Investigation on the Combustion Characteristics and Environmental Effects of Hydrogen-doped Natural Gas for Domestic Water Heaters Authors: Yiyu Chen, Liwen Long, Jie Niu, Taiming Huang, Xi Chen, Jing Zhang, Zhongmin Wan, Bo Yu Published: 2023 ABSTRACT The addition of hydrogen to natural gas is an effective approach to broaden the range of applications for hydrogen and address the issue of global warming. However, the inclusion of hydrogen alters the combustion properties of natural gas. The paper established a simplified mechanism consisting of 19 components and a 67-step reaction for hydrogen-doped natural gas combustion. With this simplified mechanism, the effects of hydrogen doping and the utilization of porous media combustion techniques on the combustion characteristics of natural gas were investigated numerically. The results suggested that the utilization of porous media combustion technology is beneficial for achieving the complete combustion of hydrogen-doped natural gas and reducing pollutant emissions. Additionally, the total gas cost and environmental impact of domestic gas water heaters with hydrogen-doping natural gas were estimated. The findings show that the use of 20% hydrogen-doped natural gas contributes to a decrement in fuel costs and reduced emissions of CO by 25.4%, NOX by 53.9%, and CO2 by 6.78%. Introduction With the aim of achieving carbon neutrality and sustainable development, hydrogen energy has gained considerable attention due to its benefits of being clean, carbon-free, green, efficient, and renewable.1−3 Nonetheless, the utilization of pure hydrogen is constrained by issues such as production, storage, transportation, and end-use. One promising solution for the large-scale implementation of hydrogen energy at a low cost is blending hydrogen into the current natural gas pipeline network and transporting it to end-users. European countries have been gradually blending hydrogen into their natural gas pipeline networks.4,5 For example, the GRHYD project in France added 6% hydrogen to the original gas pipeline, while the HyDeploy project in the United Kingdom successfully blended 20% hydrogen into the pipeline at Kiel University. However, blending hydrogen into natural gas changes its combustion characteristics and affects the end-of-the-art equipment performance. Sun et al.6 studied the effects of blending different proportions of hydrogen into natural gas on domestic gas appliances. The results showed that domestic gas water heaters would experience the phenomenon of backfire when the hydrogen doping ratio was 25%. Jones et al.7 found that backfire could be avoided in round holes with a diameter of less than 3.5 mm in a UK gas appliance when the hydrogen blend was less than 34.7 mol %. Zhao et al.8 studied the effects of blending hydrogen on the combustion and cooking performance of stove burners in the United States. It came to the conclusion that the performance of the stove burners was not significantly affected when the hydrogen blend was at 15%. Zhao et al.9 evaluated the combustion performance of mixtures with different hydrogen blends on residential and commercial oven burners. They found that blending 25% hydrogen caused an ignition backfire. When the hydrogen blend was 10%, the burner temperature increased by 63%, but a higher blend did not significantly affect the burner surface temperature. Zhan et al.10 studied the effect of different ratios of hydrogen-doped natural gas on the flame inside a domestic gas water heater. The results showed that as the hydrogen ratio increased, the height of the internal flame first increased and then decreased. Numerous studies have investigated the combustion characteristics of hydrogen-doped natural gas. Kong et al.11 studied the flame characteristics of a horizontal jet flame of mixed hydrogen and natural gas. Their results showed that the flame temperature increased after hydrogen addition. Donohoe et al.12 examined the ignition delay time of hydrogen-doped natural gas under different temperatures, pressures, hydrogen doping ratios, and long-chain hydrocarbon contents. Their results showed that the ignition delay time decreases as the parameters increase. Li et al.12,13 investigated the impact of hydrogen doping ratios and initial pressure on flame instability and found that blending hydrogen led to enhanced diffusion thermal instability and hydrodynamic instability, which caused flame instability. Ennetta et al.14 simulated the laminar burning velocity of hydrogen-doped natural gas with varying hydrogen doping ratios and found that hydrogen blending increased the laminar burning velocity. If the flow velocity of the premixed gas is equal to the flame propagation speed, then the flame will remain in a stable state. However, the addition of hydrogen gas increases the flame propagation speed, causing the flame to propagate upstream toward the burner, leading to the occurrence of a dangerous phenomenon known as backfire. Lu et al.15 conducted numerical simulations to analyze the effect of gas flow distribution on pollutant emissions from gas turbines using hydrogen-doped natural gas. Their findings indicated that the NOX concentration gradually increased when the hydrogen doping ratio was below 40%. Pan et al.16 simulated pollutant emissions from industrial furnaces burning hydrogen-doped natural gas and concluded that NOX emissions decreased as the hydrogen doping ratio increased at the given combustion temperature. The combustion performance of hydrogen-doped natural gas was often studied using numerical methods due to the flammable and explosive characteristics of hydrogen. However, the most widely accepted methane-hydrogen dynamics (GRI-Mech 3.0, USC, Aramco, and San Diego) involve dozens of components and hundreds of reactions, which makes direct calculation time-consuming.17 If the detailed mechanism is used directly for computer calculations, it will take a long time to calculate. To reduce computational costs, researchers have simplified the mechanism through certain methods while still maintaining sufficient accuracy to simulate the reaction process. Gimeno-Escobedo et al.18 used a direct relation graph (DRG) and direct relation graph with error propagation-aided sensitivity analysis (DRGEPSA) to simplify a mixture with a 50% hydrogen doping ratio based on GRI-Mech 3.0. They obtained a simplified mechanism of 26 components and 143 reactions, which was verified to have reasonable error. Liu et al.19 simplified GRI-Mech 3.0 by 82% using sensitivity analysis (SA), DRG, and DRGEPSA methods. They found that the simplified combustion model had good consistency in temperature and with some components. Compared with traditional combustion technology, porous media combustion technology has the advantages of a compact structure, better combustion stability, higher combustion efficiency, and lower pollutant emission.20−22 Kıymaz et al.23 investigated the effects of different wall temperatures and hydrogen blending ratios on the phenomenon of hydrogen-enriched natural gas flashback. Fruzza et al.24 found that the occurrence of flashback in hydrogen-enriched natural gas is closely related to the flame and burner structure. Arrieta et al.25 studied the effects of mixtures with different hydrogen doping ratios and equivalent ratios on temperature distribution, radiation efficiency, and pollutant emissions in porous media burners. Gao et al.26 studied the influence of different porous materials on flame stability. The results showed that with the increase in thermal conductivity of foam ceramics, the flame stability limit increases, and with the increase in pore density, the flame stability limit decreases. Jia et al.27 proposed a burner with a double-layer porous media structure and simulated the combustion performance of a methane-air mixture. The results showed that the new porous media burner can significantly reduce the emission concentration of NOX. In summary, porous medium combustion technology has shown good performance in reducing pollutant emissions and is promised to improve the combustion characteristics of hydrogen-doped natural gas. Lamioni et al.28 utilized a CFD model to investigate the combustion characteristics of hydrogen-enriched natural gas in perforated premixed burners. The results indicated that the blending of hydrogen gas decreases the emissions of pollutants such as CO and NO. In this study, we explored the potential of using a porous medium structure to improve the combustion stability of hydrogen-doped natural gas and reduce pollutant emissions. To achieve this, a simplified methane-hydrogen combustion mechanism in Chemkin software using SA and DRG methods based on the GRI-Mech 3.0 mechanism was established. We then applied this simplified mechanism to a two-dimensional double-layer porous media model based on the volume averaging method and compared the temperature and pollutant emissions at different hydrogen doping ratios and equivalent ratios. Finally, we evaluated the economic and environmental performance of domestic gas water heaters that utilize hydrogen-doped natural gas and porous media combustion technology. Reduce Method GRI-Mech 3.0 has been shown to simulate the combustion characteristics of pure hydrogen flames and hydrogen-rich mixtures well. In order to obtain a simplified mechanism suitable for CFD calculation, GRI-Mech 3.0 is used as the initiation mechanism of the reduction process. The simplified combustion mechanism model is based on the 0-D closed homogeneous model in Chemkin. The specific boundary conditions are selected for the reactor; for example, the operating pressure is 1 atm, the initial temperature is 1800 K, the equivalent ratio is 1.0, the hydrogen doping ratio is increased from 0 to 90%, the sampling interval is 10%, and the heat loss is ignored. The value of the parameter is taken according to the data collected during the normal operation of domestic gas water heaters. In practice, temperature, flame stability, and pollutant emissions play a key role in the design and operation of domestic gas appliances. Laminar burning characterizes the velocity of the flame front during combustion. Also, it is one of the important parameters for studying flame stability. Ueda et al.29 show that there is a good linear relationship between laminar burning velocity and (H + OH) concentration maximum for CH4/H2 mixtures. Therefore, in the reduction process, the maximum temperature, the maximum and end point of H and OH primitives, and the endpoint of CO and NOX are selected as the target flame characteristics to drive the reduction of the mechanism. In the simplification process, key basic components (CH4, H, H2, O, O2, OH, N2, NO, and NO2) and reaction products (CO, CO2, and H2O) are searched as the initial components. Next, a framework mechanism is obtained by using DRG and DRGEP. Furthermore, the SA of the framework mechanism is carried out to obtain the final simplified mechanism. The absolute error and relative error are set to 10 × 10–6 and 10%, respectively. The DRG operation reduces the original mechanism to 20 components and 81 reactions, and the DRGEP operation continues to simplify, further reducing the mechanism to 19 components, a 67-step reaction mechanism. As shown in Table 1, the final maximum error value of the simplified mechanism by DRG and DRG is 36.4% of that of the H radical, which represents a large error in the laminar burning velocity. Therefore, the SA of the H radical is carried out, and the error of laminar burning velocity is reduced by modifying the pre-exponential constants of the reaction with the largest sensitivity coefficient of the H radical. Table 1Target Error Parametercomponents and temperatureerror (%)CO0NO0NO20.0temperature0.8H36.4OH1.0 Target Error Parameter As shown in Figure 1, in the analysis of H radical sensitivity of 0.8 and 1.0, #34 reaction: OH + CO ↔ H + CO2 is one of the ten reactions with the greatest influence on H radical. And the pre-exponential constant of #34 is selected for modification. Besides, #38 reaction: CH2 + O2 → H + OH + CO is one of the ten reactions with the greatest influence on H radical in the analysis of H radical sensitivity of 1.2 and 1.4. Therefore, the pre-exponential constant of #38 is selected for modification. SA of H primitives when the equivalent ratio is 0.8–1.4. The comparison model uses a set of one-dimensional laminar premixed flame models and finally obtains the relative data of the premixed fuel-air mixture with an equivalent ratio of 0.8–1.2. When the equivalent ratio is 0.8, 1.0, and 1.2, the error of the components is less than 10%, as shown in Figure 2a and the flame speed is less than 6%, as shown in Figure 2b. Comparison of (a) mole fraction of the pollution components (the equivalent ratio is 0.8) and (b) flame speed from the detailed and the simplified mechanisms (the equivalent ratio is 0.8, 1.0, and 1.2). Numerical Models Physical Model As shown in Figure 3, this paper establishes a physical model of a double-layer porous layer in Fluent software. By creating two separate, two-layer 60 mm fluid domains as the filling regions of the porous medium. The burner cylinder has an inner diameter of 50 mm and a total length of 150 mm, and two layers of 60 mm porous medium area are filled inside as the preheating zone and combustion zone. Alumina balls are used in the preheating zone, zirconia foam ceramic is used in the combustion zone, and the parameters of the porous mediums are shown in Table 2. Physical model of double-layer porous media. Table 2Physical Property Parameters of Porous Media Materialsparameterspreheat zonecombustion zonematerialsAl2O3ZrO2density (kg m–3)34403750specific heat (J kg–1 K–1)710570PPI 10porosity0.2650.8effective thermal conductivity (W m–1 K–1)1.870.41 Physical Property Parameters of Porous Media Materials Mathematical Model In order to save computer resources, this paper simplified the physical model of a three-dimensional axis-symmetric structure to a two-dimensional structure. For the convenience of computation, this article introduces some reasonable assumptions in the process of numerical calculation.30(1)Ignore the radiation effect of the gas;(2)The gas is an incompressible ideal gas and is fully premixed;(3)The porous medium is inert and isotropic;(4)The gas and the solid are in a state of thermal equilibrium. (1)Ignore the radiation effect of the gas; Ignore the radiation effect of the gas; (2)The gas is an incompressible ideal gas and is fully premixed; The gas is an incompressible ideal gas and is fully premixed; (3)The porous medium is inert and isotropic; The porous medium is inert and isotropic; (4)The gas and the solid are in a state of thermal equilibrium. The gas and the solid are in a state of thermal equilibrium. The relevant control equations covered in this work are as follows Continuity equation1where ε is the porosity of the porous medium; ρ is the average density of the mixed gas; U is the axial gas velocity; and V is the longitudinal gas velocity. Momentum equation23where P is the pressure and μ is the viscosity. Energy equation4where keff is the effective thermal conductivity; Tg is the temperature of the gas mixture; hi is the molar enthalpy of species i; wi is the molar yield of species i; Wi is the relative molecular mass of species i; Yi is the mass fraction of species i; Dim is the mass diffusion coefficient of the gas. Species transport equation5 Ideal gas state equation6where is the average molecular weight of the gas mixture. The equivalent ratio is defined as the ratio of the actual fuel/oxygen mixing ratio to the fuel/oxygen mixing ratio under chemical equivalent conditions, which is defined as follows7 Reynolds number8D and μ represent the average diameter of the porous medium and the viscosity of the fluid, respectively. The empirical formula for viscous resistance and inertial resistance of a porous media-filled bed with foamed ceramics30,319101112 Formulas 9 and 10 represent the viscous drag coefficient of alumina balls, and formulas 11 and 12 represent the resistance coefficient of foam ceramics. Kuwahara et al.32 believe that in the flow of porous media, when Re > 80, turbulence effects cannot be ignored, and when Re > 160, turbulence effects must be considered. Therefore, the realizable k–ε turbulence model is chosen. The inlet velocity and pressure outlet boundary conditions. In addition, the heat transfer condition of the outer wall is set to a mixed heat transfer of radiation and convection; the normal emissivity of the inner wall and outer wall is 0.8,33 and the heat transfer coefficient of the wall surface is 20 W/(m2 K). The heat transfer expression is13hc represents the convective heat transfer coefficient between the combustion chamber wall and the environment, Tw and T∞ represent the outer wall temperature and ambient temperature, respectively, εs is the emissivity of the combustion chamber wall, and the Stepan–Boltzmann constant σ is 5.67 × 10–8 W/(m2 K4). Numerical Simulation Validation In order to save computer resources and improve the calculation accuracy, the mesh numbers of 3422, 14,259, and 22,692 cells are selected for simulation. Figure 4 shows the central axis temperatures for three different mesh accuracies. Overall, the temperature trend of the central axis predicted by the three meshes of different accuracy is consistent. However, according to Figure 4a, the maximum temperature difference of the central axis of 3422 cells is about 73 K, with an error of about 5%. While the maximum difference in temperature for 14,259 cells is about 24 K, and the error is about 1.5% compared to the prediction of 22,692 cells. Therefore, the number of 14,259 cells is significantly better than the number of 3422 cells. Taking into account computer resources, this paper selects 14,259 cells for grid calculation. (a) Central axis temperature with different grid cells. (b) Verification of numerical values and experimental results. In order to verify the reliability and accuracy of the mechanism and porous media combustion model, the central axis temperature is compared with detailed experimental results. Gao et al.26 conducted experiments on methane/air combustion in porous media. The diameter of the porous medium combustion is 50 mm, and the length is 200 mm. The outer wall of the burner is filled with Kaowool, which serves as insulation and multiple thermocouples are inserted in the middle of the porous medium to measure the center temperature. This article selects ZrO2 foam from the Gao experiment for verification. Figure 4b shows that under the combustion condition of an inlet velocity of 0.3 m/s and an equivalent ratio of 0.6, the numerical calculation results are basically consistent with the experimental results of Gao et al.26 In terms of other characteristics, the simulation results are in good agreement with the experimental results. Therefore, the model meets the requirements of engineering applications. Results and Discussion Effect of Hydrogen Doping on Temperature Figure 5 shows the maximum central axis temperature distribution of the burner when the equivalent ratios are 0.9 and 1.0 and the hydrogen doping ratio is 0–20%. As shown in Figure 5a, when the proportion of hydrogen increases from 0 to 20%, the peak temperature of the flame increases from 1710 to 1717 K when the equivalent ratio is 0.9. As shown in Figure 5b, when the equivalent ratio is 1.0, the peak temperature of the flame increases from 1819 K with a hydrogen doping ratio of 0 to 1836 K with a hydrogen doping ratio of 20%. Figure 6 shows a two-dimensional temperature distribution with equivalent ratios of 0.9 and 1.0 and hydrogen doping ratios of 0, 10, and 20%. In Figure 6b, the temperature contour of 1710 K is positioned slightly earlier than that in Figure 6a. In Figure 6e, the temperature contour of 1820 K is slightly ahead of that in Figure 6d. Central axis temperature of 0–20% hydrogen doping ratio. (a) Equivalent ratio is 0.9, and (b) equivalent ratio is 1.0. Two-dimensional temperature distribution of the 0/10/20% hydrogen doping ratio when the equivalent ratio is 0.9: (a) 0% H2; (b) 10% H2; (c) 20% H2/the equivalent ratio is 1.0; (d) 0% H2; (e) 10% H2; and (f) 20% H2. Since hydrogen has 1 H–H chemical bond (activation energy is 436 kJ/mol), CH4 has 4 C–H chemical bonds (activation energy is 414 kJ/mol). The activation energy consumed by hydrogen when participating in the reaction is less than CH4, so the chemical properties of hydrogen are more active and easier to react with O2, so with the increase in the hydrogen doping ratio, the combustion exothermic reaction will occur earlier. Therefore, the initial reaction location will be closer to the fuel inlet, which is consistent with the research of Fruzza et al.24 The advance of the initial reaction position will make the reaction more complete; the exothermic heat of the reaction will also increase; and the peak temperature of the flame will also increase. Effect of Porous Media Structure on Temperature of Hydrogen-Doped Natural Gas Figure 7 shows the temperature distribution of the central axis of combustion of a mixture with a hydrogen doping ratio of 0 and 20% in a burner without porous media and a burner with a porous medium at equivalent ratios of 0.9 and 1.0. As shown in Figure 7a,b, the utilization of the porous media structure will increase the peak temperature of the hydrogen-doped natural gas flame, the location of the initial reaction will be advanced, and the position of the peak temperature will be lagged. Figure 8 shows the two-dimensional temperature distribution of hydrogen-doped natural gas with a hydrogen doping ratio of 0, 10, and 20% when burned in a burner with porous media at an equivalent ratio of 0.9 and 1.0. The peak temperature (1800 K) of the 20% hydrogen doping ratio is lower than that of the 0 doped ratios in a porous medium structure.The result at an equivalent ratio of 1.0 shares a similar trend, as shown in Figure 8. Effect of porous medium on the temperature of the central axis of the 0/20% hydrogen doping ratio. (a) Equivalent ratio is 0.9, and (b) equivalent ratio is 1.0. Two-dimensional temperature distribution of the 0/10/20% hydrogen doping ratio in the porous medium when the equivalent ratio is 0.9: (a) 0% H2; (b) 10% H2; (c) 20% H2/the equivalent ratio is 1.0; (d) 0% H2; (e) 10% H2; and (f) 20% H2. The addition of porous media structure will preheat the fuel to make it easier to burn completely, and in terms of the macroscopic calorific value of methane and hydrogen, the calorific value of CH4 (39.83 MJ/m3) is higher than that of hydrogen (12.70 MJ/m3), so as the mixing amount of hydrogen gradually increases, the temperature of complete combustion of the mixture decreases. The lag of the peak temperature position lies in the existence of the porous medium preheating section because the porosity of the preheating section will be lower than that of the combustion section, which makes the tempering of hydrogen-doped natural gas more difficult to occur due to the phenomenon of backfire, so that the peak temperature is stable at the junction of the porous medium. Emissions of Pollutants Figure 9 shows the emission of CO and NOX of hydrogen-doped natural gas free flame at an equivalent ratio of 0.9 and the emissions of CO and NOX of hydrogen-doped natural gas burning in a porous medium at an equivalent ratio of 0.9. As shown in Figure 9, the emissions of CO and NOX decrease when the hydrogen doping ratio increases from 0 to 20%, regardless of whether the burner is filled with porous media or not. Effect of porous media on NOX emissions with different hydrogen doping ratios when the equivalent ratio is 0.9–1.0. The reason is that as the proportion of hydrogen doping increases, the C content in the fuel decreases, while the addition of hydrogen generates H and OH radicals that promote the conversion of CO to CO2. This is consistent with the research results of Zhan et al.10 The reason is that the influence of temperature plays a dominant role in determining the production of thermal NOX. When the temperature is higher than 1800 K, the amount of NOX generated increases sharply as the temperature increases. In this study, the gas is completely premixed, and the equivalent ratio of 0.9 is more abundant than oxygen, which means that oxygen enrichment brings a larger primary air volume, which is equivalent to a certain heat dilution in the burner so that the temperature drops and the emission of NOX decreases. This is consistent with the research results of Sun et al.6 In the burner with added porous medium, with the increase in hydrogen doping ratio, the emission of NOX is lower than those of unfilled burners because the hydrogen-doped natural gas burned in the porous medium will decrease in temperature with the increase in hydrogen doping ratio, thereby reducing the emission of thermal NOX. Another reason is that the presence of porous media makes the combustion area more uniform and inhibits the thermal NOX generated by the local high temperature. Economic and Environmental Assessment The use of hydrogen-doped natural gas can reduce the consumption of fossil energy and the emission of pollutants. In order to apply it to household gas appliances, it is necessary to analyze its economic and environmental benefits. Table 3 shows the CO and NOX emissions from three different hydrogen production methods: natural gas reforming, wind energy hydrogen production, and solar energy hydrogen production. Table 3Emissions of CO and NOX During the Hydrogen Production Process34 hydrogen production from natural gas total emissionshydrogen production from wind energy total emissionshydrogen production from solar energy total emissionsCO (g/MJ)0.0330.01420.021NOX (g/MJ)0.07610.01690.0251 Emissions of CO and NOX During the Hydrogen Production Process34 Economic Evaluation Assuming that the annual usage time is 17,520 min every year.6 According to Chinese standard ⟨⟨GB/T 17905-2008⟩⟩,35 the service life of domestic gas water heaters is 8 years. In this process, the gas consumption and economic comparison of burners burning methane without porous media and burning 20% hydrogen-doped methane in porous media are studied. The thermal power produced by pure methane burning is 21 kW, while the hydrogen-doped natural gas burning with a 20% hydrogen doping ratio is 18 kW. Considering that the calorific value of the gas changes with the proportion of hydrogen doping, the speed of the gas increases in order to achieve the same thermal power. The speed of 20% hydrogen-doped natural gas should be 0.348 m/s, and the burner will not experience the phenomenon of backfire. As shown in Figure 10a, the methane consumption for 8 years is 5533 m3 without hydrogen doping, while 4606 m3 of methane and 1151 m3 of hydrogen will be used when the heaters use a 20% hydrogen doping ratio mixture. Table 4 shows the price of hydrogen for three different hydrogen production methods of natural gas reforming, wind hydrogen production, and solar hydrogen production.36Figure 10b shows the price of hydrogen-doped natural gas using 20% hydrogen from three different hydrogen sources versus pure methane. In contrast, the cost of a gas water heater that burns pure methane is 19,867 ¥ over the entire period of use. In general, the use of hydrogen in three different hydrogen production methods at this stage can reduce the price of gas use, while among the other three methods, the price of hydrogen produced by natural gas is the lowest, at 17,851 ¥, with a decrease of about 8.6%. According to statistics,37 the sales of gas water heaters in China in 2022 were 11.6 million units. If all of them were converted to hydrogen-doped natural gas with 20% hydrogen content, it is expected to reduce the cost by 2.9 billion ¥ per year. (a) 0 and 20% doping ratio for methane and hydrogen dosage; (b) the total cost of the three different hydrogen production methods. Table 4Price of Methane and Hydrogen36hydrogen productionmethanenatural gaswind energysolar energyprice (¥/m3)3.451.72.952.41CO2 emission (kg/m3 H2) 1.68750.040.45 Price of Methane and Hydrogen36 CO Emissions Based on the calculated model, the emission of the CO from the mixture with the ratio of 0–20% hydrogen doping and the CO emissions in the hydrogen production process of three different hydrogen production methods were studied. As shown in Figure 11a, as the proportion of hydrogen doping increases, the sum of CO emissions in the three hydrogen production processes produced by combustion decreases. If the mixture with a hydrogen doping ratio of 20% is passed at a speed of 0.3 m/s in this burner, the CO produced is 3186 g, which is 25.4% lower than the CO emissions of pure methane. According to statistics, the sales of gas water heaters in China in 2022 were 11.6 million units. If this batch of water heaters is all converted to burning 20% hydrogen mixed with natural gas, it is expected to reduce 9.8 × 106 kg of CO emissions. Emission of porous medium burner and ordinary burner operating for 2236 h. (a) CO; (b) NOX; and (c) CO2. NOX Emissions Based on the calculated model, the sum of NOX emissions of a mixture with a hydrogen doping ratio of 0–20% and the production by three different hydrogen production methods are studied. As shown in Figure 11b, with the increase in the proportion of hydrogen doping, the total NOX emissions in the three hydrogen production processes and produced by combustion decrease. When hydrogen produced from wind energy is used in burners, the NOX emissions are minimal. If a mixture with a hydrogen doping ratio of 20% is passed at a speed of 0.3 m/s in this burner, the emission of NOX is 3265 g, which is 53.9% lower compared to pure methane. According to the above method, it is expected to reduce 4.72 × 107 kg of NO emissions. CO2 Emissions As shown in Table 4, the emissions of CO2 in the three hydrogen production processes are compared. Using a burner model with porous media as an example, CO2 emissions from three different sources of hydrogen are compared. As shown in Figure 11c, the use of hydrogen-doped natural gas will reduce carbon emissions with a decrease of 6.7%. However, taking the burner model with porous media as an example, the carbon emissions of hydrogen from three different sources have increased to varying degrees, among which the use of wind power to produce hydrogen has the lowest carbon emissions, and the use of natural gas reforming to produce hydrogen has the highest carbon emissions. According to the above method, it is expected to reduce 7.11 × 106 kg of CO2 emissions. Conclusions In this paper, a methane–hydrogen mixture combustion mechanism was established by SA and a direct relationship diagram, according to the detailed mechanism of GRI-Mech 3.0. The CFD model was used to study the combustion characteristics of hydrogen-doped natural gas in the porous media model. The economics, as well as the environmental effect, of hydrogen-doped natural gas with different hydrogen doping ratios based on three different hydrogen production methods were discussed. The main results are as follows:1A simplified mechanism with a 19-component, 67-step can be well applied to the equivalent ratio of 0.8–1.4 of hydrogen-doped natural gas was obtained, and it has been verified that the predictive error of the model is no more than 10%.2The peak temperature of hydrogen-doped natural gas will increase with the increase in hydrogen doping ratio, and the reaction position will advance with the increase in hydrogen doping ratio. When hydrogen-doped natural gas is applied to the porous medium structure, the peak temperature will decrease with the increase in the hydrogen doping ratio.3The fuel cost will decrease to a certain extent after using three different ways of producing hydrogen. Also, the utilization of 20% hydrogen-doped natural gas contributes to a decrement in fuel costs and reduced emissions of CO by 25.4%, NOX by 53.9%, and CO2 by 6.78%. 1A simplified mechanism with a 19-component, 67-step can be well applied to the equivalent ratio of 0.8–1.4 of hydrogen-doped natural gas was obtained, and it has been verified that the predictive error of the model is no more than 10%. A simplified mechanism with a 19-component, 67-step can be well applied to the equivalent ratio of 0.8–1.4 of hydrogen-doped natural gas was obtained, and it has been verified that the predictive error of the model is no more than 10%. 2The peak temperature of hydrogen-doped natural gas will increase with the increase in hydrogen doping ratio, and the reaction position will advance with the increase in hydrogen doping ratio. When hydrogen-doped natural gas is applied to the porous medium structure, the peak temperature will decrease with the increase in the hydrogen doping ratio. The peak temperature of hydrogen-doped natural gas will increase with the increase in hydrogen doping ratio, and the reaction position will advance with the increase in hydrogen doping ratio. When hydrogen-doped natural gas is applied to the porous medium structure, the peak temperature will decrease with the increase in the hydrogen doping ratio. 3The fuel cost will decrease to a certain extent after using three different ways of producing hydrogen. Also, the utilization of 20% hydrogen-doped natural gas contributes to a decrement in fuel costs and reduced emissions of CO by 25.4%, NOX by 53.9%, and CO2 by 6.78%. The fuel cost will decrease to a certain extent after using three different ways of producing hydrogen. Also, the utilization of 20% hydrogen-doped natural gas contributes to a decrement in fuel costs and reduced emissions of CO by 25.4%, NOX by 53.9%, and CO2 by 6.78%.