Dynamic landscape of the intracellular termini of acid-sensing ion channel 1a Authors: Megan M Cullinan, Robert C Klipp, Abigail Camenisch, John R Bankston, Jon T Sack, John R Bankston, Megan M Cullinan, Robert C Klipp, Abigail Camenisch Published: 2023 ABSTRACT Acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are trimeric proton-gated sodium channels. Recent work has shown that these channels play a role in necroptosis following prolonged acidic exposure like occurs in stroke. The C-terminus of ASIC1a is thought to mediate necroptotic cell death through interaction with receptor interacting serine threonine kinase 1 (RIPK1). This interaction is hypothesized to be inhibited at rest via an interaction between the C- and N-termini which blocks the RIPK1 binding site. Here, we use two transition metal ion FRET methods to investigate the conformational dynamics of the termini at neutral and acidic pH. We do not find evidence that the termini are close enough to be bound while the channel is at rest and find that the termini may modestly move closer together during acidification. At rest, the N-terminus adopts a conformation parallel to the membrane about 10 Å away. The distal end of the C-terminus may also spend time close to the membrane at rest. After acidification, the proximal portion of the N-terminus moves marginally closer to the membrane whereas the distal portion of the C-terminus swings away from the membrane. Together these data suggest that a new hypothesis for RIPK1 binding during stroke is needed. Introduction Acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are members of the Deg/ENaC (Degenerin/Epithelial Sodium Channel) superfamily, with relatives including the mechanosensitive MEC4 from C. elegans, Pickpocket from D. melanogaster and most recently identified, the heat-activated BRNTaC1 from S.s mutilans (Yao et al., 2023). ASICs are trimeric, proton activated, sodium selective channels located primarily in the central and peripheral nervous systems. In mammals, there are four ASIC genes giving rise to six unique isoforms that can assemble into homo- and heteromeric channels. ASICs have been shown to be involved in diverse physiological and pathophysiological conditions including pain sensing (Bässler et al., 2001; Mazzuca et al., 2007; Sluka et al., 2009), mechanotransduction (Hermanstyne et al., 2008), fear conditioning (Coryell et al., 2008; Du et al., 2014), and memory and learning (Wemmie et al., 2002). The first structure of a member of this family, ASIC1 from chicken (cASIC1), was solved at 1.9 Å and revealed the overall architecture of the channel (Jasti et al., 2007). A single subunit of cASIC1 is comprised of a large cysteine-rich extracellular domain, two transmembrane domains and short intracellular N- and C-termini. More recent structures of cASIC1 from the same group using CryoEM on channels solubilized with styrene-maleic acid copolymer revealed that residues 19–41 reenter the membrane and form part of the lower permeation path: a feature that was termed the re-entrant loop (Yoder and Gouaux, 2020). Nonetheless, the C-terminus and the cytosolic portion of the N-terminus remain unresolved. It is likely these domains are highly dynamic and largely unstructured. Despite the lack of structure, the termini play a critical role in channel function and regulation. ASICs have been shown to interact with a wide variety of intracellular proteins (Cullinan et al., 2021) like stomatin (Brand et al., 2012; Klipp et al., 2020; Price et al., 2004), NHERF (Deval et al., 2006), and CIPP (Anzai et al., 2002). These proteins can influence trafficking, gating, and localization. Moreover, mutations and truncations in the termini have been shown to impact channel gating as well (Li et al., 2021). Of critical physiological importance, ASIC1a has a clearly demonstrated role in cell death resulting from ischemic stroke (Gao et al., 2005; Wang et al., 2020; Wang et al., 2015). Inhibition of ASIC1a or genetic knockout each result in a dramatic reduction in neuronal death following ischemic event (Chassagnon et al., 2017; McCarthy et al., 2015; Pignataro et al., 2007). It has long been suggested that ASIC1a may lead to cell death by contributing to Ca2+ overload in neurons as this isoform has some permeability to Ca2+ (Xiong et al., 2004). However, an intriguing newer hypothesis has suggested that ASIC1a can act as a receptor in addition to its function as an ion channel (Wang et al., 2020; Wang et al., 2015). This hypothesis posits that, during stroke, the pH of the extracellular solution falls, leading to a conformational change in the channel which exposes a binding site on the C-terminus for serine/threonine receptor interacting protein kinase 1 (RIPK1). RIPK1 is a cytosolic protein with multiple domains including an N-terminal kinase domain, an intermediate domain, and a C-terminal death domain (Mifflin et al., 2020). RIPK1 is known for its involvement in necroptosis or regulated necrotic cell death (Galluzzi et al., 2017). There are multiple ways to trigger necroptosis but the ensuing signaling cascade is relatively conserved. Generally, RIPK1, RIPK3 and mixed-lineage kinase domain-like pseudokinase (MLKL) are necessary to form the necrosome which is the required functional unit for cell death (Wang et al., 2014). Given the hypothesis that ASIC1a is a cell death receptor, it would be very attractive to design drugs that stabilize the complex between the N- and C-termini or destabilize the C-terminal interaction with RIPK1. With this idea in mind, our goal in this study is to test the hypothesis that the N-terminal domain (NTD) and C-terminal domain (CTD) of ASIC1a may form a dynamic complex that changes with pH. To do this, we have adapted a transition metal ion FRET (tmFRET) approach which is ideally suited to measure distances on this length scale. First, we incorporate the non-canonical amino acid fluorophore, 3-((6-acetylnaphthalen-2-yl)amino)–2-aminopropanoic acid (L-ANAP) into various sites within the NTD and CTD to serve as the FRET donor (Chatterjee et al., 2013). We then measure the position of the L-ANAP relative to a metal ion that is either attached to the channel using a cysteine-reactive metal chelator or incorporated into the membrane via an NTA conjugated lipid (Gordon et al., 2018; Zagotta et al., 2016). Using this approach, we do not see evidence that the NTD and CTD are in close proximity during resting pH that would be consistent with an interaction between the two domains. In addition, we measure modest movements towards one another during acidification. To confirm this result with a direct measure of binding, we also used microscale thermophoresis (MST) to test for binding between peptides of the termini and see no binding in this assay as well. Finally, we measure FRET between L-ANAP in our cytosolic domains and metal incorporated into the plasma membrane to determine the rearrangements that these domains undergo during acidification. Based on our results, we speculate that proximity of the CTD to the membrane during resting conditions, rather than a stable complex between the NTD and CTD, may prevent RIPK1 binding. Results To determine the conformational changes that the intracellular domains of ASIC1a undergo, we first needed to develop an approach well-suited to make this measurement in full-length channels in intact membranes. To do this, we employ transition metal ion FRET (tmFRET). tmFRET utilizes a transition metal ion, such as Co2+ and Cu2+, as a non-fluorescent FRET acceptor and a small fluorophore attached to the channel at a specific site as the donor (Latt et al., 1972; Latt et al., 1970; Taraska et al., 2009). The transition metal ion quenches the donor fluorophore in a highly distant dependent manner. Our approach needed to satisfy a number of criteria. (1) We needed to be able to site-specifically attach a fluorophore that is appropriate for tmFRET to our channel. (2) We needed to have a method for incorporating metal ions into our channel. (3) The probes we used cannot be sensitive to changes in pH. (4) The distance range over which our probes work needed to correspond with the distances between the intracellular domains. To accomplish all of this we adapted multiple methods to suit our needs for developing short distance probes for ASICs. Site-specific labeling of ASICs with an unnatural amino acid To site specifically incorporate a small molecule fluorophore compatible with FRET utilizing a transition metal, we opted to incorporate the fluorescent unnatural amino acid (UAA) 3-[(6-acetyl-2-naphthalenyl)amino]-L-alanine (L-ANAP) at sites in the channel. L-ANAP, a derivative of prodan, has several advantages for measuring short intramolecular distances within an ion channel. First, L-ANAP has a small side chain, similar in size to a tryptophan (Figure 1A). This reduces artifacts in FRET measurements associated with the large size of fluorescent proteins (FP) and organic dyes, as well as long linkers that attach these chromophores to the protein of interest. In addition, its modest spectral overlap with the absorbance spectra of transition metals makes it well suited as a donor for measuring FRET over shorter distances. L-ANAP has been used to measure conformational dynamics in multiple ion channels and other proteins (Gordon et al., 2018; Kalstrup and Blunck, 2013; Shandell et al., 2019; Suárez-Delgado et al., 2023; Zagotta et al., 2016). Incorporation of L-ANAP into ASIC1a. (A) Cartoon schematic illustrating L-ANAP incorporation into rASIC1a using the amber suppression method. Gray star indicates the location of the TAG mutation where L-ANAP can be incorporated when rASIC1a is co-transfected with pANAP and the media is supplemented with free L-ANAP (Created with Biorender.com). (B) Schematic of rASIC1a construct used for tmFRET experiments. Cytosolic N- and C-termini are in blue and red, respectively. mCitrine is conjugated to the C-terminus using a linker based on a loop region in DNA polymerase (DP). (C) Fluorescent and bright field images of rASIC1a-S24TAG expressed in CHO-K1 cells. Left column shows mCitrine fluorescence while the middle columns shows the L-ANAP fluorescence signal. Images were collected either in the presence or absence of L-ANAP and pANAP. Images were collected 24 hr after transfection at 20 x. The scale bar in the top left is 50 μm and applies to all panels in C. Figure 1—figure supplement 1.DNA sequence for rASIC1a in black with conservative alternative initiation site mutations highlighted in cyan and cysteine to serine mutations highlighted in yellow.Amino acid translation is above in red. DNA sequence for rASIC1a in black with conservative alternative initiation site mutations highlighted in cyan and cysteine to serine mutations highlighted in yellow. Amino acid translation is above in red. We used the amber suppression method to attach L-ANAP at specific sites on the NTD and CTD of ASIC1a (Figure 1A; Chatterjee et al., 2013; Lee et al., 2009). This approach utilizes two plasmids. The first encodes the channel with a TAG stop codon engineered at the desired site of labelling. The second plasmid, developed by Peter Schultz’s lab and termed pANAP, encodes 4 copies of a tRNA as well as an evolved tRNA synthetase that together allows for the loading of a tRNA complementary to the TAG codon with L-ANAP (Chatterjee et al., 2013). These two plasmids were co-transfected into CHO-K1 cells that were incubated in cell-permeable methyl ester version of L-ANAP (see Methods for details of the incorporation protocol). For these studies we used ASIC1a from rat with a genetically encoded mCitrine attached to the CTD of the channel via a 13 amino acid linker (Figure 1B). Since many of our desired labelling sites were in the short NTD of the channel, we needed to ensure that we minimized any ‘leak’ expression where the channel expresses even in the absence of L-ANAP. Work on the Shaker potassium channel has shown that TAG codons in the N-terminus can lead to translation re-initiation at non-canonical start codons downstream of the TAG site (Kalstrup and Blunck, 2015). To minimize this potential problem, we made a number of conservative mutations in the first 90 base pairs (30 amino acids) of the channel to minimize the chance of alternate initiation (Figure 1—figure supplement 1). In addition, the CTD has four native cysteine residues present which were mutated to serine, allowing us to then reintroduce a single cysteine residue at a site of our choosing. All cysteine residues in the extracellular region are engaged in disulfide bonds and are also too far away to contribute to a FRET signal given the working distance of tmFRET. Figure 1C shows representative images of rASIC1a-S24TAG with a single intracellular cysteine at C469. Robust mCitrine expression was only observed when both plasmids are transfected and L-ANAP is added to the media, indicating full-length channel expression. Omission of either L-ANAP from the media or pANAP from the transfection results in failure to produce full-length channels and an absence of any measurable mCitrine signal. To further ensure that full-length channels are only produced in the presence of the UAA, western blots were performed containing a number of potential TAG positions in the NTD, re-entrant loop, and CTD of the channel. Positions were excluded if no channels were seen on the blot or if a substantial signal was detected in the absence of L-ANAP in the media. Figure 2A shows two western blots that contain four different TAG mutation sites along with our pseudo wild-type construct, C469 WT, which has a single intracellular cysteine at position 469 and no introduced TAG mutation. Position S485TAG shows no expression even in the presence of L-ANAP in the growth media. Position H515TAG shows channel expression in both the presence and absence of L-ANAP. These are each an example of positions we did not pursue further. S464TAG and M505TAG, however, show robust ASIC1a expression only when L-ANAP is present in the media making these suitable positions to move forward with. Representative western blots for every position we tested can be seen in Figure 2—figure supplement 1. Incorporation of L-ANAP into ASIC1 produces full-length channel with normal pH-dependent gating. (A) Representative western blots for rASIC1a expressed in CHO-K1 cells with a single TAG mutation at denoted position, blotted with an anti-GFP antibody. Each TAG mutant was cultured both with L-ANAP (10 μM) and without L-ANAP supplementation. Expression of channels with L-ANAP incorporated is seen with bands at ~75 kDa. Higher molecular weight bands are likely channel oligomers (dimer, trimer) and bands below are likely free mCitrine. Neither the higher nor lower bands make up a significant portion of channel expressed. Less protein was loaded in the WT (no TAG) control C469 WT. (B) Representative whole-cell recordings of TAG mutants with single cysteine at C469 (colors) and C469 WT construct (black) elicited by solution switch from pH 8 to pH 5.5. (C) pH dependence of activation for rASIC1a TAG mutants with single cysteine at C469 (colors) and the C469 WT construct (black). Data were fit to a modified Hill equation. Fit results found in Figure 2—figure supplement 1. Figure 2—source data 1.Source data for Figure 2C showing each cells individual fit pH0.5 along with the mean and SEM and P-values.Significance was determined using 1-way ANOVA with a Dunnet’s post-hoc test for multiple comparisons to a single control. Source data for Figure 2C showing each cells individual fit pH0.5 along with the mean and SEM and P-values. Significance was determined using 1-way ANOVA with a Dunnet’s post-hoc test for multiple comparisons to a single control. Figure 2—figure supplement 1.Representative western blots for all TAG mutants created in this study.Westerns were blotted with an anti-GFP antibody that recognizes the terminal mCitrine. Each TAG mutant was cultured both with L-ANAP (10 μM) and without L-ANAP supplementation. Westerns in this figure were run on Bis-Tris gels, whereas the westerns in Figure 2 were run on Tris-Glycine gels, which results in ASIC running slightly differently between the 2 gel types. Representative western blots for all TAG mutants created in this study. Westerns were blotted with an anti-GFP antibody that recognizes the terminal mCitrine. Each TAG mutant was cultured both with L-ANAP (10 μM) and without L-ANAP supplementation. Westerns in this figure were run on Bis-Tris gels, whereas the westerns in Figure 2 were run on Tris-Glycine gels, which results in ASIC running slightly differently between the 2 gel types. Incorporation of L-ANAP into ASIC1a does not dramatically alter channel function We performed whole-cell patch clamp experiments for each position to ensure that the channel remained functional despite the incorporation of L-ANAP. Each mutant channel showed a robust current when L-ANAP was present in the media (Figure 2B). Each mutant showed the typical rapid activation upon a fast switch from pH 8 to pH 5.5 followed by channel desensitization. While rASIC1a-G11TAG showed a slightly altered desensitization rate, all mutants show complete desensitization in less than 10 s. In addition, we measured the pH dependence of channel activation. Our pseudo wild-type construct, C469 WT, showed a half-activating pH of 6.52 similar to our previously measured pH0.5 for WT ASIC1a (Klipp and Bankston, 2022). The pH0.5 values for the mutants all fell between 6.42 and 6.67 indicating that normal pH-dependent gating remains largely intact in each mutant (Figure 2C). The normal function of these mutant channels, we believe, makes these well-suited to continue examining rearrangements that occur in the NTD and CTD of the channel. pH does not alter L-ANAP fluorescence or metal ion absorbance To measure conformational changes in these regions, we employed two different tmFRET methodologies. The first, termed ACCuRET (ANAP Cyclen-Cu2+ resonance energy transfer), incorporates metal ions at specific sites on the channel using a cysteine reactive metal chelator, 1-(2-pyridin-2-yldisulfanyl)ethyl)–1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane (TETAC, Figure 3A; Gordon et al., 2018). TETAC has a short linker connected to a cyclen ring that binds transition metals with a sub-nanomolar affinity (Mutsuo Kodama et al., 1977). The second method involved attaching the metal to the plasma membrane using a synthesized lipid with a metal-chelating head group called stearoyl-nitrilotriacetic acid (C18-NTA, Figure 3B; Gordon et al., 2016). We termed this method memFRET for clarity. Using TETAC and C18-NTA allowed us to introduce transition metal ions at a specific site within the protein (TETAC) or scattered across the plasma membrane (C18-NTA). For each of these approaches we calculated the expected FRET efficiency between L-ANAP and the coordinated metal ion. Figure 3C shows the emission spectrum of L-ANAP along with the extinction coefficient of Cu2+-TETAC. The extinction coefficient was determined by measuring the absorbance of Cu2+-TETAC across the appropriate wavelengths (see methods for calculation). Similarly, Figure 3D shows the same data for Co2+-NTA. Using these data and assuming a quantum yield of 0.22 (Gordon et al., 2018; Gordon et al., 2016) and κ2 of 2/3 (Fung and Stryer, 1978; Loura, 2012), we calculate an R0 for ACCuRET of 17.6 Å and for memFRET of 12.4 Å at pH 8 where we expect all the channels to be in the resting state (Table 1). Table 1.R0 values calculated for Cu2+-TETAC and Co2+-C18-NTA using Equation 3 at pH 8 and pH 6.pH 8pH 6ACCuRET17.617.2memFRET12.412.6 R0 values calculated for Cu2+-TETAC and Co2+-C18-NTA using Equation 3 at pH 8 and pH 6. Spectral properties of L-ANAP and Cu2+-TETAC and C18-NTA make both good FRET pairs capable of measuring short distances. (A) Chemical structure of free TETAC. (B) Chemical structure of C18-NTA. (C) Spectral properties of L-ANAP bound to agarose beads and Cu2+-TETAC. Absorption spectra of TETAC-Cu2+ at pH 8 (blue) and pH 6 (green) were measured and spectral properties plotted along with emission spectra from L-ANAP bound to agarose beads at pH 8 (black) and pH 6 (red). (D) Spectral properties of L-ANAP bound to agarose beads and Co2+-C18-NTA. Absorption spectra of Co2+-C18-NTA at pH 8 (blue) and pH 6 (green) were measured and spectral properties plotted along with emission spectra from L-ANAP bound to agarose beads at pH 8 (black) and pH 6 (red). Figure 3—figure supplement 1.Spectral properties of Zn2+-TETAC and Zn2+-C18-NTA at pH 8 and pH 6.(A) Absorbance spectrum (converted to extinction coefficient) shown for Zinc bound to TETAC and C18-NTA. There is no absorbance seen in the visibile spectrum. Spectral properties of Zn2+-TETAC and Zn2+-C18-NTA at pH 8 and pH 6. (A) Absorbance spectrum (converted to extinction coefficient) shown for Zinc bound to TETAC and C18-NTA. There is no absorbance seen in the visibile spectrum. L-ANAP has been previously shown to not be pH sensitive when incorporated into the protein backbone (Suárez-Delgado et al., 2023). We confirmed that result here by mimicking incorporation of L-ANAP into the protein by conjugating L-ANAP to amine reactive agarose beads and measuring the emission spectra for L-ANAP on the same microscope setup used for the subsequent experiments. The emission spectrum of L-ANAP did not differ in either our rest (pH 8) or acidification (pH 6) buffers (Figure 3C and D). In addition, the extinction coefficient of Cu2+-TETAC and Co2+-NTA also do not change when the pH of the solution is changed (Figure 3C and D respectively). This results in a minimal change in R0 values between pH 8 and pH 6 for ACCuRET (17.6 Å and 17.2 Å, respectively) and for memFRET (12.4 Å and 12.6 Å, respectively). Finally, in order to apply either of these metal labels to the CTD or the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane, we needed access to the intracellular side of the channel. To do this, we used cell unroofing which was originally used for EM (Heuser, 2000) but has been adopted for tmFRET experiments as well (Gordon et al., 2018; Gordon et al., 2016; Zagotta et al., 2016). In short, we used a fluid stream to create a mechanical shearing force to remove the dorsal surface and all the intracellular components leaving only the ventral surface of the plasma membrane that is attached to the cover glass (Figure 4A). Before unroofing the cells, the L-ANAP signal is diffuse throughout the cell, without obvious membrane localization as expected, and the mCitrine signal can be seen in the membrane and in other intracellular membranes. After unroofing the cells, only fluorescence associated with the ‘footprint’, or ventral surface, of the cell membrane is left behind. L-ANAP and mCitrine fluorescence colocalized well in the unroofed cells (Figure 4B). All together, these data show that we were able to combine multiple approaches to site-specifically label ASIC1a with the small molecule fluorophore, L-ANAP, as well as metal ions and none of the probes we use were impacted by changes in pH. With these combined approaches, we can measure conformational changes that occur in the intracellular domains of the channel. Cell unroofing isolates the plasma membrane for imaging. (A) Cartoon schematic of unroofing method used. Cultured CHO-K1 cells are washed with DPBS before being subjected to a constant stream of buffer using a needle and syringe to remove the non-adhered portion of the cells (Created with Biorender.com). (B) Representative fluorescent and bright field images at 60 x of whole cell (top) and unroofed (bottom) expressing rASIC1a-G11TAG. The scale bar in the top left is 10 μm and applies to all panels in B. Measuring the distance between the N- and C- termini With these methodologies in place, we can directly measure rearrangements within the intracellular domains of ASIC1a. The ACCuRET approach (Figure 5A) is particularly well-suited for measuring the distance between the NTD and the CTD for several reasons. (1) The R0 for our FRET pairs is on the order of ~17–18 Å which is ideal for measuring distances between the intracellular domains as the distance between the bottom of TM1 and TM2 in the channel is on the order of 10–20 Å. (2) We can measure these distances in intact channels embedded in native membranes. (3) The fluorophore and metal ion are small and have relatively few bonds connecting them to the protein backbone making them good proxies for the position of the NTD and CTD relative to one another. ACCuRET measures short-range distances between the NTD and CTD of ASIC1a. (A) Cartoon showing the ACCuRET approach (Created with Biorender.com). (B) Representative ACCuRET experiment. Fluorescence and bright field images at 60 x of rASIC1a-Q14TAG at pH 6. In brief, the first image is taken in control buffer at pH 6. This is followed by washing on TETAC preloaded with Cu2+ and then washout of the excess Cu2+-TETAC. The second image is then taken which shows a decrease in L-ANAP fluorescence indicative of FRET. Finally, Cu2+-TETAC is removed by adding DTT and the final image is taken where the L-ANAP fluorescence is restored. mCitrine bleaches across all three images and the bright field is blank, indicating the cell is successfully unroofed. The scale bar in the top left is 10 μm and applies to all panels in B. (C) Normalized FRET efficiency for example experiment in B. Signals are normalized to fluorescence before addition of metal ions. The inset cartoon shows the position of L-ANAP denoted by a blue star and the single cysteine denoted by an orange circle. Grey symbols represent other positions that are mutated in this study in order to show the relative position mutated in this example. In this instance, L-ANAP is incorporated at Q14 and the single cysteine in the C-terminus is at position C469. (D) Cartoon illustrating the current hypothesis of the orientation between the NTD and CTD at rest (left) and after prolonged acidosis (right). The inset sequence shows the putative interaction between the intracellular domains. Figure 5B shows a representative ACCuRET experiment for FRET between L-ANAP at rASIC1a-Q14TAG and Cu2+-TETAC at C469. This first image shows the L-ANAP fluorescence before addition of the metal ion. The addition of 10 µM Cu2+-TETAC- resulted in a significant reduction in the L-ANAP signal which was reversed upon application of 1 mM DTT. The normalized FRET efficiency was then calculated (see methods for details) and a summary of all the data measured between L-ANAP at rASIC1a-Q14TAG and Cu2+-TETAC at C469 is shown in Figure 5C. The mCitrine signal does not show the same quenching and recovery as the L-ANAP which is expected but does photobleach over time. Recall that the hypothesis that we are testing suggests that the NTD and CTD of ASIC1a form a complex at rest and that this complex is critical for preventing the initiation of cell death by the channel (Figure 5D). The putative interaction site between the intracellular domains was speculated to involve four consecutive glutamate residues at positions 6–9 on the NTD and residues 468–476 on the CTD (Figure 5D, inset) (Wang et al., 2020; Wang et al., 2015). Specifically, Rosetta modelling showed a very close (4.7 Å) proximity between residues E7 and K468 (Wang et al., 2020). This hypothesis predicts that the positions along the short NTD should show high FRET efficiency with metal ions incorporated into the channel at C469 at rest and that the FRET between the intracellular domains should decrease with prolonged (~minutes) acidification. ACCuRET between L-ANAP at E8 and Cu2+-TETAC at C469, the two residues immediately adjacent to the modelled close contact between the NTD and CTD, showed a modest 20% FRET efficiency putting the NTD and CTD ~22 Å apart which is significantly farther than the modelling predicted (Figure 6A, Table 2). However, it is possible that the presence of the labels in the binding site may impact the two domains ability to interact. To circumvent this, we measured distances between the NTD and CTD with a large combination of L-ANAP positions as well as Cu2+-TETAC positions. ACCuRET reveals the NTD and CTD likely do not form a complex at rest. (A) Normalized FRET efficiency between L-ANAP on the NTD and Cu2+-TETAC at position C469 at pH 8 (black) and pH 6 (red). FRET efficiencies, SEM, N and calculated distances are summarized in Table 2. Zn2+-TETAC negative control for positions E8 and G11 shows that the changes in signal measured with Cu2+-TETAC are due the presence of Cu2+ and not due to any other changes. (B) Normalized FRET efficiency between L-ANAP on the NTD and Cu2+-TETAC at position C477 at pH 8 (black) and pH 6 (red). The inset cartoons show the position of L-ANAP denoted by a blue star and the single cysteine denoted by an orange circle. Box and whisker plot with whiskers ranging from minimum to maximum values and the bottom and top edges of the box denoting the 25th and 75th quartiles, respectively. Statistical significance shown using two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple comparisons test are denoted between relevant comparison using appropriate asterisks. Ns indicates p>0.05, * indicates p≤0.05, ** indicates p≤0.01, *** indicates p≤0.001, **** indicates p≤0.0001. 60.05, * indicates p≤0.05, ** indicates p≤0.01, *** indicates p≤0.001, **** indicates p≤0.0001. 60.05, * indicates p≤0.05, ** indicates p≤0.01, *** indicates p≤0.001, **** indicates p≤0.0001. 60.05, * indicates p≤0.05, ** indicates p≤0.01, *** indicates p≤0.001, **** indicates p≤0.0001. 60.05, * indicates p≤0.05, ** indicates p≤0.01, *** indicates p≤0.001, **** indicates p≤0.0001. 60.05, * indicates p≤0.05, ** indicates p≤0.01, *** indicates p≤0.001, **** indicates p≤0.0001. p-Values are all reported in the Source Data files associated with each figure. All replicates in this study are biological replicates. All data generated or analyzed are included in the figures. This valuable study illuminates molecular movements of acid-sensing ion channels by combining advanced chemical biology and biophysical techniques. The evidence for the main claim, lack of interaction of molecular termini, is compelling and challenges prior models. This work is expected to pique interest in the ion channel signaling field, providing a fresh perspective. Cullinan et al. explore the hypothesis that the cytoplasmic N- and C-termini of ASIC1a, not resolved in x-ray or cryo-EM structures, form a dynamic complex that breaks apart at low pH, exposing a C-terminal binding site for RIPK1, a regulator of necrotic cell death. They expressed channels tagged at their N- and C-termini with the fluorescent, non-canonical amino acid ANAP in CHO cells using amber stop-codon suppression. Interaction between the termini was assessed by FRET between ANAP and colored transition metal ions bound either to a cysteine reactive chelator attached to the channel (TETAC) or metal-chelating lipids (C18-NTA). A key advantage to using metal ions is that they are very poor FRET acceptors, i.e. they must be very close to the donor for FRET to occur. This is ideal for measuring small distances/changes in distance on the scales expected from the initial hypothesis. In order to apply chelated metal ions, CHO cells were mechanically unroofed, providing access to the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane. At high pH, the N- and C- termini are close enough for FRET to be measured, but apparently too far apart to be explained by a direct binding interaction. At low pH, there was an apparent increase in FRET between the termini. FRET between ANAP on the N-and C-termini and metal ions bound to the plasma membrane suggests that both termini move away from the plasma membrane at low pH. The authors propose an alternative hypothesis whereby close association with the plasma membrane precludes RIPK1 biding to the C-terminus of ASIC1a. The findings presented here are certainly valuable for the ion channel/signaling field and the technical approach only increases the significance of the work. The choice of techniques is appropriate for this study and the results are clear and high quality. Sufficient evidence is presented against the starting hypothesis. I have a few questions about certain controls and assumptions that I would like to see discussed more explicitly in the manuscript. --As discussed by the authors, the C-terminal citrine could potentially disrupt the hypothesized interaction between the N- and C-termini. --There is apparent read-through of some of the stop codons in the absence of ANAP, which could complicate interpretation of the experiments. The largest amount of read-through is for the E6TAG, L18TAG, and H515TAG constructs, which were not used for further experiments. However, some degree of read-through is evident from western blots for V10TAG, Q14TAG, L41TAG, and A44TAG as well. Since the epitope used for western blots is on the C-terminus of the protein, the blots do not show the fraction of truncated protein. As discussed by the authors, N-terminally truncated constructs would be too small to assemble into channels. In constructs with the TAG codon towards the C-terminus, there is the potential for co-assembly of full-length and truncated subunits into trimers. Truncated subunits would not contribute directly to the fluorescence signal, but could potentially have allosteric effects on the position of the C-termini of full-length ANAP-tagged constructs in the context of a mixed channel. Summary: The authors use previously characterised FRET methods to measure distances between intracellular segments of ASIC and with the membrane. The distances are measured across different conditions and at multiple positions in a very complete study. The picture that emerges is that the N- and C-termini do not associate. Strengths: Good controls, good range of measurements, advanced, well-chosen and carefully performed FRET measurements. The paper is a technical triumph. Particularly, given the weak fluorescence of ANAP, the extent of measurements and the combination with TETAC is noteworthy. The distance measurements are largely coherent and favour the interpretation that the N and C terminus are not close together as previously claimed. Weaknesses: One difficulty, which admittedly is hard to address, is that we do not have a positive control for what binding of something to either N- or C-terminus would look like (either in FRET or otherwise). One limitation is unroofing. The concept of interaction with intracellular domains is being examined. But the authors use unroofing to measure the positions, fully disrupting the cytoplasm. Thus it is not excluded that the unroofing disrupts that interaction. But this limitation is discussed adequately in the text. Summary: The manuscript by Cullinan et al., uses ANAP-tmFRET to test the hypothesis that the NTD and CTD form a complex at rest and to probe these domains for acid-induced conformational changes. They find convincing evidence that the NTD and CTD do not have a propensity to form a complex. They also report these domains are parallel to the membrane and that the NTD moves towards, and the CTD away, from the membrane upon acidification. Strengths: The major strength of the paper is the use of tmFRET, which excels at measuring short distances and is insensitive to orientation effects. The donor-acceptor pairs here are also great choices as they are minimally disruptive to the structure being studies. Furthermore, they conduct these measurements over several positions with the N and C tails, both between the tails and to the membrane. Finally, to support their main point, MST is conducted to measure the association of recombinant N and C peptides, finding no evidence of association or complex formation. Weaknesses: While tmFRET is a strength, using ANAP as a donor requires the cells to be unroofed to eliminate background signal. This causes two problems. First, it removes any possible low affinity interacting proteins such as actinin (PMID 19028690). Second, the pH changes now occur to both 'extracellular' and 'intracellular' lipid planes. Thus, it is unclear if any conformational changes in the N and CTDs arise from desensitization of the receptor or protonation of specific amino acids in the N or CTDs or even protonation of certain phospholipid groups such as in phosphatidylserine. The authors do mention this caveat. But until a new approach is developed, the concerns over disruption by unroofing/washing and relevance of the changes remain. Upon acidification, NTD position Q14 moves towards the plasma membrane (Figure 8B). Q14 also gets closer to C515 or doesn't change relative to 505 (Figures 7C and B) upon acidification. Yet position 505 moves away from the membrane (Figure 8D). It's unclear how the NTD moves closer to the membrane, and to the CTD but yet the CTD moves further from the membrane. Future experiments or approaches may refine this model. The following is the authors’ response to the original reviews. We thank the reviewers and editor for their thoughful and careful evaluation of our manuscript. We appreciate your time and effort and have incorporated many of these suggestions to improve our revised manuscript. Reviewer #1 (Public Review): Summary: Cullinan et al. explore the hypothesis that the cytoplasmic N- and C-termini of ASIC1a, not resolved in x-ray or cryo-EM structures, form a dynamic complex that breaks apart at low pH, exposing a C-terminal binding site for RIPK1, a regulator of necrotic cell death. They expressed channels tagged at their N- and C-termini with the fluorescent, non-canonical amino acid ANAP in CHO cells using amber stop-codon suppression. Interaction between the termini was assessed by FRET between ANAP and colored transition metal ions bound either to a cysteine reactive chelator attached to the channel (TETAC) or metal-chelating lipids (C18-NTA). A key advantage to using metal ions is that they are very poor FRET acceptors, i.e. they must be very close to the donor for FRET to occur. This is ideal for measuring small distances/changes in distance on the scales expected from the initial hypothesis. In order to apply chelated metal ions, CHO cells were mechanically unroofed, providing access to the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane. At high pH, the N- and C- termini are close enough for FRET to be measured, but apparently too far apart to be explained by a direct binding interaction. At low pH, there was an apparent increase in FRET between the termini. FRET between ANAP on the N-and Ctermini and metal ions bound to the plasma membrane suggests that both termini move away from the plasma membrane at low pH. The authors propose an alternative hypothesis whereby close association with the plasma membrane precludes RIPK1 binding to the C-terminus of ASIC1a. Strengths: The findings presented here are certainly valuable for the ion channel/signaling field and the technical approach only increases the significance of the work. The choice of techniques is appropriate for this study and the results are clear and high quality. Sufficient evidence is presented against the starting hypothesis. Weaknesses: I have a few questions about certain controls and assumptions that I would like to see discussed more explicitly in the manuscript. My biggest concern is with the C-terminal citrine tag. Might this prevent the hypothesized interaction between the N- and C-termini? What about the serine to cysteine mutations? The authors might consider a control experiment in channels lacking the C-terminal FP tag. While it is certainly possible that the C-terminal citrine tag is preventing the hypothesized interaction between the intracellular termini, there are a few things that mitigate (but not eliminate) this concern. First, previous work looking at the interaction between the intracellular termini used FPs on both the N- and C-termini and concluded that in fact there is an interaction (PMID:31980622). Our channels have only a single FP, and we use a higher resolution FRET approach. Second, we aVach our citrine tag with a 11-residue linker, allowing for enhanced flexibility of the region and hopefully allowing for more space for an interaction that was posited to be between the very proximal part of the C-terminus (near the membrane and away from the tag) and the untagged N-terminus. Third, we previously showed that Stomatin, a much larger protein than the NTD, could bind the distal C-terminus of rASIC3 with a large fluorescent protein connected by the same linker on the C-terminus. In the case of Stomatin, the interaction involved the residues at the distal portion of the C-terminus close to the bulky FP. Interestingly, while we did not publish this, without this flexible linker, Stomatin could not regulate the channel and likely did not bind. Despite this, we agree that this is possible and have added a statement in our limitations section explicitly saying this. Figure 2 supplement 1 shows apparent read-through of the N-terminal stop codons. Given that most of the paper uses N-terminal ANAP tags, this figure should be moved out of the supplement. Do Nterminally truncated subunits form functional channels? Do the authors expect N-terminally truncated subunits to co-assemble in trimers with full-length subunits? The authors should include a more explicit discussion regarding the effect of truncated channels on their FRET signal in the case of such co-assembly. The positions that show readthrough (E6, L18, H515) were not used in the study. We eliminated them largely on the basis of these westerns. We elected to put the bulk of the blots in the supplement simply because of how many there were. We believe this is the best compromise. It allows us to show representative blots for all our positions without making an illegible figure with 7 blots. The N-terminally truncated subunits would create very short peptides that are not able to create functional channels. A premature stop at say E8 would create a 7-mer. Our longest N-terminal truncation would only create a protein of 32 amino acids. These don’t contain the transmembrane segments and thus cannot make functional channels. As the epitope used for the western blots in Figure 2 and supplements is part of the C-terminal tag, these blots do not provide an estimate of the fraction of C-terminally truncated channels (those that failed to incorporate ANAP at the stop codon). What effect would C-terminally truncated channels have on the FRET signal if incorporated into trimers with full-length subunits? Alternatively, C-terminally truncated subunits would be able to form functional channels because they contain the full N-terminus, the transmembrane domains, the extracellular domain and a portion of the C-terminus. We don’t think this is a major contaminant to our experiments. The only two C-terminal ANAP positions we use are 464 and 505. In each of these cases, they are only used for memFRET. The ones that do not contain ANAP are essentially “invisible” to the experiment. Since we are measuring their proximity to the membrane, having some missing should not maVer. However, there is some chance that truncations in some subunits could allosterically affect the position of the CT in other subunits. We have added a discussion of this in the manuscript. Some general discussion of these results in the context of trimeric channels would be helpful. Is the putative interaction of the termini within or between subunits? Are the distances between subunits large enough to preclude FRET between donors on one subunit and acceptor ions bound on multiple subunits? Thank you for this comment. We did not directly test whether the distances are within or between subunits. We considered using a concatemer to do this, however, the concatemeric channels do not express particularly well. Then, UAA incorporation hurts the expression as well. It was unlikely we would be able to get sufficient expression for tmFRET. However, the Maclean group has previously tested this using FRET between concatenated subunits and determined that FRET is stronger within than between subunits. We have updated the manuscript to reflect a more thorough discussion of our results in the context of their trimeric assembly. The authors conclude that the relatively small amount of FRET between the cytoplasmic termini suggests that the interaction previously modeled in Rosetta is unlikely. Is it possible that the proposed structure is correct, but labile? For example, could it be that the FRET signal is the time average of a state in which the termini directly interact (as in the Rosetta model) and one in which they do not? The proposed RoseVa model does not include the reentrant loop of the channel, so it is probable that this model would change if it were redone to include this new feature of the channel. However, we do discuss the limitation of FRET as a method that measures a time average that is weighted towards closest approach in our discussion section. The termini are most certainly dynamic and it is possible that spend some time in close proximity. Given that FRET is biased towards closest approach, we actually think this strengthens our argument that the termini don’t spend a great deal of time in complex. In addition, our MST data suggests that the termini do not bind. We have added some commentary on this to the discussion section for clarity. Reviewer #2 (Public Review): Summary: The authors use previously characterised FRET methods to measure distances between intracellular segments of ASIC and with the membrane. The distances are measured across different conditions and at multiple positions in a very complete study. The picture that emerges is that the N- and C-termini do not associate. Strengths: Good controls, good range of measurements, advanced, well-chosen and carefully performed FRET measurements. The paper is a technical triumph. Particularly, given the weak fluorescence of ANAP, the extent of measurements and the combination with TETAC is noteworthy. The distance measurements are largely coherent and favour the interpretation that the N and C terminus are not close together as previously claimed. Weaknesses: One difficulty is that we do not have a positive control for what binding of something to either N- or Cterminus would look like (either in FRET or otherwise). We acknowledge that this is a challenge for the approach. Having a positive control for binding would be great but we are not sure such a thing exists. You could certainly imagine a complex between two domains where each label (ANAP and TETAC) are pointed away from one other (giving comparatively modest quenching) or one where they are very close (giving comparatively large quenching), both of which could still be bound. This is essentially a less significant version of the problem with using FPs to measure proximity…they are not very good proxies for the position of the termini. These small labels are certainly beVer proxies but still not perfect. Our conclusion here is based more on the totality of the data. We tried many combinations and saw no sign of distances closer than ~ 20A at resting pH. We think the simplest explanation is that they are not close to one another but we tried to lay out the limitations in the discussion. One limitation that is not mentioned is the unroofing. The concept of interaction with intracellular domains is being examined. But the authors use unroofing to measure the positions, fully disrupting the cytoplasm. Thus it is not excluded that the unroofing disrupts that interaction. This should be mentioned as a possible (if unlikely) limitation. Thank you for your comment. We discuss unroofing as a potential limitation because it exposes both sides of the plasma membrane to changes in pH. We have updated this section to include acknowledgement of the possibility that unroofing disrupts the interaction via washout of other critical proteins. Reviewer #3 (Public Review): Summary: The manuscript by Cullinan et al., uses ANAP-tmFRET to test the hypothesis that the NTD and CTD form a complex at rest and to probe these domains for acid-induced conformational changes. They find convincing evidence that the NTD and CTD do not have a propensity to form a complex. They also report these domains are parallel to the membrane and that the NTD moves towards, and the CTD away, from the membrane upon acidification. Strengths: The major strength of the paper is the use of tmFRET, which excels at measuring short distances and is insensitive to orientation effects. The donor-acceptor pairs here are also great choices as they are minimally disruptive to the structure being studied. Furthermore, they conduct these measurements over several positions with the N and C tails, both between the tails and to the membrane. Finally, to support their main point, MST is conducted to measure the association of recombinant N and C peptides, finding no evidence of association or complex formation. Weaknesses: While tmFRET is a strength, using ANAP as a donor requires the cells to be unroofed to eliminate background signal. This causes two problems. First, it removes any possible low affinity interacting proteins such as actinin (PMID 19028690). Second, the pH changes now occur to both 'extracellular' and 'intracellular' lipid planes. Thus, it is unclear if any conformational changes in the N and CTDs arise from desensitization of the receptor or protonation of specific amino acids in the N or CTDs or even protonation of certain phospholipid groups such as in phosphatidylserine. The authors do comment that prolonged extracellular acidification leads to intracellular acidification as well. But the concerns over disruption by unroofing/washing and relevance of the changes remain. We acknowledge that unroofing is a limitation of our approach and noted it in the discussion. However, we have updated the section to include the possibility that the act of unroofing and washing could also disrupt the potential interaction between the intracellular domains as well as between these domains and other intracellular proteins. This was the best approach we could use to address our questions and it required that we unroof the cells. However, we look forward to future studies or new techniques that do not require the unroofing of the cells. The distances calculated depend on the R0 between donor and acceptor. In turn, this depends on the donor's emission spectrum and quantum yield. The spectrum and yield of ANAP is very sensitive to local environment. It is a useful fluorophore for patch fluorometry for precisely this reason, and gating-induced conformational changes in the CTD have been reported just from changes in ANAP emission alone (PMID 29425514). Therefore, using a single R0 value for all positions (and both pHs at a single position) is inappropriate. The authors should either include this caveat and give some estimate of how big an impact changes spectrum and yield might have, or actually measure the emission spectra at all positions tested. This is a reasonable concern and one we considered. Measuring the quantum yield would be quite difficult. However, we have measured spectra at a number of positions and see a relatively minimal shik in the peak. Most positions peak between 481 and 484nm. If you calculate the difference in R0 using theoretical spectra with a blue shik of 20nm, the difference in R0 is only ~1.5A. A shik of 20nm is on the higher side of anything we have seen in the literature (PMID 30038260) and since even with that large a shik, the difference is minimal we do not think measuring spectra for each position would impact the overall conclusions presented. As you noted, though, the quantum yield also changes. Assuming a change in yield from 0.22 to 0.47, the largest we found reported in the literature (PMID:29923827) , the R0 would increase by 2A. This same paper showed that the blue shiked position was the one with the higher extinction coefficient so these changes would be working in opposition to one another making the difference in R0 even smaller. It is important to note, that while tmFRET is a much more powerful measure of distance than standard FRET, these distances, as you point out, are quite challenging to measure precisely. Our conclusions are based less on the absolute distances and more on the observation that no positions show large quenching and that if there is any change upon acidification, it is in the wrong direction. Overall, the writing and presentation of figures could be much improved with specific points mentioned in the recommendations for authors section. See below. The authors argue that the CTD is largely parallel to the plasma membrane, yet appear to base this conclusion on ANAP to membrane FRET of positions S464 and M505. Two positions is insufficient evidence to support such a claim. Some intermediate positions are needed. We do not see in the paper where we suggest that the CTD is parallel. However, your point that we could try and determine if this was the case is correct. However, we aVempted to create several other CTD TAG mutants but struggled with readthrough and poor expression of these mutants so we opted to just include S464 and M505. Our point from these data is only that the distal CTD (505) must spend significant time near the membrane to explain our FRET data. Upon acidification, NTD position Q14 moves towards the plasma membrane (Figure 8B). Q14 also gets closer to C515 or doesn't change relative to 505 (Figures 7C and B) upon acidification. Yet position 505 moves away from the membrane (Figure 8D). How can the NTD move closer to the membrane, and to the CTD but yet the CTD move further from the membrane? Some comment or clarification is needed. This is a reasonable question and one that is hard to definitively answer. Our goal here was to test the hypothesis that the termini are bound at rest. Mapping the precise positions of the termini is difficult for reasons we will enumerate in the question that asks why we didn’t make a model. There are potentially multiple explanations but the easiest one would be that the CTD could move away from the membrane but closer to Q14, for instance, if the distal termini, say, rotated towards the NTD. This would move 505 closer and have no impact on whether or not the NTD and CTD moved away or toward the membrane. Reviewer #1 (Recommendations For The Authors): Minor concerns The authors show the spectrum of ANAP attached to beads and use this spectrum to calculate R0 for their FRET measurements. Peak ANAP fluorescence is dependent on local environment and many reports show ANAP in protein blue-shiked relative to the values reported here. How would this affect the distance measurements reported? This is an important point. See above for the answer. Could the lack of interaction between the N- and C-terminal peptides in Figure 7 arise from the cysteine to serine mutations or lack of structure in the synthetic peptides. How were peptide concentrations measured/verified for the experiment? It is possible that cysteine to serine mutations could prevent the interaction. It is also possible that these peptides are not capable of adopting their native fold without the presence of the plasma membrane or due to being synthetically created. However, the termini are thought to be largely unstructured. We received these peptides in lyophilized form at >95% purity and resuspended to our desired stock concentration (3 mM C-terminus, 1 mM N-terminus). Even if our concentration was off, we see no signs of interaction up to quite a high concentration. How was photobleaching measured for correcting the data? We executed several mock experiments at various TAG positions using either pH 8 and pH 6, where we performed the experiments as usual but with a mock solution exchange when we would normally add the metal. We normalized the L-ANAP fluorescence to the first image and averaged together these values for pH 8 and pH 6. We then corrected using Equation 2 in the manuscript.. We have updated the methods to include how we adjusted for bleaching. The authors may wish to make it more explicit that their Zn2+ controls also preclude the possibility that a changing FRET signal between ANAP and citrine may affect their data. Thank you for this comment. We agree, it would strengthen the manuscript to include this statement. We have now included this. It might be useful to the reader if the authors could include (as a supplement) plots of their data (like in Figure 6), in which FRET efficiency has been converted to distance. We considered this idea as well but felt like showing the actual data in the figures and the distances in a table would be best. Figure 5D is mentioned in the text before any other figures. This is unconventional. Could this panel be moved to Figure 1 or the mention moved to later? Changed western blot is not capitalized. Changed. Figure 1, the ANAP structure shown is the methyl ester, which is presumably cleaved before ANAP is conjugated to the tRNA. The authors may wish to replace this with the free acid structure. This is a fair point. We originally used the methyl ester structure to indicate the version of ANAP we chose to use. However, you are correct that the methyl ester is cleaved before conjugation to the tRNA. We replaced the methyl ester with the free acid structure to clarify this. Figures 1 and 4 should have scale bars for the images. Scale bars have been added to figures 1, 4, and 5. In Figure 3, the letters in the structures (particularly TETAC) are way too small. Please increase the font size. Changed In Figure 3 and Figure 3 supplement 1, the axes are labeled "Absorbance (M-1cm-1)." Absorbance is dimensionless. The authors are likely reporting the extinction coefficient. Thank you for catching this. We adjusted the axes to extinction coefficient. In Figures 5 B and C, it might be clearer if the headers read "Initial, +Cu2+/TETAC, DTT" rather than "Initial, FRET, Recovery." Changed The panel labels for Figure 8 seem to be out of order. Changed The L for L-ANAP should be rendered, by convention, in small caps. This is a good example of learning something new from the review process. This is the first I have ever heard of small caps. We can find no other papers that use small caps for L-ANAP so I am not 100% sure what convention this is referring to and don’t want to change the wrong thing in the paper. We are happy to change if the editorial staff at eLife agree but have lek this for now. Reviewer #2 (Recommendations For The Authors): With so many distances measured, why was not even a basic structural model attempted? We certainly considered it, but a number of things lead us to conclude that it might imply more certainty about the structure of these termini than we hope to give. (1) Given that the FRET is a time average of positions, these distance constraints would not do much constraining. (2) Given that the termini are likely unstructured and flexible this makes the problem in 1 worse. (3) There is no structural information to use as a starting point for a model. (4) The flexibility of the linkers for each FRET pair also introduces uncertainty. This can, in theory, be modeled as they do in EPR but all of this together made us decide not to do this. What we hope readers take home, is the overall picture of the data is not consistent with the original RIPK1 hypothesis. Maybe it would be good to draw a band on the graphs in Figure 6 for the FRET signal expected for interaction (and thus, disfavoured by these data). This would at least give context. We agree this could be helpful, but it is not so easy to do. What distance would we choose? We could put a line at ~5Å (the model predicted distance). As we noted above, a number of distances could be compatible with an interaction. However, we think it’s unlikely that if a complex was formed that none of our measurements would show a distance closer than 20Å at rest and that an unbinding event would then lead to a decrease in distance. This, to us, is the take home message. Minor points: "Aker unroofing the cells, only fluorescence associated with the "footprint", or dorsal surface, of the cell membrane is lek behind." The authors use dorsal and ventral in this section to describe parts of an adherent cell. But in the first instance, they remove the dorsal part of the cell, and then in this phrase, the dorsal part is lek behind....I am a bit confused. Thank you for pointing out this mistake, we have fixed this. It is indeed the ventral surface lek behind. "bind at rest an" - and? Changed "One previous study used a different approach to try and map the topography of the intracellular termini of ASIC1a comparable to our memFRET experiments." I think a citation is due. Citation added "great deal of precedent" even if this result is from my own lab, I would prefer that the authors note that it's one study from one lab! I think best just to delete "great deal of". “Great deal of” deleted I think the column "Significance" in the tables is unnecessary when the P value is given. Thank you for this suggestion. We agree and have made the change. Figure 7a Q14TAG has a clearly bimodal distribution at pH 8. What could be the meaning of this result? The authors do not mention it that I could find. Perhaps there is no meaning. The authors should state what they think is (or is not) going on. This is a good question and we don’t have a good answer. It appears to be experimental variability. The data from the “low fret” in this experimental condition all came from the same days. So something was different that day. We considered that they might be outliers to exclude but thought showing all of our data was the beVer path. We reperformed the ANOVA here separating out the “outlier” day and nothing of substance changed. Both populations were still different with P value less than 0.001. Typo: Lumencore Changed Maybe just a matter of taste but the panel created with Biorender in Figure 8 is not attractive and depicts the channel differently to in Figure 5D, which is again different from Figure 1A. Surely one advantage of using computer-generated artwork could be to have consistency. We agree and have used the same cartoon for all of our images with the one exception being the schematics that are just meant to show the positions that are present in each bar graph. Figure 4A was squashed to fit (text aspect ratio is wrong). Fixed Reviewer #3 (Recommendations For The Authors): Citrine is used to report incorporation. Yet citrine has a strong tendency to dimerize (PMID 27240257). Did the authors use mCitrine or just Citrine? This is quite important in interpreting their data. Thank you for pointing out this important distinction. We use mCitirine which we have added to the methods. The manuscript has numerous instances of imprecise language. For example, page 10, last para, first line, "previous studies have looked at..." or page 7, final paragraph "tell a similar story". Related, the figures could be much better. For example, in Figure 1, where the authors depict the anap chemical in red, as opposed to the blue one might expect of a blue emiqng fluorophore. In figure 6, ANAP is also in red with the quenching group in green. This is opposite to how one typically thinks of FRET with the warmer color being the acceptor not the donor. Moreover, the pH 6 condition is also colored the same shade of red as the ANAP. Labels of Cys positions would again be useful here. In Figure 3, the heteroatoms of TETAC and C18-NTA are very small and difficult to see. It would also be good to label these structures, and the spectra below, so the reader can tell at a glance without looking at the caption, what the structures and spectra arise from. Also, how are the absorption spectra normalized? This is not discussed in the methods. The lack of attention to presentation mars an otherwise nice study. Thank you for these points. We have made modifications to the manuscript to address these comments. Abstract, second last line "Aker prolonged acidification, ...", 'prolonged' could be interpreted as 'it takes a while for the domain to move' or 'the movement only happens aker a while'. This not what the authors intend to convey. Consider modifying to just 'Aker acidification,' We updated the main text to indicate that prolonged acidification is intended to describe acidification that occurs over the minutes timescale. Pdf page 6, bottom para on Anap incorporation not altering channel function: What is meant by 'steady state pH dependence of activation'? This implies the authors applied a pH stimulus, then waited until equilibrium was achieved ie. until desensitization was complete and measured the current at that point. It seems more likely they simply applied different pH stimuli and measured the peak response and that the use of 'steady state' here is a typo. We removed the phrase steady state. Same section, controls of electrophysiology allude to 485, 505 and 515 ANAP-containing channels. In fact, the authors have no way of determining what fraction (if any) of the pH evoked currents arise from channels containing Anap in those positions versus from simply having a translation stop but still functioning. This should be mentioned. This is correct. We cannot be sure the CTD TAG positions are not a mixture of ANAP-containing channels and truncations. See above for why we do not think this a big concern for the FRET experiments. Functionally, though, you are correct that we cannot tell. We now mention this in the paper. Methods, the abbreviation for SBT should be defined somewhere. Added. Methods, unroofing section, middle paragraph, the authors use nM not nm to list wavelengths of light. Changed. Figure 3C-D: There's an unexpected blip in the Anap emission spectra at ~500 nm. Are the grating efficiency of the spectrograph and quantum efficiency of the camera accounted for in these spectra? This is a good question. The data are not corrected for either camera efficiency or grating efficiency. We don’t have easy access to the actual data (although we can see a pdf version of each). There is a liVle blip in the grating efficiency graph that could partly explain the blip in our spectra. Figure 5C, were recovery experiments routinely done? If so, would be good to show more than n = 1 in the plot to get an idea of reproducibility. Recovery experiments were done in every experiment but are not shown for simplicity. We have included all FRET and recovery data for position Q14TAG-C469 at pH 6 in figure 5C to show reproducibility of our FRET and recovery data. Table 1, considering adding a Δ distance column (pH 8 versus 6) so the magnitude of changes are more easily seen. This is a reasonable suggestion but we decided not to include a Δ distance column. The data are whole numbers and people can easily determine the Δ distance. We felt that including that column would bring too much focus on what we think are preVy small changes. Our hope is that readers take away that the data are not consistent with complex formation between the determine and focus less on absolute distances. Figure 7A, Q14tag pH 8 condition has a quite a bit of spread and, likely, two populations. These data, as well as G11, are unlikely to be parametric and hence ANOVA is inappropriate. A normality test, and likely Kruskal-Wallis test is called for. Aker testing for normality, the data for Q14TAG C485 pH8 are non-normally distributed. However, a Kruskal Wallis is a non-parametric test for a one-way ANOVA and not applicable here. We separated the data out into population 1 and 2 and repeated the two-way ANOVA statistical test. When Q14TAG pH 8 is split into 2 populations, the statistics hardly change. When the data is not separated, Q14TAG pH 8 relative to pH 6 has a p-value <0.0001. When the 2 populations are separated, both populations relative to Q14TAG pH 6 still have a p-value of <0.0001.