Comparison of intubating conditions in supine (sniffing) and 25° back-up position using channelled and non-channelled video laryngoscopes - A randomised controlled study Authors: Devyani Desai, Riddhi Sompura, Sudarshan Yadav Published: 2023 ABSTRACT Background and Aims:The 25°back-up position is proposed to increase the efficacy of preoxygenation and provide better tracheal intubating conditions when using a direct laryngoscope. This study aimed to compare the ease of tracheal intubation between supine and 25° back-up positions when using two video laryngoscopes (VLS).Methods:One hundred adults with normal airways and belonging to the American Society of Anesthesiologists physical status classes I and II, requiring general anaesthesia, were randomised in groups K and M. The trachea was intubated using King Vision and McGrath VLS in either supine (groups K1 and M1) or 25° back-up (groups K2 and M2) positions. The 25° backup position was given by raising the operating table from the horizontal position by flexing the torso at the hips so that an imaginary line connected the patient's external auditory meatus to the sternal notch. Modified Intubation Difficulty Scale (mIDS) was the primary outcome, and intubation time, the number of intubation attempts, vital parameters, and complications were compared secondarily. Statistical analysis was done using MedCalc software by applying an independent t-test for parametric data and a Chi-square test for categorical data and finding the risk ratio.Result:Mean (Standard deviation) mIDS was significantly reduced using both VLS in the 25° back-up position [0.92 (0.75) versus 0.48 (0.58), P = 0.025, degree of freedom (DF): 48, mean difference (95% confidence interval [CI]):−0.44 (−0.821 to − 0.059) in group K1 versus group K2 and 0.76 (0.59) versus 0.36 (0.48), P = 0.012, DF: 48, mean difference (95% CI): −0.40(−0.706 to − 0.094) in group M1 versus group M2, respectively]. The risk ratio comparing both the positions for the total number of patients requiring manoeuvres during intubation using both the VLS was 0.48 with P = 0.0004 and 95% CI = 0.305 − 0.765. Intubation time was shorter in the 25° backup position by using King Vision (P = 0.005) and McGrath (P = 0.042) VLS.Conclusion:The 25° backup position helps provide ease of intubation using both the channelled (King Vision) and non-channelled (McGrath) VLS. INTRODUCTION Tracheal intubation is essential in securing airway patency during general anaesthesia. Traditionally, the ‘sniffing’ position is the optimal head and neck position for direct laryngoscopy.[12] The benefits of providing better laryngeal exposure and decreasing the stress response enabled video laryngoscopes (VLSs) to be widely used for endotracheal intubation.[1] However, the literature describing the ideal head and neck position for video-laryngoscopy is still lacking. Different positions, such as supine (neutral or sniffing) or 25° backup positions, are used in clinical practice.[34] Originally, a 25° backup position was used in obese patients for difficult intubation as administration of oxygen in this position increases the margin of safety for induction of anaesthesia by achieving 23% higher oxygen tension and better intubating conditions with direct laryngoscopy with comfort for the anaesthesiologist.[56] Data are available regarding the increase in the percentage of glottic opening (POGO) score and better endoscopy angles with a 25°back-up position compared to the supine position with direct laryngoscopy, and bed-up head elevated position has been proposed as the standard position in the general population using direct laryngoscopy.[78] However, data comparing the supine and 25°back-up positions for different VLSs, such as King Vision (channelled) and McGrath (non-channelled), are scarcely available. Thus, this study was conducted to compare intubating conditions in terms of the modified Intubation Difficulty Scale (mIDS) as the primary objective in supine (sniffing) and 25°back-up positions by using King Vision and McGrath VLS. Secondarily, we compared intubation time, number of attempts of intubation, vital parameters and airway complications in both positions. METHODS After obtaining approval from the Institutional Ethics Committee for Biomedical and Health Research (vide approval number: IECBHR/57-2021 dated 19/3/2021) and trial registration in the Clinical Trials Registry, India (vide registration number: CTRI/2021/04/033273; www.ctri.nic.in), this randomised controlled study was conducted at a tertiary healthcare centre from May 2021 to February 2022. Written informed consent was obtained from all the participants to use their data for research and educational purposes. The study was conducted in agreement with the Declaration of Helsinki, 2013 and adherence to the Consolidated Standard of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) guidelines. We enroled 100 adult patients of either gender of age 18–65 years, belonging to the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) physical status classes I and II and modified Mallampati grading I and II requiring general anaesthesia with endotracheal intubation. The patients having difficult airways, morbid obesity, previous oral cavity surgeries, pre-existing tracheal or laryngeal pathology, patients requiring rapid sequence intubation, those not willing to participate, and pregnant females were excluded. The patients were randomised into two groups primarily and then into two sub-groups, each by computer-generated random numbers, which were sealed in sequentially numbered sealed opaque envelopes. In the K1 group, the trachea was intubated using a King vision VLS in the supine position, and in the K2 group, the trachea was intubated using a King vision VLS in the 25° back-up position. In the M1 group, the trachea was intubated using a McGrath VLS in the supine position. In the M2 group, the trachea was intubated using a McGrath VLS in the 25° backup position. A thorough pre-anaesthetic evaluation was done, including airway assessment and necessary laboratory investigations. All patients were kept nil by mouth for 8 h for solid food with clear liquids 2 h before the procedure. After receiving the patient at the operation theatre, the monitoring included pulse oximetry, non-invasive blood pressure, electrocardiogram, and capnography. Patients were given either supine (sniffing) or a 25° backup position according to their respective study groups. In the supine position, a 7-cm-high non-compressible pillow was kept under the head of the patient. The 25° backup position was achieved by raising the operating table to 25° from the horizontal position by flexing the torso at the hips by using the controls on the operating table so that the sternal notch and external auditory meatus were in the equal plane. The 25° angulation was checked using the ‘protractor’ app on the smartphone. For patients in group K, the King Vision channelled blade of appropriate size was mounted on the monitor, and the device's functionality was checked once by having a clear image on the monitor. Next, the appropriately sized tube was lubricated with lignocaine jelly, and the device was pre-loaded with the tube in the tube guiding channel of the blade. For patients belonging to group M, the blade of the appropriate size was mounted on the McGrath VL, and the performance of the device was checked by watching the clarity of the image on the monitor. Intravenous (IV) glycopyrrolate 5µg/kg, fentanyl 2µg/kg, and ondansetron 0.1 mg/kg were given as premedication 5 min before induction. After pre-oxygenation, induction of anaesthesia was carried out with IV propofol 2.5mg/kg and suxamethonium chloride 2 mg/kg as a neuromuscular blocking drug to facilitate tracheal intubation. The technique and device were followed as per randomisation for tracheal intubation. The first effective ventilation was confirmed by continuous square-form waveform capnography. The rest of the anaesthesia was continued as per standard protocol. The study's primary outcome was to measure the ease of intubation by using mIDS. It is a predictor of difficult intubation, including seven parameters, namely the number of attempts, number of operators, number of alternative intubation techniques (e.g., use of a bougie and rotation of the VL blade or endotracheal tube or bougie), POGO score, lifting force required, external laryngeal manipulation (ELM), and position of the vocal cords at intubation. These parameters were looked for during each intubation by using the VLS in the supine and 25° backup positions, and mIDS was calculated accordingly. Secondary outcomes measured were intubation time, number of intubation attempts, vital parameters, and complications, if any. Intubation time was considered as the time from the insertion of the VLS blade between the teeth until the first effective ventilation was confirmed by capnography. If the patient could not be intubated with optimisation manoeuvres or if >120 s were required to complete the procedure, it was reported as failed intubation. In such a situation, the patient would be intubated using a Macintosh laryngoscope and excluded from the study. A maximum of two attempts with the selected VLS were allowed before changing to another device. Complications such as desaturation (peripheral oxygen saturation <95%), bronchospasm, oropharyngeal trauma, and oesophageal intubation were also noted and managed accordingly. We calculated the sample size from a pilot study on 20 patients wherein both the VLSs were used in the supine and 25°back-up positions alternately. Taking the parameter ‘mIDS’, with a mean difference of 0.6 and standard deviation (SD) of 1 between the two groups, assuming a 95% confidence interval (CI) and 80% power, a minimum of 44 patients were required in each group. Considering dropouts, we included 50 patients per group (25 patients/sub-group). The master chart was prepared in Microsoft Excel, and the values were noted as mean (SD) for parametric data and either numbers or percentages for non-parametric data. Statistical analysis was done using MedCalc software (version 19.2.6. Ostend, Belgium). An independent t-test was applied for parametric data such as mIDS, intubation time, and complications. The Chi-square test was used for categorical data such as ASA grading, gender, manoeuvres used during intubation, number of intubation attempts, and for calculating the risk ratio. The significance of the data was judged by the P value, and P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. RESULTS All patients were analysed without any dropouts [Figure 1]. Groups K1, K2, M1, and M2 were comparable demographically and in terms of airway parameters [Table 1]. The mean (SD) mIDS was less in the 25° backup position as compared to the supine position by using both the King Vision and the McGrath VLS [0.92 (0.75) versus 0.48 (0.58), P = 0.025, degree of freedom: 48, mean difference (95% CI):−0.44 (−0.821, −0.059) (K1 versus K2, respectively) 0.76 (0.59) versus 0.36 (0.48), P = 0.012, degree of freedom: 48, mean difference (95% CI):−0.40 (−0.706, −0.094) (M1 versus M2, respectively)] [Table 2]. The ELM was required in eight and four patients in groups K1 and K2, respectively. In contrast, it was needed in seven and three patients in groups M1 and M2, respectively. Six and four patients required tube rotation in groups K1M1 and K2M2, respectively. Both manoeuvres were used in three patients in group K1 and two in group M1. A total of 68% in group K1 versus 32% in group K2 [P = 0.012, degree of freedom: 1, mean difference (95% CI):36% (8.30,56.9)], respectively, who required airway manoeuvres, whereas60% versus 28% of patients needed airway manoeuvres in M1 versus M2 [P = 0.024, degree of freedom: 1, mean difference (95% CI):32% (4.53, 53.5)] during intubation [Table 2]. Calculating the total number of patients requiring manoeuvres in the 25° back-up and supine positions by using King Vision and McGrath VLS resulted in a risk ratio of 0.48, P < 0.001, 95% CI: 0.305–0.765, and an odds ratio of 0.24 with a 95% CI 0.10 − 0.55. The intubation time was shorter using the 25°back-up position compared to the sniffing position using both the King Vision [20.4 (4.48) versus16.76 (4.27), P = 0.005, degree of freedom: 48, mean difference (95% CI):−3.64 (−6.129, −1.151) and the McGrath (20.56 (6.88) versus 17.04 (4.84), P = 0.042, degree of freedom: 48, mean difference (95% CI):−3.52 (−6.903, −0.137) [Table 2]. Intubation was accomplished on the first attempt in all the groups [Table 2]. All patients remained haemodynamically stable throughout the study period. No complications were noted in any of the groups during the study. Consolidated standards of reporting trial (CONSORT) diagram showing flow of participants Table 1Demographic and airway parametersParameterGroup K1Group K2Group M1Group M2Age (years)40.4 (9.48)40 (10.33)38.05 (11.82)39.15 (8.79)Gender Male:Female14:1113:1215:1012:13ASA physical status I/II11:149:169:1614:11Mouth Opening (cm)3.62 (0.50)3.57 (0.51)3.57 (0.49)3.52 (0.49)Mallampati Grade I13151214Grading Grade II12101311Thyromental distance (cm)7.18 (0.44)7.17 (0.43)7.01 (0.55)7.02 (0.46)Data are expressed as mean (standard deviation) or numbers. ASA=American Society of Anesthesiologists Demographic and airway parameters Data are expressed as mean (standard deviation) or numbers. ASA=American Society of Anesthesiologists Table 2Study ParametersParameterGroup K1Group K2 P Mean Difference (95% CI)Group M1Group M2 P Mean Difference (95% CI)modified Intubation Difficulty Scale (mIDS)0.92 (0.75)0.48 (0.58)0.025−0.44 (−0.821 to−0.059)0.76 (0.59)0.36 (0.48)0.012−0.40 (−0.706 to −0.094)Manoeuvres used for tracheal intubation External laryngeal manipulation841-731- Tube rotation641-641- Both30--20--Total patients requiring Manoeuvres17 (68%)8 (32%)0.0136 (8.30–56.9)%15 (60%)7 (28%)0.0232 (4.53 to 53.5)%)Intubation Time20.4 (4.48)16.76 (4.27)0.005-3.64 (-6.129 to −1.151)20.56 (6.88)17.04 (4.84)0.042−3.52 (−6.903 to −0.137)Number of attempts of intubation111-111-Data are expressed as mean (standard deviation) or numbers (percentages). CI: Confidence interval Study Parameters Data are expressed as mean (standard deviation) or numbers (percentages). CI: Confidence interval DISCUSSION Our study revealed significantly lower mIDS in the 25°back-up position compared to the supine sniffing position, suggesting that the 25° back-up position provided easy intubation using both the channelled and non-channelled VLS. Wai and Graham[9] found an improvement of 8% in the POGO score by using Glidescope VL in the ramped position compared to the supine position on the human patient simulator when used by novice laryngoscopists. Pachisia et al.[5] compared laryngeal view and intubating conditions in the sniffing position and position acquired by aligning the external auditory meatus and sternal notch horizontally by using an inflatable pillow (AM-S) and found a significant reduction in the intubation difficulty scale with improved Cormack Lehane grading of laryngeal view in the AM-S position using Macintosh laryngoscope.[5] A study compared sniffing and neutral positions by using channelled (King Vision) and non-channelled (C-MAC) VLS and found comparable mIDS with lower POGO scores by using C-MAC VLS in a neutral position.[3] According to Tsan et al.,[8] Macintosh laryngoscopy in the bed-up head elevated position provides a non-inferior laryngeal view to Glidescope laryngoscopy but is superior to the view acquired in the sniffing position among the general population. Lee et al.[7] found a significantly increased POGO score while comparing the laryngeal exposure during direct laryngoscopy in the supine and 25° back-up positions (42.2% versus 66.8%). The stylet was used for all tracheal intubations done with the McGrath VL in the current study. Tube rotation and ELM were the additional manoeuvres used for endotracheal intubation using both the VLSs. Fewer patients required ancillary manoeuvres during intubation in the 25° back-up position (28% and 32%) than in the supine position (60% and 68%). Tsan et al.,[10] Reddy et al.[4] and Gudivada et al.[11] reported less frequently required ancillary laryngeal manoeuvres in either ramp or 25° back-up compared to supine position with direct laryngoscopy. Agaskar et al.[12] demonstrated a better laryngeal view by using ELM in supine sniffing rather than in the 25 ° backup position. The use of manoeuvres also aids in the intubation time. Using both the VLSs, the intubation time was shorter in the 25°back-up position. Prior studies have reported shorter intubation time using a 25°back-up or head elevated position compared to a horizontal supine sniffing position with Macintosh and Glidescope laryngoscopy.[4913] Turner et al.[14] observed in the emergency department. that every 5° increase in the angle enhances the likelihood of first-pass success with a high success rate using VL compared to a direct laryngoscope, The limitations of our study included the selection of patients with Mallampati grading Ι and Π and confined to planned surgeries. In addition, the results cannot be generalised to patients with difficult airways, obese and pregnant patients, or those requiring emergency surgeries. Furthermore, the same results cannot be extrapolated to VLSs other than King Vision and McGrath. CONCLUSION The 25° backup position is useful in providing ease of intubation using both the channelled (King Vision) and non-channelled (McGrath) VLS with less requirement of ancillary manoeuvres and shorter intubation time without complications. Study data availability De-identified data may be requested with reasonable justification from the authors (email to the corresponding author) and shall be shared after approval as per the authors’ institution policy. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.