Energy transfer of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence in the heliosphere Authors: Liping Yang, Jiansen He, Daniel Verscharen, Hui Li, Trevor A Bowen, Stuart D Bale, Honghong Wu, Wenya Li, Ying Wang, Lei Zhang, Xueshang Feng, Ziqi Wu Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractImbalanced Alfvénic turbulence is a universal process playing a crucial role in energy transfer in space, astrophysical, and laboratory plasmas. A fundamental and long-lasting question about the imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence is how and through which mechanism the energy transfers between scales. Here, we show that the energy transfer of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence is completed by coherent interactions between Alfvén waves and co-propagating anomalous fluctuations. These anomalous fluctuations are generated by nonlinear couplings instead of linear reflection. We also reveal that the energy transfer of the waves and the anomalous fluctuations is carried out mainly through local-scale and large-scale nonlinear interactions, respectively, responsible for their bifurcated power-law spectra. This work unveils the energy transfer physics of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence, and advances the understanding of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence observed by Parker Solar Probe in the inner heliosphere.Subject terms: Space physics, Plasma physics, Magnetospheric physics Introduction Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence is believed to play key roles in a wide range of plasma environments, e.g., astrophysical systems, the solar system, and plasma laboratories. The collision between counter-propagating Alfvén wave packets is credited as the fundamental physical process that drives the energy cascade of MHD turbulence. This framework has become the predominant phenomenological description in theoretical studies of MHD turbulence1–4. During such a wave collision, a wave packet suffers a nonlinear distortion from its interaction with the encountered oppositely traveling wave packet. When the wave packet undergoes an order-unity distortion, its energy is deemed to have cascaded to a smaller scale5. MHD turbulence is called “imbalanced” if the power of counter-propagating Alfvén waves is different in both directions with respect to the background magnetic field direction2–10. MHD turbulence is classified into weak and strong turbulence according to the strength of nonlinear interactions compared to linear interactions3,11,12. Nonlinear processes and the corresponding energy spectrum of the MHD turbulence are still among the most controversial problems in MHD research13. It is especially still unclear whether strong nonlinear distortions make the waves lose their identity, or whether nonlinear interactions between waves continue in a wave-like sense along the energy cascade after multiple encounters. Another important concern in MHD turbulence theory is the scale locality of the cascade, which is embedded in the classical theory of hydrodynamic turbulence and leads to the well-known Kolmogorov turbulent scaling laws13. Scale locality means that a fluctuation transfers energy to smaller-scale fluctuations primarily through the interactions with fluctuations of similar size or similar wavenumber in Fourier space14. There is a hot debate about the scale locality in MHD turbulence since large-scale magnetic fields cannot be removed through a Galilean transformation13,15–18. As a magnetized super-sonic plasma flow emanating from the Sun and filling the heliosphere, the solar wind is found to be turbulent according to in-situ measurements from space missions. Solar wind turbulence is usually imbalanced, especially close to the Sun19–23. The turbulence supplies energy to heat and accelerates the solar wind plasma, especially in the solar corona and the inner heliosphere. The turbulent solar wind serves as the medium in which energetic particles travel and are scattered. It thus has a critical influence on the dynamics and kinetics of the heliosphere. Therefore, studying solar wind turbulence is necessary to understand the transport and transfer of energy and momentum, solar–terrestrial relations, as well as fundamental plasma physics. One of the cutting-edge problems about solar wind turbulence is how the energy transfers through nonlinear interactions across scales and ultimately heats the solar wind. Elsässer variables δZ± describe two eigenmodes of Alfvén waves propagating in opposite directions24, and nonlinear interactions between δZ± generate energy cascade of the solar wind turbulence25–28. To sustain the subdominant inward propagating Alfvén waves, it is necessary to introduce the reflection of the dominant outward propagating Alfvén waves or a local source, such as velocity shears or plasma instabilities. However, the cascade due to the collision between counter-propagating waves is challenged by the fact that the solar wind fluctuations initially consist of almost purely outward propagating Alfvén waves near the Sun. In addition, this cascade scenario faces challenges in comparison to the observed spectral behavior of the solar wind turbulence23,29,30. In this work, we use Parker Solar Probe (PSP) observations and numerical simulations to examine the two foundational pillars of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence: the nature of fluctuations involved in nonlinear interactions and the scale locality of the cascade. We propose the following scenario: the outward Alfvén waves (δZ+) no longer interact with inward Alfvén waves, but instead interact with co-propagating fluctuations (δZ−), to produce an energy cascade. Through both local-scale and large-scale interactions, such a cascade process describes well both the observed and simulated imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence. Our findings unveil nonlinear interactions in imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence and lay the groundwork for the theoretical description of the imbalanced Alfvénic turbulent cascade, which can be fed into dynamical models. Results Alfvénic turbulence observed by the PSP spacecraft Our observational data is from the PSP spacecraft, which approaches the Sun to explore the nature of MHD turbulence in the new frontier of the young solar wind31. Figure 1 shows measurements by the PSP at its perihelion distance of 0.17 a.u. on 6 November 2018. The perturbed plasma velocity δV and magnetic field δB display an excellent correlation. The normalized cross-helicity σc is 0.84. The angle between the sampling direction and the ambient magnetic field direction is about 132∘. Alfvénic turbulence observed by PSP. A–C Time series of the fluctuating variables: plasma velocity component δVn (A, green line), magnetic field component δBn (A, blue line), Elsässer components δZ+ (B, green line) and δZ− (B, blue line), and proton number density Np (C, green line). D and E variation of power spectral density (PSD) of δZ+ (D, green lines), δZ− (D, blue lines), and the proton number density Np (E, green lines) with frequency f on one-hour intervals. Two power-law slopes are marked in black for reference. F and G The variations of the power-law spectral indexes with time, with their means marked by the horizontal lines. Figure 1 also shows that the amplitude of the fluctuating Elsässer variable δZ+ is generally much greater than the amplitude of its counterpart δZ−, indicating the presence of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence. The trace power spectra of δZ+ are statistically steeper than the spectra of δZ− (Fig. 1D). Such spectral differences in a short frequency range have already been observed by Helios32, although some cases occasionally show similar spectral steepness33. The power-law spectral index of δZ+ is around −1.6, while the spectral indexes of δZ− and the proton number density Np are around −1.0. The average spectral slopes of δZ+(-1.6) and δZ− (-1.0) are features of the solar wind in the frequency range between 0.001 and 0.1 Hz on 6 November 2018. Shi et al.34 show that, at a mean cross-helicity of 0.9, the typical spectral slopes are -1.64 (δZ+) and -0.99 (δZ−), and at a mean cross-helicity of 0.93, they are -1.55 (δZ+) and -1.10 (δZ−). This comparison suggests that our average spectral slopes are representative of the PSP data with very high cross-helicity. There is also precedence for a spectral slope of −1 in the high-frequency inertial range for the density power spectrum in the solar wind in Helios data, where Marsch and Tu35 report a flattening of the density power spectrum. Bruno et al.36 report that most of the flattening is due to intermittent events and the spectral slopes are all approximately −1. Borovsky et al.37 find a spectral index of the number density spectrum at high frequencies of -0.58 ± 0.36 in ACE data. Alfvénic turbulence reproduced by numerical simulation To investigate the physics of Alfvénic turbulence in the heliosphere, we conduct a decaying turbulence simulation by advancing the dimensionless compressible MHD equations in a periodic cube with 10243 grid points38,39. Considering that it is unclear what realistic driving would look like and additional dependence on the driver may be introduced into the system, here we use a decaying turbulence setup28,40 instead of a setup with driven turbulence. At a constant heliocentric distance, the turbulence in the solar wind is considered statistically stationary. When considering the radial evolution of the solar wind turbulence, however, its energy shows a decreasing profile with heliocentric distance41. The decrease is not only due to the solar wind expansion but also the decay of turbulence19. The initial fluctuation energy is equipartitioned between the kinetic and magnetic components, and the initial fluctuations are defined as Alfvén waves. The initial normalized cross-helicity σc is set to be approximately 0.7. In general, cross-helicity can be expressed in terms of δV and δB as 2<δV⋅δB>/(<∣δV∣2>+<∣δB∣2>), and in terms of δZ+ and δZ− as (<∣δZ+∣2>−<∣δZ−∣2>)/(<∣δZ+∣2>+<∣δZ−∣2>). By adjusting the relative amplitudes of δZ+ and δZ−, we set the initial normalized cross-helicity. Furthermore, we utilize the relationships between δV and (δZ++δZ−)/2 as well as δB and (δZ+−δZ−)/2, to obtain the initial spatial distributions of δV and δB. Figure 2 displays the features of our simulated MHD turbulence, which we sample with a virtual satellite whose trajectory resembles PSP’s orbital geometry in our observations. The periodic boundary conditions allow the virtual satellite to pass through and reenter the simulation domain many times. This approach provides the spacecraft trajectory with about 105 sampling points. The spectra, calculated by fast Fourier transform of the sampled points, remain constant when we sample for more than 105 points. Figure 2 shows that, at time=4.0, the transverse component of δV is well correlated with the transverse component of δB, leading to σc ~ 0.78. The simulated δZ+ follows a Kolmogorov (−5/3) spectrum, while the simulated δZ− preserves a power-law spectral index of about −1. Furthermore, the spectrum of density ρ stabilizes at a power-law index close to −1 as well. The simulated density fluctuations have relative amplitudes of about 20% of the mean density, which is slightly greater than those of the solar wind density fluctuations in Fig. 1 (about 15%). Alfvénic turbulence sampled in the numerical simulation data. A–C Spatial series of the fluctuating variables: velocity component δVx (A, green line), magnetic field component δBx (A, blue line), Elsässer components δZx+ (B, green line) and δZx− (B, blue line), and density ρ (C, green line) at time=4.0. D and E variation of power spectral density (PSD) of δZ+ (D, green lines), δZ− (D, blue lines), and the density ρ (E, green lines) with wavenumber k. The dotted lines in D show the power spectra of δZ+ and δZ− at time=4.0 from our imbalanced RMHD simulation. Two power-law slopes are marked in black for reference. F and G The evolution of the power-law spectral indexes as functions of the simulation time. The error bars denote uncertainties of the linear fit on log–log scales. The same ranges on the vertical axes are adopted for (D and E) as well as (F and G). The displayed variables are dimensionless. The simulation reproduces well the features of the Alfvénic fluctuations, which are observed in certain intervals of PSP measurements. This can also be seen in Supplementary Fig. 1, which shows the similarity between the simulated and observed distributions of occurrence numbers and pixel-averaged <∣δVA2∣>0.5 in the σr−σc plane, as well as variations of the intermittency-related scaling exponents with the order moments of the structure function. Supplementary Fig. 2 shows 2D representations of the discretized differential variables (∣∇×V∣, ∣∇⋅V∣, ∂ρ/∂t, and V⋅∇ρ), the magnetic pressure Pmag, and the thermal pressure Pth. The curvature of the velocity ∣∇×V∣ is far greater than the divergence of the velocity ∣∇⋅V∣. The distribution of ∇⋅V seems irregular and noise-like. The time derivative ∂ρ/∂t nearly equates to V⋅∇ρ (see the region marked by the white rectangles), suggesting that the advection dominates over the compressibility to generate the variation of density. Finally, the magnetic pressure Pmag and the thermal pressure Pth are in good anti-correlation (see the regions marked by the black rectangles), forming multiscale pressure-balanced structures (PBSs), which have also been observed in solar wind turbulence before42,43. The balance between the magnetic pressure and the thermal pressure weakens the role of ponderomotive force related to the spatial variation of magnetic field magnitude in generating more compressible fluctuations. Therefore, with a highly Alfvénic, incompressible initial condition, our compressible MHD simulation converges to a weakly compressible state. A comparison of Figs. 2, S1, and S2 shows that the converged status with both high Alfvénicity and weak compressibility resembles the solar wind turbulence measured by the PSP. Nature of fluctuations involved in nonlinear interactions We illustrate the spatio-temporal behavior of the simulated x- component of the Elsässer variables, δZx±, and ∣δZ±∣ for the time from 4.0 until 6.0 in Fig. 3 and Supplementary Movie 1. The fluctuations associated with δZ+ travel in the direction opposite to the guide field B0, in agreement with the dispersion relation for anti-parallel propagating Alfvén waves. However, the fluctuations associated with the minor Elsässer variable δZ− do not counter-propagate with respect to δZ+. Instead, the fluctuations of δZ− propagate in the same direction as δZ+. Distributions of the turbulent Elsässer variables in the simulation domain at time = 4.0. A and B The perpendicular components of Elsässer variables δZx+ and δZx−. C and D The magnitudes of ∣δZ+∣ and ∣δZ−∣. The displayed variables are dimensionless. The model of the PSP is illustrated in green at the center of the domain. The simulation box and the spacecraft model are not scaled to size. Their corresponding temporal propagation and evolution are shown in Supplementary Movie 1. We investigate the propagation speed of δZx± by extracting a 1D cut along the direction of the mean background field B0 (z-direction). This analysis produces the time-distance diagrams shown in Fig. 4A, B for the time from 0.0 until 1.0 and Fig. 4C, D for the time from 4.0 until 6.0. The diagrams for both δZx+ and δZx− display oblique stripes, the slopes of which correspond to the propagation speed of δZx± along the z-direction. Figure 4A and B show that δZx+ and δZx− initially have different propagation speeds. For δZx+, the propagation speed approaches −VA0, while for δZx−, it is approximately VA0. However, for the time from 4.0 until 6.0 shown in Fig. 4C and D, the propagation speed of δZx− becomes comparable to that of δZx+, which is about −VA0. This behavior reveals that δZ− is strongly distorted by δZ+ after their encounters. Furthermore, the stripes of δZx− appear to be shorter-lived in time compared to those of δZx+. Propagation and lifetime estimations of δZx+ and δZx−. A–D Time-distance (time−z) diagrams of δZx+ and δZx− for the time from 0.0 until 1.0 (A and B) and from 4.0 until 6.0 (C and D). E–H Distributions of the auto-correlation function (ACF) of δZx+ and δZx− in the τ (time lag) −l (spatial lag in the z-direction) plane for times between 0.0 and 1.0 (E and F) and for times between 4.0 and 6.0 (G and H). The black dashed lines show the expected propagation of Alfvén waves along the z-direction. The displayed variables are dimensionless. From the extracted values of δZx±, we calculate the auto-correlation functions (ACFs) of δZx±, which are functions of the spatial lag l and time lag τ. We choose about 40 1D cuts to calculate the average ACF, and show their distributions in τ−l space in Fig. 4E and F for times between 0.0 and 1.0 and in Fig. 4G and H for times in between 4.0 and 6.0. For the times between 0.0 and 1.0, the high-level ACFs of δZx+ and δZx− mainly concentrate around the line l=−VA0τ and the line l=VA0τ, respectively, confirming again that δZx+ and δZx− are Alfvén fluctuations propagating in opposite directions. However, for times between 4.0 and 6.0, the high-level ACFs of δZx+ and δZx− both concentrate around the line l=−VA0τ confirming that both δZx+ and δZx− propagate in the same direction at the negative Alfvén speed. The auto-correlation time scales, which are estimated as the time lag associated with ACF=e−1, also indicate the rapidly evolving nature of δZx−. There is no evident propagation of δZx± along perpendicular directions (see Supplementary Fig. 4), meaning that δZx± travels anisotropically and mainly along the parallel direction. From the comparison between Fig. 4 and Supplementary Fig. 4, we find that the variations of the fluctuations along the perpendicular directions are more variable than those along the parallel direction. In balanced MHD turbulence with a value of <∣δBx2∣>0.5/B0 comparable to that in our imbalanced MHD turbulence, counter-propagating waves persist throughout the development phase of the turbulence (see Supplementary Fig. 5). To delve deeper into the nature and evolution of δZ⊥−, we employ a first-principles analysis. This involves comparing the spatiotemporal distribution and evolution of each term in the governing equations. After defining the generalized compressible term with Pt being the total pressure, the compressible equation of the perpendicular fluctuating Elsässer variable δZ⊥− (see Supplementary Methods) yields: In this equation, the parallel components of δZ⊥± are taken into consideration. The effects of compressibility are embodied in the generalized compressible term Tcomp, which acts as a source for δZ⊥−. To understand the generation of δZ⊥−, the top panels of Fig. 5 show the distributions of the left-hand side of Eq. (2), the nonlinear term, and Tcomp for one component of the perpendicular fluctuating Elsässer variable, δZx−. The variation of ∂δZx−/∂t+VA0⋅∇δZx− is co-located with the variation of the nonlinear term −δZ+⋅∇δZx−, not with that of the generalized compressible term Tcomp. Distributions of the terms in the compressive governing equation (Eq. (2)) of the perpendicular fluctuating Elsässer variable δZx− at time = 4.0. A The evolution term plus the linear term, B the nonlinear term, C the generalized compressible term Tcomp (Eq. (1)), D the term Tdiv (Eq. (3)), E the term Tden (Eq. (4)), F Tdiv+Tden. The displayed variables are dimensionless. Figure 5D and E show the terms due to compressibility and due to the density fluctuations The values of Tdiv and Tden are far smaller than those of the nonlinear term. In many places, Tdiv and Tden are anti-correlated and cancel each other out, which can be readily seen from the distribution of their sum Tdiv+Tden (Fig. 5F). Synthesizing subfigures of Fig. 5 demonstrates that the nonlinear interactions between δZ− and δZ+ dominate over the compressibility-induced reflection of δZ+ in creating δZ−. The left panels of Fig. 6, Supplementary Fig. 6 and Supplementary Movie 2 clearly show that the local time derivative ∂δZx+/∂t correlates with and is mainly determined by the linear term VA0⋅∇δZx+ at times between 4.0 and 6.0. The linear term is much greater than the nonlinear term −δZ-⋅∇δZx+ in amplitude at wavenumbers k > 2. These features suggest that δZx+ behaves as anti-parallel propagating Alfvén waves while retaining a power-law spectral profile. Contributions of nonlinear and linear terms to the variations of the fluctuating Elsässer variables at time = 4.0. A–C The distributions of the evolution term (A), the nonlinear term (B), and the linear term (C) in the simulation domain for δZx+. D–F The distributions of the evolution term (D), the nonlinear term (E), and the linear term (F) in the simulation domain for δZx−. The orange-dashed and pink-dashed circles highlight the regions with good correlations between the terms. G PSDs of −δZ−⋅∇δZx+ (green line) and VA0⋅∇δZx+ (blue line) as a function of wavenumber k. H PSDs of −δZ+⋅∇δZx− (green line) and VA0⋅∇δZx− (blue line) as a function of wavenumber k. Their temporal propagation and evolution for the time from 4.0 until 6.0 are shown in Supplementary Movie 2. The displayed variables are dimensionless. For δZx− shown in the right panels of Fig. 6 and Supplementary Movie 2, we observe a clear positive correlation between ∂δZx−/∂t and −δZ+⋅∇δZx− (compare Fig. 6B and D) as well as between VA0⋅∇δZx− and −δZ+⋅∇δZx− (compare Fig. 6F and D). The magnitude of the nonlinear term is the largest and about twice the amplitude of the other terms. This suggests that the nonlinear term acts as the source term for the generation of the variations of the other two terms and make δZ− “sail along” δZ+ at speed −VA0. The prevailing anti-correlation between ∂δZx−/∂t and −VA0⋅∇δZx− (compare Fig. 6B and F) reveals again that δZ- no longer represents classical, parallel-propagating Alfvén waves. δZ− appears to “sail along” δZ+ as a result of the nonlinear term continuously generating δZ−, and δZ− does not represent a kind of waves but a kind of anomalous fluctuations propagating in the same direction as δZ+. The co-traveling δZ− is continuously generated through the nonlinearity in our work. It is seemingly similar but essentially different from the anomalous δZ− produced through the linear reflection of Alfvén waves at background inhomogeneities discussed in previous work44–49. The apparent similarity between the two is that the (apparent) propagating direction of the two is the same as that of δZ+, and both can be produced continuously under appropriate conditions. The essential differences between them are: (1) The origin mechanism is different. The anomalous δZ− in our work is driven by nonlinear coupling with δZ+; (2) The evolution process is different. In previous work, since δZ− is generated by reflection, it leaves the driving source and propagates in the opposite direction after generation, which is in analogy to smoke coming out of a ship’s smokestack46. In this work, δZ− continues to travel with the driving δZ+ and further facilitates the nonlinear cascade of its parent δZ+ and itself. In order to distinguish these two processes, we refer to the anomalous δZ− component in our work as the NCI-anomalous δZ− (where NCI stands for “nonlinear-coupling-induced”). We refer to the reflection-driven anomalous δZ− in former work as the LRI-anomalous δZ− (where LRI stands for “linear-reflection-induced”). For the current simulation, the plasma β(=Pth/Pmag) is about 1.4. To understand the influence of β or compressible perturbations on the results, we also conduct low β(≈0.71) and high β(≈7.6) simulations, in which the relative density fluctuation amplitudes are about 36% and 10%, respectively. In both simulations, the co-propagation of δZ− with δZ+ generated by the nonlinearities persists, which indicates that β and compressive fluctuations have only little influence on our results. Results of an additional simulation with small initial perturbation (δBrms/B0≈0.1) in Supplementary Fig. 7 reveal that, for δZ+, the linear term still dominates to make δZ+ propagate at −VA0. For δZ−, whose propagation direction is now opposite to that of δZ+, the nonlinear term no longer determines δZ−, and in many regions of the simulation domain, compressibility effects are responsible for the generation of δZ−. To verify the finding that δZ− is mainly produced by the nonlinearity rather than by compressibility, we conduct a decaying imbalanced reduced MHD (RMHD) simulation, which numerically solves Elsässer-potential equations with a fourth-order hyperviscosity dissipation term10. The dotted lines in Fig. 2D show the power spectra of δZ± at time=4.0 from our imbalanced RMHD simulation, which closely resemble those in the compressive MHD case (the solid lines in Fig. 2D). Nevertheless, the power of δZ− in the compressive MHD simulation is slightly higher than that in RMHD simulation. We attribute this discrepancy to the initial seeding of the minority Elsässer variable by compressibility at early times of the simulation (Supplementary Fig. 13). In previous simulations of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence in the RMHD regime, Perez and Boldyrev50 find that Elsässer energy spectra have different amplitudes but the same scaling with an index of −3/2, while Beresnyak and Lazarian23 show that the spectrum of the majority component is steeper than that of the minority component (spectral slopes between −1.12 and −1.93). The spectral slopes obtained from our simulations of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence are similar to those observed in specific intervals of PSP measurements. In our imbalanced RMHD simulation, δZ+ and δZ− propagate in the same direction (see Supplementary Fig. 9). For δZ+, the linear term dominates. For δZ−, ∂δZx−/∂t correlates closely with −δZ+⋅∇δZx−, but has an inverse relationship with −VA0⋅∇δZx−, which reveals that in imbalanced RMHD turbulence, the nonlinear term also acts as the source term to generate δZ− that co-propagates with δZ+. Scale locality of the cascade Lastly, we employ wavevector dynamics analysis to investigate the energy transfer across various scales , aiming to scrutinize the scale locality or non-locality of the nonlinear interactions of δZ+ and δZ-. We estimate the energy transfer rate ε(K,Q,P) of δZ± from the energy in wavenumber shell Q to the energy in wavenumber shell K due to interactions with δZ∓ in wavenumber shell P according to triadic interactions. Figure 7A and B show the distributions of εδZ± in K−Q−P space. Shell K receives energy from shell Q with the help of modes in shell P, leading to positive transfer rates in the plane of K=Q+P. Negative transfer rates relate that shell K contributes energy to shell Q through interaction with modes in shell P. This signal clusters near the plane of Q=K+P. In this sense, Fig. 7A and B represent quantitative visualizations of the energy transfer rate due to triadic interactions14,51. Rates of energy transfer between different scales at time = 4.0. A and B Distributions of energy transfer rates, εδZ±, from shell Q to shell K by mediation of P modes in K−Q−P space (A for δZ+ and B for δZ-). The light blue and light brown surfaces denote isosurfaces of εδZ± with the values of −0.01 and 0.01, respectively. The planes filled with blue and yellow stripes denote the relations K=Q+P, and Q=K+P, respectively. C Ratios of the energy transfer rate by large-scale interactions (dashed lines) and by local interactions (solid lines) to the transfer rate due to all triadic interactions on a band of K-shells for δZ+ (green lines) and δZ- (blue lines). The two vertical dotted lines indicate the inertial range of the simulated turbulence. The displayed variables are dimensionless. A new feature in Fig. 7A and B is that the triadic interactions are different between δZ+ and δZ−. For δZ+ in Fig. 7A, δZ− modes with P varying from small wavenumbers to large wavenumbers participate in the relevant triadic interactions. For δZ− in Fig. 7B, only δZ+ modes with small P participate in the triadic interactions. We further observe that the total energy transfer rate for δZ+, εallPδZ+, is determined by δZ− modes with P≥6, but εallPδZ− is dominated by the large-scale interactions with δZ+ modes satisfying P<6 (see Supplementary Fig. 10). Figure 7C compares the relative contributions of the large-scale interactions and the local-scale interactions at different bands of K-shells for δZ±. As K increases, the proportion of the large-scale interactions in the total interactions weakens quickly, and becomes much less than that of the local-scale interactions, suggesting that the large-scale interactions contribute less than the local-scale interactions to the energy transfer of δZ+. The energy transfer in δZ- exhibits the opposite behavior, where the proportion of the large-scale interactions in the total interactions remains greater than that of the local-scale interactions. This finding supports our interpretation that large-scale interactions play a dominant role in the energy cascade of δZ-. However, for balanced turbulence, the local-scale interactions account for a more substantial fraction of the energy transfer rate than the large-scale interactions (Supplementary Fig. 11). The dominance of the large-scale interactions can be responsible for the k−1 spectrum of δZ- (see Supplementary Discussion). Likewise, the phenomenological treatment of δZ+ suggests that the local-scale interactions are potentially responsible for the k−5/3 spectrum of δZ+ (see Supplementary Discussion). To understand the influence of the normalized cross helicity σc, we plot the dependence of δZ±’s spectral indexes with σc in Fig. 8a, and the dependencies of ratios between the large-scale energy transfer (εLS) and the local-scale energy transfer (εlocal) with σc in Fig. 8b. As σc increases, the spectral index of δZ− rises and approaches −1, while the spectral index of δZ+ stays around −1.6. These variation trends are comparable to the observational findings reported by Shi et al. 34. With increasing σc, the large-scale interactions take increasingly control of the energy transfer of δZ−. The local-scale interactions, however, continue to play the dominant role in the energy transfer of δZ+. Effects of the normalized cross helicity. A on the spectral index of δZ± and B on the ratio between the energy transfer due to large-scale interactions (εLS) and the energy transfer due to local-scale interactions (εlocal) of δZ±. In A, the star symbols represent results from Shi et al.34, the upper and lower dotted-dashed lines indicate the spectral indices of δZ± being −1.00 and −1.67, respectively. Discussion Our work suggests that the energy transfer in imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence is completed by both local and large-scale interactions between Alfvén waves (δZ+) and anomalous fluctuations (δZ−) that propagate in the same direction as the waves. Although a critical balance3,52,53 between linear and nonlinear timescales is predicted to exist for balanced turbulence (Supplementary Fig. 8), we do not find a critical balance between the linear and nonlinear terms in imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence. Instead, linearity dominates over nonlinearity for δZ+ while nonlinearity dominates over linearity for δZ−. During PSP’s first encounter, the relative density variation is typically in the range of 0.1–0.2, which suggests that the slow solar wind probed by the PSP is not completely incompressible47. In this work, we use the fully compressible MHD framework to reproduce the solar wind fluctuations with high Alfvénicity and low to intermediate density fluctuations. Our simulations start from an incompressible, highly Alfvénic state and finally converge to a weakly compressive regime. Through the use of incompressible initial conditions, we prime our simulations to converge towards incompressible solutions as well54–56. Numerical simulations by Matthaeus et al. 57 show that the level of compressive fluctuations depends critically on the initialization. Moreover, high Alfvénic correlations tend to suppress the generation of compressive modes39,58,59. During the initial stage of our compressible MHD simulation, the ponderomotive force, associated with the spatial variation of the total magnetic field magnitude, triggers density perturbations. Consequently, compressibility plays a crucial role in shaping the precursor dynamics in our analysis. As illustrated in Supplementary Fig. 13, at time=1.0, the compressibility induces density variations in some regions. The divergence of the velocity field exhibits a comparable magnitude to the curl of the velocity field in numerous regions of the simulation domain. Similarly, the compressible terms contribute to the generation of minority Elsässer variables at some locations. Hence, compressibility plays an important role in establishing the conditions during the initial stage. However, as the system evolves, the gradient of the magnetic pressure gradually assumes balance with the thermal pressure gradient, limiting the ability of the ponderomotive force to induce additional compressible effects. Consequently, the influence of compressibility diminishes gradually and, more significantly, during the late-stage evolution. When we start the compressible simulation with unidirectionally-propagating Alfvén waves (cross-helicity of 1 or −1), the ponderomotive force is the only way to generate δZ−. As δZ− becomes large enough, the nonlinearity comes into play to seed δZ−. Meanwhile, the influence of the ponderomotive force weakens as multiscale pressure-balanced structures form. As a result, the nonlinearity continues to act as a source term to produce δZ− that travels along with δZ+ in the later dynamics with stabilized power-law profiles in the energy spectra. The compressible governing equations of the perpendicular Elsässer fields (Supplementary Eqs. (5) and (6)) show that, in the compressive regime, the perpendicular Elsässer variables cannot be considered a mere representation of counter-propagating fluctuations. In this work about imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence with weak compressibility and low-amplitude density fluctuations, both δZ⊥+ and δZ⊥− propagate with the negative Alfvén velocity. Considering the fact that nonlinear interactions with large-scale δZ+ fluctuations can be stronger than those with local-scale δZ+ fluctuations, the non-local coupling with large-scale δZ+ fluctuations favors the change of the propagation direction of δZ−. In our study of homogeneous imbalanced MHD turbulence, we find a source of δZ−, which is the nonlinearity and co-exists with other sources of δZ−, like those known from inhomogeneous reflection-driven MHD turbulence. This source is local and persists, and thus is complementary to the source due to reflection, which depends on the large-scale inhomogeneity of the background. We justify that NCI-anomalous δZ− propagates along with δZ+, and the coherent interaction between co-traveling δZ± sustains imbalanced weak compressible MHD turbulence as well as imbalanced reduced MHD turbulence, which are often considered a result of the collisions between counter-propagating Alfvén waves. Fully compressible simulations of imbalanced MHD turbulence and their potential application to solar wind turbulence have received major attention in the literature recently40,60–64. The nature of the minority component and its role in the cascade of turbulence are regarded as some of the core questions related to this issue. To understand the turbulent cascade in the solar wind, Grappin et al.40 employ simulations of decaying compressible turbulence in three dimensions, considering both homogeneous and expanding cases. In the homogeneous simulations, they observe a steep dominant spectrum and a flat subdominant spectrum, and the final spectral indices depend on the initial cross helicity. In recent studies by Magyar et al.63,64, the coupling and co-propagation of Elsässer variables are proposed as a new phenomenon in MHD simulations, yet the setup in their model is a special case, which requires waves to propagate on transverse inhomogeneities as surface Alfvén waves or kink waves. In our study, the transverse inhomogeneity of the Alfvén speed is generated due to nonlinear processes. However, this inhomogeneity is weak and thus inefficient in the development of surface waves as those proposed by Magyar et al. 63. For surface waves, the total pressure perturbations act as sources for δZ⊥±, and thus couple them to propagate at the same speed. In our case, owing to the formation of multiscale pressure-balanced structures, the total pressure perturbations are small and unlikely to play a crucial role in creating δZ⊥± (Supplementary Fig. 2, Fig. 5 and Supplementary Fig. 6). For surface waves, δZ⊥± do not travel at ∣VA0∣, while the propagation speed of δZ⊥± is -∣VA0∣ in our case (Fig. 4). For β≤1, the model of nearly incompressible MHD turbulence comprises a superposition of a majority population of zero-frequency 2D fluctuations plus the minority population of slab fluctuations. The non-compressible slab fluctuations correspond to a combination of counter-propagating Alfvén modes65, and the Elsässer variables δZ⊥± contain both 2D and slab components56. In our model, weak compressible imbalanced MHD turbulence also has two components, but the dominant component consists of unidirectionally-propagating Alfvén waves (δZ⊥+) and the sub-dominant component is the NCI-anomalous δZ⊥−, which co-propagates with δZ⊥+. To overcome the shortcoming of 1D observed time series of solar wind fluctuations, we use 4D spatial–temporal simulation data to identify the propagation directions. In order to clearly diagnose the propagation characteristics of Elsässer variables observationally, we require multiple satellites to form a constellation with inter-spacecraft distances on MHD scales. At present, constellation missions are not able to meet the above measurement requirement since, for example, the Cluster-II spacecraft are typically spaced near the ion kinetic scales and the Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) spacecraft are typically spaced near electron kinetic scales66,67. In the future, to really solve the mystery of the Elsässer variables in solar wind turbulence, we call for considering a satellite constellation program with spacing distances including MHD scales. Future constellation mission concepts with many spacecraft (e.g., HelioSwarm and AME)68,69, if implemented, are expected to finally settle the critical issue of Alfvénic turbulence in the heliosphere. We analyze the case of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence with high cross helicity. The spectral slopes for δZ+ and δZ− change with cross helicity. An important prospect for future studies is the variation of the nonlinear interactions with Alfvénicity. Another issue is that we use the background magnetic field as the propagation direction since we apply statistical methods to study the collective behavior of the turbulence. A local magnetic field averaged over a local neighborhood is potentially better suited as the propagation direction when determining anisotropy. It would also be interesting to study the role of large-scale interactions versus a passive cascade in shaping the power-law spectrum of compressive fluctuations, which might be related to slow-mode-like compressive fluctuations70. We have taken a step forward in understanding the essence of imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence. A broader topic of interest is the open question as to how imbalanced Alfvénic turbulence evolves along with the solar wind’s expansion into the heliosphere. It may experience complex non-radial expansion and stream interactions34, but these lie beyond the scope of this work. The initial condition of δZ− set in this paper may be produced through other mechanisms during the evolution of solar wind turbulence. Combined with the observations by PSP and Solar Orbiter, our mechanism of energy transfer has the potential to be an important step to settle the puzzle of solar wind heating and acceleration as well as heliosphere formation within the local interstellar medium. Methods Observations by the Parker Solar Probe (PSP) We studied PSP data on 6 November 2018 when PSP was near its first perihelion. The data of magnetic fields were acquired from the fluxgate magnetometer of the FIELDS instrument suite71 with a sampling rate of 290 vectors s−1. The data of proton number density and fluid velocity were obtained from the Solar Probe Cup of the SWEAP instrument suite at a cadence of about 0.58 s72. To investigate the spectra of the solar wind turbulent fluctuations and examine their stationary randomness, we first divide the one day of magnetic field, proton velocity, and proton density data into 24 one-hour intervals, and then employ a fast Fourier transform to each interval to calculate the respective trace power spectral densities (PSDs). We find that the PSD profiles in the frequency range 0.001Hz≤f≤0.1Hz can be approximated with a single power law. Therefore, we adopt a linear fit on log-log scales to estimate the power-law indices of each interval. The spectral indices of the PSDs for the perturbed plasma velocity δV, the perturbed magnetic field δB, the fluctuating Elsässer variables δZ+=δV+δVA, with δVA=δB/ρ, ρ being density) and δZ−=δV−δVA stay stable, which indicates the stationary randomness of the different variables. Numerical simulation The compressible MHD equations are written in the following nondimensional form: e and j correspond to the total energy density and current density, respectively. ρ is the mass density, V is the flow velocity, Pth is the thermal pressure, B denotes the magnetic field, γ=5/3 is the adiabatic index, ν=10−4 is the viscosity, η(=10−4) is the magnetic resistivity, and t is the time. To solve these equations in a cube with a side length of 2π, we employ the higher-order Godunov code Athena73. Specifically, we apply a third-order piecewise parabolic method (PPM) to the reconstruction, the approximate Riemann solver with Harten–Lax–van Leer discontinuities (HLLD) to the calculation of the numerical fluxes, and the constrained transport algorithm for ensuring the divergence-free state of the magnetic field. Each side of the cubical grid of edge length L is discretized by 1024 uniform grid points, and we implement periodic boundary conditions. We initialize our simulation with non-compressive waves, and a background magnetic field B0 (=1) is imposed along the z-direction. The magnetic field can be written as B=B0+δB, with δB being the fluctuating magnetic field. The initial velocity and magnetic field fluctuations δV and δB populate a shell in Fourier k− space with 2≤k≤5. We set these modes so that they have constant amplitude and random phases. The initial root-mean-square of δV and δB is about 1, resulting in an initial turbulent Mach number and initial Alfvén Mach number of about 1.1 and 1, respectively. We run the model of decaying MHD turbulence to approach a state when the power-law spectrum is fully developed. The simulation run lasts about 6 Alfvén times tVA=1/(B0/ρ0), at which time <∣δBx2∣>0.5/B0 drops to about 0.5. Our simulation traces the evolution with time of the fluctuating kinetic energy, the fluctuating magnetic energy, the fluctuating Elsässer variables, and the normalized cross-helicity (Supplementary Fig. 3). Computation of the auto-correlation function We calculate the auto-correlation function (ACF) of δZx+ and δZx− as with l being the spatial lag and τ being the time lag. Comparison of large-scale and local-sale energy transfer rates To investigate energy transfer across different scales, we represent the fluctuating Elsässer variables δZ± by their Fourier series expansions, δZ±=∑kδZ~±(k)eik⋅x. We then divide the wavenumber space into spherical shells of unit width centered around the origin. Preserving only the modes in Fourier space with wavenumbers satisfying K≤K