Conflict over Male Parentage in Social Insects Authors: Robert L Hammond, Laurent Keller Published: 2004, PLOS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.0020248 ABSTRACT Mutual policing is an important mechanism that maintains social harmony in group-living organisms by suppressing the selfish behavior of individuals. In social insects, workers police one another (worker-policing) by preventing individual workers from laying eggs that would otherwise develop into males. Within the framework of Hamilton's rule there are two explanations for worker-policing behavior. First, if worker reproduction is cost-free, worker-policing should occur only where workers are more closely related to queen- than to worker-produced male eggs (relatedness hypothesis). Second, if there are substantial costs to unchecked worker reproduction, worker-policing may occur to counteract these costs and increase colony efficiency (efficiency hypothesis). The first explanation predicts that patterns of the parentage of males (male parentage) are associated with relatedness, whereas the latter does not. We have investigated how male parentage varies with colony kin structure and colony size in 50 species of ants, bees, and wasps in a phylogenetically controlled comparative analysis. Our survey revealed that queens produced the majority of males in most of the species and that workers produced more than half of the males in less than 10% of species. Moreover, we show that male parentage does not vary with relatedness as predicted by the relatedness hypothesis. This indicates that intra- and interspecific variation in male parentage cannot be accounted for by the relatedness hypothesis alone and that increased colony efficiency is an important factor responsible for the evolution of worker-policing. Our study reveals greater harmony and more complex regulation of reproduction in social insect colonies than that expected from simple theoretical expectations based on relatedness only. INTRODUCTION Major evolutionary transitions ( Maynard-Smith and Szathmáry 1995 ) require the evolution of mechanisms that moderate within-group conflict ( Keller 1999 ; Queller 2000 ; Michod and Roze 2001 ). One such mechanism is mutual policing, where members of a group collectively prevent individuals from acting in their own selfish interests ( Frank 1995 ). The best example of mutual policing behavior in nature is found in social insects, where workers police worker reproduction (worker-policing) by selectively removing worker-laid eggs that would otherwise develop into males ( Ratnieks and Visscher 1989 ; Foster and Ratnieks 2000 , 2001a ; Halling et al. 2001 ; Oldroyd et al. 2001 ), or by directing aggression toward workers with developing ovaries ( Monnin and Ratnieks 2001 ; Iwanishi et al. 2003 ). Selection for worker-policing depends upon two variables: the relative relatedness of workers to queen- and worker-produced males (relatedness hypothesis) and the colony-level cost of workers reproducing (efficiency hypothesis). Worker-policing theory ( Starr 1984 ; Woyciechowski and Lomnicki 1987 ; Ratnieks 1988 ), an extension of kin selection theory ( Hamilton 1964 ), has typically highlighted relatedness as the all-important variable that explains when workers should lay male-destined eggs and when they should police one another's reproduction. In contrast, the costs of worker reproduction ( Ratnieks 1988 ) have been largely ignored or given low prominence in the literature, with the effect that the relatedness hypothesis has become widely accepted as the explanation for worker-policing ( Whitfield 2002 ). Empirical investigations of worker-policing behavior initially focused on species with colony kin structures that predicted the behavior under the relatedness hypothesis, and worker-policing was first demonstrated in the multiply mated honey bee, Apis mellifera ( Estoup et al. 1994 ; Visscher 1996 ). Subsequently, similar patterns have been found in other multiply mated members of the genus Apis ( Halling et al. 2001 ; Oldroyd et al. 2001 ; Wattanachaiyingcharoen et al. 2002 ) and in the multiply mated wasp Vespula vulgaris ( Foster and Ratnieks 2001a ). Support for the relatedness hypothesis comes from contrasts between these species and closely related species that are singly mated ( Peters et al. 1999 ; Foster and Ratnieks 2001c ) and from an intraspecific study of the vespine wasp Dolichovespula saxonica, in which worker-policing behavior is facultative and occurs only in colonies headed by multiply mated queens ( Foster and Ratnieks 2000 ). There are, however, problems with the conclusion that relatedness is the underlying cause of policing behavior, because phylogeny is not controlled for in the interspecific comparisons described above. This is an important problem, because these species are clustered with respect to phylogeny (e.g., four Apis species), and related wasp species, such as Vespa crabro, show patterns of worker reproduction and worker-policing behavior that are consistent with the efficiency hypothesis but not the relatedness hypothesis ( Foster et al. 2002 ). The relatedness hypothesis explicitly predicts that the parentage of males (male parentage) is dependent upon colony kin structure. Importantly, males should be worker-produced in colonies headed by single, once-mated queens, and queen-produced in colonies headed by multiple related queens, or by multiply mated queens, because worker reproduction is prevented by worker-policing. By contrast, the efficiency hypothesis predicts no association of male parentage or worker-policing with colony kin structure. In this paper we test these predictions by analyzing, using methods that control for phylogenetic dependence, how the proportion of worker-produced males (WPM) varies with both colony kin structure and colony size. The theoretical difference in relatedness of workers to queen- and worker-produced males ( r diff ) was used to make predictions about male parentage based upon colony kin structure. We included colony size in our analyses because it potentially alters expected patterns of male parentage ( Bourke 1999 ) by altering power relationships within the colony. In small colonies a single individual may have the power to dominate male production completely, but such reproductive dominance becomes less likely as colony size increases. RESULTS We found data for 50 species: 16 ants, 20 bees, and 14 wasps ( Table 1 ; Figure 1 ). WPM varied considerably (0%–85%), but in most species, queens produced the majority of males, with less than 10% of males being worker-produced in 72% of species surveyed. In only 10% of species were more than 50% of males worker-produced. There was great variation in the number of males ( n m = 13–1,426) and likewise in the number of assignable males ( n a = 10–677, where n a is the sample size corrected for the probability of nondetection [ Foster et al. 2001 ]) that were used to estimate the WPM. However, in those species for which we had relevant data, there was no significant correlation of n m or n a with WPM (Spearman's rank correlation: n m versus WPM: ρ = 0.17, n = 45, p = 0.27; n a versus WPM: ρ = 0.11, n = 27, p = 0.59), suggesting that there was no systematic bias in our dataset. Phylogeny includes within-species variation. Duplicated species labeled 1 or 2 (e.g., Leptothorax acervorum 1 and 2) refer to taxa in which within-species variation was included in some analyses (see text for details). Dotted lines, r diff is negative; solid lines, r diff is positive. Horizontal bars indicate WPM. a  Estimates based on pedigree relatedness NA, maximum likelihood methods were used; n c , number of queenright colonies in which male parentage was analyzed; n q , average number of queens per colony; n w , colony size defined as the number of workers Tests of serial independence showed that there was significant phylogenetic dependence for all variables when within-species variation was ignored (log 10 WPM, p = 0.016; r diff , p < 0.001; log 10 of colony size [log 10 n w ], p < 0.001) and when within-species variation was included (log 10 WPM, p = 0.002; r diff , p < 0.001). This confirmed that a comparative approach using an analysis of independent contrasts was warranted ( Abouheif 1999 ; Freckleton et al. 2002 ). The WPM was not significantly correlated with colony kin structure in any of our comparative analyses. Ignoring within-species variation, the slope of the line of regression of contrast in log 10 WPM against contrast in r diff was not significantly different from zero ( Figure 2 A; slope β = −2.14, t = –1.53, df = 48, p = 0.13), and the mean contrast in log 10 WPM (–1.70 ± 5.4) was not significantly different from zero when r diff was coded categorically ( t = 0.31, df = 2, p = 0.78). Likewise, neither analysis that included within-species variation was significant ( Figure 2 B; β = –1.31, t = –1.36, df = 55, p = 0.18; mean contrast in log 10 WPM = –0.14 ± 4.81, t = 0.03, df = 7, p = 0.98). The power was high ( Figure 3 ; power greater than 0.75) for both analyses of regression to detect a large effect of relatedness on WPM, and there was relatively high power (see Figure 3 ; power greater than 0.6) to detect a medium effect in the analysis that included within-species variation. The WPM also did not show any significant relationship with colony size when all species were included ( Figure 4 A; β = –0.12, t = –1.04, df = 48, p = 0.30) or when relatedness was controlled for and we included only species with positive r diff values ( Figure 4 B; β = –0.14, t = –1.05, df = 41, p = 0.30). Axes show standardized independent contrasts in WPM (log 10 WPM) and in r diff . (A) is based on species values; (B) includes intraspecific variation for seven species (see text). Lines of regression are forced through the origin. On the graph, + data points show the power of tests in which within-species variation was ignored, and × show the power of tests in which within-species variation was included. Axes show standardized independent contrasts in the proportion of worker-produced males (log 10 WPM) and in colony size (log 10 n w ). (A) includes all species; (B) includes only species in which relatedness predicts worker-produced males (i.e., r diff is positive). Lines of regression are forced through the origin. TABLE: The WPM, Colony Kin Structure, and Colony Size in a Sample of Queenright Colonies of Eusocial Hymenoptera a  Estimates based on pedigree relatedness NA, maximum likelihood methods were used; n c , number of queenright colonies in which male parentage was analyzed; n q , average number of queens per colony; n w , colony size defined as the number of workers Species Kin Structure n q r w–w r diff n w n c n m n a WPM Reference for n w Reference for WPM and r w–w ANTS Lasius niger Monandrous 1 0.69 0.095 33 157 107.5 1.9 Fjerdingstad et al. 2002 Polyandrous 1 0.45 –0.025 13 65 46.75 2.1 Fjerdingstad et al. 2002 All 1 0.62 0.06 24,247 46 222 154.25 1.9 Fjerdingstad et al. 2003 Fjerdingstad et al. 2002 Formica exsecta Monandrous 1 0.62 0.06 35 409 205 0 Sundström et al. 1996 ; Walin et al. 1998 Polyandrous 1 0.46 –0.02 3 30 15 0 Sundström et al. 1996 ; Walin et al. 1998 All 1 0.62 0.06 12,179 38 449 220 0 Brown et al. 2002 Sundström et al. 1996 ; Walin et al. 1998 Epimyrma ravouxi 1 0.75  a 0.125 40 7 47 27.5 0 Keller et al., unpublished data Keller et al., unpublished data Leptothorax acervorum Monogynous 1 0.71 0.145 11 242 220.3 2.3 Hammond et al. 2003 Polygynous 3.6 0.28 0.005 8 86 65.9 4.6 Hammond et al. 2003 All 0.52 0.083 84.2 20 328 286.2 2.8 Chan and Bourke 1994 Hammond et al. 2003 Leptothorax nylanderi 1 0.59 0.045 37 33 163 81.5 2.5 Foitzik and Heinze 2001 Foitzik 1998 ; Foitzik and Heinze 2001 Leptothorax unifasciatus 1 0.75  a 0.125 116 10 80 73.4 2.7 Keller et al., unpublished data Keller et al., unpublished data Protomognathus americanus 1 0.68 0.09 6.3 4 13 41 Foitzik and Herbers 2001 Foitzik and Herbers 2001 Myrmica punctiventris 0.73 0.115 63.8 27 242 162.7 58 Snyder and Herbers 1991 Herbers and Mouser 1998 Myrmica tahoensis Monogynous 1 0.71 0.371 9 35 21.5 65.1 Evans 1998 ; J. Evans, personal communication Polygynous 1.7 0.57 –0.025 2 13 8.25 84.8 Evans 1998 ; J. Evans, personal communication All 0.56 0.03 175 11 48 29.75 70.6 Evans 1996 Evans 1998 ; J. Evans, personal communication Crematogaster smithi 1 0.76 0.130 165 4 55 27.5 11 Heinze et al. 1999 Heinze et al. 2000 Trachymyrmex cf. zeteki 1 0.68 0.090 300 4 30 NA 0 Villesen et al. 2002 Villesen and Boomsma 2003 Cyphomyrmex costatus 1 0.75  a 0.125 300 3 17 NA 0 Villesen et al. 2002 Villesen and Boomsma 2003 Cyphomyrmex longiscapus 1 0.73 0.116 300 3 18 NA 0 Villesen et al. 2002 Villesen and Boomsma 2003 Sericomyrmex amabilis 1 0.694 0.097 1,500 2 19 NA 0 Villesen et al. 2002 Villesen and Boomsma 2003 Trachymyrmex cornetzi sp.1 1 0.66 0.082 300 3 20 NA 0 Villesen et al. 2002 Villesen and Boomsma 2003 Nothomyrmecia macrops 1 0.61 0.055 60 4–6 21 18.6 0 Hölldobler and Wilson 1990 Sanetra and Crozier 2001 BEES Apis dorsata 1 0.29 –0.105 36,630 4 660 521 0 Seeley et al. 1982 Palmer and Oldroyd 2000 ; Wattanachaiyingcharoen et al. 2002 Apis florea 1 0.29 –0.105 6,271 4 564 269 0 Seeley et al. 1982 Palmer and Oldroyd 2000 ; Halling et al. 2001 Apis cerana 1 0.35 –0.075 6,884 5 652 365 0 Seeley et al. 1982 Palmer and Oldroyd 2000 ; Oldroyd et al. 2001 Bombus hypnorum Monandrous 1 0.65 0.075 31.4 7 162 81 0 Paxton et al. 2001 Paxton et al. 2001 , R. Paxton, personal communication Monandrous 1 0.75  a 0.125 25.5 10 1,193 595.5 18.5 Brown et al. 2003 Brown et al. 2003 , M. Brown, personal communication Monandrous combined 1 0.71 0.105 17 1,355 676.5 16.4 Polyandrous 1 0.48 –0.01 1 71 35.5 0 Paxton et al. 2001 , R. Paxton, personal communication All 1 0.69 0.095 28.5 28 1,426 712 15.4 Austroplebeia australis 1 0.83 0.165 2,000 1 94 70.5 7 A. Dollin, personal communication Drumond et al. 2000 Austroplebeia symei 1 0.72 0.11 2,000 4 130 65 5 A. Dollin, personal communication Palmer et al. 2002 Melipona quadrifasciata 1 0.75  a 0.125 750 2 47 NA 64.2 Lindauer and Kerr 1958 , 1960 ; Tóth et al. 2004 Tóth et al. 2002b Melipona scutellaris 1 0.75  a 0.125 1,000 5 46 NA 28.3 Lindauer and Kerr 1958 , 1960 ; Tóth et al. 2004 Tóth et al. 2002b Melipona marginata 1 0.65 0.075 750 3 41 NA 37.1 Tóth et al. 2004 Tóth et al. 2002b Paratrigona subnuda 1 0.74 0.12 3,750 6 418 NA 64 Tóth et al. 2002a Tóth et al. 2002a Plebeia saiqui 1 0.8 0.15 1,500 3 66 NA 0 Tóth et al. 2004 Tóth et al. 2002b Plebeia remota 1 0.8 0.15 2,900 5 83 NA 2.4 van Benthem et al. 1995 Tóth et al. 2002b Plebeia doryana 1 1 0.25 2,700 1 19 NA 0 Lindauer and Kerr 1958 , 1960 ; Machado et al. 1984 Tóth et al. 2002b Scaptotrigona postica 1 0.72 0.109 8 160 144.6 13.1 Paxton et al. 2003 1 3 62 NA 18.5 Tóth et al. 2002b (both studies combined) 1 5,750 14.7 Beig 1972 Schwarziana quadripunctata q . 1 0.75  a 0.125 1,650 16 314 NA 0 Tóth et al. 2003 Tetragona clavipes 1 0.55 0.025 6,500 5 47 NA 65 Wille and Michener 1973 Tóth et al. 2002b Trigona clypearis 1 0.73 0.115 500 4 46 42 0 A. Dollin, personal communication Palmer et al. 2002 Trigona hockingsi 1 0.68 0.09 6,500 4 79 33 0 A. Dollin, personal communication Palmer et al. 2002 Trigona mellipes 1 0.76 0.13 2,000 4 42 23 0 A. Dollin, personal communication Palmer et al. 2002 Trigona carbonaria 1 0.75  a 0.125 10,000 1 20 10 0 Heard and Dollin 1998 Green and Oldroyd 2002 WASPS Brachygastra mellifica 398 0.23 –0.135 7,951 4 60 NA 5 Hastings et al. 1998 Hastings et al. 1998 Parachartergus colobopterus 45.8 0.19 –0.155 393 5 200 NA 5 M.T. Hastings, personal communication Henshaw et al. 2000 Polistes bellicosus 1 0.63 0.065 15.75 10 46 NA 1 Arévalo et al. 1998 Arévalo et al. 1998 Polistes dorsalis 1 0.73 0.115 14.5 6 51 NA 0 Arévalo et al. 1998 Arévalo et al. 1998 Polistes gallicus 1 0.75  a 0.125 25 5 31 NA 0 Strassmann et al. 2003 Strassmann et al. 2003 Polybioides tabidus 34 0.20 –0.15 4,000 5 247 NA 5 Henshaw et al. 2002 Henshaw et al. 2002 Dolichovespula saxonica Monandrous 1 0.65 0.075 8 205 143.2 40 Foster and Ratnieks 2000 Polyandrous 1 0.46 –0.02 1 30 15 0 Foster and Ratnieks 2000 All 1 0.62 0.06 69 9 235 158.2 36.7 Foster et al. 2001 Foster and Ratnieks 2000 Dolichovespula media 1 0.71 0.105 74 8 148 7.4 Foster et al. 2001 Foster et al. 2001 Dolichovespula maculata 1 0.75  a 0.125 181 7 153.3 20.9 Foster et al. 2001 Foster et al. 2001 Dolichovespula sylvestris 1 0.68 0.09 76 10 153.5 9.8 Foster et al. 2001 Foster et al. 2001 Dolichovespula norwegica 1 0.71 0.105 44 8 151.8 2.6 Foster et al. 2001 Foster et al. 2001 Vespula vulgaris 1 0.51 0.005 1,000 9 270 171 0 Greene 1991 Foster and Ratnieks 2001a Vespula germanica Monandrous 1 0.69 0.095 6 150 35.4 0 Goodisman et al. 2002 Polyandrous 1 0.16 –0.17 6 106 27.5 50.8 Goodisman et al. 2002 All 1 0.42 –0.04 1,000 12 256 62.9 22 Greene 1991 Goodisman et al. 2002 Vespa crabro 1 0.67 0.085 550 14 282 176 0 Foster et al. 2000 DISCUSSION Our survey revealed that queens produced the majority of males in most of the species, and in less than 10% of the species did workers produce more than half of the males, in line with earlier surveys based largely on behavioral data ( Bourke 1988 ; Choe 1988 ). Since workers of all the species included in our survey have functional ovaries, this demonstrates that self-restraint and worker-policing are widespread and powerful mechanisms that regulate reproduction in colonies of social Hymenoptera. Our comparative study did not support the view that intra- and interspecific variation in male parentage can be accounted for by the relatedness hypothesis only. First, and most importantly, the proportion of males produced by workers was not significantly associated with colony kin structure. This was true both when within-species variation in colony kin structure was included and when it was ignored. In fact, although the relatedness hypothesis predicts a positive relationship between WPM and r diff , the analyses of relatedness revealed a tendency for a negative relationship. Importantly, our study included data from 50 species, and our power analyses showed that we had enough power to detect a relationship between male parentage and colony kin structure if it was of moderate or large effect. A second line of evidence against the relatedness hypothesis came from the finding that workers produce only very few males in a large number of species where, on purely relatedness grounds, they would benefit from producing males. Workers produce less than 10% of males in 30 of the 43 species (70%) in which workers were more related to worker-produced than to queen-produced males. A third line of evidence came from within-species comparisons. Only in Dolichovespula saxonica ( Foster and Ratnieks 2000 ) were patterns of male parentage compatible with the relatedness hypothesis. By contrast, patterns of male parentage contradicted the relatedness hypothesis in the ants Leptothorax acervorum ( Hammond et al. 2003 ), Lasius niger ( Fjerdingstad et al. 2002 ), Formica exsecta ( Sundström et al. 1996 ; Walin et al. 1998 ), and Myrmica tahoensis ( Evans 1998 ). Interestingly, intraspecific variation in colony sex ratios in agreement with relatedness predictions have been shown in L. acervorum ( Chan and Bourke 1994 ; Chan et al. 1999 ; Hammond et al. 2002 ), F. exsecta ( Sundström et al. 1996 ), and M. tahoensis ( Evans 1995 , 1998 ). This suggests that although workers in these species can assess within-colony relatedness, they do not appear to respond to it in the context of the conflict over male parentage ( Walin et al. 1998 ; Hammond et al. 2003 ). The lack of association between kin structure and the degree of male parentage by workers indicates that factors others than relatedness effectively act as a brake on worker reproduction. The finding of no significant effect of colony size on WPM suggests that the ratio of queens to workers is not an important general factor regulating reproductive division of labor in social Hymenoptera. The low instance of worker reproduction is therefore unlikely to be the consequence of queens using aggression or pheromones to suppress worker reproduction, except, perhaps, in the few species with very small numbers of workers (e.g., Strassmann et al. 2003 ). Most importantly, unchecked worker reproduction is likely to reduce overall colony productivity and may therefore reduce the average fitness of colony members. For example, reproductive workers have been found to spend time engaged in dominance interactions and egg-laying ( Cole 1986 ) that otherwise would be used for foraging and brood rearing. Unchecked worker reproduction could also cause a “tragedy of the commons” ( Hardin 1968 ; Frank 1995 , 1996 ), because there would be more male brood than can be reared by the colony. If queens conceal the sex of their eggs ( Nonacs 1993 ), these costs may also include workers mistakenly replacing queen-laid diploid eggs with their own male eggs. Furthermore, costs incurred by workers biasing colony sex ratios can select for worker-policing behavior ( Foster and Ratnieks 2001b ). Theory shows that these costs do not have to be large for worker-policing and self-restraint to be selected ( Ratnieks 1988 ). Our data showed considerable variation across species in the origin of males, raising the question, what are the factors underlying interspecific variation in male parentage? The efficiency hypothesis predicts that the extent of worker-produced males should depend largely on the shape and slope of the function relating colony productivity and worker efficiency. This property is expected to vary across species, and it is conceivable that closely related species, which are likely to live in similar habitats and have similar life histories, also have similar functions relating colony productivity and worker efficiency. Consistent with this prediction, our analysis revealed a significant phylogenetic signal, with closely related species being more similar in terms of the origin of males than expected by chance. Importantly, this similarity was not due to a greater similarity in kin structure and colony size between closely related species, because these two factors had no significant effect on the origin of males. Previous evidence for the view that the relatedness hypothesis can account for variation in male parentage comes mostly from matched comparisons between honey bees (genus Apis ) and singly mated stingless bees (tribe Meliponini) ( Ratnieks 1988 ; Peters et al. 1999 ) and comparisons within vespine wasps ( Foster and Ratnieks 2001c ). However, a closer inspection of these matched comparisons reveals problems. In the matched comparison with honey bees, stingless bees are generally assumed to have worker-produced males. However, there is considerable variation in levels of worker reproduction, with males in the majority of species being exclusively queen-produced ( Figure 1 ). Moreover, workers of some stingless bee species are completely sterile ( Suka and Inoue 1993 ; Boleli et al. 2000 ), indicating that considering stingless bees as a taxon with generalized worker reproduction is not warranted. Similarly, the matched comparison in vespine wasps also has problems. It is true that males are queen-produced, and that workers police one another in Vespula vulgaris, a species in which queens are multiply mated ( Foster and Ratnieks 2001a ), whereas at least some males are worker-produced in Dolichovespula, a species in which queens are singly mated ( Foster et al. 2001 ). However, the wasp most basal in the phylogeny (Vespa crabro) is singly mated, yet males are all queen-produced because workers police one another ( Foster et al. 2000 , 2002 ). Considering Vespa, Vespula, and Dolichovespula together, the most parsimonious explanation is that worker-policing is the ancestral state in vespines and it has been lost, or at least reduced, in Dolichovespula. In short, neither of these traditional lines of support for the relatedness hypothesis stand up to close scrutiny. In conclusion, our comparative analysis does not support relatedness as the general explanation of patterns of male parentage and occurrence of worker-policing in social Hymenoptera. The concentration of published examples of worker-policing in multiply mated bees and wasps probably reflects the influence of the relatedness hypothesis on the selection of study taxa, rather than relatedness being the ultimate explanation of worker-policing. Moreover, recent studies have revealed worker-policing in species in which the relatedness hypothesis predicts males to be produced by workers ( Kikuta and Tsuji 1999 ; Foster et al. 2002 ; Hartmann et al. 2003 ; Iwanishi et al. 2003 ). We conclude that costs associated with worker reproduction are likely to be significant and variation in these costs to be the main factor underlying differences across species in the origin of males. Experimental investigations of the colony-level costs of worker reproduction have begun ( Lopez-Vaamonde et al. 2003 ). More are needed. It will also be important to conduct behavioral assays to determine whether worker-policing, by either egg-eating or aggression toward workers with developing ovaries, is responsible for the lack of worker reproduction in the stingless bee genera Trigona and Plebeia. Finally, we would like to stress that the finding that kin structure alone cannot account for the intra- and interspecific variation in male parentage does not amount to saying that kin structure is unimportant. Rather, it may work in concert with costs as a force influencing patterns of male parentage in social insects. Thus, this study reveals greater harmony and more complex regulation of reproduction in social insect colonies than that expected from simple theoretical expectations based on relatedness alone. MATERIALS AND METHODS For all analyses, the response variable was WPM (see Table 1 ). For almost all studies, estimates of WPM took into account the power of the genetic markers to detect worker reproduction using either exclusion ( Foster et al. 2001 ) or maximum likelihood approaches ( Arévalo et al. 1998 ). Where this type of analysis was not included in the original paper we reanalyzed data using the exclusion-based approach of Foster et al. (2001) . Specific details of how we treated data are given for each species in Protocol S1 . With comparative analyses there is always the difficult question of deciding “quality control” criteria to ensure that data are reliable and comparable. We collated data from published, in-press, and unpublished sources where colony genetic structure and male parentage were known accurately from molecular genetic markers. We restricted our survey to those including molecular genetic data, because recent genetic studies have shown that colony kin structures inferred from behavioral observations are often incorrect (e.g., mating frequency in Leptothorax nylanderi c.f. Plateaux 1981 ; Foitzik et al. 1997 ; Foster and Ratnieks 2001c ), and in some social insect taxa (e.g., stingless bees and ants), workers lay trophic eggs that mistakenly could be counted as reproductive ( Bourke 1988 ). We also restricted our analysis to queen-containing (queenright) colonies and species in which workers have ovaries. We did this because our aim was to investigate the outcome of worker–queen and worker–worker conflict. For those studies that included data on both queenright and queenless colonies, we considered male parentage in queenright colonies only ( Protocol S1 ; e.g., Vespula germanica [ Goodisman et al. 2002 ]). For all but two species, Leptothorax unifaciatus and Epimyrma ravouxi (L. Keller, J. Heinze, and A. F. G. Bourke, unpublished data), data were for adult or pupal males. For these two exceptional species, we had estimates of WPM at only the egg stage. However, as we found few worker-laid male eggs in both species (see Table 1 ), our estimate of WPM at the egg stage most likely reflected WPM in adults. In our comparative analyses we used log 10 WPM. COLONY GENETIC STRUCTURE We made predictions about the parentage of males based on colony kin structure by calculating r diff , the theoretical difference in relatedness of workers to queen- ( r w–qm ) and to worker-produced males ( r w–wm ) (see Table 1 ). The relatedness hypothesis predicts that if r diff is positive, males are worker-produced, and if r diff is negative, males are queen-produced, because workers should police one another. For colonies headed by single queens, where variation in colony genetic structure is caused by variation in the effective mating frequency of queens ( Pamilo 1993 ), we calculated r diff as (2 r w–w – 1)/4, where r w–w is the relatedness among adult workers. For species with variation in queen number (polygyny), predictions about worker reproduction are more complicated because both queen number and queen relatedness are important ( Pamilo 1991 ). For these species, we estimated r diff from the actual relatedness of workers to queens ( r w–q ) and among workers ( r w–w ) as r diff = ( r w–w – r w–q )/2. In our comparative analyses we used r diff as a continuous explanatory variable, or we coded r diff categorically as one when r diff was greater than zero (worker-produced males predicted), or as zero when r diff was less than zero (queen-produced males predicted). COLONY SIZE We defined colony size as the number of adult workers per nest ( n w ; see Table 1 ). Where only ranges of worker number were given, we took the midpoint value, and if more than one estimate was available, we combined data by calculating unweighted means. In our comparative analysis we used log 10 n w as an explanatory variable. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS We constructed an ant, bee, and wasp phylogeny (see Figure 1 ) by combining published phylogenies. For ants, we based our phylogeny on Keller and Genoud's (see Figure 3 in Keller and Genoud [1997] ), which we modified in light of a recent combined molecular and morphological phylogeny ( Ward and Brady 2003 ); for bees, we based it on a combined DNA and morphological phylogeny (see Figure 5 in Cameron and Mardulyn [2001] ), and for wasps, on a morphological and behavioral phylogeny ( Smith et al. 2001 ). In addition, we added phylogenetic details for the Meliponini (stingless bees) following Velthuis (1997) , and for leptothoracine ants, we used the molecular phylogeny of Baur et al. (1996) . We placed bees basal to ants and wasps (see Figure 1 ) ( Brothers and Carpenter 1993 ; Brothers 1999 ). We set all branch lengths equal, corresponding to a punctuational view of evolutionary change, and we considered ambiguous nodes to be unresolved. Using this tree, we tested the assumption of the phylogenetic independence of our three variables (log 10 WPM, r diff , and log 10 n w ) by a test for serial independence ( Abouheif 1999 ) calculated by the program Phylogenetic Independence ( Reeve and Abouheif 2003 ). For these analyses, we rotated nodes within our dataset 10,000 times and randomly shuffled our data 10,000 times to generate our null distribution. As all three variables showed significant phylogenetic nonindependence (see Results ), we used Felsenstein's method of independent contrasts in our comparative analyses ( Felsenstein 1985 ). Analyses using r diff coded categorically were carried out using the “Brunch” algorithm in CAIC ( Purvis and Rambaut 1995 ), whereas analyses using r diff and log 10 n w coded as continuous variables were analyzed using the program PDTREE ( Garland et al. 1999 ; Garland and Ives 2000 ). We tested Brunch analyses for significance by comparing the mean independent contrast against zero using t -tests. We tested for the significance of contrasts generated by PDTREE by regression through the origin. We did not reduce the number of degrees of freedom (df), as has been suggested for phylogenies containing polytomies ( Purvis and Garland 1993 ), because none of our analyses were significant without such adjustment. Power analyses (see below) were calculated using R ( http://www.r-project.org/ ). All other statistical tests were performed using SPSS (version 11). We tested the hypothesis that colony kin structure determines patterns of male parentage both when within-species variation in kin structure was ignored and when it was included. In our first set of two analyses, we used estimates of WPM and r diff that were mean values for each species. We calculated independent contrasts between log 10 WPM and r diff , and with r diff coded as a categorical variable. In our second set of two analyses, we included within-species variation in colony genetic structure that was present in seven species because of facultative variation in queen number or queen mating frequency (see Table 1 ). We did this by calculating r diff per colony and grouping colonies into those where r diff was positive (worker-production of males was predicted), and those where r diff was negative (males were predicted to be queen-produced because of worker-policing). We then estimated WPM for each group. We modified the phylogeny by adding an additional bifurcation at the tips corresponding to these seven species (see Figure 1 ). Although it is not necessary to control for phylogeny when testing hypotheses within species, doing so enabled us to combine evidence from within- and among-species comparisons ( Garland et al. 1992 ). Using our modified dataset, we calculated independent contrasts between log 10 WPM and r diff , and with r diff coded as a categorical variable. We tested the role of colony size in two ways. First, we ignored any effect of relatedness and simply compared contrasts in log 10 WPM with contrasts in log 10 n w . Second, we controlled for relatedness by limiting our analysis to species in which workers were more related to worker- than to queen-produced males (i.e., r diff was positive), and then compared contrasts in log 10 WPM with contrasts in log 10 n w in this subset of the data. STATISTICAL POWER To investigate the power of our analysis, we first determined the expected relationship between WPM and r diff in our dataset. To do that we set WPM to 0% when r diff was less than zero, to 100% when r diff was greater than zero, and to 50% when r diff was equal to zero. An analysis of independent contrasts based on this hypothetical relationship gave a highly significant relationship between WPM and r diff both when within-species variation was ignored ( β = 5.48, t = 6.57, df = 48, p < 0.0001) and included ( β = 6.59, t = 9.12, df = 55, p < 0.0001). On the basis of these slopes, we conducted a power analysis by assuming two types of effects. We considered r diff to have a “large” effect on WPM when β was greater than 4.0, and a “moderate” effect when β was between 2.0 and 4.0. To test the power that our analysis had to detect a large and moderate effect, we used the model y = βx + “resampled residual of y ,” where x is the observed standardized contrast in r diff and “resampled residual of y ” is the residual of y estimated by resampling the distribution of residuals from our observed regressions through the origin. From this model, we defined power as the proportion of regressions (forced through the origin) in 1,000 simulated datasets that were significant at α ≤ 0.05 for a given slope β (the effect size). We investigated how power varied with effect size by increasing β incrementally from 1 to 5 in steps of 0.1 (see Figure 3 ). SUPPORTING INFORMATION A detailed synopsis of how data used in this paper were selected from published and unpublished sources. (86 KB DOC). REFERENCES [1] References 1 Abouheif E A method for testing the assumption of phylogenetic independence in comparative data. Evol Ecol Res 1999 1 895 909 [2] 2 Arévalo E Strassmann JE Queller DC Conflicts of interest in social insects: Male production in two species of Polistes . Evolution 1998 52 797 805 [3] 3 Baur A Sanetra M Chalwatzis N Buschinger A Zimmermann FK Sequence comparisons of the internal transcribed spacer region of ribosomal genes support close relationships between parasitic ants and their respective host species (Hymenoptera: Formicidae). Insectes Soc 1996 43 53 67 [4] 4 Beig D The production of males in queenright colonies of Trigona (Scaptotrigona) postica . J Apicult Res 1972 11 33 39 [5] 5 Boleli IC Paulino-Simões ZL Bitondi MMG Regression of the lateral oviducts during the larval–adult transformation of the reproductive system of Melipona quadrifasciata and Frieseomelitta varia . J Morphol 2000 243 141 151 [6] 6 Bourke AFG Worker reproduction in the higher eusocial Hymenoptera. Q Rev Biol 1988 63 291 311 [7] 7 Bourke AFG Colony size, social complexity and reproductive conflict in social insects. J Evol Biol 1999 12 245 257 [8] 8 Brothers DJ Phylogeny and evolution of wasps, ants and bees (Hymenoptera, Chrysidoidea, Vespoidea and Apoidea). Zool Scr 1999 28 233 249 [9] 9 Brothers DJ Carpenter JM Phylogeny of the Aculeata: Chrysidoidea and Vespoidea (Hymenoptera). J Hymenopt Res 1993 2 227 304 [10] 10 Brown MJF Schmid-Hempel R Schmid-Hempel P Queen-controlled sex ratios and worker reproduction in the bumble bee Bombus hypnorum as revealed by microsatellites. Mol Ecol 2003 12 1599 1605 [11] 11 Brown WD Keller L Sundström L Sex allocation in mound-building ants: The roles of resources and queen replenishment. Ecology 2002 83 1945 1952 [12] 12 Cameron SA Mardulyn P Multiple molecular data sets suggest independent origins of highly eusocial behavior in bees (Hymenoptera: Apinae). Syst Biol 2001 50 194 214 [13] 13 Chan GL Bourke AFG Split sex ratios in a multiple-queen ant population. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 1994 258 261 266 [14] 14 Chan GL Hingle A Bourke AFG Sex allocation in a facultatively polygynous ant: Between-population and between-colony variation. Behav Ecol 1999 10 409 421 [15] 15 Choe JC Worker reproduction and social evolution in ants (Hymenoptera: Formicidae). In: Trager JC, editor. Advances in myrmecology. 1988 Leiden (The Netherlands) EJ Brill 163 187 [16] 16 Cole BJ The social behavior of Leptothorax allardycei (Hymenoptera, Formicidae): Time budgets and the evolution of worker reproduction. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 1986 18 165 173 [17] 17 Drumond PM Oldroyd BP Osborne K Worker reproduction in Austroplebeia australis Friese (Hymenoptera, Apidae, Meliponini). Insectes Soc 2000 47 333 336 [18] 18 Estoup A Solignac M Cornuet JM Precise assessment of the number of patrilines and of genetic relatedness in honeybee colonies. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 1994 258 1 7 [19] 19 Evans JD Relatedness threshold for the production of female sexuals in colonies of a polygynous ant, Myrmica tahoensis as revealed by microsatellite DNA analysis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1995 92 6514 6517 [20] 20 Evans JD Queen longevity, queen adoption, and posthumous indirect fitness in the facultatively polygynous ant Myrmica tahoensis . Behav Ecol Sociobiol 1996 39 275 284 [21] 21 Evans JD Parentage and sex allocation in the facultatively polygynous ant Myrmica tahoensis . Behav Ecol Sociobiol 1998 44 35 42 [22] 22 Felsenstein J Phylogenies and the comparative method. Am Nat 1985 125 1 15 [23] 23 Fjerdingstad EJ Gertsch PJ Keller L Why do some social insect queens mate with several males? Testing the sex-ratio manipulation hypothesis in Lasius niger . Evolution 2002 56 553 662 [24] 24 Fjerdingstad EJ Gertsch PJ Keller L The relationship between multiple mating by queens, within-colony genetic variability and fitness in the ant Lasius niger . J Evol Biol 2003 16 844 853 [25] 25 Foitzik S Population structure and sex allocation in the ant Leptothorax nylanderi . [dissertation]. 1998 Würzburg University of Würzburg [26] 26 Foitzik S Heinze J Microgeographic genetic structure and intraspecific parasitism in the ant Leptothorax nylanderi . Ecol Entomol 2001 26 449 456 [27] 27 Foitzik S Herbers JM Colony structure of a slavemaking ant. I. Intracolony relatedness, worker reproduction, and polydomy. Evolution 2001 55 307 315 [28] 28 Foitzik S Haberl M Gadau J Heinze J Mating frequency of Leptothorax nylanderi ant queens determined by microsatellite analysis. Insectes Soc 1997 44 219 227 [29] 29 Foster KR Ratnieks FLW Facultative worker policing in a wasp. Nature 2000 407 692 693 [30] 30 Foster KR Ratnieks FLW Convergent evolution of worker policing by egg eating in the honeybee and common wasp. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2001a 268 169 174 [31] 31 Foster KR Ratnieks FLW The effect of sex-allocation biasing on the evolution of worker policing in Hymenopteran societies. Am Nat 2001b 158 615 623 [32] 32 Foster KR Ratnieks FLW Paternity, reproduction and conflict in vespine wasps: A model system for testing kin selection predictions. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 2001c 50 1 8 [33] 33 Foster KR Ratnieks FLW Raybould AF Do hornets have zombie workers? Mol Ecol 2000 9 735 742 [34] 34 Foster KR Ratnieks FLW Gyllenstrand N Thorén PA Colony kin structure and male production in Dolichovespula wasps. Mol Ecol 2001 10 1003 1010 [35] 35 Foster KR Gulliver J Ratnieks FLW Worker policing in the European hornet Vespa crabro . Insectes Soc 2002 49 41 44 [36] 36 Frank SA Mutual policing and the repression of competition in the evolution of cooperative groups. Nature 1995 377 520 522 [37] 37 Frank SA Policing and group cohesion when resources vary. Anim Behav 1996 52 1163 1169 [38] 38 Freckleton RP Harvey PH Pagel M Phylogentic analysis and comparative data: A test and review of the evidence. Am Nat 2002 160 712 726 [39] 39 Garland TJ Ives AR Using the past to predict the present: Confidence intervals for regression equations in phylogenetic comparative methods. Am Nat 2000 155 346 364 [40] 40 Garland TJ Harvey PH Ives AR Procedures for the analysis of comparative data using phylogentically independent contrasts. Syst Biol 1992 41 18 32 [41] 41 Garland TJ Midford PE Ives AR An introduction to phylogentically based statistical methods, with a new method for confidence intervals on ancestral values. Am Zool 1999 39 374 388 [42] 42 Goodisman MAD Matthews RW Crozier RH Mating and reproduction in the wasp Vespula germanica . Behav Ecol Sociobiol 2002 51 497 502 [43] 43 Green CL Oldroyd BP Queen mating frequency and maternity of males in the stingless bee Trigona carbonaria Smith. Insectes Soc 2002 49 196 202 [44] 44 Greene A Dolichovespula and Vespula . In: Ross KG, Mathews RW, editors. The social biology of wasps. 1991 Ithaca (New York) Cornell University Press 263 305 [45] 45 Halling LA Oldroyd BP Wattanachaiyingcharoen W Barron AB Nanork P Worker policing in the bee Apis florea . Behav Ecol Sociobiol 2001 49 509 513 [46] 46 Hamilton WD The genetical evolution of social behaviour, I, II. J Theor Biol 1964 7 1 52 [47] 47 Hammond RL Bruford MW Bourke AFG Ant workers selfishly bias sex ratios by manipulating female development. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2002 269 173 178 [48] 48 Hammond RL Bruford MW Bourke AFG Male parentage does not vary with colony kin structure in a multiple-queen ant. J Evol Biol 2003 16 446 455 [49] 49 Hardin G The tragedy of the commons. Science 1968 162 1243 1248 [50] 50 Hartmann A Wantia J Torres JA Heinze J Worker policing without genetic conflicts in a clonal ant. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2003 100 12836 12840 [51] 51 Hastings MD Queller DC Eischen F Strassmann JE Kin selection, relatedness, and worker control of reproduction in a large-colony epiponine wasp, Brachygastra mellifica . Behav Ecol 1998 9 573 581 [52] 52 Heard TA Dollin A Crop pollination with Australian stingless bees. In: Native bees of Australia Series Booklet 6. 1998 Sydney Australian Native Bee Research Centre 2 17 [53] 53 Heinze J Foitzik S Oberstadt B Rüppell O Hölldobler B A female caste specialized for the production of unfertilized eggs in the ant Crematogaster smithi . Naturwissenschaften 1999 86 93 95 [54] 54 Heinze J Strätz M Pedersen JS Haberl M Microsatellite analysis suggests occassional worker reproduction in the monogynous ant Crematogaster smithi . Insectes Soc 2000 47 299 301 [55] 55 Henshaw MT Strassmann JE Quach SQ Queller DC Male production in Parachartergus colobopterus a neotropical, swarm-founding wasp. Ethol Ecol Evol 2000 12 161 174 [56] 56 Henshaw MT Queller DC Strassmann JE Control of male production in the swarm-founding wasp, Polybioides tabidus . J Evol Biol 2002 15 262 268 [57] 57 Herbers JM Mouser RL Microsatellite DNA markers reveal details of social structure in forest ants. Mol Ecol 1998 7 299 306 [58] 58 Hölldobler B Wilson EO The ants. 1990 Berlin Springer Verlag [59] 59 Iwanishi S Hasegawa E Ohkawara K Worker oviposition and policing behaviour in the myrmicine ant Aphaenogaster smythiesi japonica Forel. Anim Behav 2003 66 513 519 [60] 60 Keller L Levels of selection in evolution. 1999 Princeton (New Jersey) Princeton University Press [61] 61 Keller L Genoud M Extraordinary lifespans in ants: A test of evolutionary theories of ageing. Nature 1997 389 958 960 [62] 62 Kikuta N Tsuji K Queen and worker policing in the monogynous and monandrous ant, Diacamma sp . Behav Ecol Sociobiol 1999 46 180 189 [63] 63 Lindauer M Kerr WE Die gegenseitige Verständigung bei den stachellosen Bienen. Z Vergl Physiol 1958 41 405 434 [64] 64 Lindauer M Kerr WE Communication between the workers of stingless bees. Bee World 1960 41 29 71 [65] 65 Lopez-Vaamonde C Koning JW Jordan WC Bourke AFG No evidence that reproductive bumblebee workers reduce the production of new queens. Anim Behav 2003 56 577 584 [66] 66 Machado MFPS Contel EPB Kerr WE Proportion of males sons-of-the-queen and sons-of-workers in Plebeia droryana (Hymenoptera, Apidae) estimated from data of an MDH isozymic polymorphic system. Genetica 1984 65 193 198 [67] 67 Maynard-Smith J Szathmáry E The major transitions in evolution. 1995 New York Freeman [68] 68 Michod RE Roze D Cooperation and conflict in the evolution of multicellularity. Heredity 2001 86 1 7 [69] 69 Monnin T Ratnieks FLW Policing in queenless ponerine ants. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 2001 50 97 108 [70] 70 Nonacs P Male parentage and sexual deception in the social Hymenoptera. In: Wrensch DL, Ebbert MA, editors. Evolution and diversity of sex ratio in insects and mites. 1993 New York Chapman and Hall 384 401 [71] 71 Oldroyd BP Halling LA Good G Wattanachaiyingcharoen W Barron AB Worker policing and worker reproduction in Apis cerana . Behav Ecol Sociobiol 2001 50 371 377 [72] 72 Palmer KA Oldroyd BP Evolution of multiple mating in the genus Apis . Apidologie 2000 31 235 248 [73] 73 Palmer KA Oldroyd BP Quezada-Euán JJG Paxton RJ May-Itza WdJ Paternity frequency and maternity of males in some stingless bee species. Mol Ecol 2002 11 2107 2113 [74] 74 Pamilo P Evolution of colony characteristics in social insects. II. Number of reproductive individuals. Am Nat 1991 138 412 433 [75] 75 Pamilo P Polyandry and allele frequency differences between the sexes in the ant Formica aquilonia . Heredity 1993 70 472 480 [76] 76 Paxton RJ Thorén PA Estoup A Tengö J Queen-worker conflict over male production and the sex ratio in a facultatively polyandrous bumblebee, Bombus hypnorum The consequences of nest usurpation. Mol Ecol 2001 10 2489 2498 [77] 77 Paxton RJ Bego LR Shah MM Mateus S Low mating frequency of queens in the stingless bee Scaptotrigona postica and worker maternity of males. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 2003 53 174 181 [78] 78 Peters JM Queller DC Imperatriz-Fonseca VL Roubik DW Strassmann JE Mate number, kin selection and social conflicts in stingless bees and honeybees. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 1999 266 379 384 [79] 79 Plateaux L The pallens morph of the ant Leptothorax nylanderi description, formal genetics, and study of populations. In: Howse PE, Clément JL, editors. Biosystematics of social insects. 1981 New York Academic Press 63 74 [80] 80 Purvis A Garland TJ Polytomies in comparative analyses of continuous characters. Syst Biol 1993 42 569 575 [81] 81 Purvis A Rambaut A Comparative analysis by independent contrasts (CAIC): An Apple Macintosh application for analysing comparative data. Comp Appl Biosci 1995 11 247 251 [82] 82 Queller DC Relatedness and the fraternal major transitions. Phil Trans R Soc B Biol Sci 2000 355 1647 1655 [83] 83 Ratnieks FLW Reproductive harmony via mutual policing by workers in eusocial Hymenoptera. Am Nat 1988 132 217 236 [84] 84 Ratnieks FLW Visscher PK Worker policing in the honeybee. Nature 1989 342 796 797 [85] 85 Reeve J Abouheif E Phylogenetic independence, version 2.0. 2003 Department of Biology, McGill University, Montreal, Canada [86] 86 Sanetra M Crozier RH Polyandry and colony genetic structure in the primitive ant Nothomyrmecia macrops . J Evol Biol 2001 14 368 378 [87] 87 Seeley TD Seeley RH Akratanakul P Colony defense strategies of the honeybees in Thailand. Ecol Monogr 1982 52 43 63 [88] 88 Smith AR O'Donnell S Jeanne RL Correlated evolution of colony defence and social structure: A comparative analysis in eusocial wasps (Hymenoptera: Vespidae). Evol Ecol Res 2001 3 331 344 [89] 89 Snyder LE Herbers JM Polydomy and sexual allocation ratios in the ant Myrmica punctiventris . Behav Ecol Sociobiol 1991 28 409 415 [90] 90 Starr CK Sperm competition, kinship, and sociality in the aculeate Hymenoptera. In: Smith RL, editor. Sperm competition and the evolution of animal mating systems. 1984 Orlando (Florida) Academic Press 427 464 [91] 91 Strassmann JE Nguyen JS Arévalo E Cervo R Zacchi F Worker interests and male production in Polistes gallicus , a Mediterranean social wasp. J Evol Biol 2003 16 254 259 [92] 92 Suka T Inoue T Nestmate recognition of the stingless bee Trigona (Tetragonula) minangkabau (Apidae: Meliponinae). J Ethol 1993 11 141 147 [93] 93 Sundström L Chapuisat M Keller L Conditional manipulation of sex ratios by ant workers: A test of kin selection theory. Science 1996 274 993 995 [94] 94 Tóth E Queller DC Imperatriz-Fonseca VL Strassmann JE Genetic and behavioral conflict over male production between workers and queens in the stingless bee Paratrigona subnuda . Behav Ecol Sociobiol 2002a 53 1 8 [95] 95 Tóth E Strassmann JE Nogueira-Neto P Imperatriz-Fonseca VL Queller DC Male production in stingless bees: Variable outcomes of queen–worker conflict. Mol Ecol 2002b 11 2661 2667 [96] 96 Tóth E Strassmann JE Imperatriz-Fonseca VL Queller DC Queens, not workers, produce the males in the stingless bee Schwarziana quadripunctata quadripunctata . Anim Behav 2003 66 359 368 [97] 97 Tóth E Queller DC Dollin A Strassmann JE Conflict over male production in stingless bees. Insectes Soc 2004 51 1 11 [98] 98 van Benthem FDJ Imperatriz-Fonseca VL Velthuis HHW Biology of the stingless bee Plebeia remota (Holmberg): Observations and evolutionary implications. Insectes Soc 1995 42 71 87 [99] 99 Velthuis HHW The biology of stingless bees. 1997 Utrecht (The Netherlands) Utrecht University [100] 100 Villesen P Boomsma JJ Patterns of male-parentage in the fungus-growing ants. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 2003 53 246 253 [101] 101 Villesen P Murakami T Schultz TR Boomsma JJ Identifying the transition between single and multiple mating of queens in fungus-growing ants. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2002 269 1541 1548 [102] 102 Visscher PK Reproductive conflict in honey bees: A stalemate of worker egg-laying and policing. Behav Ecol Sociobiol 1996 39 237 244 [103] 103 Walin L Sundström L Seppä P Rosengren R Worker reproduction in ants—A genetic analysis. Heredity 1998 81 604 612 [104] 104 Ward PS Brady SG Phylogeny and biogeography of the ant subfamily Myrmeciinae (Hymenoptera: Formicidae). Invertebr Syst 2003 17 361 386 [105] 105 Wattanachaiyingcharoen W Oldroyd BP Good G Halling L Ratnieks FLW Lack of worker reproduction in the giant honey bee Apis dorsata Fabricius. Insectes Soc 2002 49 80 85 [106] 106 Whitfield J The police state. Nature 2002 414 782 784 [107] 107 Wille A Michener CD The nest architecture of stingless bees with special reference to those of Costa Rica. Rev Biol Trop 1973 21 (Suppl 1) 1 278 [108] 108 Woyciechowski M Lomnicki A Multiple mating of queens and the sterility of workers among eusocial Hymenoptera. J Theor Biol 1987 128 317 327