12 Tips for Including Disability Awareness within Undergraduate Medical Education Curricula Authors: Tanvee Sinha, Caroline N. Harada, William S. Brooks, Ashley Parish, Daniëlle Verstegen, Natalie L. Shaheen, Suzanne Smeltzer, Linda S Nield, Suzanne Smeltzer, Will Brooks, Linda S Nield, Will Brooks, Ami L DeWaters, Will Brooks Published: 2024 ABSTRACT Disability is extremely common, and there is a need for high quality medical school curricula on working with persons with disabilities. The goal of disability training is to provide the proper knowledge and skills to address the unique needs of persons with disability (PWD), mitigate health disparities, and help shape more compassionate and informed physicians. This article presents 12 tips to incorporate disability training into undergraduate medical education. These tips emphasize the inclusion of PWD in all stages of the curriculum, interprofessional education, experiential learning, and exposure to a range of disability types. By leveraging these tips, educators will be able to create effective learning opportunities and improve the future healthcare of PWD. Introduction With an estimated population of approximately 70 million, persons with disabilities (PWD) comprise the largest minority group in the U.S. and contribute significantly to the diversity of U.S. residents ( CDC, 2024; Leppert & Schaeffer, 2023; Okoro et al., 2018). PWD face significant health care disparities due in part to their complex medical needs and barriers faced when accessing healthcare. As a result, chronic diseases such as obesity, diabetes, and heart disease are more prevalent within this vulnerable population ( CDC, 2024). Physicians note that a variety of barriers limit their ability to provide effective care for these individuals, including knowledge gaps, challenges with communication, and a lack of accessible facilities ( McMillan et al., 2016). Approximately half of American medical schools have a disability curriculum, which may be why fewer than half of physicians surveyed in one study reported comfort when providing care for this population ( Holder et al., 2009; Seidel & Crowe, 2017). Early and frequent exposure of medical trainees to PWD, their unique health care needs, and barriers to effective care is one strategy to address these health disparities and improve healthcare for these individuals. It must be noted that instruction regarding the pathophysiology, diagnosis and management of disabling conditions is not equivalent to instruction regarding disability. Disability awareness involves self-reflection of one’s perceptions around disability and an active role in establishing inclusion for PWD. The following 12 tips are provided for medical educators wishing to incorporate disability awareness into the medical training programs at their own institutions. These tips are based upon the authors’ experiences with disability awareness education in both undergraduate medical education (UME) and graduate medical education (GME) ( Parish et al., 2024; Sinha et al., 2024). These tips have been developed within the theoretical framework of intergroup contact theory (ICT), which stresses the importance of direct contact between minority and majority groups to break down prejudices and foster collaboration and shared understanding ( Pettigrew, 1998; Pettigrew & Tropp, 2006). A key tenet of any disability awareness program is the inclusion of PWD into every phase of the process, from development through implementation and assessment. Tip 1 – Embed persons with disabilities into all phases of the curriculum Coined during the disability civil rights movement, the slogan “nothing about us without us” refers to the idea that no policy should be decided without involvement of members of the affected group ( Chu et al., 2016). Multiple factors contribute to lower quality health care delivery to PWD, which contributes to further health care disparities and poorer health outcomes; most of these factors would be realistically modifiable with input from PWD ( Sharby et al., 2015). PWD must be included in all aspects of disability awareness curricula, including the planning, development (design and content), implementation, and assessment phases. For the planning and development phases, we recommend including PWD in the brainstorming process and soliciting their input on most important needs and goals. For implementation, embed PWD into the curricular activities as experts and partner-educators. Students must have opportunities to directly interact with these individuals for success of the curriculum. Finally, during the assessment phase, solicit feedback from PWD and include their perceptions of the activities in the evaluation process. Holding a debrief session or focus group with these participants is a great way to obtain this key data. Those who possess lived experiences and voices are most capable of making a longitudinal effect on future medical practice. Failure to engage with PWD can lead to the propagation of ableist ideas and distortion of the most important facets of disability and healthcare. Developing partnerships with local rehabilitation clinics and community centers are great ways to create professional contacts to foster a collaborative approach to disability awareness and recruit PWD to participate as educators. Tip 2 – Follow Kern’s six-step method for curriculum development As with any curriculum development process, a thoughtfully constructed plan is essential to ensure success. We recommend Kern’s six-step model ( Thomas et al., 2015). Step 1 is to conduct a general needs assessment for the medical school, and step 2 is to determine the specific needs of the medical students. Since every medical school is unique and medical students enter training from a wide array of backgrounds and experiences, there is no “one-size-fits-all" model for providing disability awareness education. A needs assessment survey and/or set of focus groups involving PWD, students, and other stakeholders can be used to tailor a disability awareness curriculum to meet the unique needs of each medical school. To ensure success, the recommendations of patients with disabilities in the local community should be solicited, to better understand what future physicians need to know. Although there are certainly recommendations that will be consistent from PWD across the globe, there may also be recommendations that are specific to a given community of which educators should be aware. For example, there may be specific cultural or institutional norms that medical students need to learn about for PWD in their community. Learning objectives, step 3, should aim to address gaps in learner knowledge and align with programmatic learning goals. Published competencies such as those from the Alliance for Disability in Health Care Education can help guide the development of objectives ( ADHCE, 2024). When identifying educational strategies, step 4, be sure that they align with the overall curricular approach and culture of your medical school to establish continuity of instruction and further contribute to success. For example, if problem-based learning (PBL) is a core curricular element of your medical school, then including patients who have disabilities in one or more PBL cases would be an appropriate strategy. If students routinely engage in service learning, then partnering with community centers that provide services to PWD would be a great option. After step 5, implementation, a well-executed evaluation plan is pivotal to determine successes and areas of growth and improvement. As noted in Tip 1, be sure to include PWD into each phase of Kern’s model. Tip 3 – Utilize diverse clinicians with experience working with PWD The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention classifies disability into six types: mobility, cognition, independent living, hearing, vision, and self-care ( CDC, 2024). Some medical and health professions, such as physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech-language pathology and physiatry, have specific roles in caring for PWD who have one or more of these disability types. Because of their prevalent roles working with this population, disability awareness is often an accreditation requirement and embedded within their training. For example, Doctor of Physical Therapy (DPT) programs integrate disability awareness, distinctively geared toward mobility-based disability, throughout their curricula ( Roush & Sharby, 2011). Nurses, who represent the largest workforce within healthcare, play diverse and often front-line roles in the care of PWD. Therefore, in addition to PWD, it is helpful to integrate healthcare professionals who have experience working with this population into the disability awareness programs for medical students. This is particularly important as PWD often require a team-based approach to care that includes a variety of health professions ( Reis et al., 2004). Inclusion of clinicians who possess these experiences can help ensure that key considerations and clinical pearls are embedded within the curricula. Tip 4 – Include Interprofessional Education (IPE) elements Emphasizing an interprofessional approach when implementing disability awareness curricula is important, because caring for PWD often requires communication and planning as a healthcare team ( Iezzoni, 2006; Reis et al., 2004). IPE has been shown as beneficial to learning, skill development, and creating a plan of care ( McCave et al., 2019; Visser et al., 2019). It is also important for future physicians to understand the role of other healthcare professionals in treating PWD as it can allow for better patient-client management and referral for those who may have unmet needs. Since many medical schools have associated health professions programs, IPE activities can involve students from physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech-language pathology, nursing, and physician associate programs to name a few. Disability awareness activities provide a robust and practical setting to meet accreditation requirements around IPE. Tip 5 – Incorporate a broad spectrum of disability types into the curriculum Disability is neither a single diagnosis nor a single human characteristic. It is a collection of physical or mental impairments that limits life activities, and it can result from myriad illnesses and injuries. Furthermore, people with disabilities are just as diverse as those who do not have a disability. Educational programs that promote disability awareness should strive to be as inclusive as possible and represent the full diversity of this population. One way to do this is to include a breadth of disability types in your instruction and learning experiences: Mobility – You could incorporate wheelchair users (manual and powerchair) and have students self-propel themselves in wheelchairs around your educational building. Mobility – You could incorporate wheelchair users (manual and powerchair) and have students self-propel themselves in wheelchairs around your educational building. Cognition – You could allow students to volunteer at community centers or other sites that provide services to individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Cognition – You could allow students to volunteer at community centers or other sites that provide services to individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Vision – You could incorporate a patient with a vision impairment into a PBL or case-based learning session or allow students to volunteer at training sites for service animals. Vision – You could incorporate a patient with a vision impairment into a PBL or case-based learning session or allow students to volunteer at training sites for service animals. Hearing – You could provide a medical sign language class or allow students to practice working with an interpreter to communicate with guests who have hearing impairments. Hearing – You could provide a medical sign language class or allow students to practice working with an interpreter to communicate with guests who have hearing impairments. When adopting Tip 1, be sure to engage a diverse group of PWD in the planning and implementation of the program, ensuring diversity of age, sex, gender, race, ethnicity, disability type, disability etiology (congenital vs. acquired), occupation, etc. Tip 6 – Include a variety of pedagogies, emphasizing experiential learning Understanding of disability awareness can be enhanced by using a multitude of pedagogies. While lectures, readings, videos or case studies might inform background information, such as the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and communication etiquette, experiential learning provides hands-on experiences that can provide a unique method for learning. Experiential learning, including direct interaction between students and PWD, should be considered as a focal element of disability curricula. Furthermore, service learning and community outreach activities allow students to see and interact with PWD in non-clinical settings. Bringing PWD onto campus for small group discussions is another way to create valuable learning experiences. In the context of patients who may have intellectual and developmental disabilities or cognitive impairments, family members and caregivers can serve as valuable teachers in these experiential settings. Tip 7 – Ensure access to appropriate equipment and facilities PWD often utilize assistive and adaptive equipment to help promote independence. As physicians are often the prescribers of equipment, it is imperative to have familiarity with types of equipment and spaces in which equipment is utilized. For example, a commonly prescribed piece of equipment for both short- and long-term mobility impairments is a wheelchair. Having various types of wheelchairs during interactive portions of disability awareness learning activities can allow students to use the equipment, which can spark discussion of costs, proper fit, and parts of wheelchairs that may be needed based on diagnosis. Similarly, gait belts and sliding boards are useful to have students practice how to transfer PWD on and off of an examination table. For language disabilities, communication devices should be used by students to experience how devices operate. Equipment integrated into the disability awareness curriculum should be diverse and based upon the type of disability being studied to allow for holistic exposure and understanding of the compatible devices that PWD may use. Tip 8 – Introduce students to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is a civil rights law that was enacted in 1990 to prohibit discrimination against individuals with disabilities, ensuring that this population has the same rights and opportunities as those without disabilities. Title III of the ADA sets the minimum standards for accessibility of public and privately-owned facilities, directs businesses to make reasonable accommodations when serving people with disabilities, and requires appropriate measures be taken to effectively communicate with individuals who have speech, hearing and vision impairments. Introducing medical students to the basic tenets of the ADA is an essential component of any disability awareness curriculum as it forms the foundation for government-mandated accommodation and accessibility considerations. Students should understand the legal implications of the ADA in their future clinical practices. This should begin as early as new student orientation when medical students are made aware of disability support services for students and processes for obtaining disability-related accommodations. As topics around disability in healthcare and considerations for patients who have specific types of disability are introduced in the formal curriculum, additional details regarding the ADA’s role in protecting the rights of PWD can be incorporated through short videos or reading assignments. The ADA National Network offers a variety of resources that could be used to serve this purpose ( ADATA, 2024). Other approaches that employ more active methods of instruction include one-on-one and small group conversations about accessibility with individuals who have disabilities and placing students into a variety of ADA compliant and non-compliant facilities. Longitudinal curricular elements such as clinical skills and learning communities offer opportunities for a threaded approach to education around the ADA. Our approach to teaching about the ADA includes both lecture-based content and experiential learning with early and longitudinal exposures. Tip 9 – Simulate first-hand experiences by placing learners “into the shoes” of PWD It is important to note that although experiential learning may allow a student to simulate what it is like to have a disability, it is not the same as living with a disability. For our approach, PWD help to create and lead experiential learning activities. This allows medical students to have a more meaningful learning opportunity versus inducing a sympathy-based response for individuals who live with disabilities. For our curriculum, physical therapy students teach medical students how to self-propel a wheelchair. Medical students then self-propel wheelchairs through their educational building alongside individuals who use wheelchairs for mobility. The wheelchair users guide students to experience the ADA-compliant and non-compliant aspects of buildings, sidewalks, and parking during this process. The wheelchair users then have an open dialogue with students to discuss the long-term effects of using a wheelchair for mobility, share their experiences, and answer questions. These meaningful learning contexts can improve student engagement, understanding, and retention of the material all while promoting deeper awareness of the emotional, social, and physical aspects of living with a disability ( Laurillard, 2012). Immersing students in these situations helps break down stereotypes, while building a sense of responsibility to improve the lack of inclusivity, the “non-disability-friendly” spaces, and increase patience in their future clinical practice. Educators should be aware that disability simulation can also have the unintended consequence of promoting ableism and discrimination against PWD. This can happen because in simulation students experience becoming disabled, thus overemphasizing trauma of the experience, which can promote pity, negative stereotypes, and underemphasize the social inequalities experienced by PWD over time ( Silverman, 2015). Caution must be taken when implementing any type of disability simulation, and it is paramount that PWD be involved in these simulations to mitigate these risks. Nonetheless, we feel that through thoughtful coaching and debriefing with PWD these unintended consequences can be avoided. Tip 10 – Create opportunities for open dialog between learners and PWD Creating opportunities for open dialogue between students and PWD who serve as the facilitators of learning experiences is crucial to fostering a more effective learning environment. These interactions help dispel misconceptions, bridge gaps between learners and facilitators, and foster more encouraging and accepting clinical practice. PWD are underrepresented as educators, but they may reflect images in the mirror for many students and help guide learners in understanding everyday challenges and triumphs for PWD ( Anderson et al., 1998). Open channels of communication in the learning environment help build collaborative relationships where facilitators and learners can discuss shared perspective and various views surrounding them as well as uncomfortable but necessary dilemmas ( Ta et al., 2023). Whether in the form of a panel discussion or experiential learning activity in pre-clerkship training, a simulated patient encounter, or an authentic clinical experience during the third- and fourth-years, there are ample opportunities within the four-year medical curriculum to incorporate these discussions and effectively utilize PWD as educators. Including a minimum of one learning activity in the pre-clerkship phase and several authentic clinical encounters in the third- and fourth-years is recommended. Through open discussions, everyone’s unique abilities and perspectives are acknowledged and integrated to better enhance learning. Tip 11 – Embed reflective elements into the activities Adding reflective elements, such as small group debriefs and reflection essays, into a disability curriculum can enhance an already dynamic and inclusive learning environment for learners and facilitators alike. For learners, research has shown that when students combine their learning with reflection, they are able to effectively understand and analyze problems that they could not otherwise ( Eyler & Giles, 1999). When students are encouraged to recognize their strengths and weaknesses and assess their learning through self-reflection, they are more likely to adopt those processes going forward ( Silverman & Cassaza, 2000). For facilitators, reflection provides structure to their teaching and encourages them to take responsibility for themselves. By understanding what is effective and what could be improved upon, reflection helps educators create more inclusive curricula with greater relevance and direction for their learners ( Daudelin, 1996). Reflective elements can easily be incorporated as part of experiential learning sessions (Tip 6) and open dialogue sessions (Tip 10). Ideally, reflection as a formal or informal learning element should accompany each component of a disability awareness curricular thread. Overall, incorporating reflective elements in a disability-based curriculum can enhance the experience for learners and stress continuity while also contributing to the professional growth of PWD as educators, creating a more refined ecosystem. Tip 12 – Create longitudinal experiences Currently, only half of U.S. medical schools have a disability awareness program ( Seidel & Crowe, 2017). For those that do, most incorporate training within the pre-clinical years but fail to provide experiences in the clinical phase of training, which limits opportunities for application in clinical practice. Both the lack of education and continuity adds to the negative bias and discomfort that many medical students and physicians feel when treating PWD; this only results in worse healthcare and medical attention for PWD ( Sharby et al., 2015). The ineffective nature of continued medical education contributes to the discrepancy between evidence/experience-based knowledge and fair practice ( Marinopoulos et al., 2007). Thus, it is vital that schools not only incorporate disability training early in medical training but thread these experiences longitudinally throughout training. During the core clinical clerkships, ensure that students have the ability to interact with patients of all disability types. Internal medicine, pediatrics, and neurology clerkships, in particular, should offer ample opportunities for students to participate in the care of PWD from each of the six categories defined by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ( CDC, 2024). Thoughtful inclusion of disability awareness should also be incorporated into obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYN) as well as pediatric clerkships in the context of parents who have a disability or parents who will be caring for children with a disability ( Amir et al., 2022; Sheppard et al., 2022). Asynchronous learning modules and simulated patient encounters can be used as supplements when students are unable to work with a specific type of disability. For example, embedding a patient who has a hearing or vision deficit or who uses a wheelchair into a simulation activity that already takes place within a clerkship is an effective way to add depth to a simulation without adding curricular time. Students should also participate in the development of management plans alongside physical or occupational therapists during their acting internships to strengthen their understanding of the complexities of caring for this patient population. Advanced electives in the care of PWD during the fourth year of medical school can provide further opportunities for students to deepen their skills prior to residency training. Conclusion The goal of these 12 tips is to provide medical educators with the necessary tools to promote students’ awareness of unique considerations when providing care for PWD and foster a platform for PWD to function as key participants in the learning environment. It is crucial that medical schools prepare the next generation of physicians to provide effective health-care for this population through diverse teaching and learning methods, interprofessional collaboration, and a focus on reflection and continuity. By embracing these tips, the teaching and learning process can become enriching for all stakeholders and cultivate trainees who will be compassionate and confident providers within their future roles. Ethics and consent Ethical approval and Consent were not required. Thank you for the opportunity to review the article '12 Tips for Including Disability Awareness within Undergraduate Medical Education Curricula'. The article contains a wealth of experience, insights and tips on how to include disability awareness in undergraduate curricula. There is some overlap between the tips, but that does not disturb me. It is very US-centered, and that makes some of the tips less useful for readers based elsewhere. It would be easy to partly address this, for example by changing Tip 8 to 'Introducing students to legal frameworks' instead of specifically the American Disability Act. Or by acknowledging that the classification of disabilities or even the definition could be different elsewhere (e.g. I am surprised not to see categories related to mental health and (health) literacy). I am an Instructional Designer by background. So, I fully agree that a systematic approach to curriculum design is a good tip. And I agree that Kern's model is suitable, but it is not the only good model. So, I would rather change Tip 2 to 'Take a systematic approach to curriculum development' and use Kern's model as an example of a good model. That same background makes me curious for more information about Tip 6: include a variety of pedagogical approaches. Could you possibly elaborate a bit more? I would also say that Tip 11 is a vital tip to go with Tip 6. I would place them together. Finally, two more practical things: Especially in the abstract it is not very clear whether 'working with persons with disabilities refers to working with patients with disabilities or to working with colleagues or students with disabilities.And would it be possible to leverage the experiences of students and staff with disabilities (or with family members with disabilities) to strengthen the disability curriculum? My experience as a PBL tutor and teacher is that this can be very powerful. Especially in the abstract it is not very clear whether 'working with persons with disabilities refers to working with patients with disabilities or to working with colleagues or students with disabilities. Especially in the abstract it is not very clear whether 'working with persons with disabilities refers to working with patients with disabilities or to working with colleagues or students with disabilities. And would it be possible to leverage the experiences of students and staff with disabilities (or with family members with disabilities) to strengthen the disability curriculum? My experience as a PBL tutor and teacher is that this can be very powerful. And would it be possible to leverage the experiences of students and staff with disabilities (or with family members with disabilities) to strengthen the disability curriculum? My experience as a PBL tutor and teacher is that this can be very powerful. If evidence from practice is presented, are all the underlying source data available to ensure full reproducibility? Not applicable Is the topic of the practical tips discussed accurately in the context of the current literature Yes Are all factual statements correct and adequately supported by citations? Yes Are the conclusions drawn balanced and justified on the basis of the presented arguments? Yes Are arguments sufficiently supported by evidence from the published literature and/or the authors’ practice? Yes Reviewer Expertise: I am an instructional designer with much experience in curriculum design. I am not a physician and not an expert on disability curriculum I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard. I appreciate and support the broad aim and argument of this paper. Healthcare professionals need more knowledge about disabled people in order to provide culturally responsive care. This paper has three primary weaknesses that must be addressed. Simulations: I acknowledge that the authors have attempted to address the concerns a previous reviewer offered about the discussion of disability simulations. However, the additions do not go far enough. They briefly nod at the literature that says disability simulations are problematic. But their framing, and minimal citation of the literature, makes it seem like the reinforcement of misconceptions is an uncommon side effect of disability simulations, which is not what the literature says. The literature on this topic is fairly robust. Silverman’s 2015 3 piece is a useful citation. But I’d encourage the authors to read deeper. The authors should also offer an alternative to disability simulations for others to consider. For example, instead of a wheelchair simulation, students could use the ADA regulations to do an audit of the campus environment on their own. Then they could conduct a second audit of the same space in collaboration with wheelchair users and realize how many barriers they missed.Implicit Bias: An examination of students’ implicit bias should be part of a curriculum that aims to improve preservice healthcare professionals work with disabled people. This could easily be incorporated into tip 11, which pertains to reflection. For example, Module 5 from the OER Disability, Learning, and Education: A Guidebook demonstrates how implicit bias is explored in an undergraduate education course. Additionally, Chapter 4 out of the short book Demystifying Disability (Ladau, 2021 2) is helpful in explorations of implicit bias.Accessible Collaboration: The authors discuss the importance of engaging disabled people in curriculum development work, I applaud them for that emphasis. However, they neglect to point out that the standard collaboration processes in academia are often inaccessible to disabled people. If medical school faculty are going to invite disabled people to collaborate in curriculum development, they must ensure that their ways of working are accessible to disabled people, otherwise they risk causing harm. Other, less critical, weaknesses that I would encourage the authors to consider addressing are: The authors did not indicate what role, if any, disabled people had in conceptualizing and writing the article.When discussing developing partnerships, I would suggest the authors add organizations of disabled people to their list of suggestions. Rehabilitation clinics and community centers are often run by nondisabled people and have a different worldview than organizations of disabled people. Organizations of disabled people that the authors could suggest including Autistic Self Advocacy Network, National Association of the Deaf, and National Federation of the Blind.All discussion of disabled people in this article presupposes that disabled people are always patients in medical settings. But disabled people are also doctors, nurses, social workers, psychologists, etc. For that matter, there are disabled students in undergraduate medical programs. I encourage the authors to consider incorporating this reality into their tips. For example, how could disabled medical students help teach their peers about disability? How could a local disabled physician collaborate with the medical school in developing a disability awareness curriculum? Simulations: I acknowledge that the authors have attempted to address the concerns a previous reviewer offered about the discussion of disability simulations. However, the additions do not go far enough. They briefly nod at the literature that says disability simulations are problematic. But their framing, and minimal citation of the literature, makes it seem like the reinforcement of misconceptions is an uncommon side effect of disability simulations, which is not what the literature says. The literature on this topic is fairly robust. Silverman’s 2015 3 piece is a useful citation. But I’d encourage the authors to read deeper. The authors should also offer an alternative to disability simulations for others to consider. For example, instead of a wheelchair simulation, students could use the ADA regulations to do an audit of the campus environment on their own. Then they could conduct a second audit of the same space in collaboration with wheelchair users and realize how many barriers they missed. Simulations: I acknowledge that the authors have attempted to address the concerns a previous reviewer offered about the discussion of disability simulations. However, the additions do not go far enough. They briefly nod at the literature that says disability simulations are problematic. But their framing, and minimal citation of the literature, makes it seem like the reinforcement of misconceptions is an uncommon side effect of disability simulations, which is not what the literature says. The literature on this topic is fairly robust. Silverman’s 2015 3 piece is a useful citation. But I’d encourage the authors to read deeper. The authors should also offer an alternative to disability simulations for others to consider. For example, instead of a wheelchair simulation, students could use the ADA regulations to do an audit of the campus environment on their own. Then they could conduct a second audit of the same space in collaboration with wheelchair users and realize how many barriers they missed. Implicit Bias: An examination of students’ implicit bias should be part of a curriculum that aims to improve preservice healthcare professionals work with disabled people. This could easily be incorporated into tip 11, which pertains to reflection. For example, Module 5 from the OER Disability, Learning, and Education: A Guidebook demonstrates how implicit bias is explored in an undergraduate education course. Additionally, Chapter 4 out of the short book Demystifying Disability (Ladau, 2021 2) is helpful in explorations of implicit bias. Implicit Bias: An examination of students’ implicit bias should be part of a curriculum that aims to improve preservice healthcare professionals work with disabled people. This could easily be incorporated into tip 11, which pertains to reflection. For example, Module 5 from the OER Disability, Learning, and Education: A Guidebook demonstrates how implicit bias is explored in an undergraduate education course. Additionally, Chapter 4 out of the short book Demystifying Disability (Ladau, 2021 2) is helpful in explorations of implicit bias. Accessible Collaboration: The authors discuss the importance of engaging disabled people in curriculum development work, I applaud them for that emphasis. However, they neglect to point out that the standard collaboration processes in academia are often inaccessible to disabled people. If medical school faculty are going to invite disabled people to collaborate in curriculum development, they must ensure that their ways of working are accessible to disabled people, otherwise they risk causing harm. Accessible Collaboration: The authors discuss the importance of engaging disabled people in curriculum development work, I applaud them for that emphasis. However, they neglect to point out that the standard collaboration processes in academia are often inaccessible to disabled people. If medical school faculty are going to invite disabled people to collaborate in curriculum development, they must ensure that their ways of working are accessible to disabled people, otherwise they risk causing harm. The authors did not indicate what role, if any, disabled people had in conceptualizing and writing the article. The authors did not indicate what role, if any, disabled people had in conceptualizing and writing the article. When discussing developing partnerships, I would suggest the authors add organizations of disabled people to their list of suggestions. Rehabilitation clinics and community centers are often run by nondisabled people and have a different worldview than organizations of disabled people. Organizations of disabled people that the authors could suggest including Autistic Self Advocacy Network, National Association of the Deaf, and National Federation of the Blind. When discussing developing partnerships, I would suggest the authors add organizations of disabled people to their list of suggestions. Rehabilitation clinics and community centers are often run by nondisabled people and have a different worldview than organizations of disabled people. Organizations of disabled people that the authors could suggest including Autistic Self Advocacy Network, National Association of the Deaf, and National Federation of the Blind. All discussion of disabled people in this article presupposes that disabled people are always patients in medical settings. But disabled people are also doctors, nurses, social workers, psychologists, etc. For that matter, there are disabled students in undergraduate medical programs. I encourage the authors to consider incorporating this reality into their tips. For example, how could disabled medical students help teach their peers about disability? How could a local disabled physician collaborate with the medical school in developing a disability awareness curriculum? All discussion of disabled people in this article presupposes that disabled people are always patients in medical settings. But disabled people are also doctors, nurses, social workers, psychologists, etc. For that matter, there are disabled students in undergraduate medical programs. I encourage the authors to consider incorporating this reality into their tips. For example, how could disabled medical students help teach their peers about disability? How could a local disabled physician collaborate with the medical school in developing a disability awareness curriculum? If evidence from practice is presented, are all the underlying source data available to ensure full reproducibility? Not applicable Is the topic of the practical tips discussed accurately in the context of the current literature Partly Are all factual statements correct and adequately supported by citations? Yes Are the conclusions drawn balanced and justified on the basis of the presented arguments? Partly Are arguments sufficiently supported by evidence from the published literature and/or the authors’ practice? Partly Reviewer Expertise: Digital accessibility, disability studies, K-12 education, blindness, accessible STEM education I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to state that I do not consider it to be of an acceptable scientific standard, for reasons outlined above. I have read this submission. I believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard. Further, the information contained in the manuscript is important and should be useful to individuals and programs that are planning strategies to address disability in medical school curricula (as well as curricula of other healthcare professions programs). If evidence from practice is presented, are all the underlying source data available to ensure full reproducibility? Yes Is the topic of the practical tips discussed accurately in the context of the current literature Yes Are all factual statements correct and adequately supported by citations? Partly Are the conclusions drawn balanced and justified on the basis of the presented arguments? Partly Are arguments sufficiently supported by evidence from the published literature and/or the authors’ practice? Partly Reviewer Expertise: NA I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard. Thank you for the opportunity to review the revised work of Sinha and colleagues. Their twelve tips are comprehensive and clear and will help enhance medical education on this topic. The one minor edit I recommend is to add “(PWD)” to the end of the first sentence of the Abstract to explain this abbreviation which is subsequently used again in the Abstract. Approval status is "Approved" with the one suggested minor edit as mentioned in my review. If evidence from practice is presented, are all the underlying source data available to ensure full reproducibility? Partly Is the topic of the practical tips discussed accurately in the context of the current literature Yes Are all factual statements correct and adequately supported by citations? Partly Are the conclusions drawn balanced and justified on the basis of the presented arguments? Partly Are arguments sufficiently supported by evidence from the published literature and/or the authors’ practice? Partly Reviewer Expertise: medical education; MD admissions I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard. While the manuscript addresses an important topic, that is, the need to address disability in medical education, there are some issues that bear authors’ attention: The estimate of prevalence of disability is low. In 2024, the CDC reported 70 million people in USA to have a disability.Document refers to “medical” care; reviewer would suggest use of “health” care as it is more encompassing and does include medical care.Authors state that “Approximately half of American medical schools have a disability curriculum”, but say nothing about the quality of those curricula. It seems important to do so as not all curricula are the same.Tip 1: would change “ these factors would be realistically modifiable” to “ most of these factors”. Some elaboration of how the steps of Kern’s approach (mentioned at end of Tip 2) would be accomplished would be helpful addition to Tip 1. Tip 3 makes no mention of the largest workforce in health care (nursing workforce); so it should be mentioned when other healthcare professions are mentioned. Nursing IS mentioned in Tip 4 (once, but discussion is cursory).Tip 6 does not mention family members/caregivers who might be the best informants, especially of individuals with significant IDD or cognitive impairment; so they should be mentioned as possible informants.Tip 8 should mention that many resources…videos, etc….can be accessed for education of students. Inclusion of mention of some examples of these resources would likely be helpful.Tip 9: Should emphasize that the ADA has legal implications; otherwise, too many health care professionals think of ADA requirements as “nice to know” rather than a legal mandate.While the caution about disability simulation experiences was an extremely important addition, another possible negative consequence of these experiences is that “learners” often approach them as a game or a joke. Instead of concluding that having a disability is worse than death (which is the view of too many HCPs), some come away from the experience with the view that it is “not a big deal”. So great caution in using such simulations should be emphasized and PWD must be involved in these simulations. Otherwise, they should be avoided.Tip 12 does not address OB/maternal care and it must do so as women with disability face ableism to a high degree because HCPs fail to consider them appropriate parents (includes males with disability, too). So it must be mentioned as an area of the curriculum and practice where disability is addressed.An issue not addressed in the 12 tips is what content about disability should be addressed and what competencies should be the goal of medical education. I would recommend that the authors review the Core Competencies developed by the Alliance for Disability in Health Care Education, Inc. (ADHCE). The competencies were developed by an interprofessional, multidisciplinary group of healthcare professionals and individuals with disability. The competencies have been reviewed and endorsed by disability and disability advocacy groups, and major professional organizations, including those from medicine. The National Council on Disability (2022) also endorsed the competencies for use in the education of health care professionals across disciplines. The content of what is or should be taught is missing from the manuscript.A point worth considering for inclusion is that faculty (and many physicians currently in practice) may have received little if any education about the topic in their own education and training. Thus, they, too, will need to receive help in identifying 1) why this important, and 2) how having a disability affects one’s ability to receive health care. Further, HCP faculty often believe that they are already teaching adequately about disability (if they are reaching about disabling conditions, which is not the same as teaching about disability), so will be reluctant to add or take on another topic. This needs to be considered in the process and the importance of addressing disability emphasized. The estimate of prevalence of disability is low. In 2024, the CDC reported 70 million people in USA to have a disability. The estimate of prevalence of disability is low. In 2024, the CDC reported 70 million people in USA to have a disability. Document refers to “medical” care; reviewer would suggest use of “health” care as it is more encompassing and does include medical care. Document refers to “medical” care; reviewer would suggest use of “health” care as it is more encompassing and does include medical care. Authors state that “Approximately half of American medical schools have a disability curriculum”, but say nothing about the quality of those curricula. It seems important to do so as not all curricula are the same. Authors state that “Approximately half of American medical schools have a disability curriculum”, but say nothing about the quality of those curricula. It seems important to do so as not all curricula are the same. Tip 1: would change “ these factors would be realistically modifiable” to “ most of these factors”. Tip 1: would change “ these factors would be realistically modifiable” to “ most of these factors”. Some elaboration of how the steps of Kern’s approach (mentioned at end of Tip 2) would be accomplished would be helpful addition to Tip 1. Some elaboration of how the steps of Kern’s approach (mentioned at end of Tip 2) would be accomplished would be helpful addition to Tip 1. Tip 3 makes no mention of the largest workforce in health care (nursing workforce); so it should be mentioned when other healthcare professions are mentioned. Nursing IS mentioned in Tip 4 (once, but discussion is cursory). Tip 3 makes no mention of the largest workforce in health care (nursing workforce); so it should be mentioned when other healthcare professions are mentioned. Nursing IS mentioned in Tip 4 (once, but discussion is cursory). Tip 6 does not mention family members/caregivers who might be the best informants, especially of individuals with significant IDD or cognitive impairment; so they should be mentioned as possible informants. Tip 6 does not mention family members/caregivers who might be the best informants, especially of individuals with significant IDD or cognitive impairment; so they should be mentioned as possible informants. Tip 8 should mention that many resources…videos, etc….can be accessed for education of students. Inclusion of mention of some examples of these resources would likely be helpful. Tip 8 should mention that many resources…videos, etc….can be accessed for education of students. Inclusion of mention of some examples of these resources would likely be helpful. Tip 9: Should emphasize that the ADA has legal implications; otherwise, too many health care professionals think of ADA requirements as “nice to know” rather than a legal mandate. Tip 9: Should emphasize that the ADA has legal implications; otherwise, too many health care professionals think of ADA requirements as “nice to know” rather than a legal mandate. While the caution about disability simulation experiences was an extremely important addition, another possible negative consequence of these experiences is that “learners” often approach them as a game or a joke. Instead of concluding that having a disability is worse than death (which is the view of too many HCPs), some come away from the experience with the view that it is “not a big deal”. So great caution in using such simulations should be emphasized and PWD must be involved in these simulations. Otherwise, they should be avoided. While the caution about disability simulation experiences was an extremely important addition, another possible negative consequence of these experiences is that “learners” often approach them as a game or a joke. Instead of concluding that having a disability is worse than death (which is the view of too many HCPs), some come away from the experience with the view that it is “not a big deal”. So great caution in using such simulations should be emphasized and PWD must be involved in these simulations. Otherwise, they should be avoided. Tip 12 does not address OB/maternal care and it must do so as women with disability face ableism to a high degree because HCPs fail to consider them appropriate parents (includes males with disability, too). So it must be mentioned as an area of the curriculum and practice where disability is addressed. Tip 12 does not address OB/maternal care and it must do so as women with disability face ableism to a high degree because HCPs fail to consider them appropriate parents (includes males with disability, too). So it must be mentioned as an area of the curriculum and practice where disability is addressed. An issue not addressed in the 12 tips is what content about disability should be addressed and what competencies should be the goal of medical education. I would recommend that the authors review the Core Competencies developed by the Alliance for Disability in Health Care Education, Inc. (ADHCE). The competencies were developed by an interprofessional, multidisciplinary group of healthcare professionals and individuals with disability. The competencies have been reviewed and endorsed by disability and disability advocacy groups, and major professional organizations, including those from medicine. The National Council on Disability (2022) also endorsed the competencies for use in the education of health care professionals across disciplines. The content of what is or should be taught is missing from the manuscript. An issue not addressed in the 12 tips is what content about disability should be addressed and what competencies should be the goal of medical education. I would recommend that the authors review the Core Competencies developed by the Alliance for Disability in Health Care Education, Inc. (ADHCE). The competencies were developed by an interprofessional, multidisciplinary group of healthcare professionals and individuals with disability. The competencies have been reviewed and endorsed by disability and disability advocacy groups, and major professional organizations, including those from medicine. The National Council on Disability (2022) also endorsed the competencies for use in the education of health care professionals across disciplines. The content of what is or should be taught is missing from the manuscript. A point worth considering for inclusion is that faculty (and many physicians currently in practice) may have received little if any education about the topic in their own education and training. Thus, they, too, will need to receive help in identifying 1) why this important, and 2) how having a disability affects one’s ability to receive health care. Further, HCP faculty often believe that they are already teaching adequately about disability (if they are reaching about disabling conditions, which is not the same as teaching about disability), so will be reluctant to add or take on another topic. This needs to be considered in the process and the importance of addressing disability emphasized. A point worth considering for inclusion is that faculty (and many physicians currently in practice) may have received little if any education about the topic in their own education and training. Thus, they, too, will need to receive help in identifying 1) why this important, and 2) how having a disability affects one’s ability to receive health care. Further, HCP faculty often believe that they are already teaching adequately about disability (if they are reaching about disabling conditions, which is not the same as teaching about disability), so will be reluctant to add or take on another topic. This needs to be considered in the process and the importance of addressing disability emphasized. If evidence from practice is presented, are all the underlying source data available to ensure full reproducibility? Yes Is the topic of the practical tips discussed accurately in the context of the current literature Yes Are all factual statements correct and adequately supported by citations? Partly Are the conclusions drawn balanced and justified on the basis of the presented arguments? Partly Are arguments sufficiently supported by evidence from the published literature and/or the authors’ practice? Partly Reviewer Expertise: NA I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard, however I have significant reservations, as outlined above. The estimate of prevalence of disability is low. In 2024, the CDC reported 70 million people in USA to have a disability. Thank you for this updated statistic. We have edited the manuscript to reflect the current estimate of 70 million. Document refers to “medical” care; reviewer would suggest use of “health” care as it is more encompassing and does include medical care. We have changed all instances of “medical care” with “healthcare”. Authors state that “Approximately half of American medical schools have a disability curriculum” but say nothing about the quality of those curricula. It seems important to do so as not all curricula are the same. We agree with the reviewer. Unfortunately, we are not aware of any data that would speak to the quality of medical school disability curricula. Quality likely varies and would be an interesting point of study for future work in this area. Tip 1: would change “these factors would be realistically modifiable” to “most of these factors”. We have made this adjustment. Some elaboration of how the steps of Kern’s approach (mentioned at end of Tip 2) would be accomplished would be helpful addition to Tip 1. We have added additional suggestions into Tip 1 for how to utilize PWD effectively into each general phase of the curriculum, including design, implementation, and assessment. For educators who are looking for more detailed ideas regarding implementation of Kern’s approach, his book, Curriculum Development for Medical Education, would be an appropriate source. Tip 3 makes no mention of the largest workforce in health care (nursing workforce); so, it should be mentioned when other healthcare professions are mentioned. Nursing IS mentioned in Tip 4 (once, but discussion is cursory). Thank you for pointing out this important omission. We have added the following statement to Tip 3: “Nurses, who represent the largest workforce within healthcare, play diverse and often front-line roles in the care of PWD.”Tip 6 does not mention family members/caregivers who might be the best informants, especially of individuals with significant IDD or cognitive impairment; so, they should be mentioned as possible informants. This is a great point. We have added the following sentence to Tip 6: “In the context of patients who may have intellectual and developmental disabilities or cognitive impairments, family members and caregivers can serve as valuable teachers in these experiential settings.” Tip 8 should mention that many resources…videos, etc…. can be accessed for education of students. Inclusion of mention of some examples of these resources would likely be helpful. Thank you. We have added a reference to the ADA National Network, which provides a variety of resources on understanding the ADA. Tip 9: Should emphasize that the ADA has legal implications; otherwise, too many health care professionals think of ADA requirements as “nice to know” rather than a legal mandate. We have added a statement to Tip 8 on the importance of students understanding the legal implications of the ADA in their future clinical practices. While the caution about disability simulation experiences was an extremely important addition, another possible negative consequence of these experiences is that “learners” often approach them as a game or a joke. Instead of concluding that having a disability is worse than death (which is the view of too many HCPs), some come away from the experience with the view that it is “not a big deal”. So great caution in using such simulations should be emphasized and PWD must be involved in these simulations. Otherwise, they should be avoided. We agree with the reviewer and have added another statement to Tip 9 emphasizing caution and the inclusion of PWD in any disability simulation to mitigate risks. Tip 12 does not address OB/maternal care, and it must do so as women with disability face ableism to a high degree because HCPs fail to consider them appropriate parents (includes males with disability, too). So it must be mentioned as an area of the curriculum and practice where disability is addressed. This is another great suggestion. We have added a statement to Tip 12 calling for “Thoughtful inclusion of disability awareness should also be incorporated into obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYN) as well as pediatric clerkships in the context of parents who have a disability or parents who will be caring for children with a disability”. Two additional citations were added to support this. An issue not addressed in the 12 tips is what content about disability should be addressed and what competencies should be the goal of medical education. I would recommend that the authors review the Core Competencies developed by the Alliance for Disability in Health Care Education, Inc. (ADHCE). The competencies were developed by an interprofessional, multidisciplinary group of healthcare professionals and individuals with disability. The competencies have been reviewed and endorsed by disability and disability advocacy groups, and major professional organizations, including those from medicine. The National Council on Disability (2022) also endorsed the competencies for use in the education of health care professionals across disciplines. The content of what is or should be taught is missing from the manuscript. While we feel that specifying the exact content and competencies for UME disability education is outside of the scope of this particular 12 tips article and will likely vary between institutions, your point of providing recommended guidance on published competencies is well taken. To that end, we have included the ADHCE as an example of competencies for medical educators to consider when developing their own learning objectives in Tip 2. A point worth considering for inclusion is that faculty (and many physicians currently in practice) may have received little if any education about the topic in their own education and training. Thus, they, too, will need to receive help in identifying 1) why this important, and 2) how having a disability affects one’s ability to receive health care. Further, HCP faculty often believe that they are already teaching adequately about disability (if they are reaching about disabling conditions, which is not the same as teaching about disability), so will be reluctant to add or take on another topic. This needs to be considered in the process and the importance of addressing disability emphasized. This is an important point and one that we agree should be included in the manuscript. We have added the following to the Introduction: “It must be noted that instruction regarding the pathophysiology, diagnosis and management of disabling conditions is not equivalent to instruction regarding disability. Disability awareness involves self-reflection of one’s perceptions around disability and an active role in establishing inclusion for PWD.” The estimate of prevalence of disability is low. In 2024, the CDC reported 70 million people in USA to have a disability. Thank you for this updated statistic. We have edited the manuscript to reflect the current estimate of 70 million. The estimate of prevalence of disability is low. In 2024, the CDC reported 70 million people in USA to have a disability. Thank you for this updated statistic. We have edited the manuscript to reflect the current estimate of 70 million. Document refers to “medical” care; reviewer would suggest use of “health” care as it is more encompassing and does include medical care. We have changed all instances of “medical care” with “healthcare”. Document refers to “medical” care; reviewer would suggest use of “health” care as it is more encompassing and does include medical care. We have changed all instances of “medical care” with “healthcare”. Authors state that “Approximately half of American medical schools have a disability curriculum” but say nothing about the quality of those curricula. It seems important to do so as not all curricula are the same. We agree with the reviewer. Unfortunately, we are not aware of any data that would speak to the quality of medical school disability curricula. Quality likely varies and would be an interesting point of study for future work in this area. Authors state that “Approximately half of American medical schools have a disability curriculum” but say nothing about the quality of those curricula. It seems important to do so as not all curricula are the same. We agree with the reviewer. Unfortunately, we are not aware of any data that would speak to the quality of medical school disability curricula. Quality likely varies and would be an interesting point of study for future work in this area. Tip 1: would change “these factors would be realistically modifiable” to “most of these factors”. We have made this adjustment. Tip 1: would change “these factors would be realistically modifiable” to “most of these factors”. We have made this adjustment. Some elaboration of how the steps of Kern’s approach (mentioned at end of Tip 2) would be accomplished would be helpful addition to Tip 1. We have added additional suggestions into Tip 1 for how to utilize PWD effectively into each general phase of the curriculum, including design, implementation, and assessment. For educators who are looking for more detailed ideas regarding implementation of Kern’s approach, his book, Curriculum Development for Medical Education, would be an appropriate source. Some elaboration of how the steps of Kern’s approach (mentioned at end of Tip 2) would be accomplished would be helpful addition to Tip 1. We have added additional suggestions into Tip 1 for how to utilize PWD effectively into each general phase of the curriculum, including design, implementation, and assessment. For educators who are looking for more detailed ideas regarding implementation of Kern’s approach, his book, Curriculum Development for Medical Education, would be an appropriate source. Tip 3 makes no mention of the largest workforce in health care (nursing workforce); so, it should be mentioned when other healthcare professions are mentioned. Nursing IS mentioned in Tip 4 (once, but discussion is cursory). Thank you for pointing out this important omission. We have added the following statement to Tip 3: “Nurses, who represent the largest workforce within healthcare, play diverse and often front-line roles in the care of PWD.” Tip 3 makes no mention of the largest workforce in health care (nursing workforce); so, it should be mentioned when other healthcare professions are mentioned. Nursing IS mentioned in Tip 4 (once, but discussion is cursory). Thank you for pointing out this important omission. We have added the following statement to Tip 3: “Nurses, who represent the largest workforce within healthcare, play diverse and often front-line roles in the care of PWD.” Tip 6 does not mention family members/caregivers who might be the best informants, especially of individuals with significant IDD or cognitive impairment; so, they should be mentioned as possible informants. This is a great point. We have added the following sentence to Tip 6: “In the context of patients who may have intellectual and developmental disabilities or cognitive impairments, family members and caregivers can serve as valuable teachers in these experiential settings.” Tip 6 does not mention family members/caregivers who might be the best informants, especially of individuals with significant IDD or cognitive impairment; so, they should be mentioned as possible informants. This is a great point. We have added the following sentence to Tip 6: “In the context of patients who may have intellectual and developmental disabilities or cognitive impairments, family members and caregivers can serve as valuable teachers in these experiential settings.” Tip 8 should mention that many resources…videos, etc…. can be accessed for education of students. Inclusion of mention of some examples of these resources would likely be helpful. Thank you. We have added a reference to the ADA National Network, which provides a variety of resources on understanding the ADA. Tip 8 should mention that many resources…videos, etc…. can be accessed for education of students. Inclusion of mention of some examples of these resources would likely be helpful. Thank you. We have added a reference to the ADA National Network, which provides a variety of resources on understanding the ADA. Tip 9: Should emphasize that the ADA has legal implications; otherwise, too many health care professionals think of ADA requirements as “nice to know” rather than a legal mandate. We have added a statement to Tip 8 on the importance of students understanding the legal implications of the ADA in their future clinical practices. Tip 9: Should emphasize that the ADA has legal implications; otherwise, too many health care professionals think of ADA requirements as “nice to know” rather than a legal mandate. We have added a statement to Tip 8 on the importance of students understanding the legal implications of the ADA in their future clinical practices. While the caution about disability simulation experiences was an extremely important addition, another possible negative consequence of these experiences is that “learners” often approach them as a game or a joke. Instead of concluding that having a disability is worse than death (which is the view of too many HCPs), some come away from the experience with the view that it is “not a big deal”. So great caution in using such simulations should be emphasized and PWD must be involved in these simulations. Otherwise, they should be avoided. We agree with the reviewer and have added another statement to Tip 9 emphasizing caution and the inclusion of PWD in any disability simulation to mitigate risks. While the caution about disability simulation experiences was an extremely important addition, another possible negative consequence of these experiences is that “learners” often approach them as a game or a joke. Instead of concluding that having a disability is worse than death (which is the view of too many HCPs), some come away from the experience with the view that it is “not a big deal”. So great caution in using such simulations should be emphasized and PWD must be involved in these simulations. Otherwise, they should be avoided. We agree with the reviewer and have added another statement to Tip 9 emphasizing caution and the inclusion of PWD in any disability simulation to mitigate risks. Tip 12 does not address OB/maternal care, and it must do so as women with disability face ableism to a high degree because HCPs fail to consider them appropriate parents (includes males with disability, too). So it must be mentioned as an area of the curriculum and practice where disability is addressed. This is another great suggestion. We have added a statement to Tip 12 calling for “Thoughtful inclusion of disability awareness should also be incorporated into obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYN) as well as pediatric clerkships in the context of parents who have a disability or parents who will be caring for children with a disability”. Two additional citations were added to support this. Tip 12 does not address OB/maternal care, and it must do so as women with disability face ableism to a high degree because HCPs fail to consider them appropriate parents (includes males with disability, too). So it must be mentioned as an area of the curriculum and practice where disability is addressed. This is another great suggestion. We have added a statement to Tip 12 calling for “Thoughtful inclusion of disability awareness should also be incorporated into obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYN) as well as pediatric clerkships in the context of parents who have a disability or parents who will be caring for children with a disability”. Two additional citations were added to support this. An issue not addressed in the 12 tips is what content about disability should be addressed and what competencies should be the goal of medical education. I would recommend that the authors review the Core Competencies developed by the Alliance for Disability in Health Care Education, Inc. (ADHCE). The competencies were developed by an interprofessional, multidisciplinary group of healthcare professionals and individuals with disability. The competencies have been reviewed and endorsed by disability and disability advocacy groups, and major professional organizations, including those from medicine. The National Council on Disability (2022) also endorsed the competencies for use in the education of health care professionals across disciplines. The content of what is or should be taught is missing from the manuscript. While we feel that specifying the exact content and competencies for UME disability education is outside of the scope of this particular 12 tips article and will likely vary between institutions, your point of providing recommended guidance on published competencies is well taken. To that end, we have included the ADHCE as an example of competencies for medical educators to consider when developing their own learning objectives in Tip 2. An issue not addressed in the 12 tips is what content about disability should be addressed and what competencies should be the goal of medical education. I would recommend that the authors review the Core Competencies developed by the Alliance for Disability in Health Care Education, Inc. (ADHCE). The competencies were developed by an interprofessional, multidisciplinary group of healthcare professionals and individuals with disability. The competencies have been reviewed and endorsed by disability and disability advocacy groups, and major professional organizations, including those from medicine. The National Council on Disability (2022) also endorsed the competencies for use in the education of health care professionals across disciplines. The content of what is or should be taught is missing from the manuscript. While we feel that specifying the exact content and competencies for UME disability education is outside of the scope of this particular 12 tips article and will likely vary between institutions, your point of providing recommended guidance on published competencies is well taken. To that end, we have included the ADHCE as an example of competencies for medical educators to consider when developing their own learning objectives in Tip 2. A point worth considering for inclusion is that faculty (and many physicians currently in practice) may have received little if any education about the topic in their own education and training. Thus, they, too, will need to receive help in identifying 1) why this important, and 2) how having a disability affects one’s ability to receive health care. Further, HCP faculty often believe that they are already teaching adequately about disability (if they are reaching about disabling conditions, which is not the same as teaching about disability), so will be reluctant to add or take on another topic. This needs to be considered in the process and the importance of addressing disability emphasized. This is an important point and one that we agree should be included in the manuscript. We have added the following to the Introduction: “It must be noted that instruction regarding the pathophysiology, diagnosis and management of disabling conditions is not equivalent to instruction regarding disability. Disability awareness involves self-reflection of one’s perceptions around disability and an active role in establishing inclusion for PWD.” A point worth considering for inclusion is that faculty (and many physicians currently in practice) may have received little if any education about the topic in their own education and training. Thus, they, too, will need to receive help in identifying 1) why this important, and 2) how having a disability affects one’s ability to receive health care. Further, HCP faculty often believe that they are already teaching adequately about disability (if they are reaching about disabling conditions, which is not the same as teaching about disability), so will be reluctant to add or take on another topic. This needs to be considered in the process and the importance of addressing disability emphasized. This is an important point and one that we agree should be included in the manuscript. We have added the following to the Introduction: “It must be noted that instruction regarding the pathophysiology, diagnosis and management of disabling conditions is not equivalent to instruction regarding disability. Disability awareness involves self-reflection of one’s perceptions around disability and an active role in establishing inclusion for PWD.” Thank you for the opportunity to review the "12 Tips for Including Disability Awareness within UGME Curricula." The topic is important and an area that must be enhanced in medical school curricula. The authors provide a valuable approach to increasing the topic throughout the curriculum; however, each individual tip could be abbreviated and more focused on one issue; with the provision of at least one concrete example of a learning event included in each tip. Suggested edits to this work are as follows: Abstract: The first two sentences include information which requires citations. Typically, citations must not be included in an abstract as the abstract must be able to stand alone. Perhaps re-wording is needed here so citations are not required. Tip 1: There are multiple tips included in this one tip. Perhaps this first tip should be limited to the concept of "identifying gaps." Tip 2: No recommended edits Tip 3: No recommended edits Tip 4: No recommended edits Tip 5: Comment-This tip is quite similar to Tip 2, regarding the need to include persons with disabilities in the process of creating and embedding learning events throughout the curriculum. Tip 6: The first sentence is somewhat awkward, therefore, can it be reworded? Tip 7: Can the authors provide an example of how equipment could be included in an actual learning event? As is written now ("Having access to various types of wheelchairs during interactive...") it is unclear exactly how to include the equipment in teaching. Tip 8: Can authors provide more guidance and be more specific about where, when and how often the ADA should be incorporated into the curriculum? Tip 9: Main reason for the "partly" rating. The authors must consider adding information about any potential negatives to "placing learners into the shoes" of persons with disabilities, such as discussed in the work of Dr. Arielle Michal Silverman. See citation from 2015. (Ref -1) Tip 10: Authors should provide more detail about where, when and how often to include these open dialogues in the curriculum, and in what format. Tip 11: please see critique of Tip 10. Tip 12: please see critique of Tip 10. The last sentence about residency programs should be deleted, as these tips are for UGME only. If evidence from practice is presented, are all the underlying source data available to ensure full reproducibility? Partly Is the topic of the practical tips discussed accurately in the context of the current literature Yes Are all factual statements correct and adequately supported by citations? Partly Are the conclusions drawn balanced and justified on the basis of the presented arguments? Partly Are arguments sufficiently supported by evidence from the published literature and/or the authors’ practice? Partly Reviewer Expertise: medical education; MD admissions I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard, however I have significant reservations, as outlined above. Thank you for the helpful review of our manuscript. Below is a point-by-point description of revisions based upon your feedback. Abstract: Reviewer Comment: The first two sentences include information which requires citations. Typically, citations must not be included in an abstract as the abstract must be able to stand alone. Response: Perhaps re-wording is needed here so citations are not required. These sentences were re-worded. Reviewer Comment: Tip 1: There are multiple tips included in this one tip. Perhaps this first tip should be limited to the concept of "identifying gaps." Response: We have edited the former Tip 1 (now Tip 2 in the revised manuscript) as “Follow Kern’s six-step method for curriculum development”. While this remains a multi-part process, the overall tip is now condensed into one coherent and well-described process. Reviewer Comment: Tip 2: No recommended edits Tip 3: No recommended edits Tip 4: No recommended edits Reviewer Comment: Tip 5: Comment-This tip is quite similar to Tip 2, regarding the need to include persons with disabilities in the process of creating and embedding learning events throughout the curriculum. Response: ​​​​​​​This tip was edited to clarify the emphasis on the need to include a broad diversity of disability types in curricula. Reviewer Comment: Tip 6: The first sentence is somewhat awkward, therefore, can it be reworded? Response: ​​​​​​​The first sentence was rewritten and integrated to make the paragraph sound more concise. Reviewer Comment: Tip 7: Can the authors provide an example of how equipment could be included in an actual learning event? Response: ​​​​​​​As is written now ("Having access to various types of wheelchairs during interactive...") it is unclear exactly how to include the equipment in teaching. More information was added to demonstrate how equipment can be used versus just having access to it. Reviewer Comment: Tip 8: Can authors provide more guidance and be more specific about where, when and how often the ADA should be incorporated into the curriculum? Response: ​​​​​​​Further information has been included in this Tip regarding how the ADA could be incorporated in the curriculum. We have recommended early exposure to coincide with school or course orientation, when information for students who have disabilities is made available and then longitudinal education as part of clinical skills or learning communities programs. Reviewer Comment: Tip 9: Main reason for the "partly" rating. The authors must consider adding information about any potential negatives to "placing learners into the shoes" of persons with disabilities, such as discussed in the work of Dr. Arielle Michal Silverman. See citation from 2015. (Ref -1) Response: ​​​​​​​Thanks for this helpful suggestion. This information has been added. Reviewer Comment: Tip 10: Authors should provide more detail about where, when and how often to include these open dialogues in the curriculum, and in what format. Response: ​​​​​​​Thank you. While there is no prescription for necessary timing of open dialogue, we have provided a list of options for successful incorporation during the pre-clinical and clinical years of training. We have recommended at least 1 activity in the preclinical phase and several authentic clinical encounters in the third- and fourth-years. Reviewer Comment: Tip 11: please see critique of Tip 10. Response: We have added the following to Tip 11: “Reflective elements can easily be incorporated as part of experiential learning sessions (Tip 9) and open dialogue sessions (Tip 10). Ideally, reflection as a formal or informal learning element should accompany each component of a disability awareness curricular thread. Reviewer Comment: Tip 12: please see critique of Tip 10. The last sentence about residency programs should be deleted, as these tips are for UGME only. Response: ​​​​​​​We have edited Tip 12 to include more specific recommendations around clerkships, acting internships, and advanced clinical electives. We have also removed the last sentence about residency programs as suggested. This 12 tips article summarizes recommendations for building curricula within undergraduate medical education on the topic of disability awareness. While this is undoubtedly an extremely important topic, and the authors are to be commended for tackling it, the tips are currently too general to provide insight into the unique considerations for disability content. In particular, tips 1, 6, 11, and 12, are tips that would apply to any curricular innovation, and is not specific to disability. Therefore, I would recommend either replacing these with more specific and relevant tips to disability curricula, or condensing them into one tip, such as "follow Kern's method for curriculum development." In addition, and most importantly, one of the most important aspects of developing curriculum on caring for patients with disabilities is not listed as a tip; it is essential that persons with disabilities be included in the design of the curriculum. In my opinion, this must be included as a tip in any perspective piece about building curricula on disability awareness. If evidence from practice is presented, are all the underlying source data available to ensure full reproducibility? Yes Is the topic of the practical tips discussed accurately in the context of the current literature Partly Are all factual statements correct and adequately supported by citations? Yes Are the conclusions drawn balanced and justified on the basis of the presented arguments? Partly Are arguments sufficiently supported by evidence from the published literature and/or the authors’ practice? Partly Reviewer Expertise: Curriculum development, health systems science, systems-based practice, disability education I confirm that I have read this submission and believe that I have an appropriate level of expertise to confirm that it is of an acceptable scientific standard, however I have significant reservations, as outlined above. Thank you for the helpful review of our manuscript. We have re-titled the former Tip 1 (now Tip 2 in the revised manuscript) as “Follow Kern’s six-step method for curriculum development” and reworked this section to include each of the six phases described in his book. We do not feel that Tips 6 (Include a variety of pedagogies, emphasizing experiential learning), 11 (Embed reflective elements), and 12 (Create longitudinal experiences) fit precisely within Kern’s model, yet are important in the context of disability awareness promotion. Therefore, we have elected to keep those as separate and unique tips to highlight their importance. The title and focus of the former Tip 2 is “Embed PWD into all phases of the curriculum”. We agree wholeheartedly with the reviewer that persons with disabilities MUST be included in the planning, design, implementation, and evaluation of a disability awareness curriculum. We have elevated this to Tip 1 in the revised manuscript and replaced the abbreviation “PWD” from the title with “persons with disabilities” to accentuate this tip and highlight its importance.