Light Variability Illuminates Niche-Partitioning among Marine Picocyanobacteria Authors: Christophe Six, Zoe V. Finkel, Andrew J. Irwin, Douglas A. Campbell Published: 2007, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0001341 ABSTRACT Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus picocyanobacteria are dominant contributors to marine primary production over large areas of the ocean. Phytoplankton cells are entrained in the water column and are thus often exposed to rapid changes in irradiance within the upper mixed layer of the ocean. An upward fluctuation in irradiance can result in photosystem II photoinactivation exceeding counteracting repair rates through protein turnover, thereby leading to net photoinhibition of primary productivity, and potentially cell death. Here we show that the effective cross-section for photosystem II photoinactivation is conserved across the picocyanobacteria, but that their photosystem II repair capacity and protein-specific photosystem II light capture are negatively correlated and vary widely across the strains. The differences in repair rate correspond to the light and nutrient conditions that characterize the site of origin of the Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus isolates, and determine the upward fluctuation in irradiance they can tolerate, indicating that photoinhibition due to transient high-light exposure influences their distribution in the ocean. INTRODUCTION The smallest category of free living photosynthetic cells is picophytoplankton, defined as less than 3 µm diameter. Picophytoplankton cells, although individually minute, dominate carbon assimilation and primary productivity over large areas of the ocean. Among the taxonomically diverse groups composing the picophytoplankton the cyanobacteria Synechococcus and Prochlorococcus are major contributors to primary production and carbon export over large areas of the open ocean [1] . Prochlorococcus , the most abundant photosynthetic organism on Earth [2] , is restricted to the warm rather oligotrophic waters of the latitudinal band extending from 40°N to 40°S [3] – [5] and laboratory experiments show it does not grow well at low temperatures [6] . Synechococcus and Prochlorococcus co-occur in many oceanographic regions, but Synechococcus tolerates a broader temperature range [6] , [7] and thrives in more meso- and eutrophic waters, even though Prochlorococcus can also grow at these higher nutrient levels [2] . Synechococcus are often less abundant in warmer, oligotrophic ecosystems where Prochlorococcus is the major primary producer [2] , [5] . Prochlorococcus and Synechococcus have cell types (often referred to as ecotypes) which have identifiable geographic ranges that correspond to particular temperature, nutrient concentration, as well as light regimes [2] . Synechococcus cell types differ in their pigment content, allowing these organisms to exploit specific spectral niches [8] – [10] , which tend to vary along a horizontal offshore-onshore axis within the upper mixed layer [11] – [15] . In contrast, Prochlorococcus ecotypes are found at different depths in the water column, and are adapted to different average irradiance [2] , . The surface ecotypes of Prochlorococcus have optimal growth irradiances similar to Synechococcus strains [6] , [19] , [20] . Average irradiance contributes to niche partitioning with depth among Prochlorococcus ecotypes, but even in combination with temperature and nutrient regime, does not fully account for the differential distribution of the Prochlorococcus and the Synechococcus strains. In particular, the absence of Prochlorococcus in temperate, permanently mixed shallow seas such as the English Channel where Synechococcus is very abundant, remains poorly understood [2] . The ocean is a dynamic environment in which phytoplankton must cope with rapid changes in resources, particularly irradiance [21] , [22] . For a phytoplankton cell, irradiance changes rapidly if light attenuation and mixing in the water column are large, as the cell moves vertically through a large depth/irradiance gradient. Downward mixing of a phytoplankton cell leads to lower irradiance and therefore a decrease in growth, but with no immediate risk of cellular death. In contrast, when a cell is taken upwards in the water column, it must often withstand both rapid and large increases in irradiance. To maintain photosynthesis and viability, phytoplankton must counter the photoinactivation of photosystem II (PSII) [23] , [24] with repair [25] through proteolytic removal of photodamaged D1 protein [26] and the coordinated insertion of newly synthesized D1 into the thylakoid membrane [27] . If an increase in irradiance causes photoinactivation to outrun repair, the cell suffers net photoinhibitory loss of photosynthetic capacity, leading potentially to cell death. The risk of exposure to upward fluctuations in irradiance may therefore constitute a potent selective pressure contributing to niche partitioning among cyanobacterial cell types. To determine if upward fluctuations in irradiance are an important selective factor in niche partitioning among marine picocyanobacteria, we quantitatively analyzed the relative capacities to tolerate a sudden increase in irradiance across five ecologically significant types of Synechococcus and Prochlorococcus isolated from habitats with contrasting dynamic irradiance regimes. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The Synechococcus and Prochlorococcus cell types exhibited a gradient in their photophysiological tolerance of upward fluctuations in irradiance ( Fig. 1 ), resulting from different capacities to induce repair ( R PSII , functional PSII gained s −1 ) to counter the PSII photoinactivation rate (PSII lost s −1 ). To tolerate and therefore exploit upward fluctuations in irradiance, PSII repair must equal the magnitude of the rate of PSII photoinactivation, which we parameterized as: (1) where E is the scalar irradiance in photons nm −2 s −1 and σ i is the effective target size for photons driving PSII photoinactivation [28] , with nominal units of nm 2 . If R PSII