A Novel Diagnostic Feature for a Wind Turbine Imbalance Under Variable Speed Conditions Authors: Amir R. Askari, Len Gelman, Russell King, Daryl Hickey, Andrew D. Ball Published: 2024 ABSTRACT Dependency between the conventional imbalance diagnostic feature and the shaft rotational speed makes imbalance diagnosis challenging for variable-speed machines. This paper focuses on an investigation of this dependency and on a proposal for a novel imbalance diagnostic feature and a novel simplified version for this feature, which are independent of shaft rotational speed. An equivalent mass–spring–damper system is investigated to find a closed-form expression describing this dependency. By normalizing the conventional imbalance diagnostic feature by the obtained dependency, a diagnostic feature is proposed. By conducting comprehensive experimental trials with a wind turbine with a permissible imbalance, it is justified that the proposed simplified version of imbalance diagnostic feature is speed-invariant. 1. Introduction A rotor imbalance is one of the most frequent faults within wind turbines, and it can be corrected if diagnosed early [1]. However, a wind turbine imbalance may lead to a catastrophic failure if not diagnosed and treated early [1]. Aside from the direct effect of a rotor imbalance on increasing the stress level in turbine components, this fault has an adverse effect on the turbine drivetrain, leading to unwanted quality loss within the generated power [2]. Wind turbine fault diagnosis has been widely addressed in the literature to date. The available diagnostic methods in the literature are generally divided into two classes of (I) model-based [3,4,5] and (II) data-driven approaches [6,7,8,9], each of which has its own advantages and limitations. Model-based techniques require strong physical backgrounds, which can be challenging to obtain without sufficient knowledge of the system specifications. On the other hand, data-driven approaches need sufficient training data covering all faulty conditions, which are expensive to obtain. Here, the most pioneering works dealing with imbalance fault diagnosis are reviewed. Imbalance fault diagnosis has been reported in many works to date. Referring to the fact that the additional centrifugal force coming from the mass imbalance rotates with the rotational speed of the machine, this fault is reflected in the fundamental harmonic intensity of the vibration signal [10,11,12,13,14]. Besides the vibration-based diagnosis, an imbalance fault can also be diagnosed through monitoring the stator current signal [15,16,17]. Because the centrifugal excitation coming from the imbalance fault makes the airgap unequal during the rotation of the induction machine rotor. So, the fault is reflected at the rotational speed sidebands around the supply frequency [15,16,17]. Instead of monitoring the intensity of certain frequencies, Ewert [18] showed that bispectral analysis can also be adopted for mass imbalance diagnosis. It was demonstrated that despite spectral analysis, the shortage of the registration time of the analyzed signal does not have any negative impact on bispectral diagnosis. Processing the vibration and current signals, it was found that bispectral analysis is more sensitive to the imbalance fault in the case of vibration-based diagnosis. These references dealt with systems operating at a single constant rotational speed. Aside from single-speed systems, some rotating machines operate at multiple constant rotational speeds. Rafaq et al. [19] monitored the vibration signal collected from a permanent magnet synchronous motor operating at multiple constant rotational speeds. Regarding the fact that all the load-related faults like mass imbalance, rotor eccentricity and asymmetric demagnetization are reflected in the fundamental harmonic intensity of the vibration signal, a signature for distinguishing between the mass imbalance fault and others was proposed. It was shown that the strong dependency between the rotational speed and the intensity of the vibration signal fundamental rotation harmonic is a signature of the mass imbalance fault [19]. This paper did not provide diagnostic technology and just referred to this important feature of mass imbalance fault. Puerto-Santana et al. [20] investigated the imbalance fault in a general rotor-disc-bearing system. Regarding the dependency between the rotational speed and the intensity of the vibrational fundamental harmonic, their technology was based on calibrating the diagnostic system at each level of rotational speed. Their study did not cover nonstationary conditions and investigated systems operating at multiple constant speeds. Focusing on wind turbines, Ramlau and Niebsch [21] simulated the dynamical behavior of these systems under imbalance fault. Solving the inverse problem that linked imbalances and the resulting nacelle vibrations, like other references reviewed above, it was also reported that the imbalance fault is reflected in the fundamental rotation harmonic intensities. The rotational speed was kept constant in this study to generate the results. This is not compatible with the operational conditions of wind turbines, as their rotational speed is continuously varying due to wind speed fluctuations. Ewert et al. [22] employed the short-time Fourier transform together with the artificial neural network to diagnose the imbalance fault in a servo-drive dual rotor system. They also reported that the imbalance fault is reflected in the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity. Despite nonstationary signal processing, this paper provided results for a system operating at only a single constant speed. Despite systems operating at single or multiple constant speeds, reviewed above, there exists a limited number of works dealing with imbalance fault diagnosis at variable rotational speed conditions. Li et al. [23] established the wind turbine model and simulated rotational inertia, rotational speed and generator output power signals using G.H. Bladed, version 4.2, software. Adopting these simulated signals, the aerodynamic torque signal was obtained and reconstructed through the order tracking method. The amplitudes of the first and the third rotational harmonics of the aerodynamic torque signal were obtained. As the wind turbine had three rotating blades, it was observed that the amplitude of the first rotational harmonic takes very small values in comparison to those of the third ones for systems working under healthy conditions. However, for systems with an imbalance fault, the amplitude of the fundamental rotational harmonic started increasing. It was reported, that the imbalance fault occurs if the ratio between the first and the third harmonic amplitudes takes values greater than one-third. According to the results reported by Li et al. [23], the dependency between the intensity of the third rotational harmonic and the rotational speed is very weak in comparison to the speed dependency of the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity. Although their paper did not investigate the speed dependency of the ratio between the first and the third harmonic amplitudes as the diagnostic feature, one can conclude that their proposed fault indicator should not be speed-invariant. Hence, like the amplitude of the fundamental vibration harmonic, this feature still may depend on the rotational speed. Consequently, its magnitude can vary by changing either the fault severity or the rotational speed. This means that the diagnostic system cannot judge the source of change by monitoring the magnitude of this feature. Adopting the order tracking method, which can be implemented either based on the speed data from a tachometer sensor [24,25] or without these data [26,27,28,29,30], Wu et al. [31] adopted a combination of the short-time Fourier transform and the seam carving algorithm to propose a tacholess order tracking method. Extracting the instantaneous frequency of the rotor and instantaneous phase under variable-speed conditions, the original nonstationary vibrational signal was transformed from the time domain to the angle domain and then to the order domain. In doing so, in comparison to the short-time Fourier transform, the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity as the fault indicator was more accurately extracted. However, the dependency between this intensity and the rotational speed was also not addressed in this study. Xu et al. [32] diagnosed the imbalance fault in a 750 kW wind turbine using the complex Morlet wavelet transform. In processing the vibrational signal collected from the surface of the drive train, the amplitudes of the first three harmonics were obtained. Selecting the sum of the first and the second rotational harmonic intensities divided by the third harmonic magnitude of the vibrational signal as the diagnostic feature, it was shown that this new feature is sensitive to the amount of imbalance. Since the dependency of the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity on the rotational speed is much stronger than the intensities of other harmonics (e.g., the second or the third ones), the proposed feature is expected to be still speed dependent. However, this issue was not investigated in this study. Based on the literature reviewed above, it is seen that the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity should be monitored to diagnose imbalance fault based on processing the vibration signal. However, besides the difficulties involved in accurately extracting the harmonic intensities in nonstationary conditions, the strong dependency between the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity and the rotational speed, in turn, makes the diagnosis challenging in variable-speed conditions. Because diagnostic systems working based on the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity cannot distinguish between the influence of the imbalance amount and the rotational speed on changing the level of the diagnostic feature, the feature can simply increase with an increase in the rotational speed without any change in the fault severity. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, the dependency between the imbalance fault indicator and the rotational speed has not been investigated in the previous studies. Therefore, this work aims to investigate this dependency in wind turbines as variable-speed rotating machinery and to develop a novel speed-invariant feature for imbalance fault diagnosis. Therefore, the dynamics of an imbalanced wind turbine rotor as an equivalent mass–spring–damper model under centrifugal excitation is assessed to obtain a closed-form expression describing the dependency between the rotational speed and the vibrational fundamental rotation harmonic intensity. Adopting this closed-form expression, the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity is normalized to have a speed-invariant imbalance diagnostic feature. To verify the speed independency of the proposed feature, a time–frequency technique, the short-time chirp Fourier transform [33], is employed to process the experimental vibration data, collected from a 2.3 MW wind turbine with a permissible imbalance. Processing the nonstationary vibration data shows that, despite the different behavior of the fundamental rotation harmonic intensities in low- and high-speed regimes, the proposed feature is speed-invariant and behaves stably over the whole operational range. The novelty of the present work is to propose for the first time in the worldwide term an imbalance diagnostic feature that is independent from the shaft rotational speed. In view of the above-mentioned novelty, the objectives of the present study are as follows:-To investigate the nonstationary dynamics of a wind turbine rotor via an equivalent mass–spring–damper system under centrifugal excitation.-To find a closed-form expression describing the dependency between the rotational speed and the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity.-To propose a speed-invariant diagnostic feature for imbalance fault diagnosis in wind turbines via simplifying the closed-form dependency for low-speed systems.-To adopt the short-time chirp Fourier transform and process the experimental vibration data collected from a 2.3 MW wind turbine with a permissible imbalance.-To obtain the local interference level and obtain the residuals describing the net feature values.-To normalize the residuals by the local interference levels.-To extract the conventional and the proposed diagnostic features and to investigate their dependencies on the rotational speed. -To investigate the nonstationary dynamics of a wind turbine rotor via an equivalent mass–spring–damper system under centrifugal excitation. To investigate the nonstationary dynamics of a wind turbine rotor via an equivalent mass–spring–damper system under centrifugal excitation. -To find a closed-form expression describing the dependency between the rotational speed and the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity. To find a closed-form expression describing the dependency between the rotational speed and the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity. -To propose a speed-invariant diagnostic feature for imbalance fault diagnosis in wind turbines via simplifying the closed-form dependency for low-speed systems. To propose a speed-invariant diagnostic feature for imbalance fault diagnosis in wind turbines via simplifying the closed-form dependency for low-speed systems. -To adopt the short-time chirp Fourier transform and process the experimental vibration data collected from a 2.3 MW wind turbine with a permissible imbalance. To adopt the short-time chirp Fourier transform and process the experimental vibration data collected from a 2.3 MW wind turbine with a permissible imbalance. -To obtain the local interference level and obtain the residuals describing the net feature values. To obtain the local interference level and obtain the residuals describing the net feature values. -To normalize the residuals by the local interference levels. To normalize the residuals by the local interference levels. -To extract the conventional and the proposed diagnostic features and to investigate their dependencies on the rotational speed. To extract the conventional and the proposed diagnostic features and to investigate their dependencies on the rotational speed. The organization of the present paper is as follows. Section 2 investigates the dynamics of an equivalent mass–spring–damper model associated with a wind turbine rotor under centrifugal excitation and provides a closed-form expression describing the dependency between the rotational speed and the fundamental rotation harmonic intensity. The details of the present diagnosis technology, including the short-time chirp Fourier transform as the processing tool, the diagnostic feature and its extraction procedure, are presented in the rest of this section. The details of the data-capturing system, installed at the nacelle compartment of the wind turbine, are also provided in this section. The speed independency of the proposed fault indicator is discussed in Section 3. The conclusions are summarized in Section 4. 2. Theoretical Background, Diagnostic Feature Proposition and Experimental Setup 2.1. Theoretical Background Figure 1 shows a schematic of a wind turbine with an arbitrary level of imbalance, in which the x^, y^ and z^ directions describe the axis along the turbine’s main shaft, the horizontal axis perpendicular to the turbine’s main shaft and the vertical axis, respectively. In addition, m denotes the resultant imbalance mass placed in the virtual location e [34]. In this case, the centrifugal force FC applied to the main bearing of the turbine is [34] (1)FC=meΩ^2 , where Ω^ stands for the variable rotational speed of the rotor, and the product of m×e is known as the amount of imbalance reported in gr.mm [34]. As the imbalance excitation occurs in the plane of blade rotation, it can be reflected over either the y^ or z^ axis. Given the lower stiffness of the wind turbine tower in the horizontal axis in comparison to that of the vertical direction, the occurrence of horizontal oscillations is more expected. Therefore, without reducing the generality of the model, we shall focus on the y^ direction and provide the governing equations for this direction. The only difference between these two directions is related to the trigonometric function describing the reflection of the centrifugal force on each direction. This trigonometric function, which is cosine for the y^ direction and sine for the z^ direction, does not affect the intensity of the fundamental harmonic of the vibrational signal. However, the validity of taking the y^ direction as the suitable direction for imbalance diagnosis is assessed in the next section. As the instantaneous rotational speed Ω^ is the first derivative of the rotational angle θ with respect to the time t^, one can write θt^=∫0t^Ω^τ^dτ^. Therefore, focusing on the y^ direction, the horizontal component of the centrifugal excitation takes the form of (2)FCy=meΩ^2cos∫0t^Ω^τ^dτ^ . Modelling the wind turbine rotor by an equivalent mass–spring–damper system, the governing equation of motion takes the form of [35] (3)d2y^dt^2+2ξωndy^dt^+ωn2y^=meΩ^2Mcos∫0t^Ω^τ^dτ^, where ξ, ωn and M are the equivalent damping ratio of the system, its natural frequency and its equivalent mass at the location of the accelerometer. It is known that any continuous smooth function can be approximated by piecewise linear functions [36,37]. Thus, it is assumed that the whole time-domain signal is subdivided into time segments, in which the rotational speed is linearly approximated. By doing so, one can write (4)Ω^t^=Ω^0+α^0t^ For Ti≤t^