Tenant Right-to-Counsel and Adverse Birth Outcomes in New York, New York Authors: Kathryn M. Leifheit, Katherine L. Chen, Nathaniel W. Anderson, Cecile Yama, Achyuth Sriram, Craig Evan Pollack, Alison Gemmill, Frederick J. Zimmerman Published: 2024 ABSTRACT Key PointsQuestionWas eviction prevention via free legal representation in housing court (right-to-counsel) in New York, New York, associated with birth outcomes in Medicaid-insured birthing parents?FindingsIn this cohort study including 260 493 live births, right-to-counsel was associated with a statistically significant 0.96–percentage point absolute reduction in adverse birth outcomes among Medicaid-insured birthing parents.MeaningThese findings suggest that right-to-counsel programs may lead to improvements in key population health indicators. Introduction Evictions are common among low-income renters and contribute to poor health. Renters with children are at particular risk, with 10.4% receiving an eviction filing each year, compared with a rate of 5.0% among those without children.1 A large and evolving literature documents adverse health effects of evictions.1,2,3,4,5 Evictions impose significant stress,6,7 disrupted health care access,8 and nutritional deficits.9 Pregnancy is a sensitive period during which adversity can pose especially strong risk to pregnant people’s health and to fetal development.10 Consequently, evictions among pregnant people are associated with adverse birth outcomes.11 A study linking eviction data to birth certificates in the state of Georgia found that evictions during pregnancy were associated with increases in infants’ probability of low birth weight and, separately, preterm birth.12 By extension, interventions to prevent evictions might improve birth outcomes. Tenant right-to-counsel is one such preventive measure. Right-to-counsel programs provide legal representation to tenants facing evictions. In contrast to criminal cases, defendants in civil cases, such as eviction hearings, are not guaranteed a lawyer under federal law. As a result, there is a power imbalance in rent courts: in 2024 data collected from 39 jurisdictions (states and large cities) spread across the country, 83% of landlords had legal representation in eviction cases, while only 4% of tenants did.13 Lacking lawyers, tenants are less able to assert their due process, win cases, or reach fair settlements with landlords. Additionally, many tenants do not appear in courts and are evicted via default judgements. New York, New York, launched the United States’ first right-to-counsel program in 2017, providing attorneys to tenants earning below 200% of the federal poverty level through an initiative known as Universal Access to Legal Services.14 New York’s program was rolled out in phases by zip code, prioritizing neighborhoods with high eviction rates and low tenant representation. The program began with 10 zip codes in winter 2017, adding new zip codes over time. In March 2020, in response to sudden increases in economic and housing strain during the COVID-19 pandemic, the program was expanded ahead of schedule to cover low-income renters across the entire city.14 Tenants were screened for eligibility by program staff and assigned a lawyer on the day of their first appearances in court.14 Previous evaluations suggest that the program has doubled rates of legal representation in eviction cases.15 Right-to-counsel access has also dramatically reduced evictions: in one study, living in a right-to-counsel zip code was associated with a 45% to 78% reduction in the likelihood that an eviction case would result in an eviction warrant (ie, a judge’s orders triggering forcible removal of a tenant).16 Qualitative research finds that right-to-counsel may improve health by helping tenants maintain housing, mitigating harms associated with evictions (eg, securing extra time for a move, reducing rent owed, or lowering stress during an eviction), and empowering renters to organize.17 In this analysis, we aimed to determine whether New York’s right-to-counsel program was associated with reduced incidence of adverse birth outcomes (preterm birth and adverse birth outcomes) among low-income residents of New York, New York. Methods This cohort study was reviewed and approved by the University of California, Los Angeles, institutional review board. The University of California, Los Angeles, institutional review board waived the requirement for informed consent, assent, and parental permission under 45 CFR 46.116, as it was a secondary data analysis posing minimal risk of harm to participants. This study is reported following the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) reporting guideline. We performed a cohort study leveraging New York’s staggered implementation of right-to-counsel from 2017 to 2020 as a natural experiment. During this study period, 9 evictions were filed per 100 renter households in New York.18 Based on national trends in evictions by income and family structure,1 it is reasonable to assume that this filing rate was 2 to 3 times higher among low-income birthing people in New York. Data and Study Population We obtained birth certificate data on all live births occurring in New York from 2016 to 2020 from the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene’s Bureau of Vital Statistics. Each record contains information pertaining to birth month, parental and infant demographics and health status, and zip code of residence at the time of birth. For the present study, we limited our sample to infants born prior to March 2020 to exclude time that was covered by the COVID-19 pandemic, when the State of New York and federal government enacted temporary eviction moratoria. To match right-to-counsel inclusion criteria, we further limited our sample to infants whose parents resided within New York, New York, and who had Medicaid insurance (a proxy for low income; Medicaid income limits for pregnant people and infants were set at 223% of the federal poverty level during the study period19). Finally, we restricted the sample to infants with complete data on gestational age and birth weight. Definition of Outcomes Our primary outcome was adverse birth outcomes, a composite, dichotomous indicator of whether the child was born either with less than 2500 g birth weight or at less than 37 weeks’ gestation. We also examine each component indicator (low birth weight, preterm birth) as unique outcomes. Specification of Right-to-Counsel Treatment We specified zip code–specific dates of right-to-counsel implementation based on reports from New York’s Office of Civil Justice. Dates were further validated via conversations with the Office of Civil Justice, people providing legal services via right-to-counsel (ie, lawyers and legal teams) in New York, and tenant advocates. Implementation was defined as the date on which essential programmatic elements (eg, courthouse-based tenant outreach) were in place and accessible to tenants. Dates used were broadly consistent with previous studies.15,16 Figure 1 maps the staggered rollout of right-to-counsel in New York. Right-to-Counsel Implementation Timing by New York, New York, Zip Code We lagged the policy treatment by 9 months to ensure that an infant’s full gestational period was covered by right-to-counsel. For example, an infant residing in a zip code where right-to-counsel was implemented in October 2017 would be counted as treated if they were born during or after July 2018. Statistical Analysis We first compared sociodemographic characteristics of birthing parents in zip codes ever vs never treated with right-to-counsel. We then plotted incidence of adverse birth outcomes over time in 2 groups: infants in zip codes that never received the intervention during the study period (never treated) and infants in zip codes that eventually received the intervention (ever-treated). Second, we compared raw incidence of outcomes before and after policy implementation in zip codes with right-to-counsel, compared with never-treated zip codes. Given the staggered rollout of right-to-counsel, we conducted these comparisons separately for each implementation phase. We then used difference-in-difference models to estimate the difference between the pre-post change in adverse birth outcomes observed in zip codes treated with right-to-counsel vs the change expected had those zip codes never been treated.20 We estimated this counterfactual using data from zip codes that did not receive right-to-counsel during the study period. The validity of this approach relies on a parallel-trends assumption, ie, that treated and untreated groups would have parallel or common trends in the absence of treatment. We tested this assumption using an event-study specification,21 where the strength of associations is allowed to vary over time, relative to treatment. Additional details on our model specification, including assumption checking, can be found in the eAppendix in Supplement 1. We used linear probability difference-in-differences models to measure associations between right-to-counsel and adverse birth outcomes.22 Treatment was specified as a time-varying, lagged indicator of whether an infant’s zip code was treated with right-to-counsel 9 months prior to birth. The indicator is coded zero for never-treated zip codes and pretreatment zip codes; it is coded 1 after treatment. To control for seasonal variation in birth outcomes and time-invariant differences between treated and untreated zip codes,23 we adjusted for year, month, and zip code. We used a robust variance estimator to account for correlation due to clustering of individuals within zip codes. We conducted a number of sensitivity analyses. To address the possibility that zip code–level demographic changes concurrent with right-to-counsel rollout might confound our results, we ran a difference-in-differences model adjusted for the following individual-level covariates: birthing parent age, race and ethnicity, education, nativity, marital status, and parity (ie, a birthing parent’s cumulative number of live births). Additionally, we tested 2 alternate exposure definitions: percentage of gestation exposed to right-to-counsel based on estimated date of conception and first trimester of right-to-counsel exposure. These 2 alternate exposure models included gestations that were partially exposed to right-to-counsel in the treatment group, whereas our main models required treatment for the full gestational period. We also ran models with birth weight and gestational age specified continuously, as well as models using more extreme outcomes (very low birth weight, defined as <1500 g, and very preterm, defined as <32 weeks). Finally, to explore potential heterogeneity by treatment phase, we estimated models separately by phase and ran heterogeneity-robust models following the Callaway and Sant’Anna method for differences in differences with multiple periods.24 Because there are large racial and ethnic disparities in eviction risk,1 equitable rollout of right-to-counsel might especially benefit the health of populations that are disproportionately evicted (in particular, infants born to non-Hispanic Black birthing parents). To explore potentially heterogeneous policy impacts between racial and ethnic groups, we stratified models by birthing parent race and ethnicity, focusing on Hispanic parents and non-Hispanic Asian or Pacific Islander, Black, and White groups for adequate sample sizes. Our analyses were not adequately powered to test for effect modification via statistical interaction. All statistical analyses were conducted in Stata software version 17.0 (StataCorp). P values were 2-sided, and statistical significance was set at P ≤ .05. Data were analyzed from February 2022 to September 2024. Results Study Population and Descriptive Results There were 479 617 live births in New York between January 2016 and February 2020 (eFigure 1 in Supplement 1). Among these, 48 241 birthing parents (10%) resided outside New York and were excluded. An additional 170 870 births (40% of New York resident births) were not Medicaid insured and were excluded. Finally, 13 births (<1% of Medicaid-insured births) were missing gestational age or birth weight and were excluded. Ultimately, our study sample included 260 493 infants (mean [SD] birthing parent age, 29 [6] years), among whom 43 081 births (17%) were to birthing parents living in zip codes ever treated with right-to-counsel. Birthing parents in zip codes ever vs never treated by right-to-counsel during the study period had similar age distributions but were more likely to be Hispanic or non-Hispanic Black, less likely to be US born or married, and more likely to be having their first child (Table 1). Table 1. Birthing Parent and Infant Characteristics by Zip Code Right-to-Counsel StatusBirthing parent characteristicsBirths by zip code–level right-to-counsel, No. (%)P valueNever (n = 217 412)Ever (n = 43 081)Age, mean (SD), y29 (6)29 (6).11Race and ethnicity Hispanic78 671 (36)20 246 (47)<.001 Non-Hispanic Asian and Pacific Islander39 952 (18)5254 (12) Non-Hispanic Black 45 406 (21)12 393 (29) Non-Hispanic White 50 634 (23)4630 (11) Another race or ethnicitya2749 (1)558 (1)