Cardaminezhangjiajieensis, a new species of Brassicaceae in China Authors: Jia-Lu Li, Cheng Zhang, Yi He, Quan-Ru Liu Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractCardaminezhangjiajieensis, a new species from Hunan Province, China, is described and illustrated. Cardaminezhangjiajieensis is similar to C.circaeoides. From the latter, C.zhangjiajieensis is readily distinguished by the terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf 4.5–7 cm (vs. 2.5–4.5 cm), mostly round or oblong (vs. oblong-oval to triangular-oval), margin undulating sinuses (vs. crenate or subentire), seed apically narrow wing (vs. wingless). Introduction Cardamine L. (Brassicaceae) is a cosmopolitan genus with over 280 species (Marhold et al. 2021), mainly distributed in the temperate regions. According to the Flora of China, there are 48 species of Cardamine in China, 24 of which are endemic (Zhou et al. 2001). Since 2001, new species and distribution records of Chinese Cardamine have been published continuously (Marhold et al. 2007; Al-Shehbaz and Boufford 2008; Al-Shehbaz 2015a, 2015b; An et al. 2016). To date, 61 species of Cardamine have been reported in China, 31 of which are endemic. We examined literature and specimens of Cardamine. Field surveys were conducted in Hunan, Sichuan, Jilin, Hebei, Yunnan from 2021 to 2023. During the specimens examination of the genus Cardamine, the author picked out one specimen which was identified as Cardaminemacrocephala Z. M. Tan & S. C. Zhou (Tan and Zhou 1996), Zhang D. G. 130502028 collected from Zhangjiajie Nature National Reserve, Hunan Province. This name had been recorded as a synonym of C.circaeoides Hook.f. & Thomson (Zhou et al. 2001). The morphological characters of the plants on the specimen Zhang D. G. 130502028 are significantly inconsistent with those of C.circaeoides, whose leaves are heart-shaped, 1.5–5.5 cm long, margin entire. In contrast, the leaves of Zhang D. G. 130502028 are oval to nearly round, 3–7 cm long, with wide undulating teeth. Therefore, in order to clarify the taxonomic status of the above two groups, this study conducted field investigations, morphological and systematic analysis. This species, C.zhangjiajieensis, is proposed as new to science. Method Sampling and morphological analyses Based on the literature examination, more than 5000 specimens from PE, KUN, CDBI, SZ and other herbaria were examined. Field surveys were conducted in Zhangjiajie Nature National Reserve during April 2021, May 2022 and May 2023, specimens’ collection sites are shown in Table 1, Fig. 1. Table 1.Taxa and sample sites.Taxa and sample sitesNo. of individualsMorphological analysesFlow cytometric measurementsC.zhangjiajieensis J.L. Li & Q.R. LiuChina Hu’nan: Zhangjiajie Nature Reserve, Wulingyuan, 29.340766°N, 110.45326°E, 880 m, May 21, 2022, J.L.Li & C. Zhang BNU2022ZJJ023√√China, Hu’nan: Zhangjiajie Nature Reserve, Wulingyuan, 29.324980°N, 110.433310°E, 600 m, May 21, 2022, J.L.Li & C. Zhang BNU2022ZJJ065√China, Hu’nan: Zhangjiajie Nature Reserve, Wulingyuan, 29.341153°N, 110.457903°E, 820 m, May 21, 2022, J.L.Li & C. Zhang BNU2022ZJJ043√China, Hu’nan: Zhangjiajie Nature Reserve, Jinbianxi, 2021, C. Zhang, zhang6709√C.circaeoides Hook.f. & ThomsonChina Yunnan: Ailaoshan, alt. 2523 m, 24.535°N, 101.023198°E, 26 May 2022, C. Zhang & X.J.Zhao BNU2022ALS0112√China Yunnan: Ailaoshan, alt. 2475 m, 24.525649°N, 101.008964°E, 26 May 2022, C. Zhang & X. J .Zhao BNU2022ALS035√China Sichuan: Yinchanggou Village, alt. 1200 m, 28°30'9.17"N, 103°30'40.83"E, 30 April 2022, C. Zhang & J.L. Li BNU2022XN019√China Sichuan:Yinchanggou Village, alt. 1200 m, 28°30'0.91"N, 103°29'10.44"E, 30 April 2022, C. Zhang & J.L. Li BNU2022XN034√China Hubei: Xuan’en, Shadaogou, C. Zhang, zhang6605√China Hu’nan: Jishou, Hangxia Spring, C. Zhang, zhang5512√China Hu’nan: Jishou, Hangxia Spring, C. Zhang, zhang5316√C.cf.scutata Thunb.China Sichuan: Michangshan, alt. 1256 m, 32.633917°N, 106.517870°E, 14 May 2022, C. Zhang & J.L. Li BNU2022MCS023√C.hupingshanensis K.M.Liu, L.B.Chen, H.F.Bai & L.H.LiuChina Hu’nan: Hupingshan April 2023, BNU2023HPS012√ Taxa and sample sites. Collection site of C.zhangjiajieensis, plus represents C.zhangjiajieensis and the cross represents C.circaeoides. Morphology characters of rhizome, stem, leaf, flower and silique have been carefully revalued by Image J. A list of morphological characters and their acronyms used in analyses has been shown in Table 2. The description of character was referred to (Šlenker et al. 2018). 14 unrelated characters were selected, and PCA was performed by Past 3 after standardization by IBM SPSS Statistics (v.27). Table 2.List of morphological characters and their acronyms used in analyses.AcronymDescription of characterRWIndument in the plant (0-hairs present, 1-hairs absent)BLLength of the terminal leaflet of the basal leaf (mm)BW/BLRatio of the length and width of the terminal leaflet of the basal leafBWL/BLRatio of the widest part length and length of the terminal leaflet of the basal leafBTAAngle of the apex of the terminal leaflet of the basal leaf (mm) BBA Angle of the basal of the terminal leaflet of the basal leaf (mm)No.BLMean number of lateral leaflets of the basal leaf (mm)BTDDepth of sinuses of the terminal leaflet of the basal leaf (mm)CLLength of the terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf (mm)No.CLMean number of lateral leaflets of the cauline leaf (mm)CTAAngle of the apex of the terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf (mm)CBAAngle of the basal of the terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf (mm) CBL/CL Ratio of the widest part length and length of the terminal leaflet of the basal leaf CTL Depth of sinuses of the terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf (mm)PLLength of petals (mm)PWWidth of petals (mm)SLLength of sepals (mm)SWWidth of sepals (mm)LFLLength of longer filaments (mm)SFLLength of shorter filaments (mm)PdLLength of the pedicel of the lowermost siliqua of the main inflorescence (mm)SqLLength of the lowermost siliqua of the main inflorescence (mm) List of morphological characters and their acronyms used in analyses. Phylogenetic analyses Fresh plant leaves were collected in the field and quickly dried with silica gel. Plant samples were sent to Beijing Novogene Corporation for quality testing and re-sequencing. The sequencing platform, Illumina HiSeq X Ten and BGI, was used to generate approximately 2–10 GB of data for each sample. The chloroplast genome was assembled from the clean data using GetOrganelle (Jin et al. 2020). Plastid Genome Annotator (PGA) was used to annotate chloroplast genome with Amborellatrichopoda Baill. from software as references (Qu et al. 2019). Then, 26 plastid genome sequences were downloaded from NCBI (Table 5), including 23 species of Cardamine and 2 species, Rorippasylvestris (L.) Besser, Rorippaindica (L.) Hiern as outgroup. The annotated sequences were imported into PhyloSuite (Zhang et al. 2020), the Mafft module was used for sequence alignment (Katoh et al. 2019), and the ModelFinder module was used to calculate the nucleotide substitution model for the aligned sequences. The maximum likelihood (ML) tree was constructed using IQ-TREE (Minh et al. 2020), with the nucleotide substitution model set to GTR+R3+F and a standard bootstrap value of 1000. Flow cytometric measurements and estimation of DNA ploidy levels Methods referring to Marhold et al. (Marhold et al. 2010) and Kobrlová and Hroneš (Kobrlová and Hrones 2019) measured the nuclear DNA content using flow cytometry. Inferred the DNA ploidy levels within the studied populations based on Cardamine species with known ploidy (Suda and Trávníček 2006; Marhold et al. 2021). The relative nuclear DNA content was determined using PI, a DNA intercalating fluorescent dye, with arbitrary units (a.u.) as the unit of measurement. The buffer solution used was LB01. Dehydrated leaves, preserved by drying at 40 °C for 18–24 months, were used for the determination of chromosome ploidy. The sample sources and voucher specimens are presented in the Table 1. In a pre-cooled culture dish, 1–2 mL of LB01 buffer solution and 2 cm2 of dry leaves were added. After rapid chopping, the mixture was filtered through a 400-mesh gauze, centrifuged at 4 °C, 3000 rpm for 10 minutes, and the supernatant was discarded. The pellet was resuspended in 600 μL of LB01 buffer solution, followed by the addition of 100 μL of PI solution (50 μg/mL), and stained in the dark for 15 minutes. Ploidy level of the stained cell suspension was determined by flow cytometry (ACEA NovoCyte 3130). Using 488 nm blue light excitation, 10,000 cells were collected at a time. The other samples were determined under the same voltage bar using C.scutata (2n = 4x = 32) as the reference for tetraploid. Result Morphological analyses The ordination diagrams of PCA based on individual plants (Fig. 2) showed that, the cumulative proportion of eigenvalue of the first five principal component axes exceeds 75%, indicated success of dimension reduction. C.circaeoides and C.zhangjiajieensis were separated on principal component axis 1 without overlap. The characters that contributed to this axis are the angle of the basal of the terminal leaflet of the basal leaf (BBA), depth of sinuses of the terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf (CTL), ratio of the widest part length and length of the terminal leaflet of the basal leaf (CBL/CL), indicating significant differences in cauline leaf morphology. The principal component axis 2 and axis 3 have overlapping distribution ranges. Ordination diagrams of principal component analyses, orange plus refers to C.circaeoides, cyan dots refers to C.zhangjiajieensis. Phylogenetic analyses The aligned plastid genome dataset included 32 species with 161195 bp characters; 6552 (4.06%) were parsimony informative. As shown in the Fig. 2, the plants used in this study were divided into three branches, Cardamine species formed a monophyletic group with moderate support (BS = 1). C.zhangjiajieensis and C.scutata converged into a single lineage, formed a clade with C.amariformis Nakai. in Fig. 3. The strict consensus tree resulted from IQ-tree analysis using plastid genome. Bootstrap (BS) are showed below branches. Blue refers to species distributed in Hunan province, rose red refers to the novelty. Flow cytometric measurements and estimations of DNA ploidy levels As shown in Table 3, the chromosome ploidy was determined by the materials stored for 18–24 months after being dehydrated, and the coefficient of variation was between 6.9% and 7.9%, indicating that dried specimens could be used in this study (Suda and Trávníček 2006). According to the relative DNA content and chromosome number of C.scutata, the relative DNA content of C.zhangjiajieensis and C.hupingshanensis was measured, as shown in the table. The chromosome ploidy of C.zhangjiajieensis was estimated to be 2n ≈ 6x. Table 3.Relative genome sizes obtained for C.zhangjiajieensis, C.scutata, C.hupingshanensis, the Relative genome sizes of C.scutata refer to (Marhold et al. 2010).Taxa and Voucher informationRelative genome size in a.u. (arbitrary units); mean (minimum–maximum)(DNA) Ploidy levelMean relative genome size per monoploid genomeVariation (%) C.zhangjiajieensis 0.727 (0.670–0.784)≈6x-7.9% C.scutata 0.466 (0.405–0.527)4x0.1176.9% C.hupingshanensis 0.911 (0.842–0.980)3x0.3047.6% Relative genome sizes obtained for C.zhangjiajieensis, C.scutata, C.hupingshanensis, the Relative genome sizes of C.scutata refer to (Marhold et al. 2010). Taxonomic treatment Cardamine zhangjiajieensis Q.R.Liu & J.L.Li sp. nov. 18D95061-D902-5FD6-868C-8ECCDE2CBE23 urn:lsid:ipni.org:names:77351286-1 Figs 4 , 5 Type. China • Hunan: Zhangjiajie Nature Reserve, Wulingyuan, 29.340766°N, 110.45326°E, 880 m, May 21, 2022, Li JL, Zhang C, BNU2022ZJJ02 (holotype:BNU0057018, isotype: BNU0057017, BNU0057016). Cardaminezhangjiajieensis Q.R.Liu & J.L.Li A plants in fruit period B new leaves emanating from aerial roots C basal leaves D flower E petal and sepals F stamens G style H siliques and seed, All drawn by Quan-Ru Liu from voucher specimens Li JL, Zhang C BNU2022ZJJ02 (BNU!) (A), Li JL, Zhang C BNU2022ZJJ04 (BNU!) (B–H). Diagnosis. Cardaminezhangjiajieensis is similar to C.circaeoides. From the latter, C.zhangjiajieensis is readily distinguished by the terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf 4.5–7 cm (vs. 2.5–4.5 cm), lateral leaflets 0–2 pairs (vs. 0–1 pairs), without auriculate petioles (vs. auriculate petioles), mostly round or oblong (vs. oblong-oval to triangular-oval), margin undulating sinuses (vs. crenate or subentire), seed apically narrow wing (vs. wingless). Morphology and habitat of C.zhangjiajieensisA, B plants in flowering and fruit period C flower D siliques and seed morphology E flower (lateral view) F leaves, indicating cauline leaves (F1, F2), basal leaves (F4), and new leaves emanating from aerial roots (F3). Photographs A, B, D, E by Zhang C, C, F by Li JL. Description. Herbs perennial, 15–40 cm tall, glabrous. Rhizomes short, sometimes with a few stolons. Stems erect, simple or branched above middle. Basal leaves not rosette, simple or 2–4 foliolate; petiole 3–6 cm, glabrous; leaf blade or terminal leaflets cordate or ovate, 3–5 cm × 3–5 cm, glabrous, base cordate, sometimes subtruncate, or subcuneate, margin often sinuous, apex obtuse; lateral leaflets (when present) petiolulate or sessile, much smaller than terminal one. Cauline leaves simple or 1 of which 2– or 3–foliolate, petiolate or rarely uppermost subsessile; petiole (0.4–)1–5 (–6) cm; leaf blade similar to that of basal leaves, cordate, sometimes ovate to ovate-lanceolate, 4.5 (–6) × 3(–4) cm. Fruiting pedicels 3–12 (–15) mm, ascending, base sometimes rooting, emitting new plants. Sepals ovate or oblong, 2.8–3.2 mm × 1.4–1.9 mm, glabrous, margin often membranous. Petals white, spatulate, 4.5–6.5 mm × 2.5–3 mm, apex notch. Median filament pairs 3.5–4.5 mm, lateral pair 1.5–2.5 mm; anthers oblong. Siliques linear, 2.5–4 cm; valves torulose, glabrous; style (0.5–)1–2 mm. Seeds brown, ovate or broadly oblong, 1.4–1.6 × 0.9–1.1 mm, with a narrow wing. Fl. and fr. April–Jul. 2n ≈ 6x. Distribution. Only found in Zhangjiajie Nature Reserve, Hunan Province, grows in wet places of roadside, forest, river sides. Specimens examined. China • Hunan: Zhangjiajie Nature Reserve, Wulingyuan, 29.324980°N, 110.433310°E, 600 m, May 21, 2022, Li JL, Zhang C, BNU2022ZJJ06 (BNU, 4 duplicates) • Zhangjiajie Nature Reserve, Wulingyuan, 29.341153°N, 110.457903°E, 820 m, May 21, 2022, Li JL, Zhang C, BNU2022ZJJ04, (BNU, 7 duplicates); April 25, 2023, Li JL, Song QR, BNU2023ZJJ01, (BNU, 2 duplicates); Jinbianxi, 2021, Zhang C zhang670, (BNU, 7 duplicates) • Tianmenshan, May 2, 2013, Zhang DG 130502028 (JIU33520) • Hunan, Exact location unknown, March 18, 1955, Xia JL 20, (PE01995438). Discussion. Major centers of Cardamine diversity estimated by the number of taxa appear to be in the European Mediterranean and the Caucasus; Eastern Asia and the Himalayas; and North and Central America (Marhold et al. 2018). Utilizing data from this study, we selected common Cardamine in Hunan and Central China, such as Cardaminelyrata, Cardamineanhuiensis, Cardamineengleriana, Cardaminefragariifolia, Cardaminecircaeoides, Cardaminescutata, Cardaminefallax, Cardamineocculta and determined the phylogenetic position of C.zhangjiajieensis within the genus. Phylogenetic analysis shows that C.zhangjiajieensis falls in a clade sister to C.scutata. From the latter, C.zhangjiajieensis is readily distinguished by lateral leaflets 0–2 pairs (vs. 1–4), the terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf 4–7 cm × 3.5–6.5 cm (vs. 2–5 × 1.5–4 cm), petals 4.5–6.5 mm × 2.5–3 mm (vs. 2.5–4.5 × 1.5–2.5 mm), sepals 2.8–3.2 mm × 1.4–1.9 mm (vs. 1.5–2.5 × 0.9–1.4 mm), vegetative propagated by adventitious buds in fruit stage. As a widespread species in East Asia, the speciation of C.scutata has been elucidated. Allotetraploid C.scutata originated by hybridization between two diploid species, C.parviflora and C.amara (Mandáková et al. 2019). Based on chloroplast genome data, our study showed that C.parviflora, C.scutata, C.zhangjiajieensis, C.amariformis formed a highly supported subclade, C.parviflora located at the base of clade, which supported the results of previous studies. Our analysis also suggested that C.scutata (2n = 4x = 32) may be involved in the speciation of C.zhangjiajieensis (2n ≈ 6x) as hybrid parent according to the ploidy level. Another notable character of C.zhangjiajieensis is vegetative reproduction by adventitious buds in fruit stage, which is also found in C.hupingshanensis, an endemic species to Hupingshan Mountains (Long 2004). From the latter, C.zhangjiajieensis is readily distinguished by glabrous (vs. hirsute), terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf oblong, not petiole auriculate-amplexicaul at base (vs. reniform or orbicular, petiole auriculate-amplexicaul at base), seed apically narrow wing (vs. wingless), as shown in Table 4. C.hupingshanensis has 2n = 24. In natural conditions, the reproduction of C.hupingshanensis relies on adventitious roots growing on each stem node after lodging, indicating that the ploidy level of C.hupingshanensis is 2n = 3x. To further clarify speciation and evolution of karyotype within Cardamine, studies with comprehensive sampling and seeds germination of C.zhangjiajieensis are needed. Table 4.Comparison of characters of C.zhangjiajieensis, C.circaeoides and C.scutata. C.zhangjiajieensis C.circaeoides C.scutata C.hupingshanensis Life cyclePerennialperennialannual or biennialperennialTrichomeGlabrouspiloseglabrous or pilose hirsuta Plant height15–40 cm9–36 cm(5–)15–50(–70) cm30–100 cmBase of petioleSimpleauriculatesimpleauriculateNo. of lateral leaflet or lobes of the basal leaf(0–)1–2(–3)0(–2)1–40(rare 1)Length of terminal leaflet of the basal leaf3–5 cm2–4 cm1.5–2.5 cm4–13 cmTerminal leaflet of the basal leafOrbicularcordate or ovalreniform or cordatereniform or orbicularBase of the basal leafTruncatecordatecordatecordate, petiole auriculate-amplexicaul at baseLength of terminal leaflet of the cauline leaf4.5–7 cm1–3.5 cm2–5 cm4–13 cmTerminal leaflet of the cauline leaforbicular to oblongcordate, ovate to ovate-lanceolateoblong-ovalreniform or orbicularBase of the cauline leafOvatecuneateovatecordate, petiole auriculate-amplexicaul at baseMargin of cauline leafundulating sinusescrenate or subentireapically sinuses 3–5crenateSepals (mm)2.8–3.2 × 1.4–1.92–3.5 × 0.8–1.51.5–2.5 × 0.9–1.45–6 × 3–4Petals (mm)4.5–6.5 × 2.5–35–7 × 2–2.52.5–4.5 × 1.5–2.58–10 × 7–9Stamens (mm)1.8–32.5–52–3.53–6Ovules of ovary18–4020–4220–40Not seenSeed (mm)1.4–1.6 × 0.9–1.10.8–1.1 × 0.6–0.90.9–1.2 × 0.6–0.91.2–1.8 × 0.9–1.3Wing of seedapically narrow wingwinglesswith wingwingless(DNA) ploidy level2n ≈ 6x2n = 2x = 162n = 4x = 322n = 3x = 24 Comparison of characters of C.zhangjiajieensis, C.circaeoides and C.scutata. Table 5.Taxa in phylogenetic analyses.GenBank accession numbersSpecimensSpecies name NC026446 Cardamineresedifolia L. MT136871 Cardaminequinquefolia (M.Bieb.) Schmalh. MK637691 Cardaminepentaphyllos (L.) Crantz NC036964 Cardamineparviflora L. NC036963 Cardamineoligosperma Nutt. MZ043777 Cardamineocculta With. MF405340 Cardaminemacrophylla Willd. MZ846206 Cardaminelyrata Bunge MK637684 Cardaminekitaibelii Bech. NC026445 Cardamineimpatiens L. ON322745 Cardaminehupingshanensis K.M.Liu MK637681 Cardaminehirsuta L. MN651504 Cardamineheptaphylla (Vill.) O.E.Schulz MK637680 Cardamineglanduligera O.Schwarz MZ043778 Cardaminefallax L. NC049605 Cardamineenneaphyllos (L.) Crantz OL634846 Cardaminecircaeoides Hook.f. & Thomson NC049603 Cardaminebulbifera (L.) Crantz MN651509 Cardaminebipinnata (C.A.Mey.) O.E.Schulz MZ043776 Cardamineamariformis Maxim. NC036962 Cardamineamara L. NC060863 Cardamineabchasica Govaerts KJ136821 Cardamineimpatiens L. NC069649 Rorippasylvestris (L.) Besser NC065833 Rorippaindica (L.) Hiern PP114745 ZJJ02, Li JL, Zhang C Cardaminezhangjiajieensis PP114744 Msc02, Li JL, Zhang CCardaminescutata Thunb. PP719683 Zhang549, Zhang CCardamineanhuiensis D.C.Zhang & C.Z.Shao PP719686 Zhang664, Zhang CCardaminehygrophila T.Y.Cheo & R.C.Fang PP719685 EM105, Li JL, Zhang CCardaminefragariifolia O.E.Schulz PP719684 Msc05, Li JL, Zhang CCardamineengleriana O.E.Schulz Taxa in phylogenetic analyses. Supplementary Material XML Treatment for Cardamine zhangjiajieensis