Marine Incursion: The Freshwater Herring of Lake Tanganyika Are the Product of a Marine Invasion into West Africa Authors: Anthony B. Wilson, Guy G. Teugels, Axel Meyer Published: 2008, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0001979 ABSTRACT The spectacular marine-like diversity of the endemic fauna of Lake Tanganyika, the oldest of the African Great Lakes, led early researchers to suggest that the lake must have once been connected to the ocean. Recent geophysical reconstructions clearly indicate that Lake Tanganyika formed by rifting in the African subcontinent and was never directly linked to the sea. Although the Lake has a high proportion of specialized endemics, the absence of close relatives outside Tanganyika has complicated phylogeographic reconstructions of the timing of lake colonization and intralacustrine diversification. The freshwater herring of Lake Tanganyika are members of a large group of pellonuline herring found in western and southern Africa, offering one of the best opportunities to trace the evolutionary history of members of Tanganyika's biota. Molecular phylogenetic reconstructions indicate that herring colonized West Africa 25–50MYA, at the end of a major marine incursion in the region. Pellonuline herring subsequently experienced an evolutionary radiation in West Africa, spreading across the continent and reaching East Africa's Lake Tanganyika during its early formation. While Lake Tanganyika has never been directly connected with the sea, the endemic freshwater herring of the lake are the descendents of an ancient marine incursion, a scenario which may also explain the origin of other Tanganyikan endemics. INTRODUCTION Ancient lakes are home to disproportionate levels of freshwater biodiversity. As standing bodies of water which have existed for at least 100,000 years [1] , these habitats have been remarkably stable when compared to more typically transitory freshwater environments. As a consequence, lakes such as Lake Baikal (25–30 MY) and the African Great Lakes Malawi (1–2 MY) and Tanganyika (9–12 MY) all contain exceptionally high numbers of freshwater taxa, of which up to 99% are endemics [2] . Habitat stability is thought to promote niche partitioning and resource specialization, providing an important engine for speciation [3] . Due to the relative stability of ancient lakes, these habitats have long been recognized as centers of spectacular adaptive radiation, exemplified by the highly specialized cichlid fishes of the African Great Lakes [4] , [5] . This pattern of often rapid in situ adaptive radiation has also been documented in other groups of fishes [6] and invertebrates [7] – [9] . At the same time, there is a growing appreciation that in addition to their role as centers of diversification, ancient lakes have also played an important role as evolutionary reservoirs, maintaining diverse groups of organisms that have been extirpated outside their borders [10] – [13] . While each of the African Great Lakes is home to high levels of endemic biodiversity, Lake Tanganyika is distinguished from Lakes Malawi and Victoria by the taxonomic breadth and morphological diversity of its endemic fauna. Freshwater lineages of crustaceans and gastropods found in the lake exhibit striking morphological similarities to marine species and cnidarians and clupeiform fishes, groups typically restricted to marine environments, are also found within the lake [14] . Due to strong morphological affinities between Lake Tanganyika's fauna and marine organisms, early investigators proposed that the lake must have been directly connected to the ocean at some point in its history [15] , [16] . Subsequent investigations of the geology of the region however indicate that the African Great Lakes were formed by rifting in the African subcontinent and were thus never in direct contact with the ocean [17] , [18] . While the hypothesis of a direct marine connection [16] appears invalid, the enigma of the “Tanganyika Problem” remains unanswered: namely, how did such a specialized and unique freshwater biota come to be found within the Lake? Unfortunately, attempts to elucidate the evolutionary origins of Tanganyikan endemics have been hampered by the absence of close relatives outside the lake. While Tanganyika appears to have been colonized by at least four ancient lineages of gastropods [12] and eight seeding lineages of cichlid fishes [11] , the colonization history of these groups cannot be easily traced due to the absence of close extant and/or fossil relatives in the African subcontinent. While clupeid fishes dominate marine fish communities and anadromous populations inhabit brackish waters, freshwater diversity of this group is typically low. West Africa is home to the largest evolutionary radiation of freshwater clupeid fishes [19] , including at least twenty species of the subfamily Pellonulinae. The pellonuline herring of West Africa exhibit striking adaptations for life in freshwater, including carnivorous forms with large canine teeth ( Cyanothrissa and Odaxothrissa ), species almost completely lacking scales ( Thrattidion ) and a general tendency towards reduced size, exemplified by species that attain sexual maturity at less than 20 mm SL ( Thrattidion and Sierrathrissa ) [20] . Pellonuline herring are also found in southern and central Africa and Madagascar as well as Australia, India and eastern Asia [21] . Two pellonuline species are endemic to Lake Tanganyika, where they are dominant members of the pelagic zone [22] . A comprehensive treatment of fossil and recent clupeomorph fishes has questioned the monophyly of clupeid subfamilies, including the pellonulines [21] . The pellonuline herring of Africa appear to fall into two major groups, the Pellonulini, a tribe containing taxa from western and central Africa, and the Ehiravini, a tribe of herring from southern Africa and India [21] . A more recent morphological investigation of African pellonuline herring supported this hypothesis and suggested that the herring of Lake Tanganyika are closely allied with those of West Africa [19] . A clear understanding of the historical biogeography of pellonuline herring may be one of our best opportunities to reconstruct the evolutionary history of members of the unique fauna of Lake Tanganyika. Here, we construct a phylogeny of clupeiform fishes based on three mitochondrial DNA genes and use a multipoint fossil calibration to determine both the timing of freshwater colonization of Africa by pellonuline herring and the timing of the colonization and diversification of herring within Lake Tanganyika. Molecular phylogenetic reconstructions reject the monophyly of pellonuline herring and support strong affinities between the endemic herring of Tanganyika and freshwater pellonulines found in western Africa. Molecular clock analyses indicate that the colonization of African freshwater by marine herring occurred during the Eocene (25–50 MYA), at the end of a period of major marine incursion in West Africa [Fig. 1; 23] . Herring subsequently spread across central Africa, colonizing Lake Tanganyika and diversifying into the two present-day endemics 2–16 MYA. RESULTS Mitochondrial sequences of 12S rDNA, 16S rDNA and cytochrome b (Cyt b ) were collected, collated and aligned for 49 species (90 specimens), resulting in a total sequence length of between 1,360 and 2,510 bp per specimen. Despite repeated attempts to amplify Cyt b from Spratelloides robustus (H101), this individual failed to yield any PCR product for this gene. While a ML homogeneity test rejected congruency of sequences from the three target loci (p<0.003 for all topologies), sequence data were concatenated in accordance with a total evidence approach [24] . Analyses of Cyt b sequence data revealed saturation of third codon transitions for Kimura-2-parameter distances greater than 0.40, a pattern confirmed by a statistical test [25] which indicated substantial saturation at third codon positions (Iss