms and 1131 ms in patients with sarcomas and benign tumors, respectively. At 3 T, Stanisz reported a T1 of 1412 ms, while we obtained values of 1470 ms and 1056 ms for sarcomas and benign tumors, respectively (the latter group consisting of only two patients). This concordance supports the use of T1 relaxation times in muscles as a baseline for comparison with soft tissue tumor values. Several methods are currently available for estimating T1 mapping. While the gold standard involves an inversion recovery spin echo sequence, this technique is time-consuming and thus not clinically practical. The variable flip angle method has proven accurate and robust but is sensitive to B1 inhomogeneities at field strengths greater than 1.5 T, requiring multiple flip angles to provide robust T1 estimations [30]. T1 mapping using the dual flip angle method has been shown to be both efficient and fast and is frequently applied in the context of dynamic contrast-enhanced (DCE) imaging. However, depending on the combination of flip angles chosen, significantly different T1 estimates may result [31]. In our study, we used only two flip angles, which is suboptimal for accurately estimating T1 values. This likely affected the quality of our measurements. For example, in the study by Baidya et al. [26], four flip angles were used, but the sequence acquisition time ranged from 12 to 15 min, whereas each of our sequences required less than 1 min. Consequently, there is significant potential for improvement in our measurements should T1 mapping be explored as a potential marker in future studies. In our study, the results were separated based on the two different field strengths, as it is well known that T1 relaxation values depend on resonance frequency [29]. In biological tissues, T1 values have been shown to increase with higher field strength, a trend that was also observed in our measurements. Skewness and kurtosis results could indeed be promising markers, as Baidya et al. [26] demonstrated that skewness was higher in healthy tissues than in sarcomas. Another recent study showed that, among other factors, ADC skewness was associated with the expression of hypoxia-inducible factor-1 alpha (HIF-1α), a key regulator of oxygen homeostasis in sarcoma [32]. However, in our study, we observed higher skewness values for sarcomas compared to healthy tissues at 1.5 T, with the opposite trend at 3 T. This discrepancy may be explained by the retrospective design of the study. Two different systems were used with different acquisition protocols for T1 mapping sequences, tailored to each patient’s area of interest. This likely introduced heterogeneity in the signal-to-noise ratio within the images, which may have affected the histogram parameters, making it difficult to separate this effect from the intrinsic T1-value heterogeneity within the lesions. Radiomic analysis has been shown to greatly improve lesion characterization when applied to MR images. For example, in bladder tumors, it is excellent at discriminating between low-grade and high-grade tumors, as well as differentiating muscle-invasive from non-muscle-invasive cancer [33]. It can also be successfully applied to T1 mapping of rectal adenocarcinoma to discriminate between mucinous and non-mucinous adenocarcinoma, as well as to differentiate low-grade from high-grade lesions [34]. This is certainly a promising tool that merits further investigation; however, we believe that the MRI protocol should first be standardized, as it has been shown that radiomic features are highly dependent on MRI field strength, the manufacturer, and acquisition parameters [35]. Our study has several limitations, the first being the small number of patients included in each group. The inclusion of “native” soft tissue tumors using the same T1 mapping protocol was the primary factor contributing to the small group size. Furthermore, the heterogeneity in acquisition techniques, with different MRI systems and varying signal-to-noise ratios obtained for each patient, likely impacted the results. The T1 map sequence parameters were adjusted for each patient based on tumor size, location, and the receiver coil used. In future studies, this should be more standardized with predefined sequences. Due to the retrospective nature of our study, we were limited to using the data and protocols already available. However, given the promising trends observed, we strongly believe that T1 mapping could be improved by incorporating additional flip angles or using other sequence types, which, while slower, may yield more robust results. Due to these limitations, we were unable to establish a cut-off for T1 values to differentiate sarcomas from benign tumors. Additionally, we did not investigate whether T1 values correlated with tumor grading or histology due to the limited number of cases. The absence of low-grade tumors further prevents us from drawing conclusions about this subgroup from our study. The small cohort size also precluded detailed analysis across different subtypes. A larger, more homogeneous cohort would allow for more granular analysis, especially as sarcomas represent a diverse group of tumors with potentially distinct T1 behaviors. This limitation underscores the need for future studies with expanded sample sizes to provide deeper insights into subtype-specific characteristics. 5. Conclusions In conclusion, our study demonstrated higher T1 relaxation values in sarcomas compared to healthy muscles and benign lesions. Despite the non-significance of our results, the data suggest that T1 relaxation times prior to contrast injection are worth considering as an additional marker for lesion characterization, potentially aiding radiologists in tumor evaluation. T1 mapping appears to be a promising tool for differentiating sarcomas from benign tumors during baseline assessments, as has been demonstrated in other organs. However, it is essential to account for technical aspects to optimize its use in sarcomas and establish it as a valuable additional marker for radiologists. Author Contributions Conceptualization, S.B. and B.M.A.D.; methodology, S.B. and B.M.A.D.; validation, S.B., B.M.A.D. and L.D.; formal analysis, L.D.; investigation, L.D.; writing—original draft preparation, L.D., B.M.A.D. and S.B.; writing—review and editing, L.D., S.B., B.M.A.D., M.S.M. and P.A.P.; supervision, S.B., M.S.M. and P.A.P. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. Institutional Review Board Statement This retrospective study was approved by the local institutional review board Commission cantonale d’éthique de la recherche scientifique de Genève (CCER), n° 2016-01821, approved on the 30 November 2016 and conducted in accordance with the principles of the Helsinki Declaration. Informed Consent Statement Patient consent was waived due to the retrospective nature of the study. Data Availability Statement Data used in the study are included in the article, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare no conflicts of interest. Funding Statement This research received no external funding. Footnotes Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement Data used in the study are included in the article, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.