Article A multinational Delphi consensus to end the COVID-19 public health threat https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-05398-2 Received: 19 May 2022 Accepted: 29 September 2022 Published online: 3 November 2022 Open access Check for updates Jeffrey V. Lazarus1,2,3 ✉, Diana Romero3, Christopher J. Kopka4, Salim Abdool Karim5,6, Laith J. Abu-Raddad7,8, Gisele Almeida9, Ricardo Baptista-Leite10,11,12, Joshua A. Barocas13, Mauricio L. Barreto14,15, Yaneer Bar-Yam16, Quique Bassat1,17,18,19,20, Carolina Batista21,22, Morgan Bazilian23, Shu-Ti Chiou24, Carlos del Rio25, Gregory J. Dore26, George F. Gao27, Lawrence O. Gostin28, Margaret Hellard29, Jose L. Jimenez30,31, Gagandeep Kang32, Nancy Lee33, Mojca Matičič34,35, Martin McKee36, Sabin Nsanzimana37, Miquel Oliu-Barton38, Bary Pradelski39, Oksana Pyzik40, Kenneth Rabin3, Sunil Raina41, Sabina Faiz Rashid42, Magdalena Rathe43, Rocio Saenz44, Sudhvir Singh45, Malene Trock-Hempler46, Sonia Villapol47, Peiling Yap48, Agnes Binagwaho49, Adeeba Kamarulzaman50, Ayman El-Mohandes3 & The COVID-19 Consensus Statement Panel* Despite notable scientific and medical advances, broader political, socioeconomic and behavioural factors continue to undercut the response to the COVID-19 pandemic1,2. Here we convened, as part of this Delphi study, a diverse, multidisciplinary panel of 386 academic, health, non-governmental organization, government and other experts in COVID-19 response from 112 countries and territories to recommend specific actions to end this persistent global threat to public health. The panel developed a set of 41 consensus statements and 57 recommendations to governments, health systems, industry and other key stakeholders across six domains: communication; health systems; vaccination; prevention; treatment and care; and inequities. In the wake of nearly three years of fragmented global and national responses, it is instructive to note that three of the highest-ranked recommendations call for the adoption of whole-of-society and whole-of-government approaches1, while maintaining proven prevention measures using a vaccines-plus approach2 that employs a range of public health and financial support measures to complement vaccination. Other recommendations with at least 99% combined agreement advise governments and other stakeholders to improve communication, rebuild public trust and engage communities3 in the management of pandemic responses. The findings of the study, which have been further endorsed by 184 organizations globally, include points of unanimous agreement, as well as six recommendations with >5% disagreement, that provide health and social policy actions to address inadequacies in the pandemic response and help to bring this public health threat to an end. Pandemics have disrupted societies and impacted public health throughout human history4. Today, almost 3 years after SARS-CoV-2 was first identified and more than 1.5 years after the first vaccines became available, pandemic fatigue5 threatens to undercut our vigilance and the effectiveness of our responses to ongoing and new pandemic-related challenges. As of September 2022, more than 620 million cases of COVID-19 and over 6.5 million deaths have been reported6, although mortality estimates range as high as 20 million7,8. The healthcare for millions more people has been delayed, often as a result of overwhelmed health systems9–12. Highly transmissible variants continue to spread globally, while surveillance for variants of concern remains largely inadequate13–15. Reinfection risks are not fully understood. Low vaccination rates16 may compound the risk from waning immunity17,18. Long COVID has emerged as a serious chronic condition19–21 that represents A list of affiliations appears at the end of the paper. 332 | Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 a considerable burden of disease and still lacks adequate understanding and appropriate preventive or curative solutions. In addition to its direct health consequences, COVID-19 has disrupted economic activity, social interactions and political processes, affected civil liberties and interrupted education at all levels22–26. Although many governments and individuals no longer have the same level of concern as earlier in the pandemic27, many public health leaders, including members of this panel28, continue to regard COVID-19 as a persistent and dangerous health threat29–31. Responses to the COVID-19 pandemic have been hindered by interrelated factors that include false information32, vaccine hesitancy33,34, inconsistent global coordination35, and the inequitable distribution of supplies36, vaccines37,38 and treatments39. Despite increased levels of trust in science during the pandemic23,40, there is information fatigue4 and waning compliance with those public health and social measures41–43 that remain in place, particularly those that affect daily lives44. Meanwhile, during periods of high community transmission, needs for services continue to exceed the capacity of many health systems45, which also are challenged by ongoing risks to the health of their workers46–48. Furthermore, long-standing social inequities have caused some populations to experience greater risk of COVID-19 infection, severe disease and death37. Many of these populations continue to have less access to COVID-19 vaccines37,49 and treatment39, as well as to resources to mitigate the mental health, social and economic consequences of the pandemic50–52. Beneficial knowledge about COVID-19 aetiology, pathophysiology, prevention, vaccination, treatment and care has rapidly advanced through rigorous scientific, medical and public health inquiry, debate and collaboration53–56. Notwithstanding these advances, the responses of individual countries have been heterogeneous and often inade­quate, in part because they lack coordination and clear goals. To develop a global consensus regarding these ongoing problems, we carried out a Delphi study with a multidisciplinary, geographically diverse panel of 386 academic, health, non-governmental organization (NGO), government and other experts in COVID-19 response from 112 countries and territories (Table 1 and Methods). We achieved response rates of 85% in the second round (R2) and 82% and 81% in the third round (R3) surveys of the 41 statements and 57 recommendations, respectively. The mean levels of combined agreement (agree + somewhat agree) increased across the three rounds of the consensus statements (R1, 89%; R2, 90%; R3, 96%) and the two rounds of recommendations (R2, 93%; R3, 98%). The resulting consensus statements and recommendations (Fig. 1) can serve as a strong basis for decision-making to end COVID-19 as a public health threat, and permit a more durable resumption of social, cultural, religious, political, healthcare, economic and educational activities, with less burden on vulnerable populations. Top-ranked consensus recommendations This multidisciplinary and multinational consensus study yielded 41 statements (Tables 2 and 3) and 57 forward-looking recommendations (Tables 4–7) on ending COVID-19 as a threat to public health grouped into six domains. Although we suggest that policymakers and other interested stakeholders review and consider the entire study findings, for expediency, we break out the top 10 recommendations ranked by the panellists in Table 8. The top three recommendations focus on whole-of-society1 action and maintaining, or in some cases returning, to a vaccines-plus approach2. First, to avoid the inefficiency and ineffectiveness of fragmented efforts, pandemic preparedness and response should adopt a whole-of-society strategy that includes multiple disciplines, sectors and actors. Second, going forward, whole-of-government approaches (such as interministry coordination) can identify, review and address resilience in health systems to make them more responsive to people’s needs. Third, all countries should adopt a vaccines-plus approach, which includes a combination of COVID-19 vaccination, other prevention measures, treatment and financial incentives such as support measures. Infection rates tend to increase when governments discontinue social measures, including non-pharmaceutical interventions, regardless of the level of vaccination57,58. The degree of consensus achieved for statements and recommendations, along with a ranking exercise in the final round, informed our synthesis of the study’s findings into six cross-cutting themes (Box 1) to which we believe decision-makers should pay particular attention: (1) SARS-CoV-2 is still present among us—despite some governments moving on—requiring continued efforts and resources to save lives; (2) vaccines are an effective tool against COVID-19 but will not alone end COVID-19 as a public health threat; (3) multisectoral collaboration Table 1 | Expert panel characteristics (n = 386) Characteristic n (%) Gender Man 225 (58) Woman 155 (40) No response 6 (2) Primary sector of employmenta Civil society 254 (66) Private 61 (16) Academic 39 (10) Public 21 (5) Other 6 (2) No response 5 (1) Primary fieldb Public health 156 (41) Clinical research/care 92 (24) Health policy/advocacy 67 (17) Basic/physical/mathematical sciences 41 (11) Other 24 (6) No response 6 (2) Country income levelc Low- or middle-income country 195 (51) High-income country 186 (48) No response 5 (1) Global region of originc Europe and Central Asia 117 (30) Latin America and Caribbean 56 (15) East Asia and Pacific 49 (13) North America 47 (12) Sub-Saharan Africa 44 (11) Middle East and North Africa 33 (9) South Asia 35 (9) No response 5 (1) Percentages may not sum to 100 owing to rounding. a Panellists were provided with these four standard categories for public health sectors and were able to provide a different response with the ‘other’ option. b Panellists were provided with six response options (clinical research, public health research, healthcare provider, advocacy, health department or ministry and health policy) and ‘other’. The text responses under the ‘other’ option (n = 76) were analysed and recategorized into the four categories reported in the table. c Country income level and global region correspond to World Bank classification for 2022 (https://datahelpdesk.worldbank.org/knowledgebase/articles/906519-world-bank-countryand-lending-groups). that centres on communities and fosters trust is needed; (4) responsive health systems are crucial for responding to the COVID-19 pandemic and require coordinated government support; (5) adverse forces challenge efforts to end the COVID-19 public health threat; and (6) none of us is safe until everyone is safe. For ease of review, we report the tophalf ranked recommendations within each domain (Extended Data Fig. 1). Areas of less agreement The Delphi process involves a review and revision methodology that can result in relatively greater agreement among statements and recommendations over successive survey rounds while also identifying areas of disagreement that may require special efforts going forward. In addition to its the four-point Likert agreement–disagreement response options available in this study, panellists could select ‘not qualified to Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 | 333 Sample Article Core group co-chairs (n = 4) Purposive Snowball Core group (n = 40) Targeted Identified core group members Population from which the panel was drawn Recommendations from the core group + Identified from the relevant literature R3 survey: statements (n = 316; RR = 82%) Data R1 survey (n = 386) • Demographic information • 42 statements • Qualitative text boxes: → 1,409 comments R2 survey (n = 328; RR = 85%) Online convening • 43 revised statements • Qualitative text boxes: → 755 comments • 28/40 (70%) core group members participated • 53 recommendations • Qualitative text boxes: → 1,025 comments • Discussed issues from R1 and R2 Fig. 1 | Delphi panel generation and data collection. Study methodology, including sample and data collection. Top, the iterative sampling approach used to generate a large, diverse Delphi panel (n = 386): four project co-chairs identified a core group of 40 academic, health, NGO, government and policy experts from 25 countries; the core group identified individuals with expertise in COVID-19; under-represented countries (that is, with fewer than one invitee) were identified and targeted through PubMed/Medline searches for authors of COVID-19 research studies in these countries. Bottom, the iterative digital data-collection process, including two survey rounds (R1 and R2) of draft respond’ for items that they perceived as falling outside their expertise (see the ‘Delphi expert panel member sample’ section in the Methods). Although our study reflects relatively few areas of disagreement, we believe that highlighting the key areas of disagreement may be instructive for decision-makers in their own prioritization processes addressing the COVID-19 pandemic. Extended Data Table 1 presents the six recommendations reflecting 5% or greater disagreement (disagree + somewhat disagree). Of those six, only two recommendations had greater than 10% disagreement: 18% of panellists disagreed with the recommendation to consider further economic incentives to potentially address vaccine hesitancy (REC3.6) and 11% disagreed with the recommendation that providers adopt a syndromic approach to COVID-19 diagnosis in settings with lower access to testing (REC2.18). The remaining four recommendations broadly relate to the use of governmental regulatory and enforcement powers in disease control efforts. For statements and recommendations with response rates of ‘agree’ alone (that is, not combined with ‘somewhat agree’) below 67%, we conducted bivariate analyses to examine potential associations with panellist demographics; six statements (STMT1.2, STMT1.3, STMT2.1, STMT2.3, STMT3.5, STMT6.6) and one recommendation (REC4.5) demonstrated significant differences. Respondents who disagreed were significantly more likely to work in low- and middle-income countries than in high-income countries (P < 0.05; Supplementary Discussion 2). Few differences in agreement were identified by sector or field of employment, except for STMT1.1, for which greater disagreement was identified among those working in the health policy/advocacy field, and for STMT1.3, for which the academic and public sectors evidenced greater disagreement than other sectors. Key statements and recommendations The following six domains summarize the main areas of agreement, with a particular focus on the recommendations. The quantitative results on agreement and disagreement for the statements and recommendations are reflected in the tables and are further illustrated in Supplementary Discussion 1. 334 | Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 • 41 final statements • Qualitative text boxes: → 188 comments R3 survey: recommendations (n = 313; RR = 81%) • 57 final recommendations • Qualitative text boxes → 2,156 comments • Within each domain ranked top half of recommendations statements; an online consensus meeting of the core group (Supplementary Discussion 3); one round of draft recommendations (R2); and a final survey round (R3) of the consensus statements and recommendations. Earlier rounds included text boxes for panellists to provide comments and suggest edits to individual statements (R1, R2) and recommendations (R2); the final statement and recommendations round (R3) allowed for overall comments at the end of each domain. For the final set of recommendations in R3, panellists ranked the top half in each of the six domains. RR, response rate. Communicate effectively Substantial combined agreement among the panellists (range, 88–100%) indicates that communication issues remain a key area of risk and opportunity for ending COVID-19 as a public health threat. Policymakers and public health agencies should take special care when communicating the causation of and continuing accountability for the pandemic (Tables 2 (STMT1.7) and 4 (REC1.1)). The lowest level of agreement in this domain (agree, 57%; combined agreement, 88%) was found for a statement about government accountability receiving less attention when unvaccinated individuals are blamed for the pandemic’s continuation (Table 2 (STMT1.6)). The panel focused primarily on the role of trust in government (Table 2 (STMT1.5)), the consequences of false information (Table 2 (STMT1.2, STMT1.3, STMT1.4)) and the rapid production of large volumes of new COVID-19-related information (Table 2 (STMT1.1)). That said, governments themselves may be a source of misinformation, for example, in the context of identifying transmission mechanisms (Table 6 (REC4.3)) and when stating that the COVID-19 pandemic has ended (Table 2 (STMT1.7)). To counteract the infodemic and false information, governments should monitor false information (Table 4 (REC1.7)), expose networks of false information (Table 4 (REC1.9)) and consider holding publishers of false information liable (Table 4 (REC1.10)). Furthermore, public health professionals and other authorities should use clear, culturally responsive messaging to combat false information (Table 4 (REC1.3)). In parallel, social media companies should implement controls that reduce the publication and dissemination of false health information (Table 4 (REC1.8)). Institutions and individuals should advance public trust by seeking training on building trust and developing trust-oriented communication strategies (Table 4 (REC1.4)), expanding collaboration with community leaders and the scientific community (Table 4 (REC1.1)), and working with individuals and organizations that have established trust in communities (Table 4 (REC1.2)). Using the preferred means of communication for different populations was unanimously recommended to further earn trust (Table 4 (REC1.1)). Table 2 | Consensus statements to end COVID-19 as a public health threat Statement Grade A (%) SA (%) SD (%) D (%) N (%) NQ (%) Communication STMT1.1 The volume and velocity of information during the COVID-19 pandemic have made it difficult for people to assess the accuracy of information. A 81 19 0 1 316 0 STMT1.2 Public health authorities contribute to the dissemination of false information when their communications do not reflect current scientific understanding that transmission of SARS-CoV-2 is primarily airborne. A 68 24 6 3 313 1 STMT1.3 Governments have inconsistently counteracted false information in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. A 70 23 4 3 312 1 STMT1.4 Sources of false information undermine the social cohesion needed for an effective public health response. A 91 8 1 0* 316 0 STMT1.5 During the pandemic, public health officials have ineffectively engaged populations that have low levels of trust in government. A 69 25 4 1 312 1 STMT1.6 Blaming unvaccinated individuals for continuation of the pandemic shifts attention away from government accountability. B 57 31 8 4 307 3 STMT1.7 A government’s decision to reduce COVID-19 pandemic control measures does not mean that the threat to public health has ended. A 94 5 1 0 315 0 Health systems STMT2.1 The world has not implemented an evidence-based, globally agreed-upon set of minimum COVID-19 pandemic response standards addressing monitoring, prevention, treatment and care. A 73 18 6 3 309 1 STMT2.2 There continue to be systemic risks of COVID-19 infection for healthcare workers in many healthcare settings. A 82 16 2 1 306 2 STMT2.3 Health systems are continuing to face abnormal staffing shortages due to the mental and physical health impacts on their workers from the COVID-19 pandemic. A 79 16 4 0 305 3 STMT2.4 Healthcare workers continue to experience unaddressed mental health issues due to the pandemic. A 81 17 2 0 296 5 STMT2.5 Governments have not always addressed the high out-of-pocket expenditure to consumers A for some pandemic control measures (for example, testing) and personal protective equipment (for example, facemasks). 78 17 3 2 310 1 STMT2.6 The COVID-19 pandemic continues to reveal vulnerabilities in the global supply-chain framework for essential public health supplies. A 91 8 1 0* 306 2 STMT2.7 The COVID-19 pandemic has catalysed opportunities for rapid innovation in digital health solutions throughout the care continuum. A 84 14 1 1 308 1 STMT2.8 Leveraging economies of scale and scope through multicountry pooled procurement can enable health systems to increase access to essential medicines and supplies during public health crises. A 85 14 1 1 305 2 STMT2.9 Community-based interventions and services to address the pandemic continue to be underused by health systems. A 79 19 2 0* 302 4 Vaccination STMT3.1 When the risk of harm to others is sufficiently severe, governments may determine that the right of all individuals to good health overrides the autonomy of any one individual to choose not to be vaccinated. A 68 24 5 4 309 1 STMT3.2 B Individual medical autonomy acknowledges that individuals who have decision-making capacity have the right to make decisions regarding vaccination, even when their decisions contradict their healthcare providers’ recommendations. 59 25 8 8 306 2 STMT3.3 Vaccine hesitancy, which ranges from delay to refusal despite the availability of vaccine services, remains a major challenge to ending the COVID-19 pandemic as a public health threat. A 75 21 3 1 309 1 STMT3.4 Discussing vaccine hesitancy as primarily a function of information or worldview is inaccurate, as vaccine hesitancy is a multifactorial phenomenon comprising other factors (for example, socioeconomic). A 82 12 3 2 308 1 STMT3.5 Continued low levels of trust in information from government sources are associated with vaccine hesitancy. A 78 17 4 2 309 1 STMT3.6 Vaccination alone is insufficient to end the COVID-19 pandemic as a public health threat. A 83 14 3 1 311 0 Grades are based on the percentage of combined agreement (agree + somewhat agree). U, unanimous (100%) agreement; A, 90%–99% agreement; B, 78%–89% agreement; C, 67%–77% agreement. Responses to each statement (STMT) are presented as percentages of the total responses. A, agree; SA, somewhat agree; SD, somewhat disagree; D, disagree; N, total number of responses; NQ, the number of participants that indicated that they were not qualified to respond. The asterisks indicate that rounding resulted in 0% despite the presence of ≥1 response in the disagreement category. Multidisciplinary research should assess the impact of the COVID19 infodemic on health behaviours and outcomes (Table 4 (REC1.5)). Research funders should commission more reviews that synthesize, evaluate and disseminate COVID-19-related evidence to inform needed interventions (Table 4 (REC1.6)). Strengthen health systems Health systems have experienced wide-ranging circumstances throughout the pandemic, from periods of relative calm to periods of near collapse. The broad agreement among panellists strongly Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 | 335 Article Table 3 | Consensus statements to end COVID-19 as a public health threat Statement Grade A (%) SA (%) SD (%) D (%) N (%) NQ (%) Prevention STMT4.1 SARS-CoV-2 is an airborne virus that presents the highest risk of transmission in indoor areas with poor ventilation. A 92 8 0* 0* 311 0 STMT4.2 The assumption that endemicity automatically means that variants will have lower virulence is not scientifically sound and should not be a basis for public policy decision-making. A 81 15 2 1 297 5 STMT4.3 SARS-CoV-2 mammal-to-mammal, outdoor transmission represents a reservoir for future zoonotic variants. A 76 20 3 1 268 14 STMT4.4 Relying on individual, voluntary compliance with transmission prevention measures is insufficient to end COVID-19 as a public health threat. A 81 15 3 1 311 0 STMT4.5 Infection rates tend to increase when governments discontinue social measures, including non-pharmaceutical interventions, regardless of the level of vaccination. A 75 19 4 2 306 2 STMT4.6 Wide use of high-filtration and well-fitting facemasks (for example, N95, KF94, KN95, FFP2/3) is important to reduce transmission, particularly in high-risk settings. A 87 9 3 1 307 1 STMT4.7 Most countries have not adequately protected children throughout the pandemic, that is, preventing SARS-CoV-2 transmission while simultaneously addressing their physical, mental and social well-being. A 77 17 5 2 309 1 A 72 20 5 2 299 4 Treatment and care STMT5.1 Prioritizing the treatment of severe COVID-19 over the prevention of SARS-CoV-2 transmission risks increasing infections, long COVID and the overall burden of disease. STMT5.2 More effective COVID-19 therapeutic options, as well as care delivery models, are needed. A 91 8 1 0 303 3 STMT5.3 In addition to the standardized long COVID case definition for adults, a standardized definition is needed for children. A 90 10 0* 0 298 4 STMT5.4 Research is needed to determine whether infection from distinct variants of SARS-CoV-2 is associated with significant differences in long-term morbidity. A 91 8 1 0 305 2 Pandemic inequities STMT6.1 The COVID-19 pandemic disproportionately impacts the most vulnerable populations within communities, countries and globally. A 92 6 1 1 311 0 STMT6.2 The decision by most high-income countries to protect intellectual property rights for COVID-19 vaccines and treatments has contributed to limited options available to low- and middle-income countries for addressing the pandemic. A 83 11 4 3 304 3 STMT6.3 It is in the best interests of high-income countries to fund the equitable distribution of vaccines and treatments to low- and middle-income countries. A 88 9 2 0* 308 1 STMT6.4 There is a disproportionate consumption of health system resources by those voluntarily unvaccinated. A 65 25 7 3 295 5 STMT6.5 When expanding use of digital communications technology (for example, online appointment systems, mobile patient communications and telehealth applications) health systems may inadvertently contribute to inequitable access to healthcare services. A 64 30 6 1 307 1 STMT6.6 The global pandemic response has generally not taken into account the underlying role of social determinants of health. A 77 21 2 0* 308 1 STMT6.7 Few governments have adequately engaged vulnerable populations to inform pandemic response priorities. A 78 17 4 0* 303 3 STMT6.8 The incorporation of research paradigms from diverse disciplines has greater potential to end COVID-19 as a public health threat than reliance on a single research paradigm (for example, evidence-based medicine). A 88 9 2 1 309 1 Grades are based on the percentage of combined agreement (agree + somewhat agree). U, unanimous (100%) agreement; A, 90%–99% agreement; B, 78%–89% agreement; C, 67%–77% agreement. Responses to each statement (STMT) are presented as percentages of the total responses. A, agree; SA, somewhat agree; SD, somewhat disagree; D, disagree; N, total number of responses; NQ, the number of participants that indicated that they were not qualified to respond. The asterisks indicate that rounding resulted in 0% despite the presence of ≥1 response in the disagreement category. suggests that, although many health systems will remain at risk of once again being overwhelmed, those risks can be mitigated. Certain sources of risk to health systems are essentially structural, such as the lack of implementation of an evidence-based, globally agreed-upon set of minimum COVID-19 pandemic response standards (Table 2 (STMT2.1)). As noted above, health systems recommendations with respect to whole-of-society (Table 4 (REC2.5)) and whole-of-government approaches (for example, multiministry coordination) (Table 4 (REC2.6)) were among the most highly ranked by the panel. As community transmission of SARS-CoV-2 continues to present a risk to health systems, particularly through variants of concern, extensive virological surveillance should be used (Table 5 (REC2.8)). Public health 336 | Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 policies should take better account of the potential long-term impact of the unchecked spread of COVID-19 given the ongoing uncertainties about the prevalence, severity and duration of post-COVID-19 morbidity (long COVID) (Table 5 (REC2.9)). Member States should authorize the World Health Organization (WHO) to lead a large, inclusive, multistakeholder, global effort to provide public health and clinical targets pertaining to SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19, with an emphasis on cases, vaccination, morbidity and mortality (Table 5 (REC2.17)). Economic impacts, notably costs borne by consumers (Table 2 (STMT2.5)), create risks to health systems. To address these risks, structural and economic recommendations include removing economic barriers to SARS-CoV-2 tests, personal protective equipment, treatment and care (Table 4 (REC2.1)), supporting the development of Table 4 | Recommendations to end COVID-19 as a public health threat Recommendation Grade A (%) SA (%) SD (%) D (%) N (%) NQ (%) Rank Communication REC1.1 Community leaders, scientific experts and public health authorities should collaborate to develop public health messages that build and enhance individual and community trust and use the preferred means of access and communication for different populations. U 96 4 0 0 312 0 1 REC1.2 Public health authorities should partner with individuals and organizations that are trusted within their communities to provide accurate, accessible information about the pandemic and inform behaviour change. A 95 5 0* 0 312 0 2 REC1.3 Public health professionals and authorities should combat false information proactively based on clear, direct, culturally responsive messaging that is free of unnecessary scientific jargon. A 94 5 0* 0* 311 0 3 REC1.4 Institutions and individuals that wish to advance public trust should: (1) draw on evidence about how trust is created and restored; (2) provide training and professional development emphasizing skills and competencies that convey trustworthiness; and (3) develop, implement and assess communication strategies that are highly likely to create or restore trust. A 94 5 1 0 311 0 4 REC1.5 Multidisciplinary researchers should assess the impact of the ‘infodemic’ on health behaviours and outcomes in specific populations of all countries. A 93 6 1 0* 311 0 REC1.6 Research funders should commission more scoping, narrative and systematic reviews to synthesize, evaluate and disseminate COVID-19-related evidence. A 83 16 1 0* 309 0 REC1.7 Governments should determine which agencies are or should be accountable for monitoring health information and develop monitoring tools to identify false information. A 81 17 2 1 312 1 REC1.8 Social media companies should engage transparently with researchers and developers, who are free of a direct conflict of interest, to implement controls for their platforms that reduce publication and dissemination of false health information. A 87 11 2 1 311 0 REC1.9 Governments, industry and non-governmental organizations should actively identify and expose individuals and networks that promote false health information about the COVID-19 pandemic. A 80 17 2 1 310 1 REC1.10 Governments should consider holding publishers of false health information liable, while balancing civil liberties. A 76 17 6 1 308 1 5 Health systems REC2.1 Governments should remove economic barriers to SARS-CoV-2 tests, personal protective equipment, treatments and care. A 90 10 0* 0 313 0 6 REC2.2 Governments and global health organizations should support the development of regional hubs for the manufacturing of COVID-19 supplies, treatments and vaccines. A 91 8 0 0* 308 2 5 REC2.3 The user experience and interface with digital health technologies should be adapted A to expand access for all, with particular attention to vulnerable groups. 86 13 0* 0* 313 0 REC2.4 Healthcare organizations should support their workers’ physical, mental and social well-being. A 97 2 0 1 311 0 4 REC2.5 Pandemic preparedness and response planning should adopt a whole-of-society approach that includes multiple disciplines, sectors and actors (for example, business, civil society, engineering, faith communities, mathematical modelling, military, media and psychology). A 95 4 1 0 312 0 1 REC2.6 Preparedness and response strategies should adopt whole-of-government approaches (for example, multiministry coordination) to identify, review and address resilience in health systems. A 93 6 1 0 309 2 2 Grades are based on the percentage of combined agreement (agree + somewhat agree). U, unanimous (100%) agreement; A, 90%–99% agreement; B, 78%–89% agreement; C, 67%–77% agreement. Responses to each recommendation (REC) are presented as percentages of the total responses. A, agree; SA, somewhat agree; SD, somewhat disagree; D, disagree; N, total number of responses; NQ, the number of participants that indicated that they were not qualified to respond. The asterisks indicate that rounding resulted in 0% despite the presence of ≥1 response in the disagreement category. regional manufacturing hubs for COVID-19 supplies, treatments and vaccines (Table 4 (REC2.2)), and considering legislative and regulatory reforms to address market failures (Table 5 (REC2.16)). Where access to PCR or antigen tests is limited, providers should consider adopting a syndromic approach (Table 5 (REC2.18)). Notably, REC2.18 is the health systems recommendation with the highest percentages of panellists disagreeing as well as panellists indicating ‘not qualified to respond’. To reduce the burden on hospitals, the role of primary health care should be strengthened (Table 5 (REC2.10)), while health care workers’ physical, mental and social well-being should be supported (Table 4 (REC2.4)). With respect to digital health, the recommendations encourage increasing investments in digital health infrastructure (Table 5 (REC2.13)), adapting user interfaces and experience to expand access, particularly for vulnerable groups (Table 4 (REC2.3)), and leveraging implementation science to determine which digital health solutions can be quickly scaled (Table 5 (REC2.12)). With respect to procurement practices, engaging continuous improvement disciplines for intercountry procurement, pooling and supply-chain management was urged (Table 5 (REC2.11)). To best leverage community-based interventions and services, community-based organizations and students pursuing degrees in health-related fields should be engaged in providing COVID-19 education, testing and vaccination services (Table 5 (REC2.14)). As social, political and economic sector risks continue to have spillover effects on health systems, key multisectoral indicators for Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 | 337 Article Table 5 | Recommendations to end COVID-19 as a public health threat Recommendation Grade A (%) SA (%) SD (%) D (%) N (%) NQ (%) Rank Health systems REC2.7 As social, political and economic sector risks continue to have spillover effects on health systems, key multisector indicators for systemic risks to health systems must be identified and assessed. A 92 7 1 0* 305 2 REC2.8 The identification of several variants of concern necessitates substantial virological surveillance based on whole-genome sequencing of positive specimens. A 86 13 1 0 287 8 REC2.9 Public health policy should take better account of the potential long-term impact of the unchecked spread of COVID-19, given ongoing uncertainties about the prevalence, severity and duration of post-COVID-19 morbidity (long COVID). A 86 13 1 0* 310 1 REC2.10 To reduce the burden on hospitals, primary care should be strengthened to include testing, contact tracing, the monitoring of mild symptoms and vaccination. A 92 6 1 0* 310 1 3 REC2.11 Governments and industry should engage continuous improvement disciplines for A intercountry procurement, pooling and supply chain management to reduce cycle times and costs, as well as improve product quality and data to rapidly scale up the availability of medicines, protective equipment and vaccines. 91 7 2 0 301 4 8 REC2.12 Public health systems should prioritize the use of implementation science to determine which digital health solutions can and should be quickly scaled up globally. A 85 13 2 0 300 4 REC2.13 Investments in digital health infrastructure, software and training should be made to institutionalize quality telehealth and telemedicine services. A 86 12 2 0 310 1 REC2.14 To reduce the burden on health systems and healthcare workers, community-based organizations and students pursuing degrees in health-related fields should be engaged to educate, test and vaccinate the population. A 77 20 3 0* 312 0 REC2.15 Health systems should identify and, where possible, reduce diagnostic, treatment and care backlogs for non-COVID-19-related medical conditions. A 88 9 1 3 305 3 REC2.16 Because the global marketplace has not satisfied demand for vaccines, treatments A and supplies, countries and regions should consider legislative and regulatory reforms to address these market failures (for example, nationalizing manufacturing capacity, negotiating global and regional trade agreements, adjusting intracountry intellectual property rights). 80 13 4 3 297 6 7 REC2.17 A In the absence of a new multilateral organization focused on pandemic control, Member States should authorize the WHO to lead a large, inclusive, multistakeholder, global effort to provide public health and clinical targets pertaining to the pandemic, with an emphasis on cases, vaccination, morbidity and mortality. 73 19 6 2 306 3 9 REC2.18 In settings in which access to PCR or antigen tests may be limited, providers should consider adopting a syndromic approach to COVID-19 diagnosis for symptomatic individuals. B 68 21 9 2 282 11 Grades are based on the percentage of combined agreement (agree + somewhat agree). U, unanimous (100%) agreement; A, 90%–99% agreement; B, 78%–89% agreement; C, 67%–77% agreement. Responses to each recommendation (REC) are presented as percentages of the total responses. A, agree; SA, somewhat agree; SD, somewhat disagree; D, disagree; N, total number of responses; NQ, the number of participants that indicated that they were not qualified to respond. The asterisks indicate that rounding resulted in 0% despite the presence of ≥1 response in the disagreement category. systemic risks to health systems should be identified and assessed (Table 5 (REC2.7)). Finally, health systems should identify and, where possible, reduce diagnostic, treatment and care backlogs for non-COVID-19-related medical conditions (Table 5 (REC2.15)). Emphasize vaccination, but not exclusively so Even assuming continued innovation of vaccines and interventions that reduce vaccine hesitancy, 97% of the panel agrees that vaccination alone is insufficient to end the COVID-19 pandemic as a public health threat (Table 2 (STMT3.6)). Thus, the panel places a strong emphasis on additional prevention measures, particularly, as noted above and in the ten highest-ranked recommendations (Table 8), for countries to adopt a vaccines-plus approach, as discussed in the next domain. Regarding the key role of vaccines, the panel made a range of recommendations. Government, philanthropic and industry funding should invest in developing vaccines that provide long-lasting protection against multiple SARS-CoV-2 variants (Table 6 (REC3.4)). As waning immunity remains a risk, calculations for immunity should consider 338 | Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 the time after the date of vaccination and/or infection and be regularly updated with new scientific evidence (Table 6 (REC3.5)). Vaccine hesitancy, which ranges from delay to refusal despite availability of vaccine services, remains a major challenge (Table 2 (STMT3.3)). To reduce vaccine hesitancy and increase uptake, several interventions are recommended: engaging trusted local leaders and organizations in vaccination efforts (Table 6 (REC3.2)), providing information that clearly explains the efficacy and limitations of current vaccines (Table 6 (REC3.1)) and tailoring messages to address the underlying bases of various populations’ specific concerns through targeted public health communications (Table 6 (REC3.3)). Vaccine hesitancy may also be associated with false information, which is addressed in the communication domain above. On the one hand, panellists largely agree that medical autonomy of individuals with decision-making ability extends to the right to make one’s own decisions regarding vaccination (Table 2 (STMT3.2)). On the other hand, panellists also acknowledge that, when the risk of harm to others is sufficiently severe, governments may determine that the right of all individuals to good health overrides the autonomy of any one individual to choose not to be vaccinated (Table 2 (STMT3.1)). These statements Table 6 | Recommendations to end COVID-19 as a public health threat Recommendation Grade A (%) SA (%) SD (%) D (%) N (%) NQ (%) Rank Vaccination REC3.1 Vaccination messaging should clearly explain the efficacy and limitations of current vaccines in preventing SARS-CoV-2 transmission and reducing the severity of COVID-19. A 93 7 0* 0* 312 0 2 REC3.2 In settings where individuals have lower levels of trust in government, vaccination efforts should engage trusted local leaders and organizations. A 93 6 1 0 311 0 REC3.3 To combat vaccine hesitancy, tailored messages that address the underlying bases of A an individual’s concerns should be used in targeted public health communications. 93 6 1 0 310 1 3 REC3.4 Government, philanthropic and industry funding should include a focus on developing vaccines that provide long-lasting protection against multiple SARS-CoV-2 variants. A 90 9 1 0 309 1 1 REC3.5 Calculations for immunity should take into consideration the time following the date of vaccination and/or infection and be regularly updated with new scientific evidence. A 93 4 2 1 398 4 REC3.6 As the causes of vaccine hesitancy are not solely a function of information or worldview, economic incentives should be considered in parallel with information and access to increase vaccination rates. B 57 25 13 5 303 3 REC4.1 Governments should regulate and incentivize the development and deployment of structural prevention measures (for example, ventilation, air filtration) to mitigate airborne transmission of SARS-CoV-2, with an early emphasis on high-risk settings. A 86 12 1 0 307 0 REC4.2 Measures that are no longer scientifically valid for COVID-19 prevention should be immediately removed from COVID-19 guidance and policy. A 88 10 2 0 307 0 REC4.3 Risk communications should clearly emphasize that transmission of SARS-CoV-2 is primarily caused by inhalation of the virus. A 90 8 2 0 302 1 REC4.4 National and international travel restrictions should be based on current scientific knowledge and prevailing transmission rates of all variants that take into account relevant, health-based factors (for example, traveller’s vaccination status, proof of recent recuperation from COVID-19 or a negative result of an antigen or PCR test). A 85 12 1 2 305 0 REC4.5 All countries should adopt a vaccines-plus approach that includes a combination of COVID-19 vaccination, prevention measures, treatment and financial incentives. A 82 14 4 0 307 0 1 REC4.6 Prevention of SARS-CoV-2 transmission in the workplace, educational institutions and centres of commerce should remain a high priority, reflected in public health guidance and supported through multiple social measures and structural interventions (for example, remote work/schooling policies, ventilation, air filtration, facemask wearing). A 85 11 3 1 307 0 2 REC4.7 Governments should consider imposing broad restrictions on civil liberties only in the event of variants of concern presenting risk of high rates of transmission and severity, coupled with (1) waning immunity or (2) vaccine resistance. A 71 21 5 3 305 0 3 Prevention Grades are based on the percentage of combined agreement (agree + somewhat agree). U, unanimous (100%) agreement; A, 90%–99% agreement; B, 78%–89% agreement; C, 67%–77% agreement. Responses to each recommendation (REC) are presented as percentages of the total responses. A, agree; SA, somewhat agree; SD, somewhat disagree; D, disagree; N, total number of responses; NQ, the number of participants that indicated that they were not qualified to respond. The asterisks indicate that rounding resulted in 0% despite the presence of ≥1 response in the disagreement category. reflect among the highest levels of combined disagreement (Table 2 (STMT3.1, 9%; STMT3.2, 16%)). Civil liberties implications are further discussed in the next domain. Promote preventive behaviours As noted above, vaccination alone will not end COVID-19 as a public health threat (Table 2 (STMT3.6)) for all people. Infection rates tend to increase when governments discontinue social measures, including non-pharmaceutical interventions, regardless of the level of vaccination (Table 3 (STMT4.5)). Thus, all countries should adopt a vaccines-plus approach, including a combination of COVID-19 vaccination, other prevention measures, treatment and possibly financial incentives (Table 6 (REC4.5)). Although the nature and vectors of SARS-CoV-2 transmission were not clearly understood early in the pandemic, current evidence guided the panellists to near-unanimous agreement that SARS-CoV-2 is an airborne virus that presents the highest risk of transmission in indoor areas with poor ventilation (Table 3 (STMT4.1)). Risk-related communications from all actors should clearly emphasize that transmission of SARS-CoV-2 is primarily caused by inhalation of the virus (Table 6 (REC4.3)). Considering the airborne nature of transmission, governments should regulate and incentivise structural prevention measures, such as ventilation and air filtration (Table 6 (REC4.1)), and high priority should be given to preventing SARS-CoV-2 transmission in the workplace, educational institutions and commercial centres (Table 6 (REC4.6)). Mammal-to-mammal transmission represents a reservoir for future zoonotic variants (Table 3 (STMT4.3)). Thus, substantial virological surveillance based on whole-genome sequencing of positive samples in human and high-risk mammal populations is an essential component of the continued pandemic response and preparedness (Table 5 (REC2.8)). National and international travel restrictions should be based on current scientific knowledge and prevailing transmission rates of all variants that consider relevant, health-based factors (Table 6 (REC4.4)). Measures that are no longer scientifically valid for COVID-19 prevention should be immediately removed from COVID-19 guidance and policy (Table 6 (REC4.2)). Going forward, governments should consider imposing broad restrictions on civil liberties only in the event of variants of concern presenting risk of high rates of transmission and severity, coupled with waning immunity or vaccine resistance (Table 6 (REC4.7)). Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 | 339 Article Table 7 | Recommendations to end COVID-19 as a public health threat Recommendation Grade A (%) SA (%) SD (%) D (%) N (%) NQ (%) Rank Treatment and care REC5.1 Global case definitions for SARS-CoV-2 and for COVID-19 morbidity and mortality should be standardized. U 92 8 0 0 305 0 3 REC5.2 Promote multisectoral collaboration to accelerate the development of new therapies for all stages of COVID-19 (for example, outpatient, hospitalization and long COVID). A 95 5 0 0* 309 1 1 REC5.3 Clinical trials and longitudinal cohorts should include statistically sufficient samples from all age groups, genders and vulnerable populations. A 93 7 0* 0 306 1 REC5.4 Expand the evidence base on the cumulative effect of COVID-19 reinfection to inform public health policy. A 90 9 1 0* 308 1 REC5.5 Governments should now prioritize early case detection so that health systems can facilitate earlier treatment and care. A 80 17 1 1 304 1 REC5.6 Prioritize research funding for long COVID to develop diagnostic tools, treatment and care, and knowledge about extrinsic factors (for example, stigma and discrimination). A 85 12 3 0 306 0 2 REC6.1 Recognizing that local and regional contexts are important for equitable responses A to the pandemic, governments should engage communities and multidisciplinary experts who understand the local context when developing operational plans for ending COVID-19 as a public health threat. 95 5 0* 0 311 0 3 REC6.2 In addition to current vaccine equity efforts, governments and global health organizations should better coordinate to make COVID-19 tests and treatments affordable for all people in all countries. A 93 6 0* 0 310 0 4 REC6.3 Decision-making bodies (for example, governments, WHO committees) should meaningfully and transparently engage with a broad base of voices to inform their decisions. A 93 6 0* 0 311 0 REC6.4 Governments, regional bodies, industry and health systems should anticipate the procurement and supply management needs for supplies, treatments and vaccines in low-resource settings (for example, transportation logistics, storage, refrigeration). A 93 6 0* 0* 306 2 REC6.5 Pandemic preparedness, response planning and policy should be reviewed and updated to protect children, emphasizing the prevention of SARS-CoV-2 transmission while simultaneously addressing their physical, mental and social well-being. A 90 9 0* 1 309 0 REC6.6 A Global trade and health organizations should coordinate with countries to negotiate the transfer of technologies enabling manufacturers in low- and middle-income countries to develop quality assured and affordable vaccines, tests and therapeutics. 95 4 1 0* 307 2 2 REC6.7 Pandemic preparedness and response should address pre-existing social and health inequities. A 94 5 1 0* 307 1 1 REC6.8 Governments, industry and health systems should prioritize minimizing closedand open-vial vaccine wastage, with an early emphasis on wastage resulting from unnecessarily short expiration dates, and by addressing regulatory barriers and procurement and supply management challenges for transferring or donating vaccine doses. A 86 13 1 0 301 3 REC6.9 Pandemic preparedness and response efforts should assess and mitigate the risks A and effects of SARS-CoV-2 transmission among people within and emigrating from conflict zones. 86 13 2 0 1 REC6.10 High-income countries should refocus the distribution of vaccines to countries with low rates of vaccination and inadequate access to vaccines. 86 12 2 0* 0 Pandemic inequities A 5 Grades are based on the percentage of combined agreement (agree + somewhat agree). U, unanimous (100%) agreement; A, 90%–99% agreement; B, 78%–89% agreement; C, 67%–77% agreement. Responses to each recommendation (REC) are presented as percentages of the total responses. A, agree; SA, somewhat agree; SD, somewhat disagree; D, disagree; N, total number of responses; NQ, the number of participants that indicated that they were not qualified to respond. The asterisks indicate that rounding resulted in 0% despite the presence of ≥1 response in the disagreement category. Expand treatments Panellists had substantially high agreement regarding all aspects of treatment and care, indicating that treatment will continue to be an area of major importance both for ending COVID-19 as a public health threat and for individual patient care. Notably, a statement addressing the risk of prioritizing treatment over prevention (Table 3 (STMT5.1)) had the highest level of combined disagreement (7%) for this domain. With current public health policies reflecting greater tolerance for community transmission and increased rates of infection, research into 340 | Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 COVID-19 must adapt and develop further evidence to understand the cumulative effect of COVID reinfection (Table 7 (REC5.4)). Research is needed to determine whether infection from distinct variants of SARS-CoV-2 is associated with significant differences in long-term morbidity (Table 3 (STMT5.4)). Additional research funding, particularly for long COVID, should be prioritized (Table 7 (REC5.6)), and multisectoral collaboration should accelerate new therapies across all stages of COVID-19 (Table 7 (REC5.2)). Moreover, global case definitions should be standardized (Table 7 (REC5.1)). Echoing some statements and recommendations in the pandemic inequities domain (discussed below), clinical trials and longitudinal Table 8 | Ten highest ranked recommendations Rank Domain Recommendation Disagreement (SD+D) (%) 1 Health systems Pandemic preparedness and response planning should adopt a whole-of-society approach that includes multiple disciplines, sectors and actors (for example, business, civil society, engineering, faith communities, mathematical modelling, military, media and psychology). 1 2 Communication Community leaders, scientific experts and public health authorities should collaborate to develop public health messages that build and enhance individual and community trust and use the preferred means of access and communication for different populations. 0 3 Prevention All countries should adopt a vaccines-plus approach that includes a combination of COVID-19 vaccination, prevention measures, treatment and financial incentives. 4 4 Pandemic inequities Pandemic preparedness and response should address pre-existing social and health inequities. 1 5 Communication Public health authorities should partner with individuals and organizations that are trusted within their communities to provide accurate, accessible information about the pandemic and inform behaviour change. 0* 6 Vaccination Government, philanthropic and industry funding should include a focus on developing vaccines that provide long-lasting protection against multiple SARS-CoV-2 variants. 1 7 Communication Public health professionals and authorities should combat false information proactively based on clear, direct, culturally responsive messaging that is free of unnecessary scientific jargon. 1 8 Health systems Preparedness and response strategies should adopt whole-of-government approaches (for example, multiministry coordination) to identify, review and address resilience in health systems. 1 9 Pandemic inequities Global trade and health organizations should coordinate with countries to negotiate the transfer of technologies enabling manufacturers in low- and middle-income countries to develop quality assured and affordable vaccines, tests and therapeutics. 1 10 Treatment and care 0* Promote multisectoral collaboration to accelerate the development of new therapies for all stages of COVID-19 (for example, outpatient, hospitalization and long COVID). SD+D, the combined percentage of ‘somewhat disagree’ and ‘disagree’ responses. The asterisks indicate that rounding resulted in 0% despite the presence of ≥1 response in the disagreement category. cohorts should be more inclusive and statistically representative regarding age, gender and vulnerable populations (Table 7 (REC5.3)). Eliminate inequities The substantial agreement of the panellists suggests that addressing inequities remains a global challenge. Immediate efforts should be made to reduce vaccine wastage (Table 7 (REC6.8)), addressing the need for cold storage, transport and other infrastructure-based barriers in low-resource settings (Table 7 (REC6.4)), addressing the affordability of testing and treatment for people in all countries (Table 7 (REC6.2)), as well as accelerating efforts to distribute vaccines in lowand middle-income countries (Table 7 (REC6.10)). Transfer agreements to increase production capacities in low- and middle-income countries should be expedited (Table 7 (REC6.6)). Pre-existing social and health inequities must be considered in pandemic preparedness and response going forward (Table 7 (REC6.7)). The findings call special attention to two vulnerable populations: children (Table 7 (REC6.5)) and those living within or fleeing from conflict zones (Table 7 (REC6.9)). The pandemic has illustrated the risk of over-reliance on experts from a small number of disciplines (Table 3 (STMT6.8)), often excluding the expertise of community members (Table 4 (REC1.2)) and vulnerable groups (Table 3 (STMT6.7)). Instead, vulnerable groups should be sought out and actively engaged (Table 7 (REC6.3)). As noted in the communication domain, community leaders should also be engaged (Table 4 (REC1.1)). Multidisciplinary experts who understand local contexts should be included in developing national operational plans for ending COVID-19 as a public health threat (Table 7 (REC6.1)). COVID-19 tests and treatments should be affordable for all people in all countries (Table 7 (REC6.2)). Discussion Wide-ranging pandemic control measures59–62 have not ended COVID19 as a public health threat63–68. Although this study echoes some earlier findings—for example, the Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response35, the European Union 2022 communication on preparedness and response69 and WHO’s 2022 plan on strategic preparedness53—it is distinct from previous efforts22 given its design, which emphasized consensus building and the reporting of disagreement through the Delphi method, panellist diversity with regard to geography and disciplines, and the large sample size. The study’s focus—ending COVID-19 as a public health threat—is defined as being evidenced by the resumption of pre-pandemic social, cultural, religious, political, healthcare, economic and educational activities in each country’s context. Some retrospective matters (for example, pandemic root-cause analysis), theoretical questions and modelling were judged to be beyond the scope of the study. Where possible, the study emphasizes recommendations that can be implemented in the short term (that is, in months, not years) to end COVID-19 as a public health threat. Although examples of countries implementing multiple recommendations exist (for example, free tests70, combining widespread testing and free treatment of positive cases along with digital technologies71, the development of vaccines providing long-lasting protection against variants72,73), the exceptions accentuate global challenges and provide new opportunities for action. Certain statements and recommendations resulting from this consensus process address gaps in WHO’s strategic plan31, most strikingly, the failure to directly address the airborne nature of transmission. Initially, the WHO incorrectly labelled airborne transmission of SARS-CoV-2 as ‘misinformation’. Only much later, after multidisciplinary scientific efforts, did the WHO recognize airborne transmission to be a predominant mode of transmission74–76. By contrast, this panel recommends that ‘risk communications clearly emphasize’ (Table 6 (REC4.3)) the causal link between inhalation of SARS-CoV-2 and the transmission of COVID-19 as well as policy incentivizing ‘structural prevention measures (for example, ventilation, air filtration) to mitigate airborne transmission’ (Table 6 (REC4.1)). The WHO’s slow pace in directly addressing the airborne nature of transmission underscores why public health policy and risk communications should be based on evidence. For example, supposing that endemicity will result in lower virulence is an erroneous assumption77–79 that may exacerbate disproportionate risks of COVID-19 among vulnerable Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 | 341 Article Box 1 Cross-cutting themes for action to end COVID-19 as a public health threat (1) SARS-CoV-2 still moves among us—despite some governments moving on—requiring continued efforts and resources to save lives. Reservoirs exist from which variants of concern may yet emerge104,105; possible endemicity45 does not necessarily mean lower disease severity106. Broad-based funding to develop long-lasting immunogenic vaccines must proceed concurrent with other prevention measures. The long-term impact of infection must be assessed, as long COVID has emerged as a chronic condition107–110. (2) Vaccines are an effective tool against COVID-19 but will not alone end COVID-19 as a public health threat. Vaccination as a sole pandemic response strategy has limitations due to immune escape111–113, waning immunity17,114,115, inequitable access34,116, vaccine hesitancy117–120 and the absence of immunization strategies121. A multifaceted public health vaccines-plus approach is needed, including testing, surveillance, treatment122, community engagement and implementation of social prevention measures (such as facemasks123,124, distancing and quarantine), structural interventions (such as ventilation and air filtration)2 and financial incentives (for example, support measures). (3) Multisectoral collaboration that centres on communities and fosters trust is needed. Ending COVID-19 as a public health threat requires whole-of-society and whole-of-government approaches engaging trusted community leaders and organizations, scientific experts, businesses, and other disciplines and sectors1,125. This expanded pool of collaborators can best address diverse needs regarding modes of access, communication, innovation and trust among different populations126,127. (4) Responsive health systems are crucial for responding to the COVID-19 pandemic and require coordinated government support. The persistent demand on health systems requires protecting the physical and mental wellbeing of healthcare workers; reducing economic barriers for equipment and treatment, including addressing supply-chain factors128; strengthening primary care; and adopting a comprehensive, intersectoral, multilevel approach to preparedness and response activities. (5) Adverse forces challenge efforts to end the COVID-19 public health threat. Counteract sovereign state actors who are openly antagonistic toward science and public health and other entities with vested interests that disseminate false information. Public health authorities should build trust in evidence-based communications and partner with those monitoring and holding accountable disseminators of false information129. (6) None of us is safe until everyone is safe. Pandemic inequities must end. This includes taking into account pre-existing social determinants of health, addressing access to affordable vaccines, tests, other supplies and treatment50,130, and paying special attention to the needs of vulnerable groups (such as older131,132 and immunocompromized133 individuals, children134 and healthcare workers48,135,136). groups80. By extension, engagement with communities through effective risk communication should remain a priority for all countries. The WHO recognizes the infodemic as a key challenge to effective communication for general populations53,81–83, vulnerable groups84 and scientists85. Governments, health authorities and healthcare providers should especially take care in the accuracy of their communications. The panel also emphasized that institutions should proactively monitor false health information and collaborate with trusted community leaders to refute it and enhance trust86. Given the disproportionate impact that the pandemic has had on vulnerable groups to date87–89, the panel voiced concern that policy decisions must aim to find ways of lowering risk within these groups after resumption of the aforementioned activities (STMT6.1). As those vulnerable to COVID-19 in many countries can no longer rely on other individuals practising basic prevention measures (such as the use of face masks and isolating after testing positive), the structural changes recommended in this study (for example, indoor ventilation and filtration) assume heightened importance. Furthermore, COVID-19 continues to prompt global discussion and vigorous debate, particularly about tensions among medical ethics, civil liberties and pandemic control measures80. This study is no exception, with statements STMT1.6 (blaming unvaccinated individuals) and STMT3.2 (individual decisions regarding vaccination) receiving the highest levels of disagreement, underscoring the need for equitable structural interventions. In countries with widespread availability of vaccines, it is important for health authorities to distinguish between those who have clearly refused and are unlikely ever to seek vaccination and those who remain hesitant and continue to delay vaccination90. In the latter case, specific factors prolonging the delay can be addressed by targeted interventions. Finally, continued 342 | Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 uncertainty about the widespread consequences of long COVID and its implications for public health policy (REC2.9) is an ongoing concern91,92. Some innovations, notably vaccines37,38, have not been equitably distributed to low- and middle-income countries, and others, such as high-quality facemasks, have not been widely adopted in high-income countries despite their availability93. Some recommendations addressing pandemic inequities remain underleveraged; for example, providing more vaccines94 to countries with a low percentage of people vaccinated (REC6.10). Other recommendations may necessitate increased funding and time— for example, calls for continued vaccine and treatment innovations (REC2.12, REC5.2, REC5.6). Importantly, the single significant difference in levels of panel agreement between those working in high-income countries and those working in low- and middle-income countries pertained to the role of economic incentives (REC3.6), probably reflective of sociocultural distinctions or perhaps disagreement over feasibility in implementation and ethics concerns95,96. Furthermore, 14% of the panellists considered themselves to be not qualified to respond to STMT4.3 concerning zoonotic variants, which probably indicates a lower understanding of biological vectors and the aetiology of variants among some of the disciplines included in the panel compared with the other topics covered97. As noted above, the panellists nearly unanimously agreed on and prioritized whole-of-society and whole-of-government approaches98–101 (Table 8). The panellists also prioritized recommendations for communicating effectively with the public and developing technologies (for example, vaccines, therapies and services) that can reach target populations (Table 8). Failure to use these approaches risks not only prolonging COVID-19 as a public health threat, but also further diversion of resources from efforts to achieve other extant public health goals102,103. Strengths and limitations One of the strengths of this study is its use of Delphi methodology. By demonstrating increased agreement with each subsequent round, this method enabled us to determine whether our incorporation of feedback was successful in refining the statements and recommendations, increasing the degree of consensus and, in some cases, reaching unani­mity. The consistently increasing mean levels of agreement with the consensus statements and recommendations observed across all three survey rounds strengthens our confidence in the relevance of the itera­tive Delphi process in eliciting feedback to improve subsequent rounds. This is particularly noteworthy given that the effort to incorporate feedback from the expert panel may have resulted in more complex (for example, multiple item) statements and recommendations. Generally, there may be concerns as to the clarity of such statements; however, levels of agreement tended to be either maintained or increased, providing greater confidence in their resonance with the panel. The overall high response rates across three survey rounds speaks to both the rigorous implementation of the method and the commitment of the assembled panel of experts. Endorsement of the resultant consensus statements and recommendations by 184 organizations in 72 countries (Supplementary Table 2) at the time of publication further testifies to their global relevance. Although the Delphi method is a robust approach (Methods) to assess levels of agreement on specific issues and explore whether a consensus can be reached, it is not without limitations. A main concern pertains to the construction of a truly representative expert panel. The sequential, multimethod sampling approach that we used (see the ‘Delphi expert panel member sample’ section in the Methods) minimized potential bias from purposive sampling of a small group and, instead, generated a large, geographically and disciplinarily diverse panel from multiple sources (that is, the core group, nominees from the core group and corresponding authors of key COVID-19 literature). While potential panellists were identified from their work related to COVID-19, infectious diseases, public health preparedness and other fields, the chairs further confirmed their appropriateness for the study by instructing them to not participate if they felt they lacked expertise concerning the pandemic. This approach appears to have been appropriate, as only 5–14% of the panellists felt they were not qualified to respond to just 5 out of the 41 statements, and 3 of the 57 recommendations. Although conducting the study in English limited the participation to English speakers, the inclusion of experts from 112 countries and territories strengthens our confidence in the potential broad applicability of these recommendations to a range of cultures and countries. With regard to the mid-study convening of the core group to discuss issues raised in the initial survey rounds, another limitation may have been that we conducted it virtually rather than in person (see the ‘Delphi data collection’ section in the Methods). and competing interests; and statements of data and code availability are available at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-05398-2. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. Conclusions The multidisciplinary panel’s emphasis on actionable, near-term recommendations guided the Delphi consensus-building process and increased the relevance of the study’s findings to a broad group of stakeholders, including governments, public health authorities, NGOs, community-based organizations, industry, and social media platforms and other media. This consensus study advances a global vision of informed decision-making on how the world can end COVID-19 as a public health threat without a return to sweeping limitations on civil liberties, without risking the health and lives of vulnerable groups, and without exacerbating economic burdens. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. Online content Any methods, additional references, Nature Research reporting summaries, source data, extended data, supplementary information, acknowledgements, peer review information; details of author contributions 36. 37. Leppo, K., Ollila, E., Peña, S., Wismar, M. & Cook, S. Health in All Policies (Ministry of Social Affairs and Health, Finland, 2013). Greenhalgh, T., Grifiin, S., Gurdasani, D. & Hamdy, A. COVID-19: an urgent call for global ‘vaccines-plus’ action. BMJ 376, o1 (2022). Lazarus, J. et al. COVID-SCORE: a global survey to assess public perceptions of government responses to COVID-19 (COVID-SCORE-10). PLoS ONE 15, e0240011 (2020). Morens, D. M., Daszak, P., Markel, H. & Taubenberger, J. K. Pandemic COVID-19 joins history’s pandemic legion. mBio 11, 3 (2020). Pandemic Fatigue: Reinvigorating the Public to Prevent COVID-19: Policy Framework for Supporting Pandemic Prevention and Management: Revised Version November 2020 (WHO, 2020); https://apps.who.int/iris/handle/10665/ COVID Live—Coronavirus Statistics (Worldometer, 2022); https://www.worldometers.info/ coronavirus/#countries. Adam, D. The pandemic’s true death toll: millions more than official counts. Nature 601, 312–315 (2022). Wang, H. et al. Estimating excess mortality due to the COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic analysis of COVID-19-related mortality, 2020–21. Lancet 399, 1513–1536 (2022). Kiss, P., Carcel, C., Hockham, C. & Peters, S. A. E. The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the care and management of patients with acute cardiovascular disease: a systematic review. Eur. Hear. J. Qual. Care Clin. Outcomes 7, 18–27 (2021). Alkatout, I. et al. Has COVID-19 affected cancer screening programs? A systematic review. Front. Oncol. 11, 1540 (2021). Murewanhema, G. & Makurumidze, R. Essential health services delivery in Zimbabwe during the COVID-19 pandemic: perspectives and recommendations. Pan Afr. Med. J. 35, 143 (2020). Shet, A. et al. Impact of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic on routine immunisation services: evidence of disruption and recovery from 170 countries and territories. Lancet. Glob. Health 10, e186–e194 (2022). Chen, Z. et al. Global landscape of SARS-CoV-2 genomic surveillance and data sharing. Nat. Genet. 54, 499–507 (2022). Malick, M. S. S. & Fernandes, H. The genomic landscape of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2. Adv. Mol. Pathol. 4, 231–235 (2021). Karthikeyan, S. et al. Wastewater sequencing reveals early cryptic SARS-CoV-2 variant transmission. Nature 609, 101–108 (2022). Coronavirus (COVID-19) Vaccinations. Statistics and Research https://ourworldindata.org/ covid-vaccinations (Our World in Data, 2021). Pérez-Alós, L. et al. Modeling of waning immunity after SARS-CoV-2 vaccination and influencing factors. Nat. Commun. 13, 1614 (2022). Feikin, D. R. et al. Duration of effectiveness of vaccines against SARS-CoV-2 infection and COVID-19 disease: results of a systematic review and meta-regression. Lancet 399, 924–944 (2022). Lopez-Leon, S. et al. Long COVID in children and adolescents: a systematic review and meta-analyses. Sci. Rep. 12, 9950 (2022). Lopez-Leon, S. et al. More than 50 long-term effects of COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Sci. Rep. 11, 16144 (2021). Subramanian, A. et al. Symptoms and risk factors for long COVID in non-hospitalized adults. Nat. Med. 28, 1706–1714 (2022). Sachs, J. D. et al. The Lancet Commission on lessons for the future from the COVID-19 pandemic. Lancet 400, 1224–1280 (2022). Global Trustworthiness Monitor https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/news/ documents/2022-01/global-trustworthiness-monitor-2021-report_0.pdf (Ipsos, 2022). Gentilini, U. et al. Social Protection and Jobs Responses to COVID-19: A Real-Time Review of Country Measures (World Bank, 2020). Haleem, A., Javaid, M. & Vaishya, R. Effects of COVID-19 pandemic in daily life. Curr. Med. Res. Pract. 10, 78–79 (2020). Oliu-Barton, M. et al. SARS-CoV-2 elimination, not mitigation, creates best outcomes for health, the economy, and civil liberties. Lancet 397, 2234–2236 (2021). Phillips, R. et al. Perceived threat of COVID-19, attitudes towards vaccination, and vaccine hesitancy: a prospective longitudinal study in the UK. Br. J. Health Psychol. 27, 1354–1381 (2022). Servick, K. Is it time to live with COVID-19? Some scientists warn of ‘endemic delusion’. Science 375, 703–704 (2022). Mukaigawara, M. et al. An equitable roadmap for ending the COVID-19 pandemic. Nat. Med. 28, 893–896 (2022). Schneider, K. R., Fanzo, J. C., Haddad, L. & Rosero Moncayo, J. A new strategy for health and sustainable development in the light of the COVID-19 pandemic. Lancet 398, 1029–1031 (2021). Bar-Yam, Y. et al. The World Health Network: a global citizens’ initiative. Lancet 398, 1567–1568 (2021). van der Linden, S., Roozenbeek, J. & Compton, J. Inoculating against fake news about COVID-19. Front. Psychol. 11, 2928 (2020). Larson, H. J., Gakidou, E. & Murray, C. J. L. The vaccine-hesitant moment. N. Engl. J. Med. 387, 58–65 (2022). Lazarus, J. V. et al. COVID-19 vaccine wastage in the midst of vaccine inequity: causes, types and practical steps. BMJ Glob. Health 7, e009010 (2022). COVID-19: Make it the Last Pandemic by The Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness & Response https://theindependentpanel.org/mainreport/ (The Independent Panel, 2021). Batista, C. et al. The silent and dangerous inequity around access to COVID-19 testing: a call to action. EClinicalMedicine 43, 101230 (2022). Bayati, M., Noroozi, R., Ghanbari-Jahromi, M. & Jalali, F. S. Inequality in the distribution of Covid-19 vaccine: a systematic review. Int. J. Equity Health 21, 122 (2022). Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 | 343 Article 38. Lazarus, J. V. et al. Vaccinate fast but leave no one behind: a call to action for COVID-19 vaccination in Spain. Commun. Med. 1, 12 (2021). 39. Pidiyar, V. et al. COVID-19 management landscape: a need for an affordable platform to manufacture safe and efficacious biotherapeutics and prophylactics for the developing countries. Vaccine 40, 5302–5312 (2022). 40. Public trust in scientists rose during the Covid-19 pandemic. Wellcome Global Monitor https://wellcome.org/news/public-trust-scientists-rose-during-covid-19-pandemic-0 (Wellcome, 2021). 41. Shanka, M. S. & Menebo, M. M. When and how trust in government leads to compliance towards COVID-19 precautionary measures. J. Bus. Res. 139, 1275–1283 (2021). 42. Skjefte, M. et al. COVID-19 vaccine acceptance among pregnant women and mothers of young children: results of a survey in 16 countries. Eur. J. Epidemiol. 36, 197–211 (2021). 43. Lazarus, J. V. et al. A global survey of potential acceptance of a COVID-19 vaccine. Nat. Med. 27, 225–228 (2021). 44. Petherick, A. et al. A worldwide assessment of changes in adherence to COVID-19 protective behaviours and hypothesized pandemic fatigue. Nat. Hum. Behav. 5, 1145–1160 (2021). 45. Third Round of the Global Pulse Survey on Continuity of Essential Health Services During the COVID-19 Pandemic https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/WHO-2019-nCoV-EHS_ continuity-survey-2022.1 (WHO, 2022). 46. Gross, J. V., Mohren, J. & Erren, T. C. COVID-19 and healthcare workers: a rapid systematic review into risks and preventive measures. BMJ Open 11, 42270 (2021). 47. Dzinamarira, T. et al. Risk factors for COVID-19 infection among healthcare workers. A first report from a living systematic review and meta-analysis. Saf. Health Work 13, 263–268 (2022). 48. Denning, M. et al. Determinants of burnout and other aspects of psychological well-being in healthcare workers during the COVID-19 pandemic: a multinational cross-sectional study. PLoS ONE 16, e0238666 (2021). 49. Watson, O. J. et al. Global impact of the first year of COVID-19 vaccination: a mathematical modelling study. Lancet Infect. Dis. 22, 1293–1302 (2022). 50. Farina, M. & Lavazza, A. Advocating for greater inclusion of marginalized and forgotten populations in COVID19 vaccine rollouts. Int. J. Publ. Health 66, 1604036 (2021). 51. Mawani, F. N. et al. COVID-19 economic response and recovery: a rapid scoping review. Int. J. Health Serv. 51, 247–260 (2021). 52. Nguyen, A., Guttentag, A., Li, D. & Meijgaard, J. V. The impact of job and insurance loss on prescription drug use: a panel data approach to quantifying the health consequences of unemployment during the COVID-19 pandemic. Int. J. Health Serv. 52, 312–322 (2022). 53. Strategic Preparedness, Readiness and Response Plan to end the Global COVID-19 Emergency in 2022 https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/WHO-WHE-SPP-2022.1 (WHO, 2022). 54. Edwards, A. M., Baric, R. S., Saphire, E. O. & Ulmer, J. B. Stopping pandemics before they start: lessons learned from SARS-CoV-2. Science 375, 1133–1139 (2022). 55. Haldane, V. et al. Health systems resilience in managing the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons from 28 countries. Nat. Med. 27, 964–980 (2021). 56. Pramesh, C. S. et al. Choosing wisely for COVID-19: ten evidence-based recommendations for patients and physicians. Nat. Med. 27, 1324–1327 (2021). 57. Linas, B. P. et al. Projecting COVID-19 mortality as states relax nonpharmacologic interventions. JAMA Health Forum 3, e220760 (2022). 58. Tam, K. M., Walker, N. & Moreno, J. Influence of state reopening policies in COVID-19 mortality. Sci. Rep. 12, 1677 (2022). 59. Greer, S. L., King, E. J., da Fonseca, E. M. & Peralta-Santos, A. The comparative politics of COVID-19: the need to understand government responses. Glob. Publ. Health 15, 1413–1416 (2020). 60. Bollyky, T. J. et al. Pandemic preparedness and COVID-19: an exploratory analysis of infection and fatality rates, and contextual factors associated with preparedness in 177 countries, from Jan 1, 2020, to Sept 30, 2021. Lancet 399, 1489–1512 (2022). 61. Tang, J. W. et al. An exploration of the political, social, economic and cultural factors affecting how different global regions initially reacted to the COVID-19 pandemic. Interface Focus 12, 20210079 (2022). 62. Zheng, C. et al. Real-world effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines: a literature review and meta-analysis. Int. J. Infect. Dis. 114, 252–260 (2022). 63. Burn, E. et al. Venous or arterial thrombosis and deaths among COVID-19 cases: a European network cohort study. Lancet Infect. Dis. 22, 1142–1152 (2022). 64. Health at a Glance https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/sites/ae3016b9-en/index.html?itemId=/ content/publication/ae3016b9-en (OECD, 2021). 65. Islam, N. et al. Excess deaths associated with covid-19 pandemic in 2020: age and sex disaggregated time series analysis in 29 high income countries. BMJ 373, n1137 (2021). 66. Clarke, J. M., Majeed, A. & Beaney, T. Measuring the impact of COVID-19. BMJ 375, e066952 (2021). 67. Strasser, Z., Hadavand, A., Shawn, M. & Estiri, H. SARS-CoV-2 Omicron variant is as deadly as previous waves after adjusting for vaccinations, demographics, and comorbidities. Preprint at Research Square https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-1601788/v1 (2022). 68. Mefsin, Y. M. et al. Epidemiology of infections with SARS-CoV-2 Omicron BA.2 variant, Hong Kong, January–March 2022. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 28, 1856–1858 (2022). 69. Directorate-General for Health and Food Safety. COVID-19—Sustaining EU Preparedness and Response: Looking Ahead https://health.ec.europa.eu/publications/covid-19sustaining-eu-preparedness-and-response-looking-ahead-0_en (European Commission, 2022). 70. Rader, B. et al. Use of at-home COVID-19 tests—United States, August 23, 2021–March 12, 2022. MMWR 71, 489–494 (2022). 71. Lee, D., Heo, K. & Seo, Y. COVID-19 in South Korea: lessons for developing countries. World Dev. 135, 105057 (2020). 72. Wang, C. Y. et al. A multitope SARS-CoV-2 vaccine provides long-lasting B cell and T cell immunity against Delta and Omicron variants. J. Clin. Invest. 132, e157707 (2022). 73. Afkhami, S. et al. Respiratory mucosal delivery of next-generation COVID-19 vaccine provides robust protection against both ancestral and variant strains of SARS-CoV-2. Cell 185, 896–915 (2022). 344 | Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 74. WHO. Fact Check: COVID-19 is Not Airborne https://twitter.com/WHO/status/124397219316 9616898?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw (Twitter, 2020). 75. Lewis, D. Why the WHO took two years to say COVID is airborne. Nature 604, 26–31 (2022). 76. Telenti, A. et al. After the pandemic: perspectives on the future trajectory of COVID-19. Nature 596, 495–504 (2021). 77. Greenhalgh, T., Ozbilgin, M. & Tomlinson, D. How COVID-19 spreads: narratives, counter narratives, and social dramas. BMJ 378, e069940 (2022). 78. Antia, R. & Halloran, M. E. Transition to endemicity: Understanding COVID-19. Immunity 54, 2172–2176 (2021). 79. Whitaker, M. et al. Variant-specific symptoms of COVID-19 among 1,542,510 people in England. Preprint at medRxiv https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.05.21.22275368 (2022) 80. Gostin, L. O., Friedman, E. A. & Wetter, S. A. Responding to COVID-19: how to navigate a public health emergency legally and ethically. Hastings Cent. Rep. 50, 8–12 (2020). 81. Wang, Y., McKee, M., Torbica, A. & Stuckler, D. Systematic literature review on the spread of health-related misinformation on social media. Soc. Sci. Med. 240, 112552 (2019). 82. Islam, M. S. et al. COVID-19-related infodemic and its impact on public health: a global social media analysis. Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg. 103, 1621–1629 (2020). 83. Purnat, T. Delivering actionable infodemic insights and recommendations for the COVID-19 pandemic response. WER 27, 313–324 (2021). 84. Choukou, M. A. et al. COVID-19 infodemic and digital health literacy in vulnerable populations: a scoping review. Digit. Health 8, 20552076221076927 (2022). 85. Palayew, A. et al. Pandemic publishing poses a new COVID-19 challenge. Nat. Hum. Behav. 4, 666–669 (2020). 86. Vaccination and Trust: How Concerns Arise and the Role of Communication in Mitigating Crises (WHO, 2017). 87. Shadmi, E. et al. Health equity and COVID-19: global perspectives. Int. J. Equity Health 19, 104 (2020). 88. Lebrasseur, A. et al. Impact of COVID-19 on people with physical disabilities: a rapid review. Disabil. Health J. 14, 101014 (2021). 89. Kumar, N. et al. Sexual health (excluding reproductive health, intimate partner violence and gender-based violence) and COVID-19: a scoping review. Sex. Transm. Infect. 97, 402–410 (2021). 90. Lazarus, J. V. et al. Revisiting COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy around the world using data from 23 countries in 2021. Nat. Commun. 13, 3801 (2022). 91. Al-Aly, Z., Bowe, B. & Xie, Y. Long COVID after breakthrough SARS-CoV-2 infection. Nat. Med. 28, 1461–1467 (2022). 92. A Clinical Case Definition of Post COVID-19 Condition by a Delphi Consensus, 6 October 2021 https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/WHO-2019-nCoV-Post_COVID-19_conditionClinical_case_definition-2021.1 (WHO, 2021). 93. Li, H. et al. Efficacy and practice of facemask use in general population: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Transl. Psychiatry 2022, 49 (2022). 94. Yamey, G. et al. It is not too late to achieve global covid-19 vaccine equity. BMJ 376, e070650 (2022). 95. Jarrett, C. et al. Strategies for addressing vaccine hesitancy—a systematic review. Vaccine 33, 4180–4190 (2015). 96. Persad, G. & Emanuel, E. J. Ethical considerations of offering benefits to COVID-19 vaccine recipients. JAMA 326, 221–222 (2021). 97. Vora, N. M. et al. Want to prevent pandemics? Stop spillovers. Nature 605, 419–422 (2022). 98. Chiriboga, D., Garay, J., Buss, P., Madrigal, R. S. & Rispel, L. C. Health inequity during the COVID-19 pandemic: a cry for ethical global leadership. Lancet 395, 1690–1691 (2020). 99. Wenham, C. What went wrong in the global governance of COVID-19? Brit. Med. J. 372, n303 (2021). 100. Global Preparedness Monitoring Board. From Worlds Apart to a World Prepared (WHO, 2021). 101. Sirleaf, R., Johnson, H. E. E. & Clark, H. H. Transforming or Tinkering? Inaction Lays the Groundwork for Another Pandemic (The Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response, 2022). 102. Shulla, K. et al. Effects of COVID-19 on the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Discov. Sustain. 2, 15 (2021). 103. The Sustainable Development Goals Report 2021 https://unstats.un.org/sdgs/report/2021/ (UN, 2021). 104. Tracking SARS-CoV-2 variants https://www.who.int/activities/tracking-SARS-CoV-2-variants (WHO, 2022). 105. Chandler, J. C. et al. SARS-CoV-2 exposure in wild white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus). Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 118, e2114828118 (2021). 106. Nesteruk, I. Influence of possible natural and artificial collective immunity on new COVID-19 pandemic waves in Ukraine and Israel. Explor. Res. Hypothesis Med. 7, 8–18 (2022). 107. Taquet, M. et al. Incidence, co-occurrence, and evolution of long-COVID features: a 6-month retrospective cohort study of 273,618 survivors of COVID-19. PLoS Med. 18, e1003773 (2021). 108. Carson, G. et al. Research priorities for long COVID: refined through an international multi-stakeholder forum. BMC Med. 19, 84 (2021). 109. Buonsenso, D. et al. Preliminary evidence on long COVID in children. Acta Paediatr. 110, 2208–2211 (2021). 110. Crook, H., Raza, S., Nowell, J., Young, M. & Edison, P. Long COVID—mechanisms, risk factors, and management. BMJ 374, n1648 (2021). 111. Khan, K. et al. Omicron BA.4/BA.5 escape neutralizing immunity elicited by BA.1 infection. Nat. Commun. 13, 4686 (2022) 112. Noh, J. Y., Jeong, H. W. & Shin, E. C. SARS-CoV-2 mutations, vaccines, and immunity: implication of variants of concern. Signal Transduct. Target. Ther. 6, 203 (2021). 113. Tian, D., Sun, Y. H., Zhou, J. M. & Ye, Q. The global epidemic of SARS-CoV-2 variants and their mutational immune escape. J. Med. Virol. 94, 847–857 (2022). 114. Goldberg, Y. et al. Waning immunity after the BNT162b2 vaccine in Israel. N. Engl. J. Med. 385, e85 (2021). 115. Ssentongo, P. et al. SARS-CoV-2 vaccine effectiveness against infection, symptomatic and severe COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Infect. Dis. 22, 439 (2022). 116. Global Dashboard for Vaccine Equity https://data.undp.org/vaccine-equity/ (UNDP Data Futures Platform, 2022). 117. MacDonald, N. E. et al. Vaccine hesitancy: definition, scope and determinants. Vaccine 33, 4161–4164 (2015). 118. El-Mohandes, A. et al. COVID-19 vaccine acceptance among adults in four major US metropolitan areas and nationwide. Sci. Rep. 11, 21844 (2021). 119. Duan, Y. et al. Disparities in COVID-19 vaccination among low-, middle-, and high-income countries: the mediating role of vaccination policy. Vaccines 9, 905 (2021). 120. Sabahelzain, M. M., Hartigan-Go, K. & Larson, H. J. The politics of COVID-19 vaccine confidence. Curr. Opin. Immunol. 71, 92–96 (2021). 121. Meng, H., Mao, J. & Ye, Q. Booster vaccination strategy: necessity, immunization objectives, immunization strategy, and safety. J. Med. Virol. 94, 2369–2375 (2022). 122. Brandon, Ng,T. S., Leblanc, K., Yeung, D. F. & Tsang, T. S. M. Medication use during COVID-19: review of recent evidence. Can. Fam. Physician 67, 171–179 (2021). 123. Chou, R., Dana, T. & Jungbauer, R. Update alert 8: masks for prevention of respiratory virus infections, including SARS-CoV-2, in health care and community settings. Ann. Intern. Med. 175, W108–W109 (2022). 124. Kuhfeldt, K. et al. Examination of SARS-CoV-2 in-class transmission at a large urban university with public health mandates using epidemiological and genomic methodology. JAMA Netw. Open 5, e2225430 (2022). 125. Samaan, G. et al. The World Health Organization’s actions within the United Nations system to facilitate a whole-of-society response to COVID-19 at country level. Front. Publ. Health. 9, 831220 (2022). 126. Bump, J. B., Friberg, P. & Harper, D. R. International collaboration and COVID-19: what are we doing and where are we going? BMJ 372, n180 (2021). 127. Tanveer, S., Rowhani-Farid, A., Hong, K., Jefferson, T. & Doshi, P. Transparency of COVID-19 vaccine trials: decisions without data. BMJ Evid. Based Med. 27, 199–205 (2021). 128. Moosavi, J., Fathollahi-Fard, A. M. & Dulebenets, M. A. Supply chain disruption during the COVID-19 pandemic: recognizing potential disruption management strategies. Int. J. Disaster Risk Reduct. 75, 102983 (2022). 129. Purnat, T. D., Wilson, H., Nguyen, T. & Briand, S. EARS—a WHO platform for AI-supported real-time online social listening of COVID-19 conversations. Stud. Health Technol. Inform. 281, 1009–1010 (2021). 130. Wu, E.-L. et al. Disparities in COVID-19 monoclonal antibody delivery: a retrospective cohort study. J. Gen. Intern. Med. 37, 2505–2513 (2022). 131. Mølhave, M., Agergaard, J. & Wejse, C. Clinical management of COVID-19 patients—an update. Semin. Nucl. Med. 52, 4–10 (2022). 132. No-One is Safe Until Everyone is Safe—Why We Need a Global Response to COVID-19 https://www.unhcr.org/news/press/2021/5/60a7fc9b4/statement-no-one-safe-safe-needglobal-response-covid-19.html (UNHCR, 2021). 133. Marra, A. R. et al. Short-term effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines in immunocompromised patients: a systematic literature review and meta-analysis. J. Infect. 84, 297–310 (2022). 134. Orben, A., Tomova, L. & Blakemore, S. J. The effects of social deprivation on adolescent development and mental health. Lancet Child Adolesc. Health 4, 634–640 (2020). 135. Paris, C. et al. Risk factors for SARS-CoV-2 infection among health care workers. Am. J. Infect. Control 50, 375–382 (2022). 136. Cahill, A. G. et al. Occupational risk factors and mental health among frontline health care workers in a large US metropolitan area during the COVID-19 pandemic. Prim. Care Companion CNS Disord. 24, 40038 (2022). Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. © The Author(s) 2022 Barcelona Institute for Global Health (ISGlobal), Barcelona, Spain. 2Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain. 3City University of New York Graduate School of Public Health and Health Policy (CUNY SPH), New York City, NY, USA. 4 Independent Researcher, Sioux Falls, SD, USA. 5University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa. 6Centre for the AIDS Program of Research in South Africa (CAPRISA), Durban, South Africa. 7Weill Cornell Medicine, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, USA. 8Weill Cornell Medicine-Qatar, Cornell University, Qatar Foundation-Education City, Doha, Qatar. 9Pan American Health Organisation, Washington, DC, USA. 10UNITE Global Parliamentarians Network, Lisbon, Portugal. 11Faculty of Health, Medicine and Life Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands. 12Institute of Health Sciences (CIIS), Catholic University of Portugal, Lisbon, Portugal. 13University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora, CO, USA. 14Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (Fiocruz), Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. 15University of Bahia, Salvador, Brazil. 16New England Complex Systems Institute, Cambridge, MA, USA. 17Manhiça Health Research Center (CISM), Maputo, Mozambique. 18Catalan Institute for Research and Advanced Studies (ICREA), Barcelona, Spain. 19Pediatrics Department, Hospital Sant Joan de Déu, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain. 20Biomedical Research Consortium in Epidemiology and Public Health (CIBERESP), Madrid, Spain. 21Doctors Without Borders (MSF), Geneva, Switzerland. 22Baraka Impact Finance, Geneva, Switzerland. 23Payne Institute, Colorado School of Mines, Golden, CO, USA. 24National Yang Ming Chiao Tung University, Taipei, Taiwan. 25Emory School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA, USA. 26University of New South Wales (UNSW) Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia. 27Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Beijing, China. 28The O’Neill Institute for National and Global Health Law, Georgetown University, Washington, DC, USA. 29Burnet Institute, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. 30Department of Chemistry, University of Colorado Boulder, Boulder, CO, USA. 31 Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences (CIRES), University of Colorado Boulder, Boulder, CO, USA. 32Christian Medical College (CMC), Vellore, India. 33Wilton Park, Steyning, UK. 34Clinic for Infectious Diseases and Febrile Illnesses, University Medical Centre, Ljubljana, Slovenia. 35Faculty of Medicine, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia. 36The London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK. 37University Teaching Hospital of Butare, Butare, Rwanda. 38Paris Dauphine University - PSL, Paris, France. 39French National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS), Grenoble, France. 40University College London (UCL), London, UK. 41Dr. Rajendra Prasad Government Medical College, Himachal Pradesh, India. 42 James P. Grant School of Public Health, BRAC University, Dhaka, Bangladesh. 43Plenitud Foundation, Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic. 44University of Costa Rica, San José, Costa Rica. 45Faculty of Medical and Health Sciences, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand. 46Independent Philosopher, Copenhagen, Denmark. 47Department of Neurosurgery, Houston Methodist Research Institute, Houston, TX, USA. 48International Digital Health & AI Research Collaborative (I-DAIR), Geneva, Switzerland. 49University of Global Health Equity, Kigali, Rwanda. 50University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. *A list of authors and their affiliations appears online. ✉e-mail: Jeffrey.Lazarus@isglobal.org 1 Nature | Vol 611 | 10 November 2022 | 345 Article The COVID-19 Consensus Statement Panel Jeffrey V. Lazarus1,2,3, Diana Romero3, Christopher J. Kopka4, Salim Abdool Karim5,6, Laith J. Abu-Raddad7,8, Gisele Almeida9, Ricardo Baptista-Leite10,11,12, Joshua A. Barocas13, Mauricio Barreto14,15, Yaneer Bar-Yam16, Quique Bassat1,17,18,19,20, Carolina Batista21,22, Morgan Bazilian23, Shu-Ti Chiou24, Carlos del Rio25, Gregory J. Dore26, George F. Gao27, Lawrence O. Gostin28, Margaret Hellard29, Jose L. Jimenez30,31, Gagandeep Kang32, Nancy Lee33, Mojca Matičič34,35, Martin McKee36, Sabin Nsanzimana37, Miquel Oliu-Barton38, Bary Pradelski39, Oksana Pyzik40, Kenneth Rabin3, Sunil Raina41, Sabina Faiz Rashid42, Magdalena Rathe43, Rocio Saenz44, Sudhvir Singh45, Malene Trock-Hempler46, Sonia Villapol47, Peiling Yap48, Agnes Binagwaho49, Adeeba Kamarulzaman50, Ayman El-Mohandes3, Salim Abdulla51, Sarah Addleman52, Gulnara Aghayeva53, Raymond Agius54, Mohammed Ahmed55, Mohamed Ahmed Ramy56, Pedro Aide17, Soo Aleman57, Jean-Patrick Alfred58, Shamim Ali59, Jorge Aliaga60, Tammam Aloudat21, Saleh A. Alqahtani62, Jameela Al-Salman63, John H. Amuasi64, Anurag Agrawal65, Wagida Anwar66, Tania Araujo-Jorge14, Osvaldo Artaza67, Leyla Asadi68, Yaw Awuku69, Michael Baker70, Lorena Barberia71, Ernesto Bascolo9, Paul Belcher72, Lizett Bell73, Adele Benzaken74, Emil Bergholtz75, Nahid Bhadelia76, Anant Bhan77, Stephane Bilodeau78, Ricardo Bitrán79, Philomena Bluyssen80, Arnold Bosman81, Fernando A. Bozza14, Melanie M. Brinkmann82, Andrew Brown83, Bruce Mellado84, Elizabeth Bukusi85, Chris Bullen45, Giorgio Buonanno86, Rochelle Burgess40, Matthew Butler87, Pauline Byakika-Kibwika88, Baltica Cabieses89, Gunilla Carlsson90, Fidelia Cascini91, Chishala Chabala92, Mohamed Chakroun93, K. K. Cheng94, Agnes Chetty95, Dmytro Chumachenko96, Gregg Consalves97, Andrew Conway Morris98, Ahmed Cordie99, Tumani Corrah100, Brenda Crabtree-Ramírez101, Naranjargal Dashdorj102, Nadav Davidovitch103, Luis Eugenio de Souza15, Akshay Chand Dhariwal104, Elena Druică105, Onder Ergonul106, Ngozi A. Erondu28, Mohammad Yasir Essar107, Andrew Ewing108, Gonzalo Fanjul1, Daniel Feierstein109, Eric Feigl-Ding110, Ramon Figueroa111, John Peter Figueroa112, Dale Fisher113, Walter Flores114, David A. Forero-Peña115, Howard Frumkin116, Amiran Gamkrelidze117, Monica Gandhi118, Patricia Garcia119, Alberto L. Garcia-Basteiro1, Adolfo García-Sastre120, Suneela Garg121, F. A. Gbeasor-Komlanvi122, Carlos Gershenson123, Ishwar Gilada124, Ligia Giovanella14, Marino González125, Manfred S. Green126, Trisha Greenhalgh127, Paul Griffin128, Stephen Griffin129, Beatriz Grinsztejn130, Tanu Anand131, Germán Guerra132, Renzo Guinto133, Mariusz Gujski134, Rahmet Guner135, Adam Hamdy136, Marian-Gabriel Hâncean105, Abusayeed Haniffa137, Kenneth Y. Hartigan-Go138, Hoda K. Hassan139, Simon I. Hay116, Matti T. J. Heino140, Zdenek Hel141, Peter Hotez142, Jia Hu143, Mirsada Hukić144, Carel IJsselmuiden145, Davidson Iroko69, Maged Iskarous146, Chimaraoke Izugbara147, Choolwe Jacobs92, Alejandro R. Jadad148, Fyezah Jehan149, Ayana Jordan150, Imane Jroundi151, Kevin Kain152, Fatjona Kamberi153, Eduard Karamov154, Abraar Karan155, Rebecca Katz28, Aris Katzourakis127, Abigail Kazembe156, Faryal Khamis157, Komiljon Khamzayev158, Judy Khanyola49, Kamlesh Khunti159, Elsie Kiguli-Malwadde160, Woo Joo Kim161, Bruce J. Kirenga88, Daniel Klimovský162, Brittany L. Kmush163, Felicia Knaul164, Manolis Kogevinas1, Frederik Kristensen165, Dinesh Kumar41, Raman Kumar166, Amanda Kvalsvig70, Marcus V. Lacerda14, Arush Lal167, Tom Lawton168, Jay Lemery13, Anthony J. Leonardi169, Yuguo Li170, Jan Löttvall108, Mohamed Lounis171, Daniel Maceira172, C. Raina MacIntyre26, Azzeddine Madani173, Gkikas Magiorkinis174, Reza Malekzadeh175, Marc Choisy176, Jasmine R. Marcelin177, Guy B. Marks26, Linsey Marr178, Jeanne Marrazzo141, Antonieta Martina179, José M. Martín-Moreno180, Carlos Mateos181, Mayfong Mayxay182, Jean Bapiste Mazarati183, Souleymane Mboup184, Jennifer McDonald52, Faye McMillan26, Enkeleint Mechili153, Andre Medici185, Sarah L. M. Davis61, Petra Meier186, Ziad A. Memish187, Jaideep Menon188, Purnima Menon189, Jonathan Mesiano-Crookston190, Susan Michie40, Ivana Mikolasevic191, Ognjen Milicevic192, Asit Kumar Mishra193, Rahma Mohamed99, Ali H. Mokdad116, Michele Monroy-Valle194, Lidia Morawska195, Sterghios A. Moschos196, Karam Motawea197, Sayed Hamid Mousavi198, Ghina Mumtaz199, Peter K. Munene200, Carmen Muñoz Almagro201, Janet Muriuki202, Sylvia Muyingo203, Denise Naniche1, C. David Naylor152, Nicaise Ndembi204, Juraj Nemec205, Igor Nesteruk206, Christine Ngaruiya207, Hung Nguyen208, Dafina Nikolova209, Dorit Nitzan103, Ole Norheim210, Mohammed Noushad211, Francine Ntoumi212,213, Gunhild Alvik Nyborg16,214, Eleanor Ochodo85, Zekaver Odabasi215, Mbah Patrick Okwen216, Keiser Olivia217, David S. Y. Ong218, Ijeoma Opara219, Miguel Orozco220, Hitoshi Oshitani221, Christina Pagel40, Madhukar Pai222, Björg Pálsdóttir223, Georgios Papatheodoridis174, Dimitrios Paraskevis174, Jeanna Parsons Leigh224, Bernard Pécoul225, Andreas Peichl226, Eddy Perez-Then227, Phuc Pham Duc228, Cécile Philippe229, Andrea Pineda Rojas230, Courtney Pladsen231, Anton Pozniak232, Rodrigo Quiroga233, Huma Qureshi234, Sanjay Rampal50, Megan Ranney235, Laura Rathe43, Scott Ratzan3, Henriette Raventos44, Helen Rees84, Renata Reis21, Walter Ricciardi91, Nesrine Rizk199, Magda Robalo236, Eleanor Robertson237, Leanne Robinson29, Casper Rokx238, Tamsin Ros239, John-Arne Røttingen240, Meir Rubin241, Kiat Ruxrungtam242, Shakhlo Sadirova243, Senjuti Saha244, Nelly Salgado245, Lizet Sanchez246, Thurka Sangaramoorthy247, Carolina Santamaria-Ulloa44, Renata Santos21, Bisher Sawaf248, Matthias F. Schneider249, Robert T. Schooley250, Alper Sener251, Jaime Sepulveda118, Jaffer Shah198, Mosa Shibani252, Sheikh Shoib253, Izukanji Sikazwe254, Aistis Šimaitis255, Amandeep Singh Gill48, Natia Skhvitaridze117, Milka Sokolović72, Roma Solomon256, Xavier Solórzano257, Sandra A. Springer207, Jakub Šrol258, Anthony Staines259, Henry T. Stelfox260, Steffanie Strathdee250, Lokman Hakim Sulaiman261, Brett Sutton262, Dag Svanæs263, Sarya Swed264, Vana Sypsa174, Kristine Sørensen265, Raji Tajudeen266, Amy Tan267, Julian Tang157, Marcel Tanner268, Tavpritesh Sethi269, Marleen Temmerman270, Kyu Kyu Than271, Halidou Tinto272, Sênoudé Pacôme Tomètissi273, Irene Torres274, K. P. Tshering275, Sotirios Tsiodras174, Benjamin Tsofa85, Anders Vahlne57, Juan Rafael Vargas44, Ivan Dario Velez Bernal276, Deisy Ventura71, Rafael Vilasanjuan1, Joe Vipond260, Sarah Wamala-Andersson277, Pawel Wargocki278, Robert West40, Angela Weyand279, Trenton M. White1,280, Guntram Wolff281, Maosheng Yao282, Christian A. Yates283, Georgina Yeboah284, Leo Yee-Sin285, Siyan Yi113, Yik-Ying Teo113, Poovorawan Yong242, Victor Zamora-Mesía286 & Anne Øvrehus287 51 Ifakara Health Institute, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. 52University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. 53Baku Health Centre, Baku, Azerbaijan. 54The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK. Mogadishu University, Mogadishu, Somalia. 56Generations for Health, Madrid, Spain. Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden. 58Ministry of Health and Population, Port-au-Prince, Haiti. 59Moi University, Eldoret, Kenya. 60Hurlingham National University, Hurlingham, Argentina. 61Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies, Geneva, Switzerland. 62King Faisal Specialist Hospital and Research Centre, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. 63Salmaniya Medical Complex, Manama, Bahrain. 64Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi, Ghana. 65Trivedi School of Biosciences, Ashoka University, Sonepat, India. 66Community Medicine Department, Faculty of Medicine, Ain Shams University, Cairo, Egypt. 67Faculty of Health and Social Sciences, University of The Americas, Santiago, Chile. 68University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. 69University of Health and Allied Sciences, Ho, Volta, Ghana. 70University of Otago, Wellington, New Zealand. 71 University of Sao Paulo, Sao Paulo, Brazil. 72European Public Health Alliance, Brussels, Belgium. 73Ministry of Health and Wellness Belize, Belmopan, Belize. 74Aids Healthcare Foundation, São Paulo, Brazil. 75Department of Physics, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden. 76Boston University Center for Emerging Infectious Diseases Policy and Research (CEID), Boston, MA, USA. 77Centre For Ethics, Yenepoya University, Mangaluru, India. 78Smart Phases, Plattsburgh, NY, USA. 79Bitran y Asociados, Santiago, Chile. 80Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands. 81Transmissible, Houten, The Netherlands. 82Institute of Genetics, Technische Universität Braunschweig, Braunschweig, Germany. 83Management Sciences for Health, Medford, MA, USA. 84University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa. 85Kenya Medical Research Institute, Nairobi, Kenya. 86University of Cassino and Southern Lazio, Cassino, Italy. 87King’s College London, London, UK. 88Department of Medicine, Makerere University College of Health Sciences, Kampala, Uganda. 89Universidad del Desarrollo, Santiago, Chile. 90The Global Fund, Geneva, Switzerland. 91Catholic University of the Sacred Heart, Rome, Italy. 92University of Zambia, Lusaka, Zambia. 93Fattouma Bourguiba Teaching Hospital, Monastir, Tunisia. 94Institute of Applied Health Research, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK. 95Ministry of Health Seychelles, Victoria, Seychelles. 96National Aerospace University “Kharkiv Aviation Institute”, Kharkiv, Ukraine. 97 Yale School of Public Health, New Haven, CT, USA. 98University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK. 99Cairo University Hospitals, Cairo, Egypt. 100Africa Research Excellence Fund (AREF), London, UK. 101Instituto Nacional de Ciencias Médicas y Nutrición Salvador Zubirán, Mexico City, Mexico. 102Onom Foundation, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia. 103Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Be’er Sheva, Israel. 104National Centre for Disease Control and National Vector Borne Disease Control Programme, Government of India, Delhi, India. 105University of Bucharest, Bucharest, Romania. 106Koç University İşbank Center for Infectious Diseases, Istanbul, Turkey. 107 Kabul University of Medical Sciences, Kabul, Afghanistan. 108University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden. 109CONICET/National University of Tres de Febrero, Caseros, Argentina. 110 Federation of American Scientists, Washington, DC, USA. 111Social Security Board, Belize City, Belize. 112The University of the West Indies, Kingston, Jamaica. 113National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore. 114Center for the Study of Equity and Governance in Health Systems, Guatemala City, Guatemala. 115Biomedical Research and Therapeutic Vaccines Institute, Ciudad Bolivar, Venezuela. 116Department of Health Metrics Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA. 117National Center for Disease Control and Public Health of Georgia, Tbilisi, Georgia. 118UCSF, San Francisco, CA, USA. 119School of Public Health, Cayetano Heredia University, Lima, Peru. 120Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York City, NY, USA. 121MAMC & Associated Hospitals New Delhi, New Delhi, India. 122University of Lomé, Lomé, Togo. 123Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, Mexico City, Mexico. 124 Organised Medicine Academic Guild—OMAG, Mumbai, India. 125Simon Bolivar University, Caracas, Venezuela. 126University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel. 127University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. 128 University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. 129University of Leeds, Leeds, UK. 130National Institute of Infectology Evandro Chagas-Fiocruz, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. 131Indian Council of Medical Research, New Delhi, India. 132National Institute of Public Health, Cuernavaca, Mexico. 133St Luke’s Medical Center College of Medicine, Quezon City, The Philippines. 134Department of Public Health, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland. 135 Ankara City Hospital Infectious Diseases and Clinical Mirobiology, Ankara, Turkey. 136 Independent Researcher, Port Louis, Mauritius. 137Ministry of Health, Colombo, Sri Lanka. 138 Ateneo School of Government, Quezon City, The Philippines. 139Independent Consultant, Cairo, Egypt. 140University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland. 141University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, AL, USA. 142National School of Tropical Medicine, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA. 14319 To Zero, Calgary, Alberta, Canada. 144Center for Disease Control and Geohealth Studies, Academy of Sciences and Arts of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina. 145COHRED, Geneva, Switzerland. 146Independent Consultant, Cairo, Egypt. 147International Center for Research on Women, Washington, DC, USA. 148Centre for Digital Therapeutics, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. 149Aga Khan University, Karachi, Pakistan. 150NYU Grossman School of Medicine, New York City, NY, USA. 151School of Medicine and Pharmacy, University Mohammed V, Rabat, Morocco. 152University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. 153Research Centre of Public Health, Faculty of Health, University of Vlore “Ismail Qemali” Albania, Vlorë, Albania. 154Gamaleya National Research Center for Epidemiology and Microbiology of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation, Moscow, Russian Federation. 155Division of Infectious Disease & Geographic Medicine, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA. 156Kamuzu University of Health Sciences, Blantyre, Malawi. 157 Royal Hospital, Ministry of Health, Muscat, Oman. 158Tashkent Pediatric Medical Institute, Tashkent, Uzbekistan. 159University of Leicester, Leicester, UK. 160African Center for Global Health and Social Transformation, Kampala, Uganda. 161Division of Infectious Diseases, Guro Hospital, College of Medicine Korea University, Seoul, Republic of Korea. 162Comenius University in Bratislava, Bratislava, Slovakia. 163Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY, USA. 164 University of Miami Institute for Advanced Study of the Americas, Coral Gables, FL, USA. 165 Coalition of Epidemic Preparedness Innovations (CEPI), Oslo, Norway. 166Institute of Family Medicine and Primary Care, Greater Noida, India. 167London School of Economics & Political Science, London, UK. 168Bradford Institute for Health Research & Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Bradford, UK. 169St Georges University of London, London, UK. 170The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China. 171University Ziane Achour Djelfa, Djelfa, Algeria. 172 University of Buenos Aires/Health Systems Global, Buenos Aires, Argentina. 173Faculty of Social and Human Sciences, Khemis-Miliana University, Khemis Miliana, Algeria. 174National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece. 175Digestive Disease Research Institute Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. 176Centre for Tropical Medicine and Global Health, Nuffield Department of Medicine, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. 55 57 177 University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE, USA. 178Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA. 179University of Cabo Verde, Praia, Cape Verde. 180Department of Preventive Medicine and Public Health and INCLIVA, University of Valencia, Valencia, Spain. 181Instituto #SaludsinBulos, Madrid, Spain. 182University of Health Sciences, Ministry of Health, Vientiane, Lao People’s Democratic Republic. 183Foundation for Innovative New Diagnostics, Geneva, Switzerland. 184Institute of Health Research Epidemiological Surveillance and Trainings (IRESSEF), Dakar, Senegal. 185Universal Health Monitor, Bethesda, MD, USA. 186University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK. 187King Saud Medical City, Ministry of Health and College of Medicine Alfaisal University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. 188Amrita Institute of Medical Sciences, Kochi, India. 189 International Food Policy Research Institute, New Delhi, India. 190Goldman Hine LLP, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. 191Department of Gastroeterology, University Hospital Center Riejka, Riejka, Croatia. 192School of Medicine, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia. 193 MaREI Centre, Ryan Institute & School of Engineering, University of Galway, Galway, Ireland. 194 University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada. 195Queensland University of Technolgy, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. 196Department of Applied Sciences, Faculty of Health and Life Sciences, Northumbria University, Newcastle, UK. 197Faculty of Medicine, Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt. 198New York State Department of Health, Albany, NY, USA. 199American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon. 200Faith to Action Network, Nairobi, Kenya. 201International University of Catalonia, Barcelona, Spain. 202IntraHealth International, Nairobi, Kenya. 203African Population and Health Research Center, Nairobi, Kenya. 204Africa Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (Africa CDC), Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. 205Masaryk University, Brno, Czech Republic. 206Institute of Hydromechanics, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, Kiev, Ukraine. 207Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA. 208 International Livestock Research Institute, Nairobi, Kenya. 209University Clinic of Gastroenterohepatology, Faculty of Medicine, University “Ss. Cyril and Methodius”, Skopje, Republic of Macedonia. 210University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway. 211College of Dentistry, Dar Al Uloom University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. 212Congolese Foundation for Medical Research, Brazzaville, Republic of the Congo. 213Institute of Tropical Medicine, University of Tübingen, Tübingen, Germany. 214Covid Action Group, World Health Network, Son, Norway. 215 Department of Infectious Diseases, Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Marmara University, Istanbul, Turkey. 216Effective Basic Services (eBASE) Africa, Bamenda, Cameroon. 217 University of Geneva, Institute of Global Health, Geneva, Switzerland. 218Franciscus Gasthuis en Vlietland, Rotterdam, The Netherlands. 219Wayne State University School of Medicine, Detroit, MI, USA. 220International Independent Expert on Health Systems, Managua, Nicaragua. 221Tohoku University Graduate School of Medicine, Sendai, Japan. 222McGill School of Population and Global Health, Montreal, Quebec, Canada. 223Training for Health Equity Network: THEnet, New York City, NY, USA. 224Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada. 225Drugs for Neglected Diseases initiative, Geneva, Switzerland. 226ifo Institute at the University of Munich, Munich, Germany. 227Two Oceans in Health, Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic. 228Vietnam One Health University Network (VOHUN), Hanoi University of Public Health (HUPH), Hanoi, Vietnam. 229Molinari Economic Institute, Paris, France. 230CIMA, UMI-IFAECI/CNRS, FCEyN, Universidad de Buenos Aires-UBA/CONICET, Buenos Aires, Argentina. 231National Health Care for the Homeless Council, Nashville, TN, USA. 232Chelsea and Westminster Hospital, London, UK. 233INFIQC-CONICET, National University of Córdoba, Córdoba, Argentina. 234Department of Botany, University of Chakwal, Chakwal, Pakistan. 235 Brown University, Providence, RI, USA. 236Institute for Global Health and Development, Bissau, Guinea-Bissau. 237NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, Glasgow, UK. 238Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands. 239Africa Europe Foundation, Brussels, Belgium. 240Norwegian Institute of Public Health, Oslo, Norway. 241Kohelet Policy Forum, Jerusalem, Israel. 242Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand. 243Research Institute of Virology under the Ministry of Health of Uzbekistan, Tashkent, Uzbekistan. 244 Child Health Research Foundation, Dhaka, Bangladesh. 245National Institute of Public Health, Mexico City, Mexico. 246Center of Molecular Immunology, La Havana, Cuba. 247 University of Maryland, College Park, MD, USA. 248Internal Medicine Department, Hamad Medical Corporation, Doha, Qatar. 249Technical University of Dortmund, Dortmund, Germany. 250 University of California San Diego, San Diego, CA, USA. 251Infectious Disease Department, Izmir Katip Celebi University Ataturk Training and Research Hospital, Izmir, Turkey. 252Faculty of Medicine, Syrian Private University, Damascus, Syrian Arab Republic. 253Department of Psychiatry, Jawahar Lal Nehru Memorial Hospital, Srinagar, India. 254Centre for Infectious Disease Research in Zambia (CIDRZ), Lusaka, Zambia. 255The Office of the Government of the Republic of Lithuania, Vilnius, Lithuania. 256CORE Group Polio Project India, Delhi, India. 257 Independent Consultant, Quito, Ecuador. 258Institute of Experimental Psychology, Centre of Social and Psychological Sciences, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Bratislava, Slovakia. 259 Dublin City University, Dublin, Ireland. 260University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada. 261 Institute for Research, Development and Innovation, International Medical University, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. 262Department of Health, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. 263Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, Norway. 264Faculty of Medicine, Aleppo University, Aleppo, Syrian Arab Republic. 265Global Health Literacy Academy, Risskov, Denmark. 266African Union, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. 267University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. 268Swiss Academies of Arts and Sciences, Bern, Switzerland. 269Indraprastha Institute of Information Technology, Delhi, India. 270Centre of Excellence in Women and Child Health, Aga Khan University, Nairobi, Kenya. 271Burnet Institute Myanmar, Yangon, Myanmar. 272Institute for Health Sciences Research (CNRST/IRSS), Nanoro, Burkina Faso. 273People’s Health Movement, Abomey-Calavi, Benin. 274Fundacion Octaedro, Quito, Ecuador. 275Khesar Gyalpo University of Medical Sciences of Bhutan, Thimphu, Bhutan. 276Antioquia University, Medellin, Colombia. 277Mälardalens University, Mälardalens, Sweden. 278Technical University of Denmark, Kongens Lyngby, Denmark. 279 University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, MI, USA. 280Hospital Clínic, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain. 281Bruegel Free University of Brussels, Brussels, Belgium. 282 College of Environmental Sciences and Engineering, Peking University, Beijing, China. 283 University of Bath, Bath, UK. 284African Forum for Research and Education in Health, Kumasi, Ghana. 285National Centre for Infectious Diseases, Singapore, Singapore. 286Gobierna Consulting Firm, Lima, Peru. 287Department of Infectious Diseases, Odense University Hospital, Odense, Denmark. Article Methods Delphi expert panel member sample We used an iterative sampling approach to generate a large panel for this Delphi study (Fig. 1). The four co-chairs ( J.V.L., A.B., A.K. and A.E.-M.) identified a core group of 40 academic, health, NGO, government and policy experts from 25 countries and territories. Selection by the co-chairs was primarily based on publication record and engagement on COVID-19 issues as well as online biographies. Twenty-nine of these experts were well known to the chairs while seven were suggested through snowball sampling to result in geographical and gender equity among the core group of 40. Furthermore, a concerted effort was made towards multidisciplinary representation in the core group, including medical sciences (such as infectious diseases, public health and vaccinology), engineering, and social sciences (such as policy, law and ethics). The core group proposed additional experts to create a global panel of approximately 400 experts. The lead chair ( J.V.L.) and methodologist (D.R.) led this core group through implementation of the project. Snowball sampling was then used as core group members identified individuals with expertise in COVID-19 from their professional networks to generate an initial list of potential Delphi panel members with the goal of broad representation. In proposing experts, co-chairs focused on identifying at least one representative from at least 100 countries. One co-chair ( J.V.L.) took responsibility for reviewing the suggestions, with support from a research assistant who shared recent publications and a professional biography for every proposed co-author. Many initial suggestions were of leading experts with whom the co-chairs had previously collaborated. The core group then reviewed the panel list for under-represented countries and PubMed/Medline searches were conducted using the search term ‘COVID-19’ in combination with the names of under-represented countries to identify authors of COVID-19 research studies involving primary data collection in these countries. Authors of relevant studies were invited to participate in the Delphi panel to further increase geographical diversity and include panellists beyond the core team members’ networks. All of the panel participants were carefully vetted; most had published in one or more relevant fields. To further validate the expertise of the panel, the study was described to the invitees (n = 696) with the following instructions: “If you consider your professional training and expertise applicable to the subject matter of this global consensus statement project, we encourage you to participate in the panel.” Informed consent was obtained for each panellist after explaining the purpose of the study and their expected contributions, including review and approval of the submitted manuscript, by accession to the Round 1 (R1) survey. Our objective was for invited participants to explicitly consider whether they had the necessary level of expertise before joining the Delphi panel. We do not have specific information regarding the basis of invitees’ non-participation but expect that these instructions enabled a substantial portion of non-respondents to self-select out of the study. We know that 84 invitees began the R1 survey but did not complete it; thus, if we assume that they did consider themselves to be eligible to participate but then decided not to do so, that would result in an estimated response rate of 82.1% (386 out of 470). The resultant expert panel is diverse in terms of demographic, disciplinary and geographical characteristics (Table 1). Delphi statement domains The core group reviewed the published literature available up to January 2022 to draft initial statements for the first Delphi survey round, grouped in the following domains: (1) communication; (2) health systems; (3) vaccination; (4) prevention; (5) treatment and care; and (6) pandemic inequities. No formal systematic review with stringent criteria for levels of evidence was performed owing to the sheer volume of COVID-19-related published studies and the frequency at which they were and continue to be published. However, all of the authors and panellists were invited to suggest relevant papers, which were reviewed by the core group members based on journal rankings, paper citations and other metrics. In R1, panellists considered draft consensus statements based on the literature before moving to the next step of recommendations in round two (R2), which emanated from the panellists’ feedback on the statements as well as new research findings over the course of data collection from 18 February 2022 to 28 April 2022. Delphi method data collection The study design consisted of digital data collection: two survey rounds (R1 and R2) of draft statements; an online consensus meeting of the core group (16 March 2022) to discuss salient issues; one round of draft recommendations (in R2); and, a final, third survey round (R3) of the consensus statements and recommendations (Fig. 1). The core group decided a priori to use a supermajority (that is, ≥67% combined agreement) minimum cut-off for consensus. This more demanding cut-off (relative to a simple majority of greater than 50%) was considered to be necessary given the project goal of supporting global policy and programmatic actions to address the COVID-19 public health crisis. We used the QualtricsXM platform to develop and distribute the surveys (round duration ranged from 1.5 to 3 weeks) with four-point Likert-type categories for measuring the level of agreement with the statements and recommendations (that is, agree, somewhat agree, somewhat disagree, disagree); a fifth ‘not qualified to respond’ option was provided given the panel’s range of COVID-19 expertise. Panellists could provide comments and suggest edits to individual statements and recommendations in text boxes, which followed each of the statements and recommendations. All rounds allowed for overall comments at the end of the survey, and the researchers reviewed 1,409, 755, and 188 comments associated with the statements in R1, R2 and R3, respectively, and 1,025 and 2,156 comments associated with the recommendations in R2 and R3, respectively. Summaries of changes based on panellist input from a previous round were available in text boxes next to each statement and recommendation in the subsequent round. Similarly, the definition for “Ending COVID-19 as a public health threat as evidenced by the resumption of social, cultural, religious, political, healthcare, economic and educational activities in each country’s context” was presented during each round so that panellists could respond to statements on the basis of a shared understanding of how the phrase “ending COVID-19 as a public health threat” was defined for the purpose of this study. In R3, panellists also ranked the top half of recommendations within each of the six domains, which were automatically randomized to mitigate order-effect bias. Using Microsoft Excel (v.16), scores were calculated and normalized using the Dowdall system to compare rankings across domains by accounting for weighting bias due to differences in the total number of recommendations in each domain137,138. An important component of the data-collection process involves the discussion among core group members of issues that emerge from the early survey rounds and how best to incorporate such feedback in subsequent rounds. Given the geographical distribution of panel members and COVID-19-related travel and health concerns, we convened the core group virtually for in-depth, real-time deliberation. This web-based approach is different from in-person discussion of complicated or contentious issues; however, panel members had multiple opportunities to provide open-ended comments in the absence of dominant voices that can inhibit the expression of minority viewpoints during in-person convenings. Thus, the combination of real-time feedback (from core group members) and written feedback (from the entire panel) probably resulted in more comprehensive contributions overall. Delphi data analysis Data analysis reflected the multiple-methods nature of Delphi studies and was managed by an analytic team of core group members, the study methodologist and research assistants. Across the three rounds, we ran frequencies of all statements and recommendations (Supplementary Discussion 2); the proportion who selected ‘not qualified to respond’ is reported in the data tables but removed from the denominator to calculate levels of agreement/disagreement from the relevant sample. The team then analysed the extensive qualitative data (that is, open-ended text-box comments). Specifically, comments were first reviewed individually by at least three core group members ( J.V.L., co-chair; D.R., methodologist; and C.J.K.) and an additional co-author (T.M.W.). For each data collection round, comments were then discussed in online review meetings, including at least three core group members and an additional co-author. After review and discussion, comment suggestions were incorporated into statement and recommendation revisions for subsequent rounds. A supermajority of core group members (28 out of 40; 70%) participated in the online consensus meeting, which permitted in-depth breakout-group discussions on salient issues from R1 and R2 informing R3 revisions (Supplementary Discussion 3). Quantitative analysis of the final R3 results involved assigning each statement and recommendation a grade to indicate the level of combined agreement (agree + somewhat agree), using a system that has been used in other Delphi studies139–141 in which ‘U’ denotes unanimous (100%) agreement; ‘A’ denotes 90%–99% agreement; ‘B’ denotes 78%–89% agreement; and ‘C’ denotes 67%–77% agreement. Although all statements and recommendations exceeded the standard supermajority minimum of ≥67% combined agreement for consensus, we highlighted those with <67% for ‘agree’ alone for further analysis. Statements and recommendations were analysed using Fisher’s exact tests in Stata (v.16) to assess differences in agreement by the following panellist characteristics: income level (high income versus low- and middle-income) for country of birth and country where currently working, primary sector of employment and primary field of employment (Supplementary Discussion 2). The use of the terms combined agreement and combined disagreement are presented in the results. Reporting summary Further information on research design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this article. Data availability Additional data will be shared on request from the corresponding author for fair use. 137. Reilly, B. Social choice in the south seas: electoral innovation and the Borda count in the Pacific Island countries. Int. Polit. Sci. Rev. 23, 355–372 (2016). 138. Fraenkel, J. & Grofman, B. The Borda count and its real-world alternatives: comparing scoring rules in Nauru and Slovenia. Aust. J. Polit. Sci. 49, 186–205 (2014). 139. Rubino, F. et al. Joint international consensus statement for ending stigma of obesity. Nat. Med. 26, 485–497 (2020). 140. Lazarus, J. V. et al. Advancing the global public health agenda for NAFLD: a consensus statement. Nat. Rev. Gastroenterol. Hepatol. 19, 60–78 (2021). 141. Lazarus, J. V. et al. Consensus statement on the role of health systems in advancing the long-term well-being of people living with HIV. Nat. Commun. 12, 4450 (2021). Acknowledgements The chairs and core author group thank all of the panellists who completed the surveys, including for their thousands of helpful comments. They specifically thank the few panellists who are not co-authors but did actively participate in the survey rounds: K. Adolf, N. Alwan, I. Araújo, M. Brookman-Amissah, C. Caceres, M. Childs, S. Duckett, F. Farzadfar, A. Glassman, H. Hopkins, M. Kall, M. Paule Kieny, M. Malebona Precious, K. Prather, V. Priesemann, P. Ananth Tambyah, K. Yaw and S. Zhan. They further thank ISGlobal research assistants L. van Selm, C. Pujol Martínez and R. Freiheit for support, and L. Ansley Hobbs (CUNY SPH) for technical support with the QualtricsXM platform. J.V.L., Q.B., A.L.G.-B., G.F., M.K., D.N., R.V. and T.M.W. acknowledge support to ISGlobal from the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities through the “Centro de Excelencia Severo Ochoa 2019–2023” Programme (CEX2018-000806-S), and from the Government of Catalonia, Spain, through the CERCA Programme. J.S. acknowledges support from J. Waller for his contributions. No funding was received for this manuscript. We thank Wilton Park for hosting and sponsoring the virtual consensus meeting on 16 March 2022. Author contributions This study was led by four co-chairs (J.V.L., A.B., A.K. and A.E.-M.) who were part of a core group of 40 co-authors (J.V.L., D.R., C.J.K., S.A.K., L.J.A.R., G.A., R.B.L., J.A.B., M.L.B., Y.B.-Y., Q.B., C.B., M.B., S.-T.C., C.d.R., G.J.D., G.G., L.O.G., M.H., J.L.J., C.K., N.L., M.M., M.M.K., S.N., M.O.B., B.P., O.P., K.R., S.R., S.R., M.R., R.S., S.S., M.T.-H., S.V., P.Y., A.B., A.K. and A.E.-M.). The co-chairs regularly updated the core group members by email and J.V.L. led an online consensus meeting hosted by Wilton Park in March 2022. D.R., the lead chair (J.V.L.) and T.M.W. led the methodology. J.V.L., D.R., T.M.W. and C.J.K. reviewed all comments submitted as part of the three survey rounds. J.V.L., C.J.K. and T.M.W. reviewed all comments sent directly by email. J.V.L., D.R., C.J.K., T.M.W. and K.R. reviewed all comments from the peer reviewers. All COVID-19 Consensus Statement Panel members had the opportunity to review the full draft of the manuscript and provide three rounds of comments through QualtricsXM. Those fulfilling authorship criteria are named (n = 364). Competing interests J.V.L. reports research grants to his institution from AbbVie, Gilead Sciences and MSD, and speaker fees from AbbVie, Gilead Sciences, Intercept, Janssen, MSD and ViiV, and an advisory board fee from AbbVie and Novavax, all unrelated to this work. R.A. is a co-chair of the Occupational Medicine Committee of the British Medical Association and a member of the Industrial Injuries Advisory Council (UK). S.A. reports honoraria for lectures and educational events from Gilead, AbbVie, MSD and Biogen, and reports grants, not related to COVID-19, from Gilead and AbbVie. The A.G.-S. laboratory has received research support from Pfizer, Senhwa Biosciences, Kenall Manufacturing, Avimex, Johnson & Johnson, Dynavax, 7Hills Pharma, Pharmamar, ImmunityBio, Accurius, Nanocomposix, Hexamer, N-fold, Model Medicines, Atea Pharma, Applied Biological Laboratories and Merck. A.G.-S. has consulting agreements for the following companies involving cash and/or stock: Vivaldi Biosciences, Contrafect, 7Hills Pharma, Avimex, Vaxalto, Pagoda, Accurius, Esperovax, Farmak, Applied Biological Laboratories, Pharmamar, Paratus, CureLab Oncology, CureLab Veterinary, Synairgen and Pfizer. A.G.-S. has been an invited speaker in meeting events organized by Seqirus, Janssen and AstraZeneca. A.G.-S. is listed as an inventor on patents and patent applications (US patent numbers: 5,820,871; 5,854,037; 6,001,634; 6,146,642; 6,451,323; 6,468,544; 6,544,785; 6,573,079; 6,635,416; 6,649,372; 6,669,943; 6,740,519; 6,852,522; 6,866,853; 6,884,414; 6,887,699; 7,060,430; 7,384,774; 7,442,379; 7,494, 808; 7,588,768; 7,833,774; 8,012,490; 8,057,803; 8,124,101; 8,137,676; 8,591,881; 8,629,283; 8,673,314; 8,709,442; 8,709,730; 8,765,139; 8,828,406; 8,999,352; 9,051,359; 9,096,585; 9,175,069; 9,217,136; 9,217,157; 9,238,851; 9,352,033; 9,371,366; 9,387,240; 9,387,242; 9,549,975; 9,701,723; 9,708,373; 9,849,172; 9,908,930; 9,968,670; 10,035,984; 10,098,945; 10,131,695; 10,137,189; 10,179,806; 10,251,922; 10,308,913; 10,543,268; 10,544,207; 10,583,188; 10,736,956; 11,254,733; and 11,266,734) on the use of antivirals and vaccines for the treatment and prevention of virus infections and cancer, owned by the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York. S.G. reports being a member of Independent SAGE and member of the Pfizer Antivirals Advisory Board. P.H. reports being co-inventor of a COVID-19 recombinant protein vaccine technology owned by the Baylor College of Medicine (BCM) that was recently licenced by BCM nonexclusively and with no patent restrictions to several companies committed to advance vaccines for low- and middle-income countries. The co-inventors have no involvement in licence negotiations conducted by the BCM. Similar to other research universities, a longstanding BCM policy provides its faculty and staff, who make discoveries that result in a commercial licence, a share of any royalty income. To date, BCM has not distributed any royalty income to the co-inventors on the COVID-19 recombinant protein vaccine technology. Any such distribution will be undertaken in accordance with BCM policy. A.K. has served as a paid consultant to the Independent Panel on Pandemic Preparedness and Response in 2020–21. K.K. is Chair of the Ethnicity Subgroup of the UK Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies (SAGE) and Member of SAGE. J.L. reports owning equity in Codiak BioSciences and Exocure Biosciences, both having developed experimental COVID-19 vaccines. G.M. reports honoraria for a presentation from Novartis and consulting fees from AstraZeneca. S.M. reports being founder and chief scientific officer of PulmoBioMed. T.S. serves as the scientific director of the O’Brien Institute for Public Health and reports funding from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research. V.S. is a member of the National Scientific Committee of Experts for COVID-19 in Greece and reports grants from Gilead and Abbvie that are not related to this work or to COVID-19 research. A.T. reports grants from the Foundation for Advancing Family Medicine Janus Research Grant; Canadian Frailty Network Research Grant, Speaking Honoraria: University of Ottawa, McMaster University, Northern Ontario School of Medicine, McGill University, University of Calgary, BC Bereavement Hotline, Early Education Teachers of Ontario-Yok Region Union, Ontario Council for Cooperation, TELUS Science World-Vancouver. R.B. has been COVID-19 adviser to UK government and acts as a senior scientific adviser for a communications company working for the UK Government on COVID-19. A.W. reports research funding from Pfizer (unrelated to COVID-19) and a consulting fee from Ocugen. K.Y. is an unpaid member of the Independent SAGE group of scientists. The other authors declare no competing interests. Additional information Supplementary information The online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-05398-2. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to Jeffrey V. Lazarus. Peer review information Nature thanks Jeremy Farrar, Sean Grant and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Reprints and permissions information is available at http://www.nature.com/reprints. Article Extended Data Fig. 1 | Top half of the ranking of the recommendations in each domain. In the third and final round of the Delphi process, panel members were asked to rank the recommendations per domain (n = 6) based on importance. This figure shows the top half of the recommendations for each of the six domains (communication; health systems; vaccination; prevention; treatment and care; and inequities). Extended Data Table 1 | Recommendations with 5% or greater disagreement Across the study, only six recommendations evidenced 5% or greater disagreement (combined “somewhat disagree/disagree”) among the 386 panellists. Areas of disagreement broadly included socio-political and socio-cultural considerations that vary among countries, geopolitical concerns that may impact public health guidance and distinct medical points of view.