Understanding smart home automation acceptance through users’ lifestyles and perceived difficulty of use: Evidence from South Korea Young-Gwan Kim, Do-Hyeon Ryu, Kwang-Jae Kim ABSTRACT Smart home automation (SHA) is an advanced service that automates household tasks with minimal human intervention, enhancing efficiency, convenience, and personalization. SHA serves as the critical bridge that transforms home environments into intelligent spaces that respond adaptively to user needs. Despite these benefits, SHA penetration remains limited due to various challenges, making it essential to understand SHA acceptance. This study examines two user-centered constructs influencing SHA acceptance: users’ lifestyles (UL) and perceived difficulty of use (PDU). Through a systematic process, the dimensions of both constructs were defined and measurement items were developed. A research model extending the Technology Acceptance Model was proposed, in which UL and PDU influence the perceived usefulness (PU) and intention to use (IU) of SHA. The model was tested using data collected from 167 non-users of SHA in South Korea. Results reveal that UL characterized by energy-saving negatively affects IU, whereas UL characterized by lack of time for household tasks positively affects IU. Additionally, PDU from automation configuration negatively affects both PU and IU. Based on these findings, practical strategies to enhance SHA acceptance are proposed. This study contributes by extending the acceptance framework for SHA through conceptualizing UL and PDU and by revealing how these user-centered constructs shape PU and IU, thereby clarifying their role in SHA acceptance and informing managerial strategies that promote broader penetration. Introduction The advancement of information and communication technologies (ICT) has introduced smart home automation (SHA) as a transformative service within smart homes, which are residential spaces where interconnected household devices, including lighting, security systems, and entertainment units, communicate and exchange data in real-time. SHA is a digital service that enables automated control of household appliances, minimizing manual operation by responding to predefined rules or real-time data [ 1 ]. For example, SHA can activate security systems, adjust thermostats, and turn off lights when users leave home. SHA improves household efficiency by automating device control based on user preferences, schedules, and environmental conditions, thereby reducing energy consumption and increasing convenience [ 2 , 3 ]. Despite these advantages, SHA penetration remains limited [ 4 ]. A recent survey revealed that 45% of homeowners rely on separate device apps, and 18% use direct controls to manage devices rather than utilizing SHA [ 5 ]. This limited penetration is closely related to user perceptions that SHA is unreliable or complex [ 6 ], highlighting that users are unsure whether SHA is truly necessary in their lives and tend to view its use as burdensome. These perceptions are captured by two user-centered concepts: users’ lifestyles (UL) and perceived difficulty of use (PDU). UL describes how individuals structure their daily activities and household routines in residential settings. Because SHA is designed to automate routine tasks that follow these daily patterns, a higher degree of fit between SHA functions and UL is likely to increase the necessity of SHA [ 7 , 8 ]. PDU captures users’ expectations about the effort required for SHA, including installation, rule design, troubleshooting, and ongoing adjustment. Because SHA requires users to make various active decisions and adjustments rather than receiving a predefined service, these tasks are easily anticipated as burdens. Such expected difficulties can form substantial anticipated barriers to acceptance, even when its advantages are already recognized [ 9 ]. Previous research has identified several factors that are relevant for explaining SHA acceptance, including privacy concerns, cost, and perceived technological complexity, but these factors have been examined mainly at the level of overall smart home technologies and environments rather than for SHA as a distinct service [ 10 – 12 ]. Because SHA is a user-driven service for managing daily routines, UL and PDU are particularly important for understanding whether and how users accept SHA. Nevertheless, UL and PDU remain underexplored in existing literature. Previous studies provide only indirect inferences about which lifestyles might benefit from SHA, and empirical validation of how UL influences SHA acceptance is limited. Similarly, the field lacks a systematic investigation of PDU and how PDU influences SHA acceptance. This study investigates the impact of UL and PDU on SHA acceptance using data from non-users of SHA in South Korea. The research model conceptualizes acceptance through perceived usefulness (PU) and intention to use (IU), and examines how UL drives user acceptance of SHA and how PDU shapes acceptance among non-users. Beyond contributing empirical evidence on these relationships, the study aims to generate practical insights for SHA providers to develop effective strategies for increasing acceptance. The study proceeds as follows: The Literature review section reviews existing literature on SHA and establishes theoretical foundations for UL and PDU. The Research model development section outlines the research model development process for examining SHA acceptance. The Empirical analysis section presents empirical analysis results and discusses practical implications. The Concluding remarks section concludes with theoretical contributions and future research directions. Literature review Smart home automation and its acceptance Smart home automation (SHA) refers to a service within the smart home that enables the automatic control and coordination of various household devices based on predefined user preferences, schedules, or environmental conditions. SHA operates through smart home assistants such as Amazon Alexa, Google Home, and Apple HomeKit, which allow users to configure automation rules that synchronize device operations according to predefined conditions or triggers. For example, a ‘Good Morning’ rule can activate at a preset time in the morning, automatically adjusting room temperature, brightening lights, and starting coffee brewing. SHA enhances daily life by reducing unnecessary energy consumption through automated control, improving convenience by minimizing manual device operation, and providing a personalized experience by adjusting settings to match user preferences. From a broader perspective, SHA functions as a foundational mechanism that underpins a wide range of smart home services, enabling capabilities such as energy management and safety monitoring while also promoting cross-device integration and fostering technological advancements across related industries [ 13 – 15 ]. Despite its potential advantages, SHA penetration remains limited. Understanding the factors that shape its acceptance is therefore an important research question. However, prior research has examined acceptance primarily at the level of overall smart home technologies and environments rather than for SHA as a distinct service. This leaves insufficient explanation of how SHA’s features connect to user-centered factors in shaping its acceptance. Within multiple theoretical frameworks such as the Technology Acceptance Model, UTAUT2, Value-based Adoption, and Innovation Diffusion Theory [ 12 , 16 ], critical determinants identified across studies include compatibility and perceived usefulness (PU) [ 4 ], perceived ease of use [ 17 ], and reliability of automation [ 18 ]. Primary motivations for acceptance include energy management, healthcare monitoring, and home security [ 19 , 20 ], while barriers comprise privacy, security risks, implementation costs, and operational complexity [ 10 , 11 ]. Trust [ 21 , 22 ], technology affinity [ 23 ], psychological factors [ 24 ], and demographic differences [ 17 , 25 ] have also been examined. However, two factors central to SHA acceptance remain insufficiently addressed: users’ lifestyles (UL), which can drive acceptance in distinct ways, and perceived difficulty of use (PDU), which can pose distinct barriers to acceptance at different stages of SHA use. Smart home automation acceptance: users’ lifestyles and perceived difficulty of use This section examines UL and PDU as key factors influencing SHA acceptance. Users’ lifestyles. UL plays an important role in SHA because automation operates within users’ daily routines. The usefulness of SHA depends on how individuals organize their everyday activities, needs, and priorities. UL therefore shapes when automation becomes necessary, which tasks users expect automation to support, and how appropriate SHA appears in their daily living patterns. For instance, users who closely monitor household energy consumption may perceive greater value in SHA due to its ability to support energy-related control and scheduling [ 26 ]. However, even UL that appears favorable to SHA does not always lead to strong acceptance. This highlights the need not only to identify which UL is favorable, but also to understand whether such UL actually drives acceptance. Prior research in technology acceptance has recognized UL as an important determinant of user behavior [ 27 , 28 ], and smart home studies similarly show that alignment between SHA features and UL enhances perceived value and supports acceptance [ 29 – 31 ]. Users tend to view SHA favorably when its functions fit or enhance their lifestyle [ 32 , 33 ]. More broadly, several studies have identified lifestyle compatibility as a key property and source of value in the smart home contexts [ 23 , 34 ]. Building on this literature, this study identifies three dimensions of UL particularly relevant to SHA acceptance in everyday home contexts: structured routines, energy-saving, and lack of time for household tasks. Energy-saving lifestyles, characterized by efforts to conserve energy and concerns about excessive energy usage, drive SHA acceptance. Users who prioritize energy efficiency tend to show stronger interest in home automation technologies [ 8 , 35 , 36 ]. Energy-conscious users may find SHA valuable for real-time energy monitoring, automated power control for idle devices, and context-aware recommendations aligned with their conservation habits. Structured routines, such as regular sleeping and waking, consistent home entry and exit times, and consistent daily tasks, create favorable conditions for SHA acceptance. Research demonstrates that automated home systems work most effectively when aligned with these structured household behavioral patterns [ 37 – 39 ]. When users follow predictable schedules, SHA can provide timely support. For example, it may adjust lighting based on sleep and wake cycles or activate security systems based on regular departure and arrival times. Lack of time for household tasks serves as a practical driver for SHA acceptance, particularly among individuals with frequent external activities, excessive schedules, or inadequate allocation of time for household tasks. For these users, SHA provides meaningful value by enabling remote and autonomous control of appliances. It supports efficient task management at early-morning or late-evening hours, when users have limited daytime availability, and automates device operations when users are occupied elsewhere [ 40 , 41 ]. Perceived difficulty of use. PDU is a key barrier to SHA acceptance because SHA operates as a user-driven service. Instead of passively receiving a predefined service, users must be involved throughout an extended process that includes selecting products, designing and revising automation rules, configuring systems, troubleshooting errors, and performing ongoing maintenance. Each stage can impose cognitive and technical burdens [ 42 ], meaning that users evaluate not only the benefits of SHA but also the effort required to obtain them [ 10 ]. PDU refers to the degree to which users believe that accepting a system requires considerable effort and involves complex processes [ 43 ]. Technology-acceptance research consistently identifies PDU as a major barrier, encompassing technical complexity, configuration difficulty, and the cognitive effort needed for system management [ 44 ]. Empirical studies show that higher PDU tends to reduce both PU and intention to use (IU) of smart home services [ 10 , 45 ]. For instance, configuration complexity and inadequate user support often lead to user withdrawal during early acceptance stages [ 46 ], while maintenance-related frustrations such as system malfunctions and poor interoperability hinder sustained acceptance [ 47 , 48 ]. These findings indicate that PDU significantly affects SHA acceptance. Building on this literature, this study identifies three dimensions of PDU, organized by the stages at which barriers typically emerge during SHA use. The first dimension, Product and Infrastructure Setup, involves device selection and hardware preparation, which is often complicated by interoperability issues and insufficient infrastructure guidance [ 46 , 49 ]. The second dimension, Automation Configuration, concerns the design and implementation of automation rules based on user needs; this stage is frequently challenging due to the abstract nature of trigger-action logic and limited support for error handling [ 50 ]. The third dimension, Management and Maintenance, relates to ongoing system operation, which imposes a continuous burden from software errors, device instability, and inadequate customer support [ 47 ]. Research gap The Users’ lifestyles and Perceived difficulty of use sections reviewed prior work on UL and PDU as factors relevant to SHA acceptance. While these studies provide valuable conceptual grounding, important gaps remain in how UL and PDU have been examined in the SHA context. SHA differs from conventional smart home devices in that it requires active user involvement throughout the entire use process, from initial setup to ongoing management, and prior research has not adequately accommodated these distinct characteristics when investigating the role of UL and PDU. Table 1 summarizes prior empirical work on smart home and SHA acceptance, showing that UL and PDU have not been jointly examined in a structured, comparative manner. 10.1371/journal.pone.0352183.t001 Table 1 Summary of prior studies on smart home and SHA acceptance and their coverage of UL and PDU. Study Sample Scope Methods Examined variables UL / PDU coverage Hubert et al. [ 4 ] n = 409, Germany Smart home Structural equation modeling integrating Technology Acceptance Model, Innovation Diffusion Theory, and Perceived Risk Theory Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, compatibility, trialability, result demonstrability, visibility, perceived security/performance/time risks UL: None (Compatibility addresses value consistency, not lifestyle.) PDU: Partial (Reduced to perceived ease of use, with perceived risks treated separately; the multidimensional procedural challenges of SHA are not captured.) Shin et al. [ 17 ] n = 310 (survey 1) and n = 2,113 (survey 2), South Korea Smart home Structural equation modeling with extended Technology Acceptance Model, complemented by multivariate probit analysis Compatibility, perceived ease of use, perceived usefulness, privacy concerns; demographic and household ICT possession factors UL: None (Compatibility addresses value consistency, not lifestyle.) PDU: Partial (Reduced to perceived ease of use, with privacy concerns treated separately; the multidimensional procedural challenges of SHA are not captured.) Schomakers et al. [ 18 ] n = 137, Germany SHA Adaptive choice-based conjoint analysis with six smart home product attributes Application area, data type, data storage location, automation reliability, awareness source, automation level UL: None (Lifestyle not addressed.) PDU: None (Automation reliability is a trust attribute, not user-perceived difficulty.) Valencia-Arias et al. [ 12 ] 12 studies Smart home Systematic literature review Perceived reliability, perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, perceived behavioral control, perceived enjoyment UL: None (Lifestyle not addressed.) PDU: Partial (Reduced to perceived ease of use; the multidimensional procedural challenges of SHA are not captured.) Chang & Nam [ 25 ] n = 400, South Korea Smart home Hierarchical regression analysis Service preferences across convenience, safety, energy, and healthcare domains; demographic and residential factors UL: None (Lifestyle not addressed.) PDU: None (Service preferences address consumer choice, not user-perceived difficulty.) Nascimento et al. [ 16 ] 24 studies Smart home Meta-analysis based on UTAUT2 Performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, facilitating conditions, hedonic motivation, price value, attitude, perceived risk; gender and publication year as moderators UL: None (Lifestyle not addressed.) PDU: Partial (Reduced to effort expectancy; the multidimensional procedural challenges of SHA are not captured.) Wang et al. [ 45 ] n = 387, China Smart home Structural equation modeling integrating Technology Acceptance Model and Innovation Diffusion Theory Compatibility, trialability, observability, perceived ease of use, perceived usefulness, intergenerational technical support, perceived cost, self-reported health UL: None (Compatibility and self-reported health address other constructs, not lifestyle.) PDU: Partial (Reduced to perceived ease of use, with perceived cost treated separately; the multidimensional procedural challenges of SHA are not captured.) Ferreira et al. [ 26 ] n = 255, multinational Smart home Structural equation modeling based on UTAUT2 Performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, facilitating conditions, hedonic motivation, price value, habit, environmental awareness UL: Partial (Environmental awareness and habit added as UTAUT2 extensions, not a structured set of UL dimensions for SHA.) PDU: Partial (Reduced to effort expectancy; the multidimensional procedural challenges of SHA are not captured.) As Table 1 indicates, the literature has predominantly examined acceptance of smart home technologies in general. Across these studies, UL has either been omitted entirely or captured only through narrow proxies such as habit or environmental awareness, rather than as a structured representation of lifestyle patterns relevant to SHA. PDU has most often been reduced to perceived ease of use, with related issues such as perceived risks and perceived cost examined as separate variables rather than integrated as components of a multidimensional construct reflecting the procedural challenges of SHA. Two gaps stand out. First, regarding UL, existing studies have generally discussed lifestyle in broad terms without organizing it into distinct patterns relevant to SHA, and empirical investigation into how individual UL dimensions relate to PU and IU has been largely absent. This gap makes it difficult to identify which types of users are more likely to accept SHA, an understanding essential for promoting acceptance across different user groups. Second, regarding PDU, prior research has frequently conceptualized difficulty through the broad notion of perceived ease of use, treating it as a single, undifferentiated construct. This approach fails to reflect the procedural challenges involved in SHA, which emerge across multiple stages from initial setup through ongoing management, and obscures the challenges that arise at different stages of SHA use. A structured understanding of PDU is necessary to identify concrete intervention points and to facilitate broader SHA acceptance. To address these gaps, the present study examines UL as a set of conditions that may favor SHA acceptance and empirically investigates their associations with PU and IU. In parallel, it defines PDU as a multidimensional construct that captures not only technical obstacles but also the cognitive burdens that users associate with implementing and operating SHA, and empirically examines the separate effects of the three PDU dimensions on PU and IU. By jointly modeling UL and PDU, the study provides an empirical account of how these two factors shape SHA acceptance in a structured, comparative manner that prior research has acknowledged in conceptual terms but has not yet examined empirically. Research model development As illustrated in Fig 1 , the overall research workflow consists of two major phases corresponding to the Research model development and Empirical analysis sections of this study: research model development and empirical analysis. The Research model development section presents the research model development process, while the Empirical analysis section presents the empirical analysis of the proposed model through confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and path analysis. CFA is conducted to assess convergent and discriminant validity, while path analysis is performed to examine the hypothesized relationships among users’ lifestyles (UL), perceived difficulty of use (PDU), perceived usefulness (PU), and intention to use (IU). 10.1371/journal.pone.0352183.g001 Fig 1 Overall research workflow. The research model development follows two steps to examine the influence of UL and PDU on SHA acceptance. First, the dimensions and measurement items of UL and PDU are developed. Second, a research model is established by positioning UL and PDU as central constructs and formulating hypotheses about their effects on SHA acceptance. This model serves as an analytical framework for testing relationships among these constructs. Constructs for users’ lifestyles The development of UL constructs followed a three-step process: literature-based dimension identification (the Users’ lifestyles section), item operationalization grounded in prior research, and expert content validation. The three dimensions identified in the Users’ lifestyles section are energy-saving (ES), structured routines (SR), and lack of time for household tasks (LT). ES contains two items: efforts to conserve energy (ES1) and concerns about excessive energy usage (ES2). Energy-saving lifestyle manifests in active behaviors such as powering off devices when not in use, using lower-energy settings, replacing appliances with more efficient alternatives, and shifting use to off-peak periods, which together describe the practical actions through which households reduce consumption [ 51 ]. Beyond these actions, households also differ in how concerned they are about using too much energy, whether environmentally or financially, and this concern represents a separate facet of energy-saving lifestyle distinct from active behavior [ 52 ]. Together, the two items capture the behavioral and attitudinal facets through which energy-saving lifestyle is expressed in daily life. SR contains three items: regular sleeping/waking (SR1), regular entry/exit (SR2), and consistent daily tasks (SR3). The regularity of sleeping and waking schedules establishes predictable morning and evening transitions, which form the most stable rhythm in daily routines [ 53 , 54 ]. The regularity of home entry and exit captures the predictability of when household members are present or absent, providing direct signals for security activation, climate adjustment, and arrival-based automation rules. Consistent daily tasks such as meals, cleaning, and exercise form recurring activity patterns that reflect the stability of daily life. Together, these items capture the temporal regularity through which households’ daily lives become aligned, or misaligned, with the predictability that SHA requires to deliver value. LT contains three items: frequent external activities (LT1), excessive schedules (LT2), and inadequate allocation of household task time (LT3). Frequent external activities such as work, social commitments, and errands reduce the time households can spend at home managing routine tasks, which raises the value of remote and autonomous appliance control. Excessive schedules reflect chronic time pressure, an ongoing experience of time shortage and feeling rushed that pervades modern household life [ 55 ]. Inadequate allocation of household task time captures the residual problem when work and external commitments crowd out the time available for domestic work, in which case households become more receptive to SHA as a practical solution. To assess content validity, the operationalized items were reviewed by two experts with research and practice backgrounds in smart home services and user experience. Their review focused on whether each item adequately represented the underlying lifestyle pattern in a smart home context, item wording, and conceptual overlap. Items were revised in wording before the final scales were deployed. The resulting operational definitions and items are presented in Table 2 . 10.1371/journal.pone.0352183.t002 Table 2 Identified dimensions and items for ULs and PDUs. Type Dimension (Code) Description Item (Code) Users’ lifestyles (UL) Energy-saving (ES) The lifestyle that prioritizes energy conservation and reflects a conscious effort to reduce energy consumption Efforts to conserve energy (ES1) Concerns about excessive energy usage (ES2) Structured routines (SR) The lifestyle that follows consistent and predictable daily patterns, emphasizing regularity in activities Regular sleeping/waking (SR1) Regular entry/exit (SR2) Consistent daily tasks (SR3) Lack of time for household tasks (LT) The lifestyle that reflects limited availability for managing household Frequent external activities (LT1) Excessive schedules (LT2) Inadequate allocation of household task time (LT3) Perceived difficulty of use (PDU) Product and Infrastructure Setup (PS) Difficulties in setting up and understanding infrastructure Selecting products and services (PS1) Insufficient infrastructure information (PS2) Lack of additional resources (PS3) Building infrastructure (PS4) Automation Configuration (AC) Difficulties in designing and configuring automation routines Designing automation (AC1) Configuring automation (AC2) Management and Maintenance (MM) Difficulties in managing and maintaining smart home automation Emotional barrier (MM1) Problem-solving (MM2) Continuous management (MM3) Constructs for perceived difficulty of use The development of PDU constructs followed a four-step process: literature-based dimension identification (the Perceived difficulty of use section), a supplementary qualitative survey of heavy SHA users to examine the dimensions and gather background for item development, item operationalization grounded in prior research, and expert content validation. The supplementary qualitative survey was conducted for PDU but not for UL because the two constructs differ in how their dimensions are grounded. UL dimensions describe general lifestyle characteristics that are well-established in broader research on household behavior, energy use, and time use, and they exist in households regardless of SHA experience. Expert content validation alone can ensure the items capture these characteristics. PDU dimensions, by contrast, describe difficulties that arise only during actual SHA use, and examining whether the literature-derived PDU dimensions correspond to the difficulties Korean SHA users actually encounter required input from respondents with direct SHA usage experience. This step concerns the dimensional structure rather than measurement of perceived difficulty of use itself. The three dimensions identified in the Perceived difficulty of use section are Product and Infrastructure Setup (PS), Automation Configuration (AC), and Management and Maintenance (MM). A supplementary qualitative survey was conducted in March 2024 with 13 heavy SHA users recruited from an online smart home community, with informed consent obtained through the same procedure as the main survey described in the Empirical analysis section. This survey served two purposes: to qualitatively examine whether the three dimensions identified in the literature review corresponded to the difficulties SHA users encounter in South Korea, and to provide concrete background that informed the wording and scope of the items developed in the next step. Participants’ responses covered all three dimensions identified in the literature review and provided concrete examples that informed the item operationalization presented in the following paragraphs. The three dimensions were established a priori from the literature review (the Smart home automation acceptance: users’ lifestyles and perceived difficulty of use section); the qualitative survey was therefore not used as a source for the construct structure of PDU but only to confirm its applicability to South Korea and to inform the development of survey items. Heavy users were appropriate for this role because qualitatively examining whether the three dimensions arise across all stages of SHA use, and gathering examples of how they manifest in practice, requires respondents with direct experience of every phase from product selection to long-term maintenance. While these heavy users may possess higher technical self-efficacy than the general non-user population, the difficulties captured by the PDU dimensions are not unique to enthusiasts and arise across users of varying experience levels. Within each dimension, the form of difficulty ranges from lower-level obstacles for less familiar users to more technical challenges for experienced users. Because SHA operates as a user-driven service requiring active user involvement throughout the entire use process, prior research has documented that product selection complexity, automation configuration burden, and ongoing maintenance demands are encountered by general and technically inexperienced households as well, with differences across user types lying in the severity and resolution speed of these difficulties rather than in their occurrence [ 8 , 42 , 46 , 56 ]. PS contains four items: selecting products and services (PS1), insufficient infrastructure information (PS2), lack of additional resources (PS3), and building infrastructure (PS4). The smart home market offers a wide variety of products with limited cross-compatibility and standardization, and households face difficulty in choosing suitable products without guidance on interoperability and reliability [ 57 ]. Households also lack the technical knowledge to assess infrastructure requirements such as network protocols (Wi-Fi, Zigbee, Z-Wave) and power needs, leading to incomplete or failed setups. Households rely on a mix of supplementary resources such as manuals, technical guides, and customer support during setup, but the resulting learning curve still makes setup a slow and effortful process that requires sustained time and trial-and-error effort [ 58 ]. Finally, configuring hubs, sensors, and wiring during physical installation requires technical proficiency that many households do not possess, often necessitating professional assistance. AC contains two items: designing automation (AC1) and configuring automation (AC2). Designing effective automation rules requires households to translate their needs into structured trigger-action logic, and many households struggle with the abstract nature of rule semantics, anticipating exceptional cases and predicting how multiple automations interact [ 59 ]. Configuring automation involves additional technical complexity such as navigating system settings, integrating devices across platforms, and debugging unexpected behavior [ 57 ]. A substantial proportion of user support requests in active SHA use concerns automation configuration, indicating that this stage remains technically and cognitively demanding even for experienced users. MM contains three items: emotional barrier (MM1), problem-solving (MM2), and continuous management (MM3). Households experience emotional burdens such as frustration, regret, and anger when SHA performance falls short of expectations or when malfunctions arise, and these negative emotional responses undermine sustained use of the technology [ 60 ]. Diagnosing and resolving system failures is technically demanding, and household members who did not initiate the technology must nonetheless take on troubleshooting tasks such as diagnosing, performing fixes, or delegating to external support, as part of unacknowledged digital housekeeping work [ 61 ]. Beyond reactive problem-solving, the continuous effort required to maintain SHA, such as software updates, hardware replacements, and adjustments to accommodate lifestyle changes, imposes an ongoing burden on households with limited time or technical skills. To assess content validity, the items were reviewed by the same two experts who validated the UL items. Their review focused on whether each item adequately represented the underlying procedural difficulty in a smart home context, item wording, and conceptual overlap. Items were revised in wording before the final scales were deployed. The resulting operational definitions and items are presented in Table 2 . Research model This study develops a research model ( Fig 2 ) to examine the impact of the proposed UL and PDU constructs on SHA acceptance. The model is based on the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) [ 62 ], incorporating hypotheses regarding the effects of UL and PDU on the PU of SHA and the IU toward SHA. The original TAM specifies PU and perceived ease of use (PEOU) as core determinants of acceptance but does not specify which external variables drive these perceptions. Earlier extensions of acceptance models in smart home research, as reviewed in the Smart home automation and its acceptance section and Table 1 , have not addressed how UL drives SHA acceptance or how PDU of SHA extends beyond general ease of use. 10.1371/journal.pone.0352183.g002 Fig 2 Proposed research model. The present study extends TAM in two ways. First, it introduces UL and PDU as new external variables tailored to SHA: UL captures how users’ everyday routines and priorities shape acceptance and drives both PU and IU, while PDU captures procedural difficulties from product selection through ongoing management and complements PEOU by representing difficulty as multidimensional rather than as a single ease of use measure. Second, each dimension of UL and PDU is modeled as a separate external variable, enabling the effect of each dimension on PU and IU to be tested individually rather than as part of a combined construct. This structured, multidimensional treatment of UL and PDU constitutes the model’s central theoretical advancement. PU is defined as the degree to which an individual believes that using SHA will enhance energy efficiency, provide convenience, and offer a personalized experience. IU represents the likelihood that an individual will intend to use SHA. As the dependent variable in this study, IU captures the planned or intended future use of SHA rather than actual use. Since actual use requires longitudinal observations, IU is widely employed as a key predictor in new technology acceptance research [ 63 , 64 ]. IU is assessed using items related to consideration of use, willingness to use, and intention to recommend SHA [ 25 ]. Because the present study targets non-users of SHA, actual use behavior cannot be observed by design, and post-acceptance phenomena such as continued usage, abandonment, and maintenance burden lie beyond its scope. This focus is appropriate given the current state of SHA, where adoption remains limited [ 65 ] and understanding what shapes non-users’ acceptance is essential to advancing it. While actual use research offers important insights into such phenomena, several of these concerns can also be examined at the pre-acceptance stage; the present study addresses them by examining how users’ perceived procedural difficulties across stages from product selection to ongoing system management shape their intention to use SHA. PU is positioned as a mediating construct that links UL and PDU to IU. However, UL and PDU may also have direct effects on IU, as they can independently influence users’ willingness to use SHA. By incorporating both direct and mediated pathways, the model provides a more comprehensive understanding of the relationships among UL, PDU, PU, and IU. The research model adopts a first-order factor structure in which each UL dimension (ES, SR, LT) and each PDU dimension (PS, AC, MM) is modeled as an independent external variable of TAM. This structure is appropriate for the present study for two reasons. First, the central research question concerns which dimensions of UL and PDU shape PU and IU, and with what direction and magnitude. A first-order structure directly estimates the separate path from each dimension to the outcomes, whereas a second-order structure would collapse the dimensions into a single composite path and obscure the effects of each dimension that the present study is designed to identify. Second, the dimensions of UL and PDU each carry a distinct influence on PU and IU, requiring separate examination to identify the contribution of each dimension. For UL, structured routines, energy-saving, and lack of time for household tasks reflect different aspects of daily life that shape SHA acceptance to different degrees and through different channels. For PDU, product and infrastructure setup, automation configuration, and management and maintenance involve cognitively different difficulties at different stages of SHA, and the strength of their negative effect on acceptance is likely to differ across stages. Aggregating the dimensions into a higher-order composite would conflate these dimension-specific influences and obscure which dimension carries the strongest effect, whereas a first-order structure preserves them, consistent with prior research that examines sub-dimensions through individual paths to outcomes when they exert qualitatively different effects [ 66 , 67 ]. The following hypotheses are proposed to examine the relationships among UL, PDU, PU, and IU in the context of SHA acceptance: