Decreasing Production and Potential Urban Explosion of Nighttime Nitrate Radicals amid Emission Reduction Efforts Authors: Yuhang Wang, Shengjun Xi, Fanghe Zhao, Lewis Gregory Huey, Tong Zhu Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractNighttime oxidation by nitrate (NO3) radicals has important ramifications on nocturnal aerosol formation and hence the climate and human health. Nitrate radicals are produced by the reaction of NO2 and O3. Despite large decreases in anthropogenic emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx = NO + NO2), a previous study found significant increases in NO3 production (PNO3) from 2014 to 2019 in China, in contrast to decreasing trends in the U.S. and Europe. Using the summer observations from 2014 to 2022, we analyze the interannual variability of nocturnal PNO3 using a systematic framework, in which PNO3 is diagnosed as a function of odd oxygen (Ox = O3 + NO2) and the NO2/O3 ratio. We did not find an increase of PNO3 from 2014 to 2022 in China due to a continuous decrease in the NO2/O3 ratio, although PNO3 is modulated by the variation in Ox. Using in situ observations obtained in Beijing in 2007, we demonstrate the potential for an upsurge resembling an “explosion” in urban nighttime NO3 radicals amid emission reduction efforts.Keywords: nighttime oxidation, nocturnal nitrate radical production, odd oxygen, nitrogen oxides, ozone Introduction Nocturnal oxidation by nitrate (NO3) radicals can produce significant amounts of secondary aerosols affecting climate and human health.1−4 While in situ measurements of NO3 have been made for decades,5 long-term records of nighttime NO3 are not available due in part to the short lifetime and high variability of its concentrations,6 making it difficult to assess the changes of nocturnal oxidation in the past due to anthropogenic emission changes in response to environmental regulations. However, the production rate of NO3, PNO3, near the surface can be diagnosed using observations of NO2 and O3 by air quality monitoring networks around the world since the reaction R1 is the main source of NO3 in a polluted boundary layer.1 In a recent study, Wang et al. analyzed the trend of nocturnal PNO3 in the warm season of China from 2014 to 2019 in comparison to those in the United States and Europe.1 They found a significant increasing trend of nocturnal PNO3 in China in contrast to the decreasing trends in the United States and Europe and further suggested that nocturnal oxidation is becoming more important in China. In this study, we analyze the variation of nighttime PNO3 in China from 2014 to 2022 using a systematic framework to separate the effects of odd oxygen (Ox = O3 + NO2) and the ratio of NO2/O3. Given the short lifetime of NO3, PNO3 can often be used to assess the nighttime NO3 radical oxidation potential in summer.1 However, the NO3 concentration and its oxidation rate of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) also depend on two other losses. The reaction of NO2 and NO3 produces N2O5, which thermolyzes back into NO2 and NO3 with a lifetime of ∼1 min at 20 °C.7 Heterogenous reactions of N2O5 that produce HNO3 and ClNO2 on aerosols remove NO3 radicals from the atmosphere.2 In addition, NO3 is also removed by reaction with NO. We examine the potential impact of urban nighttime NO on NO3 concentrations using in situ observations. Materials and Methods Similar to the previous study,1 we use the hourly observations of surface NO2 and O3 between 8 pm and 5 a.m. LT (at altitudes typically a few meters above the surface) by the China National Environmental Monitoring Center (CNEMC) network. To ensure data consistency, we only analyze summertime (June, July, and August) data from 2014 to 2022. Limiting the analysis to summer data ensures a more consistent physical and chemical environment. The ending time of nighttime analysis is changed from 6 am1 to 5 am for the summer. We use only the data from stations that were continuously operational from 2014 to 2022. The observations from 640 surface stations are used in the analysis. Furthermore, we filter out the outlier data outside the range of Q1 – k(Q3 – Q1) and Q1 + k(Q3 – Q1), where Q1 and Q3 are the 25th and 75th quartiles, respectively, and k = 1.5.8 2.65% of the measurement data are removed, although this filtering does not alter the analysis results. Lastly, to further ensure data consistency, we group the observations in China into 4 regions based on climate characteristics and topography (Figure 1). There are only 6 stations over the Tibetan Plateau region, and hence only data in the Northeast (NE), Southeast (SE), and Northwest (NW) regions are analyzed. CNEMC sites (black dots) with continuous measurements from 2014 to 2022 in three analysis regions. Chemical reaction rate constants depend on the atmospheric temperature and pressure. We use the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) Reanalysis version 5 (ERA5) hourly surface temperature and pressure at a resolution of 0.25° × 0.25°. Reaction rate constants are calculated using the kinetics data from the latest Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) compilation.7 To add a point of reference for the pre-2014 period, we analyzed the observations from the Campaigns of Air quality Research in Beijing (CAREBeijing) in August 2007. Concentrations of O3, NO, and NO2 were measured at an urban site located on a building rooftop (∼20 m above the ground level) on the campus of Peking University.9,10 The 1 minute observations were averaged hourly to be comparable to the CNEMC measurements. Results and Discussion Systematic Analysis Framework In polluted regions at night, O3 is consumed to oxidize freshly emitted NO: We define nighttime odd oxygen as Ox = O3 + NO2.11Figure 2 shows the summertime hourly averaged regional Ox, O3, and NO2 concentrations from 2014 to 2022. Ox concentrations decreased at night largely following the decreases of O3 since the variation of NO2 was relatively small compared to those of Ox and O3. The nighttime O3 and NO2 variation patterns in China are similar to those observed in the United States.12 Summertime hourly averaged regional Ox, O3, and NO2 concentrations at 8 pm to 5 am LT from 2014 to 2022 in the NE, SE, and NW regions. The hourly data points are plotted in the middle of the hour. The corresponding standard deviation distributions among the observation sites are shown in Figure S1. We write the PNO3 rate as a function of Ox, where and k1 is the reaction rate constant of R1. In this analysis framework, PNO3 is proportional to [Ox]2 and f(α), where . The maximum of f(α) is 1/4 when α = 1. Summertime Variations of PNO3 Diagnosing PNO3 as a function of Ox and NO2/O3 ratio makes it easier to understand PNO3 variations from 2014 to 2022 than the method used in the previous study.1 The averages of summertime PNO3 from 2014 to 2022 are plotted as a function of NO2/O3 and Ox in Figure 3. The background color image in the figure was computed using eq 1, which shows that PNO3 has a quadratic dependence on Ox. However, the dependence of PNO3 on the NO2/O3 ratio is more complex: it decreases with decreasing NO2/O3 ratio when the ratio is <1, but increases with decreasing NO2/O3 ratio when the ratio is >1. In the regions of this study, the NO2/O3 ratio was <1 and generally decreased with time. Consequently, PNO3 in all regions primarily decreased from 2014 to 2022 due mostly to the decrease in the NO2/O3 ratio. PNO3 values in the three regions had similar variations (Figures 3 and S2). Between 2014 and 2022, the peaks in summertime PNO3 rates occurred around 2017–2018 due to the greater effect of the increase in the level of Ox since 2014 compared to the decrease in the NO2/O3 ratio. After peaking around 2017–2018, Ox concentrations decreased to and even went below the 2014 Ox level during the 2020–2022 period, while the decrease in the NO2/O3 ratio continued. As a result, PNO3 rates in all three regions decreased to levels below those observed in 2014. The modulation effect by Ox is particularly large from 2020 to 2022 in the SE as the increase of Ox in these 3 years is faster than during any 3-year periods of 2014–2019 (Figure S2). However, the resulting increase in PNO3 is slight (Figure S2) due to the decrease of the NO2/O3 ratio from 2020 to 2022 (Figure 3). Regional averaged summer PNO3 as functions of the geometric mean of NO2/O3 and average Ox from 2014 to 2022 in the NE (squares), SE (circles), and NW (triangles) regions. The background color image was computed using eq 1 at a temperature of 20 °C. PNO3 was computed using hourly CNEMC measurements and ERA5 temperature. Therefore, regional nighttime average PNO3 values do not necessarily match those in the background color image. Averaged PNO3 for the CAREBEIJING-2007 campaign is denoted by a diamond. The geometric mean of NO2/O3 is used since it is in log scale. Figure 4 shows that hourly average PNO3 rates for the three regions decreased from 2014 to 2022 at night. The variation of PNO3 at night is larger than in daytime in summer.13 The intranight decrease of PNO3 by a factor of ∼2 was larger than those of Ox. It was driven primarily by the decay of Ox due to the quadratic dependence of PNO3 on the Ox concentrations (eq 1). Quantifying nighttime Ox decreases is therefore necessary. Same as Figure 2 but for hourly average PNO3 rate and the corresponding Ox lifetime. The corresponding standard deviations of PNO3 among the observation sites are shown in Figure S4. Figure 2 shows the nearly exponential decay of the Ox concentrations at night in all three regions. The decay shapes were fairly consistent among different years, i.e., the seasonal mean difference at 8 pm LT was largely maintained until 5 am LT. To quantify the nighttime decay lifetime, we conducted least-squares regressions using x = x8pme–t/τ, where x is Ox hourly concentration, t is the time lapse from 8 pm, and τ is the decay lifetime. The regressions have R2 values in the range of 0.97–0.99. The lifetime of Ox is ∼20 h in the NE and SE regions, but is higher at ∼30 h in the NW region (Figure 4), likely reflecting higher canopy dry deposition of O3 and NO2 in eastern China than the NW. The vegetation coverage of eastern China is much higher than the NW,14,15 resulting in larger deposition of O3 and NO2.16,17 Monthly mean midnight dry deposition velocities for O3 and NO2, simulated using a regional chemical transport model,12,18,19 are much higher in the NE and SE than the NW region (Figure S3). Model description and further discussion on the loss of Ox due to dry deposition can be found in Supporting Information. We apply least-squares regression analysis to compute interannual trends of Ox lifetimes. The SE region is the only region with a statistically significant small decreasing trend, −1.3% year–1 (p = 0.03) from 2014 to 2022. The other two regions also have negative trends, −0.28% year–1 (p = 0.63) for NE and −0.20% year–1 (p = 0.80) for NW. Moreover, taking into account significant seasonal variances that were larger than the trends, it is evident that nighttime Ox lifetimes remained largely unchanged despite substantial reductions in emissions across the three regions from 2014 to 2022, leading to fairly consistent nighttime decay patterns of Ox and PNO3 among different years (Figures 2 and 3). The finding of stable nighttime lifetimes of the Ox from 2014 to 2022 is somewhat surprising considering the significant interannual variation of PNO3 (Figure 3). Since the lifetime of NO3 is short, PNO3 equals the loss rate of NO3, which includes (1) heterogeneous reactions of N2O5 on aerosols to produce HNO3 and ClNO2, (2) reactions of NO3 and VOCs, and (3) the reaction of NO3 and NO. In the first reaction pathway, up to three O3 molecules are lost for every N2O5 molecule that is lost. In the second reaction pathway, up to two molecules of O3 are lost for every NO3 loss. The third reaction pathway did not affect Ox. Assuming the regional effect of the third reaction pathway was insignificant, an increase of PNO3 from 2014 to 2017–2018 (Figure 3) would imply a decrease of Ox lifetime, and the decrease in PNO3 from 2017 to 2018 to 2022 would have the opposite effect. However, the derived Ox lifetimes in the NE and NW regions had a peak in 2018 when PNO3 values were among the highest. The lack of correspondence between the Ox lifetime and PNO3 reflects in part the dominance of dry deposition of O3 and NO2 in determining the lifetime of the Ox at night. Another possible contributor is that the rate of N2O5 heterogeneous reactions on aerosols decreased relative to the rate of the NO3 oxidation of VOCs. The loss of Ox through the latter is less than that through the former. The decrease in NO2 concentrations (by 31–37%) from 2014 to 2022 (Figure 2) reduced the formation rate of N2O5 considering that regional averaged PNO3 rates decreased. Furthermore, the heterogeneous loss rate of N2O5 depends on aerosol surface area. There was no regulatory monitoring of aerosol surface area. However, its qualitative trend can be estimated using PM2.5 concentrations by assuming that aerosol size distribution did not change significantly. Figure S5 shows that PM2.5 concentrations decreased by nearly a factor of 2 from 2014 to 2022 in the three regions. In addition, aerosol liquid water content also tends to decrease with PM2.5,20 contributing to a decrease of aerosol surface area. The overall effect was a decrease of the aerosol N2O5 reaction rate relative to the rate of NO3 oxidation of VOCs, which tended to decrease Ox loss and increase Ox lifetime at night. Temperature at night decreases significantly and reduces the PNO3 rates. Figure S6 shows summertime hourly average temperatures from 2014 to 2022. Similar to that of Ox, the interannual difference in average temperature is much less than the decrease in temperature from 8 pm to 5 am LT and the patterns of hourly temperature decrease are consistent among different years in the three regions. The resulting effect of interannual temperature variation on PNO3 rates is small from 2014 to 2022, although lower temperature in the NW resulted in lower reaction rate constants for PNO3 compared to those in the SE and NE regions (Figure S7). Potential Explosion of Urban NO3 Radicals Higher PNO3 rates in the NE and NW than the SE region are due largely to regional differences in Ox concentrations (Figure 3). The decrease in PNO3 rates from 2014 to 2022, on the other hand, is due mostly to the decreasing NO2/O3 ratio, reflecting much larger and more consistent NO2 reductions compared to the variations of Ox and O3 in the three regions (Figure 2). We did not find evidence that nighttime variations of chemical species or temperature, which were much larger than their interannual variations, changed significantly from 2014 to 2022. The lifetimes of nighttime Ox in the three regions did not show significant changes either (Figure 4). While we find increases in PNO3 rates from 2014 to 2017–2018 in all three regions as Wang et al.1 due to increased Ox concentrations, the increases appeared to be transitory in nature due to persistent and rapid decreases in the NO2/O3 ratio as NOx emissions were reduced. Some of the post-2020 NOx emissions decreases are COVID-related.21 Nonetheless, it is possible that the rates of nighttime PNO3 increased prior to 2014. Sun et al. showed an increase of about 9.6 ppbv of maximum daily 8 h average O3 concentrations in July and August from 2003 to 2015.22 They attributed about half of the O3 increases to increased emissions of the NOx and VOCs. Although the interannual variability of O3 between 2003 and 2015 was not studied, it is likely that nighttime PNO3 increased from 2003 to 2015 given the quadratic dependence of PNO3 on Ox. Furthermore, Ding et al. showed increasing lower-tropospheric O3 concentrations in Beijing and the North China Plain region from 1995 to 2005.23 It is instructive to compare the 2014–2022 results for the NE region to the CAREBEIJING-2007 observations. The average PNO3 rate at night during the CAREBEIJING-2007 campaign was lower than the summertime average in the NE region (Figure 3) mostly due to a lower average Ox concentration. The geometric mean NO2/O3 ratio during the campaign was 1.3. Considering that the measurement altitude of 20 m is above air quality monitoring stations, it is possible that this measurement may underestimate near-surface NO/NO2 ratios due to the conversion of NO to NO2 during mixing from the surface to the measurement altitude. If this value was representative of the summer of 2008, the decrease in the NO2/O3 ratio from 2008 to 2014–2002 would slightly increase PNO3 until the NO2/O3 ratio reached 1. After this point, the decrease in the NO2/O3 ratio would start decreasing PNO3. However, this effect would not be as large as the increase in PNO3 due to increasing Ox (eq 1 and Figure 3). Both historical observations of O322,23 and CAREBEIJING-2007 measurements indicated that Ox concentrations increased prior to 2013 as anthropogenic emissions of NOx and VOCs increased. The quadratic dependence of nighttime PNO3 on Ox implies that PNO3 increased during this period. However, it does not imply that nighttime NO3 concentrations increased, particularly in urban regions. CAREBEIJING-2007 1 minute measurements had 57% of nighttime NO concentrations >1 ppbv. At this level, the steady-state NO3 radical concentration is negligible due to the rapid removal of NO3 by NO,7 NO concentrations were not reported by the CNEMC network. It is therefore difficult to quantify the effect of R3 in suppressing nighttime NO3 radical concentrations in urban areas with high NOx emissions. Figure S8 shows that hourly average O3 concentrations during the CAREBEIJING-2007 campaign stayed at ∼10 ppbv after midnight and were lower than hourly average NO2 concentrations. The observed high NO2/O3 ratios during CAREBEIJING are due to high concentrations of NO, which reacts with O3 to produce NO2. We therefore use an indirect measure, the data fraction for NO2/O3 > 1, to qualitatively examine this effect. Figure S9 shows that the data fractions for NO2/O3 > 1 decreased from 32–39% in 2014 to 17–20% in 2022 in the three regions. In comparison, the corresponding fraction in CAREBEIJING-2007 data was 47%. Figure S10 shows simulated hourly steady-state NO3 radial concentrations as a function of NO concentration using hourly averaged values of the Ox, O3, and NO2 for the NE region from 2014 to 2002. The critical NO concentrations that suppress NO3 radicals were at the level of 0.1–1 ppbv. Similar results were obtained for the SE and NW regions. As NOx emissions continuously decrease, it is plausible that in the future nighttime NO concentrations in certain urban regions may frequently decrease to levels below 0.1 ppbv. Under such circumstances, NO3 concentrations will increase by orders of magnitude (Figure S7). In this study, we analyzed surface observations from 640 stations in China to characterize regional near-surface PNO3 changes from 2014 to 2022. It is worth noting that the differential optical absorption spectroscopy measurements by Yan et al. in Beijing showed increasing NO3 radical concentrations with altitude due to in part to increasing NO3 lifetime with altitude.24 Although not subject to regulatory monitoring, understanding the vertical distributions of O3, NO2, and other atmospheric species, along with their variations, is essential in gaining insights into nighttime oxidation processes. Discussion Satellite observations showed that NOx emissions started decreasing by 2011 in southern China.25 The year 2013 marked a significant turning point in emissions reduction policies in China, leading to substantial decreases in NOx emissions.26 Before 2013, the increased emissions led to Ox increases in the summer,22,23 likely leading to a PNO3 increase since it is a quadratic function of Ox. The sensitivity of PNO3 to the NO2/O3 ratio is significantly lower than the quadratic dependence on the Ox (eq 1 and Figure 3). However, increased NOx emissions also led to higher NO concentrations in urban regions near emission sources. The lifetime of the NO could be fairly long when the O3 was titrated through R1 by continuous emissions. Therefore, higher PNO3 concentrations during this period did not necessarily imply higher NO3 radical concentrations and nighttime oxidation in urban areas with high NO emissions (Figure S10). After 2014, observations showed significant and consistent reductions of NO2 and PM2.5 in China (Figures 2 and S1). Nighttime Ox concentrations had transient increases peaking around 2017 and 2018 and then returned to and even went lower than the 2014 levels after 2020. The continuous decrease in the ratio of NO2/O3, on the other hand, contributed to a decrease in PNO3. This continuous decrease in PNO3 will be modulated by Ox variations due to meteorological conditions and O3 photochemistry.9,22 If the modulation effect by Ox in the future is neutral or negative as decreasing anthropogenic emissions cause Ox to stay near the same level or start decreasing, a PNO3 decreasing trend is expected. The reduction in the NO3 radical concentration following the decrease in PNO3 is not always directly proportional. In regions with minimal impact from fresh NO emissions, the decrease in the level of NO2 resulting from emission reduction (Figure 2) generally led to a decline in the formation rate of N2O5. Additionally, the decrease in PM2.5 (Figure S1) and, consequently, the reduction in aerosol surface area tended to slow down the loss of N2O5 to HNO3 and ClNO3 on aerosols. Both factors would contribute to decreasing the loss of NO3 by heterogeneous N2O5 reactions on aerosols, resulting in an increase of NO3 loss by its oxidation of VOCs for a given PNO3 rate. The net effect would mitigate the potential decrease of the NO3 oxidation of VOCs due to decreased PNO3. The opposite mitigation effect would likely occur during the phase of increasing anthropogenic emissions. In urban regions significantly affected by fresh NO emissions, on the other hand, much more drastic nighttime NO3 changes could be expected. If nighttime O3 titration by NO emissions and a long NO lifetime occurred over a sufficiently long time and large area of an urban region during the phase of increasing emissions, an “explosion” of nighttime NO3 radicals near the surface would likely occur during the period of emission reduction after 2013 when the NO lifetime shortened at night. As NO emissions continue to decrease, NO suppression of NO3 radicals would continue to weaken. Significant nighttime nitrate radical concentrations are necessary conditions for the formation of HNO3 from N2O5 hydrolysis2 and gaseous and particulate organic nitrates.4 Therefore, in an urban area with high NOx emissions, an upsurge could exist from minimal nighttime inorganic and organic nitrate production to significant nighttime nitrate production as a result of efforts to reduce emissions. The analysis in this work targeted summer, but the probability for this mechanism to occur is higher in other seasons, particularly in winter, since the O3 concentrations tend to be highest in summer. This mechanism could help explain some of the observed lower nitrate reductions compared to other secondary aerosol components in Beijing from 2011/2012 to 2017/2018.27 Acknowledgments This work was supported by the National Science Foundation Atmospheric Chemistry Program (Grant 1743401). The authors thank CNEMC for providing air quality monitoring data used in this work. Supporting Information Available The Supporting Information is available free of charge at https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.3c09259. Model computed nocturnal dry deposition velocity distributions for O3 and NO2 (Text S1); standard deviations of Ox, O3, and NO2, yearly summertime averages of PNO3 and Ox, model computed monthly mean dry deposition velocities for O3 and NO2, standard deviations of PNO3, summertime hourly average PM2.5 concentrations, summertime hourly average ERA5 temperature, summertime hourly average reaction rate constant of R1, hourly average concentrations of Ox, O3, and NO2 during the CAREBEIJING-2007 campaign, data fractions of nighttime hourly NO2/O3 ratio >1 from 2014 to 2022, and model calculated hourly steady-state NO3 radical mixing ratio as a function of NO (Figures S1–S10). (PDF) Model computed nocturnal dry deposition velocity distributions for O3 and NO2 (Text S1); standard deviations of Ox, O3, and NO2, yearly summertime averages of PNO3 and Ox, model computed monthly mean dry deposition velocities for O3 and NO2, standard deviations of PNO3, summertime hourly average PM2.5 concentrations, summertime hourly average ERA5 temperature, summertime hourly average reaction rate constant of R1, hourly average concentrations of Ox, O3, and NO2 during the CAREBEIJING-2007 campaign, data fractions of nighttime hourly NO2/O3 ratio >1 from 2014 to 2022, and model calculated hourly steady-state NO3 radical mixing ratio as a function of NO (Figures S1–S10). (PDF) The authors declare no competing financial interest. Supplementary Material es3c09259_si_001.pdf References Associated Data Supplementary Materials es3c09259_si_001.pdf