Metal Concentrations in E-Cigarette Aerosol Samples: A Comparison by Device Type and Flavor Authors: Angela Aherrera, Joyce Jy Lin, Rui Chen, Mina Tehrani, Andrew Schultze, Aryan Borole, Stefan Tanda, Walter Goessler, Ana M Rule Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractBackground:The rapid evolution of electronic cigarette (e-cigarette) products warrants surveillance of the differences in exposure across device types—modifiable devices (MODs), cartridge (“pod”)-containing devices (PODs), disposable PODs (d-PODs)—and flavors of the products available on the market.Objective:This study aimed to measure and compare metal aerosol concentrations by device type and common flavors.Methods:We collected aerosol from 104 MODs, 67 PODs (four brands: JUUL, Bo, Suorin, PHIX), and 23 d-PODs (three brands: ZPOD, Bidi, Stig) via droplet deposition in a series of conical pipette tips. Metals and metalloids [aluminum (Al), arsenic (As), cobalt (Co), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), antimony (Sb), tin (Sn), and zinc (Zn)] were measured using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS), results were log-transformed for statistical analysis, and concentrations are reported in aerosol units (mg/m3).Results:Of the 12 elements analyzed, concentrations were statistically significantly higher in MOD devices, except for Co and Ni, which were higher in PODs and d-PODs. Of the POD brands analyzed, PHIX had the highest median concentrations among four metals (Al, Ni, Pb, and Sn) compared to the rest of the POD brands. According to POD flavor, seven metals were three to seven orders of magnitude higher in tobacco-flavored aerosol compared to those in mint and mango flavors. Among the d-POD brands, concentrations of four metals (Al, Cu, Ni, and Pb) were higher in the ZPOD brand than in Bidi Stick and Stig devices. According to d-POD flavor, only Cr concentrations were found to be statistically significantly higher in mint than tobacco-flavored d-PODs.Discussion:We observed wide variability in aerosol metal concentrations within and between the different e-cigarette device types, brands, and flavors. Overall, MOD devices generated aerosols with higher metal concentrations than PODs and d-PODs, and tobacco-flavored aerosols contained the highest metal concentrations. Continued research is needed to evaluate additional factors (i.e., nicotine type) that contribute to metal exposure from new and emerging e-cigarette devices in order to inform policy. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP11921 Introduction Electronic cigarette (e-cigarette) use has continued to increase, despite growing evidence of their toxicity and adverse health effects.1–4 As of 2021, 11.3% of U.S. high school students (1.72 million) and 2.8% of middle school students (320,000) reported currently using e-cigarettes.5 E-cigarettes are primarily composed of a battery, a cartridge or tank, a liquid solution [e-liquid, composed of propylene glycol (PG) and vegetable glycerin (VG) with varying concentrations of nicotine and flavorings], and a heating element, typically a metallic coil, to generate an aerosol that is inhaled by the user. Within the past decade, these devices have rapidly evolved. First-generation devices (∼2005–2010) are known as cig-a-likes, as they resemble conventional tobacco cigarettes; they contain disposable prefilled cartridges (cartomizers) and low-powered rechargeable batteries with no ability to change the power.6 Second- and third-generation devices (since ∼2010) have been classified as “open” devices and include e-pen models and tank-style or modifiable devices (MODs), which are refillable, reusable systems and common among former smokers.7 Compared to cig-a-likes, MOD devices are typically larger and allow users to modify their devices by replenishing the e-liquid (varying flavors and tobacco concentrations), changing heating coils, and adjusting power output. Fourth-generation devices (since ∼2015), referred to as PODs (i.e., JUUL), were initially shaped like USB thumb drives and, similar to cig-a-likes, had low-capacity rechargeable batteries and single-use cartridges (“pods”) filled with nicotine-containing e-liquid.8,9 These PODs quickly evolved to offer options not resembling USB drives (i.e., Suorin, Vuse) that also offered refillable pods. What differentiates PODs from cig-a-likes is the e-liquid formulation; instead of using freebase nicotine, which is commonly found in e-liquids of cig-a-likes (and earlier MODs), PODs use nicotine salts, a protonated form of nicotine with lower pH, which allows for a smoother “throat hit” that can deliver higher nicotine concentration.10,11 Although the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) implemented a partial ban on JUUL flavors early in 2020 to curb use among youth, newer disposable pods (d-PODs) (i.e., Puff Bar, Bidi Stick) were introduced in 2019, eclipsing JUUL in sales as of April 202012; d-PODs have since gained popularity due to their attractive colors, low price, and fruity flavors.13 While the perception of safety and variety of appealing flavors contribute to their popularity,14–16 e-cigarettes are not toxicant-free. Metals and metalloids linked to cardiovascular and kidney disease,17–19 neurotoxicity,20 and lung cancer21,22 have been detected in the e-liquids and aerosols of cig-a-like, MODs, and PODs.23–28 Studies have shown sources of metal exposure may be from the heating coil used to aerosolize the e-liquid,14,24 the e-liquid itself,24 as well as soldered joints and other parts of the device.29,30 Across all device generations, heating coils are commonly made up of metal alloys, such as Kanthal (chromium, aluminum, iron), Nichrome (nickel and chromium), and stainless steel (iron, nickel, chromium),14,24,31 while solder joints are made up of tin and lead.29,30 Evidence of toxic metal exposure from e-cigarettes is growing, with a majority of studies to date focused on cig-a-likes25,27,29,30,32–35 and MODs.24,26,36–38 Studies investigating the constituents of POD devices39–42 have focused on e-liquid43 and aerosol samples.26,44–47 To our knowledge, only one other study has looked at exposure from the more recent and popularly used d-PODs that were released into the market in 2019.48 With the rapid evolution of e-cigarette products in recent years, differences in exposure across all three popular device generations—MODs, PODs, d-PODs—and e-liquid flavors have yet to be characterized. The aims of this study were two-fold: first, to compare metal concentrations in the aerosol of several popular brands and flavors of PODs and d-PODs and, second, to compare the metal aerosol concentrations between device types (generations) in order to inform regulatory agencies and the public of the differential risk of exposure to toxic metals. Methods A convenience sample of commercially available e-cigarette device types (194 devices: 104 MODs, 67 PODs, 23 d-PODs), brands (including six POD and seven d-POD brands), and flavors (including tobacco, mint, and mango) were analyzed for this project. All d-POD (n=23) and some POD devices (n=44) were purchased online, while all MODs (n=104) and some POD devices (n=23) were brought to the lab by e-cigarette users participating in the Exposure to Metals from E-Cigarettes (EMIT) study (R01ES030025, PI: Dr. Ana Rule). The study recruited participants from April 2015 until March 2020 through vaping conventions and flyers posted in e-cigarette shops, newspapers, college campuses, and social media platforms. Participants were instructed to bring their regular e-cigarette device and refilling dispenser of e-liquid or a replacement POD (as applicable) on the day of the interview; information relevant to this paper included type of device, brand name, and e-liquid flavor; nicotine strength, puff frequency and duration, and other demographic and behaviors not relevant to this paper were also obtained. The study was approved by the institutional review board of the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. All participants provided informed consent. Aerosol Collection For all e-cigarettes, we collected 0.25–0.50 ml of aerosol generated by the e-cigarette devices by connecting the mouthpiece via flexible tubing to a peristaltic pump inside a fume hood. The aerosol collection is based on the methodology described in Olmedo et al.24 and Hilpert et al.,49 which has been used in several other studies.26,31 To optimally generate and collect e-cigarette aerosol based on the device’s power settings, the pump’s flow rate was 0.90L/min for MODs and 0.70L/min for PODs (including d-PODs); flow rates were measured using a Primary Standard Calibrator (Bios Defender 520; Mesa Laboratories, Inc.). The pump operated at 4 s/puff and 30 s interpuff time.50 Briefly, on the downstream side of the pump, the generated aerosol was collected in a 1.5-mL centrifuge tube via impaction into a series of conical pipette tips and Tygon tubing L/S (inner radius, 4.8 mm).49 MODs were activated between 13 and 65 puffs (average of 28) to collect the required aerosol volume, while 35 to 500 puffs (average of 178) were needed for the PODs. The number of puffs required to collect from each device was recorded. The large puff range is due to the varying device, power settings, and aerosol generation characteristics of each device, and corresponds with whatever settings our participants were using in case of MODs, and with the only setting available in case of PODs and d-PODs. To improve the recovery of condensed aerosol for metal analysis, the tubing was manually flicked to dislodge the remaining droplets and connected back to the peristaltic pump. The pump was then activated for 30 s with room air, with the e-cigarette device disconnected to push the remaining droplets. Aerosol recovery using this method has been previously calculated as 72–83% for PODs and 78–83% for MODs.26 All samples were stored at room temperature before analysis of metal concentrations. To account for potential contamination from room air and/or the collection device, five samples of “blank e-liquid,” consisting of a solution of 70% propylene glycol (high purity grade; Amresco) and 30% glycerol (ultrapure; ICN Biochemicals) were poured into a 1-mL pipette tip and passed through the plastic tubing and conical pipette tips, using the peristaltic pump, drawing laboratory room air. The median concentration from these five blanks was used to correct aerosol sample results. More details on quality control and assurance are reported in Olmedo et al.24 E-Cigarette Devices Used for the Study MODs. From 2015 until 2017, we collected aerosols from 104 MODs of daily e-cigarette users who were recruited as part of the EMIT study.31,51 PODs. From 2019 until 2021, several brands of rechargeable (nondisposable) POD devices were selected based on popularity in the United States.52–54 Aerosol samples (n=67) were collected from devices purchased online (n=44) or from devices brought to the lab by e-cigarette users (n=23) participating in the EMIT Study. Brands included JUUL (JUUL Labs) (n=45), BO (BO Vaping) (n=6), PHIX (PHIX Vapor) (n=6), Suorin (n=6), and other brands brought by participants (n=4) [Nautilus (Shenzen Eigate Technology), Leap (E-Alternative Solutions), Vuse (R.J. Reynolds Vapor Company), and one unknown]. To facilitate comparability between brands, an available tobacco flavor (n=28) was selected for each brand (Virginia tobacco for JUUL, Cut tobacco for Bo, Original tobacco for PHIX, and tobacco Mi-Salt E-liquids for Suorin). To compare metal generation by flavor, mint (n=20) and mango JUUL flavors (n=14) as well as “other” flavors (n=5) from other devices (i.e., Nautilus, Leap) such as strawberry and artic berry were included; these flavor groups were included based on popularity55 as well as what participants brought to the study. Nicotine concentrations across brands ranged from 35 to 59mg/ml as indicated by the cartridge packaging or online website. d-PODs. Three brands of d-PODs were selected based on popularity and availability in the United States in March 2020 and purchased online. Although Puff Bars were the most popular d-PODs at the time,13 we were unable to purchase these devices, as they were unavailable online and at local vape shops due to FDA restrictions. The brands selected were Z-POD (Plus Distribution, Inc.), Bidi Stick (Bidi Vapor, LLC), and Stig (Stig, Inc.). To facilitate comparability with other device types and between brands, tobacco flavor (n=12) was selected (Tobacco for Z-Pod, Classic tobacco for Bidi Stick, and Cubano for Stig). To compare metal generation by flavor within a brand, mint flavors (n=11) were also selected for Stig (Mighty Mint) and Bidi stick (Mint Freeze). Although a total of 29 d-PODs were purchased, there were six d-PODS that did not generate aerosol and were not included in the analysis. Twenty-three d-PODs were successfully sampled: five of Z-Pods (tobacco), nine of Bidi Stick (three Classic tobacco and six mint), and nine of Stig (four Cubano and five Mighty Mint). Nicotine concentrations across brands ranged from 50 to 60mg/ml as indicated by the cartridge packaging or online website. Metal Analyses All aerosol samples were sent to the Institute for Chemistry, University of Graz (Graz, Austria) for metal analysis. Twelve elements were analyzed because of their human health toxicity and likelihood of presence based on coil composition and on previously conducted studies23,24,26: aluminum (Al), arsenic (As), cobalt (Co), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), antimony (Sb), tin (Sn), and zinc (Zn). Methods for metal analysis have previously been reported in detail.24 In brief, multielement analysis in all samples and calibration standards were performed on an Agilent 8800 or 8900 triple quadrupole inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICPQQQMS) (Agilent Technologies). To ensure the accuracy of the results, an internal standard and a reference standard were used. The multielement internal standard consisted of a solution containing 200mg/L of beryllium (Be), germanium (Ge), indium (In), and lutetium (Lu) and was added online to the samples prior to the nebulizer of the ICP-MS via a T-piece to compensate for instrumental instabilities and possible matrix effects. In addition, a reference standard [Reference Material NIST SRM 1640a—Trace Elements in Natural Water; National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)] and two blanks were analyzed at the beginning of each sequence and after every X sample, where X is the square root of the total number of samples in the sequence. All elements of the reference standard were found within 5% of the NIST-certified concentrations. Altogether, the standard was analyzed 12 times, with a mean recovery of 98%±2% standard deviation (SD), suggesting a very stable measurement. Concentrations were reported in a weight/weight basis (μg/kg) due to the difficulty to measure the volumes of thick and sticky samples. Limits of detection (LOD) were calculated by dividing the SD of the response of the ICP-MS by the slope of the calibration curve and multiplying the quotient by a factor of 3. LODs in solution in μg/kg varied across three analytical batches. The average LODs were 2.00×10−1 for Al, 3.87×10−3 for As, 2.80×10−4 for Co, 8.48×10−3 for Cr, 2.80×10−4 for Cu, 3.33×10−2 for Fe, 7.38×10−3 for Mn, 6.83×10−3 for Ni, 2.22×10−3 for Pb, 5.25×10−3 for Sn, 1.92×10−3 for Sb, and 1.60×10−1 for Zn. Concentrations below the LOD were replaced with the LOD divided by the square root of 2 for analysis.56 Metals with >50% of samples below LOD were excluded from statistical analyses. Conversion to Air Concentrations and Comparison to Exposure Limits Metal concentrations reported by the lab in a weight/weight basis (μg/kg) were converted into aerosol concentrations (mg/m3) as described in Olmedo et al.24 Between 13 and 500 puffs were collected for analysis; based on past recruitment, e-cigarette users reported the number of puffs per day ranged from 15 to 1,000 puffs,51 so collected condensed aerosol was assumed to be less than or equivalent to daily consumption and representative of daily exposure. We assumed that metal concentrations emitted per puff is not homogenous and can increase or decrease, depending on several factors such as the type of device, condition of the coil, battery life, and device settings; as the conversion from μg/kg to mg/m3 can be highly dependable on the aerosol production of each device/setting, results vary depending on the device. However, since the overall conclusions hold independent of the units used (Table S1), we chose to report in mg/m3 to be able to compare to health-based limits. In brief, the conversion factored in the total weight of the sample collected (mg) and the volume of air required to obtain each sample, which was calculated by multiplying the puffing flow rate Q (L/min), the puffing duration (4 s/puff or 0.066 min/puff), and the number of puffs required to collect the desired volume of aerosol (Equations 1–3). Since aerosol production is not constant along sampling, this conversion is an estimate. This conversion allows for comparison to aerosol standards and health-based exposure limits of metal concentrations a person would typically inhale (minute ventilation: 6L/min) during a window of exposure. Air concentrations of Cr, Mn, and Ni were compared to the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) chronic minimum risk levels (MRLs),57 and Pb concentrations were compared to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS).58 Both limits are 24-h exposure averages. As there are no acute, intermediate, or chronic duration inhalation MRLs for As, sample concentrations were compared to the California EPA (CalEPA) chronic inhalation reference exposure level (REL) for total As.59 In addition, aerosol metal concentration from each of our tested devices was compared to the U.S. FDA permissible daily exposure (PDE) limits for elemental impurities of As, Cr, Ni, and Pb in inhalation medications in units of μg/day.60 Metal aerosol exposure per day (μg/day) was estimated by multiplying the aerosol concentrations (μg/g) by the daily e-liquid dose in grams. MOD e-liquid consumption has been reported at a 32.5-mL median weekly51 or 5mL/day.61 Based on an e-liquid density of 1.14±0.06 (mean±SD) g/mL, previously measured in our laboratory, 5mL of e-liquid is approximately equivalent to 5.7g consumed per day. Typical consumption of four to ten cartridges per month (∼0.1–0.3g per day) for JUUL has been reported.62 The daily dose was therefore assumed to be 5.7g/day for MODs and 0.2g/day for PODs and d-PODs. Statistical Analyses Metal concentrations were right skewed and were log-transformed to perform the statistical analyses. Medians and interquartile ranges (IQR) were calculated to summarize metal concentrations. We graphically described metal concentrations by device type (MODs, PODs, and d-PODs), by POD brand and flavor, and by d-POD brand and flavor using box plots. To test whether certain POD and d-POD brands and certain flavors generate more metals in the aerosol, differences in log-transformed metal concentrations across different POD and d-POD brands and flavors were analyzed by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), and mean differences in log-transformed metal concentrations were compared by estimating geometric mean ratios (GMR) [95% confidence interval (CI)], where the mean difference (equivalent to the β-coefficient) and corresponding 95% CI are both exponentiated; POD and d-POD aerosol concentrations were converted from μg/kg to mg/m3 using Equations 1–3. For MODs, we did not have statistical power to compare metal levels by device brand and flavor, as more than 20 different brand/flavor combinations were reported by participants. We also estimated GMRs using log-transformed metal concentrations in aerosol samples of PODs and d-PODs compared to those of MODs. All analyses were performed using Stata 15.1 (StataCorp) and R software (version 3.6.2; R Project for Statistical Computing). The level of statistical significance (α) was set at 0.05, and all tests were two-sided. Results Median (IQR) aerosol concentrations found by device types are summarized using boxplots in Figure 1. A total of 194 aerosol samples were collected from MOD (n=104), POD (n=67), and d-POD devices (n=23). Aerosol metal concentrations spanned several orders of magnitude within and between e-cigarette device types (Figure 1; Table S1). For example, Sn levels (μg/kg) ranged from