Rad51 Inhibits Translocation Formation by Non-Conservative Homologous Recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae Authors: Glenn M. Manthey, Adam M. Bailis Published: 2010, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0011889 ABSTRACT Chromosomal translocations are a primary biological response to ionizing radiation (IR) exposure, and are likely to result from the inappropriate repair of the DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) that are created. An abundance of repetitive sequences in eukaryotic genomes provides ample opportunity for such breaks to be repaired by homologous recombination (HR) between non-allelic repeats. Interestingly, in the budding yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae the central strand exchange protein, Rad51 that is required for DSB repair by gene conversion between unlinked repeats that conserves genomic structure also suppresses translocation formation by several HR mechanisms. In particular, Rad51 suppresses translocation formation by single-strand annealing (SSA), perhaps the most efficient mechanism for translocation formation by HR in both yeast and mammalian cells. Further, the enhanced translocation formation that emerges in the absence of Rad51 displays a distinct pattern of genetic control, suggesting that this occurs by a separate mechanism. Since hypomorphic mutations in RAD51 in mammalian cells also reduce DSB repair by conservative gene conversion and stimulate non-conservative repair by SSA, this mechanism may also operate in humans and, perhaps contribute to the genome instability that propels the development of cancer. INTRODUCTION Cells are constantly challenged with an array of exogenous and endogenous agents that damage their DNA. Perhaps the most pernicious DNA lesion is the double-strand break (DSB) that can be lethal if left unrepaired [1] , [2] . In eukaryotic cells, a number of repair mechanisms have evolved to address this lesion, including the homology-directed mechanisms of gene conversion (GC), break induced replication (BIR), synthesis dependent strand annealing (SDSA), and single strand annealing (SSA), while a fifth mechanism, non-homologous end joining, uses little to no homology [3] , [4] , [5] . Importantly, all of the homology-directed mechanisms utilize 3′ single-stranded intermediates generated by resection of the 5′ strands at the ends of DSBs [6] , [7] . The single-stranded DNA binding protein, RPA, binds first at these intermediates, and is then displaced by the recombination mediator protein, Rad52 [8] , [9] . Rad52 also promotes the recruitment of the strand invasion protein, Rad51, forming a nucleoprotein filament that can facilitate GC, BIR, and SDSA [10] , [11] , [12] , [13] , [14] . In contrast, Rad51 is not required for SSA, and can even be inhibitory [15] , [16] , [17] . This inhibitory effect is likely to be due to the ability of Rad51 to block the annealing of complementary 3′ single-strands by Rad52, a critical step in SSA [16] , [18] , [19] . DSB repair by SSA is an efficient mechanism of genome rearrangement that can create chromosomal deletions and translocations at high frequencies in eukaryotic species from yeast to humans [20] , [21] , [22] , [23] , [24] , [25] , [26] , [27] , [28] , [29] . This is likely to be relevant to the genome instability observed following acute accidental or therapeutic exposure to IR, as numerous, widely distributed genomic DSBs are likely to stimulate SSA using repetitive genomic sequences [22] , [30] , [31] . Chromosomal deletions and non-reciprocal translocations by SSA may also account for variations in gene copy number that are thought to be important contributors to the development of cancer and genome evolution [32] , [33] . Recent studies of translocation formation by SSA in yeast have revealed a complex pattern of genetic control, indicating the existence of an elaborate apparatus for propagating these events. In particular, genetic interactions between the RAD52 paralog, RAD59 , the central mismatch repair gene, MSH2 , and the structure-specific nuclease subunit gene, RAD1 , suggest that SSA employs a specific apparatus for the removal of non-homologous tails formed upon annealing of complementary sequences on the 3′ single-stranded intermediates ( Figure 1 ) [8] , [27] , [34] , [35] , [36] , [37] . Removal of the tails is thought to be of critical importance because they block the repair synthesis and ligation that complete the formation of the rearranged chromosomes [37] . Loss of any of the factors that contribute to this apparatus results in severe reductions in the frequency of translocation [27] , [36] . ( a ) Translocation formation by HR between his3 substrates after two DSBs. 1. Recombination between the his3- Δ 3 ′ substrate at the HIS3 locus on one copy of chromosome XV (centromeres black circles, telomeres black triangles) and the his3- Δ 5 ′ substrate at the LEU2 locus on one copy of chromosome III (centromeres gray circles, telomeres gray triangles) is initiated by HO endonuclease (scissors) cutting at adjacent HO cut sites in 117 bp fragments of the y/z junction of MAT a (black rectangles). The his3- Δ 200 allele at the HIS3 locus on the other copy of chromosome XV lacks sufficient homology to generate an intact HIS3 gene by recombination with either his3- Δ 3 ′ or his3- Δ 5 ′. Exonucleolytic processing of the ends of the broken chromosomes creates 3′ single-strands. 2. Either 60 bp or 300 bp complementary sequences in the 3′ single strands associated with his3- Δ 3 ′ at the end of one fragment of chromosome XV, and his3- Δ 5 ′ at the end of one fragment of chromosome III are annealed by Rad52 and Rad59, creating 3′ non-homologous tails that are the remnants of the HOcs sequences (black rectangles). Tails are removed by Rad1-Rad10 endonuclease (scissors). At the ends of the other fragments of chromosomes XV and III, the four bp sticky ends created by HO endonuclease digestion can also be annealed in a process that is independent of Rad52, Yku70 and Yku80 [27] . 3. Repair synthesis and ligation create an intact HIS3 gene associated with the recombinant translocation chromosome tXV:III. Dnl4-independent ligation of the annealed sticky ends on the other chromosome fragments creates the recombinant translocation chromsome III:XV [27] . ( b ) Expected chromosomal products of HR between his3 substrates. Cutting on the right side of the his3- Δ 3 ′ homology box (gray box) at the HIS3 locus on chromosome XV by HO endonuclease (downward facing arrow) creates 722 kb and 369 kb fragments. Cutting on the left side of the his3- Δ 5 ′ homology box (gray box) at the LEU2 locus on chromosome III by HO endonuclease creates 225 kb and 92 kb fragments. HR between his3- Δ 3 ′ and his3- Δ 5 ′ creates an intact HIS3 coding sequence on an 814 kb tXV:III translocation chromosome. The 594 kb tIII:XV reciprocal translocation chromosome, created by a process that can utilize minimal homology between the broken ends may also appear. ( c ) Observation of recombinant translocation chromosomes by chromosome blot hybridization. Displayed on the left are chromosomes prepared from His − parent and representative His + recombinant strains were separated by CHEF on agarose gels, stained with ethidium bromide, and photographed. On the right are the gel-separated chromosomes that have been denatured in alkali, blotted to nylon, hybridized with a 32 P-labeled 1.8 kb Bam HI genomic clone containing the HIS3 coding sequence, and autoradiographed. Lanes : (1) His − parent. (2) His + recombinant carrying the tXV:III translocation chromosome. (3) His + recombinant carrying the tXV:III translocation chromosome and the tIII:XV reciprocal translocation chromosome. The current paper describes the effects of the loss of RAD51 on translocation formation by SSA. By playing a potentially inhibitory role, Rad51 could comprise part of the defense against catastrophic genome rearrangement following extensive DNA damage. In support of previous studies of the genetic control of SSA, deletion of RAD51 resulted in an increased frequency of translocation formation [15] , [16] , [17] . Importantly, rad52- 329, a mutation that deletes the C-terminal domain of Rad52 that interacts with Rad51 and permits it to execute its recombination mediator function also has stimulatory effects [38] , [39] , [40] , [41] , [42] . Most strikingly, however, was the observation that both rad51 Δ and rad52-329 suppressed the requirement for Srs2, Rad1 and Rad59, factors that are otherwise necessary for translocation formation by SSA, indicating that a distinct and more efficient mechanism of translocation formation can replace the primary SSA mechanism. This may have important implications with respect to the development of cancer in humans as mutations in RAD51 , and BRCA2 , which encodes a tumor suppressor protein with a recombination mediator function, confer similar increases in SSA [17] , [23] , [43] , [44] , [45] , [46] , [47] . Rad51 may, therefore play a critical, evolutionarily conserved role in the maintenance of genome stability by moderating the levels of DSB repair by potent non-conservative mechanisms. RESULTS We have used several assays to study HR between duplicate sequences on non-homologous chromosomes in budding yeast. Translocation formation by HR between 3′ and 5′ truncated alleles of the HIS3 gene that share 60 bp or 300 bp of identical sequence, and are located at the HIS3 locus on one copy of chromosome XV and the LEU2 locus on one copy of chromosome III has figured prominently in recent work [27] , [36] , [48] , [49] . The assay is performed three ways that differ in the manner by which recombination is initiated: T0, where recombination occurs spontaneously, T1, where recombination is stimulated by an HO endonuclease-mediated DSB adjacent to one of the his3 substrates, and, T2, where recombination is stimulated by DSBs adjacent to both substrates ( Figure 1 ) [27] . The efficiency that a functional HIS3 gene and tXV::III translocation chromosome are formed in wild type diploids depends on the mode of inititation, with T0 occurring at a rate of 6.0×10 −9 , T1 at a frequency of 1.4×10 −5 , and T2 at a frequency of 2.2×10 −2 ( Table 1 ) [27] . While the structure of the tXV:III translocation chromosome appears identical in nearly all recombinants, the structures of the occasional reciprocal tIII:XV translocations are distinct in T0, T1 and T2, as are the karyotypes of the recombinants, which can include different numbers of chromosomes carrying intact substrates (G. Manthey and A. Bailis – unpublished observations). Further, the genetic control of these processes is distinct as mutations in several DNA repair and HR genes exert different effects on T0, T1 and T2 [27] , [36] , [49] . The accumulated evidence, therefore, strongly supports the conclusion that T0, T1 and T2 proceed by distinct mechanisms. All diploid strains were homozygous for MATa::LEU2 such that no cutting by HO endonuclease occurred at the MAT locus, except for T0 strains where HO endonuclease is not expressed. Frequencies of ectopic gene conversion (EGC) in diploid cells between sam1- Δ Bgl II at the SAM1 locus on one copy of chromosome XII and sam1- Δ Sal I at the HIS3 locus on one copy of chromosome XV were determined following a HO endonuclease-mediated break in sam1- Δ Bgl II as described in the Materials and Methods . Median frequencies were determined from a minimum of 10 independent cultures for each strain. Fold differences from the median frequency observed with wild type strains are indicated in brackets with fold increases preceded by a “plus” and fold decreases preceded by a “minus“. The 95% confidence intervals are indicated in parentheses. Frequencies in wild type and rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ homozygotes described previously [49] . Rates of translocation formation in diploid cells by spontaneous HR (T0) between a 300 bp segment of the HIS3 coding sequence shared by the his3- Δ 5 ′ substrate at the LEU2 locus on one copy of chromosome V and a his3- Δ 3 ′ substrate at the HIS3 locus on one copy of chromosome XV were determined using the method of the median from a minimum of 10 independent trials as described in the Materials and Methods . Fold differences from wild type and 95% confidence intervals are displayed as described above. ND  =  not determined. These results were published previously [27] . Frequencies of translocation formation in diploid cells by HR between a 300 bp segment of the HIS3 coding sequence shared by the his3- Δ 5 ′ substrate at the LEU2 locus on one copy of chromosome III and a his3- Δ 3 ′ substrate at the HIS3 locus on one copy of chromosome XV were determined following a HO endonuclease-mediated break adjacent to the his3- Δ 5 ′ substrate (T1) as described in the Materials and Methods . Median frequencies, fold differences from wild type and 95% confidence intervals are displayed as described above. Frequencies of translocation formation in diploid cells by HR between his3- Δ 5 ′ and his3- Δ 3 ′ following HO endonuclease-mediated breaks adjacent to both substrates (T2) were determined as described in the Materials and Methods . Median frequencies, fold differences from wild type and 95% confidence intervals are displayed as described above. Plating efficiencies (PE) “Pre” and “Post” HO endonuclease cutting at his3- Δ 5 ′ and his3- Δ 3 ′ were determined as described in the Materials and Methods , and previously. Median frequencies, fold differences from wild type and 95% confidence intervals are displayed as described above. In addition to assays for non-conservative HR between chromosomes, we have utilized an assay that measures the repair of a HO-stimulated DSB by ectopic gene conversion (EGC) between duplicate sequences on non-homologous chromosomes in diploids [49] . A DSB is generated in the sam1- Δ BglII-HOcs allele at the SAM1 locus on one copy of chromosome XII, and repaired by gene conversion with the sam1- Δ SalI allele, located at the HIS3 locus on one copy of chromosome XV. In wild-type diploids, EGC creates a functional SAM1 gene at a frequency of 1.1×10 −3 ( Table 1 ) [49] . Translocation formation by reciprocal recombination between the sam1 alleles cannot be observed in this assay because it would produce dicentric chromosomes due to the opposite orientation of the sam1 alleles relative to their centromeres. We had previously shown that the frequency of EGC is reduced over 3,000-fold in rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ homozygotes, consistent with these events being highly dependent on Rad52 ( Table 1 ) [49] . In the current study, loss of Rad51 led to a nearly equivalent (p = 0.20), 1,500-fold decreased frequency in rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ homozygotes, consistent with EGC proceeding by a strand exchange-mediated mechanism [12] . Further, in rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygotes, where C-terminally deleted Rad52 is defective in its interaction with Rad51, EGC is also reduced approximately 3,000-fold, consistent with results with other systems [38] . This suggests that the recombination mediator function of Rad52 is required for Rad51 to exert its effect, and it is this function of Rad52 that is required for EGC. Together, these data suggest that the repair of a DSB by conservative gene conversion using homologous sequences on different chromosomes requires the involvement of both Rad51 and Rad52, and that Rad51 and Rad52 must interact. Our studies of the formation of chromosomal translocations by T0, T1 and T2 have demonstrated that distinct mechanisms are utiIized [27] , [36] , [49] . But, like EGC, all translocation formation displays some degree of dependence on Rad52, as it is reduced by seven- to 61-fold in rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ homozygotes ( Table 1 , Figure 2 ). In contrast, while EGC is acutely dependent on Rad51, T0, T1 and T2 are inhibited by Rad51, as translocation formation is increased from approximately two- to 18-fold in rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ homozygotes. Abrogating the interaction between Rad51 and Rad52 in rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygotes has similar effects, indicating that translocation formation does not require the mediator function of Rad52, and suggesting that Rad51 cannot inhibit translocation formation if it cannot associate efficiently with DSBs. The different effects of the mutant alleles in these assays is unlikely to be due to differences in the ability to survive DSBs as plating efficiencies are substantially similar ( Table 1 ). Considering the gene conversion and translocation data together suggests that the collaboration between Rad51 and Rad52 that potentiates DSB repair by conservative inter-chromosomal HR also limits repair by non-conservative inter-chromosomal HR. ( a ) Frequencies of His + colony formation by HR between 60 bp substrates. Frequencies of His + colony formation from a minimum of 10 trials with each strain were determined as discussed in the Materials and Methods . Median frequencies are depicted. Error bars represent 95% confidence intervals determined as described in the Materials and Methods . Fold decreases from wild-type depicted by quantities following a “minus” sign. Fold increases from wild-type depicted by quantities following a “plus” sign. Actual frequencies presented in Table S1 . ( b ) Frequencies of His + colony formation by HR between 300 bp substrates. TABLE: Spontaneous or DSB-stimulated interchromosomal recombination and plating efficiencies in wild type and homozygous mutant diploid strains. Genotype a EGC b T0 c T1 d T2 e PE f Pre Post Wild type 1.1×10 −3 6.0×10 −9 1.4×10 −5 2.2×10 −2 2.1×10 −1 1.6×10 −1 (0.6, 1.6) (4.4, 7.6) (0.8, 3.2) (1.4, 3.1) (1.4, 4.4) (1.1, 3.6) rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ 7.4×10 −7 1.1×10 −7 2.5×10 −5 6.0×10 −2 ND ND [−1487] [+18.3] [+1.8] [+2.7] (4.0, 11.8) (0.9, 1.4) (1.8, 3.3) (3.8, 12) rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ 3.6×10 −7 <8.4×10 −10 2.3×10 −7 3.0×10 −3 1.8×10 −1 4.2×10 −2 [−3056] [>−7.1] [−61] [−7.3] [−1.2] [−3.8] (1.6, 5.6) (1.2, 7.2) (1.3, 4.3) (1.3, 3.5) (3.1, 7.0) rad52-329/rad52-329 3.2×10 −7 ND 3.7×10 −5 2.0×10 −2 2.9×10 −1 1.9×10 −1 [−3438] [+2.6] [−1.1] [+1.4] [+1.2] (2.7, 4.2) (2.4, 5.8) (1.4, 3.1) (2.5, 3.9) 1.7, 3.5) THE GENETIC CONTROL OF T2 IS CONSISTENT WITH SSA T2 is the most efficient mechanism of translocation formation by HR in both yeast and mammalian cells, and may account for the high frequency of translocations observed in acutely irradiated yeast cells ( Table 1 ) [27] , [29] , [30] . We have shown previously that T2 displays a pattern of genetic control consistent with SSA, including a considerable dependence on RAD1 and RAD59 that work together in supporting the removal of non-homologous tails [27] , [49] . Consistent with our previous analyses, the rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ and rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ homozygotes both displayed strongly diminished frequencies of translocation, 75- and 41-fold reduced with the 60 bp substrates, and 115- and 82-fold reduced with the 300 bp substrates ( Figure 2 ). Similarly, Haber and colleagues had previously shown that DSB-stimulated deletion formation by SSA is also dependent on SRS2 , which encodes a helicase that facilitates the removal of Rad51 from the 3′ single strands that form at DSBs [35] , [50] , [51] , [52] . Consistent with their findings T2 was found to be dependent on Srs2, as srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ homozygotes exhibited 79- and 24-fold reduced frequencies of translocation with the 60 bp and 300 bp substrates, respectively. Epistasis analysis was used previously to determine that RAD1 and RAD59 work together to control the removal of non-homologous tails during T2, as rad1 and rad59 alleles were observed to confer mutually suppressive effects [27] , [49] . Accordingly, we examined the epistasis relationships between srs2 Δ, and both rad1 Δ and rad59 Δ. Interestingly, with the 60 bp substrates srs2 Δ displayed a synergistic interaction with both rad1 Δ and rad59 Δ as translocation frequencies were reduced 680-fold in the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ double homozygote and 567-fold in the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ double homozygote, well below the frequencies observed in any of the single homozygotes ( Figures 2 and 3 ). A similar relationship was observed for srs2 Δ and rad59 Δ when the 300 bp substrates were used as the 122-fold reduced translocation frequency in the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ double homozygote was significantly lower than the frequencies observed in the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ and rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ homozygotes (p<0.0001). However, rad1 Δ appeared to be epistatic to srs2 Δ when the 300 bp substrates were used as the 96-fold reduced frequency of translocation in the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ double homozygote was not significantly different from the frequency in the rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ homozygote (p = 0.36), suggesting that Rad1 and Srs2 may work together with the longer substates. Overall, the pattern of interaction is most consistent with Srs2 playing a distinct role in T2 from those played by Rad1 and Rad59, although these interactions are affected by substrate length. ( a ) Frequencies of His + colony formation by HR between 60 bp substrates. Median frequencies and confidence intervals were determined as described in the legend to Figure 2 and in the Materials and Methods . Fold decreases from wild-type depicted by quantities following a “minus” sign. Fold increases from wild-type depicted by quantities following a “plus” sign. Actual frequencies presented in Table S1 . ( b ) Frequencies of His + colony formation by HR between 300 bp substrates. The srs2 Δ allele also displayed interesting epistasis interactions with rad52 Δ, as in the rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ double homozygote the 112-fold decreased translocation frequency with the 60 bp substrates was not significantly different from the frequency in the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ homozygote (p = 0.37) ( Figures 2 and 3 ), while the 67-fold decreased frequency with the 300 bp substrates was significantly lower than the frequencies in either the rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ or srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ homozygotes (p<0.011)( Figures 2 and 3 ). This suggests that Srs2 and Rad52 operate together during translocation formation by SSA with the 60 bp substrates, but that they may function separately with the 300 bp substrates. The collective pattern of T2 epistasis was consistent with Srs2 working with Rad52, and separate from Rad1 and Rad59 for translocation formation with the 60 bp substrates, and with Rad1, but separate from Rad52 and Rad59 with the 300 bp substrates. ASSOCIATION BETWEEN RAD51 AND RAD52 MANDATES THE UTILIZATION OF RAD1, RAD59 AND SRS2 IN THE GENERATION OF TRANSLOCATIONS BY SSA Observing the stimulation of T2 in the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ and rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygotes suggests that the loss of Rad51, and the truncation of Rad52 such that it cannot interact with Rad51 can both stimulate translocation formation by SSA ( Table 1 , Figure 2 ). However, the frequencies of translocation were significantly different with both the 60 bp substrates, where the 16-fold increased frequency in the rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygote exceeded the 3.5-fold increased frequency in the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ homozygote (p = 0.0001), and the 300 bp substrates, where the 2.7-fold increased frequency in the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ homozygote was greater than the essentially wild type frequency in the rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygote (p = 0.0018)( Figure 4 ). These results indicate that rad51 Δ and rad52-329 have non-equivalent effects on T2, which were studied further through epistasis analysis. The 7.9-fold increased frequency of T2 with the 60 bp substrates in the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ rad52-329/rad52-329 double homozygote was intermediate to and significantly different from the frequencies in both the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ (p = 0.0062) and rad52-329/rad52-329 (p = 0.0043) homozygotes, indicating that rad51 Δ partially suppressed the effect of rad52-329 . The 5.5-fold increased frequency with the 300 bp substrates in the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ rad52-329/rad52-329 double homozygote was significantly greater than those observed in either the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ (p = 0.0009) or rad52-329/rad52-329 (p = 0.0001) homozygotes, indicating that rad51 Δ and rad52-329 had a mildly synergistic effect. This pattern of genetic interaction is most consistent with the rad51 Δ and rad52-329 alleles increasing T2 by similar mechanisms and suggests that their effects, while different in degree may be essentially interchangeable genetically. ( a ) Frequencies of His + colony formation by HR between 60 bp substrates. Median frequencies and confidence intervals were determined as described in the legend to Figure 2 and in the Materials and Methods . Fold decreases from wild-type depicted by quantities following a “minus” sign. Fold increases from wild-type depicted by quantities following a “plus” sign. Actual frequencies presented in Table S1 . ( b ) Frequencies of His + colony formation by HR between 300 bp substrates. The loss of Rad51 in the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ homozygote, and the inability of Rad52 to associate with Rad51 in the rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygote would both be expected to block formation of Rad51 nucleoprotein filaments at DSBs [40] , [42] , [53] . The increased frequencies of T2 in these mutants suggest that loss of filament formation might alter the manner in which the factors that mediate SSA associate with the recombination substrates, so we examined the genetic control of T2 in rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ and rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygotes. Since Srs2 has been demonstrated to remove Rad51 from 3′ single-stranded DNA in vitro , we examined the effect of losing Srs2 in the context of a rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygote, where Rad51 filament formation should be at a minimum [51] , [52] , [54] , [55] . The frequency of translocation formation with 60 bp substrates in the rad52-329/rad52-329 srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ double homozygote was increased 19-fold over wild type, which was not significantly different from the 16-fold increase observed in the rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygote (p = 0.078), indicating that the 79-fold reduction in T2 conferred by srs2 Δ is completely suppressed, and that rad52-329 is epistatic to srs2 Δ ( Figures 2 and 3 ). Similarly, with the 300 bp substrates T2 was increased 9.5-fold in the rad52-329/rad52-329 srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ double homozygote, indicating complete suppression of the 24-fold reduction in T2 by srs2 Δ. These results are consistent with Srs2 promoting translocation formation by SSA by acting in the removal of Rad51 from the 3′ single-stranded DNA that forms at DSBs, and that this function is not required when Rad52 cannot facilitate nucleoprotein filament formation by Rad51. Like Srs2, Rad59 has previously been shown to be an important factor in SSA, and is critically important for T2 ( Figure 2 ) [27] , [35] , [49] , [56] . In addition to displaying an annealing activity of its own, Rad59 partially mitigates the inhibitory effect of Rad51 nucleoprotein filaments on the annealing of complementary single-stranded DNA molecules by Rad52 in vitro , consistent with Rad59 playing a role in the annealing step of SSA ( Figure 1 ) [18] , [56] , [57] , [58] . Further, rad59 Δ exhibits epistasis relationships with both msh2 Δ and rad1 Δ that are consistent with Rad59 playing a critical role in the removal of non-homologous tails [27] , [36] , [49] . Together, these data indicate that Rad59 plays multiple roles in T2. Intriguingly, both rad51 Δ and rad52-329 suppressed the effects of losing Rad59, as translocation frequencies with the 60 bp and 300 bp substrates that were 82- and 41-fold decreased in the rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ homozygotes were 4.0- and 2.1-fold increased in the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ double homozygotes and 1.5- and 1.6-fold increased in the rad52-329/rad52-329 rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ double homozygotes ( Figures 2 and 4 ). These data indicate that Rad59 is not required for T2 in the absence of Rad51 nucleoprotein filament formation, but also suggest that it is the presence of filaments that specifies the requirement for Rad59 in T2. The requirement for the heterodimeric endonuclease Rad1-Rad10 in SSA is well established, including for T2 ( Figure 2 ) [27] , [36] , [49] , [59] , [60] . Rad1-Rad10 has been shown to cleave a variety of DNA structures associated with DNA repair and HR in vitro , including structures like the 3′ non-homologous tails postulated to form during T2 when complementary sequences in the 3′ single strands at the ends of the broken chromosomes are annealed ( Figure 1 ) [61] , [62] , [63] , [64] . Rad1-Rad10 also functions in the context of Rad51-dependent HR when non-homologous tails on DSBs must be removed to facilitate completion of the recombination event [37] , [59] , [60] , [65] . Given the importance of Rad1-Rad10 for a variety of DSB-stimulated HR events it was surprising to observe that the rad51 Δ and rad52-329 mutations suppressed the 75- and 115-fold reduced frequencies of T2 with the 60 bp and 300 bp substrates, as the translocation frequencies in the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ double homozygotes were wild-type, or reduced only 8.5-fold, and the frequencies in the rad52-329/rad52-329 rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ double homozygotes were wild-type ( Figures 2 and 4 ). These results indicate that Rad1-Rad10 plays a minimal role in the absence of Rad51 nucleoprotein filament formation. Further, the data suggest that the presence of filaments specifies how 3′ non-homologous tails are processed during translocation formation by SSA. The pattern of robust suppression of the requirement for SRS2 , RAD59 and RAD1 by the rad51 Δ and rad52-329 mutations is consistent with the loss of Rad51 filament formation permitting T2 to proceed without elements of the apparatus generally considered to be necessary for annealing and non-homologous tail removal ( Figure 1 ) [35] , [37] , [59] , [60] , [65] [27] , [36] , [49] . Synergistically reduced levels of T2 in the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ and srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ double homozygotes relative to the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ, rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ and rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ single homozygotes support the notion that multiple aspects of the T2 mechanism are affected by these mutations ( Figures 2 and 3 ). Consistent with loss of filament formation simultaneously affecting both annealing and tail removal, we found that rad52-329 suppressed the synergistically reduced frequencies of T2 in the double homozygotes. This was revealed by the 567- and 122-fold reduced frequencies with 60 bp and 300 bp subunits in the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ double homozygotes becoming 2.8-fold reduced and 1.6-fold increased frequencies in the rad52-329/rad52-329 srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ triple homozygotes, and the 680- and 96-fold reduced frequencies in the srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ double homozygotes becoming 3.9-fold reduced and 2.2-fold increased frequencies in the rad52-329/rad52-329 srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ triple homozygotes ( Figure 3 ). This extraordinary degree of suppression indicates that T2 can dispense with much of the canonical SSA apparatus in the absence of Rad51 filament formation, but also strongly suggests that the presence of filaments mandates the use of these same factors for translocation formation by SSA. RAD52 IS ESSENTIAL FOR TRANSLOCATION FORMATION BY T2 IN THE ABSENCE OF RAD51 Rad52 is the central HR protein in budding yeast, playing a demonstrated role in almost all Rad51-dependent and –independent HR [3] , [4] , [5] , [66] . The Rad51-independent function of Rad52 is widely understood to be related to its ability to anneal complementary single strands of DNA [19] , [67] , [68] . During T2, the formation of complementary single stranded DNA sequences at the ends of the broken chromosomes should greatly favor their interaction by Rad52-dependent annealing, particularly when there are no Rad51 filaments present to inhibit it ( Figure 1 ) [18] . Consistent with this hypothesis, the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ double homozygotes displayed 227- and 785-fold reduced frequencies of translocation with the 60 bp and 300 bp substrates, which are 21- and 108-fold lower than those observed in the rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ homozygotes ( Figures 2 and 4 ). These results indicate that Rad52 plays a crucial, and, perhaps predominant role in T2 in the absence of Rad51 filament formation. Further, it also suggests that Rad51 influences translocation formation in the absence of Rad52, perhaps through interactions that are independent of nucleoprotein filament formation [69] . DISCUSSION Eukaryotes possess a characteristic abundance of short, repetitive sequences scattered throughout their genomes [70] , [71] , [72] , [73] , [74] . As a consequence, catastrophic levels of DNA damage, such as those created by acute exposure to IR, or DNA damaging chemicals have the potential to generate genome rearrangements by interactions between homologous repetitive sequences on the same or different chromosomes [30] , [75] , [76] , [77] , [78] . For instance, exposing diploid budding yeast cells to levels of IR sufficient to cause hundreds of DSBs per genome, with several in or near the hundreds of short, delta repeats strewn throughout the genome results in the formation of an abundance of chromosomal translocations by HR between unlinked repeats [30] . This vigorous biological response to acute levels of DNA damage suggests that non-conservative HR between repetitive genomic sequences can be a potent mechanism for genome rearrangement with important implications regarding the advent of cancer and eukaryotic genome evolution [32] , [79] , [80] . While HR can be an important mechanism of genomic change in response to DNA damage, it is also an important mechanism for damage tolerance. For instance, in budding yeast resistance to IR is primarily dependent on HR [2] , [81] , [82] . However, this resistance is most likely obtained through conservative HR between homologous sequences on sister chromatids or allelic sequences on homologous chromosomes, since the majority of survivors of even the most acute exposure display normal karyotypes [30] . Further, the genetic control of radiation survivorship resembles that of conservative HR events, such as gene conversion more than it does non-conservative HR, such as SSA. For example, the repair of a HO catalyzed DSB by gene conversion and IR resistance are both greatly dependent on Rad51, while DSB-stimulated deletion and translocation formation by SSA are not ( Table 1 ) [12] , [16] , [27] , [83] . Thus, DSBs can be repaired by separate conservative and non-conservative mechanisms of HR, suggesting that the maintenance of genome stability following DNA damage may require that the cell promotes one while it inhibits the other. The data presented in this paper suggest that the interaction between Rad51 and Rad52 that facilitates Rad51 nucleoprotein filament formation may be crucial to the maintenance of genome stability by facilitating conservative HR while opposing non-conservative HR. Strikingly, whether translocation formation by HR was initiated spontaneously, or by one, or two DSBs, either the rad51 Δ allele that results in the total loss of Rad51, or the rad52-329 allele that results in the loss of the interaction between Rad51 and Rad52, stimulates translocation formation ( Table 1 and Figure 2 ). This suggests that filament formation can inhibit a mechanistically diverse set of non-conservative HR events. Further, it suggests that releasing the attenuating effect of filament formation would have a broadly destabilizing effect on the genome. Previously, the attenuating effect of RAD51 on SSA, such as its effect on T2 was interpreted as reflecting a competition between separate apparatus for strand invasion-dependent and -independent events ( Table 1 and Figure 2 ) [16] , [17] , [25] . While competition between these processes may contribute to the balance between conservative and non-conservative HR, the genetic data described in this paper clearly suggested that it is not simply the presence or absence of filaments at DSBs that steers them toward conservative and away from non-conservative mechanisms of repair. Epistasis analysis clearly suggested that Rad51 filament formation specifies the necessity for the canonical SSA machinery encoded by SRS2 , RAD1 and RAD59, as these genes were largely dispensable for T2 in rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ and rad52-329/rad52-329 homozygotes ( Figures 3 and 4 ). This suggests that in wild type cells, filaments are present at DSBs regardless of whether they are engaged in strand invasion-dependent or –independent repair. Further, this suggests the existence of a novel, and highly efficient alternative mechanism of non-conservative HR that resembles SSA but displays distinct genetic control. Previous investigation into the interaction between Srs2 and Rad51 during the formation of chromosomal deletions by SSA suggested that loss of Srs2 does not inhibit SSA, but, instead inhibits recovery from a Rad51-dependent DNA damage checkpoint [84] . Therefore, the reduced frequencies of translocation formation observed in srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ homozygotes ( Figure 2 ), as well as the epistasis interactions between srs2 Δ, and rad1 Δ. rad52 Δ, rad52-329 and rad59 Δ ( Figure 3 ) could be due to effects on checkpoint recovery. This possibility was explored by determining the plating efficiency before and after DSB formation in srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ homozygotes, and srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad1 Δ /rad1 Δ and srs2 Δ /srs2 Δ rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ double homozygotes ( Table S3 ). Because plating efficiencies in the mutants were not reduced from wild type levels, changes in checkpoint recovery were not indicated. This suggests that the effects of srs2 Δ on translocation frequency were unlikely to be due to changes in checkpoint recovery. Failure to observe altered checkpoint recovery in our experiments may be due to our use of diploid strains, where broken chromosomes have intact homologs with which to pair and attenuate the checkpoint response. Alternatively, they may be due to the fact that the DSBs occur very close to the translocation substrates, obviating the necessity to create extensive lengths of single-stranded DNA before complementary sequences are revealed. The T2 that proceeds in the absence of Rad51, while independent of the bulk of the canonical SSA machinery, is markedly more dependent on Rad52, as translocation frequencies are 21- and 108-fold lower with the 60 bp and 300 bp substrates in the rad51 Δ /rad51 Δ rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ double homozygotes than in the rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ homozygotes ( Figures 2 and 4 ). Perhaps, the much less dramatic effect of the loss of Rad52 in the presence of Rad51 reflects the ability of Rad59, which also possesses single-stranded DNA annealing activity to act like Rad52, a notion supported by the synergistically reduced frequencies of T2 observed previously in rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ rad59 Δ /rad59 Δ double homozygotes [27] , [56] , [57] , [58] . However, experiments suggest that Rad51 can only form nucleoprotein filaments when Rad52 is present to displace RPA from single-stranded DNA, and Rad59 can neither displace RPA from single-stranded DNA, nor anneal single-stranded DNA molecules bound by RPA [9] , [56] , [57] , [85] , [86] , [87] . This suggests that the contributions of Rad51 and Rad59 to T2 in the rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ homozygotes may not involve their functions in filament formation or annealing, While the role of Rad59 could possibly be related to its participation in the removal of non-homologous tails, the fact that loss of filament formation conferred by rad51 Δ and rad52-329 both suppress the necessity for Rad59 counters that suggestion as the complete absence of Rad52 conferred by rad52 Δ should also block filament formation ( Figures 2 and 4 ). The role of Rad51 in translocation formation by SSA clearly merits further investigation. While the role of Rad51 filaments in T2 is unknown, the genetic data described here, and previously support the following speculative model ( Table 1 , Figures 1 – 4 ) [27] , [36] , [49] . Following the creation of Rad51 filaments at DSBs, Srs2 removes Rad51, permitting the complementary sequences on 3′ single strands to be annealed by Rad52 and Rad59. Rad59 then collaborates with Msh2-Msh3 and Rad1-Rad10 to coordinate the removal of the non-homologous tails created by annealing the complementary segments of the 3′ single strands. Epistasis analysis suggests that Srs2 may also play a role in removing Rad51 that remains associated with non-homologous tails, or has reassociated, which may inhibit their removal by Rad1-Rad10 ( Figure 3 ). Removal of the tails facilitates repair synthesis and ligation, forming a covalent joint and a translocation chromosome. In contrast, when Rad51 filaments do not form at DSBs, Rad52 anneals complementary single strands without the assistance of Srs2 and Rad59. Without Rad59 specifying the use of Msh2-Msh3 and Rad1-Rad10 for the removal of non-homologous tails, other factors execute this task so that repair synthesis and ligation can complete the recombination event [49] . All aspects of this model are currently under investigation at the genetic and molecular levels. Because all eukaryotes likely share with budding yeast a genomic structure that features an abundance of short repetitive sequences, non-conservative recombination between unlinked repeats must be minimized in favor of conservative recombination so that genome stability can be maintained. Also conserved from yeast to man is the central strand exchange protein, Rad51, which facilitates conservative HR, even between non-allelic sequences ( Table 1 , Figure 2 ) [12] , [17] , [88] , [89] , [90] , [91] , [92] , [93] , [94] , [95] , [96] . While Rad52 is also conserved in most eukaryotes, its function in facilitating nucleoprotein filament formation by Rad51 appears to have been replaced in many species by Brca2 [23] , [46] , [47] , [97] , [98] , [99] , [100] , [101] , [102] , [103] , [104] , [105] . Fascinatingly, like the rad51 Δ and rad52-329 mutations in yeast, mutations that disable Rad51, or disrupt the interaction between Brca2 and Rad51 in worms, flies and mammals block conservative GC and stimulate non-conservative SSA [17] , [23] , [43] , [44] , [45] . Given the parallels with yeast, it is tempting to speculate that defects in filament formation in higher eukaryotes release the restriction against a mechanism of SSA that is analogous to the one described here. Given the probable link between SSA and the non-allelic HR observed in tumors and during genome evolution, revealing the molecular basis of this mechanism could have far reaching implications [32] , [33] , [106] , [107] . MATERIALS AND METHODS All yeast strains used in this study were isogenic, and were grown, maintained and manipulated using standard techniques ( Table S2 ) [108] . Plasmids were constructed using standard molecular biological techniques [109] . Construction of the gene conversion and translocation substrates was described previously [27] , [49] , [110] . Construction of the rad1 Δ [111] , rad51 Δ [112] , rad52 Δ [113] , rad59 Δ [27] , and his3 Δ 200 alleles was described previously [114] . All strains in which HO-mediated DSBs were generated at recombination substrates were homozygous for MATa::LEU2 , an allele that disrupts the mating type locus, and prevents the creation of DSBs. The rad52-329 allele used in this study was identical to the allele that was described previously and was constructed as follows (Tsukamoto 2003): A DNA fragment containing a Bam HI site juxtaposed to the RAD52 stop codon and approximately 850 bp of DNA downstream from the RAD52 locus was amplified from yeast genomic DNA by PCR using primers P1 ( 5′-CGG GAT CCC TGA AAC GCT TCC TGG CCG-3′ and P2-( 5′-GGG TCG ACG TCC AAG AAA TAC ATT GG-3′ ). The resulting fragment was cloned into the Sma I site of pBlueScript to generate pBS-rad52-329. An 850 bp fragment carrying the RAD52 stop codon and downstream DNA was excised from pBS-rad52-329 with Bam HI, and inserted into the Bam HI site of the plasmid YIp356R-RAD52, which was constructed by inserting a 1.9 kb Nhe I fragment carrying 1 kb of DNA flanking the 5′ end of the RAD52 gene and the first 900 bp of the RAD52 coding sequence into the Xba I site of YIp356R [115] . This created YIp356R-rad52-329, which contains DNA from both sides of the RAD52 locus flanking rad52-329 , an allele of RAD52 missing the DNA encoding the final 178 amino acids of the coding sequence. YIp356R-rad52-329 was linearized with Bgl II to target its insertion into the RAD52 locus, and used to transform yeast to uracil prototrophy. Uracil prototrophic transformants were grown in the presence of 5-fluoroorotic acid to select for Ura - recombinants that were screened by PCR and Southern blotting to ascertain which clones contained the rad52 - 329 allele at the RAD52 locus (M. Navarro and A. Bailis, unpublished results) [116] . The srs2 Δ allele used in this study was generated as follows: A 3,145 bp fragment of DNA corresponding to the 537 bp of genomic sequence flanking the 5′ end of the SRS2 coding sequence, and the first 2,608 bp of the SRS2 coding sequence was amplified from genomic DNA by PCR using the primers 5′SRS2 ( 5′ GCT CAC GAT CTA CGA GAT GCG GC-3′ ) and 3′SRS2 ( 5′-GCC ATT GAT TTT GGA TGG GCG-3′ ). This fragment was cloned into the Sma I site of pBlueScript, creating pLAY482. pLAY482 was linearized in the SRS2 coding sequence by digestion with Msc I, and the 1.7 kb Pvu II TRP1 fragment from pUC-TRP inserted to create pLAY484. pLAY484 was digested with Spe I and Xho I to liberate the srs2::TRP1 disruption cassette that was used to transform yeast to prototrophy for tryptophan. The resulting tryptophan prototrophs were screened by Southern blot analysis to confirm the presence of the disrupted allele at the SRS2 locus (G. Manthey and A. Bailis, unpublished results). ECTOPIC GENE CONVERSION (EGC) FREQUENCIES The design and execution of the DSB-stimulated SAM ectopic gene conversion assay in diploid strains was described in detail previously [49] , [117] . Briefly, recombination was initiated by cutting at the HO cut-site in sam1- Δ Bgl II-HOcs at the SAM1 locus on copy of chromosome XII by HO endonuclease expressed from a galactose-inducible HO gene integrated into the TRP1 locus on one copy of chromosome IV. Cutting sam1- Δ Bgl II-HOcs with HO creates broken ends that share 279 bp and 1.4 kb of homology with the sam1- Δ Sal I donor sequence inserted into the HIS3 locus on one copy of chromosome XV. The sam1- Δ Bgl II-HOcs and sam1- Δ Sal I substrates have opposite orientations relative to their centromeres, preventing the isolation of reciprocal recombinants. For each strain, 10, one or five ml cultures of complete synthetic medium containing 3% glycerol and 3% lactate as carbon sources and supplemented with 100 µg/ml S-adenosyllmethionine (AdoMet) were inoculated with single colonies and grown overnight, or two days at 30°C before the addition of 0.1 ml, or 0.5 ml aliquots of 20% galactose and a further four hour incubation at 30°C. Appropriate dilutions of each galactose-induced culture were plated on to YPD (2% dextrose, 2% bacto-peptone, 1% yeast extract) agar supplemented with 100 µg/ml AdoMet and incubated at 30°C for four to five days to determine viability. Appropriate volumes of the galactose-induced cultures were also plated on to unsupplemented YPD agar and incubated at 30°C for four to five days to determine the number of AdoMet prototrophic recombinants. The number of AdoMet prototrophic recombinants was divided by the number of viable cells plated to determine the frequency of EGC. Median EGC frequencies from a least 10 independent cultures were determined for each genotype, and 95% confidence intervals were determined using a table [117] . P values were determined using the Mann-Whitney test with the Prism (Graphpad) software package. SPONTANEOUS TRANSLOCATION RATES Rates of spontaneous translocation in wild type and mutant diploid strains were determined as previously described [27] . For each genotype a minimum of ten 10 ml YPD cultures were inoculated with single colonies and grown overnight to two days at 30°C. Appropriate dilutions of the cultures were plated on to YPD agar and incubated at 30°C for three to four days to determine viability. Appropriate volumes of culture were plated on to synthetic medium lacking histidine and incubated at 30°C for three to four days to assess translocation formation by HR between the his3- Δ 3 ′ and his3- Δ 5 ′ substrates ( Figure 1 ). Rates were determined by the method of the median and 95% confidence intervals were determined using a table [117] , [118] . In the rad52 Δ /rad52 Δ homozygotes, where over 90% of the trials resulted in no recombinants, a theoretical rate was calculated using fluctuation analysis based upon 10% recovery of histidine prototrophic recombinants with the actual rate expected to be at or below this number [119] . Selected His + recombinants were examined by genomic Southern and chromosome blot analyses to determine the nature of the recombination event as described previously (G. Manthey and A. Bailis, unpublished results) [27] . DSB-STIMULATED TRANSLOCATION FREQUENCIES Frequencies of translocation formation in wild type and mutant diploid strains subsequent to DSB formation via HO-endonuclease cleavage were determined as described previously with slight modifications [27] . Briefly, one ml cultures of YP-Gly/Lac (2% yeast extract, 2% bacto-peptone, 3% glycerol, 3% lactic acid, pH 5.8) were inoculated with single colonies and incubated 16–24 hours at 30°C. Galactose was added to a final concentration of 2% to induce the expression of the HO-endonuclease. Southern blot analysis confirmed complete cleavage of the substrates following the addition of galactose (G. Manthey and A. Bailis, unpublished data). After four hours of induction appropriate dilutions of the culture were plated to YPD to determine cell viability and to medium lacking histidine to determining the number of histidine prototrophs. The frequency of translocation was determined by dividing the number of histidine prototrophs by the number of viable cells in the culture. Median translocation frequencies from a least 10 independent cultures were reported and the 95% confidence intervals determined using a table [117] . P values were determined using the Mann-Whitney test with the Prism (Graphpad) software package. Selected His + recombinants were subjected to genomic Southern and chromosome blot analyses as described previously (G. Manthey and A. Bailis, unpublished results) [27] . PLATING EFFICIENCIES Plating efficiencies were determined as described previously [27] . Cells containing the translocation substrates were cultured in YP-Gly/Lac medium overnight, cell counts made by hemacytometer, appropriate numbers of cells plated on to YPD agar, and the plates incubated at 30°C for three to four days. Following the addition of galactose to a final concentration of 2% and four hours of additional incubation at 30°C, cells were again counted by hemacytometer, appropriate numbers of cells plated on to YPD agar, and plates incubated at 30° for three to four days. Plating efficiency was calculated by dividing the number of colonies appearing on the YPD plates by the number of cell bodies plated and multiplying the quotient by 100. The median plating efficiencies from at least 10 independent trials were reported and the 95% confidence intervals determined from a table [117] . P values were determined using the Mann-Whitney test with the Prism (Graphpad) software package. CONTOUR-CLAMPED HOMOGENOUS ELECTRIC FIELD (CHEF) ANALYSIS Chromosomes from selected His + recombinant colonies were prepared in agarose plugs using an established protocol [120] . Chromosomes were separated on 1% agarose gels with a Bio-Rad CHEF-DR II apparatus (BioRad, Hercules, CA) using parameters that were described previously [27] . The separated chromosomes were visualized after staining with 1 µg/ml ethidium bromide for 30 min and photographed. Ethidium stained chromosomes were irradiated with 60 mJoules of UV in a Stratagene Stratalinker 1800 to nick the DNA, and destained for 30 min in deionized, distilled water. The chromosomes were transferred from the gel to a nylon membrane (Hybond N  =  , GE Healthcare, Waukesha, WI) by electroblotting with a Genie Blotter apparatus (Idea Scientific Co., Minneapolis, MN). These were probed with a 1.8 kb Bam HI HIS3 genomic clone corresponding to sequences from 469 bp upstream of the HIS3 open reading frame to 634 bp downstream that had been labeled with 32 P by random priming using a Megaprime DNA labeling kit (GE Healthcare). Blots were exposed to film, and the film developed using a Konica Minolta SRX-101A processor (Konica Minolta USA, Ramsey, NJ). SUPPORTING INFORMATION T2 frequencies in wild-type and mutant diploid strains. Median frequencies are displayed. 95% confidence intervals are in parentheses. Fold differences from wild-type are in brackets. (0.05 MB PDF) Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains used in this study. All used in this study were isogenic. Full genotypes available upon request. (0.07 MB PDF) Plating efficiencies (PE) “Pre” and “Post” HO endonuclease cutting at his3-Δ5′ and his3-Δ3′ were determined as described in the Materials and Methods . Median frequencies are displayed. 95% confidence intervals are displayed parentheses. Fold differences from wild type are indicated in brackets. (0.04 MB PDF) REFERENCES [1] Ho KS 1975 Induction of DNA double-strand breaks by X-rays in a radiosensitive strain of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Mutat Res 30 327 334 [2] Resnick MA Martin P 1976 The repair of double-strand breaks in the nuclear DNA of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and its genetic control. Mol Gen Genet 143 119 129 [3] Paques F Haber JE 1999 Multiple pathways of recombination induced by double-strand breaks in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 63 349 404 [4] Symington LS 2002 Role of RAD52 epistasis group genes in homologous recombination and double-strand break repair. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 66 630 670 [5] Prado F Cortes-Ledesma F Huertas P Aguilera A 2003 Mitotic recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Curr Genet 42 185 198 [6] Mimitou EP Symington LS 2008 Sae2, Exo1 and Sgs1 collaborate in DNA double-strand break processing. Nature 455 770 774 [7] Zhu Z Chung WH Shim EY Lee SE Ira G 2008 Sgs1 helicase and two nucleases Dna2 and Exo1 resect DNA double-strand break ends. Cell 134 981 994 [8] Sugawara N Paques F Colaiacovo M Haber JE 1997 Role of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Msh2 and Msh3 repair proteins in double-strand break-induced recombination. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 94 9214 9219 [9] New JH Sugiyama T Zaitseva E Kowalczykowski SC 1998 Rad52 protein stimulates DNA strand exchange by Rad51 and replication protein A. Nature 391 407 410 [10] Sugawara N Wang X Haber JE 2003 In vivo roles of Rad52, Rad54, and Rad55 proteins in Rad51-mediated recombination. Mol Cell 12 209 219 [11] Wolner B van Komen S Sung P Peterson CL 2003 Recruitment of the recombinational repair machinery to a DNA double-strand break in yeast. Mol Cell 12 221 232 [12] Sugawara N Ivanov EL Fishman-Lobell J Ray BL Wu X 1995 DNA structure-dependent requirements for yeast RAD genes in gene conversion. Nature 373 84 86 [13] Davis AP Symington LS 2004 RAD51-dependent break-induced replication in yeast. Mol Cell Biol 24 2344 2351 [14] Aguilera A 2001 Double-strand break repair: are Rad51/RecA—DNA joints barriers to DNA replication? Trends Genet 17 318 321 [15] McDonald JP Rothstein R 1994 Unrepaired heteroduplex DNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is decreased in RAD1 RAD52 -independent recombination. Genetics 137 393 405 [16] Ivanov EL Sugawara N Fishman-Lobell J Haber JE 1996 Genetic requirements for the single-strand annealing pathway of double-strand break repair in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Genetics 142 693 704 [17] Stark JM Pierce AJ Oh J Pastink A Jasin M 2004 Genetic steps of mammalian homologous repair with distinct mutagenic consequences. Mol Cell Biol 24 9305 9316 [18] Wu Y Kantake N Sugiyama T Kowalczykowski SC 2008 Rad51 protein controls Rad52-mediated DNA annealing. J Biol Chem 283 14883 14892 [19] Mortensen UH Bendixen C Sunjevaric I Rothstein R 1996 DNA strand annealing is promoted by the yeast Rad52 protein. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93 10729 10734 [20] Lin FL Sperle K Sternberg N 1990 Repair of double-stranded DNA breaks by homologous DNA fragments during transfer of DNA into mouse L cells. Mol Cell Biol 10 113 119 [21] Maryon E Carroll D 1991 Characterization of recombination intermediates from DNA injected into Xenopus laevis oocytes: evidence for a nonconservative mechanism of homologous recombination. Mol Cell Biol 11 3278 3287 [22] Fishman-Lobell J Rudin N Haber JE 1992 Two alternative pathways of double-strand break repair that are kinetically separable and independently modulated. Mol Cell Biol 12 1292 1303 [23] Petalcorin MI Sandall J Wigley DB Boulton SJ 2006 CeBRC-2 stimulates D-loop formation by RAD-51 and promotes DNA single-strand annealing. J Mol Biol 361 231 242 [24] Schildkraut E Miller CA Nickoloff JA 2005 Gene conversion and deletion frequencies during double-strand break repair in human cells are controlled by the distance between direct repeats. Nucleic Acids Res 33 1574 1580 [25] Preston CR Engels W Flores C 2002 Efficient repair of DNA breaks in Drosophila : evidence for single-strand annealing and competition with other repair pathways. Genetics 161 711 720 [26] Blanck S Kobbe D Hartung F Fengler K Focke M 2009 A SRS2 homolog from Arabidopsis thaliana disrupts recombinogenic DNA intermediates and facilitates single strand annealing. Nucleic Acids Res [27] Pannunzio NR Manthey GM Bailis AM 2008 Simultaneous double-strand breaks on different chromosomes initiate efficient translocation formation by single-strand annealing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . DNA Repair (Amst) 7 788 800 [28] Haber JE Leung WY 1996 Lack of chromosome territoriality in yeast: promiscuous rejoining of broken chromosome ends. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 93 13949 13954 [29] Richardson C Jasin M 2000 Frequent chromosomal translocations induced by DNA double-strand breaks. Nature 405 697 700 [30] Argueso JL Westmoreland J Mieczkowski PA Gawel M Petes TD 2008 Double-strand breaks associated with repetitive DNA can reshape the genome. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 105 11845 11850 [31] Prado F Aguilera A 1995 Role of reciprocal exchange, one-ended invasion crossover and single-strand annealing on inverted and direct repeat recombination in yeast: different requirements for the RAD1 , RAD10 , and RAD52 genes. Genetics 139 109 123 [32] Carvalho CM Lupski JR 2008 Copy number variation at the breakpoint region of isochromosome 17q. Genome Res 18 1724 1732 [33] Zhang F Gu W Hurles ME Lupski JR 2009 Copy number variation in human health, disease, and evolution. Annu Rev Genomics Hum Genet 10 451 481 [34] Colaiacovo MP Paques F Haber JE 1999 Removal of one nonhomologous DNA end during gene conversion by a RAD1 - and MSH2 -independent pathway. Genetics 151 1409 1423 [35] Sugawara N Ira G Haber JE 2000 DNA length dependence of the single-strand annealing pathway and the role of Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAD59 in double-strand break repair. Mol Cell Biol 20 5300 5309 [36] Manthey GM Naik N Bailis AM 2009 Msh2 blocks an alternative mechanism for non-homologous tail removal during single-strand Annealing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . PLoS ONE 4 e7488 [37] Lyndaker AM Alani E 2009 A tale of tails: insights into the coordination of 3′ end processing during homologous recombination. Bioessays 31 315 321 [38] Tsukamoto M Yamashita K Miyazaki T Shinohara M Shinohara A 2003 The N-terminal DNA-binding domain of Rad52 promotes RAD51 -independent recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Genetics 165 1703 1715 [39] Asleson EN Okagaki RJ Livingston DM 1999 A core activity associated with the N terminus of the yeast RAD52 protein is revealed by RAD51 overexpression suppression of C-terminal rad52 truncation alleles. Genetics 153 681 692 [40] Krejci L Song B Bussen W Rothstein R Mortensen UH 2002 Interaction with Rad51 is indispensable for recombination mediator function of Rad52. J Biol Chem 277 40132 40141 [41] Milne GT Weaver DT 1993 Dominant negative alleles of RAD52 reveal a DNA repair/recombination complex including Rad51 and Rad52. Genes Dev 7 1755 1765 [42] Shen Z Cloud KG Chen DJ Park MS 1996 Specific interactions between the human RAD51 and RAD52 proteins. J Biol Chem 271 148 152 [43] Tutt A Bertwistle D Valentine J Gabriel A Swift S 2001 Mutation in Brca2 stimulates error-prone homology-directed repair of DNA double-strand breaks occurring between repeated sequences. Embo J 20 4704 4716 [44] Larminat F Germanier M Papouli E Defais M 2002 Deficiency in BRCA2 leads to increase in non-conservative homologous recombination. Oncogene 21 5188 5192 [45] Klovstad M Abdu U Schupbach T 2008 Drosophila brca2 is required for mitotic and meiotic DNA repair and efficient activation of the meiotic recombination checkpoint. PLoS Genet 4 e31 [46] San Filippo J Chi P Sehorn MG Etchin J Krejci L 2006 Recombination mediator and Rad51 targeting activities of a human BRCA2 polypeptide. J Biol Chem 281 11649 11657 [47] Carreira A Hilario J Amitani I Baskin RJ Shivji MK 2009 The BRC repeats of BRCA2 modulate the DNA-binding selectivity of RAD51. Cell 136 1032 1043 [48] Meyer DM Bailis AM 2008 Telomerase deficiency affects the formation of chromosomal translocations by homologous recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . PLoS ONE 3 e3318 [49] Pannunzio NR Manthey GM Bailis AM 2010 RAD59 and RAD1 cooperate in translocation formation by single-strand annealing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Curr Genet 56 87 100 [50] Rong L Klein HL 1993 Purification and characterization of the SRS2 DNA helicase of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae . J Biol Chem 268 1252 1259 [51] Krejci L Van Komen S Li Y Villemain J Reddy MS 2003 DNA helicase Srs2 disrupts the Rad51 presynaptic filament. Nature 423 305 309 [52] Veaute X Jeusset J Soustelle C Kowalczykowski SC Le Cam E 2003 The Srs2 helicase prevents recombination by disrupting Rad51 nucleoprotein filaments. Nature 423 309 312 [53] Seong C Colavito S Kwon Y Sung P Krejci L 2009 Regulation of Rad51 recombinase presynaptic filament assembly via interactions with the Rad52 mediator and the Srs2 anti-recombinase. J Biol Chem 284 24363 24371 [54] Antony E Tomko EJ Xiao Q Krejci L Lohman TM 2009 Srs2 disassembles Rad51 filaments by a protein-protein interaction triggering ATP turnover and dissociation of Rad51 from DNA. Mol Cell 35 105 115 [55] Colavito S Macris-Kiss M Seong C Gleeson O Greene EC 2009 Functional significance of the Rad51-Srs2 complex in Rad51 presynaptic filament disruption. Nucleic Acids Res 37 6754 6764 [56] Davis AP Symington LS 2001 The yeast recombinational repair protein Rad59 interacts with Rad52 and stimulates single-strand annealing. Genetics 159 515 525 [57] Petukhova G Stratton SA Sung P 1999 Single strand DNA binding and annealing activities in the yeast recombination factor Rad59. J Biol Chem 274 33839 33842 [58] Wu Y Sugiyama T Kowalczykowski SC 2006 DNA annealing mediated by Rad52 and Rad59 proteins. J Biol Chem 281 15441 15449 [59] Fishman-Lobell J Haber JE 1992 Removal of nonhomologous DNA ends in double-strand break recombination: the role of the yeast ultraviolet repair gene RAD1 . Science 258 480 484 [60] Paques F Haber JE 1997 Two pathways for removal of nonhomologous DNA ends during double-strand break repair in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Mol Cell Biol 17 6765 6771 [61] Bardwell AJ Bardwell L Tomkinson AE Friedberg EC 1994 Specific cleavage of model recombination and repair intermediates by the yeast Rad1-Rad10 DNA endonuclease. Science 265 2082 2085 [62] Sung P Reynolds P Prakash L Prakash S 1993 Purification and characterization of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAD1/RAD10 endonuclease. J Biol Chem 268 26391 26399 [63] Tomkinson AE Bardwell AJ Bardwell L Tappe NJ Friedberg EC 1993 Yeast DNA repair and recombination proteins Rad1 and Rad10 constitute a single-stranded-DNA endonuclease. Nature 362 860 862 [64] Tomkinson AE Bardwell AJ Tappe N Ramos W Friedberg EC 1994 Purification of Rad1 protein from Saccharomyces cerevisiae and further characterization of the Rad1/Rad10 endonuclease complex. Biochemistry 33 5305 5311 [65] Lyndaker AM Goldfarb T Alani E 2008 Mutants defective in Rad1-Rad10-Slx4 exhibit a unique pattern of viability during mating-type switching in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Genetics 179 1807 1821 [66] Krogh BO Symington LS 2004 Recombination proteins in yeast. Annu Rev Genet 38 233 271 [67] Shinohara A Shinohara M Ohta T Matsuda S Ogawa T 1998 Rad52 forms ring structures and co-operates with RPA in single-strand DNA annealing. Genes Cells 3 145 156 [68] Kagawa W Kurumizaka H Ikawa S Yokoyama S Shibata T 2001 Homologous pairing promoted by the human Rad52 protein. J Biol Chem 276 35201 35208 [69] Burgess RC Lisby M Altmannova V Krejci L Sung P 2009 Localization of recombination proteins and Srs2 reveals anti-recombinase function in vivo. J Cell Biol 185 969 981 [70] Britten RJ Kohne DE 1968 Repeated sequences in DNA. Hundreds of thousands of copies of DNA sequences have been incorporated into the genomes of higher organisms. Science 161 529 540 [71] Schmidtke J Epplen JT 1980 Sequence organization of animal nuclear DNA. Hum Genet 55 1 18 [72] Goldberg RB 1978 DNA sequence organization in the soybean plant. Biochem Genet 16 45 68 [73] Hershfield B Swift H 1990 Characterization of a tandemly repeated DNA from the fleshfly Sarcophaga bullata . Chromosoma 99 125 130 [74] Genbauffe FS Chisholm GE Cooper TG 1984 Tau, sigma, and delta. A family of repeated elements in yeast. J Biol Chem 259 10518 10525 [75] Moore CW 1978 Bleomycin-induced mutation and recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Mutat Res 58 41 49 [76] Schiestl RH Gietz RD Mehta RD Hastings PJ 1989 Carcinogens induce intrachromosomal recombination in yeast. Carcinogenesis 10 1445 1455 [77] Fasullo M Dave P Rothstein R 1994 DNA-damaging agents stimulate the formation of directed reciprocal translocations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Mutat Res 314 121 133 [78] Fasullo M St Amour C Zeng L 2005 Enhanced stimulation of chromosomal translocations and sister chromatid exchanges by either HO-induced double-strand breaks or ionizing radiation in S accharomyces cerevisiae yku70 mutants. Mutat Res 578 158 169 [79] Coghlan A Eichler EE Oliver SG Paterson AH Stein L 2005 Chromosome evolution in eukaryotes: a multi-kingdom perspective. Trends Genet 21 673 682 [80] Shaw CJ Lupski JR 2004 Implications of human genome architecture for rearrangement-based disorders: the genomic basis of disease. Hum Mol Genet 13 Spec No 1 R57 64 [81] Saeki T Machida I Nakai S 1980 Genetic control of diploid recovery after gamma-irradiation in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Mutat Res 73 251 265 [82] Resnick MA 1975 The repair of double-strand breaks in chromosomal DNA of yeast. Basic Life Sci 5B 549 556 [83] Game JC Mortimer RK 1974 A genetic study of x-ray sensitive mutants in yeast. Mutat Res 24 281 292 [84] Vaze MB Pellicioli A Lee SE Ira G Liberi G 2002 Recovery from checkpoint-mediated arrest after repair of a double-strand break requires Srs2 helicase. Mol Cell 10 373 385 [85] Sung P 1997 Function of yeast Rad52 protein as a mediator between replication protein A and the Rad51 recombinase. J Biol Chem 272 28194 28197 [86] Song B Sung P 2000 Functional interactions among yeast Rad51 recombinase, Rad52 mediator, and replication protein A in DNA strand exchange. J Biol Chem 275 15895 15904 [87] Wu Y Siino JS Sugiyama T Kowalczykowski SC 2006 The DNA binding preference of RAD52 and RAD59 proteins: implications for RAD52 and RAD59 protein function in homologous recombination. J Biol Chem 281 40001 40009 [88] Ogawa T Yu X Shinohara A Egelman EH 1993 Similarity of the yeast RAD51 filament to the bacterial RecA filament. Science 259 1896 1899 [89] Bezzubova O Shinohara A Mueller RG Ogawa H Buerstedde JM 1993 A chicken RAD51 homologue is expressed at high levels in lymphoid and reproductive organs. Nucleic Acids Res 21 1577 1580 [90] Yoshimura Y Morita T Yamamoto A Matsushiro A 1993 Cloning and sequence of the human RecA-like gene cDNA. Nucleic Acids Res 21 1665 [91] Shinohara A Ogawa H Matsuda Y Ushio N Ikeo K 1993 Cloning of human, mouse and fission yeast recombination genes homologous to RAD51 and recA. Nat Genet 4 239 243 [92] Muris DF Vreeken K Carr AM Broughton BC Lehmann AR 1993 Cloning the RAD51 homologue of Schizosaccharomyces pombe . Nucleic Acids Res 21 4586 4591 [93] Cheng R Baker TI Cords CE Radloff RJ 1993 mei-3, a recombination and repair gene of Neurospora crassa, encodes a RecA-like protein. Mutat Res 294 223 234 [94] Maeshima K Morimatsu K Shinohara A Horii T 1995 RAD51 homologues in Xenopus laevis : two distinct genes are highly expressed in ovary and testis. Gene 160 195 200 [95] Seong KY Chae SK Kang HS 1997 Cloning of an E. coli RecA and yeast RAD51 homolog, radA, an allele of the uvsC in Aspergillus nidulans and its mutator effects. Mol Cells 7 284 289 [96] Osakabe K Yoshioka T Ichikawa H Toki S 2002 Molecular cloning and characterization of RAD51-like genes from Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Mol Biol 50 71 81 [97] Adzuma K Ogawa T Ogawa H 1984 Primary structure of the RAD52 gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae . Mol Cell Biol 4 2735 2744 [98] Bezzubova OY Schmidt H Ostermann K Heyer WD Buerstedde JM 1993 Identification of a chicken RAD52 homologue suggests conservation of the RAD52 recombination pathway throughout the evolution of higher eukaryotes. Nucleic Acids Res 21 5945 5949 [99] Muris DF Bezzubova O Buerstedde JM Vreeken K Balajee AS 1994 Cloning of human and mouse genes homologous to RAD52 , a yeast gene involved in DNA repair and recombination. Mutat Res 315 295 305 [100] Shen Z Denison K Lobb R Gatewood JM Chen DJ 1995 The human and mouse homologs of the yeast RAD52 gene: cDNA cloning, sequence analysis, assignment to human chromosome 12p12.2-p13, and mRNA expression in mouse tissues. Genomics 25 199 206 [101] Kojic M Mao N Zhou Q Lisby M Holloman WK 2008 Compensatory role for Rad52 during recombinational repair in Ustilago maydis. Mol Microbiol 67 1156 1168 [102] Sakuraba Y Schroeder AL Ishii C Inoue H 2000 A Neurospora double-strand-break repair gene, mus-11 , encodes a RAD52 homologue and is inducible by mutagens. Mol Gen Genet 264 392 401 [103] Mazloum N Zhou Q Holloman WK 2007 DNA binding, annealing, and strand exchange activities of Brh2 protein from Ustilago maydis . Biochemistry 46 7163 7173 [104] Shivji MK Mukund SR Rajendra E Chen S Short JM 2009 The BRC repeats of human BRCA2 differentially regulate RAD51 binding on single- versus double-stranded DNA to stimulate strand exchange. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 106 13254 13259 [105] Ayoub N Rajendra E Su X Jeyasekharan AD Mahen R 2009 The carboxyl terminus of Brca2 links the disassembly of Rad51 complexes to mitotic entry. Curr Biol 19 1075 1085 [106] Kolomietz E Meyn MS Pandita A Squire JA 2002 The role of Alu repeat clusters as mediators of recurrent chromosomal aberrations in tumors. Genes Chromosomes Cancer 35 97 112 [107] Stankiewicz P Shaw CJ Withers M Inoue K Lupski JR 2004 Serial segmental duplications during primate evolution result in complex human genome architecture. Genome Res 14 2209 2220 [108] Sherman F Fink GR Hicks JB 1986 Methods in yeast genetics. (Cold Spring Harbor, N Y (USA), Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory) [109] Maniatis T Fritch EF Sambrook J 1989 Molecular Cloning: A Laboratory Manual. 2, 2nd edition [110] Bailis AM Maines S Negritto MT 1995 The essential helicase gene RAD3 suppresses short-sequence recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Mol Cell Biol 15 3998 4008 [111] Ronne H Rothstein R 1988 Mitotic sectored colonies: evidence of heteroduplex DNA formation during direct repeat recombination. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 85 2696 2700 [112] Schild D Calderon R Contopoulou R Mortimer RK 1983 Cloning of yeast recombination repair genes and evidence that several are nonessential genes. Cellular Responses to DNA Damage (New York, Alan R Liss Inc) [113] Schild D Konforti B Perez C Gish W Mortimer RK 1983 Isolation and characterization of yeast DNA repair genes I. Cloning of the RAD52 Gene. Curr Genet 7 85 92 [114] Fasullo MT Davis RW 1988 Direction of chromosome rearrangements in Saccharomyces cerevisiae by use of his3 recombinational substrates. Mol Cell Biol 8 4370 4380 [115] Myers AM Tzagoloff A Kinney DM Lusty CJ 1986 Yeast shuttle and integrative vectors with multiple cloning sites suitable for construction of lacZ fusions. Gene 45 299 310 [116] Boeke JD LaCroute F Fink GR 1984 A positive selection for mutants lacking orotidine-5′-phosphate decarboxylase activity in yeast: 5-fluoro-orotic acid resistance. Mol Gen Genet 197 345 346 [117] Knight W 2006 95% Confidence Intervals for Median. http://wwwmathunbca/~knight/utility/MedInt95htm [118] Lea DE Coulson CA 1949 The distribution of numbers of mutants in bacterial populations. Journal of Genetics 49 264 285 [119] Luria SE Delbruck M 1943 Mutations of bacteria from virus sensitivity to virus resistance. Genetics 28 491 511 [120] Iadonato SP Gnirke A 1996 RARE-cleavage analysis of YACs. Methods Mol Biol 54 75 85