Characterization of Unique Small RNA Populations from Rice Grain Authors: Sara E. Heisel, Yuanji Zhang, Edwards Allen, Liang Guo, Tracey L. Reynolds, Xiao Yang, David Kovalic, James K. Roberts Published: 2008, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0002871 ABSTRACT Small RNAs (∼20 to 24 nucleotides) function as naturally occurring molecules critical in developmental pathways in plants and animals [1] , [2] . Here we analyze small RNA populations from mature rice grain and seedlings by pyrosequencing. Using a clustering algorithm to locate regions producing small RNAs, we classified hotspots of small RNA generation within the genome. Hotspots here are defined as 1 kb regions within which small RNAs are significantly overproduced relative to the rest of the genome. Hotspots were identified to facilitate characterization of different categories of small RNA regulatory elements. Included in the hotspots, we found known members of 23 miRNA families representing 92 genes, one trans acting siRNA (ta-siRNA) gene, novel siRNA-generating coding genes and phased siRNA generating genes. Interestingly, over 20% of the small RNA population in grain came from a single foldback structure, which generated eight phased 21-nt siRNAs. This is reminiscent of a newly arising miRNA derived from duplication of progenitor genes [3] , [4] . Our results provide data identifying distinct populations of small RNAs, including phased small RNAs, in mature grain to facilitate characterization of small regulatory RNA expression in monocot species. INTRODUCTION Rice is one of the world's most important food crops, as it is produced in over 100 countries and is a staple food for half of the world's population (OECD, 2004). In addition to the importance of rice as a food staple, its genetic synteny, ease of transformation and an assembled genome [5] make it a model system for the study of cereal grasses. The importance of small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) and microRNAs (miRNAs) in plant developmental regulation have made the investigation of small RNA populations an important aspect in understanding the regulation of higher plant genomes and processes. Classes of small RNAs including miRNAs, ta-siRNAs, and nat-siRNAs regulate important developmental and physiological processes in land plants and most regulatory small RNAs and target genes are conserved among higher plants [1] , [2] , [6] . In general, these classes of regulatory RNAs suppress gene expression by inhibition of translation or destabilization of target mRNAs in trans . miRNAs and ta-siRNAs are derived from distinct transcriptional units that either form internal foldback structures or recruit a specific RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRP) RDR6. Additional endogenous siRNAs often associated with repetitive elements have also been characterized that are processed from long double stranded RNA (dsRNA), and function to silence transcription in cis through modification of the chromatin state. As in-depth annotation and functional gene network relationships are developed for rice, the analysis of small RNA expression will facilitate a deeper understanding of these relationships. An extensive and diverse population of small RNAs have been identified in Arabidopsis and rice utilizing high throughput sequencing methods [3] , [7] – [14] , however only developing or stressed tissues were evaluated [15] – [17] . In an attempt to gain a broader understanding of gene expression in rice grain, we characterized small RNA populations from Oryza sativa spp. japonica cv. Nipponbare utilizing a deep sequencing approach. As approximately 70% of all human food consumption is derived from seeds [18] it is important to understand the role of small RNAs in seed development given the known roles of miRNAs in organ identity, morphogenesis, and polarity in actively growing tissues. Seed development is a highly regulated and coordinated process involving deposition of seed storage reserves, novel morphogenic events to define the embryo and endosperm, and maturation drying and quiescence. Grain in the dormant state is typically characterized by little or no active translation, given this and the known roles of miRNAs in developing tissues only actively growing tissues have previously been analyzed in depth. The regulatory role of small RNAs in repression of gene expression could potentially provide an important mechanism in establishing or maintaining the dormant state in grain or altering storage reserves. In this study, we have initiated the sequencing of the small RNA population from rice grain and seedlings to determine the abundance and role of miRNAs and other small RNAs in both dormant and growing tissues. RESULTS Small RNA libraries were constructed from three pools of mature, dormant rice grain and three-week post germination seedlings utilizing RNA-adapter mediated ligation [19] , [20] . Each of the four libraries were independently sequenced using high-throughput pyrosequencing [21] . We obtained a total of 679,146 sequences from the three rice grain libraries and 257,394 from one rice seedling library ( Table 1 ). Greater than 41% of these sequences represent unique reads. Grain and seedling small RNAs were similar in size distributions with distinct peaks at 21- and 24-nt ( Figure S1 ). Consistent with previous reports, the 21-nt small RNAs comprised many redundant reads, whereas the 24-nt class comprised primarily unique or low abundance reads. In seedling, greater than 30% of the ∼21-nt redundant reads matched to known miRNAs. Despite a similar distribution of ∼21-nt redundant sequences in grain, less than 5% could be accounted for by previously characterized miRNAs. The majority of these small RNAs were from non-repetitive elements, suggesting either many novel grain specific miRNAs or alternative siRNA generating loci such as nat- or ta-siRNAs. These data represent the first large scale sequencing of small RNAs from mature rice grain and an opportunity to assess the role of small RNAs in grain. Defined as perfect match to the entire small RNA. Repeats were masked by RepeatMasker and Tandem Repeats Finder (with period of 12 or less). Only complementary matches were considered except noted. TABLE: Genome and transcriptome matches to rice small RNA sequences. Size (MB) match a match a percentage (%) Grain Seedling Total Grain Seedling Total Total small RNAs n/a 679,146 257,394 936,540 n/a n/a n/a Unique small RNAs n/a 285,873 108,485 386,633 100 100 100 Perfect matches to genomes Oryza sativa 378 242,442 98,747 334,012 84.81 91.02 86.39 Populus trichocarpa 427 14,521 3,535 16,374 5.08 3.26 4.24 Arabidopsis thaliana 120 13,288 3,079 14,820 4.65 2.84 3.83 Chlamydomonas reinhardtii 105 5,876 961 6,280 2.06 0.89 1.62 Homo sapien 2,881 4,753 1,325 5,753 1.66 1.22 1.49 Homo sapien b 1,474 1,736 664 2,320 0.61 0.61 0.60 Caenorhabditis elegans 100 1,730 345 1,898 0.61 0.32 0.49 Drosophila melanogaster 118 621 162 752 0.22 0.15 0.19 Magnaporthe grisea 39 1,113 187 1,181 0.39 0.17 0.31 Giardia lamblia 11 539 107 569 0.19 0.10 0.15 Perfect matches to transcriptomes c Oryza sativa 104 37,616 10,050 46,565 13.16 9.26 12.04 Oryza sativa (both strands) 104 92,392 22,545 110,665 32.32 20.78 28.62 Homo sapien 105 256 66 300 0.09 0.06 0.08 Drosophila melanogaster 45 119 18 132 0.04 0.02 0.03 Transcript matches in complementary to small RNAs Oryza sativa 104 25,064 13,789 26,892 39.89 21.94 42.80 Homo sapien 105 1,647 85 1,704 3.95 0.20 4.08 Transcript matches in sense strand to small RNAs Oryza sativa 104 26,590 15,348 29,179 42.32 24.42 46.44 Homo sapien 105 1,792 133 1,867 4.29 0.32 4.47 Transcript matches in both strands to small RNAs Oryza sativa 104 18,978 10,108 20,763 30.21 16.09 33.05 Homo sapien 105 1,187 1 1,193 2.84 0.00 2.86 CONSERVATION OF SMALL RNAS IN PLANTS AND ANIMALS To contribute to our understanding of small RNA function and conservation, we compared rice small RNA sequences to genomes of species representing important lineages throughout evolution. We found the highest conservation among plant species with a lesser percentage similarity among distantly related species. For example, there are 13,288 matches between the rice grain small RNA and Arabidopsis thaliana genome and 621 between the rice grain small RNA and Drosophila melanogaster genome. As previously reported [22] there is little conservation of small RNAs between rice and any animal species tested ( Table 1 ). Small RNAs conserved among distantly related non-animal species were generally low abundance sequences, whereas the highly abundant miRNAs were conserved among plants. While more small RNAs, primarily miRNAs, are conserved among plants, many small RNAs were also found with perfect homology to sequences in human and other animal transcriptomes ( Table 1 ). The majority of rice small RNAs matched to unannotated intergenic regions, with only 29% matching to the rice transcriptome, including 12% to the complement. Sequences unmatched to the rice genome were likely a result of sequencing errors or from regions of the rice genome that remain unmapped. Here, we have not removed small RNAs matching to rRNAs, tRNAs, or sn/snoRNAs from the analysis as these are unlikely to be mRNA degradation products due to the requirement for a 5′ phosphate group in the cloning protocol. However, because these small RNAs could have multiple genomic origins, we have normalized to genome copy number to help remove this potential error. We have also chosen to keep these small RNAs in the analysis group, as interesting new classes of small RNAs from similar repeat regions have been reported (piwi-RNAs) and from alternative size classes [23] . CATEGORIZATION OF SMALL RNA POPULATIONS THROUGH HOTSPOT DETERMINATION The three replicates of rice grain libraries allow us to estimate expression and assess the quality and coverage of each sequencing reaction. Amongst the three replicates, we obtained 285,873 unique sequences, however little overlap was observed among these sequences in independent libraries. We found only ∼1.4% of unique sequences were shared among all three replicates, and only ∼5.9% between at least two replicates ( Figure 1a ). This illustrates that despite the high number of sequences obtained; the endogenous rice grain small RNA population is far greater than captured by our sequencing effort. Venn diagrams illustrate overlap among rice grain replicate libraries (a) unique small RNAs or (b) 1-kb clustered hot spots ( P <1E-50). The total number of unique sequences or hotspots from each replicate is in parentheses. While miRNAs represent a significant portion of the total number of sequences obtained, in comparison they represent a minor component of the unique small RNA population. In contrast, small RNAs from repetitive loci are disperse and may account for the low overlap among unique sequences from replicate libraries [10] . To determine if clustering small RNAs from specific loci would result in greater overlap of replicates, we calculated hotspots individually for each grain library replicate. Hotspots were identified by dividing the genome into 1-kb bins and small RNA abundance was calculated for each strand of the genome separately. We calculated a P value for each bin and defined hotspots as P 0.87. (b) Low molecular weight RNA blot analysis of rice miRNAs identified from hotspots in rice, maize, and soy. (c) Validation of predicted targets for 3 novel miRNAs. Positions of the dominant 5′ RACE products (sequences with 5′ ends at position/total sequences for 5′ ends) are indicated. Bolded nucleotide indicates predicted cleavage site. The unique small RNA sequences from grain and seedling were significantly different, which could reflect either lack of sequence coverage to fully capture the complexity of the small RNA population, or regions of small RNA expression unique to each tissue. To subvert this obstacle we evaluated genomic regions by categorizing 1 Kb regions (as described above), rather than individual small RNA sequences. This changed the overlap of the three rice grain replicates to 67% for 1 Kb bins over 1.4% overlap that was found when unique sequences were compared ( Figure 1 ). For analysis of the three rice grain library replicates, we used the average normalized tpq. Using a cutoff of P 450 genes in Arabidopsis and >600 in rice [42] , [43] . Although it is not surprising to see miRNA genes derived from a rapidly expanding gene family, the preference to maintain suppression elements specific to a specific clade of PPR genes both in Arabidopsis and rice is curious. One possible model is that maintenance of proper gene dosage from this PPR clade is critical to plant fertility. Fertility restoration genes (Rf) have been found to contain PPR motifs, and mutations lead to cytoplasmic male sterility. Rapid evolution of miRNA and ta-siRNA genes from PPR progenitor genes may offer a mechanism to suppress aberrant or excess transcripts to prevent reduced fertility [3] , [12] . In Arabidopsis, small RNAs principally of the 24-nt class, accumulated in pericentromeric regions [10] , [13] whereas we observed a very different distribution in rice. Small RNA hotspots were more randomly distributed across the chromosomes, with 21-nt loci including miRNA and phased siRNA genes more readily apparent. This may be reflected in the tissues used for analysis, as epigenetic states should be established in mature grain and therefore accumulation of heterochromatin associated siRNAs is not required to the extent it would be in growing floral or vegetative tissues. Small RNA hotspot clusters accounted for over 53% and 49% of the total small RNA abundance in grain and seedling, respectively. In both tissues, clusters were confined to a very small proportion of the rice genome indicative of unique small RNA generating genes, many with unknown function. Many of these hotspots were not attributable to novel miRNAs or other characterized classes of small RNA generating loci; characterization of these genes is likely to reveal interesting and new mechanisms for gene regulation in plants. A striking finding was the abundance of 21-nt siRNAs specific to rice grain that were not attributable to miRNAs. We identified hotspots expressing extraordinarily abundant 21-nt phased siRNAs (Os06g21900) or disperse ∼21-nt siRNAs (Chr. 1 HAP5 genes, Os01g01290) specific to dormant grain. Similar miRNA-like genes have been described in Arabidopsis [4] , [12] , from which multiple, phased 21-nt siRNAs dependent primarily on DCL4 are expressed. In contrast, the phased siRNA genes in rice showed a far stricter phasing (out-of-phase siRNAs did not accumulate), and expression of nearly all phases were equivalent to expression of conserved miRNAs. The phased siRNA precursor at Os06g21900 displays similarity to POT family nitrate transporters, consistent with a model in which miRNA genes derive from inverted duplication of progenitor genes [3] , [4] , [12] . In addition to abundant grain specific phased siRNAs, three HAP5 loci were found that generate an extraordinary number of 21-nt siRNAs across the length of the transcript. These transcripts could represent nat-siRNA loci, although we were unable to identify any antisense cDNAs or MPSS data indicating antisense PolII transcription. This could be due to the lack of available transcript/cDNA from mature rice grain. There is no evidence for inverted repeats from the transcribed regions at these loci, indicating that these (siRNAs) are unlikely to be DCL4 products Together with HAP2 and HAP3 proteins, HAP5 forms a ternary CCAAT transcription factor complex. This complex has known roles in controlling expression of seed storage protein genes in Arabidopsis [44] , [45] . Our finding that, a subset of HAP5 genes generate such a large number of siRNAs in mature seed suggest post-transcriptional regulation of the HAP complex, potentially involved in modulating seed storage proteins. From the scope of all small RNA space, we observed that the reverse complementary match to the rice transcriptome is 40% over-represented for the unique grain small RNAs versus those from the seedling ( Table 1 . 13% vs. 9%). This over-representation of potential transcription repressors in grain might facilitate maintaining a general expression suppression state in the dormant grain stage. Further investigation into the roles of these siRNAs could lend insight into biology of seeds and the roles of these distinct populations of siRNAs. All data will be deposited into NCBI GEO upon publication of this manuscript. METHODS Oryza sativa spp. japonica cv. Nipponbare was used for small RNA library construction and Northern blot analysis. Plant material for RNA isolation was obtained from dehulled mature grain and 23 day old seedlings planted from the same seed lot and grown in a greenhouse under non-stress conditions. RNA was isolated for Northern analysis from Zea mays var. LH244 leaves, roots (both at stage V6), and 32–39 day after pollination kernels; Glycine max var. A3525 trifoliate leaves, roots, and S3 to S5 seed; and Arabidopsis thaliana ecotype Columbia-0. Seed for dcl1- 7 (CS3089) and dcl4-1 (GK_106G05) were obtained from the Arabidopsis Biological Resource Center. A. thaliana was transformed with a CaMV 35S binary expression vector using the floral dip method, and events containing a single T-DNA insertion selected. Total RNA was isolated from plant tissues using TRIzol reagent (Invitrogen). CONSTRUCTION AND COMPUTATIONAL ANALYSIS OF SMALL RNA LIBRARIES Small RNA library construction was performed as described previously [20] . Three micrograms of each small RNA cDNA library was sent to 454 Life Sciences for sequencing. Small RNA inserts in the raw sequences were parsed by locating the 5′ and 3′ adaptors to obtain strand and position information by Perl scripts. Small RNAs of 18–26 nt were compared with genomes using BLAST ( Table S1 for databases used). To compare small RNA expression from different libraries, abundance was calculated as transcripts per quarter million sequences (tpq) [8] , [10] . Normalized abundance was determined as tpq divided by the number of perfect matches to the rice genome. To determine small RNA expression hotspots in the rice genome, each chromosome was divided into 1-kb bins and small RNAs were assigned to specific bins. In cases where small RNAs were divided between bins, the 5′ end of the small RNA was used to determine in which bin it should be placed. Normalized small RNA abundances with each bin were summed to give the total abundance of the bin. STATISTICAL ANALYSES See Methods S1 for detailed description of statistical methods used in analysis. SMALL RNA BLOTTING AND HYBRIDIZATION Five micrograms of total RNA was separated on a 17% PAGE-urea gel and blotted as previously described [4] . Complementary oligonucleotide probes specific to small RNA sequences were end labeled with γ 32 P-ATP using OptiKinase (USB Corporation) [46] . Probe sequences are listed in Table S3 . LNA probes were ordered for miRMON13 and miRMON27. Oligo probes for ta-siR255, miR173, and phased siRNAs in Arabidopsis were end-labeled with digoxygenin according to the manufacturer's recommendation (Roche). Probe sequences are listed in Table S3 . TARGET VALIDATION Target Validation using a 5′ RACE assay was done with the GeneRacer Kit (Invitrogen). Poly(A) mRNA was isolated from 3 week old rice seedling tissue, ligated to the adaptor, converted to cDNA and PCR amplified, using gene-specific and adaptor-specific primers. PCR products were gel purified, cloned and sequenced. Successfully validated miRNA target gene-specific primer sequences are shown in Table S3 . SUPPORTING INFORMATION (a) The majority of small RNAs matched to miRNAs, rRNA repeats, and transposable elements. Annotated miRNAs from miRBase accounted for 33.0% of seedling small RNAs and 2.4% from grain. (b) The size distribution of small RNA populations from grain and seedling were similar, with 21-nt small RNAs as the most abundant class, followed by the 24-nt class. (0.08 MB AI) Small RNA expression from grain and seedling libraries, calculated as transcripts per quarter million (tpq) across the twelve rice chromosomes. Abundance was normalized by dividing small RNA tpq by the number of perfect matches in the rice genome. For rice grain, the average tpq of the three libraries was used. Centromere position is indicated by a circle and bins containing small RNA hotspots are indicated in red. Each bar represents a 100 kb bin. A ceiling of 500 tpq was used. Location of phased siRNAs are indicated by an asterisk (*). The majority of rice or monocot specific miRNAs are represented by a single locus. (0.55 MB PDF) Alignment of the foldback structure regions of exon 3 and the reverse complement of exon 2 from Os06g21900 with putative progenitor genes. Conserved positions are highlighted as follows: 7/7 red, 5/7 or 6/7 orange, 4/7 yellow, 3/7 green (including at least one conserved base in Os06g21900 foldback). (0.09 MB PDF) Sources of genome and transcriptome data. (0.02 MB XLS) Small RNA hotspots from rice. (0.10 MB XLS) Small RNA probes for Northern blot analysis & Target Validation (0.02 MB XLS) Predicted Targets for miRMON13 and miRMON18. (0.02 MB XLS) Statistical methods used in hotspot determination. (0.05 MB DOC) Sequence of phased siRNA precursor Os06g21900 (0.02 MB DOC) REFERENCES [1] Jones-Rhoades MW Bartel DP Bartel B 2006 MicroRNAs and their regulatory roles in plants. Annu Rev Plant Biol 57 [2] Mallory AC Vaucheret H 2006 Functions of microRNAs and related small RNAs in plants. Nat Genet 38 Suppl [3] Fahlgren N Howell MD Kasschau KD Chapman EJ Sullivan CM 2007 High-Throughput Sequencing of Arabidopsis microRNAs: Evidence for Frequent Birth and Death of MIRNA Genes. PLoS ONE 2 e219 [4] Allen E Xie Z Gustafson AM Sung GH Spatafora JW 2004 Evolution of microRNA genes by inverted duplication of target gene sequences in Arabidopsis thaliana . Nat Genet 36 1282 90 [5] Gale MD Devos KM 1998 Plant comparative genetics after 10 years. Science 282 656 659 [6] Brodersen P Voinnet O 2006 The diversity of RNA silencing pathways in plants. Trends Genet 22 [7] Nobuta K Venu RC Lu C Belo A Vemaraju K 2007 An expression atlas of rice mRNAs and small RNAs. Nat Biotech 25 473 477 [8] Lu C Tej SS Luo S Haudenschild CD Meyers BC 2005 Elucidation of the small RNA component of the transcriptome. Science 309 1567 1569 [9] Qi Y He X Wang XJ Kohany O Jurka J 2006 Distinct catalytic and non-catalytic roles of ARGONAUTE4 in RNA-directed DNA methylation. Nature 443 1008 1012 [10] Lu C Kulkarni K Souret FF MuthuValliappan R Tej SS 2006 MicroRNAs and other small RNAs enriched in the Arabidopsis RNA-dependent RNA polymerase-2 mutant. Genome Res 16 1276 1288 [11] Henderson IR Zhang X Lu C Johnson L Meyers BC 2006 Dissecting Arabidopsis thaliana DICER function in small RNA processing, gene silencing and DNA methylation patterning. Nat Genet 38 721 725 [12] Rajagopalan R Vaucheret H Trejo J Bartel DP 2006 A diverse and evolutionarily fluid set of microRNAs in Arabidopsis thaliana. Genes Dev 20 3407 3425 [13] Kasschau KD Fahlgren N Chapman EJ Sullivan CM Cumbie JS 2007 Genome-Wide Profiling and Analysis of Arabidopsis siRNAs. PLoS Biol 5 e57 [14] Johnson C Bowman L Adai AT Vance V Sundaresan V 2007 CSRDB: a small RNA integrated database and browser resource for cereals. Nucleic Acids Res 35 D829 D833 [15] Liu B Li P Li X Liu C Cao S 2005 Loss of Function of OsDCL1 Affects MicroRNA Accumulation and Causes Developmental Defects in Rice. Plant Physiol 139 296 305 [16] Sunkar R Girke T Zhu JK 2005 Identification and characterization of endogenous small interfering RNAs from rice. Nucleic Acids Res 33 [17] Luo YC Zhou H Li Y Chen JY Yang JH 2006 Rice embryogenic calli express a unique set of microRNAs, suggesting regulatory roles of microRNAs in plant post-embryogenic development. FEBS Lett 580 5111 5116 [18] Bewley JD Black M 1994 Seeds physiology of development and germination New York Plenum Press [19] Lau NC Lim EP Weinstein EG Bartel DP 2001 An abundant class of tiny RNAs with probable regulatory roles in Caenorhabditis elegans. Science 294 858 862 [20] Llave C Kasschau KD Rector MA Carrington JC 2002 Endogenous and silencing-associated small RNAs in plants. Plant Cell 14 1605 19 [21] Margulies M Egholm M Altman WE Attiya S Bader JS 2005 Genome sequencing in microfabricated high-density picolitre reactors. Nature 437 376 380 [22] Axtell MJ Bartel DP 2005 Antiquity of microRNAs and their targets in land plants. Plant Cell 17 [23] Katiyar-Agarwal S Gao S Vivian-Smith A Jin H 2007 A novel class of bacteria-induced small RNAs in Arabidopsis. Genes and Development 21 3123 3134 [24] Griffiths-Jones S 2006 miRBase: the microRNA sequence database. Methods Mol Biol 342 129 138 [25] Ambros V Bartel B Bartel DP Burge CB Carrington JC 2003 A uniform system for microRNA annotation. RNA 9 277 9 [26] Allen E Xie Z Gustafson AM Carrington JC 2005 microRNA-directed phasing during trans-acting siRNA biogenesis in plants. Cell 121 207 21 [27] Rhoades MW Reinhart BJ Lim LP Burge CB Bartel B 2002 Prediction of plant microRNA targets. Cell 110 513 520 [28] Ronemus M Vaughn MW Martienssen RA 2006 MicroRNA-targeted and small interfering RNA-mediated mRNA degradation is regulated by argonaute, dicer, and RNA-dependent RNA polymerase in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 18 1559 1574 [29] Wang Y Ribot C Rezzonico E Poirier Y 2004 Structure and expression profile of the Arabidopsis PHO1 gene family indicates a broad role in inorganic phosphate homeostasis. Plant Physiol 135 400 411 [30] Sunkar R Zhu JK 2004 Novel and stress-regulated microRNAs and other small RNAs from Arabidopsis . Plant Cell 16 2001 2019 [31] Borsani O Zhu J Verslues PE Sunkar R Zhu JK 2005 Endogenous siRNAs Derived from a Pair of Natural cis-Antisense Transcripts Regulate Salt Tolerance in Arabidopsis. Cell 123 1279 1291 [32] Hammond SM 2005 Dicing and slicing: the core machinery of the RNA interference pathway. FEBS Lett 579 [33] Qiu S Adema CM Lane T 2005 A computational study of off-target effects of RNA interference. Nucleic Acids Res 33 [34] Yoshikawa M Peragine A Park MY Poethig RS 2005 A pathway for the biogenesis of trans-acting siRNAs in Arabidopsis. Genes Dev 19 2164 2175 [35] Liu B Chen Z Song X Liu C Cui X 2007 Oryza sativa Dicer-like4 Reveals a Key Role for Small Interfering RNA Silencing in Plant Development. The Plant Cell 19 2705 2718 [36] Kurihara Y Watanabe Y 2004 Arabidopsis micro-RNA biogenesis through Dicer-like 1 protein functions. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 101 12753 8 [37] Xie Z Johansen LK Gustafson AM Kasschau KD Lellis AD 2004 Genetic and functional diversification of small RNA pathways in plants. PLoS Biol 2 E104 [38] Chan SW Zilberman D Xie Z Johansen LK Carrington JC 2004 RNA silencing genes control de novo DNA methylation. Science 303 1336 [39] Zilberman D Cao X Jacobsen SE 2003 ARGONAUTE4 control of locus-specific siRNA accumulation and DNA and histone methylation. Science 299 716 719 [40] Meyers BC Lee DK Vu TH Tej SS Edberg SB 2004 Arabidopsis MPSS. An online resource for quantitative expression analysis. Plant Physiol 135 801 813 [41] Yao Y Guo G Ni Z Sunkar R Du J 2007 Cloning and characterization of microRNAs from wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Genome Biology 8 R96 [42] Lurin C Andres C Aubourg S Bellaoui M Bitton F 2004 Genome-wide analysis of Arabidopsis pentatricopeptide repeat proteins reveals their essential role in organelle biogenesis. Plant Cell tpc.104.022236 [43] Small ID Peeters N 2000 The PPR motif - a TPR-related motif prevalent in plant organellar proteins. Trends Biochem Sci 25 46 7 [44] Kagaya Y Toyoshima R Okuda R Usui H Yamamoto A 2005 LEAFY COTYLEDON1 controls seed storage protein genes through its regulation of FUSCA3 and ABSCISIC ACID INSENSITIVE3. Plant Cell Physiol 46 399 406 [45] Santos MM Dubreucq B Miquel M Caboche M Lepiniec L 2005 LEAFY COTYLEDON 2 activation is sufficient to trigger the accumulation of oil and seed specific mRNAs in Arabidopsis leaves. FEBS Lett 579 4666 4670 [46] Xie Z Allen E Fahlgren N Calamar A Givan SA 2005 Expression of Arabidopsis MIRNA Genes. Plant Physiol