Effects of therapeutic exercise on the motor function of adults with Down syndrome: a systematic review and meta-analysis Authors: Melanie Méndez-Martínez, Eliana-Isabel Rodríguez-Grande Published: 2023 ABSTRACT Therapeutic exercise exerts positive effects by mitigating or reducing the motor or cognitive changes that people with Down syndrome undergo throughout their life. There are no updated systematic reviews that integrate the evidence available in a way that facilitates decision-making for physical rehabilitation teams. This study therefore aimed to consolidate the information available and compare the effects of different types of physical exercise on the motor function of adults with DS. We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials and quasi-experimental studies. The literature search was performed between January 2023 and February 2023 using the PubMed, SCIELO, Epistemonikos, and Lilacs databases. Studies were selected according to pre-determined inclusion and exclusion criteria. The risk-of-bias assessment was performed using the risk-of-bias rating tool for randomized clinical trial (RoB) and the risk of bias of non-randomized comparative studies was assessed using the risk of bias in non-randomized studies of interventions (ROBINS-I) tool. Risk-of-bias assessment and meta-analyses were performed using the RevMan software package. Sixteen studies met the eligibility criteria for the qualitative synthesis and 4 were included in the meta-analyses. Combined exercise significantly increased muscle strength both in the upper limbs (SMD = 0.74 [95% CI 0.25–1.22]) and lower limbs (SMD = 0.56[95% CI 0.08–1.04]). Aerobic exercise improved spatiotemporal gait parameters. Aerobic exercise showed significant improvements in dynamic balance while combined exercise significantly increased dynamic and static balance. The certainty of the evidence was low to moderate for all outcomes. There was low and moderate certainty of evidence for the outcomes proposed in this review. However, therapeutic exercise could be effective in improving muscle strength and gait functionality. Introduction Down syndrome (DS) is a medical condition caused by a genetic abnormality where chromosome 21 is either partially or completely duplicated1. It is the most common and prevalent genetic neurological disorder associated with intellectual disability and motor disorders characterized by hypotonia, ligamentous laxity, and limited muscle strength2, in addition to other cardiorespiratory, gastrointestinal, and immunological comorbidities3. The motor changes in balance, strength, resistance, and mobility2 caused by DS have a direct effect on motor function, defined as the ability or capacity to learn, maintain, coordinate, and assume voluntary control of postures and movement patterns4. Therefore, DS affects quality of life and the ability to perform activities of daily living (ADL), thus increasing the dependency on other individuals and the adoption of a sedentary lifestyle in many cases5. This is the reason why DS individuals require therapeutic interventions, especially rehabilitation, to improve their motor skills. Therapeutic exercise is included within these interventions, which the World Health Organization defines as “a variation of physical activity, aimed at reaching a pre-established goal, which is generally the improvement or maintenance of physical fitness or of the health condition”6. Exercise is characterized as being planned and repetitive which means that it is performed regularly6 and is divided into different types: aerobic exercise, where large muscle groups are exercised improving cardiovascular capacity; strength exercises; flexibility or stretching exercises; and neuromuscular exercises, including proprioception7–10, balance, and agility exercises11. Scientific evidence of the effects of exercise in DS individuals is extensive in this regard. Multiple interventions have been identified in the literature that evaluate the effectiveness of exercise in water1,2, progressive resistance exercise12,13, continuous aerobic exercise5,14–16, specific modalities such as Nordic walking17, and combined exercise which is simultaneous aerobic and resistance training18–20 on different motor function outcomes, such as aerobic and functional capacity2,5, dynamic balance, muscular strength, endurance1,12,14,18–20, and gait17. However, the many types of therapeutic exercises available in the literature as well as the many motor function outcomes in which the effectiveness of these types of exercise is measured impede rehabilitation teams’ decision-making when attempting to identify the type of exercise that, according to its prescription, is the most effective in improving these motor function outcomes. Despite having a substantial amount of evidence on the effect of exercise in adult DS individuals, there is no accumulation of this evidence that accounts for the effect of different types of therapeutic exercise, mode of application, and in general, the prescription parameters of effective interventions. The integration of available evidence will facilitate decision-making for physical rehabilitation teams. This study therefore aimed to consolidate the information available and compare the effects of different types of physical exercise on the motor function of adult DS individuals. Methods This review was conducted in accordance with Cochrane Handbook of Systematic Reviews of Interventions21 and the recommendations of the methodology proposed in the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines22. This analysis was prospectively registered on Open Science Framework (OSF) and it is available in https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/MRKN2. Ethical and internal review board approval was not required because no human or animal subjects were involved. Study selection criteria Participants DS individuals aged 18 years or older. Studies that included the population in this review as well as populations with other characteristics, and studies whose results for DS individuals were not presented separately, were excluded. Interventions Application of any type of therapeutic exercise—either strength or resistance, aerobic, or neuromuscular exercise—with specific prescription parameters such as intensity, duration, and frequency. Comparison Control group with no exercise intervention, or another type of exercise intervention with another prescription parameters. Outcome measures Studies that did not include at least one of the outcomes proposed for this review were excluded. The outcomes prioritized in this review were as follows:Primary: Strength, defined as the ability of a muscle group to develop contraction against resistance23; balance or equilibrium, understood as the ability to maintain the body’s stability on each side of the axis24; and gait variables, defined as bipedal walking used to move from one place to another with minimal effort and energy consumption25.Secondary: Coordination, defined as the ability to execute and control movements24; posture, defined as the alignment of body segments during movement or a sustained situation25; and functional tasks, such as climbing stairs. Primary: Strength, defined as the ability of a muscle group to develop contraction against resistance23; balance or equilibrium, understood as the ability to maintain the body’s stability on each side of the axis24; and gait variables, defined as bipedal walking used to move from one place to another with minimal effort and energy consumption25. Primary: Strength, defined as the ability of a muscle group to develop contraction against resistance23; balance or equilibrium, understood as the ability to maintain the body’s stability on each side of the axis24; and gait variables, defined as bipedal walking used to move from one place to another with minimal effort and energy consumption25. Secondary: Coordination, defined as the ability to execute and control movements24; posture, defined as the alignment of body segments during movement or a sustained situation25; and functional tasks, such as climbing stairs. Secondary: Coordination, defined as the ability to execute and control movements24; posture, defined as the alignment of body segments during movement or a sustained situation25; and functional tasks, such as climbing stairs. Designs Experimental studies such as randomized or quasi-experimental clinical trials were included. Search methods for identification of studies The literature search was carried out in the PubMed, Epistemonikos, SCIELO and Lilacs databases. The following algorithms were used to search for articles in English:DATABASEALGORITHMPubMed((((((((((((((Down syndrome) OR Trisomy 21)) AND Adult)) AND (((((((Exercise) OR Physiotherapy) OR Physical) OR Training) OR Neuromuscular exercise))) AND (((((((((Motor function) OR Functionality) OR Balance) OR Posture) OR Coordination) OR Gait) OR Strength)) NOT Physiology))Epistemonikos(((((((((basic physical abilities) OR (Speed)) OR (Resistance)) OR (Strength)) OR (Skill)) OR (Flexibility)) OR (Coordination)) OR (Balance)) OR (Agility)) AND ((((((((((therapeutic exercise) OR (physiotherapy)) OR (physical therapy)) OR (exercise)) OR (Endurance Training)) OR (Motion Therapy)) OR (Muscle Stretching Exercises)) OR (Plyometric Exercise)) OR (Resistance Training)) AND (((((Syndrome, Down) OR (Mongolism)) OR (Trisomy G)) OR (Down's Syndrome)) OR (Trisomy 21))) DATABASEALGORITHMPubMed((((((((((((((Down syndrome) OR Trisomy 21)) AND Adult)) AND (((((((Exercise) OR Physiotherapy) OR Physical) OR Training) OR Neuromuscular exercise))) AND (((((((((Motor function) OR Functionality) OR Balance) OR Posture) OR Coordination) OR Gait) OR Strength)) NOT Physiology))Epistemonikos(((((((((basic physical abilities) OR (Speed)) OR (Resistance)) OR (Strength)) OR (Skill)) OR (Flexibility)) OR (Coordination)) OR (Balance)) OR (Agility)) AND ((((((((((therapeutic exercise) OR (physiotherapy)) OR (physical therapy)) OR (exercise)) OR (Endurance Training)) OR (Motion Therapy)) OR (Muscle Stretching Exercises)) OR (Plyometric Exercise)) OR (Resistance Training)) AND (((((Syndrome, Down) OR (Mongolism)) OR (Trisomy G)) OR (Down's Syndrome)) OR (Trisomy 21))) The search was conducted between January 2023 to February 2023 and no filters by language or publication date were applied. Other sources Additionally, other sources of evidence were consulted to allow for the identification and analysis of published or unpublished literature (gray literature) that had not been detected through the systematic search. These other sources included manual searches in the reference list of the systematic reviews found through the search in the databases. Another search was performed through the L·OVE platform (Living Overview of Evidence) in the Down Syndrome section26 which let us review and compare the studies in the Epistemonikos database where an evidence matrix was built to, automatically, list the systematic reviews that share at least one study included as well as all the studies included in each of these reviews27. Study selection This was performed by two reviewers independently applying the selection criteria (MMM, YVC). Duplicate studies were initially merged into a bibliographic reference manager, followed by screening through the review of titles and abstracts to identify studies that included the population of interest for the present review, therapeutic exercise intervention, and at least one of the motor function outcomes. Subsequently, the full texts of the selected studies were retrieved, and after a comprehensive reading, studies were excluded based on their design, the population included, or because they did not include at least one of the motor function outcomes. A third reviewer (ERG) intervened to define whether or not studies for which there was no agreement should be included in this review. Data extraction and management This was conducted by two reviewers independently (MMM, YVC) in an Excel file. The following items were extracted: year of publication and authors; title; characteristics of participants such as age, sex, and number of participants per group; characteristics of the interventions applied, such as the type and mode of exercise, with their prescription of intensity, duration, and frequency; outcomes evaluated with their respective measuring instruments; and the results obtained by variable and group. Risk-of-bias assessment This was performed using the risk-of-bias (RoB) tool for randomized clinical trials21 based on seven domains, namely, sequence generation, allocation concealment, blinding of participants and personnel, blinding of outcome assessors, incomplete outcome data, selective outcome reporting, and “other aspects.” Each of these domains was assigned a rating of “low risk,” “high risk,” or “unclear risk.” The risk of bias of non-randomized comparative studies was assessed using the risk of bias in non-randomized studies of interventions (ROBINS-I) tool5. The response options for each domain-level judgement are: (1) Low risk of bias; (2) Moderate risk of bias; (3) Serious risk of bias; (4) Critical risk of bias; and (5) No information on which to base a judgement about risk of bias for this domain. Finally, the option response for an overall risk of bias judgement using ROBINS-I are: (1) Low risk of bias (the study is comparable to a well-performed randomized trial); (2) Moderate risk of bias (the study provides sound evidence for a non-randomized study but cannot be considered comparable to a well-performed randomized trial); (3) Serious risk of bias (the study has some important problems); (4) Critical risk of bias (the study is too problematic to provide any useful evidence and should not be included in any synthesis); and (5) No information on which to base a judgement about risk of bias5. Risk of bias assessment figures were developed in RevMan 5.428. Synthesis of data The selected body of evidence was assessed according to the prioritized outcomes. Each outcome described the population’s features; parameters of the interventions, including the exercise mode applied, frequency, intensity, and duration of the interventions applied in the said studies; and the quantitative results achieved with their level of significance. The data were synthesized on a Microsoft Excel base, extracting data from the population’s features, randomization methods, outcome measures, duration of follow-up, and assessment methods from each study. The meta-analysis considered direct comparisons between the experimental group that performed the interventions (aerobic exercise and resistance exercise) and a control group that performed educational activities, recreational activities, or continuity with ADL or exercise interventions with different parameters or the comparison between different types of exercise. Averages and standard deviations of the data available from the selected studies were extracted from the prioritized outcomes included in the studies. When the studies reported standard errors of the mean, the standard deviations were obtained by multiplying standard errors of the mean by the square root of the sample size. Standardized mean differences (SMD) and 95% confidence intervals (95% CI) were calculated to combine the results of the studies using different measures for the same concept or of studies presenting variability in its features. Heterogeneity between trials was assessed using the chi-squared test, with a p value of < 0.05 considered statistically significant after due consideration of the value of I2 Heterogeneity was reported as low (I2 = 0%–50%) or high (I2 > 50%)29,30. The results were combined using the random effects model and the 95% CI was calculated. All data analysis were performed using the RevMan 5 software28. Assessment of the certainty of evidence This was performed using the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations (GRADE) system21 for each outcome. This system specifies four levels of quality evidence: “High,” “Moderate,” “Low,” and “Very Low.” The level is determined by considering the risk of bias in the study, inconsistency, direction of evidence, precision of an effect estimate, and other considerations that include publication bias, whether or not the effect is large, the existence of confounding factors, and the dose–response gradient. These variables, except for “other considerations,” were evaluated on a three-level scale: “not serious,” “serious,” and “very serious.” For “other considerations,” the publication bias scale was classified as “not detected” or “strong suspicion”; large effect was graded as “no,” “large,” or “very large”; confounders were graded as “no,” “will reduce the demonstrated effect,” or “suggests a spurious effect”; and the dose–response gradient was classified as “yes” or “no.”. Results Search and selection of studies The electronic search yielded 898 studies, and 190 studies were obtained from other sources to yield a total of 1088. Of these, 188 studies were excluded owing to duplication and 798 were excluded after the review by titles and abstracts. In total, 102 studies were assessed in full text, of which 86 were excluded because they did not meet the eligibility criteria, mainly the study design, and because they did not include at least one of the outcomes prioritized in this review. Thus, only 16 studies met the eligibility criteria for the qualitative synthesis and 4 were included in the meta-analyses. This information is presented in a flowchart following the PRISMA model (Fig. 1).Figure 1Flow diagram of the different phases of the investigation. Flow diagram of the different phases of the investigation. General characteristics of the studies Table 1 shows that the studies selected for this review included a total of 402 participants aged 18–65 years. Of the 16 studies, 15 included the population aged 21–50 years1,2,5,12,13,17,19,20,31–37, with only 414,32,34,36 including the population aged 60 years and older, and included the population aged 18–2012,13,33,35–37 years. The study with the smallest sample was the one by Post et al.35, with 11 participants, while that with the largest sample was the study by Rimmer et al.20, with 52 participants.Table 1General characteristic of the studies.StudyStudy designParticipantsInterventionDosageOutcome measurement instrumentResultsDavis and Sinning (1987)33United States of AmericaQuasi- experimentalIG1: 6 men with DS. Age: 20–38.2 years. IQ ranging 32–41IG2: 6 men with mental disabilities without DS. Age 18.5–36.2 years. IQ ranging 33–57CG: 6 undergraduate and postgraduate students. Age: 19–24.3 years. Above average IQIG1 AND IG2: Strength training under the supervision of graduates and graduates in physical education who were instructed in the procedures. Individual records of weight, series and repetitions were setCG: They exercised individually and recorded their own progressMode: bench press, triceps curls, and biceps curls with free weightIntensity: 6–8 repetitions. The amount of weight for each particular set was progressively increased as the subjects were able to exceed 8 repetitionsDuration: 8 weeksFrequency: 3 times a weekElbow flexor strength:Maximum voluntary contraction: supine, right arm in 90° elbow flexion, exert 2 maximum efforts against immovable resistance. In the same position, exert a force for 5 s against a series of loads ranging from 5 lb to approximately 90% of the maximum effort measuredElectromyography:Electrodes are placed on the flexor muscle group at the elbow (biceps brachii). Integrated EMG and torque measurements of the elbow flexor muscle group were recorded simultaneously during maximal effort and step loading proceduresOnly half of the subjects increased their maximum voluntary contraction as a result of the training, but there were no significant differences between groups P > 0.05As expected, the post measurements of the group without disabilities experienced more improvement than the other two groups with disabilities, being statistically significant. p < 0.001Carmeli et al. 200210IsraelExperimental26 older adults aged 57–65 yearsMild mental retardationIQ ranging 56–75 according to the Stanford Binet scaleIG: 16 participants (10 women, 6 men)CG: 10 participants (6 women, 4 men)IG: Aerobic exercise with treadmill walkingParticipants walked only between 9:30 and 11:30 am indoors under controlled conditions (23 °C, 40% humidity)CG: They were instructed not to change their daily activity levelMode: Endless treadmill walkIntensity: Low resistance with 0% inclineIntensity: Speed below the threshold for breathlessness but as fast as they could comfortably tolerateFrequency: 3 times/weekDuration: 25 consecutive weeks. They initially walked for 10–15 min. The duration was gradually increased up to 45 min according to toleranceDynamic balance and gait speed:- Timed up and goMuscle strength:- Flexion (hamstrings) and extension (Quadriceps) of the knee in the isokinetic system (Biodex dynamometer) at speeds of 60°/s and 120°/sData were collected for peak torque (ft/lb) (highest individual value of three peak efforts), peak torque percentage of body weight (ft/lb/kg), and average power (watts)Timed up and go: IG: 25.9 ± 3 s. CG: 29.1 ± 3 s. Significant improvements between groups p < 0.05Muscle strength: Significant differences are found in all three tests (maximum torque, % maximum torque of body weight and average power) of hamstrings and quadriceps in both men and women p < 0.01Rimmer et al. (2004)16United States of AmericaExperimental52 adults with DS. Mean age 39.4 ± 6.4IG: 30 participantsCG: 22 participants. without interventionIG: Cardio and strength exercisesExercise classes were supervised by a full-time registered clinical exercise physiologist and two assistantsCARDIOVASCULAR TRAININGMode: Recumbent stepper, stationary cycle (recumbent and upright), treadmill and ellipticalDuration: 15–20 min the first 2 weeks, 20–30 min the third and fourth weeks, 30 min from the fifth week onward for 12 weeksIntensity: 50%–70% of VO2 max. Monitored with cardiac monitorsSTRENGTH TRAININGMode: seated bench and leg press, seated leg curl, triceps curl, seated shoulder press, seated row, push-upDuration: 15–20 minIntensity: initially 70% of 1-RM for a set of 10–20 reps. When participants were able to complete 20 reps for 2 consecutive sessions with proper lifting technique, the weight was increased by 10% of their 1-RMStrength: 1-RM protocol according to the ACSMLeg pressChest pressGrip Strength:Manual dynamometryLeg Press: IG: 320 lb (87) 145.1 kg (39.4). CG: 208 lb (97) 94.3 kg (43.9). Significant differences p < 0.0001Chest Press: IG: 100.7 lb (44.9) 45.6 kg (20.3). CG: 59.9 lb (33.6) 27.1 kg (15.2). Significant differences p < 0.0001Dynamometry:IG: Right hand 22.0 (8.1); Left hand 21.6 (8.7)CG: Right hand 19.0 (7.7); Left hand 17.8 (7.0)Nonsignificant differences neither on the left nor on the right side p > 0.05Tsimaras and Fotiadou (2004)30GreeceQuasi-experimental25 adults with DS all from the Center of Professional Learning of ThessalonikiIG: 15 participants. IQ range, 45–60. Age, 24.5 ± 3.9 yearsCG: 10 participants. (IQ range, 45– 59. Age 24.7 ± 2.7 yearsIG: a 12-week Cardio and strength trainingMode: walking, slow running, and free gymnastic activities that mobilize large muscle groups (10 min)15–20 min of training program activities:1. Two-foot ankle hop. 2. Single-foot side-to side ankle hop. 3. Tuck jump with knees up. 4. Tuck jump with heel kick. 5. Standing long jump. 6. Standing jump over barrier. 7. Single leg hops. 8. Double leg hops. 9. Standing on 1 foot. 10. Rocking boats. 11. Walking on line. 12. Walking across 30-cm-wide balance beam. 13. Walking across 20-cm-wide balance beam. 14. Walking across 10-cm-wide balance beamFinally, 5-min recovery periodFrequency: 3 times per week,Duration: 30–35 min/sesionPeak torque of knee extension and flexion: Cybex II isokinetic dynamometerIsokinetic muscle endurance of quadriceps muscles: after 25 repeated maximum efforts at an angular velocity of 180° , and it was defined by the percentage of decline from the peak torqueDynamic balance ability: balance deck. Number of seconds the subject could remain standing on the platform of the stabilometer in durations of 30-, 45-, and 60-s intervalsIsokinetic peak torque of anterior (300, 180, 120° p < 0.001, 60°p < 0.01) and posterior (300, 180, 120° p < 0.01, 60° p < 0.01) femoral muscles significantly improved for the experiment groupThe isokinetic endurance: it showed a significant improvement (p < 0.01) after participation in the training programDynamic balance ability: was significantly improved for the experiment group (30 s p < 0.01, 45 s and 60 s p < 0.001,No significant differences were found in any of the measurements for the control groupFor the initial and final measurements, no statistically significant differences were found between the 2 groupsAguiar et al. (2008)27BrazilQuasi-experimentalIG: 21 men Age: 23.3 ± 2.1Monitored aerobic exercise of adapted judo training for 16 weeksMode: Adapted JudoIntensity: Lactate thresholdFrequency: 3 times/weekDuration: 50 min/sessionGross motor skills:GMFM-88The judo training program significantly (P < 0.05) improved the GMFM-88 index of young adults with DSShields et al. (2008)8AustraliaExperimental20 adults. Age: 26.8 ± 7.8 years13 men, 7 womenIG: 9 participantsCG: 11 participants8 of the 20 participants worked at least 1 day/week in manual-type jobs (packing confectionery boxes, sorting and cutting clothes, and assembling car parts)IG: Group progressive resistance training in a supervised community gym. The trainer kept a record for each participant of the number of repetitions and sets and the weight lifted/exercised in each session. Participants completed the program in a group, supervised by 2 accredited fitness trainers. Each trainer supervised the training of a subgroup of 2–3 participantsCG: Continued with usual activities (work, free time, and leisure)Mode: Progressive resistance training with machines:- Shoulder press- Seated chest press- Seated rowing- Seated leg press- Knee extension- Seated calf raiseIntensity: Increased when 2 sets of 12 reps per exercise could be completedVolume: 2–3 sets of 10–12 reps per exercise to failureFrequency: 2 times a weekDuration: 10 weeksDensity: 2-min rest between setsMuscle performance:- 1 RM: Chest press and leg press- Muscular resistance: repetitions of chest and leg press with 50% of 1RMPhysical function:- Timed up and down stairs test- Grocery shelving task: Get up from a chair and take 2 bags of groceries to a bench located 2 m away. Each bag contains 10 items (410 g each, total weight of each bag 4.1 kg). Then they have to take the items out of the bag and stack them on a shelf at shoulder height1 RM Chest Press: IG: 44.9 ± 15.2 kg. CG: 31.6 ± 13.3 kg1 RM Leg Press: IG: 96.2 ± 31.6 kg. CG: 82.2 ± 19.7 kgRep Chest Press: IG: 25.9 ± 8.3. CG 17.5 ± 9.5Rep Leg Press: IG: 46.8 ± 37.1. CG: 49.4 ± 27.6Timed up and down stairs: IG: 14.4 ± 3.4 s. CG: 18.7 ± 6.5 sGrocery shelving task: IG: 67.5 ± 33.4 s. CG: pre 122.8 ± 84.0 s; post 110.7 ± 66.4 sSignificant differences between groups in 1-RM chest press (P 0.08), chest press repetitions (P 0.002), and leg press repetitions (P 0.039)No significant differences between groups in the leg press 1RM test (P 0.90), timed up and go (P 0.12) or grocery shelving task test (P 0.11)Cowley et al. 20119United States of AmericaQuasi- experimental30 adults with mild intellectual disabilities. Age: 28 ± 8 yearsIG: 9 men and 10 womenCG: 11 participants. 8 men and 3 womenIG: progressive resistance trainingEach participant worked one on one with a professional who supervised all the training sessionsCG: Maintained normal daily activitiesMode: Leg extension, leg curl, leg press, shoulder press, chest press, bicep curl, and tricep curl exercises performed on exercise machinesIntensity: 3 sets of 8–10 reps per exercise. The weight lifted by the subject was recorded during the training period and progressively increased to constantly overload the muscleFrequency: 2 days per weekDuration: 10 weeksIsometric and isokinetic strength of knee extensors and flexors: Biodex System 3 dynamometer- Maximum isometric peak torque: 3 series of 3 maximum contractions with knee extensors and flexors at a joint angle of 45°, 60°, and 75° with 3 min interval between series- Maximum isokinetic peak torque: 3 series of 5 maximum contractions with knee extensors and flexors at 60°/s with 3 min interval between seriesFunctional tasks of daily life:- Time to get up from a chair at different heights (30, 38, or 43 cm) as quickly as possible to an upright position with trunk and legs straight, keeping arms crossed over the chest- Gait speed: Walk 7.62 m- Go up and down 10 steps as fast as possible without using the support handrail and alternating feet and then go downIsometric flexor strength:Significant differences between groups P < 0.05 in the three degrees of movement (45°, 60°, and 75°)Isometric strength extensors:Significant differences in the IG in the three degrees of movement P < 0.05Flexors and extensors isokinetic strength Significant differences in the IG P < 0.05Getting up from a chair at different heights: No significant differences P > 0.05 in any of the chair heights (30 cm, 38 cm, 43 cm) or in the 5 repetitions10-step ascent and descent: Significant differences in the IG P < 0.05 in both tests. IG Ascent: .83 SD 1.19. CG: 5.10 SD 1.19. GI descent: 4.38 SD 1.19. CG: 6.23 SD 2.80Gait speed: IG: 1.72 SD 0.20. CG: 1.71 SD 0.24. No significant differences P > 0.05Mendonca et al. (2011)15PortugalQuasi- experimentalIG1: 13 participants (10 men, 3 women) with DS. Age: 36.5 ± 5.5 yearsIG2: 12 participants (9 men, 3 women) without disabilities. Age: 38.7 ± 8.3 yearsCombined resistance and strength exercise trainingThe exercise sessions were supervised by an exercise physiologist and an assistantENDURANCE TRAININGMode: Walk or run on a treadmillIntensity: target heart rate compatible with 65% (first three weeks) at 85% of VO2peak. Monitored with fc/participant clockDuration: 30 min. 12 weeksFrequency: 3 days/weekSTRENGTH TRAININGMode: repeating a set of 9 exercises twice with < 30 s of rest between them. Train with leg press, chest and shoulder press, vertical pull, lower back, leg extension, bicep curl, and tricep curl. In addition, 1 set of 15 repetitions of abdominal push-ups in each rotationIntensity: 10% increase in 12-RM load when participants were able to complete 14 reps for 2 consecutive sessions with proper techniqueFrequency: 2 days/weekMuscle strength: 12-RM protocol on variable resistance machines- Leg press- Chest press- Vertical traction- Lower back- Leg extensionEach participant was asked to perform 15 reps with relatively light resistance followed by 30 s of recovery. Resistance was then increased, and each participant performed a maximum of 5 sets of 12 repetitions until the 12-RM was reached. The recovery period between sets was exactly 2 min, and increments of 2.5–5 kg were used as each participant approached fatigue. The 12-RM was defined as the maximum load lifted through a full range of motion for a total of 12 repetitions. For most participants, the 12-RM was determined in 3–4 attemptsLeg Press: IG1: 110.2 ± 52.6. IG2: 171.3 ± 56.5Chest Press: IG1: 35.3 ± 12.2. IG2: 51.3 ± 21.0Vertical Traction: IG1: 39.2 ± 14.1. IG2: 59.4 ± 15.3Lower Back: IG1: 35.6 ± 7.4. IG2: 51.9 ± 19.3Leg Extension: IG1: 30.1 ± 10.3. IG2: 52.7 ± 17.6Participants with Down syndrome showed lower muscle strength than participants without disabilities in all dynamic exercises, both before and after trainingTraining was highly efficient in obtaining generalized improvements for 12-RM in both groups (P < 0.05). The magnitude of these improvements was similar between participants with and without Down syndromeBoer and Moss, (2016)5South AfricaExperimental42 adults. Age 33.8 ± 8.6(25 men, 17 women)IG1: 13 participantsIG2: 13 participantsCG: 16 participantsIG1: Continuous aerobic training (CAT) on a bicycle or treadmillIG2: Interval training (IT) with 10–30-s sprints on a bike or treadmillThe two IGs performed the intervention under the supervision of a licensed sport scientist and exercise physiologist in a 2:6 (professional:participants) ratioCG: No interventionDuration: 12 weeks. 30-min sessions the first six weeks (5-min warm-up, 20-min central act, 5-min cool down), the last six weeks’ sessions were increased by 5 min for the central activityIntensity: Warm up and cool down at 4 km/hFrequency: 3 times/weekIG1: CAT- Mode: Continuous aerobic training by bicycle (50%) or treadmill (50%)- Central act intensity: first six weeks 70%–80% VO2peak, last 6 weeks 85% VO2peakIG2: IT- Mode: Interval aerobic training on a bicycle (50%) or treadmill (50%)- Intensity: 10–30-s max sprints with 90-s low cadence, low intensity gait, or bikeGrip strength:- Manual dynamometry in the dominant handLower Body Strength:- Sit-to-stand testAgility and dynamic balance:- 8-ft up and goAerobic capacity and functional ability:- 6MWDGrip strength:CAT: 26.1 kg (7.9). IT: 29.9 kg (8.9). CG: 25.5 kg (9.1). No significant differences between groups P = 0.57Lower Body Strength:CAT: 15.2 (1.8). IT: 15.5 (1.8). CG: 13.3 (2.3). Significant improvements between groups P = 0.01 and only in the CAT group compared to the control group (P < 0.05)Agility and balance:CAT: 4.8 s (0.9). IT: 4.9 s (1.1). CG: 6.2 s (1.3). Significant improvements between groups P = 0.03 and only in the CAT group compared to the control group (P < 0.05)Aerobic capacity and functional ability:CAT: 563.2 m (74.9). IT: 562.6 m (81.7). CG: 495.9 m (85.2). Significant improvements between groups P = 0.01 and only in the CAT group compared to the control group (P < 0.05)Silva et al. (2017)32PortugalExperimental27 adults aged 18–60 yearsIG: 14 participantsCG: 13 participantsIG: Wii-based exercise program that included training games for aerobic endurance, balance, and isometric strengthCG: They completed their usual daily activities (usual treatment) at their occupational center, such as rehabilitation, life skills training, and art-related activitiesMode: Aerobic exercise through a Wii-based exercise program. Individual sessions or with another participant (half of the sessions in each format)Frequency: 3 sessions per weekDuration: 2 monthsPhysical aptitude: Eurofit test battery:- Limb movement speed (Plate Tapping Test)- Static arm strength (Handgrip Test)- Running speed and agility (Shuttle Run)- Balance (Flamingo Balance)- Flexibility (Sit and Reach)- Explosive power of the legs (Standing Broad)- Trunk Strength (30-s Sit-ups)- Muscular resistance (Bent Arm Hang)Functional mobility:- Timed Up and Go- Response speed subtest of the Bruininks–Oseretsky Motor Competence Test First EditionMotor skills:- Beanbag OverheadSignificant improvements in the GI in the Handgrip test (IG: 25.42 (5.53). CG: 23.92 (6.45) P 0,025), in the sit and reach (IG: 36.92 (7.22). CG: 29.46 (10.53) P 0,014), in the standing broad (IG: 99.33 (29.49). CG: 90.69 (35.20) P < 0,001) and in the Bruininks–Oseretsky First Edition test (IG: 4.67 (2.81). CG: 4.77 (2.17) P 0.028)Significant differences between groups were identified in the plate tapping test (P 0.045), shuttle run (P 0.014), sit and reach (P 0.027), standing broad (P 0.003), 30-s sit-ups (P 0.040) and timed up and go (P 0.049)No significant differences in the handgrip test (P 0.837), flamingo balance (P 0.477), bent arm hang (P 0.086), Bruininks–Oseretsky First Edition (P 0.265), neither in the beanbag overhead nor in the hand right P 0.150 nor in the left P 0.083Boer and de Beer (2019)2South AfricaQuasi- experimental23 adults. Age 31.4 ± 7.4 yearsIG: 13 participants (8 men, 5 women)CG: 10 participants (5 men, 5 women)IG: Aerobic exercise in aquatic environment. Aquatic training. Sessions controlled and monitored by test instructors and senior Human Movement Sciences students (approximately one test instructor per two participants)CG: No intervention additional to ADLsMode: Aquatic training with arm circle exercises, lateral twists, walk in place, run in place, water scoops, lateral leg raises, back flutter kick, stomach flutter kick, jumping jacks, knee twists, side shift, squat jumps, lunge jumps, and longer jog, 1.4-m-deep poolDuration: 6 weeks, 35 min the first 3 weeks, 45 min the last 3 weeks. Consider a 3-min warm up and 2-min cool downFrequency: 3 times/weekStatic Balance:- Balance on one legDynamic Balance:- Walk on a balance beamFunctional fitness:- 6MWD- 8-ft up and goMuscular strength:- Sit-to-stand test-Curl‐up modified-Isometric push-upStatic Balance:No significant differences P > 0.05 in the static balance IG: 6.6 (3.5). CG: 5.1 (3.6), nor dynamic IG: 5.6 (0.8). CG: 4.6 (2.1)Functional fitness:Significant differences between groups P < 0.05 for the 6MWD test: IG: 602.1(98.7). CG: 519. 9 (111.9). No significant differences P > 0.05 in the 8-ft up and go test: IG: .3 (0.9). CG: .5 (0.9)Muscle strength:Significant differences between groups P < 0.05 for sit-to-stand test GI: 14.5 (2.2). CG: 13.0 (1.8) and modified curl up GI: 37.9 (30.1). CG: 20.0 (28.3). Nonsignificant differences P > 0.05 for isometric push-up IG: 82.2 (50.9). CG: 36.5 (32.5)Skiba et al. (2019)13PoloniaExperimental22 adults aged 25– 40 years, with moderate intellectual disability (IQ: 36–51). 11 men, 11 womenIG: 11 participants. CG: 11 participantsIG: Aerobic exercise with Nordic walking training program. The exercises were performed by a physiotherapist, who was a qualified Nordic walking instructorCG: Did not undergo any trainingMode: Brisk Nordic walkingIntensity: Progressed over the course of the training sessionsFrequency: 3 times a weekDuration: 45 minSpatiotemporal parameters (step and stride length and speed) and maximum values of angles in the ankle, knee, hip, and shoulder joints in different phases of gait:Using the Vicon 250 Optoelectronic System for Three-Dimensional Motion AnalysisGait parameters: Significant differences in the right (P 0.002) and left (P 0.038) step length as well as for the right (P 0.002) and left (P 0.001) stride length. Regarding speed, only significant changes in right leg (P 0.011)Angular values: Significant changes for the right ankle (P 0.044) in support phase. Significant changes in the left knee, with increased flexion in the phase of medium support (P 0.002), terminal support (P 0.017) and initial sway (P 0.004). The hip does not present significant changes in the right or left leg during the initial contact (P 0.649–0.755), pre-swing (P 0.054–0.165) or terminal sway (P 0.738–0.896)Significant differences in the movement of the pelvis in the sagittal plane in the medium support phase for the right limb (P 0.038) and in the initial sway phase for the left limb (P 0.043). In the frontal plane, there were significant differences in the movement of the pelvis at the maximum point of movement of the left limb (P 0.027) and at the minimum point of movement of the right (P 0.002). In the transverse plane there are no significant differences in the right or left legBoer (2020)1South AfricaExperimental26 adults. Age 32.7 ± 6 years (13 men, 13 women)IG: 13 participantsCG: 13 participantsIG: Aerobic exercise in aquatic environment. Freestyle swimming training, accompanied by lively music and strictly controlled by the main test instructor using a whistleCG: No structured interventionMode: Freestyle swimming in a 12-m long and 1.4-m deep pool. Swim a certain length of the pool and rest while a partner completes another length in the same lane. As soon as the partner reaches the middle of the lane, the other participant is instructed to swimFrequency: 3 times/weekDuration: 20 min the first 4 weeks, 26 min the last 4 weeksStatic Balance:- Balance on one legDynamic Balance:- Walk on a balance beamFunctional fitness:- 6MWD- 8-ft up and goMuscular strength:- Sit-to-stand test-Curl‐up modified-Isometric push‐upStatic Balance:No significant differences (P > 0.05) in IG static balance: 5.9 (3.3). CG: 5.5 (4.1). Significant differences (P < 0.05) between groups in IG dynamic balance: 5.3 (1.2). CG: 3.5 (2.6)Functional fitness:No significant differences (P > 0.05) for the 6MWD IG test: 553.8 (106.9). CG: 503.1 (118.7). Significant differences between groups (P < 0.05) in the 8-ft up and go test: IG: 5.4 (1.0). CG: 6.0 (0.9)Muscle strength:Significant differences between groups for the three tests P < 0.05: Sit-to-stand test: IG: 14.3 (1.6). CG: 13.6 (1.6). Modified curl up: IG: 33.3 (30.1). CG: 16.6 (22.1). Isometric push up: IG: 79.8 (41.9). CG: 47.3 (35.1)Perrot et al. (2021)28FranceExperimental12 participants. Age: 35 to 64,IG: 6 participants, mean age: 49.3CG: 6 participants, mean age: 51.4IG: Wii based exercise program using the Nintendo Wii, a video game console with integrated motion-sensitive technology and the Nintendo Wii Balance Board to record weight and center of pressure trajectory. Each training session was supervised by the master student in adapted physical activityCG: no lifestyle changesMode: Wii-based exercise programFirst period: Wii sports (Wii Tennis and Wii Bowling)Second period: Wii Fit Plus using the balance board to play Wii Soccer Headers, Wii Ski Jump, Wii Hula Hoop, and the Wii Marbles gamesDuration: 1 h/session for 14 weeksFrequency: 2 sessions/weekFunctional mobility:- TUG- TUDSMuscular endurance: The 30-s chair stand testPhysical fitness: 6-Minute Walk TestImprovement in the IG was observed with large effect sizes for functional measures (p < 0.01, Cohen’s d = 2.23), muscular endurance (p < 0.05; Cohen’s d = 1.74), and physical fitness (p < 0.05, Cohen’s d = 1.39)The TUG and TUDS scores increased respectively by 15% and 12%, muscular endurance by 24%, and physical fitness by 5%Post et al. (2022)31United States of AmericaQuasi- experimentalIG: 6 men and 5 women clinically diagnosed with Down syndrome Age: 25.8 ± 6.4 yearsIQ: 58.3 ± 19.7 units10-week resistance training exercise protocolMode: Light Repetition Maximum (RM) (12–15 RM), moderate (8–10 RM), and heavy (4–6 RM) for three sets. It included: warm-ups from large to smaller muscle groups (leg press, bench press, leg curl, shoulder press, bicep curls, and variations to make it enjoyable each day). Exercises were performed with machines, free weights, resistance bands, and body weight aloneDuration: 45–60 min/session for 10 weeksMotor Function Testing: The TGMD-2 (short sprint, gallop, shuffle, stationary basketball dribble, catch a baseball)Flexibility: sit-and-reach testMuscular Strength: 6-repetition maximum testing for the leg press, and bench press, as well as the 30-s chair sit-to-stand testMuscular endurance: 30-s of push-ups and 30-s of sit-upsParticipants significantly improved both locomotor skill (p = 0.001), object control skill (p = 0.008), and total gross motor function (p = 0.000)This intervention significantly improved sit-and-reach flexibility, 6 RM barbell bench press, 6 RM supine leg press, 30-s push-ups, 30-s sit-ups, and 30-s chair sit-to-stand metricsCai and Baek (2022)29ChinaExperimental22 adults (18 men and 4 women) with DS between 18 to 40 yearsIG: 11 participants CG: 11 participantsIG: Basketball programme, strictly supervised, conducted in a 28-m long, 15-m wide, international standard basketball court of BasketballCG: Performed no structured exercisesMode: Basketball programme- Warm up with games for 10 min- 45 min of basic basketball skill learning (shooting, passing and handling) and physical training- Relaxing exercises for 5 minFrequency: 3 times/weekDuration: 60 min/session for 24 consecutive weeksAerobic fitness: 16-m modified shuttle-run test or PACER testBalance:- Static: standing on one leg to a maximum period of 10 s- Dynamic: number of consecutive steps (max six steps) walking on a 3.05-m balance beam that was 10.2 cm wideMuscular strength:- As many curls up as possible (maximum of 75) sliding their hands up along the upper legs to the kneecap- Standing long jump (explosive force of the lower limbs): Distance between the initial line to the heel after jumpingFlexibility: The sit-and-reach testAfter 24 weeks there was a statistically significant improvement in all functional health variables in the IG (all featured P < 0.05)The CG had no statistically significant difference between all functional health variables except for the standing long jump (all featured P > 0.05)The IG had better flexibility, sit and-reach, modified curl-up, aerobic capacity and static and dynamic balance than the control group (P < 0.05)IG Intervention group, CG Control group, DS Down Syndrome, IQ Intelligence quotient, EMG Electromiography, ACSM American College of Sports Medicine, GMFM-88 The Gross Motor Function Measure 88, 6MWD 6-min walking distance test, ADL’S Activities of daily living. TUG: The Timed Up and Go test, TUDS Timed Up and Down Stairs test, TGMD-2 Test of Gross Motor Development version 2. Table 1General characteristic of the studies.StudyStudy designParticipantsInterventionDosageOutcome measurement instrumentResultsDavis and Sinning (1987)33United States of AmericaQuasi- experimentalIG1: 6 men with DS. Age: 20–38.2 years. IQ ranging 32–41IG2: 6 men with mental disabilities without DS. Age 18.5–36.2 years. IQ ranging 33–57CG: 6 undergraduate and postgraduate students. Age: 19–24.3 years. Above average IQIG1 AND IG2: Strength training under the supervision of graduates and graduates in physical education who were instructed in the procedures. Individual records of weight, series and repetitions were setCG: They exercised individually and recorded their own progressMode: bench press, triceps curls, and biceps curls with free weightIntensity: 6–8 repetitions. The amount of weight for each particular set was progressively increased as the subjects were able to exceed 8 repetitionsDuration: 8 weeksFrequency: 3 times a weekElbow flexor strength:Maximum voluntary contraction: supine, right arm in 90° elbow flexion, exert 2 maximum efforts against immovable resistance. In the same position, exert a force for 5 s against a series of loads ranging from 5 lb to approximately 90% of the maximum effort measuredElectromyography:Electrodes are placed on the flexor muscle group at the elbow (biceps brachii). Integrated EMG and torque measurements of the elbow flexor muscle group were recorded simultaneously during maximal effort and step loading proceduresOnly half of the subjects increased their maximum voluntary contraction as a result of the training, but there were no significant differences between groups P > 0.05As expected, the post measurements of the group without disabilities experienced more improvement than the other two groups with disabilities, being statistically significant. p < 0.001Carmeli et al. 200210IsraelExperimental26 older adults aged 57–65 yearsMild mental retardationIQ ranging 56–75 according to the Stanford Binet scaleIG: 16 participants (10 women, 6 men)CG: 10 participants (6 women, 4 men)IG: Aerobic exercise with treadmill walkingParticipants walked only between 9:30 and 11:30 am indoors under controlled conditions (23 °C, 40% humidity)CG: They were instructed not to change their daily activity levelMode: Endless treadmill walkIntensity: Low resistance with 0% inclineIntensity: Speed below the threshold for breathlessness but as fast as they could comfortably tolerateFrequency: 3 times/weekDuration: 25 consecutive weeks. They initially walked for 10–15 min. The duration was gradually increased up to 45 min according to toleranceDynamic balance and gait speed:- Timed up and goMuscle strength:- Flexion (hamstrings) and extension (Quadriceps) of the knee in the isokinetic system (Biodex dynamometer) at speeds of 60°/s and 120°/sData were collected for peak torque (ft/lb) (highest individual value of three peak efforts), peak torque percentage of body weight (ft/lb/kg), and average power (watts)Timed up and go: IG: 25.9 ± 3 s. CG: 29.1 ± 3 s. Significant improvements between groups p < 0.05Muscle strength: Significant differences are found in all three tests (maximum torque, % maximum torque of body weight and average power) of hamstrings and quadriceps in both men and women p < 0.01Rimmer et al. (2004)16United States of AmericaExperimental52 adults with DS. Mean age 39.4 ± 6.4IG: 30 participantsCG: 22 participants. without interventionIG: Cardio and strength exercisesExercise classes were supervised by a full-time registered clinical exercise physiologist and two assistantsCARDIOVASCULAR TRAININGMode: Recumbent stepper, stationary cycle (recumbent and upright), treadmill and ellipticalDuration: 15–20 min the first 2 weeks, 20–30 min the third and fourth weeks, 30 min from the fifth week onward for 12 weeksIntensity: 50%–70% of VO2 max. Monitored with cardiac monitorsSTRENGTH TRAININGMode: seated bench and leg press, seated leg curl, triceps curl, seated shoulder press, seated row, push-upDuration: 15–20 minIntensity: initially 70% of 1-RM for a set of 10–20 reps. When participants were able to complete 20 reps for 2 consecutive sessions with proper lifting technique, the weight was increased by 10% of their 1-RMStrength: 1-RM protocol according to the ACSMLeg pressChest pressGrip Strength:Manual dynamometryLeg Press: IG: 320 lb (87) 145.1 kg (39.4). CG: 208 lb (97) 94.3 kg (43.9). Significant differences p < 0.0001Chest Press: IG: 100.7 lb (44.9) 45.6 kg (20.3). CG: 59.9 lb (33.6) 27.1 kg (15.2). Significant differences p < 0.0001Dynamometry:IG: Right hand 22.0 (8.1); Left hand 21.6 (8.7)CG: Right hand 19.0 (7.7); Left hand 17.8 (7.0)Nonsignificant differences neither on the left nor on the right side p > 0.05Tsimaras and Fotiadou (2004)30GreeceQuasi-experimental25 adults with DS all from the Center of Professional Learning of ThessalonikiIG: 15 participants. IQ range, 45–60. Age, 24.5 ± 3.9 yearsCG: 10 participants. (IQ range, 45– 59. Age 24.7 ± 2.7 yearsIG: a 12-week Cardio and strength trainingMode: walking, slow running, and free gymnastic activities that mobilize large muscle groups (10 min)15–20 min of training program activities:1. Two-foot ankle hop. 2. Single-foot side-to side ankle hop. 3. Tuck jump with knees up. 4. Tuck jump with heel kick. 5. Standing long jump. 6. Standing jump over barrier. 7. Single leg hops. 8. Double leg hops. 9. Standing on 1 foot. 10. Rocking boats. 11. Walking on line. 12. Walking across 30-cm-wide balance beam. 13. Walking across 20-cm-wide balance beam. 14. Walking across 10-cm-wide balance beamFinally, 5-min recovery periodFrequency: 3 times per week,Duration: 30–35 min/sesionPeak torque of knee extension and flexion: Cybex II isokinetic dynamometerIsokinetic muscle endurance of quadriceps muscles: after 25 repeated maximum efforts at an angular velocity of 180° , and it was defined by the percentage of decline from the peak torqueDynamic balance ability: balance deck. Number of seconds the subject could remain standing on the platform of the stabilometer in durations of 30-, 45-, and 60-s intervalsIsokinetic peak torque of anterior (300, 180, 120° p < 0.001, 60°p < 0.01) and posterior (300, 180, 120° p < 0.01, 60° p < 0.01) femoral muscles significantly improved for the experiment groupThe isokinetic endurance: it showed a significant improvement (p < 0.01) after participation in the training programDynamic balance ability: was significantly improved for the experiment group (30 s p < 0.01, 45 s and 60 s p < 0.001,No significant differences were found in any of the measurements for the control groupFor the initial and final measurements, no statistically significant differences were found between the 2 groupsAguiar et al. (2008)27BrazilQuasi-experimentalIG: 21 men Age: 23.3 ± 2.1Monitored aerobic exercise of adapted judo training for 16 weeksMode: Adapted JudoIntensity: Lactate thresholdFrequency: 3 times/weekDuration: 50 min/sessionGross motor skills:GMFM-88The judo training program significantly (P < 0.05) improved the GMFM-88 index of young adults with DSShields et al. (2008)8AustraliaExperimental20 adults. Age: 26.8 ± 7.8 years13 men, 7 womenIG: 9 participantsCG: 11 participants8 of the 20 participants worked at least 1 day/week in manual-type jobs (packing confectionery boxes, sorting and cutting clothes, and assembling car parts)IG: Group progressive resistance training in a supervised community gym. The trainer kept a record for each participant of the number of repetitions and sets and the weight lifted/exercised in each session. Participants completed the program in a group, supervised by 2 accredited fitness trainers. Each trainer supervised the training of a subgroup of 2–3 participantsCG: Continued with usual activities (work, free time, and leisure)Mode: Progressive resistance training with machines:- Shoulder press- Seated chest press- Seated rowing- Seated leg press- Knee extension- Seated calf raiseIntensity: Increased when 2 sets of 12 reps per exercise could be completedVolume: 2–3 sets of 10–12 reps per exercise to failureFrequency: 2 times a weekDuration: 10 weeksDensity: 2-min rest between setsMuscle performance:- 1 RM: Chest press and leg press- Muscular resistance: repetitions of chest and leg press with 50% of 1RMPhysical function:- Timed up and down stairs test- Grocery shelving task: Get up from a chair and take 2 bags of groceries to a bench located 2 m away. Each bag contains 10 items (410 g each, total weight of each bag 4.1 kg). Then they have to take the items out of the bag and stack them on a shelf at shoulder height1 RM Chest Press: IG: 44.9 ± 15.2 kg. CG: 31.6 ± 13.3 kg1 RM Leg Press: IG: 96.2 ± 31.6 kg. CG: 82.2 ± 19.7 kgRep Chest Press: IG: 25.9 ± 8.3. CG 17.5 ± 9.5Rep Leg Press: IG: 46.8 ± 37.1. CG: 49.4 ± 27.6Timed up and down stairs: IG: 14.4 ± 3.4 s. CG: 18.7 ± 6.5 sGrocery shelving task: IG: 67.5 ± 33.4 s. CG: pre 122.8 ± 84.0 s; post 110.7 ± 66.4 sSignificant differences between groups in 1-RM chest press (P 0.08), chest press repetitions (P 0.002), and leg press repetitions (P 0.039)No significant differences between groups in the leg press 1RM test (P 0.90), timed up and go (P 0.12) or grocery shelving task test (P 0.11)Cowley et al. 20119United States of AmericaQuasi- experimental30 adults with mild intellectual disabilities. Age: 28 ± 8 yearsIG: 9 men and 10 womenCG: 11 participants. 8 men and 3 womenIG: progressive resistance trainingEach participant worked one on one with a professional who supervised all the training sessionsCG: Maintained normal daily activitiesMode: Leg extension, leg curl, leg press, shoulder press, chest press, bicep curl, and tricep curl exercises performed on exercise machinesIntensity: 3 sets of 8–10 reps per exercise. The weight lifted by the subject was recorded during the training period and progressively increased to constantly overload the muscleFrequency: 2 days per weekDuration: 10 weeksIsometric and isokinetic strength of knee extensors and flexors: Biodex System 3 dynamometer- Maximum isometric peak torque: 3 series of 3 maximum contractions with knee extensors and flexors at a joint angle of 45°, 60°, and 75° with 3 min interval between series- Maximum isokinetic peak torque: 3 series of 5 maximum contractions with knee extensors and flexors at 60°/s with 3 min interval between seriesFunctional tasks of daily life:- Time to get up from a chair at different heights (30, 38, or 43 cm) as quickly as possible to an upright position with trunk and legs straight, keeping arms crossed over the chest- Gait speed: Walk 7.62 m- Go up and down 10 steps as fast as possible without using the support handrail and alternating feet and then go downIsometric flexor strength:Significant differences between groups P < 0.05 in the three degrees of movement (45°, 60°, and 75°)Isometric strength extensors:Significant differences in the IG in the three degrees of movement P < 0.05Flexors and extensors isokinetic strength Significant differences in the IG P < 0.05Getting up from a chair at different heights: No significant differences P > 0.05 in any of the chair heights (30 cm, 38 cm, 43 cm) or in the 5 repetitions10-step ascent and descent: Significant differences in the IG P < 0.05 in both tests. IG Ascent: .83 SD 1.19. CG: 5.10 SD 1.19. GI descent: 4.38 SD 1.19. CG: 6.23 SD 2.80Gait speed: IG: 1.72 SD 0.20. CG: 1.71 SD 0.24. No significant differences P > 0.05Mendonca et al. (2011)15PortugalQuasi- experimentalIG1: 13 participants (10 men, 3 women) with DS. Age: 36.5 ± 5.5 yearsIG2: 12 participants (9 men, 3 women) without disabilities. Age: 38.7 ± 8.3 yearsCombined resistance and strength exercise trainingThe exercise sessions were supervised by an exercise physiologist and an assistantENDURANCE TRAININGMode: Walk or run on a treadmillIntensity: target heart rate compatible with 65% (first three weeks) at 85% of VO2peak. Monitored with fc/participant clockDuration: 30 min. 12 weeksFrequency: 3 days/weekSTRENGTH TRAININGMode: repeating a set of 9 exercises twice with < 30 s of rest between them. Train with leg press, chest and shoulder press, vertical pull, lower back, leg extension, bicep curl, and tricep curl. In addition, 1 set of 15 repetitions of abdominal push-ups in each rotationIntensity: 10% increase in 12-RM load when participants were able to complete 14 reps for 2 consecutive sessions with proper techniqueFrequency: 2 days/weekMuscle strength: 12-RM protocol on variable resistance machines- Leg press- Chest press- Vertical traction- Lower back- Leg extensionEach participant was asked to perform 15 reps with relatively light resistance followed by 30 s of recovery. Resistance was then increased, and each participant performed a maximum of 5 sets of 12 repetitions until the 12-RM was reached. The recovery period between sets was exactly 2 min, and increments of 2.5–5 kg were used as each participant approached fatigue. The 12-RM was defined as the maximum load lifted through a full range of motion for a total of 12 repetitions. For most participants, the 12-RM was determined in 3–4 attemptsLeg Press: IG1: 110.2 ± 52.6. IG2: 171.3 ± 56.5Chest Press: IG1: 35.3 ± 12.2. IG2: 51.3 ± 21.0Vertical Traction: IG1: 39.2 ± 14.1. IG2: 59.4 ± 15.3Lower Back: IG1: 35.6 ± 7.4. IG2: 51.9 ± 19.3Leg Extension: IG1: 30.1 ± 10.3. IG2: 52.7 ± 17.6Participants with Down syndrome showed lower muscle strength than participants without disabilities in all dynamic exercises, both before and after trainingTraining was highly efficient in obtaining generalized improvements for 12-RM in both groups (P < 0.05). The magnitude of these improvements was similar between participants with and without Down syndromeBoer and Moss, (2016)5South AfricaExperimental42 adults. Age 33.8 ± 8.6(25 men, 17 women)IG1: 13 participantsIG2: 13 participantsCG: 16 participantsIG1: Continuous aerobic training (CAT) on a bicycle or treadmillIG2: Interval training (IT) with 10–30-s sprints on a bike or treadmillThe two IGs performed the intervention under the supervision of a licensed sport scientist and exercise physiologist in a 2:6 (professional:participants) ratioCG: No interventionDuration: 12 weeks. 30-min sessions the first six weeks (5-min warm-up, 20-min central act, 5-min cool down), the last six weeks’ sessions were increased by 5 min for the central activityIntensity: Warm up and cool down at 4 km/hFrequency: 3 times/weekIG1: CAT- Mode: Continuous aerobic training by bicycle (50%) or treadmill (50%)- Central act intensity: first six weeks 70%–80% VO2peak, last 6 weeks 85% VO2peakIG2: IT- Mode: Interval aerobic training on a bicycle (50%) or treadmill (50%)- Intensity: 10–30-s max sprints with 90-s low cadence, low intensity gait, or bikeGrip strength:- Manual dynamometry in the dominant handLower Body Strength:- Sit-to-stand testAgility and dynamic balance:- 8-ft up and goAerobic capacity and functional ability:- 6MWDGrip strength:CAT: 26.1 kg (7.9). IT: 29.9 kg (8.9). CG: 25.5 kg (9.1). No significant differences between groups P = 0.57Lower Body Strength:CAT: 15.2 (1.8). IT: 15.5 (1.8). CG: 13.3 (2.3). Significant improvements between groups P = 0.01 and only in the CAT group compared to the control group (P < 0.05)Agility and balance:CAT: 4.8 s (0.9). IT: 4.9 s (1.1). CG: 6.2 s (1.3). Significant improvements between groups P = 0.03 and only in the CAT group compared to the control group (P < 0.05)Aerobic capacity and functional ability:CAT: 563.2 m (74.9). IT: 562.6 m (81.7). CG: 495.9 m (85.2). Significant improvements between groups P = 0.01 and only in the CAT group compared to the control group (P < 0.05)Silva et al. (2017)32PortugalExperimental27 adults aged 18–60 yearsIG: 14 participantsCG: 13 participantsIG: Wii-based exercise program that included training games for aerobic endurance, balance, and isometric strengthCG: They completed their usual daily activities (usual treatment) at their occupational center, such as rehabilitation, life skills training, and art-related activitiesMode: Aerobic exercise through a Wii-based exercise program. Individual sessions or with another participant (half of the sessions in each format)Frequency: 3 sessions per weekDuration: 2 monthsPhysical aptitude: Eurofit test battery:- Limb movement speed (Plate Tapping Test)- Static arm strength (Handgrip Test)- Running speed and agility (Shuttle Run)- Balance (Flamingo Balance)- Flexibility (Sit and Reach)- Explosive power of the legs (Standing Broad)- Trunk Strength (30-s Sit-ups)- Muscular resistance (Bent Arm Hang)Functional mobility:- Timed Up and Go- Response speed subtest of the Bruininks–Oseretsky Motor Competence Test First EditionMotor skills:- Beanbag OverheadSignificant improvements in the GI in the Handgrip test (IG: 25.42 (5.53). CG: 23.92 (6.45) P 0,025), in the sit and reach (IG: 36.92 (7.22). CG: 29.46 (10.53) P 0,014), in the standing broad (IG: 99.33 (29.49). CG: 90.69 (35.20) P < 0,001) and in the Bruininks–Oseretsky First Edition test (IG: 4.67 (2.81). CG: 4.77 (2.17) P 0.028)Significant differences between groups were identified in the plate tapping test (P 0.045), shuttle run (P 0.014), sit and reach (P 0.027), standing broad (P 0.003), 30-s sit-ups (P 0.040) and timed up and go (P 0.049)No significant differences in the handgrip test (P 0.837), flamingo balance (P 0.477), bent arm hang (P 0.086), Bruininks–Oseretsky First Edition (P 0.265), neither in the beanbag overhead nor in the hand right P 0.150 nor in the left P 0.083Boer and de Beer (2019)2South AfricaQuasi- experimental23 adults. Age 31.4 ± 7.4 yearsIG: 13 participants (8 men, 5 women)CG: 10 participants (5 men, 5 women)IG: Aerobic exercise in aquatic environment. Aquatic training. Sessions controlled and monitored by test instructors and senior Human Movement Sciences students (approximately one test instructor per two participants)CG: No intervention additional to ADLsMode: Aquatic training with arm circle exercises, lateral twists, walk in place, run in place, water scoops, lateral leg raises, back flutter kick, stomach flutter kick, jumping jacks, knee twists, side shift, squat jumps, lunge jumps, and longer jog, 1.4-m-deep poolDuration: 6 weeks, 35 min the first 3 weeks, 45 min the last 3 weeks. Consider a 3-min warm up and 2-min cool downFrequency: 3 times/weekStatic Balance:- Balance on one legDynamic Balance:- Walk on a balance beamFunctional fitness:- 6MWD- 8-ft up and goMuscular strength:- Sit-to-stand test-Curl‐up modified-Isometric push-upStatic Balance:No significant differences P > 0.05 in the static balance IG: 6.6 (3.5). CG: 5.1 (3.6), nor dynamic IG: 5.6 (0.8). CG: 4.6 (2.1)Functional fitness:Significant differences between groups P < 0.05 for the 6MWD test: IG: 602.1(98.7). CG: 519. 9 (111.9). No significant differences P > 0.05 in the 8-ft up and go test: IG: .3 (0.9). CG: .5 (0.9)Muscle strength:Significant differences between groups P < 0.05 for sit-to-stand test GI: 14.5 (2.2). CG: 13.0 (1.8) and modified curl up GI: 37.9 (30.1). CG: 20.0 (28.3). Nonsignificant differences P > 0.05 for isometric push-up IG: 82.2 (50.9). CG: 36.5 (32.5)Skiba et al. (2019)13PoloniaExperimental22 adults aged 25– 40 years, with moderate intellectual disability (IQ: 36–51). 11 men, 11 womenIG: 11 participants. CG: 11 participantsIG: Aerobic exercise with Nordic walking training program. The exercises were performed by a physiotherapist, who was a qualified Nordic walking instructorCG: Did not undergo any trainingMode: Brisk Nordic walkingIntensity: Progressed over the course of the training sessionsFrequency: 3 times a weekDuration: 45 minSpatiotemporal parameters (step and stride length and speed) and maximum values of angles in the ankle, knee, hip, and shoulder joints in different phases of gait:Using the Vicon 250 Optoelectronic System for Three-Dimensional Motion AnalysisGait parameters: Significant differences in the right (P 0.002) and left (P 0.038) step length as well as for the right (P 0.002) and left (P 0.001) stride length. Regarding speed, only significant changes in right leg (P 0.011)Angular values: Significant changes for the right ankle (P 0.044) in support phase. Significant changes in the left knee, with increased flexion in the phase of medium support (P 0.002), terminal support (P 0.017) and initial sway (P 0.004). The hip does not present significant changes in the right or left leg during the initial contact (P 0.649–0.755), pre-swing (P 0.054–0.165) or terminal sway (P 0.738–0.896)Significant differences in the movement of the pelvis in the sagittal plane in the medium support phase for the right limb (P 0.038) and in the initial sway phase for the left limb (P 0.043). In the frontal plane, there were significant differences in the movement of the pelvis at the maximum point of movement of the left limb (P 0.027) and at the minimum point of movement of the right (P 0.002). In the transverse plane there are no significant differences in the right or left legBoer (2020)1South AfricaExperimental26 adults. Age 32.7 ± 6 years (13 men, 13 women)IG: 13 participantsCG: 13 participantsIG: Aerobic exercise in aquatic environment. Freestyle swimming training, accompanied by lively music and strictly controlled by the main test instructor using a whistleCG: No structured interventionMode: Freestyle swimming in a 12-m long and 1.4-m deep pool. Swim a certain length of the pool and rest while a partner completes another length in the same lane. As soon as the partner reaches the middle of the lane, the other participant is instructed to swimFrequency: 3 times/weekDuration: 20 min the first 4 weeks, 26 min the last 4 weeksStatic Balance:- Balance on one legDynamic Balance:- Walk on a balance beamFunctional fitness:- 6MWD- 8-ft up and goMuscular strength:- Sit-to-stand test-Curl‐up modified-Isometric push‐upStatic Balance:No significant differences (P > 0.05) in IG static balance: 5.9 (3.3). CG: 5.5 (4.1). Significant differences (P < 0.05) between groups in IG dynamic balance: 5.3 (1.2). CG: 3.5 (2.6)Functional fitness:No significant differences (P > 0.05) for the 6MWD IG test: 553.8 (106.9). CG: 503.1 (118.7). Significant differences between groups (P < 0.05) in the 8-ft up and go test: IG: 5.4 (1.0). CG: 6.0 (0.9)Muscle strength:Significant differences between groups for the three tests P < 0.05: Sit-to-stand test: IG: 14.3 (1.6). CG: 13.6 (1.6). Modified curl up: IG: 33.3 (30.1). CG: 16.6 (22.1). Isometric push up: IG: 79.8 (41.9). CG: 47.3 (35.1)Perrot et al. (2021)28FranceExperimental12 participants. Age: 35 to 64,IG: 6 participants, mean age: 49.3CG: 6 participants, mean age: 51.4IG: Wii based exercise program using the Nintendo Wii, a video game console with integrated motion-sensitive technology and the Nintendo Wii Balance Board to record weight and center of pressure trajectory. Each training session was supervised by the master student in adapted physical activityCG: no lifestyle changesMode: Wii-based exercise programFirst period: Wii sports (Wii Tennis and Wii Bowling)Second period: Wii Fit Plus using the balance board to play Wii Soccer Headers, Wii Ski Jump, Wii Hula Hoop, and the Wii Marbles gamesDuration: 1 h/session for 14 weeksFrequency: 2 sessions/weekFunctional mobility:- TUG- TUDSMuscular endurance: The 30-s chair stand testPhysical fitness: 6-Minute Walk TestImprovement in the IG was observed with large effect sizes for functional measures (p < 0.01, Cohen’s d = 2.23), muscular endurance (p < 0.05; Cohen’s d = 1.74), and physical fitness (p < 0.05, Cohen’s d = 1.39)The TUG and TUDS scores increased respectively by 15% and 12%, muscular endurance by 24%, and physical fitness by 5%Post et al. (2022)31United States of AmericaQuasi- experimentalIG: 6 men and 5 women clinically diagnosed with Down syndrome Age: 25.8 ± 6.4 yearsIQ: 58.3 ± 19.7 units10-week resistance training exercise protocolMode: Light Repetition Maximum (RM) (12–15 RM), moderate (8–10 RM), and heavy (4–6 RM) for three sets. It included: warm-ups from large to smaller muscle groups (leg press, bench press, leg curl, shoulder press, bicep curls, and variations to make it enjoyable each day). Exercises were performed with machines, free weights, resistance bands, and body weight aloneDuration: 45–60 min/session for 10 weeksMotor Function Testing: The TGMD-2 (short sprint, gallop, shuffle, stationary basketball dribble, catch a baseball)Flexibility: sit-and-reach testMuscular Strength: 6-repetition maximum testing for the leg press, and bench press, as well as the 30-s chair sit-to-stand testMuscular endurance: 30-s of push-ups and 30-s of sit-upsParticipants significantly improved both locomotor skill (p = 0.001), object control skill (p = 0.008), and total gross motor function (p = 0.000)This intervention significantly improved sit-and-reach flexibility, 6 RM barbell bench press, 6 RM supine leg press, 30-s push-ups, 30-s sit-ups, and 30-s chair sit-to-stand metricsCai and Baek (2022)29ChinaExperimental22 adults (18 men and 4 women) with DS between 18 to 40 yearsIG: 11 participants CG: 11 participantsIG: Basketball programme, strictly supervised, conducted in a 28-m long, 15-m wide, international standard basketball court of BasketballCG: Performed no structured exercisesMode: Basketball programme- Warm up with games for 10 min- 45 min of basic basketball skill learning (shooting, passing and handling) and physical training- Relaxing exercises for 5 minFrequency: 3 times/weekDuration: 60 min/session for 24 consecutive weeksAerobic fitness: 16-m modified shuttle-run test or PACER testBalance:- Static: standing on one leg to a maximum period of 10 s- Dynamic: number of consecutive steps (max six steps) walking on a 3.05-m balance beam that was 10.2 cm wideMuscular strength:- As many curls up as possible (maximum of 75) sliding their hands up along the upper legs to the kneecap- Standing long jump (explosive force of the lower limbs): Distance between the initial line to the heel after jumpingFlexibility: The sit-and-reach testAfter 24 weeks there was a statistically significant improvement in all functional health variables in the IG (all featured P < 0.05)The CG had no statistically significant difference between all functional health variables except for the standing long jump (all featured P > 0.05)The IG had better flexibility, sit and-reach, modified curl-up, aerobic capacity and static and dynamic balance than the control group (P < 0.05)IG Intervention group, CG Control group, DS Down Syndrome, IQ Intelligence quotient, EMG Electromiography, ACSM American College of Sports Medicine, GMFM-88 The Gross Motor Function Measure 88, 6MWD 6-min walking distance test, ADL’S Activities of daily living. TUG: The Timed Up and Go test, TUDS Timed Up and Down Stairs test, TGMD-2 Test of Gross Motor Development version 2. General characteristic of the studies. Davis and Sinning (1987)33 United States of America IG1: 6 men with DS. Age: 20–38.2 years. IQ ranging 32–41 IG2: 6 men with mental disabilities without DS. Age 18.5–36.2 years. IQ ranging 33–57 CG: 6 undergraduate and postgraduate students. Age: 19–24.3 years. Above average IQ IG1 AND IG2: Strength training under the supervision of graduates and graduates in physical education who were instructed in the procedures. Individual records of weight, series and repetitions were set CG: They exercised individually and recorded their own progress Mode: bench press, triceps curls, and biceps curls with free weight Intensity: 6–8 repetitions. The amount of weight for each particular set was progressively increased as the subjects were able to exceed 8 repetitions Duration: 8 weeks Frequency: 3 times a week Elbow flexor strength: Maximum voluntary contraction: supine, right arm in 90° elbow flexion, exert 2 maximum efforts against immovable resistance. In the same position, exert a force for 5 s against a series of loads ranging from 5 lb to approximately 90% of the maximum effort measured Electromyography: Electrodes are placed on the flexor muscle group at the elbow (biceps brachii). Integrated EMG and torque measurements of the elbow flexor muscle group were recorded simultaneously during maximal effort and step loading procedures Only half of the subjects increased their maximum voluntary contraction as a result of the training, but there were no significant differences between groups P > 0.05 As expected, the post measurements of the group without disabilities experienced more improvement than the other two groups with disabilities, being statistically significant. p < 0.001 Carmeli et al. 200210 Israel 26 older adults aged 57–65 years Mild mental retardation IQ ranging 56–75 according to the Stanford Binet scale IG: 16 participants (10 women, 6 men) CG: 10 participants (6 women, 4 men) IG: Aerobic exercise with treadmill walking Participants walked only between 9:30 and 11:30 am indoors under controlled conditions (23 °C, 40% humidity) CG: They were instructed not to change their daily activity level Mode: Endless treadmill walk Intensity: Low resistance with 0% incline Intensity: Speed below the threshold for breathlessness but as fast as they could comfortably tolerate Frequency: 3 times/week Duration: 25 consecutive weeks. They initially walked for 10–15 min. The duration was gradually increased up to 45 min according to tolerance Dynamic balance and gait speed: - Timed up and go Muscle strength: - Flexion (hamstrings) and extension (Quadriceps) of the knee in the isokinetic system (Biodex dynamometer) at speeds of 60°/s and 120°/s Data were collected for peak torque (ft/lb) (highest individual value of three peak efforts), peak torque percentage of body weight (ft/lb/kg), and average power (watts) Timed up and go: IG: 25.9 ± 3 s. CG: 29.1 ± 3 s. Significant improvements between groups p < 0.05 Muscle strength: Significant differences are found in all three tests (maximum torque, % maximum torque of body weight and average power) of hamstrings and quadriceps in both men and women p < 0.01 Rimmer et al. (2004)16 United States of America 52 adults with DS. Mean age 39.4 ± 6.4 IG: 30 participants CG: 22 participants. without intervention IG: Cardio and strength exercises Exercise classes were supervised by a full-time registered clinical exercise physiologist and two assistants CARDIOVASCULAR TRAINING Mode: Recumbent stepper, stationary cycle (recumbent and upright), treadmill and elliptical Duration: 15–20 min the first 2 weeks, 20–30 min the third and fourth weeks, 30 min from the fifth week onward for 12 weeks Intensity: 50%–70% of VO2 max. Monitored with cardiac monitors STRENGTH TRAINING Mode: seated bench and leg press, seated leg curl, triceps curl, seated shoulder press, seated row, push-up Duration: 15–20 min Intensity: initially 70% of 1-RM for a set of 10–20 reps. When participants were able to complete 20 reps for 2 consecutive sessions with proper lifting technique, the weight was increased by 10% of their 1-RM Strength: 1-RM protocol according to the ACSM Leg press Chest press Grip Strength: Manual dynamometry Leg Press: IG: 320 lb (87) 145.1 kg (39.4). CG: 208 lb (97) 94.3 kg (43.9). Significant differences p < 0.0001 Chest Press: IG: 100.7 lb (44.9) 45.6 kg (20.3). CG: 59.9 lb (33.6) 27.1 kg (15.2). Significant differences p < 0.0001 Dynamometry: IG: Right hand 22.0 (8.1); Left hand 21.6 (8.7) CG: Right hand 19.0 (7.7); Left hand 17.8 (7.0) Nonsignificant differences neither on the left nor on the right side p > 0.05 Tsimaras and Fotiadou (2004)30 Greece 25 adults with DS all from the Center of Professional Learning of Thessaloniki IG: 15 participants. IQ range, 45–60. Age, 24.5 ± 3.9 years CG: 10 participants. (IQ range, 45– 59. Age 24.7 ± 2.7 years Mode: walking, slow running, and free gymnastic activities that mobilize large muscle groups (10 min) 15–20 min of training program activities: 1. Two-foot ankle hop. 2. Single-foot side-to side ankle hop. 3. Tuck jump with knees up. 4. Tuck jump with heel kick. 5. Standing long jump. 6. Standing jump over barrier. 7. Single leg hops. 8. Double leg hops. 9. Standing on 1 foot. 10. Rocking boats. 11. Walking on line. 12. Walking across 30-cm-wide balance beam. 13. Walking across 20-cm-wide balance beam. 14. Walking across 10-cm-wide balance beam Finally, 5-min recovery period Frequency: 3 times per week, Duration: 30–35 min/sesion Peak torque of knee extension and flexion: Cybex II isokinetic dynamometer Isokinetic muscle endurance of quadriceps muscles: after 25 repeated maximum efforts at an angular velocity of 180° , and it was defined by the percentage of decline from the peak torque Dynamic balance ability: balance deck. Number of seconds the subject could remain standing on the platform of the stabilometer in durations of 30-, 45-, and 60-s intervals Isokinetic peak torque of anterior (300, 180, 120° p < 0.001, 60°p < 0.01) and posterior (300, 180, 120° p < 0.01, 60° p < 0.01) femoral muscles significantly improved for the experiment group The isokinetic endurance: it showed a significant improvement (p < 0.01) after participation in the training program Dynamic balance ability: was significantly improved for the experiment group (30 s p < 0.01, 45 s and 60 s p < 0.001, No significant differences were found in any of the measurements for the control group For the initial and final measurements, no statistically significant differences were found between the 2 groups Aguiar et al. (2008)27 Brazil Mode: Adapted Judo Intensity: Lactate threshold Frequency: 3 times/week Duration: 50 min/session Gross motor skills: GMFM-88 Shields et al. (2008)8 Australia 20 adults. Age: 26.8 ± 7.8 years 13 men, 7 women IG: 9 participants CG: 11 participants 8 of the 20 participants worked at least 1 day/week in manual-type jobs (packing confectionery boxes, sorting and cutting clothes, and assembling car parts) IG: Group progressive resistance training in a supervised community gym. The trainer kept a record for each participant of the number of repetitions and sets and the weight lifted/exercised in each session. Participants completed the program in a group, supervised by 2 accredited fitness trainers. Each trainer supervised the training of a subgroup of 2–3 participants CG: Continued with usual activities (work, free time, and leisure) Mode: Progressive resistance training with machines: - Shoulder press - Seated chest press - Seated rowing - Seated leg press - Knee extension - Seated calf raise Intensity: Increased when 2 sets of 12 reps per exercise could be completed Volume: 2–3 sets of 10–12 reps per exercise to failure Frequency: 2 times a week Duration: 10 weeks Density: 2-min rest between sets Muscle performance: - 1 RM: Chest press and leg press - Muscular resistance: repetitions of chest and leg press with 50% of 1RM Physical function: - Timed up and down stairs test - Grocery shelving task: Get up from a chair and take 2 bags of groceries to a bench located 2 m away. Each bag contains 10 items (410 g each, total weight of each bag 4.1 kg). Then they have to take the items out of the bag and stack them on a shelf at shoulder height 1 RM Chest Press: IG: 44.9 ± 15.2 kg. CG: 31.6 ± 13.3 kg 1 RM Leg Press: IG: 96.2 ± 31.6 kg. CG: 82.2 ± 19.7 kg Rep Chest Press: IG: 25.9 ± 8.3. CG 17.5 ± 9.5 Rep Leg Press: IG: 46.8 ± 37.1. CG: 49.4 ± 27.6 Timed up and down stairs: IG: 14.4 ± 3.4 s. CG: 18.7 ± 6.5 s Grocery shelving task: IG: 67.5 ± 33.4 s. CG: pre 122.8 ± 84.0 s; post 110.7 ± 66.4 s Significant differences between groups in 1-RM chest press (P 0.08), chest press repetitions (P 0.002), and leg press repetitions (P 0.039) No significant differences between groups in the leg press 1RM test (P 0.90), timed up and go (P 0.12) or grocery shelving task test (P 0.11) Cowley et al. 20119 United States of America 30 adults with mild intellectual disabilities. Age: 28 ± 8 years IG: 9 men and 10 women CG: 11 participants. 8 men and 3 women IG: progressive resistance training Each participant worked one on one with a professional who supervised all the training sessions CG: Maintained normal daily activities Mode: Leg extension, leg curl, leg press, shoulder press, chest press, bicep curl, and tricep curl exercises performed on exercise machines Intensity: 3 sets of 8–10 reps per exercise. The weight lifted by the subject was recorded during the training period and progressively increased to constantly overload the muscle Frequency: 2 days per week Duration: 10 weeks Isometric and isokinetic strength of knee extensors and flexors: Biodex System 3 dynamometer - Maximum isometric peak torque: 3 series of 3 maximum contractions with knee extensors and flexors at a joint angle of 45°, 60°, and 75° with 3 min interval between series - Maximum isokinetic peak torque: 3 series of 5 maximum contractions with knee extensors and flexors at 60°/s with 3 min interval between series Functional tasks of daily life: - Time to get up from a chair at different heights (30, 38, or 43 cm) as quickly as possible to an upright position with trunk and legs straight, keeping arms crossed over the chest - Gait speed: Walk 7.62 m - Go up and down 10 steps as fast as possible without using the support handrail and alternating feet and then go down Isometric flexor strength: Significant differences between groups P < 0.05 in the three degrees of movement (45°, 60°, and 75°) Isometric strength extensors: Significant differences in the IG in the three degrees of movement P < 0.05 Flexors and extensors isokinetic strength Significant differences in the IG P < 0.05 Getting up from a chair at different heights: No significant differences P > 0.05 in any of the chair heights (30 cm, 38 cm, 43 cm) or in the 5 repetitions 10-step ascent and descent: Significant differences in the IG P < 0.05 in both tests. IG Ascent: .83 SD 1.19. CG: 5.10 SD 1.19. GI descent: 4.38 SD 1.19. CG: 6.23 SD 2.80 Gait speed: IG: 1.72 SD 0.20. CG: 1.71 SD 0.24. No significant differences P > 0.05 Mendonca et al. (2011)15 Portugal IG1: 13 participants (10 men, 3 women) with DS. Age: 36.5 ± 5.5 years IG2: 12 participants (9 men, 3 women) without disabilities. Age: 38.7 ± 8.3 years Combined resistance and strength exercise training The exercise sessions were supervised by an exercise physiologist and an assistant ENDURANCE TRAINING Mode: Walk or run on a treadmill Intensity: target heart rate compatible with 65% (first three weeks) at 85% of VO2peak. Monitored with fc/participant clock Duration: 30 min. 12 weeks Frequency: 3 days/week STRENGTH TRAINING Mode: repeating a set of 9 exercises twice with < 30 s of rest between them. Train with leg press, chest and shoulder press, vertical pull, lower back, leg extension, bicep curl, and tricep curl. In addition, 1 set of 15 repetitions of abdominal push-ups in each rotation Intensity: 10% increase in 12-RM load when participants were able to complete 14 reps for 2 consecutive sessions with proper technique Frequency: 2 days/week Muscle strength: 12-RM protocol on variable resistance machines - Leg press - Chest press - Vertical traction - Lower back - Leg extension Each participant was asked to perform 15 reps with relatively light resistance followed by 30 s of recovery. Resistance was then increased, and each participant performed a maximum of 5 sets of 12 repetitions until the 12-RM was reached. The recovery period between sets was exactly 2 min, and increments of 2.5–5 kg were used as each participant approached fatigue. The 12-RM was defined as the maximum load lifted through a full range of motion for a total of 12 repetitions. For most participants, the 12-RM was determined in 3–4 attempts Leg Press: IG1: 110.2 ± 52.6. IG2: 171.3 ± 56.5 Chest Press: IG1: 35.3 ± 12.2. IG2: 51.3 ± 21.0 Vertical Traction: IG1: 39.2 ± 14.1. IG2: 59.4 ± 15.3 Lower Back: IG1: 35.6 ± 7.4. IG2: 51.9 ± 19.3 Leg Extension: IG1: 30.1 ± 10.3. IG2: 52.7 ± 17.6 Participants with Down syndrome showed lower muscle strength than participants without disabilities in all dynamic exercises, both before and after training Training was highly efficient in obtaining generalized improvements for 12-RM in both groups (P < 0.05). The magnitude of these improvements was similar between participants with and without Down syndrome Boer and Moss, (2016)5 South Africa 42 adults. Age 33.8 ± 8.6 (25 men, 17 women) IG1: 13 participants IG2: 13 participants CG: 16 participants IG1: Continuous aerobic training (CAT) on a bicycle or treadmill IG2: Interval training (IT) with 10–30-s sprints on a bike or treadmill The two IGs performed the intervention under the supervision of a licensed sport scientist and exercise physiologist in a 2:6 (professional:participants) ratio CG: No intervention Duration: 12 weeks. 30-min sessions the first six weeks (5-min warm-up, 20-min central act, 5-min cool down), the last six weeks’ sessions were increased by 5 min for the central activity Intensity: Warm up and cool down at 4 km/h Frequency: 3 times/week IG1: CAT - Mode: Continuous aerobic training by bicycle (50%) or treadmill (50%) - Central act intensity: first six weeks 70%–80% VO2peak, last 6 weeks 85% VO2peak IG2: IT - Mode: Interval aerobic training on a bicycle (50%) or treadmill (50%) - Intensity: 10–30-s max sprints with 90-s low cadence, low intensity gait, or bike Grip strength: - Manual dynamometry in the dominant hand Lower Body Strength: - Sit-to-stand test Agility and dynamic balance: - 8-ft up and go Aerobic capacity and functional ability: - 6MWD Grip strength: CAT: 26.1 kg (7.9). IT: 29.9 kg (8.9). CG: 25.5 kg (9.1). No significant differences between groups P = 0.57 Lower Body Strength: CAT: 15.2 (1.8). IT: 15.5 (1.8). CG: 13.3 (2.3). Significant improvements between groups P = 0.01 and only in the CAT group compared to the control group (P < 0.05) Agility and balance: CAT: 4.8 s (0.9). IT: 4.9 s (1.1). CG: 6.2 s (1.3). Significant improvements between groups P = 0.03 and only in the CAT group compared to the control group (P < 0.05) Aerobic capacity and functional ability: CAT: 563.2 m (74.9). IT: 562.6 m (81.7). CG: 495.9 m (85.2). Significant improvements between groups P = 0.01 and only in the CAT group compared to the control group (P < 0.05) Silva et al. (2017)32 Portugal 27 adults aged 18–60 years IG: 14 participants CG: 13 participants IG: Wii-based exercise program that included training games for aerobic endurance, balance, and isometric strength CG: They completed their usual daily activities (usual treatment) at their occupational center, such as rehabilitation, life skills training, and art-related activities Mode: Aerobic exercise through a Wii-based exercise program. Individual sessions or with another participant (half of the sessions in each format) Frequency: 3 sessions per week Duration: 2 months Physical aptitude: Eurofit test battery: - Limb movement speed (Plate Tapping Test) - Static arm strength (Handgrip Test) - Running speed and agility (Shuttle Run) - Balance (Flamingo Balance) - Flexibility (Sit and Reach) - Explosive power of the legs (Standing Broad) - Trunk Strength (30-s Sit-ups) - Muscular resistance (Bent Arm Hang) Functional mobility: - Timed Up and Go - Response speed subtest of the Bruininks–Oseretsky Motor Competence Test First Edition Motor skills: - Beanbag Overhead Significant improvements in the GI in the Handgrip test (IG: 25.42 (5.53). CG: 23.92 (6.45) P 0,025), in the sit and reach (IG: 36.92 (7.22). CG: 29.46 (10.53) P 0,014), in the standing broad (IG: 99.33 (29.49). CG: 90.69 (35.20) P < 0,001) and in the Bruininks–Oseretsky First Edition test (IG: 4.67 (2.81). CG: 4.77 (2.17) P 0.028) Significant differences between groups were identified in the plate tapping test (P 0.045), shuttle run (P 0.014), sit and reach (P 0.027), standing broad (P 0.003), 30-s sit-ups (P 0.040) and timed up and go (P 0.049) No significant differences in the handgrip test (P 0.837), flamingo balance (P 0.477), bent arm hang (P 0.086), Bruininks–Oseretsky First Edition (P 0.265), neither in the beanbag overhead nor in the hand right P 0.150 nor in the left P 0.083 Boer and de Beer (2019)2 South Africa 23 adults. Age 31.4 ± 7.4 years IG: 13 participants (8 men, 5 women) CG: 10 participants (5 men, 5 women) IG: Aerobic exercise in aquatic environment. Aquatic training. Sessions controlled and monitored by test instructors and senior Human Movement Sciences students (approximately one test instructor per two participants) CG: No intervention additional to ADLs Mode: Aquatic training with arm circle exercises, lateral twists, walk in place, run in place, water scoops, lateral leg raises, back flutter kick, stomach flutter kick, jumping jacks, knee twists, side shift, squat jumps, lunge jumps, and longer jog, 1.4-m-deep pool Duration: 6 weeks, 35 min the first 3 weeks, 45 min the last 3 weeks. Consider a 3-min warm up and 2-min cool down Frequency: 3 times/week Static Balance: - Balance on one leg Dynamic Balance: - Walk on a balance beam Functional fitness: - 6MWD - 8-ft up and go Muscular strength: - Sit-to-stand test -Curl‐up modified -Isometric push-up Static Balance: No significant differences P > 0.05 in the static balance IG: 6.6 (3.5). CG: 5.1 (3.6), nor dynamic IG: 5.6 (0.8). CG: 4.6 (2.1) Functional fitness: Significant differences between groups P < 0.05 for the 6MWD test: IG: 602.1(98.7). CG: 519. 9 (111.9). No significant differences P > 0.05 in the 8-ft up and go test: IG: .3 (0.9). CG: .5 (0.9) Muscle strength: Significant differences between groups P < 0.05 for sit-to-stand test GI: 14.5 (2.2). CG: 13.0 (1.8) and modified curl up GI: 37.9 (30.1). CG: 20.0 (28.3). Nonsignificant differences P > 0.05 for isometric push-up IG: 82.2 (50.9). CG: 36.5 (32.5) Skiba et al. (2019)13 Polonia 22 adults aged 25– 40 years, with moderate intellectual disability (IQ: 36–51). 11 men, 11 women IG: 11 participants. CG: 11 participants IG: Aerobic exercise with Nordic walking training program. The exercises were performed by a physiotherapist, who was a qualified Nordic walking instructor CG: Did not undergo any training Mode: Brisk Nordic walking Intensity: Progressed over the course of the training sessions Frequency: 3 times a week Duration: 45 min Spatiotemporal parameters (step and stride length and speed) and maximum values of angles in the ankle, knee, hip, and shoulder joints in different phases of gait: Using the Vicon 250 Optoelectronic System for Three-Dimensional Motion Analysis Gait parameters: Significant differences in the right (P 0.002) and left (P 0.038) step length as well as for the right (P 0.002) and left (P 0.001) stride length. Regarding speed, only significant changes in right leg (P 0.011) Angular values: Significant changes for the right ankle (P 0.044) in support phase. Significant changes in the left knee, with increased flexion in the phase of medium support (P 0.002), terminal support (P 0.017) and initial sway (P 0.004). The hip does not present significant changes in the right or left leg during the initial contact (P 0.649–0.755), pre-swing (P 0.054–0.165) or terminal sway (P 0.738–0.896) Significant differences in the movement of the pelvis in the sagittal plane in the medium support phase for the right limb (P 0.038) and in the initial sway phase for the left limb (P 0.043). In the frontal plane, there were significant differences in the movement of the pelvis at the maximum point of movement of the left limb (P 0.027) and at the minimum point of movement of the right (P 0.002). In the transverse plane there are no significant differences in the right or left leg Boer (2020)1 South Africa 26 adults. Age 32.7 ± 6 years (13 men, 13 women) IG: 13 participants CG: 13 participants IG: Aerobic exercise in aquatic environment. Freestyle swimming training, accompanied by lively music and strictly controlled by the main test instructor using a whistle CG: No structured intervention Mode: Freestyle swimming in a 12-m long and 1.4-m deep pool. Swim a certain length of the pool and rest while a partner completes another length in the same lane. As soon as the partner reaches the middle of the lane, the other participant is instructed to swim Frequency: 3 times/week Duration: 20 min the first 4 weeks, 26 min the last 4 weeks Static Balance: - Balance on one leg Dynamic Balance: - Walk on a balance beam Functional fitness: - 6MWD - 8-ft up and go Muscular strength: - Sit-to-stand test -Curl‐up modified -Isometric push‐up Static Balance: No significant differences (P > 0.05) in IG static balance: 5.9 (3.3). CG: 5.5 (4.1). Significant differences (P < 0.05) between groups in IG dynamic balance: 5.3 (1.2). CG: 3.5 (2.6) Functional fitness: No significant differences (P > 0.05) for the 6MWD IG test: 553.8 (106.9). CG: 503.1 (118.7). Significant differences between groups (P < 0.05) in the 8-ft up and go test: IG: 5.4 (1.0). CG: 6.0 (0.9) Muscle strength: Significant differences between groups for the three tests P < 0.05: Sit-to-stand test: IG: 14.3 (1.6). CG: 13.6 (1.6). Modified curl up: IG: 33.3 (30.1). CG: 16.6 (22.1). Isometric push up: IG: 79.8 (41.9). CG: 47.3 (35.1) Perrot et al. (2021)28 France 12 participants. Age: 35 to 64, IG: 6 participants, mean age: 49.3 CG: 6 participants, mean age: 51.4 IG: Wii based exercise program using the Nintendo Wii, a video game console with integrated motion-sensitive technology and the Nintendo Wii Balance Board to record weight and center of pressure trajectory. Each training session was supervised by the master student in adapted physical activity CG: no lifestyle changes Mode: Wii-based exercise program First period: Wii sports (Wii Tennis and Wii Bowling) Second period: Wii Fit Plus using the balance board to play Wii Soccer Headers, Wii Ski Jump, Wii Hula Hoop, and the Wii Marbles games Duration: 1 h/session for 14 weeks Frequency: 2 sessions/week Functional mobility: - TUG - TUDS Muscular endurance: The 30-s chair stand test Physical fitness: 6-Minute Walk Test Improvement in the IG was observed with large effect sizes for functional measures (p < 0.01, Cohen’s d = 2.23), muscular endurance (p < 0.05; Cohen’s d = 1.74), and physical fitness (p < 0.05, Cohen’s d = 1.39) The TUG and TUDS scores increased respectively by 15% and 12%, muscular endurance by 24%, and physical fitness by 5% Post et al. (2022)31 United States of America IG: 6 men and 5 women clinically diagnosed with Down syndrome Age: 25.8 ± 6.4 years IQ: 58.3 ± 19.7 units Mode: Light Repetition Maximum (RM) (12–15 RM), moderate (8–10 RM), and heavy (4–6 RM) for three sets. It included: warm-ups from large to smaller muscle groups (leg press, bench press, leg curl, shoulder press, bicep curls, and variations to make it enjoyable each day). Exercises were performed with machines, free weights, resistance bands, and body weight alone Duration: 45–60 min/session for 10 weeks Motor Function Testing: The TGMD-2 (short sprint, gallop, shuffle, stationary basketball dribble, catch a baseball) Flexibility: sit-and-reach test Muscular Strength: 6-repetition maximum testing for the leg press, and bench press, as well as the 30-s chair sit-to-stand test Muscular endurance: 30-s of push-ups and 30-s of sit-ups Participants significantly improved both locomotor skill (p = 0.001), object control skill (p = 0.008), and total gross motor function (p = 0.000) This intervention significantly improved sit-and-reach flexibility, 6 RM barbell bench press, 6 RM supine leg press, 30-s push-ups, 30-s sit-ups, and 30-s chair sit-to-stand metrics Cai and Baek (2022)29 China 22 adults (18 men and 4 women) with DS between 18 to 40 years IG: 11 participants CG: 11 participants IG: Basketball programme, strictly supervised, conducted in a 28-m long, 15-m wide, international standard basketball court of Basketball CG: Performed no structured exercises Mode: Basketball programme - Warm up with games for 10 min - 45 min of basic basketball skill learning (shooting, passing and handling) and physical training - Relaxing exercises for 5 min Frequency: 3 times/week Duration: 60 min/session for 24 consecutive weeks Aerobic fitness: 16-m modified shuttle-run test or PACER test Balance: - Static: standing on one leg to a maximum period of 10 s - Dynamic: number of consecutive steps (max six steps) walking on a 3.05-m balance beam that was 10.2 cm wide Muscular strength: - As many curls up as possible (maximum of 75) sliding their hands up along the upper legs to the kneecap - Standing long jump (explosive force of the lower limbs): Distance between the initial line to the heel after jumping Flexibility: The sit-and-reach test After 24 weeks there was a statistically significant improvement in all functional health variables in the IG (all featured P < 0.05) The CG had no statistically significant difference between all functional health variables except for the standing long jump (all featured P > 0.05) The IG had better flexibility, sit and-reach, modified curl-up, aerobic capacity and static and dynamic balance than the control group (P < 0.05) IG Intervention group, CG Control group, DS Down Syndrome, IQ Intelligence quotient, EMG Electromiography, ACSM American College of Sports Medicine, GMFM-88 The Gross Motor Function Measure 88, 6MWD 6-min walking distance test, ADL’S Activities of daily living. TUG: The Timed Up and Go test, TUDS Timed Up and Down Stairs test, TGMD-2 Test of Gross Motor Development version 2. Risk-of-bias assessment All included studies had some risk of bias. Three studies presented an unclear risk because there was randomization, but the method was not described17,20,32. Related to blinding only one study20 had high risk bias because participants were notified of the group they belonged to with no mention of personnel blinding. Six studies1,17,20,32,33,36 had unclear bias in blinding of outcome assess. Just one study20 had unclear risk of bias of incomplete outcome data and only two studies14,17 obtained a high risk of bias in selective outcome reporting. In other aspects assess, one study12 presented a high risk of bias due to possible confounding bias. Figures 2 and 3 summarize the information on bias risk domains.Figure 2Risk of bias graph.Figure 3Risk of bias summary. Risk of bias graph. Risk of bias summary. The methodological quality of the seven selected quasi-experimental studies2,13,19,31,34,35,37 was moderate to serious Table 2.Table 2ROBINS-I (risk of bias judgements in non-randomized studies of interventions).ConfoundingSelection of participantsClassification of interventionsDeviations from intended interventionsMissing dataMeasurement of outcomesSelection of reported resultsOverallDavis y Sinning 198733ModerateLowModerateLowLowSeriousLowSeriousAguiar et al. 200827LowLowLowLowModerateModerateModerateModerateCowley et al. 20119ModerateLowLowLowModerateSeriousLowSeriousMendonca et al. 201115LowLowLowLowModerateModerateLowModerateBoer y de Beer 20192LowLowLowLowLowModerateLowModerateTsimaras V et al. 200430LowLowLowLowLowModerateLowModeratePost E et al. 202231ModerateLowLowlowlowSeriousLowSeriousLow comparable to a well-performed randomized trial; Moderate sound for a non-randomized study, but not comparable to a rigorous randomized trial; Serious presence of important problems; Critical too problematic to provide any useful evidence on the effects of intervention; Overall risk of bias equal to the most severe level of bias found in any domain. Table 2ROBINS-I (risk of bias judgements in non-randomized studies of interventions).ConfoundingSelection of participantsClassification of interventionsDeviations from intended interventionsMissing dataMeasurement of outcomesSelection of reported resultsOverallDavis y Sinning 198733ModerateLowModerateLowLowSeriousLowSeriousAguiar et al. 200827LowLowLowLowModerateModerateModerateModerateCowley et al. 20119ModerateLowLowLowModerateSeriousLowSeriousMendonca et al. 201115LowLowLowLowModerateModerateLowModerateBoer y de Beer 20192LowLowLowLowLowModerateLowModerateTsimaras V et al. 200430LowLowLowLowLowModerateLowModeratePost E et al. 202231ModerateLowLowlowlowSeriousLowSeriousLow comparable to a well-performed randomized trial; Moderate sound for a non-randomized study, but not comparable to a rigorous randomized trial; Serious presence of important problems; Critical too problematic to provide any useful evidence on the effects of intervention; Overall risk of bias equal to the most severe level of bias found in any domain. ROBINS-I (risk of bias judgements in non-randomized studies of interventions). Low comparable to a well-performed randomized trial; Moderate sound for a non-randomized study, but not comparable to a rigorous randomized trial; Serious presence of important problems; Critical too problematic to provide any useful evidence on the effects of intervention; Overall risk of bias equal to the most severe level of bias found in any domain. Therapeutic exercise interventions used for each outcome Muscular strength This outcome was the most frequently reported within the studies included. The interventions addressed aerobic exercise in water1,2, continuous and interval aerobic exercise5, aerobic exercise14,32,33, progressive resistance exercise12,13, resistance exercise35,37, and combined exercise19,20,33,34. The duration of the interventions was between 62 and 25 weeks14 with frequencies ranging from two12,13,32 to three times a week1,2,5,14,19,20,33,34,37. The measuring instruments are shown in Table 1. Results were found in favor of interventions for abdominal strength1, increasing the number of abdominal push-ups performed. However, these results were not significant (SMD = 0.39[95% CI − 0.38–1.17]). A trend was found in favor of the experimental groups in the lower limb test (Appendix 1), where the number of times to get up and sit down on a chair in 30 s was increased1,5. However, there were no significant results after these interventions (SMD = 0.15 [95% CI −0.37–0.68]). Finally, significant results were found in the strength of both the upper (SMD = 0.74 [95% CI 0.25–1.22]) and lower limbs (SMD = 0.56 [95% CI 0.08–1.04]), regarding the interventions of combined exercise20 and progressive resistance exercise12 against the muscular strength of the upper and lower limbs (Appendix 1), with increases in the 1-repetition maximum (RM) leg press and 12-RM chest press protocols. Quasi-experimental studies using resistance13,35,37, or aerobic exercise1,2,34 also showed statistically significant differences in increasing muscle strength (Table 1). Balance Interventions used to improve balance included aerobic exercise in aquatic environment1,2 and in the terrestrial environment14,32,33, continuous and interval aerobic exercise5, and combined exercise34,36. These interventions lasted between 62 and 25 weeks14, with a frequency of two32 to three times per week. The measuring instruments are shown in Table 1. Both static and dynamic balances were assessed. For static balance, Boer et al.1 observed improvements in time maintaining balance on one leg and in the number of consecutive steps on a balance beam; however, these improvements were not significant. Regarding dynamic balance, the improvements were not significant either36. Carmeli et al.14 with aerobic exercise reported significant improvements in dynamic balance between groups p < 0.05 and finally, Cai and Baek33 with a combined exercise plan showed significant increase of dynamic and static balance. A quasi-experimental studies using aerobic exercise34 also showed statistically significant differences in dynamic balance (Table 1). Gait Two studies evaluated the effectiveness of their gait interventions13,17. The interventions applied were aerobic exercise through Nordic walking17 and progressive resistance exercise13. The measuring instruments are shown in Table 1. The interventions lasted 10 weeks with a frequency of two13 to three times per week16. Cowley et al.13 found no significant differences in gait speed after their intervention. Conversely, Skiba et al.16 found an improvement in the space–time parameters, angular changes of the limbs, and mean values of the angular deviations at the joints. Functional tasks The interventions applied included aerobic exercise in an aquatic1,2 and terrestrial32 environment, continuous and interval aerobic exercise5, progressive resistance exercise12,13, and combined exercise36. The durations ranged from 62 to 14 weeks32, with frequencies ranging from two times12,13,32 to three times per week1,2,5,36. The measuring instruments are shown in Table 1. It was found that the interventions applied for this outcome1,5 had not significant results (SMD = 0.47 [95% CI = − 0.07,1.01]) in the 6-min walk performance (Appendix 1). Similarly, the time to perform the test after the interventions was reduced in the 8-foot up and go test1,5. However, these results were not significant (SMD = − 0.48 [95% CI − 1.04–0.07]) (Appendix 1). Perrot et al.32 in a randomized clinical trial showed significant improvements in functional task using combined exercise via Nintendo Wii (Table 1). Just one quasi-experimental study using resistance exercise13 showed significant improvements in go up and down 10 steps test, or aerobic exercise also showed statistically significant differences in increasing muscle strength (Table 1). Assessment of the certainty of the evidence It was found that the certainty of evidence was low for all studies because some had a high risk of bias in the random sequence generation and an unclear risk in blinding. In other studies, the confidence intervals were wide and exceeded the no effect line and some had unclear risk of bias in 4 out of 7 criteria (Table 3).Table 3Assessment of the certainty of evidence presented for each outcome.Evaluation of certaintySummary of outcomesNo. of studiesStudy designRisk of biasInconsistencyIndirect evidenceImprecisionOther considerationsNo. of patientsEffectCertaintyTherapeutic exerciseControlRelative (95% CI)Absolute (95% CI)Aerobic exercise. Muscular strength – Sit-to-stand test (monitoring range 6–12 weeks; assessed with Number of repetitions) 2RCT1,5not seriousanot seriousnot seriousseriousbnone2629–SMD 0.15 higher(− 0.48;1.27)⨁⨁⨁◯ ModerateCombined exercise. Muscular strength—1 RM Leg press (monitoring range 10–12 weeks; assessed with Weight Lifted) 2RCT8,16Seriouscnot seriousnot seriousseriousbnone3933–SMD 0.56 higher(0.08;1.04)⨁⨁◯◯ LowCombined exercise. Muscular strength—1 RM chest press (monitoring range 10–12 weeks; assessed with Weight lifted) 2RCT8,16Seriouscnot seriousnot seriousseriousbnone3933–SMD 0.73 higher(0.25;1.22)⨁⨁◯◯ LowBalance 4RCT1,10,29,32Seriousanot seriousnot seriousseriousbnone5447Carmeli et al10 with aerobic exercise reported significant improvements in dynamic balance between groups p < 0.05. Cai et al.29 with a combined exercise plan showed significant increase of dynamic and static balance⨁⨁◯◯ LowAerobic exercise. Gait 1RCT13Seriousanot seriousnot seriousnot seriousnone1111Skiba et al. found an improvement in the space–time parameters, angular changes of the limbs, and mean values of the angular deviations at the joints⨁⨁⨁◯ ModerateCombined exercise. Functional Fitness—6 min walking distance (6MWD) (monitoring 14 weeks) 1RCT28Seriousanot seriousnot seriousNot seriousanone66Perrot et al. showed significant improvements in functional task using combined exercise via nintendo wii⨁⨁⨁◯ ModerateRCT Randomized clinical trial.aUnclear risk of bias in masking.bWide confidence intervals that pass the line of no effect.cUnclear risk of bias in 4 of 7 criteria. Table 3Assessment of the certainty of evidence presented for each outcome.Evaluation of certaintySummary of outcomesNo. of studiesStudy designRisk of biasInconsistencyIndirect evidenceImprecisionOther considerationsNo. of patientsEffectCertaintyTherapeutic exerciseControlRelative (95% CI)Absolute (95% CI)Aerobic exercise. Muscular strength – Sit-to-stand test (monitoring range 6–12 weeks; assessed with Number of repetitions) 2RCT1,5not seriousanot seriousnot seriousseriousbnone2629–SMD 0.15 higher(− 0.48;1.27)⨁⨁⨁◯ ModerateCombined exercise. Muscular strength—1 RM Leg press (monitoring range 10–12 weeks; assessed with Weight Lifted) 2RCT8,16Seriouscnot seriousnot seriousseriousbnone3933–SMD 0.56 higher(0.08;1.04)⨁⨁◯◯ LowCombined exercise. Muscular strength—1 RM chest press (monitoring range 10–12 weeks; assessed with Weight lifted) 2RCT8,16Seriouscnot seriousnot seriousseriousbnone3933–SMD 0.73 higher(0.25;1.22)⨁⨁◯◯ LowBalance 4RCT1,10,29,32Seriousanot seriousnot seriousseriousbnone5447Carmeli et al10 with aerobic exercise reported significant improvements in dynamic balance between groups p < 0.05. Cai et al.29 with a combined exercise plan showed significant increase of dynamic and static balance⨁⨁◯◯ LowAerobic exercise. Gait 1RCT13Seriousanot seriousnot seriousnot seriousnone1111Skiba et al. found an improvement in the space–time parameters, angular changes of the limbs, and mean values of the angular deviations at the joints⨁⨁⨁◯ ModerateCombined exercise. Functional Fitness—6 min walking distance (6MWD) (monitoring 14 weeks) 1RCT28Seriousanot seriousnot seriousNot seriousanone66Perrot et al. showed significant improvements in functional task using combined exercise via nintendo wii⨁⨁⨁◯ ModerateRCT Randomized clinical trial.aUnclear risk of bias in masking.bWide confidence intervals that pass the line of no effect.cUnclear risk of bias in 4 of 7 criteria. Assessment of the certainty of evidence presented for each outcome. SMD 0.15 higher (− 0.48;1.27) SMD 0.56 higher (0.08;1.04) SMD 0.73 higher (0.25;1.22) RCT Randomized clinical trial. aUnclear risk of bias in masking. bWide confidence intervals that pass the line of no effect. cUnclear risk of bias in 4 of 7 criteria. Discussion This systematic review assessed the effect of different types of physical exercise on the motor function of adult DS individuals. Among the types of exercise identified in the literature reviewed to improve muscle strength, balance, and gait are aerobic exercise in different modes, such as aquatic, judo, bicycle, and walking. Modes with mechanotherapy equipment were included within the muscle strength exercise, and endless treadmills and elliptical bike were mainly included within the cardiovascular resistance exercises. Physical exercise is important throughout life because it improves the health38. Physical exercise also has a therapeutic objective for DS individuals as they may require exercise-based clinical interventions throughout their life to improve physical abilities, such as muscle strength, flexibility, and balance39. These diminished physical abilities in DS individuals hinder the performance of ADL and impact their quality of life40. Three studies included muscle strength as an outcome. Aguiar et al.31 found no differences between the initial and final measurements after a judo training program, while Boer1 and Boer and de Beer2 observed an increase in muscle strength with aquatic aerobic exercise, as did Boer and Moss5 with a bike or treadmill workout. However, the impact of aerobic exercise on increasing muscle strength remains controversial41. The American College of Sports Medicine recommends combining the intensity, volume, and frequency of training to improve muscle strength in young, middle-aged, and older populations and to optimize muscle hypertrophy and strength gains38,42. Vigorous training intensity and/or high training frequency, however, may be difficult to include in a training program for DS individuals owing to their characteristic comorbidities as well as in older adults. Studies in other populations have reported improvements in muscle hypertrophy, and thus, in muscle strength among younger and older adults after engaging in a single type and mode of physical exercise that includes walking43,44 and riding a bicycle45,46, which is consistent with the findings of this review. Aerobic exercise and the exercise combination were used to improve balance in adults with DS in aquatic mode2, with treadmill14, basketball33 and bicycle5, and differences were reported only for the intervention in aquatic mode and with exercise combination. Earlier studies have shown the mechanisms underlying this type of exercise that can improve balance, considering that the aquatic environment can stimulate an increase in the strategies and postural adjustments necessary for the execution of different movements47. This improves the quality of motor function by improving muscle strength and balance48. The ability to walk and do ADL depends on being able to control dynamic and static balance, thus requiring the control of the trajectory of center of pressure49. Improvements in balance after resistance exercise have been attributed mostly by enhanced muscle strength, neural function and force control, as muscle torque is required to maintain balance50, thus, exercise training without a specific balance component may be effective in improving balance control due to a direct influence on muscle mass and strength. It would be important to consider the specificity principle of training, improvements in balance would be amplified by adding balance training in both static and dynamic conditions using neuromuscular exercise in combination with aerobic or resistance exercise (neuromuscular exercise)51. There were no differences in functional fitness between aerobic exercise in the aquatic or terrestrial modes. Studies including resistance exercise did not assess this outcome. Functional fitness is a construct in which all the physical abilities, which were also included as outcomes in this review, including muscle strength, balance, and posture, and other outcomes, which were not prioritized in this review, such as flexibility and mobility, were included. Physical exercise should enhance all of these abilities for an impact on functional fitness49. On the other hand, the benefits of strength may not transfer effectively to concomitant improvements in functional outcomes such as balance, functional tasks, or activities of daily living52. The contradictory evidence may be due to differences in training intensity, frequency, type of resistance training, equipment (such as free weights or resistance machines), and types of measurements used to evaluate balance, strength and ADL. Among the limitations of this study, we can mention the methodological limitations of the studies included. All the studies included met at least one of the criteria for unclear risk of bias and 9 out of 12 studies met at least one criterion for high risk of bias. This is consistent with the certainty of evidence for each of the outcomes proposed in this study, as it was low for all the outcomes included. This is partly attributable to the methodological limitations already stated, but also to the imprecision of the studies, possibly due to the small sample sizes included in the primary studies53. On the other hand. The meta-analyses report very low statistical heterogeneity or in some cases 0 according to the I2, although there is clearly clinical heterogeneity in the included primary studies. These meta-analyses were performed with a small number of primary studies, which may explain the results obtained in the assessment of heterogeneity. It should be taken into account that within the statistical test used to assess heterogeneity is χ2 (Chi-square) and the inconsistency index or I2. Both tests are influenced by the number of studies included in the meta-analyses, therefore, it is possible that the limited number of studies influence the results of the test and these are interpreted as homogeneous when in fact the opposite may occur. It is necessary that the reader and decision maker keep this information in mind when analyzing the findings of systematic reviews with meta-analyses54. The strengths of this systematic review are having analyzed the effectiveness and prescription parameters of the different types of therapeutic exercise that can be used in people with DS. As a limitation, no sensitivity analysis was performed nor was publication bias explored due to the small sample size of the studies and the low number of studies included in the meta-analysis. Future research can study the effect of different types of exercise on clinical rehabilitation goals among adult DS individuals. Studies with robust research designs and sample sizes consistent with the effect measure are required to evaluate the effects of exercise on the physical abilities of DS individuals. Conclusions There is low certainty of the evidence for the outcomes proposed in this review. Therapeutic exercise, however, could be effective in improving muscle strength and gait functionality. Standardized instruments that measure the outcomes in motor function and research of better methodological quality that assess the effectiveness of the exercise prescription parameters are required. This would facilitate the evaluation of the effectiveness of the intervention as well as decision-making in the practice regarding the type of exercise that would be indicated for each patient according to his or her therapeutic needs. Supplementary Information Supplementary Information. Supplementary Information.