Trade-Offs between the Metabolic Rate and Population Density of Plants Authors: Jian-Ming Deng, Tao Li, Gen-Xuan Wang, Jing Liu, Ze-Long Yu, Chang-Ming Zhao, Ming-Fei Ji, Qiang Zhang, Jian-quan Liu Published: 2008, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0001799 ABSTRACT The energetic equivalence rule, which is based on a combination of metabolic theory and the self-thinning rule, is one of the fundamental laws of nature. However, there is a progressively increasing body of evidence that scaling relationships of metabolic rate vs . body mass and population density vs . body mass are variable and deviate from their respective theoretical values of 3/4 and −3/4 or −2/3. These findings questioned the previous hypotheses of energetic equivalence rule in plants. Here we examined the allometric relationships between photosynthetic mass ( M p ) or leaf mass ( M L ) vs. body mass ( β ); population density vs. body mass ( δ ); and leaf mass vs . population density, for desert shrubs, trees, and herbaceous plants, respectively. As expected, the allometric relationships for both photosynthetic mass (i.e. metabolic rate) and population density varied with the environmental conditions. However, the ratio between the two exponents was −1 (i.e. β / δ  = −1) and followed the trade-off principle when local resources were limited. Our results demonstrate for the first time that the energetic equivalence rule of plants is based on trade-offs between the variable metabolic rate and population density rather than their constant allometric exponents. INTRODUCTION Many studies of mammals suggested that the relationship between basal metabolic rate and body mass can be expressed as the 3/4 power of the former [1] – [3] . In addition, when analyzing mammalian data from a wide variety of habitats across the world, Damuth [4] – 5 showed that population density was inversely scaled with body size and had an allometric exponent of −3/4. By combining both scaling relationships, they further proposed the energetic equivalence rule, which states that the amount of energy per unit area used by a population of a specific species is independent of body size. Recently, West et al. [6] – [8] developed a general mechanistic model (the WBE model), based on the fractal volume-filling theory, to predict and explain the 3/4 scaling exponent for animals and plants. Enqusit et al. [9] extended the energetic equivalence rule from mammal populations to plant populations based on the WBE theory, R  =  N max Q ∝ M 3/4 M −3/4  =  M 0 , where R is the rate of resource use per unit area; N max is the maximum population density; Q is the average rate of resource use or the metabolic rate per individual; and M is the average individual mass. These authors then extrapolated their data and concluded that the allometric exponent of the density–mass relationship for plants should be −4/3 rather than −3/2, and that energy-equivalence as a general model could be applicable to all plant populations in any environment [9] – [12] . The researchers who developed the WBE theory have claimed that the 3/4 exponent contains mathematical errors and is derived on the basis of an explicit assumption [13] – [16] and therefore does not generally apply to all organisms. Recent analyses of very large data sets on the basal metabolic rates of mammals and birds support a 2/3 exponent, rather than 3/4, derived from Eucidean geometric scaling [13] , [17] . In addition, the −3/2 power rule for plants (i.e. N∝M − 2/3 ) was ever treated as a general principle of plant population biology [18] – [19] and the total energy or resource use per unit area for a population can be expressed as: R  =  N max Q ∝ M 2/3 M −2/3  =  M 0  = constant. Both of these models show that the rate of resource use per unit area is independent of plant size, although both models assume different allometric exponents. It remains unclear whether the energy equivalence relationship can be derived from R ∝ M 3/4 M −3/4  = M 0 or R ∝ M 2/3 M −2/3 ∝ M 0 . The process for examining the applicability of the energy equivalence model is difficult and appears logically inappropriate (for discussion see [9] ). In our study, we assumed that the relationship between the rate of limiting resource use per unit area and the mean plant size can be described by R  =  KM a (where K is a constant and α is an exponent). Since the rate of resource supply per unit area is limiting, the dependent variable R is a constant K ′ so that the exponent (α) of the independent variable M must be zero for any body size, as R  =  KM 0  =  K ′ . Therefore, the energy equivalence rule R ∝ M 0 should be suitable for any given environment only if the population resource is limited [20] . The process of examining the applicability of the energy equivalence rule is mathematically difficult, and the −4/3 power rule derived from this energetic equivalence rule has been criticized and questioned by several authors [20] – [22] . In fact, many authors have suggested that the allometric exponents for the metabolic rate can vary with some biotic and abiotic factors [15] , [23] – [26] , just as the slopes of self-thinning lines vary between species, shade tolerance and site quality [20] , [22] , [27] – [31] . If the allometric exponent of the average rate of resource use per individual Q vs. plant mass is β , i.e. Q ∝ M β (where β is variable), according to the general model of energy equivalence, R  =  N max Q ∝ M 0 , the relationship between population density and plant mass should theoretically follow the model: N max ∝ M δ , where δ  = - β or δ/β  = −1. Currently, it is unclear if this trade-off relationship between the two scaling exponents is valid in natural systems. It is, therefore, necessary to investigate any synchrony in the scaling relationships between metabolic rate and population density, and plant body mass, under different environmental conditions and for different plant types. We will also examine the variability in the allometric exponents β and δ that are 3/4 and −3/4, or 2/3 and −2/3, respectively. The accurate and consistent measurement of metabolic rates is very difficult [3] . According to the predictions of the WBE model, the metabolic rate of plants, B ; rate of biomass production, G ; photosynthetic biomass, M p (i.e. the total leaf biomass, M L ); covary and all should be proportional to the 3/4 power of total plant mass, M , i.e. B ∝ G ≈ M P ( orM L )∝M 3/4 [3] , [6] – [8] . These scaling relationships have been demonstrated by a large number of authors, especially for angiosperms and gymnosperms [32] – [36] . The rate of biomass production, however, may not adequately reflect the metabolic rate or the rate of resource use because growth rates only provide estimates of an organism's net assimilation, and exclude any dissimilation energy. For the energetic equivalence rule, the average resource use rate or metabolic rate of individual plants, Q , should be more appropriately replaced by photosynthetic biomass, M L . Assuming that the rate of resource use per unit leaf biomass, K i , is constant in the same plant type (where i represents the different plant types or environmental conditions), we can generate the equation: Q  =  M L × K i ∝ M L . Combining the models: Q ∝ M β , N ∝ M δ , and Q ∝ M L , the relationship between leaf mass and density can be obtained by the equation, M L ∝ N β/δ . If the trade-off relationship between the two scaling exponents holds true, i.e. δ/β  = −1, the predicted leaf mass–density relationship should be consistent with previous studies [12] that have shown a scaling exponent of −1. In this study we examined the relationships between metabolic rate and population density, and body size, for a range of plant populations including desert shrubs, different forest types, and monoculture herbages. Our analysis of these data, which spans a size range of 11 orders of magnitude, unequivocally shows that allometric relationships between photosynthetic mass ( M p ) or leaf mass ( M L ), and population density and body mass varied greatly between desert shrubs, trees, and herbaceous plants, respectively. We further confirmed that the energetic equivalence rule of plants is based on trade-offs between the variable metabolic rate and population density. RESULTS The scaling exponents ( β ) of photosynthetic mass and body mass were statistically analyzed and ranged between 0.47 and 1.06 for the trees, shrubs and herbaceous plants ( Table 1 ). Among the 17 forest types, the 95% confidence intervals (CIs) showed that only one scaling exponent included 3/4, three values contained both 2/3 and 3/4, three values included 2/3, and the ten remaining values fell outside the 2/3 and 3/4 range. For desert shrubs and spring wheat, the CIs were above 3/4 and below 2/3, respectively ( Fig. 1A , Fig. 2A , Table 1 ). All regressions are significant at P <0.0001 and the 95% CI of the slopes are statistically different from 3/4 and −3/4 (also see Table 1 , 2 ), but the ratio of the two exponents is not statistically different from −1. All regressions are significant at P <0.0001 and the 95% CI of the slopes are statistically different from 3/4 and −3/4 (also see Table 1 , 2 ), but the ratio of the two exponents is not statistically different from −1. SE is the standard error, and CI is the confidence interval of the slope. The regression slopes of population density vs . body mass among the forest types had high variability and ranged from −0.52 to −1.15. Among the 17 forest types, two slope values had 95% CIs that contained 2/3, three contained 3/4, six had both 2/3 and 3/4 within them, and six fell outside the 2/3 and 3/4 range ( Table 2 ). The CI for the desert shrubs was greater than the theoretical value of 3/4 ( Fig. 1B ). The regression slope for spring wheat in 2002 was very close to −3/4 ( Fig. 2B ). These slopes were close to −2/3 in 2003 and 2004, although they were significantly different from 3/4 ( Table 2 ). SE is the standard error, and CI is the confidence interval of the slope. The ratio value, δ/β , was calculated for the scaling exponents, δ and β . The average value of the δ/β ratio was −0.99 ( Table 2 ). Furthermore, the regression slope between the two scaling exponents was not statistically different from the predicted value of −1 ( Fig. 3 ). The slope is very close to −1. TABLE: The scaling relationship between photosynthetic biomass, M p , and the body mass, M , for trees, desert shrubs and herbaceous plants. Plant type n Slope, β ±SE IT 95% CI r 2 Trees/Forest Boreal/temperate Larix forest 48 0.97±0.017 −1.35 0.93, 1.00 0.986 Boreal/alpine Picea abies forest 168 0.61±0.023 0.81 0.53, 0.67 0.761 Boreal Pinus sylvestris var. mongolica forest 10 0.65±0.040 0.44 0.56, 0.69 0.970 Temperate Pinus tabulaeformis forest 154 0.87±0.023 −0.45 0.82, 0.93 0.897 Temperate mixed coniferous-broadleaved forest 22 0.57±0.037 0.88 0.51, 0.59 0.915 Temperate typical deciduous broadleaved forest 165 1.06±0.041 −1.51 0.94, 1.20 0.758 Temperate/subtropical montane Populus-Betula deciduous forest 127 0.99±0.026 −1.39 0.93, 1.05 0.911 Desert riverside woodland 9 0.82±0.14 −0.84 0.66, 0.90 0.791 Subtropical mixed evergreen-deciduous broadleaved forest 22 0.89±0.079 −0.81 0.79, 1.22 0.841 Subtropical evergreen broadleaved forest 238 0.94±0.015 −1.08 0.92, 0.96 0.940 Sclerophyllous evergreen Quercus forest 9 0.87±0.049 −0.76 0.81, 0.93 0.977 Tropical rainforest and monsoon forest 13 0.96±0.13 −1.14 0.35, 1.12 0.793 Subtropical montane Pinus yunnanensis and P. khasya forest 46 0.93±0.02 −0.88 0.89, 0.96 0.980 Subtropical Pinus massoniana forest 66 0.92±0.052 −0.84 0.83, 1.02 0.798 Subtropical montane Pinus armandii , P. taiwanensis and P. densada 55 0.77±0.034 −0.013 0.71, 0.85 0.899 Subtropical Cunninghamia lanceolata forest 98 0.81±0.065 −0.21 0.65, 0.97 0.382 Subtropical montane Cupressus and Sabina forest 16 0.55±0.084 1.14 0.43, 0.67 0.677 Shrubs Desert shrubs 148 0.92±0.047 −0.71 0.84, 1.00 0.618 Herbages Spring wheat 2002 15 0.61±0.075 −0.70 0.48, 0.70 0.803 Spring wheat 2003 10 0.47±0.096 −1.02 0.36, 0.69 0.662 Spring wheat 2004 23 0.65±0.097 −0.75 0.50, 0.72 0.528 TABLE: The scaling relationship between population density, N , and body mass, M , and the ratio of the allometric exponent δ to β for trees, desert shrubs and herbaceous plants. Plant type n Slope, δ ±SE IT 95% CI r 2 δ/β Trees/Forest Boreal/temperate Larix forest 48 −0.81±0.040 3.20 −0.88, −0.74 0.887 −0.84 Boreal/alpine Picea abies forest 168 −0.671±0.023 2.50 −0.72, −0.61 0.802 −1.10 Boreal Pinus sylvestris var. mongolica forest 10 −0.70±0.055 2.51 −0.76, −0.51 0.952 −1.08 Temperate Pinus tabulaeformis forest 154 −0.81±0.037 2.88 −0.90, −0.71 0.691 −0.93 Temperate mixed coniferous-broadleaved forest 22 −0.64±0.027 2.30 −0.67, −0.60 0.964 −1.13 Temperate typical deciduous broadleaved forest 165 −0.88±0.033 3.34 −0.97, −0.81 0.773 −0.83 Temperate/subtropical montane Populus-Betula deciduous forest 127 −0.89±0.042 3.50 −0.97, −1.82 0.729 −0.90 Desert riverside woodland 9 −1.13±0.15 4.42 −1.44, −1.02 0.877 −1.37 Subtropical mixed evergreen-deciduous broadleaved forest 22 −0.66±0.08 2.48 −0.90, −0.47 0.700 −0.74 Subtropical evergreen broadleaved forest 238 −0.72±0.022 2.85 −0.78, −0.68 0.781 −0.77 Sclerophyllous evergreen Quercus forest 9 −1.15±0.15 5.21 −1.21, −0.89 0.879 −1.32 Tropical rainforest and monsoon forest 13 −0.76±0.12 3.09 −1.16, −0.64 0.737 −0.79 Subtropical montane Pinus yunnanensis and P. khasya forest 46 −0.85±0.033 3.31 −0.91, −0.77 0.933 −0.90 Subtropical Pinus massoniana forest 66 −0.73±0.051 2.74 −0.84, −0.63 0.685 −0.79 Subtropical montane Pinus armandii , P. taiwanensis and P. densada 55 −0.71±0.038 2.59 −0.79, −0.66 0.844 −0.92 Subtropical Cunninghamia lanceolata forest 98 −0.52±0.047 1.78 −0.64, −0.44 0.211 −0.64 Subtropical montane Cupressus and Sabina forest 16 −0.66±0.091 2.40 −0.84, −0.55 0.731 −1.19 Shrubs Desert shrubs 239 −0.87±0.019 2.10 −0.90, −0.83 0.882 −0.94 Herbages Spring wheat 2002 15 −0.75±0.10 2.94 −1.08, −0.61 0.752 −1.23 Spring wheat 2003 10 −0.61±0.14 3.17 −0.73, −0.55 0.598 −1.31 Spring wheat 2004 23 −0.66±0.037 3.20 −0.73, −0.62 0.936 −1.03 Mean value of β/δ ±SE −0.99 ±0.21 DISCUSSION Our results showed that the scaling exponents of both photosynthetic mass vs . body mass and population density vs . body mass varied depending on plant species and habitat type ( Table 1 , 2 ). More importantly, the trade-off relationship between the two scaling exponents supported our prediction, i.e. δ/β  = −1 ( Table 2 ). The regression slope values between the two scaling exponents, and density vs . average leaf mass were also close to the theoretical value of −1 ( Fig. 3 , Fig. 4 ) and with the previous study by Niklas et al. [12] . The regression is significant at P <0.0001 and the exponent approximates to the theoretical value of −1 (also see Table 1 , 2 ). There are two main power rules concerning the density/abundance–body size relationship, which are supported by empirical data, i.e. the −3/2 power rule [19] , [37] – [40] and the −4/3 power rule [3] , [9] , [11] , [35] – [36] , [41] . However, other researchers consider that the allometric exponents vary with environmental factors or between species [20] , [22] , [27] – [28] , [42] – [44] . White [18] suggested that the slopes (i.e. 1/ δ ) of biomass–density relationships varied within the range of −1.8 to −1.3, while Wang and Zhang [45] suggested that the theoretical values of slopes should continuously vary from −1 to -∞ when the growth forms of plants are transformed from a purely horizontal extension to absolute height growth. In fact, according to the predictions of the WBE model, (where 0≤ ε a or ε l ≤1, both of which are arbitrary exponents and a is the total plant leaf area; see [7] , the theoretical values of exponents should range between 1/2 and 3/4 when plants evolve by natural selection under different conditions of environmental stress [46] . Our results showed that allometric exponents of metabolic rate vary greatly according to a number of biotic and abiotic factors; this supports previous metabolic rate studies [13] – [14] , [23] – [26] , [47] – [50] . Although there is considerable evidence that the allometric exponents, β and δ , are variable, we found that these different values follow the trade-off law based on the energetic equivalence rule. Furthermore, this trade-off relationship implies that not only are the two types of exponents variable, but they are also co-dependent. The trade-off relationship is a fundamental principle of strategy theory in evolutionary ecology [51] , which considers that an organism adopts a suitable strategy to survive and grow under a given environment stress. The mechanism of both density–leaf mass and the allometric exponents δ , or 1/ δ - β trade-off relationships may derive from intraspecific plant dynamics. Some researchers have suggested that the leaf biomass per individual inversely scales with population density in populations that are undergoing self-thinning [12] , [43] , [52] . The decline in leaf mass per individual with increasing density results in a decrease in the rate of resource use and the allometric exponent β ( Fig. 5 ). Some studies have shown that the exponent, 1/ δ , depends on the allometric exponent between height and stem diameter [45] – [46] . The latter exponent increases with density because more energy and resources may be allocated to stem height growth as a result of competition [53] – [54] . Thus the dynamics of populations with different plant densities and height–stem diameter relationships largely determine the trade-off relationship between the exponents, β and 1/ δ , especially in dense populations. Moreover, this trade-off relationship indicates that the values of the scaling exponents, β and 1/ δ , should be continuous variables, rather than constants ( Fig. 5B ). It remains unclear how the scaling exponent between height and stem diameter quantitatively varies with population density or the intensity of competition. The population density and the photosynthetic mass show a reciprocal relationship (A) and the exponents 1/ δ and β show a negative reciprocal relationship (B). As reported for metabolic rates [55] , we found that the leaf mass reflects both photosynthetic ability and the absorbency of water and nutrients from soil. Under drought conditions, the plant individual has the relatively high ratio of photosynthetic mass to body mass may result from the thick leaves and the assimilating shoots of plants and the relatively small body size, which may lead to increases in the photosynthetic efficiency and the capacity to absorb water, and also decrease soil evaporation through canopy shading, thereby enhancing the drought stress resistance [56] – [57] . Moreover, leaves with high ratios of leaf mass/body mass may have further ecological significance in harsh environments; for example, most leaves will fall and decompose to increase soil fertility in nutrient-poor soil [58] . In contrast, high ratios imply that the body size of an individual will be constrained within a relatively small range to reduce the use of the limiting resource and enhance survival ability. The self-thinning phenomenon in plants occurs in dense populations mainly ascribing to the leaf mass per individual (or the value of exponent β ), which drops sharply with increased density and growth. It is noticeable that the fluctuating scaling relationships of leaf mass and body mass for trees are also dependent on environmental conditions and are species-specific. If only resources are limited, both the leaf mass vs . density relationship and the relationship between the scaling exponents, β and 1/ δ , would follow the trade-off law for any given environmental condition. Overall, our results demonstrate for the first time that the energetic equivalence rule of plants is based on trade-offs between the variable metabolic rate and population density rather than their constant allometric exponents. MATERIALS AND METHODS All of the data used in our analyses were collected in July and August between 2003 and 2007 from shrub-dominated communities at our experimental sites (See the Dataset S2 .). The experimental plots are located in the central and western parts of the Gansu province, China (Baiyin, Jingtai, Minqin and Linze sites) between 100°08′ and 104°24′ E longitude and between 39°22′ and 36°29′ N latitude. They are classified as arid and semi-arid regions on the boundaries of the Tengger and Badain Jaran deserts, where the annual mean precipitation ranges between 115 mm and 209 mm. The design of the sampling quadrats and the measurement of the stand density and total biomass for each population are described by Deng et al. [20] . Because the assimilating branches, twigs and petioles (green tissue) of most xerophyte plants have considerable photosynthetic capacity (in addition to the leaves), enabling them to adapt to arid environments, the mass of all the photosynthetic tissues was measured separately for sub-samples of aboveground and belowground parts of each plant species. TREES All of the data used in this study were collected from the primary literature ( [59] , included in the Dataset S1. , also see http://www.geodata.cn ). These data spanned a range of latitudes (18°N and 53°N), and altitudes (10 m to 4240 m above sea level), including 1266 plots/populations from six biomes and 17 forest types across China [59] . The species under investigation included angiosperms and gymnosperms. Luo [59] provided information on the average mass and annual net production for different plant parts (leaf, stem, and root) for different aged plants, densities and species. The units of mass and density were converted from tons of dry matter and the number of plants per ha. to grams per individual plant and number of plants per square meter, respectively. HERBAGE Field experiments with spring wheat ( Triticum aestivum L. New Cultivar No.3) were conducted at the Yuzhong experimental station of Lanzhou University, China, from May to July in 2002 and 2004. We also re-analyzed some relevant data from self-thinning experiments of spring wheat populations conducted in 2003 (See the Dataset S3. ) [31] . The experimental design combined populations sown at six and ten densities: 1, 10, 100, 1×10 3 , 4×10 3 , and 1×10 4 seeds m −2 , and 1, 100, 500, 1×10 3 , 2×10 3 , 6×10 3 , 1×10 4 , 2×10 4 , and 4×10 4 seeds m −2 in 2002 and 2004, respectively, with four replicates for each seed density. The area of each plot was 1 m×1 m, with a 0.3 m-wide buffer zone to avoid any marginal effects. The soil moisture and fertility was sufficient to ensure plant growth without any water or nutrient stress [31] . The stand density, leaf area, leaf biomass and body mass were measured in each plot at the three-leaf, tillering, elongation, heading and ripening stages, respectively. The leaf area was estimated by the Dry Weight Method described by Deng et al. [60] . The mean dry mass data were collected from 50 randomly sampled individuals in the populations with sowing densities >500/m 2 in four replicate plots at each sowing density. The dry plant mass was weighed after harvesting and being dried by ovens. STATISTICAL ANALYSES To meet the requirement of the energetic equivalence rule for spring wheat populations, we analyzed the relevant data for closed populations with sowing densities >1000 seeds m −2 . All the allometric exponents, the intercepts and the 95% confidence intervals were evaluated by Model Type II (reduced major axis i.e. RMA, 1.17version) regression of the log-transformed data. The 95% confidence intervals were used to assess whether an empirically calculated allometric exponent included the predicted theoretical values [32] . SUPPORTING INFORMATION The dataset S1 used in the analysis of our paper. (0.11 MB PDF) The dataset S2 was used in the analysis of our paper (0.13 MB PDF) The dataset S3 was used in the analysis of our paper (0.04 MB PDF) REFERENCES [1] Kleiber M 1932 Body size and metabolism. Hilgardia 6 315 332 [2] Peters RH 1983 The ecological implications of body size. Cambridge, UK Cambridge University Press [3] Brown JH Gillooly JF Allen PA Savage VM West GB 2004 Toward a metabolic theory of ecology. Ecology 85 1771 1789 [4] Damuth J 1981 Population density and body size in mammals. Nature, 290 699 700 [5] Damuth J 1987 Interspecific allometry of population-density in mammals and other animals: the independence of body-mass and population energy-use. Biol J Linn Soc 31 193 246 [6] West GB Brown JH Enquist BJ 1997 A general model for the origin of allometric scaling laws in biology. Science 276 122 126 [7] West GB Brown JH Enquist BJ 1999a The fourth dimension of life: fractal geometry and allometric scaling of organism. Science, 284 1677 1679 [8] West GB Brown JH Enquist BJ 1999b A general model for the structure and allometry of plant vascular systems. Nature 400 664 667 [9] Enquist BJ Brown JH West GB 1998 Allometric scaling of plants energetics and population density. Nature 395 163 165 [10] Enquist BJ Brown JH West GB 1999 Plant energetics and population density. Nature 398 573 [11] Enquist BJ Niklas KJ 2001 Invariant scaling relations across tree-dominated communities. Nature 410 655 660 [12] Niklas KJ Midgley JJ Enquist BJ 2003 A general model for mass-growth-density relations across tree-dominated communities. Evol Ecol Res 5 459 468 [13] Dodds PS Rothman DH Weitz JS 2001 Re-examination of the “3/4-law”of metabolism. J Theor Biol 209 9 27 [14] Kozlowski J Konarzewski M 2004 Is West, Brown and Enquist's model of allometric scaling mathematically correct and biologically relevant? Funct Ecol 18 283 289 [15] Kozlowski J Konarzewski M 2005 West, Brown and Enquist's model of allometric scaling again: the same questions remain. Funct Ecol 19 739 743 [16] O′Connor MP Kemp ST Agosta SJ Hansen F Sieg AE 2007 Reconsidering the mechanistic basis of the metabolic theory of ecology. Oikos 116 1058 1072 [17] White CR Seymour RS 2003 Mammalian basal metabolic rate is proportional to body mass 2/3 . Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 100 4046 4049 [18] White J 1980 Demographic factors in populations of plants. Solbrig OT Demography and evolution in plant populations Berkeley, California, USA University of California Press 21 48 [19] Hutchings MJ 1983 Ecology's law in search of a theory. New Scie 98 765 767 [20] Deng JM Wang GX Morris EC Wei XP Li DX 2006a Plant mass-density relationship along a moisture gradient in north-west China. J Ecol 94 953 958 [21] Li HT Han XG Wu JG 2006 Variant scaling relationship for mass-density across tree-dominated communities. J Integr P Biol 48 268 277 [22] Pretzsch H 2006 Species-specific allometric scaling under self-thinning: evidence from long-term plots in forest stands. Oecologia 146 572 583 [23] Ricklefs RE 2003 Is rate of ontogenetic growth constrained by resource supply or tissue growth potential? A comment on West et al .'s model. Funct Ecol 17 384 393 [24] Reich PB Tjoelker MG Machado JL Oleksyn J 2006 Universal scaling of respiratory metabolism, size and nitrogen in plants. Nature 439 457 461 [25] Duncan RP Forsyth DM Hone J 2007 Testing the Metabolic theory of ecology: allometric scaling exponents in mammals. Ecology 88 324 333 [26] White CR Cassey P Blackburn TM 2007 Allometric exponents do not support a universal metabolic allometry. Ecology 88 315 323 [27] Weller DE 1987 Self-thinning exponent correlated with allometric measures of plant geometry. Ecology 64 813 821 [28] Lonsdale WM 1990 The self-thinning rule: dead or alive? Ecology 71 1373 1388 [29] Morris EC 2002 Self-thinning lines differ with fertility level. Ecol Res 17 17 28 [30] Roderick ML Barnes B 2004 Self-thinning of plant populations from a dynamic viewpoint. Funct Ecol 18 197 203 [31] Liu J Wei L Wang CM Wang GX Wei XP 2006 Effect of water deficit on self-thinning line in even-aged monocultures of spring wheat ( Triticum aestivum L.). J Integr P Biol 48 415 419 [32] Niklas KJ Enquist BJ 2001 Invariant scaling relationships for interspecifc plant biomass production rates and body size. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 98 2922 2927 [33] Niklas KJ Enquist BJ 2002a On the vegetative biomass partitioning of seed plant leaves, stems, and roots. Am Nat 5 482 497 [34] Niklas KJ Enquist BJ 2002b Canonical rules for plant organ biomass partitioning and annual allocation. Am J Bot 89 812 819 [35] Enquist BJ Niklas KJ 2002 Global allocation rules for patterns of biomass partitioning in seed plants. Science 295 1517 1520 [36] Enquist BJ 2003 Scaling the macroecological and evolutionary implications of size and metabolism within and across plant taxa. Birmingham, UK Blackwell publishing [37] Yoda K Kira T Ogawa H Hozumi K 1963 Self-thinning in overcrowded pure stands under cultivated and natural conditions. (Intraspecific competition among higher plants XI). Journal of the Institute of Polytechnics, Osaka City University, Series D 14 107 129 [38] White J Harper JL 1970 Correlated changes in plant size and number in plant populations. J Ecol 58 467 485 [39] Begon M Harper JL Townsend CR 1996 Ecology 3 rd ed. Oxford, UK Blackwell Science Ltd [40] Bi HQ Wan GH Turvey ND 2000 Estimating the self-thinning boundary line as a density-dependent stochastic biomass frontier. Ecology 81 1477 1483 [41] Price CA Enquist BJ 2007 Scaling mass and morphology in leaves: an extension of the WBE model. Ecology 88 1132 1141 [42] Weller DE 1991 The self-thinning rule: dead or unsupported? A reply to Londale. Ecology 72 747 750 [43] Osawa A Allen RB 1993 Allometric theory explains self-thinning relationships of mountain beech and red pine. Ecology 74 1020 1032 [44] Reynolds JH Ford ED 2005 Improving competition representation in theoretical models of self-thinning: a critical review. J Ecol 93 362 372 [45] Wang G Zhang DY 1996 Theories of biological competition. Intraspecific competition Xi'an, Shanxi Science and technology press 28 43 [46] Wang G Yuan JL Wang XZ Xiao S Huang WB 2004 Competitve regulation of plant allometry and a generalized model for the plnt self-thinning process. J Theor Biol 66 1875 1885 [47] Bokma F 2004 Evidence against universal metabolic allometry. Funct Ecol 18 184 187 [48] Cry H Walker SC 2004 An illusion of Mechanistic understanding. Ecology 85 1802 1804 [49] Anderson KJ Jetz W 2005 The broad-scale ecology of energy expenditure of endotherms. Ecol lett 8 310 318 [50] Loeuille N Michel L 2006 Evolution of body size in food webs: does the energetic equivalence rule hold? Ecol Lett 9 171 178 [51] Kleiman D Aarssen LW 2007 The leaf size/number trade-off in trees. J Ecol 95 376 382 [52] Long JN Smith FW 1984 Relation between size and density in developing stands: a description and possible mechanisms. Fores Ecol Mana 7 191 206 [53] Richards RA 1991 Crop improvement for temperate Australia: future opportunities. Field Crop Res 26 141 169 [54] Zhang DY Sun GJ Jiang XH 1999 Donald's ideotype and growth redundancy: a game theoretical analysis. Field Crop Res 61 179 187 [55] Banavar JR Damuth J Maritan A Rinaldo A 2002 Supply-demand balance and metabolic scaling. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99 10506 10509 [56] Lyshede OB 1979 Xeromorphic features of three stem assimilating in relation to their ecology. Bot J Lin Soc 78 85 98 [57] Gong CM Gao XW Cheng DL Wang GX 2006 C 4 photosynthetic characteristics and antioxidative protection of C 3 desert shrub Hedysarum scoparium in northwest China. Pakistan J Bot 38 647 661 [58] Chen BM Wang GX Cheng DL Deng JM Peng SL 2007 Vegetation change and soil nutrient distribution along an oasis-desert transitional zone in Northwestern China. J Integr P Biol 49 1537 1547 [59] Luo TX 1996 Patterns of biological production and its mathematical 50 models for main forest types of China (in Chinese). Committee of Synthesis Investigation of Natural Resources, the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing [60] Deng JM Zhang XY Wang GX Wei XP Zhao CM 2006b The relationship between the energy use and densities of spring wheat under the different moisture levels (In Chinese with English abstract). Acta Ecolpgica Sinaca 26 2282 2287