Outdoor Time in Childhood: A Mixed Methods Approach to Identify Barriers and Opportunities for Intervention in a Racially and Ethnically Mixed Population Authors: Magdalena K Haakenstad, Maria B Butcher, Carolyn J Noonan, Amber L Fyfe-Johnson, Hui Huang, Qi Wu, Han C G Kemper Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractA growing body of literature suggests that outdoor time is beneficial for physical and mental health in childhood. Profound disparities exist in access to outdoor spaces (and the health benefits thereof) for children in communities of color. The objectives of this research were to: (1) identify challenges and solutions to outdoor time for children; (2) assess the importance of outdoor time for children; and (3) evaluate results stratified by race/ethnicity. Using a convergent mixed methods approach, we conducted a thematic analysis from 14 focus groups (n = 50) with outdoor educators, parents with children attending outdoor preschools, and community members with children. In addition, 49 participants completed a survey to identify challenges and solutions, perceived importance, and culturally relevant perspectives of outdoor time. The main challenges identified for outdoor time were safety concerns, inclement weather, lack of access to outdoor spaces, and parent work schedules. The primary proposed solution was integrating outdoor time into the school day. Nearly all participants, independent of racial identity, reported that outdoor time improved physical and mental health. Overall outdoor time was lower in participants from communities of color (~8 h/week) compared to their White counterparts (~10 h/week). While 50% of people of color (POC) reported that outdoor time was an important cultural value, only 18% reported that people in their respective culture spent time outside. This work contributes to accumulating knowledge that unique barriers to outdoor time exist for communities of color, and the children that live, learn, and play in these communities. Increasing outdoor time in school settings offers a potential solution to reduce identified barriers and to promote health equity in childhood.Keywords: outdoor time in childhood, barriers to outdoors, facilitators for outdoors, cultural perspectives on outdoor time, people of color, social determinants of health, mixed methods, nature, early childhood education 1. Introduction Nature contact is known to improve children’s health [1,2,3,4,5] by increasing physical activity [6,7], improving mental health [8,9,10,11], reducing stress [12,13], and promoting behavioral health [14,15,16]. Communities of color have disproportionately lower access to outdoor spaces [17,18,19,20] and experience more environmental barriers in outdoor spaces than their White counterparts [21,22,23,24,25,26]. Common environmental barriers in communities of color are safety concerns [21,22,23,24,25,26], lack of facilities [26,27,28], and lack of sidewalks [21,22,24,29]. One study found that 74% of communities of color in the United States (US) live in nature-deprived areas, compared with just 23% of White communities [30]. Another study examining park equity in Los Angeles, California, found that neighborhoods inhabited predominantly (>75%) by Latinos, African Americans, and Asian-Pacific Islanders had dramatically lower access to parks (0.6, 1.7, 0.3 park acres per 1000 population, respectively) than largely White areas of the city (31.8 park acres per 1000 population) [31]. Given that nature contact in childhood has known health benefits [1,6,9], yet communities of color disproportionately live, work, and play in nature-deprived areas, efforts are needed to increase access to nature-rich spaces in these communities, and the children therein. Exposure to nature-rich spaces necessitates that these spaces exist and are accessible. To ensure that future policy-level decisions around outdoor spaces in communities of color are relevant, it is crucial to better understand the specific barriers and challenges that communities of color, and families within these communities, face. To date, most of the research in this area has focused on adult populations [22,23,26] or barriers to physical activity independent of outdoor time [26,27,28]. Only three studies have explored barriers to and facilitators for children’s outdoor active play [32,33,34]. While informative, none of these studies: (1) identified barriers to outdoor time in communities of color, or (2) used a mixed methods approach to assessing barriers to outdoor time for children. One study was a scoping review that emphasized the importance of outdoor play but did not directly assess barriers and challenges to outdoor play in early childhood [33]. Another used parent and clinician-based focus groups to assess barriers to children’s active play in nature, but the parent sample size was small (n = 14 parents), and the overall aim of the study was to inform pediatric health care providers and advocate for active outdoor play in a clinical setting [34]. The last study focused on generational differences in outdoor play between mother/child dyads in a sample of 830 mothers, but the study was published in 2004, meaning it may not be as informative to current barriers to outdoor time in early childhood [32]. Collectively, these studies identified the following primary barriers to children’s outdoor time: (1) safety concerns [32,34]; (2) screen time and other digital media [32]; (3) lack of adult supervision [32]; (4) lack of physical and financial resources (e.g., access to safe outdoor spaces, time, etc.) [34]; and (5) weather concerns [34]. Despite this important work, mixed methods research aimed at identifying general barriers to and facilitators for outdoor time in childhood, specifically in communities of color, is absent. Community-based participatory research (CBPR) approaches are critical to an equity-centered research framework [35,36,37,38,39]. CBPR typically uses a multi-step approach to disable the traditional hierarchical structure of research, including collaborating with community partners as equal partners and leaders, generating research questions that align with the needs of the community, and sharing decision-making in all phases of the research process including interpretation of results and authorship roles and order [40,41]. Historically, Eurocentric research approaches and results do not align or translate, respectively, to populations with different cultural frameworks and backgrounds. Research is accelerating in this area, particularly in adult populations [42,43], but research in culturally diverse youth highlights the importance of assessing the needs of communities and youth of color [44,45,46] to better identify solutions to improve health in these populations. The National Institute on Minority Health and Health Disparities (NIMHD) research framework [47] complements the CPBR approach by categorizing levels (e.g., individual, community, etc.) and domains of influence (e.g., biological, physical/built environment, etc.) on health outcomes. Given the importance of incorporating the voices of communities of color and the relative absence of data about outdoor time in youth in general, the CBPR and NIMHD frameworks informed all stages of this research project. Thus, the objectives of this research were to: (1) identify challenges and solutions to outdoor time for children; (2) assess the importance of outdoor time for children; and (3) evaluate results stratified by race/ethnicity. 2. Materials and Methods 2.1. Theoretical Framework To systematically analyze factors influencing health disparities related to the relationship between the physical/built environment (availability and access to community outdoor resources) and the sociocultural environment (social networks; family/peer, community, and social norms; interpersonal, local, and structural discrimination), this study was theoretically guided by the research framework developed by the NIMHD [47]. To align with an equity-based approach, we embraced the CBPR framework to prioritize key stakeholder voices, perspectives, and needs in determining the challenges to and facilitators for outdoor time for children [44]. The mixed methods approach taken by the investigators in the current project is the first phase in the overall CBPR process. The second phase will be summarizing and delivering the results herein to a community-based working group tasked with designing a novel, community-informed intervention. The goal of this intervention will be to address and ameliorate some of the identified challenges herein, with the goal of increasing outdoor time for families and children and improving physical, behavioral, and mental health outcomes in communities of color. These research frameworks guided the definition of the overall research questions and the specific focus group questions. We use the term people of color (POC) for participants who self-identified as African American/Black, American Indian/Alaska Native, Asian, Native Hawaiian, Hispanic, Mexican, or being of Latino/Latina ethnicity. The decision to use this term was made after careful consideration of the following: (1) from a conversation with our community partner, it is the term that best describes and is preferred by the community, and (2) this term was the most used by our research participants who self-identified as African American/Black, American Indian/Alaska Native, Asian, Native Hawaiian, Hispanic, Mexican, or being of Latino/Latina ethnicity. We acknowledge that this term is not universally accepted because it generalizes the vastly different historical and contemporary experiences of the people who self-identify or are identified as non-White. However, the small sample size of our study does not allow us to use the specific cultural, racial, and ethnic preferences of individual participants. 2.2. Setting and Participants The Washington State University Institutional Review Board approved this study, and all participants provided informed consent. Eligibility criteria included families with a child enrolled at an outdoor preschool, being an educator or leader in an early childhood educational setting or being a parent in the community of interest. Participants were recruited between January and April 2022 through study flyers distributed by email and direct communication with the local early childhood education community network in King County, Washington. All participants received a USD 50 gift card for participating. 2.3. Procedures Using a convergent parallel mixed methods design, qualitative focus groups (n = 50) and quantitative questionnaires (n = 49) were utilized to identify areas of convergence and divergence between the results. Fourteen focus groups were conducted between April and June 2022. Five focus groups were conducted with families with a child enrolled at an outdoor preschool, five with educators or leaders in an early childhood educational setting, and four with parents in the community of interest. All focus groups lasted approximately 1 h. Three focus groups were conducted in person, and eleven were conducted virtually over Zoom. Focus group sizes ranged from 3–10, though one focus group had a single participant due to last minute scheduling conflicts with other participants. Sessions were audio recorded, and participants were anonymized during the entire interview process. Participants completed a self-report questionnaire after finishing their focus groups. All questionnaires were administered using Research Electronic Data Capture (REDCap) [48,49], an electronic data capture tool hosted at Washington State University and took approximately 20 min to complete. 2.4. Measures 2.4.1. Qualitative The focus group moderators (the first and last authors) used a systematic and comprehensive protocol to conduct all focus group interviews. This process included a standardized focus group guide with open-ended questions and follow-up probes to examine challenges and solutions to outdoor time for children [50,51]. Challenges included the following: general (e.g., what makes it hard for your child to spend time outside in your community?), weather and access to appropriate outdoor attire, general access to outdoor spaces, safety concerns, and cultural norms and traditions associated with outdoor time. One question was asked regarding how much time children spend or should spend outdoors. The final question focused on identifying potential solutions to increase outdoor time for children. 2.4.2. Quantitative All survey data were collected using REDCap, an electronic database for secure data collection and storage. Demographic variables included age, sex assigned at birth, gender and racial identification, current relationship status (e.g., married/partnered, single, etc.), employment status, highest terminal degree (e.g., high school, bachelor’s degree, etc.), and annual household income (e.g.,