The impact of digitization and conventional techniques on the fit of fixed partial dentures FPDs: systematic review and Meta-analysis Authors: Esraa A M Saeed, Samar S Alaghbari, Niu Lin Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractPurpose of the studyThe goal behind this study is to answer the question “In tooth-supported fixed partial dentures (FPDs), does the digital impression techniques compared to fabrications using conventional impression methods improve the marginal and internal fit?BackgroundThe incorporation of digital technology in the fabrication of fixed partial dentures (FPDs) has accelerated over the past decade. This study is directed at evaluating the marginal and internal fit of FPDs manufactured using digital approaches compared to conventional techniques. The need for updated data has encouraged this review.Materials and methodsAn electronic search was conducted in PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and the Grey Database to identify relevant studies. The Modified Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies (MINORS) was used to assess the risk of bias in in vitro experiments.The key results of this meta-analysis were the standard mean differences (SMDs) and 95% confidence intervals (CI) of each main variance, marginal fit, and internal fit between the digital and conventional techniques.Additional analyses were performed to assess the significance of three subgroup parameters: method of digitalization, cement spacer thickness, and span length, and their influence on the fit of the FPDs.ResultsBased on predefined criteria, of the seven articles included in this systematic review, only five were selected for the quantitative data analysis. The marginal fit results were (P = 0.06; SMD: -1.88; 95% CI: − 3.88, 0.11) (P > 0.05) and the internal fit results were (P = 0.02; SMD: -0.80; 95% CI: − 1.49, − 0.10) (P < 0.05).Regarding the subgroup analyses, the method of digitalization subgroup results were (P = 0.35; SMD: -1.89; 95% CI: − 3.89, 0.11) and (P = 0.80; SMD: -0.80; 95% CI: − 1.49, − 0.11) for marginal and internal fit, respectively. The span length results were (P = 0.10; SMD: -1.89; 95% CI: − 3.89, 0.11) for marginal fit and (P = 0.02; SMD: -0.80; 95% CI: − 1.49, − 0.11) for internal fit. The cement spacer thickness (P = 0.01; SMD: -1.89; 95% CI: − 3.89, 0.11) and (P = 0.04; SMD: -0.80; 95% CI: − 1.49, − 0.11) for marginal and internal fit, respectively.ConclusionTooth-retained fixed partial dentures FPDs produced by digital scanning and computer-aided design/computer-aided manufacturing (CAD/CAM) systems can significantly enhance the internal fit compared with those manufactured by traditional methods.Intraoral scanners can replace conventional impressions for the fabrication of FPDs because they minimize the operating time and reduce patient pain.Further clinical studies are required to obtain more conclusive results.Systematic review registrationThis systematic review and meta-analysis was registered in the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO), registration number CRD42021261397.Keywords: Marginal fit, Internal fit, Fixed partial dentures, Digital techniques, Meta-analysis Introduction Dental impressions are commonly used to record oral structures in various dental fields [1]. An accurate impression is the most essential step in the construction of FPDs [2]. Inaccurate impressions may result in ill-fitting margins around the prostheses, plaque deposition, cement dissolving [3], and an elevated risk of pathogenic bacteria, which may also result in pulpal inflammation and necrosis. This causes abutment teeth to fail in various ways [4, 5]. The accuracy of dental impressions is critical for well-adapted restorations. The parameters that determine the fit of a dental restoration FPD are marginal and internal and contribute to its long-term duration [5, 6]. It refers to the degree of intimacy between the established abutment surface and the prostheses. The accuracy of dental impressions is critical for well-adapted restorations. Holmes et al. [7] defined the marginal gap (MG) as the vertical gap between the interior surface of the restoration and the margin of a prepared tooth, whereas the internal gap is the space from the same measurement to the axial wall. The marginal and internal fit of FPDs is determined by the size of the marginal and internal gaps [8]. Although the marginal discrepancy has various clinically acceptable values, McLean and von Fraunhofer presented a value of 120 μm as clinically acceptable as long as the internal fit is between 200 and 300 μm [9]. There are two methods of obtaining a dental impression, conventional impression technique and digital impression methods [10]. In conventional impression techniques, elastomers, such as polyether or polyvinyl siloxane (PVS), are commonly used to obtain impressions of prepared teeth because of their adequate precision and stability. Although conventional impressions have been the gold standard in the construction of multiple-unit fixed dental prostheses (MFDPs) for decades, inappropriate mold selection, material preparation, impression deformations before pouring, and stone model dimensional variations remain the most obvious drawbacks [10–12]. Digital dentistry has undergone dramatic improvements, and numerous CAD/CAM systems that induce intraoral scanning and dental prosthesis manufacturing have been widely accepted [13]. The CAD/CAM system includes two procedures [14]: the CAD process for data collection by digitalization with scanners and designing restorations using accurate software, and the CAM process for manufacturing restorations after data processing. Digitalization can be performed directly on the abutment tooth using an intraoral scanner or an extraoral/laboratory scanner on the impression or definitive model. The most significant benefit of employing CAD/CAM over conventional methods is that it significantly reduces discomfort in patients who are often hesitant to make impressions using traditional techniques [15]. Additional advantages of employing CAD/CAM systems include technological advancements that have made it possible to minimize the shrinking process of the materials to be scanned while simultaneously improving patient convenience [15, 16]. Similarly, the geometry of the intraoral scanner’s light bulb has also been altered and reduced, making it more comfortable for its purpose, that is; the ratio of the apex bulb has been adjusted, allowing the scanner to detect all but the most demanding dental features with this system, notably the posterior teeth [17, 18]. The images acquired from the scan consume significantly less time than analog impressions [3], allowing the dental or technical team to identify errors and limitations at each step and correct them in CAD/CAM systems, where the scanner models, system software, and manufacturing machines are perfectly coordinated [19]. In addition, a digital mock-up provides the patient with an immediate future treatment plan and outcome [16]. Ultimately, this systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to determine whether digital scanning and manufacturing techniques may improve the marginal and internal fit of FPDs compared to conventional techniques. Furthermore, to assess the other variances that improve the marginal and internal fit of FPDs, as well as to evaluate whether intraoral scanners and CAD/CAM technology could be legitimate substitutes for traditional techniques in manufacturing FPDs. The null hypothesis H0 states that, digital impression techniques produce FPD with similar marginal and internal fit compared to conventional techniques, while the alternative hypothesis H1, the digital impression technique could improve the marginal and internal fit of FPD compared to conventional methods. Materials and methods The research protocol and registration This systematic review and meta-analysis of in vitro studies followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines. The study was registered in PROSPERO (Registration number: CRD42021261397). The full search strategy is illustrated in Fig. 1. Flow chart of the selection process according to PRISMA guidelines The search strategy Based on the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions [16], the strategy passed through five major phases: formulation of the study question, search for relevant data, study eligibility, data extraction, and evaluation of the risk of bias. Formulation of the study question Referring to the systematic review question formulation PICO, the questions for this study were as follows: “As for tooth-supported fixed partial dentures (FPDs) (P: population), does the digital impression techniques (I: intervention) compared to fabrications using conventional impression techniques(C: comparison) improve the marginal and internal fit (O: outcome)?” The PICO question structure was also designed to solve two additional investigations regarding FPDs: Do the spacer thickness, span length, and digitalization methods affect the marginal and internal fit compared to traditional workflows? Do the spacer thickness, span length, and digitalization methods affect the marginal and internal fit compared to traditional workflows? Does intraoral scanning technology replace conventional techniques for fabricating FPDs? Does intraoral scanning technology replace conventional techniques for fabricating FPDs? Searching for relevant data Multiple databases were used to conduct a rigorous search (PubMed, Scopus, and the Web of Science) and locate recently relevant published items until January 2022. In addition, grey literature was explored using Google Scholar. A special search was conducted on the annotated bibliographies of the selected studies. The search techniques and terms used in all the databases are illustrated in Table 1. Table 1The search protocol based on PICOS for each database and the associated findingDatabaseTerms used and Search techniquesNo. of resultsPubMed“Digital scanning or digital impression or dental scanning techniques or intraoral scanning technique or digital intraoral scanner impression or dental digitalization” AND “conventional impression or traditional impression techniques or analog impression or dental impression technique” AND “prostheses fit or marginal adaptation or marginal fit or marginal discrepancy or marginal misfits or marginal gap or marginal integrity” AND “internal fit or internal discrepancy or internal adaptation or internal gap or axial misfit or axial gap or axial discrepancy “AND “fixed dental prostheses or FDP or multiple units fixed partial dentures or MUFPD or fixed partial dentures or FPDs or fixed partial prosthesis”180Scopus“Digital scanning or digital impression or dental scanning techniques or intraoral scanning technique or digital intraoral scanner impression or dental digitalization” AND “conventional impression or traditional impression techniques or analog impression or dental impression technique” AND “prostheses fit or marginal adaptation or marginal fit or marginal discrepancy or marginal misfits or marginal gap or marginal integrity” AND “internal fit or internal discrepancy or internal adaptation or internal gap or axial misfit or axial gap or axial discrepancy” AND “fixed dental prostheses or FDP or multiple units fixed partial dentures or MUFPD or fixed partial dentures or FPDs or fixed partial prosthesis”70Web of Science and Grey literature and other sources“Digital scanning or digital impression or dental scanning techniques or intraoral scanning technique or digital intraoral scanner impression or dental digitalization” AND “conventional impression or traditional impression techniques or analog impression or dental impression technique” AND “prostheses fit or marginal adaptation or marginal fit or marginal discrepancy or marginal misfits or marginal gap or marginal integrity” AND “internal fit or internal discrepancy or internal adaptation or internal gap or axial misfit or axial gap or axial discrepancy” AND “fixed dental prostheses or FDP or multiple units fixed partial dentures or MUFPD or fixed partial dentures or FPDs or fixed partial prosthesis “850 The search protocol based on PICOS for each database and the associated finding Study selection criteria Inclusion criteria Experimental in vitro studies on tooth-supported FPDs using digital and conventional techniques. This review was open to papers published in any language, including English, Spanish, and Swedish. The last 6 years of studies were only included in this article due to the tremendous improvements in digital technology. In addition, the rate of innovation in scanner systems and CAD/CAM technologies has progressed drastically over the last 5 years [20]. Exclusion criteria Due to a lack of monitoring, sufficient data, and up-to-date information, we omitted in vivo randomized clinical trials and clinical research designs. Case studies, case series, descriptive studies, opinion articles, and cohort studies were also excluded. Similarly, studies based on scanning implant components or single restorations were also eliminated. Before article screening and evaluation of the consistency and reliability of data collection, the reviewing process was conducted with the calibration of two reviewers (E.S and SSA) utilizing the inclusion criteria. Data extraction The data from the included publications was collected in tables (Microsoft Excel 2016) and is illustrated in Table 2, to identify the key features of the chosen study: the author’s first name, publication year, specimen count per group (sample size), groups and impression techniques, unit count, and preparation type. The total internal gap was the average of all obtained values: cervical, axial, and occlusal gaps. The prosthetic marginal gap is defined as the mean of marginal, absolute marginal, vertical, and horizontal gaps [7]. Table 2The retrieved data from the selected studiesStudy authorSample sizeGroupsSample sizeAbutment teethNumber unitsFinish lineShembesh et al. 201740G 1: conventional impressionG 2: model scanG 3: intra oral iTero scanG 4: intra oral Lava Definition10101010mandibular second premolar and mandibular right first molar3-unitschamfer finish lineKim et al. 201860G1 DD: direct digitalizationNP, P1, P2G2 DI: indirect digitalizationNP, 1P, 2P3030premolar and molarFirst premolar and second molar3-units4-unitchamfer finish lineKocaağaoğlu et al. 201930G1 Ci Conventional impressionG2 Cdi cast scanningG3 Tdi digital impression101010canine and second premolar teeth3-unitsshoulder finish line 1.0 mm in depthMoustapha et al. 201930Group C: conventional impressionGroup S: impression scan groupGroup T: intraoral scanner101010central incisor and canine,3-unitschamfer finish lineArezoobakhsh et al. 202040G1 CIL: Conventional impressionG2 DCL: Dental CastG3 TRI: TRIOS scannerG4 CSI: CS360010101010maxillary first premolar and first molar3-unitschamfer marginStudy authorSample sizeGroupSample sizeabutmentunitsFinish lineÖzal et al. 202148G1: Trios 3 intra oral scannerG2: Trios 4 intra oral scannerG3: CEREC intra oral scannerG4: CEREClaboratory scanners:G5: InEos X5G6: 3Shape D900L121212121212maxillary left canine and second premolar teeth3-unitsdeep shoulder marginal edge,Uluc et al. 2022603S-IOS, scanning mode3S-IMP scanning impression3S-STN scanning castC-IOS, scanning model with OmnicamC-IMP, scanning impression with InEosX5 eC-STN,101010101010Maxillary Right central, canine and second premolar5-unit zirconiachamfer diamondStudy authorImpression material usedType of digital scannerDefinitive RestorationCore materialSpacer thicknessFabrication techniqueShembesh et al. 2017One-step PVS impression techniqueCadentiTero intraoral scannerLava true definition (TT oxide powder)Extraoral scannersD700 laboratory scannerzirconia FDPszirconia35 μm cement spaceHard sintering with firing temperature at 1450°Cforabout 12 hKim et al. 2018Two-stage impression PVSIntraoral scanner:CEREC Omnicam;Extra oral scanners:inEos X5; Dentsply SironaFull zirconia FDPZirconiaNot mentionedsintered to a furnaceKocaağaoğlu et al. 2019One-step with polyvinyl siloxane siliconeIntraoral scanners:CEREC Omnicom3 shape TRIOS −3LS frameworkCoCr W20 μmPrototyping technology high precision high- energy laserMoustapha et al. 2019Two-stage impression PVS A.3 shape TRIOS intraoral scannerlab scanner 1041imetric,Full zirconia FDPZirconia80 μm spacerfive-axis computer numerically controlled (CNC) machinestudy authorImpression techniquesType of the scannerDefinitive restorationMaterial usedSpacer thicknessFabrication techniquesArezoobakhsh et al. 2020Two-stage impressionPVS3 shape TRIOS intraoral scannerCS3600 intraoral scannerLS frameworkzirconia35 μm5-axis milling machine (Versamill 5X200; Axsys Dental Solutions)Özal et al. 20212-stepputty/wash polyvinyl siloxane3Shape Trios 3 (T3)3Shape Trios 4 (T4)CEREC AC OmnicamCEREC PrimescanLaboratory scanners:CEREC InEos X53Shape D900L (3Shape)Full zirconia FDPZirconia50 μmmilling device (milling axes). sintered inFire HTC for 90 min at 1500 °CUluc et al. 2022Scannable polyvinyl siloxane (PVS) impression materialTrios 3 (3ShapeOmnicam SironaDentalE3, 3Shape,Cerec, InEosX5, Sirona DentalFull zirconia FDPZirconia50 μm.Redon Hybrid Technology, 5-axis milling machineStudy authorMethod of assessing the gapNumber of measuring pointsMarginal, Mean ± SDInternal gap, Mean ± SDShembesh et al. 2017Optical comparator (Horizontal Optical Comparator)mesial, distal, buccal, lingualgroup 1: 81.4 μm ± 6.8group 2: 50.2 μm ± 6.1group3:62.4 μm ±5.0group 4:26.6 μm ± 4.7Kim et al. 2018Replica technique at ×50 magnification5 measurements were obtained from the buccal colingual sectioned planes: buccal-MG, buccal-AG, OG, lingual-AG, and lingual-MG.Group DDMG: marginal gap:NP 61 ± 131P 62.36 ± 10.32P 69.38 ± 13.55NP 108.93 ± 19.741P 110.42 ± 18.472P 127.07 ± 20.47CIL: 238 ± 92DCL:248 ± 71TRI: 104 ± 27CSI: 128 ± 16Kocaağaoğlu et al. 2019Stereomicroscope 30 × magnificationMarginal discrepancy in 4 points:Mesial distal buccal and palatalCi: 98.8 ± 16.43Cdi 63.78 ± 14.05Tdi: 65.14 ± 18.05Moustapha et al. 2019Replicatechniquemagnification of 260×marginalChamferAxialincisalC 30 ± 10S 27 ± 7T 20 ± 5C: 84 ± 11S: 78 ± 9T: 70 ± 11Study authorMethod of assessing the gapNumber of measuring pointsMarginal and internal gap, Mean ± SDArezoobakhsh et al. 2020The replica techniquestereomicroscope Microsystems) at × 50 mMarginal,axial,occlusal gapMarginal discrepancy:CIL: 91 ± 40DCL:106 ± 45TRI:60 ± 15CSI:55 ± 13Internal discrepancy/gap:CIL: 238 ± 92DCL:248 ± 71TRI: 104 ± 27CSI: 128 ± 16Özal et al. 2021Silicone replica method at ×40 magnification.4 points:Marginalaxial,axio-occlusal occlusalMarginal discrepancy:G1: 98.9 ± 22.3 98.1 ± 16.8G2: 97.6 ± 26.6,92.8 ± 12.4G3: 91.6 ± 19.1, 105.3 ± 18.5G4: 85.4 ± 12.0, 86.9 ± 19.2G5: 114.4 ± 14.1, 105.3 ± 11.2G6: 128.4 ± 10.9, 139.5 ± 16.0Internal discrepancy/gap:93.8 ± 26.9 98.4 ± 16.893.3 ± 16.2 92.5 ± 11.10105.4 ± 13.7113.4 ± 17.4106.4 ± 8.2114.5 ± 12.0113.3 ± 16.9122.7 ± 13.7118.2 ± 8.5132.1 ± 6.10Uluc et al. 2022Silicone replica methodinspection andmetrology (overlapping) method1900 points on each prepared tooth:MarginalOcclusalAxialMarginal discrepancy:3SIOS 76.2 ± 103S-IMP 81.7 ± 83S-STN 82.6 ± 8C-IOS 80.3 ± 6Internal discrepancy/gap:3S-IOS 80.1 ± 103S-IMP 86.9 ± 133S-STN 86.6 ± 10C-IOS 75.3 ± 10C-IMP 80.3 ± 15 The retrieved data from the selected studies G 1: conventional impression G 2: model scan G 3: intra oral iTero scan G 4: intra oral Lava Definition 10 10 10 10 G1 DD: direct digitalization NP, P1, P2 G2 DI: indirect digitalization NP, 1P, 2P 30 30 premolar and molar First premolar and second molar 3-units 4-unit G1 Ci Conventional impression G2 Cdi cast scanning G3 Tdi digital impression 10 10 10 Group C: conventional impression Group S: impression scan group Group T: intraoral scanner 10 10 10 G1 CIL: Conventional impression G2 DCL: Dental Cast G3 TRI: TRIOS scanner G4 CSI: CS3600 10 10 10 10 G1: Trios 3 intra oral scanner G2: Trios 4 intra oral scanner G3: CEREC intra oral scanner G4: CEREC laboratory scanners: G5: InEos X5 G6: 3Shape D900L 12 12 12 12 12 12 3S-IOS, scanning mode 3S-IMP scanning impression 3S-STN scanning cast C-IOS, scanning model with Omnicam C-IMP, scanning impression with InEosX5 e C-STN, 10 10 10 10 10 10 CadentiTero intraoral scanner Lava true definition (TT oxide powder) Extraoral scanners D700 laboratory scanner Intraoral scanner: CEREC Omnicam; Extra oral scanners: inEos X5; Dentsply Sirona Intraoral scanners: CEREC Omnicom 3 shape TRIOS −3 3 shape TRIOS intraoral scanner lab scanner 1041imetric, Two-stage impression PVS 3 shape TRIOS intraoral scanner CS3600 intraoral scanner 2-step putty/wash polyvinyl siloxane 3Shape Trios 3 (T3) 3Shape Trios 4 (T4) CEREC AC Omnicam CEREC Primescan Laboratory scanners: CEREC InEos X5 3Shape D900L (3Shape) Trios 3 (3Shape Omnicam SironaDental E3, 3Shape, Cerec, InEosX5, Sirona Dental group 1: 81.4 μm ± 6.8 group 2: 50.2 μm ± 6.1 group3:62.4 μm ±5.0 group 4:26.6 μm ± 4.7 Group DD MG: marginal gap: NP 61 ± 13 1P 62.36 ± 10.3 2P 69.38 ± 13.55 NP 108.93 ± 19.74 1P 110.42 ± 18.47 2P 127.07 ± 20.47 CIL: 238 ± 92 DCL:248 ± 71 TRI: 104 ± 27 CSI: 128 ± 16 Marginal discrepancy in 4 points: Mesial distal buccal and palatal Ci: 98.8 ± 16.43 Cdi 63.78 ± 14.05 Tdi: 65.14 ± 18.05 Replica technique magnification of 260× marginal Chamfer Axial incisal C 30 ± 10 S 27 ± 7 T 20 ± 5 C: 84 ± 11 S: 78 ± 9 T: 70 ± 11 The replica technique stereomicroscope Microsystems) at × 50 m Marginal, axial, occlusal gap Marginal discrepancy: CIL: 91 ± 40 DCL:106 ± 45 TRI:60 ± 15 CSI:55 ± 13 Internal discrepancy/gap: CIL: 238 ± 92 DCL:248 ± 71 TRI: 104 ± 27 CSI: 128 ± 16 4 points: Marginal axial, axio-occlusal occlusal Marginal discrepancy: G1: 98.9 ± 22.3 98.1 ± 16.8 G2: 97.6 ± 26.6,92.8 ± 12.4 G3: 91.6 ± 19.1, 105.3 ± 18.5 G4: 85.4 ± 12.0, 86.9 ± 19.2 G5: 114.4 ± 14.1, 105.3 ± 11.2 G6: 128.4 ± 10.9, 139.5 ± 16.0 Internal discrepancy/gap: 93.8 ± 26.9 98.4 ± 16.8 93.3 ± 16.2 92.5 ± 11.10 105.4 ± 13.7113.4 ± 17.4 106.4 ± 8.2114.5 ± 12.0113.3 ± 16.9122.7 ± 13.7 118.2 ± 8.5132.1 ± 6.10 Silicone replica method inspection and metrology (overlapping) method 1900 points on each prepared tooth: Marginal Occlusal Axial Marginal discrepancy: 3SIOS 76.2 ± 10 3S-IMP 81.7 ± 8 3S-STN 82.6 ± 8 C-IOS 80.3 ± 6 Internal discrepancy/gap: 3S-IOS 80.1 ± 10 3S-IMP 86.9 ± 13 3S-STN 86.6 ± 10 C-IOS 75.3 ± 10 C-IMP 80.3 ± 15 The methodological quality and risk of bias assessment MINORS This tool (MINORS) is commonly used to evaluate the risk of bias in in vitro studies. It consisted of 11 items. The criteria were scored as follows: 2 if data were available and adequate, 1 if data were not adequately reported, and 0 when data are unavailable. Table 3 illustrate the scores for each included study. Table 3Scores obtained for each included study using MINORSEvaluation itemsShembeshKimKaggoluMoustaphaA.AÖzalUluc1-basically stated purpose22222222-Contemporary groups20222023- Scanning technique based on guideline22222224-Control groups21212015-Definitive restoration10012226-Blindness of observer or statistician22010107-Sufficient number of observations in every study12120118-Sufficient method of observation to assess the gap22222229- Standard technique for tooth preparation222222210-Statistical analysis.2222222SCORE18151517161416Total score: equal to or greater than 18, it indicated a low risk of bias; if equal to or more than 16, it indicated a moderate risk; and if it was equal to 15 or less, it indicated a high risk of bias Scores obtained for each included study using MINORS Total score: equal to or greater than 18, it indicated a low risk of bias; if equal to or more than 16, it indicated a moderate risk; and if it was equal to 15 or less, it indicated a high risk of bias Data analysis The analysis was carried out on 200 FPDs: 60 were constructed using conventional methods and 140 via digital techniques (of which 60 models were scanned with an intraoral scanner and 80 models were scanned with a laboratory scanner). The key result measurement in this study was the SMD of each of the two variables, marginal and internal fit, constructed using two impression techniques, digital and conventional, utilizing the following formula: The internal fit was categorized as the mean of all available internal gap values illustrated in the studies: axial, cervical, and occlusal gaps. The secondary results evaluated the effect of the digitalization method, span length, and cement space thickness on the marginal and internal fit. The quantitative analysis was calculated from the mean with a 95% confidence interval for each effect size of each subgroup, depending on the SMD [21]. All statistical analyses were performed using the statistical program STATA. Results Search results The electronic search identified 1100 articles, 180 from PubMed/MEDLINE, 70 from Scopus, and 850 from other sources (Web of Science, Google Scholar, and Grey Database). After duplicate articles had been removed, 250 articles were excluded during the first screening stage for several reasons. Some experiments were conducted on single restorations and implants, and others were in vivo and case report studies. In the second stage, accompanying the eligibility criteria, screening of titles and abstracts of articles resulted in 16 articles; of these, seven studies were included in the systematic review, and the remaining were omitted as follows: five studies were published more than 7 years ago, two studies lacked related data, and the last two focused mainly on accuracy and precision rather than fit or adaptation. In the last search phase, seven full texts were comprehensively screened, and only five experiments were included in the meta-analysis, as two studies have yet to reveal a control group. The full selection process according to the PRISMA guidelines is illustrated in Fig. 1. Results from the extracted data in the included studies The chamfer margin was prepared in most studies, whereas the shoulder margin was used in two studies. In addition, three dissimilar gap measuring techniques were used: the replica technique with stereomicroscope was the predominant method in assessing the marginal and internal gaps; the other techniques include the optical comparator and scanning electron microscopy. Among all available scanners, six intraoral scanners were utilized in the included studies: Lava True Definition, iTero, TRIOS 3S, TRIOS 4S, Cerec Omnicam, and Primescan. Since diverse oral scanners employ various image collection technologies, their scanning precision and accuracy vary significantly. The methodological quality and risk of bias assessment The overall assessment results of each study are presented in Table 3. All studies stated a clear aim for the study objectives, scanning techniques according to guidelines, sufficient methods to assess the gap, tooth preparation technique, and statistical analysis. In contrast, except for a single study [19], which had a low possibility of bias, all studies demonstrated a moderate to high risk of bias in terms of the blindness of the observer and the adequate number of observations. Three studies had total scores of 17, 16, and 16, respectively, indicating a moderate risk of bias whereas three studies scored 15, 14, and 14, respectively, indicating a greater possibility of bias. Meta-analysis results Of the seven studies included in this systematic review, only five were eligible for meta-analysis. Two studies were excluded as they lacked a control group. Five studies were used to compare the marginal fit, and three experiments were used to compare the internal fit between the two impression techniques. All analyses were measured as means with a 95% confidence interval for each size model of each group, depending on the SMD. I2 tests demonstrated 96.69% in the marginal fit and 65.93% in the internal fit, revealing a significant heterogeneity between the included studies. Marginal fit results The assessment was conducted to evaluate the marginal fit, and the results of the meta-analysis are shown in Fig. 2. Based on the assumption that the outcomes of the included studies preferred the digital approach, the marginal fit results revealed a statistically non-significant difference between digital and conventional workflows (P = 0.06; SMD: -1.88; 95% CI: − 3.88, 0.11) (P > 0.05). SMDs with a 95% confidence interval in the marginal fit between digital and conventional techniques among the included studies and overall results Galbraith chart Fig. 3 and Funnel plot Fig. 4 were used to show the distribution of effect values to assess the possibility of publication bias. The random-effects analysis was further done, and showed no association between SMD and the small size effect Fig. 5. The Galbraith plot and meta-regression in the included studies indicated a risk of bias The funnel plot with Pseudo 95% confidence intervals in the marginal fit among the studies Effect size models of the included studies Subgroups analyses: Further analyses were conducted to assess the effects of each influencing factor on marginal fit, the digitalization method, span length (number of units), and cement space thickness. Subgroup 1: The analysis investigated the influence of direct and indirect digitalization on the marginal fit. Although the results of the included studies favored the full digital approach over partial techniques, the results showed a non-significant difference between the direct and indirect scanning (P = 0.35; SMD: -1.89; 95% CI: − 3.89, 0.11) (P > 0.05). The SMD results are illustrated in Fig. 6. SMD of the marginal fit between the direct and indirect scanning groups Subgroup 2: Regarding the span length evaluation, the analysis revealed a statistically non-significant difference in the marginal fit for three- and five-unit FPDs (P = 0.10; SMD: -1.89; 95% CI: − 3.89, 0.11) (P > 0.05). The SMD results of the span length in marginal fit are illustrated in Fig. 7. The SMD of the span length on the marginal fit between 3- and 5-unit FPDs Subgroup 3: The analysis was performed on the thickness of the cement space. The results showed a statistical difference between the studies in the marginal fit when using different spacer thicknesses; 35 μm, 20 μm, 80 μm, and 50 μm (P = 0.01; SMD: -1.89; 95% CI: − 3.89, 0.11) (P < 0.05). The SMD results of cement space thickness on the marginal fit are illustrated in Fig. 8. The SMD of cement space thickness on the marginal fit Internal fit results The mean and SMDs for the intaglio fit between digital and conventional workflows are illustrated in Fig. 9. The analysis indicated a statistically significant difference in the internal fit between digital and conventional workflows (P = 0.02; SMD: -0.80; 95% CI: − 1.49, − 0.10) (P < 0.05). SMDs with 95% confidence interval of the internal fit between digital and conventional techniques among the included studies and overall results Galbraith chart Fig. 10 and Funnel plot Fig. 11 were used to show the distribution of effect values to assess the possibility of publication bias. The random-effects analysis was further done, and showed an association between SMD and the small size effect Fig. 12. The Galbraith plot and meta-regression in the included studies The funnel plot with Pseudo 95% confidence intervals for internal fit among the studies Effect size models of the included studies Subgroups analyses: Subgroup 1: Subgroup 1: This analysis focuses on the impact of the digitalization approach on internal fit. Although the results presented in the included studies favored the full digital approach rather than partial techniques, the difference in the internal fit between the extraoral and intraoral scanning groups is statistically insignificant, (P = 0.80; SMD: -0.80; 95% CI: − 1.49, − 0.11) (P > 0.05). The SMD results between direct and indirect digitalization methods are presented in Fig. 13. Internal fit SMD results between direct and indirect digitalization methods Subgroup 2: Subgroup 2: In the span length analysis, there was a significant difference in the internal fit between the two groups for three-unit and five-unit FPD (P = 0.02; SMD: -0.80; 95% CI: − 1.49, − 0.11) (P < 0.05). This indicates that the span length/number of units can inversely affect the internal fit of FPD. The SMD results of the span length on the internal fit between 3- and 5-unit FPDs are illustrated in Fig. 14. The SMD of the span length on the internal fit between 3- and 5-unit FPDs Subgroup 3 analysis: Subgroup 3 analysis: Regarding the cement space thickness, a significant statistical difference (P = 0.04; SMD: -0.80; 95% CI: − 1.49, − 0.11) (P < 0.05) was observed between the three- and five-unit FPDs, indicating that spacer thickness inversely affects the internal fit of FPDs. The SMD results of cement space thickness on the internal fit are illustrated in Fig. 15. The SMD of space thickness on internal fit Discussion Recent data regarding the fit of tooth-supported FPDs that compare digital and conventional workflows are contradictory and heterogeneous, the need for updated results has encouraged this review. According to the relevant literature, this study will be the first review of scientific research discussing FPDs’ marginal and internal fit fabricated by digital and traditional approaches, with a focus on published studies within the last 6 years. The year 2017 was chosen as the cutoff for study inclusion because the rate of innovation in scanner systems and CAD/CAM technologies has drastically progressed over the last 5 years. The earliest studies revealed the greatest mean difference between digital and traditional approaches, which may have affected the analysis results [20]. Clinical studies were excluded as there were few published in vitro experiments and even fewer in vivo studies evaluating the fit of FPDs in terms of marginal and internal fit using digital and conventional workflows [22]. Ethical concerns aside, intraoral environmental challenges that restrict the scanning procedure, the swallowing movements, the existence of blood or saliva, and involuntary tongue movement may jeopardize the digitalization procedure [18]. Additionally, the results were variable, and the majority of studies confirmed the presence of many confounding factors that may have affected the analysis results. Moreover, no study has evaluated the survival and follow-up of full-coverage restorations or fixed partial dentures [23]. Furthermore, two recent meta-analyses were based on in vivo studies, obviating the need for a second analysis [22, 24]. The outcome of this analysis indicated that tooth-supported FPDs fabricated by digital techniques significantly enhance the internal fit but it didn’t influence the marginal fit compared to fabrications using conventional methods. These results are compared to a meta-analysis by Russo et al. [25], a greater marginal gap value was observed in MFDPs fabricated by scanning systems than in those fabricated by conventional techniques, however, the difference was not statistically significant. In contrast, Morsy et al. [26] revealed that the marginal and internal fit of FPDs were significantly enhanced by digital scanning. In this study, a single clinical study and eight experiments were selected for the meta-analysis. Nevertheless, the clinical and experimental values may conflict with and mislead the outcome. Furthermore, the analysis did not fully evaluate the direct and indirect scanning technique results, and the publication period of the included studies is another factor that could influence the results of this analysis. Regarding the method of digitalization, the results using extraoral and intraoral scanners showed no significant difference in marginal and internal fit, however, intraoral scanners could replace conventional impressions for the fabrication of FPDs because they minimize the operating time and remove patient pain. They also reduce fabrication processes, which may lead to errors due to less coordination between the clinic and dental laboratory. Three different fabrication methods were observed in some of the included studies, and the results were comparable to those of different combinations of the fully conventional method, full digitalization, and partially digital groups. Conventional impressions and/or stone casts were scanned using an extraoral scanner. Even though the included studies preferred intraoral scanners over conventional or partial techniques, the statistical difference was insignificant. A comprehensive review of intraoral scanner precision has been performed [18]. For short-span FPD impressions, the accuracy of the IOS was still similar to that of PVS and polyether impressions. As the span increased, the accuracy of the impression of the PVS became evident. Hasanzade et al. [21] observed that a fully digital workflow is superior to conventional techniques in terms of marginal fit. The authors suggested that the majority of inconsistencies in conventional or partial workflows were induced by stone-cast fabrication. However, in a fully digitalized group, the scanner systems, design software, and milling machines are appropriately surpassed, and the errors in each process can be corrected. When evaluating the effect of the span length /number of units based on the outcome, digital techniques can significantly enhance the internal fit of three and five-unit FPD, however the difference in the marginal fit between the digital and conventional workflows for three-unit and five-unit FPDs is statistically non-significant. Another study revealed that marginal and internal fit were significantly affected by the edentulous span length of three- and four-unit fixed partial dentures, the study also discovered that the digitalization system produces fewer marginal and internal discrepancies than traditional techniques in up to 4-unit zirconia FPDs [21]. This significant difference is probably due to the marginal and internal gap values in the experimental findings in early published literature (2017–2012). Regarding the cement spacer thickness, the results revealed a significantly better marginal and internal fit with digital workflow than a conventional workflow. The internal gap of the three-unit FPDs was significantly smaller when the spacer thickness decreased [26]. As the number of clinical studies is limited, the clinical significance of this study is that the digital scanning technique is a developing technology, and it is essential to test in standard situations while eliminating confounding factors. The results of this study will help make an initial judgment about the superiority of digital and conventional methods before making a conclusive decision about their clinical performance. There are many reasons could explain the heterogeneity between the studies; the small number of included studies, increased bias in most of the selected studies, and experimental differences such as dissimilar scanner models utilized among experiments, study sample size, impression materials, preparation design, measuring method, fabrication machines and techniques, milling system, and data analysis tests used in each study. The possible source of bias in marginal fit results between the digital and conventional group is mainly due to methodological difference between the included studies, however in internal fit analysis a publication bias was noticed due to small effect size. Conclusion This systematic review and meta-analysis produced specific conclusions based on these findings: The study revealed that tooth-supported FPDs manufactured using CAD/CAM technology significantly improved the internal fit, but did not affect the marginal fit. The study revealed that tooth-supported FPDs manufactured using CAD/CAM technology significantly improved the internal fit, but did not affect the marginal fit. Although the results of digitalization methods using extraoral and intraoral scanners showed no significant difference in marginal and internal fit, intraoral scanners could replace conventional impressions for the fabrication of FPDs because they minimize the operating time and remove patient pain. They also reduce fabrication processes, which may lead to errors owing to less coordination between the clinic and dental laboratory. Although the results of digitalization methods using extraoral and intraoral scanners showed no significant difference in marginal and internal fit, intraoral scanners could replace conventional impressions for the fabrication of FPDs because they minimize the operating time and remove patient pain. They also reduce fabrication processes, which may lead to errors owing to less coordination between the clinic and dental laboratory. Digital procedures exhibited a significant difference in internal fit between three- and five-unit FPDs, and lengthening the span of FPDs negatively impacted their fit. Digital procedures exhibited a significant difference in internal fit between three- and five-unit FPDs, and lengthening the span of FPDs negatively impacted their fit. The thickness of the cement space inversely influences the marginal and internal fit of the FPDs. The thickness of the cement space inversely influences the marginal and internal fit of the FPDs. The results should be interpreted cautiously, as they were conducted on a limited number of studies throughout a limited period. Besides, the findings focused mostly on experiments conducted in laboratory settings. Fewer clinical studies in the published literature mean less conclusive results; thus, more updated clinical studies with success and survival rates are needed to provide a stronger evidence. Acknowledgements The authors would like to express their greatest appreciation to all associate professors and colleagues at Xi’an Jiaotong University for their suggestions and constructive critiques on developing and refining this research paper. Abbreviations Fixed Partial Dentures The Modified Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies standard mean differences Confidence Interval Computer-aided design/Computer-aided manufacturing Intraoral scanner Preferred Reporting Item for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis Marginal gap Polyvinyl siloxane Multiple-unit fixed dental prostheses Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review Authors’ contributions E.A.M.S and S.S.A contributed to data collection, study design, and statistical data analysis. All authors drafted the article, critical revision, final approval, and guarantor of the manuscript. Funding This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (81970981). Availability of data and materials An electronic search was conducted on different databases including PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Grey literature to uncover relevant studies. The datasets generated and analysed during the current study are available in the Raw data excel sheet https://1drv.ms/x/s!AsFQHSyHP8BRgwqL66MFzmLrIcgF. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate ‘Not applicable’. This study is secondary research based on in vitro studies and involving literature that is in the public domain. Consent for publication ‘Not applicable’. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Esraa A. M. Saeed and Samar S. Alaghbari contributed equally to the work. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement An electronic search was conducted on different databases including PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Grey literature to uncover relevant studies. The datasets generated and analysed during the current study are available in the Raw data excel sheet https://1drv.ms/x/s!AsFQHSyHP8BRgwqL66MFzmLrIcgF.