Synthesis and redetermination of the crystal structure of NbF5 Authors: Martin Möbs, Florian Kraus Published: 2023 ABSTRACT NbF5 was synthesized in high purity by direct fluorination. IR and Raman spectroscopy confirms the high purity. The crystal structure was redetermined at 100 K with higher precision. Chemical context NbF5 was first synthesized by Ruff and Schiller (Ruff, 1909 ▸; Ruff & Schiller, 1911 ▸) from the reaction of Nb metal with elemental fluorine or from the reaction of NbCl5 with anhydrous HF. By now, several alternative ways for its synthesis have also been described in the literature (Schäfer et al., 1965 ▸; O’Donnell & Peel, 1976 ▸). Niobium penta­fluoride is a colorless, hygroscopic solid that melts at 352.1 K and has a boiling point of 506.5 K (Junkins et al., 1952 ▸). The vapor pressure (Junkins et al., 1952 ▸; Fairbrother & Frith, 1951 ▸), the enthalpy of fusion (Junkins et al., 1952 ▸), and the electrical conductivity (Fairbrother et al., 1954 ▸) of liquid NbF5 have also been determined. Infrared and Raman spectra of the solid were measured (Preiss & Reich, 1968 ▸; Beattie et al., 1969 ▸) and the structure of NbF5 in the (supercooled) liquid, glassy state and the gas phase have been investigated by Raman spectroscopy (Boghosian et al., 2005 ▸; Papatheodorou et al., 2008 ▸). In a search for a suitable laboratory synthesis of NbF5, we investigated several methods for its preparation. During our efforts, single crystals of several millimeters in size were obtained when hot NbF5 re-sublimed at colder parts of our reaction setup (see Synthesis and crystallization). The former crystal structure published by Edwards (1964 ▸) is of lower precision compared to structure determinations possible nowadays and displacement parameters had not been refined anisotropically. Structural commentary The lattice parameters obtained from powder X-ray diffraction at 293 K [a = 9.62749 (19), b = 14.4564 (3) c = 5.12831 (10) Å, β = 95.8243 (4)°] agree with those determined by Edwards (1964 ▸) [a = 9.62 (1), b = 14.43 (2), c = 5.12 (1) Å, β = 96.1 (3)°]. Although the temperature was not explicitly stated in Edwards’ work, it can be assumed that the structure was determined at room temperature. The powder X-ray diffraction pattern is shown in Fig. 1 ▸; crystallographic details of the Rietveld refinement are given in Table 1 ▸ and the supporting information. The single-crystal structure determination was performed at 100 K and thus resulted in smaller lattice parameters by about 1–3% compared to those determined at room temperature (see Table 1 ▸). Otherwise, there are no significant structural differences compared to the RT structure. The slight contraction of the lattice parameters is mainly due to the shortening of the distances between the Nb4F20 mol­ecules, while the intra­molecular F—Nb distances determined at 100 K differ only insignificantly from those determined at room temperature. NbF5 crystallizes in the space group C2/m (No. 12, Pearson code mC48, Wyckoff sequence j 4 i 3 h) with the lattice parameters a = 9.4863 (12), b = 14.2969 (12), c = 4.9892 (6) Å, β = 97.292 (10)°, Z = 8 at 100 K. NbF5 crystallizes in the MoF5 structure type (Edwards et al., 1962 ▸; Stene et al., 2018 ▸). The structure consists of NbF5 units forming tetra­meric mol­ecules that can be described by the Niggli (Niggli, 1945 ▸) formula 0 ∞{[NbF2/2F4/1]4}. The structure of the Nb4F20 mol­ecule in the solid and the crystal structure of the compound are shown in Figs. 2 ▸ and 3 ▸. Two symmetry-independent niobium atoms reside on Wyckoff positions 4h (site symmetry 2, Nb1) and 4i (site symmetry m, Nb2) and are surrounded octa­hedron-like by six fluorine atoms. By edge-linking via two cis-positioned fluorine atoms, the NbF6 units form square-like mol­ecules. The atomic distance between the Nb1 atom and the μ-bridg­ing fluorine atoms F4 is 2.0669 (9) Å, while the Nb2—μ-F4 distance is 2.0685 (10). Thus, both Nb—μ-F4 bond lengths are identical within their tripled standard uncertainty. The Nb1—μ-F4—Nb2 bridge is slightly bent by 172.94 (5)°, with the bridging fluorine atoms pointing towards the ring center (Wyckoff position 2c, site symmetry 2/m) of the planar Nb4F20 rings. The distances between the Nb and the F trans atoms, Nb1—F6 and Nb2—F3, which are opposite to the μ-bridging F atoms, are 1.8157 (11) and 1.8121 (10) Å; also overlapping within the 3σ criterion. The μ-F—Nb—F trans angles measure 172.83 (4) and 171.95 (4)°. The terminally bound fluorine ligands in axial positions (F1, F2 and F5) show slightly longer Nb—F bonds of 1.8577 (14), 1.8378 (14), and 1.8468 (10) Å compared to those oriented equatorially (F3 and F6), showing Nb—F distances of 1.8121 (10) and 1.8157 (11) Å. This phenomenon was observed to a similar extent for the structure of MoF5 (Stene et al., 2018 ▸) and can be attributed to the structural trans effect (Coe & Glenwright, 2000 ▸; Shustorovich et al., 1975 ▸). The Nb atoms in a mol­ecule lie in a flat, nearly square plane and the crystallographic point group of the Nb4F20 mol­ecule is 2/m (C 2h ). The intra­molecular Nb1⋯Nb2 distance is 4.1275 (4) Å while the Nb1⋯Nb2⋯Nb1 angle measures 89.62 (1)°. The distances between diagonally opposite Nb atoms in the ring are 5.8565 (8), and 5.8179 (6) Å. Thus, the four Nb atoms of the Nb4F20 mol­ecule do not form an ideal square. It is distorted in a diamond shape, which corresponds to a compression along the twofold axis of rotation. An overview of inter­atomic distances and angles in the structure of NbF5 is given in Tables 2 ▸ and 3 ▸. The global crystal structure can be approximately described by a cubic close-packing of the fluorine atoms, in which 1/5th of the octa­hedral voids are occupied by Nb atoms in such a way that the Nb4F20 mol­ecules are obtained (Edwards, 1964 ▸; Müller, 2009 ▸). In addition to X-ray powder diffraction, the bulk phase was also investigated by IR and Raman spectroscopy. The obtained spectra, which are given in the supporting information, agree with those reported in the literature (Preiss & Reich, 1968 ▸; Beattie et al., 1969 ▸; Papatheodorou et al., 2008 ▸), and indicate a phase pure sample. Conclusion NbF5 was synthesized from F2 and Nb metal and obtained as a colorless, phase-pure solid and by sublimation as single crystals. The previous structure model was significantly improved with much more precise atomic coordinates and all atoms refined anisotropically, giving much better bond lengths and angles for the Nb4F20 mol­ecules. Synthesis and crystallization Niobium penta­fluoride was synthesized from the elements directly using the apparatus sketched in Fig. 4 ▸. Therein, niobium metal sheets (17.28g, 185.9mmol, TANIOBIS GmbH) were loaded in a corundum boat, which was placed inside a tube furnace. One side of the inner corundum tube of the furnace was connected to a metal Schlenk line via a PTFE sealed copper fitting, allowing control of the fluorine supply, as well as evacuating and purging the system with argon. The other side was connected to a U-shaped, 3/4-inch PFA tube via a copper pipe, followed by a PFA gas wash bottle filled with perfluoro polyether (Hostinert 216) and an absorber column filled with soda lime (Carl Roth). The copper pipe, all fittings and valves were surrounded by heating sleeves or wires and heated to 473 K to prevent resublimation of solid NbF5 inside. Before use, the apparatus was thoroughly baked out and passivated using diluted fluorine (F2/Ar, 20:80 v/v, Solvay). For the reaction a stream of diluted fluorine (F2/Ar, 20:80 v/v, approx. 36 mL min−1) was applied and the furnace temperature was set to 473 K. The first single crystals of resublimed NbF5 were obtained within several minutes in the U-shaped PFA tube. After 16 h the reaction was complete, giving 34.2 g (182.0 mmol, 98%) NbF5 as a colorless, crystalline solid (see Fig. 5 ▸). Structure determination 5.1 Single crystal structure determination: A crystal of NbF5 was selected under pre-dried perfluorinated oil (Fomblin YR 1800) and mounted using a MiTeGen loop. Intensity data of a suitable crystal were recorded with an IPDS 2 diffractometer (Stoe & Cie). The diffractometer was operated with Mo Kα radiation (0.71073 Å, graphite monochromator) and equipped with an image plate detector. Evaluation, integration and reduction of the diffraction data was carried out using the X-AREA software suite (X-AREA V1.90; Stoe & Cie, 2020 ▸). A numerical absorption correction was applied with the modules X-SHAPE and X-RED32 of the X-AREA software suite. The structures were solved with dual-space methods (SHELXT; Sheldrick, 2015a ▸), and refined against F 2 (SHELXL) within the ShelXle GUI (Sheldrick, 2015b ▸; Hübschle et al., 2011 ▸). All atoms were refined with anisotropic displacement parameters. The highest residual electron density after the final refinement was 0.80 Å distant from atom F6. Representations of the crystal structures were created with the DIAMOND software (Brandenburg & Putz, 2022 ▸). 5.2 Powder X-ray diffraction: For powder X-ray diffraction, the sample was ground using a glassy carbon mortar and filled into a quartz capillary with a diameter of 0.3 mm. The powder X-ray pattern was recorded with a StadiMP diffractometer (Stoe & Cie) in Debye-Scherrer geometry. The diffractometer was operated with Cu Kα1 radiation (1.5406 Å, germanium monochromator) and equipped with a MYTHEN 1K detector. Rietveld refinements (Rietveld, 1969 ▸) were performed using the TOPAS-Academic software (version 7; Coelho, 2018 ▸). The structural model derived from single-crystal X-ray diffraction was used as the starting point for the refinement. A shifted Chebyshev polynomial was used to describe the background of the powder pattern, the peak profiles were fitted with a modified Thompson–Cox–Hastings pseudo-Voigt (‘TCHZ’) function as implemented in TOPAS, and the zero offset was refined. To account for absorption, an intensity correction for cylindrical samples was applied as implemented in TOPAS. A weak preferential orientation of the crystallites was taken into account by means of a fourth-order spherical-harmonics function. The final refinement cycles converged with free refinement of all background, profile, and lattice parameters, including the coordinates of all atoms, the isotropic displacement parameters of the F atoms and anisotropic displacement parameters of the Nb atoms. Further details concerning the Rietveld refinement are given in Table 1 ▸ and in the supporting information. Crystal data, data collection and structure refinement details are summarized in Table 4. ▸ Supplementary Material Crystal structure: contains datablock(s) I. DOI: 10.1107/S2056989023010150/ox2001sup1.cif Structure factors: contains datablock(s) I. DOI: 10.1107/S2056989023010150/ox2001Isup2.hkl Rietveld powder data: contains datablock(s) I. DOI: 10.1107/S2056989023010150/ox2001Isup3.rtv Click here for additional data file. IR and Raman spectra. DOI: 10.1107/S2056989023010150/ox2001sup4.docx CCDC references: 2309973, 2289431 Additional supporting information: crystallographic information; 3D view; checkCIF report