Pressure-Induced Metallization of BaH2 and the Effect of Hydrogenation Authors: Hannah A Shuttleworth, Israel Osmond, Calum Strain, Jack Binns, Jonathan Buhot, Sven Friedemann, Ross T Howie, Eugene Gregoryanz, Miriam Peña-Alvarez Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractUsing optical spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, and electrical transport measurements, we have studied the pressure-induced metallization in BaH2 and Ba8H46. Our combined measurements suggest a structural phase transition from BaH2-II to BaH2-III accompanied by band gap closure and transformation to a metallic state at 57 GPa. The metallization is confirmed by resistance measurements as a function of the pressure and temperature. We also confirm that, with further hydrogenation, BaH2 forms the previously observed Weaire–Phelan Ba8H46, synthesized at 45 GPa and 1200 K. In this compound, metallization pressure is shifted to 85 GPa. Through a comparison of the properties of these two compounds, a question is raised about the importance of the hydrogen content in the electronic properties of hydride systems. High pressure can be effectively used to convert insulating materials to metals1−4 and metals to insulators,5,6 producing compounds that are otherwise unstable under ambient conditions. In recent years, the use of high pressure to synthesize novel hydrogen-rich compounds has grown exponentially, facilitating the synthesis of unreported electronic states.3,7−14 Specifically, the recent discoveries of superconducting hydrides having critical temperatures approaching room temperature have led to a renewed interest in binary hydrides.7−9,13,15−18 The hydrogen-assisted superconductivity under pressure is referred to as “chemical pre-compression” of molecular hydrogen, where the light mass of hydrogen provides high-frequency phonons, enhancing the coupling to electrons.19 Although it has been proven that hydrogen can, in fact, be beneficial for electron–phonon coupling,7,8,10,11,13 the relationship between the hydrogen content and pressure required to reach such metallic superconducting states is not always obvious. The alkaline earth elements form dihydrides (MH2, with M being the metal), which are stable at ambient conditions and are composed of the ions M+2 and 2H–.20 The heavy alkaline earth dihydrides, namely, CaH2, SrH2, and BaH2, are predicted to become metallic following a series of structural transitions.20−24 The metallization pressure of such compounds is expected to decrease with an increasing metal radius, which correlates with increasing electronegativity.20,25 Specifically, the predicted metallization pressure is 102 GPa (Tc = 1 mK) for CaH2, 177 GPa for SrH2, and 50 GPa for BaH2 (Tc = 13 mK).20−24,26 Neither the metallic nor superconducting transitions of these alkaline earth dihydrides have been experimentally observed. The alkaline earth polyhydrides have also been suggested as candidates for high Tc superconductivity. For example, CaH6 was predicted to exhibit a superconducting critical temperature of 220–235 K at 150 GPa.17 This was later experimentally confirmed, with a superconducting transition observed to occur at 210 K and 160–190 GPa.15,16 In the Sr–H system, a range of strontium polyhydrides have been synthesized above 70 GPa: SrH9, SrH6, and SrH22, of which the latter two are expected to metallize at 220 and 200 GPa, respectively.12 SrH22 is predicted to be superconducting at 200 GPa and 21 K, and Sr3H13 is predicted to exhibit superconductivity at 150 GPa and 84 K.12 Numerous barium polyhydride polymorphs have also been discovered, with Ba8H46 stable at 50 GPa,27 while BaH4, BaH6, BaH10, and BaH12 are all stable above 90 GPa.11,25,28 Most notably, BaH12 has been demonstrated to exhibit superconductivity at 20 K and 140 GPa.11 However, the electrical transport properties of the other barium hydrides have not yet been measured experimentally. Hence, there is limited information about how hydrogen incorporation affects the pressure of metallization. BaH2, with the lowest predicted pressure of metallization of the alkaline earth hydrides, is an ideal candidate to study the effects of hydrogenation. Previous high-pressure studies of BaH2 report two structural phase transitions upon compression: from an insulating, cotunnite (Pnma) structure (BaH2-I) to a hexagonal close-packed Ni2In-type (P63/mmc) structure at 1.6 GPa (BaH2-II)21,23,29 and at 54 GPa from BaH2-II to an AlB2-type simple hexagonal (SH) structure (BaH2-III). Ionic (H–) transport measurements have been measured previously up to 11 GPa, in which strikingly high ionic conductivity was measured.30 Additionally, it has been predicted that BaH2-III is metallic, but this has not been experimentally realized.21,22 Furthermore, when BaH2 is compressed in a H2 medium, it incorporates H2 molecules, forming BaH4 by 40 GPa.25,27 Here, the bonding nature of H2 is altered by the pre-compression provided by Ba2+, inducing the elongation of the H2 bond. Not only that, but BaH2 undergoes further hydrogenation into a Weaire–Phelan barium polyhydride (Ba8H46) and forms a clathrate by 50 GPa, which stabilizes tetrahedral cages that fit only one hydrogen atom, thus dissociating the H2 molecules.25,27,28 It has been proven that such structural motifs can be responsible for the metallic and accompanying superconducting character of hydrides.31,32 The electronic properties of both BaH4 and Ba8H46 have not been previously studied. We have conducted a comprehensive study on how compression influences the transport properties of BaH2 and how these are altered by additional hydrogen uptake. We combine optical spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction with electrical transport measurements to investigate the behavior of BaH2 and Ba8H46 upon compression. X-ray diffraction confirms the BaH2-II (Ni2In type) → BaH2-III (SH) transition at 53 GPa, which is supported by changes in the Raman spectra. We observe that the sample becomes reflective above pressures of 53 GPa, while the extrapolation of the absorbance curve shows a pressure-induced band gap closure at 55(5) GPa. Our electrical resistance measurements confirm an insulator–metal transition undergoing completion by 57 GPa in BaH2. Electrical transport measurements performed on Ba8H46, synthesized from BaH2 + H2 at 45 GPa and 1200 K, show that the compound is metallic upon a pressure increase to 85 GPa. For a detailed description of the experimental methods, the reader is referred to the Supporting Information. The BaH2 sample was loaded and compressed to 13 GPa (surpassing the BaH2-I → BaH2-II transition). BaH2-II has two active Eg vibrational Raman modes: one at 105 cm–1, associated with the vibrational modes of the Ba atoms, and a broader excitation at 1134 cm–1, assigned to the vibrational mode of the hydrogen atoms21,23 (Figure 1a). With compression, the higher wavenumber mode hardens until it overlaps with the diamond mode at 34 GPa. At 53 GPa, the low-frequency mode related to Ba phonons decreases in intensity and disappears. These spectral changes in the Raman signature are consistent with previous studies.21,23 X-ray diffraction data were collected from 14 to 62 GPa at 300 K (Figure 1b) and are also in agreement with previous works.21−23,29 We observe that, at 14 GPa, a Ni2In-type hexagonal close-packed structure is adopted by BaH2-II. Upon further compression, at 35 GPa, we find additional diffraction peaks that can be indexed to a simple hexagonal (SH) structure corresponding to BaH2-III, emerging together with BaH2-II (Ni2In type). This overlap of phases remains up to a pressure of 47 GPa. Beyond this pressure, only BaH2-III (SH) is observed in the diffraction pattern up to 62 GPa. (a) Raman spectra on compression of BaH2-II (green) and BaH2-III (purple). The inset displays the Raman shift as a function of pressure for BaH2. The low-frequency data marked with diamonds correspond to Ba–Ba phonons, while the high-frequency values presented as circles correspond to the vibrational modes of the hydrogen atoms.21,23 (b) Rietveld refinements of BaH2-II at 47 GPa (Ni2In-type hexagonal close-packed structure with a = 4.1630 Å and c = 5.2886 Å) and BaH2-II + BaH2-III at 45 GPa (SH structure with a = 3.3648 Å and c = 2.9727 Å). A wavelength of λ = 0.2922 Å was used. The inset displays the volume per Ba atom as a function of pressure, with green symbols representing BaH2-II and purple symbols representing BaH2-III. Circular symbols correspond to our data, while empty triangles denote previously published volumetric data.22 To investigate any pressure-induced changes to the electronic properties of BaH2, we measured the absorption and reflectivity between 1.2 and 2.8 eV. At ambient conditions, BaH2 is a white, transparent solid with negligible reflectance when compared to gold (Figure 2b). With compression, the sample visibly darkens (Figure 2a), accompanied by a rapid increase in the reflectivity. For example, at 13 GPa, the reflectance at 2.1 eV is 38% when compared to gold, and at 19 GPa, this increases to 81%. At 40 GPa, the reflectance of the sample surpasses that of the rhenium gasket. At 53 GPa, the sample becomes almost entirely reflective compared to gold, with a maximum reflectance value of 98% at 2.1 eV. (a) Photomicrographs of BaH2, taken with transmitted and reflected light, at 13, 37, and 52 GPa. Gold foil can be observed on the gasket, which is used as a reference for reflectivity measurements. (b) Representative reflectivity data from a supercontinuum source at various pressures relative to a gold reference, where Isample is the sample–diamond interface and Iau is the gold–diamond interface. The reflectance spectrum of rhenium is displayed in red for comparison. The peaks at 1.91 eV are due to the notch filter. (c) Representavie absorbance spectra (A) of BaH2 from a broadband white light source presented as αEd0.5 versus energy, where α is the absorption coefficient and d is the sample thickness, the αd = A ln10 relationship is used. Linear extrapolation of the absorbance data gives an approximate value of the band gap.33−35 (d) Approximate electronic band gap (Eg) of BaH2 as a function of the pressure. A linear fit of these values gives complete band gap closure at 55(5) GPa. The absorption (A) measurements are in excellent agreement with the reflectivity. Below 24 GPa, the sample is almost entirely transparent (Figure S1 of the Supporting Information). Upon compression to 36 GPa, the sample visibly darkened and the absorbance increased (Figure S2 of the Supporting Information). In Figure 2c, we present the absorption data plotted in photon energy versus αEd0.5 (where α is the absorption coefficient, d is the sample thickness, and αd = A ln10). The absorbance continuously increases upon further compression, reaching its maximum at 53 GPa, which is the highest pressure reached. Linear extrapolation of the absorption edge allows for the estimation of the band gap, which, at 40 GPa, is approximately 1.9(2) eV (Figure 2d). At 53 GPa, the sample shows virtually no transmission within the visible region. An approximately linear decrease in the band gap is seen through extrapolation of the absorbance edge. This gives a calculated band gap closure at an estimated pressure of 55(5) GPa. Although optical measurements are highly indicative of metallicity, electrical transport measurements provide definitive insights into the electronic character of a given system. Thus, we conducted electrical resistance measurements on BaH2 up to 60 GPa (Figure 3a). Both direct current (DC) and alternating current (AC) resistance measurements as a function of the pressure were carried out in both two- and four-probe configurations (Figure S6 of the Supporting Information). At ambient conditions, BaH2 behaves as an insulating material. A measurable resistance of 100 MΩ appears only at a pressure of 21 GPa. Because such a large magnitude of resistance was measured across the semiconducting sample, impedance spectroscopy was implemented (Figure S3 of the Supporting Information) to eliminate contributions from inductive and capacitive effects. The reader is referred to the Supporting Information for further details. Between 20 and 35 GPa, the resistance only slightly decreases, changing from 6.2 MΩ at 21 GPa to 4.8 MΩ at 35 GPa, as highlighted in Figure 3a. Further compression beyond 35 GPa leads to a sharp decrease in resistance, dropping to 2.2 MΩ at 37 GPa. This is in agreement with the observations from our X-ray diffraction measurements, where the onset of the transformation into BaH2-III begins at 35 GPa, resulting in the reduction in the average band gap of the bulk sample. Above 57 GPa, the resistance of the sample reaches mΩ values and begins to plateau, indicating complete metallization of the bulk sample. (a) Resistance as a function of the pressure for BaH2 at ambient temperature in between 21 and 60 GPa. Solid symbols indicate AC measurements, while the empty symbols show DC measurements. Two-probe resistance measurements are shown with triangles, while diamonds are from the four-probe runs. The pressure regions where BaH2-II and BaH2-III are present in the X-ray diffraction data are indicated. The inset displays the resistance as a function of the pressure for BaH2 between 21 and 32 GPa, highlighting that, in the low-pressure regime, resistance still decreases. (b) Resistance of BaH2 as a function of the temperature at 42, 45 and 58 GPa, carried out on the same sample. The green data correspond to semiconducting BaH2-II measured in a two-probe configuration using an AC and are linked to the left y axis. The purple data correspond to metallic BaH2-III measured using the four-probe method with an AC and are linked to the right y axis. The inset displays the photomicrograph of BaH2 at 52 GPa, taken with transmitted and reflected light. We conducted temperature-dependent resistance measurements of BaH2 at various pressures. At 42 GPa, as shown in Figure 3b, BaH2 exhibits increasing resistance upon cooling. This is a characteristic of semiconducting materials, with fewer charge carriers able to be thermally promoted to the conduction band as the sample is cooled. Upon further compression to 45 GPa, the resistance as a function of the temperature still displays semiconducting behavior. This dependency changes at 58 GPa, at which the resistance decreases with cooling, distinctive of metallic behavior. Such a turnover shows a semiconductor–metal transition between 47 and 58 GPa. This is attributed to the s → d hybridization of the Ba atom and a charge transfer from H– to the metallic ion.20−22 To evaluate the effect that incorporating hydrogen into BaH2 would have on its electrical properties, a sample of BaH2 was laser-heated in a dense hydrogen matrix. Because BaH4 has distinctive Raman modes25 and the Raman spectrum of Ba8H46 is featureless,27 we implement Raman spectroscopy as in-house diagnostics for their synthesis, following previously established synthesis routes. Upon compression of BaH2 and H2 to 38 GPa, BaH4 forms (Figure 4a), which is in agreement with previous results.25 This is characterized by the growth of a broad mode at 3400 cm–1 related to the H–H intramolecular stretching of the H2 vibrational mode (vibron). Additionally, modes around 1000 and 1250 cm–1 from hindered rotational modes (rotons) of BaH425 are seen in the Raman spectrum, along with low-frequency Ba–Ba phonons. Upon laser heating the sample at 45 GPa to a temperature of 1200 K, the Raman spectrum resembles that previously reported for Ba8H46,27,28 in which the low-frequency Ba–Ba phonons and H–H stretching modes of BaH4 are no longer resolvable. Along with this, the intensity of the H2 vibron decreases, suggesting that the amount of free molecular hydrogen in the sample chamber is reduced. X-ray diffraction was implemented to structurally characterize the synthesis product at 45 GPa (Figure S4 of the Supporting Information). (a) Raman spectra of BaH2 + H2 at 33 GPa (green), BaH4 formed at 38 GPa (red), and Ba8H46 (blue). The characteristic modes of BaH4 are marked with crosses, while empty triangles mark the rotational modes and vibron of pure hydrogen. A diamond marks the second-order diamond Raman mode, and an asterisk denotes the Ba–Ba phonon. (b) Resistance of BaH2 + H2 (green), BaH4 (red), and Ba8H46 (blue) as a function of the pressure. The top inset displays the photomicrograph of Ba8H46 at 55 GPa, taken with transmitted and reflected light. The bottom inset displays the resistance as a function of the temperature of Ba8H46 at 85, 99, and 110 GPa. We measured the pressure-dependent resistance during the synthesis process from BaH2 + H2 → BaH4 → Ba8H46. Impedance spectroscopy was also implemented (Figure S5 of the Supporting Information). Upon BaH4 synthesis, there is an increase in resistance from 128 to 146 kΩ. Unlike BaH2, BaH4 contains molecular hydrogen.28 The electronic structure of BaH4 has distinct bands associated with Ba 5p, molecular H2, and atomic hydrogen, which gives a band structure of a small-gap semiconductor.28 Therefore, the experimentally observed increase in resistance when BaH4 forms is likely due to the presence of molecular hydrogen in the structure.25,28 Upon the formation of Ba8H46 at 45 GPa, the resistance slightly drops to 105 kΩ. Compression of Ba8H46 at 55 GPa leads to a decrease in resistance to 48 kΩ. With the sample still transmitting light (Figure 4b), it is evident that the band gap closure has not yet occurred at 55 GPa. Further compression to 85 GPa results in a significant and rapid decrease in resistance to 36 Ω, approaching values typically associated with a metallic phase. This is accompanied by the sample darkening and becoming reflective (Figure S6 of the Supporting Information). At pressures above 85 GPa, the sample resistance plateaus. These results indicate a band gap closure of Ba8H46 by 85 GPa. At 85, 99, and 110 GPa, Figure 4b shows that the resistance of Ba8H46 drops during cooling, exhibiting metallic behavior. This confirms that the metallic transition occurs by 85 GPa, a pressure significantly higher than that required for BaH2. Since it was proposed by Ashcroft that chemical pre-compression of hydrogen could be achieved by doping with electropositive elements, it has been debated whether a higher hydrogen content will result in a higher superconducting critical temperature.19 Understanding the electronic properties as a function of the hydrogen content is important in addressing this problem. Here, we highlight how hydrogen incorporation in the Ba–H system increases the pressure required for metallization. Our results leave open the potential to expand studies of metallization pressures in the Ba–H system up to BaH12, which is a superconductor with an experimentally measured Tc of 20 K at 140 GPa.11 Our findings can be extended to other heavy alkaline earth hydrides, such as Ca–H. Metallization in CaH2 has not been experimentally measured, although it has been predicted to occur at 102 GPa,20 while CaH6 has been experimentally observed to become metallic and superconducting over 170 GPa, upshifted from that predicted for CaH2.15,16 While not the only factor, hydrogen incorporation in such systems is correlated with an increase in the critical temperature of superconductivity. However, the drawback is that higher and more experimentally challenging pressures are required. In summary, the insulator–metal transition in BaH2 has been thoroughly characterized using a series of optical measurements in the visible range and electrical resistance measurements, in addition to Raman spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction for structural assignment. Absorbance measurements allow us to estimate an approximate band gap of 1.9(2) eV at 40 GPa, a value typical for semiconducting materials.33 Completion of sluggish BaH2-II (Ni2In type) → BaH2-III (SH) at 54 GPa produces the complete closure of the average bulk sample electronic band gap, a characteristic of a metallic state. Electrical transport measurements as a function of the pressure and temperature confirm the insulator–metal transition in BaH2 at 57 GPa. We demonstrate that the incorporation of H2 into BaH2 to form Ba8H46 results in an upshift in the pressure of metallization to 85 GPa. Acknowledgments The authors thank Dr. M. Kuzovnikov for his help with electrical transport measurements. Dr. Miriam Peña-Alvarez and Dr. Israel Osmond acknowledge the support of the UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) Future Leaders Fellowship (Mrc-Mr/T043733/1). The authors thank Prof. M. McMahon for lending us the glovebox of his laboratory to prepare the samples. The authors also thank Prof. A. Huxley for the use of his cryostat. The authors thank beamlines P02.2 at PETRA-III, Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron (DESY), Hamburg, Germany, and ID15b, European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF), Grenoble, France, for the use of their facilities. Dr. Ross T. Howie acknowledges that the project has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Program (Grant Agreement 948895 “MetElOne”). Dr. Sven Friedemann acknowledges the ERC Horizon 2020 Program (Grant 715262-HPSuper) and the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC, Grant EP/V048759/1). Supporting Information Available The Supporting Information is available free of charge at https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jpclett.3c02704. Experimental methods, raw transmission data and absorbance spectra, Rietveld refinement of Ba8H46, and impedance spectroscopy measurements (PDF) Experimental methods, raw transmission data and absorbance spectra, Rietveld refinement of Ba8H46, and impedance spectroscopy measurements (PDF) Transparent Peer Review report available (PDF) Transparent Peer Review report available (PDF) The authors declare no competing financial interest. This paper was published ASAP on December 12, 2023. The author order was changed and the paper was reposted on December 13, 2023. Supplementary Material jz3c02704_si_001.pdf jz3c02704_si_002.pdf References Associated Data Supplementary Materials jz3c02704_si_001.pdf jz3c02704_si_002.pdf