Determinants of the First Birth Interval Among Women in India Authors: Dewaram A Nagdeve, Manas Ranjan Pradhan Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractObjective:The first-birth interval after a marriage indicates the reproduction behavior of women and influences the population’s birth rates and size. The present study assesses predictors of the interval between marriage and first childbirth in India.Materials and methods:The study employed the Cox proportional hazard model and Kaplan Meier Survival plot based on the data collected from 79,787 ever-married women in the 15–49 age group from the National Family Health Survey 2019–2021.Results:The median age of marriage to the first birth interval was 23 months in India. The older marriage cohort had longer birth intervals than the younger. The hazard ratios (HR) showed that the risk of first birth after marriage was much higher among women with higher education (HR= 2.05, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 1.98–2.11) than women without education. Women in urban areas (HR=1.22, 95% CI = 1.20–1.25) had a higher risk of first birth after marriage earlier than women from rural areas. Women from North-east (HR=1.14, 95% CI=1.10–1.18) and South (HR=1.15, 95% CI=1.12–1.19) had a higher risk of having their first birth earlier after marriage than women in the North region. The women who married within 18–24 years of age had a 69 percent higher likelihood of first birth interval than those women who were married below the age of 18. The risk of first birth after marriage increased as women delayed marriage up to age 25 years and more (HR=3.18, 95% CI=3.02–3.35) than others.Conclusion:The timing of first birth was associated with the age at the first marital union, women’s educational attainment, place of residence, region, economic status, exposure to mass media, contraception use, and history of pregnancy termination.Keywords: First Birth Interval, Cox Proportional Hazards Model, Kaplan Meier Survival Curve, India Introduction First birth symbolizes a woman’s entry into motherhood. The first child’s birth is considered the most significant factor influencing birth rates and population size (1). The first-birth interval after marriage is one indicator that may be used to determine the fertility pattern of women in the reproductive age group (2). The length of the first birth interval impacts not just the length of the next birth intervals but also the reproduction behavior of women (3,4). Demographic and socioeconomic factors, including women’s education, age at first marriage (5), residence, wealth status, husband’s education, use of contraception, mass media exposure, and employment status (6,7), have been identified to influence the first birth interval. The woman’s age during her first birth is a significant factor affecting the population increase. Early pregnancy elongates the woman’s reproductive lifespan compared to equally fertile women who have children later (8). Women’s educational attainment was found to substantially influence the interval between marriage to first birth, with those with low or no educational attainment giving birth more soon than others (9, 10). Respondents’ rural-urban location differences also influenced the first birth interval; the interval in rural areas where marriage occurs at young ages is higher than in urban areas (Kumar & Danabalan, 2006). Socioeconomic changes affect the self-selection of spouses and the economic stability of women. In the shift from arranged to love marriages, a partner takes a long time to search for a “suitable” partner, which results in shorter birth intervals since marriage (11). Cultural traditions and social norms may greatly impact marriage to first birth. A society that mandates that women spend time with their parents or their husband’s parents after marriage may cause the first child to be delayed (8, 12). Most Indian studies have focused on predictors of birth interval with limited focus on the interval between marriage and first birth (13–15). Moreover, only a few studies conducted sufficient statistical analyses for time, i.e., survival analysis. It is crucial to study marriage to the first birth interval due to its close association with women’s reproductive health and rights, especially in the Indian context, where marriage age and spouse selection continue to be decided by parents/family for most. Thus, in the present study, a detailed analysis is made to estimate the marriage to first birth interval and assess its determinants. Materials and methods The present study used data from the fifth round of the National Family Health Survey (NFHS-5) conducted in 2019–2021 under the aegis of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW), India. The NFHS-5 is a nationally representative large-scale survey that covers all states and union territories of India. The prime objective of NFHS is to provide reliable data on various health and family welfare issues, such as fertility, mortality, maternal and child health, sexual behaviors, and domestic violence. The NFHS-5 employed a stratified two-stage random sampling design for data collection (16). As this is a secondary analysis of NFHS data available in the public domain (https://www.dhsprogram.com), no ethical approval is necessary. Ever-married women aged 15–49 covered in the state module of the survey (n=79, 787) were considered in the present analysis. In this analysis, the births in the marital union were considered to define the interval between marriage and first birth. Although premarital pregnancy might result in a first birth, these sequences were not considered due to the rarity of their occurrences in India. The analysis included 79,787 women who had their first birth after marriage (90.9%) or had no births after marriage (9.1%). The first birth interval has been grouped into three categories: before 18 months, 18–35 months, and 36 months or above (10). The first birth interval was the dependent variable. The time between marriage and the first live birth is considered the first birth interval. The demographic predictors considered for analysis were: age at first marriage (<18 years, 18–24 years, and 25 years or above), caste (Scheduled Caste-SC, Scheduled Tribe-ST, Other Backward Classes-OBC, none of them), religion (Hindu, Muslim, others), place of residence (rural, urban), region (north, central, east, north-east, west, south), marriage cohort (before 1990 before 1990–2000–2001–2010–2011–2021). Socioeconomic factors included were the education level of women and their husbands (none, 1–5 years, 6–8 years, 9–12 years, 13 years of schooling and above), wealth status (poorest, poor, middle, richer, richest), and mass media exposure (yes, no). In reproductive health-related factors included in the analysis was the mother’s age at first birth (<18 years, 18–20 years, 20 years or above), ever use of any contraceptive method, and ever terminated pregnancy. Statistical Analysis: The analysis was carried out using STATA 16.1. In addition to descriptive statistics, Cox’s proportional hazards model and Kaplan Meier’s survival plot were applied to the data to determine the key determinants that influence the marriage to the first birth interval in India. On the other hand, for those who had births, the survival time was the time interval between marriage and first birth. Results Marriage to First Birth Interval: The histogram presenting the distributional pattern of the duration of marriage to the first birth interval exhibits uni-modality and positive skewness (Figure 1). Marriage to the first birth interval of most women was above 24 months, and the decline became sharper after 36 months. It implies that most births occurred within 36 months or three years after marriage. The detailed history of first birth among the women who had experienced at least one live birth is presented in (Table 1). Histogram for length of marriage to first birth interval Table 1:Socio-demographic characteristics of married women with at least a birth in India, 2019–21 Variables n % Median Interval between marriage and first birth (months) < 18 months 18–35 months >35 months n= 29,837 n=27,209 n=15,493 Demographic factors Age at first marriage (y) less than 1832,04644.22432.4938.0829.43 18–2436,06049.71847.3337.4615.21 25 and above4,4336.11553.233.7813.02Caste SC15,58421.52139.6737.7622.57 ST6,6499.21940.438.8720.73 OBC31,79943.82141.1636.5622.28 None of them18,50725.51942.5838.4418.98Religion Hindu59,06081.42139.837.8822.33 Muslim9,78113.51944.1537.3918.46 Others3,6985.11654.433213.58Region North10,11614.01941.2339.6319.14 Central16,48822.72431.6939.6828.62 East17,28923.82236.7939.7923.42 North-east2,7133.71648.3538.7712.88 West10,22714.12044.0837.5418.37 South15,70621.71752.5931.1216.3Place of residence Urban22,75431.41944.9637.3117.73 Rural49,78568.62139.3837.623.02Marriage Cohort Before 19904,5566.32729.1735.5135.32 1990–200023,44632.32334.9337.3427.73 2001–201024,93134.42040.9737.8221.21 2011–202119,60627.01751.5337.7910.68 Socioeconomic factors Women’s Education level (y) None21,46229.62431.9238.2629.81 1–510,47414.42138.1139.2222.68 6–812,13616.72042.1538.0319.82 9–1220,08427.71749.4235.3415.24 13 and above8,38311.61647.1537.9114.94Wealth Status Poorest13,77619.02234.0438.4527.51 Poor14,87020.52138.2138.2123.58 Middle14,94220.62041.137.5621.34 Richer14,83320.51945.6335.9718.4 Richest14,11819.51846.4337.4116.15Mass media exposure No18,19325.12333.7538.5527.7 Yes54,34674.91943.637.1619.23Husband’s education (y) None13,47418.62334.6538.2627.1 1–510,68214.72139.7137.0623.23 6–812,51717.32041.4437.720.86 9–1225,10934.61944.236.6919.11 13 and above10,75714.81943.1538.7218.13 Reproductive characteristics Age at first motherhood (y) less than 1813,76719.01750.0537.8912.06 18–2048,50566.92040.3238.6721.01 >2010,26714.2233331.5335.47Ever used contraception Never used20,66428.52039.2136.1224.67 Used51,87571.52041.938.0620.04Ever had terminated pregnancy No60,47283.42042.4437.2820.28 Yes12,06716.62334.5738.6626.76Total72,5391002041.137.521.4 Socio-demographic characteristics of married women with at least a birth in India, 2019–21 All women had a median first birth interval of 20 months (1.7 years). The median interval was 24 months for women who married before age 18 and 15 months for those who married after age 25. The median first birth interval was 19 and 21 months in urban and rural areas. Among women with no education, the median first birth interval was 24 months compared with 16 months among those with higher educational attainment (13 years or above). Women in the SC category had 21 months of median first birth interval. The median interval of first birth in the marriage cohort before 1990 was 27 months, much longer than 17 months among those who married between 2011 and 2021. Survival Functions of Marriage to First Birth Interval: This study presented the patterns of survival functions of marriage to first birth interval for various factors considered in this analysis using the Kaplan-Meier survival function curves in The most notable difference in marriage to the first birth interval was found between different categories of women’s age at first marriage and at first motherhood (Figure 2). The older marriage cohort had longer birth intervals than the younger ones. In comparison to other categories of age at marriage, women who married before turning 18 showed a steeper fall. As the age at first marriage increases, women prefer to have their first child early. For other predictors, little difference in the duration of marriage to first birth interval has been observed among various categories of respondents. Urban women wanted children slightly earlier than women residing in rural areas. It has been implied that the interval in the eastern and central regions was longer than in the southern region. There is little difference in the length of marriage to first birth interval among the west and north regions. Different categories of a husband’s education had varied first birth interval lengths, which is relevant. The length of the interval was wider for those who were from richer backgrounds. Women who did not ever use any contraceptive method had shown a negative relationship. The Kaplan Meier survival functions of interval between marriage and first birth by respondent’s characteristics Risk Analysis of Marriage to First Birth Interval: Overall median survival time was 23 months, with 21 months in urban areas and 24 months in rural areas. The median survival time of the first birth interval was 18 months among women with higher education (13 years of schooling or above) and 32 months among those without educational attainment. The overall incidence rate of marriage to the first birth interval was 0.04 among those women who married between 18–24 years, 0.05 among those married after attaining the age of 25 years, and 0.02 among women married below 18 years. The univariate proportional hazard model estimates of the relative risk of factors influencing the interval between marriage and the first birth in India are shown in (Table 2). Table 2:Results of the univariate Cox proportional hazards analysis (crude analysis) to evaluated factors related to interval between marriage and first birth among ever-married women, India 2019–21 Variables IR Median ST (in months) β HR SE (β) 95% CI for HR P-value Demographic factors Age at first marriage (y) less than 180.02230Ref. 18–240.037200.451.570.010[1.53–1.60]<0.001 25 and above0.045160.621.860.018[1.79–1.92]<0.001Caste SC0.02724−0.190.010.827[0.80–0.85]<0.001 ST0.03022−0.100.010.906[0.88–0.93]<0.001 OBC0.02924−0.140.010.872[0.85–0.89]<0.001 None of them0.03421Ref.Religion Hindu0.02924Ref. Muslim0.02922−0.050.950.015[0.92–0.98]<0.01 Others0.037180.171.190.015[1.15–1.22]<0.001Region North0.03321Ref. Central0.02329−0.310.730.014[0.71–0.75]<0.001 East0.02526−0.240.790.015[0.76–0.81]<0.001 North-east0.037190.081.080.016[1.05–1.11]<0.001 West0.03222−0.010.990.017[0.96–1.03]0.638 South0.036180.061.060.015[1.03–1.09]<0.001Place of residence Urban0.034210.201.220.009[1.20–1.25]<0.001 Rural0.02924Ref.Marriage Cohort Before 19900.01447−1.240.290.024[0.27–0.31]<0.001 1990–20000.02130−0.800.450.012[0.44–0.46]<0.001 2001–20100.03223−0.410.660.011[0.65–0.68]<0.001 2011–20210.04917Ref. Socioeconomic factors Women’s Education level (y) None0.02032Ref. 1–50.027250.321.370.015[1.33–1.42]<0.001 6–80.033220.501.650.014[1.61–1.69]<0.001 9–120.041180.671.960.013[1.91–2.01]<0.001 13 and above0.042180.722.050.016[1.98–2.11]<0.001Wealth Status Poorest0.02328Ref. Poor0.027240.171.190.015[1.15–1.22]<0.001 Middle0.031220.291.330.015[1.29–1.37]<0.001 Richer0.035210.391.470.015[1.43–1.52]<0.001 Richest0.038190.471.600.015[1.55–1.65]<0.001Mass media exposure No0.02228Ref. Yes0.033210.361.430.011[1.40–1.46]<0.001Husband’s education (y) None0.02129Ref. 1–50.026260.181.200.017[1.16–1.24]<0.001 6–80.030230.321.380.016[1.33–1.42]<0.001 9–120.034210.431.530.014[1.49–1.58]<0.001 13 and above0.038200.541.720.017[1.66–1.77]<0.001 Reproductive characteristics Age at first motherhood (y) less than 180.032220.021.020.014[0.99–1.04]0.224 18–240.03123−0.210.810.017[0.79–0.84]<0.001 >=250.02424Ref.Ever used contraception Never used0.02923Ref. Used0.031230.071.070.010[1.05–1.09]<0.001Ever had terminated pregnancy No0.031220.091.090.013[1.07–1.12]<0.001 Yes0.02726Ref.IR: Incidence Rate; HR: Hazard Ratio, CI: Confidence Interval; SE: Standard Error Results of the univariate Cox proportional hazards analysis (crude analysis) to evaluated factors related to interval between marriage and first birth among ever-married women, India 2019–21 IR: Incidence Rate; HR: Hazard Ratio, CI: Confidence Interval; SE: Standard Error In the bivariate analysis, various predictors identified significantly affected marriage to the first birth interval. The hazard ratios showed that the risk of first birth after marriage was much higher among women with higher education (HR= 2.05, 95% CI=1.98–2.11) than women without education. Women in urban areas (HR=1.22, 95% CI= 1.20–1.25) had a higher risk of first birth after marriage earlier than women from rural areas. Among all ever-married women, those exposed to mass media (HR=1.43, 95% CI=1.40–1.46) were at a higher risk of having their first birth earlier than their counterparts. Table 3 illustrates Cox’s regression after adjusting for all significant factors affecting the marriage to the first birth interval. Age at marriage was a significant factor that considerably positively affected the period between marriage and the first birth. In the regression model, women from the North-east (HR =1.14, 95%CI=1.10–1.18) and South (HR=1.15, 95% CI=1.12–1.19) had a higher risk of having their first birth earlier after marriage than women in the North region. Table 3:Cox’s Proportional Hazard Regression coefficients of marriage to first birth interval by different covariates Variables HR SE 95% CI Demographic factors Age at first marriage (y) less than 18Ref. 18–241.69***0.021[1.65,1.73] 25 and above3.18***0.084[3.02,3.35]Caste SC0.90***0.014[0.88,0.93] ST0.980.017[0.95,1.02] OBC0.92***0.012[0.90,0.95] None of themRef.Religion HinduRef. Muslim0.92***0.015[0.89,0.95] Others1.010.018[0.97,1.04]Region NorthRef. Central0.83***0.013[0.81,0.86] East0.94***0.016[0.91,0.97] North-east1.14***0.021[1.10,1.18] West1.020.018[0.98,1.06] South1.15***0.018[1.12,1.19]Place of residence Urban1.01*0.012[0.98,1.03] RuralRef.Marriage Cohort Before 19900.33***0.009[0.31,0.35] 1990–20000.50***0.007[0.48,0.51] 2001–20100.68***0.008[0.67,0.70] 2011–2021Ref. Socioeconomic factors Women’s Education level (y) NoneRef. 1–51.17***0.019[1.13,1.20] 6–81.23***0.02[1.19,1.27] 9–121.30***0.021[1.26,1.34] 13 and above1.23***0.028[1.18,1.29]Wealth Status PoorestRef. Poor1.08***0.017[1.05,1.12] Middle1.14***0.019[1.10,1.18] Richer1.20***0.022[1.16,1.25] Richest1.28***0.028[1.22,1.33]Mass media exposure NoRef. Yes1.08***0.014[1.06,1.11]Husband’s education (y) NoneRef. 1–51.02**0.018[0.98,1.06] 6–81.03*0.018[1.00,1.07] 9–121.02**0.017[0.98,1.05] 13 and above1.01*0.021[0.96,1.04] Reproductive characteristics Age at first motherhood (y) less than 18Ref. 18–240.59***0.009[0.57,0.61] >=250.26***0.006[0.24,0.27]Ever used contraception Never usedRef. Used1.14***0.012[1.12,1.17]Ever had terminated pregnancy No1.11***0.014[1.08,1.13] YesRef.Log-likelihood−474576.34Model P-value<0.001*p<0.05,**p<0.01,***p<0.001; HR: Hazard Ratio; SE: Standard Error; CI: Confidence Interval Cox’s Proportional Hazard Regression coefficients of marriage to first birth interval by different covariates p<0.05, p<0.01, p<0.001; HR: Hazard Ratio; SE: Standard Error; CI: Confidence Interval The women who married within 18–24 years of age had a 69 percent higher likelihood of first birth interval than those who were married below 18. The risk of first birth after marriage increased as women delayed marriage up to age 25 years and more (HR=3.18, 95% CI=3.02–3.35) than others. Women’s education strongly positively influenced marriage to the first birth interval. The analysis shows that the respondents who had 1–5 years of schooling have a 17 percent higher likelihood of having their first birth after marriage than their uneducated counterparts. It is also observed that women who had 9–12 years (secondary) and 13 years and above (higher secondary education) had a 30 percent and 23 percent higher likelihood of giving birth than illiterates. Including the husband’s education in this model suggests that women with better-educated husbands than those with less education were at a higher risk of having their first child after marriage (HR=1.01, 95%CI=0.96–1.04). Women who ever used any method of contraception had a 14 percent higher risk of having shorter first birth intervals than those who never used it. Mothers having their first birth at 18 to 24 years had a 41 percent lower risk of first birth than those who had births on or before attaining 18 years. Discussion This study found that the average time between marriage and first birth among women is nearly two years. The significant predictors of marriage to first birth interval include women’s age at first marriage, caste, religion, geographical region, place of residence, marriage cohort, women and their husband’s educational attainment, ever use of contraception, and pregnancy termination. The study found that the median interval between marriage and first birth is 23 months. This estimated interval time is three months more than an earlier district-level study conducted one and half decades ago (8). Significant differences in the median interval between marriage and first birth across the respondent’s characteristics existed. The median interval between marriage to first birth decreased with delayed age at first marriage. This study discovered a larger likelihood of a lengthy marriage to first birth interval for women who marry before becoming 18 years old. This concurred with previous studies (9, 12, 17). This implies that women who postpone marriage often start having children shortly after marriage to compensate for their delayed entry into motherhood. This study found that women from the older marriage cohort (Before 1990) had a longer duration of marriage to the first birth interval than younger cohorts. The young age at marriage of the women in the older cohort of marriages might be responsible for this. Early-married women are neither mentally nor physiologically ready to become a mother. In addition, women used to spend a long time in their native homes before having their first birth. No education, apprehension, distress, early stage of physiological development, and unjustifiable extrapolation from family members could have affected the readiness of young girls to enter into motherhood and have reproductive health-related challenges due to young age (12). This indicated that marriage at a later age tends to decrease fertility rates among women. The impact of women’s educational attainment of marriage to first birth interval has been found in this study, which conforms to some previous studies (5, 8, 12, 18, 19). These studies also have recorded that women with no or low levels of education had longer intervals from marriage to first birth. A strong association exists between marriage to first birth interval and women’s educational attainment. This may be explained by the fact that women with higher levels of education are more prepared for marriage, better aware, and have more options when selecting their spouses. As a result, they get intimate with their partners more quickly, which leads to shorter first-birth intervals. This enabling environment might result in a shorter time between marriage and the first child and fewer births per woman. Marriage to the first birth interval was more prolonged among women in rural areas than in urban areas. A similar result was also found in previous works in China (9), Bangladesh (5, 20) and Ethiopia (12). These variations could be attributed to the fact that most women in metropolitan areas are better prepared for marriage than those in rural areas, and as a result, they are much more inclined to give birth shortly after getting married. The disparities may have also been affected by the availability of improved medical treatment in urban areas (21). The lengthy timing of first births in rural areas among women who married early and are illiterate or have low education could be attributed to high gestation loss, which is common among these women due to poor antenatal care services (21, 22). Women who reported that they had ever used contraceptives had a shorter duration of the first birth interval than those who did not use them. On the other hand, respondents who ever had terminated their pregnancy had a higher risk of longer first-birth intervals. This can be explained in this way since any contraceptive prevents pregnancy temporarily. On the contrary, since such women are more likely to experience pregnancy complications due to a previous medical termination or abortion, this may decrease the likelihood and health of another new conception (23, 24). The present study has several strengths and limitations. The results are based on the most recent large-scale nationally representative data, allowing us to reflect on the current situation of the first birth interval in the country. However, the cross-sectional nature of the dataset does not allow for any causal inference. Moreover, other biological, economic, social, and cultural factors also affect the timing of the first birth, which the current research could not include due to data unavailability. Conclusion The median interval between marriage and first birth in India is 23 months. The timing of first birth is associated with the age at the first marital union, women’s educational attainment, place of residence, region, economic status, exposure to mass media, contraception use, and history of pregnancy termination. Moreover, women from the older marriage cohort had a longer duration of marriage to the first birth interval than younger cohorts. Acknowledgments This research received no specific grant from any funding agency, commercial entity or not-for-profit organization. Footnotes Conflict of Interests Authors declare no conflict of interests. Notes: Citation: Nagdeve DA, Pradhan MR. Determinants of the First Birth Interval Among Women in India. J Family Reprod Health 2023; 17(4): 229-39. References