Inactivation of bacteria using synergistic hydrogen peroxide with split-dose nanosecond pulsed electric field exposures Authors: Zachary Rosenzweig, Jerrick Garcia, Gary L. Thompson, Lark J. Perez, Helen Onyeaka, Helen Onyeaka, Helen Onyeaka Published: 2024 ABSTRACT The use of pulsed electric fields (PEF) as a nonthermal technology for the decontamination of foods is of growing interest. This study aimed to enhance the inactivation of Escherichia coli, Listeria innocua, and Salmonella enterica in Gomori buffer using a combination of nsPEF and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2). Three sub-MIC concentrations (0.1, 0.3, and 0.5%) of H2O2 and various contact times ranging from 5–45 min were tested. PEF exposures as both single (1000 pulse) and split-dose (500+500 pulse) trains were delivered via square-wave, monopolar, 600 ns pulses at 21 kV/cm and 10 Hz. We demonstrate that >5 log CFU/mL reduction can be attained from combination PEF/H2O2 treatments with a 15 min contact time for E. coli (0.1%) and a 30 min contact time for L. innocua and S. enterica (0.5%), despite ineffective results from either individual treatment alone. A 5 log reduction in microbial population is generally the lowest acceptable level in consideration of food safety and represents inactivation of 99.999% of bacteria. Split-dose PEF exposures enhance lethality for several tested conditions, indicating greater susceptibility to PEF after oxidative damage has occurred. Introduction The decontamination of microbes in/on food products remains a global challenge [1]. Bacterial pathogens that are present can cause human illness or disease outbreaks resulting in significant financial and societal costs [2]. The most common strategies for decontamination of food products can be broadly classified as physical or chemical decontamination methods [3]. Physical methods for disinfection include treatment with heat, non-ionizing radiation, filtration, or electrical fields [4]. Chemical methods of disinfection involve treatment with a broad range of chemicals including alcohol, hypochlorite, hydrogen peroxide, and ozone. No single method exists for microbial decontamination of all food products, however, and the development of novel disinfection methods represents an important area of research and development. The application of non-thermal combination treatments for the disinfection of food products represents an especially promising area of research to preserve raw food characteristics, especially in cases for which synergistic effects are identified for the combination treatments [1, 5, 6]. Pulsed electric fields (PEFs) use short (typically μs-ms), high-voltage pulses that generate an electric field between at least two electrodes [4]. From exposure to the applied electric field, biological cells will experience a rise in their transmembrane voltage to a critical value after a characteristic charging time (τm), where pores are formed thereafter [7]. At sufficiently high intensities, these pores can fail to reseal, inducing cell death, in what is known as irreversible electroporation (IRE) [8, 9]. IRE has been used in food processing for bacterial inactivation in milk [10, 11], juices [12–14], and water [15, 16], among other media. PEF offers several advantages for food treatment over other technologies. Aside from intense exposures, PEF is a nonthermal technology, so food qualities like color, taste, texture, and nutritional composition are conserved [17]. Short processing times are required and exposures can be done in continuous flow so there is an easy implementation into existing processing lines [18]. There is also potential for the biosynthesis of vital compounds like polyphenols and carotenoids after PEF exposures [19]. There is a need for improved decontaminating technologies, as foodborne illness still affects around 600 million people and causes 420,000 deaths worldwide each year [20]. Among outbreaks involving bacteria in the United States, Escherichia coli (E. coli), Salmonella, and Listeria are three of the leading causes [21, 22]. PEF applied using pulses of nanosecond duration (nsPEF) have been recently investigated for lethal applications such as tumor ablation [23–26], electrochemotherapy [27–29], bacterial inactivation in biofilms [30] or in their planktonic state [11, 31], and the inactivation of other biological agents like viruses [32, 33]. Because of the short pulse durations, sublethal nsPEF exposures are easily attainable and several applications for them exist as well, which often involve cell stimulation or triggering of biochemical pathways for quicker or enhanced processes [19, 34]. When delivering pulses in the nanosecond range, it is important to take note of τm, which will increase with cell radius and decrease with higher extracellular conductivity [7]. At pulse durations (tp) sufficiently above the charging time, around 2–10 times longer for efficient electroporation [35], the traditional mechanism of electroporation is observed. However, at tp below τm, intracellular contents may be disrupted instead of the outer membrane [9, 36, 37]. The short-circuiting effect of the membrane capacitance allows for penetration of the electric field to inner parts of the cell at high frequencies, typically in the MHz range [38]. In order for these effects to be seen, much higher field strengths are required than those for traditional electroporation [39, 40]. Pulses of ns duration, regardless of mechanism, will require higher field strengths for significant levels of inactivation to be observed in comparison to pulses of μs or ms duration, since longer pulse durations result in more lethal exposures, even when applied for the same total treatment times [41]. In theory, the required electric field strength to reduce an E. coli population by 1 log using a single monopolar 600 ns pulse is ~70 kV/cm, compared to ~ 10 kV/cm for a 100 μs pulse [7], though delivering a train of successive pulses will increase treatment efficacy [42]. For example, Martens et al. observe ~ 1 log reduction of E. coli using 1,000 monopolar 600 ns pulses at 13.5 kV/cm or 100 pulses at 18.5 kV/cm [31]. The correlation between increasing treatment efficacy with increasing the total number of applied pulses may be dependent on several factors. Silve et al. propose an electrodesensitization theory, in which existing, conductive pores formed in the beginning portion of a train of pulses will inhibit further charging of the membrane, thus desensitizing cells to following pulses and decreasing the efficacy of the latter portion of an exposure [43]. This has been shown with applied pulses to Salmonella Typhimurium, where increased treatment time correlates to a more lethal treatment, and upon a threshold value, begins to tail off, losing its efficacy [44]. The electrosensitization theory, on the other hand, proposes that cells are sensitized to subsequent pulses [45], and more effective treatments using split-dose deliveries on mammalian cells are noted in several studies [45–48]. The efficacy of extended or delayed treatments appears to be dependent on the state of the membrane and cell post-exposure. One distinct advantage that nanosecond pulses can offer compared to those on the micro- and millisecond timescale is lower energy input per pulse, which translates to lower costs and temperature rises [49]. Although more challenging, it is desirable in these regards to reduce the necessary power output to achieve similar effects. Another key advantage is the limiting of electrolysis, which typically occurs for water at pulse durations > 10 μs [50] and will protect both adverse changes in quality/composition to the treated sample and increase the lifespan of the electrodes through diminished corrosion and fouling [51]. Complicating these features are reduced efficacy of the treatments in achieving bacterial disinfection standards, commonly defined as ≥5-log reduction in colony forming units (equal to inactivation of 99.999% of bacteria in the sample). Traditional PEF exposures involve a single train of pulses being delivered to a suspension. Split-dose exposures deliver half of the pulses, and then after a delay, the other half are applied. The same total energy is being delivered, but by using split-dose PEF, a delayed sensitization to the second train of pulses can be induced and can provide PEF treatments of similar or greater efficacy using lower voltages or doses [46, 48]. This can reduce operating costs, allow for greater electrode spacing, and limit ohmic heating, among other benefits. Despite the potential advantages only one study to date describes the application of split-dose PEF for the inactivation of bacteria [44], which does not investigate effects in combination with an additive. Recent innovations to improve nsPEF lethality include combination of this treatment with chemical disinfectants. Some studies include the investigation of chemical additives including antibiotics [52], bacteriocins [53], and carboxylic acids [54]. These papers note increased permeability after PEF allows for higher amounts of disinfectant to target intracellular contents, which is especially useful when diffusion across the membrane is low or nonexistent for viable cells. While selected chemical additives were found to be synergistic in bacterial inactivation, other treatments were not; suggesting that the identification of desirable synergistic effects for the combination treatment protocols are dependent on a complex combination of factors [4, 52–54]. One chemical disinfectant that has drawn interest of late as an alternative to current measures is hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), which has already been approved by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for different food applications such as milk treatment in cheesemaking [55, 56]. Selected additional recent applications of H2O2 as a disinfectant in food production includes the pasteurization of dairy and eggs [57–59], decontamination of meat products [60–62], fruits/vegetables [63–66], and drinking water treatment [67–70]. Two of hydrogen peroxide’s major disadvantages are that high concentrations are typically required for disinfection and low activity can be noted when in an environment with catalase-producing bacteria [71]. By combining this disinfectant with PEF, we aim to alleviate both of these issues by facilitating hydrogen peroxide’s mechanism of action against microbes through pore formation, lowering the required bactericidal concentration and exposing a greater amount of H2O2 to cells before decomposition via catalase. One ongoing challenge to employing H2O2 as disinfectant is the observation of undesired impacts on food products at concentrations suitable for disinfection resulting in fruit and vegetable browning, bleaching, and other negative effects. Catalase enzyme washes and other methods can be employed to limit these effects [72–74]. Current processes employing hydrogen peroxide as an antimicrobial agent vary in their maximal allowed treatment concentrations. For example, milk may be treated with up to 0.05% and starch up to 0.15% (21CFR184.1366) in accordance with the FDA. In almost all cases, hydrogen peroxide must be removed using proper chemical or physical methods. Residual H2O2 in food packaging may not exceed 0.5 ppm (21CFR178) in accordance with the FDA. In addition to direct food applications, H2O2 could serve as a biocide for irrigation water [75]. Multiple outbreaks in recent years have occurred where irrigation water was identified as a potential source [76, 77]. Waste and surface water are economically feasible sources for irrigation that will often need to be treated in accordance with the new Codex standard (XG 100–2023) to reduce contamination risks. H2O2 is considered to be generally recognized as safe (GRAS) because of its eventual degradation into water and oxygen [78] so its environmental impact is limited. It offers many advantages as a sanitizing agent, including lack of toxicity, limited changes to food properties, and no color or odor, among others [71]. In current processes employing hydrogen peroxide as a chemical disinfectant, one of the most common concentrations used for microbial inactivation is 3% (w/v) [79, 80]. H2O2 is used in nonfood-related applications as well. For example, H2O2 has been investigated for its use in decontaminating therapeutic pool waters to decrease the risk to bathers’ health [81]. We hypothesize that by employing PEF in combination with H2O2, it will lower the required amount of oxidant needed and will increase the effectiveness of the treatment for inactivation of bacteria. Herein, we describe our investigations of a widely applicable methodology for the combination of chemical disinfection using hydrogen peroxide with nsPEF. We describe an optimized combination treatment effective for the inactivation of several bacteria species. This study further demonstrates the synergistic effects between split-dose and traditional nsPEF exposures in combination with sub-inhibitory (less than 0.5% w/v) concentrations of hydrogen peroxide. Accordingly, our investigations provide guidance for the inactivation of bacteria in Gomori buffer with the administration of exceptionally low concentrations of H2O2. Results PEF treatment profile We evaluated nsPEF sequences up to 3000P for inactivation of E. coli, L. innocua, and S. enterica. In this experiment, we observed dose dependent increase in bacterial disinfection correlated to number of pulses approaching a plateau of maximal reduction in bacterial CFU at ~1000P (S1 Fig). The plateau of maximal efficacy of nsPEF is genera dependent. The greatest effect for this treatment is observed for E. coli, resulting in 0.87±0.08 log CFU reduction for 1000P. The nsPEF treatment was less effective for L. innocua and S. enterica, providing log CFU reductions of 0.13±0.06 and 0.25±0.04 (P<0.0001) for these genera, respectively. This is in agreeance with the commonly noted ‘tailing’ effect in inactivation curves when increasing the number of applied pulses [44, 82]. Accordingly, we focused our attention on the identification of a combination treatment for bacterial disinfection employing a PEF pulse sequence of 1000 total pulses. H2O2 disinfectant profile We sought to establish the dose-dependent reduction of bacterial CFU under the experimental conditions employed in this study for H2O2. The different bacterial species evaluated show different dose-dependent effects. We find that H2O2 shows the greatest potency against E. coli and causes greater changes in viability with lower concentrations and contact times. S. enterica and L. innocua are more resistant to H2O2 and show little to no reduction in viability from our employed concentrations (0.5%, 0.3%, and 0.1%). At concentrations ≥ 1%, viability changes drastically. EC50 values were determined to be 0.96% H2O2 for E. coli after 15 min, 0.58% H2O2 for S. enterica after 45 min, and 0.87% H2O2 for L. innocua after 45 min. For the tested contact times, a 5-log reduction is reached after incubation in 2% H2O2 for E. coli and L. innocua and in 1% H2O2 for S. enterica (S2 Fig). For combination studies with PEF, we selected three H2O2 concentrations below the EC50 value for treatment with H2O2 alone. PEF combined with H2O2 Three variables are examined to improve inactivation efficiency of our combination treatment: contact time, H2O2 concentration, and PEF exposure type. These variables were systematically evaluated for the inactivation of E. coli, L. innocua, and S. enterica (Table 1). For each treatment condition triplicate analysis was performed with good reproducibility. Greater variability is noted in selected examples in which the treatment conditions were less effective, under maximally effective treatment conditions no bacterial growth was observed in any of the replicates after 16-32h incubation on LB agar plates. We observe statistically significant impact from both changes in PEF and incubation time at each concentration of H2O2 evaluated. Graphical representation of this data, including representation of statistical differences from two-way ANOVA and Tukey’s multiple comparisons test, are included in Fig 1. The full tabulated statistical analysis is included in the Supplemental (S2 Table). Log CFU reduction of E. coli, L. innocua, and S. enterica varying pulsing conditions, contact times, and concentrations of hydrogen peroxide. Data presented as average of triplicate analysis with error bars representing standard deviation. Statistical differences from Tukey’s multiple comparisons test are presented as (ns) P > 0.05, * P < 0.05, ** P < 0.01, *** P < 0.001, **** P < 0.0001. 10.1371/journal.pone.0311232.t001Table 1Bacterial inactivation of E. coli, L. innocua, and S. enterica based on CFU determination. Escherichia coli % H2O2Contact Time0Pa1000Pb500+500Pc0.15 min0.01±0.062.40±0.202.56±0.160.110 min0.09±0.162.88±0.053.28±0.580.115 min0.22±0.073.69±0.86 5.80±0.01 0.35 min0.09±0.082.03±0.122.09±0.130.310 min0.24±0.022.56±0.594.73±1.240.315 min0.76±0.09 5.52±0.49 5.64±0.28 0.55 min0.23±0.011.37±0.091.72±0.180.510 min1.24±0.073.75±0.974.31±0.440.515 min2.48±0.47 5.80±0.00 d 5.80±0.00 d Listeria innocua 0.15 min0.16±0.070.22±0.070.27±0.100.110 min0.09±0.050.22±0.020.59±0.110.115 min0.18±0.040.29±0.070.70±0.070.130 min0.02±0.020.68±0.131.50±0.150.145 min0.01±0.040.76±0.061.59±0.060.35 min0.13±0.050.29±0.020.40±0.050.310 min0.10±0.030.49±0.131.51±0.460.315 min0.14±0.030.60±0.051.77±0.180.330 min0.02±0.022.87±0.552.98±0.310.345 min0.08±0.02 5.70±0.47 5.56±0.81 0.55 min0.09±0.050.31±0.120.39±0.070.510 min0.02±0.020.40±0.271.99±0.180.515 min0.03±0.041.18±0.322.75±0.170.530 min0.08±0.06 6.24±0.00 d 5.91±0.58 0.545 min0.12±0.04 6.24±0.00 d 6.24±0.00 d Salmonella enterica 0.15 min0.04±0.010.41±0.030.36±0.060.110 min0.02±0.010.37±0.110.77±0.050.115 min0.03±0.020.49±0.071.19±0.570.130 min0.03±0.060.49±0.161.93±0.360.145 min0.00±0.060.75±0.042.27±0.130.35 min0.03±0.010.17±0.020.36±0.080.310 min0.04±0.060.52±0.271.66±0.450.315 min0.05±0.030.96±0.262.54±0.110.330 min0.03±0.042.27±0.142.80±0.410.345 min0.05±0.034.96±0.153.40±0.190.55 min0.01±0.020.45±0.060.44±0.080.510 min0.03±0.021.91±1.121.90±0.490.515 min0.02±0.043.05±0.662.65±0.160.530 min0.10±0.04 5.95±0.17 4.60±0.160.545 min0.89±0.02 5.72±0.58 5.89±0.27 All data is reported as average log reduction in bacterial CFU of triplicate analysis with error representing standard deviation. Conditions resulting in > 5-log reduction in CFU are shown in bold.a No PEF performed.b Single train PEF treatment.c Split-dose PEF treatment.dNo bacterial colonies observed in any of the replicates during enumeration following treatment. Bacterial inactivation of E. coli, L. innocua, and S. enterica based on CFU determination. All data is reported as average log reduction in bacterial CFU of triplicate analysis with error representing standard deviation. Conditions resulting in > 5-log reduction in CFU are shown in bold. a No PEF performed. b Single train PEF treatment. c Split-dose PEF treatment. dNo bacterial colonies observed in any of the replicates during enumeration following treatment. Evaluation of disinfection for each bacterial species with H2O2 or PEF alone compared to the combination treatment demonstrates the significant benefit for the combination treatment (Fig 2). Indeed, for each of the bacterial species evaluated the combination of PEF and low concentrations of H2O2 provided synergistic levels of bacterial inactivation. Comparison of inactivation using individual treatments and the combination H2O2/PEF treatment. All data represents the average of triplicate analysis, error bars represent standard deviation. Statistical significance from Tukey’s multiple comparisons test; (ns) P > 0.05, * P < 0.05, ** P < 0.01, *** P < 0.001, **** P < 0.0001a E. coli treatment conditions: 0.1% H2O2, 15 min contact time, split-dose PEF (500+500P). b L. innocua treatment conditions: 0.3% H2O2, 45 min contact time, split-dose PEF (500+500P). c S. enterica treatment conditions: 0.5% H2O2, 45 min contact time, split-dose PEF (500+500P). The effectiveness of PEF treatments varies between the different bacteria, however it is impacted in a dose-dependent manner correlated to contact time for all bacterial species evaluated. E. coli reaches a 5 log reduction after 15 min at 0.1% H2O2 with only the split-dose exposure but does so for both exposure types after the same contact time at higher concentrations (0.3% and 0.5% H2O2). Split-dose exposures show significant increases of inactivation compared to single trains after 15 min at 0.1% H2O2 and 10 min at 0.3% H2O2 but displays similar effectiveness at 0.5% H2O2 for all examined contact times. Of note, E. coli is the most susceptible to hydrogen peroxide of the three bacteria in this study in the absence of PEF. While less than 1 log reduction inactivation is found for L. innocua and S. enterica at any concentration of H2O2 without PEF treatment, E. coli is reduced by 0.8 and 2.5 log at 0.3% and 0.5% H2O2, respectively, after 15 min. Unlike with E. coli, a 5 log reduction is not achieved at 0.1% H2O2 for either of the other bacteria evaluated in this study. We find that L. innocua and S. enterica both require minimally 0.3% H2O2 and longer contact times to reach this level of disinfection. L. innocua and S. enterica do however follow a similar trend to E. coli with enhanced effect of split-dose PEF for contact times below 30 minutes (Fig 2). At these shorter contact times for these two bacteria, less than 5 log reduction in CFU is observed. Additionally, for these contact times we observe enhanced disinfection in the samples treated with the split-dose PEF treatments by comparison to the single-dose PEF treatment. By contrast, with longer contact times the additional effect of the split-dose PEF becomes less prominent and similar levels of log CFU reduction are observed for contact times of 30 and 45 minutes with the single-dose and split-dose PEF. Interestingly, for S. enterica, certain treatments show the opposite effect to the trend of enhanced reduction of bacterial load with the split-dose PEF. Specifically, at 0.3% H2O2 and a contact time of 45 min the split dose PEF treatment achieves only 3.4 log reduction in CFU whereas the single dose PEF provides 5 log reduction. Similarly, at a concentration of 0.5% H2O2 and a contact time of 30 min, split-dose PEF results in 4.6 log reduction while the single dose PEF gives 6 log reduction. To evaluate effects on cell structure, bulk effects on cell shape or aggregation during the treatments, selected samples were evaluated by transmission light microscopy. No cell clumping or obvious morphological changes to the cell structures were observed under conditions leading to partial disinfection (S3 Fig). Electrosensitization For E. coli and L. innocua we observe enhanced disinfection for treatments employing the split-dose PEF (500+500 pulses) compared to the single-dose PEF (1000 pulses) at all concentrations of H2O2 (Fig 1). By contrast, disinfection of S. enterica cultures were not universally enhanced by split-dose PEF. To evaluate the effect of the single-dose compared to the split-dose PEF treatments we evaluated the impact of PEF delay time on bacterial viability in the absence of H2O2 (Fig 3). As anticipated, E. coli susceptibility is correlated with increased delays between PEF trains, with a maximum inactivation increase of around 40% after a 30 min delay. S. enterica and L. innocua show much greater resistance to PEF treatments in general. Despite this, L. innocua appears to display higher sensitivity to the exposures with an increasing delay reaching a maximal sensitivity at 27 min. S. enterica does not appear to display any relationship between lethality enhancement and exposure delay. Change in log reductions of different bacteria after varying time delays between two trains of 500, 600 ns pulses at 21 kV/cm in the absence of H2O2. The delay times between trains of PEF were selected to correlate with the contact times evaluated for combination treatments. A delay time of 0 represents a single train of 1000 pulses. Data is presented as the average of triplicate analysis with error bars representing standard deviation. Statistical differences from one-way ANOVA are presented as (ns) P > 0.05, * P < 0.05, ** P < 0.01, *** P < 0.001, **** P < 0.0001. Discussion Hydrogen peroxide can function as an effective bactericidal agent because of its strong oxidating properties. The formation of short-lived hydroxyl radicals occurs most commonly because of the Fenton reaction [83, 84], which involves the oxidation of Fe2+ by H2O2. Although particularly reactive with iron, hydrogen peroxide can be reduced by other transition metals as well, such as copper [85]. Electrode material can therefore play an important role in catalyzing this reaction and be susceptible to degradation. The use of aluminum electrodes in this study, however, has a negligible effect on H2O2. Aluminum is one of the most compatible materials with H2O2, even at high concentrations [86], because of an aluminum oxide layer that forms and prevents corrosion of the metal [87]. With a compatible electrode material and a buffer consisting of no added transition metal ions, the H2O2 reduction must be catalyzed by bioavailable ions. It is estimated that a third of all proteins contain metal [88] and 40% of enzymes with known structures are metal-dependent [89]. While most of the total metal content within a bacterium cell is bounded, free metal ions also exist on the μM scale [90]. H2O2 will specifically oxidize enzymes and proteins complexed to iron in addition to Fe2+ ions within the labile pool [91]. Hydroxyl radicals have been shown to be effective for microbial decontamination in food processing settings [92, 93]. Pore formation from PEF will cause either the efflux of intracellular contents or the influx of H2O2, exposing the chemical to a much higher concentration of metal ions compared with diffusion. The quicker formation of hydroxyl radicals will generate more significant damage to the surrounding proteins, enzymes, lipids, and DNA [84, 85, 91, 94]. Based on this, hydrogen peroxide would ideally be added to a production line soon before PEF exposures. This maximizes H2O2 uptake into cells through pores and minimizes the amount molecules that are degraded by catalase. The observed results strongly support the application of split-dose PEF for bacterial inactivation. Previous work [44] had examined the application of split-dose micro-second pulses for the inactivation of S. Typhimurium. Here, we expand on this finding demonstrating a strategy for the enhancement of PEF efficacy without increasing the applied energy by employing split-dose nanosecond pulses in combination with H2O2. In our study, split-dose treatments increase PEF efficiency in both Gram-positive and Gram-negative strains. The observed broad spectrum antimicrobial effects suggest a general mechanism of action for the treatment, however, the electrosensitization phenomenon alone does not explain the higher reductions seen in many instances when combined with H2O2. Lipid peroxidation is a result of reactive oxygen species (ROS), e.g., hydroxyl radicals, interacting with biomembranes, and is associated with increased membrane fluidity [95–97]. PEF exposures are often more effective at higher temperatures where membrane fluidity is also increased [98–100]. Although it is proposed that alterations in PEF resistance is more complex than simply examining changes in fluidity [98, 99], it may be a contributing factor. Future studies should incorporate scanning electron microscopy to assess membrane alterations. In a general sense, we hypothesize that oxidative damage to the membrane structure induces greater susceptibility to PEF [101]. There may be a relationship, however, between contact time and hydrogen peroxide concentration for the effectiveness of split-dose nsPEF treatments (Fig 4). Efficacy of these exposures vary, appearing to tail with time in some instances and insufficiently boost inactivation compared to their single train counterparts in others. Based on this study, some patterns can be identified that appear to be species independent. For combination treatments involving 0.1% H2O2 (Fig 4, blue) increasing benefit for split-dose treatments is observed with increasing contact times. For treatments with 0.3% H2O2 (Fig 4, green) we observe initially increasing benefit for split-dose nsPEF with increasing contact times. However at longer contact times this effect returns to zero, or in the case of S. enterica shifts to a benefit for the single-train nsPEF at the longest contact time. For treatments with 0.5% H2O2 (Fig 4, black), a pattern is less apparent. While E. coli treatments show equally effective disinfection with both single-train and split-dose nsPEF at 0.5% H2O2, L. innocua displays a polymodal profile similar to this bacteria with 0.3% H2O2 and S. enterica appears to display an inversion of this polymodal profile, initially showing enhanced potency of single-train before returning to no difference between nsPEF treatments. Difference in log CFU reductions in bacterial load between split-dose (SD) and single train (ST) exposures for bacteria. Positive values represent enhanced log CFU reduction for split-dose PEF compared to single train exposures, negative values represent enhanced log CFU reduction for single train PEF exposures compared to split-dose exposures. While evidence suggests oxidative damage aids in enhancing susceptibility to PEF exposures, longer H2O2 exposures may be inducing morphological effects that actuate the contrary. Significant reductions in volume have been shown for E. coli at H2O2 concentrations > 10 mM [102]. It is well known that smaller cells have less susceptibility to PEF due to decreased exposure areas [103]. Higher concentrations and longer contact times may sufficiently shrink cells to raise the electroporation threshold and increase resistance to treatments. Reduction in cell volume may also improve cellular ability to regenerate outer layer damages [104]. Oxidative damage is also linked to membrane depolarization [105, 106]. During an electric pulse, cell membranes will be hyperpolarized at the side facing the anode and depolarized at the side facing the cathode [107], where under hyperpolarizing conditions, larger pore size [108] and density [109] are noted. With nsPEF exposures already lacking production of large pore formation [110], inhibition or delay of hyperpolarization on the anodic facing portion of the membrane could further prompt a population of smaller pores or less pores all together, increasing likelihood for survival. Clumping of microbes may also reduce the effectiveness of PEF exposures [82] although that does not appear to be an influence in this study based to our observations with light microscopy (S3 Fig). In general, Gram-positive bacteria show greater resistance to PEF exposures than Gram-negative [111–114]. Our observations are consistent with this when comparing E. coli and L. innocua, so a lesser degree of H2O2 uptake may be part of the reason longer contact times are required to achieve sufficient log reductions in L. innocua. The thicker peptidoglycan layer of the Gram-positive L. innocua may also quench hydroxyl radical production [115]. Listeria has also been shown to have greater catalase activity than E. coli [116], so a greater chance exists that hydrogen peroxide is quenched by this enzyme, thereby preventing hydroxyl radical formation. S. enterica may be showing greater PEF resistance due to a greater membrane charging time constant. Although, as previously stated, larger cells are more susceptible to PEF exposures, in a low conductivity buffer, and with pulses of ns duration, charging time becomes a more prominent factor in determining extent of electroporation. The calculated τm for E. coli is 66 ns, about 9.1x less than the pulse duration used in this study. For S. enterica the calculated τm is more than double E. coli’s, and only about 4.4x the pulse duration. 95% membrane charging capacity is not achieved until ~ 3τm [34], so it is anticipated that E. coli is charged at a higher capacity for longer than S. enterica possibly explaining the diminished PEF efficiency against the latter. L. innocua and S. enterica display similar resistances to PEF in this study, as well as comparable reductions in populations amongst different concentrations and contact times. Taken together, our data supports the hypothesis that the extent of pore formation is a major consideration for the efficacy of combination treatments of hydrogen peroxide and nsPEF. While higher bacteria innoculation would not be expected to result in less effective PEF exposures [117], it could affect the activity of H2O2. L. innocua and S. enterica, were inoculated at higher initial bacteria populations compared to E. coli (108 vs. 107 CFU initial inoculations), so H2O2 availability to cells may decrease and total catalase in solution could increase. This could also be a factor, in addition to PEF efficiency, for why longer contact times and higher concentrations of hydrogen peroxide are required for effective inactivation to be noted for L. innocua and S. enterica compared to E. coli. Pore resealing occurs in three stages: rapid reduction in size (μs–ms), slower reduction to a size of about 0.5 nm (min), and complete closure (min–h) [118]. At higher frequencies, pulses may be delivered too quickly for proper resealing and for sensitization to develop. Enhanced lethality is observed with treatment delays of a few minutes for mammalian cells, going as low as 30 s [48]. The required delay will depend on post-exposure conditions, such as temperature and suspension media, which will dictate resealing kinetics. Factors for why sensitization occurs can include energy expenditure after pore resealing, altered cell physiology, oxidative damage, cytoskeleton rearrangement, or swelling [45, 101, 119, 120]. Delso et al. attribute delayed sensitization primarily to the cellular ability to reseal pores in varying conditions for Gram-negative S. enterica [44]. The rigidity and stability of the outer peptidoglycan layer of Gram-positive bacteria may inhibit structural changes contributing to sensitization of Gram-negative bacteria. A lesser extent of pore formation may also prevent osmotic swelling and prevent volumetric changes [121]. Electrosensitization likely occurs due to a multitude of factors, and the mitigation of some could be reasoning for a longer required delay. In this study, we find that both S. enterica and L. innocua exhibit reduced electrosensitization compared to E. coli. PEF resistance is greater amongst these two strains, indicating that the first train needs to be sufficiently intense for the second to benefit. Delaying PEF treatment appears to not have a considerable effect in heightening the effectiveness of unfavorable pulsing parameters (in terms of lethality). Beyond studies of the rate of pore formation, pore resealing kinetics and their role in electrosensitization for Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria, represents an important area for future investigations, especially using sub-μs pulses at higher field strengths. While increased temperature can greatly impact bacterial survival on its own, it can also enhance the biocidal activity of H2O2 by reducing necessary exposure times [122]. The role of Joule heating in this study, however, appears to be negligible based on COMSOL modeling with experimental validation. The PEF conditions employed in this study are observed to elevate temperature inside the cuvette by <2°C from ambient temperature (~23°C). Given that these bacteria are cultured at 37°C, the observed temperature increase from PEF is insignificant with respect to bacterial viability in this study. Not surprisingly, we find that PEF alone is ineffective at bacterial inactivation (Fig 2). Other studies have combined technologies with hydrogen peroxide addition. UV light was shown to be ineffective within the range of H2O2 concentrations tested (0.003–0.015%) [123], cold atmospheric pressure plasma jet did not note a 5 log reduction with higher H2O2 concentrations of < 1.0% H2O2 [124], and ultrasound was unable to attain a 5 log reduction in combination with 0.3% H2O2 [125]. The conductivity of the buffer employed in our studies is comparable to tap water, further enhancing the potential application of this technology in the food industry, especially for bacterial decontamination of plant cells with harder shells that can withstand high intensity, monopolar treatments, like seeds. PEF has been shown to be effective for this treatment on several seed types, including lettuce and arugula [126]. The use of this technology may also serve as a viable option in wastewater treatment [127, 128]. Using H2O2 would reduce unwanted byproducts compared to other water treatment techniques like chlorination [16]. Leveraging the disinfection strength of the described split-dose nanosecond PEF/H2O2 treatment conditions may also enable control of resistant cell types including bacterial spores [129, 130]. PEF treatment alone has been shown to be ineffective against bacterial spores [131] however ≥1% H2O2 in combination with other treatments has been observed to be sporicidal [132, 133]. Future studies exploring the sporicidal activity of the H2O2/PEF treatment described in this manuscript and potential applications in wastewater treatment are warranted [16, 81]. In summary we demonstrate a combination hydrogen peroxide/nsPEF methodology for the treatment of bacterial contamination. We demonstrate strong synergy between the combination treatments resulting in highly effective decontamination of multiple bacterial species (S7 Fig). The optimized methodology requires the addition of only low (down to 0.1% w/v) concentrations of the GRAS additive hydrogen peroxide to provide up to 5 log reduction in bacterial CFU. We hypothesize that oxidative damage from the addition of low concentrations of H2O2 increases bacterial susceptibility to PEF exposures. However, we note that this effect does appear to elicit a tolerance that is dependent on both contact time and H2O2 concentration. We, for the first time, demonstrate that split-dose nanosecond exposures enhance efficacy of the PEF treatment in both gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria. In this study we further characterize the significance of delay time between pulse trains. The biomolecular cause for the species-specific impact of delay time between PEF represents an important area for future investigations. We observe that increasing the delay time between nsPEF results in greater reduction in CFU for L. innocua and E. coli however this effect was not observed for S. enterica. Combination of nsPEF and low concentrations of hydrogen peroxide appears to be a promising procedure for decontamination, enabling lower energy exposures of PEF and significantly decreased hydrogen peroxide concentrations. Future investigations for applications of this technology for food products will most likely have higher conductivities than the Gomori buffer as we employ in our studies. Changes to the conductivity of the matrix will require reoptimization of treatment conditions as changes in matrix conductivity is expected to impact the efficacy of PEF. Applications in systems with conductivities greater than Gomori buffer should lower the outer membrane charging times and thereby increase the efficacy of nsPEF treatments. The critical transmembrane potential for pore formation to occur is not reached until after a characteristic charging time constant [134]. After the membrane is charged, structures destabilize and pores form and expand [135]. This can greatly alter exposure effects in the ns regime, which often operate using pulse durations near the membrane charging time. As external conductivity increases, membrane charging time decreases [8], and so ns pulses are more likely to operate sufficiently above the charging time that can induce efficient electroporation (~2–10 times higher [35]). We note that increased conductivity would result in increased current/energy inputs and greater temperature increases with PEF and therefore may require additional engineering considerations for application [51]. The quality of food products may also be impacted by hydrogen peroxide, although the demonstrated use of very low H2O2 concentrations is anticipated to mitigate this effect. Finally, for any specific application it is anticipated that a broad range of potential methods for bacterial inactivation will need to be evaluated. Accordingly, the described synergistic combination of H2O2 and PEF described in this manuscript thereby provides an additional potent technology for the control of bacteria. It is important to consider the cost of this technology in potential future industrial applications. Despite hydrogen peroxide’s many advantages, it can be more expensive compared to other disinfectants [136]. Based on the results of this study, necessary concentrations can be greatly reduced for microbial inactivation, which would lower the financial limitations of H2O2 use. A mixture of H2O2 and peracetic acid (PAA) forms a strong oxidizer shown to be an effective decontaminant in several food types [137] that is stronger than either alone and compared to many other commercial sanitizers [56]. The synergy between the two chemicals, in addition to the synergy in combination with PEF, could enhance lethality of treatments with even lower concentrations and PEF energy inputs, further lowering costs. Based on the positive results of this study, future investigations to further characterize the role of the kinetics of both pore formation and pore resealing in nsPEF and the impact of these phenomena on the synergy between H2O2 observed in our work would be especially valuable. Membrane damage should be assessed for a better understanding of the mechanism. Although currently no known mechanisms for bacterial resistance to PEF treatment exist, this is an underexplored area of study [138, 139]. Finally, here we focus on the decontamination of planktonic bacteria and further advances in the application of nsPEF as a treatment for bacterial pathogens will benefit from more investigations into the potential of this method for the decontamination of bacterial biofilms [140]. Materials and methods Bacteria and cultivation conditions E. coli D31 [141], Listeria innocua (L. innocua) (ATCC 51742), and Salmonella enterica subsp. enterica serovar Typhimurium (S. enterica) (ATCC 14028) were maintained on Luria Bertani (LB) agar, Miller (BD Difco™, Sparks, MD, USA) petri dishes at 4°C. Long-term storage of bacteria was done in a cryogenic -80°C freezer. A single colony from the plate was inoculated in 2 mL of LB Broth, Miller (BD Difco™, Sparks, MD, USA) in a 5 mL culture tube and incubated overnight at 37 °C with constant agitation using a vortex mixer (Crystal Industries, McKinney, TX) until stationary growth phase was reached. All media coming into contact with bacteria was sterilized using a Tuttnauer 3850 EL autoclave (Hauppauge, NY, USA). Hydrogen peroxide treatments 30% (w/v) H2O2 (Millipore Sigma, Burlington, MA, USA) was diluted with 2 mM Gomori (1.07 mM potassium phosphate dibasic and 0.93 mM potassium phosphate dibasic) buffer to make 5% (1,633 mM), 3% (980 mM), and 1% (327 mM) H2O2 solutions. The Gomori buffer was pH adjusted to 7.4 using KCl and KOH and emulated a conductivity similar to tap water at 480 μS/cm. Gomori buffer was chosen to eliminate any underlying effects from the media. Phosphate buffers are common in biological applications in protecting cells from osmotic imbalances. A pH of 7.4 mimics the pH of the body and is ideal for many bacteria. E. coli and S. enterica cultures were harvested by centrifugation at 1,400 g for 5 min and L. innocua at 6,000 g for 5 min. Cells were washed three times before a final resuspension in the Gomori buffer, which was then diluted to an optical density (OD) of 0.10 at 600 nm. This equated to 6.3x107 CFU/mL for E. coli, 1.8x108 CFU/mL for L. innocua, and 1.1x108 CFU/mL for S. enterica. 20 μL of the aforementioned H2O2 solutions and 180 μL of the cell suspension were mixed for final H2O2 concentrations of 0.1, 0.3, and 0.5%, which are ~ten-fold reductions of common concentrations of H2O2 used in industrial processes. Varying contact times were investigated for the different bacteria, ranging from 5–45 min to achieve a 5 log reduction in bacterial load. All exposures were performed at ambient temperature (~23 °C). To examine bacteria sensitivity to H2O2 alone, cells were also exposed to 1, 2, and 3% H2O2 solutions at the highest contact times tested for PEF exposures (15 minutes for E. coli, 45 min for L. innocua and S. enterica). CFU determination was performed thereafter. PEF exposures Electric pulses were delivered using a custom electroporator (S4 Fig). Exposure parameters were inputted using a BNC Model 525 Pulse/Delay Generator (San Rafael, CA, USA). This device triggered the internal MOSFET of a Behlke solid-state switch (HTS 81-06-GSM) (Billerica, MA, USA). The Extech 382200 DC Power Supply (Nashua, NH, USA) was used to power the switch, and high-voltage was fed with a GPE-3323 DC Power Supply (GW Instek, Montclair, CA, USA) in series with a potential transformer. Pulses were monitored using the DSOX1102G 70 MHz Oscilloscope (Keysight, Santa Rosa, CA, USA) and the CT3681 70 MHz Differential Probe (Cal Test Electronics, Yorba Linda, CA, USA), and ultimately delivered to a safety dome (BTX, Holliston, MA, USA) capable of harboring standard electroporation cuvettes. Electric field strength distribution during a pulse and the temperature rise after 500 pulses was determined by COMSOL simulation (S5 and S6 Figs). Temperature change during PEF follows a linear increase after about 2 s of treatment, indicating that temperature would increase by ~1.9 °C for 1,000 P or ~5.2 °C for 3,000 P. Experimental temperature measurements were collected for test samples of Gomori buffer to validate the predictions of the COMSOL model. Temperature readings were obtained using an Omega OM-EL-USB-TC Data Logger equipped with a Hypodermic Needle Probe (HYP1-30-1/2-T-G-60-SMP-M). Data was analyzed using EasyLogUSB Version 7.5.0.0 software and exported to Microsoft Excel. Temperature was recorded immediately before and after PEF exposures (1,000 P). The average temperature increase for six replicates was observed to be +1.8±0.5°C (S1 Table). Electrical exposures with additive Cells were harvested in the same manner as the H2O2 treatments. The characteristic charging times of the bacteria in Gomori buffer were found using the following equation from Schoenbach et al. [8]: τm=ρs2+ρcCmR (1) where ρs is the resistivity of the solution, ρc is the resistivity of the cell interior, Cm is membrane capacitance per unit area, and R is cell radius. Assuming a ρc of 200 Ω∙cm and Cm of 1.1 μF/cm, τm was estimated to be 66 ns for E. coli (R = 0.48 μm), 55 ns for L. innocua (R = 0.40 μm), and 135 ns for S. enterica (R = 0.98 μm). Cell radius was estimated by ½l*w, where w and l are median widths and lengths from commonly listed ranges.600 ns, square-wave, monopolar pulses were delivered to 85 μL of suspension in 1 mm gap electroporation cuvettes (Bulldog Bio, Portsmouth, NH, USA) at 10 Hz. The electric field strength used in this study averaged 21 kV/cm (from after 90% rise to before 90% fall). 180 μL of cell suspension were vortexed with 20 μL of 1, 3, or 5% H2O2 for 15 s. Electrical exposures began 1 min after H2O2 addition. Single train samples were exposed to 1,000 pulses and remained in 0.1, 0.3, or 0.5% H2O2 for 5, 10, 15, 30, or 45 min total. For the split-dose treated samples, 500 pulses were delivered 1 min after H2O2 addition. Single trains applied 600 μs of total PEF treatment time over 100 s and split-dose were half of that. A delay of 2, 7, 12, 27, or 42 min occurred before the second 500 pulse delivery for the 5, 10, 15, 30, and 45 min contact times, respectively. A flowchart of this procedure is found in Fig 5. The total specific energy input for all exposures was calculated to be 117.6 kJ/kg. Flowchart outlining the primary experimental procedures. Electrical exposures without additive Exposures without any H2O2 were also conducted using the same PEF parameters, where the maximum delay assessed matched those for the H2O2 treatments. A 30 min delay was also investigated for E. coli to further examine electrosensitization effects. CFU determination Colony forming units (CFU) were determined using the track-dilution method [142]. Samples were diluted 10-fold four times in distilled water. 10 μL of each dilution, including the original sample, were spotted in ascending concentration at the top of a square petri dish containing 30 mL of LB agar. The plates were tipped to allow migration of the spots to the opposite side of the plate, forming parallel tracks. Colonies were enumerated following 16h of growth at 37°C. L. innocua plates were incubated at 37°C for 32h to provide more well-defined colonies for enumeration. The limit of detection for this method is 100 CFU/mL. COMSOL modeling COMSOL Multiphysics ver. 6.0 (Burlington, MA, USA) is a finite element software that was employed to numerically determine temperature changes within the cuvette(s) using the electric current and heat transfer in solids Multiphysics coupling. Temperature change from electric pulses is caused by Joule, or ohmic, heating, where flow of electric current creates thermal energy, and is represented by the following equation in COMSOL: ρCP∂T∂t+ρCPu⋅∇T=∇⋅k∇T+Q (2) where ρ is density (kg/m3), Cp is specific heat capacity (J/kg/K), T is temperature (K), u is the displacement vector, k is thermal conductivity (W/m/K), and Q is heat load (W/m3). Q can be calculated by Eqs (3)–(5): Q=J·E (3) J=σE (4) E=−∇V (5) where J is current density (A/m2), E is electric field (V/m), and V is applied voltage. The cuvette model (S5 Fig) consisted of electrodes with properties of aluminum, plastic with properties of polystyrene, buffer with properties of water, aside from a differing electrical conductivity, and was entirely surrounded by air. Plastic was considered to be electrically, but not thermally, insulative, and air was considered to be both. The simulation was run for 500 square-wave, 21 kV/cm pulses of 600 ns duration, at a 10 Hz frequency. A finer, free tetrahedral mesh was used for the electrodes and buffer, and a coarser mesh was used elsewhere. Microscopy To monitor potential clumping of the bacteria, select exposures were monitored using the Olympus CKX53 microscope (Center Valley, PA, USA) with the LCACHN-IPC 40X/0.55 NA objective. Images were captured using a PL-D752MU-T camera (Pixelink, Ottawa, ON, Canada). Statistical analysis Experiments were done in triplicate, and data are expressed as mean ± standard deviation unless otherwise stated. Statistical significance was determined using GraphPad Prism ver. 10.1.1 (GraphPad Software, San Diego, California, USA). Supporting information Log reductions of E. coli, L. innocua, and S. enterica for PEF as individual treatment. (PDF) Log reductions of E. coli, L. innocua, and S. enterica for H2O2 as individual treatment. (PDF) Representative images of L. innocua after PEF/H2O2 exposures. (PDF) Schematic of custom electroporator. (PDF) Schematic of cuvette for COMSOL simulation. (PDF) Modeling of temperature effects of PEF treatment. (PDF) Isobologram analysis showing combination treatment synergy. (PDF) Experimental determined temperature changes after PEF. (PDF) Statistical analysis of data: Two-way ANOVA and Tukey’s multiple comparisons. (PDF) 12 Aug 2024 PONE-D-24-29342Inactivation of Bacteria Using Synergistic Hydrogen Peroxide with Split-Dose Nanosecond Pulsed Electric Field ExposuresPLOS ONE Dear Dr. Perez, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by Sep 26 2024 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript:A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'.A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'.An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, please include your updated statement in your cover letter. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Helen Onyeaka, PhD Academic Editor PLOS ONE Journal Requirements: When submitting your revision, we need you to address these additional requirements. 1. Please ensure that your manuscript meets PLOS ONE's style requirements, including those for file naming. The PLOS ONE style templates can be found at https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=wjVg/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_main_body.pdf and https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=ba62/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_title_authors_affiliations.pdf 2. We note that the grant information you provided in the ‘Funding Information’ and ‘Financial Disclosure’ sections do not match. When you resubmit, please ensure that you provide the correct grant numbers for the awards you received for your study in the ‘Funding Information’ section. 3. Thank you for stating the following financial disclosure: "This work was funded by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture's Agriculture and Food Research Initiative (NIFA AFRI) Food Safety and Defense Program (grant # 2022-67018-36540)." Please state what role the funders took in the study. If the funders had no role, please state: "The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript." If this statement is not correct you must amend it as needed. Please include this amended Role of Funder statement in your cover letter; we will change the online submission form on your behalf. 4. Please note that funding information should not appear in the Acknowledgments section or other areas of your manuscript. We will only publish funding information present in the Funding Statement section of the online submission form. Please remove any funding-related text from the manuscript. 5. Please include captions for your Supporting Information files at the end of your manuscript, and update any in-text citations to match accordingly. Please see our Supporting Information guidelines for more information: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/supporting-information. Additional Editor Comments: I recommend that the article be accepted after major revisions. The study presents valuable findings on the synergistic effects of PEF and H2O2 in bacterial inactivation, which is a significant contribution to the field of food safety. However, several areas require improvement to enhance the clarity, depth, and rigor of the manuscript. Clearly state the hypothesis of the study to guide the reader's understanding of the research objectives. Clearly state the hypothesis of the study to guide the reader's understanding of the research objectives. Include a flowchart or schematic diagram summarizing the experimental procedures. Include a flowchart or schematic diagram summarizing the experimental procedures. Provide more justification for the choice of H2O2 concentrations and contact times. Provide more justification for the choice of H2O2 concentrations and contact times. Expand on the statistical analysis, particularly the interpretation of ANOVA results. Expand on the statistical analysis, particularly the interpretation of ANOVA results. Discuss the variability in the results, especially concerning the standard deviations, to assess the reliability of the findings. Discuss the variability in the results, especially concerning the standard deviations, to assess the reliability of the findings. Critically evaluate the limitations of the study, including potential challenges in industrial applications. Critically evaluate the limitations of the study, including potential challenges in industrial applications. Compare the findings with other recent studies to position this research within the broader field. Compare the findings with other recent studies to position this research within the broader field. Proofread the manuscript to correct minor grammatical and typographical errors. Proofread the manuscript to correct minor grammatical and typographical errors. By addressing these revisions and the revisions by the reviwers , the manuscript will be significantly strengthened and will make a substantial contribution to the literature on microbial control and food safety. Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author 1. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? The manuscript must describe a technically sound piece of scientific research with data that supports the conclusions. Experiments must have been conducted rigorously, with appropriate controls, replication, and sample sizes. The conclusions must be drawn appropriately based on the data presented. Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #4: No Reviewer #5: Yes ********** 2. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: I Don't Know Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #4: No Reviewer #5: Yes ********** 3. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available? The PLOS Data policy requires authors to make all data underlying the findings described in their manuscript fully available without restriction, with rare exception (please refer to the Data Availability Statement in the manuscript PDF file). The data should be provided as part of the manuscript or its supporting information, or deposited to a public repository. For example, in addition to summary statistics, the data points behind means, medians and variance measures should be available. If there are restrictions on publicly sharing data—e.g. participant privacy or use of data from a third party—those must be specified. Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #4: Yes Reviewer #5: Yes ********** 4. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English? PLOS ONE does not copyedit accepted manuscripts, so the language in submitted articles must be clear, correct, and unambiguous. Any typographical or grammatical errors should be corrected at revision, so please note any specific errors here. Reviewer #1: No Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes Reviewer #4: No Reviewer #5: Yes ********** 5. Review Comments to the Author Please use the space provided to explain your answers to the questions above. You may also include additional comments for the author, including concerns about dual publication, research ethics, or publication ethics. (Please upload your review as an attachment if it exceeds 20,000 characters) Reviewer #1: The paper reports on the combination of PEF and hydrogen peroxide to inactivate Listeria, Salmonella and E. coli in Gomori buffer. The research area is of interest although there are concerns over the structure of the script, experimental approach and interpretation of results. The Abstract could be made more informative to include the methodology and key results. The Introduction should provide more details on the state-of-the-art and basis for the study. Indeed, it was only when reading the Discussion that the terms of split-dose was actually defined. The Materials and Methods should be described in sufficient detail to allow replication. Also there is a need to describe what constitutes treatment time. From the text it appears the holding period when the hydrogen peroxide was added. The Discussion is primarily composed of speculative statement that have no data to support the various theories. Indeed, the study reads as preliminary and observational with little attention for elucidation of mechanisms. In addition, it would have been informative to have performed trials in a food system given this was highlighted several times within the script. Specific points Title: Which bacteria? Which matrix? Abstract Line 5: In what matrix? Line 6: What are split-dose trains? Was PEF applied for 5-45 mins? Line 9: What is the contact time? PEF is typically a brief exposure. Line 11: What were the log reductions for the individual treatments? Introduction Line 5: There are biological options. Line 9: What about irradiation and thermal sterilization? Line 12: Do the authors mean non-thermal methods to retain the raw quality of foods? Line 17: Is heat generated? Line 22: Norovirus is the number one cause of foodborne illness. Of the bacteria, Salmonella, Campylobacter and Clostridium perfringens are the most common. E. coli and Listeria are the most virulent. Line 27: Sub-lethal treatments essentially means negligible log count reductions. The authors need to expand on the benefits of nsPEF and how these differ to normal PEF in terms of pulse time & waveform. Line 14 and throughout: Statements should be supported by citing references. Line 23: Unclear what is meant by split-dose. Line 31: The authors should expand on previous work on synergistic effects. Which bacteria, which matrix and how was synergistic action demonstrated? Line 42: Low concentrations of hydrogen peroxide followed by an antioxidant dip are typically applied. The authors should elaborate on maximum levels and allowable residue levels. Line 44: There are codex standards for agricultural water. Line 4: Hydrogen peroxide is relatively expensive compared to other sanitizers. It can also result in bleaching of foods. Line 10: What was the rationale for selecting the bacteria to test? Which matrix? Results Table 1: Should include statistical analysis. Line 18: Assume 3000P refers to 3999 pulses. Disinfection of what? Line 21: Species or genera? Line 24 and throughout: The authors should compare data in statistical terms. Line 4: The paragraph starting “effectiveness of PEF” is confusing and unclear what point the authors are trying to make. It is unclear what single or split-dose infers. Line 20: What log reductions are obtained? Is a 5 log CFU reduction required? Line 18: Increased time between pulses? This should be clarified in the revised script. Discussion Line 10-28: This belongs in the Introduction. The authors need to discuss the results obtained in the current study. Line 1: Was the work published? This should be described in the Introduction. Line 6: Could the hydrogen peroxide sensitize the cells to PEF rather than vice versa? Line 8: The authors should avoid speculating on mechanisms given no studies, apart from SEM, was performed. Line 20: It is more likely the split dose causes inversions in the membrane potential, although it depends on the waveform. Line 22: Catalase would degrade hydrogen peroxide rather than hydroxyl-radicals. Line 16: Was the temperature monitored? Line 20: What plant cells specifically? Line 32: Speculative on applications. Figure 5 can be removed as it doesn’t contribute to the work. Materials and Methods Line 7: Bacteria and cultivation conditions is a better title. Line 8: What was the rationale for selecting the bacteria? How were the bacteria stored and revived? Line 12: How was agitation applied? Line 16: What is the composition of Gomori buffer? Line 22: What did an OD 0.1 equate to in CFU/ml? Line 23: How confident were the researchers that the hydrogen peroxide was not degraded by the cells prior to PEF treatment. Line 28: How was the hydrogen peroxide neutralized prior to enumerating survivors? Line 20: How long did it take to deliver 1000 pulses? Line 34: The authors applied an unusual method for plating by spotting followed by tipping the plate. How were the bacteria evenly distributed using the method? Reviewer #2: The manuscript "Inactivation of Bacteria Using Synergistic Hydrogen Peroxide with Split-Dose Nanosecond Pulsed Electric Field Exposures" is generally well-written and presents results that are well and extensively discussed. However, there are some aspects of the scientific language that should be addressed, as well as the presentation of results. Page 3, line 2: “The decontamination of microbial contamination…”. There is redundancy and inaccuracy in this sentence. In fact, the decontamination is of the product itself and usually results in a decrease in the contamination…; This error is repeated throughout the manuscript, for example on page 4 (line 27), page 5 (line 18), page 6 (lines 3 and 7), page 10 (line 29); Page 3, line 27: “...the inactivation of other microbes like viruses…”. Viruses are biological agents but not microbes; Page 4, lines 4-7: the sentence should be rewritten for the sake of clarity; Figure 1: the bars in Figure 1, specifically those for treatment with hydrogen peroxide alone, do not match the values presented in Table 1; Page 8, line 4: “The effectiveness of PEF treatments varies between the different bacteria, however, is impacted in a dose-dependent manner correlated to contact time for all bacterial species evaluated”. According to Table 1, this is not true for Salmonella (single train 0.1% 5 min and 10 min, 0.5%, 30 and 45 min); Page 17, lines 1-3: The author claims that temperature shifts after PEF were determined using the COMSOL software. Authors should present the initial and final real temperatures (not estimated) after the several PEF treatments; Page 13, line 39 to page 14, line 10: authors acknowledge that heating caused by electric pulses has an effect on cell death and use the COMSOL software to calculate the temperature increase. This is a fundamental issue, and the authors should clarify whether they measured temperatures before and after the PEF treatment. Additionally, it would be interesting to understand the effect of thermal treatment on the reduction of microbial load at the temperature reached after PEF, but without the use of PEF. Reviewer #3: The authors did a good job in this manuscript. They combined nsPEF with H2O2 to kill different strains of bacteria. The results showed an enhanced effect for the combination compared to each technique separate. The introduction showed clearly the advantages of using nsPEF over micro or millisecond PEF in saving power. Description of the experimental procedures was concise and contained detailed descriptions of well-established procedures. The results fully discussed. Reviewer #4: The manuscript presents an interesting study on the use of Pulsed Electric Fields (PEF) combined with hydrogen peroxide for microbial inactivation. While the concept has potential applications in food safety, it would be more relevant to test this method on a food matrix rather than in a buffer system. The methodology needs clearer explanation and correction in certain sections. Additionally, the results are limited and not sufficient for a scientific publication, and the discussion is largely speculative. Overall, the manuscript, in its current form, lacks sufficient data and rigorous testing to fully support its conclusions. Further details and suggestions are provided below. Title: What bacteria were tested? Title should be more descriptive. Abstract Line 4: Was the bacterial reduction achieved in water, food matrix, or another medium? Line 8: CFU per? Line 8: Which condition resulted in more than 5 log reductions? Line 10: ‘’Split-dose PEF exposures enhance lethality for several tested conditions, indicating greater susceptibility to PEF after oxidative damage has occurred.’’ How and why is its effect different from single dose? Do you have any evidence for your conclusions? Key words: The selected keywords do not accurately reflect the focus of the study. Introduction The introduction begins by discussing food decontamination, yet the method described in the paper is not applied to food. This discrepancy should be addressed for clarity. Although the research gap is identified, it would benefit from a clearer and more detailed articulation. The stated objectives could be more specific. For instance, the rationale behind combining PEF and hydrogen peroxide needs to be better explained. It would be helpful to understand the underlying theory and the expected outcomes of using these two methods together. Clarifying these aspects would provide a stronger foundation for the study’s aims and enhance the overall coherence of the paper. - Page 3, Line 14: "PEF in food processing?" Consider expanding on why PEF is chosen for this study and its significance in food processing. A brief overview of its advantages would be helpful. - Page 4, Line 34: "Hydrogen peroxide role?" Provide a brief explanation of why hydrogen peroxide is used in conjunction with PEF. What is its expected role in microbial inactivation? - Page 5, Line 8: "Herin?" The word "Herin" seems to be a typo. It should be "Herein" or another word depending on the intended meaning. Results Several figures labeled as supplementary are essential for a comprehensive understanding of the results, particularly Figures S1, S2, and S3. These figures are critical for elucidating the process described. However, the paper lacks sufficient data to be considered a rigorous scientific study, and many of the figures largely duplicate the information found in Table 1. Furthermore, although COMSOL modeling is discussed in the methodology section, its outcomes are not presented in the results section. To improve the paper, it is crucial to conclude which treatment combinations were most effective and to offer a brief interpretation of these findings directly within the results section. This would enhance the clarity and depth of the analysis provided. - Page 5: What were the results for split-dose PEF treatment alone—45 min? The supplementary figures are necessary to give readers an idea of the process. - Page 6, Line 10: ‘’No bacterial growth observed following treatment.’’ Do you mean enrichment? How do you consider it? What was the limit of detection in your trial? - Table 1: The format of the table is not suitable for a manuscript. - Table 1: In order to compare the data in the table, a statistical analysis is needed. - Figure 1: What was your reason for choosing these conditions to show in the picture? If you wanted to show the best results for each treatment, for E. coli wasn’t it 0.5%–15 min? If it shows the conditions with lower concentrations of H2O2 that resulted in more than a 5 log CFU/ml reduction of bacteria, for E. coli it is 0.1%, 15 min, split-dose PEF. - Figure 2: It is mentioned in the abstract that ‘’Split-dose PEF exposures enhance lethality for several tested conditions, indicating greater susceptibility to PEF after oxidative damage has occurred.’’ Based on the picture, this ability is only observed in the condition of 0.1% hydrogen peroxide addition to 0.3% H2O2 only for E. coli. What is the reason for better/similar results of a single dose in a higher dosage of hydrogen peroxide? - Page 8, Line 15 to 30: What are the reasons for these results? Contact time or concentration of hydrogen peroxide? - Page 9, Line 10: What do you conclude by observing the microscopic pictures? (I wasn’t able to find the supplemental figures). - Page 9, Line 12 to 14: Significance of findings? the statistical analysis is needed for Table 1 to be able to discuss it. The results for single and split doses on Listeria reduction for 0.5% and 0.3% H2O2 for 30 and 45 min look similar. - Page 9, Line 14 to 22: Why did PEF delay time have an effect on bacterial availability? What is the theory behind it? Why is Salmonella more resistant to PEF delay time compared to Listeria and E. coli? Discussion The discussion presents various theories and ideas from other researchers, but it lacks organization and comprehensiveness in explaining the synergistic effect between PEF and hydrogen peroxide. For example, while the authors frequently address the formation of hydroxyl radicals, it remains unclear whether these radicals are produced when PEF is combined with hydrogen peroxide. Clarifying this potential formation could significantly enhance the interpretation of the results. Additionally, the discussion does not provide sufficient evidence from the results to support its speculative claims. To strengthen the paper, it would be beneficial to compare the effectiveness of the PEF-hydrogen peroxide combination with other microbial inactivation methods, providing valuable context. Furthermore, the paper should address any study limitations and propose directions for future research, especially regarding the scalability of PEF-hydrogen peroxide treatment in industrial applications. - Page 10, Line 24 to 28: "With a compatible electrode material and a buffer consisting of no added transition metal ions, the H2O2 reduction must be catalyzed by bioavailable ions. It is estimated that a third of all proteins contain metal and 40% of enzymes with known structures are metal-dependent. While most of the total metal content within a bacterium cell is bounded, free metal ions also exist on the μM scale. H2O2 will specifically oxidize enzymes and proteins bonded to iron, in addition to Fe2+ ions within the labile pool [85]. Pore formation from PEF will cause either the efflux of intracellular contents or the influx of H2O2, exposing the chemical to a much higher concentration of metal ions compared with diffusion. The quicker formation of hydroxyl radicals will generate more significant damage to the surrounding proteins, enzymes, lipids, and DNA.’’ Based on this theory, is it better to use PEF and hydrogen peroxide at the same time or expose the bacteria to PEF first and then add hydrogen peroxide? - Page 11, Line 13, 14: ‘’In a general sense, we hypothesize that oxidative damage to the membrane structure induces greater susceptibility to PEF.’’ How do you hypothesize the damage in the membrane without microscopy consideration? - Page 12, Line 2: Which evidence suggests oxidative damage aids in enhancing susceptibility to PEF exposures? Only increasing the log reduction level? Materials and Methods - Page 15, Line 5: "Initial microbial levels?" Mention the initial levels of microorganisms and the detection limits used in the study. This is crucial for interpreting the effectiveness of the treatments. - Page 15, Line 15: "Buffer choice?" Explain the rationale behind the choice of buffer, pH, and the concentration range of hydrogen peroxide. How do these factors influence the results? Page 15, Line 30, a Schematic picture of the unit will help the reader understand the process better Page 16, line 35, is 16 h enough for growing Listeria, E.coli and Salmonella on LB? Page 17, line 24, wasn’t better to use an electron microscope to consider the membrane damage instead of a light microscope? Reviewer #5: The paper aims to fill a gap in the literature for nsEP application as a means of bacterial disinfection. Specifically, the authors note that nsEP alone and nsEP plus antibiotics have been investigated to some success as well as split dose approaches to increase inherent sensitivity of the system to nsEP but neither in combination. They therefore focus on assessing the combined effects of split dose nsEP and hydrogen peroxide. The authors introduce H202 as a optimal means of sterilization across many applications due to its relatively non-toxic nature, disposal via dissociation, low cost, and lack of smell/taste. The authors did well to expose three unique bacteria types to nsep, h202, and combined exposures. Overall, they found that all bacteria were impact by the combined exposure and split exposure impacted all bacteria (although the effect was not universal or straightforward). The authors did a great job of controlling exposure time across all samples and concentrations of h202. This is admirable as I found myself asking questions about consistency in incubation time of the cells per exposure paradigm and found they had noted in the methods that they had held all samples for the same amount of time under each condition. This is rarely done in papers and shows a high level of control and quality of the experiments performed. Additionally, the results and discussion sections are thorough and leave little unturned as possible mechanism(s) for the results or future studies to do. The author does mention that oxidation of phospholipids has been both shown in impact nsEP sensitivity and also be driven by nsEP exposure (in a couple papers). This is a key point as the point of action of H202 in these bacteria is not identified by the author nor its dependence on time well explored. Understandably this is beyond the goal of this paper, but it is key to determining if the mechanism is truly functioning on amplification of the same mechanism or an interplay between two stressed that presents as reduction in bacterial population. The key drawback of the paper is therefore the lack of a mechanism of action outside of speculation in how these two stressors are working together on the bacteria. it is noted that the mechanism for nsEP remains unknown for cells both mammalian and bacteria, so it would be difficult for the authors do anything more than speculate and maintain the focus of this paper on the synergetic effects of nsEP and h020 exposures. The paper was well written and I have no negative comments regarding its quality. The paper was thoroughly reviewed by the authors and the figures were made clearly and concisely. I do question how applicable nsEP and H202 could be in a commercial application, but given this papers results, you would definitely need less of both to achieve a similar outcome of either alone. This would drive down costs of pulser systems which are currently being deployed in clinical waste water applications. This paper defined a gap in knowledge regarding nsEP for bacterial decontamination and thoroughy filled it beyond expectations by studying a large range of parameters across three dissimilar species. The authors also noted future work that needs to be done to better refine and describe the results. I believe this paper should be accepted for publication. Minor Points: Some of the supplemental figures could easily be in the paper as the trends with increasing dose are better understood by graph as opposed to table, especially unexpected trends. Page 8 Line 4 “..however is impacted” reads odd. ********** 6. PLOS authors have the option to publish the peer review history of their article (what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy. Reviewer #1: Yes: Keith Warriner Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #3: Yes: Amr Abd-Elghany Reviewer #4: No Reviewer #5: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] While revising your submission, please upload your figure files to the Preflight Analysis and Conversion Engine (PACE) digital diagnostic tool, https://pacev2.apexcovantage.com/. PACE helps ensure that figures meet PLOS requirements. To use PACE, you must first register as a user. Registration is free. Then, login and navigate to the UPLOAD tab, where you will find detailed instructions on how to use the tool. If you encounter any issues or have any questions when using PACE, please email PLOS at figures@plos.org. Please note that Supporting Information files do not need this step. 12 Sep 2024 We acknowledge the reviewers for their thoughtful feedback on our manuscript. We have made changes throughout the document in response to the comments which is described in the attached response to reviewers file. Submitted filename: Response to Reviewers.docx 17 Sep 2024 Inactivation of Bacteria Using Synergistic Hydrogen Peroxide with Split-Dose Nanosecond Pulsed Electric Field Exposures PONE-D-24-29342R1 Dear Dr. Perez, We’re pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been judged scientifically suitable for publication and will be formally accepted for publication once it meets all outstanding technical requirements. Within one week, you’ll receive an e-mail detailing the required amendments. When these have been addressed, you’ll receive a formal acceptance letter and your manuscript will be scheduled for publication. An invoice will be generated when your article is formally accepted. Please note, if your institution has a publishing partnership with PLOS and your article meets the relevant criteria, all or part of your publication costs will be covered. Please make sure your user information is up-to-date by logging into Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager® and clicking the ‘Update My Information' link at the top of the page. If you have any questions relating to publication charges, please contact our Author Billing department directly at authorbilling@plos.org. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper to help maximize its impact. If they’ll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team as soon as possible -- no later than 48 hours after receiving the formal acceptance. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. Kind regards, Helen Onyeaka, PhD Academic Editor PLOS ONE Additional Editor Comments (optional): Reviewers' comments: 25 Sep 2024 PONE-D-24-29342R1 PLOS ONE Dear Dr. Perez, I'm pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been deemed suitable for publication in PLOS ONE. Congratulations! Your manuscript is now being handed over to our production team. At this stage, our production department will prepare your paper for publication. This includes ensuring the following: * All references, tables, and figures are properly cited * All relevant supporting information is included in the manuscript submission, * There are no issues that prevent the paper from being properly typeset If revisions are needed, the production department will contact you directly to resolve them. If no revisions are needed, you will receive an email when the publication date has been set. At this time, we do not offer pre-publication proofs to authors during production of the accepted work. Please keep in mind that we are working through a large volume of accepted articles, so please give us a few weeks to review your paper and let you know the next and final steps. Lastly, if your institution or institutions have a press office, please let them know about your upcoming paper now to help maximize its impact. If they'll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team within the next 48 hours. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. If we can help with anything else, please email us at customercare@plos.org. Thank you for submitting your work to PLOS ONE and supporting open access. Kind regards, PLOS ONE Editorial Office Staff on behalf of Dr. Helen Onyeaka Academic Editor PLOS ONE