Understanding the One Belt One Road Initiative (BRI) influence on exportations of Chinese smartphones: The moderating role of the GDP per capita Authors: Karamoko N’da, Jiaoju Ge, Steven Ji-Fan Ren, Jia Wang, László Vasa, László Vasa, László Vasa Published: 2023 ABSTRACT The One Belt One Road Initiative (BRI) has been the subject of multitudinous studies from various angles. Most previous studies have focused on BRI’s economic, geopolitical, or commercial implications for China. However, the few studies that focused on BRI’s influence on the exportations or importations of Chinese products via the Chinese Cross-border Electronic Commerce Market (CCBECM) have been carried out based only on authors’ opinions rather than on empirical evidence. Therefore, the actual effect of BRI on the exportations of Chinese product brands via CCBECM in BRI countries still needs to be discovered. Utilizing B2C exportation data of Chinese smartphones and a Difference-in Difference Model (DIDM), we have first examined the actual and direct impact of BRI policy on Chinese smartphone brands exportations via the Chinese Cross-border Electronic Commerce Market (CCBECM) from 2012 to 2019 in BRI countries. Secondly, we assessed the moderating role of GDP per capita (GDP) and Internet Access Rate (IAR) between BRI policy and exportations of Chinese smartphone brands. The results showed that the impact of BRI remains insignificant on the exportations of Chinese smartphones via CCBECM in BRI countries. However, it could be significant if BRI includes more developed and economically strong countries. The study also highlighted a negative moderating role of GDP per capita between BRI policy and exportations, showing that the higher the BRI effect is, the less GDP per capita will influence Chinese smartphone exportations in BRI countries. Introduction With the lack of local industries and suppliers able to satisfy local demands, most consumers in emerging and developing countries rely only on Cross-Border E-Commerce (CBEC) markets to purchase lacking products on local markets. As a result, CBEC has become an essential transaction means between buyers and sellers worldwide. It is also an essential factor of economic growth for countries like China that understand the need to implement policies, such as the One Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), to boost that sector [1]. According to several scholars, the implementation of the BRI has provided a tremendous means for the growth of the Chinese Cross-border E-Commerce Market (CCBECM) [2] and excellent facilities for BRI countries in terms of easy access to Chinese products [3,4]. Initially announced by President Xi Jinping as a financial and trade cooperation project between China and countries members [3–5], BRI policy has been studied by many researchers from various angles, such as the geopolitics angle [6–11], economic and financial angle [12–17], infrastructural angle [18,19], cultural angle [20–22], energetic angle [23,24], environmental angle [25,26], and domestic politics angle [27]. However, some of those studies have strongly criticized the BRI policy, as they claim to see hidden diplomatic-geopolitical ambitions behind the project [7,8]. Those studies claimed that the BRI policy stake is to assert a more active foreign policy based on the new vision of the Chinese world order, which is interconnected capitalism. Therefore, BRI could be seen as an effort to strengthen China’s diplomatic and political presence in BRI countries [28]. This point of view is also that of several world organizations led by the West, such as the G7, which describes the BRI as one of the essential links in "debt trap diplomacy" [29]. Therefore, on June 26th, 2022, during the penultimate G7 summit, the group of seven most industrialized countries pledged to raise about US$600 billion in funds over the next five years to counter the BRI initiative and replace it with the newly global project named "Partnership for Global Infrastructure and Investment" to finance needed infrastructure in developing countries [29]. However, other studies pointed out that the BRI primarily aims to support China’s domestic economic growth by promoting sectors such as CCBECM to find new outlets and opportunities for Chinese industry and product brands [2–5]. Those studies claimed that implementing the BRI has contributed to boosting CCBECM. In this perspective, Hou et al. [2] stated that the advent of BRI has provided great opportunities for the growth of CCBECM. Mou et al. [30], argued that given the objective of BRI, which is to assist Chinese companies located along the BRI road to expand their market, the contribution of CCBECM will be necessary to achieve such an objective. Therefore, BRI could contribute to maintaining the increasing development of the CCBECM [31]. However, Ding et al. [32] consider that the contribution of BRI to the development of the CCBECM will depend on BRI countries’ socio-economic development through factors such as logistics infrastructures and internet access. Theoretically, some other studies have tried to explain the influence of BRI on Chinese cross-border activities. Thus, in examining the connection between Beijing’s investments in BRI nations and BRI nations’ exportations of Chinese products, Ding et al [32] found that China’s investments in BRI countries could theoretically explain Chinese product brand exportations through CCBECM. Thanks to investments in logistics and socio-economic infrastructures, the GDP of those countries increased, and those countries exported more Chinese products [32]. Therefore, BRI could bring significant opportunities to both China and BRI countries [5]. Yin and Choi [33] and Qi et al.[34] also argued that since implementing the BRI policy, CCBECM has experienced extremely rapid growth of about 27.03% of the growth rate every year. With that growth, China is now the first B2C CBEC market worldwide, with about 40% of the global share [35], especially in B2C sales of Chinese smartphones through the CBEC market [2]. However, despite the market’s unprecedented growth since BRI policy implementation, literature has remained silent regarding the actual impact of BRI policy on the exportations of Chinese smartphone brands through B2C CCBECM in BRI countries. Therefore, this study intends to examine the actual effect of BRI policy on Chinese smartphone brands’ exportations across BRI countries by investigating the following questions: Did the BRI policy influence the exportations of Chinese smartphone brands through B2C CCBECM in BRI countries since the implementation of the BRI? If not, why is that so? What factors could moderate the BRI policy impact? To provide answers to these research questions, we investigated, in addition to the BRI policy impact, the moderating effects of two macroeconomic factors (i.e., the Internet Access Rate (IAR) and GDP per capita (GDP)) between BRI policy and exportations of Chinese smartphone brands in BRI countries. In doing so, we avoid any diplomatic and geopolitical vision of the BRI policy and look only at its actual impact on the exportation of Chinese smartphones. Therefore, this study could provide valuable information to better understand the BRI policy impact on Chinese smartphone exportations through CCBECM in BRI countries. According to Hou et al. [2], among several Chinese product brand categories, Chinese smartphones are the most purchased through CCBECM after implementing BRI. Therefore, this current study focuses on Chinese smartphones exported through B2C CCBECM. The BRI project classifies countries into two groups: BRI countries and non-BRI countries. These two groups of countries are treatment groups and control groups, respectively [36]. Thus, utilizing a Difference-in Difference Model (DIDM), the result showed that the impact of the BRI policy on the exportations of Chinese smartphone brands via CBECM remains weak across BRI countries. However, it could be significant if the BRI could include more developed and economically strong countries. Fig 1 presents the theoretical model. Theoretical model. The remaining study is organized as follows: First, we examined the relevant literature related to BRI and CCBECM and analyzed how our study extends previous studies. Next, we presented the data description and developed a theoretical model, i.e., DIDM, to evaluate the impact of the BRI policy on exports of Chinese smartphone brands. Then, we analyzed and discussed the results. We ended the paper with theoretical contributions, conclusions and research limitations. 2. Literature review and hypotheses development In recent years, with the increasing development of international trade between countries associated with the rapid digitalization of societies, consumers are increasingly shopping abroad [31]. As a result, the development of CCBECM has accelerated considerably [37]. Meanwhile, BRI, which is seen as China’s new strategic cooperation policy intended to support China’s cross-border activities, got much attention [38]. Most studies have analyzed the BRI project mainly from the perspectives of diplomatic, economic, and geopolitical deployment strategies [20–39]. According to those studies, the sole objective of this project is to promote China’s diplomatic, economic, and geopolitical vision. Other studies also analyzed BRI’s impact on Chinese international trade and found a positive effect, e.g. [38–41]. Moreover, in the literature, many authors’ claims exist on the potential influence of the BRI policy on CCBECM. Some of these claims have indicated that BRI could reshape the dynamic of the CCBECM because the BRI has a strong influence on that market [31]. However, only some studies attempted to empirically verify the relationship between BRI policy impact and trade through CCBECM. The few studies that investigated that relationship focused on CCBECM and its related factors rather than BRI policy impact, e.i [30–32]. The literature on the relationship between BRI policy and CBECM could be classified mainly according to two perspectives: (1) authors’ opinions, e.i, [2–32], and (2) empirical studies, e.i, [33]. Regarding authors’ opinions, Hou et al. [2] and Xiao et al. [31] argued that the BRI had boosted Chinese international trade through CCBECM. Mou et al [30], examining buyers’ repurchase intentions through CCBECM, argued that BRI could significantly support the CCBECM in assisting Chinese companies located along the Silk Road to enter the global market. However, all these previous studies failed to provide any empirical shreds of evidence to support their claims. Accordingly, previous authors’ claims were more opinions than conclusions from empirical results. Therefore, the literature lacks empirical evidence regarding the BRI policy’s actual impact on exports of Chinese product brands via CCBECM. That lack of empirical evidence may be due to the lack of data or past studies’ incapability to propose a framework to empirically evaluate the actual impact of BRI policy on the export of Chinese products via the CCBECM. To the best of our knowledge, the only study that investigated the relationship between BRI policy and CCBECM was the study of Yin and Choi [33]. After BRI implementation, they analyzed the impacts of China’s cross-border online commerce on Chinese services and product exportations. They featured that CBEC decidedly affects service exportations more than products. However, it is critical to point out that the study of Yin and Choi [33] was not a study of the direct impact of BRI policy on CBEC exportations but rather an attempt to assess the export volumes of services and goods in BRI countries after BRI implementation. To summarize: (1) although scholars have extensively argued that BRI policy has or could significantly impact Chinese international trade through CCBECM, authors have not provided sufficient and robust empirical evidence to support their claim. (2) A very limited number of studies investigated the direct effect of BRI policy on the exportations of Chinese smartphone brands via CCBECM in BRI countries. We believe there is a need for a deeper study to clarify the debate on the actual and direct impact of the BRI policy on the export of Chinese products, such as smartphones, via CBECM within BRI countries. Therefore, this study intends to examine the actual effect of the BRI policy on the exportations of Chinese smartphone brands in BRI countries through the CCBECM since the implementation of this policy. 2.1 BRI and Chinese smartphone exportations via CCBECM As an international commercial trade between companies or individuals from various nations using international electronic marketplaces to purchase and sell while relying on the global logistics network to deliver goods, CBEC results in significant cost savings on transaction costs [33]. Its substantial savings on transaction costs are most often related to communications, market research, and administration. Encouraged in emerging economies like China, CBEC has since enabled Chinese exporters and brands to overcome the constraints linked to isolation from potential markets, limited access to information, and high entry costs in the traditional international market [33]. With this, the CCBECM generated about 11 trillion RMB from its advent to 2019, thus creating thousands of dozens of jobs in China and outside China (as most of the sellers on CCBECMs, like Alibaba, AliExpress, Etc., are sellers from outside China). As a result, CCBECM has become a vital transaction means worldwide. Its impact on international trade was even more significant during the COVID-19 outbreak, when CCBECM had become almost the only international transaction framework in China, allowing suppliers to meet buyers’ needs worldwide. It is, therefore, an industry essential to global and Chinese economic growth. As a new Chinese cooperation model between countries members and China, BRI is designed to support reciprocal commercial preferentiality [36]. As a result, supporting CCBECM in BRI countries has been identified as one of the key goals of BRI policy [33]. That objective promotes CCBECM as part of the BRI implementation across BRI countries by constructing infrastructures such as warehouses [31–33]. Those infrastructures are set up to assist and provide more facilities for Chinese companies to export to BRI countries [33]. Since then, the Chinese government has been trying to gain new trade partners to maintain the development of its international trade [31–41]. Thus, one of BRI’s missions from the beginning was to support the development of the CCBECM, which is known to affect the growth of Chinese international trade [32]. Therefore, studying BRI’s impact on exports of Chinese smartphones through CCBECM can be considered an important research topic for BRI policy, Chinese companies and Chinese smartphone brands that strive to find new market opportunities in BRI countries [33–30]. Several researchers have seen the BRI as an essential policy for China at the economic and trade level, e.g. [31–41]. Since then, BRI policy has become a proliferating research subject in Chinese international offline and online trade literature [31]. Researchers stated that the contribution of CCBECM in the exports of Chinese product brands would be necessary to achieve the BRI objectives [33]. Those objectives consist of assisting Chinese companies and brands in expanding and finding new markets across BRI countries [29]. Yin and Choi [33] argued that since the BRI policy was put forward, the CCBECM has experienced extremely rapid growth by exporting Chinese manufactured products to BRI countries. Therefore, BRI could contribute to maintaining the growing exportation of Chinese products through the CCBECM [30]. In the case of offline international trade, most existing research found a positive effect of the BRI policy on Chinese product export activities. For instance, in simulating the impact of BRI policy on China’s trade performance, [41] highlighted a positive effect of BRI policy on Chinese international trade promotion. However, they pointed out that without the impact of the BRI policy, China’s exports would have remained constant. Yu et al. [40], utilizing a DIDM, highlighted that since BRI implementation, the index of bilateral trade preferences between China and BRI countries had increased about 8% faster than that of non-BRI countries. Exploring the potential impact of BRI policy on trade flows between China and ASEAN nations from 2000 to 2016, Foo et al. [38] has also found a positive and significant influence of the BRI policy on commercial flows. This current study focuses exclusively on the B2C model of CCBECM. China is at the top B2C CBECM worldwide, with a market share estimated at $1,156bn in 2018 [35–42]. As a result, the B2C CCBECM has become a core pillar of China’s international electronic trade [29–33]. That trade mode is considered the fastest way to export Chinese smartphones outside China [43]. Allowing international consumers to access several types of Chinese product brands (e.g., electronic devices, smartphones, clothes, shoes, household goods, Etc.) [35]. Among those products, research showed that smartphones were the most exported through CCBECM [2–44]. However, despite those unprecedented exports of smartphones through CCBECM, little research has been interested in it. Therefore, we focused on Chinese smartphone products to carry out our investigation. In the literature on the relationship between BRI policy and smartphone exports to BRI countries through CBECM, one notes several claims from previous studies without any empirical evidence. For instance, Yang and Asbury [45] claimed the advent of BRI provided great opportunities to Chinese smartphones regarding their purchases and promotions within-country members. In studying different countries’ preferences for Chinese smartphone exportations via CCBECM, [2] argued that the advent of BRI has provided great opportunities for purchasing Chinese smartphone brands through CCBECM. However, despite all these claims, we note in the previous literature a lack of empirical studies demonstrating the impact of the BRI policy on Chinese smartphone exportations through the CCBECM in BRI countries. Most often, the relationship between BRI policy and CCBECM activities associated with international trade has been explained from the perspective of DIDM (e.g. [36]). This model is one of the most popular policy evaluation methods and can easily isolate the "policy effect" from the "time effect" by eliminating errors caused by imperceptible time factors [36]. Based on that method, various studies on the impact of BRI policy on Chinese cross-border activities and international trade have reported a positive effect [40]. Yu et al. [40] highlighted a positive impact of the BRI policy on China’s trade level in BRI countries. In examining BRI countries’ participation in global value chains (GVCs), Wu et al. [36] found a positive and significant impact between BRI policy and BRI countries’ participation in GVCs. Therefore, based on previous empirical research results, the BRI policy could positively influence the B2C export of Chinese smartphone products in BRI countries via CCBECM. Hence, we hypothesize that: Hypotheses 1: BRI policy’s implementation has positively influenced China’s B2C exportations of smartphones. 2.2 Moderator effect: Internet Access Rate (IRA) With the advent of the Internet and digital technologies, cross-border e-commerce is booming, allowing suppliers, sellers, and consumers to transact from different locations worldwide [46]. Research points out that countries intending to develop the CBEC industry need good internet coverage as a prerequisite [46,47]. That is because easier internet access within a country can encourage citizens to engage more in CBEC [46]. In this regard, Yin and Choi [33] defines internet access in the case of cross-border e-shopping as a means for international buyers to access e-commerce platforms to order products and have them delivered using the global logistics system. Internet access, therefore, can be seen as a prerequisite for the practice of the CBEC industry within a country. The effect of the Internet on the e-commerce industry has been extensively examined in many studies. Furthermore, most have found positive relationships between the Internet and offline and online trade practices [47]. Nuruzzaman and Weber [46] showed that companies with internet access exported more than those lacking internet access. The report explains that exportations are increasing because the Internet makes it simpler for companies to interact with purchasers. In studying the Internet impact on bilateral commerce flows between 21 underdeveloped countries and OECD countries, Xing [48] shows that Internet access is crucial for developing CBEC in underdeveloped countries. Osnago and Tan, in the report of the World Trade Organization [47], highlighted that the Internet has a significant impact on exportations. Based on bilateral trade data, Rodríguez-Crespo and Martínez-Zarzoso in the report of Nuruzzaman and Weber [46], found that internet use promotes product exportations. In exploring China’s exportations through CCBECM to nations along the Belt Road, Ding et al. [32] showed internet access was among the top indicators influencing the exportation scales of BRI nations. Based on the literature reviewed here, it can be concluded that the Internet Access Rate (IRA) could be one of the key factors influencing cross-border exportations, whether online or offline. In the BRI policy case, it is evident that most BRI countries are developing and emerging countries. That means their ability to access the Internet is a little tricky. Therefore, the ability of BRI countries to conduct cross-border electronic transactions may be less intense than that of countries with a high capacity to access the Internet. Hence, IAR may weaken international buyers’ exportability of BRI countries due to the low level of their country’s IAR. As a result, IAR may negatively alter the relationship between the BRI policy effect and Chinese product brand exportations through CCBECM. Therefore, we formulated the following hypothesis: Hypothesize 2: The Internet Access Rate (IRA) moderates the influence of BRI policy on B2C exportations of Chinese smartphones via CCBECM in BRI countries, such that the relationship will be weakened when the IAR is lower. 2.3 Moderator effect: GDP per capita Macroeconomic factors, such as GDP per capita, have been considered by several studies to be key factors in understanding and evaluating countries’ exporting capacities in the cross-border e-commerce framework [49]. For that reason, the researchers concluded that CBEC transactions should be analyzed from the perspective of variables, such as the DGP per capita [49,50]. These researchers start from the reason that richness levels estimated by GDP per capita are fundamental for internet shopping practices in a country [51]. According to Lu [52], buyers always purchase according to their purchasing power. Purchasing power is measured at each country level from macroeconomic indicators, such as GDP per capita. Several academic research mentioned that GDP per capita influences e-commerce adoption within a country as it determines consumer purchasing power [53,54]. Anvari and Norouzi [53] and He and Wang [54] showed a positive influence of GDP per capita on CBEC transactions. Gibbs et al. [51] supported this view, showing that GDP per capita explains more than half of e-commerce sales variance. In studying exportations through CCBECM to nations along the Belt Road, Ding et al. [32] showed that GDP was among the top indicators influencing the exportation scales via CCBECM. Likewise, other studies showed that GDP per capita is an essential indicator for measuring the purchasing capacity of a product such as a smartphone worldwide [55,56]. Based on the above studies’ findings, we believe GDP per capita can favour exportations of Chinese smartphone brands via CCBECM. However, as most BRI countries are developing and emerging countries, their GDP per capita could have a negative effect on their exportation capability. That implies that the capacity of consumers from BRI countries to conduct cross-border electronic transactions may be low due to their low level of wealth measured by the GDP per capita. Therefore, we believe that the BRI countries’ GDP per capita level may negatively alter the relationship between the effect of the BRI policy and the B2C exportations of Chinese smartphones through the CCEBM. Therefore, we formulate the following hypothesis: Hypothesize 3: The GDP per Capita moderates the influence of BRI policy on B2C exportations of Chinese smartphones via CCBECM in BRI countries, such that the relationship will be weakened when GDP per capita is low. 3. Method and material 3.1 Research methodology and theoretical model To quantitatively ascertain the effect of BRI policy on the exportations of Chinese smartphones in BRI nations via the CCBECM, we used the DIDM. First revealed on September 7, 2013, by President Xi Jinping, the BRI project divided countries into BRI and non-BRI countries. Therefore, these two groups of countries can be seen as treatment and control groups, respectively [40]. Accordingly, the period before 2014 may be considered the pre-policy period, while the period from 2014 to 2019 is viewed as the post-policy period. To reach our goal, we first ran a standard OLS model. We first pooled the data before and after the policy implementation by ignoring the time variable. We did so to get the reference point for comparison to evaluate the BRI policy’s effect. As highlighted by several scholars, macroeconomic indicators need to be taken into account when it comes to investigating countries’ engagement in CBEC transactions [49]. We integrated countries’ development level indicators into the equation to control differences between countries’ economic situations. Hence, we specified the standard OLS regression equation as follows: EXPORTit=α+βPOLICYit+ζxit+ϵit (1) Where EXPORTit is the Chinese smartphone exportations in OBORI countries via the CCBECM in year t. POLICYit is a binary variable that equals 1 if a sample country (i) is a member of BRI policy, and 0 otherwise. α is the constant term. β represents the coefficient of the treatment group (BRI policy). ζ and xit are the coefficient and the variable of countries development levels (status). Afterwards, we ran the DID regression model by integrating the time variable. We described the DID regression as follows: EXPORTit=α+βPOLICYit+ηPostpit+θ(POLICYit*Postpit)+γnxit+ϵit (2) In this equation, Postpit is a binary variable that equal to 1 if t is a post-policy period, and 0 otherwise; POLICYit*Postpit is the interaction term, and equal to 1 if a country i is a member of BRI policy (treatment group) during the post-policy period, and 0 if not. η is the coefficient of the year fixed effects. γn and xit are the coefficients and variables of countries development level (status) and ϵit represents the error terms. The DIDM is based on two key assumptions: (1) the random sampling of the treatment group and (2) the parallel trend assumption. Concerning the first assumption, we believe that that assumption is satisfied. The BRI, a project intended to open China to the world, has integrated countries with diverse potentiality in politico-socio-economic power. For instance, as an emerging country and the second world military superpower, Russia is a member of the initiative, like small countries such as Bangladesh or Djibouti, to name a few. Therefore, there is no proof that China might have picked BRI nations dependent on their political or financial powers [40]. Regarding the second assumption (2), Fig 2 provides visual support, showing that the exportations of BRI and non-BRI countries (NBRI) have experienced almost the same exportation trends before and after implementing the BRI. One may observe that after the implementation of BRI (2014–2019), the exportations of the treatment group (BRI countries) and control group (non-BRI countries) have followed almost the same trends. However, exportation in non-BRI countries (control group) was higher than that of the treatment group (BRI countries). BRI and non-BRI countries export trends. After running the DIDM, we further ascertain the possible source of the differential influence of BRI policy on exports based on countries’ socio-economic indicators. To this end, we evaluated the moderating effect of two main socio-economic variables on exportations. Namely, IAR and their GDP per capita. As stated by Nolan et al. [49] and Li [57], these two variables constitute important pillars to understanding countries’ exportations through a CBEC market. 3.2 Research context, data description and variable measurements Research context With BRI implementation, China has become one of the essential electronic markets, offering excellent opportunities to Chinese smartphone brands worldwide [2]. According to Hou el al. [2], Chinese smartphone brands are the most purchased worldwide among Chinese product brand categories in the context of BRI. The market for Chinese smartphones is large. Out of the 76 brands of smartphones worldwide, China alone accounts for more than 12 smartphone brands, such as Huawei, Xiaomi, Meizu, Oppo, VIVO, and Coolpad [58]. In this current study, we focused on only three of them, i.e., Huawei, Xiaomi, and Oppo, because of their popularity within the CCBECM. These brands enter the global market with a strategy of affordable prices, which increases their market shares, especially across developing and emerging countries. For instance, in 2016, Huawei smartphones were sold in around 170 countries [59]. In the second quarter of 2018, Huawei was ranked as the No.1 smartphone brand in China, with a 28.1% market share. By the end of 2018, Huawei and Xiaomi were among the best five-selling smartphone brands in the Chinese market [60]. At the same time, Huawei sold around 30.72 million smartphones with a 28.6% share, followed by Xiaomi, which sold about 12.61 million products with an 11.7% share. According to a report of Gartner [60], due to the global pandemic, while the worldwide smartphone market has experienced a decline in turnover of about 20%, Xiaomi has been the only brand that experienced growth in the first quarter of 2020 [60,61]. The report highlights that Xiaomi is the only smartphone brand that has managed to avoid a drop in turnover among the five major worldwide smartphone brands. Xiaomi recorded growth of 1.4% from 2019 to the first quarter of 2020, positioning itself as the third-largest phone brand globally ahead of Apple, with 12.1% of sales in the third quarter of 2020. Meanwhile, Huawei and Oppo sales decreased by 21.3% and 2.3%, respectively. 3.3 Data description and variables Based on data at our disposal and BRI countries’ list from the study of [14], 28 countries were set as the treatment or experimental group (BRI countries) and 41 non-BRI countries as the control group. The dataset consists of B2C export data via CCBECM from 2012 to 2019. The data used mainly comes from www.aliexpress.com and [62]. Through Aliexpress.com, Chinese product brands are sold online in B2C mode to international markets. The data was collected by Google’s programming language and Webharvy’s software. Data consists of 3 leading Chinese smartphone brands purchased by consumers from 69 countries (BRI and Non-BRI countries): Huawei, Xiaomi, and Oppo. Each brand is made up of several categories of mobile phones. Data source The data source for this study is the AliExpress platform, which we got from www.aliexpress.com. AliExpress is one of the platforms intended to promote CCBECM outside country borders. As an internationally leading platform for B2C sales, the AliExpress platform sells to about 150 million consumers from 190 countries worldwide [57]. With more than 2.4 billion visitors every year and over 100 million products [57]. It is made of about 1.1 million e-sellers located in China and outside China (Affiliated stores) [57]. Most of the sellers on the platform are retailers rather than manufacturers, and they obtain products from factories across China for reselling to international buyers [57]. Therefore, this platform somehow constitutes a gateway between Chinese smartphone brands and global consumers. The dependent variable This study examines whether the BRI policy has influenced the B2C exportations of Chinese smartphones through CCBECM in BRI countries since implementing the BRI policy. Thus, this article aims to look at the real impact of BRI policy on the exportation of Chinese smartphones into BRI nations. Furthermore, it provides empirical evidence to support or refute the opinions or claims of previous authors regarding the BRI’s potential impact on exportations of Chinese smartphone brands in BRI countries. Therefore, the main dependent variable is exportations ("EXPORT"). The dependent variable measures the exportations towards BRI countries of the three leading Chinese smartphone product brands (e.i., Huawei, Xiaomi, and Oppo) through CCBECM from 2012 to 2019. The independent variable The main independent variable of the study is BRI policy ("Policy"). To measure the impact of the BRI policy, we used the list of BRI countries from the study of [14]. We did so because the Chinese government has not officially defined the definitive list of BRI countries until now [14]. The explanatory Variable (Policy) measures whether a country is a member of the BRI policy or not. Among countries covered by the data set, 28 BRI countries represent the treatment group (coded = 1), and 41 non-BRI nations represent the control group (coded = 0). The years (2012–2019) considered in this dataset include pre- and post-BRI periods. The year 2014 is regarded as the starting year of the BRI. We coded the time: time = 0 if the year is a pre-BRI period; time = 1 if the year is a post-policy period. Another explanatory variable is the interaction term between the groups and time. Control variables The study also incorporated country development level ("Status"), Internet Access Rate (IAR), and GDP per capita (GDP) as the control variables. The World Bank classification of countries’ development levels measured the country’s development level. Thus, Lower Middle-Income countries and lower-income countries are coded as Developing countries and equal to 1; Middle-Income countries are coded as Emerging countries and equal to 2; and higher-income countries are coded as Developed countries and equal to 3. IAR and GDP per capita were obtained from the database of the [62]. Table 1 describes the study’s main variables, and Table 2 details the summary statistics of the dataset. Moreover, Tables 3 and 4 show the results of DIDM and the analysis of the moderating variables, respectively. 10.1371/journal.pone.0295307.t001Table 1Description of variables.variablesDescriptionSources EXPORT it The EXPORT level of Chinese smartphone brands by BRI countries via CCBECM www.aliexpress.com βPOLICY it BRI policy binary variable that controls for unobserved differences between groups www.aliexpress.com ηPostp it The time binary variable that controls for unobserved changes affecting both groups www.aliexpress.com θ(POLICYit*Postpit)The interaction term quantifying the effect of the treatment on the average outcome for purchase www.aliexpress.com γxit1+δyit1+ζzit1The set of Control variables controlling for observable differences within and between groups. www.aliexpress.com Description of variables. 10.1371/journal.pone.0295307.t002Table 2Summary statistics.Name of brandsNumber of product brand purchases Huawei 17767 Oppo 17485 Xiaomi 17015 Variable ObsMeanStd. Dev.MinMax EXPORT it 62193.383252.17743262 βPOLICY it 6210.4060.49101θ(POLICYit*Postpit)6210.3090.46301 ηPostp it 6210.7710.42101 γx it 6212.0050.8713 δy it 62163.5724.7624.9499.15 ζz it 62121379.0723548.2802.518118823.6 Country 6213519.932169 Region 621--114 Years 621--20122020 Summary statistics. 10.1371/journal.pone.0295307.t003Table 3Differences in differences model.Model 1Model 2VariableCoef.T value[95%Conf.Interval]Coef.T value[95% Conf. Interval] POLICY it 17.528(24.6396)0.71-30.8717 65.92741.049(37.0001)0.03-71.6309 73.7293 x it1 36.133(21.8142)1.66-6.7172 78.98232.129(28.4676)0.07-53.7913 58.0475 x it2 135.867(27.330)***4.9782.1822 189.5523101.368 (32.7989)**3.0936.9406 165.7959 x it3 107.575(18.2715)***5.8971.6839 143.465477.052(25.7455)**2.9926.4800 127.6246 Postp it 51.516(29.3027)1.76-6.0433 109.0762(POLICYit*Postpit)31.129(45.799)0.68-58.8347 121.0932R-squared0.76910.7860Adj R-squared0.76430.7643Note: Standard errors in parentheses** = p< .01*** = p< .001. Differences in differences model. Note: Standard errors in parentheses ** = p< .01 *** = p< .001. 10.1371/journal.pone.0295307.t004Table 4Moderation analysis.Model 1Model 2Model 3Model 4Model 5 POLICY 17.528(24.639)39.871(25.7659)39.871 (25.7659)40.942(26.0542)20.9519(27.372) x it1 36.1326(21.814)-82.568(41.2074)*18.971(23.7823)11.5452 (50.5391) x it2 135.8672(27.3306)***98.785(28.5927)**16.216(46.10326)116.907(27.8037)***114.099(53.4181)*** x it3 107.5747(18.2715)***96.506(37.7114)**13.938 (54.7239)116.6927 (26.947)***108.219 (55.7793)*** y it 2.459 (0.6565)****2.459 (0.6565)***2.241(1.0009)*2.874(0.6867)*** z it -0.003(0.0008)**-0.003(0.0008)**-0.003(0.0008)**-0.002(0.0008)**_cons-82.568 (41.2074)*i.POLICY##*c.yit0.317 (1.1018)i.POLICY##*c.zit-0.003(0.0014)*F(4, 548) = 22.15F(5, 546) = 6.39F(6, 546) = 18.01F(7, 545) = 15.42F(7, 545) = 16.1Prob > F0.0000.0000.0000.0000.000R-squared0.74110.55350.74110.76800.7961Adj R-squared0.73160.52660.73160.75710.7843Average marginal effectsatdy/dx Std. Err182.644 (33.39375)*1.POLICY220.952 (27.3720)3-40.740 (47.7073)Note: Standard errors in parentheses*p< .05**p< .01***p< .001. Moderation analysis. Note: Standard errors in parentheses *p< .05 **p< .01 ***p< .001. 4. Empirical results: OLS regression and Difference-in-Differences Model (DIDM) To ascertain the effect of BRI policy, we first run a simple OLS regression described in Eq (1). And the results are reported in Table 3 (Model 1). The results of Model 1 in Table 3 shows that the effect of the BRI policy on export is not significant (β = 17.5278, t. = 0.71, p>.05). However, concerning the two last control variables xit2 and xit3 representing respectively, the effect of emerging countries and developed countries they have a significant and positive impact on exportations (EXPORT) (γ2 = 135.867, t = 4.97, p< .001; γ3 = 107.575, p< .001). Model 2 (Table 3) reports estimation results of DIDM. The coefficients of the time variable (Postp), POLICY, and the interaction term (POLICYit*Postpit) are all statistically insignificant, suggesting that BRI policy implementation has not positively influenced B2C exportations of Chinese Smartphones via CCBECM in BRI countries. This finding is inconsistent with the hypothesis (H1). Therefore, hypothesis (H1) failed to be supported. 5. Moderation analysis To evaluate the moderating effect of our two macroeconomic variables, namely: Internet access rate (IAR (yit)) and Gdp per capita (GDP (zit)) on exportations (EXPORT), we proceeded in hierarchic ways (additively). Table 4 (Model 1) shows the results for the regression that includes only the POLICY (Independent variable) and countries development level variable (Status (γxit)) (control variable). In Model 2, we included all direct effects: That is to say, the independent Variable, the control variable, and our two moderators by withdrawing one of the levels e.i, xit1 of the categorical variable and running the model with the constant term. However, in Model 3, we have included all of variable of Model 2 and added the level (xit1) of the categorical Variable excluded in model 2 and ran the model without the constant term. We did so to demonstrate the equality relationship between the constant term and the level of the categorical variable excluded in model 2. As we can see from Model 2 and Model 3, the coefficient of the (xit1) is equal to the constant term (xit1 = cons = -82.568 (41.2074), p< .05) From Model 4, we started to evaluate the interaction between Policy (Independent Variable) and our two moderators (i.e., Internet access rate (IAR (yit)) and GDP per capita (GDP (zit))). In that attempt, our goal is to ascertain Exportations ((Y)) from the impact of BRIit with IAR (yit) and GDP (zit) serving as moderators of that relationship. In other words, we hypothesize that the relationship between our independent variable (POLICYit)and dependent variable Exportation (Y) is moderated by IAR (yit) and DGP (zit). Our focal independent variable Policyit is a binary variable, while IAR (yit) and DGP (zit) are continuous variables. As IAR (yit) and DGP (zit), used to create the interaction terms with independent variable POLICYit are all continuous variables and have no meaningful zero points associated with them; the simple slope tests for these predictors may be difficult to understand if zero does not fall within the range of possible values, even though the regression slope associated with the interaction terms remain significant. If zero is not a substantial value on these predictors, the intercept is meaningless during interpretation. To avoid that, we first centered (mean centering) our two moderating variables before running the interaction analysis. Next, we used the centering variables to run the interaction analysis between our POLICYit and IAR (yit) and DGP (zit), respectively. Those analyses are reported in Table 4 (models 4 and 5). In model 4, we see that the interaction term between POLICYit and IAR (yit) was not statistically significant (b = 0.317, s.e. = 1.1018, p>.05), suggesting that the relationship between the influence of BRI policy and exportations (EXPORT) is not conditional on the level of Internet Access Rate (IAR), which is inconsistent with the hypothesis (H2). Accordingly, the hypothesis (H2) failed to be supported. Next, we can see from model 5 that the interaction term between POLICYit, and DGP (zit), was negatively significant (b = -0.003, s.e. = 0.0014, p < .05), indicating that the effect of GDP (GDP per capita) is stronger on exports from Non BRI countries than BRI countries. That means the increase of the BRI policy effect will decrease the significant effect of GDP on exports. In other words, If the effect of GDP is negative on exports, its effect will be less negative with increasing the effect of the BRI policy. However, if the effect of GDP is positive, the GDP effect will be less positive with increasing the effect of the BRI policy. As a result, this finding is consistent with the hypothesis (H3). Accordingly, hypothesis (H3) is supported. Since this was significant, we probed the interaction to visualize the interaction between BRI policy and GDP at -1sd, at mean, and at +1sd on GDP (Fig 3). The blue line represents the predicted relationship between BRI policy and exports at 1sd below the mean on GDP_c (mean centring). The green line shows the predicted relationship between BRI policy and exportations at 1sd above the mean on GDP_c. And the red line is the predicted relationship between BRI policy and exportations at the mean on the GDP_c variable. We can see that at 1sd below the mean, the predicted relationship between BRI policy and exportations on GDP_c is a fairly pronounced negative relationship. At 1sd above the mean, the predicted relationship between BRI policy and exports on GDP_c has a fairly pronounced positive relationship. And at the mean, the predicted relationship between BRI policy and exportations on GDP is not much pronounced. The interaction term between BRI policy (OBORI Policy) and GDP. 6. Discussion The insignificant effect of BRI on exportations revealed in this study is opposed to the claims of most scholars, such as Hou et al. [2], who stated that implementing the BRI has contributed to boosting the exports of Chinese smartphones via CCBECM. Accordingly, as one may see from this study, the opinion of Hou et al. [2] is not supported empirically. That opinion is founded on a biased appreciation since previous studies have ignored empirically studying the BRI policy impact on the exportations of Chinese smartphone brands through CCBECM. As shown in Fig 2, the BRI policy seems to impact the exportation of Chinese smartphones to BRI countries. However, the level of those exportations is still lower compared to those from non-BRI countries. Indeed, even if the BRI could be an excellent opportunity for Chinese international trade in the future, its current impact on exports of Chinese smartphone brands is still low, as demonstrated in this study. The reason behind those insignificant outcomes could be explained by the underdevelopment level of most BRI countries. That shows that the BRI policy must include more developed and economically strong countries to influence the exports of Chinese smartphones to BRI countries significantly and offer to these countries the same advantages offered to BRI countries as part of the BRI implementation. In doing so, these developed and economically strong countries could export more Chinese smartphone brands. Regarding the moderating roles of our two main macroeconomic variables, the result showed a significant and negative moderating role of GDP per capita between BRI policy and exports. However, IAR was found to have an insignificant moderating role between BRI policy and exports. These two different results show that GDP per capita strength explains exportations of Chinese smartphone brands in BRI countries better than IAR. That result somehow highlights the strength of GDP per capita in CBEC transactions. Several previous studies, such as the studies of Nolan et al [49], Li et al. [50], and Gibbs et al [51], have already pointed out that. These previous studies have all pointed out the importance of GDP per capita in international electronic transaction studies because the economic level measured by GDP per capita is fundamental for e-shopping practice in a nation [51]. Thus, by introducing GDP per capita as a moderator between BRI policy and exportations, the study contributes to the BRI literature by showing that if the BRI is adequately implemented with all its support projects, such as the construction of port and socio-economic infrastructures, the effect of BRI could significantly reduce the impact of GDP per capita on Chinese product exports through CCBECM in the BRI countries. 7. Theoretical contributions and implications As far as BRI literature is concerned, the contribution of this study is manifold. First, unlike previous studies, our study is not based on mere opinions but on empirical evidence instead. Second, our study provides a solid theoretical contribution to the literature since there is limited research on the relationships between BRI policy and exports of Chinese smartphones through CCBECM in BRI countries since BRI policy implementation. Third, to the best of our knowledge, almost no studies focused on GDP per capita and IAR as moderators in analyzing the impact of the BRI policy on exports of Chinese smartphones. The study contributes by shedding light on the moderating role of GDP per capita and IAR in the relationship between BRI policy and exportations of Chinese smartphone brands. Thus, our theoretical framework allows decision-makers to better understand the underlying factors of Chinese smartphone exportations through CCBECM in BRI countries. Therefore, by introducing GDP per capita as a moderator between BRI policy and exportations, the study contributes to the BRI literature by showing that the higher the BRI effect, the less GDP per capita will influence Chinese smartphone product exportations in BRI countries. 8. Conclusion and limitations Utilizing DIDM to quantify the impact of the BRI on Chinese product brand exportations, the analysis showed that the BRI policy’s effect needs to be more significant to contribute to Chinese smartphone exportations within BRI countries. As shown in Fig 1, Chinese smartphone exportations have increased in BRI countries since BRI implementation. However, that growth across BRI countries is less than that of countries non-members of the BRI policy. Therefore, if the goal of the BRI is to contribute to strengthening the sale of Chinese smartphone brands, It will be necessary to promote that policy toward the developed countries since it is projected that the BRI will influence international commerce. Our model offers a more unobstructed view of the actual effect of the BRI on the exportations of Chinese smartphone brands in BRI countries. The study gives decision-makers a clear idea of the impact of BRI policy and highlights the necessary conditions to improve that impact. However, despite this study’s contribution to the literature, it has certain limitations. The first limitation of this work concerns the source of the data. Indeed, the data utilized comes from a single Chinese international online sales platform. The second limitation of this work concerns the official number of BRI countries utilized in this current study, e.i., 28 countries. New countries continue integrating the BRI policy with the geopolitical and economic dynamics. However, we could not consider those countries in this study since we only considered the BRI countries’ list available. The third limitation is the product category utilized in this study (only smartphones) since Chinese companies and brands make and sell various products to international buyers through the CCBECM. As a result, additional research could be conducted by collecting data from other or several Chinese international sales platforms with several product categories and incorporating the omitted countries in this current research to verify our results. Moreover, the data could affect our analysis and conclusions (2012–2019). First, the COVID-19 pandemic and second, the recent Russian invasion of Ukraine has also produced influences. That means policymakers would also need more recent analyses after the pandemic, from 2020–2023. Even though several scholars claimed that the implementation of the BRI had contributed to the growth of CCBECM and provided excellent business opportunities for BRI countries in terms of easy access to Chinese products, such as smartphones, this study points out that that growth in terms of smartphone exportations to BRI countries is less than that of countries that are not members of the BRI. Therefore, as BRI nations now account for only 18% of the global GDP, promoting the BRI toward developed countries will be essential if the policy’s objective is to strengthen the export of smartphones globally. Therefore, decision-makers are recommended to improve their strategies by expanding the number of BRI nations to increase the global adoption of Chinese smartphones. Supporting information (XLSX) Click here for additional data file. 6 Mar 2023 PONE-D-22-34618Understanding the One Belt One Road Initiative Policy (BRI) influence on exportations of Chinese smartphone brands in BRI countries: The moderating role of the GDP per capitaPLOS ONE Dear Dr. N'da, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by Apr 20 2023 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org. When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript:A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'.A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'.An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'.If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, please include your updated statement in your cover letter. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols. Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols. We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, László Vasa, PhD Academic Editor PLOS ONE Journal Requirements: When submitting your revision, we need you to address these additional requirements. 1. Please ensure that your manuscript meets PLOS ONE's style requirements, including those for file naming. The PLOS ONE style templates can be found at https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=wjVg/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_main_body.pdf and https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=ba62/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_title_authors_affiliations.pdf 2. We note that the grant information you provided in the ‘Funding Information’ and ‘Financial Disclosure’ sections do not match. When you resubmit, please ensure that you provide the correct grant numbers for the awards you received for your study in the ‘Funding Information’ section 3. Thank you for stating the following financial disclosure: "The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript." At this time, please address the following queries: a) Please clarify the sources of funding (financial or material support) for your study. List the grants or organizations that supported your study, including funding received from your institution. b) State what role the funders took in the study. If the funders had no role in your study, please state: “The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.” c) If any authors received a salary from any of your funders, please state which authors and which funders. d) If you did not receive any funding for this study, please state: “The authors received no specific funding for this work.” Please include your amended statements within your cover letter; we will change the online submission form on your behalf. 4. We note that you have indicated that data from this study are available upon request. PLOS only allows data to be available upon request if there are legal or ethical restrictions on sharing data publicly. For more information on unacceptable data access restrictions, please see http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/data-availability#loc-unacceptable-data-access-restrictions. In your revised cover letter, please address the following prompts: a) If there are ethical or legal restrictions on sharing a de-identified data set, please explain them in detail (e.g., data contain potentially sensitive information, data are owned by a third-party organization, etc.) and who has imposed them (e.g., an ethics committee). Please also provide contact information for a data access committee, ethics committee, or other institutional body to which data requests may be sent. b) If there are no restrictions, please upload the minimal anonymized data set necessary to replicate your study findings as either Supporting Information files or to a stable, public repository and provide us with the relevant URLs, DOIs, or accession numbers. For a list of acceptable repositories, please see http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/data-availability#loc-recommended-repositories. We will update your Data Availability statement on your behalf to reflect the information you provide. 5. We note that you have stated that you will provide repository information for your data at acceptance. Should your manuscript be accepted for publication, we will hold it until you provide the relevant accession numbers or DOIs necessary to access your data. If you wish to make changes to your Data Availability statement, please describe these changes in your cover letter and we will update your Data Availability statement to reflect the information you provide. 6. Please amend either the title on the online submission form (via Edit Submission) or the title in the manuscript so that they are identical. 7. Please review your reference list to ensure that it is complete and correct. If you have cited papers that have been retracted, please include the rationale for doing so in the manuscript text, or remove these references and replace them with relevant current references. Any changes to the reference list should be mentioned in the rebuttal letter that accompanies your revised manuscript. If you need to cite a retracted article, indicate the article’s retracted status in the References list and also include a citation and full reference for the retraction notice. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author 1. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? The manuscript must describe a technically sound piece of scientific research with data that supports the conclusions. Experiments must have been conducted rigorously, with appropriate controls, replication, and sample sizes. The conclusions must be drawn appropriately based on the data presented. Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Partly ********** 2. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes ********** 3. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available? The PLOS Data policy requires authors to make all data underlying the findings described in their manuscript fully available without restriction, with rare exception (please refer to the Data Availability Statement in the manuscript PDF file). The data should be provided as part of the manuscript or its supporting information, or deposited to a public repository. For example, in addition to summary statistics, the data points behind means, medians and variance measures should be available. If there are restrictions on publicly sharing data—e.g. participant privacy or use of data from a third party—those must be specified. Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes ********** 4. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English? PLOS ONE does not copyedit accepted manuscripts, so the language in submitted articles must be clear, correct, and unambiguous. Any typographical or grammatical errors should be corrected at revision, so please note any specific errors here. Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: No ********** 5. Review Comments to the Author Please use the space provided to explain your answers to the questions above. You may also include additional comments for the author, including concerns about dual publication, research ethics, or publication ethics. (Please upload your review as an attachment if it exceeds 20,000 characters) Reviewer #1: Comments and Suggestions for Authors First of all, I appreciate the opportunity to review your paper, which title is: Understanding the One Belt One Road Initiative Policy (BRI) influence on exportations of Chinese smartphone brands in BRI countries: The moderating role of the GDP per capita The topic is very interesting and important. The problem presented with the results is very useful, however, the paper has some shortcomings: Title: The title is a little bit too long, maybe the short title is better. Abstract is well-structured and clear at the present form, but there are some missing parts. Rather, the focus should be on the importance of the topic and the relevant (or main) issue more. The research objectives are clear, but the scientific gaps and purpose are unclear or vague. It should be more focused on the importance of the topic and main issues and scientific gaps. Introduction is well-structured, clear and well-written at the present form. In addition in the introduction some new literature sources should be cited especially in the following areas. a) Main scientific issues in the field, scientific uncertainties and gaps between the theories. b) I suggest incorporating the newest debates of prestigious international journals with foreign authors also especially in the field of OBORI. The subject is actual, and the study contributes to the development of knowledge. The first impression of reading the introduction is that it is brief, but informative and focusing on the narrowly defined topic. The literature review. The literature review is moderate and adequately supports why the impact of the OBORI policy on CCBECM should be investigated. This is clear, but the justification of why CCBECM is important for international science still needs to be demonstrated. The three hypotheses were adequately supported by the references and they are acceptable. Analysis section: Please harmonize the following sections as part of Material and Methods. 3. Research Context, Data description and Variable measurements. 4. Data description and Variables. Please correct or explain the followings: a) The exact relationships of the explanatory variables and the relationship between the explanatory variables and the control variables. b) Please explain how it can be verified that the presented and measured changes in the dependent variable were created as a result of the independent variables, that is, as a result of the OBORI policy and not as a result of spontaneous market growth? What is the evidence that the OBORI policy has a positive effect? It is understandable that the support processes have a positive effect, but what is the evidence for this, since it is not possible to compare the measured data with a control group. Maybe there is a trend level difference between the period before and after the OBORI policy? Formulate your answer taking into account the following statement: Utilizing DIDM to quantify the impact of the OBORI on Chinese product brand exportations, the analysis showed that the OBORI policy's effect is not significant enough to contribute to Chinese smartphones' exportations within OBORI countries. Research findings (Conclusions and limitations) – Conclusions are very well-structured and clear at the present form. The conclusion section, limitations of the model and future research directions are satisfactory at a high level. Please also make further suggestions for policy makers. How can stochastic factors affect the presented models and which factors can indicate uncertainty behaviour? The paper has very good potential, but the authors need to make a minor revision at this stage. I’m very glad to have the opportunity to read your work. Recommendation: Minor Revisions Required Reviewer #2: The research paper analyses a contemporary and exciting topic of Chinese smartphone export tendencies. The approach and the methods applied are unique, the research itself fills a gap in the field, so the paper can be regarded as original. The abstract is almost perfectly written, however, I would extend it with one first sentence, which indicates the reason and context, why this study was started. The title is appropriate, reflecting the content. In the introduction, the context and the research questions, research gaps are highlighted. The hypotheses are developed based on the broad and comprehensive literature review, however, this latter rather focuses on the OBOR and trade issues the than introducing the characteristics of the smartphone industry and its export. I recommend to extend the review towards these topics. Regarding methodology, first the methods then the datasets should be demonstrated, so a restructuring is needed here. The results are well demonstrated, conclusions are clears, limitations are set. The text should be checked by a native proofreader and also the terminology should be harmonized. E.g. the authors used the abbreviation OBORI while internationally it is used OBOR. ********** 6. PLOS authors have the option to publish the peer review history of their article (what does this mean?). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy. Reviewer #1: Yes: Dr. Gyenge Balázs Reviewer #2: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] While revising your submission, please upload your figure files to the Preflight Analysis and Conversion Engine (PACE) digital diagnostic tool, https://pacev2.apexcovantage.com/. PACE helps ensure that figures meet PLOS requirements. To use PACE, you must first register as a user. Registration is free. Then, login and navigate to the UPLOAD tab, where you will find detailed instructions on how to use the tool. If you encounter any issues or have any questions when using PACE, please email PLOS at figures@plos.org. Please note that Supporting Information files do not need this step. 27 Oct 2023 Reviewer #1: Comments and Suggestions for Authors First of all, I appreciate the opportunity to review your paper, which title is: Understanding the One Belt One Road Initiative (BRI) influence on exportations of Chinese smartphones: The moderating role of the GDP per capita. The topic is very interesting and important. The problem presented with the results is very useful, however, the paper has some shortcomings: 1.Title: The title is a little bit too long, maybe the short title is better. Thank you for your suggestion about the title of the article. Considering your suggestion, we have shorten the article title. The title is now: " Understanding the One Belt One Road Initiative (BRI) influence on exportations of Chinese smartphones: The moderating role of the GDP per capita" 2. Abstract is well-structured and clear at the present form, but there are some missing parts. Rather, the focus should be on the importance of the topic and the relevant (or main) issue more. The research objectives are clear, but the scientific gaps and purpose are unclear or vague. It should be more focused on the importance of the topic and main issues and scientific gaps. We sincerely appreciate your positive comments on well-structured and clarity of the Abstract. Regarding the focused of the Abstract that should be on the importance of the topic and main issues and scientific gaps, we have improved the abstract's quality based on your comments in this revised manuscript as follows: The One Belt One Road Initiative (BRI) has been the subject of multitudinous studies from various angles. Most previous studies have focused on BRI's economic, geopolitical, or commercial implications for China. However, the few studies that focused on BRI's influence on the exportations or importations of Chinese products via the Chinese Cross-border Electronic Commerce Market (CCBECM) have been carried out based only on authors' opinions rather than on empirical evidence. Therefore, the actual effect of BRI on the exportations of Chinese product brands via CCBECM in BRI countries still needs to be discovered. Utilizing B2C exportation data of Chinese smartphone brands and a Difference-in Difference Model (DIDM), we have first examined the actual and direct impact of BRI policy on Chinese smartphone brands exportations via the Chinese Cross-border Electronic Commerce Market (CCBECM) from 2012 to 2019 in BRI countries. Secondly, we assessed the moderating role of GDP per capita (GDP) and Internet Access Rate (IAR) between BRI policy and exportations of Chinese smartphone brands. The results showed that the impact of BRI remains insignificant on the exportations of Chinese smartphones via CCBECM in BRI countries. However, it could be significant if BRI includes more developed and economically strong countries. The study also highlighted a negative moderating role of GDP per capita between BRI policy and exportations, showing that the higher the BRI effect is, the less GDP per capita will influence Chinese smartphone exportations in BRI countries. 3. Introduction is well-structured, clear and well-written at the present form. Thank you for your kind comments In addition in the introduction some new literature sources should be cited especially in the following areas. a) Main scientific issues in the field, scientific uncertainties and gaps between the theories. Thank you for your constructive suggestions. First of all, regarding the main scientific issues in the field of BRI, we have already highlighted in the introduction that the advent of BRI has triggered numerous implications in several fields, so that studies on the influence of BRI have been addressed from several scientific angles. To that end we wrote: ("Initially announced by President Xi Jinping as a financial and trade cooperation project between China and countries members [3-5], BRI policy has been studied by many researchers from various angles, such as the geopolitics angle [6-7-8-9-10-11], economic and financial angle [12-13-14-15-16-17], infrastructural angle [18-19], cultural angle [20-21-22], energetic angle [23-24], environmental angle [25-26], and domestic politics angle [27].") Regarding the scientific uncertainties on the BRI, we have already pointed out that the only main scientific uncertainty about the BRI in the literature is the exact number of BRI members, which is unknown until now. Moreover, we have highlighted this out in Section 3.2 Data Description and Variables. Thank you once again for these suggestions. Finally, regarding the gaps between the theories and visions of the BRI policy, our introduction already pointed out that two prominent opinions (Studies or theories) confront each other: The first group of studies claim to see hidden diplomatic-geopolitical ambitions behind the BRI project [7-8]. Those studies claimed that the BRI policy stake is to assert a more active foreign policy based on the new vision of the Chinese world order, which is interconnected capitalism. Therefore, BRI could be seen as an effort to strengthen China's diplomatic and political presence in BRI countries [28]. It should be noted that the supporters of this vision are foreign scholars (non-Chinese citizens, such as [7 and 8]). However, the second group of studies pointed out that the BRI primarily aims to support China's domestic economic growth by finding new outlets and opportunities for Chinese industry and product brands [2-5] b) I suggest incorporating the newest debates of prestigious international journals with foreign authors also especially in the field of OBORI. Thank you for your constructive suggestion. We really appreciated this suggestion. Therefore, we have done our best to introduce in the introduction, as you suggested, the debate on the alternative to the BRI proposed by the G7 in Germany on June 26, 2022, during the penultimate G7 summit as follows: "…… This point of view is also that of several world organizations led by the West, such as the G7, which describes the BRI as one of the essential links in "debt trap diplomacy" [29]. Therefore, on June 26th, 2022, during the penultimate G7 summit, the group of seven most industrialized countries pledged to raise about US$600 billion in funds over the next five years to counter the BRI initiative and replace it with the newly global project named "Partnership for Global Infrastructure and Investment" to finance needed infrastructure in developing countries [29]". It should be noted that very few prestigious international journals with foreign authors have written on that matter. The subject is actual, and the study contributes to the development of knowledge. The first impression of reading the introduction is that it is brief, but informative and focusing on the narrowly defined topic. Thanks for your helpful comments in revising the manuscript 4. The literature review. a1/ The literature review is moderate and adequately supports why the impact of the OBORI policy on CCBECM should be investigated. This is clear, but the justification of why CCBECM is important for international science still needs to be demonstrated. Thanks for your constructive comments in revising the manuscript. Based on your comments we justified why CCBECM is important for international science and trade as follows: As an international commercial trade between companies or individuals from various nations using international electronic marketplaces to purchase and sell while relying on the global logistics network to deliver goods, CBEC results in significant cost savings on transaction costs [33]. Its substantial savings on transaction costs are most often related to communications, market research, and administration. Encouraged in emerging economies like China, CBEC has since enabled Chinese exporters and brands to overcome the constraints linked to isolation from potential markets, limited access to information, and high entry costs in the traditional international market [33]. With this, the CCBECM generated about 11 trillion RMB from its advent to 2019, thus creating thousands of dozens of jobs in China and outside China (as most of the sellers on CCBECMs, like Alibaba, AliExpress, Etc., are sellers from outside China). As a result, CCBECM has become a vital transaction means worldwide. Its impact on international trade was even more significant during the COVID-19 outbreak, when CCBECM had become almost the only international transaction framework in China, allowing suppliers to meet buyers' needs worldwide. It is, therefore, an industry essential to global and Chinese economic growth. a2/ The three hypotheses were adequately supported by the references and they are acceptable. Thank you for your kind comments in revising the manuscript. 5. Analysis section Please harmonize the following sections as part of Material and Methods.3. Research Context, Data description and Variable measurements. 4. Data description and Variables. Thank you for your kind suggestion in revising the manuscript. Based on your comments, we have harmonized the Analysis section. We now have: 3. Method and Material; 3.1 Research Methodology and Theoretical Model; 3.2 Research Context, Data description and Variable measurements; 3.3 Data description and Variables…… 6. Please correct or explain the following: a1) The exact relationships of the explanatory variables As highlighted in the manuscript, we have 3 explanatory variables. That is: 1. The explanatory variable (Policy): It measures whether a country is a member of the BRI policy or not. Among countries covered by the data set, 28 BRI countries represent the treatment group (coded = 1), and 41 non-BRI nations represent the control group (coded = 0). 2. The year (2012–2019): It includes pre- and post-BRI periods. The year 2014 is regarded as the starting year of the BRI. We coded the time: time = 0 if the year is a pre-BRI period; time = 1 if the year if t is a post-policy period. 3. The interaction term between the groups and time. The relationship between these 3 explanatory variables is obvious since policy implementation took place over several years (2014–2019 in the case of this study). Therefore, taking into account the periods before and after the implementation of the policy, as well as the interaction term between the groups and time, is necessary to judge the relevance or effect of this policy on international transactions. a2) The relationship between the explanatory variables and the control variables. As Control variables, the study incorporated 3 variables: That is 1. Country development level ("Status"). 2. Internet Access Rate (IAR), 3. GDP per capita (GDP) The country's development level was measured by the World Bank classification of the country's development levels. Thus, Lower Middle-Income countries and lower-income countries are coded as Developing countries and equal to 1; Middle-Income countries are coded as Emerging countries and equal to 2; and higher-income countries are coded as Developed countries and equal to 3. Regarding the relationship between the explanatory variables and the control variables, although we have not run a correlation matrix to show the relationships between explanatory variables and the control variables of the study, one may see from the mode1 and model 2 (Table 3) the changes in the value of coefficients of "Policy" variable and the control variable of countries development level "status". Moreover, models 4 and 5 (Table 5) give us an idea of the relationships between the study's explanatory and control variables. b) Please explain how it can be verified that the presented and measured changes in the dependent variable were created as a result of the independent variables, that is, as a result of the OBORI policy and not as a result of spontaneous market growth. Thank you for this question. First, we believe this question has already been answered in Section 3.3, Research Methodology and Theoretical Model. We have explained in that section that the implementation of the BRI did not provide a significant impact on the export trends of smartphones since the second assumption of the DID model showed that the exportations of BRI and non-BRI countries (NBRI) have experienced almost the same exportation trends before and after implementing the BRI. One may observe that after the implementation of BRI (2014–2019), the exportations of the treatment group (BRI countries) and control group (non-BRI countries) have followed almost the same trends. However, exportation in non-BRI countries (control group) was higher than in the treatment group (BRI countries). That is why we further ascertained the possible source of the differential influence of BRI policy on exports between BRI countries and non-BRI countries based on countries' socio-economic indicators after running the DID model. To this end, we evaluated the moderating effect of two main socio-economic variables (IAR and their GDP per capita) on exportations. 7. What is the evidence that the BRI policy has a positive effect? Thank you for this question. First of all, this study did not conclude that BRI policy positively affects the exportation of Chinese smartphones towards BRI countries. We clearly stated that Utilizing DIDM to quantify the impact of the BRI on Chinese smartphones' exportations, the analysis showed that the BRI policy's effect is not significant enough to contribute to Chinese smartphones' exportations within BRI countries. In other words, an insignificant effect of the BRI policy on Chinese smartphone exportations within BRI countries has been found. 8. Research findings (Conclusions and limitations) Conclusions are very well-structured and clear at the present form. The conclusion section, limitations of the model and future research directions are satisfactory at a high level. Thank you for your kind comments in revising the manuscript. Please also make further suggestions for policy makers. Even though several scholars claimed that the implementation of the BRI had contributed to the growth of CCBECM and provided excellent business opportunities for BRI countries in terms of easy access to Chinese products, such as smartphones, this study points out that that growth in terms of smartphone exportations to BRI countries is less than that of countries that are not members of the BRI. Therefore, as BRI nations now account for only 18% of the global GDP, promoting the BRI toward developed countries will be essential if the policy's objective is to strengthen the export of smartphones globally. Therefore, decision-makers are recommended to improve their strategies by expanding the number of BRI nations to increase the global adoption of Chinese smartphones”. 9. How can stochastic factors affect the presented models and which factors can indicate uncertainty behaviour? Thank You for this question. As we have already stated, some stochastic factors, such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the recent Russia-Ukraine war, can influence the presented models and produce influences. Indeed, these factors influenced the geopolitical and international transactions context. That means that the geopolitical context and international transactions have generated uncertain behaviour among potential exporters or buyers of Chinese smartphones through CCBECMs. That is why we have pointed out that policymakers would need more recent analyses after the pandemic and the Russia-Ukraine war (2020–2023). The paper has very good potential, but the authors need to make a minor revision at this stage. I’m very glad to have the opportunity to read your work. Thank you for your kind comments and suggestions in revising our manuscript. We are also happy to have you review our manuscript. Thank you once again for all your suggestions and comments, which will assist us in enriching and making our manuscript better. 1. Reviewer #2: The research paper analyses a contemporary and exciting topic of Chinese smartphone export tendencies. The approach and the methods applied are unique, the research itself fills a gap in the field, so the paper can be regarded as original. Thank you for your kind comments in revising the manuscript. 2. The abstract is almost perfectly written, however, I would extend it with one first sentence, which indicates the reason and context, why this study was started. We sincerely appreciate your positive comments on the perfect writing of the abstract. Based on your suggestions, we have improved the abstract's quality by indicating the reason and context of why this study was started in this revised manuscript as follows: The One Belt One Road Initiative (BRI) has been the subject of multitudinous studies from various angles. Most previous studies have focused on BRI's economic, geopolitical, or commercial implications for China. However, the few studies that focused on BRI's influence on the exportations or importations of Chinese products via the Chinese Cross-border Electronic Commerce Market (CCBECM) have been carried out based only on authors' opinions rather than on empirical evidence. Therefore, the actual effect of BRI on the exportations of Chinese product brands via CCBECM in BRI countries still needs to be discovered. Utilizing B2C exportation data of Chinese smartphone brands and a Difference-in Difference Model (DIDM), we have first examined the actual and direct impact of BRI policy on Chinese smartphone exportations via the Chinese Cross-border Electronic Commerce Market (CCBECM) from 2012 to 2019 in BRI countries. Secondly, we assessed the moderating role of GDP per capita (GDP) and Internet Access Rate (IAR) between BRI policy and exportations of Chinese smartphone brands. The results showed that the impact of BRI remains insignificant on the exportations of Chinese smartphones via CCBECM in BRI countries. However, it could be significant if BRI includes more developed and economically strong countries. The study also highlighted a negative moderating role of GDP per capita between BRI policy and exportations, showing that the higher the BRI effect is, the less GDP per capita will influence Chinese smartphone exportations in BRI countries. 3. The title is appropriate, reflecting the content. Thank you for your kind comments. 4. In the introduction, the context and the research questions, research gaps are highlighted. The hypotheses are developed based on the broad and comprehensive literature review, however, this latter rather focuses on the OBOR and trade issues than introducing the characteristics of the smartphone industry and its export. I recommend to extend the review towards these topics. Thank you very much for these constructive suggestions and comments. Based on your recommendation, we extended the review towards the characteristics of the smartphone industry and its exports through CCBECM as follows: In the literature on the relationship between BRI policy and smartphone exports to BRI countries through CBECM, one notes several claims from previous studies without any empirical evidence. For instance, Yang and Asbury [45] claimed the advent of BRI provided great opportunities to Chinese smartphones regarding their purchases and promotions within-country members. In studying different countries' preferences for Chinese smartphone exportations via CCBECM, [2] argued that the advent of BRI has provided great opportunities for purchasing Chinese smartphone brands through CCBECM. However, despite all these claims, we note in the previous literature a lack of empirical studies demonstrating the impact of the BRI policy on Chinese smartphone exportations through the CCBECM in BRI countries. 5. Regarding methodology, first the methods then the datasets should be demonstrated, so a restructuring is needed here. Thank you for your constructive comments and suggestions in revising the manuscript. Based on your comments and suggestions, we restructured the manuscript. We placed the methods first before the dataset description. 6. The results are well demonstrated, conclusions are clears, and limitations are set. Thank you for your kind comments. 4. The text should be checked by a native proofreader and also the terminology should be harmonized. E.g. the authors used the abbreviation OBORI while internationally it is used OBOR. Thank you for your constructive comments and suggestions in revising the manuscript. We have done our best to correct grammar errors through a proofreader and harmonized the abbreviation OBORI using BRI instead of OBORI, as you suggested. It should be noted that internationally, sometimes, BRI is used instead of OBOR. 21 Nov 2023 Understanding the One Belt One Road Initiative (BRI) influence on exportations of Chinese smartphones: The moderating role of the GDP per capita PONE-D-22-34618R1 Dear Dr. Karamoko N'da, We’re pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been judged scientifically suitable for publication and will be formally accepted for publication once it meets all outstanding technical requirements. Within one week, you’ll receive an e-mail detailing the required amendments. When these have been addressed, you’ll receive a formal acceptance letter and your manuscript will be scheduled for publication. An invoice for payment will follow shortly after the formal acceptance. To ensure an efficient process, please log into Editorial Manager at http://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/, click the 'Update My Information' link at the top of the page, and double check that your user information is up-to-date. If you have any billing related questions, please contact our Author Billing department directly at authorbilling@plos.org. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper to help maximize its impact. If they’ll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team as soon as possible -- no later than 48 hours after receiving the formal acceptance. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. Kind regards, László Vasa, PhD Academic Editor PLOS ONE Additional Editor Comments (optional): Reviewers' comments: 29 Nov 2023 PONE-D-22-34618R1 Understanding the One Belt One Road Initiative (BRI) influence on exportations of Chinese smartphones: The moderating role of the GDP per capita Dear Dr. N'da: I'm pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been deemed suitable for publication in PLOS ONE. Congratulations! Your manuscript is now with our production department. If your institution or institutions have a press office, please let them know about your upcoming paper now to help maximize its impact. If they'll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team within the next 48 hours. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information please contact onepress@plos.org. If we can help with anything else, please email us at customercare@plos.org. Thank you for submitting your work to PLOS ONE and supporting open access. Kind regards, PLOS ONE Editorial Office Staff on behalf of Prof. Dr. László Vasa Academic Editor PLOS ONE