Affinity of Amphiphilic Molecules to Air/Water Surface Authors: Chi Minh Phan Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractThe affinity of amphiphiles to the water/air surface was modeled by adapting Eberhart’s equation. The proposed method successfully describes surface tension for all amphiphilic structures, including alkanols, carboxylic acids, nonionic, ionic, and Gemini surfactants. The model is more effective than conventional analysis for amphiphiles with multiple ionic states. The prediction was consistently validated at different temperatures and nonaqueous solvents. The modeling results show a linear correlation between surface affinity and hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity. For alkanols, the affinity increment is 2.84 kJ/mol per CH2 group, the same as the reported hydrophobic energy from monomer to aggregate for nonionic surfactants. For carboxylic acids, the affinity increment per CH2 group is 3.18 kJ/mol, incorporating the degree of acid dissociation. The affinity–hydrophilicity correlation is approximately −0.22 kJ/mol per oxyethylene group. The affinity constant can be obtained for all classes of amphiphiles to clarify the relationship between the molecular structure and surface activity. Introduction The interfacial layer of aqueous solutions plays a central role in many processes, including evaporation,1 cloud aerosol stability,2 dewetting/wetting,3 and mass transfer on surface flow.4 The classical treatment of surface tension by the Young–Laplace-Gauss equation considers the interface between solution and air as a capillary surface,5 with a zero thickness. Recent advances, including molecular simulations, have provided new insights into the molecular arrangement within the interfacial layer, with a thickness of ∼1 nm.6 However, the gap between nanoscaled simulation and macroscopic data remains substantial.7 In the literature, the surface tension data are often modeled by the Gibbs adsorption equation. The most common approach is integrating the Gibbs adsorption with Langmuir isotherm to provide the Szyszkowski equation8 where γ and γw are the surface tension at concentration Cb and water surface tension, respectively, and R and T are gas constant and absolute temperature. The two fitting parameters are Γm and A, defined by Langmuir’s adsorption equation. The value of n is assumed independent of concentration and depends on the ionic state of the surfactant (n = 1 for nonionic surfactants, n = 2 for ionic surfactants). Industrial surfactants, including detergents, are characterized by a long alkyl group with very low solubility (less than 0.01% by mole). The above equation has been applied to hundreds of industrial surfactants, as reviewed by Rosen.8 In addition to fitting the surface tension data to eq 1,9 the surface adsorption can be experimentally obtained from neutron reflectometry. Recently, Penfold and co-workers re-examined the method by combining tension data with neutron reflectometry for three types of deuterated surfactants. They found that the application of the Gibbs equation is valid for nonionic surfactants,10 while being limited to a specific range for anionic11 and cationic12 surfactants. However, they showed that the approach could not be applied to surfactants that undergo ion association such as carboxylic acids and Gemini surfactants. In addition to the industrial amphiphiles, there is another group of much weaker amphiphiles, which are fully soluble in water, such as ethanol and 1-propanol. The application of Gibb adsorption isotherm to these molecules requires a quantification of the activity coefficient.13,14 For these fully miscible amphiphiles, many alternative models have been proposed in the literature.15−17 While these models can be applied to specific aqueous mixtures, a systematic description remains unclear. Between the strong surfactants and fully miscible short-chain organics, there is another group of amphiphiles with intermediate strength: the medium-chain carboxylic acids. This group is characterized by partial dissociation and partial solubility (from 0.01 to 0.1% by mole).18 These molecules are found naturally and play an important role in cloud aerosols and climate science.19 The modeling of carboxylic acids, especially with partial dissociation near the surface, is mathematically complicated.20 In summary, all current modeling approaches are limited to a specific group of amphiphiles. The theoretical connection between the weak and completely soluble (e.g., methanol) and strong and partially soluble (e.g., alkyl trimethylammonium halide) amphiphile is unavailable. This study presents a new modeling approach, based on the thermodynamic equilibrium, to predict the surface tension and interfacial layer. The model aims to universally correlate the molecular structure and surface activity. Theory In this model, the interfacial layer is considered a separate phase, limited by bulk liquid and air phases (Figure 1). The amphiphilic molecules have two processes: adsorption and desorption. The rates of the processes are where Xb and Xs are molar fractions within the interfacial layer and the bulk. Equilibrium between the interfacial and bulk. Solvent molecules are omitted for clarity. The equilibrium constant, Ka, is obtained by Thermodynamics requires that chemical potential is the same between the two phases where μb0 and μs0 are the standard part of the chemical potential in the bulk and interfacial layer. The above framework has been validated for equilibrium between bulk monomers and aggregates (micelles, invert micelles, bilayer membrane, and vesicles) of soluble surfactants.21 In this case, the interfacial layer in Figure 1 can be considered to be a monolayer with infinite area. Combining the above equations leads to The surface tension of the aqueous solution is the sum of the two-component surface tensions and is given by where γ(Xb), γa, and γw are the surface tension of the mixture, pure organic compound, and pure water, respectively. Recent molecular simulation22 and neutron reflectometry23 with water/ethanol have validated eq 7. The key challenge is the linkage between the interfacial and bulk compositions via a thermodynamic equation. The following equations are developed to address that gap. The model requires the equilibrium constant of water, Kw (Kw is defined in the same form as in eq 4). Subsequently, a binary ratio between the two components is defined24 With this constant, the surface molar fraction is related to the bulk molar fraction Consequently, eq 7 becomes Equation 10, also known as Eberhart’s equation,a has been successfully applied to water/ethanol16 and many miscible systems, including aqueous and organic solvents.25 The model implies that S is independent of Xb. For fully miscible liquids, the value of γa is experimentally obtainable. Consequently, eq 10 has only one fitting parameter, S. The pure solute surface tension condition is limited to small organic compounds. For the molecules with limited solubility or that exist in solid form, the value of γa is physically unobtainable.26 A new modeling approach allows a hypothetical value, γa*. As a result, the equation has two fitting parameters. The physical interpretation and values of γa* are discussed later. Results and Discussion First, eq 10 is applied, by least-squares fitting in Excel Solver, to six n-alkanols (Figure 2) and six carboxylic acids (Figure 3). The obtained best-fit values are tabulated in Table 1. The equation fits all data consistently. The fitting of fully miscible molecules (Figures 2a and 3a) has been discussed in the literature15,16 and is presented for completeness. As the alkyl-chain length increases, the data shift to a surfactant-liked curve showing a gradual reduction in solubility (Figures 2b and 3b). Modeling surface tension of n-alkanols (a) fully miscible13,27−31 and (b) partially miscible30,32−35 to solubility. All curves were generated by eq 10. Adapted from ref (46). Copyright (2019), Elsevier. Modeling surface tension of carboxylic acids (a) fully miscible36−38 and (b) partially miscible.36 All curves were generated by eq 10. Table 1Best-Fitted Adsorption for n-Alkanols and Carboxylic Acids (*: Fitted Values) n-alkanolcarboxylic acidnumber of carbonsSγa (mN/m)Sγa (mN/m)10.15022.330.18437.6020.044722.020.067927.1030.010323.390.018126.1740.0040117.63*0.0041926.2050.0013514.57*0.0011025.40*60.0004768.62*0.00036620.89* Best-Fitted Adsorption for n-Alkanols and Carboxylic Acids (*: Fitted Values) Subsequently, the model is applied to the surface tension39 of three nonionic surfactants (Figure 4). This group of surfactants contains multiple groups of oxyethylene (−C2H4O−), which controls the “hydrophilicity” and “hydrophilic–lipophilic balance”. The Triton X and other polyoxyethylenated series (Tween and Brij) are extensively used in many industries.8 The values of the two fitting parameters are presented in Table 2. It should be noted that the model can predict the surface tension to the critical aggregate concentration (CAC) as with the conventional model.40 A thermodynamic equilibrium can explain the transition at the CAC, as discussed with micellar formation later. Modeling surface tension of nonionic surfactants (ref (39)). The broken lines represent the extension of the model above CAC. Adapted from ref (39). Copyright (2018), John Wiley and Sons. Table 2Best-Fitted Adsorption for the Triton-X Surfactantssurfactantaverage number of C2H4O groupS × 106γa (mN/m)Triton X-1009.50.18024.92Triton X-405355.15925.68Triton X-705558.52623.37 Best-Fitted Adsorption for the Triton-X Surfactants Figures 3 and 4 show that eq 10 can predict the surface tension of partially soluble amphiphiles with an accuracy similar to that of the conventional model. Yet, the critical advantage of the equation over the conventional model is its applicability to other conditions. The main extensions are (1) changing temperature, (2) nonaqueous solvents, (3) the structure-surface affinity relationship, and (4) the degree of surfactant dissociation and surfactants with multiple-charged groups. These implications are discussed in the following sections. Before proceeding, the new term, specific surface affinity, is defined for each molecule The affinity has a unit of kJ/mol,b similar to the Gibbs free energy of adsorption25 or phase transferring energy21 and quantitatively represents the tendency of the specific molecule to be exposed to the air. With the new quantity, eq 8 can be rearranged where Aw is the specific surface affinity of water. Influence of Temperature With increasing temperature, both the μb0 and μs0 increase. Being the difference between the two potentials, the affinity (Aa in eq 11) is less dependent on the temperature. Furthermore, both Aw and Aa should change in the same direction with increasing temperature. Consequently, it can be assumed that the net impact of changing temperature on the right-hand side of eq 12 is negligible. The value of S at any temperature can be linked to S at 25 °C by An example of the extension can be found in Figure 5. The predictions are obtained from S of formic acid/water at 25 °C (Table 1) without further fitting. The predictions are consistent with the experimental data at all temperatures. Applying the same predictions to other data provides a similar consistency.37 Predicting the interfacial composition at elevated temperatures is essential to calculate the evaporation rate of the binary droplet.41,42 Surface tension of the formic acid solutions at different temperatures (data are obtained from ref (37)). All prediction curves are generated from the obtained S at 25 °C. Adapted with permission from ref (37). Copyright (1997), American Chemical Society. Nonaqueous Solvents Since ln(S) is a difference between two affinities, a complementary rule can be applied to the three related binary mixtures.24 To validate the rule, an intermediate molecule, ethylene glycol (EG), is considered. Ethylene glycol has a surface tension of 48 mN/m, almost the average value between that of water and ethanol. The surface tension of EG–water34 and EG–ethanol43 has already been reported. The complementary rule from eq 12 gives where Sethanol–EG, Swater–EG, and Swater–ethanol are the coefficients of ethanol/EG, water/EG, and water/ethanol, respectively. Since the value of Swater–ethanol is already known, the data of EG–ethanol and EG–water can be fitted simultaneously, as shown in Figure 6. The best-fit value of Swater–EG is 0.148. The data validate the rule in eq 14 and the consistency of the modeling approach. Simultaneous prediction of the surface tension of ethylene glycol mixtures with water and ethanol. Affinity-Hydrophobicity Correlation From the data in Table 1, the relative affinity is plotted as a function of the carbon length (Figure 7). Both homologous series show clear linearity. Relative affinity as a function of carbon length for n-alkanols and carboxylic acids (lines are linear regression). The slopes in Figure 7 represent the affinity increments per CH2 group. For alkanols, this value is 2.84 kJ/mol per CH2 group. The value is the same as Tahery’s regression (which contains only three miscible alcohols).25 In surfactant studies, the hydrophobic energy increment, from the bulk to aggregate, has been summarized by Israelachvili (in Table 19.2 of ref (21)).21 For homologous straight-chain nonionic surfactants (alkyl polyoxyethylene monoethers), the reported increment was 2.9 kJ/mol per CH2 group. The consistency between the two affinity increments validates the hydrophobic energy of the alkyl groups and the model. The surface activity–alkyl relationship of surfactants has been central in surface science.44 The author attempted to renew Langmuir’s 1925 “principle of independent surface action”45 via a multiple-component empirical model for alkanols.46 While the multiple-component model revealed a linearity similar to that in Figure 7, it was too complicated and incomplete. Equation 10 quantifies the alkyl hydrophobicity exceptionally well with a simple parameter. The data can also be extrapolated to a lower limit of S. As the carbon length increases, S approaches zero, and the interfacial layer is more dominated by amphiphiles. It is well known that longer alkanoic acids, such as stearic acid, form a monolayer on an air/water surface (also known as Langmuir’s monolayer). The layer is often considered insoluble and is widely used in surface studies.21 Partial Dissociation Carboxylic compounds are weak acids with a low degree of dissociation. The increasing alkyl length reduces acidity and increases pKa.47 Thermodynamically, the degrees of acid dissociation differ between those of the bulk and the interfacial layer. For example, it has been shown that the surface-pKa of medium-chain carboxylic acids is substantially higher than the bulk- pKa.48 A full adsorption modeling of all species (protonated/deprotonated acids and protons in both phases) would require a complicated mathematical model.49,50 As the data in Figure 3 were obtained without pH adjustment, eq 10 accounts for partial dissociation degrees in both the bulk and interfacial layers. The linearity of carboxylic data in Figure 7 indicates that the affinity incorporates partial dissociation very well. The increment for carboxylic acids is 3.18 kJ/mol per CH2 group. The dissociation of acids and protons attributes the deviation from the alkanols value. For acids, the values of μs0 and μb0 represent the weighted average potential of the dissociated/associated species, which is also determined via thermodynamic equilibrium. The model can even provide a critical method to calculate the pKa of short-chain acids, which are important for the cloud formation process and atmospheric chemistry.51 Affinity-Hydrophilicity Correlation The affinity of nonionic surfactants in Table 2 is plotted in Figure 8. Affinity-hydrophilicity correlations for Triton-X surfactants. It shows a negative correlation, with an energy of −0.22 kJ/mol per oxyethylene group. It should be noted that three Triton samples are industrial surfactants with mixtures of different numbers of oxyethylene. The reported numbers of oxyethylene in Table 2 are the average values. The impurities of the industrial products might lead to nonlinearity. Further study with precise control of the hydrophilic groups can clarify the increment energy. Ionic Surfactants The model can be easily applied to ionic surfactant solutions by converting the bulk concentration to the bulk molar fraction. Figure 9 shows examples of two cationic surfactants,52 cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (C16TAB) and tetradecyltrimethylammonium bromide (C14TAB), and a Gemini cationic surfactant (C12H25N(CH3)2–(CH2)3–N(CH3)2C12H25 Br2).53 Modeling surface tension of CnTAB (ref (53)) and a Gemini surfactant (ref (54)). Best-fitted parameters, C16TAB: 2.54 × 10–5 and −16.3 mN/m, C14TAB: 8.62 × 10–5 and −28.7 mN/m, Gemini: 9.04 × 10–6 and 10.4 mN/m. Adapted with permission from ref (53). Copyright (2013), American Chemical Society. The affinity increment of CnTAB in Figure 9 is 1.51 kJ/mol per CH2 group, which is smaller than the increment to the micelles (1.8 kJ/mol).21 In this case, the affinity includes the full dissociation of – (CH3)3N+/Br – pair and the hydration shell of Br –, which is far stronger than a proton.54 It should be noted that the two-parameter Szyszkowski equation, eq 1, produced a similar fitting quality with n = 2.50 However, eq 1 assumes that CnTA+/Br– is fully dissociated in the bulk and interfacial layers. The full dissociation is not supported by a recent study with combined NR/X-ray reflectometry on C16TAB, which revealed that Br– is closely condensed at the surface.55 The condensation indicates a strong association of C16TA+ and Br– within the interfacial layer. In this instance, the new model is more appropriate than the conventional approach. The modeling of the Gemini surfactant is particularly effective. The Gemini surfactants form many diffident ionic states within the interfacial layer.56 As discussed by Penfolds and co-workers, the Gibbs equation cannot be applied to Gemini surfactants.11 Since thermodynamic rules also control the equilibria between these ionic states, eq 10 captures them all in a single parameter, as with the partial dissociation of carboxylic acids. The new model provides huge advantages over the conventional model, requiring many parameters for ionic states.57,58 The proposed modeling of ionic surfactant is more reliable than the conventional method59 and overcomes the controversial saturated surface excess.9 The obtained values of Xs can be combined with Gibbs’s surface excess via the thickness of the interfacial layer.23 Conversely, the interfacial molar composition might be more relevant to surface chemistry. For instance, the interfacial composition is easier to collaborate with molecular dynamics6 or density gradient theory60 simulations. The obtained Xs can provide critical information to neutron reflectometry61 for predicting the thickness of the interfacial layer. The molar water composition, 1 – Xs, can complement the vibrational sum-frequency generation62 to understand the molecular orientation. The predicted composition can be combined with surface potential data63 to calculate the capacitance of the surfactant layer. The thermodynamic equation can also explain the break in the surface tension data near the critical micelle concentration (CMC) or CAC, such as in Figures 4 and 9. At a high concentration, the surfactant molecules coexist in three states: the bulk, the interfacial layer, and micelles/aggregates.64 The equilibrium in eq 4 is extended to where μm0, M, and Xm are the standard potential, aggregate number, and concentration of micelles/aggregates, respectively. The thermodynamic equilibrium between Xb and Xm has led to the well-established calculation of the critical micelle concentration21 The same rule can apply to the surface molar fraction Equation 17 indicates a maximum value of Xs, which is determined by the potentials of surface and micelle phases. The limit of Xs explains why a strong surfactant, such as C16TAB, can only reduce the water surface tension to ∼36 mN/m.65 Conversely, butyric acid can reduce the water tension to 22 mN/m, despite being a “weak” surfactant. Interpretation of γa for Surfactants The value of γa for long molecules can be justified by considering the value of Ka. Mathematically, the value of γa corresponds to the composition of Xs = 1. The data in Table 1 show that S decreases, and Ka increases, with increasing alkyl length. The value corresponds to the replacement ratio between the surface and the bulk. The smaller S indicates that more water molecules are being replaced by a surfactant molecule. Consequently, γa decreases with an increasing alkyl-chain length (Table 1). For ionic surfactants, replacement is massively increased and, thus, γa becomes negative. For polyoxyethylene surfactants (Table 2), the relative water/surfactant ratio is large (oxyethylene can form H-bonds with water). As a result, the value of γa for nonionic surfactant is closer to the surface tension at CAC. Affinity of Solvents Two important observations can be made regarding the relative affinity (eq 12). First, the extension of alkanols regression (Figure 7) indicates that the water affinity is small but nonzero.c The small affinity (less than the affinity of all amphiphiles) is consistent with the notion of strong water–water bonds,21 which generates higher boiling point and surface tension than other liquids. The nonzero value of affinity indicates that water also has a tendency to be exposed to air, as evidenced by the free –OH group.66 Second, the water-based affinity can be transferred to another solvent via the complementary rule in eq 14. Indeed, the rule can predict the surface composition of two molecules with similar surface tension, such as methanol/propanol mixtures or a Triton surfactant in oil. As a result, the obtained relative affinity is as useful as the absolute affinity, Aa. Conclusions A new model applies to the surface tension data of all amphiphiles over many orders of concentration. The modeling framework is quantitatively validated for changing temperature, alkyl hydrophobicity, oxyethylene hydrophilicity, and nonaqueous solvents. The affinity of carboxylic acids can capture the dissociation effect and lay a foundation to model the surface affinity of ionic surfactants. The modeling approach is applicable to the oil/water interfacial tension as well. Acknowledgments The author would like to thank Professor Ahmed Barifcani for his support and encouragement. Author Contributions C.M.P.: conceptualization, methodology, visualization. The author declares no competing financial interest. Footnotes Replacing S by 1/S, eq 9 returns to Eberhart’s original form (eq 5 in ref (24)). Conventional surfactant studies often used a “free energy of adsorption”, which has the same unit. However, it has different physical meanings and mathematic definitions, for instance, eq (2.32) in ref (8). This model allows solvent to have a nonzero affinity. The Gibbs equation assumes chemical potential is the same between the bulk and surface. References