Effect of exercise referral schemes and self-management strategies on healthcare service utilisation among community-dwelling older adults: secondary analyses of two randomised controlled trials Authors: Nanna Herning Svensson, Jonas Bloch Thorlund, Pia Øllgaard Olsen, Jens Søndergaard, Sonja Wehberg, Helene Støttrup Andersen, Paolo Caserotti, Trine Thilsing Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractObjectiveThe objective of this study is to explore whether offering an integrated self-management strategy and exercise referral scheme intervention (ERS+SMS) or a stand-alone ERS intervention is more effective in reducing healthcare service utilisation among community-dwelling older adults over time compared with a stand-alone SMS/control intervention.DesignSecondary analyses of two randomised controlled trials (RCTs) with linkage to Danish national health registries.SettingThree Danish municipalities: Esbjerg, Slagelse and Odense.ParticipantsDanish community-dwelling older adults, aged 65 years or older, were included in the study. Participants originated from two completed RCTs: the Welfare Innovation in Primary Prevention (WIPP, n=115) and the SITLESS project (SITLESS, n=333).InterventionParticipants in the two trials were randomly assigned to one of three intervention groups: ERS in combination with SMS (ERS+SMS), ERS alone or an SMS/control intervention.Main outcome measureAnnual number of days with contact to general practice (GP) and days hospitalised for all causes.ResultsNo statistically significant between-group difference was observed in the annual number of days with contact with GP between participants randomised to ERS+SMS (p=0.759) or ERS only (p=0.156) compared with those randomised to the SMS/control group. In addition, no statistically significant between-group differences in days hospitalised were observed when comparing the ERS+SMS (p=0.222) or ERS only (p=0.060) group to the SMS/control group.ConclusionNeither the integrated intervention (ERS+SMS) nor the ERS alone intervention was more effective in reducing healthcare service utilisation during a 2-year follow-up period compared with a stand-alone SMS/control intervention. A potential stabilising effect of ERS and/or SMS interventions on the general age-related increase in healthcare service utilisation cannot be ruled out but needs further exploration in future studies along with the exploration of the effects of long-term interventions.Trial registration numbersNCT04531852 and NCT02629666. STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS OF THIS STUDY The use of data from two completed randomised controlled trials in combination with Danish health registry data is a methodological strength. The use of data from two completed randomised controlled trials in combination with Danish health registry data is a methodological strength. Despite the inevitable risk of self-selection bias, a notable strength lies in the composition of the study population; specifically, our study encompasses a distinctive sample of community-dwelling older adults, a demographic traditionally challenging group to recruit for research purposes. Despite the inevitable risk of self-selection bias, a notable strength lies in the composition of the study population; specifically, our study encompasses a distinctive sample of community-dwelling older adults, a demographic traditionally challenging group to recruit for research purposes. The content of the interventions was not completely identical in the two randomised controlled trials, which we addressed by including by-project stratified analyses. The content of the interventions was not completely identical in the two randomised controlled trials, which we addressed by including by-project stratified analyses. It cannot be ruled out that some of the study outcomes may be influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic-induced lockdown in Denmark in 2020; however, changes in reporting to the Danish National Patient Registry are unlikely to have influenced our results, as no remarkable changes in the number of days hospitalised were identified in the matched comparison group following the shift in reporting. It cannot be ruled out that some of the study outcomes may be influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic-induced lockdown in Denmark in 2020; however, changes in reporting to the Danish National Patient Registry are unlikely to have influenced our results, as no remarkable changes in the number of days hospitalised were identified in the matched comparison group following the shift in reporting. Introduction In the context of ageing, there is a well-established association between advancing age and a decline in physical functions, coupled with a rise in multimorbidity.13 This shift in health profile inevitably results in an increased utilisation of healthcare services, providing an incentive for policy-makers to initiate new preventive initiatives aimed at enhancing and maintaining the health and well-being of older adults. Community-dwelling older adults constitute a distinctive target group of interest with considerable preventive potential. For both individual and socioeconomic benefits, the objective of many preventive interventions directed towards community-dwelling older adults is, therefore, to foster the maintenance of physical functioning and independence, thereby avoiding hospitalisations and reducing the use of healthcare services.4 5 Exercise referral schemes (ERSs) and self-management strategies (SMSs) are frequently used preventive strategies.6 7 ERSs are exercise-based interventions designed to facilitate exercise participation and promote physical activity.8 9 The efficacy of ERS may be heightened by integrating SMS, characterised by, for example, fostering the adoption of physically active behaviours.10 Numerous studies have demonstrated positive outcomes from offering ERS on various health metrics, such as body mass index,9 11 12 fat and muscle mass,13 blood pressure,9 11 12 fitness rating11 and quality of life.9 Additionally, studies among older adults in care homes indicate that ERS may significantly reduce fall risk factors14 and enhance physical function.15 Furthermore, positive findings from SMS interventions have been demonstrated on chronic pain16 and self-efficacy.17 Moreover, the combined intervention of ERS and SMS is effective in increasing functional capacity.18 19 Existing research indicates that both physical activity, which is the central element in ERS interventions, and SMS are linked to reduced healthcare utilisation, meaning fewer hospitalisations and general practice (GP) services.517 2023 Such effects may in part be linked to a positive association between muscle strength and health-related quality of life.24 However, the aforementioned studies are cohort studies,2022 cross-sectional studies23 or systematic reviews of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) measuring outcome postintervention at either 3 or 6 months.5 17 Based on the existing research, uncertainties persist regarding the long-term impact of ERS and SMS interventions, individually or in combination, on healthcare service utilisation. We hypothesise that an integrated ERS+SMS intervention or a stand-alone ERS intervention will be more effective in reducing healthcare service utilisation among community-dwelling older adults, compared with stand-alone SMS/control interventions. This will be investigated in the present study, with healthcare service utilisation measured through contacts to GP and hospitalisations. Methods Study population We included participants from two RCTs, The Welfare Innovation in Primary Prevention (WIPP)18 and The SITLESS project: exercise referral schemes enhanced by self-management strategies to battle sedentary behaviour in older adults (SITLESS).25 The participants resided in the Danish municipalities of Esbjerg (WIPP), Slagelse (WIPP) and Odense (SITLESS) and were all community-dwelling older adults aged 65 years or older. The participants recruited in both WIPP18 and SITLESS25 were older adults with sedentary behaviour or other key risk factors for premature disability (eg, reduced physical function). All participants were recruited to the WIPP and SITLESS studies through the nationally regulated preventive home visits offered by the municipalities according to Danish legislation, the Act on Social Service § 79a.26 One of the objectives of the home visit is to support older adults who do not receive personal care and/or practical help from the municipality and address individual needs that are crucial for enabling them to maintain independence.27 To be included in the present study, participants had to meet the following criteria: (1) they were included and randomised to an intervention in either the WIPP or SITLESS trials and (2) they had a valid Civil Registration Number (CPR number). As the WIPP and SITLESS studies were based on voluntary participation, leading to a self-selected group of individuals, we included an external matched comparison group to show general trends in the population. This group was identified from the general Danish population based on information from the Danish Central Person Register and identified through Statistics Denmark. The group was matched to the study population in a 1:10 ratio and was matched on age, sex and vital status (alive) at the time of the first intervention session for the respective study participant to whom they were matched; this is referred to as the index date. Interventions The interventions in WIPP and SITLESS have previously been described in detail.18 25 The WIPP study (www.ClinicalTrials.gov reg. no.: NCT04531852) was a two-armed RCT, where individuals were randomised to either an ERS+SMS or SMS-only intervention.10 The index date of the first and last participants was 24 September 2018 and 9 August 2019, respectively. The ERS+SMS intervention consisted of a 12-week structured exercise programme, designed to improve physical activity and physical functioning, with two supervised exercise sessions per week each of 1-hour duration, in combination with a 24-week SMS intervention consisting of 8 group-based 1.5-hour sessions. The SMS-only intervention also lasted for 24 weeks, but with a total of 12 group-based 1.5-hour sessions. The SMS intervention focused on, for example, sedentary behaviour, physical activity, diet and additional risk factors for functional loss.6 The SITLESS study (www.ClinicalTrials.gov reg. no.: NCT02629666) was a three-armed RCT. Participants were randomised to ERS+SMS, ERS-only or a control group. The index date of the first and last participants was 3 November 2016 and 16 November 2017, respectively. The ERS+SMS intervention consisted of a 16-week ERS intervention, with two supervised 1-hour exercise sessions per week, in combination with a 30-week SMS intervention consisting of six group-based sessions, one one-to-one session and four telephone calls with a duration of 20–60 minutes per session. The ERS-only intervention consisted of two supervised 1-hour exercise sessions per week for 16 weeks. The control group received a written general booklet containing WHO's recommendations regarding physical activity and was invited to two seminars, each of 2-hour duration. The seminars focused on (1) physical activity, sedentary behaviour and exercise and (2) healthy nutrition in older adults.25 According to this, we categorise the group as having undergone an SMS/control intervention. For an overview of the interventions in WIPP and SITLESS, see table 1. Table 1Overview of interventions in WIPP and SITLESS: exercise referral scheme (ERS) interventions described using parameters (frequency, intensity, time and type)ERS in combination with self-management strategies (ERS+SMS)ERSSMS/control group (SMS/control)SITLESSERSFrequency: 2 times per week for 16 weeksIntensity: Participants performed 1–2 sets of 6–8 repetitions per exercise. Repetitions will increase when 8 can be completed with ease, up to a maximum of 20. Three sets of progressively complex exercises were used. On mastering an easier set unaided, participants will advance to the next levelTime: 2×1 hour per weekType: The workout included aerobic, strength, endurance, balance and flexibility exercisesSMSDuration: 30 weeksGroup sessions: 6×1 hourIndividual sessions: 1 hour intro+4 follow-up telephone calls varying between 20 and 60 minThe aim of the SMS was, among others, to set realistic goal setting to increase physical activity and decrease sedentary behaviourFrequency: 2 times per week for 16 weeksIntensity: Participants will initially perform 1–2 sets of 6–8 repetitions per exercise. Repetitions will increase when eight can be completed with ease, up to a maximum of 20. Three sets of progressively complex exercises were used. On mastering an easier set unaided, participants will advance to the next levelTime: 2×1 hour per weekType: The workout included aerobic, strength, endurance, balance and flexibility exercisesHealth informationA booklet based on theWHOs recommendations for physical activity and healthSeminars2×2 hours focusing on physical activity and nutritionWIPPERSFrequency: Exercise 12 weeksIntensity: Participants were instructed to perform three sets of ten repetitions at a target intensity of 10 repetition maximumTime: 2×1 hour per weekType: The workout included resistance, balance, and aerobic exercisesSMS24 weeks’ durationGroup sessions, 8×1.5 hoursThe SMS focused on participant-centred activities, health information dissemination and motivational conversations. The aim was to encourage participants regarding their own ability to act, thereby reinforcing them to adopt healthier behavioursDuration: 24 weeksGroup sessions, 8×1.5 hoursThe SMS focused on participant-centred activities, health information dissemination and motivational conversations. The aim was to encourage participants regarding their own ability to act, thereby reinforcing them to adopt healthier behavioursSITLESSSITLESS project: exercise referral schemes enhanced by self-management strategies to battle sedentary behaviour in older adultsWIPPWelfare Innovation in Primary Prevention Overview of interventions in WIPP and SITLESS: exercise referral scheme (ERS) interventions described using parameters (frequency, intensity, time and type) SITLESSSITLESS project: exercise referral schemes enhanced by self-management strategies to battle sedentary behaviour in older adultsWIPPWelfare Innovation in Primary Prevention In the present study, the intervention groups from WIPP and SITLESS were merged into the following groups: ERS+SMS, ERS and SMS/control. Outcome variables and data sources The outcomes of interest were: (1) annual number of days with contact with GP (all causes) and (2) annual number of days hospitalised (all causes), retrieved from the Danish National Health Service Register28 and the Danish National Patient Register (DNPR).29 By using the CPR number, a unique personal identifier, data from WIPP and SITLESS were linked with information from the Danish National Health Service Register and DNPR. Table 2 displays the different types of contacts to GP (including service codes) included in the analyses. Data were extracted from both public and private hospitals, encompassing somatic and psychiatric departments. Due to Danish national legislation about treatment guarantees at hospitals within a given time frame a free choice of hospitals is available in Denmark,30 which is the reason for the inclusion of private hospitals. As a result of policy regulations, the reporting practice to DNPR was altered in January 2019. It was mandatory for all Danish regions, private hospitals and specialised physicians to fully adopt the new reporting standard by 3 March 2019.31 The description of the reporting practices and coding details is available in online supplemental appendix 1. Table 2Included types of contacts to general practice (GP)Type of contact with GPService codes in danish GPConsultation in the GP clinic0101Phone consultation including phone consultations without visit/consultation0201 and 0501Email consultation0105Video consultation0125Yearly status consultation for selected chronic illnesses/conditions.The purpose of these is:To gain an overview of complications and potential progression of existing complications.To gain an overview of risk factors that may necessitate intervention.To motivate and acknowledge the patient’s self-care.To conduct a medication review.400120Outpatient visit (a consultation in the home of the patient including visits in nursing homes)0411-0461 (the different codes used vary based on the distance in kilometres between the citizen’s residence and the GP), 0471, 0102 and 0491Outreach home visit (usually offered to fragile older adults +75 years, with the aim of discussing the patient’s situation and not a specific medical problem)0121 Included types of contacts to general practice (GP) To gain an overview of complications and potential progression of existing complications. To gain an overview of complications and potential progression of existing complications. To gain an overview of risk factors that may necessitate intervention. To gain an overview of risk factors that may necessitate intervention. To motivate and acknowledge the patient’s self-care. To motivate and acknowledge the patient’s self-care. To conduct a medication review.40 To conduct a medication review.40 Baseline number of days with contact with GP and days hospitalised was calculated using data from 360 days before the index date (day −361 to −1). The index date was included in the 2-year follow-up period (days 0–720), with months defined as 30-day intervals. Individuals were not excluded in the event of death or migration during the follow-up period. Instead, we estimated the time at risk for each individual, which we accounted for in the analyses. Data analysis Descriptive statistics were reported as counts (n) and proportions (%). An intention-to-treat approach was applied and a linear fixed effects regression model accounting for clustering in matched comparison groups was used to estimate between-group differences in the total number of days with contact with GP and days hospitalised, from baseline to follow-up. The primary comparisons are between ERS+SMS and SMS/control, and between stand-alone ERS and SMS/control, both within the RCT setup. Since this study involves secondary analyses of RCTs, we interpret our results as exploratory; therefore, we do not perform p value adjustments for multiplicity. The group receiving SMS/control served as the reference group in all analyses. Since the fixed effects model simultaneously models outcomes at both times, the regression coefficient of interest was included as an interaction term between time (days) and group. Each participant’s time at risk was accounted for in the analyses by dividing the counts by risk time. As this study combines data from two distinct RCTs (WIPP and SITLESS), we also conducted all analyses stratified by project to determine whether there were project-specific differences. Additionally, we assessed whether the transition in reporting to DNPR had a systematic impact on the number of days hospitalised in the matched comparison group 1 year before and after the transition. All statistical analyses were conducted by using Stata/BE V.18.0 (StataCorp), with a predetermined level of statistical significance set at 5%. Patient and public involvement The design, conduct, reporting and dissemination plans of this study were undertaken without the involvement of patients or the public. Nonetheless, the original RCTs, which serve as the data source for this study, did include patient and public involvement. Results The combined participant count from the WIPP and SITLESS studies totalled 448 individuals. Among these, 175 were randomly assigned to ERS+SMS, 110 to ERS-only and 163 to SMS/control (figure 1). Most of the participants were women (n=273 (61%)). Across all intervention groups, the predominant age range was between 75 and 84 years. Additionally, the proportion of participants with one or more chronic diseases was comparable between the three intervention groups, ranging from 17% to 19% (table 3). The median number of days with contact with GP and days hospitalised is close to similar among the three intervention groups and the matched comparison group at baseline. However, we find that the baseline maximum number of days hospitalised varies to a larger degree between the groups than the maximum number of days with contact with GP (online supplemental appendix 2). From the project-stratified baseline characteristics, we found statistically significant differences between the participants included in WIPP and SITLESS in terms of sex, age, marital status and number of chronic diseases (online supplemental appendix 3). Table 3Baseline characteristics of the study population given in counts and percentages (N (%))SMS/controlERS+SMSERSTotal intervention groupMatched comparison groupTotaln (%)163 (100)175 (100)110 (100)448 (100)4480 (100)Registry dataSexWomen99 (61)108 (62)66 (60.00)273 (61)2730 (61)Men64 (39)67 (38)44 (40.00)175 (39)1750 (39)Age group65–74 years37 (23)34 (19)30 (27)101 (23)1010 (23)75–84 years95 (58)118 (67)65 (59)278 (62)2780 (62)85–94 years31 (19)23 (13)15 (14)69 (15)690 (15)Marital statusMarried/registered partnership56 (34)64 (37)49 (45)169 (38)2291 (51)Widowed/divorced/not married107 (66)111 (63)61 (55)279 (62)2189 (49)Number of chronic diseases*0 chronic diseases77 (47)74 (42)51 (46)202 (45)2444 (55)1 chronic disease56 (34)67 (38)40 (36)163 (36)1423 (32)+1 chronic diseases30 (18)34 (19)19 (17)83 (19)613 (14)Number of days with contact with GP†0–1 days7 (4)12 (7)–‡20 (4)404 (9)2–5 days27 (17)25 (14)17 (15)68 (15)877 (20)6–10 days39 (24)46 (26)40 (36)125 (28)1066 (24)+10 days90 (55)92 (53)53 (48)235 (52)2133 (48)Number of days hospitalised†0 days128 (79)146 (83)94 (85)368 (82)3518 (79)1–3 days21 (13)18 (10)10 (9)49 (11)469 (10)4–10 days14 (9)6 (3)6 (5)20 (4)289 (6)+10 days–§5 (3)–§11 (2)204 (5)Project dataProjectSITLESS110 (67)113 (65)110 (100)333 (74)–WIPP53 (33)62 (35)–115 (26)–Matched comparison group––––4480 (100)*Chronic disease covers include chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), diabetes (type 1 and type 2), osteoporosis, and arthritis.†The Nnumber of days with contact towith GP and days hospitalised is based on a period of 360 days before the first index date. ‡Due to the low number of observations (n<5), the category ‘0–1 days’ haves been merged with ‘2–5 days’.§Due to the low number of observations (n<5), ‘+10 days’ haves been merged with ‘4–10 days’.¶WIPP; Welfare Innovation in Primary Prevention and SITLESS; SITLESS project: exercise referral schemes enhanced by self-management strategies to battle sedentary behaviour in older adults.ERSexercise referral schemeGPgeneral practiceSMSself-management strategyWIPPWelfare Innovation in Primary Prevention Baseline characteristics of the study population given in counts and percentages (N (%)) Chronic disease covers include chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), diabetes (type 1 and type 2), osteoporosis, and arthritis. The Nnumber of days with contact towith GP and days hospitalised is based on a period of 360 days before the first index date. Due to the low number of observations (n<5), the category ‘0–1 days’ haves been merged with ‘2–5 days’. Due to the low number of observations (n<5), ‘+10 days’ haves been merged with ‘4–10 days’. WIPP; Welfare Innovation in Primary Prevention and SITLESS; SITLESS project: exercise referral schemes enhanced by self-management strategies to battle sedentary behaviour in older adults. ERSexercise referral schemeGPgeneral practiceSMSself-management strategyWIPPWelfare Innovation in Primary Prevention Flow chart of the study population. WIPP, Welfare Innovation in Primary Prevention. SITLESS, SITLESS project: exercise referral schemes enhanced by self-management strategies to battle sedentary behaviour in older adults. Contacts to GP The contact pattern to GP was similar across the three intervention groups at baseline as well as follow-up. At baseline, the estimated annual mean number of days with contact with GP ranged from 12.4 to 13.7 and at follow-up, it ranged from 12.5 to 13.8. No statistically significant differences in days with contact with GP were observed between or within the intervention groups. However, a small but statistically significant increase of 0.9 days with contact with GP was identified in the matched comparison group (95% CI 0.61; 1.24) (table 4). Table 4Within-group changes and between-group differences in contacts to general practice and days hospitalised, including by project stratified analysesBaselineMean (SD)Follow-upMean (SD)Estimated within-group changes(95% CI)Between-group differences(95% CI)P value for between-group differences(Group×time interactions): Annual number of days with contact to general practice SMS/control (n=163)13.7 (9.4)13.3 (10.4)−0.5 (−2.09; 1.16)Ref. ERS+SMS (n=175)12.7 (9.7)12.5 (10.4)−0.2 (−1.35; 1.04)0.3 (−1.70; 2.33)0.759 ERS (n=110)12.4 (7.7)13.8 (12.0)1.3 (−0.56; 3.24)1.8 (−0.69; 4.31)0.156 Matched comparison group (n=4480)12.4 (11.0)13.4 (13.1)0.9 (0.61; 1.24)1.4 (−0.25; 3.04)0.095(Group×time interactions): Annual number of days hospitalised SMS/control (n=163)1.0 (2.6)4.6 (15.9)3.7 (1.21; 6.14)Ref. ERS+SMS (n=175)1.3 (6.5)3.1 (9.5)1.8 (0.12; 3.50)−1.9 (−4.85; 1.13)0.222 ERS (n=110)0.8 (3.1)1.7 (6.9)0.9 (−0.46; 2.35)−2.7 (−5.57; 0.11)0.060 Matched comparison group (n=4480)1.7 (6.5)3.9 (18.0)2.2 (1.72; 2.77)−1.4 (−3.92; 1.07)0.262By-project stratified analyses(group×time interactions): Annual number of days with contact to general practiceWIPP study SMS/control (n=53)16.3 (11.4)12.5 (10.8)−3.8 (−7.23; −0.42)Ref. ERS+SMS (n=62)14.1 (11.9)12.4 (12.3)−1.7 (−4.18; 0.78)2.1 (−2.09; 6.34)0.319 Matched comparison group (n=1150)12.1 (10.3)13.1 (13.7)1.0 (0.30; 1.71)4.8 (1.39; 8.29)0.006SITLESS study SMS/control (n=110)12.5 (7.9)13.6 (10.2)1.1 (−0.55; 2.85)Ref. ERS+SMS (n=113)11.9 (8.3)12.6 (9.3)0.7 (−0.55; 1.94)−0.5 (−2.56; 1.65)0.671 ERS (n=110)12.4 (7.7)13.8 (12.0)1.3 (-0.56; 3.24)0.2 (−2.36; 2.74)0.883 Matched comparison group (n=3330)12.6 (11.3)13.5 (12.9)0.9 (0.54; 1.25)−0.3 (−1.97; 1.47)0.774By-project stratified analyses(group×time interactions): Annual number of days hospitalisedWIPP study SMS/control (n=53)1.2 (2.7)8.5 (23.2)7.2 (0.86; 13.63)Ref. ERS+SMS (n=62)2.8 (10.5)4.9 (13.1)2.1 (−2.16; 6.40)−5.1 (−12.82; 2.56)0.189 Matched comparison group (n=1150)1.6 (5.7)4.4 (20.7)2.7 (1.48; 4.01)−4.5 (−10.93; 1.93)0.168SITLESS study SMS/control (n=110)0.8 (2.6)2.8 (10.3)1.9 (0.00; 3.83)Ref. ERS+SMS (n=113)0.5 (2.2)2.1 (6.6)1.6 (0.42; 2.86)−0.3 (−2.54; 1.99)0.812 ERS (n=110)0.8 (3.1)1.7 (6.9)0.9 (−0.46; 2.35)−1.0 (−3.34; 1.40)0.422 Matched comparison group (n=3330)1.7 (6.7)3.8 (17.0)2.08 (1.52; 2.63)0.2 (−1.82; 2.14)0.875ERSexercise referral schemeSITLESSSITLESS project: exercise referral schemes enhanced by self-management strategies to battle sedentary behaviour in older adults.SMSself-management strategyWIPPWelfare Innovation in Primary Prevention Within-group changes and between-group differences in contacts to general practice and days hospitalised, including by project stratified analyses ERSexercise referral schemeSITLESSSITLESS project: exercise referral schemes enhanced by self-management strategies to battle sedentary behaviour in older adults.SMSself-management strategyWIPPWelfare Innovation in Primary Prevention Days hospitalised The estimated annual mean number of days hospitalised ranged from 0.8 to 1.7 at baseline and increased to a range of 1.7 to 4.6 at follow-up among the three intervention groups and the matched comparison group. No statistically significant between-group differences in days hospitalised were identified. The estimated within-group changes revealed a statistically significant increase from baseline to follow-up of 3.7 days hospitalised in the SMS/control group (95% CI 1.21; 6.14), 1.8 days hospitalised in the ERS+SMS group (95% CI 0.12; 3.50) and 2.2 days hospitalised in the matched comparison group (95% CI 1.72; 2.77) (table 4). Online supplemental appendix 4 illustrates days with contact with GP and days hospitalised over time for the three intervention groups. We found no systematic changes in the number of days hospitalised within the matched comparison group following the shift in reporting to DNPR (online supplemental appendix 5). By-project stratified analyses of days with contact with GP and days hospitalised Welfare Innovation in Primary Prevention In the WIPP study, a statistically significant between-group difference of 4.8 days, indicating more GP contacts, was observed in the matched comparison group (95% CI 1.39; 8.29) compared with the SMS/control group. A statistically significant within-group increase of 1 day in the annual mean number of days with contact with GP was observed in the matched comparison group (95% CI 0.30; 1.71). No between-group differences were identified in days hospitalised among the WIPP participants. The within-group changes showed statistically significant increases of 7.2 days in the SMS/control group (95% CI 0.86; 13.63) and 2.7 days in the matched comparison group (95% CI 1.48; 4.01) (table 4). SITLESS No statistically significant between-group differences in the number of days with contact with GP were identified. A statistically significant within-group increase of 0.9 days with contact with GP from baseline to follow-up was observed in the matched comparison group (95% CI 0.54; 1.25). We found no statistically significant between-group differences in the number of days hospitalised. The within-group changes revealed a statistically significant increase of 1.6 days hospitalised from baseline to follow-up in the ERS+SMS group (95% CI 0.42; 2.86) and 2.08 days in the matched comparison group (95% CI 1.52; 2.63) (table 4). Online supplemental appendix 6 illustrates days with contact with GP and days hospitalised over time for WIPP and SITLESS participants separately, and their matched comparison group. Discussion To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to investigate whether an integrated SMS and ERS intervention (ERS+SMS) or a stand-alone ERS intervention is more effective in reducing healthcare service utilisation among community-dwelling older adults, compared with a stand-alone SMS/control intervention. We observed no significant differences between the intervention groups, suggesting that an integrated ERS+SMS or a stand-alone ERS intervention is not more effective at reducing healthcare service utilisation, measured as days with contact with GP and days hospitalised. Some previous studies on the effects of exercise programmes, alone or in combination with telephone follow-up, contradict our findings by showing fewer readmissions, GP visits32 and a shorter overall length of stay in hospital.33 Another study aligns with our results by finding no differences in hospital utilisation over time. However, it also found that the control group was significantly more prone to hospitalisations lasting more than 3 days.34 It is worth noting that the mentioned studies vary considerably in terms of intervention content and target group, and only one of the studies included a combined intervention. WIPP and SITLESS provided complex lifestyle interventions, featuring an ERS+SMS component to enhance physical functioning and activity in community-dwelling older adults. While not directly addressing healthcare service utilisation, results from WIPP and SITLESS, along with numerous other studies on complex lifestyle interventions, support their positive health effects.9 11 12 18 19 Therefore, complex lifestyle interventions may potentially reduce healthcare service utilisation by affecting various influential factors. However, common causes for admission and readmissions in older adults, such as polypharmacy, infectious diseases, dehydration, new acute diseases1 and adverse events associated with the use of analgesics,35 were not specifically targeted by the WIPP and SITLESS interventions. Participants from WIPP and SITLESS were recruited through the preventive home visits offered by the municipalities. The participants were, therefore, living independently without municipal assistance in terms of personal and/or practical help. Moreover, all participants voluntarily joined WIPP and SITLESS, indicating that they had the energy in their everyday lives to participate in a research project. This may indicate that we have recruited a selected group of individuals, and their general use of healthcare services might be expected to be lower compared with older adults receiving assistance from the municipality or residing in an assisted living facility. A significant rise in the number of days with contact to a GP was evident only in the matched comparison group. This rise aligns with the overall trend in the general Danish population of older adults.36 The absence of a corresponding rise in GP contacts within the intervention groups might be explained by the fact that community-dwelling older adults attending research projects may be selected and healthier group of individuals compared with multimorbid older adults in nursing homes. Nevertheless, the observation that the overall intervention group exhibited a higher percentage of individuals with multimorbidity compared with the externally matched comparison group suggests that the intervention offered by WIPP and SITLESS may in fact have a stabilising impact on healthcare service utilisation. Such a potential effect must be explored further in future studies specifically designed for that purpose. It is also worth investigating whether a potential stabilising effect might occur with the use of SMS interventions alone. Strengths and limitations Although we contend that our sample reasonably reflects the characteristics of typical community-dwelling older adults in Denmark, it is important to acknowledge the potential self-selection bias in voluntary research projects. Older adults residing in the community, without municipal assistance in terms of personal or practical help, who willingly participate in research projects, might be more resourceful, potentially leading to distinct patterns of healthcare system engagement compared with the general population. To address this concern, we incorporated a matched comparison group. Despite this risk of self-selection bias, a notable strength lies in the composition of the study population. Specifically, our study encompasses a distinctive sample of community-dwelling older adults, a demographic traditionally challenging to recruit for research purposes. The successful recruitment in both WIPP and SITLESS may be attributed to the integration of recruitment within the framework of preventive home visits. Both WIPP and SITLESS are completed RCTs with similar intervention components, including an ERS+SMS intervention and an SMS/control intervention. However, the SITLESS study also included a stand-alone ERS intervention. The rationale behind combining the SMS programme from the WIPP study with the SMS/control group in the SITLESS study was to form an overall intervention group comprising a stand-alone less comprehensive intervention, contrasting with the integrated ERS+SMS intervention. However, as the content of the interventions was not completely identical in WIPP and SITLESS, we also conducted by-project stratified analyses. By combining data from the two RCTs with information from the Danish health registries, we gain valuable insights into additional relevant outcomes. Using register-based outcome measures in the present study is a strength, as the validity and accuracy of the DNPR are high37 and the coverage of the Danish National Health Service Register is satisfactory.28 38 Originally, our plan included home nursing assistance as an additional outcome. However, due to insufficient data completeness, we decided not to include this outcome in the study. Yet, incorporating home nursing assistance would have been interesting and relevant, given the study’s focus on community-dwelling older adults. To elucidate the absence of statistically significant findings, a post hoc power analysis could have been conducted. However, this study represents a secondary and exploratory analysis of data from two previously completed RCTs, where power calculations were based on the primary outcomes of those trials. We acknowledge that a post hoc power analysis could highlight the potential lack of statistical power in this study to detect statistically significant changes. Nevertheless, given that the observed effect size in this study is relatively small and, in our judgement, not clinically relevant, conducting a post hoc power analysis would not be meaningful. It is unlikely that the results observed in our study have been influenced by the policy changes in reporting to the DNPR, as we did not identify systematic changes in the number of days hospitalised following the shift in reporting to DNPR. With respect to the potential influence of the COVID-19 lockdown, statistical documentation from Statistics Denmark found that there was an increase in the total number of contacts to GP during COVID-19.39 This is opposite to our findings in the by-project stratified analysis for the WIPP population, which was the study population potentially affected by COVID-19. Yet, we do find a statistically significant within-group increase in contacts to GP in the matched comparison group corresponding to the overall increase found by Statistics Denmark.39 Therefore, we cannot rule out that COVID-19 may have affected the WIPP population leading to fewer GP contacts. Conclusion An integrated ERS+SMS or stand-alone ERS intervention was not more effective in reducing healthcare service utilisation among community-dwelling older adults, as compared with a stand-alone SMS/control intervention. However, our results indicated a potential stabilising effect on the use of healthcare services compared with the external matched comparison group. Such effects should be explored further in future studies. supplementary material