Assessment of the efficacy of various maxillary molar intrusion therapies: a systematic review Authors: Sarah Abu Arqub, Dalya Al-Moghrabi, Marissa G Iverson, Philippe Farha, Hala Abdullah Alsalman, Flavio Uribe Published: 2023 ABSTRACT AbstractAimsTo systematically assess the efficacy of the various interventions used to intrude maxillary molars. Furthermore, to evaluate associated root resorption, stability of intrusion, subsequent vertical movement of mandibular molars, cost effectiveness, compliance, patient reported outcomes and adverse events.MethodsA pre-registered and comprehensive literature search of published and unpublished trials until March 22nd 2023 with no language restriction applied in PubMed/Medline, Embase, Scopus, DOSS, CENTRAL, CINAHL Plus with Full Text, Web of Science, Global Index Medicus, Dissertation and Theses Global, ClinicalTrials.gov, and Trip (PROSPERO: CRD42022310562). Randomized controlled trials involving a comparative assessment of treatment modalities used to intrude maxillary molars were included. Pre-piloted data extraction forms were used. The Cochrane Risk of Bias tool was used for risk of bias assessment, and The Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) system was used for certainty of evidence appraisal.ResultsA total of 3986 records were identified through the electronic data search, of which 24 reports were sought for retrieval. Of these, 7 trials were included. One trial was judged at high risk of bias, while the others had some concerns. Based on individual small sample studies, maxillary molar intrusion was achieved using temporary anchorage devices (TADs) and rapid molar intruder appliance (RMI). It was also observed to a lesser extent with the use of open bite bionator (OBB) and posterior bite blocks. The molar intruder appliance and the posterior bite blocks (spring-loaded or magnetic) also intruded the lower molars. Root resorption was reported in two studies involving TADs. None of the identified studies involved a comparison of conventional and TAD-based treatments for intrusion of molars. No studies reported outcomes concerning stability, cost-effectiveness, compliance and patient-reported outcomes. Insufficient homogeneity between the included trials precluded quantitative synthesis. The level of evidence was very low.ConclusionsMaxillary molar intrusion can be attained with different appliances (removable and fixed) and with the use of temporary anchorage devices. Posterior bite blocks (spring-loaded or magnetic) and the RMI offer the additional advantage of intruding the mandibular molars. However, stability of the achieved maxillary molar intrusion long term is unclear. Further high-quality randomized controlled trials are needed.Keywords: Maxillary molar intrusion, Temporary anchorage devices, Posterior bite blocks, Open bite bionator, Rapid molar intruder Background Intrusion is one of the most mechanically challenging types of tooth movement. It has been described as the apical movement of the geometric center of the root in respect to a plane perpendicular to the long axis of the tooth [1]. The mechanical stresses are often increased with intrusion at the root apex, which might increase the risk of root resorption with this specific type of tooth movement [2]. With regard to intruding posterior teeth, molar intrusion is a treatment option for patients with Anterior Open Bite (AOB); a malocclusion often characterized by the overeruption of the posterior teeth or/and under eruption of the anterior teeth [3]. Furthermore, unopposed maxillary molars for a prolonged period tend to supraerupt and encroach on the space of its lower counterpart. It has been reported that 82% of subjects presented with supraerupted maxillary molars would require adjunctive orthodontic restorative and/or endodontic interventions prior to prosthetic replacement for the opposing teeth to correct interocclusal space deficiency [4]. Therefore, orthodontic intrusion is a clinically desired treatment option for supraerupted teeth. Many treatment modalities have been suggested to control the vertical dimension in different age groups of treated subjects. These include conventional methods such as utilization of high pull headgear [5], functional appliances [6], vertical-pull chin cups [7], active vertical correctors [8], and posterior bite blocks with either springs or magnets [9]. Besides the fact that most of the above-mentioned modalities demand high level of patient cooperation, their clinical success was often correlated with the younger age group [6]. Moreover, achieving predictable intrusive movement in non-growing subjects is considered an onerous task, and depending on the intrusion severity it might involve endodontic treatment and coronal reduction or extraction [10]. Moreover, magnetic bite blocks are associated with poor three-dimensional control due the devices being deviated from the centered relation contact [9]. The introduction of temporary anchorage devices (TADs) has facilitated performance of challenging tooth movements more predictably by eliminating the compliance factor and providing absolute anchorage while intruding teeth, furthermore, preventing side effects on adjacent teeth during treatment [11]. However, TADs are not often prescribed for young individuals with deciduous or early mixed dentition [12], therefore alternative mechanisms for intrusion should be considered in this age group. Nevertheless, despite their reported failure rate, the use of TADs ensures the delivery of uninterrupted and continuous forces during intrusion. Overall, molar intrusion even with all proposed treatment mechanisms remains difficult and unpredictable, and multiple factors play a role in the success of intruding posterior teeth, such as patients’ compliance, age, bone density, number of teeth intruded, severity of malocclusion, appliance used and site of force application when using TADs (palatal, buccal or both) [13, 14]. Moreover, molars are large multirooted teeth and the mandibular cortex is dense, therefore, intruding mandibular teeth is often more challenging than intruding the maxillary teeth [15]. Reported complications of molar intrusion with the use of TADs include relapse [16] as well as root resorption [17]. Previous systematic reviews primarily investigated clinical effects of molar intrusion for correction of open bite cases [6, 16, 18, 19]. Only one previous review published in 2006 attempted to quantify the true amount of intrusion achieved during orthodontic treatment [20]. Therefore, identification of the expected amount and rate of intrusion with various appliances would be of marked value to clinicians. This systematic review aimed to critically evaluate and compare the efficacy of the various interventions used to intrude maxillary molars. Furthermore, this review sets out to appraise outcomes related to intrusion including root resorption, stability, subsequent vertical movement of mandibular molars, cost effectiveness, patient reported outcomes and adverse events that might accompany the use of various appliances for intrusion. Materials and methods Protocol and registration The systematic review protocol was registered prior to commencement in the National Institute of Health Research’s PROSPERO Protocol Registry (https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/; trial registration number: PROSPERO CRD42022310562). This systematic review was conducted in accordance with the Cochrane Handbook for systematic reviews and interventions [21] and the guidelines of Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) [22]. Eligibility criteria The PICOS scheme for this systematic review is presented in Table 1. Only randomized controlled trials reporting baseline and outcome data related to the amount of maxillary molar intrusion using conventional treatment modalities and/or with the use of temporary anchorage devices (TADs). Primary outcomes included amount and rate of maxillary molar intrusion, and secondary outcomes included amount of root resorption, stability of intrusion, patient reported outcomes, compliance, cost effectiveness, adverse effects and vertical movement of mandibular molars. No restriction on language or date of publication were applied. Table 1Eligibility criteria for the present systematic reviewDomainInclusion criteriaExclusion criteriaParticipantsOrthodontic patients requiring maxillary molar intrusion for either open bite correction or pre-prosthetic applications, without age or gender predilectionParticipants with systemic diseases or disabilitiesSubjects treated with orthognathic surgery or surgical adjunctive proceduresSubjects in primary dentition stageInterventionsIntrusion of maxillary molars with conventional treatment modalities (posterior bite blocks, headgear, magnets, vertical chin cup, spring loaded bite blocks, removable or fixed appliances) and/or with the use of TADsSurgically assisted treatment protocols for posterior segment intrusionComparisonIntrusion of maxillary molars with conventional or TAD based mechanisms, or control groupOutcomesPrimary outcomesAmount of maxillary molar intrusionRate of maxillary molar intrusionSecondary outcomesAmount of root resorption associated with intrusionVertical movement of mandibular molarsStability of intrusionPatient reported outcomesComplianceCost effectivenessAdverse effectsNo restrictions on data collection sources (dental models, clinical measurements and radiographs were considered)Study designRandomized controlled trialsAnimal studies, prospective non-randomized controlled trials, retrospective studies, systematic reviews, case reports and case seriesTAD: temporary anchorage device Eligibility criteria for the present systematic review Participants with systemic diseases or disabilities Subjects treated with orthognathic surgery or surgical adjunctive procedures Subjects in primary dentition stage Primary outcomes Amount of maxillary molar intrusion Rate of maxillary molar intrusion Secondary outcomes Amount of root resorption associated with intrusion Vertical movement of mandibular molars Stability of intrusion Patient reported outcomes Compliance Cost effectiveness Adverse effects No restrictions on data collection sources (dental models, clinical measurements and radiographs were considered) TAD: temporary anchorage device Search strategy The following databases and trials registries were searched from date of inception to March 22nd, 2023 (Appendix 1): PubMed/MEDLINE (including Pre-MEDLINE and non-MEDLINE; 1945 to March 2023), Embase (Elsevier; 1947 to March 2023), Scopus (Elsevier; 1966 to March 2023), Dentistry & Oral Science Source (DOSS, Ebsco; 1919 to March 2023), Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL; Wiley; through March 2023), CINAHL Plus with Full Text (Ebsco; 1937 to March 2023), Web of Science (Medline, Biosis, and the Zoological Record only; Clarivate; 1895 to March 2023), Global Index Medicus (World Health Organization; 1917 to March 2023), Dissertations & Theses Global (ProQuest; 1861 to March 2023), ClinicalTrials.gov (through March 2023), and the Trip Database (Trip Database Ltd, tripdatabase.com; through March 2023; Appendix 1). That was developed by an experienced health sciences librarian and the authors (AS, AD, IM). The cited references and citing references of all included studies were screened. Studies selection and data extraction Two authors (AS, FP) screened the retrieved records for eligibility assessment. Selection was based on title, abstract, study design, and full text reading if needed, to match the inclusion criteria. Conflicts were resolved by contacting a third author (AD). Using a customized data collection form, data extraction was carried out by two reviewers (AS, AH) independently and in duplicate. Conflicts were resolved by discussion with a third author (AD). Extracted data included: type of study, clinical setting, sample size, demographic information, type of appliance, details about the intervention, intrusion period, force levels, prescribed wear time for removable appliances, retention protocol if mentioned, outcome measures (primary: amount and rate of maxillary molar intrusion; secondary: subsequent vertical movement of lower molars, root resorption, stability, compliance, cost effectiveness, patient reported outcomes if any, and adverse events related to failure rates or reported harms). Risk of bias in individual studies The risk of bias for the included randomized controlled trials was assessed using the Cochrane’s tool (RoB 2) [23] by two reviewers, independently (AS, AD). Any disagreement was resolved by a third author (UF). Studies were deemed to be of high risk of bias (if at least one domain was rated at high risk), some concerns (if at least one domain was classified at unclear risk of bias) and low (if majority of domains present with low risk of bias). Quality of evidence Quality of evidence was judged according to the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) approach [24]. It was used to appraise the overall quality of evidence of the primary outcomes (the amount and rate of intrusion of the maxillary molars) reported in the included studies. Evidence was judged as very low, low, moderate, and high based on 5 domains, risk of bias, precision, consistency, directness, and other aspects outlined in the included studies. Evaluation was conducted independently by two authors (AS, AD) and in duplicate. Risk of bias across studies Standard and contoured enhanced funnel plots were planned if sufficient number of trials (more than 10 trials) were included in the meta-analysis if executed. Dealing with missing data In case of any missing information, corresponding authors of the included trials were contacted. Data synthesis It was preplanned to perform a meta-analysis, only if sufficient data and adequate studies were available to justify a valid statistical analysis. Clinical heterogeneity of studies was determined by assessing the study characteristics with particular emphasis on characteristics of participants, types of interventions, and outcomes. Weighted treatment effect with its 95% confidence intervals was to be calculated. I2 test was to be used to quantify statistical heterogeneity. Results Study selection A total of 3986 records were identified through the electronic data search (Fig. 1). After removal of duplicates using ProQuest RefWorks (Ann Arbor, USA) reference management software, 1690 articles remained for screening. A total of 1666 articles were excluded following titles and abstracts screening, and 24 reports were sought for retrieval. Subsequently, 18 were assessed for eligibility, of which 10 were excluded (Appendix 2). Finally, 8 articles [25–32], 2 of which reported data from the same trial [26, 27] were included in this review. PRISMA flowchart of the included studies Study characteristics Table 2 summarizes the characteristics of the included randomized controlled trials. All the included trials were 2-arm parallel RCTs [25–28, 30–32], except one study that was three-arm parallel group RCT [29]. All of the included trials were conducted in a university setting in various countries: Brazil [31], India [28], Egypt [26, 27], Syria [29, 30, 32] and Spain [25]. The identified studies included a total of 242 subjects. The age range fell between 7 and 40 years. Duration of the active phase of intrusion ranged between 6 months [25], 8–10 months [28, 29, 32], and 12 months [30, 31]. One study only reported a retention phase of 10 months [28]. Table 2Characteristics of the identified trials (n = 7)Study and settingParticipants and treatment groupsInclusion criteriaAppliance used/design/forcePrescribed wear timeOutcome assessment/follow up/duration of intrusionOutcomesTorres et al. [31] (2006)University setting—Braziln = 60E (crib and highpull chin cup): n = 30 (22F, 8M); 8.3 y (7–10.1 y)C (no treatment): n = 30 (23F, 7M); 8.6 y (6.8–10.4 y)(6–10 y)Class I AOBNon-extractionNo missing teeth or cross biteAbsence of oral habits and airway obstructionRemovable palatal crib: Adams clasps U6’s, labial bow, palatal crib, acrylic coverageHigh pull chin cup: 450–550 g/side14–16 h for 12 mPre- and post-TT lateral cephalogramsT 2– T 1 changes over time34 skeletal, dentoalveolar and Soft tissue measurementsDuration of intrusion: 12 mSkeletalSNA (°), SNB (°), ANB (°), ALFH (mm), SN. GoGn (°)DentoalveolarU6 Eruption (mm), L6 Eruption (mm), difference in eruption of molar (mm), overbite (mm), L6-GoMe (mm), L1-GoMe (mm), U6-PP (mm), U1-PP (mm), U1.NA (°),U1-NA (mm), L1.NB (°), L1-NB (mm), U6-FHp (mm), L6-FHp (mm), U1-FHp (mm), L1-FHp (mm), Expo U1 (mm), interincisor (°)Soft tissueH. NB (°),Nasolabial (°) mentolabial (°), Sn-ES (mm), Gl.Sn.P ′ (°), Sn-Gl vertical (mm), P ′ -Gl vertical (mm), LS-P ′ Sn (mm), LI-P ′ Sn (mm), soft AFH (mm), interlabial gap (mm)Doshi et al. [28] (2010)University setting—Indian = 20 (12F, 8 M); (8–15 y)E1 (spring loaded bite block): n = 10 (5F, 5M)E2 (magnetic bite block): n = 10 (7F, 3 M)C: matched data from growth study (Human Growth Research Center, University of Montreal, Quebec)AOBSteep mandibular planeIncreased gonial angleIncreased lower anterior facial heightClass I or IINo finger-sucking habits or evidence of enlarged tonsilsSpring loaded Bite Block:Woodside and Linder-Aronsonmandibular plate with occlusal acrylic resin block connected by buccal and lingual helical spring (0.9 mm SS), soldered to Adams clasps (0.8 mm SS)Two, a 0.9-mm SS hook were placed buccally into the occlusal bite block in the molar region to measure the amount of activationActivation: 250–300 cN/4 weeksMagnetic Bite block:Active vertical corrector (Dellinger)Similar bite blocks to spring loaded, in each arch two circular (1.5*10.0 mm) neodymium iron boron magnetsForce applied to teeth: 300 cNFull time wearPre- and post-TT lateral cephalogramsT2–T1 changes over time34 (18 linear and 16 angular) measurements, superimpositionsEMG activity of the masseter and temporalis musclesDuration of intrusion: 8 mRetention: 10 m with passive blockSkeletal angularSNA, SNB, ANB, BetaVertical angularSN-GoGn, Ar-Go-Me, Ar-Go-N N-Go-Me, Gn/FH, SN/ANS-PNS, SN/UOP, SN/LOP, S-Ar-Go, SN/Go-ArVertical linearSN-ANS, SN-PNS, S-Go, N-Me, S-Go/N-MeDentoalveolarUI-NA, LI-NB, UIE-NA LIE-NB,UIE-ANS-PNS, LIE-Go-Gn, UMC-ANS-PNS, LMC-Go-Gn, overjet, overbiteSoft tissue (mm)Upper lip-S line, lower lip-S lineEMGMean changes in masseter and temporalis activityAkl et al. [26, 27] (2020,2021)University setting-Egyptn = 20 (8–15 y)C (200 g intrusive force with miniscrews): n = 10 (19.22 ± 1.45 y)E (400 g intrusive force with miniscrews): n = 10 (18.95 ± 1.77 y)Adult aged 18 to 25 ySkeletal open biteDental open bite (3 to 8 mm)Skeletal Class I/mild to moderate skeletal Class IINormal incisal show Non-extraction No previous orthodontic treatmentPre-intrusion: segmented fixed appliance on mx posterior teeth, Roth prescriptionIntrusion phase:4 mini-screws (10 × 1.6 mm; 3 M Unitek TAD): 2 infrazygomatic and 2 palatal between the 1st and 2nd MPalatal wires and lower buccal stabilizing wires (0.9-mm wire bonded on the buccal surface)closed nickel–titanium (Ni–Ti) coil springsC: 200 g, E: 400 gRecall: 2 weeks–Pre- and post-TT CBCT imagesCBCT:Mx teeth intrusion,tipping of intruded teeth mesiodistally and buccolingually,lower teeth extrusion,root resorption: root lengths (cusp tip to the root apex of each root of all posterior teeth)Clinically:open bite closure/2 weeksDuration of intrusion: 6 mIntrusion measurements (mm) to FH for U4, U5, U6, U7Mesio-distal tipping (°) relative to Frankfort Horizontal Plane (Tooth/FH) for U4, U5, U6, U7Change in torque relative to mid-sagittal Plane (°) (Tooth/MSP) for U4, U5, U6, U7Root length (mm) (1st and 2nd pm: B,P), (1st and 2nd M: MB,DB,P)Open bite closure/2 weeks (clinically)Hasan et al. [29] (2022)University setting-Syrian = 42 (26F, 16M); (8–10 y)E1 (FPBB and LLLT): n = 14 (9F, 5M); (8.97 ± 0.58 y)E2 (FPBB): n = 14 (8F, 6M); (9.02 ± 0.51 y)C: (no TT): n = 14 (9F, 5M);(9.87 ± 0.44 y)Clinical:8–10 yFully erupted incisorsClass I or Class II skeletal1 mm AOB minimumNo previous orthodontic ttlateral cephalograms:(SN/Go Me) angle > 34°, MM-angle > 30°, and Björk sum > 40°Two posterior acrylic bite blocks (at least 2 mm thickness), connected by TPA (4 mm away from palatal mucosa)Tongue crib (0.9 mm SS wire)Force: 250 gLaser: Gallium aluminum arsenide (Ga-Al-As) laser with a continuous wavelength of 808 nmLaser parameters: The power of 250 mW, the energy at 4 J, application time 16 s per pointFrequency of application: day 1, 3, 7, and 14 of the first month, then every 15 days until the end of the treatmentFull time wearPre- and post-TT lateral cephalogramsRecall: monthlyEnd of active TT: positive overbite 1–2 mmRetention: posterior bite block and crib for 10 mDuration of intrusion:E1: (7.07 ± 1.54 m)E2: (9.42 ± 2.31 m)Clinical:Time to correct AOBCephalometric:Angular: SNA°, SNB°, ANB°, SN/MP°, PP-MP (MM)°, Björk Sum°, Y-axis°, U1/SN°, L1/MP°,Linear (mm): S-Go, N-Me, S-Go/N-Me, U1-PP, U6-PP, L1-MP, L6-MP, overbite, overjetAbellan et al. [25] (2021)University setting-Spainn = 20 (12F, 8M); (44.9 ± 9.6 y)E (PBM and TAD based mx molar intrusion): n = 10C (TAD based mx molar intrusion): n = 10Extruded U6s without curved rootsGood oral hygienePermanent dentition with presence of adjacent teeth to the molar to be intrudedNo previous trauma, orthodontic treatment or periodontal diseaseAlveolar bone loss < 30%No severe crowding in posterior teethIntrusion: 2 mini-screws (Jeil Corp, Seoul, Korea) 1.6 mm × 10 mm placed buccal mesial and palatal distal to the over erupted molarButtons were bonded buccal and lingual to molarsElastic chains (75 g force) between the buttons and mini-screw0.01 SS ligature tie between miniscews and molar after intrusion is completedPBM: A low-power diode laser (Periowave; Ondine BioPharma, Vancouver,Canada) wavelength of 670 nm, with a power of 150 mW–Pre- and post-TT CBCT imagesAt days 0 and 180 Superimposed images using Dolphin software 3D models (STL) format obtained at 0, 90, and 180 days On days 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, and 7 of the beginning of the intrusion and in each monthly follow-upDuration of intrusion: 6 mPeriodontal parameters (probing depth and bleeding of probing)Mean intruded distance (mm), intruded velocity mm/m at 3 m and 6 mResorption: mean molar volume at T0 and T2 (6 m)Mousa et al. [30] (2021)University setting-Syrian = 40 (19F, 21M), (7.5–10.5 y)E1 (OBB): n = 20, (8F, 12M), (8.8 ± 1.5 y)E2 (RPBP/C): n = 20, (11F, 9M), (8.6 ± 1.1 y)Clinical:AOB 2–5 mm7.5 to 10.5 ySkeletal Class I or Class IITongue thrustNo airway issue or previous orthodontic TTRPBP/C: Upper removable appliance with posterior bite plane (1–2 mm thickness)OBB: posterior acrylic bite blocks, palatal bar (1.2 mm), to guide the tongue into a more posterior position. Labial bow (0.9 mm) to achieve a competent sealFull time wear for 12 mRetention: night time wearPre- and post-TT lateral cephalograms9 angular and 8 linear measurementsDuration of intrusion: 12 mSkeletalAngular (°): SNA, SNB, ANB, MM, SN.GoMe, BjörkLinear (mm): S-Go, N-MeDentoalveolarAngular (°): 1U.SN,1L. GoMe,1U.1LLinear (mm): 1U-SPP, 6U-SPP,1L-GoMe, 6L-GoMe, OJ, OBHasan et al. [32] (2022)University setting—Syrian = 40 (19F, 21M)E (RMI): n = 20, (10F, 10M), (9.7 ± 0.66y)C (no TT): n = 20 (9F, 11M), (9.9 ± 0.54 y)Clinical:8–12 y (mixed dentition stage)Skeletal AOBClass I, IIRadiographic inclusion:(SN/GoMe) > 33°MM > 27° facial axis (Y-axis) > 65°RMI: TPA and lingual arch. Nickle-titanium active springs attached to the tubes of upper and lower permanent first molarsIntrusion force: 800 g per sidePulpotomy and occlusal reduction on primary molars were undertaken to reestablish occlusal contactFull time wearPre- and post-TT lateral cephalograms9 m apart20 variablesDuration of intrusion: 9 mSkeletalSNA, SNB, SN/GoMe, MM, Björk Sum, Y axis, S-Go, N-Men,DentoalveolarU1-PP, U6-PP, L6-MP, U1/SN, U1/L1, OB, OJ1M, first molar; 2M, second molar; AOB, anterior open bite; C, control; cN, centinewtons; DB, distobuccal; E, experimental; EMG, electromyography; F, females; FPBB, fixed posterior bite block; g, gram; h, hours; Go, gonion; J, joules; kv, kilovolts; L, lower; LLLT, low-level laser therapy; M, males; m, months; MB, mesiobuccal; Me, menton; MM, maxillary mandibular angle; mm, millimeters; MP, mandibular plane; mW, milliwatts; Mx, maxillary; N, nasion; nm, nanometers; OB, overbite; OBB, open bite Bionator; OJ, overjet; P, palatal, PBM, photobiomodulation; PM, premolar; RMI, rapid molar intruder; RPBB, removable posterior bite block; RPBP, removable posterior bite plane; S, sella; SS, stainless steel; TAD, temporary anchorage device; TPA, transpalatal arch; TT, treatment; U, upper; y, years Characteristics of the identified trials (n = 7) Torres et al. [31] (2006) University setting—Brazil n = 60 E (crib and highpull chin cup): n = 30 (22F, 8M); 8.3 y (7–10.1 y) C (no treatment): n = 30 (23F, 7M); 8.6 y (6.8–10.4 y) (6–10 y) Class I AOB Non-extraction No missing teeth or cross bite Absence of oral habits and airway obstruction Removable palatal crib: Adams clasps U6’s, labial bow, palatal crib, acrylic coverage High pull chin cup: 450–550 g/side Pre- and post-TT lateral cephalograms T 2– T 1 changes over time 34 skeletal, dentoalveolar and Soft tissue measurements Duration of intrusion: 12 m Skeletal SNA (°), SNB (°), ANB (°), ALFH (mm), SN. GoGn (°) Dentoalveolar U6 Eruption (mm), L6 Eruption (mm), difference in eruption of molar (mm), overbite (mm), L6-GoMe (mm), L1-GoMe (mm), U6-PP (mm), U1-PP (mm), U1.NA (°),U1-NA (mm), L1.NB (°), L1-NB (mm), U6-FHp (mm), L6-FHp (mm), U1-FHp (mm), L1-FHp (mm), Expo U1 (mm), interincisor (°) Soft tissue H. NB (°),Nasolabial (°) mentolabial (°), Sn-ES (mm), Gl.Sn.P ′ (°), Sn-Gl vertical (mm), P ′ -Gl vertical (mm), LS-P ′ Sn (mm), LI-P ′ Sn (mm), soft AFH (mm), interlabial gap (mm) Doshi et al. [28] (2010) University setting—India n = 20 (12F, 8 M); (8–15 y) E1 (spring loaded bite block): n = 10 (5F, 5M) E2 (magnetic bite block): n = 10 (7F, 3 M) C: matched data from growth study (Human Growth Research Center, University of Montreal, Quebec) AOB Steep mandibular plane Increased gonial angle Increased lower anterior facial height Class I or II No finger-sucking habits or evidence of enlarged tonsils Spring loaded Bite Block: Woodside and Linder-Aronson mandibular plate with occlusal acrylic resin block connected by buccal and lingual helical spring (0.9 mm SS), soldered to Adams clasps (0.8 mm SS) Two, a 0.9-mm SS hook were placed buccally into the occlusal bite block in the molar region to measure the amount of activation Activation: 250–300 cN/4 weeks Magnetic Bite block: Active vertical corrector (Dellinger) Similar bite blocks to spring loaded, in each arch two circular (1.5*10.0 mm) neodymium iron boron magnets Force applied to teeth: 300 cN Pre- and post-TT lateral cephalograms T2–T1 changes over time 34 (18 linear and 16 angular) measurements, superimpositions EMG activity of the masseter and temporalis muscles Duration of intrusion: 8 m Retention: 10 m with passive block Skeletal angular SNA, SNB, ANB, Beta Vertical angular SN-GoGn, Ar-Go-Me, Ar-Go-N N-Go-Me, Gn/FH, SN/ANS-PNS, SN/UOP, SN/LOP, S-Ar-Go, SN/Go-Ar Vertical linear SN-ANS, SN-PNS, S-Go, N-Me, S-Go/N-Me Dentoalveolar UI-NA, LI-NB, UIE-NA LIE-NB,UIE-ANS-PNS, LIE-Go-Gn, UMC-ANS-PNS, LMC-Go-Gn, overjet, overbite Soft tissue (mm) Upper lip-S line, lower lip-S line EMG Mean changes in masseter and temporalis activity Akl et al. [26, 27] (2020,2021) University setting-Egypt n = 20 (8–15 y) C (200 g intrusive force with miniscrews): n = 10 (19.22 ± 1.45 y) E (400 g intrusive force with miniscrews): n = 10 (18.95 ± 1.77 y) Adult aged 18 to 25 y Skeletal open bite Dental open bite (3 to 8 mm) Skeletal Class I/mild to moderate skeletal Class II Normal incisal show Non-extraction No previous orthodontic treatment Pre-intrusion: segmented fixed appliance on mx posterior teeth, Roth prescription Intrusion phase: 4 mini-screws (10 × 1.6 mm; 3 M Unitek TAD): 2 infrazygomatic and 2 palatal between the 1st and 2nd M Palatal wires and lower buccal stabilizing wires (0.9-mm wire bonded on the buccal surface) closed nickel–titanium (Ni–Ti) coil springs C: 200 g, E: 400 g Recall: 2 weeks Pre- and post-TT CBCT images CBCT: Mx teeth intrusion, tipping of intruded teeth mesiodistally and buccolingually, lower teeth extrusion, root resorption: root lengths (cusp tip to the root apex of each root of all posterior teeth) Clinically: open bite closure/2 weeks Duration of intrusion: 6 m Intrusion measurements (mm) to FH for U4, U5, U6, U7 Mesio-distal tipping (°) relative to Frankfort Horizontal Plane (Tooth/FH) for U4, U5, U6, U7 Change in torque relative to mid-sagittal Plane (°) (Tooth/MSP) for U4, U5, U6, U7 Root length (mm) (1st and 2nd pm: B,P), (1st and 2nd M: MB,DB,P) Open bite closure/2 weeks (clinically) Hasan et al. [29] (2022) University setting-Syria n = 42 (26F, 16M); (8–10 y) E1 (FPBB and LLLT): n = 14 (9F, 5M); (8.97 ± 0.58 y) E2 (FPBB): n = 14 (8F, 6M); (9.02 ± 0.51 y) C: (no TT): n = 14 (9F, 5M); (9.87 ± 0.44 y) Clinical: 8–10 y Fully erupted incisors Class I or Class II skeletal 1 mm AOB minimum No previous orthodontic tt lateral cephalograms: (SN/Go Me) angle > 34°, MM-angle > 30°, and Björk sum > 40° Two posterior acrylic bite blocks (at least 2 mm thickness), connected by TPA (4 mm away from palatal mucosa) Tongue crib (0.9 mm SS wire) Force: 250 g Laser: Gallium aluminum arsenide (Ga-Al-As) laser with a continuous wavelength of 808 nm Laser parameters: The power of 250 mW, the energy at 4 J, application time 16 s per point Frequency of application: day 1, 3, 7, and 14 of the first month, then every 15 days until the end of the treatment Pre- and post-TT lateral cephalograms Recall: monthly End of active TT: positive overbite 1–2 mm Retention: posterior bite block and crib for 10 m Duration of intrusion: E1: (7.07 ± 1.54 m) E2: (9.42 ± 2.31 m) Clinical: Time to correct AOB Cephalometric: Angular: SNA°, SNB°, ANB°, SN/MP°, PP-MP (MM)°, Björk Sum°, Y-axis°, U1/SN°, L1/MP°, Linear (mm): S-Go, N-Me, S-Go/N-Me, U1-PP, U6-PP, L1-MP, L6-MP, overbite, overjet Abellan et al. [25] (2021) University setting-Spain n = 20 (12F, 8M); (44.9 ± 9.6 y) E (PBM and TAD based mx molar intrusion): n = 10 C (TAD based mx molar intrusion): n = 10 Extruded U6s without curved roots Good oral hygiene Permanent dentition with presence of adjacent teeth to the molar to be intruded No previous trauma, orthodontic treatment or periodontal disease Alveolar bone loss < 30% No severe crowding in posterior teeth Intrusion: 2 mini-screws (Jeil Corp, Seoul, Korea) 1.6 mm × 10 mm placed buccal mesial and palatal distal to the over erupted molar Buttons were bonded buccal and lingual to molars Elastic chains (75 g force) between the buttons and mini-screw 0.01 SS ligature tie between miniscews and molar after intrusion is completed PBM: A low-power diode laser (Periowave; Ondine BioPharma, Vancouver,Canada) wavelength of 670 nm, with a power of 150 mW Pre- and post-TT CBCT images At days 0 and 180 Superimposed images using Dolphin software 3D models (STL) format obtained at 0, 90, and 180 days On days 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, and 7 of the beginning of the intrusion and in each monthly follow-up Duration of intrusion: 6 m Periodontal parameters (probing depth and bleeding of probing) Mean intruded distance (mm), intruded velocity mm/m at 3 m and 6 m Resorption: mean molar volume at T0 and T2 (6 m) Mousa et al. [30] (2021) University setting-Syria n = 40 (19F, 21M), (7.5–10.5 y) E1 (OBB): n = 20, (8F, 12M), (8.8 ± 1.5 y) E2 (RPBP/C): n = 20, (11F, 9M), (8.6 ± 1.1 y) Clinical: AOB 2–5 mm 7.5 to 10.5 y Skeletal Class I or Class II Tongue thrust No airway issue or previous orthodontic TT RPBP/C: Upper removable appliance with posterior bite plane (1–2 mm thickness) OBB: posterior acrylic bite blocks, palatal bar (1.2 mm), to guide the tongue into a more posterior position. Labial bow (0.9 mm) to achieve a competent seal Full time wear for 12 m Retention: night time wear Pre- and post-TT lateral cephalograms 9 angular and 8 linear measurements Duration of intrusion: 12 m Skeletal Angular (°): SNA, SNB, ANB, MM, SN.GoMe, Björk Linear (mm): S-Go, N-Me Dentoalveolar Angular (°): 1U.SN,1L. GoMe,1U.1L Linear (mm): 1U-SPP, 6U-SPP,1L-GoMe, 6L-GoMe, OJ, OB Hasan et al. [32] (2022) University setting—Syria n = 40 (19F, 21M) E (RMI): n = 20, (10F, 10M), (9.7 ± 0.66y) C (no TT): n = 20 (9F, 11M), (9.9 ± 0.54 y) Clinical: 8–12 y (mixed dentition stage) Skeletal AOB Class I, II Radiographic inclusion: (SN/GoMe) > 33° MM > 27° facial axis (Y-axis) > 65° RMI: TPA and lingual arch. Nickle-titanium active springs attached to the tubes of upper and lower permanent first molars Intrusion force: 800 g per side Pulpotomy and occlusal reduction on primary molars were undertaken to reestablish occlusal contact Pre- and post-TT lateral cephalograms 9 m apart 20 variables Duration of intrusion: 9 m Skeletal SNA, SNB, SN/GoMe, MM, Björk Sum, Y axis, S-Go, N-Men, Dentoalveolar U1-PP, U6-PP, L6-MP, U1/SN, U1/L1, OB, OJ 1M, first molar; 2M, second molar; AOB, anterior open bite; C, control; cN, centinewtons; DB, distobuccal; E, experimental; EMG, electromyography; F, females; FPBB, fixed posterior bite block; g, gram; h, hours; Go, gonion; J, joules; kv, kilovolts; L, lower; LLLT, low-level laser therapy; M, males; m, months; MB, mesiobuccal; Me, menton; MM, maxillary mandibular angle; mm, millimeters; MP, mandibular plane; mW, milliwatts; Mx, maxillary; N, nasion; nm, nanometers; OB, overbite; OBB, open bite Bionator; OJ, overjet; P, palatal, PBM, photobiomodulation; PM, premolar; RMI, rapid molar intruder; RPBB, removable posterior bite block; RPBP, removable posterior bite plane; S, sella; SS, stainless steel; TAD, temporary anchorage device; TPA, transpalatal arch; TT, treatment; U, upper; y, years Different appliances were utilized for intrusion, the removable palatal crib with high pull headgear was used for open bite treatment in one trial [31]. The posterior bite blocks were utilized in three trials [28–30], one compared the effects of the spring loaded to the magnetic bite blocks [28]. One study compared the effects of an upper fixed posterior bite block fixed posterior bite block (FPBB) to a no treatment group, further utilized low-level laser therapy (LLLT) in a third group of FPBB to evaluate its effect on accelerating tooth movement [29]. The removable posterior bite plane (RPBB) was used with a crib and compared to an open bite Bionator (OBB) functional appliance [30]. Additionally, the use of the rapid molar intruder (RMI) spring appliance was compared to a no treatment control in one trial [32]. As for the TAD-based maxillary molar intrusion studies, one trial compared the use of two different force magnitudes (200 g and 400 g) on the efficacy of intrusion with mini-screws [26, 27]. While the other study focused on pre-prosthetic intrusion of supraerupted molars with mini-screws, additionally assessed the effects of photobiomodulation on accelerating the rate of intrusion [25]. The 5 clinical trials that investigated the efficacy of using appliances other than TADs in intruding teeth, included subjects of a young age group [28–32], while the two studies investigating the efficacy of TADs in intrusion included adults [25, 26]. With respect to forces applied and wear instructions, the removable palatal crib with high pull headgear were prescribed for 14–16 h, with the headgear applying a force of 450–550 g/side [31]. The spring-loaded bite block was activated every 4 weeks and applied a force around 300–400 g, similar to that applied by the magnetic bite block [28]. The fixed posterior bite blocks exerted an intrusive force of approximately 250 g. The RMI exerted 800 g intrusive force on each side which gradually subsided to 450 g at the end of the first week and 250 g at the end of the second week. For the minis-screw studies, an elastomeric chain exerting a force of 75 g between each button (buccal and lingual) and 2 mini-screws (buccal and lingual) was used in Abellan et al. study [25]. While, Akl et al. compared the efficacy of 2 different force magnitudes on intrusion (200 and 400 g) [26, 27]. The duration of intrusion in the included studies ranged between 6 and 12 months. Outcome assessments were carried out with the use of lateral cephalograms [28–32], cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) images [25–27] and 3D digital models [25]. Risk of bias within the studies and quality assessment Risk of bias for the included studies is presented in Table 3. Six of the included trials were judged to have some concerns mainly due to selective reporting of the results [25, 28, 30–32] and lack of information regarding blinding of outcome assessor [25, 29–32]. One trial was judged at high risk of bias due to concerns related to the randomization process and measurement of the outcomes [28]. The overall quality of evidence for the primary outcomes (the amount and rate of intrusion of the maxillary molars), assessed by GRADE (Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluations) [33] was very low due to the heterogeneity in the interventions assessed, relatively small sample size in 5 trials [25–28, 30, 32], and based on the overall assessment of the risk of bias (Table 4). Table 3Risk of bias assessment for the included studies Risk of bias assessment for the included studies Table 4Certainty of available evidence for the amount and rate of maxillary molar intrusionQuality assessmentOverall quality of evidenceNo of studies and participantsDesignRisk of biasInconsistencyIndirectnessImprecisionOtherOutcomes: amount and rate of maxillary molar intrusion7 trialsn = 242 participantsRandomized controlled trialsVery seriousaVery seriousbNot seriousSeriouscNone Very lowaBased on the risk of bias assessmentbDue to heterogeneity in interventions assessedcRelatively small sample size in 5 trials Certainty of available evidence for the amount and rate of maxillary molar intrusion 7 trials n = 242 participants Very low aBased on the risk of bias assessment bDue to heterogeneity in interventions assessed cRelatively small sample size in 5 trials Results of individual studies Tables 5 and 6 summarize the primary (amount and rate of maxillary molar intrusion) and secondary (root resorption, subsequent vertical movement of lower molars, stability, patient reported outcomes, compliance, cost effectiveness and adverse events) outcomes reported in the identified trials. Table 5Findings related to the amount and rate of maxillary molar intrusionStudy and treatment groupsAmount of maxillary molar intrusion(mean (mm) ± SD)Calculated rate of maxillary molar intrusion(mean (mm)/month ± SD)E1E2CE1E2CTorres et al. [31] (2006)E1 (crib and HP chin cup): n = 30C (no treatment): n = 300.88 ± 1.55*–0.26 ± 1.130.07 ± 0.13–0.02 ± 0.09Doshi et al. [28] (2010)E1(spring-loaded bite block): n = 10E2 (magnetic bite block): n = 10− 0.8 ± 0.3− 1.1 ± 0.4–− 0.1 ± 0.04− 0.14 ± 0.05–Akl et al. [26, 27] (2020)E1 (400 g force): n = 10E2 (200 g force): n = 10− 2.37 ± 1.3− 2.61 ± 1–− 0.4 ± 0.22− 0.44 ± 0.16–Hasan et al. [29] (2021)E1 (FPBB and LLLT): n = 14E2 (FPBB): n = 14C (no treatment): n = 14− 1.21 ± 0.32− 0.82 ± 0.370.32 ± 0.37− 0.17 ± 0.05− 0.09 ± 0.04–Abellan et al. [25] (2021)E1 (PBM and TAD based mx molar intrusion): n = 10E2 (TAD based mx molar intrusion): n = 10− 2.31 ± 0.65− 2.95 ± 1.16–− 0.42 ± 0.13− 0.49 ± 0.17–Mousa et al. [30] (2021)E1 (OBB): n = 20E2 (RPBP/crib): n = 20− 1.44 ± 0.6− 1.11 ± 0.8–− 0.12 ± 0.05− 0.09 ± 0.07–Hasan et al. [32] (2022)E (RMI): n = 20C (no treatment): n = 20− 2.90 ± 1.66–0.55 ± 1.93− 0.32 ± 0.18–0.06 ± 0.21C, control; E, experimental; FPBB, fixed posterior bite plane; HP, high pull; mm, millimeter; OBB, open bite Bionator; PBM, photobiomodulation; RMI, rapid molar intruder; RPBP, removable posterior bite block; SD, standard deviation; TAD, temporary anchorage device; mx, maxillary; LLLT, low-level laser therapy*Positive value indicating molar extrusion Findings related to the amount and rate of maxillary molar intrusion Torres et al. [31] (2006) E1 (crib and HP chin cup): n = 30 C (no treatment): n = 30 Doshi et al. [28] (2010) E1(spring-loaded bite block): n = 10 E2 (magnetic bite block): n = 10 Akl et al. [26, 27] (2020) E1 (400 g force): n = 10 E2 (200 g force): n = 10 Hasan et al. [29] (2021) E1 (FPBB and LLLT): n = 14 E2 (FPBB): n = 14 C (no treatment): n = 14 Abellan et al. [25] (2021) E1 (PBM and TAD based mx molar intrusion): n = 10 E2 (TAD based mx molar intrusion): n = 10 Mousa et al. [30] (2021) E1 (OBB): n = 20 E2 (RPBP/crib): n = 20 Hasan et al. [32] (2022) E (RMI): n = 20C (no treatment): n = 20 C, control; E, experimental; FPBB, fixed posterior bite plane; HP, high pull; mm, millimeter; OBB, open bite Bionator; PBM, photobiomodulation; RMI, rapid molar intruder; RPBP, removable posterior bite block; SD, standard deviation; TAD, temporary anchorage device; mx, maxillary; LLLT, low-level laser therapy *Positive value indicating molar extrusion Table 6Additional findings from the included studiesStudyRoot resorptionAmount of vertical movement of mandibular molars(mean (mm) ± SD)Stability of intrusionPatient reported outcomesComplianceCost effective-nessAdverse eventsParameterE1E2E1E2CAkl et al. [26, 27] (2020,2021)E1: TADs 200 gE2: TADs 400 gChange in length of molar roots (mean ± SD)− 0.8 ± 0.88 mm− 0.82 ± 0.93 mm1.06 ± 2.06 mm0.65 ± 0.52 mm -NA NA NA NASoft tissue overgrowth around the heads of the infrazygomatic TADsTAD failure (loose): n = 2 (one infrazygomatic and one palatal TAD)No inter-group comparisonAbellan et al. [25] (2021)E1: PBM and TADsE2: TADsChange in molar volume (mean ± SD)− 52 ± 142.22 mm3− 22.4 ± 160.59 mm3NA NA NANA NANA NATAD failure: n = 4 (one developed soft tissue hypertrophy, and the other 3 became loose)Torres et al. [31] (2006)E1: crib and HP chin cupC: no treatmentNA NA NA1.06 ± 1.31 -0.84 ± 1.03NA NA NA NANIDoshi et al. [28] (2010)E1: spring-loaded bite blockE2: magnetic bite blockNA NA NA− 0.2 ± 0.3− 0.8 ± 0.4 -NA NA NA NAE1: breakage (n = 7)Hasan et al. [32] (2021)E1: FPBB and LLLTE2: FPBBC: no treatmentNANA NA0.04 ± 0.410.14 ± 0.23 -NA NA NA NANo observed harmsMousa et al. [30] (2021)E1: OBBE2: RPBP/CNA NA NA0.19 ± 1.1− 0.27 ± 1.3 -NA NA NA NAE1: tongue ulceration (n = 2)E2: tongue ulceration (n = 2) and soft tissue irritation (n = 2)Hasan et al. [32] (2022)E: RMIC: no treatmentNA NA NA− 1.54 ± 2.18 -0.56 ± 1.77NA NA NA NASpring fracture (n = 2)C, control; E, experimental; FPBM, fixed posterior bite block; HP, high-pull; LLLT, low-level laser treatment; NA, not assessed; NI, no information; OBB, open bite bionator; PBM, photobiomodulation; RMI, rapid molar intruder; RPBP, removable posterior bite plane; SD, standard deviation; TAD, temporary anchorage device Additional findings from the included studies Akl et al. [26, 27] (2020,2021) E1: TADs 200 g E2: TADs 400 g Soft tissue overgrowth around the heads of the infrazygomatic TADs TAD failure (loose): n = 2 (one infrazygomatic and one palatal TAD) No inter-group comparison Abellan et al. [25] (2021) E1: PBM and TADs E2: TADs Torres et al. [31] (2006) E1: crib and HP chin cup C: no treatment Doshi et al. [28] (2010) E1: spring-loaded bite block E2: magnetic bite block Hasan et al. [32] (2021) E1: FPBB and LLLT E2: FPBB C: no treatment Mousa et al. [30] (2021) E1: OBB E2: RPBP/C E1: tongue ulceration (n = 2) E2: tongue ulceration (n = 2) and soft tissue irritation (n = 2) Hasan et al. [32] (2022) E: RMI C: no treatment C, control; E, experimental; FPBM, fixed posterior bite block; HP, high-pull; LLLT, low-level laser treatment; NA, not assessed; NI, no information; OBB, open bite bionator; PBM, photobiomodulation; RMI, rapid molar intruder; RPBP, removable posterior bite plane; SD, standard deviation; TAD, temporary anchorage device Amount of maxillary molar intrusion With the use of a crib and high-pull (HP) chin cup, Torres et al. [31] reported no real or relative intrusion of maxillary molars, but rather upper molars were slightly extruded (0.88 ± 1.55 mm) compared to controls (0.26 ± 1.13 mm) (Table 5). Doshi et al. [28] showed that both bite blocks (spring loaded and magnetic) resulted in intrusion of maxillary molars, with more statistically significant amount of intrusion reported with the use of the magnetic bite blocks (1.1 ± 0.4* mm, P < 0.05) compared to the spring-loaded. Regarding the efficacy for the fixed posterior bite planes FPBB in intruding the maxillary molars, Hasan et al. [29] showed a statistically significant amount of intrusion with the use of the FPBB (− 0.82 ± 0.37 mm, P < 0.001) for 9 months compared to their control group. With the administration of LLLT, the reported amount of maxillary molar intrusion was − 1.21 ± 0.32 mm, P < 0.001 at 7-month follow-up. Likewise, the RMI demonstrated an active intrusion for the maxillary molars of − 2.90 ± 1.66 mm compared to the control [32]. Mousa et al. [30] compared the OBB appliance to the removable posterior bite plane RPBB with a crib, reporting almost a similar amount of maxillary molar intrusion observed with the use of both (OBB: − 1.44 ± 0.6 mm, RPBB and crib: − 1.11 ± 0.8 mm). Regarding intrusion with TADs, Akl et al. [26, 27] showed that the amount of intrusion with either 200 g or 400 g of force (200 g: − 2.61 ± 1 mm, P < 0.05, 400 g: − 2.37 ± 1.3 mm, P < 0.05), were non-statistically significant between the studied groups at 12-month follow-up. On the other hand, Abellan et al. [25] reported an amount of intrusion of (− 2.95 ± 1.16 mm) with the use of TADs for 6 months, this amount was less with the use of photobiomodulation PBM (− 2.31 ± 0.65 mm). Rate of maxillary molar intrusion The monthly rate of maxillary molar intrusion was − 0.44 ± 0.16 mm/month with the use of 200 g force with TADs [26, 27] and − 0.49 ± 0.17 mm/month when TADs were used for intrusion without PBM [25] (Table 5). The rate of molar intrusion with the use of RPBP was (− 0.09 ± 0.07 mm/month) [30] and with the use of FPBB was (− 0.09 ± 0.04 mm/month) [29] (Table 5). Secondary outcomes Root resorption Two of the included trials quantified and reported root resorption following intrusion with the use of TADs [25–27] (Table 6). One trial found minimal difference in terms of length of maxillary molar roots following the use of two different force magnitudes (200 g and 400 g) [26, 27]. In the other study, greater changes in the volume of maxillary molar root were observed when TADs were combined with PBM for maxillary molar intrusion, than with the former alone [25]. Amount of subsequent vertical movement of mandibular molars Five studies reported the amount of subsequent vertical movement of the lower molars [26–31] (Table 6). Extrusion of the lower molars, following intrusion of its opposing, was observed with the use of the crib and high pull chin cup (1.06 ± 1.31 mm) [31], and maxillary TADs (200 g: 1.06 ± 2.06 mm, 400 g: 0.65 ± 0.52 mm) [26, 27]. Vertical control of the lower molars was reported with the use of posterior bite planes in general [28–30]; the magnetic bite block slightly intruded the lower molars (–0.8 ± 0.4 mm) [28].Likewise, the RPBB had minimal intrusive effects on the lower molars (− 0.27 ± 1.3 mm) [30]. On the other hand, the use of RMI spring appliance intruded the lower molars by (− 1.54 ± 2.18 mm) [32]. Other secondary outcomes None of the included trials reported outcomes related to stability of intrusion, patient reported outcomes, compliance or cost effectiveness. In terms of adverse effects, one trial reported soft tissue overgrowth around the heads of TADs, and failure of 2 miniscrews during the experiment [26, 27] (Table 6). Another trial disclosed the failure of 4 miniscrews during the experiment [25]. Breakages of the posterior bite blocks was reported for 7 subjects in Doshi et al. trial [28].Spring fractures for the RMI were observed in 2 cases [32]. Finally, Mousa et al. [30] mentioned that tongue ulcerations and soft tissue irritation were observed in some cases with the use of OBB and crib with RPBB. Synthesis of the result A meta-analysis was precluded due to the heterogeneity in interventions, population examined and outcome variables. Discussion Based on the findings of the current systematic review, there is limited and very low level of evidence concerning the effectiveness and stability of maxillary molar intrusion achieved using various mechanotherapies. While some appliances offered better vertical control of lower molar movement or even minimally intruded the lower molars, the clinical significance is questionable. Patient-reported outcomes, levels of compliance and cost-effectiveness were overlooked in the identified trials. Furthermore, no studies included long-term evaluation of stability of molar intrusion. Therefore, no recommendation can be made in favor of conventional or TAD-based treatment. Treatment modalities assessed in the included studies varied between different age groups and malocclusions. Conventional methods of intrusion were mainly tested in a young age group [28–31], while TADS were experimented on adults [25, 26]. As a result, no studies involving a comparison of conventional methods and TADs were identified since TADs are not typically used in very young patients [34]. Treatment modalities evaluated in the identified studies were mainly focused on improving an anterior open bite by maxillary molar intrusion [26–31]. Only one RCT investigated the efficacy of TADs in intruding supra-erupted maxillary molars [25]. Overall, trials included were heterogenous in nature due to the variety of interventions, outcomes and population examined, therefore, meta-analysis was precluded. One of the early treatment modalities that provides vertical control in open bite cases is the vertical-pull chin cup [31, 35, 36]. Majourau and Nanda found that its use with expanders prevented an increase in the anterior facial height and the mandibular plane angle [37]. Ritucci and Nanda reported that the primary effect of the chin cup is on maxillary incisors [38]. However, when used in conjunction with bite blocks it significantly intruded the upper and lower molars [39], most probably due to the effect of the bite blocks rather than the chin cup itself. Moreover, anterior extrusion is often limited to dentoalveolar changes and associated with higher relapse rate. Therefore, molar intrusion can be considered a suitable way for non-surgical correction of anterior open bites [40]. However, patient compliance is known to be problematic especially with extraoral appliances [41]. Therefore, availability of intraoral appliances that are effective in achieving intrusion of maxillary molars might offer a better alternative. With regard to the posterior bite blocks, they come in different forms and designs and have been continuously modified (spring loaded, magnetic, fixed or removable) [9, 42–44]. They hinge the mandible open, therefore, stretching the surrounding musculature, along with the continues biting force, subsequently they would apply intrusive force on the posterior teeth, which allows the forward and upward autorotation of the mandible at a later stage for open bite closure [42, 43]. Moreover, they have been used to intrude supra erupted molars in adult subjects [45]. Three of the included RCTs evaluated the efficacy of these blocks in correcting open bite malocclusion in young age group [28–30]. It is evident that the amount of intrusion reported with the use of these bite blocks is greater than that achieved with other appliances (OBB and chin cup) [30, 31]. Moreover, integration of repelling magnets (the active vertical corrector) in these blocks seems to provide better vertical control [28]. The presence of magnets transforms the conventional acrylic blocks into energized blocks, the repelling forces of the opposing magnets constitutes the built-in energy system. Thus, providing reciprocal intrusive forces on the maxillary and mandibular teeth [8]. The active vertical corrector was found to be more effective in maxillary molar intrusion even in adults, since these magnets often generate a force that ranges between 600 and 650 g on the posterior teeth [8, 45]. Overall, studies included in the current review showed that intrusion of maxillary molars is possibly achievable with posterior bite blocks, with additional advantage of vertical control of mandibular molars and possible minor intrusion. Similar intrusion effect was observed in functional appliances that have integrated posterior bite blocks (e.g. OBB) [30]. Therefore, the use of posterior bite blocks might be a feasible option in intruding posterior teeth. Further, the integration of magnets can improve the predictability of intrusion with bite blocks [8]. A recently published study assessed the effectiveness of RMI appliance which consists of a nickel-titanium spring (RMI®, American Orthodontics, Sheboygan, USA) loaded fixed appliance. The spring extends from the upper to the lower first molar bands with metal pins, and exerts intrusive forces that is applied to the upper and lower molars. Therefore, significant amount of intrusion was reported with its use [32]. Despite the widespread use of TADs as well as skeletal anchorage devices, none of the identified studies involved a comparison of conventional and TAD-based treatments for intrusion of molars. Interestingly, the conjunctive use of TADs in the zygomatic buttress area with maxillary occlusal splint resulted in maxillary molar intrusion (2-4 mm) in 60% of the patients, while one patient had greater than 4 mm intrusion [46]. Furthermore, more predictable amount of intrusion can also be achieved with the use of miniplates (skeletal anchorage system), since they can be placed further away from the roots and provide more vertical component for the intrusive force [47, 48]. However, their limited insertion sites, cost and the surgical procedures required for their placement and removal makes them less popular among clinicians [49]. Tooth movement is a biological response to the applied orthodontic forces. The reported average rate of orthodontic tooth movement in a sagittal direction with continuous force is 0.8 to 1.2 mm/month [50]. The reported calculated rate for intrusion (vertical movement) in this review ranged between (− 0.11 ± 0.06 mm/month) for posterior bite blocks and (− 0.46 ± 0.16 mm/month) with the use of mini-screws. It seems like the rate of intrusion is less than the average rate of sagittal tooth movement. The area of intrusive force is concentrated over a small area at the apex, pushing against dense cortical bone, the distribution of bone density along the axis of the tooth differs, the coronal part of the root often moves against cancellous bone, while the apical part in intrusion is pushing against the dense cortical bone [51]. In a previous investigation, it has been shown that factors that limit the rate of tooth movement include bone density, turnover, and the degree of hyalinization in the periodontal ligament [52]. In terms of root resorption associated with intrusion, shortening of the maxillary molars’ roots [26, 27] and reduction in their volume [25] were observed in the two studies involving molar intrusion using TADs. The apex of the tooth often experiences greater amount of stress and compression during intrusion [53]. A recent systematic review has concluded that the average orthodontic induced root resorption (OIRR) following intrusion is 0.41 mm in the maxillary molars and the amount of force applied is not correlated with the amount of resorption [54]. Therefore, root resorption is an expected sequel of intrusion and difference in the severity of root resorption is expected with the use of different appliances due to variation in the force levels and duration exerted [53, 55]. Finally, the current review highlighted the amount of subsequent vertical movement of mandibular molars reported in the included trials. Significant amount of extrusion of mandibular molars was seen in Akl et al. with the use of maxillary TADs [26, 27] and in Torres et al. with the vertical-pull chin cup [31]. While, control of vertical movement of the lower molars was reported with the use of posterior bite blocks [28–30]. Additionally, an active intrusive force was applied with the RMI to the upper and lower molars in young patients [32]. Specifically, intrusion of lower molars was seen the most with the use of RMI (− 1.54 ± 2.18 mm) followed by the use of the magnetic bite blocks (− 0.8 ± 0.4 mm) and to a lesser extent with the springloaded bite block (− 0.2 ± 0.3 mm) [28], and OBB (− 0.27 ± 1.3 mm) [30]. Some authors suggested ligation of the lower molars to a mandibular mini-screw during intrusion [46]. This denotes the importance of controlling the vertical movement of lower molars while intruding the uppers, especially for overbite correction. Strengths and limitations In the current systematic review, overall quality of evidence ranged from low to very low due to methodological shortcomings observed in the included RCTs. Moreover, conduction of meta-analysis was precluded due to the insufficient homogeneity between the studies. This is typical in orthodontic systematic reviews, with more than two thirds are lacking a meta-analysis [56]. It is clear that that there is a need for further high-quality research encompassing outcomes related to efficacy and stability of the different interventions in terms of the amount and rate of intrusion; as well as cost-effectiveness, compliance levels, and patient-reported outcomes. All the included trials were single-centered and undertaken in university hospitals. This was previously highlighted, in which just less than 15% of orthodontic trials published over a period of 5 years being practice-based and multi-centered [57]. Moreover, the observation period for the included trials was relatively confined to the treatment duration without retention or follow-up period, therefore the amount of relapse following intrusion was not considered. The current systematic review comes as the second review following the one published in 2006 by NJ et al. [20] to quantify the amount and rate of maxillary molar intrusion. Over the last 15 years, the use of TADs became common and their effectiveness in intrusion was not assessed in any previous analysis. Moreover, CBCT scans would allow better assessment for the amount of intrusion, but with their limited use due to radiation concerns, majority of the included studies used 2D cephalometric radiographs to evaluate the amount of intrusion. Implications for research and clinical practice Future RCTs should be considered to further our knowledge on the efficacy of different interventions (conventional vs TADs or a combination between both: TADs and miniplates) in intrusion. These trials should focus on the amount and rate of posterior molar intrusion and use the up-to-date 3D radiographs for outcome assessment. Furthermore, they should take into consideration an observation period for relapse assessment and evaluate patient reported outcomes. Conclusions There is limited evidence related to the effectiveness of different appliances in achieving maxillary molar intrusion. The use of temporary anchorage devices seems to be clinically efficient in maxillary molar intrusion despite their frequent reported failure. Some of these appliances (such as spring loaded or magnetic posterior bite blocks) and the RMI provide posterior occlusal coverage, therefore, offer the additional advantage of intruding the mandibular molars. However, long-term stability of the amount of intrusion achieved is unclear. The findings were based on individual studies with small sample size. Patient-reported outcomes, compliance levels, cost-effectiveness and long-term stability were not assessed in any of the included studies. Limited number of studies assessed molar intrusion for pre-prosthetic management. The level of evidence found was of very low quality. Therefore, future well-designed clinical trials should quantify the true amount of molar intrusion achieved using various interventions. Acknowledgements Not applicable. Abbreviations Fixed posterior bite block High pull Low-level laser therapy Open bite bionator Rapid molar intruder Removable posterior bite block Removable posterior bite plane Temporary anchorage devices Appendix 1: search strategy (from inception to March 22nd, 2023) DatabaseSearch strategyHitsPubMed/Medline (including Pre-Medline and non-Medline)("Orthodontics"[Mesh] OR orthodont*[tw] OR "Open Bite"[Mesh] OR "open bite"[tw]) AND ("Molar"[Mesh] OR molar*[tw] OR "posterior teeth"[tw]) AND (intrus*[tw] OR intrud*[tw]) NOT ("Animals"[Mesh] NOT ("Humans"[Mesh] AND "Animals"[Mesh]))640Embase (Elsevier)('orthodontics'/exp OR orthodont*:ti,ab,kw OR "open bite":ti,ab,kw) AND ('molar tooth'/exp OR molar*:ti,ab,kw) AND ('intrusion'/exp OR intrus*:ti,ab,kw OR intrud*:ti,ab,kw) NOT ('animal'/exp NOT ('human'/exp AND 'animal'/exp))464Scopus (Elsevier)TITLE-ABS-KEY((orthodont* OR "open bite") AND (molar* OR "posterior teeth") AND (intrus* OR intrud*)) AND (LIMIT-TO (EXACTKEYWORD, "Human") OR LIMIT-TO(EXACTKEYWORD, "Humans"))555Dentistry & Oral Science Source (Ebsco)(DE "ORTHODONTICS" OR DE "MALOCCLUSION" OR DE "ORTHODONTIC appliances" OR TI orthodont* OR AB orthodont* OR TI "open bite" OR AB "open bite") AND (DE "MOLARS" OR TI molar* OR AB molar* OR TI "posterior teeth" OR AB "posterior teeth") AND (TI intrus* OR AB intrus* OR TI intrud* OR AB intrud*)399Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (Wiley)(orthodont* OR "open bite") AND (molar* OR "posterior teeth") AND (intrus* OR intrud*)71Cumulative Index to Nursing & Allied Health Literature (CINAHL) Plus with Full Text (Ebsco)(MH "Orthodontics" OR TX orthodont* OR TX "open bite") AND (MH "Molar + " OR TX molar* OR TX "posterior teeth") AND (TX intrus* OR TX intrud*)221Web of Science (Medline, BIOSIS Previews, and the Zoological Record only) (Clarivate)(orthodont* OR "open bite") AND (molar* OR "posterior teeth") AND (intrus* OR intrud*)759Global Index Medicus (World Health Organization)(orthodont* OR "open bite") AND (molar* OR "posterior teeth") AND (intrus* OR intrud*)650Dissertations & Theses Global (ProQuest)ab((orthodont* OR "open bite") AND (molar* OR "posterior teeth") AND (intrus* OR intrud*)) OR ti((orthodont* OR "open bite") AND (molar* OR "posterior teeth") AND (intrus* OR intrud*)) OR su((orthodont* OR "open bite") AND (molar* OR "posterior teeth") AND (intrus* OR intrud*)) OR diskw((orthodont* OR "open bite") AND (molar* OR "posterior teeth") AND (intrus* OR intrud*))42Trip Database (tripdatabase.com)(orthodont* OR "open bite") AND (molar* OR "posterior teeth") AND (intrus* OR intrud*)167ClinicalTrials.govCondition or disease: "open bite" OR "molar intrusion"18 Appendix 2: excluded studies with reasons for exclusion Title of studyReason for exclusionAl-Falahi, B., A.M. Hafez, and M. Fouda, Intrusion of Maxillary Posterior Teeth to Correct a Severe Anterior Open Bite. Journal of Clinical Orthodontics, 2017. 51(6): p. 326–334Prospective non-randomizedMarzouk, E.S., E.M. Abdallah, and W. El-Kenany, Molar Intrusion in Open-bite Adults Using Zygomatic Miniplates. International Journal of Orthodontics, 2015. 26(2)Prospective non-randomizedBarbre, R.E. and P.M. Sinclair, A cephalometric evaluation of anterior openbite correction with the magnetic active vertical corrector. The Angle Orthodontist, 1991. 61(2): p. 93–102Prospective non-randomizedDing WH, Li W, Chen F, Zhang JF, Lv Y, Chen XY, Lin WW, Fu Z, Shi JJ. Comparison of molar intrusion efficiency and bone density by CT in patients with different vertical facial morphology. Journal of oral rehabilitation. 2015 May;42(5):355–362RetrospectiveÇinsar, A., A.R. Alagha, and S. Akyalçın, Skeletal open bite correction with rapid molar intruder appliance in growing individuals. The Angle Orthodontist, 2007. 77(4): p. 632–639RetrospectivePolat-Özsoy, Ö., et al., Comparison of the intrusive effects of miniscrews and utility arches. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2011. 139(4): p. 526–532Anterior intrusionErbay, Elif, Türköz Ugur, and Mustafa Ülgen. The effects of Frankel's function regulator (FR-4) therapy on the treatment of Angle Class I skeletal anterior open bite malocclusion. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics 108.1 (1995): 9–21Irrelevant interventionKiliaridis, Stavros, Inger Egermark, and Birgit Thilander. Anterior open bite treatment with magnets. The European Journal of Orthodontics 12.4 (1990): 447–457Irrelevant outcomesRossato PH, Fernandes TM, Urnau FD, de Castro AC, Conti F, de Almeida RR, Oltramari-Navarro PV. Dentoalveolar effects produced by different appliances on early treatment of anterior open bite: a randomized clinical trial. The Angle Orthodontist. 2018 Nov;88(6):684–691Irrelevant comparisonsSlaviero T, Fernandes TM, Oltramari-Navarro PV, de Castro AC, Conti F, Poleti ML, de Almeida MR. Dimensional changes of dental arches produced by fixed and removable palatal cribs: A prospective, randomized, controlled study. The Angle Orthodontist. 2017 Mar;87(2):215–222Irrelevant interventionsThe effect of molar intrusion in fixed appliance with temporary anchorage devices vs Clear aligner – unpublished clinical trialClinical trial abstractMolar intrusion in open bite treatmentClinical trial abstractEvaluation of posterior segment intrusion using miniplates in skeletal Class II hyperdivergent adolescence: A randomized control trialClinical trial abstractSkeletal and dentoalveolar changes following posterior teeth intrusion with high pull headgear in the treatment of patients with anterior open biteClinical trial abstract Author contributions SAA: conceptualization, methodology, investigation, formal analysis, writing—original draft, writing—review & editing. DA: investigation, formal analysis, writing—review & editing. MI: formal analysis, writing-review and editing. PF: investigation, formal analysis. HA: investigation, formal analysis. FU: conceptualization, methodology, formal analysis, writing—review & editing. Funding This study received no external funding. Availability of data and materials The data underlying this article are available in the article and in its online material. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate Not applicable. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The data underlying this article are available in the article and in its online material.