Morphological Diversity and the Roles of Contingency, Chance and Determinism in African Cichlid Radiations Authors: Kyle A. Young, Jos Snoeks, Ole Seehausen Published: 2009, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0004740 ABSTRACT Deterministic evolution, phylogenetic contingency and evolutionary chance each can influence patterns of morphological diversification during adaptive radiation. In comparative studies of replicate radiations, convergence in a common morphospace implicates determinism, whereas non-convergence suggests the importance of contingency or chance. The endemic cichlid fish assemblages of the three African great lakes have evolved similar sets of ecomorphs but show evidence of non-convergence when compared in a common morphospace, suggesting the importance of contingency and/or chance. We then analyzed the morphological diversity of each assemblage independently and compared their axes of diversification in the unconstrained global morphospace. We find that despite differences in phylogenetic composition, invasion history, and ecological setting, the three assemblages are diversifying along parallel axes through morphospace and have nearly identical variance-covariance structures among morphological elements. By demonstrating that replicate adaptive radiations are diverging along parallel axes, we have shown that non-convergence in the common morphospace is associated with convergence in the global morphospace. Applying these complimentary analyses to future comparative studies will improve our understanding of the relationship between morphological convergence and non-convergence, and the roles of contingency, chance and determinism in driving morphological diversification. INTRODUCTION Adaptive radiations are important sources of biodiversity, yet uncertainty persists over the degree to which such diversity results from deterministic evolution, phylogenetic contingency, and the chance ascension of different ridges in the adaptive landscape. Though relevant microevolutionary hypotheses can be tested experimentally, the macroevolutionary process of adaptive radiation in nature is best studied by comparing patterns of morphological diversity among replicate radiations of related lineages diversifying in similar environments [1] . Morphological convergence among radiations suggests deterministic evolution is strong enough a force to overcome variation in phylogenetic background and ecological setting that may differentially constrain the morphological ‘space’ available to diversifying lineages [1] – [4] . Alternatively, radiations from similar environments that are morphologically non-convergent provide evidence that contingency and/or evolutionary chance outweigh the effect of deterministic evolution [5] – [7] . Examples of convergent adaptive radiations in nature include fish from post-glacial lakes, frogs and mammals from different continents, and lizards and spiders from oceanic islands [2] , [3] , [8] – [10] . However, evolutionary communities from similar environments are often non-convergent [6] , [11] , [12] . Similarly, experimental studies using micro-organisms suggest adaptive radiation is often deterministic and convergent [13] , [14] , but also that replicate lineages diversifying in identical [6] , [7] or similar [15] environments can be non-convergent due to evolutionary chance. Here we help resolve this empirical discord using the cichlid fish assemblages from the African great lakes. The endemic cichlid fish assemblages of Lakes Victoria (LV, ≥450 sp.), Malawi (LM, ≥450 sp.) and Tanganyika (LT, ≥200 sp.) are the most speciose and ecologically diverse radiations known and uniquely suited for a comparative study of adaptive radiation. The fish communities of all three lakes are dominated by endemic assemblages that display qualitatively convergent sets of ‘ecomorphs’ occupying nearly every imaginable niche [16] – [18] . The oldest assemblage from LT is phylogenetically structured into several distinct clades which may have been seeded by multiple distantly related colonists [19] . The assemblages of LV and LM each have just one radiation of closely related species, which may have been seeded by multiple, albeit more closely related colonists [20] . The assemblages differ in age by up to three orders of magnitude (LV, 0.015–0.2 myr.; LM, 2–4 myr.; LT, 8–16 myr.) [19] , providing rare comparative insight into the temporal progress of adaptive radiation. For a single exception [10] , previous comparative studies provide limited insight into how morphological and taxonomic diversity accumulate through time because they have compared replicate adaptive radiations of similar [2] or uniformly old age [3] , [6] , [8] , [9] . The three great lake cichlid assemblages are the evolutionary equivalent of three Galapagos archipelagos of widely different age, each with hundreds of endemic species with the niches and morphologies not only of finches, but of raptors, water fowl, and gulls. We first show that when compared in a common morphospace the assemblages of endemic cichlid fishes from the three lakes show evidence of non-convergence. We then analyze patterns of morphological diversity for each assemblage independently and find that the assemblages are diversifying along common axes through the global morphospace. Together these analyses help resolve an apparent empirical discord between of convergence and non-convergence and offer a promising approach for improving our ability to determine the roles of chance, contingency and determinism in adaptive radiation. METHODS We collected digital images of the left side of representative individuals from the collections of the Natural History Museum (London, U.K.), Africa Museum (Tervuren, Belgium), Naturalis Museum (Leiden, Netherlands) and the personal collection of O.S. Importantly, Lake Victoria cichlids were sampled from collections made prior to wide spread extinctions associated with eutrophication and population expansion of introduced Nile perch ( Lates niloticus ) [21] , [22] . For 125 individuals representing the taxonomic and morphological diversity of each assemblage (supplementary material, Table S1 ) we recorded the x-y coordinates of 21 landmarks using tpsDig 1.40 [23] ( Figure 1 ). (1) anterior tip of lower jaw, (2) posterior tip of lower jaw , (3) posterior hinge of lower jaw, (4) ventral-posterior extreme of mandible plate, (5) ventral-posterior extreme of preopercle, (6) dorsal end of preopercle just below the pterotics, (7) dorsal margin of the head directly above the centre of the eye, (8) dorsal margin of the head directly above (6), (9) posterior extreme of gill-cover at opercular blotch, (10) anterior insertion of dorsal fin, (11) posterior insertion of dorsal fin, (12) dorsal insertion of caudal fin, (13) caudal border of hypural plate at the lateral line, (14) ventral insertion of caudal fin, (15) posterior insertion of anal fin, (16) anterior insertion of anal fin, (17) anterior/dorsal insertion of pelvic fin, (18) ventral insertion of pectoral fin, (19) dorsal insertion of pectoral fine, (20) anterior extreme of snout bone, (21) end of opercular membrane ventrally. We used partial warp analysis in tpsRelw version 1.42 [24] to quantify variation in shape while controlling for variation in size. The analysis scales landmarks of each specimen to a common body size, rotates each individual to a common alignment, then computes the average shape of all individuals included in the analysis to create a consensus shape. The partial warps describe the amount of stretching, bending and twisting necessary to superimpose the coordinates of all specimens onto the consensus shape. Each specimen has a weight for the x - and y components of each partial warp, with larger weight values associated with larger deviations from the consensus morphology (i.e. more extreme morphologies). The matrices of these partial warp weights are used for subsequent analyses. We do not control for phylogenetic independence in our analyses because species level phylogenies are not available for the Lake Malawi and Lake Victoria assemblages. COMPARING MORPHOLOGICAL DIVERSITY IN THE COMMON MORPHOSPACE We first followed the traditional comparative approach by including all 375 specimens in morphometric analyses of total shape (landmarks 1–21), body shape (9–19), head shape (2,7–9,20, 21), and jaw shape (1–6). We used tpsRelw to conduct principal components analysis (PCA) on the matrix of partial warp weights to yield relative warp scores, the equivalent of PCA scores for geometric morphometric data. From each analysis we retained the four relative warp axes that explained more than 5% of the variation in morphology. These axes are hereafter referred to as M max -M 4 . We compared patterns of diversity in the common morphospaces using a new approach we call the ‘ordered-axis plot’. Ordered-axis plots are constructed and analyzed as follows ( Figure 2 ). Along an axis of the common morphospace, the relative warp scores of two assemblages are first independently ordered from lowest to highest, then combined to create a set of 125 x - y points, with the older and more diverse assemblage-that with the larger range in values-placed on the x -axis. When these 125 points are plotted in a two dimensional x - y space, the intercept and slope of a simple linear regression of y on x statistically distinguish between the four possible arrangements of the two assemblages along that axis of the morphospace. If diversification during evolutionary radiation is convergent and rapid, the assemblages will be centered at the same point along the axis (intercept = 0) and be equally diverse (slope = 1) ( Figure 2A ). The assemblages may be similarly centered (int. = 0) but have age-ordered levels of diversity (slope<1) ( Figure 2B ), implying the assemblages are convergent but that morphological diversity along that axis accumulates more gradually. Alternatively, the assemblages may be equally diverse (slope = 1) but centered at different locations along an axis (int.≠0) ( Figure 2C ), suggesting diversification is rapid but non-convergent. Finally, if diversification is non-convergent and gradual, the assemblages will be centered at different locations along the axis (int.≠0) and have age-ordered levels of diversity (slope<1) ( Figure 2D ). Ordered-axis plots discriminate between different patterns of morphological diversity along axes of a multidimensional morphospace. In this example species of two adaptive radiations with the same number of observations are represented by clouds of red (older, more diverse) and blue (younger, less diverse) points in two dimensional morphospaces defined by M max and M 2 . When their values along an axis are independently ordered from smallest to largest then combined to form a set of x - y points, the slope and intercept (int.) of the linear regression of y (blue) on x (red) discriminate between four possible arrangements along that axis. The dotted line is slope = 1. Top: (A) along M max the radiations are centered at the same point (i.e. convergent) so the int. = 0, and equally diverse, so the slope = 1; (B) along M 2 the radiations are again centered at the same point (convergent, int. = 0) but the older radiation is more diverse so the slope of the regression of y on x is <1. Bottom: (C) along M max the radiations are centered at different points along the axis (non-convergent, int.≠0) but have equal levels of diversity (slope = 1); (D) along M 2 the radiations are non-convergent (int.≠0) and the older radiation is more diverse (slope<1). Ordered-axis plots have two advantages over using means and variances to test for differences in location and diversity, respectively, along axes of a common morphospace. First, they compare relative location and diversity using a single analysis associated with a simple visual representation. Second, the intercept and slope of ordered-axis plot regressions are more sensitive to extreme morphologies than tests for the equality of means and variances. Because our samples, like the assemblages themselves, are dominated by average rather than extreme phenotypes, this sensitivity is particularly important for testing whether assemblages are centered at different locations and have different levels of morphological diversity along different axes of morphospace. For comparison, for each of the 16 axes analyzed using ordered-axis plots we present the results of pairwise parametric tests for equal means ( t -tests) and variances ( F ratios) based on a table wide α = 0.003 = 0.05/16. In all our analyses the 125 values from LT, which is the oldest and most morphologically diverse assemblage, are placed on the x -axis. The 125 values from LM and LV are placed on the y -axis. Thus, the regression lines of our ordered-axis plots represent the relationship between morphological variation among species from LM and LV ( y values) versus variation among those of LT ( x value). We discriminate between the four arrangements described above along M max -M 4 using the 99.99% confidence intervals for the slopes and intercepts from 10,000 bootstrapped linear regressions of LM and LV on LT (Note the analysis does not require that assemblages have equal numbers of species, only that the same number are randomly sampled from each). We use this strict significance level because of the number tests and the sensitivity of the analysis. For graphical clarity we test for differences between LV and LM by comparing their confidence intervals from regressions on LT. The results are the same as regressing LV on LM and testing for intercept = 0 and slope = 1. COMPARING MORPHOLOGICAL DIVERSITY IN THE GLOBAL MORPHOSPACE Comparing patterns of diversity in a common morphospace requires that the diversities of the assemblages are summarized along common axes, even if the true axes of diversification actually vary among assemblages. We removed this constraint by analyzing each assemblage separately, which allows the axes of morphological divergence to be defined independently for each assemblage. We then compared these axes of diversification to test whether the three assemblages are diversifying in parallel through the unconstrained global morphospace. We recalculated the same four partial warp matrices (total, body, head and jaw shape) for each assemblage separately and conducted PCA on each partial warp matrix to yield relative warp scores. For each assemblage we again retained M max -M 4 (those axes explaining >5% of variation) for total shape and its three elements. We then tested whether the assemblages are diverging in parallel through the global morphospace using SpaceAngle6b [25] , [26] . Formally, this tests whether the angles between two assemblages’ M max axes, 2-D planes, and 3- and 4-D spaces of morphological divergence are more different than the angles between two random samples of either single assemblage. First, we calculated the 95% confidence interval (CI) for the angle between two assemblages by re-sampling 100 specimens of each assemblage with replacement and calculating the angle between them 700 times. We then tested the null hypothesis that the angle between two assemblages could result from the random subdivision of either assemblage, i.e. that the assemblages are ‘the same’. Each assemblage was randomly partitioned into two and 4900 bootstrapped angles between them calculated. Two assemblages were considered to be diversifying along non-parallel axes if the lower 95% CI for the between assemblage angle was greater than the larger of the two upper 95% CI for within assemblage estimates. For all analyses we used the maximum sample sizes and replicates allowed by the software. COMPARING MORPHOLOGICAL VARIANCE-COVARIANCE STRUCTURES The results of global morphospace analysis suggest that body, head and jaw shape covary similarly in the three assemblages. To formally test the hypothesis that the different elements of total shape covary similarly we further decomposed body, head and jaw shape into three, two and two sub-elements, respectively [upper body (9–11), caudal area (11–15), lower body (16–18), upper head (7–9), lower head (9,20,21), cheek (3–6), and lower jaw (1–3)( Figure 1 )]. Importantly, no two sub-elements share more than a single landmark, so variation in the shape of one does not strictly require or affect variation in the other. For each assemblage we conducted PCA in tpsRelw on the partial warp matrix for each of the seven sub-elements separately. For each sub-element we first confirmed that the M max scores of each assemblage had the same relationship between sign (positive and negative) and shape change. For example, we checked that for the lower jaw triangle (points 1–3 in Figure 1 ) positive M max scores corresponded to lengthening in each assemblage (in cases where they were reversed, we multiplied all values by −1). For each assemblage we then used the 125 specimens’ seven M max scores to calculate a 7×7 morphological variance-covariance matrix. We tested whether shape across the seven independent sub-elements covaried similarly by comparing the variance-covariance matrices using Mantel’s test of matrix correlation in MANTEL version 1.15 [27] with 10,000 random row permutations of one of the matrices. RESULTS The common morphospace analysis provides three insights ( Figure 3 , Table 1 ). First, despite occupying broadly overlapping regions of morphospace, the cichlid assemblages from the three African great lakes show consistent evidence of non-convergence. Figure 3A shows for each of the three elements of total shape the locations of the 375 individuals in the two dimensional morphospaces defined by M max and M 2 . The non-zero intercepts of the ordered-axis plots of LM and LV ( y -axis) regressed on LT ( x -axis) suggest that only along M max for body shape are two assemblages centered at the same point in morphospace ( Figure 3B , Table 1 ). For total shape and its three elements, along no axis explaining ≥5% of morphological diversity ( M max -M 4 ) are all three assemblages centered at the same location; along 12 of 16 axes the three assemblages are each centered at a different location ( Table 1 ). Standard t -tests detect fewer significant differences in locations along the axes. For example, for total shape and its three elements, along five axes all assemblages have the same mean, while along only three axes do all three assemblages have different means. Variation in body, head and jaw shape diversity in common morphospaces among the cichlid assemblages from Lakes Victoria (LV-green), Malawi (LM-blue) and Tanganyika (LT-pink). (A) Locations of species of the three assemblages in the three morphospaces. (B) Ordered-axis plots along M max and M 2 (with LT along the x -axis) showing the 99.99% confidence intervals of linear regressions of LV and LM on LT. Non-equal intercepts show assemblages are centered at different locations along the axis. Non-equal slopes indicate the assemblages have different levels of diversity along the axis. See Table 1 for tests of equality for the intercepts and slopes. (C) The relationship between assemblage age and relative morphological diversity (slopes of the regression of LV and LM on LT from the ordered-axis plots, with LT = 1 ) along the three M max axes. For these plots the approximate ages of the assemblages are: LV-0.1 myr., LM-2 myr., LT-10 myr. Note that the lines connecting the points are included for comparison, not to imply temporal trends in diversity of a single radiation. The results of ordered-axis plot comparisons along the first four axes ( M max -M 4 ) of total shape and its three elements. The percent of the total variance explained by each axis is presented in the first column for each analysis. The axes scores of species from Lakes Malawi (m) and Victoria (v) are regressed on those from Lake Tanganyika (defined as slope = 1, intercept = 0). Assemblages with equal intercepts are centered similarly along the axis. Assemblages with equal slopes are equally diverse along the axis. When statistically equal, the assemblages are in rank order, left to right. Equality is tested using the 99.99% confidence intervals for the slopes and intercepts from 10,000 bootstrapped linear regressions of LM and LV on LT. In parentheses below the results of ordered-axis plot regressions are results of F tests for equal variances (equal slopes) and t -tests for equal means (equal intercept) based on a table wide P  = 0.003 = 0.05/16. Second, morphological diversity appears to accumulate continually and be unrelated to species richness. For all but three of the16 axes the rank order of diversity (i.e. slopes of LM and LV on LT with LT = 1) matches that of assemblage age ( Figure 3 , Table 1 ). For example, the slopes of the ordered-axis plots ( Figure 3B ) show that along M max and M 2 for the three elements of total shape, LV is never as diverse as LT (all slopes<1) and is as diverse as LM only along M max for jaw shape. Species richness is higher in the young and middle-aged LV and LM assemblages, respectively, than in the older and morphologically more diverse LT assemblage. As before, F ratio tests for the equality of variances revealed similar patterns with fewer significant differences. Finally, morphological diversity in head and jaw shape appears to accumulate faster than in body shape. Whereas shape diversity is age-ordered along M max -body, LV is as diverse as LM along M max -jaw and LM as diverse as LT along M max -head ( Figures 3B,C ). These observations regarding the temporal accumulation of different components of morphological diversity hold regardless of the exact ages of the three assemblages, the reasonable estimates of which do not overlap [19] – [20] . TABLE: Comparison of cichlid assemblages in the common morphospace. axis total shape body shape head shape jaw shape % slope int. % slope int. % slope int. % slope int. M max 32 v