Symbiotic Legume Nodules Employ Both Rhizobial Exo - and Endo -Hydrogenases to Recycle Hydrogen Produced by Nitrogen Fixation Authors: Christopher O. Ciccolella, Nathan A. Raynard, John H-M. Mei, Derek C. Church, Robert A. Ludwig Published: 2010, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0012094 ABSTRACT In symbiotic legume nodules, endosymbiotic rhizobia (bacteroids) fix atmospheric N 2 , an ATP-dependent catalytic process yielding stoichiometric ammonium and hydrogen gas (H 2 ). While in most legume nodules this H 2 is quantitatively evolved, which loss drains metabolic energy, certain bacteroid strains employ uptake hydrogenase activity and thus evolve little or no H 2 . Rather, endogenous H 2 is efficiently respired at the expense of O 2 , driving oxidative phosphorylation, recouping ATP used for H 2 production, and increasing the efficiency of symbiotic nodule N 2 fixation. In many ensuing investigations since its discovery as a physiological process, bacteroid uptake hydrogenase activity has been presumed a single entity. Azorhizobium caulinodans , the nodule endosymbiont of Sesbania rostrata stems and roots, possesses both orthodox respiratory ( exo -)hydrogenase and novel ( endo- )hydrogenase activities. These two respiratory hydrogenases are structurally quite distinct and encoded by disparate, unlinked gene-sets. As shown here, in S. rostrata symbiotic nodules, haploid A. caulinodans bacteroids carrying single knockout alleles in either exo - or- endo -hydrogenase structural genes, like the wild-type parent, evolve no detectable H 2 and thus are fully competent for endogenous H 2 recycling. Whereas, nodules formed with A. caulinodans exo -, endo -hydrogenase double-mutants evolve endogenous H 2 quantitatively and thus suffer complete loss of H 2 recycling capability. More generally, from bioinformatic analyses, diazotrophic microaerophiles, including rhizobia, which respire H 2 may carry both exo - and endo -hydrogenase gene-sets. In symbiotic S. rostrata nodules, A. caulinodans bacteroids can use either respiratory hydrogenase to recycle endogenous H 2 produced by N 2 fixation. Thus, H 2 recycling by symbiotic legume nodules may involve multiple respiratory hydrogenases. INTRODUCTION Legume root and stem nodules fix atmospheric dinitrogen (N 2 ) yielding anabolic-N, which augments growth and reproduction of host plants. In these nodules, the biochemical conversion of N 2 to ammonium is owed to endosymbiotic rhizobia (bacteroids) who carry the N 2 fixation genes encoding the dinitrogenase complex. Whether N 2 fixation occurs in legume nodules [ 1 ] or in pure cultures of diazotrophic (able to use N 2 as sole N-source) bacteria [ 2 ] , hydrogen gas (H 2 ) is then co-produced. From subsequent mechanistic studies of dinitrogenase activity, H 2 co-production is both stoichiometric and requires 2 ATP per H 2 formed [ 3 ] – [4] . Yet in agronomic surveys, many legume nodules typically evolve H 2 at high levels, and such H 2 evolution rates correlate with N 2 fixation rates [ 5 ] . However, in certain symbiotic legume nodules, bacteroids avidly fix N 2 yet reproducibly evolve little or no H 2 [ 1 ] . As this endogenous H 2 production consumes metabolic energy, H 2 recycling, which recoups that energy, allows increased efficiency of N 2 fixation and, in principle, increased plant biomass yields [ 6 ] – [7] . This symbiotic nodule H 2 recycling capability correlates with specific bacteroid strains, although host legume cultivars also contribute to H 2 recycling and yield [ 8] , [ 9 ] . Indeed, in biochemical assays, bacteroids isolated from H 2 recycling (non-evolving) nodules show high levels of respiratory uptake hydrogenase activity [ 10] , [ 11 ] . H 2 recycling during N 2 fixation was first observed with the aerobe Azotobacter vinelandii , a diazotroph but not a legume symbiont. In pure culture, A. vinelandii induces a particulate (respiratory) hydrogenase activity which oxidizes H 2 at the expense of and tolerant of O 2 [ 2 ] . In following studies with legume nodule bacteroids, such uptake hydrogenase activity was also affirmed [ 10 ] . In the ensuing forty years, hydrogenases, extensively studied, have proven both biochemically diverse and broadly distributed across bacteria and archaea [ 12 ] . Among aerobes and microaerophiles able to use H 2 as energy source, uptake hydrogenase activities are typically classified as group I: heterodimeric, globular, hydrophilic proteins carrying a heteronuclear Ni,Fe-catalytic center; group I hydrogenases are generally O 2 tolerant [ 12 ] . In cellular terms, the group I, Ni,Fe uptake hydrogenases are tightly associated with respiratory membranes via integral diheme b- type cytochromes, required for physiological activity [ 13] , [ 14 ] [Bernhard]. As the group I cell membrane-peripheral complexes face the periplasm, or cell exterior [ 15 ] , they may be termed exo- hydrogenases. Azorhizobium caulinodans , a microaerophilic α- proteobacterium originally isolated as nodule endosymbiont of the host legume Sesbania rostrata , is capable of N 2 fixation both in planta and in pure diazotrophic culture [ 16 ] . Recently, we discovered in A. caulinodans a second, novel respiratory hydrogenase encoded by the seven-gene hyq operon [17] . The inferred Hyq hydrogenase includes six different structural proteins, including a heterodimeric Ni,Fe-catalytic center hydrogenase conserved with group I enzymes. From bioinformatic analyses, the remaining four Hyq proteins are all membrane-integral [17] . Because all six Hyq hydrogenase subunits are NADH:quinone oxidoreductase (respiratory complex I) homologs [ 18 ] , the Hyq complex is classified with the reversible group IV hydrogenases [ 12 ] . Given structural and functional homology to respiratory complex I [ 18 ] , the Ni,Fe-catalytic center heterodimers of group IV complexes associated with respiratory membranes presumably face the cell-interior and thus may be termed endo -hydrogenases. RESULTS To assess physiological roles for both bacteroid Hup exo - and Hyq endo- hydrogenases in symbiotic legume nodules fixing N 2 and recycling H 2 , A. caulinodans haploid derivatives carrying precise (to the nucleotide pair) in-frame deletions of hup and hyq structural genes encoding the conserved catalytic subunits of, respectively, exo - and endo -hydrogenases were constructed and verified by nucleotide sequencing of mutant loci [ 17 ] . Specifically, A. caulinodans exo -hydrogenase null mutants carried in-frame, precise, complete hupSL deletions; endo- hydrogenase null mutants comprised precise, complete hyqRBCEFGI operon deletions. As well, haploid recombinant double-mutants carrying both exo - and endo -hydrogenase null alleles were also constructed ( Methods ). Pure A. caulinodans cultures were used to inoculate both stems and roots of S. rostrata seedlings aseptically germinated and individually cultivated under N-limitation ( Methods ). In S. rostrata , symbiotic nodules are developmentally determinate, not meristematic. While both stem- and root-nodules subsequently developed on inoculated plants only, as they are invariably absent on uninoculated plants, stem nodules were chosen for further study. Three week-old and five week-old determinate stem nodules were excised from inoculated plants and individually tested for N 2 fixation activity, assaying acetylene-dependent ethylene production by gas chromatography with flame ionization detection ( Methods ). Excised stem nodules all showed similar (±15%) high levels of acetylene reduction activity when normalized per fresh nodule biomass ( Table 1 ). Accordingly, all A. caulinodans strains tested were assigned both nodulation-competent (Nod + ) and N 2 fixation-competent (Fix + ) phenotypes. µmol (C 2 H 2 -dependent)C 2 H 4 g −1 hr −1 µmol H 2 g −1 hr −1 Additional excised nodules from these S. rostrata plants were simultaneously tested under air for H 2 evolution activity using gas chromatography coupled to a reducing-compound photometric detector ( Methods ). In kinetic studies with excised nodules elicited by A. caulinodans strains 61305R (parental), 66081 ( exo -hydrogenase mutant) and 66132 ( endo -hydrogenase mutant), H 2 evolution was nonexistent ( Figs. 1a,b ). Whereas, nodules elicited by double ( exo - and endo -hydrogenase) mutant 66204 evolved H 2 at very high rates ( Fig. 1a ) comparable to those measured for acetylene reduction ( Table 1 ). Thus, H 2 evolution by double-mutant 66204-elicited nodules was quantitatively owed to N 2 fixation (dinitrogenase) activity. Results with five week-old determinate nodules from additional S. rostrata plants entirely corroborated results with three week-old nodules (data not presented). Pure bacterial cultures were reestablished from aseptically crushed nodules and strain identities verified by nucleotide sequencing of hup and hyq loci ( Methods ). In conclusion, A. caulinodans bacteroids in S. rostrata nodules employ both exo - and endo- hydrogenases to recycle endogenous H 2 produced by N 2 fixation. Moreover, H 2 recycling is quantitative, entirely accounting for N 2 fixation activities. Yet as measured by H 2 evolution rates, bacteroid exo - and endo -hydrogenase are interchangeable and individually are fully competent to handle endogenous H 2 recycling in symbiotic S. rostrata nodules. (A) 70 µmol scale; (B) expanded ordinate, 1 µmol scale; evolved H 2 measured as µmol g −1 (fresh biomass). TABLE: N 2 fixation and H 2 recycling in S. rostrata–A. caulinodans stem nodules. A. caulinodans endosymbiont Genotype Phenotype N 2 fixation † H 2 evolved ‡ 61305R 57100 nic5R (virtual) wild-type 31.0±0.4 0.30±0.05 66081 61305R ▵hupSL2 exo -hydrogenase negative 33.0±0.4 0.32±0.05 66132 61305R ▵hyqRI7 endo -hydrogenase negative 25.0±0.3 0.36±0.05 66204 61305R ▵hupSL2 ÄhyqRI7 exo - and endo -hydrogenase neg. 25.0±0.3 27.0±0.3 N 2 FIXING, MICROAEROPHILIC Α-PROTEOBACTERIA ABLE TO RECYCLE H 2 CARRY EXO - AND ENDO -HYDROGENASE GENE-SETS From bioinformatic analyses ( Table 2 ), orthologous hyq + operons encoding endo -hydrogenase are generally present in N 2 fixing microaerophiles able to recycle endogenous H 2 . These strains include both free-living diazotrophs as well as certain rhizobia, such as B. japonicum, the endosymbiont of Glycine max (soy). In Rhizobium leguminosarum , a metastable species with several descendant biovars each with genomes comprised of variable multipartite replicons, H 2 recycling capability in symbiotic legume nodules varies among strains. As well, both the hup + /hyp + ( exo -hydrogenase) and the hyq + ( endo -hydrogenase) gene-sets are also variables [ 9 ] , [ 19] , [ 20 ] . Yet other diverse rhizobia ( e.g. Sinorhizobium meliloti 1021; Mesorhizobium loti MAFF303099; Rhizobium etli CFN42; Rhizobium sp . NGR234) all incapable of H 2 recycling in symbiotic legume nodules, completely lack both hup + /hyp + and hyq + gene-sets ( Table 2 ). As the hyq + operon is also absent from anaerobic (fermentative) diazotrophs, fully aerobic diazotrophs ( e.g. Azotobacter spp .), and non-diazotrophs generally, Hyq endo -hydrogenase seems co-selected with N 2 fixation in microaerophilic (non-fermentative) α-proteobacteria. Nevertheless, in every N 2 fixing microaerophile with both exo - and endo -hydrogenases, these gene-sets, as well the nif genes encoding N 2 fixation activities are all unlinked ( Table 2 ). Moreover, A. caulinodans haploid strains carrying complete (20-gene) hup + /hyp + (including hupSL + ) operon deletions entirely lacking exo -hydrogenase and ancillary activities, nevertheless retain full H 2 recycling activity both in pure cultures and in S. rostrata stem nodules. As well, Rhodocista centenaria (aka Rhodospirillum centenum ) SW, which possesses the hyq + operon but not the hup + /hyp + operon ( Table 2 ), completely recycles H 2 in diazotrophic culture (data not presented). Accordingly, these exo - and endo -hydrogenase gene-sets seem fully autonomous. TABLE: N 2 -fixing microaerophilic α-proteobacteria carrying orthologous hup + /hyp + ( exo- hydrogenase) and hyq + ( endo -hydrogenase) genes. H 2 recycling proficient: legume host diazotrophy hupSL + genes hyq + operon Azorhizobium caulinodans ORS571 Sesbania rostrata + AZC0598-0599 AZC4361-4355 Beijerinckia indica ATCC 9039 – + BIND1150-1151 BIND2473-2479 Bradyrhizobium japonicum USDA110 Glycine max – BLR1720-1721 BLR6338-6344 Rhodocista centenaria SW – + – RC11420-1415 Rhodopseudomonas palustris BisB5 – + RPD1162-1163 RPD3855-3850 Xanthobacter autotrophicus PY2 – + XAUT2173-2174 XAUT0165-0171 H 2 recycling deficient: Sinorhizobium meliloti 1021 Medicago sativa – – – Mesorhizobium loti MAFF303099 Lotus japonicus – – – Rhizobium etli CFN42 Phaseolus vulgaris – – – Rhizobium sp . NGR234 Vigna unguiculata – – – DISCUSSION Among legume- Rhizobium symbioses, H 2 recycling was first reported in Pisum sativum (garden pea) nodules elicited by specific Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae strains [ 2 ] . Genetic studies were subsequently undertaken with [ Brady ] Rhizobium japonicum strains able to recycle H 2 in Glycine max (soy) nodules [ 21] , [ 22 ] . Many subsequent studies with H 2 recycling legume nodules all presumed uptake hydrogenase activity a single entity. These studies include combined genetic and physiological analyses which might have challenged this assertion. For the case of A. caulinodans , single mutants W58, U58 as well as hupSL impaired strain ORS571.2 all were reported to suffer substantial to complete loss of uptake hydrogenase activity [ 23] , [24] , [ 25 ] . Such conclusions are incompatible with the present finding: A. caulinodans employs two structurally and functionally distinct, genetically-independent, respiratory hydrogenases to recycle endogenous H 2 produced by N 2 fixation. Whereas, early on the investigative timeline, B. japonicum single mutants unable to be cultured autotrophically on exogenous H 2 yet still able to recycle endogenous H 2 in soy nodules were identified [ 26 ] . As these strains showed induction of uptake hydrogenase activity in cultures shifted to O 2 limitation (≤11 µ M DOT), they were perhaps understandably considered transcriptional control mutants hypersensitive to O 2 . With the benefit of hindsight, this phenotype is precisely that expected of true loss-of-function point mutants affecting hup operon structural genes encoding Hup exo -hydrogenase activity, were the observed limiting-DOT uptake hydrogenase activity in fact owed to Hyq endo- hydrogenase. In A. caulinodans , hyq operon expression requires NifA as transactivator [17] , and the p nifA + promoter is in turn strongly transactivated by Fnr, which process requires physiological O 2 limitation in diazotrophic culture [ 27 ] . In principle, both exo - and endo -hydrogenase gene-sets, despite being encoded at disparate loci in all organisms identified, might nevertheless share a common genetic predisposition, allowing strategic single mutations to convey dual loss-of-function. However, as strains carrying complete hyq operon deletions still possess wild-type Hup exo- hydrogenase activity, and vice versa , evidence for any genetic, post-transcriptional interaction or interdependence between the two gene-sets is entirely lacking. As shown previously, in pure diazotrophic (N 2 as sole N-source) cultures, A. caulinodans exo- hydrogenase knockout mutants grow as wild-type, whereas endo -hydrogenase knockout mutants exhibit slow growth [ 17 ] . Are exo - and endo -hydrogenase H 2 recycling efficiencies in pure culture and in legume nodules then demonstrably different? Or, do diazotrophic phenotypes imply additional endo- hydrogenase function(s), e.g. chemiosmotic work associated with membrane ion translocation [ 28 ] not undertaken by exo -hydrogenase? Obviously, effective exo - and endo- hydrogenase cellular concentrations and/or distributions might be dissimilar in legume nodules and in pure diazotrophic cultures, even though both hup + /hyp + ( exo -hydrogenase) and hyq + ( endo -hydrogenase) gene-sets are then strongly transcribed [ 17] , [ 25 ] , [ 29 ] . Because hup mutants suffer loss of chemoautotrophy with exogenous H 2 as energy substrate [ 17] , [ 26 ] , exo- hydrogenase kinetic behavior may constitute simple diffusion control. Because hyq mutants do not adversely impact chemoautotrophy with exogenous H 2 , endo- hydrogenase kinetic behavior might not constitute simple diffusion control. A critical test of this hypothesis is still lacking. Diazotrophic liquid batch cultures typically employ constant sparging with relatively high gas-phase exhaust rates (0.5 min −1 ), complicating kinetic behavior and analysis of cellular processes with gaseous substrate(s) subject to simple diffusion control. In such pure liquid diazotrophic batch cultures bacterial densities typically reach 10 8 cc −1 , whereas in determinate S. rostrata nodules, bacteroid densities approach 10 11 cc −1 , the latter obviously more conducive to endogenous H 2 recycling under simple diffusion control. Notwithstanding, given their apparent co-selection in N 2 fixing micoaerophilic α-proteobacteria capable of H 2 recycling, exo - and endo -hydrogenases likely possess additional, distinctive functionalities yet to be elucidated. METHODS Azorhizobium caulinodans ORS571 wild-type (strain 57100), originally isolated from Sesbania rostrata stem-nodules [ 16 ] , was cultured as previously described [ 30 ] . As 57100 wild-type is a pyridine nucleotide auxotroph, to serve as ‘virtual’ wild-type, all experiments reported here employ A. caulinodans 61305R, a 57100 derivative carrying an IS 50 R insertion in the (catabolic) nicotinate hydroxylase structural gene. Precise, in-frame deletion mutants were constructed by a ‘crossover PCR’ method [ 31 ] . Haploid exo -hydrogenase knockout mutants each carry a hup Δ SL2 allele in which the (upstream) hupS translation initiation codon is fused in-frame to a synthetic 21np linker sequence fused in-frame to the (downstream) hupL termination codon. Similarly, haploid endo -hydrogenase mutants each carry a hyq Δ RI7 allele, in which the hyqRBCEFGI operon has been replaced by a deletion allele comprising the hyqR initiation codon fused in-frame to the 21np linker sequence fused in-frame to the hyqI termination codon. After gene replacement, haploid strains carrying deletion alleles were verified by PCR and DNA sequencing analyses [ 17 ] . SESBANIA ROSTRATA NODULATION TESTS S. rostrata plants were germinated, cultivated aseptically, and stem inoculated with pure A. caulinodans strain cultures as described [ 16 ] . Either three or five weeks post-inoculation, stem nodules were detached, weighed, individually placed in septated vials. Dinitrogenase activity was assayed kinetically by acetylene reduction [ 32 ] and product ethylene was measured by gas chromatography with flame-ionization detection. H 2 evolution was assayed kinetically and measured by gas chromatography with reducing compound photometer detection (RCP1; Peak Laboratories LLC, Mountain View, CA.), both at atmospheric pressure and 29°C [ 33 ] . Enzymatic activities are expressed per gram nodule fresh-biomass at 29°C. REFERENCES [1] Phelps AS Wilson PW 1941 Occurrence of hydrogenase in nitrogen-fixing organisms. Proc Soc Exp Biol 47 473 476 [2] Hyndman LA Burris RH Wilson PW 1953 Properties of hydrogenase from Azotobacter vinelandii . J Bacteriol 65 522 531 [3] Thorneley RNF Lowe DJ 1985 in Molybdenum Enzymes ; Spiro TG New York Wiley-Interscience 221 284 [4] Burgess BK Lowe DJ 1996 Mechanism of molybdenum nitrogenase. Chem Rev 96 2983 3011 [5] Schubert KR Evans HJ 1976 Hydrogen evolution: A major factor affecting the efficiency of nitrogen fixation in nodulated symbionts. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 73 1207 1211 [6] Albrecht SL Maier R J Hanus FJ Russell SA Emerich DW 1979 Hydrogenase in Rhizobium japonicum increases nitrogen fixation by nodulated soybeans. Science 203 1255 1257 [7] Eisbrenner G Evans HJ 1983 Aspects of hydrogen metabolism in nitrogen-fixing legumes and other plant-microbe associations. Ann Rev Plant Physiol 34 105 136 [8] Bedmar EJ Phillips DA 1984 Pisum sativum cultivar effects on hydrogen metabolism in Rhizobium . Can J Bot 62 1682 1686 [9] López M Carbonero V Cabrera E Ruiz-Argüeso T 1983 Effects of host on the expression of the H 2 -uptake hydrogenase of Rhizobium in legume nodules. Plant Sci Lett 9 191 199 [10] Dixon ROD 1972 Hydrogenase in legume root nodule bacteroids: occurrence and properties. Arch Mikrobiol 85 193 201 [11] Dixon ROD 1968 Hydrogenase in pea root nodule bacteroids. Arch Mikrobiol 62 272 283 [12] Vignais PM Billoud B Meyer J 2001 Classification and phylogeny of hydrogenases. FEMS Microbiol Rev 25 455 501 [13] Cauvin B Colbeau C Vignais PM 1991 The hydrogenase structural operon in Rhodobacter capsulatus contains a third gene, hupM , necessary for the formation of a physiologically competent hydrogenase. Mol Microbiol 5 2519 2527 [14] Bernhard M Benelli B Hochkoeppler A Zannoni D Friedrich B 2004 Functional and structural role of the cytochrome b subunit of the membrane-bound hydrogenase complex of Alcaligenes eutrophus . Eur J Biochem 16 179 186 [15] Burgdorf T Lenz O Buhrke T van der Linden E Jones AK 2005 [NiFe]-hydrogenases of Ralstonia eutropha H16: modular enzymes for oxygen-tolerant biological hydrogen oxidation. J Mol Microbiol Biotechnol 10 181 196 [16] Dreyfus BL Dommergues YR 1981 Nitrogen fixing nodules induced by Rhizobium on strains of the tropical legume Sesbania rostrata . FEMS Microbiol Lett 10 313 317 [17] Ng G Tom CGS Park AS Zenad L Ludwig RA 2009 A novel endo -hydrogenase activity recycles hydrogen produced by nitrogen fixation. PLoS ONE 4(3) e4695 doi: 101371/journalpone0004695 [18] Sazanov LA Hinchcliffe P 2006 Structure of the hydrophilic domain of respiratory complex I from Thermus thermophilus . Science 311 1430 1436 (2006) [19] Ruiz-Argüeso T Hanus J Evans HJ 1978 Hydrogen production and uptake by pea nodules as affected by strains of Rhizobium leguminosarum. Arch Microbiol 116 113 118 [20] Nelson LM Grosskopf E Tichy HV Lotz W 1985 Characterization of hup -specific DNA in Rhizobium leguminosarum strains of different origin. FEMS Microbiol Lett 30 53 58 [21] Lepo JE Hickok RE Cantrell MA Russell SA Evans HJ 1981 Revertible hydrogen uptake deficient mutants of Rhizobium japonicum . J Bacteriol 146 614 620 [22] Drevon JJ Frazier L Russell SA Evans HJ 1982 Respiratory and nitrogenase activities of soybean nodules formed by hydrogen uptake negative (Hup − ) mutant and revertant strains of [Brady] Rhizobium japonicum characterized by protein patterns. Plant Physiol 70 1341 1346 [23] De Vries W Ras J Stam H van Vlerken MMA Hilgert U 1988 Isolation and characterization of hydrogenase-negative mutants of Azorhizobium caulinodans ORS571. Arch Microbiol 150 595 599 [24] Boogerd FC Ferdinandy-Van Vlerken M Mawadza C Pronk AF 1994 Nitrogen fixation and hydrogen metabolism in relation to the dissolved oxygen tension in chemostat cultures of the wild type and a hydrogenase-negative mutant of Azorhizobium caulinodans . App Env Microbiol 60 1859 1864 [25] Baginsky C Palacios JM Imperial J Ruiz-Argüeso T Brito B 2004 Molecular and functional characterization of the Azorhizobium caulinodans ORS571 hydrogenase gene cluster. FEMS Microbiol Lett 237 399 405 [26] Maier RJ Merberg DM 1982 [Brady] Rhizobium japonicum mutants that are hypersensitive to repression of H 2 uptake by oxygen. J Bacteriol 150 161 167 [27] Loroch AI Nguyen B Ludwig RA 1995 FixLJK and NtrBC signals interactively regulate Azorhizobium nifA transcription via overlapping promoters. J Bacteriol 177 7210 7221 [28] Ohnishi T Salerno JC 2005 Conformation-driven and semiquinone-gated proton-pump mechanism in the NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I). FEBS Lett 579 4555 4561 [29] Brito B Martinez M Fernandez M Rey L Babrera E 1997 Hydrogenase genes from Rhizobium leguminosarum bv viciae are controlled by the nitrogen fixation regulatory protein NifA. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94 6019 6024 [30] Donald RGK Nees D Raymond CK Loroch AI Ludwig RA 1986 Three genomic loci encode [Azo] Rhizobium sp ORS571 N 2 fixation genes. J Bacteriol 165 72 81 [31] Link AJ Phillips D Church GM 1997 Methods for generating precise deletions and insertions in the genome of wild-type Escherichia coli : application to open reading frame characterization. J Bacteriol 179 6228 6237 [32] Burris RH Arp DJ Benson DR Emerich DW Hageman RV 1980 The biochemistry of nitrogenase, Stewart WDP Gallon JR London Academic Press 37 54 in Nitrogen Fixation , [33] Vreman HJ Mahoney JJ Van Kessel AL Stevenson DK 1988 Carboxyhemoglobin as measured by gas chromatography and with the IL282 and 482CO-oximeters. Clin Chem 34 2562 2566