Realtime estimation of average sand grain diameter and sand bed height and mass for a trailing suction hopper dredger Authors: Bolong Zhou, Menghong Yu, Xianhui Zhou, Zhaoxu Zhou, Ningning Liu Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractA Trailing Suction Hopper Dredger (TSHD) in the sailing process, excavating seabed sediment with the drag head and pumping it through the pipeline to the spoil hopper sedimentation. The spoil hopper sedimentation process, as a critical factor affecting the loading yield and efficiency of a dredger, is susceptible to the influence of different average sand grain diameter dm. However, the soil type tends to change continuously during the loading process, making it difficult to obtain the dm by measurement or calculation. In this paper, combined with the existing simplified one-dimensional sedimentation model and simulated loading data, the Bootstrap Particle Filter (BPF), Gaussian Particle Swarm Optimized Particle Filter (GPSO-PF), Assisted Particle Filter (APF), Continuous-Discrete Feedback Particle Filter based on the constant feedback gain approximation (CD-FPF-CG) and the Galerkin method feedback gain approximation (CD-FPF-GL) are applied in the numerical simulations for online estimation of important variables such as the average sand grain diameter dm, the sand bed height hs and mass ms, respectively. The simulations results show that the CD-FPF-CG has a higher numerical accuracy and efficiency than the BPF, GPSO-PF, APF and CD-FPF-GL. Therefore, the CD-FPF-CG is used to estimate the above important variables for the actual vessel and the initial value of the average sand grain diameter dm for the CD-FPF-CG is determined via Simulated Annealing Multiple Population Genetic Algorithm (SAMPGA).Keywords: Trailing suction hopper dredger, Spoil hopper sedimentation process, Average sand grain diameter, Sand bed height and mass, Continuous-discrete feedback particle filterSubject terms: Environmental sciences, Solid Earth sciences Introduction As a type of hydraulic dredger, the Trailing Suction Hopper Dredger (TSHD) periodically performs loading operation by using the drag head to excavate seabed sediment in the course of sailing and conveying it through a pipeline to the cargo space, the so-called spoil hopper, for sedimentation. Compared with other types of dredgers, it has the unique advantages of being self-propelled, self-loading, self-unloading, deep dredging depth, flexibility and manoeuvrability, etc. The TSHD has been widely used in harbour and waterway construction and maintenance, reclamation, offshore mining and many other marine engineering applications. In order to predict and optimize the dynamic behaviors and characteristics of the TSHD. It is necessary to develop the system mechanism models that can reflect the loading process of the TSHD, including drag head excavation, dredge pump pipeline transport and spoil hopper sedimentation. Among them, the spoil hopper sedimentation process, as a crucial component for enhancing the loading performance of the TSHD, is susceptible to the differences in dredging soils. Therefore, a timely understanding and knowledge about the type and nature of the in situ soil is essential to determine the soil-related parameters inherent in the sedimentation model. However, the average sand grain diameter dm, as the crucial soil parameter in the hopper sedimentation process, changes continuously with excavation position of the dredger, which makes it hard to measure the dm directly with measuring equipment or to derive it from empirical formulae. Alternatively, once a suitable sedimentation model has been selected, it can be combined with the measured data and appropriate estimation method to accurately and efficiently estimate the soil parameter including dm and the co-dependent variables including sand bed height hs and mass ms formed at the bottom of the spoil hopper. Various researchers and scientists had developed static or dynamic models of the spoil hopper deposition process. As early as 1936, Camp proposed the use of an ideal settling tank to simulate the entire sedimentation process, which resulted in the classical spoil hopper sedimentation model1. Subsequently, Camp considered the effect of turbulent diffusion on the settling of sand grains2. Yagi presented a model based on the concentration distribution of the open channel flow from the Camp model3. Vlasblom and Miedema had re-estimated overflow losses and deposition efficiency by adding relevant factors that hinder sedimentation, erosion, and reduction in flow depth to the Camp model4,5. In Ooijens’s experiments introduced time effects into the model and obtained the overflow rate and density of sand-water mixtures from experimental measurements of the model with a large scale6,7. The above models are relatively simple models developed for the field of sewage and water treatment. Although the sludge sedimentation process in the secondary clarifier has strong similarities to the sediment in the hopper, the former used idealized or simplified mixture inflow and outflow configurations and defined settling tank velocity distributions. The one-dimensional probabilistic sedimentation models suggested in the literatures8,9 were based on the advection–diffusion equation for multi-sized mixtures and took into account the effects of the vertical velocity component and the sand particle diameter distribution inside the spoil hopper. The two-dimensional complex sedimentation model proposed later was constructed on the basis of the Reynolds Averaged Navier–Stokes equation and the k-ε turbulence model10. The sedimentation model included multi-component transport of suspended sediment, simulating in more detail the entire process of sediment deposition within the hopper. Braaksma et al.11 developed three different mathematical models, linear, exponential and water-layer, to predict the overflow density. They demonstrated that the overflow density calculated by the water-layer model was closest to the true values using data from the actual dredger. Overall model of the TSHD loading process was then constructed and eventually integrated into the onboard global Model Prediction Controller (MPC)12,13. In literature14, an abbreviated spoil hopper sedimentation model was derived by discussing the factors that influence the rising rate of the sand bed during sediment deposition. Inspired by Braaksma sedimentation model, Jensen and Saremi considered the effect of sediment particle diameter distribution on the deposition process in the spoil hopper and treated the mixture layer on the sand bed as a single layer instead of two layers as suggested by Braaksma15. Konijn developed a two-dimensional complex sedimentation model for the hopper, but the model showed (almost) no entrainment in the inflow jet and the density flow disappeared quite rapidly in the model during the sedimentation simulation16. Motivated by van Rhee’s two-dimensional model, Sloof constructed a new two-dimensional model for the sedimentation process17. However, due to the complexity of the two-dimensional model, the computational time was too long. Therefore, She developed and validated another simple phenomenological layer model. Su et al.18 established a three-dimensional model using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) to simulate the movement of different soil grain diameters in the hopper. It was found that the results obtained from the Braaksma sedimentation model and the developed three-dimensional model were consistent. Most of the above models are based on one- or two-dimensional partial differential equations. Although they can provide an accurate and elaborate description of the physical sedimentation process in the hopper, these models usually contain many unknown or uncertain parameters regarding the ambient characteristics of dredged soils. It also takes a considerable amount of time to solve the two- or three-dimensional sedimentation models. Therefore, the complexity and uncertainty of these models make them unsuitable for use in online onboard controllers. On the other hand, the model developed by Braaksma utilizes a simplified one-dimensional mathematical model in the vertical direction to describe the entire sedimentation process of the spoil hopper12, which contains only four uncertain soil parameters to be estimated, i.e. the sand bed density ρs, the undisturbed sedimentation velocity vso, the scour flow coefficient ke and the hindered sedimentation coefficient β. The model has already been successfully applied to the MPC to optimize the loading process of the TSHD19. In particular, when the soil type of the excavation is known to be grained with sand, the original four soil parameters are reduced to one parameter of average soil grain diameter dm. This is because all four uncertain soil parameters in the model can be approximated by different analytical equations with dm as the independent variable20. In addition, the estimated dm can be applied to other subsystem models of the TSHD, and by substituting the dm into the Braaksma spoil hopper sedimentation model, important variables such as sand bed height hs and mass ms can be predicted. For all of the above reasons, the Braaksma model is adapted in this paper to solve the estimation problem associated with hopper sedimentation. Some scientists had already solved some estimation problems closely related to the hopper sedimentation process of the TSHD based on the Braaksma model. In the literature21, the Bootstrap Particle Filter (BPF)22,23 was used to design centralized observer for simultaneous estimation of overflow rate Qo and density ρo, but the results suffered from high variance. Afterwards, the Unscented Kalman Filter (UKF)24 and the BPF were combined to construct a cascaded observer and the outputs were compared with the centralized observer for estimating overflow losses25. The experimental results indicated that the optimal combination of cascade observer was to apply UKF or BPF for Qo and BPF for ρo. Braaksma et al. applied the BPF and Extended Kalman Filter (EKF)26,27 to estimate the overflow losses and dredging forces, respectively28. The Pattern Search (PS) method, combined with actual dredger loading data, achieved better offline estimation of uncertain soil parameters in the spoil hopper sedimentation model12. Stano et al. attempted to perform the BPF to estimate the average sand grain diameter dm in both the no-overflow and constant-volume stages29. Although the experimental results were relatively accurate, the BPF adopted the resampling technique to avoid particle degeneracy, which could lead to an increase in the computational burden and the occurrence of sample impoverishment. To solve the above problems, the continuous-time Feedback Particle Filter (FPF)30,31, Reduced-Order Particle Filter (ROPF) and Improved Saturated Particle Filter (ISPF) had been used to estimate the average sand grain diameter dm and other variables for the three stages of no-overflow, constant-volume and constant-load20,32. Because the FPF requires small sampling intervals (< 0.05 s) to ensure high estimation accuracy, but the sampling intervals of the sensors installed on the dredger range from 1 to 30 s. Consequently, if the FPF is used to solve the estimation problem on the TSHD, the FPF may produce inferior or even scattered estimation results. In contrast, the Continuous-Discrete time Feedback Particle Filter (CD-FPF)33 ensures that the accuracy of the estimation results is not significantly degraded at larger sampling interval times. For this reason, Su et al. applied the CD-FPF to estimate the dm for both the no-overflow and constant-volume phases34. The method was able to provide a precise and rapid estimation of the average sand grain diameter dm even at lower sampling frequencies compared to the BPF. However, the effectiveness of this method for estimating soil parameters under actual vessel conditions had not been verified. In our previous research, the soil parameters were estimated offline by the Genetic Algorithm (GA), Simulated Annealing and Genetic Algorithm (SAGA), Multiple Population Genetic Algorithm (MPGA) and Simulated Annealing and Multiple Population Genetic Algorithm (SAMPGA)35. Compared to other three methods, the SAMPGA had a faster convergence speed and superior accuracy. The estimated results were highly adaptable to different vessel trips in the same dredging area, but the soil parameters had to be re-estimated under different dredging areas and online estimated to adapt to various soil types. Based on the above discussion, it is believed that the CD-FPF can obtain posterior samples directly from prior samples through its unique innovative error feedback structure, avoiding the BPF importance density function selection and resampling process36. In particular, the estimation accuracy of this method is still well maintained at lower sampling frequencies. The conceptual framework of the paper is shown in Fig. 1. In this paper, we first construct the state space model and fitness function required for the online and offline estimation problems based on the simplified spoil hopper dynamic sedimentation model. Secondly, two methods, CD-FPF-CG based on the constant feedback gain approximation and CD-FPF-GL based on the feedback gain approximation of the Galerkin method31, in numerical simulations to estimate the average sand grain diameter dm, the sand bed height hs and mass ms. They are also compared to the BPF and its two improved methods, the Gaussian Particle Swarm Optimization Particle Filter (GPSO-PF)37 and the Auxiliary Particle Filter (APF)38. The estimation method that performs best in the numerical simulations is finally applied to the estimation of actual vessel state variables. In the computational results of numerical simulation, CD-FPF-CG and CD-FPF-GL are better than BPF, GPSO-PF and AP in terms of accuracy and stability of estimation, and the operation steps of CD-FPF-CG are simpler than those of CD-FPF-GL. Therefore, CD-FPF-CG is selected as the online estimation method for actual vessel applications. In the calculation results of the actual vessel application, the CD-FPF-CG is able to accurately derive the average sand grain diameter dm, the sand bed height hs and mass ms in the online estimation. In addition, SAMPGA has higher estimation accuracy and faster convergence speed than GA, so the offline estimation result of the average sand grain diameter dm from SAMPGA is used as the initial value for the online estimation of the system state variable as a way to improve the accuracy of the online estimation of the CD-FPF-CG. The experimental results show that the estimation accuracy of CD-FPF-CG is less affected by the process noise standard deviation w5 and the sampling interval time Ts. Even at higher sampling interval time Ts=30 s, the algorithm still maintains a high estimation accuracy. Schematic diagram of the conceptual framework. This paper is structured in the following way. First, the spoil hopper sedimentation process and its dynamical model are described in section “Spoil hopper sedimentation process and its dynamical model”. The online and offline estimation problems are presented in section “Overflow density”. Section “Height and mass of the sand bed” introduces the methods for solving estimation problems. Then, in section “Soil parameters related to the soil type”, the estimation results from numerical simulations and actual vessel applications of the sedimentation process are shown and discussed. Finally, section “Conclusions” is a summary of the paper. Spoil hopper sedimentation process and its dynamical model This section focuses on the specific sedimentation process in the spoil hopper and model this dynamic process. Spoil hopper sedimentation process Figure 2 illustrates the overall structure of a TSHD, which consists mainly of the spoil hopper, overflow weir, drag head, dredge pump, suction pipe, suction pipe hanger, and other dredging equipment. The TSHD is normally equipped with one or two suction pipes to transport excavated sediment from the drag head. After it reaches the designated location, the drag head and suction pipe are first slowly lowered through the suction pipe hanger until the drag head just touches the seabed. The dredger then sails at a set speed, using the drag head to break up the clumped soil and excavate sediment from the seabed. At this point, the mixture of soil and water excavated by the drag head is sucked in by the dredge pump and hydraulically transported through the suction pipe to the spoil hopper for sedimentation, and the lower density mixture above the hopper is discharged through the overflow weir to increase the loading capacity of the spoil hopper. Finally, when the hopper is full, the suction pipe is lifted and the loading operation is complete. Schematic diagram of the overall structure for a TSHD. The process of sediment deposition in the spoil hopper is illustrated in Fig. 3. The mixture of soil–water enters the hopper with the flow rate Qi and density ρi. The sand grains settle to the bottom of the hopper with the flow rate Qs, gradually forming a sand bed with the height hs and density ρs. In the middle of the hopper, unsettled soil–water mixture of the height (ht-hs-hw) and average density ρm is generated. As the sediment settles, the water flows in the inverse direction with the flow rate Qw, producing an extremely fine water layer with the height hw and density ρw above the hopper. When the mixture level ht is higher than the overflow weir height ho, the upper mixture with lower density flows out of the hopper through the overflow weir with the flow rate Qo and density ρo, thus causing overflow losses. The mass mt of sediment loaded into the hopper and the mass mo of overflow losses depend not only on the soil type, but also on the magnitude of the incoming flow rate Qi and density ρi. Schematic diagram of the spoil hopper sedimentation process. The loading process of a TSHD can usually be divided into three distinct stages. A typical spoil hopper loading curve is shown in Fig. 4, which depicts the changes in the total mass mt of the soil–water mixture in the hopper, the tonnes of dry solids (TDS) and the mass mo of overflow losses during the loading process. The TDS is the mass of the sediment excluding the water in the pores of the sediment particles39. Schematic diagram of a typical spoil hopper loading curve. Stage 1—No-overflow stage: At this stage, the soil–water mixture level ht in the spoil hopper does not exceed the overflow weir height ho. All the sediment entering the hopper is stored, and the total mass mt and the TDS increase rapidly. Stage 2—Constant-volume stage: As loading process continues, the upper lower density mixture flows out of the overflow weir after the mixture level ht exceeds the overflow weir height ho. This has the immediate effect of slowing the rate of increase in the total mass mt, but the TDS still continues to increase and at the same time the mass mo of overflow losses begins to appear. Because the overflow weir height ho does not change at this stage, the volume of the hopper remains unchanged. Stage 3—Constant-load stage: When the total mass mt reaches the maximum draught of the dredger, the overflow weir height ho is lowered to exclude the lower density soil–water mixture above the hopper, so that the total mass mt remains unchanged and the sediment loaded in the hopper continues to increase. However, later in this stage, the reduction in the cross-sectional area of the mixture above the sand bed and the increased erosive effect on sand bed resulted in a rapid increase in the mass mo of overflow losses and a slow increase in the TDS. In summary, it can be seen that in the TSHD loading process, stage 3 has a lower overflow weir height ho compared to stages 1 and 2. This results in a more variable flow of the soil–water mixture above the sand bed, giving this stage intricate dynamic characteristics. Therefore, this paper mainly focuses on the investigation and analysis of stages 1 and 2. Spoil hopper dynamical sedimentation model The dynamical sedimentation model for the spoil hopper mainly includes hopper volume and mass balance equations, overflow rate and density equations, sand bed height and mass equations and soil parameters equations. In this section, variables are all functions of the time t. The parameter t is omitted to simplify the symbolic representation, and d in the equations denotes the differential sign. A complete list of symbolic variables can be found in the Appendix A. Volume and mass balance equations for the spoil hopper1adVt=(Qi-Qo)dt1bdmt=(Qiρi-Qoρo)dtwhere Vt and mt are the soil–water mixture volume and mass in the spoil hopper, respectively. Qi and ρi are the mixture flow rate and density entering the hopper, respectively. Qo and ρo are the mixture overflow rate and density, respectively. The above equations reflect the balance between the mixture volume and mass loaded into the hopper in a given period of time. Volume and mass balance equations for the spoil hopper1adVt=(Qi-Qo)dt1bdmt=(Qiρi-Qoρo)dtwhere Vt and mt are the soil–water mixture volume and mass in the spoil hopper, respectively. Qi and ρi are the mixture flow rate and density entering the hopper, respectively. Qo and ρo are the mixture overflow rate and density, respectively. The above equations reflect the balance between the mixture volume and mass loaded into the hopper in a given period of time. Assuming that the spoil hopper is a regular rectangular parallel hexahedron with a base area A, the above Eq. (1a) can be transformed into an equation for the mixture level ht: 2.Overflow rate Overflow rate If the low-density mixture flows through the overflow weir unhindered, the overflow rate Qo is given by: When a valve switch is installed in the overflow weir, the overflow rate Qo is given by: where ht and ho are the mixture level of the hopper and the height of the overflow weir, respectively, and ko is an uncertain parameter that depends on the geometry and perimeter of the overflow weir. 3.Overflow density Overflow density Above the sand bed, the soil–water mixture in the spoil hopper shows a decreasing density with increasing height, so the mixture density distribution in the hopper can be described by a segmented function (water-layer model)11,12. The mixture average density ρm can be given by: where ρs and ms are the density and mass of the sand bed, respectively, and ms is derived from the sand bed mass balance Eq. (6). where Qs is the sand flow rate and is derived from the following equation: where ke is the erosion coefficient, vso is the undisturbed sedimentation velocity of a single sand grain, β is the hindered settling coefficient, and together with ρs in Eq. (5), the four variables mentioned above are closely associated with the soil type and properties. ρw is the seawater density (1024 kg/m3), ρq is the quartz density (about 2650 kg/m3). hm is the soil–water mixture height above the sand bed and is given by: where hs is the sand bed height. The overflow rate Qo consists of the water flow rate Qw and the mixture flow rate Qm. The water flow rate Qw is given by: Then the overflow density ρo obtained after mixing Qw and Qm is given by: The water-layer model for the overflow density ρo is given by Eqs. (9)–(11) together. 4.Height and mass of the sand bed Height and mass of the sand bed As the TSHD continues to load, the volume Vs and mass ms of the sand bed formed by the sediment settling in the hopper will gradually increase. The equations for the mass ms and the volume Vs can be expressed by Eqs. (6) and (12). Because the hopper is a regular rectangular parallel hexahedron, the Eq. (13) for the sand bed height hs is obtained by transforming Eq. (12): 5.Soil parameters related to the soil type Soil parameters related to the soil type When the excavated soil is sand, the four soil parameters ρs, ke, β and vs0 in Eqs. (5) and (7) can be approximated as the analytical form of functions with average sand grain diameter dm as the independent variable11,20,40,41. Estimation problems This section focuses on the development of the system state equations, the observation equations and the fitness function required for the online and offline estimation problems based on the spoil hopper sedimentation model in the previous section. Online estimation problem The stochastic dynamic equations required to estimate the relevant state variables, including the sand bed height hs and mass ms, can be derived from the spoil hopper sedimentation model for the no-overflow and overflow stages, respectively. However, the time-varying soil parameter dm appears to change continuously with the type and nature of the excavated soil, which makes modelling the dynamic changes for the average sand grain diameter dm extremely difficult. It has been suggested in the literature42 that the process of varying unmodeled uncertain parameters to be estimated can be described by a random walk. Therefore, the following stochastic differential equation is built to describe the dynamics of changing dm. where wd is a Wiener process which has a constant standard deviation σd. Currently, most TSHDs are equipped with various types of sensors that can measure online the total mass mt and level ht of the soil–water mixture, as well as the incoming mixture flow rate Qi and density ρi. Although real-time measurement devices for the sand bed height hs and mass ms have not been successfully developed and applied on a TSHD, it is possible to achieve an accurate online determination of the sand bed height hs using a conductivity concentration meters under ideal experimental conditions12. This section analyses and discusses the online estimation problem of the average sand grain diameter dm, the sand bed height hs and mass ms under two different cases, namely the simulated loading operation with a measurable sand bed height hs and the actual vessel loading operation with an unmeasurable sand bed height hs, in the no-overflow and constant-volume stages, respectively. Case 1—sand bed height can be measured Case 1—sand bed height can be measured No-overflow stage. No-overflow stage. For the simulated loading situation where the sand bed height hs can be measured online, based on equilibrium Eqs. (1), (2), (6) and (13) for the mass (mt, ms) and height (ht, hs), and the stochastic differential Eq. (15) for the average sand particle diameter dm. The following state vector and input vector can be obtained for the no-overflow stage: The continuous-time dynamical system model for the no-overflow stage is given by: where wt is the time-invariant Gaussian process noise with zero mean and σt standard deviation. Ts is the system sampling interval time. In the case of no-overflow, where the sand bed height hs is measurable, the system observation vector is given by: The observation equation is given by: where vt is the time-invariant Gaussian observation noise with zero mean and εt standard deviation, independent of wt. (2)Constant-volume stage. Constant-volume stage. The presence of air in the overflow weir prevents accurate and timely measuring of overflow losses. Therefore, it is necessary to explore practical and feasible methods to estimate the overflow rate Qo and density ρo of the soil–water mixture in the overflow weir. Although the spoil hopper sedimentation model includes the models of overflow rate Qo and density ρo, there are some uncertain parameters in the models that cause the calculated overflow losses to deviate from the true value. In this paper, a cascade observers are used to achieve decentralized estimation of UKF for Qo and BPF for ρo25, and the above two estimated variables are used as deterministic input variables for the constant-volume stage. The state vector and input vector of the overflow stage are given by: The continuous-time dynamical system model for the overflow stage is given by : In case 1, the observation vector and equation for the constant-volume stage are the same as for the no-overflow stage. 2.Case 2—sand bed height cannot be measured Case 2—sand bed height cannot be measured No-overflow stage. No-overflow stage. In the case of an actual vessel loading with an unmeasurable online sand bed height hs. The state vector and equation of the continuous-time dynamical system for the no-overflow stage in case 2 are the same as case 1. But the system observation vector is given by: The observation equation is given by: (2)Constant-volume stage. Constant-volume stage. In case 2, the state vector and equation of the continuous-time dynamical system for the constant-volume stage are the same as case 1, and the observation vector and equation of the system are the same as case 2 with no-overflow stage. In conclusion, the main objective of the online estimation problem for the no-overflow and constant-volume stages is to explore and apply suitable non-linear estimation methods in combination with the simulated and the actual vessel loading data to estimate the average sand grain diameter dm, the sand bed height hs and mass ms. Offline estimation problem Due to the fact that there is insufficient information about the average sand grain diameter dm in the actual vessel loading operation. Therefore, it is necessary to combine the spoil hopper sedimentation model and actual vessel loading data, and apply an efficient and appropriate nonlinear intelligent optimization algorithm to estimate the dm, which is used as the initial value for the online estimation of the average sand particle diameter dm in the actual vessel applications. The fitness function required for the offline estimation problem should be created before estimating the average sand grain diameter dm. In this paper, the difference between the estimated value of the loaded mass derived from the hopper sedimentation model and the true value obtained from actual measurements is considered to generate the objective function, and the fitness function is an inverted objective function. The objective function is given by the following equation: where m^t(dm) and m¯t are the model output and measured value of the loading mass at time t, respectively. The smaller the deviation between the two values, the higher the accuracy of the average sand grain diameter dm, corresponding to the individual with a higher fitness value in the algorithm. H is the total number of samples. Estimation methods This section introduces several of the non-linear estimation methods used to solve the online and offline estimation problems. Online estimation methods The online estimation of the average sand grain diameter dm, the sand bed height hs and mass ms is a typical non-linear system state estimation problem, so the below five particle filter (PF) algorithms are applied and compared in this paper: BPF: The Bootstrap PF as detailed in Chapter 9 of the book43. BPF: The Bootstrap PF as detailed in Chapter 9 of the book43. GPSO-PF: The Gaussian Particle Swarm Optimized PF as detailed in the literature37. GPSO-PF: The Gaussian Particle Swarm Optimized PF as detailed in the literature37. APF: The Auxiliary PF as detailed in the literature38. APF: The Auxiliary PF as detailed in the literature38. CD-FPF-CG: The CD-FPF utilises the constant feedback gain approximation as detailed in Chapter 4 of the dissertation33. CD-FPF-CG: The CD-FPF utilises the constant feedback gain approximation as detailed in Chapter 4 of the dissertation33. CD-FPF-GL: The CD-FPF utilises the Galerkin feedback gain approximation as detailed in the literature36. The basis functions of the polynomial are given by x1x2x3x4x5x12x22x32x42x52\}, where xi\{i=1,2,3,4,5} is a component of the state vector in the system state equation. CD-FPF-GL: The CD-FPF utilises the Galerkin feedback gain approximation as detailed in the literature36. The basis functions of the polynomial are given by x1x2x3x4x5x12x22x32x42x52\}, where xi\{i=1,2,3,4,5} is a component of the state vector in the system state equation. Among the five PF algorithms mentioned above, BPF, also known as Sampling Importance Resampling (SIR) filtering, generates a set of particle population with initial weights in the state space that correspond to the empirical conditional distribution of the system’s state vector. It then continuously updates the weights and positions of the particles with the latest measurements to ensure that the adapted particle information is close to the posterior distribution of the state vector. The BPF applies a systematic resampling technique44 at each discrete time step to avoid particle degeneracy, using the more easily implemented prior probability density as the importance density function. The other two algorithms, GPSO-PF and APF, are improved BPF algorithms by introducing the intelligent optimization algorithm and improving the resampling technique. For reasons of space, more detailed information on the three algorithms can be found in the relevant literature and are not be repeated here, while the implementations of the two algorithms CD-FPF-CG and CD-FPF-GL are described below. For the continuous-discrete time estimation problem, the system state and observation equations are given by where xt∈Rd and ut∈Rd are the state and input vectors of the system at continuous time t, respectively. zk∈Rm is the measurement of the system at discrete time tk.f(·)=(f1,…,fd) and h(·)=(h1,…,hm) are the state transfer and observation functions of the system, respectively, and both belong to the C1 function. wt∈Rd and vk∈Rm are Gaussian process noise and Gaussian observation noise with mutually independent zero mean and covariance matrices of Q and R, respectively. The objective of the estimation problem (21) is to derive the posterior distribution πt|t of the system state vector xt based on the historical observation sequence Zt=σ{zk:∀k,tk∈[0,t]}. CD-FPF is a controlled particle ensemble system based on an innovative error feedback structure that treats each particle as a controllable stochastic system. Each particle under the influence of feedback control can be divided into two steps to realize the evolution by its own state and the empirical distribution characteristics of the particle ensemble, as depicted in Fig. 5 for the schematic diagram of the CD-FPF two-step evolution structure33. Schematic diagram of the two-step evolutionary structure for the CD-FPF. In Step 1, at time t∈[tk-1,tk), the dynamics of the i-th particle can be expressed as follows: where {xti,i=1,…,N} is the state of the i-th particle at time t, and N is the number of particles. At the start time t=0, all particles are sampled from the prior distribution p∗(x,0). Assuming that the state xtk-1i of the i-th particle at the previous time is known, the right limit of the state xti is defined as In Step 2, when the latest measurement zk is obtained at a discrete time t=tk, a particle flow Ski(λ) is introduced in the form of differential equations to account for this observation. where the parameter λ is the pseudo time, which can be conceptualised as the time t in the continuous time FPF45,46. If the initial state Ski(0)=xtk-i of the i-th particle is known, then after iterative computation, the state of the i-th particle at time t=tk is xtki=Ski(1). Kki(Ski(λ),λ)∈Rd×m is the feedback gain function, uki(Ski(λ),λ)∈Rd is the correction term, and Iki(Ski(λ),λ)∈Rm is the update term based on the innovation error. where h^≈1N∑i=1Nh(Ski(λ)). It can be seen from Eq. (25) that the CD-FPF has a high similarity to the Kalman Filter (KF) in terms of its feedback control structure. The critical part of the CD-FPF is the derivation of the gain function in Eq. (24). It is common to consider the Kullback–Leibler divergence (KLD) as a measure of the difference between the true posterior probability distribution and the feedback posterior probability distribution. The solution of the feedback gain via the Euler–Lagrange boundary value problem (E-L BVP) is derived by minimising the equivalent of the KLD. For j=1,2,…m, the function ϕ=(ϕ1,…ϕm) is the solution of the following second-order differential equation, where p(Ski(λ),λ) is the conditional distribution of Ski(λ) for the observation sequence Zt. In these solutions, for l=1,2,…d, the gain function is: The CD-FPF solves for the feedback gain Klji(Ski(λ),λ) at each discrete time step, and its two approximation algorithms can be divided into the constant feedback gain approximation solution in Algorithm 1 and the Galerkin finite-element method feedback gain approximation solution in Algorithm 231. The function uki(Ski(λ),λ) is given by where Ω=∇ϕ is obtained by solving the following equation: where g=∑j=1m∇ϕj·∇hjT and g^=h^2-h2^, and h2^≈1N∑i=1Nh(Ski(λ))Th(Ski(λ)). Derivation of the feedback gain function: constant gain approximation. Derivation of the feedback gain function: Galerkin approximation. The solution of the correction term uki(Ski(λ),λ) in Eq. (24) is similar to that of the feedback gain Kki(Ski(λ),λ), except that h and h^ are replaced by g and g^ in algorithms 1 and 2 respectively. To simulate the CD-FPF, the variables t and λ require Euler-discretization. Then Algorithm 3 is the discretized algorithm33. Introduction of CD-FPF. Offline estimation methods The offline estimation of the average sand grain diameter dm is achieved by combining SA (Simulated Annealing, SA)47 with strong local search capability and MPGA (Multiple Population Genetic Algorithm, MPGA)48 with strong global search capability to form the SAMPGA (Simulated Annealing and Multiple Population Genetic Algorithm, SAMPGA). The hybrid algorithm is applied to the spoil hopper sedimentation model for fast and accurate estimation of the average sand grain diameter dm. Since SAMPGA incorporates the “annealing” operation, it can effectively overcome the “premature” phenomenon in the traditional genetic algorithm (GA). Furthermore, the SAMPGA uses multiple populations simultaneously to carry out genetic operations such as selection, crossover, mutation, migration, etc., which enhances the search ability and efficiency of the hybrid algorithm in the solution space. The implementation process of the SAMPGA is depicted in Fig. 6. Schematic diagram of the SAMPGA implementation process. The detailed steps of SAMPGA are as follows: Step 1: Initialization algorithm control parameters: these include the number of populations as Mp, the number of individuals in the population as NP, and the number for generations of optimal individuals maintained in the elite population as MN. Generation gap probability Pn(I), crossover probability Pc(I) and variance probability Pm(I) for different populations, where I∈[1Mp]. Initial annealing temperature T0, temperature cooling factor kc and final annealing temperature Tend. Step 2: For each population within the boundary region, randomly create NP individuals as an initial population, and calculate the corresponding individual fitness values for each population. Step 3: Multiple populations evolve in parallel and set the evolutionary generation count variable GEN = 0. Step 4: Multiple populations independently and synchronously perform genetic operations and compare the fitness values of the new and old individuals in each population. If the fitness value of the new individual is greater than the old individual, the new individual replaces the old one. Conversely, either the new or the old individual is selected according to the probability provided by the Metropolis criterion49. After all populations have completed the evolutionary operation, the immigration operator introduces the superior individual produced by one population during the evolutionary process into another population, which in turn serves the purpose of co-evolution of multiple populations. Step 5: Save the superior individuals (those with the highest fitness values) in the different populations to the elite population. If the number of generations that the superior individuals saved in the elite population remain constant is less than MN, gen=gen+1, go to step 4; else, go to step 6. Step 6: When the temperature at time i is Ti