Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 Guided Uncertainty in public service journeys: A behavioral framework for understanding administrative burden and operational friction Guided Uncertainty em jornadas de serviços públicos: Um framework comportamental para compreender o fardo administrativo e a fricção operacional Guided Uncertainty en las trayectorias de los servicios públicos: Un framework conductual para comprender la carga administrativa y la fricción operativa Received: 08/27/2026 | Accepted: 08/31/2026 | Published: 09/02/2026 Cristiano Nascimento Pombo da Paz ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0007-8306-5529 Independent Research, United States E-mail: cristiano@guideduncertainty.com Abstract This conceptual study aims to develop Guided Uncertainty, an applied behavioral framework for public service journeys in which an important outcome remains uncertain while the person continues navigating the process under meaningful guidance from a person, team, organization, or system. Methodologically, the article integrates literature on administrative burden, behavioral public administration, uncertainty management, service experience, and journey design; examines documented U.S. cases involving the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) as analytical tests of fit and boundaries; and compares the framework with existing behavioral and simplification approaches. The resulting framework distinguishes Outcome Uncertainty from Journey Uncertainty, proposes Emotional Phases as an analytical unit distinct from operational steps, and organizes intervention through four connected movements: Understand, Design, Guide, and Learn. Guided Uncertainty links cognitive and emotional conditions to plausible behavioral and operational risks and uses this diagnosis to structure preventive responses in process, information, communication, and guidance. The study concludes that public organizations may reduce avoidable uncertainty about the journey and mitigate experiential, behavioral, and operational consequences even when substantive uncertainty must remain, without changing decision criteria or implying a favorable outcome. The article also formulates testable propositions and a research agenda for empirical development across public service contexts. Keywords: Administrative burden; Behavioral public administration; Public service delivery; Uncertainty; Guided Uncertainty. Resumo Este estudo conceitual tem como objetivo desenvolver Guided Uncertainty, um framework comportamental aplicado a jornadas de serviços públicos nas quais um resultado relevante permanece incerto enquanto a pessoa continua navegando pelo processo sob orientação significativa de uma pessoa, equipe, organização ou sistema. Metodologicamente, o artigo integra literatura sobre fardo administrativo, administração pública comportamental, gestão da incerteza, experiência de serviços e design de jornadas; examina casos documentados dos Estados Unidos envolvendo Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) e Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) como testes analíticos de adequação e limites; e compara o framework com abordagens comportamentais e de simplificação existentes. Como resultado, Guided Uncertainty distingue Outcome Uncertainty de Journey Uncertainty, propõe Emotional Phases como unidade analítica distinta das etapas operacionais e organiza a intervenção em quatro movimentos conectados: Understand, Design, Guide e Learn. O framework relaciona condições cognitivas e emocionais a riscos comportamentais e operacionais plausíveis e orienta respostas preventivas no processo, informação, comunicação e condução. O estudo conclui que organizações públicas podem reduzir incerteza evitável sobre a jornada e mitigar consequências experienciais, comportamentais e operacionais mesmo quando a incerteza substantiva precisa permanecer, sem alterar critérios de decisão ou presumir resultados favoráveis. Palavras-chave: Fardo administrativo; Administração pública comportamental; Serviços públicos; Incerteza; Guided Uncertainty. 1 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 Resumen Este estudio conceptual tiene como objetivo desarrollar Guided Uncertainty, un framework conductual aplicado a trayectorias de servicios públicos en las que un resultado importante permanece incierto mientras la persona continúa navegando por el proceso bajo una orientación significativa de una persona, equipo, organización o sistema. Metodológicamente, el artículo integra literatura sobre carga administrativa, administración pública conductual, gestión de la incertidumbre, experiencia de servicios y diseño de trayectorias; examina casos documentados de Estados Unidos relacionados con Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) y Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) como pruebas analíticas de adecuación y límites; y compara el framework con enfoques conductuales y de simplificación existentes. Como resultado, Guided Uncertainty distingue Outcome Uncertainty de Journey Uncertainty, propone Emotional Phases como unidad analítica distinta de las etapas operativas y organiza la intervención mediante cuatro movimientos conectados: Understand, Design, Guide y Learn. El framework relaciona condiciones cognitivas y emocionales con riesgos conductuales y operativos plausibles y utiliza este diagnóstico para estructurar respuestas preventivas en el proceso, la información, la comunicación y la orientación. El estudio concluye que las organizaciones públicas pueden reducir la incertidumbre evitable sobre la trayectoria y mitigar consecuencias experienciales, conductuales y operativas incluso cuando la incertidumbre sustantiva debe permanecer, sin modificar los criterios de decisión ni implicar un resultado favorable. Palabras clave: Carga administrativa; Administración pública conductual; Servicios públicos; Incertidumbre; Guided Uncertainty. 1. Introduction A public service can be legally and operationally legitimate and still place a person in a journey that is difficult to navigate. Someone who depends on a decision regarding a retirement benefit must live with uncertainty about access to a source of income that is important to their life while navigating a process that may be complex and prolonged. The agency cannot legitimately guarantee approval before completing its analysis, but it can substantially influence how that person experiences the journey. During periods of high personal importance, waiting, and low control, anxiety, insecurity, urgency, or frustration may coexist with the need to understand requests, gather evidence, respond correctly, and decide when to act or seek help. If the information received is insufficient, ambiguous, late, or inconsistent—including during service interactions— the person may misinterpret what is required, submit inadequate or incomplete documentation, miss a necessary action, or repeatedly seek clarification. The result may be a cumulative sequence: error, new requirement, rework, more waiting, and intensification of the same conditions that already made the journey difficult—potentially culminating, in some cases, in more serious avoidable consequences such as substantial delay, abandonment, or loss of access to a benefit because of failures that occurred during the journey itself. The same logic appears in other high-stakes journeys. A professional who depends on the issuance or renewal of a license to continue working may face increasing pressure as time passes without a decision or without sufficient information to understand progress and prepare appropriately. A student whose enrollment or ability to remain at a university depends on financial aid may face similar insecurity in the presence of delays, silence, or uninformative updates. The point is not that these people will necessarily react in the same way, but that foreseeable cognitive and emotional conditions can alter how information is interpreted and actions are performed. Depending on how process, communication, and guidance were designed, these conditions may be mitigated or aggravated. This makes preventive design of the process and guidance—considering the cognitive and emotional conditions reasonably expected throughout the journey—a central part of the problem, not merely a service detail. This guidance may be embedded in the process itself, digital systems, automated communications, and human interactions, which together or separately influence what the person understands, expects, and does throughout the journey. When human interaction exists, prepared professionals can play a particularly important role by anticipating foreseeable questions and risks, providing highquality information at the appropriate time, confirming understanding, preserving continuity, and calibrating guidance without interfering with the substantive decision. For the public organization, this capacity may mean fewer inadequate or incomplete 2 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 submissions, additional requests for information, avoidable contacts, reprocessing, and wasted operational time, as well as a better flow of information for analysis and substantive decision-making. The central problem examined in this article, therefore, is not simply satisfaction or emotional comfort. It is how cognitive and emotional conditions associated with uncertainty interact with process, information, and guidance and, through that interaction, may produce consequences for both the user and the public organization’s ability to execute its processes efficiently. Guided Uncertainty builds on established foundations in behavioral science, service design, uncertainty research, and public administration and organizes them for a specific domain: journeys in which an outcome of significant personal or professional importance remains materially uncertain while the person must continue navigating the process under meaningful guidance from a person, team, organization, or system. In this domain, the framework uses Outcome Uncertainty diagnostically—what remains unknown about the substantive outcome or its timing—and Journey Uncertainty—what remains unclear about navigation, such as the meaning of events, expectations, duration, next steps, required actions, or confirmation of completion. The literature already recognizes forms of uncertainty associated with process and outcome (Viglia et al., 2019; Ulaga & Kohli, 2018); the contribution proposed here lies in integrating this distinction with Emotional Phases, prospective risk, preventive design, continuous guidance, and learning. The framework further proposes that the human experience should not be forced into the same segmentation as the organization’s operational flow. An Emotional Phase is an analytical period characterized by a materially similar cognitiveemotional configuration that is relevant to behavior and guidance. It may span several operational steps, and a significant change in the person’s state may occur even when the formal process has not advanced. Waiting is the clearest example: operationally, nothing may change; psychologically and behaviorally, the journey may change substantially. Guided Uncertainty organizes the work into four connected movements. Understand identifies the journey’s Emotional Phases, expected cognitive and emotional conditions, plausible drivers, forms of uncertainty, and associated behavioral and operational risks. Design translates this diagnosis into preventive changes to process, information, expectations, communication, preparation, interaction, or other elements, seeking to anticipate risks before they become observable error or friction. Guide addresses how the person is actually guided through the journey as uncertainty unfolds, through the systems, communications, channels, and human interactions that constitute that guidance. It examines information quality and timing, proactivity, confirmation of understanding, continuity, handoffs, degraded trust, intensified conditions, and, when relevant human contact exists, the actions of the professionals responsible for guidance. Learn compares expectations with evidence, analytically measures outcomes at multiple levels, documents null and adverse results, and revises the diagnosis or framework when the metrics indicate that need. The research question is: How do cognitive and emotional conditions associated with uncertainty shape behavioral and operational friction throughout public service journeys, and how can these risks be systematically identified and addressed? This conceptual study aims to develop Guided Uncertainty, an applied behavioral framework for public service journeys in which an important outcome remains uncertain while the person continues navigating the process under meaningful guidance from a person, team, organization, or system. This article proposes three contributions. First, it specifies an uncertainty-centered problem structure within public service delivery, connecting the established literature on administrative burden and behavioral insights to a narrower and more complex class of journeys in which significant uncertainty persists. Second, it proposes Emotional Phases as an analytical unit distinct from operational steps, allowing diagnosis to follow material changes in cognitive-emotional conditions rather than only the agency’s workflow. Third, it extends diagnosis and intervention design to continuous guidance during execution, 3 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 including how that guidance is embedded in processes, systems, communications, and human or hybrid interactions, and connects that guidance to explicit measurement and revision. These contributions generate constructs, mechanisms, and propositions that can be subjected to empirical testing. Future studies may independently evaluate the propositions and the mechanisms integrated by the framework across different service contexts. 2. Methodology 2.1 Conceptual development and analytical approach This study combines documentary research based on official U.S. public-service sources, specifically documented evidence concerning Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), with a qualitative narrative review of relevant literature. Narrative reviews allow the integration and interpretive synthesis of theoretically relevant sources without the exhaustive and reproducible selection procedures characteristic of systematic reviews (Fernandes et al., 2023; Ogassavara et al., 2025). Consistent with this approach, the literature was selected for its direct relevance to the mechanisms and conceptual relationships examined in the study, while official and peer-reviewed evidence from U.S. public services was used to examine the framework’s fit and boundaries. The methodological structure supports the development of an applied behavioral framework for public service journeys (Risemberg et al., 2026). This article adopts a conceptual framework-development approach. Guided Uncertainty is examined and articulated as a framework for a bounded class of journeys in which an important outcome remains uncertain while the person must continue navigating the process under meaningful guidance. Relevant literature from administrative burden, behavioral public administration, uncertainty management, service research, procedural justice, and journey-oriented design is used to ground specific mechanisms, examine conceptual relationships, and position the framework relative to existing knowledge. The objective is not to report a new randomized trial or observational study, but to specify the problem domain, define analytical constructs, organize relationships among those constructs, and derive propositions that can be examined empirically. The framework is therefore evaluated in this article through conceptual coherence, correspondence with documented service problems, comparison with related approaches, and the formulation of observable implications for future testing. The analytical process proceeded in three connected steps. First, the article identified recurring problems in public service journeys in which an important outcome or its timing remains outside the user’s control while the user must continue interpreting information and performing required actions. Second, the framework’s constructs and relationships were examined against relevant literature and documented public-service evidence to clarify their theoretical grounding, areas of overlap, and distinctions from existing approaches. Third, these elements were organized into an applied architecture connecting diagnosis, preventive design, guidance during execution, and learning from observed outcomes. 2.2 Literature and comparative foundations The literature used in the conceptual development was selected for its direct relevance to the framework’s proposed mechanisms rather than as a systematic review intended to exhaust all scholarship in each field. Administrative burden research provides the principal public-administration foundation for learning, compliance, and psychological costs. Behavioral and psychological research informs appraisal, emotion, perceived control, responsiveness, and procedural experience. Service and uncertainty research supports distinctions among forms of uncertainty and the role of process and communication. Publicsector behavioral toolkits, behavioral journey mapping, sludge audits, human-centered design, and related approaches are examined comparatively to identify areas of overlap and the specific analytical problem that Guided Uncertainty seeks to address. 4 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 2.3 Selection and use of U.S. public service cases Documented U.S. public service cases were selected as analytical illustrations because they contain observable combinations of uncertainty, administrative requirements, communication or navigation problems, user action, and operational consequences. The 2024 Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) implementation and multiple Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) interventions provide evidence from governmental or peer-reviewed sources that permits examination of both fit and boundaries. These cases are not presented as empirical tests of Guided Uncertainty and the article does not attribute their observed outcomes to the framework. Instead, they are used to examine whether the proposed distinctions can organize documented problems without displacing technical, legal, capacity, eligibility, or other causal mechanisms outside the framework’s specific contribution. The resulting framework is assessed through testable propositions and a multilevel measurement logic that distinguishes experiential, behavioral, operational, and substantive outcomes. This design preserves a clear boundary between conceptual development and empirical validation: the article specifies what should be measured and which relationships should be tested, while independent applications and future studies are required to estimate effects, replicability, transferability, and incremental value. 3. Results 3.1 Administrative burden and public service journeys Research on administrative burden provides both a conceptual foundation and an important boundary for Guided Uncertainty. Moynihan et al. (2015) define administrative burden as learning, compliance, and psychological costs experienced in citizen-state interactions. Learning costs include the resources required to discover a program, understand eligibility, interpret requirements, and determine how to proceed. Compliance costs include the time, effort, documentation, and actions required to satisfy administrative requirements. Psychological costs include stress, stigma, loss of autonomy, cognitive load, and other adverse experiences associated with interacting with government. Herd and Moynihan (2018) show that these costs can influence access to programs and the practical availability of rights and benefits. These categories may interact within the same journey. A request for additional documentation resulting, for example, from a misunderstood instruction or from a requirement that was not adequately anticipated in the structure of the journey may combine learning costs, new compliance work, and psychological strain; if this combination makes it harder for the person to understand or respond and guidance is insufficient to help them correctly perform what is required, a legitimate requirement may generate an incorrect submission, another requirement, rework, and more waiting. Guided Uncertainty does not propose a replacement taxonomy: it asks how these conditions evolve when uncertainty is material, where they create execution risk, and how process, information, and guidance can be proactively structured to reduce these risks, support understanding and proper execution of required actions, and avoid errors, repeated contacts, and rework that affect both the user and the organization responsible for the service. Evidence that bureaucratic encounters can generate distinct emotional responses reinforces the need to take this question seriously. Hattke et al. (2020) experimentally examined emotional responses to excessive bureaucracy and found that administrative burden and delay elicited negative emotions, especially confusion, frustration, and anger. Their laboratory design used 136 participants and deliberately prioritized internal validity, so the results should not be mechanically generalized to U.S. public services or every administrative interaction. The contribution is narrower but important: emotion in citizen-state interaction is an empirically investigable phenomenon, not merely a rhetorical description of “poor user experience.” The existence of a legitimate administrative requirement does not, by itself, determine how that requirement will be 5 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 experienced or executed. Public agencies often require information to establish eligibility, protect public resources, ensure safety, or apply legal standards. Some uncertainty is also inevitable. An agency may be unable to determine whether a benefit, license, or authorization will be granted until the evidence is evaluated. The relevant question, therefore, is not always “How can this requirement be eliminated?” It may be: “How can the journey be structured and the person guided—through its processes, systems, communications, and, when applicable, human interactions— through a legitimate and uncertain requirement, reducing avoidable confusion, error, incomplete action, and rework without compromising the substantive decision?” This distinction separates Guided Uncertainty from a general burden-reduction agenda. Some burden is produced primarily by unnecessary paperwork, duplicate data collection, poor digital design, or excessive procedural requirements. These problems may be addressed more directly through process simplification, digitization, sludge reduction, legal reform, or investment in capacity. Guided Uncertainty becomes relevant when its domain conditions are present and cognitive or emotional conditions related to uncertainty plausibly contribute to behavioral or operational risk. The same distinction matters for evaluation. User experience, behavior, operational performance, and substantive outcomes may be related without moving together. A clearer status message may reduce repeated calls without changing eligibility; a redesigned uploader may reduce denials for incomplete information without increasing participation. Guided Uncertainty treats this separation as a methodological requirement: satisfaction is not a proxy for operational effectiveness, and a favorable substantive outcome is not a proxy for good guidance. The question is whether the target risk changed in the predicted direction and whether the evidence supports the proposed mechanism. 3.2 U.S. cases as tests of fit and boundaries Documented cases in the United States make it possible to examine how the distinctions proposed by Guided Uncertainty appear in observable public service delivery problems and to identify the limits of its application. The Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) are analyzed as cases of fit and boundary, allowing friction related to experience, behavior, and journey execution to be distinguished from predominantly technical, legal, or capacity problems. 3.2.1 FAFSA: A pattern of high fit within a broader implementation failure The 2024 implementation of the redesigned Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) provides a useful realworld boundary test. The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) found that the launch was delayed by three months and affected by technical problems that prevented some students from starting or completing the application. Among first-time applicants, submissions were about 9% below the prior cycle as of August 25, 2024. During the first five months of implementation, 4.0 million of 5.4 million calls to the Department of Education call center—74%—went unanswered. GAO also found that applicants did not always receive timely information about processing delays or how to navigate technical problems; some were told to “try again later,” while resolution sometimes took months. GAO concluded that the lack of timely support and clear communication contributed to applicant confusion (GAO, 2024). A significant portion of the documented FAFSA problems resulted from technical failures and capacity constraints that require their own solutions. For Guided Uncertainty, the complementary question is how people are guided through the journey while those conditions persist and an important outcome remains uncertain. It is precisely in this dimension that part of the documented FAFSA problems aligns with the framework. Students faced an important outcome—access to financial aid and the ability to make enrollment decisions. Relevant uncertainty about 6 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 timing and outcome remained outside their control. They had to continue making decisions while interpreting delays, technical errors, and incomplete status information. The organization had significant responsibility for guiding them through the process. In this subset, Journey Uncertainty is analytically distinct from the underlying technical failure: What does this error mean? Should I try again? Is my application preserved? When will the problem be fixed? Will I be notified? What should I do while I wait? These questions show how a technical failure can also produce a journey problem: in addition to fixing the defect, it becomes relevant to anticipate the cognitive and emotional conditions that may arise during the wait and structure process, information, communication, and guidance to reduce the risk of confusion, inappropriate actions, repeated contacts, and other avoidable consequences. FAFSA therefore illustrates both the potential and the boundary of the framework. Guided Uncertainty offers an architecture for diagnosing risks generated in the journey experience around a technical failure and proactively structuring how the user will be informed, prepared, and guided while it remains unresolved. This logic also allows foreseeable disruption or crisis scenarios to be incorporated into journey design, anticipating not necessarily the specific failure but the cognitive, emotional, behavioral, and operational conditions that may arise when normal flow is interrupted and pre-structuring appropriate forms of communication, guidance, and escalation. Correcting the technical failure still requires the corresponding technical solution; the framework acts on the behavioral and operational problems that may arise or intensify while the user navigates the situation. 3.2.2 SNAP: Incomplete action, process redesign, and divergence of outcomes Administration of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) provides an even cleaner example because the behavioral and operational targets are directly observable. In a 2024 U.S. Office of Evaluation Sciences (OES) evaluation involving 33,574 online applicants in a large southern state, applicants had to provide verification documents and complete an interview. Failure to complete required steps could result in denial for incomplete information rather than a determination of substantive ineligibility. OES observed that applicants could face cognitively demanding password requirements and uncertainty about whether documents had already been submitted. A text-message campaign linking to a simplified, mobilefriendly document uploader reduced denials for incomplete eligibility information by 1.1 percentage points, although it did not produce a detectable increase in overall SNAP participation (OES, 2024). This result is particularly relevant to Guided Uncertainty because it demonstrates why Learn must separate outcome classes. The intervention changed an operational process-related outcome—fewer denials for incomplete information—without significantly changing the final participation rate. A framework that measured only participation could fail to detect a meaningful process improvement; a framework that treated the reduction in procedural denial as evidence of increased benefit receipt would overstate the result. Guided Uncertainty explicitly requires this separation. The OES case also illustrates the difference between substantive and navigational uncertainty: the eligibility decision remained outside the applicant’s control, while questions about login, submission, and confirmation of documents were potentially modifiable. The intervention acted on the journey, not on eligibility. A separate randomized field experiment involving approximately 65,000 SNAP applicants in Los Angeles identified the initial interview as a major administrative barrier. Offering access to flexible interviews initiated by applicants themselves increased approvals by 6 percentage points, doubled early approvals, and increased long-term participation by more than 2 percentage points (Giannella et al., 2024). This experiment demonstrates that features of administrative design can materially affect user behavior and the procedural outcomes of a service journey. For Guided Uncertainty, the finding is particularly relevant because it shows that how a requirement is structured and executed can influence whether people are able to progress 7 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 appropriately through the process and, in some cases, affect later procedural and substantive outcomes. The study thus provides empirical support for the relevance of journey design, while the specific cognitive-emotional mechanisms proposed by Guided Uncertainty remain additional hypotheses to be examined empirically. 3.2.3 What these cases establish—and what they do not Taken together, these cases show that administrative burden, incomplete action, process navigation, communication, and operational capacity can produce measurable consequences, and that process outcomes and substantive outcomes can diverge. Table 2 summarizes the problems documented in these cases, their potential relevance to Guided Uncertainty, and other mechanisms or causes that also contributed to the observed outcomes. They also make it possible to observe, in real U.S. public service contexts, journey problems compatible with the domain examined by Guided Uncertainty and to delimit where its contribution may be relevant alongside technical, structural, or substantive causes that require other solutions. From here, the article formally presents the domain, constructs, and operational architecture of Guided Uncertainty (Section 3.3), examines its application to different public service scenarios (Section 3.4), and then situates its mechanisms within theoretical foundations and related approaches (Sections 4.1 and 4.2). 3.3 Guided Uncertainty: domain, constructs, and architecture 3.3.1 Domain conditions Guided Uncertainty is not intended for every public interaction or every administrative burden. Three conditions define the domain. First, the outcome has significant personal or professional importance for the Guided User, the person whose journey is being analyzed. Stakes may be financial, medical, legal, occupational, educational, familial, or otherwise materially relevant. Routine low-impact transactions may be inconvenient without warranting the framework. Second, a relevant part of the outcome or its timing is outside the Guided User’s control. The person may influence the outcome through preparation, documentation, choices, or timely action, but cannot determine it unilaterally. Third, meaningful guidance exists throughout the journey. A person, team, organization, or system plays a relevant role in how the Guided User understands, prepares for, and progresses through the process. Guidance may be human, digital, or hybrid; guidance is a function of the journey, not necessarily a human role. Once these conditions are met, the intensity of application may vary according to the journey’s duration, complexity, number of actors, waiting, handoffs, and behavioral risk. 3.3.2 Guided User, Guiding Professional, and Decision Authority The Guided User is the primary person or population whose journey is the object of analysis. Other people may participate materially without becoming the primary Guided User. Guidance refers to the function of guiding the Guided User through the journey, influencing how the user understands, prepares for, and progresses through the process. This function may be performed by people, digital systems, processes, or combinations of these mechanisms. When guidance is performed by a professional, Guided Uncertainty uses the term Guiding Professional to designate this human role. Decision Authority is the person, unit, organization, or other structure responsible for determining the substantive outcome when an identifiable decision-making authority exists. It may be the same person as the Guiding Professional, another person or unit within the same organization, or an external entity. 8 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 The distinction is especially important in government. A public organization may guide the person through the process and also apply the substantive criterion. Improving guidance does not require changing the criteria that determine the outcome. 3.3.3 Outcome Uncertainty and Journey Uncertainty Outcome Uncertainty concerns uncertainty about the substantive outcome or when it will occur: Will the benefit be approved? Will the license be granted? When will a determination be issued? Part of Outcome Uncertainty legitimately remains until evidence is analyzed or an external event occurs. Journey Uncertainty concerns uncertainty experienced while navigating the path: What is happening? Why was this requested? Is this delay normal? What does this status mean? What happens next? How long may this step take? What action is required? Was the document received? The distinction guides different responses. Avoidable Journey Uncertainty may be reduced through improvements to process, information, communication, or guidance. When Outcome Uncertainty must remain, process, preparation, and guidance can still, in some cases, reduce its cognitive and emotional impact and the likelihood that its effects produce errors, incomplete actions, repeated contacts, abandonment, or rework. 3.3.4 Emotional Phases Operational processes are usually segmented according to the work: application, review, request for evidence, interview, decision, appeal, renewal. Guided Uncertainty adds a different analytical segmentation. An Emotional Phase is a portion of the journey in which the Guided User can reasonably be expected to experience a materially similar cognitive-emotional configuration that is relevant to behavior and guidance. The phase changes when that configuration changes significantly, not simply when the organization advances to a new operational step. Several operational steps may occur within an Emotional Phase because the Guided User experiences similar emotions, concerns, and uncertainties. A single operational step—especially waiting—may contain several Emotional Phases as expectations, perceived control, concern, or trust change over time. Figure 1 illustrates this distinction by showing how Emotional Phases may span different numbers of operational steps and change independently of the formal progression of the process. 9 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 Figure 1. Relationship between operational stages and Emotional Phases. Source: Developed by the author. As Figure 1 illustrates, Emotional Phases and operational stages represent different dimensions of the same journey. An operational stage may contain multiple Emotional Phases, while an Emotional Phase may extend across more than one operational step. This distinction allows changes in the user’s experience and associated risks to be examined even when the formal process remains unchanged. 3.3.5 Diagnostic chain The diagnostic chain connects Emotional Phase, cognitive or emotional condition, plausible driver, behavioral risk, and observable consequences. For example, prolonged waiting may be associated with anxiety and low perceived control; plausible drivers may include high stakes and little information about timing; and risks may include repeated checking, escalation, disengagement, or missing a later action. Identified risks may be prioritized by considering their plausibility, the potential severity of the consequence, the frequency or population exposed, and the possibility of intervention. This prioritization helps focus Design on the risks whose prevention offers the greatest value to the journey and the operation. The chain is probabilistic: the objective is not to assume that a condition causes a particular behavior, but to identify plausible risks in advance to guide the design of a journey capable of responding preventively to those risks. Figure 2 summarizes the four connected movements through which Guided Uncertainty translates this diagnostic logic into preventive intervention, execution, measurement, and continuous learning. 10 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 Figure 2. Guided Uncertainty framework: Understand, Design, Guide, and Learn. Source: Developed by the author. As shown in Figure 2, the movements are connected rather than isolated stages: Understand informs Design, Design is carried into execution through Guide, and Learn uses observed evidence to revise subsequent diagnosis and intervention. 3.3.6 Understand Understand maps the journey from the Guided User’s perspective. It identifies operational moments, Emotional Phases, expected cognitive-emotional conditions, plausible drivers, forms of uncertainty, behavioral risks, and potential consequences. The mapping should reflect actual guidance—human, digital, or hybrid—and, when relevant, plausible disruptions to normal flow. Understand requires evidence discipline. Expected states may be investigated through interviews, complaints, administrative data, contact reasons, practical observation, surveys, prior cases, frontline professional experience, or existing research. When available, journey data—such as abandonment, errors, resubmissions, repeated contacts, time between steps, and escalation patterns—can help locate where risks concentrate and which phases require deeper investigation. Observed evidence must be separated from inference. The framework’s replicability depends on criteria clear enough for different evaluators to independently delimit the same journey, identify the main Emotional Phases, record the evidence used, and reach sufficiently consistent priority diagnoses. 3.3.7 Design Design converts diagnosis into preventive intervention involving process structure, sequence, information, expectations, timing, preparation, communication, interaction, and legitimate opportunities for action. Instead of waiting for anxiety, confusion, urgency, or distrust to become visible, Design prepares the journey in advance for reasonably foreseeable conditions in each Emotional Phase. This includes designing for plausible adverse conditions before they need to be individually identified, provided the intervention remains appropriate for other users. When relevant disruptions to flow are also foreseeable, Design can prepare contingency responses—such as communication, expected actions, responsibilities, and escalation criteria—to limit secondary 11 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 consequences while the primary cause is addressed. More communication is not automatically better. Additional information can increase cognitive load or ambiguity; insufficient information can produce misinterpretation, rework, and additional waiting. Design asks which intervention responds to the identified driver and risk, at what moment, and with the least unnecessary burden. Design also distinguishes between reducing avoidable uncertainty and mitigating the effects of uncertainty that must remain. 3.3.8 Guide Guide is the execution layer: it transforms preventive design into concrete guidance as the journey unfolds. This function may be performed by people, digital systems, or hybrid architectures. A technically adequate intervention can fail through inconsistent execution. Inadequate information may lead to incorrect interpretation or action; handoffs may break continuity; and intensified conditions may require guidance different from that anticipated in the standard flow. When a broader disruption occurs, Guide executes and adapts the previously designed contingency response. Guide includes proactivity, information quality, continuity, calibration, and escalation. Calibration adapts the form of guidance to the needs of the journey or user without changing substantive criteria applicable to the case. Guidance can anticipate foreseeable questions and risks instead of waiting for the problem to grow throughout the user’s journey. When relevant human interaction exists, this may require listening, more humanized communication, greater responsiveness, or escalation as the situation requires. This logic requires organizational preparation. People, systems, and channels responsible for guidance need to execute the objectives of the intervention consistently, including across handoffs. Trust is contextual. In an advisory relationship, it may involve perceived competence and alignment; in a neutral authority, it may involve perceptions of fairness, consistency, transparency, and respect. 3.3.9 Learn Learn converts application into evidence. It compares expected and observed patterns, evaluates whether interventions changed target risks or outcomes, documents limitations, unintended effects, and implementation failures, and feeds findings back into the framework. When guidance occurs through multiple channels or a contingency response, Learn should evaluate, when feasible, where execution worked, failed, or required escalation. Findings may lead not only to adjustment of the intervention but also to revision of the Emotional Phases, drivers, and risks originally identified, making Learn a stage for updating the diagnosis itself. Measurement and data analysis should occur at multiple levels when feasible and begin from a baseline appropriate to the problem being analyzed. Experience measures may assess clarity, control, trust—including trust in the organization or institution when relevant—burden, or relevant emotional states; behavioral measures may include completion, response, error, or abandonment; and operational measures may include contacts, escalation, service time, rework, or throughput. Joint analysis of these measures makes it possible to examine not only whether change occurred, but where it occurred and whether the observed pattern is consistent with the predicted mechanism. Success may also occur when Outcome Uncertainty remains but its cognitive or emotional impact decreases, or when those effects no longer produce certain behavioral or operational consequences. Existing instruments should be used when they fit the construct. Jilke, Bækgaard, Herd, and Moynihan (2024), for 12 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 example, developed brief measures of experienced administrative burden distinct from federal customer-experience indicators. Learn should also allow evaluation not only of when the diagnosis is supported by results, but when the evidence contradicts it. The application should specify expected results and which observations would be inconsistent with the diagnosis or with the expected effect of the intervention. 3.4 Applying Guided Uncertainty to service scenarios Guided Uncertainty can be applied at different points in a public service journey where uncertainty, cognitive and emotional conditions, and execution requirements interact. Its application is not limited to waiting periods or requests for additional information and may span entry into and preparation for a process, administrative checkpoints, transitions between channels or units, disruptions to expected flow, and communication after a decision. The common element is not a specific process step, but the presence of the framework’s domain conditions and risks that can be anticipated or mitigated through changes in journey design or guidance. 3.4.1 Essential service journeys under uncertainty Many public services involve outcomes of great importance to people’s lives—access to benefits, licenses, authorizations, education, assistance, and other services—without the outcome or its timing being entirely under the user’s control. Uncertainty can therefore be a legitimate feature of the journey itself: the agency needs to analyze information, apply criteria, perform checks, or wait for steps that cannot be replaced by an immediate-outcome experience. Guided Uncertainty proposes that these journeys be designed not only around the steps the organization must execute, but also around the conditions under which the person will need to navigate them. This involves anticipating how uncertainty, waiting, stakes, and changes in cognitive and emotional conditions may affect interpretation and behavior; reducing unnecessary Journey Uncertainty; preparing the person for what can be anticipated; and structuring guidance for uncertainty that legitimately remains. The potential benefit is bilateral. For the user, a journey that is more understandable and predictable in its execution may reduce confusion, errors, unnecessary effort, and, in some cases, the cognitive and emotional impact of uncertainty. For the public organization, the same interventions may improve the quality of journey execution: more complete information, fewer procedural errors, repeated contacts, corrections, and rework, better use of operational capacity, and, in certain contexts, greater trust in the institution and in how the process is conducted. The objective is not to treat the citizen as a customer who must be satisfied regardless of the outcome, but to structure a journey in which the user and the organization can perform their respective roles more effectively while the outcome remains uncertain for the user. 3.4.2 Preparation and execution of critical actions Many public service journeys require the person to correctly perform actions on which progress depends: understanding requirements, gathering documentation, completing forms, attending interviews or assessments, responding to additional requests, and meeting deadlines. In these situations, conditions such as anxiety, cognitive overload, urgency, low perceived control, or confusion may interact with process complexity and increase the risk of error, omission, or incomplete action. Guided Uncertainty structures the early identification of where these risks may concentrate and the design of the journey to respond to them before they produce consequences. This may involve not only making instructions clearer, but adjusting sequence, timing, preparation, expectations, confirmations, and guidance to the identified risk. A request for 13 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 additional documentation, for example, can be designed considering both what the agency needs to receive and the conditions under which the applicant will have to interpret and execute the requirement. Preventing an incorrect response can avoid another requirement, rework, and additional waiting, benefiting both the user and the agency’s execution of the process. 3.4.3 Waiting, transitions, and journey continuity Waiting periods, handoffs between units or channels, and steps with no visible progress present a different problem. Reducing processing time and improving how a person navigates a necessary wait are related but distinct objectives. The process may remain operationally unchanged while the person’s experience changes as time passes, expectations go unmet, or new decisions need to be made. This divergence between operational process and experience is precisely one reason for separating Emotional Phases from the formal steps of the journey. A transfer between units, for example, may be administratively correct and still generate uncertainty about who is handling the case, whether prior information has been preserved, and what the next step will be. Likewise, the same period of silence may initially be interpreted as normal processing but later raise questions about delay, missing information, or whether action is required. In these contexts, avoidable Journey Uncertainty can be reduced through better information about status, next steps, responsibilities, expectations, and meaningful progress milestones, such as confirmation that information was received or that no additional action is currently required. Repeated generic updates may provide communication without materially reducing Journey Uncertainty. When Outcome Uncertainty or the wait itself cannot legitimately be eliminated, guidance may still, in some cases, reduce their cognitive and emotional effects and prevent them from turning into repeated contacts, escalations, abandonment, premature actions, or other journey costs. Guidance may occur through professionals, portals, notifications, automated messages, or combinations of these mechanisms, preserving continuity even when different actors participate in the process. 3.4.4 Flow disruptions and contingency responses Journeys may also be affected by system failures, extraordinary delays, channel or infrastructure unavailability, organizational errors, or other disruptions that divert the process from its expected flow. The primary cause may require a technical, operational, or institutional response outside the scope of Guided Uncertainty, but how the human journey moves through the disruption remains a design and guidance problem. The temporary unavailability of a document-submission channel, for example, may lead users to resubmit the same material through different means, generating duplication, uncertainty about which submission is valid, and additional work for the organization. When relevant types of disruption can be reasonably anticipated, Guided Uncertainty allows contingency responses to be incorporated into journey design: what information should be provided, what the user should or should not do, how expectations should be recalibrated, when new communications should occur, and when the situation requires escalation. The objective is to prevent an initial disruption from producing a secondary chain of confusion, duplicate attempts, inadequate submissions, repeated contacts, loss of trust, and rework. Applying GU in this context does not replace correction of the original failure; it seeks to prevent its effects on the journey from becoming greater than they need to be. 3.4.5 Guidance when the organization also exercises Decision Authority In many public services, the organization responsible for guiding the user also participates in the substantive decision 14 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 or contains the Decision Authority. This configuration does not eliminate the possibility or legitimate interest in an appropriately guided journey. The organization can remain neutral regarding the substantive outcome of each case while seeking to make the journey understandable, executable, consistent, and efficient for the people who navigate it. Eligibility, licensing, or authorization criteria may remain unchanged while the organization improves how requirements are understood, actions are prepared, expectations are managed, and the process is navigated. In a licensing process, for example, the organization may explain a documentary deficiency and guide its correction without changing the technical criterion used to approve or deny the application. This distinction is important because the objective does not need to be increasing the probability of an outcome favorable to the user. Better guidance can increase the likelihood that the agency receives complete and appropriate information, reduce procedural errors, repeated contacts, and rework, and allow the Decision Authority to evaluate the case based on more appropriate execution of the process. At the same time, clarity, continuity, procedural predictability, and respectful treatment can improve the person’s experience and help preserve trust in the institution and the process even when the final decision remains uncertain or is unfavorable. Guided Uncertainty therefore allows human experience and operational efficiency to be treated as potentially related outcomes without confusing them with the merits of the substantive decision. 3.5 Testable propositions The propositions below translate central Guided Uncertainty mechanisms into relationships that can be examined empirically. Proposition 1: Emotional Phases may add diagnostic value beyond operational steps. In compatible journeys, segmentation by Emotional Phases may allow identification of relevant cognitive, emotional, or behavioral variations that are not fully captured by operational steps and that may guide diagnosis or intervention design. Proposition 2: Reducing modifiable Journey Uncertainty may influence experience, execution, and, in certain journeys, the substantive outcome. When Journey Uncertainty arises from modifiable characteristics of process, information, expectations, timing, communication, or guidance, reducing it may improve understanding, preparation, trust, or execution and, through that pathway, influence experiential, behavioral, or operational outcomes. In journeys in which the Guided User’s behavior or performance constitutes a legitimate part of the decision-making process, these effects may also contribute to the substantive outcome. Proposition 3: Guidance may mitigate the effects of Outcome Uncertainty even when it remains. When Outcome Uncertainty cannot legitimately be eliminated, appropriately structured process and guidance may reduce its cognitive or emotional impact and/or prevent those effects from becoming harmful behavioral or operational consequences. Proposition 4: Distinct cognitive-emotional conditions may require different responses to the same operational situation. In the same operational situation, different cognitive or emotional conditions and their drivers may produce distinct risks. Responses oriented to these differences may produce different outcomes from a uniform intervention based only on the operational step or observed problem. Proposition 5: Improvements in one outcome dimension do not imply equivalent improvements in others. An intervention may improve operational outcomes without eliminating negative emotion, reduce the impact of an emotion without eliminating it, or improve experience without changing operational performance. Changes in one class of 15 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 outcome therefore do not presuppose equivalent changes in the others. Proposition 6: Preventive interventions may reduce problems before they manifest. When adverse conditions and their associated risks can be reasonably anticipated, incorporating preventive responses into journey design may reduce the probability or intensity of behavioral, experiential, or operational problems that would arise if the organization acted only after their manifestation. Proposition 7: Journey design may proactively accommodate plausible adverse conditions without requiring individual identification. When an adverse cognitive or emotional condition is reasonably plausible in a given Emotional Phase, the journey can be designed to accommodate it preventively even without knowing which users will actually experience it. When this accommodation is also appropriate and does not introduce material harm for users who do not experience the condition, it may reduce behavioral or operational risks without depending on prior individual diagnosis. 4. Discussion 4.1 Behavioral and psychological foundations Guided Uncertainty integrates mechanisms informed by established literatures, which provide theoretical grounding for its main components and help situate its contribution in relation to existing knowledge. 4.1.1 Appraisal, stress, and coping The transactional model of stress proposed by Lazarus and Folkman (1984) emphasizes appraisal: people evaluate what is at stake and whether the resources available are sufficient to deal with the demands they face. This perspective is relevant to public service journeys because the same objective uncertainty may have different psychological meaning depending on stakes, information, perceived resources, prior experience, and control. A waiting period may be tolerable when its purpose and expected duration are understood, but threatening when the outcome is important and the user cannot interpret what the delay means. Guided Uncertainty therefore does not treat uncertainty as synonymous with anxiety. It treats uncertainty as a condition that may be appraised in different ways and associated with multiple states, including concern, hope, frustration, confusion, distrust, relief, or relative stability. 4.1.2 Emotion in bureaucratic interactions Hattke et al. (2020) provide direct evidence from public administration that bureaucratic conditions can elicit distinct emotions. In their laboratory experiment, administrative burden and delay generated significant negative emotional responses, especially confusion, frustration, and anger. As a laboratory study, its results provide evidence regarding the occurrence and differentiation of these emotional responses without determining how they manifest in every administrative journey. For Guided Uncertainty, the importance of Hattke et al. is not to prove a specific Emotional Phase or establish that emotion causes repeated contact or error. The study shows that emotional response to bureaucratic procedures is empirically measurable and that different administrative conditions can produce distinguishable affective reactions. The framework extends this problem temporally by asking whether relevant cognitive-emotional configurations change throughout a journey and whether those changes provide incremental diagnostic value beyond operational steps. 16 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 4.1.3 Uncertainty management Brashers’s (2001) uncertainty management perspective is important because it rejects the premise that uncertainty is always negative or that reducing it is always the appropriate objective. People may seek, avoid, maintain, or reinterpret uncertainty depending on context. A public agency therefore should not manufacture certainty where none exists, and an uncertainty-centered framework should not define success as making the user certain about an outcome that cannot be known. Viglia et al. (2019), in the context of services and payment decisions, distinguish uncertainty related to the service process and outcome; Ulaga and Kohli (2018), in the context of business-to-business solutions, distinguish need, process, and outcome uncertainty. Guided Uncertainty develops this family of distinctions at the journey level and assigns it a specific diagnostic function. Journey Uncertainty concerns what the person does not understand about navigating the path: what is happening, what an event means, what to expect, timing, next steps, required actions, or whether an action was completed. Outcome Uncertainty concerns the substantive outcome or its timing. The framework uses the distinction to decide what can be reduced through design and guidance and what must be navigated without false assurance. Research on waiting further supports distinguishing objective duration from the experience of waiting. Expectations, information, and perceived control can influence how waiting is experienced even when its actual duration does not change (Hui & Zhou, 1996; Nie, 2000; Taylor, 1994). 4.1.4 Perceived control and legitimate participation Langer and Rodin (1976) showed that meaningful choice and personal responsibility can affect participation and wellbeing in an institutional setting. Guided Uncertainty does not generalize this finding into a universal prescription to “give users control.” In many public service contexts, the user cannot control the decision and should not be led to believe otherwise. The relevant principle is legitimate perceived control. Where real choices or actions exist, they should be visible and usable. This may include knowing what information can be prepared, when action is required, which channel can be used, what the person can monitor, and what genuinely remains outside their influence. The distinction matters because false control can be as harmful as opacity. 4.1.5 Responsiveness and service encounters Service research demonstrates that direct encounters influence how people evaluate an organization. Bitner (1990), for example, showed that employee responses and explanations can shape evaluations of service encounters. Perceived Partner Responsiveness, originating in research on intimacy and close relationships (Reis & Shaver, 1988; Laurenceau et al., 1998), is more distant from citizen-state interaction and should not be transplanted as though the relationships were equivalent. Its narrower relevance is that people form judgments about whether the other party understands, validates, and responds appropriately to their concerns. For Guided Uncertainty, these literatures support an applied proposition: in important and uncertain journeys, the quality of guidance may affect interpretation, trust, and execution. This guidance is a function of the journey and may be performed by systems, automated communications, professionals, or combinations of these mechanisms. When human interaction occurs, correct and timely information, anticipation of questions, confirmation of understanding, continuity, and responses proportionate to intensified conditions may mitigate risks that late, generic, or inconsistent guidance would aggravate. In digital environments, the same logic requires examining whether interfaces, notifications, status messages, emails, confirmations, next steps, and escalation mechanisms provide guidance appropriate to the anticipated conditions and risks. In the public sector, this does not require a personal bond or alignment with the user’s desired outcome; trust may mean 17 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 perceptions of competence, consistency, transparency, respect, and fairness in application of the process. 4.1.6 Procedural justice Research on procedural justice provides the strongest theoretical basis for this distinction in authority or neutrality environments. Tyler’s (1990) work shows that evaluations of legal and governmental authorities depend not only on favorable outcomes but also on characteristics of the process. Voice, neutrality, respect, and trustworthiness are recurring elements in judgments of procedural justice. This is directly relevant when the organization responsible for guidance also participates in the Decision Authority— the person, unit, or structure responsible for the substantive decision about the outcome—or when that authority is located within the organization itself. Guided Uncertainty separates the role of guiding the user from the role of determining the substantive outcome, even when both responsibilities are within the same organization. The separation avoids a conceptual error: good guidance does not require the agency to favor the outcome desired by the user. A licensing authority may apply a criterion neutrally while also explaining requirements, preserving continuity, communicating respectfully, and making the process understandable. Procedural justice provides a theoretical basis for explaining why these characteristics may matter independently of substantive victory. This perspective is particularly relevant to Guided Uncertainty because it helps explain how the quality of guidance and procedural experience may influence the user’s relationship with the process even when the organization cannot control or anticipate the substantive outcome. Taken together, these literatures provide theoretical grounding for central Guided Uncertainty mechanisms and for how the framework connects uncertainty, cognitive and emotional conditions, preventive design, guidance, and behavioral and operational consequences throughout the journey. 4.2 Related approaches and comparative positioning The closest comparison set for Guided Uncertainty is not a single competing framework. It is a family of approaches that address important parts of the problem: administrative burden analysis, behavioral insights, behavioral journey mapping, sludge audits, service design, and structured behavioral intervention toolkits. 4.2.1 U.S. Department of Labor behavioral interventions The U.S. Department of Labor Behavioral Interventions (DOL-BI) initiative’s Practitioner’s Playbook describes a sixstep process—Understand, Diagnose, Design, Support, Test, and Learn—for identifying behavioral barriers, developing interventions, supporting their implementation, testing them, and incorporating results into program learning (Darling et al., 2017). DOL-BI provides a relevant example of how behavioral principles can be translated into a structured sequence of diagnosis, intervention, and learning within public programs. Guided Uncertainty organizes a distinct and more delimited problem: important service journeys in which material uncertainty remains outside the user’s control while a person, organization, or system plays a significant role in guidance. Within this domain, GU distinguishes Outcome Uncertainty from Journey Uncertainty, analyzes how cognitive and emotional conditions evolve across Emotional Phases that need not coincide with operational steps, and uses this diagnosis to proactively structure process, information, communication, and guidance. This difference also appears in the Guide movement. In Guided Uncertainty, guidance during unresolved uncertainty is part of the framework’s architecture itself and may occur through the process, digital systems, automated communications, professional action, or hybrid combinations. The comparison with DOL-BI therefore situates GU within a tradition of 18 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 structured application of behavioral science while highlighting its specific domain, constructs, and intervention logic. 4.2.2 Behavioral journey mapping Office of Evaluation Sciences (OES) work with the Social Security Administration’s Ticket to Work program provides a relevant example of integrating journey analysis and behavioral diagnosis. OES produced a behavioral journey map representing steps traveled by applicants, possible behavioral barriers, and opportunities for evidence-based interventions. This approach demonstrates how a behavioral perspective can enrich analysis of a service journey by identifying barriers associated with different moments in the process. Guided Uncertainty adds a distinct analytical layer by also organizing human experience through Emotional Phases, defined by relevant changes in the cognitive and emotional conditions expected throughout the journey. These phases are mapped independently of operational structure: an Emotional Phase may span several process steps, while a relevant change in the person’s experience may occur even when the formal process remains at the same step or shows no visible progress. This separation makes it possible to examine how different cognitive-emotional configurations may produce distinct risks within the same operational structure and guide preventive responses specific to those conditions. Instead of depending on individual identification of these conditions during execution, the framework allows reasonably foreseeable adverse conditions in each phase and their associated behavioral and operational risks to be anticipated, incorporating preventive responses into the design of process, information, communication, preparation, and guidance. This logic also extends to journey execution. The Guide movement carries preventive design into the systems, communications, human interactions, or hybrid combinations through which the person is actually guided while uncertainty remains, and Learn connects observed outcomes to refinement of phases, risks, and interventions. 4.2.3 Sludge audits and administrative simplification Sludge audits identify unjustified frictions that make actions or processes unnecessarily difficult. Guidance from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) describes sludge audits as structured behavioral science approaches for identifying, quantifying, and preventing unjustified frictions and psychological burdens in public services (OECD, 2024). Sludge reduction shares with Guided Uncertainty’s Design movement the objective of identifying and reducing avoidable friction, but begins from a different analytical problem. Guided Uncertainty focuses especially on situations in which reducing friction does not eliminate the journey’s central uncertainty. A benefit applicant may receive a clear notice and a simple form and still remain legitimately uncertain about eligibility. A license applicant may understand all requirements and still face a review with an uncertain outcome. Guided Uncertainty asks what should be reduced, what remains uncertain, and how process, information, and guidance should be structured around the uncertainty that remains—including when a disruption to normal flow intensifies these conditions and requires a previously prepared response. 4.2.4 OECD BASIC The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) BASIC Toolkit provides a general process for applying behavioral insights to public-sector problems, including behavioral analysis, development of intervention strategies, testing, and implementation (OECD, 2019). It offers a broad structure for transforming behavioral knowledge into interventions applicable to different public policy and service problems. Guided Uncertainty operates in a more specific domain, but its difference is not limited to scope. In journeys in which 19 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 a relevant outcome remains uncertain and outside the user’s control, the framework organizes diagnosis around the evolution of cognitive and emotional conditions across Emotional Phases and the behavioral and operational risks that may emerge from those conditions. This diagnosis supports a prospective logic: anticipating reasonably foreseeable adverse conditions and proactively structuring process, information, communication, preparation, and guidance before their effects need to manifest as observable problems. The Guide movement extends this logic into execution, treating guidance during persistent uncertainty as part of the framework’s architecture, and Learn connects outcomes to refinement of phases, risks, and interventions. 4.2.5 Service process and outcome uncertainty The literature provides antecedents for distinguishing forms of uncertainty. Viglia et al. (2019), in the context of services and payment decisions, examine uncertainty related to the service process and outcome; Ulaga and Kohli (2018), in the context of business-to-business solutions, distinguish need, process, and outcome uncertainty. Guided Uncertainty incorporates antecedents of this kind into journey analysis through Outcome Uncertainty and Journey Uncertainty and connects this distinction to Emotional Phases, risks, Design, Guide, and Learn. This integration guides two distinct responses: reducing modifiable Journey Uncertainty and, when Outcome Uncertainty must remain, structuring the journey to mitigate its cognitive-emotional effects and associated behavioral or operational risks. 4.2.6 Administrative checkpoints and human-centered design Kim, Herd, Jilke, Moynihan, and Rodden (2025) connect administrative burden and human-centered design through the concept of administrative checkpoints—mandatory administrative requirements that a person must satisfy to advance through a process. In a field experiment with 1,554 Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) applicants, textmessage reminders combined with greater flexibility in interview scheduling increased interview completion by approximately 10 percentage points and benefit approval by 6 to 7 percentage points compared with the group that received only the traditional mailed reminder. Interviews in this group were also completed, on average, 3 to 4 days earlier, while reducing learning costs and increasing applicants’ confidence in their ability to manage the process. These findings are particularly relevant to Guided Uncertainty because they demonstrate that how an administrative requirement is structured, communicated, and embedded in the journey can affect behavior, execution, and perceived experience. Guided Uncertainty broadens the analytical focus by examining how these requirements are navigated under cognitive and emotional conditions that may change while uncertainty persists and how risks associated with those conditions can be anticipated in journey design and guidance. The distinction between administrative checkpoint and Emotional Phase is central to this relationship. A checkpoint identifies an administrative requirement necessary for the person to advance; an Emotional Phase identifies a period of the journey characterized by a cognitive and emotional configuration sufficiently similar to guide diagnosis and intervention. The same Emotional Phase may span several checkpoints, while a phase change may occur without any new checkpoint or operational advance. The two concepts therefore segment different dimensions of the same journey: checkpoints help locate what the process requires; Emotional Phases help explain the conditions under which the person navigates those requirements and which risks can be anticipated as a result. 4.2.7 Uncertainty in customer journey models Recent research on customer journey modeling shows that the structure and progression of journeys can be formally 20 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 represented in richer ways than a linear sequence of touchpoints (Halvorsrud et al., 2023). Guided Uncertainty uses uncertainty as a diagnostic element of journey experience and execution. The distinction between Outcome Uncertainty and Journey Uncertainty helps separate what remains unknown about the substantive outcome from what remains uncertain during navigation and can be influenced by journey design. This analysis is then connected to Emotional Phases, associated behavioral and operational risks, preventive design, and guidance while uncertainty remains. 4.2.8 Comparative positioning The approaches examined in this section provide important antecedents for different components of Guided Uncertainty, but the framework articulates them within its own diagnostic and intervention logic. In journeys marked by relevant uncertainty, GU distinguishes uncertainty associated with the outcome from uncertainty produced by navigating the process itself; segments the journey into Emotional Phases independent of operational steps; and uses the conditions identified in each phase to anticipate behavioral and operational risks before they necessarily manifest. This diagnosis guides preventive design of process, information, communication, preparation, and guidance for reasonably foreseeable adverse conditions in each phase. The intervention may seek to reduce avoidable Journey Uncertainty and, when Outcome Uncertainty must remain, reduce its cognitive and emotional impact and the likelihood that its effects produce errors, incomplete actions, repeated contacts, abandonment, rework, or other execution problems. Guide carries this design into the ongoing journey through digital, human, or hybrid means, while Learn uses observed outcomes to revise diagnosis, design, and guidance. The contribution proposed by Guided Uncertainty therefore lies not only in the domain to which it applies, but in the architecture through which conditions under uncertainty are anticipated, translated into risks, and used to proactively structure the journey before and during execution. Table 1 summarizes the main areas of overlap and the specific positioning of Guided Uncertainty relative to the approaches examined. Table 1. Comparative positioning of Guided Uncertainty relative to related approaches. Approach Behavioral diagnosis Journey/process mapping Testing / learning What GU adds or emphasizes DOL-BI Playbook Yes Program/process oriented Yes Emotional Phases independent of operational steps; Outcome vs. Journey Uncertainty; anticipation of risks under uncertainty; preventive Design and Guide during execution OES Behavioral Journey Mapping Yes Yes Often linked to evaluation Emotional Phases as an analytical unit; anticipation of cognitiveemotional conditions and associated risks; preventive responses before manifestation; Guide during the journey Sludge audits Yes, with a focus on friction May map process burdens May quantify/test burden reduction Distinguishes avoidable friction from uncertainty that may legitimately remain; structures the journey around that uncertainty and seeks to reduce its cognitive-emotional, behavioral, and operational effects OECD BASIC Yes Yes / behavioral analysis Yes Diagnostic architecture centered on the evolution of conditions under uncertainty, their prospective translation into risks, preventive Design, and guidance during execution Source: Developed by the author based on the approaches discussed in Section 4.2. The comparison highlights that Guided Uncertainty does not depend on the absence of existing behavioral or journeyoriented approaches. Its proposed contribution lies in integrating uncertainty type, Emotional Phases, prospective risk identification, preventive Design, guidance during execution, and learning within a single architecture for compatible journeys. 21 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 4.3 Interpretation of the framework’s contribution The central argument of this article is that, in compatible journeys, cognitive and emotional conditions associated with uncertainty may interact with process, information, and guidance in ways that simultaneously affect user experience and the agency’s operational execution. First, administrative burden can be analyzed dynamically. Learning, compliance, and psychological costs may change throughout the journey; Emotional Phases offer a testable hypothesis for capturing this variation and guiding preventive responses. Second, not all uncertainty should be treated as friction to be eliminated. Part of Outcome Uncertainty may be legitimate and still have modifiable cognitive and emotional effects. The organization may not make the outcome more predictable, but it may, in some cases, reduce anxiety, insecurity, confusion, or loss of control and prevent these conditions from producing avoidable consequences for the user and the operation. Third, guidance deserves to be treated as an operational component. It may be executed by people, systems, or hybrid architectures. Inadequate guidance may generate error, a new requirement, rework, and additional waiting; proactive and coherent guidance may reduce the probability that these effects accumulate throughout the journey. The same preventive logic may be prepared for relevant flow disruptions without turning GU into a general incident-management framework. Fourth, measurement should distinguish outcome classes. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) uploader illustrates the point: it reduced denials for incomplete information without significantly increasing participation. Likewise, reducing the impact of uncertainty may constitute a relevant outcome even when Outcome Uncertainty itself remains. 4.4 Validation, limitations, and research agenda Guided Uncertainty was developed and refined through practical experience in real-world service contexts. Its principal mechanisms are consistent with established findings across relevant behavioral, administrative, and service literatures, while the framework brings these mechanisms into a distinct architecture centered on uncertainty throughout the service journey. Continued application and empirical research can further document its effects across different service contexts and examine how these effects vary across journey conditions. Future research can examine the replicability of Guided Uncertainty through applications that document the journey, diagnosis, interventions, and outcomes and compare the consistency of diagnoses produced by different evaluators. An Implementation Guide under development seeks to operationalize the framework’s principal constructs and application criteria to support greater consistency across applications. Combining administrative, behavioral, and experience evidence may also strengthen measurement of the conditions and effects identified by the framework. Beyond the framework’s aggregate performance, future research may examine the incremental value of its distinctive components, including Emotional Phases, Journey Uncertainty, preventive Design, and Guide. The Guided Uncertainty research agenda includes questions about generalization, mechanisms, implementation, and measurement. The practical experiences that contributed to its development provide an initial empirical basis that can be expanded through independent applications in different contexts. A central line of inquiry is the incremental value of the proposed constructs: to what extent Emotional Phases reveal relevant information beyond operational steps and Journey Uncertainty adds diagnostic capacity to existing process-uncertainty constructs. It is also important to understand how different cognitive and emotional conditions—such as anxiety, confusion, distrust, low perceived control, and cognitive overload—interact with different drivers, risks, and contexts. 22 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 In public services, research may examine the effects of different forms of framework implementation within requirements of decisional neutrality, rights, and accessibility; which guidance functions are most appropriately performed by people, digital systems, or hybrid architectures; and under which conditions contingency design reduces secondary consequences of foreseeable disruptions. Measurement should also seek a balance between evidence quality and additional burden imposed on the journey. Empirical priorities include inter-rater reliability; incremental value of Emotional Phases and Journey Uncertainty; comparison between preventive interventions and reactive responses; effects of guidance while Outcome Uncertainty remains; human, digital, and hybrid guidance; and independent applications across different public services. 5. Final Considerations Public service journeys often contain uncertainty that cannot legitimately be eliminated. This does not mean that its cognitive, emotional, behavioral, and operational effects are equally inevitable. Guided Uncertainty proposes an architecture for identifying how cognitive and emotional conditions change throughout these journeys, anticipating risks, distinguishing avoidable uncertainty from uncertainty that must remain, proactively structuring process and guidance, and learning from observed outcomes. This guidance may be human, digital, or hybrid and, when relevant, include preparation for plausible disruptions. An agency may be unable to anticipate whether a benefit will be approved or when a decision will be issued, but it can improve information, preparation, expectations, legitimate perceived control, and guidance; reduce, in some cases, the impact of uncertainty; and decrease errors, incomplete actions, repeated contacts, escalations, and rework. This can simultaneously benefit the user and the operational efficiency of the service. The central proposition is testable: in compatible journeys, how cognitive and emotional conditions under uncertainty are anticipated, accommodated by design, and guided during execution may influence human experience and journey performance even when the substantive outcome remains outside the user’s control. Table 2 summarizes how the U.S. examples examined in the article help reveal journey problems, relevant mechanisms, and boundaries of Guided Uncertainty application. Table 2. U.S. cases used to examine fit, mechanisms, and boundaries. Case Documented problem Relevance to Guided Uncertainty Factors outside GU’s specific contribution Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) implementation (GAO, 2024) Technical failures, delays, unanswered calls, weak status/support communication, and confusion Meaning of delays and errors, expectations, waiting, impact of uncertainty, next steps, and communication consistency Software, service capacity, and eligibility Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) document uploader (OES, 2024) Complex upload/login, uncertainty about submitted documents, and denials for incomplete information Journey Uncertainty, cognitive load, confirmation, prevention of incomplete action, and multilevel measurement Substantive eligibility and other determinants of participation Flexible SNAP interviews (Giannella et al., 2024) Interview burden and procedural denial Process design, completion risk, and behavioral/operational effects Other determinants of eligibility and participation SNAP administrative checkpoints (Kim et al., 2025) Mandatory interview, learning costs, and difficulty managing the process Journey Uncertainty, communication, flexibility, confidence in navigating the process, and completion risk Other administrative-burden mechanisms and substantive program factors Source: Developed by the author based on GAO (2024), OES (2024), Giannella et al. (2024), and Kim et al. (2025). 23 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 Table 2 should be read as an analytical map of fit and boundaries rather than as validation of Guided Uncertainty. The cases show documented journey problems that can be organized using the framework’s constructs while preserving technical, substantive, capacity, and other mechanisms that remain outside GU’s specific contribution. References Bitner, M. J. (1990). Evaluating service encounters: The effects of physical surroundings and employee responses. Journal of Marketing, 54(2), 69–82. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224299005400206 Brashers, D. E. (2001). Communication and uncertainty management. Journal of Communication, 51(3), 477–497. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1460-2466.2001.tb02892.x Darling, M., Lefkowitz, J., Amin, S., Perez-Johnson, I., Chojnacki, G., & Manley, M. (2017). Practitioner's playbook for applying behavioral insights to labor programs. Chief Evaluation Office, U.S. Department of Labor. Fernandes, J. M. B., Vieira, L. T., & Castelhano, M. V. C. (2023). Revisão narrativa enquanto metodologia científica significativa: reflexões técnicasformativas. REDES – Revista Educacional da Sucesso, 3(1), 1–7. Giannella, E., Homonoff, T., Rino, G., & Somerville, J. (2024). Administrative burden and procedural denials: Experimental evidence from SNAP. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 16(4), 316–340. https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20220701 Halvorsrud, R., Sanchez, O. R., Boletsis, C., & Skjuve, M. (2023). Involving users in the development of a modeling language for customer journeys. Software and Systems Modeling, 22(5), 1589–1618. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10270-023-01081-w Hattke, F., Hensel, D., & Kalucza, J. (2020). Emotional responses to bureaucratic red tape. Public Administration Review, 80(1), 53–63. https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13116 Herd, P., & Moynihan, D. P. (2018). Administrative burden: Policymaking by other means. Russell Sage Foundation. https://doi.org/10.7758/9781610448789 Hui, M. K., & Zhou, L. (1996). How does waiting duration information influence customers’ reactions to waiting for services? Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 26(19), 1702–1717. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1559-1816.1996.tb00093.x Jilke, S., Bækgaard, M., Herd, P., & Moynihan, D. (2024). Short and sweet: Measuring experiences of administrative burden. Journal of Behavioral Public Administration, 7. https://doi.org/10.30636/jbpa.71.340 Kim, J. Y., Herd, P., Jilke, S., Moynihan, D. P., & Rodden, K. (2025). Administrative checkpoints, burdens, and human-centered design: Increasing interview access to raise SNAP participation. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 44(4), 1153–1170. https://doi.org/10.1002/pam.70007 Langer, E. J., & Rodin, J. (1976). The effects of choice and enhanced personal responsibility for the aged: A field experiment in an institutional setting. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 34(2), 191–198. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.34.2.191 Laurenceau, J.-P., Barrett, L. F., & Pietromonaco, P. R. (1998). Intimacy as an interpersonal process: The importance of self-disclosure, partner disclosure, and perceived partner responsiveness in interpersonal exchanges. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74(5), 1238–1251. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.74.5.1238 Moynihan, D. P., Herd, P., & Harvey, H. (2015). Administrative burden: Learning, psychological, and compliance costs in citizen-state interactions. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 25(1), 43–69. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopart/muu009 Nie, W. (2000). Waiting: Integrating social and psychological perspectives in operations management. Omega, 28(6), 611–629. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0305-0483(00)00019-0 OECD. (2019). Tools and ethics for applied behavioural insights: The BASIC toolkit. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/9ea76a8f-en OECD. (2024). Fixing frictions: ‘Sludge audits’ around the world: How governments are using behavioural science to reduce psychological burdens in public services (OECD Public Governance Policy Papers No. 48). OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/5e9bb35c-en Ogassavara, D., Ferreira, T. S., Tertuliano, I. W., Bartholomeu, D., Costa, J. F., & Montiel, J. M. (2025). Trilhas metodológicas para a revisão narrativa: orientações pragmáticas para sua elaboração. Ensino & Pesquisa, 23(3), 308–318. https://doi.org/10.33871/23594381.2025.23.3.10317 Reis, H. T., & Shaver, P. (1988). Intimacy as an interpersonal process. In S. Duck (Ed.), Handbook of personal relationships: Theory, research and interventions (pp. 367–389). Wiley. Risemberg, R. I. C., Wakin, M., & Shitsuka, R. (2026). A importância da metodologia científica no desenvolvimento de artigos científicos. E-Acadêmica, 7(1), e0171675. https://doi.org/10.52076/eacad-v7i1.675 Taylor, S. (1994). Waiting for service: The relationship between delays and evaluations of service. Journal of Marketing, 58(2), 56–69. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224299405800205 Tyler, T. R. (1990). Why people obey the law. Yale University Press. Ulaga, W., & Kohli, A. K. (2018). The role of a solutions salesperson: Reducing uncertainty and fostering adaptiveness. Industrial Marketing Management, 69, 161–168. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.indmarman.2017.11.008 24 Research, Society and Development, v. 15, n. 9, e0515951644, 2026 (CC BY 4.0) | ISSN 2525-3409 | DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.33448/rsd-v15i9.51644 U.S. General Services Administration, Office of Evaluation Sciences. (n.d.). Increasing participation in Ticket to Work through redesigned mailers. https://oes.gsa.gov/projects/ticket-to-work U.S. General Services Administration, Office of Evaluation Sciences. (2024). Decreasing Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) denials due to incomplete information. https://oes.gsa.gov/results/decreasing-snap-denials U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2024). FAFSA: Education needs to improve communications and support around the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (GAO-24-107407). https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-24-107407 Viglia, G., Maras, M., Schumann, J., & Navarro-Martínez, D. (2019). Paying before or paying after? Timing and uncertainty in pay-what-you-want pricing. Journal of Service Research, 22(3), 272–284. https://doi.org/10.1177/1094670519835308 25