2 EAT-Lancet Commission on Healthy, Sustainable, and Just Food Systems 3 EAT-Lancet Commission on Healthy, Sustainable, and Just Food Systems 1 4 5 6 Authors 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 Rockström, Johan, Shakuntala Thilsted, Walter Wille , Line J. Gordon, Mario Herrero, Chris na C. Hicks, Daniel Mason-D’Croz, Nitya Rao, Marco Springmann, Ellen Cecille Wright, Rina Agus na, Suma Bajaj, Anne Charlo e Bunge, Bianca Carducci, Costanza Con , Namukolo Covic, Jessica Fanzo, Nita G. Forouhi, Ma hew Gibson, Xiao Gu, Ermias Kebreab, Claire Kremen, Amar Laila, Ramanan Laxminarayan, Theresa Marteau, Carlos A. Monteiro, Anna Norberg, Jemimah Njuki, Thais Diniz Oliveira, An Pan, Wen-Harn Pan, Juan A. Rivera, James P. W. Robinson, Marina Sundiang, Sofie te Wierik, Detlef van Vuuren, Sonja Vermeulen, Patrick Webb, Lujain Alqodmani, Ramya Ambikapathi, Anne Barnhill, Isabel Baudish, Felicitas Beier, Damien Beillouin, Arthur Beusen, Jannes Breier, Charlo e Chemarin, Maksym Chepeliev, Jennifer Clapp, Wim de Vries, Ignacio Perez Dominguez, Natalia Estrada-Carmona, Dieter Gerten, Christopher D. Golden, Sarah K. Jones, Peter Søgaard Jørgensen, Marta Kozicka, Hermann LotzeCampen, Federico Maggi, Emma Marzi, Abhijeet Mishra, Fernando Orduna, Alexander Popp, Lena Schulte-Uebbing, Elke Stehfest, Fiona H.M. Tang, Kazuaki Tsuchiya, Hannah Van Zanten, Willem-Jan van Zeist, Xin Zhao, and Fabrice DeClerck. 20 21 22 23 24 Corresponding Author: Fabrice DeClerck PhD. EAT, Rådhusgata 23, 0158 Oslo, Norway; Bioversity Interna onal, CGIAR; Parc Scien fique Agropolis II, 1990 Bd de la Lironde, 34397 Montpellier; France. Tel: +33 (0) 6 76 05 94 70); email: fabrice@ea orum.org 25 26 Execu ve summary 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 The global context has shi ed drama cally since 2019, with increased geopoli cal instability, soaring food prices, and the COVID-19 pandemic exacerba ng exis ng vulnerabili es and crea ng new challenges. Yet food systems remain squarely centred at the nexus of food security, human health, environmental sustainability, social jus ce and the resilience of na ons. Ac ons on food strongly impact the lives and well-being of all and are necessary to progress toward cri cal goals as ar culated in the Sustainable Development Goals, the Paris Climate Agreement, and the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, amongst others. While current food systems have largely kept pace with popula on growth, ensuring sufficient caloric intake for many, they are the single most influen al driver of planetary boundary transgression. More than half the world's popula on struggles to access healthy diets, leading to devasta ng consequences for public health, social equity, and the environment. Although hunger has declined in certain regions, recent increases linked to expanding conflicts and emergent climate change 1 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 impacts have reversed this posi ve trend. Obesity rates con nue to rise globally, and the pressure exerted by food systems on planetary boundaries shows no signs of aba ng. In this moment of increasing instability, food systems s ll offer an unprecedented opportunity build the resilience of environmental, health, economic and social systems and are uniquely placed enhance human well-being while contribu ng massively to Earth system stability. This updated analysis builds upon the 2019 EAT-Lancet Commission, expanding its scope and strengthening its evidence base. The first Commission defined food group ranges for a healthy diet and iden fied the food system shares of planetary boundaries. In this Commission, we add an analysis of the social founda ons for a just food system. It incorporates new data and perspec ves on distribu ve, representa onal, and recogni onal jus ce, providing a global overview on equity in food systems. Substan al improvements in modelling capacity and data analysis allow for the use of a mul -model ensemble to project poten al outcomes of a transi on to healthy and sustainable food systems. The Planetary Health Diet (PHD) remains a cornerstone of our recommenda ons and can be seen as a framework within which diverse and culturally appropriate diets can exist. Robust updated evidence reinforces a strong associa on with improved health outcomes, large reduc ons in all-cause mortality, and a substan al decrease in the incidence of major diet-related chronic diseases. The reference PHD emphasises a balanced dietary pa ern, predominantly plant-based, with moderate inclusion of animalsource foods and limited consump on of added sugars, saturated fats, and salt. The successful implementa on of the PHD requires careful considera on of cultural contexts and the promo on of culturally appropriate and sustainable dietary tradi ons. This diversity of contexts, bounded by the PHD’s reference values, represents significant flexibility and choice across cultures, geographies and individual preferences. However, confronted with today’s mul ple crises, transforma on will require urgent and meaningful changes in our individual and collec ve behaviours and culture of unhealthy, unjust, and unsustainable food produc on and consump on. For the first me we quan fy the global food system share of all nine planetary boundaries. These food system boundaries (FSB) confirm that food is the single largest cause for transgression of the planetary boundaries driving the transgression of five of the six breached boundaries. In addi on, food systems exert a significant impact on the transgressed climate boundary and on the Ocean acidifica on boundary. Food becomes the most significant driver of climate when its transporta on, and energy use contribu ons are included. Unsustainable land conversion, par cularly deforesta on, remains a major driver of biodiversity loss and climate change calling for zero conversion of remaining intact ecosystems. Food systems account for the near totality of nitrogen and phosphorus boundary transgression, highligh ng a cri cal need for improvements in nutrient management, efficient nutrient redistribu on, and the development of circular nutrient systems. The massive use of novel en es in food produc on, processing, and packaging (ranging from plas cs to pes cides) remains of significant concern, yet alarmingly understudied. Our assessment of jus ce integrates three dimensions—distribu ve, representa onal, and recogni onal—within a human rights framing that includes the rights to food, a healthy environment, and 2 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 decent work. Analyses reveal important inequi es in access to healthy diets, decent work condi ons, and healthy environments, dispropor onately affec ng marginalised groups in low-income regions. We therefore propose nine social founda ons that enable these rights to be met and assess their status. Enabling access to, affordability of, and demand for healthy diets is paramount. Equally crucial is the right to live and work within a healthy environment and a stable climate system, recognising the profound impact of environmental degrada on on human health and well-being. Meanwhile, a living wage and meaningful representa on would enable individuals to be recognized, heard, and par cipate in building healthy, sustainable, and just food systems. However, nearly half of the world's popula on falls below these founda ons, undermining their ability to meet basic human rights. At the same me, the dietary pa erns of most (6.9 billion people) of the world exert pressures that threaten to further transgress planetary boundaries. The destabilising effect of unhealthy overconsump on on the Earth's systems highlights the cri cal importance of viewing healthy diets not just as a human right, but also as a shared responsibility. A model intercomparison including ten integrated assessment models (IAMs) across mul ple scenarios reveals the substan al poten al for reducing environmental and health impacts through dietary shi s, improved agricultural produc vity, and reduc ons in food loss and waste. Crea ng demand for and increasing adop on of diets that adhere to the PHD, coupled with ambi ous climate mi ga on policies, will result in significant reduc ons in greenhouse gas emissions and land use. However, the results are sobering, showing that even with the ambi ous transforma ons (sustainable intensifica on, reduced food loss and waste, and transi on to ea ng within the PHD), the world is barely able to come back into the safe space for freshwater use and climate change, while con nuing to transgress the biogeochemical boundary for nitrogen and phosphorus loading - albeit with significant reduced pressure. Deep-dive analyses focusing on sustainable and ecological intensifica on food produc on prac ces, along with more circular nutrient systems, suggest that widespread adop on of these prac ces could reduce further greenhouse gas emissions , increasing carbon sequestra on , reducing the land area dedicated to food produc on, decreasing water footprints, and make substan al progress on addressing nitrogen and phosphorus boundaries, even in the face of a growing global popula on and food consump on. To advance towards the goals of healthy (the PHD), sustainable (within the food system boundaries), and just (above the social founda ons) food systems by 2050, eight priority solu ons are proposed, each accompanied by specific ac ons and policy measures: (1) create food environment to increase demand for healthy diets ensuring they are more accessible and affordable; (2) protect and promote healthy tradi onal diets; (3) implement sustainable and ecological intensifica on prac ces; (4) apply strong regula ons to prevent loss of remaining intact ecosystems; (5) improve infrastructure, management, and consumer behaviour change to reduce food loss and waste; (6) secure decent working condi ons; (7) ensure meaningful voice and representa on; and (8) recognise and protect marginalised groups. These proposed solu ons and ac ons should be organized into coherent ‘bundles’ of interven ons to enhance poli cal feasibility and policy effec veness. The most suitable and effec ve bundles will vary by context and tailored to the specific challenges and opportuni es of each region and sector. 3 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 This Commission reinforces the urgent need for a “great food transforma on”. The targets of the EATLancet Commission for healthy people (PHD) on a healthy planet (FSB) with just food systems (social founda ons) can only be met through concerted global ac on and unprecedented levels of transforma ve change. The Commission calls for cross-sectoral coali ons, that develop context-specific roadmaps, aligning with exis ng and emerging global frameworks, such as the Paris Agreement, the Conven on on Biological Diversity, and the post-2030 SDG agenda. These roadmaps include the se ng of science-based targets with monitoring and accountability mechanisms in place. Mechanisms must be established to insulate policymaking from undue corporate influence, while civil society and social movements play a vital role in promo ng transparency and oversight. 146 means for enabling it. Significant financial resources, es mated between US$200-500 billion per year, are needed to support the transforma on to healthy, sustainable, and just food systems. However, there is good evidence that the price of ac on is much lower than the cost of inac on, and that the investments rapidly shi to economic benefits, es mated at US$5 trillion per year. There is an opportunity to repurpose exis ng finance by realigning incen ves with goals, such as shi ing exis ng support to producer communi es adop ng sustainable ecological intensifica on prac ces or transi oning to the produc on of currently underconsumed food groups, while elimina ng support to pollu ng prac ces or to foods whose overproduc on drives poor health. The Commission posi ons jus ce as both a goal and a driving force for food systems transforma on. Food systems cannot be just without ensuring healthy diets that meet the PHD are affordable and accessible, and without significantly reducing planetary boundaries transgressions. At the same me, jus ce is necessary to overcome the deeply entrenched structural barriers that currently impede transforma ve change. In this sense, jus ce is not only an outcome of food systems transforma on, but a prerequisite 147 148 Introduc on: Healthy, Sustainable, and Just Food Systems 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 The food system has an outsized impact on human wellbeing and planetary health. What we eat, and where and how this food is produced and distributed strongly influences the length and quality of people's lives, as well as our capacity to stay within planetary boundaries. How food systems are governed and managed determine the extent to which people can par cipate and benefit. Since the 2019 publica on of Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT-Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems, 1 evidence from a growing number of sources show an alarming rise in stress to all natural systems on Earth, escala ng diet-related ill-health across the world, worrying inequali es in food consump on pa erns within and between countries, and disrupted food supplies. Given this context and the expected increase in the global popula on to approximately 9.6 billion people in 2050, the need and urgency for a food system transforma on to remain within 1.5 degrees C of global warming (Figure 1) and to mee ng a broad range of global goals related to human health, environmental sustainability and social jus ce is clear. 160 4 161 162 163 164 165 166 167 168 169 170 171 172 173 174 175 176 177 178 179 180 181 182 183 184 185 186 187 Figure 1: A. Projec ons of global emission reduc ons from agriculture, forestry, and other land use (AFOLU) (CO 2, CH4 and N2O) and energy and industry (CO2), including nega ve AFOLU CO2 emissions and carbon sequestra on from BECSS (Bioenergy with Carbon Capture and Storage) required to limit warming to 1.5 °C with no or limited overshoot (C1). The dashed line shows this report’s trajectory of the food systems’ share of the safe opera ng space for climate; the Food System Boundary (FSB) amoun ng to 5 Gt CO2eq/yr consis ng of minimized flows of CH4 and N2O. Data are from IPCC sixth assessment report following selected scenarios (n=62) within the C1 category. Addi onal carbon sequestra on measures (e.g. CCS from Fossil Fuel Use and Industry, not depicted here) are necessary for 1.5 ° pathways. B. Non-CO2 emissions (CH4 and N2O) from AFOLU in 2020. Unsustainable food systems threaten the func oning of the biosphere and the stability of the en re climate system, and underpin unhealthy diets, which accounts for approximately 15 million avoidable deaths each year (see Panel 2). Access to food is inequitable, with an insufficient access to healthy diets.3– 5 The food system produces enough calories to feed the world’s popula on, yet average diets trend to low composi onal quality with global underconsump on of whole grains, fruits, nuts, and vegetables.3,6 Unhealthy overconsump on, notably of red meat, is a leading driver of climate and land-use impact. 1 Our food supply is inherently sensi ve to water scarcity and clima c variability, and is increasingly sensi ve to rapidly rising human climate change induced extreme events, like droughts, floods, heatwaves, or pest and disease outbreaks. Prevailing food produc on prac ces are driving biodiversity loss, water scarcity, overuse of pes cides and overloading of fer lisers, climate change, and excessive use of an microbials. Food prices do not reflect the true cost of unsustainable produc on, while rising global poverty makes healthy diets too expensive for billions of people.7,8 This is a major challenge, as it shows that the planet is subsidizing cheap food as no environmental externali es (e.g., biodiversity loss, nutrient overloading, freshwater use, and GHG emissions) are paid for, while almost one billion people suffer from undernutri on. The economic costs of these challenges are staggering, while global food system generates US$10 trillion in value each year, the nega ve externali es are es mated at US$15 trillion, with the health sector contribu ng the most.9,10 5 188 189 190 191 192 193 194 195 196 197 198 199 200 These trends drive cri cal and unacceptable injus ces. The current socio-economic situa on for billions of people in the world undermines fundamental human rights. Inadequate and inequitable access to safe, sufficient, and nutri ous food for nearly 50% of the global popula on10 violates the right to food, contribu ng to malnutri on, ill-health, and maternal and child mortality.6 The food system drives transgression of mul ple planetary boundaries viola ng the right to a healthy environment and a stable planet, resul ng in illness, and the loss of work, food, and life. Poor labour condi ons for many food system workers, o en underpaid, and lacking social benefits, violate the right to decent work, resul ng in exploita on and low purchasing power.11–13 In addi on, the lack of representa on and freedom of expression of many food system workers, alongside market concentra on, with a few large food system firms influencing decision-making, policies, and prices, undermines the achievement of all of these rights.14–17 201 Growing a en on to food systems, but progress is slow 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 The global food agenda has made significant progress over the past five years. New evidence provides stronger support for the importance of food for human health and planetary stability, and there is a rising recogni on that food jus ce forms an integral part of successful food transforma ons. Scien fic a en on to food systems has surged with new evidence emerging daily, including more than 10,500 cita ons of the 2019 EAT-Lancet Commission alone. This evidence spans the development of planetary health diet indices,18,19 na onal downscaling of dietary impacts on human health and environmental condi ons,20,21 economic analyses of food systems transforma on assessments on novel technologies,22–24 and behaviour change. Most of this evidence supports the 2019 findings, adding new insights and stronger support for food policy, ac on on public health, and raising public awareness, but it also signals need for addi onal a en on to socioeconomic dimensions feasibility, and environmental impacts across all planetary boundaries.25 228 Cri cal scien fic assessment Complemen ng the growing a en on by the research community, a diversity of interna onal, na onal, and local actors is driving a variety of commitments and ini a ves. A key moment came in 2021 with the United Na ons Food Systems Summit (UNFSS). Since then, two thirds of countries have adopted na onal food systems transforma on pathways and have commitments to integrate foods into their Na onally Determined Contribu ons (NDCs) to the Paris Climate Agreement. More than 290 ci es, with a combined popula on of 490 million, have signed onto the Milan Urban Food Policy Pact enac ng more than 620 specific food system ac ons. Both the IPCC and IPBES have assessed food systems, 26,27 no ng food’s dependency, and impacts on biodiversity, climate, water, and health. The Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework signed in 2023 set specific food system targets. In these efforts, and other, food is recognised as uniquely central in the nexus of human health, social jus ce, and environmental sustainability.28 We are alarmed by recent efforts to undermine, hide, or obfuscate climate science, environmental protec ons, and a en on to jus ce. Ignoring these trends aggravates, rather than resolves the challenges they represent and their growing impact on human society. 6 229 230 231 232 233 234 235 236 237 238 239 240 241 242 243 244 245 246 247 248 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 The growing a en on in science and prac ce is encouraging. Yet with few excep ons, emerging plans have targets that are poorly ar culated, non-specific with no accountability, insufficiently ambi ous,29 include too few and siloed interven ons,30–32 and lack appropriate financial support. The slow rate of ac on is unjust and dangerous to both current popula ons and future genera ons.33,34 Considering this surge in evidence, and interest in food system ac on, an updated assessment is cri cally needed. Our primary objec ve of this Commission is to provide that update. First, we review new evidence published since 2019 on diet and health to provide the latest scien fic update on the PHD paying specific a en on to research on dietary pa erns and incorpora ng evidence from a broader range of popula ons and world regions. We highlight long-established or tradi onal dietary pa erns that are in line with the PHD and emphasise the poten al of achieving culturally diverse healthy diets. However, we also recognise that there is similarly ample evidence that ‘modern’ diets, appropriately configured, can provide similar health benefits. The diversity of fruits, nuts, vegetables, and whole grains available in many modern socie es, and the interest in ethnic cuisines from around the world is unprecedented, as is the number of choices available to those desiring healthy op ons where they are available. In addi on, we provide updated health impacts and nutri onal assessments of adop ng the PHD and related dietary pa erns by country and socio-demographic group. Second, we review the evidence on the impact of food produc on systems on the Earth system and assess the current state of food systems across all nine planetary boundaries, upda ng the five quan fied in the 2019 EAT-Lancet Commission. For the first me, we propose specific food system boundaries, as a food system share of the safe opera ng space provided by the planetary boundaries, for use in target se ng for food. We provide a novel assessment of how sustainable and ecological intensifica on food produc on prac ces can support a transforma on of food produc on systems within safe food system boundaries. Third, we establish social founda ons of a just food system and assess where current food systems are placed in rela on to the founda ons. By adding a focus on jus ce, we place people at the centre of food systems recognising that a just food system is one where human rights can be met. We assess the global distribu on of injus ces focusing both on where unhealthy food consump on exerts undue pressure on planetary boundaries, and regions where social jus ce in rela on to the food system are not met. Fourth we include a mul -model analysis to quan fy the consequences of a food systems transforma on to healthy diets, sustainably produced by 2050. We include ten well-established agro-economic and environmental models with socio-economic rebound effects to expand our understanding of the poten al outcomes of the proposed food systems transforma on, including direct effects on food produc on quan es and environmental impacts, and a greater considera on of poten al socio-economic impacts. Finally, based on the reviewed evidence, we propose solu ons and ac ons to ensure access to, and demand for, healthy, sustainable, and just food systems for all. While these solu ons are impac ul in making healthy and sustainable diets available, accessible, and affordable, we emphasize the opportunity and need to ensure that foods offered must also be delicious and aspira onal to ensure that demand 7 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 helps fuel their adop on. We discuss and suggest steps to develop roadmaps that can guide and accelerate the urgent and systemic food systems transforma on that is needed. 287 Treatment of Uncertainty 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300 301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 As with the 2019 Commission, we recognize that few decisions on dietary health, environmental sustainability, and social jus ce can be made based on absolute certainty. In many cases, exis ng evidence is incomplete, imperfect, and evolving. This Commission takes stock of how knowledge has evolved over the past five years as one means of reducing this uncertainty. We have based our es mates on the best science acknowledging uncertain es where they exist. Confidence levels are provided and improved through wider systemic reviews and broader community efforts to test the validity of findings. For example, a new contribu on of this Commission’s work is a mul -model intercomparison, involving 10 integrated assessment modelling teams, tes ng the contribu on of adop ng the PHD and transi on to sustainable food produc on prac ces, in feeding humanity within planetary boundaries (featured in sec on 4). This work highlights the degree of certainty, and variance, in outcome results. We have adopted treatment of uncertainty in the same manner addressed by IPCC and IPBES. All of the models in the model intercomparison exercise have calibrated their results ensuring that historical trajectories can be reproduced. Considering the 2019 Commission, and the new research summarized here, we have a high level of scien fic certainty about the overall direc on and magnitude of change required, although considerable uncertainty can exist around some of the more detailed quan fica ons. Our modelling work considers major trends and opportuni es; however, it is important to recognize the myriads of pathways that food systems actors might choose to navigate this transi on, and which we encourage them to explore. While the challenges are daun ng, we find that achieving access to healthy diets for all, produced, processed, distributed, and consumed fairly within planetary boundaries largely remains biophysically possible. Important synergies between economic, social, and environmental outcomes exist, but are currently missed in today’s socio-economic and socio-poli cal systems. These synergies should be be er leveraged. Healthy diets are not only a fundamental right, but a shared responsibility. Major efforts are needed to manage an increasingly urgent food systems transforma on that secures human and planetary health, addressing the cri cal lock-ins and poli cal economies inhibi ng progress on this necessary transi on. The urgency to accelerate the “great food transforma on” is undeniable. This Commission provides clear quan ta ve guidance on health, sustainability, and jus ce with the aim that this guidance will assist food system actors to navigate this progress with greater confidence and impact. The “great food transforma on” needed to achieve healthy, sustainable, and just food systems is huge; it will require the efforts of individuals, organisa ons and governments at levels from local to global and across essen ally all sectors in society. This Commission provides scien fic measures for healthy, sustainable, and just food systems based on our current understanding. The model results are our current best es mate of plausible change (or lack thereof), and their implica ons for human health and planetary stability. However, the actual feasibility and impact will vary based on decisions and pathways adopted by individual socie es. We do not assess 8 311 312 313 314 315 316 317 318 319 how we got to our current state but evaluate a broad range of solu ons with demonstrated impacts in the research literature and encourage food system actors to urgently evaluate and adopt appropriate solu ons to their contexts. Here it is worth reminding that the PHD and the FSBs merely provide healthy and sustainable boundary condi ons, within which a myriad of food dietary composi ons and prac ces fit. It is beyond the scope of this Commission to prescribe which ac ons should be adopted locally, and we recognize the need for much greater interac ons between science, policy, and prac oners in finding context specific solu ons. 9 320 Key Messages 1. Food systems sit at the nexus of health, environment, climate, and jus ce. A food systems transforma on is fundamental for solving the climate, biodiversity, crises, and the food related health and jus ce health crises. The nexus posi on of food systems emphasizes the interac ons between goals, rather than each goal separately. This calls for adop ng food system ac ons as a global integrator across economic, governance and policy domains. 2. The updated Planetary Health Diet (PHD) has an appropriate energy intake, a diversity of whole or minimally processed foods that are mostly plant-sourced, fats that are primarily unsaturated with no par ally hydrogenated oils, and limited amounts of added sugars and salt. It allows flexibility and is compa ble with a wide variety of foods, cultures, dietary pa erns, tradi ons, and individual preferences. The PHD provides both nutri onal adequacy and diminishes the risks of non-communicable diseases. At present, all na onal diets deviate substan ally from the PHD, but a shi to this pa ern could avert approximately 15 million deaths per year (27% of total). Such transi on would reduce the rates of many specific noncommunicable diseases and promote healthy longevity. 3. Food drives five out of six planetary boundary transgressions, including land system change, biosphere integrity, blue water change, biogeochemical flows, and novel en es, while accoun ng for approximately 30% of greenhouse gas emissions driving climate change. How and where food is produced, which foods are produced and consumed, and how much is lost and wasted, all contribute to planetary boundary transgressions. There is no safe solu on to the climate and biodiversity crises without a global food system transforma on. Even if the world succeeds with the global energy transi on away from fossil-fuels, the food system alone will make the world breach the Paris Climate agreement range of limi ng global mean surface temperature to 1.5°C. 4. Human rights related to food systems (the rights to food, a healthy environment, and decent work) are not being met, with nearly half the world’s popula on below social founda ons. Meanwhile, across countries and people, responsibility for the planetary boundary transgressions from food systems is not equal: the diets of the richest 30% of the global popula on contribute over 70% of the environmental pressures from food systems. This highlights the large inequali es in the distribu on of both benefits and burdens of current food systems. Na onal policies that address inequi es in the distribu on of both benefits and burdens of current food systems would go some way to mee ng human rights as they relate to food systems. 5. The Planetary Health Diet needs to be available, affordable, convenient, aspira onal, and delicious. To increase demand for healthy sustainable diets and enable necessary dietary 10 shi s, food environment interven ons, increased purchasing power, and protec on and promo on of healthy tradi onal diets are important ac ons. 6. An EAT-Lancet aligned food system transforma on that includes a shi to healthy diets, improved agricultural produc vity, and reduced food loss and waste would substan ally reduce environmental pressures on emissions and land-, water-, nitrogen-, and phosphoroususe. However, no single ac on is sufficient to ensure a healthy, just, and sustainable food system. Comparing 2050 values to current state, a shi to healthy diets in isola on could lead to a 15% reduc on in agricultural emissions, compared to 20% when all three ac ons are implemented. Individually all three ac ons modestly reduce future nitrogen- and phosphorous-use (27-34% vs 41% increase compared to 2020 under business as usual), however in combina on they substan ally reduce future growth in nitrogen- and phosphorous-use (15% increase compared to 2020) 7. Addi onal nature-posi ve benefits are accrued through sustainable and ecological intensifica on prac ces. Unprecidented investments and effort in these prac ces poten ally making the food system net carbon nega ve. A diversity of context-specific prac ces can sequester addi onal carbon biomass, create and connect habitat, reduce nutrient applica ons and increase intercep on and capture of excessive crop fer liser before it pollutes ground and surface water systems. These prac ces can be enabled by securing equitable access to land and water resources, strengthening public advisory services, addressing structural imbalances between producers and dominant agribusinesses, and through public and private sector investments that support farmers shi ing towards sustainable prac ces. 8. An EAT-Lancet aligned food system transforma on could lead to a less resource- and labourintensive food system capable of supplying a healthy diet for 9.6 billion people with modest impacts on food costs. This would however have profound implica ons regarding what, how, and where food is produced and those involved in these processes. For example, as a part of this restructuring some sectors would need to contract (e.g., ruminant meat: -33%) and others would need to expand (e.g. fruits, vegetables, and nuts: +63%) compared to 2020 produc on levels. 9. Jus ce is needed to unlock and accelerate ac on for transforma on. A fair distribu on of opportuni es and resources, such that the rights to food, a healthy environment, and decent work are met, and a fair distribu on of the responsibility to produce, distribute, and consume healthy diets within planetary boundaries are the basis of a successful food systems transforma on. Power asymmetries, discriminatory social and poli cal structures prevent these rights from being met, which results in harms to health of people, precarious livelihoods of food systems workers, and lack of voice undermining freedom, agency, and dignity. Ensuring liveable wages, and collec ve bargaining while regula ng and limi ng market concentra on and improving transparency, accountability, representa on, and access to informa on are all 11 impac ul ac ons. We emphasize the protec on of basic human rights in conflict areas a as fundamental founda on of jus ce. 10. Unprecedented levels of ac on are required to shi diets, improve produc on, and enhance jus ce. A just transforma on requires building coali ons with actors from inside and outside the food system; iden fying bundles of ac ons; developing na onal and regional roadmaps for implementa on; unlocking finance for the transforma on; and rapidly pu ng joint plans into ac on. Such efforts should closely align with other sustainability and health ini a ves (Paris Agreement, Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, Na onal Food Based Dietary Guidelines). These frameworks have equally iden fied food system ac ons as powerful, par cularly in their capacity to integrate across goals. Mobilising and repurposing finance is cri cal to enabling this transforma on 321 322 12 323 Glossary Planetary Health Diet Based on latest evidence on diet and health, the Planetary Health Diet represents a dietary pa ern that supports op mal health outcomes, and which can be applied globally for different popula ons and different contexts while suppor ng cultural and regional varia on. It emphasizes a plant-rich diet where whole grains, fruits, vegetables, nuts, and legumes comprise a greater propor on of foods consumed, with moderate or small amounts of fish, dairy, and meat. The Planetary Health Diet is en rely based on direct effects of diets on human health, not on environmental criteria. We refer to it as the Planetary Health Diet since there is good evidence that its adop on would lower the environmental impacts and nutri onal deficiencies of most current diets. Food System Boundaries Food system boundaries are science-based targets represen ng the share of the safe opera ng space for food systems. They are based on the available evidence represen ng the required or possible mi ga on of food systems to return or remain within planetary boundaries, including the present-day contribu on of food systems to planetary boundary transgressions in rela on to other sectors, es mates of minimum environmental impacts from food systems that are hard-to-abate (i.e. through op miza on modelling across sectors), and es mates of limited Earth system impact while remaining produc ve agricultural systems. Sustainable and Ecological Intensifica on (SEI) Sustainable Intensifica on (SI) entails achieving important reduc ons in the environmental impacts though increased efficiency, reduced losses, and reduced pollu on. Ecological Intensifica on (EI) is a subset of SI that enhances the environmental performance by promo ng ecological processes within agricultural fields, farms and landscapes, such as above and below ground carbon sequestra on, nutrient cycling and storage, pollina on, and biological pest regula on. Social Founda ons Social founda ons require basic human rights, such as food, water, health, and energy, to be met for everyone. We build on previous work defining the minimum resources required to meet people’s human rights, to avoid resource depriva ons and harms, and focus on the minimum condi ons that enable people’s human rights to be met. Great Food Transforma on An unprecedented commitment globally and na onally to an interlinked range of ac ons to be taken by all sectors to make healthy food accessible to all—produced, processed, distributed, and consumed fairly within planetary boundaries 324 325 326 13 327 Section 1: What is a Healthy Diet? 328 329 330 331 332 333 334 335 We review the evidence on diet and health and present reference values for food group intakes in the reference Planetary Health Diet (PHD) (Table 1). Since the 2019 Commission,1 we included additional health outcomes, considered effects of food processing, and examined implications for young children and women of reproductive age. The relation between the PHD with mortality and other health outcomes has now been examined in numerous epidemiological studies that we summarise. This section also describes gaps between current dietary intakes and the PHD in different regions, and how different dietary cultures may align with the PHD. 336 Approach to Defining Healthy Diets 337 338 339 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 Healthy diets should be adequate, diverse, balanced, and moderate.35 Defining healthy diets for a global population is complicated because nutritional requirements vary by, for example, age, sex, body size, physical activity level, pregnancy and lactation, health status, and genetic factors. However, the effects of diet are similar across ancestry or ethnic groups due to common underlying human biology. 36,37 Here, we focus on diets of generally healthy populations two years and older, although the PHD is also key to resolving health risks in populations facing a high prevalence of undernutrition. 360 Review of Evidence on Diet and Health 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 The goal of this Commission in defining the PHD is to provide the evidence and a quantitative description of a healthy dietary pattern that can be applied globally for different populations and different contexts while supporting cultural and regional variation. In summarising evidence and evaluating causality, we considered prospective epidemiologic studies, randomised trials with intermediate risk factors as endpoints, and the few available randomised trials with health endpoints (Panel 1). Because changes in dietary components by individuals or populations are usually made within a constrained total energy intake, isocaloric substitution analyses comparing specific dietary components, such as red meat versus We have described healthy diets as combinations of foods as this most directly connects health with food production and consumption. Nutrient adequacy is important and included in our analyses, but our primary considerations are specific health outcomes related to insufficient or excessive food intakes, rather than numerical targets for essential nutrients (e.g., average requirements (ARs) or estimated average requirements (EARs)). Nutrient requirements are largely based on small, short-term studies, and are often not supported by sufficient evidence for long-term overall health. In addition to food groups, we include added fats, sugar, and salt as they are substantial components of most diets. Our conclusions assume that most foods are consumed whole, unprocessed, or minimally processed. Although the PHD is based on direct effect of diets on health, we also discuss potential indirect effects of diets on health, including antimicrobial resistance, pandemic risk, and those mediated by environmental changes (Panel 3). Control of microbial and other contaminants of food and water is critical but not comprehensively reviewed here. While the cost and affordability of diets, and the environmental impacts of their production and consumption, are critical issues and influence people’s access to healthy diets, these factors do not define what is healthy in a diet. We address those separately in other sections. 14 368 369 370 371 legumes, nuts, or fish, are particularly informative because these represent realistic dietary choices. A key part of this Commission is the evaluation of the PHD as an overall dietary pattern in relation to mortality and other health outcomes. Panel 1: The Planetary Health Diet and Health: Evidence for Causality Ideally, evidence for effects of specific foods, nutrients, and overall diets on major health outcomes would be based on large, randomised trials with disease and functional endpoints in representative populations across the world. However, this type of evidence is limited because such trials require many thousands of participants, many years or even decades of follow-up, and sustained high adherence to assigned diets. This is neither feasible nor ethical, and randomised trials not meeting these criteria can easily yield misleading, null or negative results. Thus, for studies of diet, and other behavioural and environmental exposures, frameworks to assess causality, such as the Bradford-Hill criteria,P1 have been developed. For dietary factors, these typically include reproducible evidence from prospective epidemiologic studies (e.g., following a cohort over time) in combination with randomised trials that include intermediate risk factors as outcomes.P2 Rigorous control of confounding factors by study design and statistical methods is essential. An example illustrates the value of combined evidence from observational and experimental studies in informing the links between the PHD and health. A central feature of the PHD is the importance of nuts and legumes, including beans, pulses, and soy as major protein sources, with limited amounts of red meat and dairy foods. The far higher ratio of polyunsaturated to saturated fatty acids in these plant foods compared with red meat and dairy products predicts lower LDL-cholesterol levels; this was confirmed in a meta-analysis of randomised trials of red meat intake. P3 In long-term cohort studies with repeated assessments of diet, mortality was lowest when plant protein was compared to red meat, dairy foods, and poultry;P4 associations with type 2 diabetes and coronary heart disease have been similar.P5 Other key features of the PHD include relatively high amounts of fruits and vegetables, shown to lower blood pressure in the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) randomised trial;P6 whole grains, shown to improve blood lipids in randomised trials;P7 and largely unsaturated plant oils, shown to reduce LDL-cholesterol.P8 Components of the PHD may operate by additional pathways, including modulation of the microbiome, but at a minimum, beneficial effects on firmly established risk factors are clear. As described in the main text, in multiple large cohort studies with careful adjustment for smoking and other potentially confounding variables, participants with diets most consistent with the PHD have had lower risks of many major health outcomes, including type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and total mortality. Important causal evidence for benefits of the PHD also comes from decades of research on the traditional Mediterranean dietary pattern, a specific example of the PHD. P9 In addition to the types of evidence from observational studies and trials of intermediate endpoints described above, P10 in a large, randomised trial in people with raised cardiovascular disease risk, a Mediterranean diet with added nuts or olive oil reduced the risk of cardiovascular disease,P11 type 2 diabetes,P12 cognitive decline,P13,P14 and other adverse health outcomes.P15 In another randomised trial, adherence to a Mediterranean diet reversed the prevalence of a pre-diabetic state by half over one year, P16 and in a two-year randomised trial, this dietary pattern reduced body weight compared to low fat or high fat diets;P17 weight loss was sustained at six years.P18 15 Together, the combination of evidence on the composition of food groups, randomised trials with risk factors as outcomes, and large cohort studies provides strong evidence that adherence to the PHD will have major health benefits. This conclusion is further reinforced by randomised trials of the Mediterranean diet, a dietary pattern that is one example of the PHD, documenting benefits for major health outcomes. 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 Based on this body of evidence, PHD reference values (Table 1) were developed to provide a foundation for optimal health outcomes, and to use as a starting point to evaluate global environmental impacts of food consumption that are addressed in subsequent sections. Importantly, for individuals, these values should not be considered as exact targets, but rather represent approximate ranges and proportions, with potential substitutions among foods to accommodate different total energy intakes and preferences. An updated review of available evidence is included in Appendix 1A; a summary is provided here. Dietary energy requirements vary greatly between individuals depending on age, sex, body size, physical activity, and metabolic factors. We estimated an average global energy intake of 2400 kcal/day for adults using a new doubly-labelled water-based methodology, assuming an ideal BMI of 22 kg/m 2 and an active level of physical activity (Appendix 1C).38 Assuming current average global physical activity levels and BMI among adults of approximately 25 kg/m2 leads to a similar energy intake. Grains, including a diversity of options such as wheat, rice, maize, oats, barley, rye, teff, amaranth, fonio, buckwheat, millets, quinoa, and others are the primary sources of energy worldwide and an important source of fibre, protein, and many micronutrients. Consumption of whole grains (100% of the bran, germ, and endosperm in an intact grain), but not refined (depleted) grains, improves blood lipid values and other biomarkers39 and is inversely associated with risks of weight gain,40,41 type 2 diabetes,42 coronary heart disease,43,44 colorectal cancer,43 and total mortality.45 The inverse association between intake of whole grains and weight appears linear, but a concern is that high intake of whole grains could displace other healthy foods and reduce micronutrient absorption. Thus, we used 210 g/day dry weight as a reference value for grains (midway within a ~20-50% of energy), considering this to be flexible and emphasising whole grains versus refined grains. Tubers, including potatoes, sweet potatoes, taro, yams, and cassava amongst others, are a major energy source in some populations, but commonly consumed white potatoes do not provide the amounts of fibre or micronutrients as do whole grains. Compared with whole grains or non-starchy vegetables, consumption of potatoes is associated with greater weight gain46 and risk of type 2 diabetes,47,48 and the association is stronger for fried potatoes than non-fried potatoes.47,48 Data on other tubers are limited. Because these findings support consumption of whole grains over potatoes as a major energy source, we used 50 g/day as the reference value. Fruits and vegetables, including seaweeds and other aquatic plants, are a primary source of many nutrients and phytochemicals. Intakes are inversely associated with risks of weight gain, 40,49 type 2 16 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 428 429 430 431 432 433 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444 445 446 447 448 diabetes,50,51 coronary heart disease,51 some cancers,52,53 and total mortality.54 More recent evidence supports a reduced risk of cognitive decline and dementia.55–57 Because of differences in the composition of specific fruits or vegetables and their distinct associations with health outcomes, a variety is desirable, specifically including green leafy and dark orange foods. Most health benefits accrue with about five servings per day; we used 500 g/day as the reference value with no specified upper limit. Nuts, legumes, and seeds provide protein, unsaturated fats, fibre, and many micronutrients. Nuts and legumes have beneficial effects on blood lipids,58 and consumption of nuts, including peanuts, have been associated with lower risks of type 2 diabetes,51 coronary heart disease,51,59 and total mortality.60,61 Soy foods contain substantial amounts of both omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids and are uniquely high in phytoestrogens, and consumption has been associated with lower risks of cardiovascular disease 62,63 and breast cancer.64 As nuts and legumes are healthy sources of protein, the reference value includes 125 g/day dry weight (about 3-5 servings per day of legumes, nuts, and seeds, including at least 1 serving of nuts); a variety is encouraged. Red (mammalian) meat is high in protein, haem iron, and other minerals, but is also high in saturated fat and cholesterol and low in essential polyunsaturated fatty acids. In populations consuming very high amounts of carbohydrates, small amounts of red meat or other animal-source foods can provide critical amounts of essential nutrients that have positive health benefits. Consistent with the fatty acid composition, and compared with plant sources of protein such as nuts, soy, and other legumes, consumption of red meat increases blood levels of LDL-cholesterol39,65 and is associated with increased risk of coronary heart disease.51,66 Also, consumption of red meat is linearly associated with elevated risk of type 2 diabetes among different populations, including Asia, Europe, and North America; both unprocessed and processed red meat contribute to risk but the latter association is stronger. 37,67 Red meat intake has also been positively associated with unhealthy weight gain and risks of gestational diabetes,67 colorectal cancer (especially processed red meat),68 frailty,69 and unhealthy ageing.70,71 Consumption of red meat is associated with higher risk of total mortality in countries that have been consuming high amounts for many decades.72 Because the association of red meat with type 2 diabetes has been documented in many large studies,37,51,66,67,73–75 and diabetes is a sentinel disease for many adverse cardiometabolic outcomes, this dose-response relationship was used to determine the reference value in Table 1. According to data from three large US cohorts with over 22,000 incident cases of diabetes and many repeated measures of diet over three decades, the increase in diabetes incidence with increase in red meat consumption was approximately linear with a minimal risk close to zero consumption of red meat. 76 We used 15 g/day (about one serving per week) as the reference value with a range including zero to allow a modest intake while avoiding statistically significant increases in risk (see Appendix 1A for additional details). Poultry meat has nutritional values similar to red meat but an intermediate polyunsaturated fat composition between red meat and plant protein sources. Associations with risks of non-communicable diseases and mortality have also generally been intermediate;37,77,78 an inverse association with stroke has 17 449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456 457 458 459 460 461 462 463 464 465 466 467 468 469 470 471 472 473 474 475 476 477 478 479 480 481 482 483 484 485 486 487 488 489 490 been an exception.51 Because these relationships suggest a priority of poultry over red meat, we used 30 g/day of poultry (about two servings per week) as the reference value. Eggs are a concentrated source of protein and essential nutrients and can play an important role in childhood diets. They are also high in dietary cholesterol and have generally been intermediate with respect to non-communicable diseases risk79,80 except for positive associations with risks of coronary heart disease among people with diabetes.81,82 Consistent with other guidelines, we used 15 g/day or about two eggs/week as the reference value. Milk and derivatives have broad nutritional value but high content of saturated fat and little polyunsaturated fat. High calcium content has been a primary justification for substantial lifetime consumption. However, calcium requirements have been based on short-term studies, and milk intake has not been clearly related to risk of bone fractures.83 Consistent with its fatty acid composition, dairy fat substantially increases LDL-cholesterol compared to unsaturated plant oils.84 Epidemiologic evidence is largely based on cow milk; as predicted, dairy fat is positively associated with cardiovascular disease. 85 Risks of cardiometabolic disease51 and overall mortality86,87 associated with milk intake are intermediate between red meat and healthy plant sources of protein. Consumption of dairy foods is associated with low risks of colorectal cancer88 but elevated risks of prostate cancer.89 Some evidence suggests that yoghurt consumption, and possibly other fermented products, may be associated with less weight gain 90 and reduced risks of type 2 diabetes51 compared with other dairy foods. We used 250 g/day of milk or the equivalent amount of milk derivatives (one serving per day) as the reference value because of its intermediate relation with non-communicable diseases risk and substantial contribution to calcium intake; the range includes zero because many populations globally do not consume milk and still have low fracture risk.83 In a recent meta-analysis, a small decrease in risk of cardiovascular disease was seen with about one serving/day of dairy foods, especially low fat milk and cheese, but li le further change in risk with higher intakes. 91 Fish, shellfish, and other aquatic animal-source foods are major sources of protein and essential nutrients for many populations, including in low and middle-income countries. In many diets, small fish and bivalves are often overlooked as potential foods. Collectively, these foods are particularly important as a source of omega-3 fatty acids (minimally present in terrestrial animal-source foods); low intakes of omega-3 fatty acids can slow down neurologic development in childhood92 and possibly with cognitive decline in adults;93 high intakes of omega-3 fatty acids are associated with reduced risk of cardiovascular disease.94,95 The relation between intake of fish or omega-3 fatty acids and cardiovascular diseases appears to be non-linear;94 most of the benefit is achieved with 30 g/day of fish (about two 100-g servings per week), which is used as the reference value. Added fats Evidence from prospective cohort studies and randomised trials has not suggested a reduction in cardiovascular disease96 or cancer97 by decreasing total fat intake. However, added fats differ greatly in their composition and health effects; partial hydrogenation creates deleterious trans isomers that are associated with increased risks of cardiovascular diseases98 and all-cause mortality99 and this process is now banned in many countries.100 Non-hydrogenated plant oils that contain mainly unsaturated fatty 18 491 492 493 494 495 496 497 498 499 500 501 502 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514 515 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 526 acids reduce LDL-cholesterol,101 and intake is strongly related to lower risks of cardiometabolic diseases and total mortality.102 These inverse associations appear linear within the ranges studied. Palm oil is relatively high in saturated fat and low in polyunsaturated fatty acids; although studies of health outcomes are limited, available evidence favours relatively unsaturated plant oils. 103 Compared with plant oils, dairy fat increases LDL-cholesterol and is associated with increased risk of cardiovascular disease and total mortality.84,85,91 Because non-hydrogenated plant oils have positive health effects, intake can be flexible within limits for total energy, for example, if exchanged isocalorically with whole grains. We used an intake of 17% of energy (primarily as unsaturated plant oils including both omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids) as a reference value, which is similar to that in a Mediterranean diet that reduces incidence of cardiovascular disease.104 527 Overall Dietary Patterns and Health 528 529 530 531 Evaluations of overall dietary patterns in relation to risk of health outcomes represent the combined effects of all dietary components, including their interactions (Appendix 1A). Dietary patterns have been developed to describe traditional diets of specific regions or cultures (e.g., Mediterranean or Japanese),112,113 using statistical approaches such as principal components or reduced rank regression Added or free sugars provide no nutritional value and can cause harms in excessive intakes. Intakes, particularly in the form of sugar-sweetened beverages, have adverse cardiometabolic effects and have been positively associated with weight gain,105 type 2 diabetes,106 coronary heart disease,107 and total mortality.106 Consistent with conclusions of the WHO108 and national guidelines, a maximum intake of 5% of energy from added or free sugars is used as a reference value. Sodium, commonly consumed as salt or mono-sodium glutamate, is essential, but intakes greater than 1500 mg/day increase blood pressure, and intakes greater than about 2000 mg/day are linearly associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease.109 Thus, up to 2000 mg/day sodium (5 g/day as salt) was used as the reference value. Food processing Minimal processing, such as drying grains, pulses and nuts, chilling or freezing fruits and vegetables, pasteurizing milk and fermenting milk into yoghurt, reduce food microbial contamination, extend freshness, enhance sensory properties, facilitate preparation, add variety to diets, 110 and reduce the time and labour costs of food preparation. Micronutrient fortification can improve micronutrient density, notably for nutritionally vulnerable populations. However, processing can also have adverse effects, including reduction in food nutritional content, addition of excessive salt and sugar, and use of unhealthy fats and refined grains. Processes that destroy the structure of whole foods, chemically alter their components, and assemble them with a variety of sensory-related additives into products that are liable to displace unprocessed or minimally processed foods and freshly prepared dishes and meals are considered ultra-processing.110 Dietary patterns high in ultra-processed foods have been associated with thirty-two adverse health outcomes spanning mortality, cancer, and mental, respiratory, cardiovascular, gastrointestinal, and metabolic health outcomes.111 The Commission concluded that most foods should be consumed whole, unprocessed, or minimally processed. 19 532 533 534 535 536 537 538 539 540 541 542 543 544 545 546 547 548 549 550 551 552 553 554 555 556 557 558 559 560 561 562 563 564 565 566 567 analysis,114 or, as for the PHD, based on available evidence relating dietary components to health outcomes. In meta-analyses, dietary patterns similar to the PHD were associated with lower risk of all-cause mortality.115,116 Within three large cohorts, the Mediterranean dietary score and five other commonly used indices of diet quality were similarly inversely associated with overall mortality and a composite outcome of major chronic diseases.117 Within-person improvements in dietary quality scores over time were associated with lower risks of all-cause mortality.118 These and other dietary patterns have also been associated with many other outcomes, including lower risks of depression and dementia. 119,120 Over recent decades, supported by extensive analyses in many populations, a substantial convergence has developed over the broad definition of a healthy dietary pattern. Since the 2019 Commission, multiple investigators have created indices representing consistency with the PHD, which is strongly correlated with other dietary quality indices.18,121 In prospective studies across the world, significant inverse associations were reported for the PHD and a number of health outcomes including total cardiovascular diseases, ischaemic heart disease, myocardial infarction, atrial fibrillation, stroke, heart failure, type 2 diabetes, obesity, colorectal cancer, lung cancer, and other cancers. A few studies reported null associations, but these findings need to be placed in the context of methodological limitations (see Appendix 1A).122–124 In an analysis of 206,404 men and women followed for up to 33 years, over 54,000 deaths were documented; overall mortality was 28% lower comparing the highest to the lowest decile of adherence to the PHD (Appendix 1A).18 Although findings on the PHD and mortality in two cohorts of Chinese adults125,126 are consistent with what has been seen in the United States and Europe (Appendix 1A), data from low- and middle-income countries are limited by the lack of large cohort studies in most regions. Associations could vary depending on dietary preferences within food groups, and further research from those areas is needed. Table 1 presents reference values of the PHD pattern for flexitarian adults. Scenarios for vegetarian or pescatarian dietary patterns and different total energy intakes are presented in Appendix 1A. The PHD pattern described in the current Commission is not substantially different from the 2019 Commission. 1 The dietary components in Table 1 have been re-ordered to facilitate interpretation and with slight rounding of several numbers. Total population level adult energy intake is specified at 2400 kcal/day (instead of 2500 kcal/day as in the 2019 Commission) based on updated values (Appendix 1B) and recognising that energy requirements vary by individuals.38 20 568 569 570 571 572 573 574 Table 1: Dietary targets for a healthy reference diet for adults, with possible ranges, for a population level energy intake of ~2,400 kcal/daya Most foods are assumed to be unprocessed or minimally processed. The targets, ranges, and exchanges (see footnotes) in this flexitarian version of the PHD are intended to provide flexibility within a specific energy intake while limiting intake of animal-source foods to approximately two servings per day with one being dairy (250 g milk equivalents) and one being non-dairy (e.g. 75 to 100 g from among fish, poultry, red meat or eggs). Various versions of this dietary pattern, including specific vegetarian, vegan, or pescatarian diets, those of different food cultures, and with different total energy intakes are described in Appendix 1B. Per capita recommended intake g/day (range) kcal/day 575 576 577 578 579 580 581 582 583 584 585 586 587 588 Plant foodsb Whole grainsc 210 (20-50% of energy) 735 Tubers, starchy rootsd 50 (0-100) 50 e Vegetables 300 (200-600) 95 Fruitsf 200 (100-300) 145 Tree nuts/peanuts 50 (0 -75) 275 Legumesg 75 (0-150) 275 b,h Animal foods Milk or equivalents (e.g. cheese) 250 (0-500) 145 Chicken, other poultry 30 (0-60) 60 i Fish and shellfish 30 (0-100) 25 Eggs 15 (0-25) 20 Beef, Pork or Lamb 15 (0-30) 45 Fats, sugar, and salt Unsaturated plant oilsj 40 (20-80) 355 Palm, coconut oil 6 (0-8) 55 k Lard, tallow, butter 5 (0-10) Sugar (added or free) 30 (0-30) 115 Sodium (mg) <2000 Total 2,400 a At individual level, the optimal energy intake to maintain a healthy weight in adults and growth in children depends on body size, level of physical activity and physiologic status (e.g., pregnancy, lactation in women). bMostly whole, unprocessed, or minimally processed foods; when processed, added sugar, refined starch, saturated fat, and sodium to be minimal. cWhole-grain rice, wheat, maize, oats, millets, sorghum, and other whole grains are all exchangeable and replace refined grains; dE.g., Potatoes, yams, cassava, sweet potatoes, and taro. eCombinations of dark green, red and orange, and other vegetables, including aquatic plants. fAll fruits and berries. gBeans, lentils, and peas (50%) and soy foods (50%). hBeef, lamb, and pork are exchangeable. Red meat, chicken, and other poultry can be replaced with eggs or fish, or plant protein sources. Dairy food servings are exchangeable for approximately 30 g servings of poultry, fish, or pork, provided calcium intake is satisfied by other food groups. iIncluding fish and shellfish (e.g., mussels and shrimps) from capture and farming. jUnsaturated oils include olive, soybean, rapeseed (or canola), sunflower, peanut oil, and most other plant/vegetable oils. kEnergy value for butter, tallow, and lard included with dairy and meats. 589 21 590 Nutrient Adequacy of the PHD 591 592 593 594 595 596 597 598 599 600 601 602 603 604 605 606 607 608 609 610 611 612 613 614 615 616 617 618 619 620 621 622 623 624 625 626 627 628 629 630 The primary evaluation of nutrient adequacy of an overall diet is based on health outcomes, which represent the cumulative consequences of all aspects of diet quality, including intakes of total calories, essential nutrients, other dietary components, effects of processing, and their interactions. We evaluated the nutrient adequacy of the PHD for adults compared to current diets by pairing estimated intake with nutrient densities and comparing those to the average requirements of each population group (Appendix 1D). 127Current intake was estimated by triangulating waste-adjusted food availability data with data from dietary surveys and estimated energy requirements (Appendix 1F). For most nutrients, the PHD is adequate and performs better than current average diets, notably for fatty acid profile, protein, free/added sugar, fibre, folate, magnesium, potassium, and zinc (Appendix 1D). Intakes of calcium, vitamin B12, iron, and iodine from the PHD warrant further attention, especially in populations that have low dietary diversity. Important differences are observed by national income (Appendix 1D). In low-income countries, required intakes of most nutrients in the PHD are substantially higher than current intakes, while in higher income countries, intakes of some micronutrients like vitamin B12 and B6 are lower than current intakes, while remaining adequate. Op misa on within the PHD reference values for general food groups (e.g., increasing the propor on of green leafy vegetables for iron, fermented soy foods for B12, and algae for B12 and iodine) can ensure nutri onal adequacy for all popula on groups.128 On average, calcium intake in the PHD is higher than current intakes, but it was estimated to be lower than recommended intake in some countries without optimisation (Appendix 1D). However, calcium requirements are likely overestimated because they are based on short-term studies. 83 Notably, Indonesia has the lowest calcium intake (approximately 250 mg/day), and the lowest fracture rate.83 Global average vitamin B12 intakes, already currently slightly below adequate intake, were slightly reduced in the PHD when not optimised. Vitamin B12 intakes are likely to be low if intakes of all animalsource foods are on the lower end of the PHD ranges (e.g., in vegan and vegetarian diets) and no supplementary foods are consumed; this merits attention because deficiencies can result in permanent neurologic damage.129 Dietary modifications with traditionally available food sources (e.g., fermented soybeans and algae in East Asia, fermented sesame in Western Africa, bivalves in coastal areas, and nutritional yeast more widely) can ensure vitamin B12 adequacy.128 In populations with biochemical evidence of inadequate intake, fortification or micronutrient supplementation should be considered. Absorbed iron intake in the PHD reference diet is similar to the current global average intake. Absorption efficiency was estimated by accounting for regulatory components such as phytates, vitamin C, and haem and non-haem iron in diets (Appendix 1D). The iron needs of women of reproductive age merit specific attention (see section below). Specific attention should be placed to ensure adequate intake of iron-rich food sources, including legumes, soy products, dark green vegetables, and whole grains. Increases in red meat consumption (as an iron source) above the recommended ranges of the PHD are associated with other adverse health outcomes as outlined above and in Appendix 1A. Estimated iodine intake currently and from the PHD appear marginal, but intake depends strongly on soil composition where foods are produced (proximity to marine environments) and seafood consumption including algae. 22 631 632 633 634 635 636 637 638 639 640 641 642 643 644 645 646 647 Absorption of nutrients like iron, zinc, and vitamin A can be compounded by parasitic and other infectious diseases common in low and middle-income countries (LIC, MIC). Because of complexities in estimated nutrient intake, absorption, and losses, monitoring the prevalence of nutrient deficiency is critical. Improvements in diet quality, together with appropriate fortification (e.g., of salt for iodine deficiency) or micronutrient supplementation strategies and non-nutritional interventions (e.g., water, sanitation, and infectious disease control), are possible approaches to address nutrient deficiency. 648 Women of Reproductive Age 649 650 651 652 653 654 655 656 657 658 659 660 661 662 663 664 665 More than one billion adolescent girls and women suffer from undernutrition, anaemia, and other micronutrient deficiencies which can result in devastating health impacts.134 The overall health of women of reproductive age is supported by the PHD as presented in Table 1 and Appendix 1E. The iron needs of women of reproductive age merit specific attention due to menstrual loss, pregnancy, and lactation. 666 Dietary needs of Infants and Young Children 667 668 669 670 671 Young children under the age of two years have unique requirements for rapid growth and development. Exclusive breast feeding, including timely access to colostrum, in the first six months of infancy is strongly advised to ensure optimal nutrition, reducing risk of infectious disease, prevention of both undernutrition and obesity, and for other benefits for infants and their mothers.140 From around six months of age, introduction of safe complementary foods based on diverse, locally available, and nutrient-dense food is The PHD provides approximately 14% of energy from protein, which exceeds requirements (EAR 0.7 g/kg body weight, approximately 10% of energy intake), and will provide sufficient essential amino acids. 130 The relation between protein intake and health outcomes will depend on the protein sources. In a metaanalysis, protein intake was inversely associated with lower overall mortality, but this apparent benefit was en rely due to plant rather than animal sources of protein.131 Somewhat higher protein intakes (e.g., 15 to 30% of energy) have been suggested as important for older adults.132 This was supported in an analysis on healthy ageing, where the benefit was almost entirely due to plant rather than animal sources of protein.133 The PHD provides approximately 53% of calories from carbohydrates and 35% from total fat, which is compatible with the flexible amounts of these macronutrients. A healthy diet during pregnancy is critical to prevent adverse maternal outcomes, support healthy foetal development, and avoid foetal programming that can transmit metabolic dysfunction to future generations.135 Overall food intake should be adjusted for optimal weight gain, and include a variety of healthy foods,136,137 consistent with the PHD (Table 1). Although balanced vegetarian diets can support healthy foetal development,138 use of micronutrient supplements or fortified foods may be indicated if animal-sourced foods are below the reference intakes. Because of extra nutritional demands of pregnancy, the WHO recommends136 routine iron and folic acid supplementation to prevent maternal anaemia, puerperal sepsis, spina bifida, and anencephaly. Other context-specific recommendations include specific micronutrient supplementation (calcium, vitamin A, and zinc) or routine use of multiple micronutrient supplementa on during pregnancy, which is now used rou nely in many countries because of benefits beyond those provided by iron and folate alone.139 23 672 673 674 675 676 677 678 679 680 681 682 683 684 685 686 essential for optimal growth and development.141 Continued breast feeding is important and deserves promotion, protection, and support. 687 Adopting the PHD pattern globally 688 689 690 691 692 693 694 695 696 697 698 699 700 701 702 703 704 705 706 707 708 709 710 711 712 The components of healthy diets, described broadly in Table 1 as reference values with ranges and potential exchanges among food groups, allow great flexibility because they are compatible with a wide variety of foods, agricultural systems, cultural traditions, and individual dietary preferences. 128 Possible ranges for individual components are described, but with overall intakes of animal-sourced foods being approximately two servings per day. The suggested daily or weekly amounts can be consumed at once or spread out in small amounts; for example, red meat might be consumed as an 80 to 100 g serving once a week or as small amounts in mixed dishes or soups, as is customary in many food traditions. Dietary habits and taste preferences are developed in early childhood, and it is important that children become familiar with healthy foods that lays the foundation for a healthy life. Fish, meat, eggs, and dairy foods are rich sources of some key nutrients for children of this age, including iron, vitamin B12, zinc, and calcium.142,143 The amounts of these animal-source foods in Table 1 would be suitable for most young children 6-24 months of age.140 Lower amounts of animal-source foods can result in nutritional deficiencies if not adequately replaced, including Vitamin B12 deficiency, which is associated with poor neurodevelopment in young children.142 For children with animal-source food intakes below the PHD reference values, complementing their diet with the use of nutrient supplements or fortified foods can make nutrient intakes adequate.140,143,144 Minimally processed foods should be prioritised, while ultraprocessed foods and beverages should be minimised as most are nutritionally unbalanced and may contain harmful additives. The balance of healthy animal- and plant-source foods presented in the PHD is consistent with many dietary patterns, including Indigenous diets,145,146 the well-studied Mediterranean diet,113,147 and other traditional diets from around the world. The traditional diets have in common with the PHD a base of whole grains or tubers, a wide variety of greens and other vegetables, legumes, and small to modest amounts of fish or meat with herbs and sauces that add flavour, variety, and nutritional value. 145,148,149 Moreover, many traditional food practices support improved bioavailability of nutrients and build on rich knowledge of the seasonality of cultivated and wild food species, supporting year-round food and nutrition security.145,146 Although more research on traditional diets in different regions is desirable, many of these patterns are consistent with high dietary quality 150 and low rates of chronic disease. Protecting healthy traditional diets and food systems can be a critical way to avoid transitions to unhealthy consumption. Examples of healthy meals based on tradi onal foods and flavours and consistent with the PHD are described in Appendix 1H. In settings with humanitarian crises, deep food insecurity, or in populations where diets remain dominated by staple carbohydrates (e.g. largely rice or cassava), food supplements, including fortified foods, may be required while improving diet quality.151,152 The time-cost and labour, mainly of women, for food preparation needs to be considered, and if cooking fuel is limited, this can prevent the preparation 24 713 714 715 716 717 718 719 720 721 722 723 724 725 726 of nutrient-dense foods, such as legumes. Availability of refrigeration and cooking facilities may also constrain food preparation. In some situations, processed, ready-to-eat foods may be necessary, and care is needed to ensure these are nutritionally balanced. Adequate amounts of safe water for drinking and sanitation are always essential. Importantly, achieving PHD-aligned diets represents an important goal for populations shouldering a high burden of undernutrition. 727 Summary and Conclusions of Healthy Diets 728 729 730 731 732 733 734 735 736 737 738 739 740 741 742 743 744 745 746 747 748 749 750 751 752 753 We draw on key evidence from long-term observational studies relating individual dietary components and overall dietary patterns to major chronic disease outcomes, randomised trials with intermediate-risk factors as outcomes, together with randomised trials of health endpoints. Figure 2 describes the gaps between the PHD reference values and current diets that vary greatly among regions. Notably, red meat and tuber/starchy root intakes are excessive in most regions except South Asia. Tuber/starchy root intake in Sub-Saharan African substantially exceeds the reference value and is higher compared to other regions. Free or added sugars intake is higher than the reference value in all regions except Sub-Saharan Africa and East Asia-Pacific. In most regions, intakes of many healthy foods are low, including vegetables, fruits, legumes, nuts and seeds, and whole grains (replacing refined grains); increasing consumption of these foods offer important opportunities to improve health. New evidence, including dose-response rela onships, has added substan al support for the health benefits of the PHD described in the 2019 EAT-Lancet Commission (Appendix 1A).1 This further supports emphasising whole grains over refined grains and potatoes, 48 plant sources of protein (legumes, pulses, and nuts) over red meat (unprocessed or processed),51,76 unsaturated plant oils over saturated fats,85,153,154 including generous amounts of fruits and vegetables,52 moderate amounts of dairy, fish, eggs, and poultry, and limi ng free or added sugars and salt.109,155,156 The elements of a healthy diet and the recommended intake ranges for main food groups outlined in Table 1 allow great flexibility because they are compatible with a wide variety of foods, agricultural systems, cultural traditions, and individual dietary preferences. They can be combined in various types of omnivorous or flexitarian diets as well as vegetarian and vegan diets. The findings of health benefits in many populations for this and similar dietary patterns show that healthy dietary patterns can be achieved in contemporary populations and in many countries globally. In making global estimates of impacts of diets on health, another general conclusion is that available data on the composition of foods, national dietary intakes, and the relation of dietary factors to health are far from optimal. Notably, large cohort studies with long follow-up are lacking from Africa, Latin America, and most parts of Asia. Because aspects of diet strongly influence health, enhancements in data availability and quality are needed to provide better precision in future analyses and more specific regional and local dietary guidance. 25 754 755 756 757 758 759 760 761 762 763 Figure 2: Differences between adult diets in 2020 and planetary health diet globally and by region. The ver cal 100% line represents the reference values of the flexitarian version of the Planetary Health Diet (PHD) from Table 1 (see Appendix 1B for source). 26 764 Panel 2: The Planetary Health Diet and Estimated Reduction in Avoidable Deaths among Adults The poten al reduc on in avoidable deaths among adults by adop ng the planetary health diet (PHD) has been es mated in two ways for this Commission. One approach used an updated compara ve risk assessment (CRA) analysis based on rela ve risks for specific dietary factors and incidence of specific diseases (e.g., red meat intake and type 2 diabetes) using published meta-analyses of cohort studies, most having a single assessment of diet (Appendix 1G). These associa ons were then applied to country-specific data on diets and cause-specific mortality. In this approach, adop on of the PHD was es mated to prevent about 10 million avoidable deaths per year among adults globally, represen ng 17% of total mortality.P19 About half of the reduc on in avoidable deaths was due to composi onrelated risks, including increased whole grains, fruits and vegetables, legumes and nuts, and less red and processed meat consump on. The remaining half was due to an cipated reduc ons in underweight, overweight, and obesity. To es mate more comprehensively the poten al popula on level impact of adop ng the overall PHD pa ern on mortality, the PHD reference valuesP20 were used to create the PHD Index (PHDI), a score for the consistency of individual or na onal diets with the PHD pa ern.P21,P22 The associa on between individual PHD scores and mortality was es mated from the follow-up of over 200,000 men and women over more than 30 years; diet was assessed every four years to account for changes in food consump on over me and to reduce measurement errors (Appendix 1A).P21 Combining the rela ve risks for PHD scores and mortality with the same data on country-specific diets and mortality used for the CRA analysis(described above), an es mated 15 million avoidable deaths per year among adults (27 % of total deaths) could be avoided globally by achieving a PHD score of 120 (140 being perfect consistency).P22 This es mate did not include assump ons about reduc ons in overweight or obesity; including such benefits would result in greater reduc ons in mortality. Notably, when only the baseline dietary assessment was used in the follow-up study, about two-thirds of the mortality reduc on was missed. Because achieving a global PHD score of 120 is ambi ous, we also es mated the poten al benefit from achieving a global PHD score of 100 (only 15 points above current diets); the es mated reduc on of avoidable deaths was seven million annually (13% of total deaths). In both the CRA and the PHD pa ern analyses, effects of sodium intake were not included due to difficul es in measurement, and both analyses did not include indirect effects of diet mediated by the environmental impacts of food produc on. Both analyses used data primarily from high-income countries for es ma ng rela ve risks because studies from other world regions are currently lacking, represen ng an important research gap that should be addressed. However, much evidence supports that rela ve risks for diet and health outcomes are quite generalizable across popula ons. Addi onal benefits due to substan al improvements in diet quality are also likely for children, but these are difficult to es mate quan ta vely because of major interac ons between diet and infec ous diseases, which are par cularly important in low- and middle-income countries. 27 In summary, different methods for es ma ng the impacts of adherence to the PHD yield different es mates of the popula on level impact on mortality. As expected, the use of an overall dietary pa ern that incorporates the addi ve and interac ve effects of most major dietary components, combined with repeated assessments of diet over the follow-up period to calculate rela ve risks, provides a higher es mate of avoidable deaths. For thoroughness and transparency, we have provided results from two approaches; with con nued improvements in data sources, further refinements can be expected in the future. 765 766 Panel 3: Indirect Effects of Diet on Human Health In addi on to the direct effects of diet on human health, food systems and diets also have many indirect effects on health mediated by their environmental impacts (see sec on on Sustainable Food Systems within Planetary Boundaries) or societal factors (see sec on on Jus ce in Food Systems). Here we provide some examples mediated by environmental impacts which we recommend merit greater a en on by the scien fic community. Climate Change has many extensively documented effects on human health, including heat stress directly affec ng human health, extreme weather events such as windstorms, flooding, and prolonged droughts affec ng food produc on, water security, and a endant deteriora on in sanita on pu ng people at risk of malnutri on, and increases in geographic areas and number of people affected by infec ous diseases such as dengue, malaria, and West Nile fever. P23 Moreover, climate change affects crop yields,P24 nutri onal content,P25 and food-based pathogens, with major indirect effects on human health through effects on the availability and affordability of nutri ous food. Air Pollu on resul ng from food produc on includes small par culate ma er and ground level ozone, which increase rates of cardiovascular, pulmonary, and neurogenera ve disease, and premature deaths.P26 Globally agriculture accounts for 650,000 deaths or 20% of mortality related to poor air quality.P27 This is largely from nitrogen pollu on from fer lizers leading to emissions of nitrogen oxides, and nitrogen dioxide pollu on associated with around 4 million new cases of paediatric asthma a year.P28 Biomass burning, notably in the global south, accounts for a smaller propor on, including from land clearing and cooking fuel (164,000 deaths, 5% of mortality related to poor air quality). An es mated 3 to 6% of global exposure to small par culate air pollu on could be avoided by adop on of more plant-rich diets, resul ng in approximately 100,000 to 300,000 avoidable deaths annually.P29 Nitrogen Pollu on of drinking water due to excess fer liser use has been associated with methemoglobinemia, colorectal cancer, thyroid disease, and birth defects. P30 Other adverse effects of nitrogen pollu on in waters may be mediated by eutrophica on of water bodies and overgrowth by toxic algal blooms.P31 The ground water threshold is exceeded in 38% of agricultural lands globally P32 par cularly impac ng the health of vulnerable rural popula ons with strong groundwater dependencies. 28 Biocides (including pes cides, herbicides, and fungicides) are used extensively in agriculture. P33 Although biocides are regulated in most countries to prevent risks to human health, their misuse (i.e. overapplica on and lack of appropriate protec ve measures, par cularly for agricultural workers) and co-exposure resul ng from mixtures in the environment, has mul ple adverse effects on health.P34 Chronic exposure to pes cides, including by consump on of contaminated foods, is associated with risks of Parkinson’s disease, diabetes, cancer, cardiovascular disease, and possibly with infer lity.P35 An microbial Resistance and Pandemic Risk have increased in part due to increased animal–human contact (either through direct interac on with wildlife or indirectly through vectors or intermediate, domes cated species) which is a prerequisite for zoono c spillover.P36 The large-scale global increases in consump on of animal-source foods coming from a very small number of species, o en produced in highly concentrated systems, increases risk.P37,P38 Ca le and hogs now make up ~43% of the mammalian biomass on the planet (humans make up ~38%),P39 and domes c poultry makes up ~70% of the avian biomass.P40 This large biomass poses a risk for the emergence of novel pathogens affec ng humans and animals, with an accelera on in the frequency of such epidemic/pandemic disease events.P41 The scaleup in animal-source food produc on has been enabled by using an microbials as growth promoters, and an microbials used for animal produc on represent about two-thirds of the global produc on of an microbials.P42 The risk of an microbial resistance emerging from the use of an microbials in animals is well-documented,P43,P44 and an es mated 1.4 million people die each year from untreatable microbial infec ons.P45 We es mated that adop on of the PHD would decrease an microbial use by ~42% due to reduc ons in animal sourced foods.P46 767 768 29 769 770 771 772 773 774 775 776 777 778 779 780 781 782 783 784 785 786 787 788 789 790 791 792 793 794 795 796 797 798 799 800 801 802 803 804 Section 2: Sustainable Food Systems within Planetary Boundaries Planetary boundaries is an Earth system’s framework157 that quantifies limits for biophysical processes that regulate the stability and resilience of life-support systems on Earth. Transgression of these boundaries pushes the Earth system into an unsafe environmental space for humanity. The latest update of the planetary boundary framework158 concludes that six of nine planetary boundaries have already been transgressed. The 2019 EAT-Lancet Commission assessed five of these boundaries — land, biodiversity, climate, blue water flows, and biogeochemical flows — and found that food systems carry the greatest responsibility for boundary transgressions. Here we re-evaluate the evidence on food systems impact on all nine planetary boundaries, including four boundaries not included in the 2019 Commission: aerosol loading, ozone depletion, ocean acidification, and novel entities (Table 2). We quantify specific food system boundaries that represent the share of the Planetary boundaries allocated to food systems (Figure 3). In contrast to planetary boundaries, food system boundaries are not based on increasing risk levels in the Earth system but represent science-based environmental targets for the global food system, aligned with the planetary boundary framework. As there is no consistent framework to define such targets, we define food system boundaries based on three principles from the exis ng literature: (i) through propor onal reduc ons necessary to move back to the safe opera ng space (based on present-day food system contribu ons to transgressions); (ii) through top-down sectoral op miza on of mi ga on costs using integrated assessment models; and (iii) by considering food system boundaries equal to planetary boundaries (based on large uncertain es or the on dominant contribu on of food systems to planetary boundary transgressions). In some cases, food system boundaries are based on evidence that considers limi ng Earth system impacts while retaining the produc vity of agricultural systems (see Text A2.1 and Table A2.1).159 Mee ng rising food demands must be achieved from less land, with food produc on that generates rather than degrades ecological func ons.160,161 Sustainable Intensifica on (SI) entails achieving important reduc ons in the environmental impacts through increased efficiency, reduced losses, and reduced pollu on.162 Ecological Intensifica on (EI) is a subset of SI that enhances the environmental performance of food produc on by promo ng ecological processes within agricultural fields, farms and landscapes, such as above- and belowground carbon sequestra on, nutrient cycling and storage, pollina on, and biological pest regula on.163,164 We synthesise evidence on the impacts of key groups of prac ces for sustainable and ecological intensifica on (SEI) across field-scale indicators, to assess the poten al of SEI in mi ga ng planetary boundary transgressions (Sec on Reducing the Environmental Foodprint of Food Produc on). We use a novel ecological intensifica on module from the FABLE model165 to assess the global poten al of these prac ces across planetary boundaries (Panel 6). 30 805 806 807 808 809 810 811 812 813 Figure 3: Status of the food system pressures across all nine planetary boundaries (indicated by the black dotted pattern) and the food system boundaries (red line). The food system boundaries are normalised in relation to planetary boundaries (green sphere). Radar plot is adapted from (Richardson et al., 2023 153). The contribution to the food system (in percentages, see Table 2) is projected based on the length of each wedge starting from the planetary boundary. Note that CO2 concentration is provided here in terms of CO 2, in contrast to the CO2- equivalents in Table 1. Adapted from te Wierik et al., 2025.159 31 814 815 816 817 Table 2: Planetary boundaries, current food system pressures (relative contribution in brackets), and the proposed food system boundary. Food system pressures and food system boundaries are defined in te Wierik et al., 2025. 159 The planetary boundaries control variables are predominantly based on Richardson et al., 2023 158, except if indicated otherwise. Earth System Process Climate change Land system change Control Variables Atmospheric CO2 concentration (ppm CO2) Total anthropogenic radiative forcing at top-ofatmosphere Global: Area of intact land as the percentage of original cover a Ecoregions: Area of intact land as the percentage of original cover by ecoregion a Biosphere integrity Current state 1.2 W m-2 + 2.91 W m-2 Global: 50– 60% remaining intactness Global: 50% remaining intactness Ecoregions: 5060% remaining intactness (with par cular a en on to forest ecoregions) 419 ppm CO2 Ecoregions: 10-95% remaining intactness Current food system state 16–17.7 GtCO2e yr-1 (30% of total anthropogenic emissions) 24% of total net radiative forcing Food system boundary 5 GtCO2e yr-1 Global: 48 Mkm2 (34% of total land surface) Agricultural land < 48 Mkm2 (requires halting land conversion of intact nature; <40–50% agricultural land at ecoregion level; restoring 8.5 Mkm2 intactness in forest ecoregions Ecoregions: 33% of ecoregions below the intactness threshold (50%) due to agriculture alone Biosphere Functional integrity (HANPP, in GtC yr-1) 5.5 GtC yr-1 (<10% of Holocene NPP) 13–16.8 GtC yr-1, (25–30% of HoloceneNPP) 9.9–11.7 GtC yr-1 (72–85% of total HANPP) 5.5 GtC yr-1 Ecosystem Functional Integrity a >20–25% habitat per km2 for supporting agroecosystem functioning. <5% reduction from preindustrial level assessed by latitude (~276 DU) ≥80% of the mean preindustrial surface ocean Ωarag of 3.44 30–60% of agricultural lands below boundary 88% of agricultural lands used for food production 100% of all foodproducing lands within the boundary 284 DU 3.9–4.2 Tg N2O-N yr-1 (54-69% of total N2O emissions) 1.8 Tg N2O-N yr-1 2.8 25% of CO2 emissions, as main driver of change in Ωarag Zero CO2 emissions from land use change and fossil energy use in the food chain 6.1 Tg of P yr −1 9.7 Tg P yr-1 7.2 Tg P yr-1 (75% of total delivery) 4.6 Tg P yr-1 Stratospheric ozone depletion Stratospheric O3 concentration (global average) (Dobson Unit, DU) Ocean acidification Carbonate ion concentration, average global surface ocean saturation state with respect to aragonite (Ωarag) Phosphorus: P loss to surface water (Tg of P yr1) b Biogeochemical flows: N and P Planetary Boundary 350 ppm CO2 32 Freshwater change Atmospheric aerosol loading Nitrogen: N surplus (Tg N yr-1) c 57 Tg N yr-1 119 Tg N yr-1 Consumptive blue water use (km3 yr-1) d Green water (% ice-free land area beyond 5th– 95th variability envelope) Interhemispheric difference in AOD 2,800 km3 yr-1 1,800–2,600 km3 yr-1 11.1% of land area with local deviations 15.8% of land area with local deviations 0.1 (mean annual interhemispheric difference) 0.076 50, 70, 80% to deposition, surface water load, and groundwater leaching >1,200–1,800 km3 yr1, including groundwater 16.8% of agricultural lands are beyond local variability envelope Northern hemisphere: >80% of NH3 emissions forming PM2.5 Southern hemisphere: >50% of PM2.5 emissions from biomass burning Novel entities Percentage of synthetic chemical released to the environment without adequate safety testing e,f 0% Transgressed Pesticides Active Substances (PAS) application: 3.3–3.7 Tg PAS yr-1 (85–90% of total pesticide use) <57 Tg N yr-1 (agricultural N inputs <134 Tg N yr1 with current NUE) 2,000 km3 yr-1 Remaining within pre-industrial green water variability envelopes on all agricultural land Northern Hemisphere: <20 Tg NH3 ) Southern Hemisphere: halting biomass burning emissions from land conversion 1 Tg PAS yr-1 to avoid high pollution risk; 0.2 Tg PAS yr-1 to remain below low pollution risk 818 819 Antimicrobial use in Halting prophylactic food-animals: use; Limiting use 73–130 kilotons yrto max. 36,000– 1 (73% of total 75,000 tons yr-1 antimicrobial use) a Rockström et al., 202334; b Beusen et al., 2022166; c Schulte-Uebbing et al., 2022167; d Willet et al., 20191; e Maggi et al., 2023168; f Van Boeckel et al., 2015169 820 Climate change 821 822 823 824 825 826 827 828 829 830 831 832 833 Our food systems release almost a third of the emissions driving climate change, and are also especially vulnerable to global warming, with profound effects on people’s food supply and health.170 Agriculture and food release 16–17.7 GtCO2e yr–1, or about 30% of total global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.170– 172 Around a third of these emissions come from agriculture, including both livestock and crop production, a third from conversion of natural ecosystems to cropping and grazing lands, and a third from nonagricultural aspects of food supply — including transport, cold storage, processing, retail, catering, food management in the home, the manufacture of fertilisers and other agricultural inputs, and waste management (Table A2.2).170,172 Most agricultural emissions come from produc on of animal-source food (Figure 10a). Enteric fermenta on from ruminant animals (i.e. beef and lamb, and dairy) and manure management linked to red meat and poultry account for large shares (Figure 1). Ruminant farming is the primary driver of land use change.164 Up to a third of food system-wide emissions derive from off-farm food-related processes, including fer lizer produc on and distribu on, post-farm food processing and transforma on and transporta on. For example, more than 10% (1.9 GtCO2e yr-1) of the global food 33 834 835 836 837 838 839 840 841 842 843 844 845 846 847 848 849 850 851 852 853 854 855 856 857 858 859 860 861 862 863 864 865 system emissions are a ributed to food that is lost or wasted along the supply chain.173 Reaffirming the boundary set in the 2019 Commission, we propose that GHG emissions from food systems are kept under 5 GtCO2e yr–1 by 2050 to keep global warming below 1.5 or 2°C (Figure 1). Several recent analyses support a 5 GtCO2e yr–1 boundary, highligh ng that a more ambi ous boundary is possible when mi ga on op ons include dietary change (Table A2.3). The residual emissions in this food system boundary comprise only methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O) emissions from biological processes in agriculture. These emissions are difficult to abate even with global adoption of the PHD, though the boundary could in theory be further reduced with wider adoption of increasingly plant-rich diets or major advances in emission-reducing technologies. 866 Land system change 867 868 869 870 871 872 873 Human activities have substantially altered the Earth surface through conversion of intact lands to croplands, grazing lands, and other industrial and urban land uses. Approximately 50% of ice-free lands can still be considered largely 'intact' (natural ecosystems with low human appropriation or use). 31 Halting further conversion of these lands, particularly protecting large forest biomes, is necessary to halt biodiversity loss, reduce human climate forcing, and secure hydrological functioning of ecosystems. 31,158,177 We set the land boundary at 85% intactness of ecoregions included in boreal and tropical forest biomes and at 50–60% for all other ecoregions as defined in the Planetary Boundaries and Earth To meet the climate boundary involves tremendous ambition. Full energy decarbonisation and zero land use change would together eliminate two-thirds of food system emissions, by largely eradicating CO 2 emissions. Energy use would need to be decarbonised throughout the food system, including in food transport, refrigeration and preparation, on-farm machinery, and manufacture of agricultural inputs. Netzero land use change, aligned with the Land System Change and Biosphere Integrity boundaries, needs a combination of secure land governance, increases in productivity, and reductions in demand. The remaining third – the residual CH4 and N2O emissions from agriculture – can be reduced through dietary change, management of food waste, and farming prac ces (e.g. improved livestock feed and fer liser use efficiency). A further opportunity to keep food systems within the boundary is carbon sequestra on in agriculture, which, when coupled with emissions reduc ons, could make food systems a net carbon sink (e.g. Panel 5 & 6, Sec on Improving Environmental Performance of Food Produc on) by removing by removing 1.4–5.5 –1GtCO2e (es mated economic poten al at a carbon price of US$100 per tonne).170,174,175 Sustainable and ecological intensifica on prac ces that sequester carbon include soil carbon management and agroforestry with an es mated 0.4–0.9 GtCO2e yr-1 and 0.4–1.1 GtCO2e yr-1 respec vely with a soil carbon prices of US$100 per tonne. A systems approach is essential to navigate trade-offs and rebound effects. Since options to reduce emissions diminish as our remaining carbon budget falls below 200 GtCO2, direct capture of emissions is now a universal component of scientific pathways to achieve 1.5 or 2°C (Figure 1). The preferred technology is Bioenergy, Carbon Capture and Storage (BECCS), a land-intensive solution that would compete with afforesta on and offset reduced demand for land to feed livestock.176 34 874 875 876 877 878 879 880 881 882 883 884 885 886 887 888 889 890 891 892 893 894 895 896 897 898 899 900 901 Commission.34 These levels are required to mi gate the impacts of climate change, and to halt the loss of biodiversity. 902 Biosphere integrity 903 904 905 906 907 908 909 910 911 912 913 914 Life on our planet depends on the capacity of the biosphere to safeguard critical Earth system functions, which in turn requires healthy, functioning ecosystems. Two complementary control variables for biosphere integrity include biosphere functional integrity and ecosystem functional integrity. Biosphere functional integrity refers to the sum of Net Primary Produc vity (NPP) from all ecosystems on Earth and thus is used as an Earth system-wide control variable.183 NPP captures the photosynthe c energy and material flows into the biosphere, with the devia on between poten al NPP of intact ecosystems and the actual NPP of converted systems. The biosphere integrity boundary sets a limit to human appropria on of this energy (HANPP) at <10% of Holocene NPP (5.5 GtC yr-1).158 Func onal integrity of ecosystems is defined as ecosystems’ capacity to sustain nature’s contribu ons to people (e.g. food produc on).184 Intact ecosystems are func onally intact, i.e. with high func onal integrity. This boundary, which is set at 20–25% natural or semi-natural habitat per km2, is thus applied to agricultural and urban land-use systems. From an Earth system perspec ve, func onal integrity contributes to ensuring gene and species Currently, 48 Mkm2 (37% of the global land area) are used for agricultural production, of which croplands and grazing lands cover 33% and 67% respectively.178 Almost 70% of ecoregions fall below the 50% intactness boundary,31 predominantly driven by historical conversion of intact nature to agriculture (Figure A2.1). Agricultural land alone breaches the local intactness boundary (>50% agricultural land cover) in a third of the ecoregions (Figure A2.2). The con nuing loss of intact ecosystems, notably forests, is predominantly driven by agriculture,179 and is particularly high in tropical forests that are cleared for pasture, oil crops and soy production.179,180 Remaining within the land system boundary requires zero conversion of intact lands, by keeping global agricultural area well below 48 Mkm2. This is a modification of how the land boundary was articulated in the 2019 EAT-Lancet Commission as 13 M km2 which only included croplands. In addition to halting conversion, reducing agricultural land and restoring intactness is critical across ecoregions, and particularly important in forest biomes that are currently strongly transgressed, and require 5.5 Mkm 2 and 3 Mkm2 of tropical and temperate forest restoration, respectively, at the expense of agricultural land (Figure A2.3). The key strategy to reduce agricultural land area is a shift to healthy diets, particularly away from animalbased products and associated feed production (Section 4).181,182 Decreasing food loss and waste is a lever with which the demand-side pressure can be further reduced. In aggregate, maintaining or increasing yields is cri cal to keep agriculture within a reduced land area, recognising regional differences depending on current yield levels. Sustainable and ecological intensifica on (SEI) prac ces chiefly demonstrate either improved (desirable effect sizes) or maintained (negligible effect sizes) produc vity (Sec on Reducing Environmental Foodprints of Food Produc on). EI would require slightly more land than other practices aiming to improve production but still fall below the land boundary globally (Panel 4). 35 915 916 917 918 919 920 921 922 923 924 925 926 927 928 929 930 931 932 933 934 935 936 937 938 939 940 941 942 943 944 945 946 947 948 949 950 flow within and between ecosystems, reducing the risk of species ex nc ons when complemented with the land boundary described above. The 2019 Commission used a 10% threshold with evidence that below this value ecosystem services to and from food produc on are lost. Recent reviews have increased this threshold to 20–25% necessary to maintain minimal func oning, rather than complete loss of func on.184,185 951 Freshwater change 952 953 954 955 956 Freshwater availability is critical to support drinking water needs, ecosystem functioning, and climate mitigation by enabling carbon sequestration in the biosphere. 189 The freshwater cycle is increasingly altered by human actions, affecting both blue water (rivers, reservoirs and groundwater) and green water (held in soil and in plants).190 Recent planetary boundary assessments show that we have transgressed boundaries for both blue and green water.158,191 These boundaries propose limits to the occurrence of Agricultural systems, notably extensive monocultures, are the single largest drivers of both biosphere and ecosystem functional integrity loss, through lowering actual NPP from land conversion, extracting NPP by harvesting biomass, and below threshold retention of habitat within agricultural lands. Agriculture is responsible for appropriating 72–85% of the total HANPP (9.9–11.7 GtC yr-1)186, while a significant portion of agricultural lands (33–66%) are below functional integrity thresholds, and 88% of agricultural land are used for food production (Figure 4a).184,187 Remaining within the food system boundary for biosphere integrity requires a reduction of HANPP back within the safe planetary boundary level (<5.5 GtC yr-1),159 by increasing productivity on existing cropland (i.e. closing agricultural yield gaps from e.g. nutrient deficits, see Section Nitrogen), and restoring ecosystems on former agricultural lands (e.g. reforestation), to increase actual NPP back to levels of potential NPP (Section Land System Change). Ecological Intensification practices, while not directly assessed against HANPP here, include practices that ensure that larger portions of NPP are retained in or returned to fields, for example as crop residue, manure, or perennial vegetation. Maximum field scale HANPP of sustainable production systems merits attention as a key scalable sustainability metric. Furthermore, reducing HANPP from harvested crops (currently ±2 GtC yr-1)186 is only possibly through dietary shifts that reduce HANPP from crop production for animal feed, and by reducing food loss and waste and feeding losses. Globally, around 775 kcal per capita per day is lost or wasted (represen ng approximately 20% of the agricultural land use), of which the majority are crops. These losses occur along the full supply chain (post-harvest, retail, food service, households), see Panel 4173,188 (Section Transformation). Increasing the functional integrity on productive lands requires widespread inclusion of embedded habitat in agricultural lands to reach the planetary boundary safe zone.184,185 This target can be achieved by protecting and restoring riparian buffers and hedgerows, improved fallows, returning crop waste to fields, and other practices fitting agroecosystem context. Agricultural diversification practices support the ecosystem functional integrity directly and can be managed to further enhance carbon sequestration (Climate Boundary), increase biological pest control and pollination (Novel Entities Boundary), and reduce losses of nutrients to the environment (Biogeochemical Flows Boundary). 36 957 958 959 960 961 962 963 964 965 966 967 968 969 970 971 972 973 974 975 976 977 978 979 980 981 982 983 984 985 986 987 988 excep onally dry and wet local events (including blue and green water availability), and deviate from the blue water boundary proposed in the 2019 Commission, which is based on volumetric limits to consumptive water use. It constrained the global agricultural consumptive use to <2,500 km3 yr-1 192 to preserve regional ecosystem flow requirements (hereafter ‘EFR’, meaning the minimum water volume, timing and quality needed to maintain good ecological status of aquatic systems). Here, we adopt the novel boundary defini on for green water (i.e. global land area beyond pre-industrial local green water variability baseline), while keeping – although upda ng – the volumetric limit for blue water. Food systems are major blue water users, mainly via irrigation.159,193 Water withdrawal estimates from rivers and groundwater range between 2,700–3,100 km3 yr-1 ,171,193 of which between 1,200–1,800 km3 yr1 are consumptive use.193,194 Irrigation is responsible for around 70–90% of the global consumptive water use, although estimates vary depending on the accounting methods and models used. 159,194 The majority of agricultural land and produc on159 is rainfed and hence depends solely on green water193, but soil moisture availability is changing across the world,191 including on agricultural lands (16.8% of agricultural land is currently transgressed).196,197 We preliminarily define the food system boundary for green water based on the latest planetary boundary definition (i.e. limi ng the land area beyond pre-industrial variability baseline to 11%)159). For blue water, we propose that agricultural water consump on remains below 2,000 km3 yr-1, which is lower than in the 2019 Commission (2,500 km3 yr-1), that allocated 90% of the safe opera ng space to agriculture. We propose a more stringent approach considering uncertain es in agricultural consump ve water use 193, and acknowledge the lower (stricter) end of the planetary boundary uncertainty range (1,100 km3 yr-1).192 While this suggests that food systems are within the safe operating space globally (Table 2), many rivers are experiencing severe water stress from irrigation water withdrawal alone.198 In fact, >5% of the global food production depends on regional blue water transgressions by tapping into EFRs (Figure 4b).198 In those areas, limiting irrigation water demand without affecting crop yield could be achieved through shifting production to less water demanding foods, 199 reducing food loss and waste (currently wasting 20-25% of freshwater withdrawals),171,173 and increasing water productivity through the adoption of agricultural practices that improve soil water holding capacity (Section Reducing Environmental Footprint of Food Production). SEI practices are significantly effective in increasing soil organic carbon (SOC) content, which in turn improves the water-holding capacity of soils.200 Crop and non-crop diversification, especially agroforestry (e.g., Muchane et al., 2020 201), exhibit strong desirable effects on the water regulation of soils by e.g. creating diverse root-systems and enabling infiltration. 989 37 990 991 992 993 994 38 995 996 997 998 999 1000 1001 1002 1003 1004 1005 1006 1007 1008 Figure 4a-d: Present-day status of planetary boundaries for land, biodiversity, water, nitrogen and pesticide use. a. Intact land (dark green) based on Rockström et al., 202334 and ecosystem functional integrity on existing agricultural land based on Mohamed et al., 2024184 b. Blue water, with regions where irrigation use exceeds freshwater ecosystem flow requirements (EFR), expressed as kcal of food produced yr-1 from water use that taps into EFRs. Restricting irrigation without compensatory measures can affect yields in half of irrigated croplands (data from Jägermeyr et al., 2017198 and Gerten et al., 2020202) c. Regions where local N boundary is exceeded (values > 0), and regions where N surplus boundaries are not yet exceeded and allow for increase in N to meet crop demand (kg N ha yr-1, data from Schulte-Uebbing et al., 2022167) d. Pesticide risk scores, indicating the exposure of agricultural land to pesticide pollution, classified into risks scores following average species sensitivity curves: low risk (0 –1), medium risk (2–3), high risk (>3). Data from Tang et al., 2021.203 Gray areas indicate no data. 1009 Biogeochemical flows: nitrogen and phosphorus losses 1010 1011 1012 1013 1014 1015 1016 1017 1018 1019 1020 1021 1022 1023 1024 1025 1026 1027 Nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) play a critical role in biological life, including crop and pasture production. In some regions, crop yields are below their potential due to deficient N and P availability, while in others, agricultural N and P surplus from excessive inputs cause environmental pollution, leading to biodiversity loss and human health impacts.166,204 In addition, N2O emissions from fertiliser and manure contribute to climate change (Section Climate Change) and stratospheric ozone depletion (Section Stratospheric Ozone Depletion). Here, we adopt the ‘N surplus’ from agricultural land as control variable,167 defined as N input minus the removal of N via crops and grasses. In contrast to ‘N input’ adopted in the 2019 Commission, N surplus covers remaining reactive nitrogen that can lead to environmental harm via deposition on natural ecosystems, groundwater leaching and surface water load. Unlike N input, es mates of N surplus are not affected by nitrogen use efficiencies (NUE, i.e. N removal from plants compared to total N input), but ignore N removal from plants that moves up the food supply chain and can end up in the environment via waste-water streams (i.e. via human excreta). The planetary boundary for N surplus on agricultural land is 57 Tg N yr-1, allowing for an increase in N use in regions that are currently deficient (Figure 4c). For P, we adopt ‘P losses to surface water’, which strongly depend on the available P stocks in soils and erosion rates. Unlike the ‘P applica on’ control variable used in the 2019 Commission, we use P losses since applied (excess) P can be adsorbed and build up soil P stocks without directly causing harmful environmental effects (unlike N). Based on critical P concentrations to preserve 39 1028 1029 1030 1031 1032 1033 1034 1035 1036 1037 1038 1039 1040 1041 1042 1043 1044 1045 1046 1047 1048 1049 1050 1051 1052 1053 1054 1055 1056 1057 1058 1059 1060 1061 1062 1063 1064 1065 1066 1067 1068 good ecological status of global surface waters,205,206 we propose a global P loss boundary of 6.1 Tg of P yr-1 .207 Current agricultural N inputs on cropland and managed grasslands (233 Tg N yr-1) are partly removed by crops (114 Tg N yr-1), while 119 Tg yr-1 remains as surplus.167 This surplus — together with other N sources from wastewater, aquaculture, NOx deposition from transport, and natural sources (i.e. allochthonous matter)— contributes to N deposition on terrestrial ecosystems (23 Tg N yr-1, around 50% from food systems), N loading in surface water (71 Tg N yr-1, around 70% from food systems), and leaching to ground water (56 Tg of N yr-1, around 80% from food systems) (Table A2.4).159,207 Furthermore, almost 10 Tg of P yr-1 is delivered from soils to surface water, with 75% of the P delivery (7.2 Tg P yr-1) derived from food systems (Table A2.4).166 Bringing agricultural N surplus back within global safe levels (< 57 Tg N yr-1) requires a reduc on of agricultural N input from 233 to 134 Tg N yr-1,167 (Panel 4) based on current NUE. Assuming propor onal reduc ons across other sectors can only slightly relax this value (to 140 Tg N yr -1)167 since most N sources are a ributed to the food systems (including agriculture, aquaculture and N from waste water) (Table A2.4); while further reducing the contribu on from natural N sources (from allochthonous organic ma er) is not possible. We therefore propose the food system boundary for N surplus to be equal to the planetary boundary. Increasing NUE from 0.48 (current global average) to an achievable 0.67 208 may bring us close to the safe operating space without compromising yield.167 Nutrient surpluses are highly unevenly distributed, with redistribu on being as important as a reduc on in fer lizer rates to limit planetary boundary effects (Figure 4c). Agricultural diversification and fertiliser management show significant potential to reduce nutrient losses to the environment, improve NUE, with some increased and chiefly neutral yield effects (Section Reducing the Environmental Foodprints of Food Production). While reduced disturbance showed mixed results for reducing nutrient losses in general, no-tillage significantly reduces phosphorus losses. Soil P stocks below target levels should be increased globally, and P applica on should maintain this soil P status by replacing P removed during cul va on and harvest and reducing physical loss via erosion control. Returning within boundary conditions remains a challenge without greater attention to food system losses originating from food consumption. Recovery of N and P sources from sewage water must similarly be implemented to prevent post-consumption losses (i.e. around 26 Tg N yr-1 from human excreta of which 12 Tg N yr-1 is lost to surface waters).166 The impact of circular systems remains poorly assessed (but see Panel 4) and merits attention. Recycling of N and P on fields, not only by using manure but also compost and sludge, decreases losses to the biosphere, although these practices are increasingly challenged by novel entity contaminants (e.g. Forever Chemicals or PFAS) in organic waste streams which can make agricultural fields toxic.209 40 Panel 4: Circular food systems Transi oning to more circular systems is thought to poten ally reduce (mineral) N and P use. To assess these poten al contribu ons, we used CiFoS,P47 a biophysical op miza on model to simulate four 2050 scenarios that were benchmarked to a 2020 simula on (see Van Zanten et al., 2025P48 and Appendix 2 for more details): 1. BAU-2050-Opt: scenario op mizes a future 2050 scenario by minimizing mul ple environmental impacts (use of land, N and P and GHG emissions) towards the food system share of planetary boundaries, by realloca ng produc on globally. The economic and social implica ons of this realloca on were not assessed. 2. BAU-2050-Opt+Cir: in addi on to the BAU-2050-Opt, allows a transi on to a more circular food system where le overs (e.g., by-products, human excreta, feeding losses and food loss and waste) are recycled. 3. EL-Opt: simulates a scenario which takes into account dietary shi s compa ble with the Planetary Health Diet, allows food loss and waste (FLW) reduc ons of 50% and produc on increases (in line with the mul -model ensemble described in Sec on 4). 4. EL-Opt+Cir: scenario adds circularity components to EL-Opt. In the BAU-Opt scenario the produc on of le overs was lower (4.1 Gt) compared to BAU-Opt+Cir (6.8 Gt) and the difference between EL-Opt (1.7Gt) and EL-Opt+Cir (3.1Gt). U lized le overs increased from 24% in BAU-Opt to 84% for BAU-Opt+Cir and from 22% in EL-Opt to 90% for EL-Opt+Cir (Panel Figure A). Results in the circular scenarios (BAU-Opt+Cir and EL-Opt+Cir) show a preference for recycling over reducing the produc on of le overs. In 2020, the total use of N is 259 TgN and total use of P is 40 TgP, including both mineral fer lizers and organic sources (Panel Figure B). Compared to 2020, in an op mized but not circular food system (BAU-Opt) the use of N decreased by 21% to 205 TgN, and the use of P decreased by 49% to 21 TgP. Adding circularity measures (BAU-Opt+Cir) reduced N by 29% to 184 TgN and P by 55% to 18 TgP and EL-Opt reduced N by 45% to 142 TgN and P by 67% to 13TgP. Combining circularity with an EAT-Lancet-aligned food system (EL-Opt+Cir) reduced N by 50% to 128TgN and P by 73% to 11TgP. N and P use in both EL scenarios are in line with staying within their respec ve planetary boundary (boundary value of 134 TgN total N input to stay within the N surplus boundary of 57 TgN per year (Table 2) and between 8 - 16 Tg of mineral P fer lizer per year based on Springmann et al., 2018 P49 to limit the amount of P reaching surface waters). Although the results of EL-Opt and EL-Opt+Cir only slightly differ, there are clear differences in the fer lizer sources used, e.g. more organic fer lizer sources are used in EL-Opt+Cir (Panel Figure B). Nevertheless, despite substan al reduc ons in mineral fer lizer use due to increases in circular sources of N and P (ElOpt+Cir), mineral fer lizers remain a cri cal input into agricultural produc on. 41 Panel Figure AB. Effect of circularity on le overs use and biogeochemical cycles on a global food system level. (A) Total le overs and total le overs used per scenario. (B) Nitrogen use and phosphorus use per scenario by source. 1069 1070 1071 Novel entities 1072 1073 1074 1075 1076 1077 1078 1079 The planetary boundary for novel entities proposes limits to the release of human-made substances in the environment — ranging from synthetic chemicals, such as plastics and endocrine disruptors, to radioactive materials and genetically modified organisms. The risk posed to Earth system stability and resilience from novel entities is uncertain, but potentially large and persistent following cumulative and mixing effects (i.e. chemical interaction of multiple substances in the environment), thereby threatening all life on Earth. There are >350,000 synthetical chemicals produced and released in the environment, and many are insufficiently tested for their potential environmental risks.210 Uncertainties regarding the associated risks of novel entities continue to frustrate the definition of a novel entities boundary, which 42 1080 1081 1082 1083 1084 1085 1086 1087 1088 1089 1090 1091 1092 1093 1094 1095 1096 1097 1098 1099 1100 1101 1102 1103 1104 1105 1106 1107 1108 1109 1110 1111 1112 1113 1114 1115 1116 is therefore preliminarily and precautionarily placed at zero release of synthetic chemical compounds without adequate safety testing that can demonstrate that no harmful environmental effects occur upon release.158,210 1117 Aerosol loading 1118 1119 1120 Air pollution is a major human health issue (Panel 3), negatively affects crop production by changing the photosynthetically available light,222 and can have critical Earth system impacts on precipitation and circulation patterns of the atmosphere and ocean. The planetary boundary for aerosol loading is While novel entities were not assessed in the 2019 Commission, food systems contribute to the release of various novel entities, such as pesticides,168,203 genetically modified crops, antimicrobials, (micro)plastics, 211 and ‘forever chemicals’, such as PFAS, throughout the food chain.212 Here, we adopt ‘pesticide application’ and ‘antimicrobial use’ as indicators for novel entities, because their widespread use in agriculture and potential risks to the environment and human health. 159,213,214 Pesticides are widely used in crop protection and weed control and pose major health risks to non-target species. Global pesticide application amounts to 3.3–3.7 Tg of pesticide active substances (PAS) yr-1 213, of which 85–90% is used in agriculture.215 Safety levels for individual pesticide concentrations are crossed throughout terrestrial and aquatic systems (Figure 4d). Although most pesticides degrade over time, remaining residues build up in organisms and pose risks through mixing-effects in the environment. 216 Furthermore, legacy contamination can continue for extended periods of time, decades in some cases, in soil, surface water and groundwater.168 These factors challenge the definition of safe levels of pesticide use. To minimise exceedance of high risks (i.e., a greater than 90% probability for a random species to be affected by pesticides), we propose a global reduction of 70% compared to current levels equa ng to a maximum applica on of 1 Tg of PAS yr-1 (Figure A2.4). A further reduction of more than 95% (max. application of 0.2 Tg PAS yr-1) is required to remain below “low” environmental risks (i.e., a less than 5% probability for a random species to be affected by pesticides).159,203 Ecological intensifica on prac ces can manage pest outbreaks without compromising crop yield, while enhancing biosphere ecosystem func onal integrity (Figure 5).217 However, some agricultural prac ces such as reduced soil disturbance can result in higher weed loads (Figure 5), highligh ng the importance of employing integrated complementary prac ces (Panel 5). An microbial use for food-animal produc on is es mated at 73–130 kilotons yr-1 169,218,219 and has increased an microbial resistance prevalence.66 Se ng a boundary for an microbial use is challenging due to the uncertain es in the environmental risks from increasing an microbial resistance.214 Based on WHO recommenda ons and available evidence on lowering average applica on rates while keeping effec ve produc on systems,219 we propose the complete hal ng of prophylac c an microbial use, and halving of exis ng average applica on rates from 2020 values of 50 to 25 mg kg-1 animal.159 Global shi s to flexitarian diets can reduce global an microbial use by around 42% compared to baseline values for 2050, whereas combining with moderate biosecurity measures could reduce global use by 49%.221 43 1121 1122 1123 1124 1125 1126 1127 1128 1129 1130 1131 1132 1133 1134 1135 1136 1137 1138 1139 1140 1141 1142 1143 1144 1145 1146 1147 1148 1149 expressed as the mean annual interhemispheric difference in the aerosol optical depth (AOD), 158 capturing the reduction in sunlight from air pollutants, such as nitrogen components (NH3, NOx and N2O), SO2, CO, organic compounds, and particulate matter (PM). Increased AOD affects regional rainfall patterns, and changes in the interhemispheric difference are associated with abrupt transitions in monsoon systems. Although the planetary boundary for atmospheric aerosol loading is not transgressed (Table 2), food systems are a prominent source of air pollutants (Figure A2.5), such as ammonia from fertiliser use and livestock production (37–47 Tg N yr-1, 86% of total NH3 emissions);167,223 airborne dust from human-driven land system change (e.g. desertification and land management practices); and primary PM2.5 emissions, i.e. aerosols’ diameter smaller than 2.5 micrometre (>28% of total primary PM2.5; emissions), mostly from burning for clearing vegetation.223 Dominant sources of emissions vary regionally and between hemispheres.224 In parts of the northern hemisphere, N-based emissions from livestock and fertiliser are the dominant source of aerosol-loading, accounting for >80% of NH3 emissions forming secondary PM2.5 particles, while in the southern hemisphere, biomass burning is the predominant source of trace-gas emissions and PM2.5 concentrations.224 Emissions from biomass burning (globally estimated to contribute 42 Tg yr-1 PM2.5),225 that can be attributed agriculture are uncertain, although some estimates suggest that 28% of the global direct PM2.5 emissions are food related (Table A2.1). Regionally, shares can be higher, particularly in countries in the southern hemisphere (i.e. biomass burning contributes 90% to PM2.5 in Angola).224 1150 Ocean Acidification 1151 1152 1153 1154 1155 1156 1157 1158 1159 1160 1161 Ocean acidification is linked to loss of marine species dependent on calcium carbonate, and changes to marine carbon storage. Acidification also aggravates impact of other biogeochemical changes (e.g. ocean warming and associated thermal heat stress) and therefore is considered a threat multiplier to marine life.228 Ocean acidification, measured through the change in the aragonite saturation state (Ω arag),158 is driven by atmospheric CO2 concentration (i.e. 25% of historical anthropogenic CO2 emissions are absorbed by the ocean229) and is therefore strongly related to the climate boundary. Although the ocean acidifica on planetary boundary is not transgressed (Table 2),158 it is moving rapidly into the zone of increasing risk following relatively constant CO2 emissions (total of 40.6 GtCO2 yr-1  of which food systems are responsible for nearly 25%.159,172 Remaining with the food system boundary for climate change and biosphere integrity can effec vely bring back CO2 emissions close to zero and allows us to remain within ocean acidifica on boundary. Remaining within aerosol boundaries requires emission reductions in both the northern and southern hemisphere. The boundary for nitrogen surplus (Sec on Biogeochemical Flows) suggests a reduction of NH3 emissions (>45% reduc on of current emissions, from 37 to 20 Tg N yr-1) is required, mostly in the northern hemisphere where N surplus (and associated NH3 emissions from manure and fertilizer167) is high (Figure 4c). Dietary shifts can reduce agricultural NH3 emissions with more than 50% in North America and Europe.226 In the southern hemisphere, biomass burning from land conversion and on agricultural lands should be eliminated in line with the Land System change and Climate change boundaries. However, it is uncertain how much reduced NH3 emissions and biomass burning can bring back total PM2.5 concentrations across hemispheres.159 44 1162 1163 Stratospheric ozone depletion 1164 1165 1166 1167 1168 1169 1170 1171 1172 1173 1174 1175 The planetary boundary for stratospheric ozone depletion limits the breakdown of ozone that protects life on Earth from harmful solar radiation. Coordinated global intervention phasing out production of ozone-depleting chlorofluorocarbons and halons (i.e. through the Montreal Protocol adoption in 1987) has restored the ozone layer.158 However, the most important ozone-depleting substance remaining is N2O, which is not regulated under the Montreal Protocol. Agriculture is the largest emitter of anthropogenic N2O (54–69% of total N2O emissions),230 but ozone depletion rates remain insignificant. Even without reductions in N2O emissions, stratospheric ozone levels are expected to recover by the end of this century.167 We therefore restate the nitrogen surplus boundary that respects local boundaries for biodiversity and water quality (Section Nitrogen and Phosphorus losses), and thereby reduces N2O emissions from reduced fertilizer and manure applications with 55% compared to current levels (from 3.9 to 1.8 Tg N yr-1).159,167 1176 Reducing the environmental footprint of food production 1177 1178 1179 1180 1181 1182 1183 1184 1185 1186 1187 1188 1189 1190 1191 1192 1193 1194 1195 1196 1197 1198 1199 1200 1201 1202 Sustainable and ecological intensifica on (SEI) practices offer considerable potential to mitigate planetary boundary transgressions without nega vely affec ng yields (Figure 5). Importantly, many practices offer simultaneous benefits across several boundaries. Soil organic carbon (SOC) accumula on can be enhanced with agricultural diversification practices that promote plant root-formation, microbial activity, and the return of organic matter to soils, thereby reducing HANPP, while uncertain es remain regarding the permanence of soil carbon pools which challenge estimates of this potential. 231,232 Agricultural diversification increases agroecosystem biodiversity, which can be specifically managed to assist in weed and pest abatement, or to reduce the prevalence of crop diseases and nutrient losses while maintaining or improving yields. Improved fer liser management enhances crop NUE, reduces nutrient losses, and contributes to SOC, although with higher variability for GHG emissions and yields. The effects of the prac ces (Figure 5) are not directly addi ve, since they were typically obtained from studies comparing a single prac ce against a controlled alterna ve. Prac ce effects vary depending on context-specific, biophysical factors such as clima c and soil condi ons, as well as the exact implementa on of the prac ce. Working farms typically implement mul ple prac ces simultaneously, and the evidence to date suggests synergies leading to enhanced environmental, as well as social, benefits.233 While the meta-analyses provide valuable informa on on the technical poten al at the fieldscale, es mates of the global poten al of selected SEI prac ce groups have also been explored in modelling studies such as, but not limited to those men oned in Panels 5-7. These modelling studies, using different methodologies, factor in addi onal constrains and moderators, such as our current understanding of applicable areas. When applied to all suitable areas globally and assuming maximum complementarity among measures, sets of SEI prac ces were found to provide a poten al increase in nitrogen use efficiency, from its average of 48%, to 78%,208 and a global carbon sequestra on poten al between 0.44 and 0.68 Gt C yr−1. When limita ons of applica on as well as current applica on levels were factored in, the carbon sequestra on poten al was es mated to be 0.28 to 0.43 Gt C yr–1,175 while the GHG mi ga on poten al of 4.4 Pg CO2e on average, was es mated to occur by 2050.234 Despite these 45 1203 1204 1205 1206 1207 1208 1209 1210 1211 1212 1213 1214 1215 limita ons, our synthesis shows substan al evidence that the evaluated, key groups of SEI prac ces can contribute to maintaining or improving yields while mi ga ng planetary boundary transgressions, based on the indicators considered (Figure 5; Table A2.5, Appendix 2B). The poten al global benefits of accelera ng adop on of ecologically intensive prac ces on cropland vary across boundaries, but in combina on with other food system prac ces enable significant impacts notably on climate and biosphere integrity boundaries (Panel 6). Figure 5: Sustainable and ecological intensification (SEI) practices’ relative contributions across field scale planetary boundary indicators (see Table A2.5, Appendix 2B), measured in percentage changes.208,235–241 Rows indicate practices (e.g. no tillage), organised into principles (e.g. reduced disturbance), and further into groups (e.g. agricultural diversification). The effect sizes represent the mean relative change when a practice is applied, in comparison to a conventional alternative, or absence of applying the prac ce. Positive effect sizes are desirable for 46 1216 1217 1218 1219 1220 1221 1222 1223 1224 1225 1226 1227 1228 1229 1230 1231 1232 1233 1234 1235 1236 1237 1238 1239 1240 1241 1242 1243 1244 1245 1246 1247 all indicators except greenhouse gas emissions (column e), where the desired effect is a reduction and hence negative. Sizes of the symbols represent the amount of experimental data used for calculating the effect size, as indicated in the legend. The error bars show the 95% confidence intervals (CI) for the mean effect sizes. When the CIs do not overlap with zero (dashed vertical line), the effect is considered statistically significant. Missing values indicate no evidence found. The horizontal axis, where the grid cell width corresponds to a 50% pts, is square-roottransformed. The data used for the figure is provided in Data S1. See also Appendix 2B for details on the planetary boundary indicators (Table A2.6) and the prac ce typology (Table A2.6). Integra ng livestock in food produc on systems, when respec ng local environmental capaci es, such as nutrient loads and grazing intensi es, can represent an SEI strategy that supports ecological processes in agricultural ecosystems (Panel 8).242 Livestock can play an integral role in the food web, such as nutrient and energy cycling, as well as promo ng biodiversity. Animals and crop produc on prac ces can be interlinked via feed produc on, for both terrestrial livestock and farmed fish, with synergies to be gained through e.g. cover-crop grazing,243 forage rota ons, or integra ng animals for weed or pest management.244 While grazing can increase SOC of grasslands, the evidence is variable, 237 but shows that grazing intensity has a significant effect, with less intensive systems enhancing SOC. 245 Some of the prac ces assessed here (Figure 5) include livestock-integration, namely silvopastoral systems, using manure as organic amendments, and rice-animal co-cultures. A comprehensive assessment of foods from aquatic systems is provided by the Blue Foods Assessment. 246 For wild fisheries, improved yields and environmental performance can be achieved by fishing within ecological limits, informed by scientific advice247,248 and using production methods that limit indirect impacts to ecosystems (e.g. habitat destruction and bycatch,249 including co-management of marine areas with local communities.250,251 In aquaculture, most environmental impacts are driven by feeds252 that emit GHG and use cropland,253 while aquatic farms impact local ecosystems through acidification, eutrophication, and disease risks for wild populations.254,255 These impacts can be limited through SEI practices that improve nutrient cycling and feed efficiencies. For mariculture, integrated multitrophic systems such as those growing bivalves and seaweeds near fish farms can increase yields, capture carbon, and reduce nutrient pollution.256 Targeted feed improvements through continued reductions in wild fish use,255 improved by-product utilisation,257 and higher conversion efficiencies of plant ingredients, can further help improve environmental performance of 'fed’ aquatic foods. 258 Panel 5: Conservation Agriculture, a combination of sustainable and ecological intensification practices with impact at scale Conservation agriculture (CA) is a well-establishedP50,P51 widely applicable and appliedP52 example of the complementarity of SEI practices, whereby reduced soil disturbance, continuous soil cover, and crop diversification form the basis of the system. In this integrated approach, reduced soil disturbance protects the soil from erosion and conserves moisture, continuous cover suppresses weeds, and crop diversification reduce pests and disease. Global models applying CA, which here consists solely of no llage, crop residues on field, and non-leguminous cover crops, on all agricultural lands resulted, es mate there will be an overall decrease in nitrogen leaching (-22%), and an increase in root-zone soil moisture (+15%) and SOC (+2%) by 2050, when compared to a land-use scenario without CA (averaging over two Integrated Assessment Models and five Global Change Models; Appendix 2B). Importantly, 47 other SEI practices can be combined with CA. When rainwater harvesting was combined with CA, global modelling results showed a minor added reduction (–2%) for nitrogen leaching and a small increase in root-zone soil moisture (+2%), but effectively no change for SOC. While field studies have shown that the exact outcomes of CA are context-specific, evidence shows that CA improves crop productivity, especially in dry climates and rainfed production systems, thus offering a climate-change adaptation strategy.P53,P54 In resource-poor and vulnerable smallholder farming systems, socioeconomic challenges in the appropriate adoption of CA need to be carefully considered. P54 1248 Panel 6: Initial estimates of environmental gains made through ecological intensification (EI) by the Food, Agriculture, Biodiversity, Land-use and Energy (FABLE) Calculator The FABLE Calculator is a demand-driven food and land use system model designed to explore the food, biodiversity, climate, water, and socioeconomics impacts of future development pathways. P55 It includes 88 agricultural products to model how demand for these products drives land use change and associated impacts on food and nutri on security, climate mi ga on, biodiversity, and socio-economic outcomes. The FABLE Calculator differen ates between types of agricultural prac ces used on cropland and can therefore be used to explore the impact of scaling ecological intensifica on prac ces. Here, ecological intensifica on (EI) represents crop and non-crop diversifica on, including intercropping, cover crops, crop rota ons, agroforestry, cul var mixtures, and embedding natural vegeta on into cropped landscapes. We modelled the effect of con nuing current trends (BAU pathway), compared to expanding EI prac ces across all cropland by 2050 in combina on with the EAT-Lancet (EL) popula on growth, economic growth, climate change, diet, produc vity, food loss and waste assump ons as described in the modelling sec on and Table A.4.3 (EL+EI pathway). The EL pathway represents a decomposi on scenario on the EL+EI pathway, where agricultural prac ces match BAU assump ons, allowing us to isolate the effects of EI. See Appendix 2 for further methodological details. Land for Agriculture (Bha) Cropland Use (Mha) GHG Emission (GtCO2e) Blue Water Use (M km3) Nitrogen Use (Tg N) Phosphorus Use (Tg P) None (16.08) Land Available for Biodiversity (%) 50% (50%) Boundary (Current State) BAU 4.80 (4.56) 5.00 (6.76) 2 .00 (4.63) 134 (234) 12 (29.4) 4.82 18.53 48% 7.35 5.37 306 35.9 EL 3.49 16.00 56% 2.75 4.52 214 35.4 EL+EI 3.46 15.69 56% -0.51 4.41 211 34.4 Panel Table: Environmental impacts of food and land use systems projected to 2050 under three future scenarios represen ng Business as Usual (BAU), EAT-Lancet assump ons (EL) and the addi on of ecological intensifica on prac ces to EL (EL+EI), compared to food system planetary boundaries (Table 2) and the current state (2020). 48 Cells are coloured according to whether results fall inside our proposed food system planetary boundaries: within boundary (green), close to boundary (orange), beyond boundary (red). FABLE model results show that under BAU, the food system boundaries for land, biodiversity, emissions, water and nutrient use are exceeded by 2050. Under an EL pathway, the food system stays within land, biodiversity, and emission boundaries. Increases in produc vity, dietary shi s, and reduced food loss and waste, reduce the land area needed for agricultural produc on which in turn drives the expansion of natural land available for biodiversity. Annual net GHG emissions would fall from 7.35 Gt CO2e in 2050 under BAU to 2.75 Gt CO2e under EL (~60% reduc on compared to 2020). This reduc on in GHG emissions is greater than those suggested by the economic model ensemble (median 20%), or DIA-GIO (32%) (Figure 10b), which may be explained by differences in how emissions are computed across models. GHG emission reduc ons in the FABLE EL pathway are driven by a decrease in emissions from agricultural produc on for both crops and livestock, and increased carbon sequestra on from avoided deforesta on and restora on of abandoned agricultural land to forest and other natural land (with higher rates of carbon sequestra on in living biomass and soil). Nitrogen use is reduced by 30% compared to BAU, while there are rela vely small reduc ons in water consump on and phosphorus use, yet nutrient and water use con nue to exceed food system boundaries. Combining EL with ecological intensifica on (EL+EI pathway) further reduces agricultural land area, water and nitrogen use, and substan ally reduces emissions to -0.51 Gt CO2e. Many of the EI prac ces that the FABLE Calculator are not used in many of the ensemble models. Emission reduc ons are driven by increased sequestra on on croplands (in soil) and, to a lesser extent, addi onal conversion of agricultural land to other uses due to enhanced produc vity for some commodi es. The FABLE model results suggest that significant effort in integra ng EI prac ces could contribute to achieving a net zeroemission food system. Es mates of the effect of the prac ces on soil organic carbon sequestra on are taken from global meta-analyses, and do not account for regional or local soil carbon satura on limits,P56 which mean the results should be interpreted with cau on. The most effec ve applica on of EI prac ces needs to be tailored to local contexts and should be coselected with local farmers and landscape stakeholders, integra ng local and scien fic knowledge. The complexity of implementa on at scale across mul ple domains, and local carbon sequestra on satura on points may limit both the speed of implementa on, and dura on of carbon sequestra on poten al of ecological intensifica on. 1249 1250 49 1251 Section 3: Justice in Food Systems 1252 1253 What is a Just Food System 1254 1255 1256 1257 1258 1259 1260 1261 1262 1263 1264 1265 1266 1267 1268 1269 1270 1271 1272 1273 1274 1275 1276 1277 1278 1279 1280 1281 1282 1283 1284 1285 1286 1287 1288 1289 1290 1291 Justice involves the ‘fair treatment’ of people, both individuals and groups. Although various ar cula ons of jus ce exist across disciplines and sectors (e.g., Philosophy, Economics, Sociology, and Law), here we draw on three interrelated dimensions of jus ce that feature prominently in the literature on social and environmental jus ce: namely, Distribu ve, Representa onal (or Procedural), and Recogni onal (Figure 6).259,260 Distributive justice involves the fair distribution of important resources, opportunities, or capabilities (healthy food, wages, clean, healthy, and sustainable environment) as well as the fair allocation of benefits and burdens.33 Representational justice concerns decision-making and power, including formal policymaking processes as well as broader societal decision-making processes.259,261 It requires fair processes and a fair distribu on of power, the protec on of key freedoms, and poli cal voice and representa on, including meaningful participation by those most affected by injus ce. Recognitional justice manifests in the structures and norms of society and recognises a diversity of intersecting identities and experiences, shaped by cultural, legal, historical and spatial contexts, and involves people from all social groups being able to participate as equals.259,261,262 Our analysis concerns how these three dimensions of jus ce play out both within and across socie es. For a society to be just, all people must experience distribu ve, representa onal and recogni onal jus ce, and for global and interna onal jus ce this must also exist among na ons and people throughout the world.261,263 Our analysis also encompasses both jus ce among people living at the same me (intragenera onal jus ce) and jus ce among people in different genera ons (inter-genera onal jus ce).33 For example, intergenera onal jus ce requires that there be distribu ve jus ce across genera ons, including a fair distribu on of benefits and burdens between current and future genera ons of people. Keeping food systems within planetary boundaries can help to ensure that in the future, people have a safe environment, and ensuring healthy diets are accessible to all, par cularly for women of childbearing age and young children, can help ensure the health of future genera ons. Jus ce of all these forms is central to our analysis and recommenda ons. Another form of jus ce, interspecies jus ce, concerns whether humans treat other species fairly.33 However, beyond recognising the need to transi on to within the planetary boundaries, including keeping the Earth within 1.5 degrees C of global warming, and the need to minimise biodiversity and environmental losses, we do not focus on interspecies jus ce in our jus ce analysis. Establishing what counts as ‘fair treatment’ for an analysis of jus ce, requires consensus,264 and in the absence of a global process relevant to food systems, we chose to align substan ally our account of ‘fair treatment’ with interna onal human rights trea es and other instruments (Figure 6).265,266 These human rights instruments represent a consensus view of what cons tutes minimum acceptable standards for specific resources (e.g., food) and opportuni es (e.g., work).265 We appeal to the content of recognized human rights to iden fy jus ce-based en tlements, and to specify, and quan fy minimum acceptable levels (Figure 7, Appendix 3, Table 3). Our account of jus ce within food systems can thus be seen as the minimum condi ons for what would cons tute jus ce. Recognising that all human rights are universal, 50 1292 1293 1294 1295 1296 1297 1298 1299 1300 1301 1302 1303 1304 1305 1306 1307 1308 1309 1310 1311 1312 1313 indivisible, interdependent, and interrelated, we focus on three rights closely related to food systems: the right to food, the right to a healthy environment, and the right to decent work. We also draw on interna onal human rights’ commitments to non-discrimina on, par cipa on, and civil and poli cal rights. Central to our account is agency, understood as people’s capacity to make choices that shape their own circumstances and to exercise voice through par cipa on in broader societal decision-making processes. Agency is recognized as an important contributor to food security, secure livelihoods and to addressing inequi es within food systems (Clapp et al., 2022) (Appendix 3). Justice thus requires that everyone everywhere, regardless of social identity, has their rights to food, a healthy environment, and decent work realized, and has poli cal voice and fair representa on. Achieving jus ce therefore requires recognizing the social systems and other condi ons that can promote jus ce, or, conversely, can func on as structural barriers to it. These include poli cal ins tu ons and economic systems, and the interplay between them, resul ng in different kinds of voice, power, and agency for government, businesses, formal and informal food producers and workers, civil society organiza ons, and the public; food, health, educa onal, and other social systems, which provide important resources and opportuni es; and other social structures and norms. People are unevenly impacted by these social systems, with some groups systema cally having fewer resources and opportuni es, and less voice, power, and agency, thus experiencing structural inequality that leaves them vulnerable and marginalised (Panel 7) Achieving jus ce may require fundamental transforma on of these poli cal systems. However, here our focus is that jus ce requires paying par cular a en on to these people and addressing their specific needs.262 51 1314 1315 1316 1317 1318 1319 Figure 6. Conceptual framework of the jus ce sec on. The three jus ce dimensions and three human rights are interrelated and interdependent. Achieving the three jus ce dimensions of distribu ve, recogni onal, and representa onal jus ce requires mee ng the human rights. Panel 7: Recogni onal Injus ces: The need for a en on to gender and intersec onality Different groups of people – women, men, and children – of different wealth and social groups, age and stage in the life cycle, of different ethnici es, and from different geographic loca ons have different livelihood opportuni es and o en have differen al nutri onal needs. They also have differing levels of choice in terms of how far they can access and afford healthy diets and decent work. Not paying a en on to these group differences can lead to significant harm, not only for the individuals concerned, but for humanity more broadly by losing contextual knowledge and prac ces (e.g., Indigenous farming prac ces). Ethnic minori es and Indigenous peoples are o en at the greatest risk of losing their livelihoods and access to healthy and culturally important food, processes that start with a loss of access to land or natural resources (e.g., forests) through unjust conserva on or extrac on policies (e.g., exclusion from management),P57 or the lack of protec on policies. Many of these marginalised groups, including women, and par cularly women from minority groups, also face significant structural barriers and discrimina on, rooted in colonialism, racism, and patriarchy leading to lower access to technology, 52 training and underrepresenta on in poli cal and managerial posi ons,P58,P59 making it difficult for them to build decent and resilient livelihoods. People living in countries with conflict are especially marginalised in numerous ways. Hunger and starva on have o en been used as poli cal weapons of war, and con nue to be used as such today, through inten onal destruc on of food systems, especially agricultural lands (e.g., Sudan, Ukraine and Pales ne), withholding/restric ng food aid (e.g., Yemen and Pales ne), and unilateral coercive measures (e.g., Sudan, Venezuela and Syria). The impact of these conflicts spread across the whole food system, affec ng the availability and price of food and other resources (e.g., fer lizer), regionally and globally, though par cularly amongst the rural and those in poverty.P60 Thus, conflicts and war lead to further marginalisa on and directly or indirectly cause hunger, food insecurity, and famines undermining the right to food for all,P61 with worse effects on people in poverty, minority groups, women, and children. These characteris cs are not exhaus ve as marginalisa on can manifest differently across and within regions/countries. Furthermore, the opportuni es people have access to o en differ based on the intersec on of key characteris cs, such as wealth or poverty with gender, geographic loca on, age, and ethnicity. For example, in middle-income countries (MIC) women tend to be more food-insecure than men (Appendix 3, Figure A3.1). Yet, women appear to have greater dietary quality than men, especially in higher income countries (Appendix 3, Figure A3.1). Meanwhile poverty is increasingly urbanising at a global scale, with the urban poor lacking access to healthy food, pa erns that emerge in part due to a changing climate and the migra on of the rural poor to urban areas.P62 An intersec onal lens (i.e. paying a en on to mul ple injus ces and aspects of iden ty that intersect to exacerbate the experience of marginalisa on) is therefore key to iden fying the specific vulnerabili es affec ng marginalised people.P63 This requires sufficient levels of data disaggrega on across contexts, as well as recogni on of alterna ve knowledge systems, especially Indigenous knowledge.P64 Yet, data remains skewed towards par cular social groups and geographic regions. For example, evidence from Canada and the US suggests that migrant workers face poor and dangerous working condi ons and food insecurity, but literature on migrant workers in other regions, especially LMICs, is limited.P65 Similarly, some geographies, such as the Middle East, are persistently underrepresented in English published literature. 1320 1321 Social Foundations 1322 1323 1324 1325 1326 1327 1328 We opera onalise our jus ce analysis through the lens of social founda ons which require basic human rights, such as food, water, health, and energy, to be met for everyone. 267,268 Previous work has focused on defining the minimum resources required to meet people's human rights, to avoid resource depriva ons and harms.33,268 However, the availability of resources alone is insufficient to avoid these harms.269 Therefore, we instead focus on the condi ons that enable people’s human rights to be met. We specify condi ons (i.e., social founda ons) that would help enable each of the three rights (food, decent work, healthy environment) to be realized (Table 3). Through a combina on of expert consulta on and a 53 1329 1330 1331 1332 1333 1334 1335 1336 1337 1338 1339 1340 review of the literature, we first iden fy the individual and cross-cu ng food system components relevant to each human right. Next, and drawing on the outcomes from a recently completed mul -stage, mul stakeholder evalua on of food systems indicators,29 we iden fy a suite of candidate indicators for each component and screen for coverage, scale, relevance, and overlap. Where indicators for key food system components were not available (e.g., individual and collec ve agency) we reviewed the literature to propose addi onal indicators for development and monitoring.270 The final selec on included a limited set of indicators that conveyed discrete dimensions of the condi ons that enable people’s rights to be met, rather than outcomes of these rights being (un)met, which act as our proxy variables. (Appendix 3). For each proxy variable, we specify the level at which the social founda on would be considered met, es mate the number of people falling below each social founda on globally, and examine the extent of harms associated with each of the three human rights not being realized (Table 3, Figure A3). 1341 1342 1343 1344 1345 Figure 7a-f: The global status of social foundations in food systems. Each panel visualizes one of six (out of 8), proxy variables and its corresponding social foundation (Table 3). Maps show the global distribution of values, with places that fall below the social foundation in brown, and those where the social foundation is intact in green (white indicates no data available). Histograms on the colour legends indicate the total number of people that fall below 54 1346 1347 1348 1349 1350 1351 1352 1353 1354 each social foundation. Variables are: a) cost of a healthy diet (CoHD) (foundation: healthy diet cost <52% of national average income); b) consumption of SSB (foundation: consumption added or free sugar <10% of total energy intake); c) nitrogen leaching into groundwater (foundation: exceedance of WHO safe limit for drinking water = 0); d) changes in the suitability of the human environmental niche, between current conditions and RCP8.5 in 2070 (foundation: heat exposure, ≤29C Mean Annual Temperature, MAT); e) agricultural wages relative to a living wage (foundation: wages > 67% or 55% of median incomes in each country); f) access to collective bargaining (foundation: Employees covered > 75% of workforce). Data sources and variable definitions are described in Table 3, Appendix 3A, and Table A3.1. Data were unavailable for countries in white, except for nitrogen exceedance (c), where white values indicate non-agricultural lands. 1355 1356 1357 55 1358 1359 1360 1361 Table 3: Human rights, social founda ons, and the proxy variables that allow conditions to be tracked. For each variable we specify the level at which the social foundation could be met. Falling below these social foundations results in a range of specified harms. We estimate globally, the number of people currently falling below these social foundations and the extent of social harms. Human Rights Social foundation Proxy variables People below foundation Social harms Extent of harm Harms Figures Moderate or severe food Insecurity 2.3 billion people (29%)1 Affordable Healthy 2.8 billion people 19.8 million Low Birthweight Diets Cost of Healthy globally cannot newborns (15%)1 (CoHD <52% average Diet (CoHD) afford a healthy Unsafe drinking 2.1 billion people income) diet water (27%)1 269 million children2 Anaemia in children Right to food (40%) Fig A3.1 5.6 billion people Diets high in SSB 75,725 deaths Healthy Food globally live in 3.6 million DALYs Environment Intake of Sugar countries with a Unhealthy diets (National intake of sugar Sweetened national average from SSB at <10% of Beverages (SSB) intake of sugar >1billion people Obesity total energy intake) >10% of total (16%)1 energy intake Non-toxic 5 billion people Disability adjusted Environments Nitrogen leaching exposed to life years (DALYs) 42 million DALYs (N leaching < 50mg from Agriculture unclean water from unsafe water Right to a nitrate/L) above WHO limit source healthy Fig A3.2 Safe Climate 419 million people environment Mean Annual will be exposed to DALYs from high (Temp ≤29C, Mean Temperature 14 million DALYs ≥29C MAT by temperatures Annual Temperature (MAT) change 2070 (MAT)) A Living Wage3 394 million (32%) Food system worker FSW wages FSW earn below a Child labour (FSW) wages > living living wage 159 million children Right to decent wage Fig A3.3 work 2.6 billion people Meaningful 50% Collec ve Gender wage gap w/o access to representa on bargaining collective coverage (coverage >72%) bargaining Market share held Freedom from Higher food prices, by the top four corporate control suppressed wages, firms in the sector (CR4 <40%) (CR4) weakened livelihood opportunities, Cu ng across all Civil and political Freedom of rights (Individual Not determined Clapp et al 2025 Fig A3.4 undermining freedoms Expression Index and Collec ve working conditions, Agency) lobbying, weakened Social ins tu ons representation Non-Discrimination and Gender Index Percentage of global population Children aged 6-59 months 3 Living wage is defined as being > 67% median wage in developing countries and 55% in developed (ILO 2020) 1 2 1362 1363 56 1364 Evaluating Injustices 1365 1366 1367 1368 1369 1370 1371 1372 1373 1374 1375 1376 1377 1378 1379 1380 1381 1382 1383 1384 1385 1386 1387 1388 1389 1390 1391 1392 1393 1394 1395 1396 1397 1398 1399 1400 1401 1402 1403 1404 The Right to Food The right to food involves the right to a secure and stable supply of sufficient quan es of affordable, healthy, culturally appropriate and sustainably produced food that considers peoples’ prac ces and customs, to ensure all forms of malnutri on can be avoided, and a dignified life supported.271,272 The right to food has been interpreted not only as a right to have access to sufficient food to enable a healthy diet but also as placing responsibili es on states to promote good nutri on and health, for example through regula ng food adver sing, labelling requirements and other measures that shape food environments to encourage healthier diets.271,273 We thus iden fy two social founda ons linked to the right to food, namely healthy affordable diets and food environments that do not undermine people’s capaci es to make healthy choices, which we refer to as “healthy food environments.” Healthy diets are considered, by the FAO, to be affordable when they cost less than 52% of average household income.274 We therefore align our minimum condi on/social founda on for affordable healthy diets with the FAO’s defini on of an affordable healthy diet (Table 3). In 2022, 2.8 billion people globally were below the social founda on of an affordable healthy diet. This causes diet-related harms that extend beyond their immediate impacts to damage economies and increase risk of conflict and disease. Indeed, in the same year 2.3 billion people were food insecure and 1.8 billion had no access to clean waterstrongly linked condi ons to poor food safety and nutrient absorp on (Table 3, Figure 7). The extent to which regions fall below these foundations, and the severity of the associated harms, differ across geography and social group (i.e., ethnicity, gender, and wealth). While the rapid globalisa on of the food system through trade and subsidies has made more food available globally and brought food prices down, it has also suppressed wages and the prices producers receive, leaving healthy diets least affordable in Low-Income Countries (LIC) and Lower Middle-Income Countries (LMIC), where food insecurity, low-birth weights, and anaemia are also most prevalent (Figure 7, Figure A3.1). It is also these contexts where most food system workers live, leaving them o en least able to afford a healthy diet. Although jus ce requires that healthy food becomes more affordable and available, this will not necessarily result in healthier diets.4,275 As economies develop and family incomes grow, healthy diets become more affordable but ultra-processed foods, animal-sourced red meats, and sugar sweetened beverages also become more available and exposure to unhealthy food adver sing increases.275–277 As a result, diet quality globally is lowest in Upper Middle-Income Countries (UMIC) and High-Income Countries (HIC), par cularly among men, while rates of overweight and obesity are highest in these same regions, par cularly among women (Figure A3.1). Furthermore, while healthy diets are more affordable in HIC, they remain unaffordable or inaccessible to many people, resul ng in lower diet quality and higher obesity rates for those on low incomes.278,279 In contrast, in UMIC such as places in La n America, higher income groups, despite being food secure, have a poorer diet quality than low-income groups, likely due to the hyper-availability of unhealthy foods.280 Rapidly changing food environments and unequal access to housing, water, health and market services mean LMIC and UMIC, par cularly in urban and peri-urban 57 1405 1406 1407 1408 1409 1410 1411 1412 1413 1414 1415 1416 1417 1418 1419 1420 1421 1422 1423 1424 1425 1426 1427 1428 1429 1430 1431 1432 1433 1434 1435 1436 1437 1438 1439 1440 1441 1442 1443 1444 1445 1446 areas, are now epicentres of mul ple forms of malnutri on and associated outcomes (Figure A3.1).4,281 These regions are also where most of the global popula on currently lives, and where most future popula on growth will occur, underscoring the cri cal global importance of healthy diets being available and affordable, in a food environment that is conducive to healthy choices. 25 Food environments are the physical, economic, political, socio-cultural and digital contexts in which consumers engage with the food system to make decisions about acquiring, preparing and consuming food.282 Food environments and food choices are increasingly shaped by adver sing and commercial marke ng, thus expenditure on marke ng of unhealthy food would be an apt proxy variable for healthy food environments. However, global data on this exposure is lacking. As an alterna ve proxy indicator for an unhealthy food environment, we use intake of sugar from sugar sweetened beverages (SSB), which is associated with cardiometabolic disease and social inequities.283 We align our minimum condition for a healthy food environment with the WHO’s recommenda on of less than 10% of total energy intake from free or added sugars (ideally reduced to less than 5%, as used in the PHD).108 In 2018, 5.6 billion people globally, were below the minimum condi on/social founda on of a healthy food environment, with their intake of free or added sugar exceeding this level. These pa erns are associated with over 75,000 early deaths, 2.5 billion adults, and 360 million children and adolescents who are overweight or living with obesity (Table 7, A3). Food environments determine food choices in a range of ways depending on context, and considering the affordability, availability, accessibility or convenience, and desirability of foods in the food environment, especially for healthy food versus unhealthy food.284 Thus, while higher incomes can promote greater diet diversity, the type of food environment can weaken or strengthen this rela onship.284 In the face of rising corporate concentra on and marke ng of unhealthy food, territorial and local markets, with a focus on small-scale and informal actors, are seen to have the poten al not just to revitalise and stabilise local produc on but also enhance healthy consump on choices for poor people.281 This becomes cri cally important where rapid urbanisa on is changing food environments in UMIC and LMIC, crea ng food voids (environments ‘lacking in food’), food deserts (areas where sufficient healthy food is inaccessible)282 and food swamps (areas where unhealthy, usually ultra-processed, foods285 are abundantly available, accessible, and affordable),282 earlier seen only in HIC (HLPE Report 19). In each of these cases, people are at higher risk of food insecurity, micronutrient deficiencies, overweight/obesity, and NCDs, 281,282,286,287 but for different reasons. Low diet quality could be due to lack of availability, accessibility, and/or affordability of healthy foods, or because unhealthy foods are abundantly available, affordable, and convenient.282 Changes in food environments have also accompanied changes in food cultures. The shift to unhealthy diets is characterised by a loss of traditional foods and food deskilling – a loss of cooking skills and knowledge.275,288 Changes in food cultures can be explained by several factors. First, time poverty has increased especially for families due to greater women’s participation (who largely remain in charge of food provisioning despite improvements in gender equality) in the labour force and generally low food involvement of fathers.289,290 Second, the loss of local biodiversity, notably cultivated and foraged species, and resource access have impacted healthy food provision in some regions, especially amongst Indigenous communities.291 Children are especially susceptible to unhealthy food advertising, leading to unhealthy 58 1447 1448 1449 1450 food habits, which can persist to adulthood. Shifts to unhealthy diets can involve moving food culture away from traditional foods, including family meals. These changes have implications for diets and health, but equally for the acquisition of food knowledge and skills, especially for children. 293 1451 1452 1453 1454 1455 1456 1457 1458 1459 1460 1461 1462 1463 1464 1465 1466 1467 1468 1469 1470 1471 1472 1473 1474 1475 1476 1477 1478 1479 1480 1481 1482 1483 1484 1485 1486 1487 The Right to a Healthy Environment The right to a healthy environment rests on the recogni on that realizing the right to food and many other rights requires having a clean, healthy and sustainable environment. This right is understood as encompassing several substan ve rights, including to a safe climate and non-toxic environment, which we adopt as two social founda ons of this right.294 Climate conditions habitable for humans have been broadly characterised as land with a mean annual temperature of ≤ 29 C°, 297,298 and we use this as our minimum condition for a safe climate. By 2070, 419 million people globally will fall below the social founda on of a safe climate, and already in 202233 high temperatures accounted for the loss of 14 million DALYs6 (Figure 7, Table 3, Figure A3.2). Climate impacts are and will continue to be experienced inequitably, intersecting with poverty and geography to disproportionately impact certain peoples and regions. Despite being the least responsible, climate change will exacerbate experiences of food insecurity for many LICs across Africa and for people living in poverty.299,300 Meanwhile, women, particularly in rural areas, LMICs and Indigenous communities, and agricultural producers and workers are more likely to have their livelihoods undermined by climate change, and experience physical injury and ill-health. 296,301–303 More generally, within food systems, women, children, Indigenous and rural communi es, and those in poverty, because of their marginaliza on, are most impacted by unsafe and unhealthy environments,295,296 underscoring the importance of human rights for all. A wide range of food system pollutants exist that create toxic environments and have nega ve human health effects (Panel 3).33 We focus on only nitrogen leaching to groundwater, 75% of which comes from agriculture,33 due to data availability. Nitrogen pollution is connected to adverse reproductive effects, and cancer in humans.33,167 WHO guidelines specify a safe level of nitrogen for drinking water as 50 mg NO3−/litre,304 thus defining our minimum condition for healthy environments. In 2022, 5 billion people globally fell below this social founda on and were exposed to unsafe levels of nitrogen leaching, which was associated with the loss of 42 billion DALYs (Figure 7, Table 3, Figure A3.2) and 4 million new cases of paediatric cancer a year.6,33,167,304 As with the right to food, these harms are not distributed equally with rural dwellers most likely to be affected by agricultural pollution305,306 and with the poorest regions of the world particularly across Africa, South Asia, and China experiencing the greatest number of DALYs due to unsafe water, with as few as 10% of rural populations having access to clean water (Figure A3.2). The Right to Decent Work The right to decent work15,307 entails the right of everyone to live in dignity,13,307,308 to work in just and favourable condi ons, to be free to choose their work with a salary that allows them to live and support a family, and to receive equal pay. We iden fy two social founda ons linked to the right to decent work, namely a living wage and meaningful representa on. A living wage conveys the minimum level of renumera on necessary to support an acceptable standard of living for the worker and their family. 307,308 Although not always put into effect, a legal minimum wage has been set in 90% of the 187 ILO countries. 59 1488 1489 1490 1491 1492 1493 1494 1495 1496 1497 1498 1499 1500 1501 1502 1503 1504 1505 1506 1507 1508 1509 1510 1511 1512 1513 1514 1515 1516 1517 1518 1519 1520 1521 1522 1523 1524 1525 1526 1527 1528 1529 It equates to an average of 67% of the median wage in developing and 55% in developed na ons,13 which we use as the social founda on of a living wage. In 2022, an es mated 34% of the food system workforce, including agricultural (agriculture, forestry, fishing) and non-agricultural, formal and informal workers, was below the social founda on of a living wage, women earned 50% of what men did, and 159 million children were involved in child labour, predominantly in agriculture (Table 3, Figure 7, Figure A3.3).309,310 However, trade-offs exist and policies must balance the compe ng need of ensuring healthy food is affordable while providing adequate and liveable renumera ons (Sec on 5). Women’s work in agriculture remains undervalued and often seen as an extension of domestic chores. 311 Women are often paid by the piece instead of hourly rates like men, and their wages are sometimes given to male relatives, limiting their economic independence.312 If gendered wage gaps in agricultural labour remain unaddressed, condi ons will likely worsen because of the ongoing “feminisation of agriculture” in all regions other than HICs.313 This is due to men leaving for non-farm work in sectors such as construction to obtain more stable and lucrative livelihoods, infla ng the presence of women in a low-paid sector.314 Furthermore, sexual harassment due to power imbalances between female farmworkers and employers remains pervasive (for example, studies have reported incidences of 24-93% in the US), with few opportunities for reporting due to stigma and risk of retaliation.312 However, food system injustices are not limited to women as male migrant farm workers, for example in the US, also face abuse and exploitation.312 Jus ce and the right to decent work require living wages for all food systems workers, regardless of gender and other forms of marginalisa on. Collec ve bargaining is one way to enable the meaningful representa on of both workers and employers and ensure opportuni es to regulate the condi ons of work are present.316 The right to collec ve bargaining is a fundamental ILO conven on (No 98)317 and an enabling right that paves the way for inclusive and effec ve governance of work, ensuring decent wages and working condi ons, and social protec on.316 Collec ve bargaining coverage varies considerably around the world, but when present facilitates equality, contributes to safe and healthy work places, and builds resilience. We set our social founda on for meaningful par cipa on at a collec ve bargaining coverage rate of 72% of employees, which although below the EU’s threshold of 80%, 318 is equivalent to that found by the ILO in mul employer se ngs, that tend to be more successful. Between 2008-2020, 2.6 billion people globally were below the social founda on of meaningful representa on, with no access to collec ve bargaining (Figure 7, Table 3).319 Collective bargaining is highest in HICs, reaching close to 100% in some countries (e.g., Italy, France), but low in LMICs, where it ranges from 0%-40% and can be close to 1% (e.g., in Malaysia and Paraguay). 316 The majority (69%) of the approximately 1.02 billion people employed in food systems (Figure A3.3),320 who support an es mated 3.8 billion people,310 are found in LMICs (i.e., Asia or Africa). Most of these jobs are informal, seasonal, unregulated, and unmonitored, with workers living in poverty, reflec ng the low levels of representa on. Average agricultural wages are near or below na onal minimum wages (Figure A3.3),13 leaving food system workers likely one of the groups least able to afford a healthy diet. Yet, in these contexts, agricultural livelihoods account for over 50% of employment (Figure A3.3) underscoring the considerable and cascading importance of meaningful representa on for these workers. 60 1530 1531 1532 1533 1534 1535 1536 1537 1538 1539 1540 1541 1542 1543 1544 1545 1546 1547 1548 1549 1550 1551 1552 1553 1554 1555 1556 1557 1558 1559 1560 1561 1562 1563 1564 1565 1566 1567 1568 1569 1570 1571 Despite generally high levels of collective bargaining in HIC, recent shifts in food systems towards more concentrated systems and specialized units of production (e.g., intensive production of a single crop or species with high technological inputs such as salmon or chicken) has undermined worker participation resulting in poor labour standards and animal welfare.315 This is partly due to informal contracts being the norm among small and medium enterprises in LMICs and some HICs.321,322 There is evidence that informal enterprises are highly organized and streamlined, yet the labour conditions can be exploitative, including exploitation of child labour.323,324 Forced labour is prevalent on land and at sea, not only in LMICs but also in some HIC, including the US food supply chain.325 Therefore, a just food system would include food systems workers (especially smallholders) earning a living wage, with access to collective bargaining and the ability to advocate for their rights and working conditions. Individual and Collec ve Agency Agency, people’s capacity to make choices that shape their own circumstances and to par cipate in broader societal decision-making processes, has been recognized as an important contributor to food security and nutri on, secure livelihoods, decent work, healthy environments, and to addressing wider inequi es within food systems. Meanwhile, ample evidence exists on how people’s freedoms and agency are curtailed within current food systems.296,326,327 We thus recognise individual and collec ve agency as not just important in themselves, but specific forms of agency are also, arguably, guaranteed by human rights. Human rights emphasise the importance of rightsholders par cipa ng in decisions that affect them, and human rights trea es and other instruments include many rights guaranteeing civil and poli cal freedoms, and specific forms of choice or control for individuals and groups. Human rights is commi ed to elimina ng discrimina on. Taken together, these components of human rights embody a broad commitment to individual and collec ve agency. Recognising that it is not possible to fully quan fy agency, and that it remains challenging to iden fy proxy variables that capture agency in this capacious sense, we propose three social founda ons and related proxy variables that capture three facets of agency: non-discrimina on, freedom from corporate control, and freedom of voice and expression.270,328– 330 Non-Discrimina on People’s agency – their capacity to make choices and par cipate in decision-making -- can be constrained by structural inequali es shaped by social posi on and iden ty, par cularly class and gender. Ensuring that all people have agency thus requires addressing discrimina on in all its forms, including inequali es in access to key resources and services, unjust power differen als between different groups and inten onal discrimina on. As a proxy variable for non-discrimina on, we use the Social Ins tu ons and Gender Index which measures discrimina on against women, though this indicator is par al given the presence of discrimina on against many dis nct groups. Discrimina on against women is prevalent globally, although highest in South Asia, the Middle East & North Africa, and across many parts of sub-Saharan Africa (Figure A3.4). In no country in the world are women afforded the same opportunities as men that allow them equal representation in government or in the workforce more broadly, undermining their access to decent work and healthy food. 331 Agency is 61 1572 1573 1574 1575 1576 1577 1578 1579 1580 1581 1582 1583 1584 1585 1586 1587 1588 1589 1590 1591 1592 1593 1594 1595 1596 1597 1598 1599 1600 1601 1602 1603 1604 1605 1606 1607 1608 1609 1610 1611 1612 1613 therefore about inequality and choice; what ma ers is the “inequali es in people’s capacity to make choices rather than in differences in the choices themselves”.270,296,326–328 Freedom from corporate control Highly concentrated market structures, where just a few firms dominate key steps along food supply chains,332 can signal power imbalances where dominant firms, due to weakened compe on, can exercise market power that enables them to generate excess profits14,333,334 The exercise of market power by large firms can in turn undermine the agency within food systems, especially for the most marginalized people. Most economists consider that the likelihood of firms exercising market power increases where the top four firms control over 40% of the market.334 Although other metrics are also o en used, due to data limita on we focus on CR4, for which data is more available, and specify 40% as our minimum social founda on for freedom from corporate control, CR4 above 40% would indicate people’s agency is at risk of being curtailed and thus requires further inves ga on (Table 3). Strong evidence has shown a very high degree of corporate concentra on all along food supply chains, with just a few large firms domina ng interna onal markets for agricultural inputs (seeds and fer lisers), agricultural commodity trade (soybean, poultry), certain processed and packaged foods (biscuits, confec onary, so drinks) and na onal markets for food retail.14 Evidence suggests that access to market power is extensive in food systems, allowing dominant firms to set prices and generate excess profits. 14,17 Concentrated firms’ capacity to raise prices for seeds, fer lizer, grain, or packaged foods, has an impact on people’s access to food, influencing which foods they can and cannot consume. Dominant firms that source from smaller scale food producers have a degree of ‘buyer power’, meaning they can dictate the prices they are willing to pay to producers and other suppliers, such as workers, thus directly impac ng suppliers’ incomes and ability to access food.17 Large firms and concentrated commercial ac vity also shape broader condi ons within food systems through business decisions. Corporate strategies to increase the level of processing of packaged convenience foods, for example, have widespread impacts on both food produc on and consump on environments, and can encourage people to eat less healthy foods because of limited product choices and manipula ve adver sing and packaging.17,335 Business decisions of dominant firms have a dispropor onate effect on agricultural produc on technologies, labour condi ons for food systems workers, including in some cases forced labour,336 and environmental prac ces,337 which directly impact producers’ and consumers’ op ons. Large and dominant firms in concentrated markets can influence policy and governance processes in ways that influence democra c par cipa on in food systems governance, which can directly undermine agency.14 This influence is through direct lobbying as well as indirect means including sponsorship of research and revolving door appointments between industry and government, influencing measures such as dietary guidelines and regula ons within food systems,338,339 o en crowding out ci zen voices in the policy process. Measuring the impact of corporate power on human agency in food systems is not straigh orward, in large part because well-established metrics for agency do not exist, 330 and firms’ market share data and other indicators like firms’ marginal profits and markups (the amount firms charge over and above their 62 1614 1615 1616 1617 1618 1619 1620 1621 1622 1623 1624 1625 1626 1627 1628 1629 1630 1631 1632 1633 1634 1635 1636 1637 1638 1639 1640 1641 1642 1643 1644 1645 1646 1647 1648 1649 1650 1651 1652 1653 1654 1655 costs) are not always publicly available. Corporate concentra on (as measured by CR4) and profit data can usefully serve as proxy indicators to iden fy where corporate power may exist within food systems. However, food systems market data, at both global and na onal scales is o en unavailable or behind prohibi ve paywalls presen ng challenges for assessment of these dynamics. We therefore underscore the need for companies to make profit and markup data available, enabling the tracking of an indicator of market power. Although this approach would benefit from more transparent data repor ng from firms, these indicators highlight markets where dominant firms are more likely to influence food systems in ways that can constrain people’s agency. Stronger policies are needed at the na onal and interna onal levels to prevent corporate concentra on from subver ng agency through market and other forms of power available to large and dominant firms. More robust compe on policies, for example, can help in preven ng excessive market power and ensure prices remain fair for both buyers and sellers.17,340 Freedom of expression and par cipa on in decision-making We focus on freedom of expression as an important facet of individual and collec ve agency, because it allows ci zens and governments to be be er informed, enables civil society to hold corpora ons to account, and helps to sustain a range of other human rights 16 However, in many parts of the world, most notably in parts of the Middle East, North Africa, Eastern Europe, and Asia, freedom of expression is significantly curtailed, which in turn undermines agency (Figure A3.4). Although indicators can never fully capture complex concepts, as policies and laws are mediated by social context, the V-Dem freedom of expression index captures the extent to which a government respects freedom of press and media, freedom of people to discuss poli cal ma ers at home or in public, as well as the freedom of academic and cultural expression. Countries with laws upholding the freedom of expression, may curtail freedom in prac ce and vice versa, we nevertheless draw on this as a preliminary indicator in the absence of more nuanced data. When people have agency to par cipate in food systems governance and decision-making in meaningful ways, they can shape their food systems to make them more just. Mul ple possibili es for civil society and ci zen engagement exist in democracies, including on ma ers related to food systems, such as elec ons, public debates, and consulta ons on keys laws and policies.4 However, where these opportuni es to engage are lacking due to discrimina on, exclusion or in many cases, lack of freedom of expression (table 3), people are more likely to be marginalised and exposed to harm, and may take ac on through protests or other forms of movements.15 With the growing concentration of power - financial, technological, economic, and political – across many food systems, citizen agency is increasingly claimed or manifested through diverse forms of food activism. These forms of food ac vism span rights-based movements for justice, reactive street protests, alternative food systems governance structures, initiatives safeguarding the quality and cultural significance of food, and other modes of individual and collective advocacy.341 Movements for food jus ce and protests o en involve marginalised groups – farmers, women, Indigenous and rural peoples – and are mo vated by concerns about food and nutri on security, prices and affordability, and livelihoods, and seek the 63 1656 1657 1658 1659 1660 1661 1662 1663 1664 1665 1666 1667 1668 1669 1670 1671 1672 1673 1674 implementa on of the basic right to food. At mes however, as in Europe more recently, farmers’ protests, though challenging the growing concentra on of power within the food system, may go against more ambi ous state policies to address climate change or food systems transforma ons.342 Nevertheless ci zens’ freedom of expression and other aspects of agency remain central to addressing structural inequali es and discrimina on within the food system.341,343 1675 A Safe and Just Space 1676 1677 1678 1679 1680 1681 1682 1683 1684 1685 1686 1687 A just transforma on should look to keep everyone within a safe and just space, below the boundary that provides planetary stability, and above the founda on that supports jus ce (shown in green in Figure 8). However, the social harms associated with falling below the social founda ons defined here are not evenly distributed, leaving far too many people with unmet human rights (to the le of the dashed ver cal line in Figure 8). Meanwhile, people are not equally responsible for the extent to which the food system boundaries are already transgressed; far too many people’s dietary habits, if adopted globally, would cause the global food system to exceed the planetary boundaries (e.g. dietary pa erns of countries that lie above the dashed horizontal line in Figure 8). Moving the global population to a safe and just space requires everyone to take reasonable responsibility for keeping the food systems within planetary boundaries, by minimising the pressures they exert on the planet and suppor ng efforts to ensure the benefits from food systems are distributed fairly and everyone's human rights are met (Figure 8). 1688 1689 1690 1691 1692 1693 1694 1695 Decisions regarding what constitutes ‘reasonable responsibility’ for keeping the food systems within planetary boundaries involve considerations of fair allocation. These decisions should be reached through deliberative processes that take current capabilities and past responsibilities into account, including where lasting legacies (e.g. colonial histories) continue to produce unjust outcomes for many marginalised communities. These processes can draw on existing principles and mechanisms that support equitable burden-sharing in international processes and negotiations (e.g. climate change and trade), such as common but differentiated responsibilities and differentiated capabilities.344 The nature of state response to ci zen agency varies, ranging from neglect or repression to concessions and even policy change, and widespread ci zen consulta on in processes of decision-making cannot be taken for granted.341 States appear responsive to movements for food justice, o en to avoid poli cal conflict or public cri que, though at mes also driven by the global push for sustainability.342 Different forms of ci zen agency and their associated state responses give voice to diverse groups of stakeholders affected by food system changes and are key to representa onal jus ce.341 In sum, agency is a social founda on for the rights to food, decent work and a healthy environment, and is independently important from a jus ce perspec ve. Freedom of expression and other civil and poli cal freedoms support agency within food systems, while corporate concentra on and discrimina on undermine it. When people lack agency, they may assert it with protests and other forms of ac vism. For all these reasons, it is important to try and characterize, quan fy and track agency. 64 1696 1697 1698 1699 1700 1701 1702 1703 1704 1705 1706 1707 1708 1709 1710 1711 1712 1713 1714 1715 1716 1717 1718 1719 1720 1721 1722 Here, we apply the simplest principle as a star ng point, which assumes an equal share of the planetary boundaries but makes no accommodation for differentiated capabilities or needs (e.g. more efficient technologies).344 For each country, and for five planetary boundaries where combined data is available (GHG emissions, land use, water use, nitrogen, phosphorus), we calculate if and how the food systems share of the planetary boundary values would be exceeded if the dietary consumption patterns of that one nation were to be adopted globally. We contrasted this with es mates of a country’s distance from three social founda ons, which had the most comprehensive data (diet affordability, agricultural wages, and nitrogen leaching) (Appendix 3). We used Kobe plots to visualize associations between the social foundations and planetary boundaries. On average 3.7 billion people, predominantly in low-income and lower-middle countries in Sub Saharan Africa and South Asia do not benefit from the social foundations (countries whose foundation <100). In these contexts, key barriers limit ci zens abili es to meet their human rights. At the same me, 6.9 billion people, from all income groupings, lie above the planetary boundaries (countries with average boundary >100%) (Figure 8). These are countries whose dietary pa erns, if adopted globally, would transgress all planetary boundaries. Therefore, policies that look to secure social founda ons, must simultaneously ensure that changes to dietary pa erns will not put dispropor onate pressure on planetary boundaries. Meanwhile only 115 million people are currently in the safe and just space. Efforts to support jus ce have not succeeded in protec ng the planet, and conversely condi ons that support a safe planet, do not necessarily guarantee jus ce. Policies are therefore needed to simultaneously protect the planet and address jus ce, because currently, almost every country in the world is outside (or on the edge) of the Safe and Just corridor, with places least responsible for destabilising the planet falling the furthest below the social founda ons. Similarly, those furthest above the planetary boundaries tend also to be the wealthiest, with the diets of the top third of the global popula on, from High-Income and Upper Middleincome na ons, amoun ng to over 70% of the food system share of the planetary pressure. 65 1723 1724 1725 1726 1727 1728 1729 1730 1731 1732 1733 1734 1735 1736 Figure 8: Global population distribution among planetary boundaries and social foundations. Kobe plot contrasts each country’s food system contribution to five planetary boundaries (y-axis, average % for GHG emissions, land, nitrogen, phosphorus, and water, where 100% is the boundary) by their status of three social foundations (x-axis, average status for diet affordability, agricultural wages, and nitrogen exceedance to groundwater, where 0% is the foundation). Large circles are regional averages, sized by total population. We estimated the total number of people in countries that fell below social foundations (3.7 billion people) or transgressed planetary boundaries (6.9 billion people). Countries above social foundations and below planetary boundaries would be in the Safe and Just corridor. Kobe plots comparing each social foundation and planetary boundary are shown in Figure A3.4. Each country’s social founda ons status was normalized to have each social founda on = 100%, where countries would fall below (<100%) or above (>100%) the founda on. Values above the founda on were capped at a maximum of 300%. 1737 66 1738 1739 1740 1741 1742 1743 1744 1745 1746 1747 1748 1749 1750 1751 1752 1753 1754 1755 1756 1757 1758 1759 1760 1761 1762 1763 1764 1765 1766 1767 1768 1769 1770 1771 1772 1773 Sec on 4: Assessing poten al environmental and socioeconomic consequences of a food systems transforma on Exploring what food systems that are more aligned with health, environmental, and justice objectives could look like, requires assessing the potential consequences of how food systems would be restructured by dietary change, increased productivity, and reduced food loss and waste (FLW). We use two complementary modelling approaches for that purpose. First, we assembled a multi-model ensemble of ten global economic models used in high-level assessments of climate change, land use and food security345–350 and involved in the Agricultural Model Intercomparison and Improvement Project (AgMIP).350–352 The ensemble of economic models includes a mix of par al equilibrium models (agricultural sector only), with more detailed biophysical and sectoral representa on, and general equilibrium models (whole of economy), which can simulate interac ons across non-agricultural sectors (e.g., energy). All simulate important system dynamics that would drive changes across a transforming food system, including, for example, the ability of producers to subs tute inputs based on their availability and cost. Second, we used DIA-GIO (the Global Input-Output module of the Dietary Impact Assessment model), an updated version of the static input-output food model developed for the 2019 EAT-Lancet Commission (See modelling description in Appendix 4 for summary of updates).194 This was done to improve comparability with the modelling methodology used by the 2019 Commission, and recognizing there is uncertainty to the capacity of economic systems to adapt to rapid large-scale changes. Delays to a food systems transforma on, for example, would constrain the scope of food systems to adapt, limi ng the possibility to efficiently reallocate resources across alternate uses such as energy or fibre produc on. Therefore, we used DIA-GIO as an accoun ng tool to scope the biophysical op on space based on the current and projected supply, demand, and trade rela onships, but without the effects of economic feedback. This allowed us to consider poten al implica ons of a food system with constrained capacity for, or dedicated policies (e.g., on land-use changes) that would regulate, resource realloca on. There is substantial uncertainty in how food systems would transform, and using a range of models and modelling approaches allows us to engage with this uncertainty, which we will do by reporting ensemble median, and where appropriate the full ensemble range (i.e., min to max) as well as comparing to DIA-GIO. See supplementary materials (Appendix 4) for more detailed documentation on models, and modelling approaches applied in this analysis. 1774 Defining alternative future food systems 1775 1776 1777 1778 1779 1780 1781 In addition to updating and extending the modelling suite, this analysis has updated the scenario framework used to assess global and regional changes across food systems. We constructed three core scenarios described below (Table A4.3). The business-as-usual scenario (BAU) projects how food systems could look by 2050 assuming a continuation of current trends and policies. This scenario assumes population and economic growth based on the “Middle-of-the-Road" scenario (SSP2) of the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways, a scenario 67 1782 1783 1784 1785 1786 1787 1788 1789 1790 1791 1792 1793 1794 1795 1796 1797 1798 1799 1800 1801 1802 1803 1804 1805 1806 1807 1808 1809 1810 1811 1812 1813 1814 1815 1816 1817 framework designed for the IPCC to model the consequences of climate change in the 21st century.353– 356 This scenario projects global population and GDP to grow by 23% to 9.6 billion people and 127% to 282 trillion US$ between 2020 and 2050 respectively (Figure A4.2, Table A4.9).357–359 To simulate the consequences of climate change in the BAU, we applied a representa ve concentra on pathway (RCP 7.0) which assumes limited mi ga on efforts and temperature increases of around 2°C by 2050. The biophysical consequences of this future climate were represented using published estimated changes in crop yields,360 livestock yields,361 and agricultural labour productivity.362 Following model parameterization in the 2019 Commission,1,194 DIA-GIO BAU projections to 2050 were informed by projections from IMPACT363, one of the participating global economic models. The EL scenario (EAT-Lancet style food systems transformation) starting in 2020 deviates from BAU along three key dimensions. In EL, we assume that by 2050: (1) Healthy diets (Table 1) are adopted by all; (2) a 7-10 percent increase on top of global BAU agricultural productivity based on projections quantified as a part of previous model intercomparisons350,364 for SSP1,350,364 a more sustainable shared-socioeconomic pathway (Table A4.10); and (3) a halving of BAU food loss and waste (FLW), consistent with SDG 12.3. Finally, an additional scenario, ELM (EAT-Lancet Mitigation) combines EL with ambitious mitigation. 347,350 Ambitious mitigation was based on previous modelling efforts to assess determinants of land-use across SSP projections350 and land-use policies and decarbonization pathways to achieve 1.5°C warming by the end of the century.347,350 Ambi ous mi ga on includes a range of policies (emissions pricing and land-use regula ons), which define market condi ons that determine the mix of technologies and prac ces (e.g., afforesta on, renewables, and bioenergy) adopted to maintain carbon budgets. Each economic model has somewhat different capacity to model decarboniza on pathways, see Table A4.17 for a summary of each model's implementa on of mi ga on. This scenario was run recognising that a transi on towards more sustainable food systems cannot be achieved without a wider societal transition towards greater sustainability. This scenario also allowed us to assess potential synergies and trade-offs between a food systems transforma on and ambi ous economy-wide mi ga on efforts, par cularly through poten al compe on for landuse. While mi ga on efforts would be expected to reduce climate impacts by end-of-century, we keep BAU climate impacts (RCP 7.0) in ELM, recognising the uncertainty of these efforts transla ng to reduc ons in climate impacts by 2050. We emphasise that these scenarios aim to explore end points of a food systems transformation, and do not explore possible pathways that could lead to these outcomes by 2050. Assessing the implication of these endpoints is an important first step in understanding the potential benefits and costs of the changes simulated in these scenarios. Future work is needed to explore the pathways of change under varying assumptions of global development. 1818 1819 Comparing alternative food systems projections across modelling approaches 1820 1821 1822 1823 1824 1825 Across the model ensemble, the BAU scenario, compared to 2020, shows a 37% increase in global agricultural production by 2050 (Figure 9a). Livestock production increases by around 33% and crops by 37%. All regions see increased overall agricultural production from 2020, with the largest increases in Sub-Saharan Africa (around 100%) and the smallest increases in China (11% for ensemble, 18% for DIA-GIO) and Europe (18% for ensemble, 16% for DIA-GIO) (Figure 9b). 68 1826 1827 1828 1829 1830 1831 1832 1833 1834 1835 1836 1837 1838 1839 1840 1841 1842 1843 1844 1845 1846 1847 1848 1849 1850 1851 1852 1853 1854 1855 1856 1857 1858 1859 1860 1861 1862 1863 1864 1865 1866 1867 1868 1869 1870 Model results suggest that by 2050, the combined effects in an EL scenario could result in total agricultural production (AGR) near 2020 levels, but with important changes to the composition of production (Figure 9c). Compared to 2020, livestock production declines by 22% (27% for DIA-GIO). Driven primarily by reductions in demand for crop production for animal feed which would decline substantially from BAU 2050 levels. While the models agree on the direction of change (i.e., declining crop production compared to BAU) there is less agreement on the magnitude of this reduction, with some models suggesting 2050 crop production would remain above 2020 levels, whereas others suggesting it could fall slightly below 2020 levels. A sectoral analysis demonstrates that the largest declines are in ruminant (RUM) production (cattle, goats, sheep) with a 55% (75% for DIA-GIO) reduction compared to BAU 2050 levels, or a 33% (63% for DIA-GIO) decline on 2020 levels across the ensemble (Figure 9c, Figure A4.3). This is accompanied by a decline in global ruminant animal numbers of 26% (result reported by IMPACT and GLOBIOM). Nonruminant production saw a smaller decline of 24% (-46% in DIA-GIO), with larger declines for pork (48% based on three ensemble models reporting, -83% in DIA-GIO) than poultry (-14% for both DIA-GIO and the mean of two reporting ensemble models) production (Figure A4.4). The economic models generally show smaller declines in production compared to DIA-GIO, as other sectors (e.g., for pet food, bone meal) increase their demand for animal sourced foods (See Figure A4.10 for changes in food, feed, and other demand). EL demand for animal feed declines (-3%) from around 2.5 billion tonnes in 2020 to 2.4 billion tonnes by 2050. This compares to a 39% increase in feed production to around 3.5 billion tonnes in BAU. There is less ensemble model agreement on changes in cereals, but the median results show modest production declines in rice (-13%), wheat (-4%), and coarse grains (all other grains) (-3%). Sugar crop production also shows absolute declines (-7% for ensemble, -30% for DIA-GIO) on 2020 levels in EL. The modelling approaches differ in the projections of vegetables, fruits, nuts and seeds, legumes, roots and tubers, primarily due to different commodity aggregations methods (VFN in Figure 9). When we disaggregate the food group, we see much greater agreement between the ensemble and DIA-GIO, with vegetable production increasing by 42% (48% for DIA-GIO), fruit by 61% (36% for DIA-GIO), nuts by 172% (155% for DIA-GIO), legumes by 187% (56% for DIA-GIO), with roots and tubers declining by 9% (-42% for DIA-GIO). Differences in legumes can be attributed to ensemble models reporting soybeans (accounting for the bulk of legume production) as oilseeds (OSD) rather than legumes, highlighting differences in how different disciplines (i.e., nutrition vs production) analyse food production and consumption. When we combine OSD and legumes across the ensemble the median production by 2050 for EL is 1.07 billion tonnes compared to 1.08 billion for DIA-GIO. Considering the impacts of individual drivers, if we only include improved productivity the median projec on for produc on across the ensemble is similar to BAU (38% vs 37% for BAU), but the range of model projec ons is somewhat higher (31%-53% min-max vs 25%-41% in BAU) (Figure A4.5). The use of global economic models highlights that, in isolation (and without dedicated policies), efficiency gains may not translate to lower overall production and may even increase it. Reducing FLW or dietary change in isolation leads to a smaller increase in production of 29% (17% for DIA-GIO) and 15% (18% for DIA-GIO) respectively compared to 2020 (Figure A4.5). Reduced FLW achieves this by shrinking the gap between what is consumed and what is purchased, signalling a need for less production to meet 69 1871 1872 1873 1874 1875 1876 1877 1878 1879 1880 1881 1882 1883 1884 1885 1886 1887 1888 1889 1890 1891 1892 1893 1894 1895 1896 demand, whereas a shift to healthy diets would avoid overconsumption and reduce the demand for more resource intensive animal sourced foods and animal feed. ELM shows larger declines in production compared to EL across livestock sectors, with RUM, NRM, and DRY declining by 37, 35, and 15 percent compared to 33, 24, and 7 percent respectively. These larger declines are the consequence of increased production costs from the pricing of emissions. On the other hand, ELM has slightly larger increases across crop production, due to increased demand for crops from a growing bioeconomy (e.g., biofuels, biomass, bioplastics) to facilitate a transition away from fossil fuels (Figure 9e, Figure A4.10). Figure 9: Projecting 2050 agricultural production by sector and region. a. global production by sector for BAU vs 2020. b. agricultural production by region for BAU vs 2020. c. global production by sector for EL vs 2020. d. agricultural production by region for EL vs 2020. e. global production by sector for ELM vs 2020. f. agricultural production by region for ELM vs 2020. All scenario results are reported as the percent change between 2050 and 2020. Individual model results in the ensemble are given by vertical lines within the grey shaded range of results (dark grey = inter-quartile range, light grey = min-max range). Black vertical lines indicate median values which are also expressed numerically in each figure. Results are coloured blue for a percentage decrease and red for a percentage increase. The DIA-GIO model results are given by the unfilled black circle and only include BAU and EL scenarios. Sectors are grouped by crop and livestock commodities. Sectors: AGR = all agricultural products (excluding FSH), LSP = all livestock products (excluding FSH), RUM = ruminant meat, NRM = nonruminant meat (poultry, pork, eggs), DRY = dairy, CRP = all crops, RIC = rice, WHT = wheat, CGR = coarse grains, VFN = vegetables, fruits, and nuts (and legumes, roots and tubers), OSD = oilseeds, SGC = sugar crops., FSH = fisheries and aquaculture. Regions are ordered in terms of size of total agricultural production in 2020 based on FAO data 365. Regions: WLD = World, ANZ = Australia and New Zealand; BRA = Brazil; CAN = Canada; CHN = China; EUR = Europe; ECC = Eastern Europe, Caucasus, Central Asia; IND = India; MEN = Middle East and North Africa; OAS = Other Asia; 70 1897 1898 1899 OSA = Other South and Central America; SEA = Southeast Asia; SSA = Sub-Saharan Africa; USA = United States of America. 1900 Exploring the biophysical option space of a food systems transformation 1901 1902 1903 1904 1905 1906 1907 We estimated the consequences of an EAT-Lancet food systems transformation on the Earth system. Where possible, we align the control variables with the food system boundaries defined in Section 3 (land, GHG, blue water). However, where models cannot currently report against these variables (Nitrogen surplus and Phosphorus loss) we have used control variables from the 2019 Commission (Nitrogen use and Phosphorus use) as proxy indicators. 1908 1909 1910 1911 1912 1913 1914 1915 1916 1917 1918 1919 1920 1921 1922 1923 1924 1925 1926 1927 1928 1929 1930 1931 1932 1933 1934 1935 1936 1937 1938 1939 1940 1941 Assessing potential impact on Climate, Land, Water, Nitrogen, and Phosphorous Boundaries The modelling results show that in BAU, the environmental impact of agricultural production is projected to increase compared to 2020, where agricultural production is already above the food share of multiple planetary boundaries, with animal products responsible for the majority of emissions, and grains for the majority of nitrogen, phosphorous, and water use (Figure 10a). Agricultural emissions are expected to rise by 33% (20 to 50%; 51% for DIA-GIO) in the model ensemble, primarily driven by a 22% (18 to 25%) increase in ruminant animal numbers. The model ensemble projects agricultural crop yields to increase by 24% (17 to 46%), slowing but not preventing agricultural land expansion, which increases by 4% (1 to 7%; 16% for DIA-GIO) or ~200 Mha, with cropland expanding by 10% (4 to 25%). Resource use for producing crops increases in BAU according to ensemble results, with blue water use increasing by 13% (-10 to 43%; 1% for DIA-GIO), suggesting uncertainty on future increases on water-use efficiency (i.e., adoption of irrigation technologies, planting of more water efficient crops) and rates of expansion of irrigated area to 2050. Nitrogen and phosphorous application increasing by 41% (22 to 55%; 31% for DIA-GIO) and 41% (36 to 46%; 26% for DIA-GIO) respectively. BAU results suggest food systems could exceed the resource-use boundaries by more than 100% for nitrogen-use and by 55-75% for land, water, and phosphorous use (Figure 10b). All three components of EL (dietary change, increased productivity, reduced FLW) contribute to more efficient and less resource-intensive food systems by 2050. To achieve the agricultural emissions target of 5 GtCO2e yr-1 from CH4 and N2O from biological processes, non-CO2 emissions at the farm-gate would need to decrease by more than 30% from current estimates of 7.1 GtCO 2e yr-1.172 Under EL, agricultural non-CO2 emissions decline, primarily due to fewer ruminants, with the ensemble median and DIA-GIO showing a 20% and 32% decline compared to 2020 respectively. However, there is low agreement across models on whether these reductions are sufficient to meet the food system boundary (–48 to 13% from 2020 across models). All regions show emissions reductions in EL compared to BAU by 2050, with the largest decreases occurring in Sub-Saharan Africa, Brazil, and the rest of Latin America (Figure A4.6). When EL is coupled with emissions pricing and land-use policies in ELM, the model ensemble shows agricultural emissions declining further to 34% (-84 to -18%) of 2020 levels, and below the food system boundary. Ensemble results suggest total global agricultural land use (cropland + grazing land) could fall by 7% (26% to 1%) below 2020 levels (decrease of ~340 Mha) in EL, a substantial departure from BAU projections described above. Most of this decline comes from reductions in grazing land (-11%, -59% to 1%). Latin America accounts for 30% of the decline in grazing land from 2020 (with Brazil alone 71 1942 1943 1944 1945 1946 1947 1948 1949 1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 accounting for 16%), while Sub-Saharan Africa accounts for 22%. Such a reduction in future agricultural land-use could provide room for conservation or restoration of natural ecosystems, particularly in these regions. The ensemble results suggest an increase in cropland (10%, -3% to 42%) from 2020, whereas DIA-GIO suggests that cropland area could decrease to 22% below 2020 levels without other uses of land (Figure A4.9). Coupling ambi ous mitigation with a shift to healthy diets under ELM shows even greater reductions in future agricultural area, with agricultural land declining globally by 14% (28 to -4%) compared to 2020. This larger reduc on is due to both drivers reducing the demand for and produc on of animal products, and in par cular ruminant produc on, the main users of grazing land. Current estimates indicate that global blue water use remains below the food system boundary. However, regional water scarcity remains a critical concern, and addi onal efforts may be needed to increase water use efficiency and manage water-use, particularly in areas already experiencing water stress (e.g., Indo-Gange c plains, Mediterranean, etc.). EL lowers water use compared to BAU 2050 levels, but there is low agreement across the ensemble in terms of whether this reduction is sufficient to fall below 2020 levels (4%, -25 to 39%; -8% for DIA-GIO). Ensemble results suggest similar blue water use in ELM compared to EL (3%, -40 to 45%), but with results showing a wider range of outcomes. While EL reduces both N- and P- use compared to BAU, usage levels are s ll projected to increase compared to 2020 (15%, -17 to 32%; and 15%, 5 to 25%, respec vely), and remain above the planetary boundaries. DIA-GIO results suggest that under EL, nitrogen and phosphorus inputs could decline substan ally compared to current levels (-35 and -53%, respec vely) and near or below planetary boundaries, when demand from non-food sectors does not increase. There are important complementari es across the three drivers of EL, which in combina on achieved be er environmental outcomes than any individual driver in isola on.366 Dietary change alone could substan ally contribute to improvements along land and emissions boundaries, but there is greater uncertainty on the outcome across water, N- and P-use by 2050, as many commodi es growing in demand also require these inputs. DIA-GIO showed greater environmental gains from increased produc vity and reduced FLW, than did the economic models, where rebound effects in demand limit the environmental gains from these drivers. For example, increased produc vity in ruminant produc on lowers the cost of ruminant products, which in turn leads to lower consumer prices and s mulates increased consumer demand. This increase in demand leads to a larger ruminant herd leading to similar emissions under the increased produc vity scenario compared to BAU (Fig 10b). A shi to healthy diets would avoid this outcome as it would reduce demand for ruminant products. A shi to healthy diets, on the other hand, would increase demand for more perishable fruits and vegetables and could increase the volume of FLW, highligh ng the increased importance of interven ons to reduce FLW in an EL future. The range of environmental results (cropland extent, and blue water, N, and P use) highlights substan al uncertainty in how agri-food systems could respond to a food system transforma on. A transi on to a healthy diet would include reduc ons in demand for some agricultural commodi es (e.g., animal-sourced foods, and sugar), accompanied by reduc ons in intermediate demand from these sectors for inputs (e.g., animal feed). However, this transi on would also increase the demand for other agricultural commodi es (e.g., fruits, vegetables, legumes, and nuts). 72 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Whether this transi on would lead to a net reduc on in resource use by agriculture depends on a variety of factors. First is whether resources (cropland, water, fer lizers) dedicated to producing crops no longer demanded can easily be converted to producing agricultural commodi es that are increasing in demand. For example, not all cropland dedicated to feed crops would be suitable (agro-clima cally or economically) to produce fruits, vegetables, legumes, and nuts. Second, are the crops increasing in demand less resource intensive than those that are declining in demand. While animal-sourced foods are generally resource intensive, many of the crops increasing in demand can also be rela vely resource intensive, par cularly with respect to water and fer lizer use. Third, many crops that are important animal feeds (e.g., cereals and oilseeds) are also inputs to a variety of industrial uses (e.g., cosme cs, bioplas cs, biofuels, etc.). Less demand for animal feeds would make these agricultural commodi es cheaper, which could spur addi onal demand from outside the food system, limi ng environmental gains. Models with larger reduc ons in resource use (i.e. DIA-GIO), assume limited rebounds in demand and less compe on for realloca ng resources to producing a healthy diet, whereas many of the economic models suggest there could be a wider range of poten al uses for resources that could lead to smaller environmental gains without addi onal economic incen ves (e.g., true cost accoun ng) or policies (land-use regula on). Poten al increased compe on for resource use is more evident in ELM, where there is increased demand for agricultural products from the bioeconomy (i.e., biofuels, biomass, bioplastics) as a part of transitioning away from fossil fuels, and land-use policies that restricts land expansion leading to increased agricultural intensification of existing cropland. This suggests that the modelled changes could contribute substantially to reducing environmental pressure across many dimensions compared to remaining on a BAU trajectory. However, there is uncertainty with respect to reducing environmental impact compared to today or fully remaining within a safe operating space. Much of this uncertainty depends on how broad the scope is for alterna ve uses for natural resources and agricultural commodi es, emphasising the need to couple supply- and demand-side changes to avoid undesired consequences and rebound effects. The model results present a cri cal founda on for a food system transforma on, even as additional policies and innovations367,368 that promote improved food system efficiency and resource use (e.g., precision ag, fertilizer management, improved produc on alloca on), further reductions in FLW, applications of sustainable intensification approaches (Panels 5 and 6 and Appendix 2), or circularity369–371 (Panel 4) may be required to ensure a complete transi on to a safe opera ng space. 73 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036 2037 2038 2039 2040 Figure 10: Environmental impacts of food systems. a. Direct environmental contribution towards planetary boundaries of food groups in 2020 (i.e., nitrogen use for animal feed production appears in crop production). Source: DIA-GIO. Food groups: (grains in violet) RIC = rice, CGR = coarse grains, WHT = wheat, (crops in teal) OSD = oilseeds, SGC = sugar crops, VFN = vegetables, fruits, and nuts (and legumes, roots and tubers), OCR = other crops, (livestock products in blue) RUM = ruminant meat, DRY = dairy, NRM = nonruminant meat (poultry, pork, eggs) b. Projected environmental impacts of different scenarios in 2050. The first row shows the current state (grey line) of the food system for five environmental variables —Land for Agriculture, Non-CO₂ Emissions from Agriculture, Water Withdrawals for Crops, Nitrogen Use for Crops, and Phosphorus Use for Crops—and their food system boundaries (orange line). The percentage change needed from the current level to reach the boundary is indicated between the two lines. The lines continue from the first row and are translated to percentage change from the current state in the subsequent rows. Each subsequent row represents percentage changes relative to the current state for different scenarios in 2050: the core scenarios (highlighted in grey) BAU (Business-As-Usual), EL (EAT-Lancet), and ELM (EAT-Lancet with mitigation), and their drivers (increased productivity, reduced food loss and waste (FLW), diet shift, and climate mitigation). The thicker vertical lines represent the multi-model median, with the lighter dots indicating individual model results. Colours indicate whether results are below (green), between (orange), or exceeding (red) the food system boundary. Open black circles indicate results from the DIA-GIO model. 2041 Socioeconomic and justice implications of food systems transformation 2042 2043 2044 2045 2046 2047 Assessing agricultural labour and livelihood implications Changes in labour demand can have implica ons for produc on costs and income, as well as ul mately produc on and total demand.372 Across all scenarios (BAU, EL, ELM), assumed economic development and increasing urbaniza on leads to an agriculture sector that contributes a smaller share of total economic output and employment by 2050.373,374 While the structural change in demand suggested by a dietary change in EL (Figure 9) would have important consequences on which sectors are increasing 74 2048 2049 2050 2051 2052 2053 2054 2055 2056 2057 2058 2059 2060 2061 2062 2063 2064 2065 2066 2067 2068 2069 2070 2071 2072 2073 2074 2075 2076 2077 2078 2079 2080 2081 or decreasing their demand for labour, globally, we see modest addi onal reduc ons in labour demand under EL or ELM compared to BAU (Figure 11a, and Appendix 4 Table A4.22). These results are consistent with recent analyses using current sectoral and regional labour requirements, which found a shift to a healthy diet would lead to a less labour-intensive global food system.375 All of which suggests that a shift to a healthy diet would not only be less resource-intensive, as highlighted in the previous sec on; but also modestly less labour-intensive to produce. The global reduc on in labour intensity is driven by various factors, including a reduc on in the produc on of animal feeds, and a reduc on in output from more labour-intensive sectors like industrial pork, poultry, and dairy produc on offse ng increased labour demand in expanding crop sectors like vegetable, fruits and nuts. Livestock sectors would face par cular economic challenges, with the livestock share of total agricultural value of produc on declining from ~40% in 2020 to around 15% by 2050 in EL and ELM (Figure 11b). This is due to a 41% decline in global produc on, coupled with a 31% decline in producer prices for livestock products,376 which contributes to a 36% reduc on in livestock labour demand by 2050 compared to BAU. The increased demand for some plant-based foods, especially vegetables, fruits, and nuts, would drive increased demand for labour in these expanding sectors, which globally across all of agriculture offset most of the declines in livestock labour demand. These ensemble results are broadly consistent with DIA-GIO results, which suggest the shi s in sectoral demand for labour would result in a modest reduc on in overall agricultural labour demand (<5%) globally. The agricultural sector contributes a larger share of GDP and employment in lower-income regions (up to 40%) compared to higher-income regions (<5%).377 Despite a decline in the contribu on of agriculture to the economy compared to current levels, by 2050 agriculture would remain a relatively large source of GDP and employment in many regions (e.g., India, and Sub-Saharan Africa). The labour demands by sector also vary substantially across region and food system. As such, the challenges of restructuring agriculture and food sectors would vary regionally.378 The restructuring of food systems could be relatively more challenging in regions with large agricultural labour forces (e.g., India, SubSaharan Africa, and China), or large livestock sectors (e.g., Latin America). Regions with larger vegetable, fruit and nut sectors (e.g., China), may benefit from changes in demand without the need for substantial reallocation of resources across agricultural sectors. Figure 11 shows the size of agricultural labour force by region (panel a) and the relative importance of the livestock sector and the VFN sectors (panel b) to highlight regions where restructuring of labour demand could present greater challenges. 75 2082 2083 2084 2085 2086 2087 2088 2089 2090 2091 2092 2093 2094 2095 2096 2097 2098 Figure 11: Summary of regional disaggregation of agricultural labour and value of production. a. agricultural labour force (millions) for the world and 13 regions by 2050 under BAU, EL and ELM. Intensity of shading reflects regional share of global agricultural employment. Employment numbers are derived from benchmarking the percentage change (2050 vs 2020) of the median model to agricultural employment in 2020.365 Percentage change from 2020 by scenario shown in parentheses. Full model results are given in Table A4.22. b. the share of value for livestock (LSP) and vegetables, fruits, legumes and nuts (VFN) in total agricultural value of production for 2020 (grey), BAU (red), EL (blue), ELM (purple). Agricultural value of production is given in current prices. Changes in labour demand would impact livelihoods beyond employment levels. Model ensemble results suggest that agricultural wages could keep pace with the overall economy, with average agricultural wages increasing by 81%, 74%, and 73% by 2050 for BAU, EL, and ELM respectively. However, substantial restructuring across agricultural sectors (i.e., reduc ons in animal produc on, expansion of fruits and vegetables) would have important justice implications. These results assume a smooth transition to 2050 across all three scenarios. For this to occur in the EL scenario, there would need to be clear and consistent market signals to discourage new entrants (e.g., producers newly entering a specific sector) into contracting sectors (i.e., ruminants), while encouraging entry into 76 2099 2100 2101 expanding sectors (i.e., VFN), along with the necessary investments in human and physical capital to facilitate labour transitions both within and outside of food systems. Panel 8: Challenges and changes in livestock produc on An EAT-Lancet aligned food systems transforma on would ‘mark a paradigm shi in our rela onship with farmed animals’,P66 with a considerably transformed and smaller livestock system globally (Panel Figure). To match nutri onally healthy meat consump on from the human diet point of view, we es mate that the producer animal numbers would decline globally to 1.1 billion (-26%) ruminants for meat (ca le, sheep, goats), 785 million (-4%) dairy animals, 66 billion (-19%) nonruminants (of which >95% poultry, <5% pigs). Conversely, fish produc on would increase to 220 million tonnes (+46% on 2020 levels). From the perspec ve of value of produc on, we see an absolute contrac on from 2020 levels, with a 43% decline across the global terrestrial livestock sector (-US$650 billion) by 2050. Propor onally this is more marked for ruminant meat (-71%), than non-ruminants (-46%) or dairy (-20%). It also represents a 50% decline in terrestrial livestock sector employment by 2050, no ng that in a BAU scenario we see a decline of around 25%. Panel Figure: Projected changes in the number of livestock producing animals and fish produc on under BAU and EL scenarios. a. Global animal numbers for ruminant meat (ca le, sheep, goats). b. Global animal numbers for dairy. c. Global animal numbers for non-ruminants (poultry, pigs). d. Global fish produc on (million tonnes). The grey bar gives current animal numbers based on FAO data.P67 The red and blue bars give projected numbers from modelling for the Commission in a BAU and EL scenario respec vely. The unfilled black marker in d. gives results for the DIA-GIO model. Note that different units of measure are applied for each category. Change in livestock animal numbers indicate reduc ons in CH4 and N2O emissions (-22% versus 2020), and grazing land (-11% versus 2020, ~340Mha). Further improvements and innova ons in prac ces can and should be developed and applied to further reduce emissions and both increase and capture environmental benefits of livestock produc on. For example, some of the methane emissions linked to ruminant management can poten ally be mi gated in the futureP68 (Figure 5). 77 The meat and dairy sectors are the most impacted by shi s to healthy diets, which must cri cally take into account livelihoods, culture, and power dynamics. While we recognise the conten ous and complex nature of animal-sourced foods produc on and consump on, a smaller livestock sector creates opportuni es to give greater considera on to animal health and wellbeing, environmental outcomes, and labour quality. We flag six important opportuni es and considera ons to navigate this transi on which we recommend considering in combina on, rather than in isola on: Gains through Efficiency and Technology: There are significant efficiency gains in produc on, notably in the global south, that can markedly reduce an cipated environmental and health impacts of produc on. Emissions intensity can be improved so that per unit produc on, less GHG would be emi ed.P69 Cau on is urged around densely occupied confined systems notably around other environmental effects such as concentrated nutrient pollu on, and disease risk, over-use of an microbials, animal health and welfare and labour condi ons. The assumed conserva on gains of improved efficiency are only a ained with complementary policies and ac ons that limit, for example, con nued expansion into intact lands. Zero Conversion of Intact Forests, and Grasslands: The addi onal conversion of forests for pasture or feed systems is antagonis c to achieve both human and environmental goals. O en forgo en are intact grasslands, which are even more threatened than forest globally. Only 30% of intact grasslands are remaining, making them the most converted, but also least protected ecosystems globally.P70 Gains through Nature Posi ve Rangeland Management: While intensive (over)grazing contributes to land degrada on,P71,P72 integra ng grazing livestock to maintain grasslands is also a possibility for conserving and restoring grassland ecosystemsP73 including carbon sequestra on. Bai et al. es mate increases in SOC of 2.3 to 7.3 GtCO2e year−1 for grassland restora on in general, with Improved grazing management providing 0.15 to 0.7 GTCO2e year−1.P74 Improving grazing management ranges from complete removal of grazing livestock to different ways of reducing grazing intensity, highligh ng the need to balance the management with the agroecosystem condi ons.P73 Importantly, the produc on of supplementary feeds needs to be internalised into the overall effects of the livestock produc on systems, due to e.g. deforesta on.P75 In forest biomes, silvo-pastoral systems present some opportunity to mi gate effects of livestock while contribu ng to produc vity gains.P76 Gains Through Integra on: Modern agriculture has o en separated animal and plant produc ons systems. Methods reconnec ng these systems, whether integrated in landscapes or connected through circular produc on such as insect-based feed offer promise.P77-79 Feeding livestock with byproducts in circular systems has poten al, but the number of animals that could be reared is limited by the availability of such feed, resul ng in substan ally lower produc on levels than what is currently produced.P79 Gains in Animal Welfare: Perspec ves emphasising the welfare and wellbeing of animals in agriculture have risen due to a growing concern related to intensive, confined, industrialised farming systems, or ‘factory farming’. For instance high stocking densi es,P81,P82 long transporta on mes,P83 restric ng natural behaviourP84 pose animal welfare concerns, and also extensive systems come with 78 their own challenges.P85 Animal welfare concerns have also been shown to influence consumer choice, along with the produce quality, even outranking environmental concerns.P86 Importantly, discussion on animal welfare and wellbeing should reflect current, mul disciplinary knowledge, bringing together advancing research on animal cogni on and behaviour, veterinary science and ethics.P87 Non-ruminant Animal Sourced Foods: In some regions beef consump on is flat or declining (e.g. USA, Europe), largely replaced by poultry and pork produc on. Blue foods, or aqua c foods are common to many cultures and tradi ons. In general, animal sourced foods will have higher environmental footprints than plant sourced foods because of lost energy conversion between trophic levels. This loss is lowest for aqua c and avian animal sourced foods and can be further mi gated by more circular systems. However, most livestock produc on systems share similar disease, and pollu on risks at scale, notably in dense highly confined systems and all have concerns related to animal health and welfare. 2102 2103 2104 2105 2106 2107 2108 2109 2110 2111 2112 2113 2114 2115 2116 2117 2118 2119 2120 2121 2122 2123 2124 2125 2126 2127 2128 2129 2130 2131 Assessing production costs and food expenditure implications Using various modelling approaches, we observe a smaller and less resource intensive food system with EL compared to BAU. It is one that would require fewer natural resources (i.e., land and water), chemical (N and P), and labour inputs. Across the ensemble, these changes could amount to a moderate reduction in average agricultural producer prices of 8% for EL by 2050 compared to BAU (Figure 12a). Assuming current input requirements and prices, DIA-GIO projected a similar reduction in costs (10%). This suggests that transformed food systems by 2050 could produce healthy diets for all while reducing input costs, natural resource use, as well as environmental pressures compared to BAU. However, whether this potential is realized will ultimately depend on the transi on pathway (i.e., the mix of policies, technologies, and cultural changes) followed to foster an EL compa ble food system transforma on. Across food systems, lower production costs could increase average food affordability if passed along to consumers. That said, it is important to note that lower producer prices can contribute to lower agricultural wages and income with negative consequences on food affordability, particularly in rural areas. Ensemble results suggest that average agricultural prices would not change substantially from 2020 levels for both BAU and EL. This contrasts with ELM, where increases in producer prices contribute to a 10% increase in consumer prices compared to 2020. Food expenditure (reported by AIM, ENVISAGE, and MAGNET), which is a factor of consumer prices and food demand, is projected to grow in all three scenarios, but at a slower rate than per capita income, with the share of global income spent on food falling from 7% to 5%, 4%, and 4% by 2050 for BAU, EL, and ELM respectively (Figure 12b). Globally, changes in food expenditure between BAU and EL are driven by two offsetting shifts in the consumption bundle. First, a decline in the demand for, and the prices of, relatively more expensive animal sourced foods. For example, demand for, and consumer prices of, ruminant meat fall by 62% and 16% respectively compared to 2020, even as ruminant prices remain substantially higher than prices of all other commodities (Figure 12a). Second, demand for and prices of VFN increase substantially, which at the global level mostly offset decreased spending on animal products. 79 2132 2133 2134 2135 2136 2137 2138 2139 2140 2141 2142 2143 2144 2145 2146 2147 2148 2149 2150 2151 2152 2153 2154 2155 2156 2157 While globally, by 2050, these two shifts mostly offset each other, some regions currently consuming relatively low levels of animal sourced foods (e.g., India), or would require relatively large increases in VFN demand (e.g., Eastern Europe, Caucasus, and Central Asia) to achieve a healthy diet could see increased food expenditure in 2050 compared to BAU. By contrast, regions that are currently overconsuming animal sourced foods (e.g. USA) could see declining food expenditures. This result is consistent with recent analysis using DIA-GIO that found that for individual consumers today, healthy diets could already be more affordable than current unhealthy diets in high- and upper middle-income countries, even as they remain more expensive in low- and lower middle-income countries8. Even as the share of income spent on food is declining for all regions and scenarios compared to 2020, the affordability of diverse healthy diets remains a concern. Lower income regions that import a substantial share of their VFN (e.g., Other Asia), could have additional concerns for increased vulnerability to international price shocks on domestic food affordability and availability. And while progress is made, Sub-Saharan Africa continues to spend a larger share of income (21%) on food in EL than any other region. This suggests lower income regions (bottom of list of regions in Figure 12b) could remain relatively more vulnerable to food poverty, and that targeted interventions to account for higher VFN prices and social protections to ensure consumers can afford a healthy diet may be needed. These results highlight that a food systems transformation, if achieved, could contribute towards social and environmental goals. However, the mechanisms for getting there (e.g., taxes, repurposing of subsidies, incorporation of true cost of food approaches) will be critical to informing and incentivizing behaviour change towards more sustainable production practices and healthier consumption patterns. The cost of these actions will ultimately determine whether a food system transformation increases or decreases the cost of individual foods and the overall diet. 80 2158 2159 2160 2161 2162 2163 2164 2165 2166 2167 2168 2169 2170 2171 2172 2173 2174 2175 2176 2177 2178 2179 2180 2181 2182 2183 2184 Figure 12. Changes in agricultural producer prices and food expenditure implications. a. global average prices by sector for 2020 (grey), BAU in 2050 (red), EL in 2050 (blue), and ELM in 2050 (purple). Global prices are expressed in 2020 US$/t, note the different scale for non-meat and meat prices. Prices for 2020 were obtained from FAOSTAT 365. Percentage change in prices (from 2020 to 2050) given by model results were applied to FAO 2020 prices. b. GDP per capita and food expenditure by region for BAU, EL, ELM expressed as a percentage change from 2020. Median GDP per capita for 3 reporting models (AIM, ENVISAGE, and MAGNET) is located at the region's first row followed by food expenditure results in the second row, which are expressed as percentage change from BAU 2020. Sectors: AGR = all agricultural products, RUM = ruminant meat, NRM = non-ruminant meat (poultry, pork, eggs), DRY = dairy, VFN = vegetables, fruits, and nuts (and legumes, roots and tubers), OSD = oilseeds, SGC = sugar crops, RIC = rice, WHT = wheat, CGR = coarse grains. Regions: WLD = World, ANZ = Australia and New Zealand; BRA = Brazil; CAN = Canada; CHN = China; EUR = Europe; ECC = Eastern Europe, Caucasus, Central Asia; IND = India; MEN = Middle East and North Africa; OAS = Other Asia; OSA = Other South and Central America; SEA = Southeast Asia; SSA = Sub-Saharan Africa; USA = United States of America. Mitigation efforts (Figure A4.7) could increase the cost of agricultural production by limiting land supply and pricing emissions. Across the ensemble, mitigation efforts in isolation would increase consumer prices by 17% (0 to 40%) compared to BAU 2050 prices. This is broadly consistent with past studies suggesting that mitigation efforts could increase food prices. 349 This increased risk can be explained by multiple factors that raise the price of producing and consuming food. First, land use and mitigation policies increase the cost of key agricultural inputs (e.g., land, fertilizers) raising the cost of production. Second, emissions pricing raises the cost of agricultural products, particularly of emission intensive commodities like ruminant meat. Vulnerability to changes in food prices varies, with lower income regions already at higher risk of food insecurity, like Sub-Saharan Africa, the most vulnerable to price increases. Panel 9 explores how the EL components contribute to changes in producer and consumer prices, and their potential policy implications. 81 2185 2186 2187 2188 2189 2190 2191 2192 2193 2194 2195 2196 2197 Low- and middle-income regions contribute the largest reductions in emissions and agricultural landuse in EL and ELM (e.g., China, Brazil, Sub-Saharan Africa), and predominantly are regions where dietary change risks increasing food prices. These are also the regions that historically have experienced large changes in land-use or had the least access to novel technologies and affordable reliable energy. This highlights the importance of increased productivity to reduce agricultural yield gaps, as well as reducing FLW, both of which could play a critical role in alleviating price pressures caused by a shift to healthy diets and/or ambitious mitigation. There are potential complementarities between a shift to a healthy diet and ambitious mitigation, both alleviates pressure on land, and globally, reduces GHG-intensive foods in the consumption bundle. Further demand-side interventions could also play a role in managing food affordability concerns. Modelling suggests that targeted food subsidies bundled with mi ga on policies379,380 or full cost efforts381 could help manage these price increases, as discussed in the following section. Panel 9: Understanding the drivers of price changes to inform policy priorities To assess which scenario drivers (dietary change, increased produc vity, reduced food loss and waste, and ambi ous mi ga on) were most responsible for changes in agricultural prices we conducted a decomposi on analysis using four models from the ensemble (AIM, CAPRI, ENVISAGE, and MAGNET) that reported regional consumer and producer (e.g., farm gate) prices (See Appendix 4 Fig A4.7 for full ensemble results of producer prices). Ambi ous mi ga on could increase the cost of produc on in all regions by limi ng agricultural land expansion and pricing emissions. Increased producer prices translate to higher consumer prices, posing a risk to food security. Dietary change on the other hand has more varied impact on prices. In Brazil and the USA, regions with high animal-sourced food consump on, adop on of healthy diets could reduce average consumer prices by 7% and 4% respec vely (Panel figure g and h, yellow bar). However, in India, where there is low red meat consump on, increased demand for vegetables, fruits, and nuts could contribute to a 10% increase in average consumer prices (Panel figure e, yellow bar) Increased produc vity and reduced FLW contribute to more efficient food systems, reducing the cost of produc on and leading to lower consumer prices in all regions. The poten al to mi gate price increases is par cularly cri cal in lower income regions with greater food security challenges. For example, in India and Sub-Saharan Africa reduced FLW and increased produc vity par ally offset the price increases due to ambi ous mi ga on and dietary change (Panel figure blue and red bars). FLW reduc ons contribute more to reduc ons in consumer prices than producer prices, with the biggest gains in regions with rela vely high consumer waste (e.g., USA Panel figure h). Broadly, these results suggest the importance of supply-side interven ons that increase the efficiency of food systems, par cularly in low-income se ngs where price rises pose immediate food security risks. Previous modellingP88–91 has suggested supply-side measures (investments in resource use efficiency, agricultural R&D, improved extension services), would be insufficient to alleviate food insecurity. As such, policies and interven ons that improve infrastructure and func oning of markets, as well as demand-side interven ons, such as price subsidies and poverty allevia ons measures, would be needed to manage higher diet costs in lower income regions. 82 Panel figure: The key drivers of price changes in ELM. Regional impact of ELM (purple) on producer (a-d) and consumer (e-h) prices as percent change (%) from the business-as-usual (BAU) scenario, decomposed into four key drivers shown as percentage points (%p): mi ga on (green), diet shi (yellow), improved produc vity (blue), and reduced food loss and waste (FLW) (red). Note that decomposi on values are not addi ve, as there are interac ons between the four scenario drivers, see SI for explana on of decomposi on. 2198 2199 83 2200 2201 2202 2203 2204 2205 2206 2207 2208 2209 2210 2211 2212 2213 2214 2215 2216 2217 2218 2219 2220 2221 2222 2223 2224 2225 2226 2227 2228 2229 2230 2231 2232 2233 2234 2235 2236 2237 2238 Section 5: Solutions and actions to improve health, environmental sustainability, and justice A “great food transformation”1 is required if the world is to align with the EAT-Lancet's vision by 2050. This transformation must operate across multiple leverage points, including profound shifts in the underlying objec ves of food systems outcomes.382,383 The focus must move beyond simply maximizing profit and volume in agriculture to achieving food security in ways that priori ze diet quality and advance health, sustainability, and social justice. Equally essen al is interven ons that change underlying rules and incen ves of the food system, such as taxes, subsidies, and regulations,382,383 as these form the condi ons under which deeper shifts in values, norms, and governance can emerge. This section focuses on these underlying rules and incentives through the lens of eight domain-specific solutions aimed at advancing health, environment, and/or justice goals simultaneously. For every solution, we identify two to three actions that the Commission has evaluated, based on synthesis of exis ng literature, as critical for transforming food systems. These ac ons are grounded in available scientific evidence demonstra ng their poten al to deliver meaningful impacts across health, environment, and jus ce outcomes, while also crea ng the enabling environment for more profound systems change. Figure 13 summarizes these solutions and their associated actions. Several analyses have shown that individual policies and interventions, on their own, are insufficient to drive multi-goal transformative change. Instead, bundled or integrated approaches are needed— for example, to keep global warming below 1.5 degrees384 or to reduce the hidden costs of current food systems (estimated to be 15 trillion US$/year).9 This is because the drivers and outcomes of food systems are highly interconnected, interacting in both direct and indirect ways.385 Investing in coordinated sets or packages of solutions is therefore essen al to steer food systems transformation in positive directions. We highlight some of these dynamics in actions 3 and 15-23. The domain-specific actions presented in this sec on are not isolated; rather, they are deeply interconnected and can produce synergistic effects across goals, while also naviga ng poten al trade-offs. For example, introducing regulations to limit land use expansion may promote health and environmental sustainability but could risk undermining justice if it restricts access for marginalized or indigenous people’s access to that land. However, if such regulations are implemented alongside efforts that recognise and protect the resource use of these groups, both sustainability and justice can be enhanced. By implementing actions as part of carefully designed 'bundles,’ it becomes possible to advance multiple goals simultaneously (see Section 6: Transformation). 84 2239 2240 2241 2242 2243 Figure 13: Goals, solutions, and actions to achieve healthy, sustainable, and just food systems. Depending on how they are implemented, all actions have the potential to contribute positively to other goals. The suggested strength of positive impact is developed based on dialogue with the Commissioners. 85 2244 2245 Goal 1: Achieve the Planetary Health Diet for All 2246 2247 2248 2249 2250 2251 2252 2253 2254 2255 2256 2257 2258 2259 2260 2261 2262 2263 2264 2265 2266 2267 2268 2269 2270 2271 2272 2273 2274 2275 2276 2277 2278 2279 2280 2281 2282 2283 2284 2285 2286 2287 Solu on 1: Shi to healthy diets To shi diets towards The Planetary Health Diet, it should ideally be more available, affordable, convenient, aspira onal, and delicious than unhealthy alterna ves. Two sets of feasible interven ons emerged from a scoping review of systema c reviews.386 Both sets of interven ons focus on food environments—the physical, economic, poli cal, and sociocultural se ngs in which people engage with the food system to acquire food387 —most o en considered more cost-effec ve and equitable than those targe ng individuals or households.387–389 The first set includes price-based interven ons, which are likely to reduce the purchase and consump on of unhealthy foods.390–392 The second set involves non-price-based interven ons that restrict adver sing and availability of unhealthy foods and mandate warning labels on them. Taxes on foods and beverages with high content of added sugar, salt, or saturated fats (or a combina on thereof) are par cularly impac ul when combined with subsidies on nutri ous foods that decrease their rela ve price.392,393 Modelling studies suggest op mal price levels for mi ga ng health and environmental impacts of unhealthy foods and meat that would require calibra on by context.379,380 By contrast, restric ng adver sing and marke ng of unhealthy foods could shi popula ons towards healthier foods.394,395 Labelling foods to denote higher energy content and those high in fat, sugar, and salt decreases purchasing and consump on396,397 using either mandatory frontof-pack warning labels as in several La n American countries or traffic light systems as is common in Europe.398 Reducing the propor on of unhealthy foods that are available in the market in parallel with increasing the propor on of healthier foods399,400 can reduce purchasing and consump on, as can reducing por on, package, and serving sizes of energy dense and unhealthier foods. 401,402 Affordability of food is determined by supply and demand side dynamics as well as by purchasing power.8,287 When making the PHD affordable for all, increasing purchasing power for lower income consumers is more important than ‘reducing the price’ of foods.403 Social protec on measures (see also Solu on 8) including, providing nutri ous school meals (Panel 11), public procurement and distribu on systems, employment guarantee schemes, and government investments in healthpromo ng insurance systems, all have the poten al to contribute to increased affordability for lowincome households. Living wages, universal basic income, income growth, and targeted income transfers, especially for economically disadvantaged people,404 and more equitable distribu on of the benefits of na onal economic growth through fiscal policies, would also support increased purchasing power. Previous modelling studies suggest that the rela ve cost of a healthy diet can be substan ally reduced, even in LMICs, through combina ons of pro-poor income growth, reduced food loss and waste, and a cost accoun ng that includes the cost of diet related climate and health.8 Solution 2: Protect and promote healthy, traditional diets In some regions, traditional diets are closely aligned with the principles of the Planetary Health Diet.147,405,406 While it is important to acknowledge that not all traditional diets are inherently healthy or sustainable in their current form, they frequently embody a deep connec on to the local environment, biological diversity, agricultural practices, cultural beliefs, and long-standing adaptations to available resources.149,407 However, revitalizing traditional diets pose significant challenges. Efforts 86 2288 2289 2290 2291 2292 2293 2294 2295 2296 2297 2298 2299 2300 2301 2302 2303 2304 2305 2306 2307 2308 2309 2310 such as the promo on of millets in India and anchovetas in Peru illustrate the difficulty and resistance such initiatives can face, often due to opposi on from entrenched commercial or political interests.408 Amid ongoing nutrition transitions and the rapid rise in the supply and demand of ultra-processed foods, it is increasingly urgent to identify, protect, and promote healthy, traditional dietary patterns that are at risk of erosion.145 Various approaches exist that recognise and enhance the cultural, environmental, and nutri onal value of Indigenous and tradi onal diets. These approaches aim to make such diets more desirable, accessible, and affordable.148,409 Cultural valorisa on, including the celebration of traditional foods, can elevate their social status and render them more aspirational.148 For example, the Food and Agriculture Organiza on’s designa on of the “Interna onal Year of Millets” sought to raise awareness of the environmental, climate resilience, and health benefits associated with these crops.410 Incorpora ng tradi onal, healthy foods into national food-based dietary guidelines and nutrition education programs can help safeguard local knowledge and culinary prac ces.409 Moreover, linking these efforts to public procurement policies—such as school feeding programmes— and social protection schemes can magnify their reach and impact. Public investment in local and territorial markets can further strengthen value chains and s mulate demand for underutilized, nutri ous, and locally produced foods.411–414 Similarly, the development and support of local seed systems can play a cri cal role in preserving and scaling up agrobiodiversity, par cularly under-consumed fruits, nuts, legumes and vegetables.415 These species and their wide range of varie es within species have o en been displaced by dominant staples like wheat and rice. Yet, they offer poten ally climate resilience and nutri on benefits, and merit renewed a en on.416 2311 2312 Goal 2: Produce the Planetary Health Diet within Planetary Boundaries 2313 2314 2315 2316 2317 2318 2319 2320 2321 2322 2323 2324 2325 2326 2327 2328 2329 2330 2331 Solution 3: Implement sustainable and ecological intensification In regions characterized by significant yield gaps, policies aimed at increasing productivity through sustainable and ecological intensification (SEI) practices can increase resource use efficiency by lowering the environmental impact per unit of production.417 Conversely, in areas where agricultural productivity is already high, policy efforts should prioritize reducing environmental degradation and pollution associated with intensive farming systems and practices. Securing long-term access to land and water resources is essential to enabling farmers to adopt and implement SEI practices, many of which entail substan al up-front costs and/or require longer time horizons to yield benefits—particularly when used to rehabilitate or recover exhausted or degraded lands.418 Access to land is especially cri cal for women, who frequently face additional and entrenched legal and sociocultural barriers to ownership and control.419 Despite their pivotal role in suppor ng marginal groups and remote communi es, public advisory (extension) services have suffered from chronic underfunding.420 Revitalizing and redesigning these services, with coordinated support from public, private and civil society actors, is essen al to assist farmers in transitioning and adopting new methods towards sustainable prac ces.420 Strategic investments in farmer networks—facilitating knowledge exchange, equipment sharing, and improved market access—can also lower adoption barriers. Brazil's success in promo ng diversified and organic farming through the integra on of farmer networks with suppor ve public policies offers a compelling model.421 87 2332 2333 2334 2335 2336 2337 2338 2339 2340 2341 2342 2343 2344 2345 2346 2347 2348 2349 2350 2351 2352 2353 2354 2355 2356 2357 2358 2359 2360 2361 2362 2363 2364 2365 2366 2367 2368 2369 2370 2371 2372 2373 2374 2375 2376 Addressing the structural imbalances between producers and dominant agribusiness corporations is critical. Strengthening anti-trust legislation and implementing policies to reduce excessive market concentration can reduce systemic barriers to SEI adoption and practices.421 Robust competition policies can foster more equitable pricing for producers, support diversified market structures, and stimulate innovation,14 all while contributing to the resilience of food systems.422,423 In parallel, tighter regulation of food commodity speculation could stabilise producer incomes and create more favourable conditions for long-term investments.424 Both public and private sector investments are needed to support the transition to SEI practices, par cularly in offse ng ini al costs to advance the research and development of innovations and appropriate technologies.425 Investment in labour-saving technologies can reduce the burden of otherwise labour-intensive practices, while crop breeding for high-yielding or climate resilient varie es suited to low chemical input condi ons can improve the productivity and profitability for SEI. Financial mechanisms such as payments for ecosystem services,426 cost-share payments,421 and similar instruments could provide crucial support to farmers shifting towards sustainable prac ces. Historically, most agricultural subsidies have been directed toward a narrow set of staple crops— wheat, rice, maize, soy (for feed), and dairy.417 To realign agricultural produc on to dietary recommenda ons that emphasize increased consump on of legumes, nuts, fruits, and vegetables, subsidies must reform.427 Targeted investment in under-supported foods, alongside research to improve their yield, resilience, and regional adaptability, is essen al to building more sustainable, health promo ng agriculture systems. Solution 4: Halt agricultural conversion of intact ecosystems The multi-model ensemble results indicate a projected 7% decline in agricultural land by 2050 rela ve to 2020 driven by dietary shifts, increased agricultural productivity, and reductions in food loss and waste. However, to limit the expansion of agriculture and aquatic systems into intact systems, a combination of regulatory policies, community management, and multi-sectoral commitments and coordina on are necessary. This may include the strict protection of natural ecosystems, and the suspension or limi ng of logging concessions and commercial fishing licenses in protected areas. It is essen al that these regulations are implemented in ways that minimise leakage, i.e. ensuring that the protection of land and water in one region does not inadvertently result in increased exploita on elsewhere.428 A en on should be given to popula ons inhabi ng or using resources in protected areas. This includes ensuring meaningful stakeholder engagement and where appropriate, empowering leadership by Indigenous communi es.429 Recognizing and securing land and sea tenure rights for these communi es is essen al. Retaining biodiversity intactness can also be compatible with certain forms of sustainable land/water use, such as wild harvesting, selec ve logging with native species, or extensive rangeland management that maintains na ve biodiversity. In such cases, sustainable uses are those that are well below the 10% Human Appropriation of Net Primary Productivity (Table 2), and where biodiversity intactness index values stay well above 95, thereby minimizing impact on species composition.157 Both regional policies and voluntary ini a ves in the EU and the UK have introduced zero deforestation commitments across supply chains.432 While a few region- and commodity-specific commitments have contributed to small reductions in deforestation,433 the evidence of effectiveness of these efforts is 88 2377 2378 2379 2380 2381 2382 2383 2384 2385 2386 2387 2388 2389 2390 2391 2392 2393 2394 2395 2396 2397 2398 2399 2400 2401 2402 2403 2404 2405 2406 2407 2408 2409 2410 2411 limited, as they are still understudied and relatively new.434,435 Yet, these initiatives have spurred progress in monitoring, traceability, and awareness of deforestation, and expanding their implementation to cover a larger share of the market could greatly increase their impact on global deforestation reduc on.435 2412 Goal 3: Secure Social Foundations 2413 2414 2415 2416 2417 2418 2419 2420 2421 Solution 6: Secure decent work Solution 5: Reduce food loss and waste The ensemble scenario results indicate that halving food loss and waste (FLW), in alignment with SDG target 12.3, yields moderate benefits across all five modelled Planetary Boundaries. Some level of loss or waste is inevitable for food safety and reliability of supply. Food losses and waste can be reduced, so that there is less demand on food produc on, or else recycled into the circular economy (see Panel 4). The ‘Food Waste Pyramid’436 outlines a hierarchy of recycling management options based on financial and environmental returns: depending on context, the highest priority is usually to feed waste to livestock (though livestock numbers are reduced in one of the EAT-Lancet scenarios), followed by industrial uses—including anaerobic diges on for biogas and other products—then compos ng, incinera on, and finally, landfill disposal. In lower-income contexts, food loss predominantly occurs at the produc on and post-harvest stages, whereas in higher-income contexts, consumer-level food waste is the main contributor.437 Reducing food loss depends on improving storage, transporta on logistics, and access to labour and equipment to ensure mely harvests and transforma on of crops into food products sought a er by the consumer. In some cases, shortening supply chains may reduce food loss by reducing the need for extended storage and distribu on. Circular economy opportunities—such as the produc on of lowcost high-quality animal feed, renewable energy usage, and improved food safety—can provide demonstrable benefits (see Panel 4).438 To address food waste in households, food service, and retail, education ini a ves, awareness campaigns, and skill-building remain the primary institutional tools. Technical interven ons focus on leveraging data and analytics to improve the efficiency of food supply chains. To raise effectiveness of these soft tools, they should be complemented by regulatory measures, taxes and subsidies.439 More systemic resolution of food waste must confront underlying drivers, ins tu onal lock-ins, and rebound effects.440 For example, aesthe c standards and preferences (e.g., size, colour, blemishes) imposed by markets contribute to supply chain losses and consumer waste. Similarly, current food safety laws and regula ons, combined with exis ng investments in infrastructure, o en favour incineration or landfill over alterna ve uses such as feeding waste to animals. There are several measures that can be implemented to ensure that work within food systems is safe, dignified, and equitable without discrimination based on gender, race, or other forms of difference. Securing decent work requires, among other ac ons, raising wages for food system workers to living wage levels4 and promo ng gender equitability across all roles and sectors.441 Current workers may be affected by the changes in production and consumption patterns that are essen al for food systems transformation. For example, a reduction in livestock production could impact employment across local, regional, and national scales, depending on how and where such transi ons occur.442 Therefore, improving working conditions and preventing exploitation should include more robust implementation 89 2422 2423 2424 2425 2426 2427 2428 2429 2430 2431 2432 2433 2434 2435 2436 2437 2438 2439 2440 2441 2442 2443 2444 2445 2446 2447 2448 2449 2450 2451 2452 2453 2454 2455 2456 2457 2458 2459 2460 2461 2462 2463 2464 2465 and enforcement of legislation against child labour and forced labour,443 protection from exposure to agricultural pollutants,444 and preven on of gender-based violence and sexual harassment in the workplace.445 Governments should also priori ze educa onal ini a ves and legal support mechanisms for workers to strengthen the enforcement and uptake of such protec ons. Solution 7: Ensure meaningful voice and representation Securing meaningful voice and representation is cri cal to ensuring that decision-making processes in food systems are more democratic and inclusive. Collective bargaining mechanisms, supported and implemented through unions and civil society organiza ons, can advocate effectively for the rights and interests of food systems workers and small-scale producers and actors. For policies concerning both production and consumption, the proactive engagement of diverse coalitions and perspec ves — including unions, civil society actors, and marginalised populations—can foster more democratic and participatory decision-making governance.330 Although these processes may be slowed by disagreements and trade-offs, expert facilitation and the establishment of clear procedural guidelines can help ensure momentum and constructive progress.330 Importantly, such inclusive platforms can contribute to improved food systems governance by enabling interaction among actors across sectors and scales,446 while empowering local institutions and promoting decentralised decision-making authority.447 Power imbalances similarly affect consumers, who often have limited influence over the terms of food access, affordability, and quality.423 Ensuring consumer representation through regulatory mechanisms, participatory food policy councils, and consumer advocacy groups can help rebalance these asymmetries and strengthen individual and collective agency within food system governance.448 Addi onal measures to democra ze food systems include the alloca on of reserved seats in policy forums for marginalised groups,449 the ins tu onalisa on of citizens’ assemblies and consultations.450 Efforts to counter corporate influence and concentra on should involve stricter regula ons on political donations, mechanisms to mitigate conflicts of interest, and greater transparency in lobbying and the funding of scientific research.14 Policies to address corporate concentra on should include strengthened na onal and interna onal compe on frameworks,14 alongside regulatory mechanisms to iden fy, monitor, and mi gate undue corporate influence on policy and governance processes. Deliberate efforts to build inclusive coalitions that include marginalised groups while also increasing transparency and accountability and expanding access to information can create new spaces for dialogue. Solution 8: Recognise and protect marginalised groups Embedding justice into decision-making processes ensures that the responsibility for advocacy does not fall dispropor onately on marginalised groups. The implementation of a comprehensive set of social protection policies can improve access to, and affordability of, healthy and sustainable diets. Social protection measures—including school meals (Panel 11), unconditional cash transfers, maternity entitlements, old age pension, and disability benefits—are broad-based interven ons that directly or indirectly improve food security and nutri on.4,451 90 2466 2467 2468 2469 2470 2471 2472 2473 2474 2475 2476 2477 2478 2479 Addi onal strategies include targe ng financial support for women farmers, crop and livestock insurance to buffer against shocks, subsidies for farm inputs and technologies, and food price stabilisation mechanisms such as internationally coordinated food storage policies.452 Ensuring that solutions are co-created with marginalised communi es can help create context-specific solutions that are socially acceptable.453 Co-creation should be facilitated through improved representation, as previously discussed, and by engaging directly with affected groups—especially early in the transformation process.454 This also requires sustained support, including funding for inclusive initiatives and training programs that build capacities within marginalised popula ons. Finally, NGOs play a vital role in safeguarding basic human rights for people in conflict-affected areas, and this role should be supported by multilateral organisations and na onal governments. Interventions may include establishing safe zones as a short-term measure, rebuilding food supply chains with interna onal assistance in the medium term, and crea ng dedicated funding mechanisms to prevent and alleviate famines in conflict areas over the longterm.327 2480 Adopt responsible, equitable technology and innovation across solutions 2481 2482 2483 2484 2485 2486 2487 2488 2489 2490 2491 2492 2493 2494 2495 2496 2497 2498 2499 2500 2501 2502 While none of the solutions explicitly focus on emerging technologies, technological innovation is relevant across food system transforma on. Emerging technologies—such as artificial intelligence, cellular agriculture, nanotechnology, and robotics—have the poten al to significantly reshape and disrupt agriculture and food systems.367,455 These innova ons could enhance agricultural productivity without expanding land use, thereby contribu ng to reduced deforestation and habitat loss. They may also facilitate precision farming, reduce waste, and optimize the use of key inputs like water and fertilizers.367 The effec veness of these technologies will depend on balanced and strategic investments that align their development, deployment, and use with principles of equity, responsible innovation, and coherent policy frameworks,456,457 as well as the broader transition to renewable energy sources. Redirecting public and private funding toward near-ready technologies that support the solutions described in this report will be critical. Comprehensive evaluation of emerging technologies— considering their impacts across different geographical and cultural contexts—is essen al to ensure they contribute to just food systems transformations.458 This includes recognizing that technologies can have both positive and negative effects, many of which remain uncertain—par cularly in the case of rapidly advancing tools like ar ficial intelligence. To avoid and or mi gate unintended environmental and social trade-offs, investments should be carefully targeted to ensure broad accessibility and fair distribu on of the technologies.455,457 Among the most discussed technologies relevant to dietary shifts are novel alternatives to replacing conven onal meat. Panel 10 explores their potential implications for health, environment, and justice. Panel 10: The poten al role of meat alterna ves in mee ng EAT-Lancet targets The Commission recommends a plant-rich diet with large shares of protein coming from minimally processed plant foods, such as legumes (Sec on Healthy Diets). We also find that globally, and in most regions, consump on of red meat and other meats is above healthy and sustainable levels. As consumer studies have revealed several barriers to replacing animal protein sources with tradi onal plant protein sources, including convenience, taste, and cultural values, P92 a range of meat alterna ves are emerging across several regions, par cularly in HICs. They include plant-based alterna ves (PBAs), 91 fermenta on-derived products (using microorganisms to produce protein-rich foods), and cul vated meat from animal cells designed to replicate the sensory proper es of animal-source foods.P92 Previous systema c reviewsP94,P95 and modelling studiesP96,P97 suggest that replacing conven onal meat with these alterna ves could have both posi ve and nega ve implica ons on health, environment, and jus ce. The poten al impacts are context-dependent and vary based on the specific ingredients, processing levels, and what they replace within the diet. Environmental Implica ons It is well established that whole high-protein plant foods and tradi onal products prepared from these foods (tofu, tempeh) have lower environmental impacts than animal foods. Meta-analyses and modelling studies indicate that PBAs can also have substan ally lower environmental impacts compared to meat, par cularly regarding greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and land use, but greater impacts than minimally processed plant foods.P94,P95,P97 Cul vated meat and fermenta on-derived products are an cipated to have higher GHG emissions than PBAs and minimally processed plant foods, and lower to similar GHG emissions, land and water use compared to conven onal meat, with its impact reduc on poten al being largely dependent on the transi on to renewable energy sources.P93,P98 Health Implica ons Replacing red meat with legumes and other plant protein sources can provide several health benefits. The nutri onal performance of emerging meat alterna ves varies widely based on each product´s specific formula on, levels of processing, nutri onal composi on and density, and what they are replacing in the diet. PBAs that contain substan al amounts of legumes, vegetables, and nuts are found to have favourable nutri onal profiles,P95 contribu ng to higher intake of fibre and folate, and lower saturated fat intake.P94,P97 However, some PBAs are highly processed, high in added sugar, salt, and saturated fat. Further research is required on the bioavailability of vitamins and minerals as well as the protein quality of PBAs and fermenta on-based alterna ves for a be er understanding of the nutri onal effects of integra ng them into diets. Cul vated meat is expected to have a similar nutri onal profile as conven onal meat and might therefore be similarly associated with colorectal cancer and other diet-related diseases.P97 The recommended consump on levels of processed meat alterna ves remain similar to those of conven onal meat in Table 1. Jus ce Implica ons There is less understanding of the role of emerging meat alterna ves on socio-economic consequences including food and nutri on security. Price is a key driver of purchase and consump on. While unprocessed legumes are least expensive, PBAs are currently o en more expensive than the products they aim to replace.P97 Cul vated meats are currently not widely available, but despite high uncertain es, the exis ng peer-reviewed assessments not related to industry interests suggest it will not be a cost-compe ve product even with substan al investment and improved produc on methods.P99–101 The alterna ve meat industry could have addi onal implica ons for the labour market, e.g., by genera ng and shi ing employment from rural areas to ci es.P93,P102 As many large transna onal food corpora ons enter the emerging market for meat alterna ves, there are concerns regarding further market concentra on/consolida on in the form of protein companies.P102,P103 Emerging alterna ves may mi gate animal welfare concerns, although cul vated meat s ll involves some animal use through ssue biopsy removal.P104 92 2503 2504 93 2505 Sec on 6: A Just Food Systems Transforma on is possible 2506 2507 2508 2509 2510 2511 2512 2513 2514 The magnitude of changes needed to shi from an unsustainable ‘status quo' to the outcomes advocated for in this Commission are admi edly enormous. Figure 14 illustrates the differences between the present state, the projected trajectory under business-as-usual (BAU) scenarios for environmental and dietary pa erns from the DIA-GIO model, and the projected trajectory needed for desired future state aligned with global adop on of the Planetary Health Diet, food system boundaries, and social founda ons by 2050. For all the variables where we have modelled current trends (a-i), is shown how substan ally different the future trajectory needs to be compared to the current one. 2515 2516 2517 2518 2519 2520 2521 2522 2523 2524 2525 2526 2527 2528 2529 2530 Figure 14. The development trajectories needed to meet the Commission‘s suggested targets for produc on of food groups to support the Planetary Health Diet, impacts on Food Planetary Boundaries, and associated annual and decadal rate of change required to meet targets in 2050. Environment targets (a,b,c,d,e) are based on the food system boundaries (Table 2). Note that irriga on water withdrawal required is based on aggregated regional overshoot of ecological flow requirements in water basins. Global produc on targets (f,g,h,i) are based on food demand following Planetary Health Diet implementa on and halving of FLW under SSP2 based on DIAGIO model results. BAU trajectories for the produc on and environmental targets are also based on DIA-GIO model results (Modelling sec on). Social founda ons (j,k,l) are based on ensuring everyone is above the social founda on (i.e. 100% of the global popula on), where trajectories show the current global popula on (%) that is below each social founda on, based on recent es mates (Jus ce sec on). To accelerate progress, the Commission calls for the development of transforma ve roadmaps to ensure that, by 2050, all individuals have access to healthy diets that are equitably produced, processed, and distributed within planetary boundaries. These roadmaps should be tailored to different sectors, scales, actors, and geographies. We propose five steps to guide their development: 94 2531 2532 2533 2534 2535 2536 2537 (1) establish context-specific bundles of ac ons and policies; (2) set and track targets that enable collec ve ac on and transparent accountability; (3) build coali ons of diverse actors; (4) iden fy and address barriers to change; and (5) unlock financial resources for transforma on. These steps broadly align with prior work to develop implementa on roadmaps for food systems,161,367,459,460 climate, and biodiversity.27 In the sec ons that follow, we elaborate on each step, highligh ng its ra onale and the enabling condi ons for its success. 2538 Establish context-specific bundles of ac ons and policies 2539 2540 2541 2542 2543 2544 2545 2546 2547 2548 2549 2550 2551 2552 2553 2554 2555 2556 2557 2558 2559 2560 2561 2562 2563 2564 2565 2566 2567 2568 2569 2570 2571 2572 2573 2574 2575 All solu ons iden fied earlier (Figure 13) contribute to a specific goal (health, sustainability, or jus ce), with poten al posi ve or nega ve addi onal contribu ons to other goals. For example, fiscal policies aimed at promo ng healthy diets (Ac on 1) can yield co-benefits for both public health and environmental sustainability. However, such policies may generate trade-offs with jus ce unless accompanied by public investments in social protec on that increase purchasing power for lowincome households (Ac on 3, 15 and 22-23). While these interven ons may independently contribute to shi s in produc on management and consump on pa erns toward more sustainable and equitable outcomes, their transforma ve poten al is fully realized only when implemented as contextually appropriate bundles of mutually reinforcing ac ons. Bundling is the implementa on of mul ple ac ons simultaneously or in an inten onally staggered manner. We refer to bundles as ‘a coherent set of interven ons designed explicitly to achieve a single or mul ple objec ves of interest’.9 An example of an ac on bundle is the UK ini a ve ‘A blue print to halve obesity’ in five years, which comprises more than 30 inten onally integrated policies spanning different domains.462 Bundling has been proposed as a necessary condi on for food systems transforma on.27,461 Iden fying and bundling ac ons is an inherently social process that requires coopera on and coordina on beyond the implementa on of singular policy or technical measures.461 It extends beyond policy coherence by addressing both short- and long-term objec ves, demanding a en on to the governance of transi on.463 Resistance to change, o en mobilized by actors adversely affected by specific measures, can constrain implementa on.461 Systema c bundling offers a means to mi gate trade-offs between poli cal feasibility and policy effec veness.27,464 It can also increase the acceptability of measures by, for example, combining ac ons that increase costs for consumers (e.g., taxes on meat), with those that offer discounts on low-emission food alterna ves.464 Integra ng social protec on mechanisms or retraining opportuni es with priori zed interven ons can help mi gate resistance by addressing short-term vulnerabili es associated with structural transi ons.461 For instance, combining ac ons to shi dietary pa erns (Solu on 1) and improve sustainable and ecological intensifica on of healthy food groups (Solu on 3) with the provision of training in skills to support redeployment (Ac on 16) can support the broader goal of securing decent work (Solu on 6). Well-sequenced and gradually enacted policies can generate posi ve pping points,465 whereby early successful interven ons build public trust and facilitate broader acceptance of subsequent reforms. In contexts where interven ons are met with scep cism or bias, combining interven ons with robust evalua ons can foster support over me, allowing ci zens to engage with the interven ons directly and observe its effects.466 Careful policy sequencing is therefore cri cal: poorly med or misaligned reforms can erode confidence in government abili es, undermining legi macy for future ini a ves. 95 2576 2577 2578 2579 2580 2581 2582 2583 2584 2585 2586 2587 2588 2589 2590 2591 2592 2593 2594 2595 2596 2597 2598 2599 2600 2601 2602 2603 2604 2605 2606 2607 2608 2609 2610 2611 2612 2613 2614 2615 2616 2617 For example, changes in agricultural management require me to build the necessary skills and condi ons to adopt sustainable and ecological prac ces. In Sri Lanka, the abrupt ban on agrochemicals in pursuit of organic agriculture failed to account for the me required to train farmers in organic techniques, build soil organic ma er, and develop integrated pest management prac ces.467 This led to collapsing yields, which could have been avoided with a more phased and strategically sequenced policy roll out. Similar challenges have arisen in the Netherlands with the implementa on of nitrogen regula ons,468 and in France, where the fuel tax contributed to the emergence of the Yellow Vest movement.469 2618 Set and track targets to enable collec ve ac on and accountability 2619 2620 Target-se ng has emerged as a strategy to align diverse actors around shared ambi ons and responsibili es, improve policy integra on, and help overcome barriers to transforma on.463 Global Governments can enhance their ability to effec vely bundle, sequence, and priori se interven ons through ins tu onal mechanisms that foster cross-sectoral collabora on—such as inter-ministerial coordina on—and by partnering more closely with research organisa ons. A compelling example of this type of partnership is Brazil’s Fome Zero (Zero Hunger) Program470, which integrated efforts across Ministries of Health, Educa on, and Social Development, in collabora on with research organisa ons. The program strategically bundled policies including cash transfers for poor households, support for small-scale farmers, and nutri on educa on to address food insecurity and promote sustainable agriculture.470,471 Priori zing different ac ons in different regions Bundles of ac ons for food system transforma on will vary significantly across contexts. For example, consump on side ac ons to achieve the PHD (Solu on 1) need to be a high priority in HICs and upper MICs, as per capita consump on contributes dispropor onately to transgressing planetary boundaries. The per capita externality costs to human health and ecosystems are nearly four mes higher in North America and Oceania than in Sub-Saharan Africa,472 despite the rela ve burden of these costs (as a share of GDP) being greater in LICs. HICs8 also bear a greater responsibility for reducing energy-related emissions and suppor ng food systems improvements in LMICs,473 efforts that are essen al to achieving the mi ga on pathway modelled in this Commission (ELM). Accordingly, the societal benefits of dietary shi s towards the PHD would be especially high in HICs and upper MICs.8 In many LICs and MICs, priori es should instead include maintaining exis ng healthy dietary pa erns (especially among youth), addressing hunger and undernutri on, and preven ng expansion of unhealthy diets (Solu on 2). MICs, in par cular, have the greatest overall poten al to reduce food systems-related climate emissions on the produc on side by shi ing toward more sustainable agricultural prac ces (e.g. Solu on 3) and adop ng cleaner, more circular processing systems (incl. Solu on 5).473 Others474 work that includes stakeholder consulta ons on regional food systems priori es have highlighted the following priori za on focal areas: increasing food availability in East and Southern Africa; promo ng income growth in West and Central Africa; improving the nutri onal quality of diets in the Pacific; and protec ng against deforesta on in La n America. 96 2621 2622 2623 2624 2625 2626 2627 2628 2629 2630 2631 2632 2633 2634 2635 2636 2637 2638 2639 2640 2641 2642 2643 2644 2645 2646 2647 2648 2649 2650 2651 2652 2653 2654 2655 2656 2657 2658 2659 2660 2661 2662 2663 2664 targets can shape interna onal agendas and catalyse bold policies across mul ple scales. For example, net-zero emissions targets aligned with the Paris Agreement—while insufficient on their own—have nonetheless accelerated progress in carbon markets (e.g., the EU Emissions Trading System TS) and spurred rapid expansion of renewable energy development. The iden fica on of PHD reference values and ranges, food system boundaries, and social founda ons represents an ini al step toward establishing science-based targets for food systems. While global targets can foster a shared vision and ambi on, their transla on into concrete ac ons across scales and sectors is essen al for achieving meaningful impact.475 Such target se ng should be grounded in independent scien fic assessments, be a ainable and ac onable, and supported by a transparent analy cal ra onale. Their achievement must be measurable.476 Science-based targets are most effec ve when developed and implemented through inclusive dialogues with diverse stakeholders.477 There is a cri cal need for methodological advancements to enable disaggrega on of targets (and their indicators) across geographic scales (local, municipal, na onal, global) and across sectors.476 Recently, there has been a growing uptake of voluntary science-based target commitments by companies, ci es (see e.g. Panel 12), and na onal governments—such as wide adop on of the ‘Voluntary Guidelines on Food Systems and Nutri on’, established by the Commi ee on World Food Security.478 Voluntary commitments have corresponded with increased ac on,479 especially in the climate domain. Corporate ini a ves can drive transforma on by leveraging their leadership posi ons, enabling mutual learning among adopters of science-based targets, and fostering trust and compe veness through engagement with expert groups and accountability mechanisms.480 However, research on voluntary science-based target se ng remains nascent. Emerging evidence suggests that without effec ve implementa on, monitoring and evalua on, such commitments may risk hindering transforma ve change—e.g., by legi mising powerful corporate actors and insula ng them from democra c oversight.479 To accelerate progress and ensure measurable improvements, transi oning science-based targets from voluntary frameworks to regulatory mechanisms is essen al.478 Ensure monitoring and evalua on of targets and ac ons Improved monitoring across food systems is essen al for monitoring progress towards proposed targets, and informing adap ve, evidence-based decision-making. Recent calls from the scien fic community have emphasized the need for monitoring frameworks that move beyond tracking isolated indicators and instead integrated, mul -layered, cross-sectoral data—bridging analyses that have tradi onally been treated in silos.482,483 Such approaches enhance compliance and accountability.482 One example is the Food System Countdown to 2030 Ini a ve29,460 which promotes greater accountability and transparency through comprehensive global monitoring of food systems across five domains: diets, nutri on, and health; environment, natural resources, and produc on; livelihoods, poverty, and equity; governance; and resilience.29,484 Robust monitoring and evalua on (M&E) systems are also important for suppor ng learnings about what works, par cularly given the limited contextspecific evidence on the effec veness of food system interven ons, par cularly when bundled.27 M&E 97 2665 2666 2667 2668 2669 2670 2671 2672 2673 2674 2675 2676 2677 2678 2679 2680 2681 2682 2683 frameworks must therefore facilitate itera ve refinement of strategies and ac ons in response to emerging evidence and shi ing condi ons.486 2684 Build coali ons of diverse actors 2685 2686 2687 2688 2689 2690 2691 2692 2693 2694 2695 2696 2697 2698 2699 2700 2701 2702 2703 2704 2705 2706 2707 2708 2709 Effec ve bundling of ac ons requires coali ons of actors to nego ate between contending interests, navigate difficult choices,367,461 and ensure that the necessary capaci es are deployed for transforma on.490 The recent UN Food Systems Summit highlighted coali ons as essen al for addressing food systems' mul -sectoral and mul -scalar challenges, leading to over 20 coali ons being formed to deal with issues like school meals (Panel 11), deforesta on, agroecology, blue foods, data transparency, and fair wages.491 The current evidence gaps, combined with the urgent need for ac on, underscore the need to improve science-policy interfaces through greater integra on, itera on, and interac on among researchers, policy actors and stakeholders across society487,488. Effec ve M&E frameworks should be co-developed by mul ple stakeholders—including government, industry, civil society, and research ins tu ons.367,457 While scien fic assessments play a key role in synthesising exis ng knowledge, novel tools are required to evaluate the impacts of bundled and sequenced interven ons rather than isolated ac ons.489 Stronger alignment between global and sub-global assessments—such as those from the Lancet Commissions, the Food System Economic Commission, the High-Level Panel of Experts on Food Security and Nutri on, and IPES-Food—and corresponding assessments on climate, environment, biodiversity health, and jus ce (e.g., with IPCC, IPBES, and the Earth Commission to name a few) would enhance the capacity to integrate and leverage collec ve knowledge across domains.483 Na onal food system pathways, supported by the UN Food Systems Summit, offer a mely opportunity to develop integrated roadmaps that connect food system transforma on with climate, biodiversity, health, and economic objec ves. Coali ons can bring a variety actors with divergent interests and perspec ves to the table to nego ate more inclusive, viable, and realis c pathways.487 Food policies will have different winners and losers, and tensions will need to be managed.9 For instance, fear of job losses in certain sectors can paralyse reforms towards sustainability. In such cases, coali ons could nego ate ways to compensate those who stand to lose or invest in new opportuni es that would benefit them.9 Different food system actors have varying capaci es to enact change. Interven ons that could enable system shi s have some mes stalled, o en due to delays and bo lenecks in regulatory processes.4 Communi es, Interna onal NGOs, and other stakeholders can deploy different capabili es to support transforma on in different ways. By forming stronger alliances and coali ons, these actors can implement more coordinated and mely interven ons for transforma ve change.492 Realizing food systems transforma on will require novel forms of partnership among inter-governmental and global ins tu ons, na onal governments, sub-na onal public authori es (e.g., ci es, states, and municipali es), and inter-ministerial commi ees can align policies across sectors. Engagement from the private sector, civil society, and social movements is equally cri cal.473 Different actors bring dis nct capaci es and mandates, each playing a unique role in shaping systemic change.458 Transforma on cannot occur without forging coali ons that span boundaries, reconcile divergent interests, and build broad-based legi macy for new policy pathways.490,493 Ini a ves such as the UN Zero Hunger coali on, 98 2710 2711 2712 2713 the EU Farm to Fork policy framework, and the School Meals Coali on (Panel 11) illustrate how diverse competencies and agendas can be integrated to advance health, environmental sustainability, and jus ce in tandem. 2714 Iden fy and address barriers to change 2715 2716 2717 2718 2719 2720 2721 2722 2723 2724 2725 2726 2727 2728 2729 2730 2731 2732 2733 2734 2735 2736 2737 2738 2739 2740 2741 2742 2743 2744 2745 2746 2747 2748 2749 2750 2751 2752 Coali ons aiming to advance food systems transforma on involve actors and stakeholders with different interests and tac cs to preserve such interests, some mes designed to maintain the status quo.494,495 These compe ng interests shape the incen ves and constraints surrounding transforma ve efforts.461 For coali ons to func on effec vely, three key barriers must be addressed: (1) lack of poli cal leadership; (2) corporate interests; and (3) weak and fragmented demand for ac on. Lack of poli cal leadership and appropriate governance framework Poli cal leadership has been notably absent in driving transforma ve food policy agendas and commi ng resources to long-term structural change to food systems.423 Short electoral cycles o en discourage support for policies whose benefits, such as improvements in popula on health, are realized beyond a single poli cal term. This hesitancy is compounded by substan al upfront investments required for transforma on, and the perceived risks these pose to, for example, employment and food prices.9,496 Moreover, government subsidies o en favour large corporate actors over broader public welfare and public goods.497 Effec ve transforma on requires coordinated, intersectoral policy ac ons that extend beyond food systems themselves. Yet current governance arrangements o en fall short to systema cally address and integrate agriculture and the environment, health and nutri on, infrastructure, energy, growth, and equity.484 Corporate interests used against public interests The second major barrier is the exercise of corporate power in ways that undermine public interests. The high degree of corporate concentra on across food systems remains an intractable governance issue.333,498 This is partly due to the out-sized influence of large transna onal food and beverage companies who have considerable power and resources at their disposal to block ini a ves.17 Concentrated market structures, with a few dominant firms, are common in food systems from produc on (agricultural inputs), trade (commodity trade), and consump on (food processing and retail),14,499 that impact people’s access to food e.g. through manipula ve pricing, as well as adver sing and packaging that shapes consumers’ preferences.500 Corporate actors employ tac cs such as direct lobbying of governmental officials to undermine poli cal priori es, including dietary guidelines and regulatory interven ons.501 Another avenue of influence by corporate interests is in the sponsorship of scien fic studies that aligns with commercial interests and the dissemina on of misinforma on aimed at discredi ng independent scien fic evidence—such as in cases involving meat industry-sponsored scien sts.502,503 Furthermore, public-private partnerships are increasingly co-opted by corporate actors to shape discourses, par cularly in the area of sustainability, in ways that reinforce their legi macy and market power.504,505 Weak and fragmented demand for ac on 99 2753 2754 2755 2756 2757 2758 2759 2760 2761 2762 2763 2764 2765 2766 2767 2768 2769 2770 2771 2772 2773 2774 2775 A perceived lack of effec ve public demand and acceptance for transforma ve change is frequently cited by policymakers and private sector actors as jus fica on for depriori sing ambi ous reforms. Ci zens may resist policies that ul mately serve the public due to the difficulty of weighing short-term costs, par cularly in terms of employment in affected sectors, against long-term benefits.466,486 While grassroot actors play a cri cal role in building public engagement and poli cal momentum for more equitable and sustainable food systems,506 their efforts are o en fragmented and constrained by entrenched power dynamics and the structural inequi es of food systems.499,507 In some repressive poli cal contexts, civil society and grassroot organisa ons are deliberately excluded or marginalized by authoritarian regimes, further silencing calls for change. In other contexts, grassroot mobilisa on can itself become a source of polarisa on with some backing policies that might not promote public good over the long term. Fragmenta on in public demand can also stem from a lack of consensus on priori es and insufficient space for dialogue—par cularly facilitated, inclusive processes that can clarify areas of disagreement and forge common ground.477 These challenges are especially pronounced with global commitment mechanisms—such as the Paris Agreement or the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework— into local or na onal ac ons.21 Misinforma on further compounds public disengagement, especially when systemic challenges like public health are framed as ma ers of individual responsibility. This framing distorts public understanding of the structural determinants and diminishes support for necessary reforms.508 The absence of transparent monitoring systems exacerbates the problem by undermining public trust in transforma onal policies and fostering uncertainty or misconcep ons about their poten al for delivering broad-based benefits.509 2776 2777 Unlock financial resources for transforma on 2778 2779 2780 2781 2782 2783 2784 2785 2786 2787 2788 2789 2790 2791 2792 2793 2794 2795 2796 It has been suggested that financial resources, averaging US$500 billion each year between now and 2050, are needed to enable necessary food systems transforma ons.9 However, benefits could amount to more than 5 trillion a year.9 Importantly, not all ac ons require large amounts of financial resources to be successful. Some can be implemented at rela vely low cost or can even be cost neutral. However, they require willingness to repriori ze current resource spending. Here, we first look at the poten al to unlock resources within the food system, primarily through bundling of different ac vi es that already happens in the food system. We then explore how to unlock resources by bundling with broader policy agendas. Repurposing subsidies, and other food systems investments Subsidies to the agriculture sector represent a significant resource es mated at roughly US$851 billion in the 2020-2022 period (for the 54 countries that report to the Organiza on for Economic Coopera on and Development). The Food Systems Economic Commission has es mated that the cost of food systems transforma on is between US$200-500 billion per year.9 Without changing the degree of financing provided to food produc on, se ng clear condi ons for the use of these currently earmarked public funds in favour of public goods such as public health, and environmental security would be a major first step towards transforma on.417 At least a third of agricultural subsidies have no public benefit and could be repurposed.510 In the EU, 82% of the European Union’s agricultural subsidies favour animal-based agriculture.510 Farm sector subsidies could be used to incen vize or invest in 100 2797 2798 2799 2800 2801 2802 2803 2804 2805 2806 2807 2808 2809 2810 2811 2812 2813 2814 2815 2816 2817 2818 2819 2820 2821 2822 2823 2824 2825 2826 2827 2828 2829 2830 2831 2832 2833 2834 2835 2836 2837 2838 2839 2840 2841 sustainable/ecological intensifica on, focusing on management of opportunity crops that are currently neglected in rela on to healthy diet, while promo ng dietary change.427 Fisheries subsidies of around US$35 billion each year, could be used to support sustainable aqua c produc on prac ces rather than contribute to falling fish stocks and declining profitability, which in turn fuels more over-fishing as well as environmentally damaging forms land-based aquaculture.511 Shi s in agricultural and other subsidies, or value-added tax (VAT) can reduce health costs and increase health benefits, while lowering climate impacts.380 Health directed taxa on of meat products could yield a 9% decrease in premature deaths associated with red and processed meat consump on, with an es mated 14% decrease in a ributable health costs globally, notably in high and middle-income countries.380 Measures that seek to distribute income more equitably (via e.g. social protec on measures or progressive tax policies), combined with a serious public and private sector commitment to reducing food loss and waste along all food value chains, can together improve the rela ve affordability of healthy dietary pa erns. When these and other measures were combined in a previous modelling effort, the cost of Planetary Health Diet aligned diets fell by 25-29% in low-income to lower middleincome countries.8 However, the substan al restructuring of any sector, including the ‘repurposing’ of any kind of subsidy should be handled with care, since the poten al unintended effects of shi ing resources from one targeted purpose to another can be as significant as the intended effects.512 Alignment of investments with the climate-, nature/biodiversity-, and economic agendas Another way to unlock resources for food systems transforma on is to align approaches and financial priori es with other cri cally and mutually interdependent policy and investment agendas. A share of climate or biodiversity finance funding could be turned towards food systems transforma on. For example, at the Conference of Par es (COP) climate summit in Egypt in 2022 (COP27), the COP Presidency and World Health Organiza on launched the Ini a ve on Climate Ac on and Nutri on (ICAN), to be er integrate the global delivery of climate change adapta on and mi ga on goals and the policy ac on necessary to meet nutri on and sustainable food systems goals.513 This alignment requires future summit agendas, focused on climate, fossil fuels, renewable energy, employment growth, food systems, and more, to work towards integra on of targets and investment modali es. However, many ini a ves currently lack coherence and alignment with agriculture and other policies at different levels. This is the case, for instance, of the many ini a ves on tree plan ng which, if showing considerable benefits for food security, nutri on and the environment, remain largely uncoordinated (Vansant 2024.514,515 By ramping up these efforts, governments can work more strategically to integrate and coordinate these mul ple agendas to repurpose fiscal incen ves away from economic “bads” (e.g. carbon emissions, biodiversity destruc on, consump on of excessive sugar, salt or trans-fats, etc.) towards public goods.516 In 2022, subsidies to the energy sector (currently driven by fossil fuels) were es mated to be around US$7 trillion.517 Ending subsidy support to pollu ng energy produc on would allow for a repurposing of resources to alterna ve public sector investments.518 The la er would include regenera ve energy to support diet quality through, for example, solar-powered drying and chilling of perishable foods, and other innova ons in cold chain technologies that significantly reduce nutrient-rich food loss and waste. However, project-level climate financing for food systems stands at only 4.3%, or US$28 billion, of global 101 2842 2843 2844 2845 2846 2847 2848 2849 2850 2851 2852 2853 2854 2855 2856 2857 2858 2859 2860 2861 2862 2863 2864 2865 2866 2867 2868 climate finance for mi ga on and adapta on in all sectors, with specific mi ga on finance in the food sector being only 2.2% of total climate finance.473 In their “Recipes for a Liveable Planet Report”, the World Bank es mates that annual investments in reducing food systems emissions will need to increase by 18 mes, to US$260 billion, to reduce current food system emissions by half by 2030. 473 2869 Conclusions: accelera ng meaningful ac on 2870 2871 2872 2873 2874 2875 2876 2877 2878 2879 2880 2881 2882 2883 2884 2885 2886 The Commission calls for an urgent, comprehensive approach to food systems transforma on, centred on the development of context-specific roadmaps that lay out viable evidence-based solu on sets. Such roadmaps should focus on bundling ac ons, se ng science-based targets, building inclusive coali ons, establishing and building on already exis ng monitoring and accountability mechanisms, and mobilising financial resources at scale. At the core of the Commission's framework are three founda onal elements: (1) recommended food group intake values for the Planetary Health Diet to advance human health; (2) food system planetary boundaries to ensure achieve environmental sustainability; and (3) social founda ons to guide the crea on of just food systems. These values, boundaries, and founda ons can provide the guide for target-se ng and collec ve ac on, adaptable across geographies and sectors. Different ways to unlock finance for food systems transforma on could work if banks, investors, and large businesses adopt and report against the Taskforce on Climate Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), help develop the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosure (TNFD), and set ScienceBased Targets (SBTs), targe ng Paris-aligned/net zero por olios.519 Through these agendas, financial ins tu ons can commit to a variety of por olios to shi towards more sustainable food systems, such as deforesta on-free por olios (e.g., deforesta on-free pension funds). Public spending should also create mechanisms for private investment in food systems transforma on. Central banks can for example introduce stress tes ng for financial ins tu ons based on their viability in a future economy that fully accounts for nega ve externali es. The cost of food systems transforma on for lower-income groups and countries are beyond their current financing capacity. Li ing their financing constraints is cri cal to unlock the global benefits of transforma on.473 Countries with limited fiscal capacity need interna onal support to invest in food systems sustainability.517 Wealthy countries and other donors should increase Overseas Development Assistance (ODA) from current low levels (rela ve to their actual and projected na onal wealth), as well as climate finance for food systems adapta on through mul lateral development finance ins tu ons. Wealthy governments can introduce targeted debt relief to facilitate the flow of capital to food systems transforma ons, including debt for food swaps. This could be supported by innova ve financial instruments, such as guarantees for a new type of perpetual/long-dated social and environmental bond, with capped adjustable rates. The Commission has iden fied eight solu ons and 23 ac ons to enable food systems transforma on. These can be organized into coherent ‘bundles’ of interven ons that simultaneously advance health, environmental and jus ce goals. Bundling enhances poli cal feasibility and policy effec veness, par cularly when designed to priori se the needs of marginalised and disadvantaged popula ons. The most suitable and effec ve bundles will vary by context and should be tailored to the specific challenges and opportuni es of each region and sector. 102 2887 2888 2889 2890 2891 2892 2893 2894 2895 2896 2897 2898 2899 2900 2901 2902 2903 2904 2905 2906 2907 2908 2909 2910 Cross-sectoral coali ons—including actors from public ins tu ons, private sector, and civil society— are essen al to achieve synergis c governance. These coali ons must align with exis ng and emerging global frameworks, such as the Paris Agreement, the Conven on on Biological Diversity, and the post2030 SDG agenda. Ensuring accountability within such coali ons is cri cal. Mechanisms must be established to insulate policymaking from undue corporate influence, while civil society and social movements play a vital role in promo ng transparency and oversight. The Commission also underscores the need for ac ons beyond the food system. Its modelling indicates that the PHD can only be achieved within GHG and land-use planetary boundaries if mi ga on efforts in other sectors are also scaled up. Similarly, shi ing diets among low-income and vulnerable groups requires coupling dietary interven ons with broader social protec on measures. Affordability must be achieved not only by lowering food prices but also by addressing structural poverty and inequi es. Financing for food systems transforma on must draw from broader funding streams—such as those targe ng climate mi ga on and biodiversity conserva on and protec on—rather than relying solely on current food systems financing. Finally, the Commission posi ons jus ce as both a central goal and a driving force for food systems transforma on. Food systems cannot be just without ensuring the PHD is affordable and accessible to all, and without significantly reducing transgressions of planetary boundaries. At the same me, jus ce is necessary to overcome the deeply entrenched structural barriers that currently impede transforma ve change. In this sense, jus ce is not only an outcome of food systems transforma on, but a prerequisite for enabling it. Panel 11: School meals School meals are increasingly recognised as a cost-efficient investment for governments to advance mul ple policy objec ves, including health and nutri on, educa on, social protec on, and agriculture.P105 Well-designed and strategically implemented school meal programmes throughout the next 7,000 days – the period of development between the first 1,000 days of life and adulthood – can make a las ng impact, par cularly on the most vulnerable children and adolescents, by improving a endance and academic performance, and reducing dropout rates.P106 Moreover, school meals programmes make up one of the largest outputs of the global food system, feeding 420 million children daily. Sustainable school meals coupled with consistent and ac onoriented food educa on can empower future genera ons by fostering healthier and more sustainable food habits at a cri cal age when life-long dietary preferences and social a tudes are formed and carried into adulthood. In 2021, in recogni on of the unique poten al of school meals for improving child health, wellbeing, and educa on following the COVID-19 pandemic, na onal governments formed the global School Meals Coali on (SMC), declaring their commitment to scaling up and strengthening their na onal school meals programmes to ensure every child has access to a nutri ous meal at school by 2030. To support the (now) 105 SMC member states to achieve this ambi ous mission, the independent Research Consor um for School Health and Nutri on, with the input of 160 global experts from more 103 than 80 organisa ons, iden fied evidence-based policy approaches to support the delivery of diverse, balanced, and sustainably produced school meals. Since these programmes are overwhelmingly domes cally financed and managed, the policy levers lie in the hands of na onal governments, allowing for significant change to be made at pace. Incorpora ng sustainable school meal policies can lower environmental impact, improve climate resilience and leverage food system transforma on in both high- and low-income se ngs. Key policy strategies to support posi ve change in this area include providing nutrient-rich menus, that are predominantly plant-based; sourcing produc on from local farms using sustainable and ecological intensifica on prac ces that support agrobiodiversity and climate resilience, as well as structured demand and stable markets to smallholder farmers and processors; shi ing to efficient cooking solu ons to reduce nega ve health and environmental impacts; reducing food loss and waste; and ensuring ac onoriented food and climate educa on to enable future genera ons to make sustainable choices. With increased awareness, children also serve as powerful agents of change among their families and broader communi es.P107 Countries and regional bodies are already demonstra ng that these ac ons are possible. Europe, for example, now requires a minimum share of organic foods in school menus, P108 and approximately 40% of na onal school meals programmes currently have agriculture policy objec ves such as agrobiodiversity, food sovereignty, and climate-smart foods.P109 The na onal school meals programme in Brazil legislates that at least 30% of the food used in the prepara on of school meals is locally sourced from family farms.P110 Like Brazil, many countries in Africa and Asia have implemented a food systems approach to school meals, o en involving public-private partnerships. While financing is o en the barrier to scale-up, food-related costs of providing healthy and sustainable school meals to every child could amount to up to 1% of GDP in low-income countries where school meal coverage is low.P111 When weighing the long-term costs of inac on—such as the treatment of diet-related health issues and the impact of greenhouse gas emissions—the case for inves ng in school meals becomes undeniably compelling. The study iden fied savings of US$ 120-200 billion in trea ng diet-related illnesses (including US$ 7-13 billion in low-income countries), and a reduc on in climate change costs of US$ 18-70 billion (including US$ 1-5 billion in low-income countries). The savings were greatest, in each case, for meal composi ons in line with recommenda ons for healthy and sustainable dietary pa erns. In summary, sustainable school meals policies can posi vely influence dietary preferences of the next genera on, and promote the adop on of sustainable produc on prac ces, broaden the local food basket and s mulate crop diversity, along with other social and economic development outcomes. The inclusion of school meals on the climate finance agenda, as well as in Na onally Determined Contribu ons for both health and the environment are cri cal steps to more resilient, sustainable, and equitable food systems. 2911 2912 104 Panel 12: 40 Ci es Ini a ve to achieve the Planetary Health Diet for All by 2030 Launched in October 2019 by C40, a global network of almost 100 mayors of leading ci es commi ed to addressing climate change, 16 ci es signed up to an ambi ous ini a ve aiming to achieve the Planetary Health Diet for all by 2030 in ways that are “reflec ve of the culture, geography, and demography of their residents”. Seven of the ci es are in Europe, five in North America, one in South America, two in East Asia and one in South-East Asia. The ci es signing up pledged to implement four important measures by 2030:  Aligning their food procurement to the Planetary Health Diet.  Suppor ng an overall increase of healthy plant-based food consump on by shi ing away from unsustainable, unhealthy diets.  Reducing food loss and waste by 50% from a 2015 baseline.  Working with residents, businesses, public ins tu ons and other organiza ons to develop a joint strategy for implemen ng these measures and achieving these goals inclusively and equitably and incorpora ng this strategy into Climate Ac on Plans, including incorpora on into na onally determined contribu ons to climate goals. Interim evalua on In September 2023, 15 of the 16 par cipa ng ci es submi ed interim reports on their progress. Sufficient data were provided by seven ci es to quan fy progress towards the first two measures. Between them, these seven ci es serve over 400 million meals a year for different groups and establishments including schools and hospitals. Measured against different baseline years from between 2015 and 2022, ci es reported an increase in their purchasing of plant-sourced protein of 44% (from a mean of 6,356 to 8,667 tonnes) and a decline in their meat purchasing of 19% (from a mean of 16,648 to 12,765 tonnes). In recogni on of its significant poten al in shi ing millions of meals in major ci es to be healthier and more sustainable, this ini a ve won the pres gious US$2-million Food Planet Prize awarded by The Curt Bergfors Founda on, in June 2024. Many examples of progress towards all four measures were described by ci es in the interim evalua on in 2023 including engaging with ci zens, restaurants, store owners and town planners to change food environments so healthier and sustainable op ons are readily available and offering training for businesses on how to reduce food waste. But while excellent examples abound, the extent of progress for each of the four measures across all 16 ci es remains unknown at the me of wri ng because monitoring systems using similar robust metrics across all ci es have yet to be put in place. Barriers to progress reported by ci es Two barriers to progress were commonly reported by par cipa ng ci es: Misaligned na onal procurement standards: Procurement standards don’t include considera on of the environmental impact of foods purchased. To achieve the PHD for all, ci es are having to make the case for, and then implement this change throughout the en re public food supply chain on their own. 105 Insufficient resources for evalua on: Budgetary restric ons, coupled with increasing food prices are curtailing ci es’ capacity to gather data on their progress towards each of the four aims of this ini a ve. Maximising the impact of the C40 Good Food Ci es Ini a ve Providing addi onal resources to C40 Good Food Ci es at this juncture is vital to maximise its impact and value as a global exemplar of transi oning food systems, by achieving the following:  Data collec on: se ng up and running monitoring mechanisms to assess progress and adjust if off-track for achieving its 2030 goal.  Coali ons: se ng up mul -level pla orms to engage different authori es and ci zens to create a shared vision.  Advocacy: support for campaigns and other forms of advocacy to inspire na onal governments and interna onal partners to increase ambi on and ac on at the scale needed to achieve PHD for all. Lessons from C40 all ini a ves needed to achieve the Planetary Health Diet for all Mayors from 16 ci es around the world are leading the way in transforming the food in their ci es. Similar ambi ous ini a ves are now needed in every city, town and village on our planet to achieve the Planetary Health Diet for all. But these pioneering ci es highlight that realizing these ambi ons will require each ini a ve to be matched - at its incep on - by sufficient resources for two core ac vi es:  implemen ng a programme of interven ons built on exis ng evidence;  Robust evalua on, built in from incep on as part of the implementa on plan, so that progress is monitored in real me. This will allow interven ons showing promise to be op mized and those that are ineffec ve to be stopped, and others started. 2913 106 2914 2915 2916 2917 2918 2919 2920 2921 Declara on of genera ve AI and AI-assisted technologies in the wri ng process During the prepara on of this work the corresponding author (FDC) used ChatGTP to produce an ini al execu ve dra of the summary by uploading a pdf of the Commission to the tool. A er using this service, FDC reviewed and edited the content as needed and takes full responsibility for the content of the publica on. 2922 2923 2924 2925 2926 References 1 Wille W, Rockström J, Loken B, et al. Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT–Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems. The Lancet 2019; 393: 447–92. 2927 2928 2 Van Vuuren D, Stehfest E, Gernaat D, et al. The 2021 SSP scenarios of the IMAGE 3.2 model. 2021; published online Oct 11. DOI:10.31223/X5CG92. 2929 2930 2931 3 Mason-D’Croz D, Bogard JR, Sulser TB, et al. Gaps between fruit and vegetable produc on, demand, and recommended consump on at global and na onal levels: an integrated modelling study. Lancet Planet Health 2019; 3: e318–29. 2932 2933 4 HLPE. Reducing inequali es for food security and nutri on. Rome: CFS HLPE-FSN, 2023 h ps://www.fao.org/3/cc6536en/cc6536en.pdf. 2934 2935 5 Huang J, Neufeld LM, Badiane O, Caron P, Forsse LS. Equitable livelihoods must underpin food systems transforma on. Nat Food 2022; 3: 394–6. 2936 2937 6 Afshin A, Sur PJ, Fay KA, et al. Health effects of dietary risks in 195 countries, 1990–2017: a systema c analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. The Lancet 2019; 393: 1958–72. 2938 2939 7 Bai Y, Herforth A, Masters WA. Global varia on in the cost of a nutrient-adequate diet by popula on group: an observa onal study. Lancet Planet Health 2022; 6: e19–28. 2940 2941 2942 8 Springmann M, Clark MA, Rayner M, Scarborough P, Webb P. The global and regional costs of healthy and sustainable dietary pa erns: a modelling study. Lancet Planet Health 2021; 5: e797– 807. 2943 2944 2945 2946 9 Ruggeri Laderchi, C., Lotze-Campen, H., DeClerck, F., et al. The Economics of the Food System Transforma on. Food System Economics Commission (FSEC), Global Policy Report. The Food System Economics Commission, 2024 h ps://foodsystemeconomics.org/wpcontent/uploads/FSEC-Global_Policy_Report.pdf (accessed Jan 29, 2024). 2947 2948 10 FAO, IFAD, UNICEF, WFP, WHO. The State of Food Security and Nutri on in the World 2024. FAO; IFAD; UNICEF; WFP; WHO;, 2024 DOI:10.4060/cd1254en. 2949 2950 11 Selig ER, Nakayama S, Wabnitz CCC, et al. Revealing global risks of labor abuse and illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing. Nat Commun 2022; 13: 1612. 2951 2952 12 Kurtz J, Blackstone NT, Decker Sparks JL, Rodriguez R, Pinto C. The true cost of labour must be worker-defined. Nat Food 2021; 2: 630–1. 107 2953 2954 13 ILO. Global wage report 2020-21: wages and minimum wages in the me of COVID-19. Geneva: INTL LABOUR OFFICE, 2020. 2955 2956 14 Clapp J. The problem with growing corporate concentra on and power in the global food system. Nat Food 2021; 2: 404–8. 2957 2958 2959 15 ILO. ILO declara on on fundamental principles and rights at work and its follow-up. 2022 h ps://www.ilo.org/sites/default/files/2024-04/ILO_1998_Declara on_EN.pdf (accessed Nov 19, 2024). 2960 2961 2962 16 Khan I. Disinforma on and freedom of opinion and expression: report of the Special Rapporteur on the Promo on and Protec on of the Right to Freedom of Opinion and Expression, Irene Khan. Geneva: UN, 2021 h ps://digitallibrary.un.org/record/3925306 (accessed Nov 7, 2024). 2963 2964 2965 17 Wood B, Williams O, Nagarajan V, Sacks G. Market strategies used by processed food manufacturers to increase and consolidate their power: a systema c review and document analysis. Glob Health 2021; 17: 17. 2966 2967 18 Bui LP, Pham TT, Wang F, et al. Planetary Health Diet Index and risk of total and cause-specific mortality in three prospec ve cohorts. Am J Clin Nutr 2024; 120: 80–91. 2968 2969 19 Cacau LT, De Carli E, de Carvalho AM, et al. Development and Valida on of an Index Based on EAT-Lancet Recommenda ons: The Planetary Health Diet Index. Nutrients 2021; 13: 1698. 2970 2971 20 Mosnier A, Javalera-Rincon V, Jones SK, et al. A decentralized approach to model na onal and global food and land use systems. Environ Res Le 2023; 18: 045001. 2972 2973 2974 21 Mosnier A, Schmidt-Traub G, Obersteiner M, et al. How can diverse na onal food and land-use priori es be reconciled with global sustainability targets? Lessons from the FABLE ini a ve. Sustain Sci 2023; 18: 335–45. 2975 2976 22 Mazac R, Järviö N, Tuomisto HL. Environmental and nutri onal Life Cycle Assessment of novel foods in meals as transforma ve food for the future. Sci Total Environ 2023; 876: 162796. 2977 2978 2979 23 Mazac R, Meinilä J, Korkalo L, Järviö N, Jalava M, Tuomisto HL. Incorpora on of novel foods in European diets can reduce global warming poten al, water use and land use by over 80%. Nat Food 2022; 3: 286–93. 2980 2981 24 Kelly L, Kebreab E. Recent advances in feed addi ves with the poten al to mi gate enteric methane emissions from ruminant livestock. J Soil Water Conserv 2023; 78: 111–23. 2982 2983 2984 25 Tulloch AIT, Borthwick F, Bogueva D, et al. How the EAT–Lancet Commission on food in the Anthropocene influenced discourse and research on food systems: a systema c review covering the first 2 years post-publica on. Lancet Glob Health 2023; 11: e1125–36. 2985 2986 2987 2988 2989 26 IPCC. Summary for Policymakers. In: Shukla PR, Skea J, Calvo Buendia E, et al., eds. Climate Change and Land: an IPCC special report on climate change, deser fica on, land degrada on, sustainable land management, food security, and greenhouse gas fluxes in terrestrial ecosystems. 2019. h ps://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/sites/4/2020/02/SPM_UpdatedJan20.pdf. 2990 2991 27 IPBES. IPBES Nexus Assessment on Biodiversity, Water, Food, Health and Climate. Bonn, Germany: IPBES, 2024. 108 2992 2993 2994 28 Singh BK, Fraser EDG, Arnold T, et al. Food systems transforma on requires science–policy– society interfaces that integrate exis ng global networks and new knowledge hubs. Nat Food 2022 2022; : 1–3. 2995 2996 29 Schneider KR, Fanzo J, Haddad L, et al. The state of food systems worldwide in the countdown to 2030. Nat Food 2023; 4: 1090–110. 2997 2998 2999 30 Caron P, Ferrero y de Loma-Osorio G, Nabarro D, et al. Food systems for sustainable development: proposals for a profound four-part transforma on. Agron Sustain Dev 2018; 38: 41. 3000 3001 3002 3003 31 DeClerck FAJ, Koziell I, Benton T, et al. A Whole Earth Approach to Nature-Posi ve Food: Biodiversity and Agriculture. In: von Braun J, Afsana K, Fresco LO, Hassan MHA, eds. Science and Innova ons for Food Systems Transforma on. Cham: Springer Interna onal Publishing, 2023: 469–96. 3004 3005 32 DeClerck F, Barrios E, Benton TG, et al. Biodiversity, agriculture and sustainable produc on: GBF Target 10. PLOS Sustain Transform 2023; 2: e0000048. 3006 3007 3008 33 Gupta J, Bai X, Liverman DM, et al. A just world on a safe planet: a Lancet Planetary Health–Earth Commission report on Earth-system boundaries, transla ons, and transforma ons. Lancet Planet Health 2024; 8: e813–73. 3009 3010 34 Rockström J, Gupta J, Qin D, et al. Safe and just Earth system boundaries. Nature 2023; 619: 102– 11. 3011 3012 3013 35 FAO, WHO. What are healthy diets? Joint statement by the Food and Agriculture Organiza on of the United Na ons and the World Health Organiza on. Rome, Italy: WHO; FAO;, 2024 DOI:10.4060/cd2223en. 3014 3015 36 Rhee JJ, Ma ei J, Hughes MD, Hu FB, Wille WC. Dietary diabetes risk reduc on score, race and ethnicity, and risk of type 2 diabetes in women. Diabetes Care 2015; 38: 596–603. 3016 3017 3018 37 Li C, Bishop TRP, Imamura F, et al. Meat consump on and incident type 2 diabetes: an individualpar cipant federated meta-analysis of 1.97 million adults with 100 000 incident cases from 31 cohorts in 20 countries. Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol 2024; 12: 619–30. 3019 3020 3021 38 Springmann M. Es mates of energy intake, requirements, and imbalances based on anthropometric measurements at global, regional, and na onal levels and for sociodemographic groups. Submi Manuscr submi ed manuscript. 3022 3023 3024 39 Schwingshackl L, Hoffmann G, Iqbal K, Schwedhelm C, Boeing H. Food groups and intermediate disease markers: a systema c review and network meta-analysis of randomized trials. Am J Clin Nutr 2018; 108: 576–86. 3025 3026 3027 40 Schlesinger S, Neuenschwander M, Schwedhelm C, et al. Food Groups and Risk of Overweight, Obesity, and Weight Gain: A Systema c Review and Dose-Response Meta-Analysis of Prospec ve Studies. Adv Nutr 2019; 10: 205–18. 3028 3029 41 Wan Y, Tobias DK, Dennis KK, et al. Associa on between changes in carbohydrate intake and long term weight changes: prospec ve cohort study. BMJ 2023; 382: e073939. 109 3030 3031 42 Yu J, Balaji B, Tinajero M, et al. White rice, brown rice and the risk of type 2 diabetes: a systema c review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open 2022; 12: e065426. 3032 3033 43 Reynolds A, Mann J, Cummings J, Winter N, Mete E, Te Morenga L. Carbohydrate quality and human health: a series of systema c reviews and meta-analyses. Lancet 2019; 393: 434–45. 3034 3035 3036 44 Aune D, Keum N, Giovannucci E, et al. Whole grain consump on and risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer, and all cause and cause specific mortality: systema c review and dose-response meta-analysis of prospec ve studies. BMJ 2016; 353: i2716. 3037 3038 3039 45 Hu H, Zhao Y, Feng Y, et al. Consump on of whole grains and refined grains and associated risk of cardiovascular disease events and all-cause mortality: a systema c review and dose-response meta-analysis of prospec ve cohort studies. Am J Clin Nutr 2023; 117: 149–59. 3040 3041 46 Mozaffarian D, Hao T, Rimm EB, Wille WC, Hu FB. Changes in diet and lifestyle and long-term weight gain in women and men. N Engl J Med 2011; 364: 2392–404. 3042 3043 47 Schwingshackl L, Schwedhelm C, Hoffmann G, Boeing H. Potatoes and risk of chronic disease: a systema c review and dose-response meta-analysis. Eur J Nutr 2019; 58: 2243–51. 3044 3045 3046 48 Mousavi SM, Gu X, Imamura F, et al. Total and type of potato intake and risk of type 2 diabetes: Results from three US cohort studies and a subs tu on meta-analysis. Submi Manuscr submi ed manuscript. 3047 3048 3049 49 Bertoia ML, Mukamal KJ, Cahill LE, et al. Changes in Intake of Fruits and Vegetables and Weight Change in United States Men and Women Followed for Up to 24 Years: Analysis from Three Prospec ve Cohort Studies. PLoS Med 2015; 12: e1001878. 3050 3051 50 Muraki I, Imamura F, Manson JE, et al. Fruit consump on and risk of type 2 diabetes: results from three prospec ve longitudinal cohort studies. BMJ 2013; 347: f5001. 3052 3053 3054 51 Miller V, Micha R, Choi E, Karageorgou D, Webb P, Mozaffarian D. Evalua on of the Quality of Evidence of the Associa on of Foods and Nutrients With Cardiovascular Disease and Diabetes: A Systema c Review. JAMA Netw Open 2022; 5: e2146705. 3055 3056 3057 52 Aune D, Giovannucci E, Boffe a P, et al. Fruit and vegetable intake and the risk of cardiovascular disease, total cancer and all-cause mortality-a systema c review and dose-response metaanalysis of prospec ve studies. Int J Epidemiol 2017; 46: 1029–56. 3058 3059 53 Farvid MS, Barne JB, Spence ND. Fruit and vegetable consump on and incident breast cancer: a systema c review and meta-analysis of prospec ve studies. Br J Cancer 2021; 125: 284–98. 3060 3061 3062 54 Wang DD, Li Y, Bhupathiraju SN, et al. Fruit and Vegetable Intake and Mortality: Results From 2 Prospec ve Cohort Studies of US Men and Women and a Meta-Analysis of 26 Cohort Studies. Circula on 2021; 143: 1642–54. 3063 3064 3065 55 Mo aghi T, Amirabdollahian F, Haghighatdoost F. Fruit and vegetable intake and cogni ve impairment: a systema c review and meta-analysis of observa onal studies. Eur J Clin Nutr 2018; 72: 1336–44. 3066 3067 3068 56 Grodstein F, Kang JH, Glynn RJ, Cook NR, Gaziano JM. A randomized trial of beta carotene supplementa on and cogni ve func on in men: the Physicians’ Health Study II. Arch Intern Med 2007; 167: 2184–90. 110 3069 3070 57 Yeh TS, Yuan C, Ascherio A, Rosner BA, Wille WC, Blacker D. Long-term Dietary Flavonoid Intake and Subjec ve Cogni ve Decline in US Men and Women. Neurology 2021; 97: e1041–56. 3071 3072 3073 58 Guasch-Ferre M, Tessier AJ, Petersen KS, et al. Effects of Nut Consump on on Blood Lipids and Lipoproteins: A Comprehensive Literature Update. Nutrients 2023; 15. DOI:10.3390/nu15030596. 3074 3075 3076 59 Arnesen EK, Thorisdo r B, Barebring L, et al. Nuts and seeds consump on and risk of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes and their risk factors: a systema c review and metaanalysis. Food Nutr Res 2023; 67. DOI:10.29219/fnr.v67.8961. 3077 3078 3079 60 De Souza RJ, Dehghan M, Mente A, et al. Associa on of nut intake with risk factors, cardiovascular disease, and mortality in 16 countries from 5 con nents: analysis from the Prospec ve Urban and Rural Epidemiology (PURE) study. Am J Clin Nutr 2020; 112: 208–19. 3080 3081 3082 61 Zargarzadeh N, Mousavi SM, Santos HO, et al. Legume Consump on and Risk of All-Cause and Cause-Specific Mortality: A Systema c Review and Dose-Response Meta-Analysis of Prospec ve Studies. Adv Nutr 2023; 14: 64–76. 3083 3084 62 Zuo X, Zhao R, Wu M, Wan Q, Li T. Soy Consump on and the Risk of Type 2 Diabetes and Cardiovascular Diseases: A Systema c Review and Meta-Analysis. Nutrients 2023; 15: 1358. 3085 3086 63 Al-Shaar L, Sa ja A, Wang DD, et al. Red meat intake and risk of coronary heart disease among US men: prospec ve cohort study. BMJ 2020; 371: m4141. 3087 3088 3089 64 Nagata C, Mizoue T, Tanaka K, et al. Soy intake and breast cancer risk: an evalua on based on a systema c review of epidemiologic evidence among the Japanese popula on. Jpn J Clin Oncol 2014; 44: 282–95. 3090 3091 3092 65 Guasch-Ferre M, Sa ja A, Blondin SA, et al. Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials of Red Meat Consump on in Comparison With Various Comparison Diets on Cardiovascular Risk Factors. Circula on 2019; 139: 1828–45. 3093 3094 3095 66 Zeraatkar D, Johnston BC, Bartoszko J, et al. Effect of Lower Versus Higher Red Meat Intake on Cardiometabolic and Cancer Outcomes: A Systema c Review of Randomized Trials. Ann Intern Med 2019; 171: 721–31. 3096 3097 67 Shi W, Huang X, Schooling CM, Zhao JV. Red meat consump on, cardiovascular diseases, and diabetes: a systema c review and meta-analysis. Eur Heart J 2023; 44: 2626–35. 3098 3099 68 World Cancer Research Fund/American Ins tute for Cancer Research. Diet, nutri on, physical ac vity and colorectal cancer. 2018 dietandcancerreport.org. 3100 3101 69 Struijk EA, Fung TT, Sotos-Prieto M, et al. Red meat consump on and risk of frailty in older women. J Cachexia Sarcopenia Muscle 2022; 13: 210–9. 3102 3103 3104 70 Zhang H, Greenwood DC, Risch HA, Bunce D, Hardie LJ, Cade JE. Meat consump on and risk of incident demen a: cohort study of 493,888 UK Biobank par cipants. Am J Clin Nutr 2021; 114: 175–84. 3105 3106 71 Li Y, Li Y, Gu X, et al. A Prospec ve Study of Long-Term Red Meat Intake, Risk of Demen a, and Cogni ve Func on in US Adults. Neurology in press. 111 3107 3108 3109 72 Iqbal R, Dehghan M, Mente A, et al. Associa ons of unprocessed and processed meat intake with mortality and cardiovascular disease in 21 countries [Prospec ve Urban Rural Epidemiology (PURE) Study]: a prospec ve cohort study. Am J Clin Nutr 2021; 114: 1049–58. 3110 3111 3112 73 Hill ER, O’Connor LE, Wang Y, et al. Red and processed meat intakes and cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes mellitus: An umbrella systema c review and assessment of causal rela ons using Bradford Hill’s criteria. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 2022; : 1–18. 3113 3114 74 Lescinsky H, Afshin A, Ashbaugh C, et al. Health effects associated with consump on of unprocessed red meat: a Burden of Proof study. Nat Med 2022; 28: 2075–82. 3115 3116 3117 75 Yu H, Zhang J, Xie J, et al. Dose-Response Meta-Analysis on Risk of Diabetes in Rela on to Red and Processed Meat Consump on - Asian Popula ons, 2006-2021. China CDC Wkly 2023; 5: 1012–6. 3118 3119 3120 76 Gu X, Drouin-Char er JP, Sacks FM, Hu FB, Rosner B, Wille WC. Red meat intake and risk of type 2 diabetes in a prospec ve cohort study of United States females and males. Am J Clin Nutr 2023; 118: 1153–63. 3121 3122 3123 77 Zhong VW, Van Horn L, Greenland P, et al. Associa ons of Processed Meat, Unprocessed Red Meat, Poultry, or Fish Intake With Incident Cardiovascular Disease and All-Cause Mortality. JAMA Intern Med 2020; 180: 503–12. 3124 3125 78 Papier K, Knuppel A, Syam N, Jebb SA, Key TJ. Meat consump on and risk of ischemic heart disease: A systema c review and meta-analysis. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 2023; 63: 426–37. 3126 3127 3128 79 Drouin-Char er J-P, Schwab AL, Chen S, et al. Egg consump on and risk of type 2 diabetes: findings from 3 large US cohort studies of men and women and a systema c review and metaanalysis of prospec ve cohort studies. Am J Clin Nutr 2020; 112: 619–30. 3129 3130 3131 80 Dehghan M, Mente A, Rangarajan S, et al. Associa on of egg intake with blood lipids, cardiovascular disease, and mortality in 177,000 people in 50 countries. Am J Clin Nutr 2020; 111: 795–803. 3132 3133 81 Tang H, Cao Y, Yang X, Zhang Y. Egg Consump on and Stroke Risk: A Systema c Review and Dose-Response Meta-Analysis of Prospec ve Studies. Front Nutr 2020; 7: 153. 3134 3135 3136 82 Tong TYN, Appleby PN, Key TJ, et al. The associa ons of major foods and fibre with risks of ischaemic and haemorrhagic stroke: a prospec ve study of 418 329 par cipants in the EPIC cohort across nine European countries. Eur Heart J 2020; 41: 2632–40. 3137 83 Wille WC, Ludwig DS. Milk and Health. N Engl J Med 2020; 382: 644–54. 3138 3139 3140 84 Brassard D, Tessier-Grenier M, Allaire J, et al. Comparison of the impact of SFAs from cheese and bu er on cardiometabolic risk factors: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr 2017; 105: 800–9. 3141 3142 85 Zhao B, Gan L, Graubard BI, et al. Plant and Animal Fat Intake and Overall and Cardiovascular Disease Mortality. JAMA Intern Med 2024; 184: 1234–45. 3143 3144 3145 86 Dehghan M, Mente A, Rangarajan S, et al. Associa on of dairy intake with cardiovascular disease and mortality in 21 countries from five con nents (PURE): a prospec ve cohort study. The Lancet 2018; 392: 2288–97. 112 3146 3147 87 Farvid MS, Malekshah AF, Pourshams A, et al. Dairy Food Intake and All-Cause, Cardiovascular Disease, and Cancer Mortality: The Golestan Cohort Study. Am J Epidemiol 2017; 185: 697–711. 3148 3149 3150 88 Vieira AR, Abar L, Chan DSM, et al. Foods and beverages and colorectal cancer risk: a systema c review and meta-analysis of cohort studies, an update of the evidence of the WCRF-AICR Con nuous Update Project. Ann Oncol 2017; 28: 1788–802. 3151 3152 89 Zhao Z, Wu D, Gao S, et al. The associa on between dairy products consump on and prostate cancer risk: a systema c review and meta-analysis. Br J Nutr 2023; 129: 1714–31. 3153 3154 3155 90 Schwingshackl L, Hoffmann G, Schwedhelm C, et al. Consump on of Dairy Products in Rela on to Changes in Anthropometric Variables in Adult Popula ons: A Systema c Review and MetaAnalysis of Cohort Studies. PLOS ONE 2016; 11: e0157461. 3156 3157 91 Zhuang P, Liu X, Li Y, et al. A global analysis of dairy consump on and incident cardiovascular disease. Nat Commun 2025; 16: 437. 3158 3159 92 Campoy C, Escolano-Margarit MV, Anjos T, Szajewska H, Uauy R. Omega 3 fa y acids on child growth, visual acuity and neurodevelopment. Br J Nutr 2012; 107: S85–106. 3160 3161 3162 3163 93 Wei B-Z, Li L, Dong C-W, Tan C-C, Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Ini a ve, Xu W. The Rela onship of Omega-3 Fa y Acids with Demen a and Cogni ve Decline: Evidence from Prospec ve Cohort Studies of Supplementa on, Dietary Intake, and Blood Markers. Am J Clin Nutr 2023; 117: 1096–109. 3164 3165 94 Manson JE, Cook NR, Lee IM, et al. Marine n-3 Fa y Acids and Preven on of Cardiovascular Disease and Cancer. N Engl J Med 2019; 380: 23–32. 3166 3167 3168 95 Abdelhamid AS, Brown TJ, Brainard JS, et al. Omega-3 fa y acids for the primary and secondary preven on of cardiovascular disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2020; 2020. DOI:10.1002/14651858.CD003177.pub5. 3169 3170 3171 96 Pren ce RL, Aragaki AK, Van Horn L, et al. Low-fat dietary pa ern and cardiovascular disease: results from the Women’s Health Ini a ve randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr 2017; 106: 35–43. 3172 3173 3174 97 Pren ce RL, Caan B, Chlebowski RT, et al. Low-fat dietary pa ern and risk of invasive breast cancer: the Women’s Health Ini a ve Randomized Controlled Dietary Modifica on Trial. JAMA 2006; 295: 629–42. 3175 3176 98 Mozaffarian D, Katan MB, Ascherio A, Stampfer MJ, Wille WC. Trans fa y acids and cardiovascular disease. N Engl J Med 2006; 354: 1601–13. 3177 3178 3179 99 Kim Y, Je Y, Giovannucci EL. Associa on between dietary fat intake and mortality from all-causes, cardiovascular disease, and cancer: A systema c review and meta-analysis of prospec ve cohort studies. Clin Nutr 2021; 40: 1060–70. 3180 3181 100 WHO. Saturated Fa y Acid and Trans-Fa y Acid Intake for Adults and Children: WHO Guideline. Geneva, 2023. 3182 3183 3184 101 Schoeneck M, Iggman D. The effects of foods on LDL cholesterol levels: A systema c review of the accumulated evidence from systema c reviews and meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials. Nutr Metab Cardiovasc Dis 2021; 31: 1325–38. 113 3185 3186 3187 102 Mar nez-González MA, Sayón-Orea C, Bullón-Vela V, et al. Effect of olive oil consump on on cardiovascular disease, cancer, type 2 diabetes, and all-cause mortality: A systema c review and meta-analysis. Clin Nutr 2022; 41: 2659–82. 3188 3189 3190 103 Sun Y, Neelakantan N, Wu Y, Lote-Oke R, Pan A, van Dam RM. Palm Oil Consump on Increases LDL Cholesterol Compared with Vegetable Oils Low in Saturated Fat in a Meta-Analysis of Clinical Trials. J Nutr 2015; 145: 1549–58. 3191 3192 3193 104 Estruch R, Ros E, Salas-Salvado J, et al. Primary Preven on of Cardiovascular Disease with a Mediterranean Diet Supplemented with Extra-Virgin Olive Oil or Nuts. N Engl J Med 2018; 378: e34. 3194 3195 105 Te Morenga L, Mallard S, Mann J. Dietary sugars and body weight: systema c review and metaanalyses of randomised controlled trials and cohort studies. BMJ 2012; 346: e7492. 3196 3197 3198 106 Qin P, Li Q, Zhao Y, et al. Sugar and ar ficially sweetened beverages and risk of obesity, type 2 diabetes mellitus, hypertension, and all-cause mortality: a dose-response meta-analysis of prospec ve cohort studies. Eur J Epidemiol 2020; 35: 655–71. 3199 3200 3201 107 Te Morenga LA, Howatson AJ, Jones RM, Mann J. Dietary sugars and cardiometabolic risk: systema c review and meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials of the effects on blood pressure and lipids. Am J Clin Nutr 2014; 100: 65–79. 3202 3203 108 WHO. Guideline: sugars intake for adults and children. Geneva: World Health Organiza on, 2015 h ps://iris.who.int/handle/10665/149782 (accessed Nov 5, 2024). 3204 3205 109 Ma Y, He FJ, Sun Q, et al. 24-Hour Urinary Sodium and Potassium Excre on and Cardiovascular Risk. N Engl J Med 2022; 386: 252–63. 3206 3207 3208 110 Monteiro CA, Cannon G, Moubarac JC, Levy RB, Louzada MLC, Jaime PC. The UN Decade of Nutri on, the NOVA food classifica on and the trouble with ultra-processing. Public Health Nutr 2018; 21: 5–17. 3209 3210 111 Lane MM, Gamage E, Du S, et al. Ultra-processed food exposure and adverse health outcomes: umbrella review of epidemiological meta-analyses. BMJ 2024; 384: e077310. 3211 3212 112 Tsugane S. Why has Japan become the world’s most long-lived country: insights from a food and nutri on perspec ve. Eur J Clin Nutr 2021; 75: 921–8. 3213 3214 3215 113 Hu FB, Drescher G, Trichopoulou A, Wille WC, Mar nez-González MA. Three decades of the Mediterranean diet pyramid: A narra ve review of its history, evolu on, and advances. Am J Clin Nutr 2025; published online May 13. DOI:10.1016/j.ajcnut.2025.04.036. 3216 3217 114 Zhang C, Schulze MB, Solomon CG, Hu FB. A prospec ve study of dietary pa erns, meat intake and the risk of gesta onal diabetes mellitus. Diabetologia 2006; 49: 2604–13. 3218 3219 115 English LK, Ard JD, Bailey RL, et al. Evalua on of Dietary Pa erns and All-Cause Mortality: A Systema c Review. JAMA Netw Open 2021; 4: e2122277. 3220 3221 3222 3223 116 Schwingshackl L, Bogensberger B, Hoffmann G. Diet Quality as Assessed by the Healthy Ea ng Index, Alternate Healthy Ea ng Index, Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension Score, and Health Outcomes: An Updated Systema c Review and Meta-Analysis of Cohort Studies. J Acad Nutr Diet 2018; 118: 74-100 e11. 114 3224 3225 117 Wang P, Song M, Eliassen AH, et al. Op mal dietary pa erns for preven on of chronic disease. Nat Med 2023; 29: 719–28. 3226 3227 118 Sotos-Prieto M, Bhupathiraju SN, Ma ei J, et al. Associa on of Changes in Diet Quality with Total and Cause-Specific Mortality. N Engl J Med 2017; 377: 143–53. 3228 3229 119 Lai JS, Hiles S, Bisquera A, Hure AJ, McEvoy M, A a J. A systema c review and meta-analysis of dietary pa erns and depression in community-dwelling adults. Am J Clin Nutr 2014; 99: 181–97. 3230 3231 3232 120 Liu YH, Gao X, Na M, Kris-Etherton PM, Mitchell DC, Jensen GL. Dietary Pa ern, Diet Quality, and Demen a: A Systema c Review and Meta-Analysis of Prospec ve Cohort Studies. J Alzheimers Dis 2020; 78: 151–68. 3233 3234 3235 121 Stubbendorff A, Stern D, Ericson U, et al. A systema c evalua on of seven different scores represen ng the EAT-Lancet reference diet and mortality, stroke, and greenhouse gas emissions in three cohorts. Lancet Planet Health 2024; 8: e391–401. 3236 3237 3238 122 Berthy F, Brunin J, Alles B, et al. Associa on between adherence to the EAT-Lancet diet and risk of cancer and cardiovascular outcomes in the prospec ve NutriNet-Sante cohort. Am J Clin Nutr 2022; 116: 980–91. 3239 3240 123 Mente A, Dehghan M, Rangarajan S, et al. Diet, cardiovascular disease, and mortality in 80 countries. Eur Heart J 2023; 44: 2560–79. 3241 3242 124 Wille WC, Hu FB, Forouhi NG. A healthy diet should consider environmental impact. Eur Heart J 2024; 45: 1375. 3243 3244 125 Ye YX, Geng TT, Zhou YF, et al. Adherence to a Planetary Health Diet, Environmental Impacts, and Mortality in Chinese Adults. JAMA Netw Open 2023; 6: e2339468. 3245 3246 3247 126 Chen H, Wang X, Ji JS, et al. Plant-based and planetary-health diets, environmental burden, and risk of mortality: a prospec ve cohort study of middle-aged and older adults in China. Lancet Planet Health 2024; 8: e545–53. 3248 3249 127 Bajaj S, Springmann M. A review of the quality of evidence of nutrient reference values. Lancet Planet Health; Submi ed. 3250 3251 3252 128 Springmann M, Auclair O, Bajaj S, et al. Many diets for many people: planetary health diets and their health and environmental impacts at global, regional, na onal, and demographic levels. Nature; Submi ed. 3253 3254 129 Smith AD, Refsum H. Homocysteine, B Vitamins, and Cogni ve Impairment. Annu Rev Nutr 2016; 36: 211–39. 3255 3256 130 Mario F, Gardner CD. Dietary Protein and Amino Acids in Vegetarian Diets-A Review. Nutrients 2019; 11. DOI:10.3390/nu11112661. 3257 3258 3259 131 Chen Z, Glisic M, Song M, et al. Dietary protein intake and all-cause and cause-specific mortality: results from the Ro erdam Study and a meta-analysis of prospec ve cohort studies. Eur J Epidemiol 2020; 35: 411–29. 3260 3261 132 Baum JI, Kim IY, Wolfe RR. Protein Consump on and the Elderly: What Is the Op mal Level of Intake? Nutrients 2016; 8. DOI:10.3390/nu8060359. 115 3262 3263 3264 133 Ardisson Korat AV, Shea MK, Jacques PF, et al. Dietary protein intake in midlife in rela on to healthy aging - results from the prospec ve Nurses’ Health Study cohort. Am J Clin Nutr 2024; 119: 271–82. 3265 3266 134 UNICEF. Undernourished and overlooked: a global nutri on crisis in adolescent girls and women: execu ve Summary. 2023. 3267 3268 135 Fleming TP, Watkins AJ, Velazquez MA, et al. Origins of life me health around the me of concep on: causes and consequences. Lancet 2018; 391: 1842–52. 3269 136 WHO. Nutri on counselling during pregnancy. E-Libr. Evid. Nutr. Ac ons ELENA. 2023. 3270 3271 137 WHO. WHO recommenda ons on antenatal care for a posi ve pregnancy experience. World Health Organiza on, 2016. 3272 3273 138 Piccoli GB, Clari R, Vigo FN, et al. Vegan-vegetarian diets in pregnancy: danger or panacea? A systema c narra ve review. BJOG 2015; 122: 623–33. 3274 3275 139 Dewey KG, Zlotkin SH. Antenatal mul ple micronutrient supplements: me for alignment to support country ac on. The Lancet 2025; 405: 1033–5. 3276 3277 3278 140 Santos-Guzmán A, Unar-Munguía M, Rivera JA, Ramírez-Silva I. Addressing infant and young child feeding recommenda ons from a planetary health perspec ve. Adv Nutr 2024. DOI:h ps://doi.org/10.1016/j.advnut.2024.100303. 3279 3280 141 Hagan JF SJ. Bright Futures: Guidelines for Health Supervision of Infants, Children, and Adolescents. Elk Grove Village, IL: American Academy of Pediatrics, 2017. 3281 3282 3283 142 Kvestad I, Hysing M, Shrestha M, et al. Vitamin B-12 status in infancy is posi vely associated with development and cogni ve func oning 5 y later in Nepalese children. Am J Clin Nutr 2017; 105: 1122–31. 3284 3285 3286 143 Ulak M, Kvestad I, Chandyo RK, et al. The effect of infant vitamin B(12) supplementa on on neurodevelopment: a follow-up of a randomised placebo-controlled trial in Nepal. Br J Nutr 2023; 129: 41–8. 3287 3288 144 Krebs NF. Food Based Complementary Feeding Strategies for Breas ed Infants: What’s the Evidence that it Ma ers? Nutr Today 2014; 49: 271–7. 3289 3290 145 FAO. The White/Wiphala Paper on Indigenous Peoples’ food systems. FAO, 2021 DOI:10.4060/cb4932en. 3291 3292 3293 146 Armes S, Bhanjdeo A, Chakraborty D, Kaur H, Ray S, Rao N. Aligning Santal Tribe Menu Templates with EAT-Lancet Commission’s Dietary Guidelines for Sustainable and Healthy Diets: A Compara ve Analysis. Nutrients 2024; 16: 447. 3294 3295 147 Guasch-Ferre M, Wille WC. The Mediterranean diet and health: a comprehensive overview. J Intern Med 2021; 290: 549–66. 3296 3297 148 Argumedo A, Song Y, Khoury CK, et al. Biocultural Diversity for Food System Transforma on Under Global Environmental Change. Front Sustain Food Syst 2021; 5: 685299. 116 3298 3299 3300 149 LeBlanc KE, Baer-Sinno S, Lancaster KJ, et al. Perspec ve: Beyond the Mediterranean DietExploring La n American, Asian, and African Heritage Diets as Cultural Models of Healthy Ea ng. Adv Nutr 2024; 15: 100221. 3301 3302 3303 150 Pan W-H, Wu S-Y, Chang P-C. Is Nutrient Quality of the Locally-Exis ng, EAT-Lancet-like PlantBased Diet Be er or Worse than the Average Diet in Taiwan? An Example of Local Transla on. Nutrients 2024; 16: 2775. 3304 3305 151 UNICEF. Improving Young Children’s Diets During the Complementary Feeding Period. New York: UNICEF, 2020. 3306 152 Dewey K. Guiding principles for complementary feeding of the breas ed child. 2003. 3307 3308 153 Guasch-Ferre M, Li Y, Wille WC, et al. Consump on of Olive Oil and Risk of Total and CauseSpecific Mortality Among U.S. Adults. J Am Coll Cardiol 2022; 79: 101–12. 3309 3310 3311 154 Schwingshackl L, Bogensberger B, Benčič A, Knüppel S, Boeing H, Hoffmann G. Effects of oils and solid fats on blood lipids: a systema c review and network meta-analysis. J Lipid Res 2018; 59: 1771–82. 3312 3313 155 Dennis KK, Wang F, Li Y, et al. Associa ons of dietary sugar types with coronary heart disease risk: a prospec ve cohort study. Am J Clin Nutr 2023; 118: 1000–9. 3314 3315 156 Huang Y, Chen Z, Chen B, et al. Dietary sugar consump on and health: umbrella review. BMJ 2023; 381: e071609. 3316 3317 157 Rockström J, Steffen W, Noone K, et al. A safe opera ng space for humanity. Nature 2009; 461: 472–5. 3318 3319 158 Richardson K, Steffen W, Lucht W, et al. Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries. Sci Adv 2023; 9: eadh2458. 3320 3321 159 Te Wierik S, Rockström J, Norberg A, et al. Food system boundaries: iden fying the safe opera ng space for food. Manuscr Submi Publ 2025. 3322 3323 160 Garne T, Appleby MC, Balmford A, et al. Sustainable Intensifica on in Agriculture: Premises and Policies. Science 2013; 341: 33–4. 3324 3325 161 Rockström J, Williams J, Daily G, et al. Sustainable intensifica on of agriculture for human prosperity and global sustainability. Ambio 2017; 46: 4–17. 3326 3327 162 Pre y J, Benton TG, Bharucha ZP, et al. Global assessment of agricultural system redesign for sustainable intensifica on. Nat Sustain 2018; 1: 441–6. 3328 3329 163 Tamburini G, Bommarco R, Wanger TC, et al. Agricultural diversifica on promotes mul ple ecosystem services without compromising yield. Sci Adv 2020; 6. DOI:10.1126/sciadv.aba1715. 3330 3331 3332 164 Beillouin D, Cardinael R, Berre D, et al. A global overview of studies about land management, land-use change, and climate change effects on soil organic carbon. Glob Change Biol 2022; 28: 1690–702. 117 3333 3334 3335 165 Jones SK, Monjeau A, Perez-Guzman K, Harrison PA. Integrated modeling to achieve global goals: lessons from the Food, Agriculture, Biodiversity, Land-use, and Energy (FABLE) ini a ve. Sustain Sci 2023; 18: 323–33. 3336 3337 3338 166 Beusen AHW, Doelman JC, Van Beek LPH, et al. Exploring river nitrogen and phosphorus loading and export to global coastal waters in the Shared Socio-economic pathways. Glob Environ Change 2022; 72: 102426. 3339 3340 167 Schulte-Uebbing LF, Beusen AHW, Bouwman AF, de Vries W. From planetary to regional boundaries for agricultural nitrogen pollu on. Nature 2022; 610: 507–12. 3341 3342 168 Maggi F, Tang FHM, Tubiello FN. Agricultural pes cide land budget and river discharge to oceans. Nature 2023; 620: 1013–7. 3343 3344 169 Van Boeckel TP, Brower C, Gilbert M, et al. Global trends in an microbial use in food animals. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2015; 112: 5649–54. 3345 3346 3347 170 Nabuurs G-J, Mrabet R, Abu Hatab A, et al. Agriculture, Forestry and Other Land Uses (Chapter 7). In: Shukla AR, Skea J, Slade R, et al., eds. . Cambridge, UK and New York, NY, USA: Cambridge University Press, 2022: 747–860. 3348 3349 171 Caleffi S, Mozaffarian D, Micha R, Springmann M. The socio-demographic characteris cs of foodrelated environmental impacts. Prep. 3350 3351 172 Tubiello FN, Rosenzweig C, Conchedda G, et al. Greenhouse gas emissions from food systems: building the evidence base. Environ Res Le 2021; 16: 065007. 3352 3353 173 Ga o A, Chepeliev M. Global food loss and waste es mates show increasing nutri onal and environmental pressures. Nat Food 2024; 5: 136–47. 3354 3355 174 Roe S, Streck C, Obersteiner M, et al. Contribu on of the land sector to a 1.5 °C world. Nat Clim Change 2019; 9: 817–28. 3356 3357 175 Lessmann M, Ros GH, Young MD, de Vries W. Global varia on in soil carbon sequestra on poten al through improved cropland management. Glob Change Biol 2021; 28: 1162–77. 3358 3359 176 Zhao X, Mignone BK, Wise MA, McJeon HC. Trade-offs in land-based carbon removal measures under 1.5 °C and 2 °C futures. Nat Commun 2024; 15: 2297. 3360 3361 177 Lade SJ, Steffen W, de Vries W, et al. Human impacts on planetary boundaries amplified by Earth system interac ons. Nat Sustain 2020; 3: 119–28. 3362 3363 178 FAO. Land sta s cs 2001–2022. 2024. h ps://openknowledge.fao.org/handle/20.500.14283/cd1484en (accessed July 4, 2024). 3364 3365 179 Cur s PG, Slay CM, Harris NL, Tyukavina A, Hansen MC. Classifying drivers of global forest loss. Science 2018; 361: 1108–11. 3366 3367 180 Pendrill F, Gardner TA, Meyfroidt P, et al. Disentangling the numbers behind agriculture-driven tropical deforesta on. Science 2022; 377: eabm9267. 3368 3369 181 Springmann M. A mul criteria analysis of meat and milk alterna ves from nutri onal, health, environmental, and cost perspec ves. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2024; 121: e2319010121. 118 3370 3371 182 Poore J, Nemecek T. Reducing food’s environmental impacts through producers and consumers. Science 2018; 360: 987–92. 3372 3373 183 Richardson K, Steffen W, Lucht W, et al. Earth beyond six of nine planetary boundaries. Sci Adv 2023; 9: eadh2458. 3374 3375 184 Mohamed A, DeClerck F, Verburg PH, et al. Securing Nature’s Contribu ons to People requires at least 20%–25% (semi-)natural habitat in human-modified landscapes. One Earth 2024; 7: 59–71. 3376 3377 185 Garibaldi LA, Oddi FJ, Miguez FE, et al. Working landscapes need at least 20% na ve habitat. Conserv Le 2021; 14: e12773. 3378 3379 3380 186 Stenzel F, Braun J, Breier J, et al. biospheremetrics v1.0.2: an R package to calculate two complementary terrestrial biosphere integrity indicators – human coloniza on of the biosphere (BioCol) and risk of ecosystem destabiliza on (EcoRisk). Geosci Model Dev 2024; 17: 3235–58. 3381 3382 187 Foley JA, Ramanku y N, Brauman KA, et al. Solu ons for a cul vated planet. Nature 2011; 478: 337–42. 3383 3384 3385 188 UNEP. Food Waste Index Report 2024. Think Eat Save: Tracking Progress to Halve Global Food Waste. Nairobi, 2024 h ps://wedocs.unep.org/handle/20.500.11822/45230 (accessed May 20, 2025). 3386 3387 3388 3389 3390 3391 189 Ingemarsson ML, Weinberg J, Rudebeck T, Wang-Erlandsson L. The essen al drop to Net-Zero: Unpacking freshwater’s role in climate change mi ga on. Stockholm Interna onal Water Ins tute, Stockholm Resilience Centre, Potsdam Ins tute of Climate Impact Research, United Na ons Development Programme and Deutsche Gesellscha für Interna onale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ) GmbH., 2022 h ps://siwi.org/publica ons/essen al-drop-to-net-zero/ (accessed Nov 13, 2024). 3392 3393 190 Gleeson T, Wang-Erlandsson L, Porkka M, et al. Illumina ng water cycle modifica ons and Earth system resilience in the Anthropocene. Water Resour Res 2020; 56: e2019WR024957. 3394 3395 3396 191 Porkka M, Virkki V, Wang-Erlandsson L, et al. Notable shi s beyond pre-industrial streamflow and soil moisture condi ons transgress the planetary boundary for freshwater change. Nat Water 2024; 2: 262–73. 3397 3398 3399 192 Gerten D, Hoff H, Rockström J, Jägermeyr J, Kummu M, Pastor AV. Towards a revised planetary boundary for consump ve freshwater use: role of environmental flow requirements. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 2013; 5: 551–8. 3400 3401 193 McDermid S, Nocco M, Lawston-Parker P, et al. Irriga on in the Earth system. Nat Rev Earth Environ 2023; : 1–19. 3402 3403 194 Springmann M, Clark M, Mason-D’Croz D, et al. Op ons for keeping the food system within environmental limits. Nature 2018; 562: 519–25. 3404 3405 195 Te Wierik SA, Rockström J, Norberg A, et al. Food system boundaries: iden fying the safe opera ng space for food. Prep. 3406 3407 3408 196 Gerten D, Heinke J, Hoff H, Biemans H, Fader M, Waha K. Global Water Availability and Requirements for Future Food Produc on. 2011; published online Oct 1. DOI:10.1175/2011JHM1328.1. 119 3409 3410 197 Te Wierik S, Gerten D, Anderson L, et al. A ribu on of global freshwater changes to climate and land use changes. Manuscr Prep n.d. 3411 3412 3413 198 Jägermeyr J, Pastor A, Biemans H, Gerten D. Reconciling irrigated food produc on with environmental flows for Sustainable Development Goals implementa on. Nat Commun 2017; 8: 15900. 3414 3415 199 Scarborough P, Clark M, Cobiac L, et al. Vegans, vegetarians, fish-eaters and meat-eaters in the UK show discrepant environmental impacts. Nat Food 2023; 4: 565–74. 3416 200 Lal R. Soil organic ma er and water reten on. Agron J 2020; 112: 3265–77. 3417 3418 3419 201 Muchane MN, Sileshi GW, Gripenberg S, Jonsson M, Pumariño L, Barrios E. Agroforestry boosts soil health in the humid and sub-humid tropics: A meta-analysis. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2020; 295: 106899. 3420 3421 202 Gerten D, Heck V, Jägermeyr J, et al. Feeding ten billion people is possible within four terrestrial planetary boundaries. Nat Sustain 2020; 3: 200–8. 3422 3423 203 Tang FHM, Lenzen M, McBratney A, Maggi F. Risk of pes cide pollu on at the global scale. Nat Geosci 2021; 14: 206–10. 3424 3425 204 De Vries W. Impacts of nitrogen emissions on ecosystems and human health: A mini review. Curr Opin Environ Sci Health 2021; 21: 100249. 3426 3427 3428 205 Poikane S, Kelly MG, Salas Herrero F, et al. Nutrient criteria for surface waters under the European Water Framework Direc ve: Current state-of-the-art, challenges and future outlook. Sci Total Environ 2019; 695: 133888. 3429 3430 3431 206 Poikane S, Phillips G, Birk S, Free G, Kelly MG, Willby NJ. Deriving nutrient criteria to support ʽgoodʼ ecological status in European lakes: An empirically based approach to linking ecology and management. Sci Total Environ 2019; 650: 2074–84. 3432 3433 207 de Vries W, Schulte-Uebbing LF, Beusen AHW, Te Wierik SA. Revisi ng planetary boundaries for nitrogen and phosphorus. Prep. 3434 3435 3436 208 You L, Ros GH, Chen Y, et al. Global mean nitrogen recovery efficiency in croplands can be enhanced by op mal nutrient, crop and soil management prac ces. Nat Commun 2023; 14: 5747. 3437 3438 209 Wee SY, Aris AZ. Revisi ng the “forever chemicals”, PFOA and PFOS exposure in drinking water. Npj Clean Water 2023; 6: 1–16. 3439 3440 210 Persson L, Carney Almroth BM, Collins CD, et al. Outside the Safe Opera ng Space of the Planetary Boundary for Novel En es. Environ Sci Technol 2022; 56: 1510–21. 3441 211 He L, Li Z, Jia Q, Xu Z. Soil microplas cs pollu on in agriculture. Science 2023; 379: 547–547. 3442 3443 212 MacLeod M, Breitholtz M, Cousins IT, et al. Iden fying Chemicals That Are Planetary Boundary Threats. Environ Sci Technol 2014; 48: 11057–63. 3444 3445 213 FAO. Pes cides use and trade, 1990–2022. 2024. h ps://openknowledge.fao.org/handle/20.500.14283/cd1486en (accessed Nov 12, 2024). 120 3446 3447 214 Jørgensen PS, Ak pis A, Brown Z, et al. An bio c and pes cide suscep bility and the Anthropocene opera ng space. Nat Sustain 2018; 1: 632–41. 3448 3449 3450 215 Cassou E. Pes cides. World Bank. 2018. h ps://documents.worldbank.org/en/publica on/documentsreports/documentdetail/689281521218090562/Pes cides (accessed Aug 19, 2024). 3451 3452 3453 216 Geissen V, Silva V, Lwanga EH, et al. Cocktails of pes cide residues in conven onal and organic farming systems in Europe – Legacy of the past and turning point for the future. Environ Pollut 2021; 278: 116827. 3454 3455 217 Wyckhuys KAG, Gu B, Ben Fekih I, et al. Restoring func onal integrity of the global produc on ecosystem through biological control. J Environ Manage 2024; 370: 122446. 3456 3457 218 Schar D, Klein EY, Laxminarayan R, Gilbert M, Van Boeckel TP. Global trends in an microbial use in aquaculture. Sci Rep 2020; 10: 21878. 3458 3459 219 Van Boeckel TP, Glennon EE, Chen D, et al. Reducing an microbial use in food animals. Science 2017; 357: 1350–2. 3460 3461 220 Van Boeckel TP, Pires J, Silvester R, et al. Global trends in an microbial resistance in animals in low- and middle-income countries. Science 2019; 365: eaaw1944. 3462 3463 221 Burke, Springmann M. Dietary and food system changes can dras cally reduce an -microbial use in animals. in prep. 3464 3465 222 Lobell DB, Burney JA. Cleaner air has contributed one-fi h of US maize and soybean yield gains since 1999. Environ Res Le 2021; 16: 074049. 3466 3467 3468 223 Crippa M, Solazzo E, Guizzardi D, Van Dingenen R, Leip A. Air pollutant emissions from global food systems are responsible for environmental impacts, crop losses and mortality. Nat Food 2022; 3: 942–56. 3469 3470 224 Lelieveld J, Evans JS, Fnais M, Giannadaki D, Pozzer A. The contribu on of outdoor air pollu on sources to premature mortality on a global scale. Nature 2015; 525: 367–71. 3471 3472 3473 225 Liu Y, Chen J, Shi Y, Zheng W, Shan T, Wang G. Global Emissions Inventory from Open Biomass Burning (GEIOBB): u lizing Fengyun-3D global fire spot monitoring data. Earth Syst Sci Data 2024; 16: 3495–515. 3474 3475 226 Springmann M, Van Dingenen R, Vandyck T, Latka C, Witzke P, Leip A. The global and regional air quality impacts of dietary change. Nat Commun 2023; 14: 6227. 3476 3477 227 Burton C, Lampe S, Kelley DI, et al. Global burned area increasingly explained by climate change. Nat Clim Change 2024; : 1–7. 3478 3479 228 Gruber N. Warming up, turning sour, losing breath: ocean biogeochemistry under global change. Philos Trans R Soc Math Phys Eng Sci 2011; 369: 1980–96. 3480 3481 229 Friedlingstein P, O’sullivan M, Jones MW, et al. Global carbon budget 2024. Earth Syst Sci Data Discuss 2024; 2024: 1–133. 121 3482 3483 230 Tian H, Pan N, Thompson RL, et al. Global nitrous oxide budget (1980–2020). Earth Syst Sci Data 2024; 16: 2543–604. 3484 3485 3486 231 Dynarski KA, Bossio DA, Scow KM. Dynamic Stability of Soil Carbon: Reassessing the “Permanence” of Soil Carbon Sequestra on. Front Environ Sci 2020; 8. DOI:10.3389/fenvs.2020.514701. 3487 3488 232 Chenu C, Angers DA, Barré P, Derrien D, Arrouays D, Balesdent J. Increasing organic stocks in agricultural soils: Knowledge gaps and poten al innova ons. Soil Tillage Res 2019; 188: 41–52. 3489 3490 233 Rasmussen LV, Grass I, Mehrabi Z, et al. Joint environmental and social benefits from diversified agriculture. Science 2024; 384: 87–93. 3491 3492 234 McClelland SC, Bossio D, Gordon DR, et al. Managing for climate and produc on goals on croplands. Nat Clim Change 2025; : 1–8. 3493 3494 3495 235 Arndt C, Hristov AN, Price WJ, et al. Full adop on of the most effec ve strategies to mi gate methane emissions by ruminants can help meet the 1.5 °C target by 2030 but not 2050. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2022; 119: e2111294119. 3496 3497 236 Beillouin D, Ben-Ari T, Malézieux E, Seufert V, Makowski D. Posi ve but variable effects of crop diversifica on on biodiversity and ecosystem services. Glob Change Biol 2021; 27: 4697–710. 3498 3499 237 Beillouin D, Corbeels M, Demenois J, et al. A global meta-analysis of soil organic carbon in the Anthropocene. Nat Commun 2023; 14: 3700. 3500 3501 238 Bonfan J, Langridge J, Avadí A, et al. Global review of meta-analyses reveals key data gaps in agricultural impact studies on biodiversity in croplands. 2024; : 2024.04.19.590051. 3502 3503 239 Grados D, Bu erbach-Bahl K, Chen J, et al. Synthesizing the evidence of nitrous oxide mi ga on prac ces in agroecosystems. Environ Res Le 2022; 17: 114024. 3504 3505 240 Young MD, Ros GH, de Vries W. Impacts of agronomic measures on crop, soil, and environmental indicators: A review and synthesis of meta-analysis. Agric Ecosyst Environ 2021; 319: 107551. 3506 3507 241 He X, Batáry P, Zou Y, et al. Agricultural diversifica on promotes sustainable and resilient global rice produc on. Nat Food 2023; 4: 788–96. 3508 3509 242 Van Zanten HHE, Herrero M, Van Hal O, et al. Defining a land boundary for sustainable livestock consump on. Glob Change Biol 2018; 24: 4185–94. 3510 3511 243 Blanco-Canqui H, Wilke K, Holman J, Creech CF, Obour AK, Anderson L. Grazing cover crops: How does it influence soils and crops? Agron J 2023; 115: 2801–28. 3512 3513 244 Cui J, Liu H, Wang H, et al. Rice-Animal Co-Culture Systems Benefit Global Sustainable Intensifica on. Earths Future 2023; 11: e2022EF002984. 3514 3515 245 Byrnes RC, Eastburn DJ, Tate KW, Roche LM. A Global Meta-Analysis of Grazing Impacts on Soil Health Indicators. J Environ Qual 2018; 47: 758–65. 3516 3517 246 Crona BI, Wassénius E, Jonell M, et al. Four ways blue foods can help achieve food system ambi ons across na ons. Nature 2023; 616: 104–12. 122 3518 247 Costello C, Cao L, Gelcich S, et al. The future of food from the sea. Nature 2020; 588: 95–100. 3519 3520 248 Melnychuk MC, Kurota H, Mace PM, et al. Iden fying management ac ons that promote sustainable fisheries. Nat Sustain 2021; 4: 440–9. 3521 3522 249 He, P.; Chopin, F.; Suuronen, P.; Ferro, R.S.T.; Lansley, J. Classifica on and illustrated defini on of fishing gears. FAO, 2021 DOI:10.4060/cb4966en. 3523 3524 250 Smallhorn-West P, Cohen PJ, Phillips M, Jupiter SD, Govan H, Pressey RL. Linking small-scale fisheries co-management to U.N. Sustainable Development Goals. Conserv Biol 2022; 36: e13977. 3525 3526 3527 251 Gelcich S, Reyes-Mendy F, Arriagada R, Cas llo B. Assessing the implementa on of marine ecosystem based management into na onal policies: Insights from agenda se ng and policy responses. Mar Policy 2018; 92: 40–7. 3528 3529 3530 252 Li le DC, Young JA, Zhang W, Newton RW, Al Mamun A, Murray FJ. Sustainable intensifica on of aquaculture value chains between Asia and Europe: A framework for understanding impacts and challenges. Aquaculture 2018; 493: 338–54. 3531 3532 253 Halpern BS, Frazier M, Verstaen J, et al. The environmental footprint of global food produc on. Nat Sustain 2022; 5: 1027–39. 3533 3534 3535 254 Henriksson PJG, Belton B, Jahan KM-, Rico A. Measuring the poten al for sustainable intensifica on of aquaculture in Bangladesh using life cycle assessment. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2018; 115: 2958–63. 3536 3537 255 Naylor RL, Kishore A, Sumaila UR, et al. Blue food demand across geographic and temporal scales. Nat Commun 2021; 12: 5413. 3538 3539 256 Nederlof MAJ, Verdegem MCJ, Smaal AC, Jansen HM. Nutrient reten on efficiencies in integrated mul -trophic aquaculture. Rev Aquac 2022; 14: 1194–212. 3540 3541 257 Stevens JR, Newton RW, Tlusty M, Li le DC. The rise of aquaculture by-products: Increasing food produc on, value, and sustainability through strategic u lisa on. Mar Policy 2018; 90: 115–24. 3542 3543 3544 258 Bohnes FA, Hauschild MZ, Schlundt J, Laurent A. Life cycle assessments of aquaculture systems: a cri cal review of reported findings with recommenda ons for policy and system development. Rev Aquac 2019; 11: 1061–79. 3545 3546 259 Coolsaet B, Néron P-Y. Recogni on and environmental jus ce. In: Environmental Jus ce. Routledge, 2020. 3547 3548 260 Walker G, Day R. Fuel poverty as injus ce: Integra ng distribu on, recogni on and procedure in the struggle for affordable warmth. Energy Policy 2012; 49: 69–75. 3549 261 Fraser N. Abnormal Jus ce. Crit Inq 2008; 34: 393–422. 3550 3551 3552 262 Blackstone NT, Ba aglia K, Rodríguez-Huerta E, et al. Diets cannot be sustainable without ensuring the well-being of communi es, workers and animals in food value chains. Nat Food 2024; 5: 818–24. 3553 3554 263 Okereke C. Global Jus ce and Neoliberal Environmental Governance: Ethics, Sustainable Development and Interna onal Co-Opera on, 1st edn. Routledge, 2010 123 3555 3556 h ps://www.routledge.com/Global-Jus ce-and-Neoliberal-Environmental-Governance-EthicsSustainable/Okereke/p/book/9780415599467 (accessed Nov 9, 2023). 3557 264 Rawls J, editor. Jus ce as Fairness: A Restatement. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2001. 3558 3559 265 Petersmann E-U. Theories of Jus ce, Human Rights, and the Cons tu on of Interna onal Markets. Loyola Los Angel Law Rev 2003; 37: 407. 3560 3561 266 Ensor J, Hoddy E. Securing the social founda on: A rights-based approach to planetary boundaries. Earth Syst Gov 2021; 7: 100086. 3562 3563 3564 267 Raworth K. Doughnut Economics. Chelsea Green Publishing, 2017 h ps://www.chelseagreen.com/product/doughnut-economics-paperback/ (accessed Nov 20, 2024). 3565 3566 268 O’Neill DW, Fanning AL, Lamb WF, Steinberger JK. A good life for all within planetary boundaries. Nat Sustain 2018; 1: 88–95. 3567 3568 269 Sen A. Poverty and Famines: An Essay on En tlement and Depriva on. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1981. 3569 3570 270 Clapp J, Vriezen R, Laila A, et al. Concentrated Corporate Power Ma ers for Agency in Food Systems. 2025. 3571 3572 3573 271 UN. General Comment No. 12 on the right to adequate food. 1999 h ps://www.ohchr.org/en/documents/general-comments-and-recommenda ons/ec1219995general-comment-no-12-right-adequate-food (accessed Nov 29, 2024). 3574 3575 3576 272 UN. Interna onal Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. 1966 h ps://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/interna onal-covenanteconomic-social-and-cultural-rights (accessed Nov 29, 2024). 3577 3578 3579 273 FAO. Voluntary guidelines to support the progressive realiza on of the right to adequate food in the context of na onal food security. Rome: FAO, 2005 h ps://www.fao.org/4/y7937e/y7937e00.htm (accessed May 23, 2025). 3580 3581 274 Herforth A, Bai Y, Venkat A, Mahrt K, Ebel A, Masters WA. Cost and affordability of healthy diets across and within countries. FAO, 2020 DOI:10.4060/cb2431en. 3582 3583 3584 275 Popkin BM, Ng SW. The nutri on transi on to a stage of high obesity and noncommunicable disease prevalence dominated by ultra-processed foods is not inevitable. Obes Rev 2022; 23: e13366. 3585 3586 3587 276 Baker P, Machado P, Santos T, et al. Ultra-processed foods and the nutri on transi on: Global, regional and na onal trends, food systems transforma ons and poli cal economy drivers. Obes Rev 2020; 21: e13126. 3588 3589 277 Carducci B, Chen Y, Luo H, Webb P, Fanzo J. Nutri on Transi on Pa erns in the Context of Global Food Systems Transforma on. 2024; published online July 19. DOI:10.21203/rs.3.rs-4657489/v1. 3590 3591 3592 278 He P, Feng K, Baiocchi G, Sun L, Hubacek K. Shi s towards healthy diets in the US can reduce environmental impacts but would be unaffordable for poorer minori es. Nat Food 2021; 2: 664– 72. 124 3593 3594 3595 279 Unar-Munguía M, Cervantes-Armenta MA, Rodríguez-Ramírez S, Bonvecchio Arenas A, Fernández Gaxiola AC, Rivera JA. Mexican na onal dietary guidelines promote less costly and environmentally sustainable diets. Nat Food 2024; 5: 703–13. 3596 3597 3598 280 Mayén A-L, Marques-Vidal P, Paccaud F, Bovet P, Stringhini S. Socioeconomic determinants of dietary pa erns in low- and middle-income countries: a systema c review1234. Am J Clin Nutr 2014; 100: 1520–31. 3599 3600 3601 3602 281 HLPE. Strengthening urban and peri-urban food systems to achieve food security and nutri on, in the context of urbaniza on and rural transforma on. Rome: CFS HLPE-FSN, 2024 h ps://sfcs.fao.org/docs/devhlpelibraries/report-19/hlpe-19---main-report_en_cd1459en.pdf (accessed Aug 22, 2024). 3603 3604 282 HLPE. Nutri on and food systems. 2017. h ps://www.fao.org/3/i7846e/i7846e.pdf (accessed Jan 9, 2024). 3605 3606 283 Lara-Castor L, Micha R, Cudhea F, et al. Sugar-sweetened beverage intakes among adults between 1990 and 2018 in 185 countries. Nat Commun 2023; 14: 5957. 3607 3608 284 Herforth A, Ahmed S. The food environment, its effects on dietary consump on, and poten al for measurement within agriculture-nutri on interven ons. Food Secur 2015; 7: 505–20. 3609 3610 285 Monteiro CA, Cannon G, Levy RB, et al. Ultra-processed foods: what they are and how to iden fy them. Public Health Nutr 2019; 22: 936–41. 3611 3612 286 Bevel MS, Tsai M-H, Parham A, Andrzejak SE, Jones S, Moore JX. Associa on of Food Deserts and Food Swamps With Obesity-Related Cancer Mortality in the US. JAMA Oncol 2023; 9: 909–16. 3613 3614 287 FAO. The State of Food and Agriculture 2024 – Value-driven transforma on of agrifood systems. Rome: FAO, 2024 DOI:10.4060/cd2616en. 3615 3616 3617 288 Mar n A, Eckert K, Haines J, Fraser E. Food literacy, pedagogies, and dietary guidelines: Converging approaches for health and sustainability. In: Routledge Handbook of Sustainable Diets. Routledge, 2022. 3618 3619 289 Rao N, Raju S. Gendered Time, Seasonality, and Nutri on: Insights from Two Indian Districts. Fem Econ 2019; 26: 95–125. 3620 3621 3622 290 Johnston D, Stevano S, Malapit HJ, Hull E, Kadiyala S. Review: Time Use as an Explana on for the Agri-Nutri on Disconnect: Evidence from Rural Areas in Low and Middle-Income Countries. Food Policy 2018; 76: 8–18. 3623 3624 3625 291 Pearson J, Jackson G, McNamara KE. Climate-driven losses to knowledge systems and cultural heritage: A literature review exploring the impacts on Indigenous and local cultures. Anthr Rev 2023; 10: 343–66. 3626 3627 292 Key J, Burne D, Babu JR, Geetha T. The Effects of Food Environment on Obesity in Children: A Systema c Review. Children 2023; 10: 98. 3628 3629 293 Mingay E, Hart M, Yoong S, Hure A. Why We Eat the Way We Do: A Call to Consider Food Culture in Public Health Ini a ves. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2021; 18: 11967. 125 3630 3631 3632 294 UNDEP. What is the Right to a Healthy Environment. 2022 h ps://www.undp.org/sites/g/files/zskgke326/files/2023-01/UNDP-UNEP-UNHCHR-What-is-theRight-to-a-Healthy-Environment.pdf (accessed Nov 29, 2024). 3633 3634 3635 295 Domínguez L, Luoma C. Decolonising Conserva on Policy: How Colonial Land and Conserva on Ideologies Persist and Perpetuate Indigenous Injus ces at the Expense of the Environment. Land 2020; 9: 65. 3636 3637 296 Laila A, Hicks C, Rao N, et al. An overview of food systems injus ces experienced by marginalised groups: A scoping review of reviews. . 3638 3639 297 Lenton TM, Xu C, Abrams JF, et al. Quan fying the human cost of global warming. Nat Sustain 2023; 6: 1237–47. 3640 3641 298 Xu C, Kohler TA, Lenton TM, Svenning J-C, Scheffer M. Future of the human climate niche. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2020; 117: 11350–5. 3642 3643 299 Daoudy M, Sowers J, Weinthal E. What is climate security? Framing risks around water, food, and migra on in the Middle East and North Africa. WIREs Water 2022; 9: e1582. 3644 3645 300 Woodhill J, Kishore A, Njuki J, Jones K, Hasnain S. Food systems and rural wellbeing: challenges and opportuni es. Food Secur 2022; 14: 1099–121. 3646 3647 301 Jain V, Tewathia N, Barik K. Gender-differen ated labor and adapta on effects of climate change in rural areas: A systema c literature review. Gend Issues 2023; 40: 168–84. 3648 3649 302 Cas llo F, Mora AM, Kayser GL, et al. Environmental health threats to La no migrant farmworkers. Annu Rev Public Health 2021; 42: 257–76. 3650 3651 303 Levy BS, Patz JA. Climate change, human rights, and social jus ce. Ann Glob Health 2015; 81: 310–22. 3652 3653 3654 304 WHO. Nitrate and Nitrite in Drinking-water. 2016 h ps://cdn.who.int/media/docs/defaultsource/wash-documents/wash-chemicals/nitrate-nitrite-backgroundjan17.pdf?sfvrsn=1c1e1502_4 (accessed Nov 20, 2024). 3655 3656 3657 305 Glenn BE, Espira LM, Larson MC, Larson PS. Ambient air pollu on and non-communicable respiratory illness in sub-Saharan Africa: a systema c review of the literature. Environ Health 2022; 21: 40. 3658 3659 306 Katoto PDMC, Byamungu L, Brand AS, et al. Ambient air pollu on and health in Sub-Saharan Africa: Current evidence, perspec ves and a call to ac on. Environ Res 2019; 173: 174–88. 3660 3661 3662 307 ILO. ILO Cons tu on. 2021 h ps://www.ilo.org/sites/default/files/wcmsp5/groups/public/%40asia/%40ro-bangkok/%40ilohanoi/documents/publica on/wcms_818973.pdf (accessed Nov 7, 2024). 3663 3664 3665 3666 3667 308 ILO. General Survey of the reports on the Minimum Wage Fixing Conven on, 1970 (No. 131), and the Minimum Wage Fixing Recommenda on, 1970 (No. 135) | Interna onal Labour Organiza on. 2014; published online Feb 7. h ps://www.ilo.org/resource/conferencepaper/ilc/103/general-survey-reports-minimum-wage-fixing-conven on-1970-no-131-and (accessed Nov 7, 2024). 126 3668 3669 309 UNICEF. What is child labour?| UNICEF. 2021. h ps://www.unicef.org/protec on/femalegenital-mu la on?copy_content (accessed Nov 20, 2024). 3670 3671 310 FAO. The state of Food Security and Nutri on in the World 2023. Rome, 2023 DOI:10.4060/cc3017en. 3672 3673 311 Kawarazuka N, Doss CR, Farnworth CR, Pyburn R. Myths about the feminiza on of agriculture: Implica ons for global food security. Glob Food Secur 2022; 33: 100611. 3674 3675 3676 312 Barrick K. Human trafficking, labor exploita on and exposure to environmental hazards: The abuse of farmworkers in the US. In: The Routledge Interna onal Handbook of Rural Criminology. Routledge, 2016. 3677 3678 313 Asadullah MN, Kambhampa U. Feminiza on of farming, food security and female empowerment. Glob Food Secur 2021; 29: 100532. 3679 3680 314 Rao N, Lawson ET, Raditloaneng WN, Solomon D, Angula MN. Gendered vulnerabili es to climate change: insights from the semi-arid regions of Africa and Asia. Clim Dev 2019; 11: 14–26. 3681 3682 315 Reinecke J, Donaghey J. Towards Worker-Driven Supply Chain Governance: Developing Decent Work Through Democra c Worker Par cipa on. J Supply Chain Manag 2021; 57: 14–28. 3683 3684 3685 3686 316 ILO. Social Dialogue Report 2022: Collec ve bargaining for an inclusive, sustainable and resilient recovery. 2022; published online May 5. h ps://www.ilo.org/publica ons/flagshipreports/social-dialogue-report-2022-collec ve-bargaining-inclusive-sustainable-and (accessed Nov 7, 2024). 3687 3688 3689 3690 317 ILO. Conven on C098 - Right to Organise and Collec ve Bargaining Conven on, 1949 (No. 98). 1949. h ps://normlex.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:12100:0::NO::P12100_Ilo_Code:C09 8 (accessed Nov 7, 2024). 3691 3692 3693 3694 318 European Parliament, Council of the European Union. Direc ve (EU) 2022/2041 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 October 2022 on adequate minimum wages in the European Union. Strasbourg, 2022 h ps://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2022/2041/oj/eng (accessed May 25, 2025). 3695 3696 319 ILO. Sta s cs on labour income and inequality. ILOSTAT. 2023. h ps://ilostat.ilo.org/topics/labour-income/ (accessed Nov 25, 2024). 3697 3698 320 Davis B, Mane E, Gurbuzer LY, et al. Es ma ng global and country-level employment in agrifood systems. FAO, 2023 DOI:10.4060/cc4337en. 3699 3700 321 Corrado A, Caruso FS. Essen al but Exploitable: Migrant Agri-Food Workers in Italy and Spain. 2022; published online July 28. DOI:10.1163/15718166-12340126. 3701 3702 322 Liverpool-Tasie LSO, Wineman A, Young S, et al. A scoping review of market links between value chain actors and small-scale producers in developing regions. Nat Sustain 2020; 3: 799–808. 3703 3704 323 Resnick D, Sivasubramanian B. Poli cal trust and informal traders in African ci es. J Mod Afr Stud 2023; 61: 389–412. 127 3705 3706 324 Guidi CF, Ber F. Labor exploita on in the Italian agricultural sector: the case of vulnerable migrants in Tuscany. Front Sociol 2023; 8. DOI:10.3389/fsoc.2023.1234873. 3707 3708 325 Blackstone NT, Rodríguez-Huerta E, Ba aglia K, et al. Forced labour risk is pervasive in the US land-based food supply. Nat Food 2023; 4: 596–606. 3709 3710 3711 3712 326 Michael Fakhri. Starva on and the right to food, with an emphasis on the Pales nian people’s food sovereignty - Report of the Special Rapporteur on the right to food, Michael Fakhri (A/79/171). 2024 h ps://www.un.org/unispal/document/right-to-food-report-17jul24/ (accessed Sept 12, 2024). 3713 3714 3715 327 HLPE. Conflict-induced acute food crises: poten al policy responses in light of current emergencies. 2024 h ps://openknowledge.fao.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/836632c4-01084c66-bd68-08150fee2d81/content (accessed Nov 19, 2024). 3716 3717 328 Kabeer N. The Condi ons and Consequences of Choice: Reflec ons on the Measurement of Women’s Empowerment. 1999. 3718 3719 3720 329 Rao N. Agency and the Capacity to Adapt: Addressing gendered vulnerabili es to climate change. In: Handbook on Climate Change Vulnerability, Environments and Communi es. London: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2025. 3721 3722 330 Clapp J, Moseley WG, Burlingame B, Termine P. Viewpoint: The case for a six-dimensional food security framework. Food Policy 2022; 106: 102164. 3723 3724 331 World Bank. Women, Business and the Law 2024. The World Bank, 2024 DOI:10.1596/978-14648-2063-2. 3725 3726 332 Berry S, Gaynor M, Sco Morton F. Do Increasing Markups Ma er? Lessons from Empirical Industrial Organiza on. J Econ Perspect 2019; 33: 44–68. 3727 3728 333 Béné C. Why the Great Food Transforma on may not happen – A deep-dive into our food systems’ poli cal economy, controversies and poli cs of evidence. World Dev 2022; 154: 105881. 3729 3730 3731 3732 334 Law J, editor. A Dic onary of Business and Management. In: A Dic onary of Business and Management. Oxford University Press, 2016. h ps://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/acref/9780199684984.001.0001/acref9780199684984 (accessed Nov 7, 2024). 3733 335 Clapp J, Scrinis G. Big Food, Nutri onism, and Corporate Power. Globaliza ons 2017; 14: 578–95. 3734 3735 3736 336 Dempsey SE, Zoller HM, Hunt KP. The meatpacking industry’s corporate excep onalism: racialized logics of food chain worker disposability during the COVID-19 crisis. Food Cult Soc 2023; 26: 571–90. 3737 3738 337 Grabs J, Carodenuto SL. Traders as sustainability governance actors in global food supply chains: A research agenda. Bus Strategy Environ 2021; 30: 1314–32. 3739 3740 338 Fabbri A, Holland TJ, Bero LA. Food industry sponsorship of academic research: inves ga ng commercial bias in the research agenda. Public Health Nutr 2018; 21: 3422–30. 128 3741 3742 3743 339 Pedroza-Tobias A, Crosbie E, Mialon M, Carriedo A, Schmidt LA. Food and beverage industry interference in science and policy: efforts to block soda tax implementa on in Mexico and prevent interna onal diffusion. BMJ Glob Health 2021; 6: e005662. 3744 3745 3746 340 Buthelezi T, Hammadi M, Roberts S, Smaller C. Empowering African Food Producers and Agricultural Enterprises Through Stronger Compe on Law and Policy. 2023; published online Nov. 3747 3748 341 Rao N, Marzi E, Baudish I, Laila A, Con C, Hicks C. Ci zen voice and state response in the context of food system transforma on. . 3749 342 Bujdei-Tebeica V. Green Policies, Gray Areas: Civ Szle 2024; 21: 31–47. 3750 3751 343 Altuna N, Dell’Era C, Landoni P, Vergan R. Developing radically new meanings through the collabora on with radical circles. Eur J Innov Manag 2017; 20: 269–90. 3752 3753 3754 344 Häyhä T, Lucas PL, van Vuuren DP, Cornell SE, Hoff H. From Planetary Boundaries to na onal fair shares of the global safe opera ng space — How can the scales be bridged? Glob Environ Change 2016; 40: 60–72. 3755 3756 345 MA. Millennium Ecosystem Assessment. Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Synthesis. Island Press, 2005 h p://www.maweb.org/en/Global.aspx. 3757 3758 3759 3760 346 IPCC. Global warming of 1.5°C. An IPCC Special Report on the impacts of global warming of 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels and related global greenhouse gas emission pathways, in the context of strengthening the global response to the threat of climate change,. Interna onal Panel on Climate Change, 2018 h ps://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/. 3761 3762 3763 347 IPCC. Climate Change and Land: an IPCC special report on climate change, deser fica on, land degrada on, sustainable land management, food security, and greenhouse gas fluxes in terrestrial ecosystems. Interngovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 2019. 3764 3765 348 IPBES. The IPBES assessment report on land degrada on and restora on. Zenodo, 2018 DOI:10.5281/ZENODO.3237393. 3766 3767 349 Hasegawa T, Fujimori S, Havlík P, et al. Risk of increased food insecurity under stringent global climate change mi ga on policy. Nat Clim Change 2018; 8: 699–703. 3768 3769 350 Stehfest E, Zeist W-J van, Valin H, et al. Key determinants of global land-use projec ons. Nat Commun 2019; 10: 2166. 3770 3771 351 Nelson GC, Valin H, Sands RD, et al. Climate change effects on agriculture: Economic responses to biophysical shocks. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2014; 111: 3274–9. 3772 3773 3774 352 Rosenzweig C, Ruane AC, Antle JM, et al. Coordina ng AgMIP data and models across global and regional scales for 1.5°C and 2.0°C assessments. Philos Trans R Soc Math Phys Eng Sci 2018; 376: 20160455. 3775 3776 353 van Vuuren DP, Riahi K, Calvin K, et al. The Shared Socio-economic Pathways: Trajectories for human development and global environmental change. Glob Environ Change 2017; 42: 148–52. 3777 3778 354 Vuuren DP van, Kriegler E, O’Neill BC, et al. A new scenario framework for Climate Change Research: scenario matrix architecture. Clim Change 2014; 122: 373–86. 129 3779 3780 355 O’Neill BC, Kriegler E, Riahi K, et al. A new scenario framework for climate change research: the concept of shared socioeconomic pathways. Clim Change 2014; 122: 387–400. 3781 3782 3783 356 Riahi K, Vuuren DP van, Kriegler E, et al. The Shared Socioeconomic Pathways and their energy, land use, and greenhouse gas emissions implica ons: An overview. Glob Environ Change 2017; 42: 153–68. 3784 3785 357 Dellink R, Chateau J, Lanzi E, Magné B. Long-term economic growth projec ons in the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways. Glob Environ Change 2017; 42: 200–14. 3786 3787 358 KC S, Lutz W. The human core of the shared socioeconomic pathways: Popula on scenarios by age, sex and level of educa on for all countries to 2100. Glob Environ Change 2017; 42: 181–92. 3788 359 IIASA. SSP Scenario Explorer version 3.0.1. 2024. h ps://data.ece.iiasa.ac.at/ssp. 3789 3790 360 Jägermeyr J, Müller C, Ruane AC, et al. Climate impacts on global agriculture emerge earlier in new genera on of climate and crop models. Nat Food 2021; 2: 873–85. 3791 3792 361 Thornton P, Nelson G, Mayberry D, Herrero M. Impacts of heat stress on global ca le produc on during the 21st century: a modelling study. Lancet Planet Health 2022; 6: e192–201. 3793 3794 362 Nelson GC, Vanos J, Havenith G, Jay O, Ebi KL, Hijmans RJ. Global reduc ons in manual agricultural work capacity due to climate change. Glob Change Biol 2024; 30: e17142. 3795 3796 3797 363 Robinson S, Dunston S, Mishra A, et al. The Interna onal Model for Policy Analysis of Agricultural Commodi es and Trade (IMPACT): Model documenta on for version 3.6. 2024; published online July 8. h ps://hdl.handle.net/10568/148953 (accessed Nov 21, 2024). 3798 3799 364 Zeist W-J van, Stehfest E, Doelman JC, et al. Are scenario projec ons overly op mis c about future yield progress? Glob Environ Change 2020; 64: 102120. 3800 365 FAO. FAOSTAT Database. 2024. h ps://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data. 3801 3802 366 Sundiang M, Oliveira TD, Mason D’Croz D, et al. Bundling of ac ons can unlock the poten al for food systems transforma on. forthcoming 2025. 3803 3804 367 Herrero M, Thornton PK, Mason-D’Croz D, et al. Innova on can accelerate the transi on towards a sustainable food system. Nat Food 2020; 1: 266–72. 3805 3806 368 Herrero M, Thornton PK, Mason-D’Croz D, et al. Ar cula ng the effect of food systems innova on on the Sustainable Development Goals. Lancet Planet Health 2021; 5: e50–62. 3807 3808 369 Leip A, Bodirsky BL, Kugelberg S. The role of nitrogen in achieving sustainable food systems for healthy diets. Glob Food Secur 2021; 28: 100408. 3809 3810 370 van Zanten HHE, Simon W, van Selm B, et al. Circularity in Europe strengthens the sustainability of the global food system. Nat Food 2023; 4: 320–30. 3811 3812 371 Van Zanten HHE, Bekkers V, Gerwien L, et al. Circularity contributes to achieve the EAT-Lancet 2.0 food systems transforma on. 2025. 3813 3814 372 Zhao X, Sheng D, Edmonds J, et al. Agroeconomic and environmental implica ons of future labor market evolu on. 2024; published online May 16. DOI:10.21203/rs.3.rs-4259856/v1. 130 3815 3816 373 Jiang L, O’Neill BC. Global urbaniza on projec ons for the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways. Glob Environ Change 2017; 42: 193–9. 3817 3818 374 Chen S, Huang Q, Mu arak R, et al. Upda ng global urbaniza on projec ons under the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways. Sci Data 2022; 9: 137. 3819 3820 375 Vi s Y, Obersteiner M, Godfray, H. Charles J, Springmann M. Labour requirements for healthy and sustainable diets at global, regional, and na onal levels. 2023. 3821 3822 376 Gibson MF, Sundiang M, Mason D’Croz D, et al. Food systems transforma on leads to radical revaluing of global agriculture. 2025. 3823 377 World Bank. World Bank Development Indicators (WDI). 2024. 3824 3825 378 Thais Diniz Oliveira, Marina Sundiang, Daniel Mason-D’Croz, et al. Regional Food Systems Transforma on in a 1.5C World: Challenges and Opportuni es. . 3826 3827 379 Springmann M, Mason-D’Croz D, Robinson S, et al. Mi ga on poten al and global health impacts from emissions pricing of food commodi es. Nat Clim Change 2017; 7: 69–74. 3828 3829 3830 380 Springmann M, Mason-D’Croz D, Robinson S, et al. Health-mo vated taxes on red and processed meat: A modelling study on op mal tax levels and associated health impacts. PLOS ONE 2018; 13: e0204139. 3831 3832 381 FAO. The State of Food and Agriculture 2023: Revealing the true cost of food to transform agrifood systems. Rome, Italy: FAO, 2023 DOI:10.4060/cc7724en. 3833 3834 382 Meadows D. Leverage points: Places to intervene in a system. Hartland: The Sustainability Ins tute., 1999. 3835 3836 383 Dorninger C, Abson DJ, Apetrei CI, et al. Leverage points for sustainability transforma on: a review on interven ons in food and energy systems. Ecol Econ 2020; 171: 106570. 3837 3838 384 Clark MA, Domingo NGG, Colgan K, et al. Global food system emissions could preclude achieving the 1.5° and 2°C climate change targets. Science 2020; 370: 705–8. 3839 3840 385 Schneider KR, Remans R, Bekele TH, et al. Governance and resilience as entry points for transforming food systems in the countdown to 2030. Nat Food 2025; 6: 105–16. 3841 3842 3843 386 Marteau TM, Con C, Bunge AC, et al. Food environment interven ons to shi consump on pa erns towards planetary health diets for all: protocol for a scoping review of reviews. 2023; published online May 6. DOI:10.17605/OSF.IO/KBFEP. 3844 3845 387 Swinburn BA, Sacks G, Hall KD, et al. The global obesity pandemic: shaped by global drivers and local environments. 2011; 378: 804–14. 3846 3847 388 Marteau TM, White M, Ru er H, et al. Increasing healthy life expectancy equitably in England by 5 years by 2035: could it be achieved? The Lancet 2019; 393: 2571–3. 3848 3849 389 Peeters A. Obesity and the future of food policies that promote healthy diets. Nat Rev Endocrinol 2018 147 2018; 14: 430–7. 131 3850 3851 3852 390 Philipsborn P von, Stra l JM, Burns J, et al. Environmental interven ons to reduce the consump on of sugar-sweetened beverages and their effects on health. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2019. DOI:10.1002/14651858.CD012292.pub2. 3853 3854 3855 391 Andreyeva T, Marple K, Moore TE, Powell LM. Evalua on of Economic and Health Outcomes Associated With Food Taxes and Subsidies: A Systema c Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA Netw Open 2022; 5: e2214371. 3856 3857 392 Pineda E, Gressier M, Li D, et al. Review: Effec veness and policy implica ons of health taxes on foods high in fat, salt, and sugar. Food Policy 2024; 123: 102599. 3858 3859 3860 393 Andreyeva T, Marple K, Marinello S, Moore TE, Powell LM. Outcomes Following Taxa on of Sugar-Sweetened Beverages: A Systema c Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA Netw Open 2022; 5: e2215276. 3861 3862 3863 394 Boyland E, McGale L, Maden M, et al. Associa on of Food and Nonalcoholic Beverage Marke ng With Children and Adolescents’ Ea ng Behaviors and Health: A Systema c Review and Metaanalysis. JAMA Pediatr 2022; 176: e221037. 3864 3865 3866 395 Yau A, Berger N, Law C, et al. Changes in household food and drink purchases following restric ons on the adver sement of high fat, salt, and sugar products across the Transport for London network: A controlled interrupted me series analysis. PLOS Med 2022; 19: e1003915. 3867 3868 3869 396 Taillie LS, Bercholz M, Popkin B, Rebolledo N, Reyes M, Corvalán C. Decreases in purchases of energy, sodium, sugar, and saturated fat 3 years a er implementa on of the Chilean food labeling and marke ng law: An interrupted me series analysis. PLOS Med 2024; 21: e1004463. 3870 3871 3872 397 Clarke N, Ferrar J, Pechey E, et al. Impact of health warning labels and calorie labels on selec on and purchasing of alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinks: A randomized controlled trial. Addic on 2023; 118: 2327–41. 3873 3874 3875 398 Evans R, O’Flaherty M, Putra IGNE, Kypridemos C, Robinson E, Colombet Z. The es mated impact of mandatory front-of-pack nutri on labelling policies on adult obesity prevalence and cardiovascular mortality in England: a modelling study. 2024; : 2024.10.14.24315283. 3876 3877 3878 399 Mingay E, Hart M, Yoong S, et al. The Impact of Modifying Food Service Prac ces in Secondary Schools Providing a Rou ne Meal Service on Student’s Food Behaviours, Health and Dining Experience: A Systema c Review and Meta-Analysis. Nutrients 2022; 14: 3640. 3879 3880 400 Hollands GJ, Cartwright E, Pilling M, et al. Impact of reducing por on sizes in worksite cafeterias: a stepped wedge randomised controlled pilot trial. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 2018; 15: 78. 3881 3882 3883 401 Hollands GJ, Shemilt I, Marteau TM, et al. Por on, package or tableware size for changing selec on and consump on of food, alcohol and tobacco. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2015; 2015: CD011045. 3884 3885 3886 402 Robinson E, McFarland-Lesser I, Patel Z, Jones A. Downsizing food: a systema c review and meta-analysis examining the effect of reducing served food por on sizes on daily energy intake and body weight. Br J Nutr 2023; 129: 888–903. 3887 3888 3889 403 McCullough EB, Lu M, Nouve Y, Arsenault J, Zhen C. Nutrient adequacy for poor households in Africa would improve with higher income but not necessarily with lower food prices. Nat Food 2024; 5: 171–81. 132 3890 3891 404 Sumaila UR, Wabnitz CCC, Teh LSL, et al. U lizing basic income to create a sustainable, povertyfree tomorrow. Cell Rep Sustain 2024; 1: 100104. 3892 3893 3894 405 Nomura M, Yamaguchi M, Inada Y, Nishi N. Current dietary intake of the Japanese popula on in reference to the planetary health diet-preliminary assessment. Front Nutr 2023; 10. DOI:10.3389/fnut.2023.1116105. 3895 3896 3897 406 Salis S, Virmani A, Priyambada L, Mohan M, Hansda K, Beaufort C de. ‘Old Is Gold’: How Tradi onal Indian Dietary Prac ces Can Support Pediatric Diabetes Management. Nutrients 2021; 13: 4427. 3898 3899 3900 407 Sidiq FF, Coles D, Hubbard C, Clark B, Frewer LJ. The Role of Tradi onal Diets in Promo ng Food Security for Indigenous Peoples in Low- and Middle-Income Countries: A Systema c Review. IOP Conf Ser Earth Environ Sci 2022; 978: 012001. 3901 3902 408 IFFO. Case study: Peruvian Anchovy - Why feed, not food? 2017. h ps://www.iffo.com/casestudy-peruvian-anchovy-why-feed-not-food (accessed Oct 8, 2024). 3903 3904 409 UNICEF. Review of na onal Food-Based Dietary Guidelines and associated guidance for infants, children, adolescents, and pregnant and lacta ng women. New York: UNICEF, 2020. 3905 3906 410 FAO. Unleashing the poten al of millets – Interna onal Year of Millets 2023. Rome: FAO, 2023 h ps://doi.org/10.4060/cc7484en. 3907 3908 3909 411 Li X, Yadav R, Siddique KHM. Neglected and Underu lized Crop Species: The Key to Improving Dietary Diversity and Figh ng Hunger and Malnutri on in Asia and the Pacific. Front Nutr 2020; 7. DOI:10.3389/fnut.2020.593711. 3910 3911 412 IPES-Food. Food from somewhere: Building food security and resilience through territorial markets. 2024 h ps://ipes-food.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/FoodFromSomewhere.pdf. 3912 3913 3914 413 GAIN. Strengthening Demand for Underu lised Crops: A Summary Report of a Workshop Focused on the ‘Vision for Adapted Crops and Soils’ Ini a ve. Global Alliance for Improved Nutri on, 2024 DOI:10.36072/cp.8. 3915 3916 414 FAO. Compendium of forgo en foods in Africa – A companion publica on for Integra ng Africa’s forgo en foods for be er nutri on. Accra: FAO, 2024 DOI:10.4060/cc5044en. 3917 3918 3919 3920 415 Pimbert M. Reclaiming Diverse Seed Commons Through Food Sovereignty, Agroecology and Economies of Care. In: Nishikawa Y, Pimbert M, eds. Seeds for Diversity and Inclusion: Agroecology and Endogenous Development. Cham: Springer Interna onal Publishing, 2022: 21– 39. 3921 3922 3923 416 Béné C, Devereux S. Resilience, Food Security and Food Systems: Se ng the Scene. In: Béné C, Devereux S, eds. Resilience and Food Security in a Food Systems Context. Cham: Springer Interna onal Publishing, 2023: 1–29. 3924 3925 417 FAO. A mul -billion-dollar opportunity – Repurposing agricultural support to transform food systems. Rome, Italy: FAO, UNDP, and UNEP, 2021 DOI:10.4060/cb6562en. 3926 3927 418 Chapman M, Wiltshire S, Baur P, et al. Social-ecological feedbacks drive pping points in farming system diversifica on. One Earth 2022; 5: 283–92. 133 3928 419 FAO. The gender gap in land rights. Rome, 2018. 3929 3930 420 Davis KE, Makhija S, Spielman DJ. Agricultural extension and rural advisory services: What have we learned? What’s next? Washington, DC: IFPRI, 2021 DOI:10.2499/p15738coll2.134719. 3931 3932 421 Blesh J, Mehrabi Z, Wi man H, et al. Against the odds: Network and ins tu onal pathways enabling agricultural diversifica on. One Earth 2023; 6: 479–91. 3933 3934 422 Hertel T, Elouafi I, Tan charoen M, Ewert F. Diversifica on for enhanced food systems resilience. Nat Food 2021; 2: 832–4. 3935 3936 3937 3938 423 IPES-Food. From uniformity to diversity: a paradigm shi from industrial agriculture to diversified agroecological systems. Interna onal Panel of Experts on Sustainable Food systems, 2016 h ps://www.ipes-food.org/_img/upload/files/UniformityToDiversity_FULL.pdf (accessed July 11, 2024). 3939 424 IPES-Food. Another perfect storm? 2022. 3940 3941 425 DeLonge MS, Miles A, Carlisle L. Inves ng in the transi on to sustainable agriculture. Environ Sci Policy 2016; 55: 266–73. 3942 3943 3944 3945 426 Jackson L, Rosenstock T, Thomas M, Wright J, Symstad A. Managed ecosystems: biodiversity and ecosystem func ons in landscapes modified by human use. In: Naeem S, Bunker DE, Hector A, Loreau M, Perrings C, eds. Biodiversity, Ecosystem Func oning, and Human Wellbeing, 1st edn. Oxford University PressOxford, 2009: 178–94. 3946 3947 427 Springmann M, Freund F. Op ons for reforming agricultural subsidies from health, climate, and economic perspec ves. Nat Commun 2022; 13: 82. 3948 3949 428 Meyfroidt P, de Bremond A, Ryan CM, et al. Ten facts about land systems for sustainability. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2022; 119: e2109217118. 3950 3951 429 Dawson NM, Coolsaet B, Sterling EJ, et al. The role of Indigenous peoples and local communi es in effec ve and equitable conserva on. Ecol Soc 2021; 26: art19. 3952 3953 430 FAO. Voluntary Guidelines on the Responsible Governance of Tenure of Land, Fisheries and Forests in the Context of Na onal Food Security. Rome: FAO, 2022. 3954 3955 3956 3957 431 IPBES. Summary for Policymakers of the Thema c Assessment Report on the Sustainable Use of Wild Species of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Pla orm on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services. Bonn, Germany: IPBES secretariat, Bonn, Germany, 2022 h ps://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.6425599. 3958 3959 3960 432 Cesar de Oliveira SEM, Nakagawa L, Lopes GR, et al. The European Union and United Kingdom’s deforesta on-free supply chains regula ons: Implica ons for Brazil. Ecol Econ 2024; 217: 108053. 3961 3962 433 Carlson KM, Heilmayr R, Gibbs HK, et al. Effect of oil palm sustainability cer fica on on deforesta on and fire in Indonesia. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2018; 115: 121–6. 3963 3964 434 Garre RD, Levy S, Carlson KM, et al. Criteria for effec ve zero-deforesta on commitments. Glob Environ Change 2019; 54: 135–47. 134 3965 3966 435 Lambin EF, Furumo PR. Deforesta on-Free Commodity Supply Chains: Myth or Reality? Annu Rev Environ Resour 2023; 48: 237–61. 3967 3968 3969 436 Papargyropoulou E, Lozano R, K. Steinberger J, Wright N, Ujang Z bin. The food waste hierarchy as a framework for the management of food surplus and food waste. J Clean Prod 2014; 76: 106– 15. 3970 3971 437 GLOPAN. Preven ng nutrient loss and waste across the food system: Policy ac ons for highquality diets. London: Global Panel on Agriculture and Food Systems for Nutri on, 2018. 3972 3973 3974 438 Rolker H, Eisler M, Cardenas L, Deeney M, Takahashi T. Food waste interven ons in low-andmiddle-income countries: A systema c literature review. Resour Conserv Recycl 2022; 186: 106534. 3975 3976 439 Fesenfeld LP, Sun Y. A systema c literature review on food waste/loss preven on and minimiza on methods. J Environ Manage 2021; 286: 112268. 3977 3978 440 Messner R, Johnson H, Richards C. From surplus-to-waste: A study of systemic overproduc on, surplus and food waste in hor cultural supply chains. J Clean Prod 2021; 278: 123952–123952. 3979 441 FAO. The status of women in agrifood systems. FAO, 2023 DOI:10.4060/cc5343en. 3980 3981 442 HLPE. Promo ng youth engagement and employment in agriculture and food systems. Rome, 2021. 3982 3983 3984 443 ILO. Conven on C182 - Worst Forms of Child Labour Conven on, 1999 (No. 182). 1999. h ps://normlex.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:12100:0::NO::P12100_ILO_CODE:C1 82 (accessed Nov 19, 2024). 3985 3986 3987 444 ILO. Conven on C184 - Safety and Health in Agriculture Conven on, 2001 (No. 184). 2001. h ps://normlex.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:12100:0::NO::P12100_ILO_CODE:C1 84 (accessed Nov 19, 2024). 3988 3989 3990 445 ILO. Conven on C190 - Violence and Harassment Conven on, 2019 (No. 190). 2019. h ps://normlex.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:12100:0::NO::P12100_ILO_CODE:C1 90 (accessed Nov 19, 2024). 3991 3992 446 Herens MC, Pi ore KH, Oosterveer PJM. Transforming food systems: Mul -stakeholder pla orms driven by consumer concerns and public demands. Glob Food Secur 2022; 32: 100592. 3993 3994 447 FAO, Rikolto, Ruaf. Urban and peri-urban agriculture sourcebook – From produc on to food systems. Rome: FAO and Rikolto, 2022 DOI:10.4060/cb9722en. 3995 3996 3997 448 Gupta C, Campbell D, Munden-Dixon K, et al. Food Policy Councils and Local Governments: Crea ng Effec ve Collabora on for Food Systems Change. J Agric Food Syst Community Dev 2018; 8: 11–28. 3998 3999 4000 4001 449 Aktar S, McIntyre-Mills J. Reserved Seats for Women in Rural Local Government: Achieving a Level Playing Field. In: McIntyre-Mills J, Romm NRA, eds. Mixed Methods and Cross Disciplinary Research: Towards Cul va ng Eco-systemic Living. Cham: Springer Interna onal Publishing, 2019: 371–97. 135 4002 4003 450 Morison J. Ci zen Par cipa on: A Cri cal Look at the Democra c Adequacy of Government Consulta ons. Oxf J Leg Stud 2017; 37: 636–59. 4004 4005 4006 451 Shekar M, Kyoko SO, Mireya V-C, Dell’Aira C. Investment Framework for Nutri on 2024. Washington, D.C.: World Bank, 2024 h ps://hdl.handle.net/10986/42164 (accessed Nov 19, 2024). 4007 452 HLPE. Social protec on for food security. Rome, 2012. 4008 4009 453 Eseonu T. Co-crea on as social innova on: including ‘hard-to-reach’ groups in public service delivery. Public Money Manag 2022; 42: 306–13. 4010 4011 454 OECD. The OECD Reinforcing Democracy Ini a ve: Monitoring Report – Assessing Progress and Char ng the Way Forward. OECD, 2024 DOI:10.1787/9543bc -en. 4012 4013 4014 455 Klerkx L, Rose D. Dealing with the game-changing technologies of Agriculture 4.0: How do we manage diversity and responsibility in food system transi on pathways? Glob Food Secur 2020; 24: 100347–100347. 4015 4016 4017 456 Klerkx L, Jakku E, Labarthe P. A review of social science on digital agriculture, smart farming and agriculture 4.0: New contribu ons and a future research agenda. NJAS - Wagening J Life Sci 2019; 90–91: 100315–100315. 4018 4019 4020 4021 457 Hall A, Dijkman J. Public Agricultural Research in an Era of Transforma on : The Challenge of Agri-Food System Innova on. Rome and Canberra: CGIAR Independent Science and Partnership Council (ISPC) Secretariat and Commonwealth Scien fic and Industrial Research Organisa on (CSIRO), 2019. 4022 4023 4024 458 Bunge AC, Wood A, Halloran A, Gordon LJ. A systema c scoping review of the sustainability of ver cal farming, plant-based alterna ves, food delivery services and blockchain in food systems. Nat Food 2022; 3: 933–41. 4025 4026 459 Barre CB, Benton TG, Cooper KA, et al. Bundling innova ons to transform agri-food. Nat Sustain 2020; 23: 974–6. 4027 4028 4029 460 Remans R, Zornetzer H, Mason-D’Croz D, et al. Backcas ng supports cross-sectoral collabora on and social-technical innova on bundling: case studies in agri-food systems. Front Sustain Food Syst 2024; 8. DOI:10.3389/fsufs.2024.1378883. 4030 4031 4032 461 Barre CB, Benton T, Fanzo J, et al. Socio-Technical Innova on Bundles Tailored to Dis nct AgriFood Systems. In: Barre CB, Benton T, Fanzo J, et al., eds. Socio-Technical Innova on Bundles for Agri-Food Systems Transforma on. Cham: Springer Interna onal Publishing, 2022: 159–68. 4033 4034 462 Nesta. A blueprint to halve obesity in the UK. Blueprint. 2024. h ps://blueprint.nesta.org.uk/ (accessed Nov 20, 2024). 4035 4036 4037 463 De Schu er O, Jacobs N, Clément C. A ‘Common Food Policy’ for Europe: How governance reforms can spark a shi to healthy diets and sustainable food systems. Food Policy 2020; 96: 101849. 4038 4039 464 Fesenfeld LP, Wicki M, Sun Y, Bernauer T. Policy packaging can make food system transforma on feasible. Nat Food 2020; 1: 173–82. 136 4040 4041 4042 4043 465 Fesenfeld LP, Sun Y. Enabling Posi ve Tipping Points in Public Support for Food System Transforma on: The Case of Meat Consump on. In: Resnick D, Swinnen J, eds. The Poli cal Economy of Food System Transforma on: Pathways to Progress in a Polarized World. Oxford University Press, 2023: 0. 4044 4045 466 Cara ni S, Dur R, List J. Policy evalua on and the causal analysis of public support. Science 2024; 386: 490–2. 4046 4047 467 Malkanth SHP. Outlook of Present Organic Agriculture Policies and Future Needs in Sri Lanka. 2021; 21: 55–72. 4048 4049 4050 468 Collet AM. Dissec ng misalignment in agri-environmental policy design : The Case of the PAS and the Dutch Nitrogen Crisis. University of Twente, 2023 h ps://essay.utwente.nl/96165/ (accessed Nov 20, 2024). 4051 4052 469 Tatham M, Peters Y. Fueling opposi on? Yellow vests, urban elites, and fuel taxa on. J Eur Public Policy 2023; 30: 574–98. 4053 4054 4055 470 FAO. The Fome Zero (Zero Hunger) Program: The Brazilian experience. 2011 h ps://www.fao.org/fsnforum/resources/reports-and-briefs/fome-zero-zero-hunger-programbrazilian-experience (accessed Nov 15, 2024). 4056 471 Sachs J, Silva GJ. Brazil’s Fome Zero Strategy: Can It Be Replicated. 2010. 4057 4058 472 Lucas E, Guo M, Guillén-Gosálbez G. Low-carbon diets can reduce global ecological and health costs. Nat Food 2023; 4: 394–406. 4059 4060 4061 473 Su on WR, Lotsch A, Prasann A. Recipe for a Livable Planet: Achieving Net Zero Emissions in the Agrifood System. Washington, DC: World Bank, 2024 h p://hdl.handle.net/10986/41468 (accessed Nov 24, 2024). 4062 4063 474 Dengerink J, Dirks F, Likoko E, Guijt J. One size doesn’t fit all: regional differences in priori es for food system transforma on. Food Secur 2021; 13: 1455–66. 4064 4065 475 Eckert N, Rusch G, Lyy mäki J, et al. Sustainable Development Goals and risks: The Yin and the Yang of the paths towards sustainability. Ambio 2023; 52: 683–701. 4066 4067 476 Andersen I, Ishii N, Brooks T, et al. Defining ‘science-based targets’. Natl Sci Rev 2021; 8: nwaa186. 4068 4069 477 Kalibata A, Nabarro D. Food systems transforma on through dialogues. Nat Food 2024; published online Oct 22. DOI:10.1038/s43016-024-01060-4. 4070 4071 478 Commi ee on World Food Security. CFS: Voluntary Guidelines on Food Systems and Nutri on. 2022. h ps://www.fao.org/cfs/vgfsn/en) (accessed March 8, 2025). 4072 4073 479 Bjørn A, Tilsted JP, Addas A, Lloyd SM. Can Science-Based Targets Make the Private Sector ParisAligned? A Review of the Emerging Evidence. Curr Clim Change Rep 2022; 8: 53–69. 4074 4075 4076 480 Fink LO. What drives firms to successfully cooperate on climate change? - an ins tu onal analysis of the Science Based Targets ini a ve. 2018. h ps://www.irithesys.org/media/Masterarbeit_Fink.pdf. 137 4077 4078 481 Thomas H, Chung YF, Maron M, et al. Achieving “nature posi ve” requires net gain legisla on. Science 2024; 386: 383–5. 4079 4080 4081 482 Nordhagen S, Fanzo J. Tracking Progress and Genera ng Accountability for Global Food System Commitments. In: Resnick D, Swinnen J, eds. The Poli cal Economy of Food System Transforma on, 1st edn. Oxford University PressOxford, 2023: 338–59. 4082 4083 483 Caron P, Ferrero de Loma-Osorio G, Ferroni M, Lehmann B, Me enleiter TC, Sokona Y. Global food security: pool collec ve intelligence. Nature 2022; 612: 631–631. 4084 4085 4086 484 Fanzo J, Haddad L, Schneider KR, et al. Viewpoint: Rigorous monitoring is necessary to guide food system transforma on in the countdown to the 2030 global goals. Food Policy 2021; 104: 102163–102163. 4087 4088 4089 485 Govaerts B, Negra C, Villa TCC, et al. One CGIAR and the Integrated Agri-food Systems Ini a ve: From short-termism to transforma on of the world’s food systems. PLOS ONE 2021; 16: e0252832. 4090 4091 486 Con C, Hall A, Orr A, Hambloch C, Mausch K. Complexity-aware principles for agri-food system interven ons: Lessons from project encounters with complexity. Agric Syst 2024; 220: 104080. 4092 4093 487 Duncan J, DeClerck F, Báldi A, et al. Democra c direc onality for transforma ve food systems research. Nat Food 2022; 3: 183–6. 4094 4095 488 Turnhout E, Metze T, Wyborn C, Klenk N, Louder E. The poli cs of co-produc on: par cipa on, power, and transforma on. Curr Opin Environ Sustain 2020; 42: 15–21. 4096 4097 489 Den Boer AC, Broerse JE, Regeer BJ. The need for capacity building to accelerate food system transforma on. Curr Opin Food Sci 2021; 42: 119–26. 4098 4099 490 den Boer ACL, Kok KPW, Gill M, et al. Research and innova on as a catalyst for food system transforma on. 2021; 107: 150–6. 4100 4101 491 Swinnen J, Resnick D. Policy coali ons in food systems transforma on. Interna onal Food Policy Research Ins tute, 2023 h ps://hdl.handle.net/10568/140100 (accessed Nov 15, 2024). 4102 4103 4104 492 Con C, Hall A, Moallemi EA, et al. Top-down vs bo om-up processes: A systema c review clarifying roles and pa erns of interac ons in food system transforma on. Glob Food Secur 2025; 44: 100833. 4105 4106 4107 493 Con C, Hall A, Percy H, Stone-Jovicich S, Turner J, McMillan L. What does the agri-food systems transforma on agenda mean for agricultural research organisa ons? Exploring organisa onal prototypes for uncertain futures. Glob Food Secur 2024; 40: 100733. 4108 4109 4110 494 Slater S, Lawrence M, Wood B, Serodio P, Akker AVD, Baker P. The rise of mul -stakeholderism, the power of ultra-processed food corpora ons, and the implica ons for global food governance: a network analysis. Agric Hum Values 2024. DOI:10.1007/s10460-024-10593-0. 4111 4112 495 Resnick D, Swinnen J, editors. Conclusions. In: The Poli cal Economy of Food System Transforma on: Pathways to Progress in a Polarized World. Oxford University Press, 2023: 0. 4113 4114 496 Deconinck K, Giner C, Jackson LA, Toyama L. Making be er policies for food systems will require reducing evidence gaps. Glob Food Secur 2022; 33: 100621. 138 4115 4116 4117 497 Béné C, Lundy M. Poli cal economy of protein transi on: Ba les of power, framings and narra ves around a false wicked problem. Front Sustain 2023; 4. DOI:10.3389/frsus.2023.1098011. 4118 4119 498 Con C, Zanello G, Hall A. Why are agri-food systems resistant to new direc ons of change ? A systema c review. Glob Food Secur 2021; 31: 100576–100576. 4120 4121 4122 499 IPES-Food. Too Big to Feed: Exploring the impacts of mega-mergers, consolida on and concentra on of power in the agri-food sector. 2017 h ps://ipes-food.org/report/too-big-tofeed/ (accessed Nov 24, 2024). 4123 4124 4125 500 Gaucher-Holm A, Wood B, Sacks G, Vanderlee L. The structure of the Canadian packaged food and non-alcoholic beverage manufacturing and grocery retailing sectors through a public health lens. Glob Health 2023; 19: 18. 4126 4127 501 Swinburn B. Power dynamics in 21st-century food systems. Nutrients 2019; 11. DOI:10.3390/nu11102544. 4128 4129 502 Morris V, Jacquet J. The animal agriculture industry, US universi es, and the obstruc on of climate understanding and policy. Clim Change 2024; 177: 41. 4130 4131 503 Kra enmacher J, Espinosa R, Sanders E, Twine R, Ripple WJ. The Dublin Declara on: Gain for the Meat Industry, Loss for Science. Environ Sci Policy 2024; : 103922. 4132 4133 504 Clapp J, Noyes I, Grant Z. The Food Systems Summit’s Failure to Address Corporate Power. Development 2021; 64: 192–8. 4134 505 Clapp J, Fuchs DA. Corporate Power in Global Agrifood Governance. MIT Press, 2009. 4135 4136 4137 506 Gahman L, Smith S-J, Penados F, Mohamed N, Reyes J-R, Mohamed A. Health, food sovereignty, solidarity economies. In: A Beginner’s Guide to Building Be er Worlds - Ideas and Inspira on from the Zapa stas. Bristol, UK: UK Policy Press, 2022: 128–49. 4138 4139 4140 507 Con C, Hall A, Williams TG, Kumar V, Zanello G. Detec ng ‘green shoots’ of agri-food systems transforma on: a framework and insights from the spread of non-pes cide approaches in South India. Innov Dev 2024; : 1–19. 4141 4142 4143 508 Baker P, Hawkes C, Wingrove K, et al. What drives poli cal commitment for nutri on? A review and framework synthesis to inform the United Na ons Decade of Ac on on Nutri on. BMJ Glob Health 2018; 3: e000485. 4144 4145 509 As ll J, Dara RA, Campbell M, et al. Transparency in food supply chains: A review of enabling technology solu ons. Trends Food Sci Technol 2019; 91: 240–7. 4146 4147 510 Kortleve AJ, Mogollón JM, Harwa H, Behrens P. Over 80% of the European Union’s Common Agricultural Policy supports emissions-intensive animal products. Nat Food 2024; 5: 288–92. 4148 4149 511 Damania R, Balseca E, de Fontaubert C, et al. Detox Development: Repurposing Environmentally Harmful Subsidies. Washington, DC : World Bank, 2023 DOI:10.1596/978-1-4648-1916-2. 4150 4151 512 Segerson K, Polasky S, Scheffer M, et al. A cau ous approach to subsidies for environmental sustainability. Science 2024; 386: 28–30. 139 4152 4153 513 WHO. Ac on framework for developing and implemen ng public food procurement and service policies for a healthy diet. Geneva: WHO, 2021. 4154 4155 514 Vansant E, den Braber B, Hall C, et al. Food-sourcing from on-farm trees mediates posi ve rela onships between tree cover and dietary quality in Malawi. Nat Food 2024; 5: 661–6. 4156 4157 515 Ickowitz A, McMullin S, Rosenstock T, et al. Transforming food systems with trees and forests. Lancet Planet Health 2022; 6: e632–9. 4158 4159 516 Singh BK, Arnold T, Biermayr-Jenzano P, et al. Enhancing science–policy interfaces for food systems transforma on. Nat Food 2021; 2: 838–42. 4160 4161 4162 517 Black S, Parry I, Vernon-Lin N. Fossil Fuel Subsidies Surged to Record $7 Trillion. IMF. 2023; published online Aug 24. h ps://www.imf.org/en/Blogs/Ar cles/2023/08/24/fossil-fuelsubsidies-surged-to-record-7-trillion (accessed Nov 24, 2024). 4163 4164 4165 518 IRENA. Offshore renewables: An ac on agenda for deployment. Abu Dhabi: Interna onal Renewable Energy Agency, 2021 h ps://www.irena.org//media/Files/IRENA/Agency/Publica on/2021/Jul/IRENA_G20_Offshore_renewables_2021.pdf. 4166 4167 4168 4169 519 World Bank. Climate change ac on plan 2021-2025. 2021 h ps://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/705731624380363785/pdf/World-Bank-GroupClimate-Change-Ac on-Plan-2021-2025-Suppor ng-Green-Resilient-and-InclusiveDevelopment.pdf. 4170 4171 4172 4173 4174 Panel References 4175 4176 P1 Hill AB. The Environment and Disease: Associa on or Causa on? Proc R Soc Med 1965; 58: 295–300. 4177 4178 P2 Mozaffarian D, Forouhi NG. Dietary guidelines and health-is nutri on science up to the task? BMJ 2018; 360: k822. 4179 4180 4181 P3 Guasch-Ferre M, Sa ja A, Blondin SA, et al. Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials of Red Meat Consump on in Comparison With Various Comparison Diets on Cardiovascular Risk Factors. Circula on 2019; 139: 1828–45. 4182 4183 P4 Song M, Fung TT, Hu FB, et al. Associa on of Animal and Plant Protein Intake With All-Cause and Cause-Specific Mortality. JAMA Intern Med 2016; 176: 1453–63. 4184 4185 4186 P5 Wang Y, Liu B, Han H, et al. Associa ons between plant-based dietary pa erns and risks of type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, cancer, and mortality - a systema c review and meta-analysis. Nutr J 2023; 22: 46. 4187 4188 4189 4190 P6 Filippou CD, Tsioufis CP, Thomopoulos CG, et al. Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) Diet and Blood Pressure Reduc on in Adults with and without Hypertension: A Systema c Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Adv Nutr 2020; 11: 1150–60. 140 4191 4192 4193 P7 Hollaender PL, Ross AB, Kristensen M. Whole-grain and blood lipid changes in apparently healthy adults: a systema c review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled studies. Am J Clin Nutr 2015; 102: 556–72. 4194 4195 P8 Mensink RP, Katan MB. Effect of dietary fa y acids on serum lipids and lipoproteins. A metaanalysis of 27 trials. Arter Thromb 1992; 12: 911–9. 4196 4197 4198 P9 Hu FB, Drescher G, Trichopoulou A, Wille WC, Mar nez-González MA. Three Decades of the Mediterranean Diet Pyramid: A Narra ve Review of Its History, Evolu on, and Advances. Am J Clin Nutr 2025; : S0002-9165(25)00259-X. 4199 4200 P10 Guasch-Ferre M, Wille WC. The Mediterranean diet and health: a comprehensive overview. J Intern Med 2021; 290: 549–66. 4201 4202 4203 P11 Estruch R, Ros E, Salas-Salvado J, et al. Primary Preven on of Cardiovascular Disease with a Mediterranean Diet Supplemented with Extra-Virgin Olive Oil or Nuts. N Engl J Med 2018; 378: e34. 4204 4205 P12 Salas-Salvado J, Bullo M, Estruch R, et al. Preven on of diabetes with Mediterranean diets: a subgroup analysis of a randomized trial. Ann Intern Med 2014; 160: 1–10. 4206 4207 P13 Mar nez-Lapiscina EH, Clavero P, Toledo E, et al. Mediterranean diet improves cogni on: the PREDIMED-NAVARRA randomised trial. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2013; 84: 1318–25. 4208 4209 P14 Valls-Pedret C, Sala-Vila A, Serra-Mir M, et al. Mediterranean Diet and Age-Related Cogni ve Decline: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Intern Med 2015; 175: 1094–103. 4210 4211 P15 Guasch-Ferre M, Salas-Salvado J, Ros E, et al. The PREDIMED trial, Mediterranean diet and health outcomes: How strong is the evidence? Nutr Metab Cardiovasc Dis 2017; 27: 624–32. 4212 4213 4214 P16 Salas-Salvado J, Diaz-Lopez A, Ruiz-Canela M, et al. Effect of a Lifestyle Interven on Program With Energy-Restricted Mediterranean Diet and Exercise on Weight Loss and Cardiovascular Risk Factors: One-Year Results of the PREDIMED-Plus Trial. Diabetes Care 2019; 42: 777–88. 4215 4216 P17 Shai I, Schwarzfuchs D, Henkin Y, et al. Weight loss with a low-carbohydrate, Mediterranean, or low-fat diet. N Engl J Med 2008; 359: 229–41. 4217 4218 P18 Schwarzfuchs D, Golan R, Shai I. Four-year follow-up a er two-year dietary interven ons. N Engl J Med 2012; 367: 1373–4. 4219 4220 4221 P19 Springmann M, Auclair O, Bajaj S, et al. Many diets for many people: planetary health diets and their health and environmental impacts at global, regional, na onal, and demographic levels. Nature; Submi ed. 4222 4223 P20 Wille W, Rockström J, Loken B, et al. Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT–Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems. The Lancet 2019; 393: 447–92. 4224 4225 P21 Bui LP, Pham TT, Wang F, et al. Planetary Health Diet Index and risk of total and causespecific mortality in three prospec ve cohorts. Am J Clin Nutr 2024; 120: 80–91. 4226 4227 4228 P22 Gu X, Bui LP, Wang F, Wang DD, Springmann M, Wille WC. Global adherence to a healthy and sustainable diet and poten al reduc on in premature death. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2024; 121: e2319008121. 141 4229 4230 4231 P23 Romanello M, Napoli C di, Green C, et al. The 2023 report of the Lancet Countdown on health and climate change: the impera ve for a health-centred response in a world facing irreversible harms. Lancet Lond Engl 2023; 402: 2346–94. 4232 4233 P24 Rezaei EE, Webber H, Asseng S, et al. Climate change impacts on crop yields. Nat Rev Earth Environ 2023; 4: 831–46. 4234 4235 P25 Smith MR, Myers SS. Impact of anthropogenic CO2 emissions on global human nutri on. Nat Clim Change 2018; 8: 834–9. 4236 4237 P26 Fuller R, Landrigan PJ, Balakrishnan K, et al. Pollu on and health: a progress update. Lancet Planet Health 2022; 6: e535–47. 4238 4239 P27 Lelieveld J, Evans JS, Fnais M, Giannadaki D, Pozzer A. The contribu on of outdoor air pollu on sources to premature mortality on a global scale. Nature 2015; 525: 367–71. 4240 4241 4242 P28 Achakulwisut P, Brauer M, Hystad P, Anenberg SC. Global, na onal, and urban burdens of paediatric asthma incidence a ributable to ambient NO2 pollu on: es mates from global datasets. Lancet Planet Health 2019; 3: e166–78. 4243 4244 P29 Springmann M, Van Dingenen R, Vandyck T, Latka C, Witzke P, Leip A. The global and regional air quality impacts of dietary change. Nat Commun 2023; 14: 6227. 4245 4246 P30 Ward MH, Jones RR, Brender JD, et al. Drinking water nitrate and human health: an updated review. Int J Environ Res Public Health 2018; 15: 1557. 4247 4248 P31 De Vries W. Impacts of nitrogen emissions on ecosystems and human health: A mini review. Curr Opin Environ Sci Health 2021; 21: 100249. 4249 4250 P32 Schulte-Uebbing LF, Beusen AHW, Bouwman AF, de Vries W. From planetary to regional boundaries for agricultural nitrogen pollu on. Nature 2022; 610: 507–12. 4251 4252 P33 Tang FHM, Lenzen M, McBratney A, Maggi F. Risk of pes cide pollu on at the global scale. Nat Geosci 2021; 14: 206–10. 4253 4254 4255 P34 Nicolopoulou-Stama P, Maipas S, Kotampasi C, Stama s P, Hens L. Chemical Pes cides and Human Health: The Urgent Need for a New Concept in Agriculture. Front Public Health 2016; 4: 148. 4256 4257 4258 P35 Pathak VM, Verma VK, Rawat BS, et al. Current status of pes cide effects on environment, human health and it’s eco-friendly management as bioremedia on: A comprehensive review. Front Microbiol 2022; 13: 962619. 4259 4260 P36 Shepon A, Wu T, Kremen C, et al. Exploring scenarios for the food system-zoono c risk interface. Lancet Planet Health 2023; 7: e329–35. 4261 4262 P37 WHO. Red and processed meat in the context of health and the environment: many shades of red and green. Informa on brief. World Health Organiza on, 2023. 4263 4264 P38 Moreno-Madriñan MJ, Kontowicz E. Stocking Density and Homogeneity, Considera ons on Pandemic Poten al. Zoono c Dis 2023; 3: 85–92. 4265 4266 P39 Greenspoon L, Krieger E, Sender R, et al. The global biomass of wild mammals. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2023; 120: e2204892120. 142 4267 4268 P40 Bar-On YM, Phillips R, Milo R. The biomass distribu on on Earth. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2018; 115: 6506–11. 4269 4270 P41 Marani M, Katul GG, Pan WK, Parolari AJ. Intensity and frequency of extreme novel epidemics. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2021; 118: e2105482118. 4271 4272 P42 Mulchandani R, Wang Y, Gilbert M, Van Boeckel TP. Global trends in an microbial use in food-producing animals: 2020 to 2030. PLOS Glob Public Health 2023; 3: e0001305. 4273 4274 4275 P43 Tang KL, Caffrey NP, Nobrega DB, et al. Restric ng the use of an bio cs in food-producing animals and its associa ons with an bio c resistance in food-producing animals and human beings: a systema c review and meta-analysis. Lancet Planet Health 2017; 1: e316–27. 4276 4277 P44 An microbial Resistance C. Global burden of bacterial an microbial resistance in 2019: a systema c analysis. Lancet 2022; 399: 629–55. 4278 4279 P45 Van Boeckel TP, Pires J, Silvester R, et al. Global trends in an microbial resistance in animals in low- and middle-income countries. Science 2019; 365: eaaw1944. 4280 4281 P46 Burke, Springmann M. Dietary and food system changes can dras cally reduce an -microbial use in animals. in prep. 4282 4283 P47 van Zanten HHE, Simon W, van Selm B, et al. Circularity in Europe strengthens the sustainability of the global food system. Nat Food 2023; 4: 320–30. 4284 4285 P48 Van Zanten HHE, Bekkers V, Gerwien L, et al. Circularity contributes to achieve the EATLancet 2.0 food systems transforma on. 2025. 4286 4287 P49 Springmann M, Clark M, Mason-D’Croz D, et al. Op ons for keeping the food system within environmental limits. Nature 2018; 562: 519–25. 4288 4289 P50 Kassam A, editor. Advances in Conserva on Agriculture: Volume 1: Systems and science. London: Burleigh Dodds Science Publishing, 2020 DOI:10.1201/9780429268724. 4290 4291 P51 Kassam A, editor. Advances in Conserva on Agriculture: Volume 2: Prac ce and Benefits. London: Burleigh Dodds Science Publishing, 2020 DOI:10.1201/9780429268731. 4292 4293 P52 Kassam A. Advances in Conserva on Agriculture: Volume 3: Adop on and Spread. London: Burleigh Dodds Science Publishing, 2022. 4294 4295 P53 Jat ML, Chakraborty D, Ladha JK, et al. Conserva on agriculture for sustainable intensifica on in South Asia. Nat Sustain 2020; 3: 336–43. 4296 4297 P54 Pi elkow CM, Liang X, Linquist BA, et al. Produc vity limits and poten als of the principles of conserva on agriculture. Nature 2015; 517: 365–8. 4298 4299 P55 Mosnier A, Javalera-Rincon V, Jones SK, et al. A decentralized approach to model na onal and global food and land use systems. Environ Res Le 2023; 18: 045001. 4300 4301 P56 Stewart CE, Paus an K, Conant RT, Plante AF, Six J. Soil carbon satura on: concept, evidence and evalua on. Biogeochemistry 2007; 86: 19–31. 4302 4303 P57 Skinner K, Pratley E, Burne K. Ea ng in the City: A Review of the Literature on Food Insecurity and Indigenous People Living in Urban Spaces. Socie es 2016; 6: 7. 143 4304 4305 4306 P58 Bryan E, Ringler C, Meinzen-Dick R. Gender, Resilience, and Food Systems. In: Béné C, Devereux S, eds. Resilience and Food Security in a Food Systems Context. Cham: Springer Interna onal Publishing, 2023: 239–80. 4307 P59 FAO. The status of women in agrifood systems. FAO, 2023 DOI:10.4060/cc5343en. 4308 4309 P60 Arndt C, Diao X, Dorosh P, Pauw K, Thurlow J. The Ukraine war and rising commodity prices: Implica ons for developing countries. Glob Food Secur 2023; 36: 100680. 4310 4311 4312 4313 P61 Michael Fakhri. Starva on and the right to food, with an emphasis on the Pales nian people’s food sovereignty - Report of the Special Rapporteur on the right to food, Michael Fakhri (A/79/171). 2024 h ps://www.un.org/unispal/document/right-to-food-report17jul24/ (accessed Sept 12, 2024). 4314 4315 4316 4317 P62 HLPE. Strengthening urban and peri-urban food systems to achieve food security and nutri on, in the context of urbaniza on and rural transforma on. Rome: CFS HLPE-FSN, 2024 h ps://sfcs.fao.org/docs/devhlpelibraries/report-19/hlpe-19---mainreport_en_cd1459en.pdf (accessed Aug 22, 2024). 4318 4319 P63 Kuran CHA, Morsut C, Kruke BI, et al. Vulnerability and vulnerable groups from an intersec onality perspec ve. Int J Disaster Risk Reduct 2020; 50: 101826. 4320 4321 P64 Brock S, Baker L, Jekums A, et al. Knowledge democra za on approaches for food systems transforma on. Nat Food 2024; 5: 342–5. 4322 4323 P65 Schneider KR, Fanzo J, Haddad L, et al. The state of food systems worldwide in the countdown to 2030. Nat Food 2023; 4: 1090–110. 4324 4325 P66 Gibson M, Sundiang M, Mason-D’Croz D, et al. Food systems transforma on leads to radical revaluing of global agriculture. 2025. 4326 P67 FAO. FAOSTAT Database. 2024. h ps://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data. 4327 4328 4329 P68 Arndt C, Hristov AN, Price WJ, et al. Full adop on of the most effec ve strategies to mi gate methane emissions by ruminants can help meet the 1.5 °C target by 2030 but not 2050. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2022; 119: e2111294119. 4330 4331 4332 P69 Tricarico JM, Kebreab E, Wa aux MA. MILK Symposium review: Sustainability of dairy produc on and consump on in low-income countries with emphasis on produc vity and environmental impact. J Dairy Sci 2020; 103: 9791–802. 4333 4334 P70 Scholtz R, Twidwell D. The last con nuous grasslands on Earth: Iden fica on and conserva on importance. Conserv Sci Pract 2022; 4: e626. 4335 4336 P71 Mi W, Ren W, Chi Y, et al. Heavy grazing reduces the poten al for grassland restora on: a global meta-analysis. Environ Res Le 2024; 19: 103001. 4337 4338 P72 Ren S, Terrer C, Li J, Cao Y, Yang S, Liu D. Historical impacts of grazing on carbon stocks and climate mi ga on opportuni es. Nat Clim Change 2024; 14: 380–6. 4339 4340 P73 Wang C, Tang Y. A global meta-analyses of the response of mul -taxa diversity to grazing intensity in grasslands. Environ Res Le 2019; 14: 114003. 4341 4342 P74 Bai Y, Cotrufo MF. Grassland soil carbon sequestra on: Current understanding, challenges, and solu ons. Science 2022; 377: 603–8. 144 4343 4344 4345 P75 Pendrill F, Persson UM, Godar J, Kastner T. Deforesta on displaced: trade in forest-risk commodi es and the prospects for a global forest transi on. Environ Res Le 2019; 14: 055003. 4346 4347 P76 Pent GJ. Over-yielding in temperate silvopastures: a meta-analysis. Agrofor Syst 2020; 94: 1741–58. 4348 P77 van Huis A, Gasco L. Insects as feed for livestock produc on. Science 2023; 379: 138–9. 4349 4350 P78 Bonaudo T, Bendahan AB, Saba er R, et al. Agroecological principles for the redesign of integrated crop–livestock systems. Eur J Agron 2014; 57: 43–51. 4351 4352 4353 P79 Notenbaert AMO, Douxchamps S, Villegas DM, et al. Tapping Into the Environmental Cobenefits of Improved Tropical Forages for an Agroecological Transforma on of Livestock Produc on Systems. Front Sustain Food Syst 2021; 5. DOI:10.3389/fsufs.2021.742842. 4354 4355 P80 Van Zanten HHE, Herrero M, Van Hal O, et al. Defining a land boundary for sustainable livestock consump on. Glob Change Biol 2018; 24: 4185–94. 4356 4357 P81 Bryant C, Aiking H, Alessandrini R, et al. The Dublin Declara on fails to recognize the need to reduce industrial animal agriculture. Nat Food 2024; : 1–3. 4358 4359 4360 P82 Schodl K, Wiesauer L, Winckler C, Leeb C. Reduced Stocking Density and Provision of Straw in a Rack Improve Pig Welfare on Commercial Fa ening Farms. Front Vet Sci 2021; 8. DOI:10.3389/fvets.2021.656211. 4361 4362 P83 EFSA Panel on Animal Health and Welfare (AHAW), Nielsen SS, Alvarez J, et al. Welfare of ca le during transport. EFSA J 2022; 20: e07442. 4363 4364 P84 Mikuš T, Marzel R, Mikuš O. Early weaning: new insights on an ever-persistent problem in the dairy industry. J Dairy Res 2020; 87: 88–92. 4365 4366 P85 Temple D, Manteca X. Animal Welfare in Extensive Produc on Systems Is S ll an Area of Concern. Front Sustain Food Syst 2020; 4. DOI:10.3389/fsufs.2020.545902. 4367 4368 P86 Ammann J, Mack G, Irek J, Finger R, El Benni N. Consumers’ meat commitment and the importance of animal welfare as agricultural policy goal. Food Qual Prefer 2023; 112: 105010. 4369 4370 P87 Blaxter T, Åsbjer E, Fraanje W. Animal welfare and ethics in food and agriculture. TABLE, 2024 DOI:10.56661/f2d8f4c7. 4371 4372 P88 Mason-D’Croz D, Sulser TB, Wiebe KD, et al. Agricultural investments and hunger in Africa modeling poten al contribu ons to SDG2 – Zero Hunger. World Dev 2019; 116: 38–53. 4373 P89 Laborde D, Bizikova L, Lallemant T, Smaller C. Ending Hunger: What would it cost? . 4374 4375 4376 P90 Chichaibelu BB, Bekchanov M, Braun J von, Torero M. The global cost of reaching a world without hunger: Investment costs and policy ac on opportuni es. Food Policy 2021; 104: 102151. 4377 4378 P91 Wiebe K, Sulser TB, Dunston S, et al. Modeling impacts of faster produc vity growth to inform the CGIAR ini a ve on Crops to End Hunger. PLOS ONE 2021; 16: e0249994. 4379 4380 P92 Fehér A, Gazdecki M, Véha M, Szakály M, Szakály Z. A Comprehensive Review of the Benefits of and the Barriers to the Switch to a Plant-Based Diet. Sustainability 2020; 12: 4136. 145 4381 4382 4383 P93 UNEP. Fron ers 2023. What’s Cooking? An assessment of the poten al impacts of selected novel alterna ves to conven onal animal products. United Na ons Environment Programme, 2023 DOI:10.59117/20.500.11822/44236. 4384 4385 4386 P94 Bunge AC, Wood A, Halloran A, Gordon LJ. A systema c scoping review of the sustainability of ver cal farming, plant-based alterna ves, food delivery services and blockchain in food systems. Nat Food 2022; 3: 933–41. 4387 4388 4389 P95 Nájera Espinosa S, Hadida G, Jelmar Sietsma A, et al. Mapping the evidence of novel plantbased foods: a systema c review of nutri onal, health, and environmental impacts in highincome countries. Nutr Rev 2024; : nuae031. 4390 4391 4392 P96 Mazac R, Meinilä J, Korkalo L, Järviö N, Jalava M, Tuomisto HL. Incorpora on of novel foods in European diets can reduce global warming poten al, water use and land use by over 80%. Nat Food 2022; 3: 286–93. 4393 4394 P97 Springmann M. A mul -criteria analysis of meat and milk alterna ves from nutri onal, health, environmental, and cost perspec ves. Submi Manuscr submi ed manuscript. 4395 4396 P98 Tuomisto HL. Challenges of assessing the environmental sustainability of cellular agriculture. Nat Food 2022; 3: 801–3. 4397 4398 P99 Garrison GL, Biermacher JT, Brorsen BW. How much will large-scale produc on of cellcultured meat cost? J Agric Food Res 2022; 10: 100358. 4399 P100 Humbird D. Scale-up economics for cultured meat. Biotechnol Bioeng 2021; 118: 3239–50. 4400 4401 P101 Risner D, Li F, Fell JS, et al. Preliminary Techno-Economic Assessment of Animal Cell-Based Meat. Foods 2021; 10: 3. 4402 P102 IPES-Food. Another perfect storm? 2022. 4403 4404 P103 Guthman J, Butler M, Mar n SJ, Mather C, Biltekoff C. In the name of protein. Nat Food 2022; 3: 391–3. 4405 4406 P104 Rubio NR, Xiang N, Kaplan DL. Plant-based and cell-based approaches to meat produc on. Nat Commun 2020; 11: 6276. 4407 4408 4409 P105 Bundy DA, Gen lini U, Schultz L, et al. School Meals, Social Protec on, and Human Development: Revisi ng Trends, Evidence, and Prac ces in South Asia and Beyond. Washington, DC: World Bank, 2024 DOI:10.1596/41431. 4410 4411 4412 P106 GLOPAN. Healthy Meals in Schools: Policy Innova ons Linking Agriculture, Food Systems and Nutri on. London, UK: Global Panel on Agriculture and Food Systems for Nutri on, 2015 h ps://glopan.org/sites/default/files/HealthyMealsBrief.pdf (accessed Nov 26, 2024). 4413 4414 4415 4416 P107 Pastorino S, Hughes D, Schultz L, et al. School meals and food systems: Rethinking the consequences for climate, environment, biodiversity, and food sovereignty. London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, 2023 h ps://hdl.handle.net/10568/137479 (accessed Nov 20, 2024). 4417 4418 4419 P108 European Parliament. European Parliament resolu on of 9 May 2023 on the implementa on of the school scheme for fruit, vegetables, milk and dairy products under the Common Market Organisa on Regula on (2021/2205(INI)). 2023. 146 4420 4421 h ps://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/TA-9-2023-0135_EN.html (accessed Nov 26, 2024). 4422 4423 4424 P109 GCNF. School Meals Programs around the World: Results from the 2021 Global Survey of School Meal Programs. Sea le: GCNF (Global Child Nutri on Founda on), 2022 h ps://gcnf.org/global-reports/ (accessed Nov 20, 2024). 4425 4426 4427 P110 Alves Da Silva E, Pedrozo EA, Nunes Da Silva T. The PNAE (Na onal School Feeding Program) ac vity system and its media ons. Front Environ Sci 2023; 10. DOI:10.3389/fenvs.2022.981932. 4428 4429 4430 P111 Springmann M. The health, environmental, and cost implica ons of providing healthy and sustainable school meals for every child by 2030: a global modelling study with country-level detail. Prep. 4431 4432 147